buchanan dtlawrencedesign final
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/13/2019 Buchanan DTLawrenceDesign Final
1/69
-
8/13/2019 Buchanan DTLawrenceDesign Final
2/69
2
-
8/13/2019 Buchanan DTLawrenceDesign Final
3/69
3
Downtown Lawrence
Performance-Based Design Standards
Prepared For
The City of Lawrence, Kansas
Prepared By
Matt Buchanan, May 2013
M.U.P. Candidate, May 2014
School of Architecture, Design & Planning
University of Kansas
-
8/13/2019 Buchanan DTLawrenceDesign Final
4/69
4
Table of Contents
1. Introduction...5
Current Dilemmas..........6
Moving Forward..........8
2. The Mass Street District...9
Land-Use .....11
Bulk .......13
Faades ......15
Environmental .......18
Streetscape ...........19
Parking ....21
Signage....22
Financing Tools & Project
Prioritization.....24
3. The Warehouse Arts District....25
Land-Use ........27
Bulk ..........30
Faades .........32
Environmental .......35
Streetscape .......36
Parking ...........38
Signage ..........39
Financing Tools & Project
Prioritization.........41
4. The Riverside District..42
Land-Use .45
Bulk 46
Faades ..48
Environmental ...50
Streetscape 51
Parking .53
Signage....54
Financing Tools & Project
Prioritization.56
Appendices
A. Glossary of Terms...57B. Diagrams..64C. District Design Review
Boards...67
D. Downtown-wide ProjectPrioritization.69
-
8/13/2019 Buchanan DTLawrenceDesign Final
5/69
5
Figure 1.1: Historic buildings and tree-lined streets establish downtown Lawrencesdistinct sense of place
Image Source: danjdavis, Flickr
1. IntroductionDowntown Lawrence is defined by its quaint local boutiques and restaurants, walkable
tree-lined streets, live music, art, culture, and historic architecture. This vibrant
environment, which has become ardently cherished by Lawrence residents and visitors,
is the product of planners abilities to employ unique economic development
strategies, secure historical district designations, and write prudent urban design
guidelines. In their success of establishing a distinct sense of place, planners have
created an environment that may become more difficult to preserve as both
population and property demand increase over time.
The recent construction of three mid-rise mixed-use towers and a new proposal for a
mid-rise hotel demonstrate increased demand for various types of properties
downtown. The pressures to allow new and denser forms of development create
several serious questions for planners to address. While the mixture of land uses does not
conflict with established downtown uses, the density and design of new development
are deviations from traditional forms of development. These changes to the cherished
downtown neighborhood are viewed by some Lawrencians as dangerous threats tothe communitys long established image, atmosphere and identity.Herein lies the all-
encompassing dilemmashould future development be strictly controlled to preserve
downtown as we know it today, or should developers be given the flexibility to meet
property demand and maximize revenues? This plan addresses this issue by laying out a
clear path forward that protects what Lawrencians love most about their downtown,
while also encouraging smart and attractive new forms of development.
-
8/13/2019 Buchanan DTLawrenceDesign Final
6/69
6
Current DilemmasTraditionally, lot sizes, building dimensions, and setbacks in downtown Lawrence have
created an atmosphere akin to a small towns Main Street(Figure 1.1). As Lawrences
population increases, the demand for downtown property increases. Because of the
neighborhoods relatively small footprint, pressure to develop larger and taller buildings
is growing. Within recent years, higher density projects have been constructed orpropose (figures 1.2-1.4).
Many Lawrencians have vehemently opposed higher density development proposals
from occurring, arguing that the higher density buildings undermine downtowns small
town charm. Shadowing concerns from homeowners living near downtown have also
objected to these projects. Conversely, project proponents have argued that larger
and taller buildings increase prosperity downtown, resulting in greater tax revenues for
local government. All of these arguments are valid, and should guide future policies
that regulate density through restrictions on floor area ratio (FAR), lot coverage, building
height, and setbacks.
Figure 1.2: Image source: Treanor Architects Figure 1.3: Image source: City of Lawrence
Figure 1.4: Image source: Pbase.com
901 New Hampshire
(Figure 1.2), the
proposed Marriott Hotel
building (Figure 1.3) and
the Hobbs Taylor
Building (Figure 1.4),
contradict the lower
density development
pattern downtown has
historically exhibited.
-
8/13/2019 Buchanan DTLawrenceDesign Final
7/69
7
In addition to the density dilemma, concerns over urban design consistency and quality
demonstrate the need for new and more stringent policies. Traditionally, downtowns
image, atmosphere and identity have been strongly defined by common building
materials, architectural features, and historical significance. However, there are several
structures in downtown Lawrence that deviate from the traditional aesthetic
environment. While downtowns national historic district designation does help control
area urban design, more specific performance policies should be introduced to more
effectively protect and advance the aesthetic standards that define downtowns
current image, identity, and atmosphere.
The buildings pictured in figures 1.5-1.8 deviate from the traditional aesthetic standards that define
downtowns traditional image, identity and atmosphere, which is illustrated in Figure 1.1.
Figure 1.5 Image Source: Cannellfan,Flickr Figure 1.6 Image Source: costar.com
Figure 1.7 Image Source: Johnbalawan, Panoramio Figure 1.8 Image Source: Mrs. Mass
-
8/13/2019 Buchanan DTLawrenceDesign Final
8/69
8
Moving ForwardIn order to address rising population and property demands, while also working to
preserve downtowns current image, atmosphere,and identity, this planrecommends a
balanced approach to the outward and upward expansion of downtown Lawrence.
The expanded downtown will comprise three adjacent districts (Map 1.1), each
expressing its own distinct environment, circumscribed by varying floor area ratios (FAR),land uses, and performance-based policies. Such policies will be aimed to preserve
cherished established structures and urban forms in some areas, while guiding new
forms of development in other areas. This plan also aspires to augment established
neighborhood identities into the design of future development.
Map 1.1
-
8/13/2019 Buchanan DTLawrenceDesign Final
9/69
9
Figure 2.1Source: Colleen Prohaska, Pbase
Figure 2.2Source: Stephensre.com Figure 2.3Source: DanJDavis, Flickr Figure 2.4Source: fotoedge,
tumblr
Figures 2.1-2.4 illustrate the architectural and environmental features that define the Mass Street District
identity that should be emulated by future development.
2. The Mass Street DistrictThis district (Maps 2.1-2.3) will comprise the entire downtown footprint as we know it
today, as well as expand into some residential areas west of Kentucky Street and southsurrounding South Park. The boundaries for this design overlay district were drawn to
better manage the environs of the downtown historic district. All future development
and building modifications within the design overlay district will be subject to density
and design policies that conform and complement to the contributing properties of the
historic district. The districts expansion into nearby residential areas w ill allow for the
controlled and gradual redevelopment of certain properties into more intense uses,
whether multi-family residential, office, retail, or mixed uses.
-
8/13/2019 Buchanan DTLawrenceDesign Final
10/69
10
Te
nnessee
M
assachusetts
NewHampshire
Vermont
Ke
ntucky
Rh
odeIsland
Connecticut
N
ewYork
12th
9th
11th
10th
8th
7th
6th
Ohio
The Mass Street
District
North
.125 Mi .25 Mi
Map 2.1
-
8/13/2019 Buchanan DTLawrenceDesign Final
11/69
11
Mass Street Land-Use Requirements
Goal 2.1: Mixed-Uses
Promote a viable mix of uses that promote living, working, and
playing.
Policy 2.1.1: Mixed-use development shall provide office or
retail space on the ground level, and either multi-family
residential, office, or retail space on all upper levels.
Goal 2.2: Intensity
Minimize any adverse impacts that development or
redevelopment may have on single-family residential
neighborhoods surrounding the downtown
Policy 2.2.1: High intensity (greater than 5:1 FAR) commercial
or mixed-uses shall be buffered by lower intensity (1.25:1 or
lower FAR) uses such as green spaces, low intensity
commercial or medium intensity multi-family residential uses.
Goal 2.3: Downtown Living
Encourage a growing and diverse downtown residential
population
Policy 2.3.1: All future development in the district that
exceeds an FAR of 4:1 must comprise at least 50 percent
multi-family usage.
Policy 2.3.2: All future development in the district that
exceeds an FAR of 6:1 must comprise at least 50 percent
multi-family usage, 50 percent of which must be dedicated
as affordable housing.
Goal 2.4: Green Space
Preserve existing green spaces
Policy 2.4.1: Green spaces delineated in Map 2.2 of this plan
shall be preserved as such, and shall continue to be used for
public recreational purposes.
Appropriate
Land-Uses for the
Mass Street District
Figure 2.6Source: fansshare.com
Figure 2.5Source: Unl.edu
Figure 2.7Source:
Auntie Zooie, Flickr
-
8/13/2019 Buchanan DTLawrenceDesign Final
12/69
12
Connecticut
NewYork
12th
9th
11th
10th
8th
7th
6th
Tennessee
Massachusetts
Vermont
Kentucky
RhodeIslandN
ewHampshire
Ohio
Mass Street DistrictFuture Land-Use Map
North
.125 Mi .25 Mi
Single-Family ResidentialSingle-Family orMulti-Family ResidentialMixed-Use Retail, Office
and/or Multi-Family
ResidentialOffice or RetailGreen Space
InstitutionalMass Street District
Boundary
Map 2.2
-
8/13/2019 Buchanan DTLawrenceDesign Final
13/69
-
8/13/2019 Buchanan DTLawrenceDesign Final
14/69
14
Map 2.3
-
8/13/2019 Buchanan DTLawrenceDesign Final
15/69
15
Figure 2.11Source: Mrs. Mass
Figure 2.12Source: Downtown
Campbellsville, KY
Mass Street District Faade Controls
Goal 2.7: Architectural Integrity
Strengthen neighborhood character by preserving or restoring
historic properties and ensuring that all future development
reflects the districts established design principles.
