born again disks as signposts for planets john h. debes space telescope science institute

32
Born Again Disks as Signposts for Planets John H. Debes Space Telescope Science Institute

Upload: suzan-carson

Post on 30-Dec-2015

212 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Born Again Disks as Signposts for Planets John H. Debes Space Telescope Science Institute

Born Again Disks as Signposts for Planets

John H. DebesSpace Telescope Science Institute

Page 2: Born Again Disks as Signposts for Planets John H. Debes Space Telescope Science Institute

Slide from B. Gaensicke

Page 3: Born Again Disks as Signposts for Planets John H. Debes Space Telescope Science Institute

Slide from B. Gaensicke

Page 4: Born Again Disks as Signposts for Planets John H. Debes Space Telescope Science Institute

Slide from B. Gaensicke

Page 5: Born Again Disks as Signposts for Planets John H. Debes Space Telescope Science Institute

Dusty White Dwarfs are Signposts for

Planets• In 1987, the ZZ Ceti G29-38 was discovered to have an infrared excess

• Excess first attributed to brown dwarf, eventually attributed to dust (i.e. Graham et al., 1991) Zuckerman & Becklin

(1987)

Page 6: Born Again Disks as Signposts for Planets John H. Debes Space Telescope Science Institute

Data from Reach et al. (2005)

Rin=10 RWD

Rout=30 RWD

Page 7: Born Again Disks as Signposts for Planets John H. Debes Space Telescope Science Institute

StructureAfter Jura (2003), Jura et al., (2007), Reach et al., (2009)

Dust Sublimation Tidal Disruption Radius

Page 8: Born Again Disks as Signposts for Planets John H. Debes Space Telescope Science Institute
Page 9: Born Again Disks as Signposts for Planets John H. Debes Space Telescope Science Institute

Slide from B. Gaensicke

Gaseous WD Disks Are Signposts

Page 10: Born Again Disks as Signposts for Planets John H. Debes Space Telescope Science Institute

Metal line White Dwarfs are

Signposts for Planets• G29-38 also

showed absorption lines due to Ca, Mg, and Fe

• Large telescopes with high resolution spectrographs discovered that 25% of WDs have metal pollution (Zuckerman et al., 2003; Koester et al., 2005)Debes et al. (2010)

Page 11: Born Again Disks as Signposts for Planets John H. Debes Space Telescope Science Institute

CompositionZuckerman et al. (2007)

Page 12: Born Again Disks as Signposts for Planets John H. Debes Space Telescope Science Institute

COS can find exquisite

abundances

Gaensicke et al. (2011, in prep)

Page 13: Born Again Disks as Signposts for Planets John H. Debes Space Telescope Science Institute

+ =

Page 14: Born Again Disks as Signposts for Planets John H. Debes Space Telescope Science Institute

Planetesimal Survival

Dong et al., (2010)

Page 15: Born Again Disks as Signposts for Planets John H. Debes Space Telescope Science Institute

Survival of Planetesimals

Sublimation

Lmax=2x104 Lʘ

Gas Drag

3 Mʘ

1.5 Mʘ

1 MʘLmax=104 Lʘ

Page 16: Born Again Disks as Signposts for Planets John H. Debes Space Telescope Science Institute

How do you get asteroids in?

Debes & Sigurdsson (2002)

Unstable Planets

Page 17: Born Again Disks as Signposts for Planets John H. Debes Space Telescope Science Institute

Bonsor et al., (2011)

Exterior Resonances

Page 18: Born Again Disks as Signposts for Planets John H. Debes Space Telescope Science Institute

Debes et al., in prep

Interior Resonances

Page 19: Born Again Disks as Signposts for Planets John H. Debes Space Telescope Science Institute

Accretion from Interior

Resonances

Gaensicke COS Survey

Debes et al., in prep

Page 20: Born Again Disks as Signposts for Planets John H. Debes Space Telescope Science Institute

Predict Belt Masses from Polluted WDs

Debes et al., in prep

Page 21: Born Again Disks as Signposts for Planets John H. Debes Space Telescope Science Institute

For more info, check out this

new book!

