bca & dda/access compliance review · to accompany the construction certificate application....
TRANSCRIPT
BCA & DDA/ACCESS COMPLIANCE
REVIEW North Kellyville Primary School
North Kellyville Primary School ISSUE FOR REVIEW
DATE 2ND MARCH 2018
PROJECT 17447
NBRS & PARTNERS Pty Ltd
Level 3, 4 Glen Street
Milsons Point
NSW 2061 Australia
Telephone +61 2 9922 2344 - Facsimile +61 2 9922 1308
ABN: 16 002 247 565
Nominated Architects
Geoffrey Deane: Reg No. 3766; Andrew Duffin: Reg No. 5602; Garry Hoddinett: Reg No 5286
This document remains the property of NBRS & PARTNERS Pty Ltd.
The document may only be used for the purposes for which it was produced.
Unauthorised use of the document in any form whatsoever is prohibited.
ISSUED REVIEW ISSUED BY
Date. 2nd March 2018 Issue for Review Trevor Eveleigh
Date. 27th February 2018 Draft Issue for Review Trevor Eveleigh
BCA COMPLIANCE REVIEW – NORTH KELLYVILLE PRIMARY SCHOOL.
REPORT – 17447- North Kellyville Primary School P:\17\17447\05_DOC\02_REPORTS\BCA\17447- BCA Review.docx PAGE 3 OF 27
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1.0 INTRODUCTION ................................................................................................................................................................................ 5
1.1 GENERAL ....................................................................................................................................................................... 5
1.2 Site Details .................................................................................................................................................................... 5
1.3 The proposal ................................................................................................................................................................. 6
1.4 BCA Requirements ...................................................................................................................................................... 6
1.5 Building Height, Rise in Storeys & Effective Height ............................................................................................... 6
2.0 BCA DEEMED TO SATISFY PROVISIONS ......................................................................................................................................... 7
2.1 Part A – Fire compartments and Fire ratings ........................................................................................................ 7
2.2 Building Floor areas & Compartmentation ............................................................................................................. 7
2.3 Boundary Separation................................................................................................................................................... 7
2.4 Part C- Fire Resistance ............................................................................................................................................... 7
Vertical Separation of Openings ............................................................................................................................... 8
Entertainment Venue Fire separation requirements. ..........................................................................................10
2.5 Part D – Access and Egress ....................................................................................................................................10
Number of Exits..........................................................................................................................................................10
Travel Distance to Exits ............................................................................................................................................10
Exits Provided ............................................................................................................................................................. 11
2.5.3.1 Level 1 Floor Level .................................................................................................................................................. 11
2.5.3.1 Level 2 Floor Level .................................................................................................................................................. 11
Exit Width .................................................................................................................................................................... 13
2.5.4.1 Level 1 Floor Level .................................................................................................................................................. 13
2.5.4.2 Level 2 Floor Level .................................................................................................................................................. 14
Site Security and Evacuation Principles ................................................................................................................ 14
Construction of Exits Part D2 .................................................................................................................................. 15
Part D3.1 – General Access requirements ........................................................................................................... 16
Part D3.2 General building access requirements ................................................................................................ 16
Part D3.3 Parts of Building to be accessible. ....................................................................................................... 17
Lift 18
Accessible Toilet Facilities ....................................................................................................................................... 18
Part D3.5 car parking................................................................................................................................................. 18
Part D3.6 Identification of accessible facilities, service and features ............................................................. 18
Part D3.7 Hearing Augmentation ............................................................................................................................ 18
Part D 3.8 Tactile Ground Surface Indicators....................................................................................................... 19
Part D3.9 Wheelchair Seating spaces in Class 9b Assembly Buildings .......................................................... 19
2.5.16.1 Amphitheatre adjacent to Stair 6. ........................................................................................................................ 19
2.5.16.1 Amphitheatre adjacent to Stair 9. ........................................................................................................................ 19
2.5.16.1 Seating adjacent to Stair 5. ...................................................................................................................................20
2.6 Part E – Essential Fire Safety Measures. .............................................................................................................. 21
2.7 Part F – Health and Amenity ................................................................................................................................... 22
Part F1 – Damp and Weatherproofing .................................................................................................................. 22
Part F2 – Sanitary and other facilities ................................................................................................................... 22
2.8 Part F3 – Room Sizes ............................................................................................................................................... 23
2.9 Part F4 – Light & Ventilation ................................................................................................................................... 23
2.9.1.1 Lighting ..................................................................................................................................................................... 23
2.9.1.2 Ventilation ................................................................................................................................................................. 23
Part F5 – Sound Insulation ...................................................................................................................................... 23
2.10 Part H – Special Use Buildings ............................................................................................................................... 23
2.11 Part J – Energy Efficiency ........................................................................................................................................ 23
Part J1 – Building Fabric .......................................................................................................................................... 23
Part J1.2 Thermal Construction ............................................................................................................................. 24
PART J1.3 Roof and Ceiling Insulation .................................................................................................................. 24
Part J1.4 Roof LIghts ................................................................................................................................................ 24
Part J1.5 Walls ........................................................................................................................................................... 24
Part J1.6 Floors .......................................................................................................................................................... 24
BCA COMPLIANCE REVIEW – NORTH KELLYVILLE PRIMARY SCHOOL.
REPORT – 17447- North Kellyville Primary School P:\17\17447\05_DOC\02_REPORTS\BCA\17447- BCA Review.docx PAGE 4 OF 27
Part J2 – External Glazing ....................................................................................................................................... 24
2.11.7.1 Part J2.4 Glazing Method 2................................................................................................................................... 24
2.12 Part J3 - Building sealing .......................................................................................................................................... 25
Part J3.3 Rooflights ................................................................................................................................................... 25
Part J3.4 Windows and doors ................................................................................................................................. 25
Part 3.5 – Exhaust Fans ........................................................................................................................................... 25
2.13 Part 3.6 - Construction of roofs, walls and floors ................................................................................................ 25
2.14 PART 3.7 – Evaporative Coolers ............................................................................................................................. 25
2.15 Part J5 – Air Conditioning and Ventilation Systems .......................................................................................... 25
2.16 Part J6 – Artificial Lighting and Power .................................................................................................................. 25
2.17 Part J7 – Heated Water Supply and Swimming Pool and Spa Plant. ............................................................. 25
3.0 CONCLUSION & RECOMENDATIONS.............................................................................................................................................. 26
BCA COMPLIANCE REVIEW – NORTH KELLYVILLE PRIMARY SCHOOL.
REPORT – 17447- North Kellyville Primary School P:\17\17447\05_DOC\02_REPORTS\BCA\17447- BCA Review.docx PAGE 5 OF 27
1.0 INTRODUCTION
1.1 GENERAL
NBRS Architecture have been engaged by Adco Constructions Pty Ltd to document the design for
the North Kellyville New Primary School, on the new site at Hezlett Road Kellyville for the Department
of Education.
As part of the design process a review has been undertaken of the proposed design against current
building regulations and to ensure that the design meets the appropriate building regulations,
including the provision of equitable access for all occupants.
This report sets out the outcome of the BCA Compliance and Access review, and has been prepared
to accompany the Construction Certificate Application.
The review compares the proposed design, against the requirements set out in the following
documents:
• The Building Code of Australia 2016 version (BCA) and
• The associated relevant standards
The proposed design for the development is represented in the following plans prepared by NBRS
Architecture which have been used as part of this review.
