blackwater residential historic district -- property ...blackwater residential historic district --...

CountyAddress

Blackwater Residential Historic District -- Property Information FormPrepared by Debbie Sheals for the City of Blackwater Summer 2007

304 Blackwater, MOField Survey #

Present local name or designation

no yes

On National Register?

no yes probably

Eligible for NR as individual?

Eligible for NR as part of a district?

excellentgood

fairpoor

Condition:

little changedhighmoderate

lowIntegrity:

Architectural Style

Vernacular Type

Foundation Material(s) Ext. Wall Materials

Roof Type and/or Features

Window Types

Historic Name

Roof Materials

1900Construction Date:

Window Comments

no yes probably

No. stories

ca.

Special features/ notes:* indicates exact date of construction is known

editedprinted

ready to print

Too many changes to be eligible.

Photo date and number

1No. of Outbuildings

0No. contributing

1

Source of date:

District Namenone

29. Early owners

Porch Type porch comments

CountyAddress



Hipped


no yes


no yes probably



excellentgood

fairpoor

Condition:


lowIntegrity:

CraftsmanArchitectural Style

Pyramid SquareVernacular Type

not visibleFoundation Material(s)

WeatherboardExt. Wall Materials


1/1 Window Types

Historic Name

AsphaltRoof Materials

1920sConstruction Date:

early or originalWindow Comments

no yes probably

1No. stories

ca.


editedprinted

ready to print

Probably eligible as-is; the porch is enclosed, but largely intact.



0No. contributing

2

site visit onlySource of date:

District Namenone

29. Early owners

Porch TypeFull

porch commentsearly or original

CountyAddress



Hipped


no yes


no yes probably



excellentgood

fairpoor

Condition:


lowIntegrity:


BungalowVernacular Type

Foundation Material(s)Vinyl

Ext. Wall Materials


10/1 Window Types

Historic Name




no yes probably

1.5No. stories

ca.


editedprinted

ready to print

The only change is the siding, and most exterior detailing is intact.


No. of Outbuildings No. contributing

3


District Namenone

29. Early owners

Porch TypeFull


CountyAddress



Hipped


no yes


no yes probably



excellentgood

fairpoor

Condition:


lowIntegrity:



Concrete Foundation Material(s)



4/1 Window Types

Historic Name




no yes probably

1No. stories

ca.


editedprinted

ready to print



1No. contributing

4


District Namenone

29. Early owners

Porch TypeFull


DoddridgeAddress



Gable


no yes


no yes probably



excellentgood

fairpoor

Condition:


lowIntegrity:

Late Victorian/CraftsmanArchitectural Style

Gable Front and WingVernacular Type

StoneFoundation Material(s)



QA /4/6 Window Types

Historic Name


1890s/1948Construction Date:


no yes probably

1No. stories

ca.


editedprinted

ready to print

A Late Victorian house with a newer porch (1948). The porch date is on the steps. There are some newer rear additions.



0No. contributing

date stoneSource of date:

District Namenone

29. Early owners

Porch TypeOther Bay

porch commentsearly, not original

DoddridgeAddress



Gable


no yes


no yes probably



excellentgood

fairpoor

Condition:


lowIntegrity:

Late VictorianArchitectural Style

gable frontVernacular Type

Rock FacedFoundation Material(s)

VinylExt. Wall Materials


1/1 Window Types

Historic Name


1905-10Construction Date:

newer right sizeWindow Comments

no yes probably

1.5No. stories

ca.


editedprinted

ready to print

May be eligible as-is, with good windows and a nice wrap-around porch.



1 gaNo. contributing

13-15


District Namenone

29. Early owners

Porch TypeFull


DoddridgeAddress


300 ? Blackwater, MOField Survey #

Gable

Blackwater Elementary SchoolPresent local name or designation

no yes


no yes probably



excellentgood

fairpoor

Condition:


lowIntegrity:

SchoolArchitectural Style

Vernacular Type

Concrete Foundation Material(s)

BrickExt. Wall Materials


1/1 Window Types

Historic Name


1911-1952Construction Date:

new, but right size, etc.Window Comments

no yes probably

2No. stories

ca.


editedprinted

ready to print

The addition in the rear is 50 years old. The front addition has no relationship to the historic school, and would need to be removed for this to be eligible.