Policy 2.7.1: Alterations or additions to buildings listed as
contributing structures of the Lawrence Downtown Historic
District shall be conducted following The Secretary of the
Interiors Standards for the Treatment of Historic Properties.
Policy 2.7.2: Materials, massing, colors, and detailing of the
original structure shall guide the design of additions or
alterations of historic structures.
Policy 2.7.3: Historic architectural features of historic buildings
shall be retained and repaired, rather than removed. If these
features are severely damaged, they shall be replaced with
features identical in appearance to the original features.
Policy 2.7.4: Where buildings within the block face establish
regular pattern of windows, floor height, or other building
details, new or remodeled buildings shall remain consistent
with these regular patterns.
Policy 2.7.5: Primary exterior building materials for new
construction shall include wood or masonry units (brick,
stone, tile, or split face alternate course concrete). If panelmaterials are used, each panel shall not exceed a maximum
of nine square feet.
Policy 2.7.6: New infill buildings or exterior renovations shall
exhibit only neo-classical architectural features.
Goal 2.8: Pedestrian Oriented Windows
Ensure retail visibility that supports the pedestrian-scale.
Policy 2.8.1: Street level facades, exluding single-family
homes, must exhibit a minimum of 60 percent transparentdisplay windows. Upper floor facades shall contain a
minimum of 40 percent transparent windows. Windows
fronting streets or the riverfront shall use transparent, non-
reflective and non-tinted materials.
Policy 2.8.2: Windows shall be vertically proportioned from a
3:2 to 2:1 height to width ratio.
Appropriate Faades for
the Mass Street District
Figure 2.13Source:
Mrs. Mass
-
8/13/2019 Buchanan DTLawrenceDesign Final
16/69
16
Mass Street District Faade Controls (Continued)
Goal 2.9: Pedestrian Orientated Design
Present visually interesting architectural features and patterns
designed to reduce mass and scale.
Policy 2.9.1: All faades must have a recognizable "base"
consisting of (but not limited to):
a. thicker walls, ledges or sills;
b. integrally textured, colored, and patterned materials
d. lighter or darker colored materials, mullions or panels;
e. cornices/caps
f. planters;
g. plinth treatments;
h. commercial property bases shall have display windows
which abide by Policy: 2.8.1-2.8.3.
Policy 2.9.2: All faades of buildings greater than four stories
in height must have a recognizable "middle" consisting of
(but not limited to):
a. Building middle cap;
b. integrally textured materials which differentiate from
the base and top;
c. integrally colored and patterned materials which
differentiate from the base and top;
d. lighter or darker colored material that differentiate
from the base and top;
e. windows which contrast from the base through
exposed lintels, sills, shape, and proportions.Overallwall composition within for Building Middles shall
contain at least 30%, but no more than 60% glazing. A
vertical proportion of window panes or window
openings (3:2 to 2:1 height: width ratio) shall be used.
Policy 2.9.3: All faades must have a recognizable "top"
consisting of (but not limited to):
a. cornice treatments, other than colored "stripes" or
"bands" alone, with integrally textured materials
b. sloping roof with overhangs and brackets;
c. stepped parapets.
Policy 2.9.4: Large areas of blank wall shall be avoided by
design accents such as windows, panels, pilasters, trellises,
murals or other faade articulations which will reduce the
overall scale appearance.
Appropriate Faades for
the Mass Street District
Figure 2.14 Source:St. Joseph, Missouri, Flickr
Figure 2.16 Source:
Planetware.com
Figure 2.15 Source: Foutch Bros.
-
8/13/2019 Buchanan DTLawrenceDesign Final
17/69
17
Mass Street District Faade Controls (Continued)
Policy 2.9.5: Awnings that overhang windows or entries on
street level facades shall be constructed of canvas or heavy
cloth, utilizing neutral colors.
Goal 2.10: Building Materials
Buildings should be made of high-quality and attractive
materials
Policy 2.10.1: All building sides, visible from primary and
secondary streets must include materials and design
characteristics consistent with those on the front. Use of
inferior or lesser quality materials for side facades is not
permitted.
Policy 2.10.2: Allowed faade building materials include:brick (traditional red-clay colors), stone, stucco, and non-
reflective glass (cumulative surface area of less than 40
percent of all exterior walls). The following materials are
expressly prohibited: vinyl siding, reflective glass, asphalt
siding, aluminum lap siding, wood siding, corrugated metal,
and siding grade plywood.
Policy 2.10.3: The design of accessory buildings shall reflect
and coordinate with the general style of architecture
inherent in the primary structure for the proposeddevelopment.
Appropriate Faades for
the Mass Street District
Figure 2.19 Source: St. Joseph,
Missouri CVB, Flickr
Street level display windows and
articulated architectural features
illustrated in Figure 2.19 demonstrate
how a large building should be
visually related to the human scale.
Figure 2.17 Source: Activerain.com
Figure 2.18 Source:
Davidsonnews.net
-
8/13/2019 Buchanan DTLawrenceDesign Final
18/69
18
Mass Street District Environmental Requirements
Goal 2.11: Shadows
Adverse shadow effects caused by multi-story properties should
be mitigated to ensure adequate sunlight.
Policy 2.11.1: A preliminary shadow analysis conducted by a
neutral third party consultant shall be required for all
proposed development greater than 45tall, in order for the
districts design review boardto determine if a shadow
threat on neighboring properties warrants additional
analysis.
Policy 2.11.2: Shadowing shall not be allowed to adversely
impact single-family residential districts or green spaces
delineated by Map 2.2. Adverse impacts shall be
determined by a shadow analysis conducted by a neutral
third party consultant.
Goal 2.12: Sustainability
Construct an environmentally sustainable built environment.
Policy 2.12.1: Parking structures with open top decks shall
integrate photovoltaic panels and/or roof gardens to
capture storm water runoff.
Policy 2.12.2: Buildings shall be permitted to integrate
photovoltaic panels and/or roof gardens to capture storm
water runoff.
Policy 2.12.3: Photovoltaic panels must not be visible from
the street.
Appropriate
Environmental Features
for the Mass Street District
Figure 2.20 Source: McGurn
Management Company
Figure 2.21 Source:
T0wnley.info
-
8/13/2019 Buchanan DTLawrenceDesign Final
19/69
19
Mass Street District Streetscape Requirements
Goal 2.13: Pedestrian Oriented Layout
Ensure a walkable, pedestrian oriented environment
Policy 2.13.1: A building or permitted projection may projectover the required sidewalk easement above a height of 40
and below a depth of 5 to accommodate street trees.
Policy 2.13.2: Streetscapes shall provide a minimum 6wide
continuous path of travel and 18-24 wide access zone next
to the curb, which includes a 6 curb and 12 wide granite
or brick edge band adjacent to the back of curb.
Policy 2.13.3 Streetscapes in commercial or mixed-use zoned
areas shall provide a minimum 10wide continuous path of
travel and 18-24 wide access zone next to the curb, which
includes a 6 curb and 12 wide brick edge band adjacent
to the back of curb.
Policy 2.13.4: All pedestrian level lighting shall be no higher
than 15 and down-lit. Light poles shall be in a historical style
light standard to be selected by the district design review
board.
Policy 2.13.5: Street trees shall be provided on all streets
(except on alleys) and shall be planted approximately 3 ft.
behind the curb line. Spacing should be an average of no
more than 30 ft. on center (measured per block face). Theminimum caliper size for each tree should be 3 in. and a
minimum of 12 ft. in height at planting. Species selected
should be native, drought and disease tolerant.
Goal 2.14: Pedestrian Amenities
Encourage street level activity that embraces art, culture, and
entertainment.
Policy 2.14.1: Space for outdoor dining, retail, or live music
may occur on any portion of the paved sidewalk provided a
minimum 6 wide continuous path of travel is maintained.
Policy 2.14.2: Bulb-outs shall be provided on every street
corner on Vermont, Massachusetts, and New Hampshire
streets between 6thand North Park streets. Bulb-outs must
provide space for sculpture or water feature, trash
receptacles, lighting, bike racks, and planters with ledge
seating (8 person minimum capacity).
Appropriate Streetscape
Elements for the
Mass Street District
Figure2.25 Source:
South Bay Realty Pro
Figure 2.23 Source: Truth or
Consequences, Main Street
Figure 2.24 Source:
Hostilegospel, Tumblr
-
8/13/2019 Buchanan DTLawrenceDesign Final
20/69
20
Mass Street District Streetscape Requirements (Continued)
Policy 2.14.3: Space for seating shall be provided no more
than every 30 ft. on center (measured per block face)on
Vermont, Massachusetts, and New Hampshire streets
between 6thand North Park streets. Each block face shallprovide seating capacity for at least 25 people, including
bulb-out seating. Seating may be provided by benches,
planter ledges, fountain ledges, or street sculpture.
