board leadership succession
TRANSCRIPT
1
Securing the Future of Your Blood Bank Through
Succession Planning
© Signature Resources 2015
Les Wallace, Ph.D.
2
Who is this guy? Ideal 21C job: Grandparent!
University professor / administrator
Hospital administrator—traditional Board
International consulting company…
Touch 20,000 people yr. / Coach 28 Execs / 17 Boards a year
50% for-profit / 50% government & not-for-profit clients
Served on a regional Bank Board of Directors
Serving on Counterpart International Board
Serving on World Future Society Board© Signature Resources 2015
© Signature Resources 2015 3
Today’s topicsWhat is leadership succession?
The Future of Governance.
What is governance leadership succession?
How do you plan for it?
Active recruitment of board members.
Selection processes.
Board development to enhance competency.
© Signature Resources 2015 4
What is leadership succession?Leadership succession is the responsibility of
boards and organizational leaders to assure that a leadership development plan is in place to prepare future key leaders.
An emergency succession policy is commonplace: who will take charge should a key leader suddenly become not available?
Investing in leadership succession in-house does not come with any promise of succession from the board or organization—both entities should always conduct a wide search for replacing key leadership.
© Signature Resources 2015 5
What is Governance leadership succession?
Governance leadership succession is the responsibility a board has to assure board makeup and future appointments meet the changing needs of the organization.
Leadership succession implies advanced thinking, recruiting and assessment of board members before they are needed.
Maintaining / improving competencies of current board members is also “competency succession.” Est. average 1 hr./month.
© Signature Resources 2015 6
3 Biggest Values A Board Member Can Bring
Intellectual capital
You can do something about all three
Time
Networks
© Signature Resources 2015 7
Values A Board Member Can Bring
Intellectual capital:
Plan for future board composition.
Invest 70% of most meetings in strategic discussion.
Invest in board awareness: external business environment, benchmarking best practices, officer development. +/- 2 hours a month.
© Signature Resources 2015 8
Values A Board Member Can Bring
Time:
Refresh your agenda efficiency.
Invest in Chair, Vice-Chair and committee chair development.
Right committee structure.
Consent agendas.
Executive summaries and reports.
© Signature Resources 2015 9
Values A Board Member Can BringNetworks:
Identify the networking the organization needs for effective branding, marketing, insight.
Include in your board job description: “use your networks of influence and connections to further the mission success of the organization.”
Spend time during strategy discussion on “who in our network might help us here?”
o With introductions, insight, marketing, etc.
10
My Job Today
© Signature Resources 2015
A look @ high performance governance
practices as assembled from BoardSource,
National Association of Corporate Directors,
American Hospital Association, American
Society of Association Executives, The
Conference Board and others.
Candid opinions based on work with 300+
boards:
For-profit, non-profit, international,
financial, healthcare, community, national
associations.
Open dialogue—your question is not an
interruption!
11
Your Job Today:Final Exam
© Signature Resources 2015
What might you take back to your board to
start the conversation about the board of the
future?
© Signature Resources 2015 12
What is The Future of Governance?
“The future is already here—it’s just not evenly distributed yet.”
© Signature Resources 2015 13
Synthesis of Elements of Governance
“Nothing ages faster than the future.” David Carr
© Signature Resources 2015 14
“The problem is never how to get new innovative thoughts into your mind, but how to get the old ones out.” Dee Hoc, Retired CEO
Visa Card Executive
Today’s Governance From the Literature
NACD Public Company Governance Survey, Nat. Association of Corp. Directors (2014)
“What Directors Think” (2014), Spencer Stuart
© Signature Resources 2015
priorities for Boards from national surveys:
① Strategic planning and oversight.
② Board composition
③ Board refresh.
④ Risk oversight.
⑤ Regular board assessments are considered very effective by 85% of the survey population.
15
The Governance Future that is Here
© Signature Resources 2015
Term limits combined with governance leadership succession initiative keeps board refreshed.
Majority of meeting time invested in “strategically focused agenda.”
Competency based director nominations.
Competency development of directors receives serious focus--40 hrs. a year [3.3 hrs. a month].
Robust ERM committee and organizational activity.
Governance Self-assessments become annual routines.
