banyan tree
DESCRIPTION
Banyan Tree Holdings Limited is a Singapore-owned company with core businesses in hotel, resort and spa investment, management and operations. Driven by the founder’s vision, the group has just become a public-listed company 2 years ago, showing its commitment towards being a global company. In 2008, Banyan Tree group has numbers of investments and operations in several exotic cities in China, Maldives, Thailand, Indonesia and Bahrain. This report investigates Banyan Tree’s expansion stage in Asia-Pacific region, with focus on entering Indian market. The first section of the report provides details of the current situation of the company and the industry. The second section gives an in-depth analysis of the factors that favors Indian market as the next potential target country, as well as assessing the best mode of entry(s) into that market. The last section presents the strategies and implications of the chosen mode of entry(s).TRANSCRIPT
Banyan Tree: Entering Indian market
Table of Contents Page
“Bringing Paradise to Life”
Executive summary.....................................................................................................03
Introduction ..............................................................................................................04
Current Situation .......................................................................................................05
Opportunity Analysis – OLI model ..............................................................................06
Segmentation and positioning of Banyan Tree in Indian market ................................11
Strategic implications of the business strategies ........................................................13
Sustainability of the company in the global market ...................................................15
References .................................................................................................................16
1. Executive summary
Banyan Tree Holdings Limited is a Singapore-owned company with core businesses
in hotel, resort and spa investment, management and operations. Driven by the
2
“Bringing Paradise to Life”
founder’s vision, the group has just become a public-listed company 2 years ago,
showing its commitment towards being a global company. In 2008, Banyan Tree
group has numbers of investments and operations in several exotic cities in China,
Maldives, Thailand, Indonesia and Bahrain. This report investigates Banyan Tree’s
expansion stage in Asia-Pacific region, with focus on entering Indian market. The first
section of the report provides details of the current situation of the company and the
industry. The second section gives an in-depth analysis of the factors that favors
Indian market as the next potential target country, as well as assessing the best
mode of entry(s) into that market. The last section presents the strategies and
implications of the chosen mode of entry(s).
2. Introduction
Banyan Tree is a leading manager and developer of premium hotels, resorts and spa
in the Asia Pacific region. The company was established in 1993 by Ho Kwon Ping
3
“Bringing Paradise to Life”
(founder), and the business has been run under family umbrella. After 51 years
working as a developer of economist-cum-journalist backpacker in the Singapore, He
transformed his family business into a focused hotel and resort group. Due to its
rapid expansion needs and strategies, the company then became a public-listed
company in Singapore Stock Exchange in 2005.
Banyan Tree Group has six core businesses in tourism and hospitality markets: hotel
investment, hotel management, property sales, spa operations, gallery operations
and design services. The company focuses on the premium/high end market, with its
core competency in design and management know-how. The brand is also strongly
recognized by consumers/visitors with its characteristics of outstanding services and
beautiful and romantic sensations. At the end of 2006 financial year, Banyan Tree’s
family business operated 20 resorts, 53 spas and 62 galleries at around 20 countries
in Asia Pacific. As part of its global expansion strategy, Banyan Tree had launched
new projects, which include three core components of the Banyan Tree’s line of
business (i.e. resorts development, spas and retail galleries) in more than 10
countries.
3. Current Situation
Banyan Tree has a strong portfolio of near about 20 resorts, 53 spas and 62 galleries
around 20 countries in Asia Pacific. In hotels, resorts and spas industry, Banyan Tree
4
“Bringing Paradise to Life”
is seen as a well-known brand in the market. Resorts like Banyan Tree Maldives
Vabbinfaru and Banyan Tree Phuket are considered as some of the best resorts in
Asia Pacific as well as in the world.
Since the launch of the first Banyan Tree resort, Banyan Tree Phuket, in 1994,
Banyan Tree has received over 250 awards and accolades for the resorts, hotels
and spas that the Group manages. The Group has also received recognition for its
commitment to environmental protection and emphasis on corporate social
responsibility. Currently Banyan Tree is among the most rapidly growing resort and
spa chain which has already created a well known brand image globally.
