book review: research highlights in social work 29. developing services for older people and their...

1
BOOK REVIEWS Research Highlights in Social Work 29. Developing Services for Older People and Their Families, Edited by ROSEMARY BLAND. In the Research Highlights series this book is really a textbook or position statement. Part I contains a chapter on ageism suggesting that working in partnership with older people may help to stem the systematic voices of dehumanization and patronizing attitudes. There is a chapter on demography where Tony Warnes refreshingly reminds us that statistics are as easily manipulated as the elderly. He says the health care demands of the elderly per se have been relatively restrained in comparison to other age groups and that politics in the form of the changes in residential care and community health services and the specialization of hospitals as acute services with loss of continuing, nursing and palliative care have put far more strain on resources and manage- ment than the modest changes in the number of older people. There are further solid chapters on the economic disadvantages of being over 75 and describing why the lemming-style rush to community care has been politic- ally motivated through the EU. There is little, however, in these research highlights that encourages us to think that we are healing the elderly. For example, Julie Curran’s review of day care for patients with dementia underlines the fact that while there is no evidence they help patients, carers desperately want them, and respite care likewise. The chapter in the ‘does he take sugar’ vein—‘I was given options not choices’—while politically correct did cause one to be mindful that the elderly are not the only ones who do not get exactly what they want in our society. Of course, by suggesting that, one risks being branded a heretic but one must not become ridiculous in one’s attempt to foster individuality and on several occasions I felt that fine divide was crossed. Having said that, the chapter on housing was a timely reminder of how undignified life can be when one is no longer able to ‘choose’ one’s dwelling—again the development of innovative schemes can keep people at home, but what if the residential care options were real options, were really aordable, dignified, private places, would we still want to stay at home with the army of strangers attending to us? The final section urges us: to be patient with the care management process (I draw a veil over that); that specialist social work teams for the elderly are incontro- vertibly a good thing; and finally reprises the empower- ment and anti-ageist arguments which are always useful to reread. Overall, though I found little novel in this book, it was interesting and one or two points were well made. It was more a review of the status quo than research high- lights, but certainly would have a place in the social work library and as a basis for student seminars. DAVID WILKINSON Western Community Hospital Southampton # 1997 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF GERIATRIC PSYCHIATRY, VOL. 12: 1046–1047 (1997) Vascular Dementia: Current Concepts. Edited by I. PROHOVNIK, J. WADE, S. KNEZEVIC,T.TATEMICHI and T. ERKINJUNTTI. Wiley, Chichester, 1996. No. of pages: 399. This textbook gives an up-to-date view of all presenta- tions of vascular dementia and the content of the book, as the title implies, is entirely devoted to the subject. The contributors are current experts in this field from centres around the world including the USA, UK, Canada, Israel, Japan, Germany, Switzerland and Finland. The book is well organized in that the chapters flow logically, progressing from the historical development of the diagnosis and criticisms of current diagnostic criteria to epidemiology, neuropathology, white matter disease, neuropsychology, neuroimaging, hypoperfusion and finally treatment. The chapter on structural imaging using MRI is exceptional and gives many fine-quality illustrations of the great variety of abnormalities that can be seen. These even include perivascular spaces if matched proton density and T2 sequences are used in the image acquisition. The frank discussions of the problems with definition, not least because of the dierent types of vascular dementia, will be of interest to all those working in the field of dementia. Most of the content of the book has clinical application and is therefore of interest to clinicians and researchers alike. Because cerebrovascular disease is such a wide field, this book will be enlightening even for those with a specialist knowledge of the subject. STEVE SIMPSON Manchester Royal Infirmary Manchester

Upload: david-wilkinson

Post on 06-Jun-2016

212 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

BOOK REVIEWS

Research Highlights in Social Work 29. DevelopingServices for Older People and Their Families, Edited byROSEMARY BLAND.

In the Research Highlights series this book is really atextbook or position statement. Part I contains a chapteron ageism suggesting that working in partnership witholder people may help to stem the systematic voices ofdehumanization and patronizing attitudes. There is achapter on demography where Tony Warnes refreshinglyreminds us that statistics are as easily manipulated as theelderly. He says the health care demands of the elderlyper se have been relatively restrained in comparison toother age groups and that politics in the form of thechanges in residential care and community healthservices and the specialization of hospitals as acuteservices with loss of continuing, nursing and palliativecare have put far more strain on resources and manage-ment than the modest changes in the number of olderpeople. There are further solid chapters on the economicdisadvantages of being over 75 and describing why thelemming-style rush to community care has been politic-ally motivated through the EU.

There is little, however, in these research highlightsthat encourages us to think that we are healing theelderly. For example, Julie Curran's review of day carefor patients with dementia underlines the fact that whilethere is no evidence they help patients, carers desperatelywant them, and respite care likewise. The chapter in the

`does he take sugar' veinÐ`I was given options notchoices'Ðwhile politically correct did cause one to bemindful that the elderly are not the only ones who do notget exactly what they want in our society. Of course, bysuggesting that, one risks being branded a heretic butone must not become ridiculous in one's attempt tofoster individuality and on several occasions I felt that®ne divide was crossed. Having said that, the chapter onhousing was a timely reminder of how undigni®ed lifecan be when one is no longer able to `choose' one'sdwellingÐagain the development of innovative schemescan keep people at home, but what if the residentialcare options were real options, were really a�ordable,digni®ed, private places, would we still want to stay athome with the army of strangers attending to us?The ®nal section urges us: to be patient with the care

management process (I draw a veil over that); thatspecialist social work teams for the elderly are incontro-vertibly a good thing; and ®nally reprises the empower-ment and anti-ageist arguments which are always usefulto reread.Overall, though I found little novel in this book, it was

interesting and one or two points were well made. It wasmore a review of the status quo than research high-lights, but certainly would have a place in the socialwork library and as a basis for student seminars.

DAVID WILKINSON

Western Community HospitalSouthampton

# 1997 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF GERIATRIC PSYCHIATRY, VOL. 12: 1046±1047 (1997)

Vascular Dementia: Current Concepts. Edited byI. PROHOVNIK, J. WADE, S. KNEZEVIC, T. TATEMICHI

and T. ERKINJUNTTI. Wiley, Chichester, 1996. No. ofpages: 399.

This textbook gives an up-to-date view of all presenta-tions of vascular dementia and the content of the book,as the title implies, is entirely devoted to the subject. Thecontributors are current experts in this ®eld from centresaround the world including the USA, UK, Canada,Israel, Japan, Germany, Switzerland and Finland. Thebook is well organized in that the chapters ¯ow logically,progressing from the historical development of thediagnosis and criticisms of current diagnostic criteriato epidemiology, neuropathology, white matter disease,neuropsychology, neuroimaging, hypoperfusion and®nally treatment. The chapter on structural imaging

using MRI is exceptional and gives many ®ne-qualityillustrations of the great variety of abnormalities that canbe seen. These even include perivascular spaces ifmatched proton density and T2 sequences are used inthe image acquisition.The frank discussions of the problems with de®nition,

not least because of the di�erent types of vasculardementia, will be of interest to all those working in the®eld of dementia. Most of the content of the book hasclinical application and is therefore of interest toclinicians and researchers alike. Because cerebrovasculardisease is such a wide ®eld, this book will be enlighteningeven for those with a specialist knowledge of the subject.

STEVE SIMPSON

Manchester Royal In®rmaryManchester