Table 1
Drawing number Issue Drawing name Date
17447-AWD-100-PL-LV1 C Level 1 Full Plan
17447-AWD-101-PL-LV1-A B Level 1 Partial Plan – A
17447-AWD-102-PL-LV1-B B Level 1 Partial Plan – B
17447-AWD-103-PL-LV1-C B Level 1 Partial Plan – C
17447-AWD-104-PL-LV1-D D Level 1 Partial Plan – D
17447-AWD-105-PL-LV2 C Level 2 Full Plan
17447-AWD-106-PL-LV2-A B Level 2 Partial Plan – A
17447-AWD-107-PL-LV2-B B Level 2 Partial Plan – B
17447-AWD-108-PL-LV2-C B Level 2 Partial Plan - C
17447-AWD-109-PL-LV2-D C Level 2 Partial Plan – D
1.2 SITE DETAILS
The site for the existing school campus is 120 Hazlett Road Kellyville, NSW 2155.
The existing site includes the following lots;
- Lot 101 DP 1216659
The site is within the Hills Council Local Government area, which is Climate Zone 6.
BCA COMPLIANCE REVIEW – NORTH KELLYVILLE PRIMARY SCHOOL.
REPORT – 17447- North Kellyville Primary School P:\17\17447\05_DOC\02_REPORTS\BCA\17447- BCA Review.docx PAGE 6 OF 27
Figure 1-Existing Sites ( From Maps.SIX.nsw.gov.au )
1.3 THE PROPOSAL
The proposal is for the construction of a new two storey primary school, including classrooms,
Library, Administration office area, Multi purpose hall and associated facilities constructed around
a central courtyard space.
Level Use Use Type
Ground
Floor
Administration Offices,
Library, Hall, Canteen, Classrooms & amenities
Class 5 associated with Class 9b
Class 9b
Level 1 Classrooms & amenities Class 9b
Level Use Class Approx. floor area
1.4 BCA REQUIREMENTS
The Building Code of Australia (BCA) sets out number of Performance Requirements that a building
solution must meet to achieve a reasonable level of safety, access to buildings, and functional
performance.
Where due to the configuration within individual building or site applications, the detailed design
does not meet the Deemed to Satisfy Provisions of the BCA, there is an opportunity for the design
to be assessed as an Alternative Solution, against the Performance Requirements of the BCA.
Any alternative Performance Solutions will be subject to the approval of the Principal Certifying
Authority.
The requirements for the building are based on the scale of the building, the number of occupants
and the usage of the building.
1.5 BUILDING HEIGHT, RISE IN STOREYS & EFFECTIVE HEIGHT
The building has a rise of storey of 2.
A total floor area of 7,948 m2
The building has an effective height of 6m.
Proposed School Site
BCA COMPLIANCE REVIEW – NORTH KELLYVILLE PRIMARY SCHOOL.
REPORT – 17447- North Kellyville Primary School P:\17\17447\05_DOC\02_REPORTS\BCA\17447- BCA Review.docx PAGE 7 OF 27
2.0 BCA DEEMED TO SATISFY PROVISIONS
2.1 PART A – FIRE COMPARTMENTS AND FIRE RATINGS
The proposed building is considered as one Class 9b School development with a few areas of Class
5 office use associated with the main class 9b use of the site.
A building of two storeys with a class 9b use is required to be of Type B construction under clause
C1.1 and Table C1.1 of the BCA.
The building has a floor area of 7,948 m2, which exceeds the maximum area permitted for a building
of Type B construction (max. 5,500 m2). To address this the building is proposed to be of Type A
construction which is permitted to be of up to 8,000 m2. Therefore the building will meet the Deemed
to Satisfy provisions for the size of the fire compartment.
2.2 BUILDING FLOOR AREAS & COMPARTMENTATION
The building regulations limit the floor area of a building based on the use and the type of
construction.
For buildings of Type A construction the maximum floor area is 8,000 m2 or a volume of 48,000 m3.
The impacts of changing from type B construction to type A construction is that:
- Fire rating requirements for the building increases. The floor structural fire rating is increased
to floors having a FRL of 120/120/120.
- Fire rated spandrels are required to effectively fire separate each floor level.
2.3 BOUNDARY SEPARATION
The proposed building is located centrally on the site and away from the perimeter site boundaries.
Therefore no specific fire rating is required due to proximity to the site boundaries and other
buildings.
2.4 PART C- FIRE RESISTANCE
The Following table sets out the requirements for fire resistance dependent upon the classification
and distance of the building from the site boundaries or other buildings, taken from Clause 3.1 and
Table 3 of Specification C1.1. Table 2- Required Fire ratings for Class 9b Usage
External Walls Distance from Boundary/Fire Source Loadbearing Distance from Fire source Non-Loadbearing
(Including columns in walls) < 1.5 m 120/120/120 < 1.5 m "-/120/120"1.5 to 3 m 120/90/90 1.5 to 3 m "-/90/90"3 to 9 m 120/60/30 More than 3m "--/--/--"
9 to 18 m 120/60/30More than 18 m 120/60/30
External Columns < 1.5 m 120/--/--1.5 to 3 m 120/--/--
More than 3m 120/--/--
Internal Columns 120/--/--Top Floor Columns -/-/-
Fire Wall 120/120/120
Loadbearing Non Loadbearing
Fire Stairs, lifts shafts 120/120/120 "--/120/120"
Loadbearing Non Loadbearing
Walls to SOU, & Public Corridors 120/--/-- NA
Floors 120/120/120
Roofs "--/--/--"
Fire Rating Required (Part C)
-
Note: Fire rated spandrel required at perimeter windows/openings unless sprinkler protected.
-
-
BCA COMPLIANCE REVIEW – NORTH KELLYVILLE PRIMARY SCHOOL.
REPORT – 17447- North Kellyville Primary School P:\17\17447\05_DOC\02_REPORTS\BCA\17447- BCA Review.docx PAGE 8 OF 27
POTENTIAL NON-COMPLIANCE NO. 1 Table 3 of Specification C1.1. requires that all structural columns in the external wall are required to
have a structural fire rating of FRL 120/--/-- or FRL 120/60/30 when more than 18m from a fire
source feature.
Within the design the external columns to the upper floor are not planned to be fire rated and this is
a non-compliance to Specification C1.1 and Table 3 and is to be addressed as a Performance
Solution within a fire engineered assessment, to be undertaken.
Within Design BCA DTS Clause Performance
Requirement
Comments
1 External
Columns on the
first floor are
not fire rated
Specification C1.1
3. TYPE A FIRE-RESISTING CONSTRUCTION
3.1 Fire-resistance of building elements
In a building required to be of Type A construction—
(a) each building element listed in Table 3 and any
beam or column incorporated in it, must have an
FRL not less than that listed in the Table for the
particular Class of building concerned; and
Table 3 TYPE A CONSTRUCTION: FRL OF
BUILDING ELEMENTS
CP1
A building must have
elements which will,
to the degree
necessary, maintain
structural stability
during a fire
appropriate to—
(a) the ……..
Performance
Solution to be
developed
OTHER LOADBEARING INTERNAL WALLS,
INTERNAL BEAMS, TRUSSES
and COLUMNS— FRL 120/--/--
VERTICAL SEPARATION OF OPENINGS
As the building is to be of Type A construction Clause C2.6 of the BCA requires openings in external
walls that are located above each other to be provided with fire protection to prevent fire transfer
from one floor to the next. This is either by way of a vertical fire rated spandrel or a horizontal fire
rated projection above the lower opening.
Within the design the concrete upper level floor extends out past the line of the external wall to
provide protection above the opening in the lower level, but the projection does not meet the detail
requirements of Clause C2.6 as the projection is only 800mm.