“Independent Director” / “Outside Director” appointment to bolster Board strength. [In the U.S. independent outsiders make up 66% of all board and 72% of S&P 500 Company boards]
Are these themes surfacing with your Board?16
Future Governing Boards
© Signature Resources 2015
“In the not to distant future, new board members, at all levels of
enterprise--from community organization to corporations--will be
required to ‘certify governance competency’ to quality for an
appointment / election.”Les Wallace
17
Future Governing Boards
© Signature Resources 2015
Term limits the norm.
Recruitment focuses on competencies and connections.
Compensation for not-for-profit board will support increased
competencies.
Diverse board makeup will become the norm rather than the
exception.
Board officer development will become a higher priority
investment.
Board coaches will be commonplace.
18
High Performance Governance
Assessment
1. Is Our Board Composition Right for the Challenge?
2. Are We Addressing the Risks That Could Send Our Company Over the Cliff?
3. Are We Prepared to Do Our Job Well When a Crisis Erupts?
4. Are We Well Prepared to Name Our Next CEO?
5. Does Our Board Really Own the Company’s Strategy?
6. How Can We Get the Information We Need to Govern Well?
7. How Can Our Board Get CEO Compensation Right?© Signature Resources 2015 19
High Performance Governance
Assessment
8. Why Do We Need a Lead Director Anyway?
9. Is Our Governance Committee Best of Breed?
10. How Do We Get the Most Value out of Our Time?
11. How Can Executive Sessions Help the Board Grow?
12. How Can Our Board Self-Evaluation Improve Our Functioning and Our Output?
13. How Do We Stop from Micromanaging?
14. How Prepared Are We to Work with Activist Shareholders and Their Proxies?
© Signature Resources 2015 20
© Signature Resources 2015 21
And then there’s committee work…
A dark alley down which good ideas are led to be strangled!
22
21st Century Governance Boards as Committees (‘50s-’60s)
CEO Driven
Boards as Managers (’60s-’70s)
Operational / Fiduciary
Boards as Trustees (‘80s-90’s)
Policy and Strategy (John Carver)
21st Century Boards
Transformational Leaders
“Board of Directors must be a strategic asset.”© Signature Resources 2015
© Signature Resources 2015 23
Strategy is about Transforming the Organization to Remain…
Viable ValuableVibrant!
24
21st Century Governance and Strategy
21st Century Boards
Transformational Leaders
The Board should be a strategic asset to the organization!
What’s the implication for board makeup?
For succession?© Signature Resources 2015
© Signature Resources 2015 25
Transformational
Transform: to completely change something.
Transformational: a focused effort to make significant changes to strengthen the relevance and value of an organization.
“Evolution keeps you alive; Revolution keeps you
relevant.” Gary Hamel, Leading the Revolution
© Signature Resources 2015 26
Transformational
Where are the revolutions happening
in your domain?
Who are the disruptors?
A Board should know these and
discuss how they are doing on a regular basis.
If the national / regional conferences you go to
Don’t discuss these—find a different conference!
© Signature Resources 2015 27
Strategy is about Transforming the Organization to Remain Viable,
Valuable, and Vibrant!
So your board needs to be…
Strategic thinkers.
Change compatible.
Focused on transformation of the enterprise.
Effectively navigating changing customer, regulatory
and constituent demands.
Strategic planning looking three to five years out.
Annually refreshing the strategic plan.
28
High Performance Governance: Competence
Board job descriptions identify leadership competencies required.
Nominations, interviews, screening confirm competencies.
Term limits (officers and board seats) assures governance refresh and infusion of fresh eyes / new competencies.
Governance Leadership succession program in place develops future leaders from the field early… 1-3 years out:
and future board officers.
No emeritus status board members.
Board members failing the involvement / attendance / conduct standards are removed for cause: bylaws are specific to these expectations.
© Signature Resources 2015
29
High Performance Governance
Competent
Real time assessment* of effectiveness following each board meeting.
Annual self-assessments and development plans drive improvement.
All committees / task forces have written charters and clearly identified outcomes or deliverable expectations.
Committee charters reviewed every couple of years. A dose of governance leadership development at every meeting (+/-
15 minutes) e.g. compliance refresh, board’s role in organizational culture, board succession planning, etc.). [Ave director education investment 22.1 hrs. each per NACD 2012-13 survey]
*Assessment: http://www.slideshare.net/LesWallace/board-self-assessment
© Signature Resources 2015
30
Governance CompetencyGovernance is less about the technical literacy of a board member regarding a specific challenge facing the organization (e.g., HR, marketing, finance/budget, legal, ERM)…
…It’s more about the leadership competencies that give a board member a sophisticated peripheral vision to oversee a complex business enterprise.
