bshf european end street homelessness campaign evaluation€¦ · the european end street...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that](https://reader030.vdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022040214/5eb8e5f6a04f5d4e024880fc/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
BSHFEuropeanEndStreetHomelessnessCampaignevaluationJimCoe&JeremySmith,November2017
![Page 2: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that](https://reader030.vdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022040214/5eb8e5f6a04f5d4e024880fc/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
2
contents
Summary.............................................................................................31 Introduction...................................................................................7
1.1 Purposeofthisreview.................................................................................................71.2 Reviewapproach.........................................................................................................71.3 Backgroundtothereview............................................................................................8
2 Strategyandstrategicassumptions................................................82.1 Campaignprinciples.....................................................................................................82.2 BSHF’sstrategicrole..................................................................................................13
3 Implementationandmanagement...............................................163.1 SupportBSHFprovides..............................................................................................163.2 Sharinglearningandtrackingprogress......................................................................18
4 Campaignoutcomes.....................................................................194.1 Improvedevidencebase............................................................................................194.2 Enhancedengagementandinterest..........................................................................204.3 Towardschangesinpolicyandpractice....................................................................234.4 Impactonpeoplewhoarestreethomeless..............................................................244.5 Commentaryonprogressandachievements............................................................26
5 Lookingahead..............................................................................275.1 Growingthecampaign...............................................................................................275.2 AEuropeancampaign?..............................................................................................295.3 Futurecoordinationapproachandstructures...........................................................305.4 Developingthestrategy.............................................................................................31
6 Recommendations........................................................................33Appendix1:Campaigntimeline.........................................................35Appendix2:Campaignprinciples.......................................................36Appendix3:Surveyresponses:campaignoutcomes..........................37Figure1:Partners’survey:Perspectivesonthecampaignprinciples.......................................9Figure2:Volunteers’viewsofthecampaign..........................................................................12Figure3:Partners’survey:FeedbackonBSHFsupport...........................................................16Figure4:Partners’survey:Feedbackonspecificresourcesupport........................................17Figure5:Volunteers’previousinvolvementinhomelessnessissues......................................22Figure6:Partners’survey:Perspectivesonbenefitstolocalhomelesspeople.....................25Figure7:Summarycampaigntimeline....................................................................................35Figure8:Partners’survey:Perspectivesoncampaignoutcomes...........................................37Figure9:Partners’survey:Perspectivesonorganisationalbenefits......................................37
![Page 3: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that](https://reader030.vdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022040214/5eb8e5f6a04f5d4e024880fc/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
3
Summary
INTRODUCTION TheEuropeanEndStreetHomelessnessCampaignisfundedandcoordinatedbyBSHF.Itwassetupontheprinciplethat“thetimehascometostopmanaginghomelessnessandstartendingit”.Thisevaluationfocusesonthefollowingmainareas:(a)Strategicassumptions(b)Campaigndeliveryandmanagement,and(c)Campaignoutcomes.Theevaluationdrawson: • Areviewofrelevantdocuments. • Asurveycompletedby8citypartnerorganisations(outof20thatreceivedit)from
across5cities. • Interviews(20intotal)withBSHFstaffandconsultants,strategicpartners,citylevel
partnersandvolunteersin4cities(Croydon,Valencia,TorbayandBrussels).• Ashortsurveyforvolunteersinvolvedinthecampaign,circulatedtovolunteersin
WestminsterandBarcelona,throughwhichwereceived111responsesintotal.
CAMPAIGN PRINCIPLES Thecampaignisdeeplyambitiousinitsgoaltoachievesystemicchange.Thesixcampaignprinciplesframethisambition,andsoitisencouragingthatsurveyfeedbacksuggeststhatpartnersstronglysupportallthecampaignprinciples. Thetwokeyorganisingprinciples–HousingFirstandcommunityinvolvement–arebothdeliberatelydisruptiveofthestatusquo.Contributorsstronglysupport(theneedfor)thiselementofdisruption. ThefactthatHousingFirsthasalreadysometractionandcredibilityishelpfulinreducingthepotentiallyalienatingeffectofthisdisruption.SurveyresultsshowthatpartnersstronglysupporttheHousingFirstapproachandstronglyagreethatthisprojectisupholdingtheapproachinpractice.Interviewfeedbackwasslightlymorenuanced,withsomestressingtheneedtomovefromthecurrentsituationtoasystemwhichincorporatesHousingFirst(butnotastheonlyapproach). Partnersshowedstrongbuyintotheprincipleofcommunityinvolvement,althoughinmanycasesthishasn’t(yet)extendedbeyondinvolvementinConnectionsWeeks.Volunteerssurveyedindicatedthattheywerewillingtoparticipateinthecampaigninfuture.Somewouldlikeopportunitiesforongoinginvolvementandseveralwerekeentohearmoreabouttheprogressofthecampaign. Itcouldbeclearerwhatthecommunityinvolvementexpectationsareinpractice.Somepartnersfeltthatcommunitymembers’ongoinginvolvementinthecampaignshouldbebetterintegratedfromthebeginning.
![Page 4: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that](https://reader030.vdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022040214/5eb8e5f6a04f5d4e024880fc/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
4
BSHF’S STRATEGIC ROLE Asanindependentvoice,BSHFiswellplacedtoinitiateandcoordinatethecampaign.ButsomepointedtothefactthatBSHFisnewtothefieldashavingsomepotentialdisadvantagesthatneedtobemanaged,notablyarounditsreachandcontactsacrossEuropeandthebreadthofcitieswhichareinvolved.Mostfeltthatcityselectionwasinitiallymadeonapragmaticratherthanastrategicbasis.Thismadesensepracticallybutithasskewedthegeographyofparticipatingcitiesinthecampaigntodate.ThereareearlysignsofthisnowshiftingtoamoreEuropean-wideapproach. Theflexibilitythatthecampaigngivestocitylevelpartnerscreatesapositivecontextforactionatthatlevel.
IMPLEMENTATION AND MANAGEMENT Thecampaignconcentratesattentionandhelpsraiseparticipants’morale.Partnersvaluethesenseofsolidaritythatbeingpartofthecampaignbrings.Forsome,itbringsaddedcredibilitytotheircitylevelwork. PartnersareverypositiveabouttheoverallsupportthatBSHFprovidesandaboutthespecificsupportpackagesonoffer.Partnersarepositiveabouthowlearningissharedbutsaythereisroomformore.Thereisanaturaltendencyforcitiestoexchangewithcitiesintheirowncountry,buttheremaybeincreasingopportunitytoextract-andmorewidelyshare-generalisablelessonsfromcities'experiences.Approachestotrackingandreportingshouldbefurtherdevelopedasthecampaigngrows.
CAMPAIGN OUTCOMES Thecampaignisbeginningtodemonstrateasetofoutcomesthatshowprogresstowardsthegoalofsecuringsustainablehousingforstreethomelesspeople. Forsomecities,conductingthestreetsurveyshasgeneratedvaluablenewdataandevidence. Inmanycities,therearepositivesignsofgrowthofinterestin,andsupportto,thecampaignanditsprinciplesfromlocalcivilsocietyorganisationsandassociations.Partnersmentionedthatthereisevidenceoflocalmediacoverageandsocialmediadissemination.CommunityengagementhasgenerallybeenstrongduringConnectionsWeeks.Inmostcases,effortsatinvolvingthecommunityinamoreongoingwayareintheirearlystages.Thisisanareathatmanycitiesarecommittedtodeveloping. Therearesomesignsthatmunicipalauthoritiesareengagingwiththecampaign.Therearesomeexamplesofapparentinfluenceonmunicipalauthorities’policyandpracticeemerging,but-notsurprisinglygiventhechallengesinvolved-progresstendstobeslowevenwherecommitmentsareinplace.
![Page 5: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that](https://reader030.vdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022040214/5eb8e5f6a04f5d4e024880fc/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
5
Therearesomeearly(butnotalwaystotallyclear)signsthatsmallnumbersofpeoplehavebeenbeinghousedasaresultofthecampaign(orthatthecampaignhasinsomewaycontributedtothis).Partnersmentionthatthereareotherbenefitstostreethomelesspeople–forexamplethroughthehumanisingexperienceofthesurveyengagement–butwehavelimitedinformationaboutthis.Thecampaignisnotyetachievingchangeatscalebutitwouldnotberealistictoexpecttoseethissosoon.Thereareenoughsignsofprogresstobeencouragedabouttheapproachbeingtaken.Inanumberofcities,shortageofhousingstock/landseemstobeakeybarrier.ItseemsthatevenwherecityauthoritiescollaboratecloselywithcampaignpartnersandsupportHousingFirst,theymaybeunabletoapplyitinpractice.
LOOKING AHEAD ThereisasetofconsiderationsandoptionsforBSHFaroundwhether,howandhowfast,andwhere,togrowthecampaign. Partnerssupportgrowthinthenumberofparticipatingcitiesinprinciplebutidentifysomeconcernsinpractice,includinginrelationtothecampaign’scapacitytosupportamuchlargernumberofcitieswhilebeingsurethatthosealreadyinvolvedhavereachedalevelofengagementsuchthattheirrelianceonBSHFislimited.Somefeltitwouldbehelpfultodemonstratesuccessmoredefinitivelybeforeexpandingthenumberofcitiesinvolved. Citylevelcampaignsseemtobemosteffectivewhentheybuildonexisting,iflatent,supportforchange.Therearesomestrategicchoicesthatthecampaignmightwanttomakearoundhowmuchtofocusontheareaswherethereismostlikelytobe(relatively)quickprogress.Asthecampaigngrows,theremayneedtobesomeadditionalcampaigncommunication(internallyandexternally)inlanguagesotherthanEnglish.Somepartnersseethepotentialtodevelopamorecoordinatedcampaigningapproach.Thecurrent,city-basedmodelisaviableonebutsomefeltthatcomplementingthiswithsomemorecentralisedadvocacyisanalternativeworthconsidering. Therearesomedifferentoptionsforhowthestructuralcoordinationofthecampaigncouldevolve.Alltheoptionshavesomeadvantagesbutnoneofthemprovideanobviousandclearrouteforward.It’sgoodthatresourcingtosupportthecampaignisinplaceoverthemediumterm–butthismaynotfullyresolvethequestionofresourcing,dependingondecisionsaboutthecampaign'sstrategicpurposeandthefuturerolethatBSHFwillplay. Nowisagoodtimetoreviewtheoverallcampaignstrategy.Thereareasetofinter-relatedchoicesabout(a)whatsortof‘campaign’itshouldbe
![Page 6: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that](https://reader030.vdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022040214/5eb8e5f6a04f5d4e024880fc/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
6
(b)whatthegrowthstrategyshouldbe(c)whatkindofstrategicpartnershipsshouldsupportnationallevelaction(d)whatresourcesareneededandwheretheyshouldcomefrom(e)thebestsystemsforsharinglearningandencouragingcross-fertilisation,andtherolethatBSHFshouldplayinthis.Thereisaquestionaboutwhoisinvolvedinconsideringfuturestrategy,withsomedifferentoptionsabouthowthatcouldbedone.