POTENTIAL NON-COMPLIANCE NO. 2 The details of the horizontal projection not being the minimum required by Clause C2.6 is a non-
compliance and will need to be either extended to meet the requirements of Clause C2.6 or assessed
as a Fire Engineered Performance Solution to show that the design meets the associated
Performance Requirement of CP2. Performance Solutions are permitted based on Clause A05 of the
BCA 2016.
BCA COMPLIANCE REVIEW – NORTH KELLYVILLE PRIMARY SCHOOL.
REPORT – 17447- North Kellyville Primary School P:\17\17447\05_DOC\02_REPORTS\BCA\17447- BCA Review.docx PAGE 9 OF 27
Figure 2- Wall Section
Below is the details of the Non-compliance and the associated performance requirement.
Within Design BCA DTS Clause Performance Requirement Comments
2 No fire rated
spandrels are
included in
the design to
the external
perimeter of
the first floor.
The design
does include
a short slab
projection
(800mm)
No Fire rated
spandrels are
included to
the internal
perimeter of
the central
void.
BCA Clause C2.6 Vertical separation of openings in
external walls
(a) If in a building of Type A construction, any part
of a window or other opening in an external wall is
above another opening in the storey next below and
its vertical projection falls no further than 450 mm
outside the lower opening (measured horizontally),
the openings must be separated by—
(i) a spandrel which—
(A) is not less than 900 mm in height; and
(B) extends not less than 600 mm above the upper
surface of the intervening floor; and
(C) is of non-combustible material having an FRL of
not less than 60/60/60; or
(ii) part of a curtain wall or panel wall that complies
with (i); or
(iii) construction that complies with (i) behind a
curtain wall or panel wall and has any gaps packed
with a non-combustible material that will withstand
thermal expansion and structural movement of the
walling without the loss of seal against fire and
smoke; or
(iv) a slab or other horizontal construction that—
(A) projects outwards from the external face of
the wall not less than 1100 mm; and
(B) extends along the wall not less than 450 mm
beyond the openings concerned; and
(C) is non-combustible and has an FRL of not less
than 60/60/60.
CP2
(a) A building must have elements
which will, to the degree
necessary, avoid the spread of
fire—
(i) to exits; and
(ii) to
(iii) between buildings; and
(iv) in a building.
(b) Avoidance of the spread of fire
referred to in (a) must be
appropriate to—
(i) the function or use of the
building; and
(ii) the fire load; and
(iii) the potential fire intensity; and
(iv) the fire hazard; and
(v) the number of storeys in the
building; and
(vi) its proximity to other property;
and
(vii) any active fire safety systems
installed in the building; and
(viii) the size of any fire
compartment; and
(ix) fire brigade intervention; and
(x) other elements they support;
and
(xi) the evacuation time.
To be
addressed
as a
Performanc
e solution
based on
short
projection
which is
less than
the
1100mm
length
required
Upper Floor Window
Lower Floor Window
800mm Projection
Low wall not fire rated
BCA COMPLIANCE REVIEW – NORTH KELLYVILLE PRIMARY SCHOOL.
REPORT – 17447- North Kellyville Primary School P:\17\17447\05_DOC\02_REPORTS\BCA\17447- BCA Review.docx PAGE 10 OF 27
POTENTIAL NON-COMPLIANCE NO. 3 Where a floor or wall is required to be fire rated by Specification C1.1, any openings through the
element are required to be treated to prevent the spread of fire from one site of the element to the
other.
Within the design it is proposed to not included protection of mechanical service penetrations
through the upper floor slab which is required to be fire rated. This is a technical non-compliance to
the requirements of Clause C3.12 & C3.15 and is to be addressed as a performance solution within
a Fire Engineered assessment for the project to show that the design meets the associated
Performance Requirement of CP2. Performance Solutions are permitted based on Clause A05 of the
BCA 2016.
Within Design BCA DTS Clause Performance
Requirement
Comments
3 Penetrations in
First Floor Slab
not provided with
fire damper
C3.15 Openings for service installations
Where an electrical, electronic, plumbing, mechanical
ventilation, air-conditioning or other service penetrates
a building element (other than an external wall or roof)
that is required to have an FRL with respect to integrity
or insulation or a resistance to the incipient spread of fire,
that installation must comply with any one of the
following:
(a) Tested systems
(i) The service, building element and any protection
method at the penetration are identical with a
prototype assembly of the service, building element
and protection method which has been tested in
accordance with AS 4072.1 and AS 1530.4 and has
achieved the required FRL or resistance to the incipient
spread of fire.
(b) Ventilation and air-conditioning — In the case of
ventilating or air-conditioning ducts or equipment, the
installation is in accordance with AS/NZS 1668.1.
CP8
Any building element
provided to resist the
spread of fire must be
protected, to the degree
necessary, so that an
adequate level of
performance is
maintained—
(a) where openings,
construction joints and
the like occur; and
(b) where penetrations
occur for building
services.
To be Addressed
as a Performance
Solution
ENTERTAINMENT VENUE FIRE SEPARATION REQUIREMENTS.
The new Multipurpose Hall and Gym are not considered to be “Entertainment Venues”, however the
NSW DOE Education Facilities Standard and Guidelines (EFSG) sets out specific design
requirements for School halls and Gyms, due to the potential for the facilities to be used by the
community. This includes the requirement for store rooms to have a FRL 60/60/60 fire separation
from other areas.
2.5 PART D – ACCESS AND EGRESS
The requirements for access to and egress from a building are dependent upon the number of
occupants within the building and their characteristics.
The new facilities will be design for approximately 1000 students and associated staff.
NUMBER OF EXITS
A class 9b Educational School building is required by Clause D1.2 to have at least two exits from
each level.
TRAVEL DISTANCE TO EXITS
Travel distances to exits is set by Clause D1.4 which requires the following:
General Areas
• No point on the floor of each level is to be more than 40m from one of two exits with travel to
a point of choice of two exits within 20m.
BCA COMPLIANCE REVIEW – NORTH KELLYVILLE PRIMARY SCHOOL.
REPORT – 17447- North Kellyville Primary School P:\17\17447\05_DOC\02_REPORTS\BCA\17447- BCA Review.docx PAGE 11 OF 27
• A maximum of 60 m between two exits measured through the point of choice.
• The travel distance from upper level down to ground level and to an outside Open Space is to
be a maximum of 80m.
EXITS PROVIDED
The design includes 5 stairs connecting the ground and first floor levels and a multiple exits from
the ground floor level directly to outside, in multiple directions.
2.5.3.1 LEVEL 1 FLOOR LEVEL
Within the design on Level 1 there are multiple exits from the different areas of the building as
follows:
- All home bases have a door leading directly to outside which ensures short travel distances to
an exit.
- The administration office and staff area, the Library and the hall all have an exit directly to
outside that ensures travel distances to outside of less than 40m as well as alternate exits via
the central courtyard.
- The exit from the Special programs area is via the ramp and stair which lead down to ground
level and to outside. In this case the exit is via a ramp or stair and therefore the ramp or stair is
considered to be the defined “Exit” and travel to outside open space is less than the maximum
permitted of 80m.
Figure 3- Level 1 Floor Plan
2.5.3.1 LEVEL 2 FLOOR LEVEL
Within the design on Level 2 due to the location of the 5 stairs, travel distances from the
classrooms and all areas is less than 40m to one of two exits and less than 20m to a point of
choice.
Within the design the travel distance from some areas via the stairways to ground level and to
open space are up to 90m which is more than the maximum 80m permitted under Clause
D1.9 of the BCA.This is to be addressed as a Performance Solution to show that the design
meets the appropriate performance requirement for the provisions of exits.
