bring it all together · august 9-10, 2016 | fargo, nd| in -place recycling & reclaiming...

39
August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In-Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar Bring It All Together THOMAS J. WOOD PAVEMENT SPECIALIST WSB & ASSOCIATES 1

Upload: others

Post on 07-Aug-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Bring It All Together · August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In -Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar Performance Data YEAR CUMULATIVE BESALs 2009 773,000 2010 1,356,300

August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In-Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar

Bring It All Together THOMAS J. WOOD

PAVEMENT SPECIALIST WSB & ASSOCIATES

1

Page 2: Bring It All Together · August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In -Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar Performance Data YEAR CUMULATIVE BESALs 2009 773,000 2010 1,356,300

August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In-Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar

Agenda

Case Study

Benefits

Construction

Performance examples

2

Page 3: Bring It All Together · August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In -Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar Performance Data YEAR CUMULATIVE BESALs 2009 773,000 2010 1,356,300

August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In-Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar

3 Bituminous Recycling Options

Page 4: Bring It All Together · August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In -Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar Performance Data YEAR CUMULATIVE BESALs 2009 773,000 2010 1,356,300

August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In-Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar

Why do FDR, CIR, or HIR?

Cost effective CIR cost 30 to 60 % less than reconstruction FRD cost 20 to 50% less than reconstruction HIR depends on cost of HMA and Availability

4

Page 5: Bring It All Together · August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In -Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar Performance Data YEAR CUMULATIVE BESALs 2009 773,000 2010 1,356,300

August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In-Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar

Why do FDR, CIR, or HIR

Environmentally acceptable Reuse existing roadway materials Less energy used Less green house gases given off

5

Page 6: Bring It All Together · August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In -Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar Performance Data YEAR CUMULATIVE BESALs 2009 773,000 2010 1,356,300

August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In-Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar

Why do FDR, CIR, or HIR

Add structure to pavement Limits grade change Can use other surfacing methods Fast Easy

6

Page 7: Bring It All Together · August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In -Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar Performance Data YEAR CUMULATIVE BESALs 2009 773,000 2010 1,356,300

August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In-Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar

What’s Import for Agencies

Proper project selection What is the in place pavement like

Evaluation of existing road Strength

Drainage

Safety

7

Page 8: Bring It All Together · August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In -Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar Performance Data YEAR CUMULATIVE BESALs 2009 773,000 2010 1,356,300

August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In-Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar

What’s Import for Agencies

What is the estimated future loadings

What type of surface HMA

Chip Seal

Other

8

Page 9: Bring It All Together · August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In -Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar Performance Data YEAR CUMULATIVE BESALs 2009 773,000 2010 1,356,300

August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In-Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar

What’s Import for Agencies

Planning Specifications

Design

Additives

Pay items

Incentives

Contactor availability

9

Page 10: Bring It All Together · August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In -Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar Performance Data YEAR CUMULATIVE BESALs 2009 773,000 2010 1,356,300

August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In-Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar

What’s Import for Agencies

Construction Do you have trained inspectors

In house

Consulates

Numerous source for training UGPTI

ARRA

10

Page 11: Bring It All Together · August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In -Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar Performance Data YEAR CUMULATIVE BESALs 2009 773,000 2010 1,356,300

August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In-Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar

What’s Import for Agencies

QC / QA plan

Check depths

Cross slope

Compaction, Compaction, Compaction

Drainage, Drainage, Drainage

11

Page 12: Bring It All Together · August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In -Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar Performance Data YEAR CUMULATIVE BESALs 2009 773,000 2010 1,356,300

August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In-Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar

Cold In-place Recycling (CIR)

12

Page 13: Bring It All Together · August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In -Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar Performance Data YEAR CUMULATIVE BESALs 2009 773,000 2010 1,356,300

August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In-Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar

13

Check depth of cut & cross slope every hour

Check milling teeth often

Page 14: Bring It All Together · August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In -Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar Performance Data YEAR CUMULATIVE BESALs 2009 773,000 2010 1,356,300

August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In-Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar

14

Calibrate additive meters

No holes is screed deck or paving fabric

Check Pug mill paddles for wear

Keep paver close to train

Page 15: Bring It All Together · August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In -Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar Performance Data YEAR CUMULATIVE BESALs 2009 773,000 2010 1,356,300

August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In-Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar

Using CIR to Improve Ride 15

Some type of profile system

Page 16: Bring It All Together · August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In -Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar Performance Data YEAR CUMULATIVE BESALs 2009 773,000 2010 1,356,300

August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In-Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar

16

40’ ski on paver

Page 17: Bring It All Together · August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In -Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar Performance Data YEAR CUMULATIVE BESALs 2009 773,000 2010 1,356,300

August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In-Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar

Full Depth Reclamation 17

Correct Drainage

Pre -Grind

Page 18: Bring It All Together · August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In -Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar Performance Data YEAR CUMULATIVE BESALs 2009 773,000 2010 1,356,300

August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In-Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar

18

Re-mix for consistence

Page 19: Bring It All Together · August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In -Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar Performance Data YEAR CUMULATIVE BESALs 2009 773,000 2010 1,356,300

August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In-Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar

19

Compact until walks out

Page 20: Bring It All Together · August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In -Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar Performance Data YEAR CUMULATIVE BESALs 2009 773,000 2010 1,356,300

August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In-Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar

20

Watch width of roadway

Page 21: Bring It All Together · August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In -Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar Performance Data YEAR CUMULATIVE BESALs 2009 773,000 2010 1,356,300

August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In-Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar

Compaction, Compaction, Compaction

21

Page 22: Bring It All Together · August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In -Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar Performance Data YEAR CUMULATIVE BESALs 2009 773,000 2010 1,356,300

August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In-Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar

22

Page 23: Bring It All Together · August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In -Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar Performance Data YEAR CUMULATIVE BESALs 2009 773,000 2010 1,356,300

August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In-Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar

Some Interesting Uses for In-place recycling

23

Page 24: Bring It All Together · August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In -Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar Performance Data YEAR CUMULATIVE BESALs 2009 773,000 2010 1,356,300

August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In-Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar

Using CIR on BOC 24

CIR of BOC

Page 25: Bring It All Together · August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In -Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar Performance Data YEAR CUMULATIVE BESALs 2009 773,000 2010 1,356,300

August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In-Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar

FDR With Thin HMA Surfacing

MnROAD Cells 2, 3, & 4 mainline 3.5 Million ESALS Design 5 years to reach design life 85% of pave road in MN > 3.5 ESALS design

25

Page 26: Bring It All Together · August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In -Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar Performance Data YEAR CUMULATIVE BESALs 2009 773,000 2010 1,356,300

August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In-Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar

26

Page 27: Bring It All Together · August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In -Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar Performance Data YEAR CUMULATIVE BESALs 2009 773,000 2010 1,356,300

August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In-Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar

Performance Data

YEAR CUMULATIVE BESALs 2009 773,000 2010 1,356,300 2011 1,988,300 2012 2,707,500 2013 3,684,600 Reached design loadings 2014 4,507,600 2015 5,258,800 2016* 5,709,600 * Estimated through June, 2016

27

Page 28: Bring It All Together · August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In -Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar Performance Data YEAR CUMULATIVE BESALs 2009 773,000 2010 1,356,300

August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In-Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar

28

Page 29: Bring It All Together · August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In -Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar Performance Data YEAR CUMULATIVE BESALs 2009 773,000 2010 1,356,300

August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In-Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar

Using CIR to Widen Roadway

29

Page 30: Bring It All Together · August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In -Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar Performance Data YEAR CUMULATIVE BESALs 2009 773,000 2010 1,356,300

August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In-Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar

30

Page 31: Bring It All Together · August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In -Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar Performance Data YEAR CUMULATIVE BESALs 2009 773,000 2010 1,356,300

August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In-Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar

31

Page 32: Bring It All Together · August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In -Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar Performance Data YEAR CUMULATIVE BESALs 2009 773,000 2010 1,356,300

August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In-Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar

32

New 13’ Lane 11’ Lane

Page 33: Bring It All Together · August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In -Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar Performance Data YEAR CUMULATIVE BESALs 2009 773,000 2010 1,356,300

August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In-Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar

Alternate method for streets or county roads reconstruction

33

Page 34: Bring It All Together · August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In -Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar Performance Data YEAR CUMULATIVE BESALs 2009 773,000 2010 1,356,300

August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In-Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar

Emulsion Stabilized FDR 34

Page 35: Bring It All Together · August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In -Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar Performance Data YEAR CUMULATIVE BESALs 2009 773,000 2010 1,356,300

August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In-Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar

Double Chip Surface 35

Page 36: Bring It All Together · August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In -Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar Performance Data YEAR CUMULATIVE BESALs 2009 773,000 2010 1,356,300

August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In-Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar

70 + laps per day at 80K 36

Page 37: Bring It All Together · August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In -Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar Performance Data YEAR CUMULATIVE BESALs 2009 773,000 2010 1,356,300

August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In-Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar

Current Condition 37

Page 38: Bring It All Together · August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In -Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar Performance Data YEAR CUMULATIVE BESALs 2009 773,000 2010 1,356,300

August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In-Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar

Questions? 38

Page 39: Bring It All Together · August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In -Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar Performance Data YEAR CUMULATIVE BESALs 2009 773,000 2010 1,356,300

August 9-10, 2016 | Fargo, ND| In-Place Recycling & Reclaiming Seminar

Thank You 39