ben burningham brown dwarfs in large scale surveys brown dwarfs come of age fuerteventura, 21 st may...
TRANSCRIPT
Ben Burningham
Brown dwarfs in large scale surveys
Brown dwarfs come of ageFuerteventura, 21st May 2013
Plan
a bit of history
the recent past
the state of the art
future challenges
The first wide area surveys
not digital relatively simple data
pipeline c 1200 BC 36 stars
L5 dwarf @ ~100 au T5 dwarf @ ~ 100 au
Greek pioneers
Timocharis & Aristillus c300BC
Hipparchus c135BC 1022 stars m < 6 updated in 964 (Sufi) and
1543 (Copernicus) no brown dwarfs (but did discover
precession of equinox)
L5 dwarf @ ~2000 au T5 dwarf @ ~ 1000 au
The next 2000 years…. Tycho Brahe (1598):
m < 6 1004 stars astrometric accuracy ~2’
Lalande et al (1801) 50K stars m < 9
Henry Draper (1918 – 1924) first spectroscopic survey all sky m < 10
Bonner Durchmusterung (1852 – 1859); Cordoba Durchmusterung (1892); Cape Photographic Durchmusterung (1896) total 1 million stars all sky m < 9 - 10
L5 dwarf @ ~10000 au T 5dwarf @ ~2000 au
Photographic surveys20th century dominated by three
facilities:
Palomar observatory: POSS I (1949 – 1958)
-27 to +90 degrees B ~ 21
POSS II Bj < 22.5, Rc < 20.8, Ic < 19.5
UK & ESO Schmidt telescopes: ESO/SERC
Bj ~ 22.5, Rc ~ 21 Ic band
Ic < 19
L5 dwarf @ ~20 pc T5 dwarf @ ~ 4 pc
The first brown dwarfs - 1995
Rebolo, Zapatero Osorio,& Martin, 1995
Nakajima et al 1995
Kelu - 1
L2 dwarf selected by proper motion
1st epoch: ESO survey plates
2nd epoch: dedicated follow-up of
400 sq degs
examined with a blink comparator
Ruiz et al (1997)
Legacy of photographic surveys
DSS I & II
Catalogues from densitometer scans: GSC I & II USNOA, B superCOSMOS
Proper motion catalogues e.g. LHS, LSPM, PPMXL etc identification of (ultra) cool >M7 dwarfs the first L dwarf (Ruiz et al 1997)
(the trickle before the flood)
The age of digital sky surveys
Facilitated by :
new detectors
improvements in data processing and storage
first brown dwarfs identified in late 1990s
(important: allows photometric selection)
New generation dominated by 3 surveys:
DENIS
2MASS
SDSS
DENIS Overview
southern sky (ESO 1m schmidt) i < 18.5, J < 16.5 , Ks < 14.0 finished in 2001 355 million sources
Results: 49 L dwarfs:
Delfosse et al (1997, 1999) Martin et al (1999) Bouy et al (2003) Kendall et al (2004) Phan-Bao et al (2008) Martin et al (2010)
1 T dwarf Artigua et al (2010)
L5 dwarf @ ~40 pc T5 dwarf @ ~ 20 pc
2MASS All sky
JHK (J < 16.5; H < 15.7; Ks < 15.2)
>99% complete for J < 15.8, H < 15.1, Ks < 14.3
game changer for substellar science
L5 dwarf @ ~45 pc T5 dwarf @ ~ 20 pc
Brown dwarfs in 2MASS 2MASS team searched via cross match of 2MASS against USNO for B+R
band dropouts visual inspection to ensure no optical detection distinguished as L and T candidates based on JHK colours
subsequent searches cross matched 2MASS with e.g. SDSS, and included proper motion searches
403 L dwarfs identified to-date: Kirkpatrick et al (1999, 2000, 2008, 2010); Reid et al (2000, 2008); Gizis
(2002); Gizis et al (2000, 2003); Kendall et al (2003, 2007); Cruz et al (2003, 2007); Burgasser et al (2003, 2004); Wilson et al (2003); Folkes et al (2007); Metchev et al (2008); Looper et al (2008) Sheppard & Cushing (2009); Scholz et al (2009); Geissler et al (2011)
55 T dwarfs: Kirkpatrick et al (2000, 2010); Burgasser et al (1999, 2000, 2002, 2003,
2004, ); Cruz et al (2004) Tinney et al (2005); Looper et al (2007); Reid et al (2008)
SDSS
SDSS DR9: 14,555 square degrees 932,891,133 “sources” 1.7 million extragalactic spectra 700K stellar spectra z’ < 20.8ish
“arguably the most successful scientific project ever undertaken”
L5 dwarf @ ~75 pc T5 dwarf @ ~ 40 pc
Brown dwarfs in SDSS381 L dwarfs to-date:
photometric selection: Fan et al (2000) Hawley et al (2002); Geballe et al
(2002); Schneider et al (2002); Knapp et al (2004); Chiu et al (2006); Zhang et al (2009); Scholz et al (2009)
spectroscopic selection: Schmidt et al (2010) highlights risky nature of photometric selection
57 T dwarfs: Leggett et al (2000); Geballe et al (2002); Knapp et al
(2004); Chiu et al (2006)
Highlights from the end of the beginning
definition of the “L” spectral class 830 L dwarfs discovered extended to halo population and
young moving groups
definition of the “T” spectral class 113 T dwarfs discovered extended sequence to Teff ~ 700K
(T8)
diversity of properties beyond Teff sequence apparent gravity? metallicity? dust properties?