© Signature Resources 2015
31
Governance CompetencyFiscal literacy about large enterprise business
(diversification, capital investment, tracking KPIs).
Serious customer service or market based planning experience.
Strategic mindset and experience.
Change & organizational transformation leadership.
Executive oversight—leading organizational leaders.
Technology literate.
Mergers / Acquisitions.
Compliance / regulatory savvy.© Signature Resources 2015
32
Governance Youth Movement(As seen by some)
© Signature Resources 2015
33
Governance Diversity and
Youth Movement
© Signature Resources 2015
“Suddenly—Age is a Diversity Issue”www.cues.org/article/view/id/Good-governance-age-is-board-diversity-issue
34
Director Refresh Questions
How does your Board assure competent nominations to the Board of Directors?
How many potential board members do you currently have in the pipeline?
Can both of these be enhanced?
© Signature Resources 2015
© Signature Resources 2015 35
Questions?
Next UP:Planning and Active Recruitment
SelectionContinuing Board Development
36
Governance Leadership Succession
© Signature Resources 2015
① Profile the ideal board member for where you’re going
—not where you are.
② Identify a pool of candidates.
③ Engage, Develop, Cultivate the pool.
④ Narrow the pool by giving the most capable and
Committed greater immersion and development.
⑤ Encourage the best to stand for board appointment.
Create a Board Makeup Dashboard: Current and Desired in the Future
© Signature Resources 2015 37
Board Profile:Today - Tomorrow
Gender
Age
Ethnicity
Length of blood bank board service
Leadership experience and competencies
Special competencies / experience / networks
e.g. risk management, M & A, Chamber of Commerce, managed care, FDA, etc.
38
Governance Leadership Succession Timeline?
Board of Directors makes annual commitment to identify and develop potential new board members ahead of vacancies.
A minimum 12 months before a known vacancy, a pool of potential candidates are identified and screened as to interests and qualifications.
Preferable:
2-3 years in advance of a board appointment the Board of Directors has identified people with potential and is involving them in some way in governance development and/or volunteer efforts for the enterprise.
© Signature Resources 2015
© Signature Resources 2015 39
Planning for a Future BoardChair and Vice Chair have crucial conversations with
board members who should move on.
Term limits assure opportunity for new appointments without having to have difficult conversations.
Three year terms with one reappointment is typical.
Create a “board profile” of what you will need 3-5 years out.
Create a pool of potential candidates and actively screen them for competency and mission alignment.
Actively recruit.
© Signature Resources 2015 40
Planning for a Future BoardCrucial conversations regarding legacy
moves:
“Based upon our profile of future board needs we would like to act quickly on refreshing our makeup.”
“You’ve given valuable service however we would like you to consider relinquishing your board seat for a new appointment.”
The CEO should not be involved in these conversations with board members who need
to move on!
© Signature Resources 2015 41
Who Guides Board Recruitment?
Governance and Nominating committee
Executive Committee
What’s the role of the CEO?
Involved in conversations about potential future board needs
Involved in end of screening interviews with potential candidates
Heavily involved in new board orientation
42
Where / How do you find folks who might fit the ideal profile?
Board & past Board know some in the community.
The Executive / Management team knows some.
Your networks of community and business leader contacts know some.
You can research names from the university, community leadership & chamber lists for potential.
© Signature Resources 2015
© Signature Resources 2015 43
Finding Competent Board Members
88% Ask for board member recommendations.
69% evaluate board composition via a gap analysis or matrix.
63% invite non board members to serve on committees.
63% cultivate relationships with colleagues or community leaders.
41% cultivate relationships with corporations or other organizations.
BoardSource Nonprofit Government Index 2012.
44
Board Members:Where do you Find Them?
© Signature Resources 2015
Colleges and Universities—faculty and graduate students
Chambers of Commerce
Specialty Chambers—Black, Latino, Asian, Native American
Young Professional Groups
Professional Associations
Small Business Alliance Groups
Specialty Legal Societies
State not-profit societies
Mid-to upper managers of business in your area
Your network of high performance leaders!
© Signature Resources 2015 45
SelectionYou will end up with a number of highly
qualified candidates who might serve your blood center.
Narrowing the group to the vital few must align with all the goals of your new board profile: competencies, experience, demographic addition, networks.
Don’t be afraid to add a board member with which the current board was not familiar before the search.
