awaxb yzp[uhahn/research/cerp/papcerp.pdf$- ./ ! 0 +( 1#324 57678&9:; + ! ) ? @3acb...

29

Upload: others

Post on 30-Mar-2021

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: AWAXB YZP[Uhahn/research/CERP/papCERP.pdf$- ./ ! 0 +( 1#324 57678&9:; + ! ) ? @3ACB DCEGFHJILKMFB1N OQPR@3A STH/BVU AWAXB YZP[U \^]/H_EGET`ba[cRd>` efef` ghH NiP[j3AXF

����������� ����������� ��� ��������� � �!�"��#%$&��� '(�)� *+���

, �)$-�.�/���!�0�+�(�1#324��57678&9:�;� ���+��!��� �)�<9=�>�?�

@3ACB�DCEGF�HJILKMF�B1N�OQPR@3A�STH/BVU AWAXB�YZP[U \^]/H_EGET`ba[cRd>`�efef`�ghH�NiP[j3AXF�`lk�H/mnNoPap`.ml\qEra[c�stF�\^B Y `.B�u:vw`.]/x�FVkyc[z3AWu�\�]J]|{

N�}�~T�?�-���o�r~T�f�����������.����~G�3���h�i�~T�w�-�o���T�7�������q�i�-�o�����o���T��q�i���q�����������M�y���� f~Z���������

�q�i���q�¡���o�^���X¢�£�¤ ¥&¥§¦©¨-ª©«;¬&­&®�®O ~T�w�����°¯[�.�����C± ���²�Z³´��µ��f���¶�³·~G��µ

�.�����~&¯y¸�­&¬�¥§¹�­&¬fº§«;»&¬q¦�º�¢^�/�h¼p¯y¸�­&¬.¥§¹�­&¬qº§«½»©ªq¨&®Y } �� ����������¾���)�0���&�<~Z�����w�©���3¿������À� ����~G�����r~T�q�

£��-�o���&�.�©��Á�~G�f��~T�7�J����Â��G¼����T������Ãf���G�©�X¿�~T��~G�©���Q�W¢.Ä[}��Å ~ZÆX~T�����&�W¢.� ¿ ¦&º-®q¦©¨

{ }�~T�?�-���o�r~T�f�����R���������i�-�o�����o���T��y���� f~Z���������²�����y���-�©���o�©�Ç�J������~G�����G���>���Z��~T���Z~T�ªf¬&®.¥yÈl~G�É� �3�©�����.�©� �q�o��~Z~Z�G¢C�����-��¦©».¥

Ê �Ë���o��~Ì¿����i�X¢�� ¿ ¦&º�º©®qÍ

Page 2: AWAXB YZP[Uhahn/research/CERP/papCERP.pdf$- ./ ! 0 +( 1#324 57678&9:; + ! ) ? @3ACB DCEGFHJILKMFB1N OQPR@3A STH/BVU AWAXB YZP[U \^]/H_EGET`ba[cRd>` efef` ghH NiP[j3AXF

Î)Ï©Ð!ѽÒ;ÓZÔ�ÑÕ¾Ö_×�ØZÙÛÚ|ÜpÝ�Þ·ß�ÚJÚ_àâáTÝ�ßÉÜ_àã×�ä�åZÖ_×iÝ°æ!çZÙ%Ö_æ�à·Ú"ç%æ�è�æ!Þã×�å§æ!ç�ØZß�Ú_æ!ç�×�ä�æ!äÛÚ|æ!é�ØZÞãæ!Ú"×�êÝ�Þ·ß�Úìë

Ú_àâáZæ�Ö/Ú�í�îCàãÜ_ïðæ!ß�ÝJïtÝ�Þ·ß�ÚJÚ_àâáZæ�ÖRÝ°×�äZÚ|Ü|ÖJÙÛÝ°Ü|æ!çñê´Ö_×�é4ßyçÛàãòGæ�Ö_æ!äoÜRÚ|æ�Ü1×�êpåÛÖ_æ!çÛàóÝ°Ü|×�ÖJÚ[ç%æ°ëÜ|æ�ÖJé[à·äÛæ!ç�Øiô7ß)ÖJß�äÛçÛ×�éõåTßÉÖ_Ü_àãÜ_àã×�äÇ×�ê^Ü_ïÛæ>æ!äoÜ_àãÖ_æ�Ú|æ�Ü"×�ê�åÛÖ_æ!çÛà·Ý°Ü|×�Ö/Ú�öW÷.ï%æ>åÛÖ_×�å§×�Ú|æ!çé�æ�Ü_ï%×QçÛÚ>Ý°×�é�ØZàóä%æ1Ü_ïÛæ1Ö_æ!ÚJÙÛÞãÜ_ÚW×�êCé�ÙÛÞ·Ü_àãåZÞãæRÝ�Þóß�Ú_Ú_àâáZæ�Ö/ÚWÜ|×�ß�ÝJïÛà·æ�è�æ�ßÇÚ_Ù%ØTÚ|Ü_ß�ä�Ü_àóß�Þ·Þãôà·é�åÛÖJ×½è�æ!ç�åÛÖ_æ!çZà·Ý°Ü_àã×�ä�Ý°×�é�åZßÉÖ_æ!ç+Ü|×0Ü_ï%æ�×�åÛÜ_à·é[ß�ÞfÚJà·ä%ø�Þãæ�Ý�Þ·ß�Ú_Ú_àãáZæ�Ö!ö�÷.ïÛà·Ú"ßÉåÛåÛÖJ×�ß�ÝJïà·ÚWç%æ!ÚJàãø�ä%æ!ç+Ú|å§æ!Ý�àâáGÝ�ß�Þ·Þãô�êù×�Ö�ïZàãø�ïQë�çÛà·é[æ!äÛÚ_àã×�äÛß�Þ�çÛßÉÜ_ß7Ú|æ�Ü_Ú�êù×�Ö�îCïÛà·ÝJïyß�Ý�Þ·ß�Ú_Ú_àãáZæ�Ö�à·ÚÚ|×�Ù%ø�ïoÜ�öqú�ô�Ý°×�é�ØZà·äZà·ä%øpÝ�Þ·ß�Ú_Ú_àãáZæ�ÖJÚ&ØZÙÛàóÞãÜ©êùÖ_×�éwæ!ß�Ý/ï1ÚJÙ%ØZÚ|åZß�Ý°æ�×�ê§Ü_ï%æ?åÛÖ_æ!çÛà·Ý°Ü|×�Ö/Ú�í�Ü_ï%æåÛÖ_×�å§×�Ú|æ!ç7é�æ�Ü_ï%×QçÛÚCß�Ý/ïÛàãæ�è�æ�ß)Ý°×�é�åZÙ%Ü_ßÉÜ_àã×�äZß�Þ©ß�ç%èÉß�äoÜ_ßÉø�æ[à·ä�Ü_ß�ÝJûiÞ·àóä%øRÜ_ï%æ>ø�Ö_×;î?à·ä%øåÛÖ_×�ØZÞ·æ!éü×�êWçÛà·é�æ!äZÚ_àã×�äÛß�Þ·à·Ü�ô�öþýÛ×�Ö)æ!ß�Ý/ïtÚ_Ù%ØZÚ|åTß�Ý°æ�×�êpÜ_ï%æ�åZÖ_æ!çÛà·Ý°Ü|×�ÖJÚ!í�î�æ�ØTÙÛà·Þ·çðßÝ�Þ·ß�Ú_Ú_àãáTÝ�ßÉÜ_àã×�ä7Ü|Ö_æ�æ�×�ÖpÞã×�ø�à·Ú|Ü_à·Ý�Ö_æ�ø�Ö_æ!ÚJÚ_àã×�äÇÜ|Ö_æ�æ�ö>ÿ"ÙÛÖXÚ|Ü_ÙZç%ô�Ú_ï%×;î?Ú�í ÙÛÚ_àóä%ø1êù×�Ù%ÖXÖ_æ!ß�ÞçÛßÉÜ_ß�Ú_æ�Ü_ÚqêùÖ_×�éMçÛàãòGæ�Ö_æ!äoÜqßÉÖ_æ!ß�Ú�íiÜ_ïÛßÉÜ�×�Ù%Ö^é�æ�Ü_ï%×QçÛÚ^åGæ�ÖJê´×�ÖJéwÝ°×�äZÚ_à·Ú|Ü|æ!äoÜ_Þãô�î�æ!ÞóÞÛÝ°×�é�ëåZßÉÖ_æ!ç�Ü|×CîCà·ç%æ!Þãô"ÙÛÚ|æ!ç�Ý�Þ·ß�Ú_Ú_àâáGÝ�ßÉÜ_àã×�ä�é[æ�Ü_ï%×içZÚ�ö©ý%×�ÖfÙÛäoØZß�Þ·ß�äZÝ°æ!ç�çÛßÉÜ_ßQí�×�Ù%Ö&ßÉåÛåÛÖJ×�ß�ÝJïé[ß�à·äoÜ_ß�à·äÛÚ&Ü_ï%æ?ØZß�Þ·ß�äÛÝ°æ.اæ�Ü�î�æ�æ!ä1Ú|æ!äÛÚ_àãÜ_à·èiàãÜ�ô>ß�äZç[Ú|å§æ!Ý�àâáTÝ�àãÜ�ô�é�×�ÖJæ?ß�ç%æ � ÙÛßÉÜ|æ!Þãô�Ü_ïÛß�äé[ß�äoô1×�Ü_ï%æ�ÖXÝ�Þ·ß�Ú_Ú_àãáTÝ�ßÉÜ_àã×�ä0é�æ�Ü_ï%×QçÛÚ.Ý°×�äZÚ_à·ç%æ�Ö_æ!ç0àóä�Ü_ïÛà·Ú�Ú|Ü_ÙÛçÛô�ö���������� ������ Þ·ß�Ú_Ú)åÛÖ_æ!çÛàóÝ°Ü_àã×�ä�� � Þ·ß�Ú_ÚJàâáTÝ�ßÉÜ_àã×�äþÜ|Ö_æ�æ�� � Ö_×�Ú_Ú)è�ß�Þóà·çÛßÉÜ_àã×�ä����-×�ø�à·Ú|Ü_à·ÝÖ_æ�ø�Ö_æ!Ú_ÚJàã×�ä����Çß��ì×�ÖJà·Ü�ô�è�×�Ü_à·ä%ø�� �Cà·Ú|û1åÛÖ_×ÉáTÞ·àóä%ø

! "$#&%('*),+.-./0%(1�)#

2436587:9.;=<�>?>A@4BDCDED<�F�7G3�HIH EKJDLD<�CDHNM<�CDHOCP3�L�9Q39.JDFG<�ED5?R�3�5?HNCKMHIED<�>TSDBU58>?3WVXF�HNMY3�LDHOBD7�9OCUED7HOVZ9�[O9Q58>\9QSD>8<]JUF�<�EU58R�3�HNF:[Q9OF�589OSD>?<�7_^a`_bc9OCUEd9�F�<�>\9Q3�5?[N<�>?ef7�Mg9O>8>=7�9OMJD>8<&7G58h�<f^aijbcR�9OCkSl<m BD5?3�<cBDCD7n3o9OSD>?<p^rqp5?>8>8<�F�s$tQuNu�tNbwvcqpH ED<�>?7�3�L�9Q3x9QF�<cED<y[N<�>?HNJl<�EfBU7�58CUzp9QC{5?C�3�<�CU7�<67�<�>8<�Ry3�5?HNCJDFGHIR�<�7�7|9QF�<:LD5?zNLD>Ae,JDF�HNCU<}3�H&RoL�9QCDzN<};05A3�L�9~CD<y;�3�F�9O5?CD58CUzg7�9OMgJU>8<Ov���BUFG3�LU<�F�MHNFG<Os�3�LD<�FG<58709cM:BU>?3�5?JD>85?R�5A3�ecHOV�zNHIH E&MHIED<�>87T;0LU<�Cji���`.s�9O7�HNSD7G<�Fn[N<�E�S�e]<y�U9OM58C�9Q3�58HNC~HOV�MH ED<�>� 3�vK2�Ck3�LD<,zN<�CD<,<w�UJUF�<�7G7�5?HNCd>?5?3�<�F�9Q3�BDF�<Qs�M:BDRoLkL�9O7cSl<�<�Ck;0F�5A3�3�<�CPHNCK3�LD<,58CU7G3o9QSD58>?5?3�e{HOVzN<�CD<p<w�IJDF�<�7�7�5?HNC��G7G58zNCD9Q3�BDFG<�7G�Dvd��BDM<�F�HOBD7g7n3�BDEU58<�7L�9�[N<p58>?>8BD7n3�F�9�3�<�E�3�LD<,[O9QF�5\9QSD58>?5?3�e{HOV3�LU<ZR�HOMgJlHNCD<�C�3�7�HOV�3�LD<Z7G58zNC�9�3�BDFG<�9OCDE~L�9�[N<�R�9OBU3�5?HNCD<�E~3�L�9�3T3�LU< � C�9Q>�MHIEU<�>87=9OFG<Z7�5?MgJU>?eF�<�JDF�<�7�<�C�3�9Q3�5A[N<:HQV*M~9QC�e,HQ3�LD<�FZJlHO3�<�C�3�5\9O>�JUF�H � >?<�7}^r�IJD9OF�9OCUH~<�3�9O>rvAs�tOuNu�� ��q_58RoLD5?<�>870<y3�9O>�v?stOuNuN�Nbyv(qpHNF�<�H�[N<�F�sI3�LD<�MH ED<�>D7G<�>?<�R�3�<�E]Mg9�eczN<�CD<�F�9O>85?h�<0J�H HNFG>?e}3�H}9|CD<y;�E�9Q3�9x7G<�3�v�� 58MJD>8<

Page 3: AWAXB YZP[Uhahn/research/CERP/papCERP.pdf$- ./ ! 0 +( 1#324 57678&9:; + ! ) ? @3ACB DCEGFHJILKMFB1N OQPR@3A STH/BVU AWAXB YZP[U \^]/H_EGET`ba[cRd>` efef` ghH NiP[j3AXF

MHIED<�>N9�[N<�F�9OzO58CDzW^��=BDF�CDLD9OM�9OCUEx �CDED<�F�7�HOC¡s�tOuOu�tNb�L�9Q7�S�<�<�CxBU3�5?>858h�<�EZ3�H�9OEDEDFG<�7�7�3�LD587¡5?7�7GBD<S�e6BD7�5?CDzx9|;=<�5?zNL�3�<�E~9�[N<�F�9OzO<�HOV�M~9QC�e}R�HNMJl<�3�5?CDz|MgH ED<�>87�sN;0LU<�F�<03�LU<0;=<�5?zNL�3�587*S�9O7G<�EgHNC9OC.5?CUVXHNF�Mg9Q3�58HNC_3�LD<�HNF�<y3�58R}7G3o9�3�587n3�5?R}7�BURoLf9O7� �2n¢£^X Z¤�9O5?¤O<Os ��¥�¦Q§ bwvx¨�LU587|9O>?>8H�;07�3�LD< � C�9O>JDFG<�ED5?R�3�5?HNC~3�H:S�<�9WVXBDCDRy3�58HOC]HOV$Mg9OC�e~ED5A©�<�F�<�C�3�MgH ED<�>?7�sI9}F�<�7�BD>A3T3�L�9Q3�5?7T58CULD<�FG<�C�3�>Ae~MHNF�<7G3�9OSD>?<�3�L�9OCp9c7�5?CDzN>8<�MH ED<�>�v

