blood in the streets - amazon s3 fhp photo shows driver rickie lee maiorano after her car killed...

1
ple such as Jeffrey Kerutis, who was running errands the day a 92-year-old great- grandmother left the safety of a curb and, before he knew it, he was dialing 911 amid her dying groans. It shatters Edward Cof- fie, who prayed night after sleepless night for forgive- ness in the months after two teenage girls ran in front of his car. “Regardless that I wasn’t at fault, a young lady lost her life, and that will eat me up the rest of my life,” Cof- fie said. Like Coffie, the vast ma- jority of drivers were not at fault in the crashes. Cristyn Rochelle, who struck and killed a drunken pedestri- an, said learning that she did nothing wrong did little to lighten her burden. “I unfortunately am a victim … that’s still alive,” said Rochelle, who is now 20 but was 17 at the time of the crash. “You will always wonder if you could’ve done something different, gone a different way or left earlier. … It is a part of who I am now.” Wounds hidden The wounds drivers en- dure may not be as visible but are still damaging. Psy- chologist Frank Fine said the trauma they face is not unlike that of soldiers re- turning home from war. Though the circum- stances are different, both drivers and soldiers make decisions that can lead to the deaths of others. The stress stemming from those choices triggers simi- lar emotional reactions, he said. “They can be angry at God, angry at the people who died, angry at them- selves or even at the car- maker,” said Fine, who has provided crisis interven- tion for people after natural disasters such as Hurricane Katrina and for survivors of the World Trade Center at- tacks. “The reality is one second would have changed the outcome com- pletely, but there is nothing they can do to change it.” The overwhelming de- sire to take back that split- second gnaws at their core, drivers said. Matthew McAdams felt the urge to flee when he realized the sickening sound against his pickup’s bumper was a human be- ing striking it. Kason Bailey, 16, died in October 2010, ly- ing in a crowd of friends surrounding him on Aloma Avenue. Troopers later discov- ered the teen was drunk and tried to get up after he was struck by McAdams’ truck. A second vehicle de- livered the fatal blow and ran him over. “It was tough to swallow because I thought I killed him,” the 50-year-old said. “For the first hour or so, I really couldn’t get my head around it.” ‘It’s a long road’ Fine said patients have two options: They can con- tinue living or stop alto- gether. For Coffie, 27, putting his goals on hold seemed the only reasonable recourse he had after the accident. Coffie had no time to stop before a pair of best friends ran across State Road 46 in April 2012 on their way to the county fair. Xiomara Muñoz, 15, and Thalia Cruz, then 14, mis- calculated traffic and paid the price. Xiomara was declared brain-dead six days later. Thalia survived but was se- verely disabled. Coffie had been studying for state exams to become a licensed occupational ther- apist but couldn’t finish the test after the crash. It felt wrong to move forward if the girls couldn’t do the same, he said. Rochelle was in high school when she killed Pat- rick Loftis on South Orange Blossom Trail in July 2010. She, too, was not at fault. “I couldn’t laugh or smile, have a good time or enjoy my life because I felt guilty knowing this man would never laugh and smile and have a good time because of me,” Rochelle said. “They kept telling me I didn’t need to feel guilty, but it’s not about having done something wrong but that I took someone’s life away.” During sessions, Fine said he challenges his pa- tients’ irrational thoughts and self-destructive behav- iors. “I tell them, ‘No matter how much punishment you get, it won’t bring [the victims] back,’ ” he said. But even the strongest, such as