It is noted that the central open walkway crossover requires the occupant to entry back into
the building before proceeding to one of the stair exits. The doors to the central open walkway
are to be unlocked while the school is occupied and may be locked for security purposes after
hours. This is considered appropriate and the likelihood of the doors being accidently locked
Exit to
outside
Exits to
outside
BCA COMPLIANCE REVIEW – NORTH KELLYVILLE PRIMARY SCHOOL.
REPORT – 17447- North Kellyville Primary School P:\17\17447\05_DOC\02_REPORTS\BCA\17447- BCA Review.docx PAGE 12 OF 27
while a person is on the walkway is low, due to the clear visibility of the area from the adjacent
corridors.
Figure 4 -Level 2 Floor Plan
POTENTIAL NON-COMPLIANCE NO. 4 The travel distance from some areas of the first floor via the central stairs to ground level and to
open space is up to 90m which is more than that permitted under Clause D1.9 of the BCA and is to
be addressed as a Fire Engineered Performance Solution to show that the provision exits meets the
performance requirement of DP4. Performance Solutions are permitted based on Clause A05 of the
BCA 2016.
Within Design BCA DTS Clause Performance Requirement Comments
4 Exit Travel
distance via
open stair to
open space
on southern
side is up to
90m.
D1.9 Travel by non-fire-isolated stairways or
ramps
(a) A non-fire-isolated stairway or non-fire-
isolated ramp serving as a required exit must
provide a continuous means of travel by its
own flights and landings from every storey
served to the level at which egress to a road
or open space is provided.
(b) In a Class 2, 3 or 4
(c) In a Class 5, 6, 7, 8 or 9 building, the
distance from any point on a floor to a point
of egress to a road or open space by way of a
required non-fire-isolated stairway or non-fire-
isolated ramp must not exceed 80 m.
(d) In
DP4
Exits must be provided from a
building to allow occupants to
evacuate safely, with their
number, location and
dimensions being appropriate
to—
(a) the travel distance; and
(b) the number, mobility and
other characteristics of
occupants; and
(c) the function or use of the
building; and
(d) the height of the building;
and
(e) whether the exit is from
above or below ground level.
To be
Addressed as
a
Performance
Solution
4 central
exit stairs
Additional
exit stair
Central open
crossover
walkway
BCA COMPLIANCE REVIEW – NORTH KELLYVILLE PRIMARY SCHOOL.
REPORT – 17447- North Kellyville Primary School P:\17\17447\05_DOC\02_REPORTS\BCA\17447- BCA Review.docx PAGE 13 OF 27
EXIT WIDTH
The required exit width is based on the number of occupants within the area.
NSW D1.6 requires that exit widths in a class 9b school to be at least 1m wide for up to 100
occupants of an area plus 250mm for each additional 25 occupants above 100.
Where there are more than 200 occupants, D1.6 requires a width of 2m plus 0.5m per 60
occupants where the exit path involves steps or 75 occupants when stairs are not included.
2.5.4.1 LEVEL 1 FLOOR LEVEL
The lower level (Level 1) includes a number of different areas and functions, which is set out in the
table below.
Space Area Occupant Density Occupants
9 Home bases 25 students + 1 staff per room 234
3 special programs 12 students + 1 Staff per room 39
Administration office 460 10m2/p 46
Library 260 2m2/p 130
Library office 170 10m2/p 17
Multipurpose hall. 320 1m2/p 320
Total 786
For the 786 occupants the total clear width required is 6.5 m for exits without stairs and 7m for exits
involving stairs.
There are multiple exits from the ground floor with some areas having an exit directly to outside and
others sharing the exits from the central court.
The following table sets out the areas and their exits.
Space Occupants Exits
9 Home bases 234 Shared exits with central court
3 special programs 39 Exit via western corner
Administration office 46 Exit directly to outside via double doors
Library 130 Exit directly to outside via double doors
Library office 17 Exit via main library area
Multipurpose hall. 320 Multiple exits directly to outside
The ground floor exits are also shared with the occupants that have used the 4 central courtyard
stairs.
The exits from the courtyard areas are:
- Exit to the western corner which has a clear width of 3m and provides an exit for the occupants
from:
o Central Stair 1, (172 occupants)
o Western home bases ( 130 Occupants)
o Special Programs area ( 39 occupants)
- Exit to the south western corner which has a clear width of minimum 3m and provides exits for
occupants from:
o Central Stair 2, (172 occupants)
o Hall ( 100 occupants)
- The main entry / exit to south eastern corner which has a clear width minimum 4m and provides
an exit for occupants from:
o Central Stair 3 (172 occupants)
o Central Stair 4 (172 occupants)
o Northern corner home bases (72)
- The exit adjacent to stair 5 has a double door with a clear width of at least 1.5m and provides
an exit for occupants from:
o Stair 5 (118 occupants)
o Northern corner home bases (32 occupants)
The following figure shows the ground floor exits.
BCA COMPLIANCE REVIEW – NORTH KELLYVILLE PRIMARY SCHOOL.
REPORT – 17447- North Kellyville Primary School P:\17\17447\05_DOC\02_REPORTS\BCA\17447- BCA Review.docx PAGE 14 OF 27
Figure 5- Ground Floor (Level 1) Exits
The 4 central stairs each have a clear width of 1.75m and the eastern end stair has a clear width of
1.2m giving a total clear width of 8.2m.
Therefore the current design stairs have sufficient clear width for the number of occupants.
2.5.4.2 LEVEL 2 FLOOR LEVEL
The Upper Level (Level 2) includes a total of 31 home bases (classrooms) each could be expected
to accommodate up to 25 students plus one teacher. This would give a total number of occupants
on the level of 775 students and 31 staff, or 806 total.
For the 806 occupants the total clear width required is 7.5 m.
The 4 central stairs each have a clear width of 1.7m and the eastern end stair has a clear width of
1.2m giving a total clear width of 8m.
Therefore the current design stairs have sufficient clear width for the number of occupants.
SITE SECURITY AND EVACUATION PRINCIPLES
As part of the management of the school, an evacuation plan will be developed which is expected
to include:
- Staff and teachers informed of an event that requires evacuation.
- Evacuation of the classes to a safe location at a distance away from the building, that is
accessible from a public roadway.
- The evacuation would be undertaken by staff (Teachers)
- In a school normally students are orderly evacuated by teachers and staff to the sports field
as part of the evacuation process.
Within the proposed design the school perimeter will be fenced with a security fence to 2100mm
high and gates located at pedestrian and vehicle entry points.
The gates will have security control with the gates being closed and locked during school hours.
There are a total of 10 gates to the perimeter of the site, of these the following gates are the main
entry and exit gates that will be provided with secure access and egress.
The proposed works also includes internal fences to provide separation between vehicle and
student areas, with gates that will not be locked. To ensure free egress from the building.
All staff will be provided with security swipe access through these gates, which will ensure that
they can exit the site at all times;
BCA COMPLIANCE REVIEW – NORTH KELLYVILLE PRIMARY SCHOOL.
REPORT – 17447- North Kellyville Primary School P:\17\17447\05_DOC\02_REPORTS\BCA\17447- BCA Review.docx PAGE 15 OF 27
- G1 – Main school pedestrian entry from Hazlett road, 2.4m double swing pedestrian gates,
with electric lock, swipe access / egress and intercom connection to main office.
- G2 – Main school vehicle entry from Hazlett road via motorized sliding vehicle gate with
electric lock, swipe access / egress and intercom connection to main office.
- G6 – Emergency access gate to Sporting field from the corner of Hipwell and Prentice (rear
road) via double swing vehicle gates with emergency services access.
- G7 – Rear of school pedestrian entry from the corner of Hipwell and Prentice, via a single
pedestrian gate with electric lock and swipe access / egress.