Policy 2.14.4: Street art shall be permitted provided a
minimum 6 wide continuous path of travel is maintained
and the street art is approved by the district design review
board.
Appropriate Streetscape
Elements for the Mass
Street District
Figure 2.28 Source: naturalhistory.ku.edu
The vibrancy captured in Figure 2.28 should be replicated along Vermont, Massachusetts,and New Hampshire streets between 6thand North Park streets. This may be achieved
through providing ample seating, space for outdoor dining, street performers, art, and
bike/ped amenities. Figures B2 through B4 in Appendix B should be used as a guide for
streetscape development along the aforementioned streets.
Figure 2.27 Source:
Alloveralbany.com
Figure 2.26 Source:
Yelp.com
-
8/13/2019 Buchanan DTLawrenceDesign Final
21/69
21
Mass Street District Parking Requirements
Goal 2.15: Parking Arrangements
Provide ample on-street and off-street parking in places that
limit visibility and congestion as not to undermine the pedestrian
experience.
Policy 2.15.1: Surface lots are prohibited except for
residential properties (not mixed-use) with fewer than 25
dwelling units.
Policy 2.15.2: Except for on-street parking and the minimum
ground-level frontage required for access to garages and
loading, no parking or loading shall be visible on the ground
floor of any building faade that faces a retail street. Parking
structures shall provide habitable floor area along all retail
street frontages.
Policy 2.15.3: Parking, loading or circulation located above
the ground floor shall be lined by habitable floor area along
all street frontages. If the project developer demonstrates
that it is not feasible to line the parking with habitable space
above the ground floor, it shall be integrated into the design
of the building faade and abide by Policy 2.7 to 2.10.
Policy 2.15.4: Where parking above the ground floor that is
not lined with habitable space is permitted, a maximum of
three parking levels fronting on a public street shall be
allowed above the ground floor when FAR requirementspermit (sections 2.5-2.7).
Policy 2.15.5: Drive-through lanes are not permitted.
Goal 2.16: Structure Design
Parking structures will be visually appealing and blend in with
the surrounding built-environment.
Policy 2.16.1: Parking structures shall have an external skin
designed using the standards set forth in sections 2.7 to 2.10.
Policy 2.16.2: Elevator/stair corridors shall be located on
primary pedestrian corners and be highlighted
architecturally.
Policy 2.16.2: The design of public art and lighting shall be
integrated with the structures architecture to reinforce a
unique identity.
Appropriate Parking
Structures for the
Mass Street District
Figure 2.28 Source:
Carl Walker
Figure 2.29 Source:
Peterlfrench, Flickriver
-
8/13/2019 Buchanan DTLawrenceDesign Final
22/69
22
Mass Street District Signage Controls
Goal 2.17: Pedestrian Oriented Signage
Signage type and positioning should suit a pedestrian-oriented
environment.
Policy 2.17.1: Wall signs shall not exceed 15 percent of the
exposed area of the wall on which they are located. Wall
signs shall not project beyond 6 from the wall surface.
Policy 2.17.2: Hanging signs will be limited to nine square feet
in area and may not project beyond four feet from the
building surface. Material used for fastening or supporting
hanging signs will be restricted to metals with porcelain
enamel, stainless steel, brass or bronze finished. Signs shall be
placed between eight and 12 feet above grade
Policy 2.17.3: Temporary window signs shall not exceed 10
percent of the window.
Policy 2.17.4: Temporary sandwich board signs (or A-frame
signs) shall be permitted as long as they do not interfere with
pedestrian movement or visibility along sidewalks.
Policy 2.17.5: Monument signs shall not exceed five feet in
height and 15 square feet in area. Monument signs in the
public right-of way shall not interfere with pedestrian
movement or visibility along sidewalks. Signs shall not block
motorists visibility along the sidewalk or roadway, or sightlines at entry driveways and circulation aisles will not be
blocked. Monument signs are prohibited on Vermont,
Massachusetts, and New Hampshire Streets between 6thand
North Park streets.
Policy 2.17.6: Projecting signs shall not project beyond 4 (6
for wall signs) from the building and shall be located at least
25 from other projecting signs to maximize visibility and
reduce visual clutter. Projecting signs shall be placed at a 90
degree angle from the building surface and shall be located
no lower than 8 from grade and no higher than the corniceor roof line.
Policy 2.17.7: The following types of signs shall be prohibited
within the district: billboards, digital signs, pole signs, portable
signs (except temporary signs listed in policies 2.17.3 and
2.17.4), rooftop signs, and any form of sign that flashes, flies,
inflates, internally illuminates or moves.
Appropriate
Signage for the
Mass Street District
Figure 2.30 Source: Mrs. Mass
Figure 2.31 Source: Mrs. Mass
Figure 2.32 Source:
Earthbound Trading Co.
Figure 2.33 Source:
Blue Water Signs
-
8/13/2019 Buchanan DTLawrenceDesign Final
23/69
23
Mass Street District Signage Controls (Continued)
Goal 2.18: Signage Design
Sign quality should complement the district character.
Policy 2.18.1: Monument signs shallbe
accented withlandscaping equal to two square feet for every one square
foot of sign face and include a supporting base composed
of allowed building materials listed in Policy 2.10.2.
Policy 2.18.2: Sign materials shall be extremely durable.
Permissible materials include: painted or carved wood;
carved wooden letters; epoxy letters; galvanized sheet
metal; slate, marble, or sandstone; gold leaf; gilt, painted,
stained, or sandblasted glass; clear and colored acrylic;
neon; or stained glass. Paper and cloth signs shall be
prohibited for exterior use (except high quality, weather-
resistant canvas for awnings). Wood signs should be sealed
and maintained to prevent deterioration from moisture.
Policy 2.18.3: All new permanent signs (including awning
signs) shall be reviewed and approved by the district design
review board, as part of the sign permitting process. The
board shall approve signs based on whether they
complement or contribute to the district character as it has
been described by Chapter 2 of this document.
Goal 2.19: Signage Uniformity
Public signage should unify the district by exhibiting consistentdesign elements which promote the district identity.
Policy 2.19.1: Light poles, parking meters, banners, street
signage, way-finding markers, paving graphics, and any
other form of public signage shall be unique to the district by
exhibiting consistent traditional designs that complement
the districts historic integrity. Public signage shall be
approved by the district design review board.
Policy 2.19.2: Public signage identified in Policy 2.19.1 shall
exhibit traditional design through incorporating neutralcolors and one of the following fonts:
Policy 2.19.3: Nonconforming signage replacement shall be
amortized over 5 years upon the adoption of this plan.
Baskerville Old Face Bookman Old Style Goudy Old Style
Garamond Modern No. 20 Calisto MT
Appropriate
Signage for the
Mass Street District
The following signs are
exempt from signage policy
due to their unique historical
contributions:
The Granada Theater Sign
Varsity Theater Sign
Figure 2.34 Source: Metro
Atlantic
Figure 2.35 Source: South
Beach St. Historic District
-
8/13/2019 Buchanan DTLawrenceDesign Final
24/69
24
Mass Street District Financing Tools & Project Prioritization
PriorityLevel Project Financing Tool
High District-Unified Way-finding System Business Improvement District (BID)
High Parking Garages Revenue Bonds, Transportation
Development District (TDD)
High Faade Improvement Revolving Loan
Fund
BID
Medium Bike Racks, Bike Awareness Street
Signage/Striping along Vermont,
Massachusetts, and New Hampshire
TDD, Transportation Alternatives
(TAP) Grant (if awarded)
Medium Public Bike Rental Program User Fees, TDD
Medium Sidewalk Seating/Planters, trashreceptacles along Vermont,
Massachusetts, and New Hampshire
BID
Medium District Unified Public Signage/Banners BID
Medium Undergrounding Utility Poles User Fees4% Utilities Bill Surcharge
City-wide (in cooperation with utility
companies)
Medium Plaza Space at 900 Massachusetts BID
Low Decorative Sidewalk Improvements
along Vermont, Massachusetts, and
New Hampshire
TDD, Transportation Alternatives
(TAP) Grant (if awarded)
Low Public Sculpture/Art along Vermont,Massachusetts, and New Hampshire
BID
Low Decorative Street Improvements
along Vermont, Massachusetts, and
New Hampshire
TDD
Table 2.1District Project Prioritization and Financing
For financing tool definitions, see Appendix A.
For Downtown-wide project prioritization, see Appendix D.
-
8/13/2019 Buchanan DTLawrenceDesign Final
25/69
25
3. The Warehouse Arts DistrictIn recent years, public-private partnerships have fostered development around a
newly-established warehouse arts district in east Lawrence. Through this project, old
warehouses are being converted to lofts, offices, retail and art studio space designed
to accommodate the creative class. Although this project is still in its infancy,momentum is building that may one day produce a neighborhood similar in nature to
Kansas Citys Crossroads Arts District or Omahas Old Market. To help cultivate such an
environment, this plan recommends policies that foster higher intensity uses that support
the arts community. Policies encourage the development of art-oriented businesses
and organizations, as well as promote housing accommodations designed for artists.