Orlando business- man Kerutis, can even- tually fall apart. One day in May 2011, the light turned green at Water Bridge Boulevard when the entrepreneur, now 49, placed his foot on the ac- celerator of his Cadillac Es- calade to roll south on Or- ange Blossom Trail. “Then all of a sudden out of my periphery, something caught my eye,” Kerutis re- called. “I swerved.” A 92-year-old great- grandmother tried to cross the wide, busy road at mid- block. The SUV sideswiped her. Isabel Maria Pagan rolled twice and came to a rest. “Mamita” — known for her cooking and love of gambling — went into car- diac arrest, according to her obituary. She died three days later. Florida Highway Patrol troopers at the scene told him: “It wasn’t your fault.” So, bottling the pressure, he went to the next job that day, setting up a party for his catering business. As weeks passed, Kerutis shel- tered himself in his wood- working, fashioning furni- ture from exotic lumber in his man cave, but said noth- ing. Yet life ground him down. His wife lost her job. His father got cancer. Pa- gan’s family sued. He be- came angry all the time, short with others and im- patient. “That’s when it hit me,” Kerutis said. He sought counseling to work through the latent emotional stress. In the worst of cases, the consequences of being in- volved in another person’s death are grave. Fine said his patients often contem- plate suicide. Recovery means having a trauma victim make a conscious decision to keep going. “It’s a long road, and I can’t guarantee someone can come back from that,” Fine said. “It’s not some- thing you can get over, but you can get through it.” arehernandez @tribune.com or 407-420-5471. smpowers @tribune.com or 407-420-5441. An FHP photo shows driver Rickie Lee Maiorano after her car killed pedestrian Jeffrey Brian, who had a blood-alcohol level of 0.20, on Universal Boulevard in 2011. Charged with misdemeanor DUI, in a plea deal she got 6 months of work release. FLORIDA HIGHWAY PATROL DRIVERS Continued from Page A1 County Lake Orange Osceola Seminole Central Florida 6-year total Pedestrian deaths: The number of pedestrians killed in car crashes rose and fell during the past 6 years. ’07 8 40 7 7 62 ’08 10 26 9 8 53 ’09 3 32 5 5 45 ’10 9 32 3 11 55 ’11 11 28 14 15 68 ’12 6 38 2 4 50 47 196 40 50 333 Rank/state 2011 population estimate Pedestrian deaths Deaths per 100,000 SHINIKO R. FLOYD/STAFF ARTIST Deaths by state: Florida is the most dangerous state in America for pedestrians. In 2011, the last year for which national data are available, Florida saw 2.6 pedestrians killed for every 100,000 state residents. Here are America’s 10 deadliest states for pedestrians: SOURCES: U.S. National Highway Traffic Safety Administration’s Fatality Analysis Reporting System, Florida Department of Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles, staff research 1. Florida 2. South Carolina 3. Arizona 4. Delaware 5. New Mexico 6. Louisiana 7. Maryland 8. Nevada 9. Hawaii 10. California 19.1M 4.7M 6.5M 907,135 2.1M 4.6M 5.8M 2.7M 1.4M 37.7M 490 113 147 18 41 88 102 46 23 625 2.6 2.4 2.3 2.0 2.0 1.9 1.8 1.7 1.7 1.7 Deaths locally and nationally Sunday, July 7, 2013 Orlando Sentinel | News | A13 For a developmentally disabled man of 55, Bobby Stout lived the good life. He had two jobs: one cleaning and another wash- ing dishes at a neighborhood tavern. He played in Special Olympics in three sports year-round. He lived inde- pendently in an apartment. He walked or took the bus most anywhere he needed to go. “Bobby was amazing,” said his sister Penny Stout of Apopka. That was true until a car skipped a curb on North Goldenrod Road near Or- lando and ran him down while he walked home shortly after midnight July 9, 2011. The car smacked Stout off a sidewalk into a parking lot. He tumbled across four parked cars — smashing the windshield of the first — and died. The Toyota