belize’s recent debt restructuring - 2007
TRANSCRIPT
-
7/29/2019 Belizes Recent Debt Restructuring - 2007
1/24
Belizes Recent Debt
Restructuring
Dr Carla Barnett,
Financial Secretary,
Ministry of Finance, Government of Belize
Third Annual MeetingLatin American and Caribbean Public DebtManagement Specialists, April 20, 2007
-
7/29/2019 Belizes Recent Debt Restructuring - 2007
2/24
The Problem
-
7/29/2019 Belizes Recent Debt Restructuring - 2007
3/24
Fiscal Deficits and Increasing Debt
The fiscal deficit and the public debtburden grew sharply since 1999because of:
The need to repair hurricane damage; The policy decision to grow the
economy through public sectorinvestment; and
The refinancing of debt falling due
The fiscal deficit amounted to 9% ofGDP in 2004.
-
7/29/2019 Belizes Recent Debt Restructuring - 2007
4/24
Economic Policy Adjustments since 2005
Sustained Economic Growth is
required for employment andmedium term stabilization of bothfiscal and balance of paymentsperformance. Revenue and Expenditure measures
have sharply reduced the fiscal deficit toaround 3% of GDP and generated a
substantial primary surplus Supporting monetary policies have
tightened liquidity and helped tosafeguard foreign reserves
-
7/29/2019 Belizes Recent Debt Restructuring - 2007
5/24
The Debt Burden A year ago, Belizes public debt totalled
about US$1.1 billion, which was equal toalmost 100% of estimated GDP;
About 90% of the debt was external and,of this US$550 million was to commercial
creditors holding bonds and notes.
Interest payments on this debt absorbedalmost 30% of fiscal revenue and almost
50% of Belizes annual foreign currencyearnings.
-
7/29/2019 Belizes Recent Debt Restructuring - 2007
6/24
Decision to Restructure
Macroeconomic projections showed that,
notwithstanding the sharp tightening of fiscalpolicy, Belize would experience severe financingshortfalls on the fiscal and balance of payments inthe short- to medium-term.
These financing shortfalls were estimated on theassumption that Governments economic reformprogramme would continue
The Belize Government decided to undertake acomprehensive restructuring of its direct external
commercial debt to pre-empt a generaliseddefault and a disorderly adjustment that wouldresult from a balance of payments crisis.
The fundamental objective was to achievemedium term debt sustainability.
-
7/29/2019 Belizes Recent Debt Restructuring - 2007
7/24
Challenges
How to successfully restructure the debtwithin a short timeframe in order tominimise the risk of a disorderly default?
How to do so without an IMF programme?
How to convince creditors that Belize wasunable to continue to pay its debt onexisting terms, even though Belize hadnever defaulted on any of its debt?
How to avoid open confrontation with ourcreditors and limit long-term damage toinvestor relations?
-
7/29/2019 Belizes Recent Debt Restructuring - 2007
8/24
The Outcome
-
7/29/2019 Belizes Recent Debt Restructuring - 2007
9/24
Participation by Creditors
Belize launched an exchange offer
December 18, 2006, just before theholidays. The offer expired on January 26and the deal was closed on February 20,2006.
Holders of 97% of the affected debttendered their claims Belize used the Collective Action Clause in
one of its instruments [the 9.75% Note due
2015] to apply the restructuring terms tountendered notes in that instrument. In total over 98% of the affected debt has
been restructured.
-
7/29/2019 Belizes Recent Debt Restructuring - 2007
10/24
-
7/29/2019 Belizes Recent Debt Restructuring - 2007
11/24
The Overall Result
Macro-economic projections show that the
restructured debt will bring about asustained improvement in overall debtdynamics, as long as a prudent fiscalpolicy stance is maintained
As a result of this success, the ratingagencies have raised Belizes credit rating
The debt exchange has consolidated the
commercial debt into a single benchmark-size instrument improving liquidity forcreditors a major gain for creditors.
-
7/29/2019 Belizes Recent Debt Restructuring - 2007
12/24
How Did Belize Do this?
-
7/29/2019 Belizes Recent Debt Restructuring - 2007
13/24
1. Engagement with Creditors
Belize obviously needed the support of
its creditors to ensure the success of therestructuring. This was obvious.Therefore Belizes strategy was to Engage our creditors in an open and
cons t r uc t i v e d ia logue Ensure f u l l t ranspa rency in the
dissemination of all economic and financialdata by posting to the Central Bank of Belizewebsite.