ª*CD7�<�M:SD>8<|M<�3�LDHIEUHN>8HNzQeg5?709cC�9Q3�BUF�9O>¡CU<y� 3�7G3�<�J_3�Hc7�5?MgJD>?<�MHIED<�>¡9�[N<�F�9OzO58CDzcVXHNF�R�>\9O7G7JDFG<�ED5?R�3�5?HNC¡v� �CP<�CD7G<�M:SD>?<,BD7�<�73�LD<,JDF�<�ED58Ry3�58HOCD7cHOV�M:BD>A3�58JU>8<~SD9O7�<,R�>89O7�7G5 � <�F�7�s�3�e JD5?R�9O>?>?e3�LUF�HNBDzOLpMg9¬«GHNFG5?3�e~[OHO3�<xHNF�9�[N<�F�9OzN<�E�JDFG<�ED5?R�3�58HNC¡sI3�HJDF�H EDBDR�<}9 � C�9Q>­<�CD7�<�M:SD>?<y@�SD9O7�<�E�ED<w@R�5?7�5?HNC®^��TFG<�58Mg9OC¡s ��¥N¥N¯ s ��¥N¥N° s�tOuNu � �D��FG<�BDCUEj9OCDE��IRoL�9QJD58FG<Os ��¥N¥O¯ byv�¨�LD<x<�CD7G<�M:SU>8<y@4S�9O7G<�EJDFG<�ED5?R�3�5?HNCf3�e JD5?R�9O>?>?e{L�9O7:>?H�;T<�F:zN<�CU<�F�9Q>858h�9Q3�5?HNC{<�F�FGHNF:F�9Q3�<�7:3�L�9OCfBD7�5?CDz�9j7�5?CDzN>8<MHIED<�>r�3�LU<ZED5A©�<�F�<�CUR�<�ED<�J�<�CDED5?CDz:HNC~3�LD<�3�e Jl<�HOV�SD9O7�<�R�>\9O7G7�5 � <�F=BD7�<�E¡sU<�CD7�<�M:SD>8<Z7�58h�<�9OCUE~3�LD<�ED5A@[N<�F�7G5?3�e,HNF�R�HNF�FG<�>\9�3�58HOC]S�<y3�;T<�<�CjSD9O7�<|R�>89O7�7G5 � <�F�7�v�±®<|ED<�MHNCD7n3�F�9Q3�<�5?C�� <�R�3�58HNCpt}3�LD9Q30>8H�;HNF�CD<�z�9Q3�5?[N<�>?e&R�HNF�FG<�>89Q3�<�E_R�>\9O7G7�5 � <�FG7�5?MgJUF�H�[N<|9OR�R�BDF�9OR�e,H�[O<�F0J�HO7�5?3�5?[O<�>?e~R�HNFGF�<�>\9Q3�<�E,HNCD<�7�v

 ZR�R�HNFGED58CDz�3�H�²�BD5?C:9OCDEc¨�9��&^rtOuOuNu�bysQ<�CD7G<�M:SU>8<�M<�3�LDHIEU7�VXHNF�R�HNM:SD5?CD58CUz�R�>\9O7G7�5 � <�F�7�Va9O>8>58C�3�Hg3�LUF�<�<WR�9Q3�<�zNHOF�58<�7�³ � b0<�CD7�<�M:SD>?<�7�3�L�9Q3�R�HNM}SD58CD<xR�>89O7�7G5 � <�F�7�HOV(3�LU<W7�9OMg<|3�e J�<W3�F�9Q58CD<�EHNC_ED5?©�<�FG<�C�303�e J�<�7�HOV�VX<�9Q3�BDF�<�7W^aJ�9OF�9O>8>?<�>�R�HNM:SU58CD5?CDz�bys�tNbT<�CD7G<�M:SU>8<�703�LD9Q3�R�HNM:SU58CD<�R�>\9O7G7�5A@� <�F�7�HOV�ED5A©�<�F�<�C�3�3�e Jl<�7�3�F�9O58CD<�E.HNC.3�LD<c7�9OM<:7�<y3|HOV�VX<�9Q3�BDF�<�7~^X7G3�9ORo¤O<�E®R�HNM:SD5?CD58CDz�bys¡9QCDE´ b�<�CD7G<�M:SU>8<�7W3�L�9Q3}R�HNM}SD58CD<R�>89O7�7G5 � <�F�7WHOV�3�LU<~7�9QMg<3�eIJl<g3�F�9O5?CD<�EfHNC®3�LD<~7�9OMg<g7�<y3,^aHOF7�BUSD7�<y3�7ZHQV�3�LD<W7�9OM<x7G<�3ob�HQV�VX<�9�3�BDFG<�7W^X;=<�9O¤&R�HNM:SD5?CD58CUz�byv*¨�LD5?70J�9OJl<�F05870R�HOCDR�<�F�CD<�Ep;05?3�L<�CU7�<�M}SD>8<�7�58CgR�9Q3�<�zNHNFne ´ v*µ0<�R�<�C�3�>?e63�LDF�<�<�<�CD7G<�M:SU>8<�[OHO3�5?CDz:9QJDJDF�HN9ORoLD<�7T58Cg3�LD587=R�9Q3�<�zNHOFGeNsSlHIHN7n3�5?CDz6^r� RoL�9OJD5?F�<Os ��¥N¥ uU����F�<�BDCDE69OCUE~� RoL�9OJD5?F�<Os ��¥N¥N¯ s ��¥N¥�¦ bwsNS�9OzNzO58CDz6^a�TF�<�58Mg9OC¡s ��¥N¥N¯ b9OCDE¶F�9OCUEDHNM 7�BDSU7�J�9OR�<�7�^aµZ�l³=·�HDs ��¥O¥N° bcL�9�[N<�FG<�R�<�5?[O<�E¸9Q3G3�<�C�3�58HNC�v¸�THIHO7G3�5?CDz{RoL�9OCDzN<�79OE�9QJU3�5A[N<�>Ae:3�LU<�ED5?7G3�F�58SUBU3�5?HNCcHOV�3�LD<�3�F�9O58CD5?CDz�7�<y3TSD9O7�<�E]HNC63�LD<0Jl<�FGVXHOF�Mg9OCDR�<0HOV�JDF�<y[ 58HNBD7G>?eR�FG<�9Q3�<�E_R�>89O7�7G5 � <�F�7�v���HNF�R�HNM:SD5?CD58CDzW3�LD<|R�>89O7�7G5 � <�F�7�s�5?3�3o9Q¤O<�7�9c;T<�58zNL�3�<�E_M~9¬«GHOF�5?3�e[NHQ3�<|HOV3�LU<�58FxJDFG<�ED5?R�3�5?HNCD7�v]¨�LD<~SD9OzNzN5?CDz�9Q>8zNHNFG5?3�LDM¹BD7G<�7WS�H HO3�7n3�F�9OJf7�9OMgJU>8<�7�3�H�SDBD5?>8E�3�LD<S�9O7G<R�>89O7�7G5 � <�F�7�v�¨�LD< � C�9O>­R�>89O7�7G5 � R�9Q3�5?HNC_JDF�H EDBDR�<�EjS�e_3�LD<W<�CD7G<�M:SD>?<}HOV�3�LD<�7�<}SD9O7�<:R�>\9O7G7�5 � <�FG7587�HOSU3o9O5?CD<�E,BD7G58CDz6< m BD9O>�;T<�58zNL�30[NHO3�58CDzUv�µZ�]R�HOM:SD58CU<�7�M:BD>A3�5?JD>8<�R�>\9O7G7�5 � R�9Q3�58HNC]3�F�<�<�70R�HNC @7G3�F�BDRy3�<�EK58C�F�9OCDEDHNM>?ej7�<�>?<�Ry3�<�EP7GBDSD7�JD9OR�<�7�v.¨�LD< � C�9O>�R�>\9Q7�7�5 � R�9�3�58HOCf587WHNSU3�9O58CD<�EfS�ef9OC

t

Page 4: AWAXB YZP[Uhahn/research/CERP/papCERP.pdf$- ./ ! 0 +( 1#324 57678&9:; + ! ) ? @3ACB DCEGFHJILKMFB1N OQPR@3A STH/BVU AWAXB YZP[U \^]/H_EGET`ba[cRd>` efef` ghH NiP[j3AXF

< m B�9Q>I;=<�58zOL�3�[NHO3�58CDz�HQV�3�LD<�SD9O7�<T3�F�<�<�7�v��=F�<�5?M~9QC&^rtQuNu � b�ED<�[O<�>?HNJ�<�Eµ�9OCUEDHNMº��HNF�<�7G3�^aµ��*bS�e�R�HNM}SD58CD5?CDz&R�>89O7�7G5 � R�9Q3�5?HNCj3�FG<�<�7x7GBDRoLf3�L�9Q3|<�9QRoL®3�FG<�<6587�zO<�CD<�F�9Q3�<�EfS�e.SD9OzNzN5?CDz,9OCDE®9F�9QCDEDHNM»7GBDSD7GJ�9OR�<xHOV­3�LD<|JDFG<�ED5?R�3�HNF�70587�BU7�<�E�9Q30<�9QRoL�CDH ED<Ov

±f<T58C�3�FGHIEDBUR�<�9QC:<�CD7G<�M:SU>8<y@4S�9O7G<�E69OJDJUF�H�9ORoLWVXHNF�R�>\9O7G7�5 � R�9Q3�58HNCxR�9O>?>8<�Ec¢�ª�µ�¼¶^r¢T>89O7�7G5 � @R�9�3�58HOCcS�e:ª*CD7�<�M:SD>8<�7*VXF�HNM�µ�9QCDEDHNM½¼�9OFn3�5?3�58HNCU7obyv­¨�LD5?7�9OJDJDFGH�9ORoL6587*ED<�7�5?zNCD<�E67GJ�<�R�5 � R�9O>?>?eVXHNF0LD5?zNLI@�EU58M<�CD7G58HNC�9Q>¡E�9Q3�97G<�3�7�VXHNF�;0LD58RoL.96R�>89O7�7G5 � <�F�5?7�7GHNBDzNL�3�v�¾�9OF�589OSD>8<�JUF�<y@47�<�>8<�Ry3�5?HNC587cCUHO36F�< m BU58F�<�E¡v�±®<p9QF�<,9OSD>?<]3�H.S�e J�9O7G7g3�LU<&R�HNCD7n3�F�9O58C�36HOV�>\9OFGzN<]` 9OCDEP7�Mg9O>8>Ti S�eF�9QCDEDHNM>?eWJ�9OFn3�5?3�58HNCU58CDzZ3�LD<0`¿[Q9OFG5\9OSU>8<�7�58C�3�H|À,M:BU3�B�9O>8>Ae}<w�IR�>8BU7�5?[O<07�BDSD7GJ�9OR�<�7�v� �Sl<�CD< � 358C~J�9OFG3�5?3�58HNCD5?CDzW3�LD<�5?CDJDBU3�7GJ�9OR�<�587T3�L�9Q3�<�9ORoL,7�BDSD7GJ�9OR�<WMg9�e~Sl<Z3�FG<�9Q3�<�E,7�<�J�9OF�9Q3�<�>?egBDC�3�58>9OzNzOF�<�zN9Q3�5?HNC¡s¡9]R�HNMJDBU3o9�3�58HOC�9O>�9OEU[Q9OC�3o9OzO<}3�L�9�3�;058>?>�Sl<:58MJ�HOFG3o9QC�3�9O7Z3�LD<cED58M<�CU7�58HOCjHOVE�9Q3�9�7�<y3�7�zNF�H�;07*Sl<�eOHNCDE63�L�9Q3�;0LD58RoL6Mg9�eWSl<�<�9O7G58>?exL�9QCDED>8<�E658C69Z;0LDHN>?<Ov� ZC6HNJU3�58Mg9O>�3�F�<�<^��=F�<�5?M~9QC&<�3�9O>rvAs ��¥N°O§ b=5?7�SDBD5?>?3�;05A3�LD5?C&<�9ORoLp7�BDSD7GJ�9OR�<WBD7G58CDz6HNCU>?e~3�LD<|`_ÁQÀl@4ED58M<�CU7�58HOC�9O>7�JD9OR�<xHOV­3�LD<�[Q9OF�589OSD>?<�7�5?C,3�LD<|J�9OFn3�5?3�58HNC�v*¢�ª�µ�¼ÂBU7�<�703�;=HgMg9O58C&M<�3�LDH ED7�VXHNF�zN<�CU<�F�9�3�58CUzS�9O7G<|R�>\9Q7�7�5 � <�FG7�³�¢�@4¨�¢�ª�µ�¼dR�FG<�9Q3�<�70HNJU3�58Mg9O>�R�>\9O7G7�5 � R�9Q3�58HNCg3�F�<�<�7�9OCDE_Ã$µ�@�¨Ä¢�ª�µ�¼dR�F�<w@9Q3�<�7T>?HNzN5?7G3�5?R�F�<�zNF�<�7�7�5?HNC~3�F�<�<�7�^X7�<�<Z ZLDC&9QCDE,¢TLD<�C¡s ��¥O¥�¦ byv(�THO3�LgMg<y3�LDH ED7=9OF�<�58>?>8BD7n3�F�9�3�<�E58C_3�LD5?7�9OFn3�5?R�>8<Qv�¢�ª�µ�¼ÄR�HNM:SD5?CD<�7�3�LD<:FG<�7GBD>?3�7ZHOV*3�LD<�7G<cM:BD>?3�58JD>?<�3�FG<�<�7�3�H&9ORoLD5?<�[O<c9OCj5?M6@JDFGH¬[O<�E.9QR�R�BUF�9ORyepHQV(R�>89O7�7�JDFG<�ED5?R�3�5?HNC,S�e�96Mg9¬«GHNF�5A3�e~[OHO3�5?CDzgHOF�S�e&3o9Q¤ 5?CDz63�LD<W9�[N<�F�9OzN<xHOV3�LU<JUF�<�EU58R�3�<�E�[Q9O>8BD<�7�;05?3�LU58C�9OC{<�CD7G<�M:SU>8<Ov62�C®Ã$µ�@4¨Å¢�ª�µ�¼�s$>8HNzO587G3�58RWF�<�zOF�<�7G7�5?HNC®MH ED<�>R�9QC~Sl<�BU7�<�Eg;05?3�LUHNBU3�>8HN7G58CDz�3�LD<�<�CD7�<�M:SD>?<Z9OR�R�BDF�9OR�ecVXHOF�ED9Q3o9�;05?3�L~i�� `£S�e~9|F�9QCDEDHNMJ�9OFn3�5A3�58HOC~;05?3�LDHNBU3�9:[Q9OF�589OSD>8<Z7�<�>?<�Ry3�58HOC¡v