RECOMMENDATIONS 1. ReviewhowcampaignpositionsaroundHousingFirstaresetoutandcommunicated,to
ensurecommonunderstandingamongstparticipatingorganisations.
2. Developguidancethatencouragespartnerstoupdatevolunteersandotherinterestedpartnersoncampaignprogress.
3. Reviewhowcampaignpositionsaroundcommunityinvolvementaresetoutandcommunicated,toensurecommonunderstandingamongstparticipatingorganisations.
4. Considerpracticalwaystoencouragelearningopportunitiesbetweencities,boththroughBSHFandbilaterally,takingintoaccountdifferentiatedneeds(accordingtogeographyandhistoryofinvolvementforexample).
5. Developanapproachtocampaigntrackingandmonitoringthatsupportsbettergenerationofandaccesstoreal-timeinformation.Somepracticalstepscouldincludedeveloping:
• An‘outcomebank’withsomeguidanceonwhatoutcomesareofparticularinterest;
• Acampaign‘evidencedatabase’thatallcanaddto;• Supportandguidancearoundreviewinginformationinwaysthatfeedinto
planning;• Supporttoeffortstodevelopcasestudiesthatillustrateprogressbeingmade.
6. Considerdevelopingsomeprotocolsandguidancearoundcommunicatingdifficultmessages,suchasinrelationtomigrantsandrefugees.
7. Establish-aspartofcampaigntracking–asetofcommondefinitions/indicatorsthatclearlyexpressthechangesthecampaignseeks(whichwouldincludenumbersofpeoplehousedinHousingFirstaccommodation,butalsomeasurestodowithhowthathousingstatusissustained);andagreehowthatinformationwillberecordedandreported.
8. Considersettingupaprocessorforumtoconsidercommonchallengesandhowtoovercomebarrierslinkedtolimitsonhousingstockandland.
9. Developagrowthstrategythatsetsoutideasonthespeedandsequencingofexpansiontonewcitiesandthebestmixofcitiestoinvolve,andimplicationsarisingfromthis(aroundlanguageforexample).
10. Considerthepotentialforcomplementingcityleveladvocacywithsomecoordinatedadvocacythatdrawsonexperiencesacrosscities.
11. Considerwhetherandhowbesttoinvolvepartnersindevelopingstrategicoptions.
![Page 7: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that](https://reader030.vdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022040214/5eb8e5f6a04f5d4e024880fc/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
7
1 Introduction
1.1 PURPOSEOFTHISREVIEW
TheEuropeanEndStreetHomelessnessCampaignisfundedandcoordinatedbyBSHF.Itwassetupontheprinciplethat“thetimehascometostopmanaginghomelessnessandstartendingit”.Insupportofthisgoal,thecampaignhasbeen:• creatinggreaterawarenessofroughsleeping,thepeoplewhoareaffected,andwhat
canbedoneaboutit;• findinganddeliveringbetter,quickerwaystohelppeopleoffthestreets–inparticular
thosewithmultipleandcomplexneeds-andintopermanenthousing.1Inlinewithourproposal,thisevaluationfocusesonthefollowingmainareas(a)Strategicassumptions(b)Campaigndeliveryandmanagement,and(c)Campaignoutcomes.Insettingoutanenquiryframeworkinmoredetail,wenotedthat“itmakessensetofocusinparticularon• the‘interimoutcomes’(signsofprogresstowardsthelongertermgoal);and• theoverallapproachandimplementationofit(toestablishhowwellsetupthe
campaignistoachievetheresultsitseeks).Thisreportaddressestheseareasandfollowstheguidanceinthecallforproposalsthattheend-productreportshould“identifythestrengths,resultsandimpactofthecampaign'sworktodate,andrecommendanychangesorenhancementsthatwouldimprovethequality,reachandimpactofwhatwedo”.
1.2 REVIEWAPPROACH
Theevaluationdrawson:1/Areviewofrelevantdocuments.2/Asurveycompletedby8citypartnerorganisations(outof20thatreceivedit)fromacross5cities.Wehaveincludeddatafromthesurveythroughoutthereport,butgiventherelativelylowresponserate,weshouldnotethatfindingsmaynotnecessarilyberepresentativeofoverallopinionamongstcitypartners.1FromBSHF,callforproposals–oneyearfollowupevaluation
![Page 8: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that](https://reader030.vdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022040214/5eb8e5f6a04f5d4e024880fc/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
8
3/Interviews(20intotal)withBSHFstaffandconsultants,strategicpartners,citylevelpartnersandvolunteersin4cities(Croydon,Valencia,TorbayandBrussels).4/Ashortsurveyforvolunteersinvolvedinthecampaign,circulatedtovolunteersinWestminsterandBarcelona,throughwhichwereceived111responsesintotal.Thesurveywascompletedby34volunteersfromWestminsterand77fromBarcelona(whereitwasavailableinSpanishandCatalan).Thissurveywasnotsentouttoothercityvolunteerstoavoidmakingtoomanyrequestsofcitypartnersduringthecourseoftheevaluation.WereviewedallinformationandsharedinitialfindingsandconclusionsinasessionwithBSHFstaffbeforedraftingthisreport.
1.3 BACKGROUNDTOTHEREVIEW
Theprogrammewasinitiatedin2015.BSHFandFEANTSAinitiallyselectedsixcitiesforinvolvement.Threeofthesecitiesmaintainedtheirinvolvementandwerejoinedbyafourth,Croydon,inthepilotphaseoftheprogramme.In2016,BSHFcommissionedanevaluationofthepilotphaseofthecampaign,whichvalidatedtheconceptandwaspositiveaboutprogresstodate.Followingthepilotphase,othercitieshavejoinedthecampaign,andBSHFhasdevelopedamorestructuredprogrammeofsupport(discussedinsection3.1).WesetoutasummarycampaigntimelineinAppendix1.
2 Strategy and strategic assumptions
2.1 CAMPAIGNPRINCIPLES
Thecampaignisdeeplyambitiousinitsgoaltoachievesystemicchange.Thesixcampaignprinciplesframethisambition,andsoitisencouragingthatsurveyfeedbacksuggeststhatpartnersstronglysupportallthecampaignprinciples.ThecampaignprinciplesarelistedinAppendix2.Weaskedforfeedbackinthesurvey(a)whetherthesearetherightprinciples,and(b)howwelltheyarebeingfollowedinimplementation.Plottingtheseresultsreveals:• Thereisgoodsupportfortheprinciples,althoughsupportiscomparativelylessstrongin
regardtothe‘improvingsystems’approach,althoughitisnotclearwhythisshouldbe
![Page 9: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that](https://reader030.vdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022040214/5eb8e5f6a04f5d4e024880fc/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
9
• Surveyrespondentsseesomeprinciplesasbeingmoreclearlyimplementedthanothers,notablythatthereismoreworktodoaroundtrackingprogress.Thisisconsistentwithinterviewfeedback(wediscusstrackingandmonitoringinsection3.2).
Figure1:Partners’survey:Perspectivesonthecampaignprinciples
Thisgraphplotsaverageresponses,onascaleof1-5fromstronglydisagreetostronglyagreeThetwokeyorganisingprinciples–HousingFirstandcommunityinvolvement–arebothdeliberatelydisruptiveofthestatusquo.Contributorsstronglysupport(theneedfor)thiselementofdisruption.Disruptionisbuiltintothecampaign.Asthe2016evaluationexplainedit,“Intendedtobedisruptive,thecampaignhelpedsomepeoplewhohadbeenworkinginthisareaforalongtime,whowerefrustratedbythelackofprogress,tobreakorchangetherules”.Respondentsstressedthatthecampaignisdesignedasachallengeto‘businessasusual’mentalitiesandpracticesandtothe“homelessnessindustry”.Whileoneintervieweenotedthatbeingdisruptiveis"anunintendedconsequenceofusingadifferentapproach”,othersembracedisruptionasapositiveforce.
HousingFirst
Knowingwho'soutthere
Trackingprogress Involvingthe
communityImprovinglocal
systems
Learning&sharing
1.00
2.00
3.00
4.00
5.00
1 4
stronglyagree
Rightprinciple?
stronglydisagree
stronglystronglydisagreeBeingapplied?agree
![Page 10: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that](https://reader030.vdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022040214/5eb8e5f6a04f5d4e024880fc/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
10
Butforthisradicaldisruptiontotakeholdthroughnewwaysofaddressingproblemsofhomelessnessbeingadopted,thereisaneedtobringpeoplealong.Sothereisatensionthatcitypartnersmustnavigate:“Peopleinthesectormayfeelwearecriticisingtheirintentionswhenwearecriticisingtheirmethods.Thereisariskoflosingpeoplewhohaveworkedagainsthomelessnessforalongtime…weneedtoengagethemsensitively”.Asweexplorebelow,citypartnershavemadesomeprogressinbuildingsupportamongstcommunitiesandgroups,butthisisnotastraightforwardorquickundertaking.ThefactthatHousingFirsthasalreadysometractionandcredibilityishelpfulinreducingthepotentiallyalienatingeffectofthisdisruption.Inmanyways,HousingFirstisradicallychallenging.Butthereisevidencetosupportit(althoughsomeofthismaybecontested)anditbuildsonsomeexistinginterestinpartsofEurope.Intervieweesreportthatmanyinthehomelessnesssectorrecognisethatexistingapproacheshavenotworked.Sointhatsense,althoughHousingFirstrepresentsaradicalreorientation,thereareatleastsomepositiveconditionsinplacethathelpcreateapotentialtobuildsomemomentumaroundit.SurveyresultsshowthatpartnersstronglysupporttheHousingFirstapproachandstronglyagreethatthisprojectisupholdingtheapproachinpractice.Interviewfeedbackwasslightlymorenuanced,withsomestressingtheneedtomovefromthecurrentsituationtoasystemwhichincorporatesHousingFirst(butnotastheonlyapproach).HousingFirstrepresentsashiftfrommanagingtoendinghomelessness.Accordingtoonepartner,“itturnsontheirheadthethingswethoughtweknow…[it]hasbeenvaluableandchallenging”.Anotherstressedthat“Itisbasedonhousingbeingaright.Thisiscentraltowhyitworks”.Onepartnerdescribeditasagoodwaytoby-passtheexisting,over-complexsystem.Thereisstronginterestandbuy-intoHousingFirstamongstparticipantsinthecampaign.Thecampaignisupholdingthiscentralprincipletotheextentthatsomecities’involvement,includingtheinvolvementofsomeofthepilotcities,hasfalteredonthelackofstrongcommitmentto,andprioritisationof,HousingFirstprinciples.Butit’salsothecasethatsomepartnersareinterpretingHousingFirstaspartofapackageofapproaches.Onecitypartnernotedthat“Itisrighttoendconditionalityofsupport,butthisisnotforeveryone.HousingFirstisnotapanacea-youneedarangeofoptions”andanotherthat“Itworksiftargetedattherightpeople”.ThisraisesaquestionastowhetherthecampaignisadvocatingHousingFirstasthesolution,orasoneelementofawidersolution.Perhapstheredoesnothavetobeadefinitiveviewaboutthiswithinthecampaign,buthavingaclearerlinemightbehelpful.