Of these, two new resorts were launched in 2006: Banyan Tree Lijiang, China and
Angsana Velavaru, Maldives are the new services in the resorts market with a
unique pristine location and outstanding services. The company had a robust growth
in 2006; All six of our operating business segments performed well, showing marked
improvement over the previous year.
Banyan Tree group has experienced, qualified management team whose core
members have been instrumental in our development since inception. The team
possesses the appropriate mix of multi-disciplinary expertise and experience. The
company targets to enlarge our footprint to 81 locations in 29 countries by 2010.
4. Opportunity Analysis – OLI model
To understand opportunity in a new market, the OLI model is used as a basis of the
overall analysis. Inside each factor, specific models are applied to perform a more in-
5
“Bringing Paradise to Life”
depth analysis.
4.1. Ownership advantage
In a global environment, Banyan Tree must only focus on its core competency
that can be applied globally. The company’s competitive advantages are:
Strong brand recognition in Asia Pacific and global markets.
Experienced team who have mastered Banyan Tree’s unique, eco-friendly
design and management know-how.
Special location, this is really important role for success of hotels and spas
industry and by located at the pristine location like mountains, oceans, and
forests that already become the CA of Banyan Tree.
Clever marketing campaigns.
Innovative and efficient service management/operation.
These competitive advantages must be protected by the company. In global
market, where competition is very fierce and imitation of competitive advantages
is a major issue, a company like Banyan Tree who depend on the skill and
management know-how must be able to secure its competitive advantages. The
mode of entries and strategies to be used in entering a new market must be in line
with such protection.
4.2. Location-specific advantage
The selection of location is crucial, especially at the initial step in entering a new
market. The first city that Banyan Tree wants to choose could be used as a
foundation for its next tier of expansion strategy, and also to promote brand
presence in the market. It is wise to choose a country that already has a tourism
exposure locally and globally, since the demand (i.e. the ‘pull effect’) is already
there. Banyan Tree just needs to expose its brand, run and promote it (i.e.
creating the ‘push effect’). To filter the target countries around the world, we use
SES (Strategically Equivalent Segment) model by selecting some important
criteria. After a country has been chosen, then we can focus on the PESTEL
analysis of that particular country
4.2.1. SES (Strategically Equivalent Segment):
6
“Bringing Paradise to Life”
The target countries we choose for banyan tree are Vietnam, Australia,
India, New Zealand and Oceania (refer to fig. 1.0) as these countries have
comparative advantage like geographical condition (Under Asia Pacific
region, Untapped coastal lands/islands and exotic views, natural
attractiveness), rich in local culture, and economic advantages (Growing
economy especially in tourism and hospitality industry, tourism demand).
Out of these five, Banyan Tree may want to consider India as the first
country to enter. The reasons for choosing India (i.e. the criteria we use)
among all other countries are:
Political instability in several countries in Oceania, Srilanka and Vietnam
to certain extends. This increases the risk of doing business in these
countries.
Unlike New Zealand, countries like India, Vietnam and others still do not
have high-end spa facilities targeting at niche market. So its will be the
first mover advantage for Banyan Tree.
Tourist arrivals in India increased to 4.43 million in 2006, up 14.2 per cent
from 3.92 million in 2005. The foreign exchange earnings from tourism
grew to $6.569 billion in 2006, an increase of 14.6 per cent from 2005.
These numbers also include the non-resident Indians that make more
than one trip to India every year (Brand Channel.com, 2008). Others are
also growing, but not at the faster rate as opposed to Banyan Tree. It
means the there is a huge demand is India.
The cost of entering the country and setting up the business there would
be cheaper and worthy, therefore, increase the benefit factors.