0No. of Outbuildings No. contributing

24

date stoneSource of date:

District Namenone

29. Early owners


DoddridgeAddress



Gable

West End TheatrePresent local name or designation

no yes


no yes probably



excellentgood

fairpoor

Condition:


lowIntegrity:

Gothic RevivalArchitectural Style

Center Steeple ChurchVernacular Type




Gothic Window Types

ChurchHistoric Name

Asphalt with Roof Materials



no yes probably

1No. stories

ca.


editedprinted

ready to print

There is a low addition to the north side.


barn to NorthNo. of Outbuildings No. contributing

8-9


District Namenone

29. Early owners


DoddridgeAddress



Gable


no yes


no yes probably



excellentgood

fairpoor

Condition:


lowIntegrity:


Vernacular Type

BrickFoundation Material(s)



QA Window Types

Historic Name




no yes probably

1.5No. stories

ca.


editedprinted

ready to print

The fish scale shingles, architectural detailing and porch are all highly intact.



0No. contributing

5-7

Bobby DannerSource of date:

District Namenone

29. Early owners

Porch TypeOther Bay


MainAddress



Gable


no yes


no yes probably



excellentgood

fairpoor

Condition:


lowIntegrity:






1/1 Window Types

Historic Name



collage, early or originalWindow Comments

no yes probably

1No. stories

ca.


editedprinted

ready to print

One or the other could make this eligible. Some architectural detailing is still exposed and intact. There are some exposed fish scale shingles.



0No. contributing

45-46

Source of date:

District Namenone

29. Early owners

Porch TypeOther Bay

porch commentsearly, enclosed

MainAddress



Gable/Hip


no yes


no yes probably



excellentgood

fairpoor

Condition:


lowIntegrity:

Architectural Style





1/1 Window Types

Historic Name




no yes probably

1No. stories

ca.


editedprinted

ready to print

The porch is enclosed, and the wide new siding is a big change. Reopening the porch may be enough to make this eligible.



1 small No. contributing

47


District Namenone

29. Early owners

Porch TypeOther Bay


MainAddress



Gable


no yes


no yes probably



excellentgood

fairpoor

Condition:


lowIntegrity:

Queen AnneArchitectural Style





QA Window Types

Historic Name




no yes probably

1No. stories

ca.


editedprinted

ready to print

The porch is early or original and elaborate. Fish scale shingles are in the front gable end.



0No. contributing

48, 49


District Namenone

29. Early owners

Porch TypeOther Bay


MainAddress



Gable


no yes


no yes probably



excellentgood

fairpoor

Condition:


lowIntegrity:

Architectural Style



Vinyl-wideExt. Wall Materials


1/1 Window Types

Historic Name




no yes probably

1No. stories

ca.


editedprinted

ready to print

Removal of the siding would be the best change to enhance eligibility.



0No. contributing

51


District Namenone

29. Early owners

Porch TypeWrap-Around

porch commentsearly, with new posts

MainAddress



Gable


no yes


no yes probably



excellentgood

fairpoor

Condition:


lowIntegrity:

Architectural Style



Vinyl-wideExt. Wall Materials


2/2 Window Types

Historic Name



some early or original, someWindow Comments

no yes probably

1No. stories

ca.


editedprinted

ready to print

Removing the siding here would probably be enough to make it eligible--the porch enclosure appears to be fairly early and is not too extreme a change.



0No. contributing

52-53


District Namenone

29. Early owners

Porch TypeOther Bay


MainAddress



Gable


no yes


no yes probably



excellentgood

fairpoor

Condition:


lowIntegrity:



Rock Faced Concrete Foundation Material(s)



1/1 Window Types

Historic Name




no yes probably

1No. stories

ca.


editedprinted

ready to print

The wrap-around rock faced concrete block porch is open and early or original. The modern roof addition is not appropriate.



0No. contributing

55-56


District Namenone

29. Early owners



MainAddress



Gable


no yes


no yes probably



excellentgood

fairpoor

Condition:


lowIntegrity:






QA 1/1 Window Types

Historic Name




no yes probably

1No. stories

ca.


editedprinted

ready to print

The porch is early, but not original. Siding and windows are highly intact. The door andat least one window have early art glass panes.



2 garageNo. contributing

57


District Namenone

29. Early owners

Porch TypeOther Bay


MainAddress



Gable


no yes


no yes probably



excellentgood

fairpoor

Condition:


lowIntegrity:


Vernacular Type

R. F. Conc.Foundation Material(s)



1/1 Window Types

Historic Name




no yes probably

2.5No. stories

ca.


editedprinted

ready to print

Siding is only change, and the rest of the house is highly intact, with extensive original architectural detailing.