![Page 11: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that](https://reader030.vdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022040214/5eb8e5f6a04f5d4e024880fc/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
11
Speakingconceptually,briefly:inthecontextofreferencestoHousingFirstasa‘paradigmshift’,systemsthinkerDonellaMeadowssetoutthebestwaystochangethestructuresofasystem.Sheadvocatedthatthesecondmosteffectivewaytoshiftasystemisbycreatinganewparadigm-butthatthemosteffectiveapproachistotranscendparadigms,“tostayflexible,torealisethatnoparadigmis‘true’toeveryone”.2WemightseeplacingHousingFirstmoreflexiblyasonepotentialsolution,ratherthanasthesolution,fitswellwiththis‘transcendingparadigms’approach.SeeRecommendation1.Partnersshowedstrongbuy-intotheprincipleofcommunityinvolvement,althoughinmanycasesthishasn’t(yet)extendedbeyondinvolvementinConnectionsWeeksManypartnersstressedthatvolunteerinvolvementhasbroughtinnewactors,newenergyandnewperspectives.Asoneintervieweeputit,communityinvolvement“improvedthequalityofthediscussion,madepeoplestepbackandnotassumedoingthesamethingthesamewayisright”.Thisisexpressedintheprinciplethat“Weneedtotakean'unprofessional'approachtoserviceprovision”.Theprincipleofcommunityinvolvementwasverystronglysupportedbythevolunteerssurveyed,withextraordinarilyhighagreementamongstBarcelonavolunteers(seeFigure2)ConnectionsWeeksthemselveshavehadsomechallengesinsomecities,butmanyfelttheywerepositiveexperiences.Inonecity,someintervieweesraisedaspecificissuearoundtheConnectionsWeekduplicatingexistinginitiatives.Weheardonecriticismofthecampaignthatithasn’tbeenclearenoughinsettingoutwhatwasmeantbycommunityinvolvement,beyondtheConnectionsWeeks.Theactualpictureseemsmoremixedthanthis,withsomecities,notablyCroydon,activelyembeddingthiselementwithinthewidercampaign,andothersshowingadevelopingcommitmenttobuildinginongoingcommunityinvolvementinfuture(seesection4.2).Butinsomeothercities,therehasnotbeenmuch,ifany,communityinvolvementbeyondtheConnectionsWeeksthemselves.Volunteerssurveyedindicatedthattheywerewillingtoparticipateinthecampaigninfuture.Somewouldlikeopportunitiesforongoinginvolvementandseveralwerekeentohearmoreabouttheprogressofthecampaign.Insurveyfeedback,volunteersstressedthattheyparticipatedinthecampaignbecausetheywantedtocontributeinsomeway,andshowsolidarity,andthattheywelcomedapracticalwayofshowingtheirconcernandfulfillingadesiretodosomething.Forsomeitwasawaytobecomebetterinformed-“ithasbeenveryimportantformetohavetheopportunityto
2DonellaMeadows,ThinkinginSystems,p162-4,Earthscan,2009
![Page 12: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that](https://reader030.vdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022040214/5eb8e5f6a04f5d4e024880fc/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
12
listento[homelesspeople]directly”.AcoupleofvolunteersinWestminstermentionedthattheyhadexperiencedhomelessnessthemselves.SeveralvolunteersinBarcelonaspecificallymentionedtheimportanceofhavinggoodinformationinordertobeabletoaddresstheproblem(i.e.goingbeyondmoregeneralisedreasonsforbeinginvolvedandexplicitlyidentifyingthattheyfeltthisparticularinterventionwasaworthwhileone).Inbothcitiescoveredbythevolunteers’survey,volunteersexpressedstrongwillingnesstoparticipateinthecampaigninfuture,withsomesuggestingthisrepresenteduntappedpotential:“thereweredozensofpeoplewillingtogivetheirtimetocarryondoingstuffandthiswasnotexploited”.ThisseemedtobeastrongerfeelingamongstWestminstervolunteers,althoughasmallnumberofBarcelonavolunteersdidalsoraiseit:“Oncethecounthasbeenmadehowcanacommunitycallbemadetosolvetheproblem?”Probablylinkedtothis,thevolunteers’surveyindicatesthat-whilststillpositiveoverall-volunteersinthetwocitiesconcernedagreedrelativelylessstronglyabouttheeffectivenessofcommunityinvolvementinthiscase,thecontributiontheyhadmade,andwhatthecampaignhasachieved.ThereisstrongeragreementineachcasefromvolunteersinBarcelonathanfromthoseinWestminster:
Figure2:Volunteers’viewsofthecampaign
Graphshowsaverageresponsesonascale1-5,where1=stronglydisagreeand5=stronglyagree
4.58
4.25
4.21
3.87
3.69
3.48
4.89
4.71
4.69
4.42
4.17
3.66
1 2 3 4 5
Itisimportantthatthereis'acommunitysolu=ontoacommunityproblem'
IwasgiventhesupportIneededtotakepartinthecampaign
It’sbeenclearwhathasbeenexpectedofme
Thiscampaignoffersaneffec=vewaytoinvolvethecommunityinaddressinghomelessnessinmycity
IfeelIhavemadeavaluablecontribu=ontotacklinghomelessnessinmycity
Thecampaignhasledtoposi=veresultsforhomelesspeopleinmycity
Pleasetellushowmuchyouagreewiththefollowingstatements:
Westminster Barcelona
![Page 13: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that](https://reader030.vdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022040214/5eb8e5f6a04f5d4e024880fc/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
13
Indeed,inresponsetothesurveyquestion“thecampaignhasledtopositiveresultsforhomelesspeopleinmycity”,36%ofvolunteersinWestminsterreplied‘don’tknow’,makingthisthemostcommonanswer.InBarcelona,21%replied‘don’tknow’.Thissuggestsitcouldbegoodforpartnerstothinkaboutwaystokeepvolunteersbetterinformedaboutcampaignprogress.SeveralvolunteersinWestminstermentionedthattheywantedtoknowmore,andbekeptuptodate,aboutwhatwashappeningwiththecampaign:“Ipersonallyhaven'theardagreatdealaboutitsinceIdidmysmallpart”;“Iwouldliketohaveheardmoreabouttheoutcomesandfindingsofthework”.ThesmallnumberofvolunteersweinterviewedforthereviewmentionedthattheyhavelittlesenseofitbeingaEuropeancampaignandwouldwelcomemorecontactwithothercities,andtobemoreawareofthebiggerpicture.SeeRecommendation2.Itcouldbeclearerwhatthecommunityinvolvementexpectationsareinpractice.Somepartnersfeltthatcommunitymembers’ongoinginvolvementinthecampaignshouldbebetterintegratedfromthebeginning.Therewassomefeedbackfrompartnersquestioninghowessentialcommunityinvolvementactuallyisinadvancingthegoalsofthecampaign.Inacoupleofcitiespartnersexpressedasensealongthelinesthat:“thereisnoneedtoinvolvethecommunityforitsownsake,ifyoucanachieveyourgoalsbydirectengagement”.Thisraisesaquestionastowhethercommunityinvolvementisameanstoapolicyendand/orsomethingbroaderthanthat.Inturn,itmaybeunclearwhatpartnersaresigninguptowhentheycommittothecommunityinvolvementprincipleaspartofthecampaign.Giventhis,itcouldbehelpfultohaveaclearerandmoreexplicitpositiononthestrategicpurposeofinvolvingcommunitiesacrossthecampaignasawhole.Inparticular,thiscouldhelpacceleratecommunityinvolvementefforts,inthatitwouldbeclearerfromthestartwhatthatlookslike.Thisisconsistentwiththerecommendationfromapartnerthat“Keywouldbetoplanwhatyouaregoingtodoafterwards[tofacilitateongoingcommunityinvolvement]beforetheendoftheConnectionsWeek.Thequickeryougetitgoingthebetter”.SeeRecommendation3.
2.2 BSHF’SSTRATEGICROLE
Asanindependentvoice,BSHFiswellplacedtoinitiateandcoordinatethecampaign.BSHFsawaneedandanopportunityandsteppedin.OtherrespondentscorroboratedBSHF’sownsensethatitiswellplacedandabletooperateasanhonestbroker:“wehave
![Page 14: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that](https://reader030.vdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022040214/5eb8e5f6a04f5d4e024880fc/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
14
independenceandhaveusedthattoouradvantage”.Oneexternalinterviewee,forexample,feltthat,“Itneedsoutsiderstoshakethingsup.It'sverylaudablethatBSHFtooktheplunge.Thatothershavejoinedthecampaignvindicatesthat”.GivenhowwellplacedBSHFistoidentifygoodpractice,wethinkit’salogicalandpositivesteporganisationallyforBSHFtofollowthisthroughandbemorepracticallyinvolvedinfindingwaystoreplicategoodpractice.Asoneinternalintervieweeexplainedit,“Weareinauniquepositiontofindoutthingsthatwork,sohaveadutytotrytogetthosetoworkinotherplaces”.ButsomepointedtothefactthatBSHFisnewtothefieldashavingsomepotentialdisadvantagesthatneedtobemanaged,notablyarounditsreachandcontactsacrossEuropeandthebreadthofcitieswhichareinvolved.Mostfeltthatcityselectionwasinitiallymadeonapragmaticratherthanastrategicbasis.Thismadesensepracticallybutithasskewedthegeographyofparticipatingcitiesinthecampaigntodate.ThereareearlysignsofthisnowshiftingtoamoreEuropean-wideapproach.Internalintervieweesaswellaspartnersrecognisedthattheapproachintheearlystageswasessentiallypractical,togowheretheinterestwas.Thefactthatpartnersputthemselvesforwardshowedsomecommitment,butbeyondthattheinitialcitieswerenotselectedonthebasisofanywiderstrategiclogic.SeveralrespondentsfeltthatthemixofcitieshastendedtodependonBSHF'sexistingcontacts,althoughthisopiniondownplaystherolethatFEANTSAhasplayedinsuggestingcitiestoapproach.Oneintervieweesuggestedthatthelimitationsarenotsimplydowntoreach:“TheissueislessabilityofBSHFtoreachcities,buthowcitiesreceivethemessageofthecampaign”.Theapproachtodatehashadsomecostintermsofgeographicalspread,withthecampaigntodateshowingadisproportionateUKfocus(bothintermsofcitiesselectedandofcitiesthathaveremainedengagedinthecampaign).