Building design specifications will be more flexible in this district, compared to the Mass
Street District so as not to limit artistic expression.
This districts boundaries aim to capture areas prone to growth due to their proximity to
the recently converted warehouses, the riverfront, as well as downtown. The majority of
properties currently within this area are older single-family homes. Plans would preservea relatively low density residential environment on local residential streets (Connecticut,
New York, New Jersey), while encouraging higher intensities on higher volume routes
(7th, 8th, 9th, Pennsylvania, and Delaware). Depending on demand, new development
should allow for residential, office, retail, or mixed-uses. Density and design of new
development adjacent to single-family homes will be controlled to ensure a level of
congruity.
Figures 3.2Source: Foursquare.com
Figures 3.1-3.2 offer a vision of how
Lawrences Warehouse District couldappear through implementing the
policies outlined in Section 3.
Figures 3.1Source: Planitzen
-
8/13/2019 Buchanan DTLawrenceDesign Final
26/69
26
9th
8th
7th
R
hodeIsland
C
onnecticut
N
ewYork
N
ewJersey
Pennsylvania
Delaware
Warehouse Arts District
North .0625 Mi .125 Mi
Map 3.1
-
8/13/2019 Buchanan DTLawrenceDesign Final
27/69
27
Figure 3.4Source:
hilgerproperties.com
Figure 3.3Source: Lawrence
Warehouse Arts District
Warehouse Arts District Land-Use Requirements
Goal 3.1: Mixed-Uses
Promote a viable mix of uses that promote living, working, and
playing.
Policy 3.1.1: Mixed-use development shall provide office or
retail space on the ground level, and either multi-family
residential, office, or retail space on all upper levels.
Goal 3.2: Creative Class Accommodations
Provide space for artists to live, work, and sell/display their art.
Policy 3.2.1: Any mixed-use property in the district shall be
permitted to provide artists studio/dwelling units, whichare
designed for and are occupied by not more than one family
and include adequate working space reserved for the artist
or artists residing therein. Retail and gallery uses are not
permitted within the studio/dwelling unit. See Figure B5 in
Appendix B for model layout.
Policy 3.2.2: A professional artist may maintain a studio as
accessory to his or her dwelling in a single-family residential
zone if the A hobby artist may maintain a studio if by
nature it qualifies as incidental and accessory to the
residential use.
Policy 3.2.3: The following arts-oriented uses are permitted
outright in the districtsmixed-use zone: galleries, studios,movie theaters (single screen), stage theater, music venues,
design firms, recording studios, art schools, culinary schools,
dance studios, and art incubators. A maximum capacity of
500 seats applies to all theaters/performance venues.
Goal 3.3: Intensity
Minimize any adverse impacts that development or
redevelopment may have on single-family residential
neighborhoods south of the district.
Policy 3.2.1: High intensity (greater than 8:1 FAR)commercial, residential or mixed-uses shall be buffered by
lower intensity uses such as green spaces, low intensity
(1.25:1 FAR or lower) commercial or medium intensity (3:1
FAR) multi-family residential uses.
Appropriate Land-Uses for
the Warehouse Arts District
Figure 3.5Source: Black
Trumpet Bistro
-
8/13/2019 Buchanan DTLawrenceDesign Final
28/69
28
Warehouse Arts District Land-Use Requirements (Continued)
Goal 3.4: Downtown Living
Encourage a growing and diverse residential population
Policy 3.4.1: All future development in the district thatexceeds an FAR of 4:1 must comprise at least 50 percent
multi-family usage, with at least 50 percent of which must be
dedicated as affordable housing.
Policy 3.4.2: All future development in the district that
exceeds an FAR of 6:1 must comprise at least 50 percent
affordable multi-family usage, with at least 50 percent of
which must be dedicated as artists studio/dwelling unitsor
student housing.
Appropriate Land-Uses for
the Warehouse Arts District
Figure 3.7Source: Black
Trumpet Bistro
Figure 3.8Source: Struct/Restruct
The Warehouse District should support ongoing neighborhoodrevitalization efforts, including Struct/Restruct projects like the one pictured
in Figure 3.8. Support can be provided by developing urban design
policies that allow the flexibility for artistic expression and economic
growth, while still providing a high standard for design quality.
Figure 3.6Source:Wonderlane, Flickriver
-
8/13/2019 Buchanan DTLawrenceDesign Final
29/69
29
Ma 3.2
-
8/13/2019 Buchanan DTLawrenceDesign Final
30/69
30
Warehouse Arts District Bulk Controls
Goal 3.5: Increased Density
Increase the districts density to capture downtown property
demand and allow the expansion of the downtown footprint.
Policy 3.5.1: All structures shall abide by the following
minimum and maximum height restrictions, which are tiered
based on the allowed FAR delineated by Map 3.3:
a. Structures restricted by a maximum FAR of 0.1:1 shallnot exceed one story (12 feet) in height.
b. Structures restricted by a maximum FAR of 1.25:1 shallnot exceed three stories (36 feet) in height.
c. Structures restricted by a maximum FAR of 3:1 shall beat least two stories (24 feet) in height and shall not
exceed four stories (48 feet) in height.
d. Structures restricted by a maximum FAR of 8:1 shall beat least four stories (48 feet) in height and shall not
exceed 10 stories (120 feet) in height.
Policy 3.5.2: Row houses shall be encouraged in residentially
zoned areas.
Goal 3.6: Pedestrian Oriented Scale
Ensure retail visibility and support pedestrian-scale development
Policy 3.6.1:All retail, office, mixed-use or row house
properties shall directly abut the sidewalk unless to allow the
following:a. Highlight Entrances: A minimum setback of four feet
from the sidewalk shall be allowed to highlightentrances or to provide wider sidewalks;
b. Corner Lots: A maximum setback of up to 10 feet from
the sidewalk on corner lots shall be allowed to provide
plaza space.
Appropriate Bulk for the
Warehouse Arts District
Figure 3.9 Source:
Iggmoe.com
Figure 3.10 Source:
Struct/Restruct
Figure 3.11 Source:
Brasch Barry
Where appropriate, row housing (Figure 3.9) should be
allowed to increase neighborhood density. Other areaswith lower density single-family detached units (Figure
3.10) should be preserved to maintain established
neighborhood character. Such areas are demarcated
by Map 3.3.
-
8/13/2019 Buchanan DTLawrenceDesign Final
31/69
31
Map 3.3
-
8/13/2019 Buchanan DTLawrenceDesign Final
32/69
32
Warehouse Arts District Faade Controls
Goal 3.7: Architectural Integrity
Strengthen neighborhood character established by historic
buildings, while fostering creative expressions on the built-
environment.
Policy 3.7.1: Alterations or additions to buildings listed as
contributing structures of the East Lawrence Industrial Historic
District or the North Rhode Island Historic District shall be
conducted following The Secretary of the Interiors
Standards for the Treatment of Historic Properties.
Policy 3.7.2: Materials, massing, colors, and detailing of the
original structure shall guide the design of additions or
alterations of historic structures.
Policy 3.7.3: Historic architectural features of historic buildings
shall be retained and repaired, rather than removed. If these
features are severely damaged, they shall be replaced with
features identical in appearance to the original features.
Policy 3.7.4: Where buildings within the block face establish
regular pattern of windows, floor height, or other building
details, new or remodeled buildings shall remain consistent
with these regular patterns.
Policy 3.7.5: Primary exterior building materials for new
construction shall include wood or masonry units (brick,stone, tile, or split face alternate course concrete). If panel
materials are used, each panel shall not exceed a maximum
of nine square feet.
Goal 3.8: Pedestrian Oriented Windows
Ensure retail visibility that supports the pedestrian-scale.
Policy 3.8.1: Display windows must be included in all
commercial property street level faades.
Policy 3.8.2: Faades and street fronting walls shall contain aminimum of 60 percent transparent windows. Upper floor
facades shall contain a minimum of 40 percent transparent
windows or fixed glass. Windows fronting streets or the
riverfront shall use transparent, non-reflective and non-tinted
materials.
Figure 3.12 Source:Liberty Real Estate
Appropriate Faades for
the Warehouse Arts District
Figure 3.13 Source: Film
Commission of Greater
Kansas City
Figure 3.14 Source: My
Scene KC
-
8/13/2019 Buchanan DTLawrenceDesign Final
33/69
33
Warehouse Arts District Faade Controls (Continued)
Goal 3.9: Pedestrian Oriented Design
Present visually interesting architectural features and patterns
designed to reduce mass and scale.
Policy 3.9.1: All buildings greater than four stories must have
a recognizable "base" consisting of (but not limited to):
a. thicker walls, ledges or sills;
b. integrally textured, colored, and patterned materials;
c. lighter or darker colored materials, mullions or panels;
d. cornices/caps
e. planters;
f. plinth treatments;
g. commercial street level property bases shall have
display windows which abide by Policy: 3.7.1-3.7.2.
Policy 3.9.2: All buildings greater than four stories must have
a recognizable "middle" consisting of (but not limited to):
a. Building middle cap;
b. integrally textured, colored, and/or patterned
materials which differentiate from the base and top;
c. windows which contrast from the base through
exposed lintels, sills, shape, and proportions.Overall
wall composition within for Building Middles shall
contain at least 30%, but no more than 60% glazing.