qpBD>A3�58JU>8<c<�CU7�<�M}SD>8<�7:9OFG<zO<�CD<�F�9Q3�<�E�S�e�F�9QCDEDHNM>?e.FG<y@4J�9OFG3�5?3�58HNCD5?CDz~3�LD<VX<�9Q3�BUF�<7�J�9OR�<9OCDEgSDBD5?>8ED5?CDz�3�FG<�<�7�v(±¸LD58>?<�¢�ª�µ�¼KR�9OJI3�BDFG<�7TMHN7n3=HQV�3�LU<�VX<�9Q3�BDFG<�7�R�HNC�3�9O58CD<�E~5?C3�LD<�ED9Q3o9UsHNCD>Ae&9cVX<�;ÆF�9OCDEUHNMg>Ae]7G<�>8<�R�3�<�E,[O9QF�5\9QSD>8<�709OF�<|BD7G<�E�S�e&<�9ORoLp3�F�<�<xR�>\9O7G7�5 � <�F058Cp¢�@4¨Ç¢�ª�µ�¼HNFÃ$µ�@4¨»¢�ª�µ�¼�v*±¸LD<�C¶;=<_LD9�[O<�M:BU>?3�5?JD>8<g<�CD7G<�M:SU>8<�7�sTVXF�<�7�LkCD<�;»58CUVXHNFGM~9�3�58HOC�R�9OCkSl<HNSU3�9O58CU<�EfS�e®9pEU5?©�<�F�<�C�3}J�9QFG3�5A3�5?HNC�HOV�3�LU<[Q9OFG5\9OSD>?<�7|58C®<�9ORoL�9OEDED5A3�58HOC�9O>(<�CD7�<�M:SD>8<Qv,¨�LD<M:BD>A3�5?JD>8<�<�CD7�<�M:SD>8<�7�R�HOC�3�F�5?SDBU3�<03�H:9xVXBDFn3�LD<�FTz�9O5?CgHQV¡3�LD<�H�[N<�F�9O>8>�9OR�R�BDF�9OR�eOv* ÆMg9¬«GHNF�z�9O5?CHOV�¢�ª�µ�¼KH�[N<�FT9W7G58CDzN>?<0HNJU3�5?M~9Q>I3�FG<�<�587�9ORoLD5?<�[N<�E]S�e63�LD<�F�9OCDEUHNMÈJ�9OFn3�5?3�58HNCU58CDz�5?C~9x7�5?CDzN>8<<�CU7�<�M}SD>8<Qv~¨�LD<gM:BD>?3�58JD>?<:<�CU7�<�M}SD>8<g9O>8>?H�;07�H¬[O<�FG>\9OJ{HOVTVX<�9Q3�BUF�<7�J�9OR�<�7�s*9OCDE�3�LD<z�9O5?C�S�e

´

Page 5: AWAXB YZP[Uhahn/research/CERP/papCERP.pdf$- ./ ! 0 +( 1#324 57678&9:; + ! ) ? @3ACB DCEGFHJILKMFB1N OQPR@3A STH/BVU AWAXB YZP[U \^]/H_EGET`ba[cRd>` efef` ghH NiP[j3AXF

9OEDEU58CDz6<�CU7�<�M}SD>8<�7�5?7�MgH ED<�F�9Q3�<Ov Z>A3�LDHNBUzNLk¢�ª�µ�¼½5?7cCDHO3:VXBUCDE�9OM<�C�3o9Q>8>?e®ED5A©�<�F�<�C�3cVXFGHNMY3�LD<,HO3�LU<�Fc<�CU7�<�M}SD>8<&R�>\9O7G7�5A@

� R�9Q3�5?HNCdM<�3�LDHIEU7�sT3�LD<�M<�3�LDHIEkVXHNFR�F�<�9Q3�5?HNCdHQV�ED5?[O<�FG7�<�SD9O7�<jR�>\9O7G7�5 � <�FG7g5?C¶3�LU<.¢�ª�µ�¼9O>?zNHNF�5A3�LDM¿Mg9�e]9O>8>?H�;ÄVXHNF�Sl<�3G3�<�F�9QR�R�BUF�9ORye&;05?3�L_7�Mg9O>?>8<�FT<�CD7G<�M:SD>?<�7�v=¨�LD<|VX<�9�3�BDFG<x7GJ�9OR�<�758CPED5A©�<�F�<�C�3R�>\9O7G7�5 � <�F�79OFG<,M:BU3�BD9O>8>Aef<w�UR�>8BD7G5?[O<p5?Cd¢�ª�µ�¼ÅEDBD<&3�H®9.F�9OCUEDHNMÉJ�9QFG3�5A3�5?HNC¡v�THO3�L.µ��d9OCDEjµZ�,R�9OBD7G<:H�[N<�F�>\9QJjHOV(3�LD<}JDFG<�ED5?R�3�HNF�[Q9OFG5\9OSD>?<�7�9OMHNCDzgS�9O7�<WR�>89O7�7G5 � <�F�7ZEUBD<3�H{3�LD<pF�9OCUEDHNM�7�<�>8<�R�3�5?HNCdHQV�VX<�9Q3�BDF�<�7�vÄ·Z9OCU7�<�CÂ9OCDE¸�U9Q>\9OMHNCÄ^ ��¥O¥ u�bysT·�H¸^ ��¥N¥N° b69QCDEÊ�BDCDRoLD<y[Q9]<�3�9Q>rv­^rtQuNu ´ b�CDHO3�<�E�3�L�9Q3�<�CD7G<�M:SD>?<}<�F�F�HOF�F�9Q3�<W587�MgHN7n3ZFG<�EDBUR�<�E.5?C�<�CD7�<�M:SD>8<�7;0LDHN7G<&Mg<�M:Sl<�F�7}M~9O¤Q<]58CUED5?[ 58EUB�9O>�<�FGF�HNFG7:58CK9j>?<�7G7:R�HNFGF�<�>\9Q3�<�EKMg9OCDCD<�F�v.¨�LD<�F�<�VXHOF�<Os*;=<<y�IJl<�Ry3�9cF�9QJD58E,<�FGF�HNF�FG<�EDBUR�3�5?HNC_S�e~3�LD<W¢�ª�µ�¼�9QJDJDF�HN9ORoL¡v

Ë�7G58CDz|VXHNBDF�LD5?zNLI@�EU58M<�CD7G58HNC�9Q>IE�9�3o9|7�<�3�7=VXFGHNMÅED5A©�<�F�<�C�3=9OFG<�9O7�HOV¡9OJDJD>?58R�9�3�58HOC¡sO;=<�R�HNM6@J�9OFG<W¢�ª�µ�¼d3�Hc3�LD<|MgHN7n3�R�HNMMgHOCD>?egBD7�<�Ej9OCUE_Sl<�7n3ZJl<�FnVXHNF�M58CUzcR�>\9Q7�7�5 � R�9�3�58HOC&Mg<y3�LDH ED7�³µ��Ts��IBDJDJlHNFG3�¾�<�Ry3�HNF�q�9ORoLD5?CD<�7:^r� ¾�q®³�¾�9OJUCD58¤�s ��¥N¥ �Nbwsl�THIHO7G3�5?CDzDs�Ì�@���<�9QF�<�7n3���<�58zOL SlHNFG7^a¤ ����bys¡Ã$5?CD<�9QF�²�587GR�F�5?Mg5?C�9OC�3� ZC�9Q>?e 7�5?7^�Ã$²� �bys¡�ILDF�BUCD¤O<�C�¢T<�C�3�F�HN5?E¶^r�D¢Z³¡¨�5?SD7�LU58F�9QCD5�<y39O>�v?s$tQuNu�tNb�9OCUE{7G58CDzO>8<:HNJI3�58Mg9O>­3�F�<�<�7g^r¢T Zµ�¨�³$�TFG<�58Mg9OC.<y3x9O>rvAs ��¥N°O§ �­Í|Ë�ª��I¨�³­Ã$HOL®9QCDE�ILD5?L¡s ��¥O¥�¦ byvZ¨�LD<69OJDJD>?58R�9Q3�5?HNCD7�9OF�< � b�3�LD<}ED<�3�<�R�3�58HNC.HQVT9Q>8>8<�>85?Rx<w�IJDF�<�7�7�5?HNC�HOV�58MJDFG58C�3�<�EzN<�CD<�7=S�9O7�<�E]HNCL�BDM~9QC]9OCDEgMgHOBD7�<�zN<�CUHNMg5?R0E�9Q3o9g^�µ0<�5?¤69OCDE±�9O>A3�<�F�s tOuNu � bysItNb(3�LD<�R�>89O7n@7�5 � R�9�3�58HOC�HOV�L�BDMg9OCjR�HN>8HNC_3�5?7�7�BU<:7�9OMJD>?<�7�VXHOFZR�9QCDR�<�F�7G3�9Q3�BD7ZS�9O7�<�E.HNCjzN<�CDHNM58RxJDF�H � >8<�7^a �>8HNCg<�309Q>rvAs ��¥O¥N¥ bys ´ b*3�LD<�R�>\9Q7�7�5 � R�9�3�58HOC~HOV$RoLD<�Mg5?R�9O>?7=;05A3�L]FG<�7�Jl<�Ry3�3�H}<�7G3�F�HNzO<�C&SD5?CDED58CUz9ORy3�5?[ 5A3�ejS�9O7G<�E{HNC�7G3�F�BDRy3�BDF�9O>*ED<�7GR�FG58JU3�HNF�7x9OCDE{JDL�e 7�5?R�9O>*JDFGHNJl<�FG3�58<�7^��T>89O58F�<y3x9O>rvAs­tOuNuOu�bys9OCDE § b�3�LD<�R�>89O7�7G5 � R�9Q3�5?HNC~HQV­9OR�BU3�<�>8<�BD¤O<�Mg589O7�58C�3�Hc9QR�BU3�<�>?e MJDLDHNSD>89O7G3�58R0>8<�BD¤O<�Mg589]^X �Ã$íbHNFT9OR�BU3�<�M}eO<�>8HO58E~>?<�BD¤Q<�M5\9&^X �q�íb=SD9O7�<�E&HNC]<�9QRoL_5?CDED5A[I5?EDB�9O>�J�9�3�58<�C�3�ÎÏ7TzN<�CD<y@4<y�IJDF�<�7�7G58HNCJDFGH � >8<^�Ð|HO>8BDS,<�3�9O>�v?s ��¥N¥N¥ byv(±®<W7GLDH�;Æ3�LD9Q303�LD<x9OR�R�BDF�9OR�e,HOV(¢�ª�µ�¼Â5?7�R�HNCU7�587n3�<�C�3�>?e,HNCU<HOV¡3�LD<ZSl<�7n3�9OMHNCDz|3�LU<ZR�>89O7�7G5 � R�9Q3�5?HNCMg<y3�LDH ED7�R�HNCD7G58ED<�F�<�E&9OCDE~3�L�9Q3�¢�ª�µ�¼PR�9OCg58MJDF�H�[O<3�LU<ZS�9O>89OCDR�<�HOV¡7�<�CU7�5?3�5?[ 5?3�e9QCDE~7GJ�<�R�5 � R�5?3�eH�[N<�F�R�<�FG3�9O58CgHO3�LD<�F=M<�3�LDH ED7�v(243T587=9OC�3�5?R�58JD9Q3�<�E3�LD9Q3}3�LD<~JDFGHNJlHN7�<�EKMg<y3�LDH ED7}R�9OC�Sl<~BD7G<�E�3�Hj58MJDF�H�[O<gR�>\9O7G7:JDF�<�ED58Ry3�5?HNCf5?CfMg9OC�e®HQ3�LD<�F9OFG<�9O70HOV�9OJDJD>?58R�9Q3�5?HNC]58C�[OHN>?[ 58CUzcLD58zNL @�ED5?Mg<�CD7�5?HNC�9O>lJDF�<�ED58Ry3�5?HNC,7�<�3�7�v

¨�LD<KJDFGHNJ�HO7�<�EÇM<�3�LDH ED7.9OFG<�58MJD>8<�Mg<�C�3�<�EÄ58CÑ¢Ò9OCUEѵxv� Z>8>|3�LU<�J�9OF�9OMg<y3�<�F�[Q9O>A@

§

Page 6: AWAXB YZP[Uhahn/research/CERP/papCERP.pdf$- ./ ! 0 +( 1#324 57678&9:; + ! ) ? @3ACB DCEGFHJILKMFB1N OQPR@3A STH/BVU AWAXB YZP[U \^]/H_EGET`ba[cRd>` efef` ghH NiP[j3AXF

BD<�7p9QF�<.ED<y3�<�FGMg5?CD<�E¸5?CÂ3�LD<j3�F�9O5?CD58CDzfJDL�9O7G<OvȨ�LD<�F�<�VXHOF�<Os�CDH � CD<.3�BUCD58CDzK5?7&CD<�R�<�7G7�9OFne58C¶F�BDCUCD58CDzK¢�ª�µ�¼�v= ¹EDH�;0CD>?H�9OE�9QSD>8<,[N<�F�7�5?HNC�HOVx¢�@4¨Ó¢�ª�µ�¼�JDF�HNzOF�9OM�5?7~JDFGH¬[ 5?ED<�E�9�3L�3�3�J¡³ÕÔOÔ�;�;�;|vÖ9QMg7�v=7GBDC�eI7GS¡vÏ<�EDB�ÔO×|L�9QLDC�ÔQFG<�7�<�9OF�RoL�ÔN¢�ª�µ�¼­vØL�3�M>rv

Ù ÚÇ#.ÛjÜ}#./�Ý�Þ Ý�#]% )6ßÒà£á�Ü:â�â ã½'�Ý�+.1�/0%(1�)# ä&å Ú�#.â�Ý�Þ ä.á�Ý

æ )c%*1�#jç è ÝZ%*Ûj),+.â

 ÑMgHQ3�5?[Q9Q3�58HNCgVXHNF0<�CD7G<�M:SD>?<�7�587�3�L�9Q3�9R�HNM:SD5?C�9Q3�58HNC&HOV�3�LD<|HNBI3�JDBU3�7�HQV�Mg9OC�e];=<�9O¤,R�>89O7n@7�5 � <�FG7cJDF�H EDBDR�<�79.J�H�;=<�FnVXBD>�R�HOMgM5?3G3�<�<j^�·�9O7G3�58<&<�39Q>rvAs�tOuNu � bwv® �7�7GBDMg<&5?CDED<�J�<�CDED<�CUR�<9OMHNCDz]3�LD<6ÀkR�>\9O7G7�5 � <�FG7�s�;0LD<�FG<6Àk5?7�HIEUE¡v:±f<cCUHO3�<c3�LD9Q3|M~9Q¤ 5?CDz&ÀPHIEUE{JUF�<�[O<�C�3�7x3�5?<�7�vÃ�<�3xé6êTED<�CDHO3�<~9_F�9OCDEUHNMë[Q9OF�589OSD>8<c5?CDED5?R�9Q3�58CDz,9_R�HNFGF�<�Ry3}R�>\9O7G7�5 � R�9Q3�58HNC{S�e.3�LD<gì�3�LfR�>89O7n@7�5 � <�F�v}24V�3�LU<JUF�<�EU58R�3�58HNCj9OR�R�BDF�9ORye.HOV�<�9QRoL®R�>\9O7G7�5 � <�F�5?7�í�s�3�LU<�C�éê(×î�T<�F�CDHOBD>8>?5�^ïí�bys¡9QCDE3�LU<�C�BDM:Sl<�FgHOV|9OR�R�BDF�9Q3�<pR�>\9Q7�7�5 � R�9�3�58HOCD7gS�eP3�LU<�<�CU7�<�M}SD>8<pM~9¬«GHOF�5?3�ef[NHO3�58CDz®Mg<y3�LDH Ed5?7ðÉñóò]ôêïõ�ö é6ê|×¹SD5?CDHNM5\9O>4^aÀ�÷�ílbyv�±f<,>?<�36ÀÇñótNÌø � s�;0LD<�FG<jÌK58769.CDHOCDCD<�zN9Q3�5A[N<,58CI@3�<�zN<�F�vj²�< � CD<]ù ô ñûú~^aðýü»Ìø � byvp¨�LD<�C�3�LD<]JDFG<�ED5?R�3�58HNCf9OR�R�BDF�9ORyefHQV�3�LD<g<�CD7G<�M:SD>?<R�>89O7�7G5 � R�9Q3�5?HNC&S�e_9cM~9¬«GHOF�5?3�e[NHQ3�58CUz5?7