Table1:InvolvementofUKandmainlandEuropeancitiesinthecampaign
Total StillinvolvedAllcities 14 10UK 6 6
Thismakeupisbeginningtochange.WeunderstandthenewtrancheofcitieswillhelpintroducefurtherdiversityandmovethecentreofgravityfurtherEast.Developingthisgeographicalspreadwillbekeytothenextphaseofthecampaign(seesection5.1).Adoptingamodelthatinvolvesworkingwithandthroughothers,whilstoperatinginanewareabringschallengesintermsofhowcontactsareforgedandpartnersidentified.It’s
![Page 15: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that](https://reader030.vdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022040214/5eb8e5f6a04f5d4e024880fc/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
15
difficultforanewactortobuilditsnetworksinnewcountries:thereisinevitablyacertainrelianceonstrategicsupportfromexistingactorsandthishasn’talwaysbeenfullyonoffer.OnerespondentalsomentionedthatBSHF’srelativelysmallsizecouldmakeitdifficulttomaintainasenseofownershipoverthecampaign.BSHFisalerttothisandismanagingthischallengebynotgoingbeyondtheboundariesofwhatislikelytobesustainable.Theflexibilitythatthecampaigngivestocitylevelpartnerscreatesapositivecontextforactionatthatlevel.Theparametersofthecampaignaresetbytheprinciples,andbeyondthatthereisalotoflatitudedelegatedtocitylevel:“thereisalevelthatyoumustdo,therestisflexible”.Citylevelpartnersverymuchappreciatethisapproachasnotedelsewhere.It'sanapproachthatseemsverymuchinlinewitha‘directednetwork’modelofcampaigns,which“aretypicallyledbyacentralbodythatframestheissuesandcoordinatesenergiestowardssharedmilestonesbutalsoleavesafairamountoffreedomandagencyto…supportersand…allies”.Areviewofthisapproachfoundthatthesetypesofdirected-networkcampaigns“performedexceptionallywellintermsofbothimpactandforceamplification”comparedtomoretraditionalmodels”.3Thecampaignconcentratesattentionandhelpsraiseparticipants’morale.Partnersvaluethesenseofsolidaritythatbeingpartofthecampaignbrings.Forsome,itbringsaddedcredibilitytotheircitylevelwork.Thefactthatmultiplecitiesareengagedinacommonendeavourhasbeenhelpfultomanyofthecitylevelpartners.Onefeltthat“hearingthatothershavethesameproblemsmadeusfeellessisolated”andanothernotedthat“havingtheopportunitytoworkalongsideagroupofpeoplewithasharedcommitmenttosignificantsystemchangeisanalltoorareopportunity”.EventhoughthecampaignisnotyetestablishedacrossEurope,somepartnersstillexpressedthesensethattohavea‘Europeancampaign’aroundwhichpeoplewererallyinghelpedthemfeelpartofsomethingbigger.Thiswasgoodformoraleandhasboostedcredibility-“ithelpsusstrengthenourargumentstobeabletorefertothecampaign”-aswellashelpingtogivesomeadditionalfocustothecampaignlocally.Incontrast,oneintervieweefeltthat"it’snot[yet]anadvantagetomentiontheEuropeancampaignlocally.ItneedstoreachfurtherbeyondtheUKandSpainfirst".Andonepartneralsosensedthatthecampaign’scredibilitywasnotyetestablished:“[weare]waiting…formoreresults.Itneedsmoretime”.
3TomLiacas&JasonMogus,“NetworkedChange:HowProgressivecampaignsarewoninthe21stcentury”,NetChangeConsulting,2016
![Page 16: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that](https://reader030.vdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022040214/5eb8e5f6a04f5d4e024880fc/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
16
3 Implementation and management
3.1 SUPPORTBSHFPROVIDES
PartnersareverypositiveabouttheoverallsupportthatBSHFprovides.PartnerscommendedBSHFforbeing“veryresponsive”andparticularlyforthefacilitativenatureofthesupportbeingprovided:“BSHFhavebeenperfect..theyhavegivenalotoflatitudetolocaldecisions,andsupportisthereifneeded”.Onepartnernotedthat“logisticalsupport…isfaultless”.Surveyresultscorroboratethisinterviewfeedback.Acrossarangeofareas,themajorityinmostcasesstronglyagreedthatthesupportBSHFhadprovidedhasbeeneffective:
Figure3:Partners’survey:FeedbackonBSHFsupport
Andpartnersarepositivetooaboutthespecificsupportpackagesonoffer.
0
0
1
0
0
0
0
1
0
1
0
0
1
0
2
1
1
0
0
0
0
0
4
1
3
3
1
2
4
3
4
5
5
6
6
0% 100%
Establishingeffec7vewaysoftrackingandassessingprogressbeingmade
SeCngoutclearexpecta7onsofusasapartnerorganisa7on
Helping(us)tofosterpartnershipsatlocallevel
Coordina7ngthecampaignataEuropeanlevel
Suppor7ngmyorganisa7ontoplanandtakeac7on
Communica7ngaboutthecampaign
Sharinglearningandexperiencesbetweenci7es
BSHFhasbeeneffec.vein...
Stronglydisagree Disagree Neitheragreenordisagree Agree Stronglyagree
![Page 17: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that](https://reader030.vdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022040214/5eb8e5f6a04f5d4e024880fc/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
17
Surveyresponsesshowthatpartnersvaluethedifferentelementsofsupportavailable.Resultssuggestthatpartnersparticularlyvaluetheannualgathering,andthebespokesupport:
Figure4:Partners’survey:Feedbackonspecificresourcesupport
Partners’feedbackonthewebinarswasalsopositive:“Thecampaignislearningbydoing,solivefeedbackonprogressofothersattemptingthesamethingisveryinterestinganduseful”.Acoupleofpartnerssuggestedfuturewebinarscouldbemoreinteractive,withmorespacetoshareexperiences.Partnerscommendedthetoolkittoo,withonecallingit“fantastic”,althoughonerespondentcommentedthatitwasdifficulttonavigate.Asonepartnerputit,“Ifyouhavethetoolkitandwebinars,youhavethebasisforthecampaigninyourowncity”.
11
2
3
2
1
3
2
5
5
0
7
onlinetoolkitwebinarstailoredsupportannualgathering
Howhelpfulhavethefollowingresourcesbeen...
Nothelpful Par<allyhelpful
Generallyhelpful Veryhelpful
![Page 18: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that](https://reader030.vdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022040214/5eb8e5f6a04f5d4e024880fc/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
18
SomepartnersmentionedthepossibilityofBSHFbeingmoreactivelyinvolvedincampaignpromotionandcommunication(seesection5.2).Volunteerssurveyedalsofeltwellsupported,showinggoodagreementstostatements‘IwasgiventhesupportIneeded’and‘It’sbeenclearwhatwasexpectedofme’[seeFigure2).
3.2 SHARINGLEARNINGANDTRACKINGPROGRESS
Partnersarepositiveabouthowlearningissharedbutsaythereisroomformore.Thereisanaturaltendencyforcitiestoexchangewithcitiesintheirowncountry,buttheremaybeincreasingopportunitytoextract-andmorewidelyshare-generalisablelessonsfromcities'experiences.Accordingtoonepartner,“Weareconstantlylearningfromothers.BSHFisgoodatsharingthelearning–throughtoolkits,regularupdates,bringingpeopletogether”.Andpartnersvaluethissharingofintelligence.Asonesurveyrespondentputit,itis“Incrediblyusefultogetmultipleperspectivesonsimilarissues,learningmoreaboutdifferentcontextsandpotentialsolutionsfromotherareas”.Buttherewasalsoastrandoffeedbackalongthelinesthatthereisscopeformoresharingofinformationandreflections,throughBSHF’scoordinationrolebutalsobilaterallybetweencities.Whilstrecognisingthatcontextsaredifferent,especiallybetweencountries,somecitypartnerspointedtoanumberoflikelyissuesincommonwherethevalueinsharingisnotbeingfullyexploited.Somepartnersidentifiedthatmoreorganic,city-to-citysharingisalreadyhappening,andthatinteractionbetweencities“doesnotdependonmediationfromBSHF.Weknowpeoplewell”.Therearesomesignsofnewercitieslearningfromtheoriginaltranche.Butothersfeltthiswasstillpatchyandpartial:“Peoplestickwiththepeopletheyknow”;“Thereisnotenoughcommunicationbetweencities…[we]needmoreregularupdatesoraregularforumforexchange”.Onepartnermadetheimportantpointthat,asnumbersofparticipatingcitiesgrow,thenlearningopportunitiesmayneedtobemoredisaggregated–forexamplebyseparating‘old’and‘new’citiesinwebinarsandinotherlearningmoments.SeeRecommendation4.Approachestotrackingandreportingshouldbefurtherdevelopedasthecampaigngrows.Somerespondentsidentifiedaneedforaclearerreal-timesenseofcampaignoutcomesandachievements.Oneintervieweeforexampleacknowledgedthat“Tangibleresultsarenotcollatedproperly…Thereisalotofinformationgoingaroundthatisnotbeingcollated”.
![Page 19: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that](https://reader030.vdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022040214/5eb8e5f6a04f5d4e024880fc/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
19
Surveyfindingsalsopointtopartnersseeing‘trackingprogress’asbeingacomparativelyweakareaofimplementationinthecampaigntodate(seeFigure1).Thisareadidn’tfeaturestronglyinpartnerfeedbackbutneverthelesswethinkthatwhilstsomeinformationisflowing,trackingsystemswillneedtobestrengthened,especiallyasthecampaigngrows,sothatinformationismorecomprehensivelycollectedandshared.Astronger,moreembeddedapproachtomonitoringprogresswould• GiveBSHFandcitypartnersaclearersenseofwhetherthecampaignisontrack,and
allowforinformedreview,andsupportadaptationwhereneeded.• Helpparticipantsshowthedirectionoftravelandhighlightachievements,importantto
buildingsupportforthecampaign-“Ifcommunitiesareachievingsuccess,andthevalueofHousingFirstisdemonstrated,itwillsnowball”.