Policy 3.9.3: All buildings higher than 4 stories must have arecognizable "top" consisting of (but not limited to):
a. cornice treatments, other than colored "stripes" or
"bands" alone, with integrally textured materials;
b. sloping roof with overhangs and brackets;
c. stepped parapets.
Policy 3.9.4: Large areas of blank wall shall be avoided by
design accents such as windows, panels, pilasters,
trellises, murals or other faade articulations which will
reduce the overall scale appearance.
Policy 3.9.5: Awnings that overhang windows or entries on
street level facades shall be constructed of canvas or heavy
cloth. No color restrictions.
Appropriate Faades for
the Warehouse Arts District
Figure 3.15 Source: Marriott
Figure 3.16 Source: The
Sherbert Group
Figure 3.17 Source:
Robert K. Chin
-
8/13/2019 Buchanan DTLawrenceDesign Final
34/69
34
Warehouse Arts District Faade Controls (Continued)
Goal 3.10: Building Materials
Buildings should be made of high-quality and attractive
materials.
Policy 3.10.1: All new construction (excluding single-family
homes), shall exhibit at least 70 percent brick (traditional red-
clay colors). Brick may be painted over with colors
approved by the district design review board.
Policy 3.10.1: Side or rear exterior walls in street view shall not
be made of inferior or lesser quality materials from the front
faade.
Policy 3.10.2: Allowed faade building materials include:
brick, stucco, wood siding, decorative CMUs (concrete
masonry units), and non-reflective glass (cumulative surface
area of less than 40 percent of all exterior walls). The
following materials are expressly prohibited: vinyl siding,
reflective glass, asphalt siding, aluminum lap siding, and
siding grade plywood. Materials not listed are subject to
approval of the district design review board.
Policy 3.10.3: Corrugated metal may be used to reinforce an
artistic design theme, but must make up a cumulative
surface area of less than 25 percent of all exterior walls.
Policy 3.10.4: Murals and outdoor sculpture are strongly
encouraged and shall be subject to approval by the
districts design review board.
Policy 3.10.5: Proposed faade construction or alterations
must be approved by the districts design review board.
Appropriate Faades for
the Warehouse Arts District
Figure 3.18 Source: Art
Observer
Figure 3.19 Source: Erika
Singer Burke
Figures 3.18 and 3.19 illustrate
colorful murals covering the
entire faade. These forms of
artistic expression should be
encouraged within the
warehouse arts district.
-
8/13/2019 Buchanan DTLawrenceDesign Final
35/69
35
Warehouse Arts District Environmental Requirements
Goal 3.11: Shadows
Adverse shadow effects caused by multi-story properties should
be mitigated to ensure adequate sunlight.
Policy 3.11.1: A preliminary shadow analysis conducted by a
neutral third party consultant shall be required for all
proposed development greater than 45tall, in order for the
districts design review boardto determine if a shadow
threat on neighboring properties warrants additional
analysis.
Policy 3.11.2: Shadowing shall not be allowed to adversely
impact single-family residential districts or green spaces
delineated by Map 2.2. Adverse impacts shall be
determined by a shadow analysis conducted by a neutral
third party consultant.
Goal 3.12: Sustainability
Construct an environmentally sustainable built environment.
Policy 3.12.1: Parking structures with open top decks shall
integrate photovoltaic panels and/or roof gardens to
capture storm water runoff.
Policy 3.12.2: Buildings shall be permitted to integrate
photovoltaic panels and/or roof gardens to capture storm
water runoff.
Policy 3.12.3: Photovoltaic panels must not be visible from
the street, unless they are incorporated into art and
approved by the District Design Review Board.
Appropriate
Environmental Features for
the Warehouse Arts District
Figure 3.21 Source:
Annamog.blogspot.com
Figure 3.20 Source: Trudden
Technology
-
8/13/2019 Buchanan DTLawrenceDesign Final
36/69
36
Warehouse Arts District Streetscape Requirements
Goal 3.13: Pedestrian Oriented Layout
Ensure a walkable, pedestrian oriented environment.
Policy 3.13.1: A building or permitted projection may projectover the required sidewalk easement above a height of 40
and below a depth of 5 to accommodate street trees.
Policy 3.13.2: Streetscapes shall provide a minimum 6wide
continuous path of travel and 18-24 wide access zone next
to the curb, which includes a 6 curb and 12 wide brick
edge band adjacent to the back of curb.
Policy 3.13.3: Streetscapes in commercial or mixed-use
zoned areas shall provide a minimum 10wide continuous
path of travel and 18-24 wide access zone next to the curb,
which includes a 6 curb and 12 wide brick edge band
adjacent to the back of curb.
Policy 3.13.4: All pedestrian level lighting shall be unique or
artistic in nature so it may serve as public art. Lighting shall
be selected by the Warehouse Arts District Design Board.
Policy 3.13.5: Street trees shall be provided on all streets
(except on alleys) and shall be planted approximately 3 ft.
behind the curb line. Spacing should be an average of no
more than 30 ft. on center (measured per block face). The
minimum caliper size for each tree should be 3 in. and aminimum of 12 ft. in height at planting. Species selected
should be native, drought and disease tolerant.
Goal 3.14: Pedestrian Amenities
Encourage street level activity that embraces art, culture, and
entertainment.
Policy 3.14.1: Space for outdoor dining, retail, or live music
may occur on any portion of the paved sidewalk provided a
minimum 6 wide continuous path of travel is maintained.
Appropriate Streetscape
Elements for the
Warehouse Arts District
Figure 3.22 Source:
houzz.com
Figure 3.23 Source: scoop.it
-
8/13/2019 Buchanan DTLawrenceDesign Final
37/69
37
Warehouse Arts District Streetscape Requirements (Continued)
Policy 3.14.2: Bulb-outs shall be provided on every street
corner on Pennsylvania and Delaware streets (between 8th
and 9th), 7th street (between New Hampshire and New Jersey
streets), and 8thand 9thstreets (between New Hampshireand Delaware). Bulb-outs must provide space for sculpture
or water feature, trash receptacles, lighting, bike racks, and
planters with ledge seating (4 person minimum capacity).
Policy 3.14.3: Space for seating shall be provided no more
than every 30 ft. on Pennsylvania and Delaware streets
(between 8thand 9th), 7th street (between New Hampshire
and New Jersey streets), and 8thand 9thstreets (between
New Hampshire and Delaware). Each block face shall
provide seating capacity for at least 15 people, includingbulb-out seating. Seating may be provided by benches,
planter ledges, fountain ledges, or street sculpture.
Policy 3.13.4: Street art shall be permitted provided a
minimum 6 wide continuous path of travel is maintained
and the street art is approved by the district design review
board.
Appropriate Streetscape
Elements for the
Warehouse Arts District
Figure 3.24 Source:
walkoverstates.wordpress.com
Figure 3.25 Source:
Times Union
Figure 3.26 Source: Intriguing News
Street performances, as illustrated in figure 3.26, may be encouraged within the
Warehouse Arts District by providing ample performance space. Figures B2 through B4 in
Appendix B should be used as a guide for streetscape development along Pennsylvania
and Delaware streets (between 8thand 9th), 7th street (between New Hampshire and
New Jersey streets), and 8thand 9thstreets (between New Hampshire and Delaware).
-
8/13/2019 Buchanan DTLawrenceDesign Final
38/69
38
Warehouse Arts District Parking Requirements
Goal 3.15: Parking Arrangements
Provide ample on-street and off-street parking in places that
limit visibility and congestion as not to undermine the pedestrian
experience.
Policy 3.15.1: Surface lots are prohibited except for
residential properties (not mixed-use) with fewer than 25
dwelling units.
Policy 3.15.2: Except for on-street parking and the minimum
ground-level frontage required for access to garages and
loading, no parking or loading shall be visible on the ground
floor of any building faade that faces a retail street. Parking
structures shall provide habitable floor area along all retail
street frontages.
Policy 3.15.3: Parking, loading or circulation located above
the ground floor shall be lined by habitable floor area along
all street frontages. If the project developer demonstrates
that it is not feasible to line the parking with habitable space
above the ground floor, it shall be integrated into the design
of the building faade and abide by Policy 3.7, to Policy 3.9.
Policy 3.15.4: Where parking above the ground floor that is
not lined with habitable space is permitted, a maximum of
three parking levels fronting on a public street shall be
allowed above the ground floor when FAR requirementspermit (sections 3.5-3.6).
Policy 3.14.5: Drive-through lanes are not permitted.
Goal 3.16: Structure Design
Parking structures will be visually appealing and blend in with
the surrounding built-environment.
Policy 3.16.1: Parking structures shall have an external skin
designed using the standards set forth in sections 3.7-3.10.
Policy 3.16.2: Elevator/stair corridors shall be located on
primary pedestrian corners and be highlighted
architecturally.
Policy 3.16.2: The design of public art and lighting shall be
integrated with the structures architecture to reinforce a
unique identity.
Appropriate Parking
Structures for the
Warehouse Arts District
Figure 3.24 Source: La Farge
Figure 3.25 Source:
beaconhillpatch.com
Figure 3.26 Source:
northparkscene.com
-
8/13/2019 Buchanan DTLawrenceDesign Final
39/69
39
Warehouse Arts District Signage Controls
Goal 3.17: Pedestrian Oriented Signage
Signage type and positioning should suit a pedestrian-oriented
environment.