61-626-13-07


District Namenone

29. Early owners

Porch TypeOther Bay


Main StreetAddress


306 Blackwater, MO 1Field Survey #

Hipped


no yes


no yes probably



excellentgood

fairpoor

Condition:


lowIntegrity:

Folk VictorianArchitectural Style





1/1 Window Types

Moore, John H. HouseHistoric Name



modern, similar to originalWindow Comments

no yes probably

1No. stories

ca.


editedprinted

ready to print

Highly intact early porch with turned posts, a spindled frieze, and fishscale shingles.



0No. contributing

5-30-08

real estate tax recordsSource of date:

District NameBlackwater Residential Historic District

29. Early owners1897 Erhardt Fischer1900 Erhardt Fischer1903 John H. Moore1908 John H. Moore1916-1925 S. G. and Kate Whitlew1929 Herbert Shamwell and Wife1933-1945 or later S. G. WhitlewProbably built for Moore, ca 1902.

Porch TypeCentral Bay


Main StreetAddress



Gable


no yes


no yes probably



excellentgood

fairpoor

Condition:


lowIntegrity:

Architectural Style

Gabled EllVernacular Type

ConcreteFoundation Material(s)



1/1 Window Types

Poe, Lucy E. HouseHistoric Name




no yes probably

1.5No. stories

ca.


editedprinted

ready to print



1No. contributing



29. Early owners1897-1900 Erhardt Fischer1903 Lucy E. Poe1908 Kate Machler1916-1945 or later Lawrence R. ErvineThe house was probably built ca. 1902 by Lucy Poe, and remodeled ca. 1925 by Ervine.

Porch TypeOther Bay


ScottAddress



Gable


no yes


no yes probably



excellentgood

fairpoor

Condition:


lowIntegrity:


Hall and ParlorVernacular Type


Vinyl narrow lapExt. Wall Materials


1/1 Window Types

Historic Name




no yes probably

1No. stories

ca.


editedprinted

ready to print

The porch is early or original and the setting is nicely intact. This would probably be contributing even with the siding.



1No. contributing

64, 65


District Namenone

29. Early owners



ScottAddress



Gable


no yes


no yes probably



excellentgood

fairpoor

Condition:


lowIntegrity:


Gabled EllVernacular Type

Stamped Foundation Material(s)



2/2 horiz. Window Types

Abney, W. L., HouseHistoric Name



early, not originalWindow Comments

no yes probably

1No. stories

ca.


editedprinted

ready to print

Porch is early or original and there have been no additions or other changes to the formor function.



2No. contributing

245-30-08


District NameBlackwater Residential Hisotric District

29. Early owners1899-1900 Erhardt Fischer1903 Jas F. Bums1908 Tillie W. Fray1916 M.R. Huffman1920-1945 or later W. L. AbneyProbably built between 1916 and 1919, for Abney.

Porch TypeOther Bay


ScottAddress



Gable


no yes


no yes probably



excellentgood

fairpoor

Condition:


lowIntegrity:

Architectural Style





6/6 Window Types

Historic Name




no yes probably

1No. stories

ca.


editedprinted

ready to print

Too many changes, including siding and windows.



30


District Namenone

29. Early owners


ScottAddress



Gable


no yes


no yes probably



excellentgood

fairpoor

Condition:


lowIntegrity:

Architectural Style





1/1 Window Types

Hill, Jane, HouseHistoric Name




no yes probably

1No. stories

ca.


editedprinted

ready to print

One or the other of those changes may be enough to make this eligible.



0No. contributing

28



29. Early owners1899 Erhardt Fischer1900 Erhardt Fischer1903 Fred W. Weber1908 Jane Hill1916-1945 or later Jane and Maud HillProbably built ca, 1907 for Jane Hill.



ScottAddress



Gable


no yes


no yes probably



excellentgood

fairpoor

Condition:


lowIntegrity:






1/1 Window Types

Harris, H. K., HouseHistoric Name




no yes probably

1No. stories

ca.


editedprinted

ready to print

Probably eligible as-is; porch is open now and windows and trim are early.



0No. contributing

296-13-07



29. Early owners1899-1903 Erhardt Fischer1908 H. K. Harris1916-1920 R. B. Clark and Wife1925-1933 Archie Eichmann1940 Samuel and Maggie Gann1945 Maggie Gann etalThis may have been built for H. K. Harris, ca 1907, but is more likely to have been done for R. B. Clark and wife ca. 1915.