ù ô ñôþ

êïõDÿ���ö � À ì�� í ê ^ ��� ílb�ô�� ê ^ � b

Ã$9OM 9OCDEÂ�IBD<�CÇ^ ��¥N¥�¦ b:7�LUH¬;=<�EÂ3�L�9Q3ù���ÿ ��ö,ñ �.VXHNFg̸ñýuU÷ � ÷ �� ;0LU<�CfíÆñ �I�03�LU<7�< m BD<�CDR�<��¬ù���ÿ���ö���587�7G3�F�58Ry3�>AeW5?CDR�FG<�9O7G58CDz�;0LD<�C|í�� � ��9OCDE��¬ù���ÿ ��ö���587�7n3�FG58R�3�>?exED<�R�F�<�9O7�5?CDz;0LD<�C6í�� �Iv(24V­Àp587T>89OF�zO<Os�3�LD<�C,ð ���� i�^XÀIí�÷�À í­^ ��� ílbGb=S�eg3�LD<�R�<�C�3�F�9Q>�>85?Mg5A3*3�LD<�HNF�<�Mpv243*5?7�<�9O7GeW3�H�7GLDH�;¶3�L�9Q3(>?58M:ÿ ���.ù���ÿ���ö�ñ � s�9OCUE:3�LD<=JDF�<�ED58Ry3�58HOCc9OR�R�BDF�9QR�e:HQV�3�LD<=<�CD7G<�M:SD>?<[NHQ3�58CUzM<�3�LDH E_R�HNC�[N<�F�zN<�7�3�H � ;0LD<�Cgí�� �Is

24V¡3�LU<�R�>\9O7G7�5 � <�F�7�5?C3�LD<�<�CD7�<�M:SD>?<Z9OFG<0R�HNFGF�<�>89Q3�<�E¡s�3�LD<�Cg;=<ZR�9OC~BD7G<�3�LD<�S�<y3o9�@4SD58CDHOMg589O>MHIED<�>�^ ±¸58>8>?5\9OM7�s ��¥�¦ �Nbyv�¨�LD5?7cMgH ED<�>T9O>8>?H�;07}HNCD>AefJlHN7G5?3�5A[N<]R�HNF�FG<�>89Q3�5?HNC �{58CKHNFGED<�F}3�H7�9�3�587nV ef¾�9OF�^ïílb��ûuIvK¼*F�<�C�3�58R�<{^ ��¥N°N¯ bW7�LDH�;=<�Ek3�L�9Q3c3�LD<&Sl<�3o9¬@�SD5?CDHNM5\9O>�MHIED<�>TMg9�e�Sl<<y� 3�<�CDED<�E�3�HR�9Q7�<�7�;0LD<�FG<!�"�¸u6VXHNF�R�<�Fn3o9O5?C_[Q9O>?BD<�7�vT·�5870<y� 3�<�CDED<�EjS�<y3o9�@4SD58CUHNMg589O>�MH ED<�>

Page 7: AWAXB YZP[Uhahn/research/CERP/papCERP.pdf$- ./ ! 0 +( 1#324 57678&9:; + ! ) ? @3ACB DCEGFHJILKMFB1N OQPR@3A STH/BVU AWAXB YZP[U \^]/H_EGET`ba[cRd>` efef` ghH NiP[j3AXF

587�[Q9O>?58E];0LD<�C#�gü�M~9���� � í­^aÀ � í ��� b � ö ÷ � ^ ��� ílb%$ À � ^ ��� í�b ���'& � ö ��v¨�9OSD>8< � ³)( äÛïÛß�äÛÝ°æ!é[æ!ä�Ü.×�ê�Ü_ï%æWåZÖ_æ!çÛà·Ý°Ü_àã×�ä�ß�Ý�Ý�Ù%Ö/ß�Ý°ô0Øoô)æ!äÛÚ|æ!é�ØZÞãæWé[ß��|×�ÖJàãÜ�ô1è�×�Ü_àóä%ø%ö*#+ åÛÖJæ!çÛà·Ý°Ü_àã×�ä0ß�Ý�Ý�Ù%Ö/ß�Ý°ô)×�ê&æ!ß�Ý/ï�ØZß�Ú|æ�Ý�Þ·ß�Ú_Ú_àâáTæ�Ö-,. / ö10�2 ö10�0 ö13�2 ö54'2 ö16�2 ö17�2 ö17�08 ë_ö92:0 ö10 ö10�6 ö13�3 ö16�2 ö17<; ö17�6 =XÕ?>2 ö10 ö10:4 ö13:4 ö54�6 ö17�2 ö17:4 ö17�7

ö@; ö10 ö10:4 ö13'A ö54�3 ö16:4 ö17�0 ö17�6ö 8 ö10 ö10�3 ö13�B ö54 8 ö16'A ö17 8 ö17:44 ë_ö92:B�0 ö10 ö13�B ö54 8 ö17�2 ö17�6 =XÕ =XÕ2 ö10 ö13<; ö54C; ö16:4 ö17:4 ;Éö92�2 ;Éö92�2�Dö@; ö10 ö10�7 ö13:4 ö16<; ö17�B ö17�6 ö17�7ö 8 ö10 ö10:4 ö13 8 ö54�0 ö16�3 ö17'A ö17:4;E0 ë_ö92F; ö10 ö13:4 ö16<; ö17�3 ;Éö92�2 =XÕ =XÕ2 ö10 ö13�0 ö54�7 ö17�0 ;Éö92�2 ;Éö92�2 ;Éö92�2ö@; ö10 ö13�2 ö54'2 ö16�0 ö17�0 ö17�7 ;Éö92�2ö 8 ö10 ö10:4 ö13'A ö54�3 ö16:4 ö17�0 ö17�6B�0 ë_ö92F; ö10 ö54�B ö16�6 ö17�7 =XÕ =XÕ =XÕ2 ö10 ö13�7 ö16�0 ö17�7 ;Éö92�2 ;Éö92�2 ;Éö92�2ö@; ö10 ö13<; ö54C; ö16:4 ö17�3 ö17�7 ;Éö92�2ö 8 ö10 ö10:4 ö13'A ö54�4 ö16:4 ö17�0 ö17�6;�2F; 2 ö10 ö16'A ö17�6 ;Éö92�2 ;Éö92�2 ;Éö92�2 ;Éö92�2ö@; ö10 ö13�B ö54 8 ö16�7 ö17:4 ;Éö92�2 ;Éö92�2ö 8 ö10 ö10:4 ö13'A ö54�4 ö16�6 ö17�0 ö17�6G-H-IJLKNMOKPRQ9KS QRTVU-WXPRH YZJ\[ T]T_^`J\TNH a TNa)SET_JbKdceS-PRH IOfgP9KQ%fgIha TNQ'SjilkCm\TnHjJ\PRonTgp önqOrOsjt u YOm\TnKdJXTNmvJX[�KHwIOmxTNyhU�KQ�J\Iwz qOqO{

¨�9QSD>8< � 58>8>?BD7G3�F�9Q3�<�7*3�LU<�JDF�<�ED58Ry3�5?HNC&9OR�R�BDF�9OR�egHNSU3�9O58CD<�E]S�e~<�CD7�<�M:SD>?<�M~9�«GHNF�5A3�ec[NHO3�58CDzDv±¸LD<�C �{ñ»uUs$3�LD<g7G3o9QCDE�9OFGE�SD58CUHNMg589O>(JDFGHNS�9OSU58>85A3�ej5?C�^ � b�5?7WBU7�<�E�VXHOFWÀ}|»tO�Is�9QCDEf3�LU<CDHNFGM~9Q>�9OJDJDFGH��U5?M~9�3�58HOC&5870BD7�<�EpVXHNF�96>\9OFGzN<�F�À�v=¨�LU<WSl<�3�9�@�SD5?CDHNM5\9O>lMHIED<�>�587�BD7G<�E�;0LU<�C3�LU<R�HNF�FG<�>89Q3�5?HNC.587|JlHN7�5A3�5?[O<Os$9OCUE{3�LD<6<y� 3�<�CDED<�EfS�<y3o9�@4SD58CDHOMg589O>�MH ED<�>(5?7|BD7�<�E®;0LD<�C®3�LU<R�HOF�F�<�>\9Q3�58HNC�5?7,CD<�z�9�3�5?[O<Ov�¨�LD<�3o9OSU>8<.58>?>8BD7n3�F�9Q3�<�7]3�L�9Q3,CU<�z�9Q3�5?[O<�>?eÂR�HNFGF�<�>89Q3�<�EÄR�>\9O7G7�5 � <�FG758MJDFGH¬[O<Z3�LU<xJUF�<�EU58R�3�58HNC]9OR�R�BDF�9ORye&MHNF�<�F�9OJD5?ED>?e3�L�9QC,3�LD<�58CUED<�Jl<�CDEU<�C�3�R�>\9Q7�7�5 � <�FG7�sU;0LU58>8<3�LU<x5?MgJUF�H�[N<�Mg<�C�307G>8H�;070EDH�;0Cp;0LD<�Cp3�LD<|R�HNFGF�<�>89Q3�5?HNC]5?CDR�FG<�9O7G<�7�v

¨�LD<]5?MgJDFGH�[N<�M<�C�3}HOV�3�LU<]<�CD7G<�M:SU>8<]9QR�R�BUF�9ORyef5?>8>8BU7G3�F�9Q3�<�Ef9QS�H�[N<~587W[Q9O>?58E{BDCDED<�F}3�LU<9O7G7�BDMJU3�5?HNC,HOV�< m B�9O>­9OR�R�BDF�9OR�e,HOV­3�LU<xSD9O7�<|R�>89O7�7G5 � <�F�7�9OCDE_< m B�9Q>�R�HNFGF�<�>89Q3�5?HNC,9OMHNCDzc3�LU<R�>89O7�7G5 � <�F�7�vѱ¸5A3�LDHOBU3~3�LD<�7G<{R�HNCD7n3�F�9Q58C�3�7�sZ�TFG<�5?M~9OC�^rtOuOu � bHOSU3o9O5?CD<�EÂ3�LD<jBDJUJ�<�F&S�HNBUCDEVXHNFc3�LU<�zN<�CD<�F�9O>85?h�9Q3�58HNCK<�F�F�HOF;0LD<�Cd3�LU<j9OR�R�BDF�9OR�ekHOVZ<�9ORoLÂR�>\9O7G7�5 � <�F5879Q3g>8<�9O7G3g9®LD9O>?V v ZR�R�HNFGED58CUz}3�H:3�LD587�3�LD<�HNF�<�Mps 3�LD<�<�CD7�<�M:SD>?<�9OR�R�BDF�9QR�e]R�HNC�[N<�F�zN<�7�3�H � ;0LD<�C&3�LD<�R�>\9O7G7�5 � <�FG7

¯

Page 8: AWAXB YZP[Uhahn/research/CERP/papCERP.pdf$- ./ ! 0 +( 1#324 57678&9:; + ! ) ? @3ACB DCEGFHJILKMFB1N OQPR@3A STH/BVU AWAXB YZP[U \^]/H_EGET`ba[cRd>` efef` ghH NiP[j3AXF

9OFG<�58CDED<�J�<�CDED<�C�3�v�±¸LU<�C,3�LD<|R�>89O7�7G5 � <�F�709OFG<|R�HNFGF�<�>89Q3�<�E¡sU3�LD<x9OR�R�BDF�9ORye];058>?>�R�HNC�[N<�FGzN<|3�H9JlHN58C�3T;05A3�LD5?Cg3�LD<�F�9QCDzN<�Sl<�3�;=<�<�C ��� �l^ ����~ � b�Á ~ � 9OCUE � sI;0LD<�F�< ~ 587�3�LD<Z7G3�FG<�CDzQ3�L&HOV$3�LU<7�<y3�HOV�R�>\9O7G7�5 � <�FG7�9QCDE �g587�3�LD<x9�[O<�F�9OzN<|R�HNFGF�<�>\9Q3�58HNC&HOV­3�LU<|3�F�<�<xR�>\9O7G7�5 � <�FG7�v

¨�LD<�7G<�F�<�7�BD>A3�7�58MJD>?e:3�L�9Q3�3�LD<�<�CD7G<�M:SU>8<�[OHO3�5?CDz}M<�3�LDH E~S�e63�LD<�¢�ª�µ�¼k9OJDJDFGH�9ORoL]R�9OCSl<5?MgJUF�H�[N<�E�Va9Q7G3x58C.3�<�F�M7|HOVTR�>\9O7G7|JDF�<�ED58Ry3�58HOC®9QR�R�BUF�9ORye.S�e�F�<�EUBDR�5?CDzpLU58zNL�R�HOF�F�<�>\9Q3�58HNCR�9QBD7�<�E~S�ec3�LD<0H�[N<�F�>89OJgHQV�JDFG<�ED5?R�3�HNF*[O9QF�5\9QSD>8<�7�v(·�H�;T<y[N<�F�sI3�LD<�FG<�5?7�9|>?58M5?3�9Q3�5?HNC¡v­�I5?CDR�<�3�LU<C�BDM:Sl<�F�HOV(EU587X«GHO58C�307�BDSU7�<�3�7ZVXHNF�9 � �I<�Ej7G<�3�HOV(JDFG<�ED5?R�3�HNF�7�5870>85?Mg5A3�<�E¡sUR�HNC�[N<�FGzN<�CUR�<}3�Hg3�LU<Jl<�FGVX<�R�3�9OR�R�BDF�9OR�e,R�9OCDCDHO3�Sl<x9ORoLD58<y[N<�E.9OCDE,3�LD<�F�<|587�9cSlHNBDCDE¡v=��BDFG3�LD<�FGMgHOF�<OsQí�ED<�R�FG<�9O7G<�79O76À¸58CDR�F�<�9O7�<�7gSl<�R�9OBD7�<_3�LD<,C�BDM:Sl<�F6HOVZED587 «GHN58C�367GBDSD7�<y3�7j^aÀ�b:5?C¶9QC¶<�CD7�<�M:SD>8<_9OCUE¶3�LU<C�BDM:Sl<�F�HOV�JDFG<�ED5?R�3�HNF�7�5?C�9,7GBDSD7G<�3W9OF�<c5?C�[N<�FG7�<�>?ejJUF�HNJlHNFG3�58HNCD9O>�zO5?[N<�C{9 � �I<�E{C BUM:S�<�F�HOVJDFG<�ED5?R�3�HOF�7T5?C]9}ED9Q3o9x7�<�3�v*¨�L�BD7�3�LD<�58MJDF�H�[O<�M<�C�3�HOV�3�LD<�<�CD7G<�M:SD>?<�9OR�R�BDF�9OR�eg587�<y�IJl<�R�3�<�E3�HWS�<�7�>?H�;T<�F�3�L�9OCg3�LD<ZC�BDM}S�<�F�7T7GLDH�;0C]58C¨�9OSD>8< � v*·�H�;T<y[N<�F�sUVXHNF�LD5?zNLI@�EU58M<�CD7G58HNC�9Q>UE�9Q3�9;05?3�L�L�BDCDEUF�<�EU7�HNF�3�LDHNBD7�9OCDED7ZHOV*JDFG<�ED5?R�3�HOF�[Q9OFG5\9OSD>?<�7�s�9Va9O7G3�58MJDF�H�[O<�M<�C�3�HOV(JDF�<�ED58Ry3�58HOC9OR�R�BDF�9OR�e,R�9OCpSl<|9ORoLD5?<�[O<�E�S�e&3�<�CD70HNF�L�BDCDEUF�<�EU7ZHOV�R�>89O7�7G5 � <�F�70zN<�CU<�F�9�3�<�E_58Cp¢�ª�µ�¼�v