- G8 – Pedestrian entry from Thorogood Blvd, via single swing gate with electric lock and swipe
access / egress.
The sporting field will provide a safe space to evacuate to and enable management of the
occupant evacuation. Following evacuation to the muster point all occupants will be able to
evacuate through the gates to the adjacent road.
The following figure indicates the site perimeter fencing and the gate locations.
The building may be used by community groups out side of general school hours. As part of
normal procedures users of the facilities will be issued with swipe access to the building
which will enable egress via gates G1, G2, G6 & G8 at all times.
Figure 6 - Site access and Egress
CONSTRUCTION OF EXITS PART D2
The stairs and exit paths are to be designed to meet the requirements of Part D2 of the BCA, which
will include
• Store rooms or other enclosed spaces if included under stairs are to be fire rated enclosures
(FRL 60/60/60).
• Going lengths and riser heights for the new stair are to meet the following requirements.
− Riser – Max 190mm high, - Min 115mm high.
− Going – Max 355mm long, - Min 250mm long
− 2 x R + G – Max 700mm – Min 550mm.
• Continuous conspicuous nosing(min 30% contract) to each of the stair treads.
School Oval,
Evacuation
muster point
Gate G6 & G7
Gate G1 & G2
Gate G8
BCA COMPLIANCE REVIEW – NORTH KELLYVILLE PRIMARY SCHOOL.
REPORT – 17447- North Kellyville Primary School P:\17\17447\05_DOC\02_REPORTS\BCA\17447- BCA Review.docx PAGE 16 OF 27
• Threshold height at any external door to be less than 50mm. however to ensure that an
accessible path is provided the change in level needs to be less than 3mm and threshold
ramps should be included.
• Handrails to be provided to both sides of the new stair, with extensions at the ends to comply
with AS1428.1.
• As the building is a primary school a second handrail is to be included on each stairway with a
height between 665mm and 750mm above the stair treads.
• Door locks and latches are to be located between 900mm and 1100mm above the floor and
offer single action exit function at all times.
• The sliding doors to the homebases are not to be fitted with locking devices to ensure that exit
via pushing on the door handle will enable the door to open for exit.
• The doors to the central open walkway are to be unlocked while the school is occupied and
may be locked for security purposes after hours.
• Balustrades to edges of landings to be at least 1m high with no footholds between 150mm
and 750mm.
• Tactile ground surface indicators will be required at the top and bottom of all stairs except
enclosed fire stairs.
• Landings ramps and stairs to have the following slip resistant characteristics.
Table D2.14 SLIP-RESISTANCE CLASSIFICATION
APPLICATION SURFACE CONDITIONS
DRY WET
Ramp steeper than 1:14 P4 or R11 P5 or R12
Ramp steeper than 1:20 but not steeper than 1:14 P3 or R10 P4 or R11
Tread or landing surface P3 or R10 P4 or R11
Nosing or landing edge strip P3 P4
PART D3.1 – GENERAL ACCESS REQUIREMENTS
Under the BCA requirements in Part D3.1, an access pathway is required to areas depending upon
the usage of the area as indicated in the table below, except as permitted by Clause D3.4.
Applying this requirement to the proposed works, access is required to all areas as indicated in the
following table.
Table 3 Access Requirements
USAGE TYPE BCA REQUIREMENTS( D3.1) APPLICATION TO DESIGN COMPLIANCE
Class 9b
School
building
To and within all other areas
normally used by the
occupants.
Access to be provided to all floor areas used
by occupants, except for non-accessible
toilet facilities.
Access to the first floor is to be provided by
a lift.
Yes
PART D3.2 GENERAL BUILDING ACCESS REQUIREMENTS
Part D3.2 of the BCA requires an accessible pathway to be provided from the main street frontage,
at least 50% of all entries and the accessible parking space to the building.
Within the proposed design there are 4 potential pedestrian entries to the site, being:
• From the Hazlett Street frontage via the main building entry.
• From Hazlett street frontage and through the north east façade entry.
• From Wicham Place to the north west, which is an entry but will not be encouraged to be
used.
• From the south western corner of the site, which links to a proposed future roadway.
Of these entries to the site three of them have an accessible pathway to the building. The exception
being the entry from Wickham Place.
BCA COMPLIANCE REVIEW – NORTH KELLYVILLE PRIMARY SCHOOL.
REPORT – 17447- North Kellyville Primary School P:\17\17447\05_DOC\02_REPORTS\BCA\17447- BCA Review.docx PAGE 17 OF 27
As part of the development new carparking, including 2 accessible parking spaces will be
constructed adjacent to the main building entry and an accessible pathway will be provided from
the parking space to the main entry.
Based on this the main entry to the site and at least 50% of all entries area accessible and therefore
the design meets the Deemed to Satisfy requirements for the provision of an accessible pathway to
the building under part D3.2.
PART D3.3 PARTS OF BUILDING TO BE ACCESSIBLE.
Under part D3.2 of the BCA, access is required to all areas normally used by the occupants and
includes areas such as toilet facilities, meeting rooms and kitchens etc.
Access paths, door widths and door clearances are to comply with AS1428.1 - 2009
The current design for the room layouts indicate that access will be provided to all areas on all levels
using the lifts indicated.
The following criteria from As1428.1 sets out the requirements for providing access, that should be
included within the detailed design:
• All doorways should be minimum 850mm clear (requires min. 920mm leaf doors)
• Provide side clearances to doors as per Figure 31 of AS1428.1 ( refer below.)
• Provide lobbies with min 1450mm clear lengths to enable usability. (refer below)
BCA COMPLIANCE REVIEW – NORTH KELLYVILLE PRIMARY SCHOOL.
REPORT – 17447- North Kellyville Primary School P:\17\17447\05_DOC\02_REPORTS\BCA\17447- BCA Review.docx PAGE 18 OF 27
LIFT
A lift is included within the design, to provide access between the various levels and floors of the
Building, to meet the DTS requirements for an accessible pathway through the building.
The lift will travel less than 12m, therefore the lift car floor dimensions will need to be as set out in
the following table.
ACCESSIBLE TOILET FACILITIES
The design includes new accessible facilities provided adjacent to the location of other toilet
facilities in each area and the documented detailed design of the facilities are to meet the planning
requirements of AS1428.1-2009. Refer to Section 2.7.2 of this report for details.
PART D3.5 CAR PARKING
Where car parking is provided part D3.5 of the BCA requires a minimum of 1 accessible space per
50 car parking spaces is to be provided.
The current design includes the provision of 12 parking spaces to the southern side of the building
adjacent to the entry, two of which are accessible parking spaces with a central circulation space.
The current design of the parking spaces in size and configuration meet the Australian Standard
requirements.
Therefore the design meets the requirements for the provision of accessible parking spaces.
PART D3.6 IDENTIFICATION OF ACCESSIBLE FACILITIES, SERVICE AND FEATURES
Part D3.6 requires signage complying with Specification D3.6 to be included within the building in, a
number of locations to identify the following:
• All sanitary facilities
• Identification of exit ( where exit signage is included.)
• Path of travel to the Lift if not evident from the main entry.
Signage is to be included as part of the detailed design.
PART D3.7 HEARING AUGMENTATION
Part D3.7 requires that where an amplification system within a meeting room of more than 100m2
a hearing augmentation system is to be installed.
Within the design if sound amplification systems is included then a hearing augmentation system
will be required.
-
Lift Travel distance Less than 12m Depth Width
Lift Required Lift Car dimensions 1400mm 1100mm
Lift Requirements
Emergency Lift Not Required
Streatcher Facilities Not Required
BCA COMPLIANCE REVIEW – NORTH KELLYVILLE PRIMARY SCHOOL.