Policy 3.17.1: Wall signs shall not project beyond 6 from the
wall surface.
Policy 3.17.2: Hanging signs will be limited to nine square feet
in area and may not project beyond four feet from the
building surface. Signs shall be placed between eight and
12 feet above grade.
Policy 3.17.3: Temporary window signs shall not exceed 25
percent of the window.
Policy 3.17.4: Temporary sandwich board signs (or A-frame
signs) shall be permitted as long as they do not interfere with
pedestrian movement or visibility along sidewalks.
Policy 3.17.5: Monument signs shall not exceed five feet in
height and 15 square feet in area. Monument signs in the
public right-of way shall not interfere with pedestrian
movement or visibility along sidewalks. Signs shall not block
motorists visibility along the sidewalk or roadway, or sight
lines at entry driveways and circulation aisles will not be
blocked.
Policy 3.17.6: Projecting signs shall not project beyond 6 (2
for wall signs) from the building and shall be located at least
6 from other projecting signs to maximize visibility. Projecting
signs shall be placed at a 90 degree angle from the building
surface and shall be located no lower than 8 from grade
and no higher than the cornice or roof line.
Policy 3.17.7: The following types of signs shall be prohibited
within the district: billboards, pole signs, portable signs
(except temporary signs listed in policies 3.16.3 and 3.16.4),
and any form of sign that flashes, flies, inflates, internallyilluminates or moves.
Policy 3.17.8: Digital signs less than 10 square feet in area
shall be permitted but must display static messages for a
minimum of 10 seconds with a 1-2 second fading transition.
Appropriate
Signage for the
Warehouse Arts District
Figure 3.27 Source: Poehler Lofts
Figure 3.28 Source: atmtxphoto.com
Figure 3.29 Source:
theragblog.blogspot.com
-
8/13/2019 Buchanan DTLawrenceDesign Final
40/69
40
Warehouse Arts District Signage Controls (Continued)
Goal 3.18: Signage Design
Sign quality should complement the district character.
Policy 3.18.1: Monument signs shallbe
accented withlandscaping equal to two square feet for every one square
foot of sign face and include a supporting base composed
of allowed building materials listed in Policy 3.9.2.
Policy 3.18.2: Sign materials shall be extremely durable.
Permissible materials include: painted or carved wood;
carved wooden letters; epoxy letters; galvanized sheet
metal; slate, marble, or sandstone; gold leaf; gilt, painted,
stained, or sandblasted glass; clear and colored acrylic;
neon; stained glass; or other proposed materials approved
by the district design review board. Paper and cloth signs
shall be prohibited for exterior use (except high quality,
weather-resistant canvas for awnings). Wood signs should be
sealed to prevent deterioration from moisture.
Policy 3.18.3: All new permanent signs (including awning
signs) shall be reviewed and approved by the district design
review board, as part of the sign permitting process. The
board shall approve signs based on whether they
complement or contribute to the district character as it has
been described by Chapter 3 of this document.
Goal 3.19: Signage UniformityPublic signage should unify the district by exhibiting consistent
design elements which promote the district identity.
Policy 3.19.1: Light poles, parking meters, banners, street
signage, way-finding markers, paving graphics, and any
other form of public signage shall be unique to the district by
exhibiting consistent traditional designs that complement
the districts historic integrity. Public signage shall be
approved by the district design review board.
Policy 3.19.2: Public signage identified in Policy 3.18.1 shallexhibit unique design by incorporating consistent colors and
fonts.
Policy 3.19.3: Nonconforming signage replacement shall be
amortized over 5 years upon the adoption of this plan.
Appropriate
Signage for the
Warehouse Arts District
The following signs are
exempt from signage
policy due to their unique
historical contributions:
Poehler Mercantile Sign
Figure 3.30 Source:
askmissa.com
Figure 3.31 Source: Emily Bell
Figure 3.32 Source: David Boyer
-
8/13/2019 Buchanan DTLawrenceDesign Final
41/69
41
Warehouse Arts District Financing Tools & Project Prioritization
PriorityLevel Project Financing Tool
High Mixed-Use and Multi-Family Residential
Redevelopment Projects
Tax-Increment Financing (TIF)
High Sidewalk Seating/Planters, Trash
Receptacles along Pennsylvania,
Delaware, 7th, 8th, and 9thstreets
BID
High District-Unified Way-finding System Business Improvement District (BID)
High Public Sculpture/Art along
Pennsylvania, Delaware, 7th, 8th, and
9thstreets
BID
High Parking Garage(s) Revenue Bonds, TransportationDevelopment District (TDD)
Medium District Unified Public Signage/Banners BID
Medium Undergrounding Utility Poles User Fees4% Utilities Bill Surcharge
City-wide (in cooperation with utility
companies)
Medium Bike Racks, Bike Awareness Street
Signage/Striping along Pennsylvania,
Delaware, 7th, 8th, and 9thstreets
TDD, Transportation Alternatives
(TAP) Grant (if awarded)
Medium Plaza Space at SE Corner of 8thand
Pennsylvania
BID
Low Decorative Sidewalk Improvementsalong Pennsylvania, Delaware, 7th, 8th,
and 9thstreets
TDD, TAP Grant (if awarded)
Low Decorative Street Improvements
along Pennsylvania, Delaware, 7th, 8th,
and 9thstreets
TDD
Low Faade Improvement Revolving Loan
Fund
BID, User Fees
Table 3.1District Project Prioritization and Financing
For financing tool definitions, see Appendix A.
For Downtown-wide project prioritization, see Appendix D.
-
8/13/2019 Buchanan DTLawrenceDesign Final
42/69
42
Figure 4.1Source: growomaha.com
Figure 4.2Source: Trettel Design
Figures 4.1 and 4.3 illustrate a future vision of the Riverfront
District, which is partly inspired by the modern design of existing
N. Lawrence properties designed by local architect Scott Trettel
(Figure 4.2).
Figure 4.3Source: Arnold Imaging
4.0 The Riverside DistrictTo help alleviate demand for growth downtown, adjacent areas like the riverside area
of North Lawrence could be redeveloped to accommodate higher density residential,
office, retail and mixed uses. With views of the river and downtown, this area offers
great potential. The districts boundaries aim to capture areas near the river and the N.
2nd
Street arterial route. Similar to the Warehouse Arts District, the majority of propertiescurrently within this area are older single-family homes. Plans would preserve a relatively
low density residential environment certain areas, while encouraging higher intensities
on higher volume routes and on the river. Depending on demand, new development
should allow for residential, office, retail, or mixed-uses. Density and design of new
development adjacent to single-family homes will be controlled to ensure a level of
congruity. Design guidelines will be influenced by established North Lawrence
properties designed by local architect Scott Trettel.
-
8/13/2019 Buchanan DTLawrenceDesign Final
43/69
43
Riverside District
North .1 Mi .2 Mi
N.2nd
N.3rd
N.4th
N.5th
N.1st
Walnut
Elm
Locust
MaplePerryLincoln
Pleasant
LyonMap 4.1
-
8/13/2019 Buchanan DTLawrenceDesign Final
44/69
-
8/13/2019 Buchanan DTLawrenceDesign Final
45/69
45
Map 4.2
-
8/13/2019 Buchanan DTLawrenceDesign Final
46/69
-
8/13/2019 Buchanan DTLawrenceDesign Final
47/69
47
Map 4.3
North
.1 Mi .2 Mi
Riverside District Boundary0%50%75%50%
Minimum Lot Coverage0.1:11.25:13:18:1
Maximum FAR
Riverside DistrictFAR/Lot Coverage Map
-
8/13/2019 Buchanan DTLawrenceDesign Final
48/69
48
Riverside District Faade Controls
Goal 4.7: Architectural Integrity
Strengthen emerging neighborhood character being
established by existing modern-styled North Lawrence
properties designed by local architect Scott Trettel.
Policy 4.7.1: New infill buildings or exterior renovations of
existing structures shall exhibit only modern architectural
features, unless the structure was built prior to 1950.
Goal 4.8: Pedestrian Oriented Retail
Ensure retail visibility and support pedestrian-scale development
Policy 4.8.1: Display windows must be included in all
commercial property street level faades.
Policy 4.8.2: Faades and street or river fronting walls shall
contain a minimum of 60 percent transparent windows or
fixed glass. Windows fronting streets or the riverfront shall use
transparent, non-reflective and non-tinted materials.
Goal 4.9: Pedestrian Oriented Design
Present visually interesting architectural features and patterns
designed to reduce mass and scale.
Policy 4.9.1: All buildings greater than four stories must have
a recognizable "base" consisting of (but not limited to):
a. thicker walls, ledges or sills;b. integrally textured, colored, and patterned materials;
c. lighter or darker colored materials, mullions or panels;
d. cornices/caps
e. planters;
f. plinth treatments;
g. commercial street level property bases shall have
display windows which abide by Policy: 4.7.1-4.7.2.