7
INDIA OCEANIANEW ZEALAND
SRILANKAVIETNAM
KERALA
BANYAN TREE ”HOTEL AND RESORT”
GOA NANITALL
“Bringing Paradise to Life”
Fig 1.0 SES diagram
There are numbers of attractive tourist places in India such as: Goa, Kerela,
Nanitaal, Jaipur and Simla. Out of these cities, Kerela, Goa and Nanitaal could
be considered in this first stage of Banyan Tree’s expansion strategy in India
due to the availability of infrastructures and the level of cultural readiness to
accept foreigners in the particular cities. The very first city the company may
want to consider is Kerela as in comparison to other states, Kerala is the one
that has the most tourist arrivals by destinations in India (Ministry of Tourism
India, 2007). This city, as explained above, is the most demanded by
foreigners. So, Banyan Tree may use this place to further expand its resort
business in India (i.e. Beachhead strategy by Drucker, 1999). After
establishing a business there, the company can then target the second tier
cities like: Goa and Nanitaal.
4.2.2. Environmental analysis (PESTEL) of India
Political factors:
India remains relatively stable nowadays (i.e. little issues on internal
political unrest), and the local government is stimulating opportunities for
foreign investors by inducing various ways to reducing the barriers to
entry. Example of government’s commitment, especially towards tourism
infrastructure can be seen from the budget allocation to tourism sector
with 4 new institutes of hotel management were being set up (Asian
Development Bank, 2006). However, the level of government intervention
and self-protection is still quite high in India, and sometime organizations
8
“Bringing Paradise to Life”
face with some difficulties because of that. Another concern is India’s
trans-border issues with its neighbours (Pakistan, Nepal, Bangladesh, and
even China) due to borders issues (CIA, 2007), which may affect the
cities nearby the borders as well as the businesses.
Economic conditions:
Economic factors affect organizations' decision in terms of tax rate,
stability of economy, exchanged rate and so on. When we see the India's
economy in general, the country's GDP is in a good condition that it grew
to 9.4 % in 2006 and 8.5% in 2007 (CIA, 2007). India’s per capital also
grew to US$2,700 in 2007. It can be seen as India is more stable than
before and it is obvious that India's economy is doing well and it tends to
growth in the future. Moreover, according to official in July in 2007, the
number of tourists visiting in India was 2.82 million in 2006 and only in
January 2007 nearly 532,000 tourists arrived, which is a highest record so
far for India’s tourism industry (Presszoom, 2007). So, India’s tourism
industry is seen as one of the fastest growing in the world now. This gives
the great chances for Banyan Tree to expand their businesses to the India
market.
Socio-culture:
People’s life style, tradition, size of the population and education of a
country determine the level of market attractiveness. In India, all aspects
are supportive for the growth of tourism industry; except that Banyan Tree
must consider the level of poverty in India is still at the moderate, slightly
high (official figure is 25% of population). The income level is not well
distributed and because of that, the standard of living, clean air, etc may
not be as good as developed countries.
Technology:
Technology available in a country is one factor that organizations need to
look at before they go into a market. As Technology becomes essential in
production, distribution and all process of an organization, a country
cannot be an attractive market if it cannot provide necessary technology.
India is seen as one of the countries with the fastest growing technology
9
“Bringing Paradise to Life”
in the world. This condition favours the growth of hotel and resort
development by simplifying the management and operational activities.
4.3. Internalization advantage
Partnership (Joint Venture) with a local company
At the initial stage, Banyan Tree may want to consider forming a partnership with a
well-established resort construction in India. For the company, the advantages of
partnership strategy at this stage are:
- Leverage of local knowledge, experience and brand: Since India is a new
market for Banyan Tree, partnering with a local company will speed up its
understanding and adaptation process to the local differences (i.e. in term of
culture, needs, etc). The brand of the local company may also be one of the
factors that benefits Banyan Tree by attracting loyal consumers into the
business.
- Easy access to India market: although the India market is opening and
attractive to FDI, the government is still produce lots of protection against
foreign company. Tying up with a local company will make Banyan Tree’s way
easier in doing business in India.
- Reduce the cost of doing business in India: entering a new country, especially a
developing country, may incur high risk. Using a partnership, the risk is shared
by both parties.