� àûÚ��Òã��£àîá�Ü:â(â(1��{/�Üx%*1�)# ä]å ÚÇ#.â�Ý�Þ ä.á�Ý�â ß�'*)gÞ �ÓÜ}#��+j)gÞ ãÆÜ:'(%*1�%(1�)#.â

±®<�JUF�HNJlHN7�<09�M<�3�LDHIEcVXHNF*R�HNCD7n3�F�BUR�3�5?CDzW¢�ª�µ�¼­v�¨�LD<�zOH�9O>UHQV�3�LD587*7n3�BDEUe65?7�s�S�ecR�HNM:SD5?CD58CDz9gzOF�HNBDJ_HOV(;=<�9Q¤O<�FZR�>\9Q7�7�5 � R�9�3�58HOC,3�F�<�<�7�s�3�H~9ORoLD5?<�[N<}9gR�>\9O7G7�5 � <�F�;05?3�Lj96LD58zNLU<�F�JDF�<�ED58Ry3�58HOC9OR�R�BDF�9OR�ek3�L�9QC¸9®7�5?CDzN>?<pHNJI3�58Mg9O>�3�FG<�<pHNSU3o9Q58CD<�EdVXF�HNM�3�LD<�7�9OMg<p7�9OMJD>?<Ovƨ�LU<jH�[N<�F�9O>8>7�RoLU<�M<cHOV�3�LD<}3�<�RoLDCU5 m BD<c587Z7�LDH�;0C�58C.��58zNBDFG< � v�±®<:>?<�3��ÈSl<}3�LD<c7GJ�9OR�<cHOV*3�LD<}JDF�<�ED58Rw@3�HOF�7�v�2�C6HNF�ED<�F(3�H�M58CD5?Mg5?h�<*3�LU<�R�HNFGF�<�>\9Q3�58HNCc9QMgHNCUzZ3�LD<�<�CD7�<�M:SD>?<�HOV�3�F�<�<�7�sx�¸5?7(F�9OCUEDHNM>?eJ�9OFn3�5A3�58HOCD<�E&5?C�3�HÌ]7�BDSD7GJ�9OR�<�7c^��$öy÷E�]��÷�������÷���ÿ�b=;05A3�L,F�HNBUzNLD>?eg< m B�9Q>­7G58h�<�7�v=�I5?CDR�<�3�LD<|7�BDS @7�JD9OR�<�7W9QF�<:F�9OCDEDHNM>?e,RoLUHN7�<�C{VXFGHNM�3�LD<:7�9OMg<}ED587n3�F�5?SDBU3�58HNC¡s�;=<69O7�7GBDMg<:3�L�9Q3�3�LD<�FG<:587ZCDHSD589O7�58C.7G<�>?<�R�3�58HNC�HOV�3�LD<6JDF�<�ED58Ry3�HNFG7�58C.<�9QRoL®7GBDSD7�JD9OR�<Qvc �3|<�9ORoL{HOV�3�LD<�7�<67�BUSD7�J�9QR�<�7�s�;=<R�HOCD7G3�F�BDRy309}7�5?CDzN>?<�HNJI3�58Mg9O>D3�F�<�<ZR�>\9Q7�7�5 � <�F�v*��9O7G<�E&HNCg3�LD<�F�9OCDEUHNMgCU<�7�7�sU;=<�<y�IJl<�R�3�CD<�9OFG>?e< m B�9Q>¡JDF�HOS�9OSD5?>85?3�eHOV$3�LD<�R�>89O7�7G5 � R�9Q3�5?HNC]<�FGF�HNF�9OMgHOCDz}3�LU<xÌ&R�>\9O7G7�5 � <�FG7�s�9OCUE&58MJDF�H�[N<�Mg<�C�3

¦

Page 9: AWAXB YZP[Uhahn/research/CERP/papCERP.pdf$- ./ ! 0 +( 1#324 57678&9:; + ! ) ? @3ACB DCEGFHJILKMFB1N OQPR@3A STH/BVU AWAXB YZP[U \^]/H_EGET`ba[cRd>` efef` ghH NiP[j3AXF

� Ó%Ñ;Ó� Óx���Z�����©ÓZÒ½Ñ%�´Ñ%�X�L��V�©Ï�ÐE�©ÓZÔ:��� �]�©Ï©ÐE��ÓÛÔ:��� �]�-Ï�ÐE��ÓÛÔ:� �¡ ¡ ¡ ¡ ¡ ¡ ¡ ¡ ¡ ¡¢¢¢¢¢¢¢¢¢¢ £F£F£¤ ¤ ¤¥¥¦ Ò'�C���

¥¥¦ Ò%�C� � §F§F§

¥¥

¦ Ò'���"¨¤

Ω���<�©ÐE�C��Ï«ªX�¬�b�®­�¯ �!°��5?zNBDF�< � ³ ÷.ï%æ�åZÖ_×�å§×�Ú|æ!ç � ( ��± ßÉåZåÛÖ_×�ß�ÝJïhö)÷.ïÛæ[åÛÖ_æ!çÛàóÝ°Ü_àã×�ä�à·Úp×�ØÛÜ_ß�àóä%æ!ç�Øiô�ß�äyæ!äÛÚ|æ!é�ØZÞãæ[×�êà·äÛçZàãèiàóçÛÙÛß�ÞZÝ�Þóß�Ú_Ú_àâáTÝ�ßÉÜ_à·×�ä�Ü|Ö_æ�æ!Ú.êùÖ_×�é3æ!ß�Ý/ï�Ú_Ù%ØTÚ|åZß�Ý°æp×�ê&Ü_ï%æpåÛÖ_æ!çZà·Ý°Ü|×�ÖJÚ�ö

HOV¡3�LD<ZJUF�<�EU58R�3�58HNC~9OR�R�BDF�9QR�egR�9OC]Sl<�9QRoLD58<y[N<�E,9Q7=ED<�MgHOCD7G3�F�9Q3�<�E]5?C&�I<�R�3�5?HNC,tIv*¢�@�¨ ¢�ª�µ�¼BD7G<�7|9~R�>\9O7G7�5 � R�9Q3�58HNC�3�F�<�<c9OCDE�Ã$µ�@�¨º¢�ª�µ�¼¸BD7G<�7x9~>8HOzN587n3�58R|FG<�zNFG<�7�7G58HNCj3�F�<�<c9O7Z3�LD<:S�9O7G<R�>89O7�7G5 � <�F�v=¢�ª�µ�¼¶R�HNM:SU58CD<�703�LD<|F�<�7�BD>A3�70HOV­3�LD<�7�<xM:BD>?3�58JD>?<Z3�FG<�<�703�H~9QRoLD58<y[N<x9OC_58MJDF�H�[N<�E9OR�R�BDF�9OR�e{HOVTR�>\9Q7�7|JDF�<�ED58Ry3�5?HNC®S�e{9,M~9�«GHNF�5A3�ej[NHO3�58CDz_HOV=3�LD<R�>89O7�7G5 � <�F�7|HNF|S�e{3�9O¤�58CDz,3�LU<9�[N<�F�9OzN<�HOV�3�LD<0JDFG<�ED5?R�3�<�Eg[Q9O>?BD<�7*;05?3�LD58C9OC<�CU7�<�M}SD>8<Qv���HOF�9|VXBDFn3�LD<�F�58MJDF�H�[N<�Mg<�C�3=HQV�3�LU<Jl<�FGVXHOF�Mg9OCDR�<�HQV*¢�ª�µ�¼�s�;T<|5?C�[O<�7n3�58zN9Q3�<�E�9cMg9¬«GHNF�5A3�e~[OHO3�5?CDz9OMgHOCDz69c7�<�3�HOV�<�CD7G<�M:SU>8<�7�v

¨�LD<�C�BDM:Sl<�F�HQV�VX<�9Q3�BDF�<�7GJ�9OR�<�7058C~9:F�9OCDEUHNM£JD9OFG3�5?3�5?HNC587TEU<�3�<�F�M58CD<�E&58C~3�LD<Z3�F�9O5?CD58CDzJDL�9Q7�<xS�e_96CD<�7G3�<�E�R�F�HN7G7�[Q9O>?58E�9Q3�58HNC~58C_<�9ORoLp>8<�9QF�CD5?CDzc7�<y3�vT  � u¬@4VXHN>?E_¢=¾�5?70BD7�<�EpVXHNF�3�LU<¢�@�¨Ä¢�ª�µ�¼�sDSDBI3�9 ´ @4VXHO>8E&¢=¾Ñ5?7TBD7G<�E,VXHNF�Ã$µ�@�¨Ä¢�ª�µ�¼PVXHNFTR�HNMJDBU3o9�3�58HOC�9O>�<%²R�5?<�CDRyeNv�2�C<�9QRoL{>?<�9OFGCD58CUz]7�<y3WHQVT9 � u�@4VXHN>?E.¢=¾}s�;T< � FG7G3|J�9QFG3�5A3�5?HNCp3�LD<cJDF�<�ED58Ry3�HNFZ7�J�9OR�<67�BDRoL�3�L�9�3|97�BUSD7�J�9QR�<�L�9Q7(9OFGHNBDCDE}i6ÁNt�JDFG<�ED5?R�3�HNF�7�sNSDBD5?>8EW9�¢�ª�µ�¼.MHIEU<�>rs�9OCUE:R�9O>?R�BD>89Q3�<*3�LD<�9OR�R�BDF�9OR�e58C{<�9QRoLf7�BUSD7�J�9QR�<Ov,2�C{3�LD<7�9OM<6;�9�eNs­;T<~9Q3�3�<�MJU3Wi6Á ´ s�i6Á § ÷ '� ÷�i6Á � u_9OCDE�i6Á � t&VXHOF3�LU<�7�5?h�<�HOV$<�9ORoL,7�BDSU7�J�9OR�<Ov�¨�LD<�J�9QFG3�5A3�5?HNC~7G58h�<ZF�<�7GBD>?3�58CDzW58C~3�LD<�LD5?zNLD<�7G3�H�[N<�F�9O>?>¡9OR�R�BDF�9OR�e587�RoLDHN7G<�C{9OMHNCDz~3�LD<�7G<Ov�¨�L�BD7|i6ÁQìT;05?>8>­S�<WRoLDHN7G<�C�VXHNFZ7GHNMg<W58C�3�<�zN<�FZì�s�ì=ñÅt ÷ �� ÷ � ugHOF� tIv�¨�LD<Z7G<�R�HOCDE&7G3�<�J&587�3�HW7�<�9OF�RoL]3�LD<ZHNJI3�58Mg9O>D7G58h�<ZHOV¡3�LD<Z7GBDSD7GJ�9OR�<�7�S�e]9xEDB�9O>lSD587G<�Ry3�58HOCM<�3�LUHIE�Sl<�3�;=<�<�CPi6ÁU^aì �Ä� b�9OCDE®i6ÁQì�s�9OCDE{S�<y3�;T<�<�CKi6Á�ìZ9OCUEfi6ÁD^Xì$ø � b�S�9O7�<�EfHNC�3�LU<

°

Page 10: AWAXB YZP[Uhahn/research/CERP/papCERP.pdf$- ./ ! 0 +( 1#324 57678&9:; + ! ) ? @3ACB DCEGFHJILKMFB1N OQPR@3A STH/BVU AWAXB YZP[U \^]/H_EGET`ba[cRd>` efef` ghH NiP[j3AXF

H�[N<�F�9O>?>(9OR�R�BDF�9OR�eOv|��FGHNM 3�LD5?7�s�;=<:L�9�[O<:3�;TH,R�9QCDED58ED9Q3�<�7ZVXHNF�3�LD<:J�9QFG3�5A3�5?HNCp7G58h�<Ov�±®<}3o9O¤Q<3�LU<�HNCU<�;05A3�LLD58zNLU<�F�H¬[O<�F�9O>8>�9OR�R�BDF�9OR�eOv�¨�LD587�9OE�9QJU3�5A[N<�SD587G<�R�3�58HNCg9O>?zNHNF�5A3�LDM�587*Va9O7n3�<�F�3�LD9OC9~zNFG58Ej7G<�9OFGRoL¡vx��BDFG3�LD<�F�s¡5?3�R�9OC.7GBDR�R�<�<�E{3�H&HNSU3o9Q58Cp3�LD<:zN>?HNS�9O>­Mg9��I58M:BDM»;0LU58RoL.Mg9�epSl<M587�7G<�E,S�e&3�LD<|R�HNC�[N<�C�3�58HNC�9Q>­SU587�<�R�3�58HNC,M<�3�LUHIE¡v