Pursue a solution that would not only closeBelize financing gaps, but would a lso bepe rceived as fa i r by ou r cr ed i to r s. Theprinciple of inter-creditor equity wasemphasised.
-
7/29/2019 Belizes Recent Debt Restructuring - 2007
14/24
2. Cooperation and Support ofMultilateral and Bilateral partners
Engage the support of the IMF, the IDB,and the CDB by i m p l e m e n t i n gapp rop r i at e m acroeconom ic re fo rm
measu res well in advance of launching
the debt restructuring. Official international support through
Policy based loans [IDB and CDB]
Bilateral support [Venezuela] TA support for Tax Reform, Expenditure
Review etc.
-
7/29/2019 Belizes Recent Debt Restructuring - 2007
15/24
3. The Case for Debt Relief
Belize built a case for debt relief byproducing detailed macroeconomicprojections that took into account: the impact of the Governments
economic reforms which were alreadybeing successfully implemented, and
the financial support expected frommultilateral and bilateral lenders under
several facilities which were negotiatedin a parallel, mutually supportive,process.
-
7/29/2019 Belizes Recent Debt Restructuring - 2007
16/24
4. Data Transparency
Macro-economic projections werepublished to the Central Bankwebsite to: Familiarise creditors with the economic
difficulties faced by Belize, Detail the efforts being made by the
Government to stabilise the economy,
Explain that despite these efforts,Belize would be unable to meet its debtservice commitments in the short- and
medium-term
-
7/29/2019 Belizes Recent Debt Restructuring - 2007
17/24
5. Formal Creditor Consultations
The first round of formal consultations with
creditors began in August 2006. In this first round of discussions, we sought
to update creditors on the situation in Belizeand to listen to initial creditor concerns.
A second phase of the consultative processbegan in late October 2006, after thepublication of the IMF Article 4 ConsultationReport.
At that time Belize also published revisedmacroeconomic and financial projections thattook into account the findings of the IMFReport.
-
7/29/2019 Belizes Recent Debt Restructuring - 2007
18/24
Formal Creditor Consultation
During the second phase of consultations,
Belize encouraged a frank exchange of viewsover macroeconomic projections, governmenteconomic policy and debt restructuringscenarios
Meetings were held with individual creditor as
well as with a number of Caribbean creditors inan informal grouping. Overall, Belize maintained contact with over 40
creditors holding more than 80% of the facevalue of the affected debt
The creditor feedback garnered throughout theconsultation process was critical to thedefinition of the restructuring terms ultimatelyincorporated into the exchange offer.
-
7/29/2019 Belizes Recent Debt Restructuring - 2007
19/24
6. Use of Indicative Scenarios
We prepared and presented several
i nd i ca t i ve deb t r est r u ct u r i ngscenar ios, all of which were designed toyield a similar level of debt relief.
These scenarios were all comparable inNPV terms, but they incorporateddifferent structural features.
This publication of debt restructuring
scenarios is an innovation that we feelwas instrumental in the success of theexchange offer.
-
7/29/2019 Belizes Recent Debt Restructuring - 2007
20/24
Conclusions
-
7/29/2019 Belizes Recent Debt Restructuring - 2007
21/24
Conclusions
When Belize launched the exchange
offer, there was no certainty of theoutcome.
Based on our extensive consultations,we felt, that our creditors were mostlyin agreement with us on the extent ofthe debt relief that was necessary.
We also felt that we reasonably
understood what our creditorspreferences were in terms of structureand conditions of the new bond to be
offered in exchange.
-
7/29/2019 Belizes Recent Debt Restructuring - 2007
22/24
Conclusions
Our creditors have acknowledged that
Belize conducted itself in a transparentand responsible manner. This, we feel,was a critical factor in garnering
creditor support. Through the success of the debt
exchange, Belizes credibility in theinternational financial community has
been boosted. We have had no litigation emerge from
what was a very complicated process.
-
7/29/2019 Belizes Recent Debt Restructuring - 2007
23/24
Keys to Success
The high participation rate and the absence
of litigation suggest that our creditors feltthat we were open, transparent and fair.
We had the support of the key multilateral
financial institutions. Our numbers were credible, therefore the
question to be answered at the end of theday was not whether or how much debtrelief was necessary, but how to structure adeal that provided this relief.
-
7/29/2019 Belizes Recent Debt Restructuring - 2007
24/24
Thank You!