- Decision making right: Banyan Tree will have a decision making right in the
business. The level of the right may vary depending on the ‘Partnership deed’,
but at least 51% of the right must be there because the company have to have
a power in the business.
Franchising
10
“Bringing Paradise to Life”
After entering the Indian market, Banyan Tree may expand its business using
franchising method. It will suit a foreign company by giving more decision making
power and become independent to the local company. Some of the advantages are:
- Increase in decision making power
- leveraging its management know-how, with care. Franchising agreements protect
against imitation of the company’s competitive advantages.
5. Segmentation and positioning of Banyan Tree in Indian market
Positioning:
Banyan tree positions itself in the niche market segment by promising its customers
with the best experiences in terms of spa and resort facilities. The Banyan tree
provides distinct experience to the visitors by developing and operating resorts
without disturbing the natural beauty of the place where it is located and giving high
concern for environmental conservation (i.e. combination of eco-friendliness with
contemporary design, as well as quality services). The villas of the Banyan tree are
priced high, when compared with other resorts and is considered as the premium
resorts.
Figure 2.0 the positioning map of Banyan Tree relative to the nearest competitors in India
11
Eco-friendly concept
Low
High
High
LowPrice
“Bringing Paradise to Life”
Using Porter’s generic strategies, Banyan tree uses the focus and differentiation
strategy to position itself in the global market. The company focuses on developing
state-of-the-art, eco-friendly spas and resorts. The company has strong brand
recognition which it takes as a strategy to differentiate from others who are
competing in price. There will be some package promotions, but reducing price for
the purpose of competing with others will not be Banyan Tree’s main strategy.
Market Segmentation:
Psychographic
On the basis of Psychographic, the company has to divide its target market based
on life style and interests. It has to give focus in attracting people who has interests
on tourism, leisure, spa treatments, etc. Banyan tree, while developing its resorts it
has given prime importance to environmental conservation so itself, they can attract
segments which are interested in environmental concerns. (eg: setting up a
restaurant which sells organic food can attract people who don’t prefer to take food
which are chemically treated).
Demographic
In India, Banyan tree hotels and resorts can segment the market on the basis of
demography. This can be on the basis of age, income level, life stage and
occupation. The company can target at people who are in mid age who are looking
for spa treatments and other resort facilities. Also they can target at old aged people
who are looking for relaxation and peace. On the basis of income level, they have to
look on to people who have high income as the company itself is considered as
premium in the market.
Product – Benefit Segmentation
It is based on the perceived value or advantages that the consumers get from the
product. Banyan tree hotels and resorts are unique for its spa and resort facilities,
also with its concern for preserving the environmental / natural beauty of the place
where it is located. It has to give more importance in developing all its unique
advantages so as to attract people who are keenly looking for such facilities.
6. Strategic implications of the business strategies
12
“Bringing Paradise to Life”
As in entry level, Banyan tree is now expanding its business in South India with
focus on Kerala, as it is one state which has got better tourism potential, good
climatic conditions, natural resources, etc. so itself the state is abundant with lots of
competitors with similar business, however the place still lacks a branded company
like Banyan Tree in the resort and spa sector.
Banyan tree has good background in doing the resort and spa businesses. The
main factor behind its success it greater value of customer satisfaction and its high
concern for environmental conservation. So while going into new markets like India,
the company has to focus on standardizing its success factors. The company has to
follow direct investment to start up with (that is it has to build its own resorts rather
than going for franchising or joint venture). For this, the company has to follow the
best option from the international business strategies which are plotted below.
Figure 3.0 four types of strategies to enter global market
The international business strategies are formulated on the basis of two factors –
pressure for local responsiveness and pressure for cost reduction. For Banyan tree
hotels and resorts it is strategized to the premium segment and so it has little
pressure for price. The company is unique in terms of value added customer
service, conservation for environment / environment friendly, spa facilities and
design. The pressure for local responsiveness is also low due to its eco-friendly
13
High
Pressure for cost reduction
Low
High
Pressure for local responsiveness
Global standardization strategy
Transnational
Localization
Low
Replication strategy
“Bringing Paradise to Life”
design ability and the company’s vision. Hence the best strategy to enter the Indian
market is replication strategy or international strategy.