Policy 4.9.2: All buildings greater than four stories must have
a recognizable "middle" consisting of (but not limited to):
a. Building middle cap;b. integrally textured, colored, and/or patterned
materials which differentiate from the base and top;
c. windows which contrast from the base through sills,
shape, and/or proportions.Overall wall composition
within for Building Middles shall contain at least 30
percent, but no more than 60 percent glazing.
Appropriate Faades
for the Riverside District
Figure 4.10 Source:
Kundig Architects
Figure 4.9 Source:
Liberty Real Estate
Figure 4.11 Source:
Rows at SoMa
-
8/13/2019 Buchanan DTLawrenceDesign Final
49/69
-
8/13/2019 Buchanan DTLawrenceDesign Final
50/69
50
Riverside District Environmental Requirements
Goal 4.11: Shadows
Adverse shadow effects caused by multi-story properties should
be mitigated to ensure adequate sunlight.
Policy 4.11.1: A preliminary shadow analysis conducted by a
neutral third party consultant shall be required for all
proposed development greater than 45tall, in order for the
districtsdesign review board to determine if a shadow
threat on neighboring properties warrants additional
analysis.
Policy 4.11.2: Shadowing shall not be allowed to adversely
impact single-family residential districts or green spaces
delineated by Map 4.2. Adverse impacts shall be
determined by a shadow analysis conducted by a neutral
third party consultant.
Goal 4.12: Sustainability
Construct an environmentally sustainable built environment.
Policy 4.12.1: Parking structures with open top decks shall
integrate photovoltaic panels and/or roof gardens to
capture storm water runoff.
Policy 4.12.2: Buildings shall be permitted to integrate
photovoltaic panels and/or roof gardens to capture storm
water runoff.
Policy 4.12.3: Photovoltaic panels must not be visible from
the street, unless they are incorporated into art or building
design and are approved by the districts design review
board.
Appropriate
Environmental Features
for the Riverside District
Figure 4.15 Source:
Hammerlikeagirl.wordpress.com
Figure 4.16 Source:
besthousedesign.com
-
8/13/2019 Buchanan DTLawrenceDesign Final
51/69
51
Riverside District Streetscape Requirements
Goal 4.13: Pedestrian Oriented Layout
Ensure a walkable, pedestrian-oriented environment throughout
the district.
Policy 4.13.1: A building or permitted projection may project
over the required sidewalk easement above a height of 40
and below a depth of 5 to accommodate street trees.
Policy 4.13.2: Streetscapes shall provide a minimum 6wide
continuous path of travel and 18-24 wide access zone next
to the curb, which includes a 6 curb and 12 wide brick
edge band adjacent to the back of curb.
Policy 4.13.3: Streetscapes in commercial or mixed-use
zoned areas shall provide a minimum 10wide continuous
path of travel and 18-24 wide access zone next to the curb,
which includes a 6 curb and 12 wide brick edge band
adjacent to the back of curb.
Policy 4.13.4: All pedestrian level lighting shall be modern in
nature so it corresponds to the surrounding architecture.
Lighting shall be selected by the district design review
board.
Policy 4.13.5: Street trees shall be provided on all streets
(except on alleys) and shall be planted approximately 3 ft.
behind the curb line. Spacing should be an average of nomore than 30 ft. on center (measured per block face). The
minimum caliper size for each tree should be 3 in. and a
minimum of 12 ft. in height at planting. Species selected shall
be native, drought and disease tolerant.
Goal 4.14: Pedestrian Amenities
Encourage street level activity that embraces art, culture, and
entertainment.
Policy 4.14.1: Space for outdoor dining, retail, or live music
may occur on any portion of the paved sidewalk provided aminimum 6 wide continuous path of travel is maintained.
Appropriate
Streetscape Elements
for the Riverside District
Figure 4.17 Source:
Dan Heller
Figure 4.18 Source:
vi.sualize.us
Figure 4.19 Source:
Matt Buchanan
-
8/13/2019 Buchanan DTLawrenceDesign Final
52/69
52
Riverside District Streetscape Requirements (Continued)
Policy 4.14.2: Bulb-outs shall be provided on every street
corner on N. 2ndStreet (between Lyon and Elm), Locust
Street (between N. 2ndand N. 5th), and any future streets
constructed that provide access to new developmentbetween the river and N. 2nd. Bulb-outs must provide space
for sculptures or water features, trash receptacles, lighting,
bike racks, and planters with ledge seating (8 person
minimum capacity).
Policy 4.14.3: Space for seating shall be provided no more
than every 30 ft. on N. 2ndStreet (between Lyon and Elm),
Locust Street (between N. 2ndand N. 5th), and any future
streets constructed that provide access to new
development between the river and N. 2nd. Each block faceshall provide seating capacity for at least 15 people,
including bulb-out seating. Seating may be provided by
benches, planter ledges, fountain ledges, or street sculpture.
Policy 4.14.4: Water features shall be permitted provided a
minimum 6 wide continuous path of travel is maintained
and the water feature is approved by the district design
review board.
Appropriate
Streetscape Elements
for the Riverside District
Figure 4.21 Source:
Figure 4.20 Source: Fresh Tilt
Figure 4.21 Source: Jyoti,
Blogger.com
Figure 4.22 Source: Urbanrelations.info
Multiple public fountains and water features, as illustrated in figures 4.21 and 4.22,
should unify the district around a common identity. Figures B2 through B4 in Appendix B
should be used as a guide for streetscape development along N. 2ndStreet (between
Lyon and Elm), Locust Street (between N. 2ndand N. 5th), and any future streets
constructed that provide access to new development between the river and N. 2nd.
-
8/13/2019 Buchanan DTLawrenceDesign Final
53/69
53
Riverside District Parking Requirements
Goal 4.15: Parking Arrangements
Provide ample on-street and off-street parking in places that
limit visibility and congestion as not to undermine the pedestrian
experience.
Policy 4.15.1: Surface lots are prohibited except for
residential properties (not mixed-use) with fewer than 25
dwelling units.
Policy 4.15.2: Except for on-street parking and the minimum
ground-level frontage required for access to garages and
loading, no parking or loading shall be visible on the ground
floor of any building faade that faces a retail street. Parking
structures shall provide habitable floor area along all retail
street frontages.
Policy 4.15.3: Parking, loading or circulation located above
the ground floor shall be lined by habitable floor area along
all street frontages. If the project developer demonstrates
that it is not feasible to line the parking with habitable space
above the ground floor, it shall be integrated into the design
of the building faade and abide by policies 4.7 through 4.9.
Policy 4.15.4: Where parking above the ground floor that is
not lined with habitable space is permitted, a maximum of
three parking levels fronting on a public street shall be
allowed above the ground floor when FAR requirementspermit (sections 4.5-4.6).
Policy 4.15.5: Drive-through lanes are not permitted.
Goal 4.16: Structure Design
Parking structures will be visually appealing and blend in with
the surrounding built-environment.
Policy 4.16.1: Parking structures shall have an external skin
designed using the standards set forth in sections 4.7 through
4.10.
Policy 4.16.2: Elevator/stair corridors shall be located on
primary pedestrian corners and be highlighted
architecturally.
Policy 4.16.2: The design of public art and lighting shall be
integrated with the structures architecture to reinforce a
unique identity.
Appropriate Parking
Structures for the
Riverside District
Figure 4.23 Source:
Tree Hugger
Figure 4.24 Source:Sampson Construction
-
8/13/2019 Buchanan DTLawrenceDesign Final
54/69
54
Riverside District Signage Controls
Goal 4.17: Pedestrian Oriented Signage
Signage type and positioning should suit a pedestrian-oriented
environment.
Policy 4.17.1: Wall signs shall not project beyond 6 from the
wall surface.
Policy 4.17.2: Hanging signs will be limited to nine square feet
in area and may not project beyond four feet from the
building surface. Signs shall be placed between eight and
12 feet above grade.
Policy 4.17.3: Temporary window signs shall not exceed 25
percent of the window.
Policy 4.17.4: Temporary sandwich board signs (or A-frame
signs) shall be permitted as long as they do not interfere with
pedestrian movement or visibility along sidewalks.
Policy 4.17.5: Monument signs shall not exceed five feet in
height and 15 square feet in area. Monument signs in the
public right-of way shall not interfere with pedestrian
movement or visibility along sidewalks. Signs shall not block
motorists visibility along the sidewalk or roadway, or sight
lines at entry driveways and circulation aisles will not be
blocked.
Policy 4.17.6: Projecting signs shall not project beyond 6 (2
for wall signs) from the building and shall be located at least
6 from other projecting signs to maximize visibility. Projecting
signs shall be placed at a 90 degree angle from the building
surface and shall be located no lower than 8 from grade
and no higher than the cornice or roof line.
Policy 4.17.7: The following types of signs shall be prohibited
within the district: billboards, pole signs, portable signs
(except temporary signs listed in policies 4.16.3 and 4.16.4),
roof signs, and any form of sign that flashes, flies, inflates, ormoves.
Policy 4.17.8: Digital signs less than 10 square feet in area
shall be permitted but must display static messages for a
minimum of 10 seconds with a 1-2 second fading transition.
Appropriate
Signage for the
Riverside District
Figure 4.25 Source: Jordan
Parnass Digital Architecture
Figure 4.26 Source: terryldesign.com
Figure 3.27 Source:
modernsigndesign.com
-
8/13/2019 Buchanan DTLawrenceDesign Final
55/69
55
Riverside District Signage Controls (Continued)
Goal 4.18: Signage Design
Sign quality should complement the district character.