REPORT – 17447- North Kellyville Primary School P:\17\17447\05_DOC\02_REPORTS\BCA\17447- BCA Review.docx PAGE 19 OF 27
PART D 3.8 TACTILE GROUND SURFACE INDICATORS
Part D3.8 of the BCA requires that tactile ground surface indicators (TGSI’s) be installed at the top
and bottom of open stairs and ramps to warn occupants of the associated hazard, where the area
is to be accessible.
The detailed documented design is to include tactile indicators to the top and bottom of all stairs
and ramps to meet the DTS requirements.
PART D3.9 WHEELCHAIR SEATING SPACES IN CLASS 9B ASSEMBLY BUILDINGS
Part D3.9 and table D3.9 sets out the requirements for the provision of seating spaces for wheel
chairs where fixed seating is provided and requires that where there is up to 150 fixed seats at least
3 spaces for wheel chairs is provided.
Within the design there is amphitheater seating provided in the following locations:
2.5.16.1 AMPHITHEATRE ADJACENT TO STAIR 6.
The Amphitheatre area includes stepped tiered floor which is designed to be seating for up to
approximately 100 students.
The area is provided with a space to the end that can accommodate two wheelchairs adjacent to
the seating. Table D3.9 would require 3 wheel chair seating spaces in this area.
The current design includes space for potentially 2 wheel chairs and an additional space is required
as indicated in the figure below.
Figure 7- Seating Area
2.5.16.1 AMPHITHEATRE ADJACENT TO STAIR 9.
The Amphitheatre area includes stepped tiered floor which is designed to be seating for up to
approximately 60 students.
Table D3.9 would require 3 wheel chair seating spaces in this area.
The area is provided with a space at one end that can accommodate two wheelchairs adjacent to
the seating and a space at the other end for one wheel chair to meet the requirements for wheelchair
seating.
Space for 2 wheel
chairs
Space for 1 extra
wheel chair is required
BCA COMPLIANCE REVIEW – NORTH KELLYVILLE PRIMARY SCHOOL.
REPORT – 17447- North Kellyville Primary School P:\17\17447\05_DOC\02_REPORTS\BCA\17447- BCA Review.docx PAGE 20 OF 27
Figure 8- Seating Area
2.5.16.1 SEATING ADJACENT TO STAIR 5.
The space adjacent to stair 5 is designed for casual informal student seating.
The area is provided with a space at one end that could accommodate two wheelchairs adjacent to
the seating. However Table D3.9 would required three seating spaces.
In light of the small area of seating and the informal nature of the seating it is considered that the
current design would be acceptable.
This is to be addressed as a Performance Solution to show that the design meets the intent of
Associated Performance Solution or the design is to be modified to include additional seating
spaces..
Figure 9- Seating Area.
Space for 2 wheel
chairs
Space for 1 wheel chair
BCA COMPLIANCE REVIEW – NORTH KELLYVILLE PRIMARY SCHOOL.
REPORT – 17447- North Kellyville Primary School P:\17\17447\05_DOC\02_REPORTS\BCA\17447- BCA Review.docx PAGE 21 OF 27
2.6 PART E – ESSENTIAL FIRE SAFETY MEASURES.
The Essential Fire Safety Measures to be installed in the building are based on the type size and
scale of the building,
The following table sets out the essential fire safety measures that are to be installed.
It is noted that an exemption exists for classrooms to not be provided with fire hose reel coverage,
therefore the proposed design includes a fire hose reel to the ground floor level of the relocated
modular building only.
The Current Design includes the following essential fire safety measures:
• Fire Hydrant coverage to all floor areas to As2419.1.
• Fire hose reel coverage to the administration areas, library and hall but not to the
classrooms as permitted under Clause E1.4 (iv).
• Emergency Lighting and illuminated Exit signage.
Within the Design, it is noted that a mechanical exhaust system is to be installed to provide cross
ventilation to the classrooms and ventilation to the withdrawal rooms. The system ductwork will
connect a number of rooms together .
The system would not be classified as a minor exhaust system under Clause 5 of AS 1668.1 or a
Kitchen exhaust system under Clause 6 of AS1668.1 and therefore a detection system in line with
Clause 5 of NSW BCA E2.2a would be required to initiate shutdown of the exhaust system in the
event of a fire to prevent smoke transfer between rooms.
Clause 5 c (ii) of NSW BCA E2.2a does not require the system to activate an occupant warning
system.
Fire Hydrants Required
Fire Hose Reels Required Within 4m of an Exit
Sprinkler Protection
Carpark
Fire Control Centre Not Required
Smoke Hazard Management
Above Ground Only Exits
Stair Pressurisation No
Smoke Detection
Smoke Exhaust System
General Area
Stage Requirements
Exit Signs & Lighting
SSISEP
Sound Systems and Intercom Systems for Emergency Purposes
Not required in School Classrooms
Located externally, in fire stairs or next to required stair
Essential Fire Safety Measures (Part E)
-
-
No
Not Required
Basement Level Exits
-
Exit signs & Emergency Lighting Required
-
Not Required
Not Required
Sprinkler Protection required if Flying Scenery included
BCA COMPLIANCE REVIEW – NORTH KELLYVILLE PRIMARY SCHOOL.
REPORT – 17447- North Kellyville Primary School P:\17\17447\05_DOC\02_REPORTS\BCA\17447- BCA Review.docx PAGE 22 OF 27
2.7 PART F – HEALTH AND AMENITY
PART F1 – DAMP AND WEATHERPROOFING
Part F1 of the BCA requires that the external façade of the building be designed to maintain
weatherproofing and prevent water ingress to the building.
This has been included in the detailed design documentation.
PART F2 – SANITARY AND OTHER FACILITIES
Part F2 of the BCA sets out the required number of toilets to be provided based on the number of
people that will be catered for within the building and the use of the building.
For a school building the following criteria is required.
- Separate facilities are to be provided for Students and Staff.
- Separate Male and Female facilites are to be provided
- At least one ambulatory male and female cubicles are to be included in each group of facilities.
The total facilities to be provided across the school campus are to be as set out in the following
table for the total of 1000 students and approximatley 40 staff.
Table 4- Total Facilities
Within the current design the following facilites are provided: Location User Female Male Access
Wc Amb.
Wc
HB Wc Amb.
Wc
U HB Wc HB
Level 1
Adm /Office area Staff 1 1 1 1 1(L) 1
Library Staff 1 (R ) 1
North east Students 1 1 2 1 3 2
Home base 1 &3 Students 3
( 2L, 1R)
3
West Corner Students 10 1 7 3 1 5 7 1(R ) 1
Canteen Students 1 1 2 1 1 2
Level 1 Total Students 12 3 11 4 3 8 11 4
(2L, 2 R)
4
Level 2
North Corner Students 1 1 2 2
North East Students 4 1 4 1(L) 1
North East Staff 1* 1* 1*(0) 1*(0)
Western SIde Staff 1*(0) 1*(0) 1* 1*
Western Side Students 1(L) 1
West Corner Students 4 1 4
South Corner 1 1 3 4
Level 2 Total Students 8 2 8 2 2 5 6 2(2L) 2
Students Total Students 20 5 19 6 5 13 17 6
(4L, 2R)
6
Staff Total Staff 3 3 3 3 2
Staff Total
Adjusted*
Staff* 2 2 2 2 2
(1L, 1R)
2
Note *
It is noted that the current design includes a number of Unisex staff toilet facilities located in various
locations on the ground and first floor level. As the current total number of staff facilities exceeds
the number required for the number of staff, if the unisex facilities were to be allocated as either
male of female staff then the appropriate number of facilities per staff would be appropriate.