Kirkpatrick et al 1999, 2000
Burgasser et al 2006
Beyond stamp collecting
luminosity function of L dwarfs Cruz et al (2007)
space density of T dwarfs constraining the IMF Allen et al (2005) Metchev et al (2008)
binary statistics (e.g. Burgasser et al 2003)
benchmarks (e.g. G570D, HD3651B)
weather!!! (e.g. Radigan et al 2012; Buenzli et al 2012)
Photometric survey exploitation cookbook
Select candidates from survey(s) using colours
Follow-up photometry to remove contaminants
Spectroscopic confirmation
SCIENCE
e.g. z’ – J > 2.5
e.g. scattered M dwarfs;
SSOs
UKIRT Infrared Deep Sky Survey (UKIDSS)Lawrence et al 2007
UKIDSS consists of 5 surveys
Large Area Survey (LAS) 3600 sq. degs, J = 19.6 2 epoch for ~1500 sq degs
Galactic Plane Survey (GPS) 1800 sq. degs, K=19
Galactic Clusters Survey (GCS) 1400 sq. degs K=18.7
Deep Extragalactic Survey (DXS) 35 sq. degs, K=21.0
Ultra Deep Survey (UDS) 0.77 sq. degs, K=23.0
Casali et al 2007L5 dwarf @ ~175 pc T5 dwarf @ ~ 110 pc
171 T dwarfs identified(Lodieu et al 2007; Pinfield et al
2008; Burningham et al (2008, 2009, 2010a,b, 2013)
~70 (+) L dwarfs (Day-Jones et al 2013)
extended T sequence to Teff ~ 500K (Lucas et al 2011)
halo T dwarfs (Smith et al – today!)
more young L dwarfs (see Marocco et al poster)
CFBDS(IR) ~1000 sq degs in i & z (+NIR sections)
early T8+ discovery (CFBDS 0059; Delorme et al 2008)
L5 – T8 luminosit function (Reyle et al 2010)
extremely cool binary CFBDSIR J1458+1013AB (Liu et al 2011)
planetary mass T dwarf CFBDSIR2149-0403 (Delorme et al 2012)
WISE – another leap forwards
all sky
3.4, 4.6, 12, and 22 μm
Y dwarfs (Cushing et al 2011; Kirkpatrick et al
2012)
seriously, Teff ~ 300K brown dwarfs!!
halo(?) T dwarfs (Gomes et al – today!)
buckets of bright T dwarfs(Mace et al 2013)
complementary data facilitating all sorts of cool science with UKIDSS, 2MASS etc
Kirkpatrick et al (2011)
L5 dwarf @ ~80 pc T5 dwarf @ ~ 50 pcY dwarf @ ~12 pc
WISE vs UKIDSS – FIGHT!
J <18.3 18.3 < J <18.8
Survey league table
Survey L dwarfs T dwarfs Y dwarfs
DENIS 49 1 0
2MASS 403 55 0
SDSS 381 57 0
UKIDSS 50 230 0
CFBDS(IR) 170(?) 45 1
WISE 10 176 14
VISTA-VHS 0 5 0
The immediate futureVISTA:
VISTA Hemisphere Survey (VHS) (Y)J(H)Ks J < 19.6 ~100K L0 – T5 ~2000 late-T dwarfs
VIKING 1500 sq degs ZYJHK J < 21.0
Dark Energy Survey: 4000 sq degs grizy (z < 24.7, y < 23.0)
PanStarrs (+UKIRT Hemisphere Survey): griz (+J) z < 23.0 (+ J < 19.6)
L5 dwarf @ ~330 pc T5 dwarf @ ~200 pc
~1 MILL
ION
BROWN
DWARFS!!!
!
…and that’s before LSST
What’s the point? rare objects:
benchmarks halo T dwarfs/subdwarfs young objects
improved space density
scale height for BDs (as a function of spectral type)
need kinematic data
need to use survey data for more than candidate selection
Photometric redshifts spectral types
Skrzypek & Warren (poster here!)
Large scale spectroscopic surveysEUCLID:
VIS (<24.5 AB) + YJH (<24 AB) wide imaging survey over 15000 sq deg
YJH < 26.5 (AB) over 40 sq degs,
slitless spectroscopy (J ~ 19?)
VLT-MOONS (proposed):
500 sq arcminute, 500 object NIR MOS
deep survey key element of science case
scale height for LT dwarfs
c.f SDSS for M dwarfs!
What do we want next?
proper motions (PanStarrs; LSST; 2nd epoch of VHS !?)
deep spectroscopic survey (VLT-MOONS; EUCLID)
what about photometric surveys?
best colours for characterisation?