Policy 4.17.1: Monument signs shallbe
accented withlandscaping equal to two square feet for every one square
foot of sign face and include a supporting base composed
of allowed building materials listed in Policy 4.9.2.
Policy 4.18.2: Sign materials shall be extremely durable.
Permissible materials include: painted or carved wood;
carved wooden letters; epoxy letters; galvanized sheet
metal; slate, marble, or sandstone; gold leaf; gilt, painted,
stained, or sandblasted glass; clear and colored acrylic;
neon; stained glass; or other proposed materials approved
by the district design review board. Paper and cloth signs
shall be prohibited for exterior use (except high quality,
weather-resistant canvas for awnings). Wood signs should be
sealed to prevent deterioration from moisture.
Policy 4.18.3: All new permanent signs (including awning
signs) shall be reviewed and approved by the district design
review board, as part of the sign permitting process. The
board shall approve signs based on whether they
complement or contribute to the district character as it has
been described by Chapter 4 of this document.
Goal 4.19: Signage UniformityPublic signage should unify the district by exhibiting consistent
design elements which promote the district identity.
Policy 4.19.1: Light poles, parking meters, banners, street
signage, way-finding markers, paving graphics, and any
other form of public signage shall be unique to the district by
exhibiting consistent traditional designs that complement
the districts historic integrity. Public signage shall be
approved by the district design review board.
Policy 4.19.2: Public signage identified in Policy 4.18.1 shallexhibit modern design by incorporating consistent colors
and one of the following modern fonts:
Century Gothic Impact Dotum Calibri
Policy 4.19.3: Nonconforming signage replacement shall be
amortized over 5 years upon the adoption of this plan.
Appropriate
Signage for the
Riverside District
Figure 4.28 Source:
Silicon Valley Lofts
Figure 3.28 Source: Emily Bell
Figure 3.29 Source: Integrated
Sign & Graphic, Inc.
-
8/13/2019 Buchanan DTLawrenceDesign Final
56/69
56
Riverside District Financing Tools & Project Prioritization
PriorityLevel Project Financing Tool
High Riverside Mixed-Use Redevelopment Tax-Increment Financing (TIF)
High Sidewalk Seating/Planters, Trash
Receptacles along N. 2ndand Locust
BID
High District-Unified Way-finding System Business Improvement District (BID)
High Parking Garages Revenue Bonds, Transportation
Development District (TDD)
Medium Undergrounding Utility Poles User Fees4% Utilities Bill Surcharge
Citywide (in cooperation with utility
companies)
Medium Bike Racks, Bike Awareness StreetSignage/Striping along N. 2ndand
Locust
TDD, Transportation Alternatives(TAP) Grant (if awarded)
Medium Public Bike Rental Program User Fees, TDD
Medium District Unified Public Signage/Banners BID
Medium Plaza at NE Corner of N. 2ndat Locust BID
Low Decorative Sidewalk Improvements
along N. 2ndand Locust
TDD, TAP Grant (if awarded)
Low Public Sculpture/Art along N. 2ndand
Locust
BID
Low Decorative Street Improvements
along N. 2ndand Locust.
TDD
Table 2.1District Project Prioritization and Financing
For financing tool definitions, see Appendix A.
For Downtown-wide project prioritization, see Appendix D.
-
8/13/2019 Buchanan DTLawrenceDesign Final
57/69
57
Appendix A:
Glossary of Terms
Adaptive Re-Use: conversion of a building into a use other than that for which it was
designed, such as changing a warehouse into a gallery space or housing.
Affordable housing: Rental housing with rents controlled so residents do not have to pay
more than 30 percent of the households annual income.
Animation: a quality of the built environment which supports sustained activity through
the architectural and artistic embellishment of materials and details, the visual and
physical accessibility of interior activities from the exterior, and the introduction of
supportive public facilities and amenities.
Areas of Archaeological Potential: Areas favorable with medium or high potential for
the discovery of archaeological resources. This potential is based on the presence of awide range of geographic and historical features which influenced past settlement.
Archaeological potential is confirmed through archaeological assessment.
Area of Sign: the total area within the extreme perimeter of the attraction area
intended to draw attention to the sign, including all open spaces and the supports
which the sign rests upon.
Artist: A person who is regularly engaged in the visual, performing or creative arts.
ArtistsStudio/Dwellinga combination working studio and dwelling unit for artists. An
artists dwelling unit consists of a room or suite of rooms on one or more floors designedfor and occupied by not more than one family and including adequate working space
reserved for the artist or artists residing therein.
Awning: any structure, such as canvas, projecting from the wall of a building over a
window or entrance.
Barrier-Free Design: building and site design which is accessible to all people, regardless
of age and abilities.
Bay: a vertical division of a faade or a structure division of a building, marked by
column spacing, roof compartments, windows or similar measures.
Boulevard: the portion of land on either side of a street, between the curb and the
property line, and may include sidewalk.
Buffer: a strip of land established to provide separation between land uses and typically
developed as a landscaped area.
-
8/13/2019 Buchanan DTLawrenceDesign Final
58/69
58
Building Envelope: the volume of space that may be occupied by a building, usually
defined by a series of dimensional requirements such as setback, stepback, permitted
maximum height, maximum permitted lot coverage.
Business Improvement Districts (BIDs): geographically defined areas in which property
owners agree to pay an assessment in addition to property taxes to fund cleaning
streets, providing security, making capital improvements, construction of pedestrian
and streetscape enhancements, and marketing the area. These services supplement
those provided by City government.
Canopy: a permanent fixture designed to shelter pedestrians and display goods from
adverse weather conditions; a fixed awning.
Circulation: movement patterns of pedestrian and vehicular traffic.
Compatibility: the characteristics of different designs which, despite their differences
allow them to be located near each other in harmony, such as scale, height, materials,
fencing, landscaping and location of service areas.
Cornice: an ornamental molding along the top of a wall.
Cultural Heritage Landscape: A defined geographical area of heritage significance
which has been modified by human activities.
Such an area is valued by a community, and is of significance to the understanding of
the history of a people or place.
Design Guidelines: criteria established to guide development toward a desired level of
quality through the design of the physical environment, and which are applied on adiscretionary basis relative to the context of development.
Digital Sign: sign that displays still images, scrolling images, or moving images, including
video or animation, through a series of grid lights, including cathode ray, light emitting
diode display, liquid crystal display, plasma screen, fiber optic, or other electronic
media or technology, where the display can be changed through electronic means.
Districts: geographic areas of relatively consistent character, such as exhibited in many
residential neighborhoods and the downtowns.
Drip Line: The outer boundary of an area on the surface of the ground that correspondsto the outer edge of the crown of the tree3
Elevation: a drawing showing an external face of a building.
Enclosure (sense of): an experience in which a pedestrian feels sheltered with a semi-
private realm. Buildings, trees, landscaping and street widths are all factors in creating a
sense of enclosure.
-
8/13/2019 Buchanan DTLawrenceDesign Final
59/69
59
Facades: the exterior wall of a building exposed to public view or that wall viewed by
persons not within the building.
Fenestration: the arrangement of windows in a building.
Floor Area Ratio (FAR): the relationship between the amount of useable floor areapermitted in a building (or buildings) and the area of the lot on which the building
stands. It is obtained by dividing the gross floor area of a building by the total area of
the lot.
Focal Point: a prominent structure, feature or area of interest or activity.
Gable: any basically triangular-shaped, upper part of a building wall, usually under a
pitched roof; sometimes upper walls topped with stepped parapets are referred to as
gables or stepped gables.
Gateway: the design of a building, site or landscape to symbolize an entrance or arrival
to a special district.
Hanging Sign: a sign suspended from a building or structure which is perpendicular or
parallel to the facade of the building.
Heritage Conservation: the activity undertaken to protect, safeguard, pass on or
enhance heritage resources.
Human Scale: the quality of the physical environment which reflects a sympathetic
proportional relationship to human dimensions and which contributes to the citizens
perception and comprehension of the size, scale, height, bulk and/or massing of
buildings or other features of the built environment.
Infill: the placement of new buildings into established built-up urban areas, which
usually results in an increase in the existing building stock.
Landmarks: buildings, structures and spaces which create distinct visual orientation
points that provide a sense of location to the observer within the neighborhood or
district, such as that created by a significant natural feature or by an architectural form
which is highly distinctive relative to its surrounding environment.
Mass: the combination of the three dimensions of length, height, and depth which give
a building its overall shape; a building is often composed of many masses, hence theterm massing, which is often used to describe the form or shape of structures.
Mixed Use: a development or area comprised of mixed land uses either in the same
building or in separate buildings on either the same lot or on separate lots or, at a larger
scale, in nodes.
-
8/13/2019 Buchanan DTLawrenceDesign Final
60/69
60
Modulation: variation in the plane of a building wall, often used to provide visual
interest.
Monument Sign: an independent structure supported from grade to the bottom of the
sign with the appearance of having a solid base.
Parapet: a portion of a wall that projects above a roof.
Pedestrian: all people on foot or moving at walking speed, including those who use
mobility aids (wheelchairs, scooters, etc.), persons with strollers and