driven by Natalie T. Houle, now 25, then slammed into a light pole and rolled. Tests recorded her blood-alcohol level at 0.169 percent, more than twice the 0.08 legal limit. Her passenger, Travis J. Main, now 27, also was charged because he said he grabbed the wheel at the critical moment. In a plea deal for vehicular manslaughter, each got a year of house arrest plus 15 years’ probation. At the Thirsty Gator tavern where he worked, everybody knew Stout’s name. Today, his photograph hangs on the wall as a memorial, between University of Florida posters and beer signs. “He was a very happy man. Very happy. He had so many friends. He didn’t have an enemy in the world,” said Stout’s mother, Lucille Stout of Apopka. “We had over 300 people at the funeral.” Brother Bruce Stout of Oviedo recalled the time that Bobby’s Special Olympics volleyball team was badly defeat- ing — shutting out — a less-skilled team of disabled athletes. Bruce Stout said his brother pulled his teammates together and quietly urged them to let the other team score so its players would not go home humiliated. “I was so proud,” he said. Scott Powers HIS GOOD LIFE IS CUT SHORT Bobby Stout was killed July 9, 2011, while walking on a Goldenrod Road sidewalk. COURTESY OF PENNY STOUT DUI crash claims Special Olympian in instant Scott Powers and Arelis R. Hernández wrote the articles after analyzing government databases and law-enforcement and court reports on pedestrian-automobile crashes in Central Florida from 2007 through 2012. Photographs and video were shot by George Skene. The series was edited by Lisa Cianci. ABOUT THIS SERIES Don’t leave me . After the accident, the then-17-year-old always needed someone. Always. Going to the store. I’m coming. Running next door. Wait for me. Cristyn Rochelle was tethered to her parents. On the brink of adulthood, Cristyn regressed into child- hood after the July 15, 2010, crash that killed pedestrian Pat- rick Loftis, 55. She wanted to draw pictures or play video games — any- thing to keep from thinking about it. “You’re going back to a time when things were easier,” Rochelle recalled her therapist telling her, “when life was good and your parents guarded you.” But they weren’t there that night. Rochelle was a rising high-school senior in the throes of summer and young love when she came off the Interstate 4 exit ramp onto Orange Blossom Trail in the Honda sport utility vehicle her father had just bought her. “I will never forget that night,” Rochelle said. Loftis was invisible until Rochelle was 2 feet from hitting him. The pop of breaking glass and falling pieces caused her to hyperventilate. The Orange County deputy sheriff checked Loftis, who was already dead, and walked over to a screaming Rochelle. Over and over, she asked the teenager what happened. When Rochelle learned Loftis had been intoxicated, it did little to ease her self-loathing questions. Could I have done something different? Should I have left earlier or gone a different way? Why did it happen to me? Will I ever forgive myself? The burden, she said, was too much. Acting like a child seemed like the perfect shelter from it all. A therapist and maturity helped her move on. She is work- ing full time for a transportation company to save enough for college. “I just want people to know he’s not the only victim in this situation,” Rochelle said. “I am a victim — that’s still alive.” Arelis R. Hernández CRASH LEAVES GIRL CHANGED Teen withdraws after accident kills pedestrian Jeffrey Kerutis, a driver who accidentally killed a 92-year-old great-grandmother in May 2011, says he went through struggles afterward. Isabel Maria Pagan tried to cross a wide, busy road at midblock, and his SUV sideswiped her. GEORGE SKENE/STAFF PHOTOGRAPHER In 2009, Matthew McAdams’ truck hit Winter Park High teen Kason Bailey on Aloma Avenue. GEORGE SKENE/STAFF PHOTOGRAPHER Blood in the Streets