Occupants Use for toilets Split /Females WC HB WC U HB Access
1000 50% 13 9 7 6 9 1
40 50% 2 1 1 1 1 1
Toilet Requirements Female
H-School 9b - Students
Male
G-School 9b - Employees
BCA COMPLIANCE REVIEW – NORTH KELLYVILLE PRIMARY SCHOOL.
REPORT – 17447- North Kellyville Primary School P:\17\17447\05_DOC\02_REPORTS\BCA\17447- BCA Review.docx PAGE 23 OF 27
The Accessible toilet facilities provided are required to include an even distribution of left and right
handed facilities.
From the table above it can be seen that the facilites meet this requirement except for the Accessible
student facilities on Level 2 where Access Toilet L2.07 should be changed to being right handed.
From the table above the number of facilities proided is sufficient for the total number of students
and staff proposed in the building.
2.8 PART F3 – ROOM SIZES
Part F3 of the BCA requires the following ceiling heights in certain rooms within a building:
• Airlocks bathrooms storerooms, tea prep areas and the like – 2.1m
• General area – 2.4m
• Above stairways, measured vertical above the nosing – 2m
• Auditoriums and corridors leading to auditoriums that accommodate more than 100
occupants – 2.7m
The design appears to be able to meet these requirements.
2.9 PART F4 – LIGHT & VENTILATION
2.9.1.1 LIGHTING
Lighting is required to all rooms in the building. This can be achieved by either natural daylight, or
other lighting methods. If daylight is used the area of windows is to be at least 10% of the floor area.
Therefore an external window and the size of the windows are to be at least 10% of the floor area of
the room served to meet the requirements of Clause F4.1
All classrooms are required to be provided with natural daylight via a window. The current design
includes external windows to all classrooms with an area of approximately 9m2 per classroom,
which is more than 10% of the typical classroom size of 63m2 and therefore meets the
requirements.
2.9.1.2 VENTILATION
Ventilation is to be provided to all rooms and this can be achieved by either natural ventilation
through operable windows and doors or by mechanical ventilation to AS1668. If natural ventilation
is to be used then the area of the operable windows should be at least 10% of the floor area of the
room.
PART F5 – SOUND INSULATION
The BCA under Part F5 requires sound insulation of walls and floors that separate Sole Occupancy
Units from other adjacent SOU’s or other spaces within the building. Particularly in Class 2 & 3
buildings.
This does not apply to the proposed works which is of class 9b use.
2.10 PART H – SPECIAL USE BUILDINGS
Part H of the BCA applies to buildings which are used as Entertainment Venues and therefore does
not apply to the proposed works.
2.11 PART J – ENERGY EFFICIENCY
Energy efficiency requirements of the BCA generally apply to part of a building that are air
conditioned, which are not of Class 2 usage. NSW Basix legislation applies to the Residential Class
2 buildings
PART J1 – BUILDING FABRIC
The proposed building is class 9b use located in climate zone 7 and will require the following thermal
performance of the various parts.
BCA COMPLIANCE REVIEW – NORTH KELLYVILLE PRIMARY SCHOOL.
REPORT – 17447- North Kellyville Primary School P:\17\17447\05_DOC\02_REPORTS\BCA\17447- BCA Review.docx PAGE 24 OF 27
PART J1.2 THERMAL CONSTRUCTION
The installation of materials associated with the thermal performance of the building are to be in
accordance with AS 4859.1.
Assuming that the roofing material colour is a mid to dark colour (Solar Absorbance of 0.6 or more)
Then the following table shows the insulation requirements for the roof and ceiling combination for
the various zones from Table J1.3a. These values assume that more than 99% of the roof area is
insulated.
Table 5
PART J1.3 ROOF AND CEILING INSULATION
The combined roof and ceiling insulation is to give a total R value of R3.2 or more. The insulation is
to be provided as a combination of roof and ceiling insulation.
PART J1.4 ROOF LIGHTS
Part J1.4 of the BCA sets out specific requirements for roof lights when the area exceeds 1.5% of
the floor area and permits skylights to be up to 5% of the floor area.
Where roof lights or skylights are included their thermal performance will need to achieve minimum
thermal performance criteria dependent upon the proportional area of the skylight to the space
served.
Curranty the design does not include skylights.
PART J1.5 WALLS
External walls are required to achieve a minimum Total R-Value of at least R2.8.
The insulation is to be included in the detailed design specification.
PART J1.6 FLOORS
Specific thermal performance requirements are set out in Part J1.6 of the BCA for suspended floors
with unenclosed perimeters on the lower levels.
If there are any new suspended floors that are open below, they will be required to be insulated to
prevent heat loss.
The current design does not include insulation to the underside of the upper floor floor slab under
classroom areas. This is a technical non-compliance that is planned to be included as part of the
Thermal performance assessment to the undertaken using the JV3 process.
PART J2 – EXTERNAL GLAZING
2.11.7.1 PART J2.4 GLAZING METHOD 2
Compliance with Part J2.4 is achieved by analysis of the areas of the external façade and the
proportional areas of the external glazing.
The analysis is undertaken during the detailed design to show compliance based on the building
façade elements and will be required as part of the Construction Certificate documentation.
Zone 6 Roof & CeilingInternal envelope walls
Roof Colour R 3.2No Slab Heating R1.0
No Slab Heating Nil
Other DownwardsWith Slab Heating R1.25
With Slab Heating R1.25
Shaft index Shylight % of floor areaMax SHG Value
Max total U Value
Skylight Requirements < 0.5 4 to 5% 0.34 3.4
Downwards
or Cavity masonry, 30 degree shaded and insulation (Total R 1.8)
Allows for less than 0.5% of ceiling area to be uninsulated
space enclosed and vent <1.5AC = R1.0,
otherwise R1.8
Or where space is top hats, Total R1.4 & Glazing option B
Other Wall OptionsOR Cavity masonry with insulation( total R2.3)
Insulation Requirements (Part J) Space above /below Encl & witth <1.5 AC/hr
Insulation to Slab on Ground
or Cavity masonry, 60 degree shaded and insulation (R1.3)
Total R2.8 R2.0
Suspended Slab if Open Under
External Walls
BCA COMPLIANCE REVIEW – NORTH KELLYVILLE PRIMARY SCHOOL.
REPORT – 17447- North Kellyville Primary School P:\17\17447\05_DOC\02_REPORTS\BCA\17447- BCA Review.docx PAGE 25 OF 27
Due to a number of factors, including the area of external glazing and the desire for cross
ventilation, the compliance of the building to Part J, will be assessed as a Alternative/ Performance
Solution is to be developed using a JV3 model assessment.
2.12 PART J3 - BUILDING SEALING
PART J3.3 ROOFLIGHTS
Any roof lights are to be sealed roof lights or if ventilated are to meet the requirements of Clause
J3.3.
PART J3.4 WINDOWS AND DOORS
Part J3.4 of the BCA requires seals to be fitted to doors and windows that are part of the conditioned
envelope.
Compliance is achieved by specifying new windows to comply with AS2047
PART 3.5 – EXHAUST FANS
Exhaust fans to conditioned spaces, where installed, are to be fitted with self closing dampers.
2.13 PART 3.6 - CONSTRUCTION OF ROOFS, WALLS AND FLOORS
Construction documented will comply if linings specified to internal surfaces with sealed junctions
by caulking, skirting, architraves, cornices or the like.
2.14 PART 3.7 – EVAPORATIVE COOLERS
Any evaporative coolers installed in the building are to be fitted with self closing dampers to reduce
heating loss when not used or during winter.