2�C�9,M~9�«GHNF�5A3�e�[NHQ3�58CUzDs­3�LD<6JDF�<�ED58Ry3�<�E®[Q9O>8BU<�7W9OF�<6R�>89O7�7G5 � <�Ef9Q7W<�5?3�LU<�Fxu_HOF � BD7G58CDzp9zN5A[N<�CK3�LDF�<�7�LDHN>?EPS�e�<�9ORoLkS�9O7G<&R�>\9Q7�7�5 � <�F�v���HNF:<�9ORoLkHNSD7�<�FG[Q9Q3�58HNC¡s�9jMg9¬«GHNFG5?3�e{[NHO3�58CDz.5?7Jl<�FGVXHOF�M<�E¡v� Z7�9OCj9Q>?3�<�F�C�9�3�5?[O<|9OJDJDFGH�9ORoL_3�H63�LD<xM~9�«GHNF�5A3�e~[NHQ3�58CUzDsD;T<xR�HOCD7�5?ED<�FG<�E.9OCp9�[�@<�F�9OzN5?CDz&Mg<y3�LDH E¡vc2�C�3�LD5?7x9OJDJDFGH�9ORoL¡s�3�LU<JUF�<�EU58R�3�<�E�[Q9O>8BD<�7�VXF�HNM¹9O>8>­3�LD<6S�9O7G<gR�>\9O7G7�5 � <�FG758C�9OCj<�CD7�<�M:SD>8<}9OF�<}9�[N<�F�9OzN<�E�9OCDEjR�>\9O7G7�5 � <�E.9O7�<�5A3�LD<�FZu~HOF � BU7�58CUz]9g3�LDF�<�7�LDHN>?EjHNC_3�LD5?79�[N<�F�9OzN<Qv� �>?3�LDHNBDzNL_3�LD<WM~9�«GHNF�5A3�e][NHO3�58CDz~9OCDE.9�[O<�F�9QzN58CDzgMg<y3�LDH ED7�9OF�<W7�5?Mg5?>\9OF�5?C�JDFG58CDR�5A@JD>?<Os�3�LD<c>\9Q3G3�<�F�BU3�5?>85?h�<�7�3�LD< � 3�3�<�E{[Q9O>?BD<�7ZHOV�3�LD<6>8HOzN587n3�58RxF�<�zNF�<�7�7G58HNC�Sl<�3�3�<�F�5?C.<�9ORoL.3�FG<�<Qv¨�L�BD7�3�LD<6FG<�7�BU>?3�7�S�e�Ã$µ�@�¨�¢�ª�µ�¼ÄzN5?[O<�C�58Cj3�LD587�J�9QJ�<�F|9OF�<cHNSI3o9O5?CD<�E.S�ej3�LD<69�[N<�F�9OzN5?CDzM<�3�LUHIEP;05?3�LD58C¶9OCk<�CD7G<�M:SD>?<Os�;0LD5?>8<]3�LD<�FG<�7�BU>?3�7S�e¶¢�@�¨ ¢�ª�µ�¼�9OF�<_HNSU3�9O58CD<�E¶S�eP3�LU<Mg9¬«GHNF�5A3�e:[NHQ3�58CUzWM<�3�LDHIE�v(¨�LD<ZJl<�FnVXHNF�Mg9OCDR�<�HQV$¢�ª�µ�¼K5?7=<y[O9Q>8B�9Q3�<�EBD7�5?CDz}FG<�Jl<�9Q3�<�E,¢=¾Z79O70ED<�7�R�FG58Sl<�E_58Cp�I<�R�3�5?HNC ¯ v

³ c`´ s�µC¶ s ·�v¹¸»º�s ]_`�EGEGHj¼�½f`w¾§H_AXB�¶7g \q\ s ·�v¹¸ ZCgHNJU3�58Mg9O>UR�>\9O7G7�5 � R�9Q3�58HNCc3�FG<�<�S�9O7G<�E]HNC63�LU<�¢T Zµ�¨�9O>?zNHNF�5A3�LDM»^��TFG<�5?M~9OC6<y3�9O>�v?s ��¥N°O§ b�5?7BD7G<�E]9Q7T9|S�9O7G<�R�>\9O7G7�5 � <�F�58Cg¢�@�¨Â¢�ª�µ�¼­vI2�CHNF�EU<�F*3�HW9�[NHN5?EgH�[N<�F � 3G3�5?CDz}E�9�3o9Us�3�LU<�M58CU58Mg9O>R�HO7G3G@4R�HNMJD>?<y�I5?3�epJDF�BUCD58CDz~Mg<y3�LDH E.587�BU7�<�E�v} �V 3�<�F�9]>89OF�zO<W3�FG<�<c5?7�R�HNCU7G3�FGBDR�3�<�E¡s­9~CU<�7G3�<�E7�< m BD<�CDR�<6HOV*7�BUSU3�FG<�<�7�5?7�HOSU3o9O5?CD<�EpS�e�JDFGHNzNFG<�7�7G5?[O<�>?e_ED<�>8<y3�58CUz~SDF�9OCDRoLD<�7|9OR�R�HNF�ED5?CDzg3�H~3�LU<JDFGBDCD58CUzcMg<y3�LDH E¡v*  � u�@rVXHN>8E]¢=¾º587�BD7G<�E,3�HcHNSI3o9O5?C,9OC&HNJU3�58Mg9O>�7G58h�<�HOV�3�F�<�<Ov*2�C,7�<�>8<�Ry3�5?CDz3�LU<_7GBDSU3�F�<�<&;05A3�LK3�LD<,7GM~9O>?>8<�7G3c<�7G3�5?M~9�3�<�E¶¢=¾ <�F�F�HOF�s�;T<,BD7G<_3�LD< � @n�Iª½F�BD>?<�^��=F�<�5?M~9QC<�3g9O>�v?s ��¥O°O§ byvK2�Ck9�S�9O7G<,3�F�<�<_HQV�¢�@4¨û¢�ª�µ�¼­s�9�CUHIED<,EDH <�76CDHQ3g7GJD>85A369OCDEk587cEU<�R�>89OF�<�E9]3�<�F�M58C�9O>�CDH ED<c5?V�3�LU<CUHIED<6R�HNC�3o9O5?CD7|9&7�9OMJD>8<}58C�HNCD>AejHNCD<cR�>\9O7G7�s$HNF�3�LD<c7�JD>?5?3�R�9OBD7G<�79pRoLU58>8E®CDH ED<gLD9�[ 5?CDz.9p7�9OMJD>8<67�5?h�<g>8<�7G7W3�L�9OCK� v_¨�LU<~<�C�3�58F�<]¢�@�¨¿¢�ª�µ�¼º9Q>8zNHNFG5?3�LDM¹5?758MJD>?<�M<�C�3�<�E®5?C�¢Zv­¨�LD<~SD9O7�<~3�F�<�<g5?7W5?MgJD>?<�M<�C�3�<�E®5?CK¢Zs­9OCDE®3�LD<gF�<�7GBD>?3�7WMg9Q3�RoL®;05?3�L¿ÀLÁC¿E ^a¨�LD<�F�CD<�9OBf9QCDE® �3�¤�58CD7GHNC¡s ��¥N¥�¦ b�;0LD58RoL{587�S�9Q7�<�E{HNC�3�LD<g¢T Zµ�¨½M<�3�LDHIEUHN>8HNzQe�5?C

¥

Page 11: AWAXB YZP[Uhahn/research/CERP/papCERP.pdf$- ./ ! 0 +( 1#324 57678&9:; + ! ) ? @3ACB DCEGFHJILKMFB1N OQPR@3A STH/BVU AWAXB YZP[U \^]/H_EGET`ba[cRd>` efef` ghH NiP[j3AXF

3�LU<WµÄJ�9ORo¤�9OzN<|>85?SDF�9QFGeNv

³ cOà k�vĵC¶ s ·�v¹¸»º[k�ACDCH_Ex¾§Hh½�vw\qDCg \qETE§H_AXB�¶7g \q\ s ·�v¹¸ Z7,9QC¸9O>?3�<�F�CD9Q3�5A[N<.9OJUJDF�H�9QRoL¸3�Hk¢�@�¨Ó¢�ª�µ�¼­s�;T<.EU<�[N<�>8HNJl<�EÄÃ$µ�@4¨Ó¢�ª�µ�¼�vT ë>8HNzO587G3�58RF�<�zNF�<�7�7G58HNC¸MHIED<�>ZFG< m BD58FG<�7,9f[Q9OFG5\9OSD>?<�7G<�>8<�R�3�58HNC�5AV�3�LD<.C�BDM:Sl<�F&HQVWJUF�<�EU58R�3�HNF�7~<y�IR�<�<�ED73�LU<}7�9QMgJD>?<|7�58h�<Ov�2�C.Ã$µ�@�¨�¢�ª�µ�¼�slLDH�;=<�[N<�F�s�[Q9OFG5\9OSU>8<|7�<�>8<�Ry3�5?HNCp5?7�CUHO3ZFG< m BD5?F�<�E�S�<�R�9OBD7G<<�9QRoL{3�F�<�<65?7�R�HNCD7n3�FGBDR�3�<�E®VXFGHNMë9&7GM~9O>?>�7GBDSD7�JD9OR�<gHOV�3�LD<6JDFG<�ED5?R�3�HOF�[O9QF�5\9QSD>8<�7�BDCD>?<�7�7|3�LU<7�9QMgJD>?<�7�5?h�<�5?C69Z3�<�FGMg5?C�9O>ICDHIEU<�587�[O<�FGe:7�Mg9O>8>�v���HNF�LD58zNL @�ED5?Mg<�CD7�5?HNC�9O>�E�9Q3�9UsN3�LU587(5?7�9�L BUzN<9OEU[Q9OC�3�9OzN<TH�[O<�F(HO3�LD<�F�Mg<y3�LDH ED7�S�9O7�<�EcHNC:>?HNzN587n3�5?R�FG<�zNFG<�7G7�58HOC:MgH ED<�>87�v���9O7G<T3�FG<�<�7(HOV�Ã$µ�@�¨¢�ª�µ�¼K9QF�<�R�HNCD7n3�FGBDR�3�<�E]BD7G58CDz ¿ÀLÁC¿E 5?C3�LD<�µÂJ�9ORo¤�9OzN<�>85?SDF�9OFneNv­ �3T<�9ORoL~3�<�F�M58CD9O>DCDH ED<0HOV3�LU<�JDF�BDCU<�E6S�9O7G<�3�F�<�<�7*5?C6íµ�@�¨¶¢�ª�µ�¼�sO;=< � 3(3�LD<�VXBD>8>I>8HNzO587G3�58R�F�<�zNF�<�7�7G58HNC6MHIED<�>I;05A3�L:3�LU<zN5A[N<�C�7GBDSD7�<y3|HOV�JDF�<�ED58Ry3�HNFG7�58Cj<�9ORoL{7�BDSD7G<�3xHOV�3�LU<:F�9OCUEDHNM¹JD9OFG3�5?3�5?HNC¡v�±®<:58MJD>?<�M<�C�3�<�E3�LU<�<�C�3�5?F�<�9Q>8zNHNFG5?3�LDMÈHOV­Ã$µ�@4¨Ä¢�ª�µ�¼¶5?C&µ|vU �CDH ED<�HQV­9:S�9O7�<�3�F�<�<�EDH <�7�CDHQ3�7�JD>?5?3T9OCDE&5?7ED<�R�>\9QF�<�E,3�<�F�M58C�9Q>¡5?V­3�LD<|7�9OMgJU>8<|7�5?h�<|5870>8<�7�7�3�LD9OCjtQuUv=24V�3�LD<|7�9OMgJU>8<�7�5?h�<~^aÀ�Åab�58707�Mg9O>8>?<�F3�LD9OC6HNF�< m B�9O>D3�H|3�LD<0C�BDM:Sl<�F�HOVlJDF�<�ED58Ry3�HNFG7�^a`�Å�b�58C9�3�<�F�M58C�9Q>UCDH ED<ÇÆwsN3�LD<�C~9|BDCD5A[Q9OF�589Q3�<>8HOzN587n3�58RF�<�zNF�<�7�7G58HNCPMHIED<�>�587 � 3c;05?3�LK<�9ORoLkJDF�<�ED58Ry3�HNF�s�9OCDEK3�LD<&À�Å � t�JDFG<�ED5?R�3�HOF�7:;05?3�L3�LU<c7�Mg9O>8>?<�7G3ZED<�[ 589OCDR�<�7�JD>8BU7�3�LD<:5?C�3�<�FGR�<�JU3�3�<�F�Më9QF�<c58CUR�>8BUED<�E.5?C�3�LD<cMH ED<�>�vW·�H�;T<y[N<�F�s;=<_HOSD7�<�FG[N<�E¶3�L�9Q3c3�LU<_7�9OMJD>8<]7G58h�<,;T9O76>\9QF�zN<�F}3�L�9QCP3�LD<&C�BDM:Sl<�F6HOV�JDF�<�ED58Ry3�HNFG7c58CK3�LU<3�<�F�M58C�9Q>�CDH ED<|MgHO7G30HOV­3�LD<�3�58M<Ov

2�CpHOF�ED<�F�3�H658MJDF�H�[O<|96SD9O>\9OCUR�<�Sl<�3�;=<�<�Cp7�<�CD7�5A3�5?[ 5A3�e,9OCDE,7�Jl<�R�5 � R�5?3�eOsD3�;THg9OJDJDFGH�9ORoLD<�7L�9�[N<WS�<�<�C.9�3�3�<�MgJI3�<�EpS�epFG<�7G<�9OFGRoLD<�FG7�v�¼�9Oh�h�9OCD5­<�3Z9O>rv­^ ��¥N¥O§ b09QCDEj²�HNM58CUzNHN7x^ ��¥N¥N¥ b�9O7 @7�5?zNCD<�Ef9&LD5?zNL�R�HN7n3x3�H,Mg5?7�R�>89O7�7G5 � R�9Q3�5?HNCjHOV�3�LU<M58CUHNF�5A3�epR�>\9O7G7�s­9OCDEf¢TLD<�Cf<�3W9O>�v*^�tOuNu��NbJDFGHNJ�HO7�<�EÂ9OCÂ<�CU7�<�M}SD>8<pR�>\9Q7�7�5 � <�FS�edSUBD58>?ED58CDz�S�9Q7�<jR�>\9O7G7�5 � <�F�7;05?3�LdS�9O>89OCDR�<�Ed7�9OMJD>8<�7BD7G58CDzcFG<�7�9QMgJD>?58CDzW3�<�RoLUCD5 m BD<�7�v�2�CpÃ$µ�@�¨Ä¢�ª�µ�¼­s�9OC,HNJU3�58Mg9O>�ED<�R�587G58HNC]3�LDF�<�7�LDHN>?E&VXHNF�R�>89O7n@7�5 � R�9�3�58HOC}587­7�<�9OF�RoLU<�Ec58Cx3�LD<TS�9O7�<=R�>89O7�7G5 � <�F�7�5?CW3�LD<=3�F�9O5?CD58CDz�JDL�9Q7�<Ov�¨�LD587�9OJDJDFGH�9ORoL:7GL�9OF�<�73�LU<�7�9OMg<�JDFG58CDR�58JD>?<09O7�3�LD<�Mg<y3�LDH ED7�S�e~¼�9Oh�h�9OCD5l<�3T9O>rv�^ ��¥N¥Q§ b*9OCDEg²�HNMg5?CDzNHN7�^ ��¥N¥N¥ byv�2�C @7G3�<�9OEpHOV�963�LDF�<�7�LDHN>?EpHQVTvÖ�Is�9cLD58zOLpM587GR�>\9Q7�7�5 � R�9�3�58HOC]R�HN7n3�M~9�e&Sl<x9O7�7G58zNCD<�EpS�e,BD7G58CDz63�LU<F�9�3�<cHOV�3�LU<cJ�HN7G5?3�5?[N<}F�<�7GJ�HOCD7�<�7W5?Cj3�LD<cE�9�3o9&9O7|9~3�LDF�<�7�LDHN>?E¡vW±¸LU<�C�È~587�3�LD<cF�9�3�<:HOV�3�LU<

� u

Page 12: AWAXB YZP[Uhahn/research/CERP/papCERP.pdf$- ./ ! 0 +( 1#324 57678&9:; + ! ) ? @3ACB DCEGFHJILKMFB1N OQPR@3A STH/BVU AWAXB YZP[U \^]/H_EGET`ba[cRd>` efef` ghH NiP[j3AXF