Upload: hahanh

Post on 03-Jul-2018

214 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

ple such as Jeffrey Kerutis,who was running errandsthedaya92-year-oldgreat-grandmother left the safetyof a curb and, before heknew it, he was dialing 911amidher dying groans.

It shatters Edward Cof-fie, who prayed night aftersleepless night for forgive-ness in the months aftertwo teenage girls ran infront of his car.

“Regardless that Iwasn’tat fault, a young lady losther life, andthatwill eatmeup the rest of my life,” Cof-fie said.

Like Coffie, the vast ma-jority of driverswere not atfault in the crashes. CristynRochelle, who struck andkilled a drunken pedestri-an, said learning that shedidnothingwrongdid littleto lightenher burden.

“I unfortunately am avictim … that’s still alive,”said Rochelle, who is now20 butwas 17 at the time ofthe crash. “You will alwayswonder if you could’vedone something different,gone a different way or leftearlier. … It is a part of whoI amnow.”

WoundshiddenThe wounds drivers en-

dure may not be as visiblebut are still damaging. Psy-chologist Frank Fine saidthe trauma they face is notunlike that of soldiers re-turninghome fromwar.

Though the circum-stances are different, bothdrivers and soldiers makedecisions that can lead tothe deaths of others. Thestress stemming fromthose choices triggers simi-lar emotional reactions, hesaid.

“They can be angry atGod, angry at the peoplewho died, angry at them-selves or even at the car-maker,” said Fine, who hasprovided crisis interven-tionforpeopleafternaturaldisasterssuchasHurricane

KatrinaandforsurvivorsoftheWorldTradeCenter at-tacks. “The reality is onesecond would havechanged theoutcomecom-pletely, but there is nothingthey cando to change it.”

The overwhelming de-sire to take back that split-second gnaws at their core,drivers said.

Matthew McAdams feltthe urge to flee when herealized the sickeningsound against his pickup’sbumper was a human be-ingstriking it.KasonBailey,16, died inOctober 2010, ly-ing in a crowd of friendssurroundinghimonAlomaAvenue.

Troopers later discov-ered the teen was drunkand tried to get up after hewas struck by McAdams’truck. A second vehicle de-

livered the fatal blow andranhimover.

“Itwas tough to swallowbecause I thought I killedhim,” the 50-year-old said.“For the first hour or so, Ireally couldn’t get my headaround it.”

‘It’s a long road’Fine said patients have

twooptions: They can con-tinue living or stop alto-gether.

ForCoffie, 27, puttinghisgoals on hold seemed theonly reasonable recoursehehad after the accident.

Coffie had no time tostop before a pair of bestfriends ran across StateRoad 46 in April 2012 ontheirway to the county fair.Xiomara Muñoz, 15, and

Thalia Cruz, then 14, mis-calculated traffic and paidthe price.

Xiomara was declaredbrain-dead six days later.Thalia survivedbutwas se-verely disabled.

Coffiehadbeenstudyingfor stateexams tobecomealicensedoccupational ther-apist but couldn’t finish thetest after the crash. It feltwrong to move forward ifthe girls couldn’t do thesame, he said.

Rochelle was in highschoolwhenshekilledPat-rickLoftisonSouthOrangeBlossom Trail in July 2010.She, too,was not at fault.

“I couldn’t laugh orsmile, have a good time orenjoy my life because I feltguilty knowing this manwould never laugh andsmile and have a good time

because of me,” Rochellesaid. “They kept telling meI didn’t need to feel guilty,but it’s not about havingdone somethingwrong butthat I took someone’s lifeaway.”

During sessions, Finesaid he challenges his pa-tients’ irrational thoughtsand self-destructive behav-iors.

“I tell them, ‘No matterhow much punishmentyou get, it won’t bring [thevictims] back,’ ” he said.

But even the strongest,such as Orlando business-man Kerutis, can even-tually fall apart.

One day inMay 2011, thelight turned green atWaterBridgeBoulevardwhentheentrepreneur, now 49,placed his foot on the ac-

celeratorofhisCadillacEs-calade to roll south on Or-angeBlossomTrail.

“Thenallofasuddenoutofmyperiphery, somethingcaughtmy eye,” Kerutis re-called. “I swerved.”

A 92-year-old great-grandmother tried to crossthewide, busy road atmid-block.TheSUVsideswipedher.

Isabel Maria Paganrolled twice and came to arest. “Mamita” — knownfor her cooking and love ofgambling — went into car-diac arrest, according toherobituary.Shediedthreedays later.