2.15 PART J5 – AIR CONDITIONING AND VENTILATION SYSTEMS
Compliance with Part J5 is not assessed in this review as the system is designed by the mechanical
engineer, who will provide a detailed assessment of the design of the systems
2.16 PART J6 – ARTIFICIAL LIGHTING AND POWER
Compliance with Part J6 is not assessed in this review as the system is designed by the specialist
engineer, who will provide a detailed assessment of the design of the systems
2.17 PART J7 – HEATED WATER SUPPLY AND SWIMMING POOL AND SPA PLANT.
Compliance with Part J7 is not assessed in this review as the system is designed by the specialist
engineer, who will provide a detailed assessment of the design of the systems
BCA COMPLIANCE REVIEW – NORTH KELLYVILLE PRIMARY SCHOOL.
REPORT – 17447- North Kellyville Primary School P:\17\17447\05_DOC\02_REPORTS\BCA\17447- BCA Review.docx PAGE 26 OF 27
3.0 CONCLUSION & RECOMENDATIONS
Based on the review of the proposed design, as outlined in the assessment above, it is considered
that the proposed design as indicated on the drawings generally will meet the relevant Deemed to
Satisfy Provisions of the Building Code of Australia 2016, with the exception of the following items
which are to be addressed as Performance Solutions within a fire Engineered Assessment report.
Within Design BCA DTS Clause Performance Requirement Comments
1 External
Columns on
the first floor
are not fire
rated
Specification C1.1
3. TYPE A FIRE-RESISTING CONSTRUCTION
3.1 Fire-resistance of building elements
In a building required to be of Type A construction—
(a) each building element listed in Table 3 and any
beam or column incorporated in it, must have an
FRL not less than that listed in the Table for the
particular Class of building concerned; and
Table 3 TYPE A CONSTRUCTION: FRL OF
BUILDING ELEMENTS
CP1
A building must have
elements which will, to the
degree necessary, maintain
structural stability during a
fire appropriate to—
(a) the ……..
Performance
Solution to be
developed
OTHER LOADBEARING INTERNAL WALLS,
INTERNAL BEAMS, TRUSSES
and COLUMNS— FRL 120/--/--
2 No fire rated
spandrels are
included in
the design to
the external
perimeter of
the first floor.
The design
does include
a short slab
projection
(800mm)
No Fire rated
spandrels are
included to
the internal
perimeter of
the central
void.
BCA Clause C2.6 Vertical separation of openings in
external walls
(a) If in a building of Type A construction, any part
of a window or other opening in an external wall is
above another opening in the storey next below and
its vertical projection falls no further than 450 mm
outside the lower opening (measured horizontally),
the openings must be separated by—
(i) a spandrel which—
(A) is not less than 900 mm in height; and
(B) extends not less than 600 mm above the upper
surface of the intervening floor; and
(C) is of non-combustible material having an FRL of
not less than 60/60/60; or
(ii) part of a curtain wall or panel wall that complies
with (i); or
(iii) construction that complies with (i) behind a
curtain wall or panel wall and has any gaps packed
with a non-combustible material that will withstand
thermal expansion and structural movement of the
walling without the loss of seal against fire and
smoke; or
(iv) a slab or other horizontal construction that—
(A) projects outwards from the external face of
the wall not less than 1100 mm; and
(B) extends along the wall not less than 450 mm
beyond the openings concerned; and
(C) is non-combustible and has an FRL of not less
than 60/60/60.
CP2
(a) A building must have
elements which will, to the
degree necessary, avoid the
spread of fire—
(i) to exits; and
(ii) to
(iii) between buildings; and
(iv) in a building.
(b) Avoidance of the spread
of fire referred to in (a) must
be appropriate to—
(i) the function or use of the
building; and
(ii) the fire load; and
(iii) the potential fire
intensity; and
(iv) the fire hazard; and
(v) the number of storeys in
the building; and
(vi) its proximity to other
property; and
(vii) any active fire safety
systems installed in the
building; and
(viii) the size of any fire
compartment; and
(ix) fire brigade intervention;
and
(x) other elements they
support; and
(xi) the evacuation time.
To be
addressed as
a
Performance
solution
based on
short
projection
which is less
than the
1100mm
length
required
3 Penetrations
in First Floor
Slab not
provided with
fire damper
C3.15 Openings for service installations
Where an electrical, electronic, plumbing,
mechanical ventilation, air-conditioning or other
service penetrates a building element (other than
an external wall or roof) that is required to have an
FRL with respect to integrity or insulation or a
resistance to the incipient spread of fire, that
installation must comply with any one of the
following:
CP8
Any building element
provided to resist the
spread of fire must be
protected, to the degree
necessary, so that an
adequate level of
performance is
maintained—
To be
Addressed as
a
Performance
Solution
BCA COMPLIANCE REVIEW – NORTH KELLYVILLE PRIMARY SCHOOL.
REPORT – 17447- North Kellyville Primary School P:\17\17447\05_DOC\02_REPORTS\BCA\17447- BCA Review.docx PAGE 27 OF 27
(a) Tested systems
(i) The service, building element and any protection
method at the penetration are identical with a
prototype assembly of the service, building element
and protection method which has been tested in
accordance with AS 4072.1 and AS 1530.4 and has
achieved the required FRL or resistance to the
incipient spread of fire.
(b) Ventilation and air-conditioning — In the case of
ventilating or air-conditioning ducts or equipment,
the installation is in accordance with AS/NZS
1668.1.
(a) where openings,
construction joints and the
like occur; and
(b) where penetrations
occur for building services.
4 Exit Travel
distance via
open stair to
open space
on southern
side is up to
90m.
D1.9 Travel by non-fire-isolated stairways or ramps
(a) A non-fire-isolated stairway or non-fire-isolated
ramp serving as a required exit must provide a
continuous means of travel by its own flights and
landings from every storey served to the level at
which egress to a road or open space is provided.
(b) In a Class 2, 3 or 4
(c) In a Class 5, 6, 7, 8 or 9 building, the distance
from any point on a floor to a point of egress to a
road or open space by way of a required non-fire-
isolated stairway or non-fire-isolated ramp must not
exceed 80 m.
(d) In
DP4
Exits must be provided from
a building to allow
occupants to evacuate
safely, with their number,
location and dimensions
being appropriate to—
(a) the travel distance; and
(b) the number, mobility
and other characteristics of
occupants; and
(c) the function or use of
the building; and
(d) the height of the
building; and
(e) whether the exit is from
above or below ground
level.
To be
Addressed as
a
Performance
Solution
5 Seating area
adjacent to
Stair 5 only
includes
space for 2
wheelchairs
D3.9 Wheelchair seating spaces in Class 9b
assembly buildings
Where fixed seating is provided in a Class 9b
assembly building, wheelchair seating spaces
complying with AS 1428.1 must be provided in
accordance with the following:
(a) The number and grouping of wheelchair seating
spaces must be in accordance with Table D3.9.
DP1
Access must be provided,
to the degree necessary, to
enable—
(a) people to—
(i) approach the building
from the road boundary and
from any accessible
carparking spaces
associated with the
building; and
(ii) approach the building
from any accessible
associated building; and
(iii) access work and public
spaces, accommodation
and facilities for personal
hygiene; and
(b) identification of
accessways at appropriate
locations which are easy to
find.
Performance
Solution to be
developed.
Seating Number of
Spaces
Grouping
Up to 150 3 spaces 1 group of 2 and
1 single
Trevor Eveleigh Studio Principal - Advisory
NBRSARCHITECTURE ( M.FSE, Grad. Dip Build. Surv. & Assess)