• Helpbuildaninternalsenseofmomentum.• Provideclearerevidenceonthenumbersofpeoplebenefittingfromthecampaign(see
section4.4)• Allowforthecollectionandcollationofindividualstories.The100kHomesCampaigndevelopedasetofSMARTobjectivesandatarget-focusedapproach.Butthisdoesn’tsoundlikethesortofapproachBSHFshouldadopt,giventhatit’shardtoseehowlinearmodelsofchangeareappropriatetothiscampaigncontext,andinthelightoftheneedforanytrackingsystemdevelopednottobetooformalised,ortoactasaconstraintonlocalflexibility.Henceonepartnernotedthat“ThewholethingistoocomplexforBSHFtosetoutaframeworkforwherepeopleshouldbe”.Butsomelight-touchsystemsthatallowprogresstobecapturedandconsideredarelikelytobebeneficial.SeeRecommendation5.
4 Campaign outcomes Thecampaignisbeginningtodemonstrateasetofoutcomesthatshowprogresstowardsthegoalofsecuringsustainablehousingforstreethomelesspeople.
4.1 IMPROVEDEVIDENCEBASE
Forsomecities,conductingthestreetsurveyshasgeneratedvaluablenewdataandevidence.The2016evaluationidentifiedthatresultsinValencia“werehighlysignificant…forthefirsttimeitprovideddetailedinformationaboutthemake-upofthatpopulationandpeople’sindividualneeds”,andthatthesurveyrevealednewinformationaboutpeoplelivingonthestreetsinBarcelonatoo.
![Page 20: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that](https://reader030.vdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022040214/5eb8e5f6a04f5d4e024880fc/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
20
Thissenseoftheusefulnessofthedatacamethroughinthesurveyresults,withhighagreementthatthecampaignhasbeensuccessfulinproducingnewevidence(Figure8),andthatithasresultedinhavingbetterdata(Figure9).Partnershighlightedthatthesurveyshaduncoveredcertainparticularlyrelevantpiecesofinformation,suchasthenumberofhomelesspeoplewithGPs,ornumberswhohadbeenarrested,orwhohadattendedAccident&Emergencyservices.Insomecities,thesefindingsrevealednewinformationandhelpedmakethecaseforaction:“Datahasbeenuseful,particularlysomeoftheimpactmeasures,thethingsthatmakepeopletakenotice–andsomeofthehumanstories–theseareimpactful”.Butpartnersdidnotuniversallyregardthedatafromthesurveysassignificant.Somebelievedthatthatdatadidnotaddtoinformationthatalreadyexisted,andthattheaddedvalueofthesurveyswaslimited:“Itconfirmedwhatweknew.Wehadgoodlocaldata,thenumberswerenosurprise.Itgaveusevidence,casestoriesofthesituationofthestreethomeless”.GlasgowhasnotyetconductedaConnectionsWeek,partlybecauserobustdataalreadyexists.Alsoonerespondentmadethepointthatdatasnapshotsarenotasusefulaslivedatathatallowsfortrackingofprogress.Aspartofthedevelopingcampaignsupportprogramme,CroydonpartnershavebeenselectedtoworkwithCommunitySolutions–thecoordinatorsofthe100KHomesCampaignintheUS–tolookatwaysthatthiscouldbedone.
4.2 ENHANCEDENGAGEMENTANDINTEREST
Inmanycities,therearepositivesignsofgrowthofinterestin,andsupportto,thecampaignanditsprinciplesfromlocalcivilsocietyorganisationsandassociations.The2016evaluationnotedthat,inWestminster,“[TheConnectionsWeek]wasthefirsttimeforyearsthatthemanyorganisationsdeliveringhomelessnessservicesinWestminsterhadworkedtogetheronasingleproject”.Andtherearesomeadditionalsigns,indifferentcities,ofadevelopingengagementandwillingnesstoexploresolutionscollaboratively.Inonecity,forexample,thecampaignSteeringGroupnowincludesarepresentativeoffaith-basedgroups,asignificantadditioninthatinthepastfaith-basedgroupshavetendedtobemarginaltopublicsector-ledinitiatives.Therearesignsofprogresselsewheretoo.Acitypartnernotedpreviousresistancetoengagefromgroupsworkingwithroughsleepersbutthatthemajorityofgroupsnow“arenowwillingtositroundatableandcoordinatearesponse”.Andanothercitypartnerfeltthat,“themovementisgrowing…somearerespondingpositively,othersare[still]notsosure”.
![Page 21: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that](https://reader030.vdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022040214/5eb8e5f6a04f5d4e024880fc/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
21
PartnersfeltthatholdingtheConnectionsWeekhasbeenimportantinbuildingconsensus;it“madeusvisible,ledtomoreassociationsjoiningthecampaign–itmadeusmorecredible”.And,moregenerally,“thecampaignhas…improvedthequalityofthediscussion”.Butinsomeplacescontinuingchallengesremain,withtalkinonecityof“asenseofterritoriality”andinanotherthat“otherNGOsrejectHousingFirstandsticktothesameapproach”.Partnersmentionedthatthereissomeevidenceoflocalmediacoverageandsocialmediadissemination.The2016evaluationnotedthattherehadbeen“solidandpositivecoverage”ofthecampaigninmediaandsocialmedia.Thereportedrangeofsocialmediacoverageforthecampaigninsurveyresults(across‘very’,‘mostly’and‘partly’successful)probablyreflectsvariationinpartners’existingsocialmediapresence.Surveyresponsesshowtoothatasmallnumberofpartnersidentifythattherehasbeen‘verysuccessful’localmediacoverage,withhalfsuggestingthatcoveragehasbeen‘mostlysuccessful’).Reportedresultsfornationalmediacoverageare,notsurprisingly,lower(Figure8).WeunderstandthatincitieslikeCroydonandBrusselstherehasbeensomepositivelocalmediapick-up,inthelattercaseincludingbyjournalistvolunteersinvolvedinthecampaign.Oneissuethatcouldprovechallenginginrelationtomediacoverage,andcommunicationsandframingmoregenerally,isthat,asoneintervieweeexplained,“alotofthecitieshavegothighlevelsofpeoplewhoaremigrantsorrefugees…that’snotthestorypeoplewanttohearordealwith…[but]ifyouaretalkingaboutthedata,aboutcollectingstoriesanddata,youcan’tthenignoreitwhenit’snottellingyouwhatyouwanttohear”.SeeRecommendation6.CommunityengagementhasgenerallybeenstrongduringConnectionsWeeks.Asnotedabove,onecornerstoneelementofthecampaignisthat“weareenablingpeopletohaveanopportunitytodosomethingaboutit.Thecampaignisallaboutthewholecommunity”.TheConnectionsWeekshavegenerallybeensuccessfulinattractingsupportfromlargenumbersofvolunteers,withagoodmixofpreviouslycommittedvolunteersandthosewithnohistoryofpastinvolvement.Volunteersurveyresponsesconfirmthatahighproportionofvolunteershadnotpreviousinvolvementinsupporthomelessnessefforts(nearly50%inWestminsterandover50%inBarcelona):
![Page 22: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that](https://reader030.vdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022040214/5eb8e5f6a04f5d4e024880fc/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
22
Figure5:Volunteers’previousinvolvementinhomelessnessissues
Barcelonan=70,Westminstern=32Partnersnotedthatinsomecities,suchasBrusselsandCroydon,itwasstrikinghowvolunteerscamefromdiversebackgrounds(althoughoneWestminstervolunteerfelt“itwasgearedtowardsyoungerpeople…whowerenotparticularly'thecommunity'”).Thissupporthasbroughtenergytothecampaign:“TherewasabigchangewhenwedidtheConnectionsWeek…Forustoseethelevelsofsupport,peoplewantingtohelp,itwasaverygoodexperience.Otherassociationswerescepticalaboutusingvolunteers,itwasagooddemonstrationthatitwaspositive.Sincethen…moreassociationsarerealisingthatcitizensmustbepartofamovement”.Inmostcases,effortsatinvolvingthecommunityinamoreongoingwayareintheirearlystages.Thisisanareathatmanycitiesarecommittedtodeveloping.Croydonhasledthewayindevelopinganapproachthatsupportsongoingcommunityinvolvement,throughestablishingfive‘TaskandFinish’groups.Thegroupsaremakingprogress,slowly,andvolunteerinvolvementisopeningdoorsforthecampaign:“wearelinkedinwithmorecompanies,largeorganisationswewouldn’totherwisehavebeen”.Otherpartnersaregenerallypositiveaboutinvolvingcommunitymembersinfindingsolutionstoproblemsofhomelessness.Oneintervieweestressedthat,“Professionalsdon’thavetheanswer,that’swhythecommunityengagementaspectissoimportant,awaytodiversifythegroupofpeopleworkingontheproblem”.Anotherpointedoutthat,“[involving
21% 21%
57%
28% 28%
44%
Iwasac.velyinvolved Ihadsomepastinvolvement
Ihadnopastinvolvement
“Wereyouinvolvedinanyvolunteerworktotrytohelpendhomelessness,orhelppeopleaffectedbyhomelessness,inyourcitypriorto
thiscampaign?”
Barcelona
Westminster
![Page 23: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that](https://reader030.vdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022040214/5eb8e5f6a04f5d4e024880fc/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
23
membersofthecommunity]givesabroaderrangeofopinions…professionalscomeupwiththesameanswers…itmakesyourealisehownarrowyourfocusis”.Butreflectingonhowcommunitymembershadbeeninvolvedinthecampaigntodate,acoupleofsurveyrespondentsidentifiedthatprogressinthisareahadbeenlessthantheyhadhoped.Onenotedthat“abitmoretimeisneededtoworkouthowcommunityinvolvementwillworkinpractice”.Asnotedabove(section2.1),volunteersarekeentobemoreinvolvedinthecampaign.Somecitypartnersaredevelopingconcreteideasandplanstoexpandthiselementofthework.Insomecities,volunteersareprovidingpastoralsupport,torehousedformerhomelesspeopleforexample,orthereareplanstosetupandexpandthiskindofsupport.Volunteerinvolvementislikelytoinvolvecommunitymembersasadvocatestoo-“some[volunteers]havegoodcontactswithdecisionmakers…weareworkingonit,thatwillbeabiggerpartinthefuture”.Andtherearesomeplanstoinvolvevolunteersinfindingsolutions;inonecase,forexample,ateamofvolunteersisbeingtaskedwithsourcinghousing.