“Fresh eyes” will be a valuable contribution to your board.
© Signature Resources 2015 46
OnboardingAdequate orientation is critical to helping the
new board member to a fast start.
Based upon an hourly value of board service for you @ $500/hr. and an estimated 62+ hours of service a year—you’re bringing on the equivalent of a $31,000 investment (first year value).
One day on site with the executive team and key staff for briefings and dialogue is a minimum.
Another 3+ hours with Board Chair, Reviewing committee minutes, strategic plan and other documents is a minimum.
47
New Board Orientation : Materials Review
Offsite materials review
History of the organization.
Mission, vision, values statements
Summary of services, special capabilities, planned services.
Newsletters, press clippings.
Financial performance past three years including external audit.
Regulatory / compliance review findings.
Annual Report.
HR org. chart & bio-sketch of professional backgrounds of key staff.
Strategic Plan.
Board by-laws.
Three years of board minutes.
Board policy and procedures.
Current board profile and professional background bio-sketches.
Board commitment and conflict of interest statements for signing.
Recent governance self-assessment results.
Committee structure and charters.
Committee Minutes.
Board calendar.© Signature Resources 2015
48
New Board Orientation II
Onsite introductions and briefings
Staff leadership welcome meeting and introductions.
Key programmatic one on one meetings.
Financial briefing from CFO and review of board financial dashboard.
ERM briefing from the Chief Risk Officer or Supervisory committee chair.
Human resources briefing
including review of board “organizational climate” dashboard.
Customer briefing including last twelve months satisfaction and value survey results.
Board Chair briefing: Board composition philosophy and leadership succession.
Recent board self-assessment results.
Board committee assignment.
© Signature Resources 2015
49
New Board Orientation III
Governance Education
Digest assigned articles and booklets—even better, require specific reading prior to the appointment—voluntary pre-certification.
Phone consultation with Governance committee chair upon completion of reading and orientation.
Discuss annual calendar of conferences and expectations for attendance and learning commitments.
© Signature Resources 2015
© Signature Resources 2015 50
Sustaining CompetencyAnnual self assessment guides board
improvement
Special emphasis on environmental scanning, benchmarking, board tutorials (e.g. regulation, quality, supply chain, etc.), keep eyes on the changing horizon.
Officers and future officers need specific development about their roles, functions and leadership approaches.
© Signature Resources 2015 51
Questions?
Final Exam:What might you take back to your board to start the conversation
about the board of the future?
52
Contemporary Literature on Governance
Twelve Principles of Governance that Power Exceptional Boards (BoardSource 2005)
Owning UP: The 14 Questions Every Board Member Needs to Ask (Ram Charan, 2009)
Governance as Leadership: Reframing the Work of Nonprofit Boards (Richard Chait, et. al., 2005)
The Future of Governance (Jay Lorsch, 2012)
Principles of 21st Century Leadership: Journey to High Performance (Les Wallace, 2013)
What are you reading?
© Signature Resources 2015
© Signature Resources 2015 53
Who is this guy?
54
Les Wallace, Ph.D.President, Signature Resources [email protected]
Dr. Wallace is recognized for tracking business environment and workplace trends and their impact upon business and government. His publications have appeared in Leadership Excellence, Personnel Journal, Credit Union Management, Public Management, and Nation's Business as well as numerous research and conference proceedings. His latest book, co-authored with Dr. Jim Trinka, A Legacy of 21st Century Leadership, outlines the leadership organizations need in a global, fast moving business environment. His book, Principles of 21st Century Governance (2013) is being used by many boards in the profit and not-for-profit sectors to design governance development approaches.
His new book, Personal Success in a Team Environment (2014) is used by individuals and organizations to improve teamwork, career building and success at work.
Les is a frequent consultant and speaker on issues of organizational transformation and leadership, employee engagement, strategic thinking and board of directors development and governance. His clients include Fortune 100 businesses, Government agencies, and not-for-profit organizations world-wide. Dr. Wallace is also the host resource on the 9Minute Mentor, a series short video tutorials governance.
Les has served on the Board of Security First Bank and currently serves on the international Boards of the World Future Society and Counterpart International. He is a member of the National Association of Corporate Directors. Les writes an on-line column for CUES Center for Credit Union Board Education.
Preview his video series on governance: www.signatureresources “Dr. Wallace on Camera.”
https://twitter.com/9MinuteMentor
© Signature Resources 2015