Porch TypeOther Bay


ScottAddress



Gable


no yes


no yes probably



excellentgood

fairpoor

Condition:


lowIntegrity:

Architectural Style

Gabled FrontVernacular Type


Asbestos + 50Ext. Wall Materials


1/1 Window Types

Mosely, Evrett, HouseHistoric Name




no yes probably

1No. stories

ca.


editedprinted

ready to print

No changes of note to the house or shed in well over 50 years, one of the more intact properties in the district.



1 EOE ShedNo. contributing

27 & 336-13-07



29. Early owners1899-1903 Erhardt Fischer1908 H. K. Harris1916 Effie L. Piatti1920 Hugh Alec1925-1933 Evrett Mosely1940 Anna M. Wolfe and Emma Durley1945 Emma DurleyThis appears to have been built ca. 1932 for Evrett Mosely; the value increased significantly between 1929-1933.

Porch TypeThree Quarter


ScottAddress



Church of ChristPresent local name or designation

no yes


no yes probably



excellentgood

fairpoor

Condition:


lowIntegrity:

Architectural Style

Vernacular Type

Foundation Material(s) Ext. Wall Materials


Window Types

Historic Name

Roof Materials


Window Comments

no yes probably

No. stories

ca.


editedprinted

ready to print

no photo available; not eligible



Source of date:

District Namenone

29. Early owners


TriggAddress



Gable


no yes


no yes probably



excellentgood

fairpoor

Condition:


lowIntegrity:






1/1 Window Types

Sims, Tom J., HouseHistoric Name




no yes probably

1No. stories

ca.


editedprinted

ready to print

A big rear shed and smaller garage are intact. The two front doors are both early or original. Integrity is based upon siding begin removed.



2No. contributing

43-446-13-07



29. Early owners1897-1903 John W. Son 1908 Evert A. And Rosa May Wilson 1910 Henry G. Fraybefore 1916 all five lots on this block were one parcel; the house at may have been built by Fray ca. 1908, and this one may have been built by Sims after he bought it, ca. 1914. 1916 T. J. SimsFrom 1920 on, both this and the house at 302 had a single owner. The lot on the east end of the block, which had a large garage or commercial building on it, was a separate parcel throughout this time period. Tom Sims owned the garage in 1920. 1920 Amos Gorrell (both houses) 1920 Amos Gorrell and Tom Sims (garage lot) 1925 Amos Gorrell (garage andboth houses) 1929 Linnie G. Netherton and Husband (House at 302 only) Amos Gorrell (300 and garage) 1933 John Whitlow Jr. (both houses 300 and 302) 1933 Riley Holman (Garage) 1940-45 or later John Whitlow Jr (both houses) 1940-45 or later John Whitlow and Wife (garage)

Porch TypeOther Bay


TriggAddress



Flat hipped


no yes


no yes probably



excellentgood

fairpoor

Condition:


lowIntegrity:






1/1 Window Types

Fray, Henry G., HouseHistoric Name




no yes probably

1No. stories

ca.


editedprinted

ready to print

The house is highly intact. The cornice band is bracketed.



early shed No. contributing

39-406-13-07



29. Early owners1897-1903 John W. Son 1908 Evert A. And Rosa May Wilson 1910 Henry G. Fraybefore 1916 all five lots on this block were one parcel, this house may have been built first, by Fray.1916 Chas. B. PoindexterFrom 1920 on, both this and the house at 300 usually had the same owners. The lot on the east end of the block, which had a large garage or commercial building on it, was a separate parcel throughout this time period. Tom Sims owned thegarage in 1920. 1920 Amos Gorrell (both houses) 1920 Amos Gorrell and Tom Sims (garage lot)1925 Amos Gorrell (garage and both houses) 1929 Linnie G. Netherton and Husband (House at 302 only) Amos Gorrell (300 and garage) 1933 John Whitlow Jr. (both houses 300 and 302) 1933 Riley Holman (Garage)1940-45 or later John Whitlow Jr (both houses and garage)



TriggAddress



Gable


no yes


no yes probably



excellentgood

fairpoor

Condition:


lowIntegrity:



ConcreteFoundation Material(s)



1/1 Window Types

McClain, Ray, HouseHistoric Name

Asphalt with Roof Materials


early or original storms, tooWindow Comments

no yes probably

1No. stories

*


editedprinted

ready to print

The single frame garage is early or original, and there is a small frame shed directly behind the house as well. The small shed could be older than the house. The porch andposts are early or original. Weatherboards on porch posts are early or original; the rest is vinyl.