JlHN7�5A3�5?[O<}FG<�7�JlHNCD7G<�7�s$;=<cR�>89O7�7G5?V e�9~7�9QMgJD>?<:9O7 � 5?V*3�LU< � 3�3�<�E.[Q9O>8BU<}587Z>\9OFGzN<�F03�L�9QCÉÈIs�9QCDER�>89O7�7G5?V e{5?3}9O7cupHO3�LD<�FG;05?7�<Ov.¨�LU<]F�9Q3�<~HOV�3�LD<]JlHN7�5A3�5A[N<~FG<�7GJ�HNCU7�<�7c5?7}CDHQ3cCD<�R�<�7G7�9OFG58>?e{3�LU<HNJU3�58Mg9O>�RoLUHN58R�<xHQV�3�LU<|3�LDF�<�7�LDHO>8E_58C&3�<�F�M7�HQV�S�9Q>\9OCDR�58CDzc7G<�CD7G5?3�5?[ 5?3�e,9QCDEp7GJ�<�R�5 � R�5A3�eNv�¨�LD<HNJU3�58Mg9O>�3�LDF�<�7�LDHN>?E�BD7GB�9O>?>?e&>?58<�70Sl<�3�;=<�<�C�uUvÕ�69OCDE_3�LD<WF�9Q3�<|HOV(3�LU<WJlHN7�5A3�5A[N<|F�<�7�JlHNCD7�<�7�v�2�C3�LU587|7G3�BDEUeNs$;=<gHNSU7�<�Fn[N<�Ef3�L�9�3x3�LD<RoLDHN58R�<6HOV�9]3�LUF�<�7GLDHN>?EfED5?E{CUHO3W9Q©�<�R�3|3�LU<gS�9Q>\9OCDR�<cHOV¢�@�¨Æ¢�ª�µ�¼¶7�58zOCD5 � R�9OC�3�>AeNv*·�H¬;=<�[O<�F�s�;=<�VXHNBDCDE_9c7�BUSD7G3�9OC�3�5\9Q>¡58MJDF�H�[O<�M<�C�3�58C,S�9Q>\9OCDR�58CDz7�<�CD7�5A3�5A[I5A3�eK9OCUEk7GJ�<�R�5 � R�5A3�e�VXHNFcÃ$µ�@�¨î¢�ª�µ�¼½BD7G58CDz{9.ED5A©�<�F�<�C�3c3�LDF�<�7�LDHN>?EKVXF�HNM uUvÕ�pVXHOFBDC�S�9O>89OCDR�<�E_E�9Q3o9Iv

¨�Hx7�<�9OF�RoL3�LD<�HNJU3�58Mg9O>I3�LDF�<�7�LDHO>8EHOV¡Ã$µ�@�¨d¢�ª�µ�¼­sI9|CD<�7G3�<�E � u¬@4VXHN>?E¢=¾Ä5?7*J�<�FGVXHNFGMg<�E58C_<�9QRoLj>8<�9OF�CD5?CDz67�<y3ËÊ(ê4slì*ñ � ÷ '� ÷ � ug9Q7�VXHN>?>8H�;07�³�±¸5?3�LD58C�Ê(ê4s�;=<}BD7G<:9 � CD5?3�<xzOF�58E,;05?3�L58CUR�F�<�Mg<�C�3�HQV(uUvØu � Sl<�3�;=<�<�C�uUvÖ�69QCDE�È v

� v��=e.9OJDJD>AeI5?CDz,<�9ORoL®HOV�3�LD<c3�LUF�<�7GLDHN>?ED7�Æ ~�Ì sgÆ ~EÌ ñ£u �OuU÷�u � � ÷ �� ÷ È.^aHNFËÆ ~�Ì ñÍÈ�÷-È�øu u � ÷ �� ÷ou §�¥ ÷ou �Ou�bws�R�HOCDEDBDRy3­3�LD<(VXHN>?>8H�;058CDz � u�@rVXHN>8E|¢=¾}³¬¢THNCD7n3�FGBDR�3�9OCxÃ$µ�@4¨®¢�ª�µ�¼R�>\9O7G7�5 � <�F|;05?3�L®HNCD<g<�CD7G<�M:SD>?<~5?C®<�9ORoLKHOV�3�LD<~>?<�9OFGCD58CDz,7�9OMgJU>8<�7!Ê(ê8öy÷ �' ÷�Ê(êXÎ önÏc9QCDE<y[O9Q>8B�9Q3�<�3�LD<x9OR�R�BDF�9OR�e,BU7�58CUz63�LD<|R�HNFGF�<�7�JlHNCDED5?CDzc3�<�7n3Z7�9OMJD>8<�7�;05?3�L Æ ~�Ì v

tIv�¢TLDH HN7G<Z3�LD<�3�LDFG<�7�LUHN>8E~;05A3�L~3�LD<�LD5?zNLD<�7G3�JUF�<�EU58R�3�58HNC]9OR�R�BDF�9ORyegVXFGHNM�J�9OFn3 � s 7�9�e"Æ ~ ê4v´ v0 �JDJD>?e¬Æ ~ ê­3�H3�LD<�3�<�7G3�7�9OMJD>?<�R�HNFGF�<�7GJ�HOCDED58CUz63�HÐÊ*ê4vÑ CD>?eWHNCD<T<�CD7G<�M:SD>?<�587�BD7�<�E5?C}3�LU587(CD<�7G3�<�Eg¢=¾¸S�<�R�9OBU7�<�HOV�3�LD<�3�<�CDED<�CUR�e:3�L�9Q3�3�LD<�HNJU3�58Mg9O>

3�LUF�<�7GLDHN>?E_VXHNF0Ã$µ�@�¨Æ¢�ª�µ�¼d5?707�58M58>89OF�VXHNF�HNCD<|HNF�M:BU>?3�5?JD>8<�<�CD7G<�M:SU>8<�7�v

Ò ÚÔÓp1�â�%*1�#jç à£á�Ü}â(â(1%�{/0ÜW%(1�)# Ü:#.+ ã½'*Ý�+.1�/�%*1�)g# è ÝZ%(Ûj),+.â

Õ c`´ vwdÖºRvw`.B�u�ACm d>ACg \qEx¾µ��Ä587}9�[O9Q58>\9QSD>8<69O7}9pJ�9QRo¤Q9QzN<�^O× ÁCØ�ÙxÚÜÛÞÝlÚÜ¿ ß�à� bZ5?C�µ|v�¨�LD<~C BUM:S�<�F}HOVT3�F�<�<�7:zO<�CD<�F�9Q3�<�EMg9�ef[O9QFGe�BU7�58CUz{3�LD< ØVÂ�¿ ß�ß HOJU3�5?HNCK58Ckµ|s*SDBU35?36L�9Q7Sl<�<�C¶7GLDH�;0C¶3�H{;=HNF�¤®;T<�>8>09Q363�LU<ED<yVa9OBD>?30HQV(À�ÆjÈ�á�á�ñ��QuNuUv*¾�9OF�5?HNBD7�[Q9O>8BU<�70HOV�À�ÆjÈ�á�á}L�9�[N<xS�<�<�Cp<y�U9OM58CD<�E_VXHNF09Q>8>¡E�9�3o967�<�3�7;=<cR�HNCD7G58ED<�F�<�E¡s$SDBU3�CDH&5?MgJUF�H�[N<�Mg<�C�3�L�9O7�Sl<�<�C�HNSU7�<�Fn[N<�E®S�ej5?CDR�FG<�9O7G58CDz&5A3�Sl<�eOHNCDEf�OuNuUv

�N�

Page 13: AWAXB YZP[Uhahn/research/CERP/papCERP.pdf$- ./ ! 0 +( 1#324 57678&9:; + ! ) ? @3ACB DCEGFHJILKMFB1N OQPR@3A STH/BVU AWAXB YZP[U \^]/H_EGET`ba[cRd>` efef` ghH NiP[j3AXF

¨�LD<�À�ÆjÈCá�áZ[Q9O>?BD<0;05?3�Lg3�LD<�S�<�7G3�9QR�R�BUF�9ORye~5?7TJDFG<�7�<�C�3�<�E,5?Cg3�LU587�R�HNMJ�9OFG587�HOC¡v(¨�LD<�C�BDM}S�<�FHOV(VX<�9Q3�BUF�<�7�7�<�>8<�Ry3�<�E.F�9OCDEUHNMg>Ae,9Q3�<�9ORoL.CUHIED<WM~9�e_9O>?7�HS�<x[Q9OF�5?<�E¡�lLDH�;T<y[N<�F�s¡3�LU<}ED<yVa9OBD>?3[Q9O>8BU<�HOV�` ö�â� ^aHOFäã�HIHOF�^a` ö�â� b=VXHOF�9cCDHNCD5?C�3�<�zN<�F�[O9Q>8BD<�b=7�<�<�M7�3�HLD9�[O<|R�HNCD7G587n3�<�C�3�>?e&zNH H EF�<�7�BD>A3�79OR�F�HN7G7Mg9OC�e�<w�U9OMgJU>8<�769QR�R�HOF�ED5?CDz.3�H�HNBDF:3�<�7G36;05A3�L�[Q9OF�5?HNBD7cRoLDHO58R�<�7�vK¨�LD<pµ��JDFGHNzNF�9QMî58C&3�LD<xµÆJ�9ORo¤�9OzN<�;05A3�L,3�LD<|Sl<�7G3�HNJI3�58HOCD709OF�<�BU7�<�Ep58C,HNBDF�R�HNMJ�9OF�5?7�HNC�v

Õ cOà å�æ�U ºÞå�ç�x�x)ACgL¾èæñ\é½Z¾§A?gwU `)½-F�HJB�\qE¨�LD<0��¾|q£JDFGHNzNF�9OMÑ58C:µKBD7G58CDz�3�LD< ß'êxë�ì:ê J�9ORo¤�9OzN<T587­BD7�<�Ec58CW3�LD<TR�HNMJ�9OF�5?7�HNC�v(�IHOMg<=R�9OFG<CD<�<�ED7�3�H}Sl<Z3o9O¤Q<�C];05A3�L~FG<�7GJ�<�R�3�3�Hx3�LD<ZRoLDHN58R�<ZHOV$¤Q<�FGCD<�>�^ ;T<Z<y�U9OM58CD<�E~>85?CD<�9QFT9OCUE]F�9OEU5\9O>S�9O7G587|BD7G58CDz,ED<yVa9OBD>?3|JD9OF�9OM<�3�<�FG7ob�9O7�;=<�>8>�9Q7|3�LD<6J�9OF�9OMg<y3�<�F�7�VXHNF�3�LU<�7�<63�F�9OCD7nVXHNF�Mg9Q3�5?HNCD77�BURoLj9O70¤O<�F�CD<�>�;058CDEDH�;07�v

Õ c ³ í A�A?Ex¾§HJB�D�U \«¾§F�AWu�E¨�LD<�µ��TH HN7G3�58CDz|J�9ORo¤�9OzO<:^`î Ú�Ú�à� b(R�HOC�3�9O58CU7�VXHNBUF�EU5?©�<�F�<�C�3T9QJDJDF�HN9ORoLD<�7�³* ZE�9O�THIHO7G3�s Ã�HNzN5A3G@�TH HN7G3�sNítO�TH HN7n3*9OCDE:��9Oz��TH HN7n3�v�Ã$HOzN5?3��THIHO7G3­J�<�FGVXHNFGMg7­7�>?58zNL�3�>?e|Sl<�3�3�<�F­3�L�9OC} ZE�9N�=HIHN7n3(5?CzN<�CD<�F�9O>�58Cg9x[Q9OF�5?<�3�e6HOV�3�F�9OED5?3�58HNCD9O>UR�>\9O7G7�5 � R�9Q3�58HNCJDF�HOSD>8<�Mg7�9OCDEgMg5?R�FGH�9OF�F�9�e:zN<�CD<Z<w�UJUF�<�7 @7�5?HNC:E�9�3o96^�²�<y3�3�>858CUz�9OCDE6�=BDLD>8Mg9OC¡sNtOuNu ´ byv��I58CDR�<���9OzN�THIHO7G3*R�HNCDEDBDRy3�7*FG<�Jl<�9Q3�<�E6S�9OzNzO58CDzN758C]9OEDED5A3�58HOCg3�H6�=HIHN7n3�5?CDzDs 5?3�5?7�MHNF�<�R�HNMJDBU3�<�Fn@458C�3�<�CD7�5A[N<�3�L�9OC]3�LU<�HO3�LU<�FT3�LDF�<�<�Mg<y3�LDH ED7�v�I5?CDR�<WÃ�HNzN5?3��TH HN7G3�s�Ã�tQ�THIHO7G3�9OCDE.�T9Oz��TH HN7G3�z�9�[O<}7�5?Mg5?>\9OFTF�<�7GBD>?3�7�s�;T<W58CDR�>8BDEU<x �E�9N�TH HN7n39OCDE]Ã$HOzN5?3��THIHO7G3=58Cg3�LD<�R�HNMgJD9OF�5?7�HNC¡v�¨�LD<�7G<|µÄ�=HIHN7n3�5?CDz}JDFGHNzNF�9OMg7=BD7�<�3�LD<�R�>\9Q7�7�5 � R�9�3�58HOC3�FG<�<�^ ¿ÀLÁC¿E b�;05?3�L:9�7�5?CDzN>?<=7GJD>85A3�9Q7�3�LU<�S�9O7G<TR�>89O7�7G5 � <�F�v�¨�LD<�C�BDM:Sl<�F�HOV�SlHIHN7n3�5?CDz�5A3�<�F�9Q3�58HNCD7BD7G<�Ep;T9O7 � uNu_^ ÛäïðØ�ÁCñ ñ � uNu�bwv

Õ c Õ IWj3jͺóò«µoj3\q`�g \qEx¾wj3\^H_DXF�ô)A?g¡s ]_`�EGEGHj¼[\qg E¨�LD<|µ ¤I����J�9ORo¤�9OzN<^ õ ñöÁÜà�à b�5?7�BD7�<�Ep5?C~3�LU587�R�HNMgJD9OF�5?7�HNC¡v(��HO>8>8H�;05?CDzW3�LD<�M<�3�LUHIE&HOV�²�BI@EDHN5A3*<�3=9O>�v�^rtQuNu�tNbwsO;T<�BD7G<�E63�LD<0F�9�3�58H�HQV�Sl<�3�;=<�<�C]zNF�HOBDJc3�H|;05?3�LU58CczNFGHNBDJ67�BDM7�HOV�7 m B�9OFG<�7^���± F�9Q3�5?H�b$VXHOF(<�9ORoLcVX<�9Q3�BDFG<09OCDEcFG<�3o9Q58C:3�LUHN7�<�;05A3�L:3�LU<�LD58zOLD<�7n3�F�9Q3�58HDv Ñ JU3�5?M~9O>�C�BDM:Sl<�FG7HOV�JUF�<�EU58R�3�HNF|[O9QF�5\9QSD>8<�7]^ ílbx9QCDE®3�LD<g[Q9O>?BD<gHQV�Ì®58C{3�LD<gCD<�9QF�<�7n3:CD<�58zNL�SlHNF|;T<�F�<]7G<�9OFGRoLD<�E