Page 22: Born Again Disks as Signposts for Planets John H. Debes Space Telescope Science Institute

Wide-field Infrared Survey Explorer

WISE Mission Overview

Salient FeaturesSalient Features• 4 imaging channels covering 3 - 25 microns 4 imaging channels covering 3 - 25 microns

wavelengthwavelength• 40 cm telescope operating at <17K40 cm telescope operating at <17K• Two stage solid hydrogen cryostatTwo stage solid hydrogen cryostat

• Delta launch from WTR on December 14, 2009 Delta launch from WTR on December 14, 2009 • Sun-synchronous 6am/6pm 500km orbitSun-synchronous 6am/6pm 500km orbit• Scan mirror provides efficient mappingScan mirror provides efficient mapping

• Operational life: estimate 11 monthsOperational life: estimate 11 months• 4 TDRSS tracks per day4 TDRSS tracks per day

Salient FeaturesSalient Features• 4 imaging channels covering 3 - 25 microns 4 imaging channels covering 3 - 25 microns

wavelengthwavelength• 40 cm telescope operating at <17K40 cm telescope operating at <17K• Two stage solid hydrogen cryostatTwo stage solid hydrogen cryostat

• Delta launch from WTR on December 14, 2009 Delta launch from WTR on December 14, 2009 • Sun-synchronous 6am/6pm 500km orbitSun-synchronous 6am/6pm 500km orbit• Scan mirror provides efficient mappingScan mirror provides efficient mapping

• Operational life: estimate 11 monthsOperational life: estimate 11 months• 4 TDRSS tracks per day4 TDRSS tracks per day

ScienceScience• Sensitive all sky survey with 8X redundancySensitive all sky survey with 8X redundancy

– Find the most luminous galaxies in the universe– Find the closest stars+brown dwarfs to the sun– Provide an important catalog for JWST– Provide lasting research legacy

ScienceScience• Sensitive all sky survey with 8X redundancySensitive all sky survey with 8X redundancy

– Find the most luminous galaxies in the universe– Find the closest stars+brown dwarfs to the sun– Provide an important catalog for JWST– Provide lasting research legacy

National Aeronautics and Space Administration

Jet Propulsion LaboratoryCalifornia Institute of Technology

Page 23: Born Again Disks as Signposts for Planets John H. Debes Space Telescope Science Institute

• Dominic Benford - GSFC• Andrew Blain - Caltech• Martin Cohen - UCB• Roc Cutri - IPAC• Peter Eisenhardt -JPL• Nick Gautier - JPL• Tom Jarrett - IPAC• Davy Kirkpatrick - IPAC• David Leisawitz - GSFC• Carol Lonsdale - NRAO

• Amy Mainzer - JPL• John Mather - GSFC• Ian McLean - UCLA• Robert McMillan - UA• Bryan Mendez - UCB• Deborah Padgett - IPAC• Michael Ressler - JPL• Michael Skrutskie - UVa• Adam Stanford - LLNL• Russell Walker - MIRA

PI: Edward L. Wright - UCLA

National Aeronautics and Space Administration

Jet Propulsion LaboratoryCalifornia Institute of Technology

Page 24: Born Again Disks as Signposts for Planets John H. Debes Space Telescope Science Institute

The WIRED Team

Stefanie Wachter, (IPAC, lead)

Don W. Hoard (IPAC)Dave T. Leisawitz (GSFC)

Martin Cohen (MIRA)

Page 25: Born Again Disks as Signposts for Planets John H. Debes Space Telescope Science Institute

WISE Nominal

Sensitivities

Debes et al., ApJS, submitted

Page 26: Born Again Disks as Signposts for Planets John H. Debes Space Telescope Science Institute

Debes et al., ApJS, submitted

Page 27: Born Again Disks as Signposts for Planets John H. Debes Space Telescope Science Institute

Known Disk

Page 28: Born Again Disks as Signposts for Planets John H. Debes Space Telescope Science Institute
Page 29: Born Again Disks as Signposts for Planets John H. Debes Space Telescope Science Institute

Circumbinary Dust

Page 30: Born Again Disks as Signposts for Planets John H. Debes Space Telescope Science Institute

Known WDs

Page 31: Born Again Disks as Signposts for Planets John H. Debes Space Telescope Science Institute

The Take Home Messages

•Dusty/Polluted/Gaseous Disk WDs need at least ONE giant planet to exist

•Mass and location of such planets may be constrained (and observed in the future with HST/JWST)

• IR+photospheric absorption lines give you detailed composition of exoasteroids

Page 32: Born Again Disks as Signposts for Planets John H. Debes Space Telescope Science Institute

Take Home Messages-2•WIRED will provide a host of new

candidates that need to be confirmed and characterized

•WIRED will provide variability info for known dusty white dwarfs

•WISE will provide legacy information as known WDs become complete to ~100pc (currently, only complete to ~20pc)

•Preliminary WISE catalogue is publicly available