4.3 TOWARDSCHANGESINPOLICYANDPRACTICE
Therearesomesignsthatmunicipalauthoritiesareengagingwiththecampaign.Somelocalauthoritiesaresupportingthecampaignasactual,ordefacto,partners,aswithTorbayandCroydon.Inothercases,therearesomesignsofengagement:“Itisdifficulttoworkwithpolicy-makers,wearetryingtochangetheirwholeapproach.Butthedoorisopen,theylisten”.Andthereareexamplesemergingofsolutionsbeingdevelopedorconsidered,oratleastidentified.InCroydon,forexample,contractspecificationsaroundlengthofstayintransitionalaccommodationarebeingreviewed,havingbeenraisedthroughthecampaign.Meanwhile,Torbayhasestablishedamulti-stakeholderSystemsOptimisationGrouptoshareinformationanddiscusssupportprovision.This,itwassaid,hascoincidedwiththecampaign,notcausedbyit,butthecampaignisfeedinginusefulexamplesandevidencetothegroup.Therearesomeexamplesofapparentinfluenceonmunicipalauthorities’policyandpracticeemerging,but-notsurprisinglygiventhechallengesinvolved-progresstendstobeslowevenwherecommitmentsareinplace.EvidencefromValencia,forexample,showsprogressbeingmade,butalsohowslowlythingscanmove:• The2016evaluationnotedthatthe“Mayor,regionalgovernmentandmunicipality…are
supportingaHousingFirstpilotinthecityasaresultofthe[ConnectionsWeek]”;• Towardstheendof2016,thishadbeenformallyannounced,asnotedinthecampaign
Decemberupdate:“FollowingtheirRegistryWeek,ameetingbetweenRAISFundación,
![Page 24: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that](https://reader030.vdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022040214/5eb8e5f6a04f5d4e024880fc/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
24
Valencia’sMayorandtheregionalgovernmentledtotheannouncementofaHousingFirstpilotbeinglaunchedinthecity”;
• Finally,inAugust2017,acityupdateconfirmsanagreementtolaunchthispilotisinplace:“asignedagreementwiththecitycouncilforaHousingFirstpilottolaunchintheautumn.Thecommitmentisforfiveunitsratherthantheinitial10plannedyetitisagoodfirststep”.
Asimilardynamic–withprospectsofchange,butslowprogress–isevidentinWestminster,wherethe2016evaluationreportsa“meetingofagenciesonpost-RegistryWeekcommitments,inputintocouncilroughsleepingstrategy”.Amorerecentupdateonthisisthat“[thelocalauthority]saidtheywerere-evaluatingtheWestminsterroughsleepingstrategy.Thenitwentquiet.Theyarestillengaged…”Inothercitiestoo,localauthoritiesaremakingsomepositivecommitments.HousingFirstisapolicypriorityfortheGlasgowgovernment,forexample.AndinSpain,HousingFirstisincludedinnationalstrategy,withtheonusnowoncityandregionalauthoritiestodevelopplansaccordingly.Buttherearealsoexamplesoflocalmunicipalitiesshowingcontinuingresistance,oratleastreluctancetoengagemeaningfully.Onecitypartner,forexample,reportedthat“Thelocalauthorityisnotagainsttheinitiative,thereissomeinterest,buttheyarenotreallycommitted,theyhaveanothervision…Wearebuildingmomentum…Wehaven’tseenachangeintheirvision.Thetaskofthecampaignistochangeit.Butit’snoteasy”.Inanothercity,weheardthatthelocalcouncilbaulkedatleasinglandforhousingatlowcostbecauseofarunofbadpublicityrelatingtohomelesspeople,drugsandpettycrime.Onecitypartnersuggestedthattheslownessofprogressraisedaquestionofhowseriousthecommitmentoftherelevantauthoritiesreallyis,alsostressingtheimportanceofmaintainingenergywithinthecampaignwhereprogressisstalled.
4.4 IMPACTONPEOPLEWHOARESTREETHOMELESS
Byimpactwemeanthe“significantorlastingchangesinpeople’slives,broughtaboutbyagivenactionorseriesofaction”.4Therearesomeearly(butnotalwaystotallyclear)signsthatsmallnumbersofpeoplehavebeenbeinghousedasaresultofthecampaign(orthatthecampaignhasinsomewaycontributedtothis).InTorbay,thecampaignhascontributedtoten(orbysomeaccountseight)peoplebeinghoused.Thiswasconfirmedinarecentcampaignbulletin,whichnotedthatTorbayhad“madegreatprogressintheircampaignbyfindinghomesforeightoftheindividualswhohadbeensleepingonthestreets…[as]adirectresultofthelocalcampaign'sactions”.
4ChrisRoche,‘ImpactAssessmentforDevelopmentAgencies:LearningtoValueChange’Oxfam,1999
![Page 25: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that](https://reader030.vdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022040214/5eb8e5f6a04f5d4e024880fc/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
25
Numberssuggestedbyrespondentsinvariouscitieshavenotalwaysconsistent;wehearddifferentfiguresfromdifferentpeopleinthesamecity.Areasonableestimatewouldbethatmaybe20peopleintotalhavebeenhousedthroughthecampaigntodate,halfofthemfromTorbay.Additionally,itappearsthatsmallnumbersofpeoplewhoweresurveyedduringConnectionsWeeksweresubsequentlyaccommodated,butnotdirectlythroughthecampaignitself(inCroydon,BrusselsandTorbay).LookingaheadthereisapositiveforecastfromGlasgow,whichisabouttoimplementnewHousingFirstdemonstrationprojects,withfirstresultsexpectedbytheendoftheyear.SeeRecommendation7.Partnersmentionthatthereareotherbenefitstostreethomelesspeople–forexamplethroughthehumanisingexperienceofthesurveyengagement–butwehavelimitedinformationaboutthis.The2016evaluationnotedthehumanisingvalueof“Speakingwithsomeonewhohadtimetotalk,ateachperson'spaceandwasn'tdrivenbycommissionedoutreachtargets”.SomepartnersechoedthissensethatthequalityofengagementduringtheConnectionsWeeksitselfhassomebenefitandonevolunteeralsomadethispoint:“ThefeedbackIreceivedfromsomeoftheroughsleepersIspoketowasthatitfeltdifferenttohavemembersofthecommunityratherthantheprofessionalworkerstalktothem”.Anothernotedthat“Imetsomepeoplewhohadn'thadaconversationwithsomeoneinweeks”.Thesurveyresultspointtosomeotherperceivedbenefits,althoughnotstrongly,inthattherewasatleastsomedisagreementexpressedinresponsetoeachquestion:
Figure6:Partners’survey:Perspectivesonbenefitstolocalhomelesspeople
1
2
2
1
2
0
1
3
3
5
3
2
1
0
1
1
0% 100%
Enhancedconnec0onswiththelocalcommunity
Be:erinforma0onaboutservicesandsupportavailable
Astrongervoiceindecisionsabouttheirfuture
Be:erprospectsforgoodhousingoutcomes
Forpeoplewhoarehomelessandsleepingonthestreetslocally,thecampaignhasledto...
Stronglydisagree Disagree Neitheragreenordisagree Agree Stronglyagree
![Page 26: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that](https://reader030.vdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022040214/5eb8e5f6a04f5d4e024880fc/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
26
Verypractically,inCroydon,anumberofthosesurveyedweren’tpreviouslyknowntotheoutreachteam,meaningthat“23peoplenotknowntooutreachservicesarenowbeingsupported”.Onevolunteermentionedthevalueinhomelesspeoplebeinginvolvedinthesearchforsolutions:“Itwouldbeinterestingtobeabletoincreasethecommunicationbetweenthehomelessandthosethatoffertheservicessincetherearemanythingstoimprove,andtheythemselvescanhavepracticalandeffectivesolutions”.Wehavenothaddirectinputfrompeoplewhoarestreethomelessaspartofthisreview.
4.5 COMMENTARYONPROGRESSANDACHIEVEMENTS
Thecampaignisnotyetachievingchangeatscalebutitwouldnotberealistictoexpecttoseethissosoon.Thereareenoughsignsofprogresstobeencouragedabouttheapproachbeingtaken.BSHFandpartnersarerightlyinterestedinhowsuccessfullythecampaignishelpingthosewhoarestreethomelessgetintosecure,sustainablehousing.Butcampaignsaimingtosecuresystemicchangearenotobviouscandidatesforquickwins:“Ifitwasstraightforwarditwouldhavebeensolvedalready”.Itisalsoimportantcontext,asmentionedinthesurvey,thatmanypartnersareundertakingthisworkalongsideexistingworkloads:“ourmajorissuehasbeencapacity…Thecampaigndoesneedlongterminvestmentoftimetobesuccessful”.Inanumberofcities,shortageofhousingstock/landseemstobeakeybarrier.ItseemsthatevenwherecityauthoritiescollaboratecloselywithcampaignpartnersandsupportHousingFirst,theymaybeunabletoapplyitinpractice.Manypartnersflaggedissuesaroundshortageofhousingandeventhedifficultiesofacquiringlandforhousing.Onecouncilislookingatusingexistinghousingstockdifferentlyforexample.Butinotherlocations,theblockageseemstomorecomplexthanbeingjustaboutfreeingupexistinghostelaccommodation.Inonecity,forexample,“TheCouncilaretalkingaboutit,it’sontheagenda.Thechallengeistosecuretheaccommodation”.Inanother,thereappeartobeideas,butalsoproblems,aroundleasingoracquiringland.Itseemstherearesomecommonthemesaroundhousingsupplyandhowthebarrierstothiscanbeovercomeandhowpartnerscanbestbeinvolvedinfindinghousingsolutionsthatcouldbeusefullyexploredacrosscities.SeeRecommendation8.