2No. contributing

426-13-07



29. Early owners1897 Harvey L. Green 1903 Thos M. Horne 1899-1900 Robert Anderson1908-1916 Thomas M. Horne 1920 Annie G. Horn 1925 Annie G. Bruce1929 Herbert H. Helm1933-1940 Ray H. McClain1945 May PoindexterThere was another house and a print shop here in 1921, according to the 1921 Sanborn map. The 1933 assessment book(for 1932) has the words “new house” added after McLain’s name.

Porch TypeThree Quarter


TriggAddress



Gable


no yes


no yes probably



excellentgood

fairpoor

Condition:


lowIntegrity:




AsbestosExt. Wall Materials


1/1 2/2 Window Types

Quigg, H. D., HouseHistoric Name




no yes probably

1No. stories

ca.


editedprinted

ready to print

The porch has been altered some, but is open, and siding is more than fifty years old.



0No. contributing

36 & 386-13-07



29. Early owners1897-1910 H. D. Quigg1916-1945 or later Lee O’NealThis appears to have been built for Quigg before 1897 (The first available tax record), and added to or otherwise improvedsignificantly by O’Neal around 1920.This is on the 1921 Sanborn, which showed only a coal shed and an outhouse on the lot. The existing rear ell is shown onthat map.

Porch TypeOther Bay


TriggAddress



Gable

Just ‘n’ HabitPresent local name or designation

no yes


no yes probably



excellentgood

fairpoor

Condition:


lowIntegrity:


gable frontVernacular Type




2/2 Window Types

n/aHistoric Name

MetalRoof Materials


new? Pedimented trimWindow Comments

no yes probably

1No. stories

ca.


editedprinted

ready to print

Moved here, not eligible.



0 newer? o.No. contributing

34-35



29. Early owners


TriggAddress



Gable


no yes


no yes probably



excellentgood

fairpoor

Condition:


lowIntegrity:




Asbestos Ext. Wall Materials


1/1 Window Types

Sims, John N. , HouseHistoric Name




no yes probably

1No. stories

ca.


editedprinted

ready to print

There are pent end gables, and dentil molding at roof line. There are two nice sheds at rear. Porch is to be reopened soon.



2No. contributing

20,21,23



29. Early owners1899-1903 Erhardt Fischer1908-1925 John N. Sims1929-1940 or later Jennie E. ThompsonThis may have been built ca. 1902 by Erhardt Fischer; there was an increase in value between 1900 and 1903, or Sims may have built it around 1907. It is more likely that Sims did it, since Fischer was selling lots in the addtion.

Porch TypeOther Bay


TriggAddress



Gable


no yes


no yes probably



excellentgood

fairpoor

Condition:


lowIntegrity:

Queen AnneArchitectural Style

Vernacular Type

Foundation Material(s)Vinyl and Fish scale

Ext. Wall Materials


QA Window Types

Fischer?Historic Name




no yes probably

2.5No. stories

ca.


editedprinted

ready to print

This is the biggest intact house in Blackwater. The porch is early or original and there isa good deal of original exterior woodwork in place.



0No. contributing

18-196-13-07



29. Early owners



TriggAddress



Gable


no yes


no yes probably



excellentgood

fairpoor

Condition:


lowIntegrity:






6/6 Window Types

Historic Name



newWindow Comments

no yes probably

1No. stories

ca.


editedprinted

ready to print

The porch is intact, but the new siding and windows are a big change. The roof line is the same as 409. The garage is early.



1No. contributing

16


District Namenone

29. Early owners

Porch TypeOther Bay


TriggAddress



Gable


no yes


no yes probably



excellentgood

fairpoor

Condition:


lowIntegrity:



Foundation Material(s)WeatherboardExt. Wall Materials


1/1 Window Types

Fischer family?Historic Name




no yes probably

1No. stories

ca.


editedprinted

ready to print

The porch is early or original, and overall integrity is high.



0No. contributing

17



29. Early owners

Porch TypeOther Bay


TriggAddress



Trunc Hip


no yes


no yes probably



excellentgood

fairpoor

Condition:


lowIntegrity:






1/1 Window Types

Historic Name




no yes probably

1No. stories

ca.


editedprinted

ready to print

Probably eligible as-is; the siding is the only change of note.



0No. contributing

14, 15


District Namenone

29. Early owners

Porch Typefull

porch commentsEarly or Original

blackwater residential historic district -- property ...blackwater residential historic district --...

Documents