Based on the replication/international strategy, Banyan Tree will need to focus on its
core competencies. Banyan tree develops its resorts by adapting itself into the
nature, which is the company give high concern for environments while building their
resorts and spa facilities. The resorts are built in such a way that the environment /
landscape in which it is located is not altered or modified and this has become one
of the major core competencies of Banyan tree. Other than that, Banyan tree
promises its customers in delivering value added services and world class spa
treatment facilities. The company has to give focus on improving / developing these
core competencies so that it remains unique in the Indian market which has got so
much of competitors. This can be done by exporting its core products like
technology for spa treatments, organic food products, room amenities, etc. from the
home country to India. Corporate training programs can be offered to staff so as to
standardize the level of services globally. Doing this, the government of India as well
as the society will also have little worry and even prefer Banyan Tree to do business
in their homeland.
However, the company still need to customize some of its aspect. In this, the major
aspects to consider are the products and the price. The company has to come up
with products which are localized, which will fulfil the tourist demand (i.e. Most of
them – if not all – want to have Indian-style products and services that are unique,
because they are having holiday in India), along with the products that are
standardized globally. For example, when Banyan tree starts its resort in Kerala, it
can come up with traditional Kerala ‘ayurvedic treatments’ as part of its spa
treatments. Even though the company is targeted at premium segment, they have to
consider the economic and inflation trends of the country and pricing should be
customized as required.
7. Sustainability of the company in the global market
14
“Bringing Paradise to Life”
Consistency of the internal organizational structure with the strategies
Banyan Tree’s expansion strategy must be balanced with the internal organization
structure. A centralized structure would be the best choice for the company, since
protecting/controlling core competencies is a critical factor to sustain in this industry.
The current condition of the company is actually favours the use a WWP (World
Wide Product) concept. Banyan Tree’s headquarter (HQ) is based in Singapore,
and the subsidiaries can be placed in each specific country. However, the main
problem is that the HQ will be far away from the consumers (i.e. tourists in each
subsidiary). However, the development in technological environment in India can be
a positive factor that contributes to the consistency of the company as a whole.
Consistency of the partnership and franchising strategies with the local environment
India is a new market and new environment for Banyan Tree, so the business
operations must fit with the local culture, the employees and the local community
surrounding the business. The company must create ‘a learning culture’ from the
entire organizations wherever the subsidiaries are. It must adopt both top-bottom
and bottom-up approaches altogether so as to allow the top managements
(franchisor to franchisee, Banyan Tree with the its local partner, employer with
employee and also Banyan Tree with the government and society) to learn local
culture. On the other hand, the local companies, the employees can learn from the
Banyan Tree’s top management’s expertise and knowledge. This will create a
balance situation in order to achieve sustainability.
8. References
15
“Bringing Paradise to Life”
Banyan Tree, retrieved: 19 January 2008, from: http://www.banyantree.com/
Bieson University, retrieved: 19 January 2008, from: http://bieson.ub.uni-
bielefeld.de/volltexte/2004/507/pdf/m_entry.pdf
Brand Channel corporation, retrieved: 19 January 2008, from:
http://www.brandchannel.com/careers_profile.asp?cr_id=52
Finaly, P (2000), Strategic Management, Pearson Education Limited.
Government of India, retrieved: 19 January 2008, from:
http://www.incredibleindia.org/india_tourism_05_06.pdf
Hill, C (2006), International Business: Competing in the Global Market 4th edt,
Pearson Education Limited
Susan, SH and David, F (1999), The Dynamics of International Strategy,
International Thomson Publishing
http://www.lhw.com/searchresults.aspx?
searchcriteria=banyan&ext=GLWbrnd&gclid=CKGuxvqp848CFRNJTAodvTmgIw
http://www.adb.org/Documents/Economic_Updates/IND/2006/eco-bulletin-ind02.pdf
https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/geos/in.html
http://presszoom.com/print_story_141333.html
16