![Page 27: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that](https://reader030.vdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022040214/5eb8e5f6a04f5d4e024880fc/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
27
5 Looking ahead
5.1 GROWINGTHECAMPAIGN
ThereisasetofconsiderationsandoptionsforBSHFaroundwhether,howandhowfast,andwhere,togrowthecampaign.Partnerssupportgrowthinthenumberofparticipatingcitiesinprinciplebutidentifysomeconcernsinpractice,includinginrelationtothecampaign’scapacitytosupportamuchlargernumberofcitieswhilebeingsurethatthosealreadyinvolvedhavereachedalevelofengagementsuchthattheirrelianceonBSHFislimited.The2016evaluationindicatesacampaigntarget“toengageupto50Europeancities…by2020”.Thisspeedofgrowthseemsunlikelygiventhereisalimittohowmanynewcitiescouldreasonablybetakenoneachyear.Butitdoesreflectapresumptionofgrowth,andthatthisismanageable,basedonthelogicthat“themorewegrowitthemoreimpactitwillpotentiallyhave”.Feedbackfrominterviewsandfromsurveyrespondentssuggeststhatpartnerssupporttheideaofgrowthinprincipleandcanseethebenefits,includingintermsofconsolidatingthecampaign,generatingincreasedinterestandvisibility,andbuildingandsharingknowledgeamongstacommunityofcities.Butpartnersarealsoawareoftherisksandchallenges.Wediscussissuesaroundcoordination,governanceandresourcingbelow.Somealsomentionedconcernsaroundpossibledispersalanddilutionofeffortandfocus:“[thecampaign]needsastrongcentralbodytokeepthefocusonimpactandfacilitatethesharing.ThismaybelostifBSHFisspreadtoothinly”.Hencetherewasastrandofopinionamongstpartnersthatanygrowthneedstobemanagedcarefullyandsequencedright.Onepartnersuggestedthat“Youneedtohaveaveryactiveanddynamiccoregroup,withamomentum,beforeyoutoexpandfurther”.Anothernotedthat“Maybeweshouldbecarefulnottohavetoomanycitiesinvolved,becauseitwillbedifficulttobecomeactive,involvedandpersonal,whichisimportantinsuchcampaigns”.Somefeltitwouldbehelpfultodemonstratesuccessmoredefinitivelybeforeexpandingthenumberofcitiesinvolved.Onepartnernotedthat“Ifwe'renotabletoevidenceimpactofthecampaign,theconcernisthatthecampaignisonlyatalkingshop...Weneedtokeepshowingpeoplethatitdoeswork”.Anotherfeltthatitwouldbeeasiertopromoteandexpandthecampaign,onceresultsareclearer:“theproblemisthattherearesomeexamplesbut…theydon’tseemrelevanttoEurope…Ifwecanshow[it’spossibleinEurope]thatwouldbevaluable”.In
![Page 28: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that](https://reader030.vdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022040214/5eb8e5f6a04f5d4e024880fc/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
28
relationtothis,variouspartnersfromothercitieshavehighhopesforTorbayasacitythatcanleadthewayinshowingthatthisapproachcanbesuccessful.Onedescribeditas“agoodtestingground”,althoughsuccessheremayraiseaquestionofhowtransferableeffectivepracticeinasmalltownwitharelativelyfavourablecontextistolarger,morecomplicatedcities.Citycampaignsseemtobemosteffectivewhentheybuildonexisting,iflatent,supportforchange.Therearesomestrategicchoicesthatthecampaignmightwanttomakearoundhowmuchtofocusontheareaswherethereismostlikelytobe(relatively)quickprogress.It’sbecomingapparentthatasetofconditionshelpunderpincitylevelprogress:• Support,oratleastconstructiveinterest,frommunicipalauthorities;• Partnerswhoarecommittedtothecampaignprinciplesandwillingandabletoshow
leadershiptoadvancethem;• Partnerswhohaveexistinglocallinksandrelationships,orhavethepotentialtodevelop
them,includingwithdecision-makers.
It’sprobablytruethatincitieswheremostprogresshasbeenmadesofar,alocal‘willingnesstochange’coincidedwiththecampaign,ratherthanbeingcreatedbyit.Thecampaignhasthenhelpedbuildandinstitutionalisethissupport.Therelationalaspecttothisiskey.Asonepartnerputit,“Youhavetoinvesttimeinbuildingtrustwithalltheservice-providers.Ittookalongtimebutoncewehavethetrust,wecoulddeliverabetterapproach…Thecampaignhasbeenavehicle,itgaveusanethostogatherpeoplearound”.Andanotherpartnersimilarlyhighlightedthisideaofthecampaignprovidingafocustomobilisearound:“Thecampaignisgreatincoalescinganeedforsystemicchange…Thecampaignhasunblockedthepathtoclosercooperation”.Thispointstotheexistenceinsome,perhapsmany,citiesofalatentdesireforchangethatthecampaignisabletoexploit.Thissuggeststhatthecampaignistimely.Atleastsomecityauthoritiesareopentochangeandthereisopportunitytopushon,andtakethisnewapproachtoendinghomelessnesstoanotherlevel.Butalsothatitislikelytobe“difficulttosucceedwithoutlocalauthoritysupport”.Andthatraisesthequestionofhowmuchthecampaigniswillingtotakeon‘hardercases’,wherethebarrierstochangearegreaterandthepaceofchangelikelytobeslower.Thislinksinwithdiscussionaboutexpandingthegeographicalreachofthecampaign.Thereislikelyatrade-offbetweenfindingconducivecities,wheresuccessisrelativelylikely,andexpandingtonewpartsofEurope,suchasCentralandEasternEurope.Oneonhand“beingcrediblyEuropeanandachievingnothingforbeingspreadtoothinlyisaworseoption”butontheother“theriskatthemomentthoughisthattheyworkwhereitiseasiest”.Maybetherightresponsetothisistobedeliberateinselectingamixofcities,ensuringtherearesomewhereconditionssuggesttherearereasonableprospectsofquickerwins(aswithTorbayforexample)butalsoinvolvingcitieswherethechallengesaregreater?
![Page 29: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that](https://reader030.vdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022040214/5eb8e5f6a04f5d4e024880fc/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
29
Asthecampaigngrows,theremayneedtobesomeadditionalcampaigncommunication(internallyandexternally)inlanguagesotherthanEnglish.CampaigncommunicationiscurrentlyinEnglish,whichmeansthat“languageisaproblemforsomecountriesandsomepeople”.Asitexpands,onesuggestionwasthatthecampaign“couldhavesomelevelofexchangeinEnglish,andsomeotherlevelsusingotherlanguageswhichallowsmorepeopleandmorecountriestobeinvolved”.Decisionsaboutlanguagearealsoaboutpositioning:“ExternallyitwouldbebetterifthereweremorelanguagesthanjustEnglish.Itwouldthenraisemoreattentioninsomeothercountries”.SeeRecommendation9.
5.2 AEUROPEANCAMPAIGN?
Somepartnersseethepotentialtodevelopamorecoordinatedcampaigningapproach.Thecurrent,city-basedmodelisaviableonebutsomefeltthatcomplementingthiswithsomemorecentralisedadvocacyisanalternativeworthconsidering.Severalintervieweesmadesuggestionsaroundhavingmoreofaunifyingcampaigngoaland/orsetofmessages.Asoneputit,“WhatBSHF[provide]iscentralresourcesandtraining,whichisuseful,buthasalimit.Wehavetodecideifwewanttocreateacommunicationcampaignshowingthingsarehappeninginmanycities”.Anotherasked:“Theprojectcancontinuetoprovidehelptoindividualcities,andthenwhat?ArewetryingtohaveaEuropeancampaign?”Maintainingthefocusofthecampaignatcity-levelacrossmultiplecities,withadegreeofcrossfertilisationbetweencities,isaviableoptionforthefuture.Butsomepointedtothedrawbacksofthis,offeringthecritiquethat,withoutanoverarching,unifyinggoal,thecampaignlacksavisionof“howtoreachatippingpointbywhich…themovementofthemostvulnerablepeopleoffthestreetsacrossEurope[gathers]momentum”.SomefelttoothatmoreproactivecommunicationswouldhelpgenerateagreatersenseofbeingpartofaEuropeanmovement.Andforsome,theabsenceofnationalorregionalleveladvocacyalsomissestheopportunitytojointhedotsandsupportlocallevelwork,asthefollowingquotesillustrate:• “Alotoftheproblemsrelatetonationally-decided,centralgovernmentpolicy…[asthe
campaigngrows]herecouldbescopeforsomesemi-coordinatedadvocacyfromacrosscities”.
• “Therearepocketsofsupport[forHousingFirstandthecampaign]amongNGOsandauthoritiesacrossEurope,soweneedtoconnectthemup”.
![Page 30: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that](https://reader030.vdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022040214/5eb8e5f6a04f5d4e024880fc/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
30
• “Thereisaninternationalassociationofmayors.Woulditbeusefultoraisequestionofhomelessnessatthislevel?Ifwegoonbothsides,wemightprogressmorequickly”.
SeeRecommendation10.
5.3 FUTURECOORDINATIONAPPROACHANDSTRUCTURES
Therearesomedifferentoptionsforhowthestructuralcoordinationofthecampaigncouldevolve.Alltheoptionshavesomeadvantagesbutnoneofthemprovideanobviousandclearrouteforward.Alongsimilarlinestotheoptionssetoutinthe2016evaluation,weseefourpossiblestructuralmodelsforthecampaign.1/BSHFremainsthecoordinatingbody.Oneoptionsetoutin2016evaluation.Thisisthemoststraightforwardandhasworkedtodate.But,asnoted,itislikelytobedifficultforBSHFtoleadagenuinelypan-Europeancampaignwithoutactivestrategicpartnerships:“ThereisalackofleadershipintermsofEuropeanhomelessnesscampaigning.BSHFisdoingthebestitcan,theygivegoodsupport,buttogofurther,weneedtheinvolvementofstrongEuropeanactors”.MaintainingthisapproachalsocreatesahighlevelofrelianceonBSHF’scontinuinginvolvement.2/BSHFoperatesinconjunctionwithaEuropeanstrategicpartner.Again,thiswasoutlinedasanoptioninthe2016evaluation.Onthefaceofit,FEANTSAistheobviousstrategicpartneratthepan-Europeanlevel,butthatwoulddependonprioritiesbeingaligned.BeyondFEANTSA,bymostaccounts,therearelimitedoptions,withfewifanyothershavingtherightkindofcombinationofgeographicalreachandinterest.3/BSHFpartfundsaleadbody.Thiswasathirdoptionsuggestedinthe2016evaluation,drawingontheCommunitySolutionsmodelappliedinCanada.Presumablyoption2couldevolveintothis,asBSHFprogressivelystepsback.Butithasthesamechallengesaswithoption2:notably,whowouldbetheleadbody?4/BSHFmaintainsoverarching(lighttouch)campaigncoordinationwithaseriesofcountryleadpartnersand/orcoalitionsresponsibleforcoordinationatcountrylevel.Thisoptionwasnotconsideredinthe2016evaluationreportbutacoupleofcontributorstothisreviewsuggestedsomethingalongthoselines.Suchamodelwouldbeconsistentwithcampaignaspirationtobebottom-upanditwould(intheoryatleast)allowfordifferentlevelsofcoordination,andofcommunication–bylinguisticgroup/nationallyforexample.Butitdoesintroduceanotherlayeroforganisationsowouldinvolvemorecomplicatedcampaignmanagementarrangement.Still,itcouldbeapossiblelongertermsolutionworthconsidering.