Florida Highway Patroltroopers at the scene toldhim: “Itwasn’t your fault.”

So, bottling the pressure,hewent to thenext job thatday, setting up a party forhis catering business. Asweekspassed,Kerutis shel-tered himself in his wood-working, fashioning furni-ture from exotic lumber inhismancave,butsaidnoth-ing.

Yet life ground himdown.Hiswife lost her job.His father got cancer. Pa-gan’s family sued. He be-came angry all the time,short with others and im-patient.

“That’s when it hit me,”Kerutis said.

He sought counseling towork through the latentemotional stress.

In theworst of cases, theconsequences of being in-volved in another person’sdeath are grave. Fine saidhis patients often contem-plate suicide.

Recovery means havinga trauma victim make aconscious decision to keepgoing.

“It’s a long road, and Ican’t guarantee someonecan come back from that,”Fine said. “It’s not some-thing you can get over, butyou can get through it.”

[email protected]. [email protected].

An FHP photo shows driver Rickie Lee Maiorano after her car killed pedestrian Jeffrey Brian, who had a blood-alcohol levelof 0.20, on Universal Boulevard in 2011. Charged with misdemeanor DUI, in a plea deal she got 6 months of work release.

FLORIDA HIGHWAY PATROL

DRIVERSContinued from Page A1

County

Lake

Orange

Osceola

Seminole

Central Florida

6-year total

Pedestrian deaths: The number of pedestrians killed in car

crashes rose and fell during the past 6 years.

’07

8

40

7

7

62

’08

10

26

9

8

53

’09

3

32

5

5

45

’10

9

32

3

11

55

’11

11

28

14

15

68

’12

6

38

2

4

50

47

196

40

50

333

Rank/state2011 population

estimatePedestrian

deathsDeathsper 100,000

SHINIKO R. FLOYD/STAFF ARTIST

Deaths by state: FloridaisthemostdangerousstateinAmerica

forpedestrians.In2011,thelastyearforwhichnationaldataare

available,Floridasaw2.6pedestrianskilledforevery100,000state

residents.HereareAmerica’s10deadlieststatesforpedestrians:

SOURCES: U.S. National Highway Traffic Safety Administration’sFatality Analysis Reporting System, Florida Department of HighwaySafety and Motor Vehicles, staff research

1. Florida

2. South Carolina

3. Arizona

4. Delaware

5. New Mexico

6. Louisiana

7. Maryland

8. Nevada

9. Hawaii

10. California

19.1M

4.7M

6.5M

907,135

2.1M

4.6M

5.8M

2.7M

1.4M

37.7M

490

113

147

18

41

88

102

46

23

625

2.6

2.4

2.3

2.0

2.0

1.9

1.8

1.7

1.7

1.7

Deaths locally and nationally

Sunday, July 7, 2013 Orlando Sentinel | News | A13

For adevelopmentallydisabledmanof 55,BobbyStout lived thegood life.

Hehad two jobs: onecleaning andanotherwash-ingdishes at aneighborhoodtavern.Heplayed inSpecialOlympics in three sportsyear-round.He lived inde-pendently in anapartment.Hewalkedor took thebusmost anywhereheneeded togo.

“Bobbywas amazing,”saidhis sisterPennyStout ofApopka.

Thatwas trueuntil a carskippeda curbonNorthGoldenrodRoadnearOr-landoand ranhimdownwhilehewalkedhomeshortly aftermidnight July 9, 2011.Thecar smackedStout offa sidewalk into aparking lot.He tumbledacross fourparkedcars—smashing thewindshieldof the first—anddied.

TheToyotadrivenbyNatalieT.Houle, now25, thenslammed into a light pole and rolled.Tests recordedherblood-alcohol level at 0.169 percent,more than twice the0.08legal limit.Herpassenger,Travis J.Main, now27, alsowaschargedbecausehe saidhegrabbed thewheel at the criticalmoment. In apleadeal for vehicularmanslaughter, eachgota year ofhouse arrest plus15 years’ probation.