![Page 31: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that](https://reader030.vdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022040214/5eb8e5f6a04f5d4e024880fc/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
31
It’sgoodthatresourcingtosupportthecampaignisinplaceoverthemediumterm–butthismaynotfullyresolvethequestionofresourcing,dependingondecisionsaboutthecampaign'sstrategicpurposeandthefuturerolethatBSHFwillplay.BSHFhascommittedabudgettosupportthiswork,whichwethinkisveryhelpfulinensuringsomeleveloffuturestability.Existingbudgetsessentiallycoverstaffcostsandfundingforsupport–throughwebinars,bespokesupportfromconsultants,andanannualgathering.WhilstthisrepresentsasignificantcommitmentofsupportfromBSHF,therearestillquestionsastowhetherthisisadequateforfutureneed.Thereareplanstogrowthecampaignfairlysubstantially,withoutequivalentgrowthinresourcingorbudgets.Therationaleforthisisessentiallythat(i)growthbringseconomiesofscaleandthat(ii)citypartnerscanthemselvesplayanexpandedrole,sothatsupportbecomesmorebilaterallydriven,forexample.Theseseembroadlyreasonableassumptionsalthoughattheoptimisticendofthespectrum.However,oneconsequenceisthat,withgrowth,it’slikelythattheroleofBSHFbecomeslessaboutleadingthecampaignandmorearoundprovidinganoverallframeworkwithinwhichlocalcampaignscanoperate.Thiswillprobablymakeithardertotroubleshoot(andofferadditionalsupportwhere/ifneeded,forexample)andtherewilllikelybelessofarolethatBSHFcanplayinsharinglearning,andencouragingthis,acrosscities.Therecouldbepinchpoints,tooaroundtheexpandingcostsofmeetingsasnumbersgrowand,possibly,futuretranslationcosts.Itisalsountestedwhetherchampionswithinexisting(ornew)citiescantakemoreofarole.Oursenseisthattheyarewillingbutalreadystretched.AsBSHFisaware,thesequestionsaboutresourcingarelinkedtothoseaboutpartnershipsandstrategy.Partnershipswouldlikelybringadditionalresourcing.Anddifferentstrategiescomewithdifferentresourceimplications.IfthecampaignevolvestowardshavingacomplementaryEuropeanand/ornationaldimensionalongthelinesmentionedaboveinsection5.2,forexample,thenthereisaneedforcentralresourcingthatwouldn’totherwisebethere.Soitdoesn’tmakesensetothinkaboutresourcingoutofcontext.WhilstitisgoodthatafoundationalelementofBSHF’sresourcingsupportisbanked,thisdoesnotmakeitasettledissue.
5.4 DEVELOPINGTHESTRATEGY
Nowisagoodtimetoreviewtheoverallcampaignstrategy.Thereareasetofinter-relatedchoicesabout(a)whatsortof‘campaign’itshouldbe(b)whatthegrowthstrategyshouldbe(c)whatkindofstrategicpartnershipsshouldsupportnationallevelaction(d)whatresourcesareneededandwheretheyshouldcomefrom
![Page 32: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that](https://reader030.vdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022040214/5eb8e5f6a04f5d4e024880fc/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
32
(e)thebestsystemsforsharinglearningandencouragingcross-fertilisation,andtherolethatBSHFshouldplayinthis.Thestrategydeployedhasbeenappropriatetodate.Butasweflaginthisreport,therearesomedifferentideas,andviablealternativeoptions,thatitmightbegoodtoexplore.ButthenagainifBSHFdoesn’thavethescopeorinterestinturningthecampaignintosomethingdifferentfromwhatitiscurrently,thenthatitselfcouldstillbeaperfectlyreasonablepositiontoadopt.Inanycase,itwouldbehelpfultobeclearabouttheparametersandscopeforevolution.Thereisaquestionaboutwhoisinvolvedinconsideringfuturestrategy,withsomedifferentoptionsabouthowthatcouldbedone. Whatthefuturestrategymightlooklikeislinkedtoaquestionaroundwhomightbeinvolvedindevelopingthatstrategy.TodateithasbeenBSHF’svisionandstrategydrivingthecampaign’sevolution.BSHF–astheinitiatorandcoordinatorofthecampaign–hassetoutanoverarchingstrategicapproachwithinwhichthereisoperationalflexibility.ItmaybethatBSHFwouldliketoretainalevelofstrategic‘control’ofthecampaigninfuture.ButnowmightbeagoodtimeforBSHFtothinkaboutwhether,andhowmuch,toinvolvecitypartnersinthinkingthroughfuturestrategyoptions.Onepartnercalledforastructureddiscussionaboutstrategyamongstpartners,andothersmootedasimilaridea:“Theyaredoingagoodjob,but…maybeneedtogivespacetootheractors,shareleadership…”Thinkingaboutastrategydevelopmentprocess,theoptionsforthisareessentially:1. BSHFsetsoutthecampaignstrategyandinviteotherstobepartofit.2. BSHFretainsresponsibilityforstrategybutseekspartners’inputs(whichthisreportand
discussionarounditshouldprovide)beforesettingouttheproposedfuturestrategicdirection.
3. BSHFjointlydevelopsstrategywithpartners(orsomesubgroupof‘nominatedrepresentatives’)throughacollaborativeprocess.
Therearestrengthsandweaknessestoeachoftheseapproaches–butitcouldbehelpfultomakecleartheprocessandthelevelofparticipationofcitypartners.SeeRecommendation11.
![Page 33: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that](https://reader030.vdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022040214/5eb8e5f6a04f5d4e024880fc/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
33
6 Recommendations Recommendation1ReviewhowcampaignpositionsaroundHousingFirstaresetoutandcommunicated,toensurecommonunderstandingamongstparticipatingorganisations.Recommendation2Developguidancethatencouragespartnerstoupdatevolunteersandotherinterestedpartnersoncampaignprogress.Recommendation3Reviewhowcampaignpositionsaroundcommunityinvolvementaresetoutandcommunicated,toensurecommonunderstandingamongstparticipatingorganisations.Recommendation4Considerpracticalwaystoencouragelearningopportunitiesbetweencities,boththroughBSHFandbilaterally,takingintoaccountdifferentiatedneeds(accordingtogeographyandhistoryofinvolvementforexample).Recommendation5Developanapproachtocampaigntrackingandmonitoringthatsupportsbettergenerationofandaccesstoreal-timeinformation.Somepracticalstepscouldincludedeveloping:• An‘outcomebank’withsomeguidanceonwhatoutcomesareofparticularinterest;• Acampaign‘evidencedatabase’thatallcanaddto;• Supportandguidancearoundreviewinginformationinwaysthatfeedintoplanning;• Supporttoeffortstodevelopcasestudiesthatillustrateprogressbeingmade.Recommendation6Considerdevelopingsomeprotocolsandguidancearoundcommunicatingdifficultmessages,suchasinrelationtomigrantsandrefugees.Recommendation7Establish-aspartofcampaigntracking–asetofcommondefinitions/indicatorsthatclearlyexpressthechangesthecampaignseek(whichwouldincludenumbersofpeoplehousedinHousingFirstaccommodation,butalsomeasurestodowithhowthathousingstatusissustained);andagreehowthatinformationwillberecordedandreported.Recommendation8Considersettingupaprocessorforumtoconsidercommonchallengesandhowtoovercomebarrierslinkedtolimitsonhousingstockandland.Recommendation9Developagrowthstrategythatsetsoutideasonthespeedandsequencingofexpansiontonewcitiesandthebestmixofcitiestoinvolve,andimplicationsarisingfromthis(aroundlanguageforexample).
![Page 34: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that](https://reader030.vdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022040214/5eb8e5f6a04f5d4e024880fc/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
34
Recommendation10Considerthepotentialforcomplementingcity-leveladvocacywithsomecoordinatedadvocacythatdrawsonexperiencesacrosscities.Recommendation11Considerwhetherandhowbesttoinvolvepartnersindevelopingstrategicoptions.
![Page 35: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that](https://reader030.vdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022040214/5eb8e5f6a04f5d4e024880fc/html5/thumbnails/35.jpg)
35
Appendix 1: Campaign timeline
Figure 7: Summary campaign timeline
Oct�15
Jan�16
Apr�16
Jul�16
Oct�16
Jan�17
Apr�17
Jul�17
Oct�17
Valencia CW
Barcelona CW CW
Westminster CW CW
Brno
Copenhagen
Lyon
CW CW
CW
CW
CW
CW
CW
PILOT�PHASE
u
u u u
u u
u
KEY
Cardiff
u u u
Croydon
Brussels
Torbay
Glasgow
Alicante
Brighton
Toolkit�producedWebinars
participating�city
engaged�city
CW�=�Connections�Week
Peer�exchange�visit
Budapest
Leicester
BSHF-organised�city�gatheringsOther�city�meetings
![Page 36: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that](https://reader030.vdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022040214/5eb8e5f6a04f5d4e024880fc/html5/thumbnails/36.jpg)
36
Appendix 2: Campaign principles
1. Housing First: Ensuring (or working towards ensuring) homeless people are housed in permanent, safe, appropriate and affordable housing with support to sustain it.
2. Knowing who’s out there: Getting to know every homeless person by name by going onto the streets to find them and assess their needs.
3. Tracking progress: Regularly collecting person-specific data to accurately track progress toward ending homelessness.
4. Many people are concerned about the individuals in their communities who have no roof to sleep under and they want to play a meaningful part in helping to find solutions.
5. Improving local systems: Building coordinated housing and support systems that are simple to navigate, while targeting resources quickly to those who need it the most.
6. Learning from and sharing with others: Working collaboratively to help the campaign make the biggest difference to those who are homeless.
![Page 37: BSHF European End Street Homelessness Campaign evaluation€¦ · The European End Street Homelessness Campaign is funded and coordinated by BSHF. It was set up on the principle that](https://reader030.vdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022040214/5eb8e5f6a04f5d4e024880fc/html5/thumbnails/37.jpg)
37
Appendix 3: Survey responses: campaign outcomes
Figure8:Partners’survey:Perspectivesoncampaignoutcomes
Figure9:Partners’survey:Perspectivesonorganisationalbenefits
0
0
0
0
1
0
1
1
2
2
3
4
3
3
3
5
2
4
3
2
2
4
3
1
4
2
2
2
2
0
0
0
0% 100%
ProducingusefulnewevidenceforNGOs,chari>esandagenciesworkingonhomelessnessissues
Genera>nglocalmediacoverage
BuildingabeCerunderstandingoftheproblemstobetackledinordertoendstreethomelessness
Crea>nginterestonsocialmedia
Influencingdecisionmakersinlocal,regionalormunicipalauthori>es
Involvingmembersofthecommunityinhomelessnesscampaigning
Genera>ngna>onalmediacoverage
Genera>ngcommunitysolu>onstocommunityproblems
Howsuccessfulwouldyousaythelocalcampaignhasbeensofarin...
Notatall Partly Mostly Very
1
0
0
0
0
4
5
4
0
0
2
3
3
6
3
1
0
1
2
4
0% 100%
Be,erlinkstorelevantlocalorganisa9ons
Astrongerinfluenceonlocaldecisionmakers
Improvedworkingrela9onshipswithrelevantlocalorganisa9ons
Aclearerideaabouteffec9vewaystohelppeopleoffthestreets
Be,erdata
Asaresultofpar-cipa-nginthecampaign,myorganisa-onorlocalcoali-onhas...
Stronglydisagree Disagree Neitheragreenordisagree Agree Stronglyagree