At theThirstyGator tavernwhereheworked, everybodyknewStout’s name.Today, his photographhangson thewallas amemorial, betweenUniversity ofFloridaposters andbeer signs.

“Hewas averyhappyman.Veryhappy.Hehad somanyfriends.Hedidn’t have anenemy in theworld,” saidStout’smother, Lucille Stout ofApopka. “Wehadover 300people atthe funeral.”

BrotherBruceStout ofOviedo recalled the time thatBobby’s SpecialOlympics volleyball teamwasbadlydefeat-ing—shuttingout—a less-skilled teamofdisabled athletes.BruceStout saidhis brotherpulledhis teammates togetherandquietly urged themto let theother teamscore so itsplayerswouldnot gohomehumiliated.

“Iwas soproud,”he said.

ScottPowers

HIS GOOD LIFEIS CUT SHORT

Bobby Stout was killed July9, 2011, while walking on aGoldenrod Road sidewalk.

COURTESY OF PENNY STOUT

DUI crash claims Special Olympian in instant

Scott Powers and Arelis R. Hernández wrote the articles after analyzing government databases and law-enforcementand court reports on pedestrian-automobile crashes in Central Florida from 2007 through 2012. Photographs and videowere shot by George Skene. The series was edited by Lisa Cianci.

ABOUT THIS SERIES

Don’t leaveme. After theaccident, the then-17-year-oldalwaysneeded someone.Always.

Going to the store. I’mcoming.Runningnextdoor.Wait forme.CristynRochellewas tethered toherparents.

On thebrinkof adulthood,Cristyn regressed into child-hoodafter theJuly15, 2010, crash that killedpedestrianPat-rickLoftis, 55.

Shewanted todrawpicturesorplayvideogames—any-thing tokeep fromthinkingabout it.

“You’re goingback to a timewhen thingswereeasier,”Rochelle recalledher therapist tellingher, “when lifewasgoodandyourparents guardedyou.”

But theyweren’t there thatnight.Rochellewas a risinghigh-school senior in the throesof summerandyoung lovewhenshecameoff the Interstate 4exit rampontoOrangeBlossomTrail in theHonda sportutility vehicleher fatherhad just boughther.

“Iwill never forget thatnight,”Rochelle said.Loftiswas invisibleuntilRochellewas2 feet fromhitting

him.Thepopofbreakingglass and fallingpieces causedhertohyperventilate.

TheOrangeCountydeputy sheriff checkedLoftis,whowasalreadydead, andwalkedover to a screamingRochelle.Over andover, sheasked the teenagerwhathappened.

WhenRochelle learnedLoftis hadbeen intoxicated, it didlittle to easeher self-loathingquestions.

Could Ihavedone somethingdifferent? Should Ihave leftearlier or goneadifferentway?Whydid it happen tome?Will Iever forgivemyself?

Theburden, she said,was toomuch.Acting like a childseemed like theperfect shelter from it all.

A therapist andmaturityhelpedhermoveon. She iswork-ing full time for a transportationcompany to saveenough forcollege.

“I justwantpeople toknowhe’snot theonly victim in thissituation,”Rochelle said. “I amavictim—that’s still alive.”

ArelisR.Hernández

CRASH LEAVESGIRL CHANGEDTeen withdraws after accident kills pedestrian

Jeffrey Kerutis, a driver who accidentally killed a 92-year-old great-grandmother in May 2011, says he went throughstruggles afterward. Isabel Maria Pagan tried to cross a wide, busy road at midblock, and his SUV sideswiped her.

GEORGE SKENE/STAFF PHOTOGRAPHER

In 2009, Matthew McAdams’ truck hit WinterPark High teen Kason Bailey on Aloma Avenue.

GEORGE SKENE/STAFF PHOTOGRAPHER

Blood in the Streets