� t

Page 14: AWAXB YZP[Uhahn/research/CERP/papCERP.pdf$- ./ ! 0 +( 1#324 57678&9:; + ! ) ? @3ACB DCEGFHJILKMFB1N OQPR@3A STH/BVU AWAXB YZP[U \^]/H_EGET`ba[cRd>` efef` ghH NiP[j3AXF

58C,3�LU<x3�F�9O5?CD58CDz6JDLD9O7�<xBD7�5?CDz~CU<�7G3�<�E�¢=¾}vl¼�9O5?F�7�HOV0^ í�÷wÌDbT;05?3�L_3�LD<xLD58zNLU<�7G3Z9OR�R�BDF�9OR�e,;T9O7RoLDHN7G<�Cj5?C,<�9ORoLp>8<�9QF�CD5?CDz67�<�3�v���HNF*í�sD;=<W5?CDR�>?BDED<�E_3�LD<x[Q9O>?BD<�70HOVlí�;05A3�L,58CUR�F�<�Mg<�C�3ZHOV � uUs7G3�9OFG3�58CDz];05A3�L � uUv}��HNF�3�LD<cHOJU3�5?M~9O>�í�VXHNBDCDE�s$3�LD<cSl<�7G30í�[Q9OF�589OSD>?<�7�;=<�FG<g7G<�>?<�R�3�<�E{S�9O7G<�EHNC,F�9QCD¤�58CDz6HOV�3�LD<x�=± F�9Q3�58HDv

Õ cO÷ k�H/B�\q`�gùø¡H_EL½fghHJm HJB�`.Bú¾ÀKMB�`.]jû�EGHJEýü�kóøwKÿþ¨�LD<�F�<x9OF�<�[Q9OFG58HNBD7=VXHNF�M7�HOV�Ã$²� Wv�2�C_HOBDF�R�HNMJ�9OFG587GHNC¡sU3�LD<|µÆJ�9ORo¤�9OzO<�7W^ à�ÛÐÁ VXHNF0²�Ã$²� 9OCDE ÛÐÁÜà�à VXHNF��(Ã$²� �b�9OF�<WBD7�<�E¡s¡9OCUEp3�LU<:�=± F�9Q3�5?H5?7�BU7�<�E.5?C_3�LD<W[Q9OFG5\9OSU>8<|7�<�>8<�Ry3�5?HNC�5?C>8<�9OF�CU58CDz7�<y3�7�v� �7�ED<�7�R�FG58Sl<�Ej5?C��I<�R�3�5?HNC § v § slHNJU3�58Mg9O>�C�BDM:Sl<�F�HOV�JUF�<�EU58R�3�HNF�7�58C_3�<�FGMg7�HOV9OR�R�BDF�9OR�e_58707G<�>8<�R�3�<�EjBD7G58CDz63�LU<}�=± F�9Q3�58H658C_>8<�9OF�CD5?CDz67�<y3�7ZBU7�58CUzgCD<�7G3�<�E{¢=¾:v�±¸LD<�C�3�LU<C�BDM:Sl<�F�HOV�VX<�9Q3�BUF�<�7�<y�IR�<�<�ED7�3�LD<x7�9OMJD>?<x7G58h�<Os�3�LD<xR�H�[Q9OFG5\9OCDR�<WMg9Q3�F�5A�]58Cp�(Ã$²� Ç;05?>8>¡CDHQ3L�9�[N<0VXBD>?>DF�9OCU¤ls 9OCUE3�L BU7�5A3�R�9OCUCDHO3�S�<�5?C�[N<�Fn3�<�E¡v* ¸JD7�<�BDEDH}5?C�[N<�FG7�<�587*BD7G<�Eg58CD7n3�<�9QEHQV�3�LU<BD7GB�9O>*Mg9Q3�FG5A��58C�[N<�F�7�<58Cj3�LD587�R�9O7�<Qv6¨�LD<~µºVXBDCDR�3�58HNC ñöÙFÁ BD7�<�7�3�F�BUCDR�9Q3�<�E®7�58CUzNBD>\9QFZ[Q9O>8BD<ED<�R�HNMJ�HO7�5?3�58HNC�v

Õ c�� å�F�g]ç�B�IC\^B=s \^Bú¾§g ACHJu ü:å�sÄþ¨�LD<Tµk7GHOV 3�;�9QF�<TJD9ORo¤�9OzN<�^ ÀLÁCÛ ¿ b$HOV��D¢�^a¨�5?SD7�LD5?F�9OCU5 <y3*9O>�v?sOtOuNuNtNb�;05?3�L}9�7GHOV 3�3�LDF�<�7�LDHN>?ED58CUzHNJU3�58HNCc5?7*BD7�<�Eg5?C6HNBDF*R�HOMgJ�9QF�587GHNC¡v­ Z7�ED<�7�R�FG58Sl<�E58C�I<�R�3�58HNCD7 § v § s�9OCUE § vÕ�IsN;=<0J�<�FGVXHNFGMg<�E[Q9OF�589OSD>?<�7�<�>8<�Ry3�5?HNC,BD7�5?CDz�=± F�9Q3�5?Hc58C,>8<�9OF�CD5?CDzc7�<y3�70VXHNF�<�9QRoLpE�9�3o9Uv

Õ c�� å�H/B�DC]_\��rx�¾§H/ml`.]"¶�g \^\qE¨�LD<WHNJU3�5?M~9Q>�3�FG<�<�7ZHNSU3o9Q58CD<�E_VXFGHNM�¢T �µ�¨Ñ9QCDE.Í�ËZª��I¨º9O>?zNHNFG5?3�LUMg7�9QF�<x58CDR�>8BDED<�E�5?Cp3�LU<R�HOMgJ�9QF�587GHNC¡v �7�58CUzN>8<g¢T �µ�¨½3�FG<�<587|SDBD5?>?3x9O7|ED<�7�R�FG58Sl<�E®58Cf�I<�Ry3�58HOC ´ v � v±f<BD7�<�Ef3�LU<R�>89O7�7G5 � R�9Q3�5?HNCp3�F�<�<cJDF�HNzOF�9OM 58CUR�>8BUED<�E.5?C�3�LD<c¢�@�¨½¢�ª�µ�¼¸JDF�HNzOF�9OM 3�H]SUBD58>?E.9OC.HNJU3�58Mg9O>¢T �µ�¨£3�FG<�<Qv¶2�C¶R�HNC�3�F�9O7G363�H{3�LD<,<y�IL�9OBD7n3�5A[N<_7�<�9QF�RoLdM<�3�LDH E¶HOV�¢T �µ�¨�sTÍ�Ë�ª=� ¨îBD7G<�79�ED5?7�R�FG58M58C�9QC�3n@�S�9Q7�<�E¶JDF�H R�<�EDBDFG<jVXHNF~7GJD>85A3�3�5?CDzDvÑÍ�Ë�ª=� ¨ÓR�9OC�BD7�<.>?58CD<�9OFR�HNM:SU58C�9Q3�58HNC7�JU>85?3�7�58C�HNF�ED<�FZ3�H,9QRoLD58<y[N<6z�9O5?CD7Z5?C.R�>\9Q7�7�5 � R�9�3�58HOC.9OR�R�BDF�9QR�ejH�[O<�F�BDCD5A[Q9OF�589Q3�<W7�JD>?5?3�7�v|¨�LD<SD5?C�9OFGeP<w�I<�R�BI3o9OSD>?<�5?7gHNSI3o9O5?CD<�EPVXF�HNM�L�3G3�J¡³ÖÔNÔ�;�;�;|vÏ7G3�9Q3�v ;0587GROvÏ<�EDB�ÔO×|>?HNL�Ô m BD<�7G3�vÏL�3�M>rvÄ 

��´

Page 15: AWAXB YZP[Uhahn/research/CERP/papCERP.pdf$- ./ ! 0 +( 1#324 57678&9:; + ! ) ? @3ACB DCEGFHJILKMFB1N OQPR@3A STH/BVU AWAXB YZP[U \^]/H_EGET`ba[cRd>` efef` ghH NiP[j3AXF

7�LU<�>8>�JDFGHNzNF�9OMë587|ED<y[N<�>8HNJl<�E{3�H_R�HNCDEUBDR�3ctOu�¢=¾Z7WBU7�58CUz_3�LD587x<y�I<�R�BU3o9QSD>8<JDF�HOzNF�9OM_v¨�LD<>85?CD<�9QF�R�HNM:SD5?C�9Q3�5?HNC}7GJD>85A3(HNJI3�58HOC:587(BU7�<�E�v(243*587�¤ CUH¬;0Cc3�H�J�<�FGVXHNFGM�Sl<�3G3�<�F�3�L�9OC:3�LD<�ED<yVa9OBD>?3HNJU3�58HNC&HQV(BDCD5A[Q9OF�589Q3�<�7GJD>85A3�58C,zN<�CD<�F�9O>rv(±®<|BD7�<�E_3�LD<|ED<�Va9QBD>?3�70VXHOF�3�LD<|HO3�LD<�F�HNJI3�58HOCD7�v

� �YÜW%�Ü �&ÝZ%(â

÷"c`´ %u�\^B侧HO¼�½f`w¾ H_AXB A��Ûm x�ghHJBä¾G\qu� ¾\�B�\qE2�MJDF�5?C�3�<�ExzN<�CU<�7�zO5?[N<�F�5?7�<*3�H�C�BDMg<�F�HNBU7�L�BDMg9OC}EU587�<�9O7�<�7�^aµ�<�58¤�9OCUEW±f9O>?3�<�F�sOtOuNu � byv$¨�LD<�7�<zN<�CD<�7�9OF�<�BDC�BD7�BD9O>8>Ae�JDF�<�ED587GJ�HO7�<�EW3�H�R�9OBD7G58CDzZ9�EU587�<�9O7�<=S�<�R�9OBU7�<THQVU3�LU<=7G58>8<�CDR�5?CDz0HOV�<w�UJUF�<�7 @7�5?HNC:HOVDHNCD<�HOVU3�LD<T3�;=H�LDHNMHN>?HNzNBD<�7�9�3*9OC:5?MgJUF�58C�3�<�E}>?HIR�BD7�sQF�< m BU58F�5?CDzZHOCD>?exLD<y3�<�FGHNh�e zNHO7�5?3�eVXHNFx9pM}BU3o9Q3�58HNC{9Q©�<�Ry3�5?CDzp3�LD<~9QR�3�5A[N<g9O>8>?<�>?<:3�H�R�9OBD7G<~R�HOMgJD>?<�3�<>?HN7�7xHOVTzN<�CD<g<y�IJDFG<�7�7G58HNC�v Z7�3�LD<|J�9Q3�3�<�FGC_HQV�7G58>8<�CDR�5?CDzcF�<�ã�<�Ry3�703�LD<|z�9QMg<y3�58R�HNF�5?zN58C~HOV�3�LD<|zN<�CU<OsD3�LU<xzN9OMg<y3�<�5?7�7�9O5?E3�H&5?MgJUF�58C�3�3�LD<c>?HIR�BD7�;05A3�L�9]M<�MHNFGepHOV�5A3�7�HNFG58zN5?C¡v|Ð�F�<�9O>8>Ae�^�tOuNu�tOb�ED<�7�R�FG58Sl<�E.3�LU< � F�7n3RoL�9OF�9OR�3�<�FG587G3�58R�7G< m BD<�CUR�<}JD9OF�9OM<�3�<�F�3�L�9Q30ED5?7�R�FG58M58C�9�3�<�7=58MJDF�5?C�3�<�E&FG<�zN5?HNCD7 � 9cJ�9OBUR�5?3�e~HOV7�LUHNFG3�58C�3�<�F�7GJ�<�F�7G<�Ep3�F�9OCU7�JlHN7�9OSU>8<�<�>?<�M<�C�3�7W^��I2 �Zª*7obwv

¨�LD<�zN<�CDHOMg5?R*E�9Q3o9�R�HN>8>?<�R�3�<�E|3�H07G3�BDEUe|5?MgJDFG58C�3�<�E�zN<�CU<�7$;T<�F�<=VXFGHNMÄ3�LD<�Ë�¢��D¢fÐ|<�CDHNM<�TFGH¬;07G<�F]^aL�3�3�J¡³ÕÔOÔQzN<�CUHNMg<QvØBUR�7�RQvØ<�EDB�ÔNbwvp �CDCDHO3�9Q3�5?HNC{E�9Q3o9&;=<�F�<~EDH�;0CD>8H�9QED<�E{VXHNF�3�LD<gL B @Mg9OCÆzN<�CDHNM<�^XLDz ��¯ s��OBU>?eÆtOuNu ´ VXF�<�<�h�<�byvÓ¨�LD<�E�9Q3�9¶R�HNC�3o9O5?C ��´U� 7�9OMJD>8<�7�9QCDE ��§N§N¯JDFG<�ED5?R�3�HOF�7�v¹ ZMHNCDz¶3�LD< ��´I� 7�9QMgJD>?<�7�s §N´ 9OF�<®58MJDF�5?C�3�<�EÆ9OCDE °O° 9OF�<®R�HNC�3�F�HN>WzN<�CD<�7^aCUHNCI@�5?MgJUF�58C�3�<�E�bwvº¨�LU<.R�BDFGF�<�C�3_E�9Q3�9�7�<y3pLD9O7&S�<�<�C¸Mg9OED<.9�[Q9O58>89OSD>?<pS�e��OHNLUCÆÐ�F�<�9O>8>Ae9Q30L�3�3�J¡³ÖÔNÔQzNFG<�9O>?>?e >\9OS�vÖ9O<�R�HNM_v eIB�vØ<�EDB�ÔN×�zNF�<�9O>8>AeUÔQ58MJDF�5?C�3�58CUz E�9Q3�9UvÏ3n� 3�v

÷"cOà s ]_`�EGEGHj¼�½f`w¾§H_AXB A� s AX]_ACB�¶ HJETE ç�\ å�`.m x�]_\qE¨�LD<�²��� dMg5?R�F�HN9OF�F�9�e|3�<�RoLDCDHO>8HNzOe}L�9O7*Sl<�<�C5?CDR�FG<�9O7G58CDzO>?eWBD7�<�E5?CcR�9OCUR�<�F�FG<�7�<�9OF�RoL�s�;0LU58RoL<�CD9OSD>8<�7�R�>89O7�7G5 � R�9Q3�5?HNC.HOV�3�5?7�7�BU<c7�9OMJD>8<�7�S�9O7G<�E�HNCD>AejHNC.zN<�CD<6<y�IJDFG<�7�7G58HNC{E�9Q3�9Us�;05A3�LDHNBI3JDFG58HNFc9QCDE¶HQV 3�<�CP7GBDS «G<�Ry3�5A[N<�SU58HN>?HNzN58R�9O>�¤�CDH�;0>8<�EUzN<�^�Ð|HO>8BDSK<y3~9Q>rvAs ��¥N¥N¥ �T²�BDEDHN5A3c<�3g9O>�v?stOuNuNtNbyv�Ð�<�CU<]<y�IJDFG<�7�7G58HNCP5?C § u�R�HN>8HNC�9OED<�CUHIR�9OF�R�58CDHNMg9_3�587G7�BD<&7�9OMgJU>8<�7}9OCDEktNt_CDHNF�Mg9O>R�HO>8HNC,3�5?7�7�BU<}7�9QMgJD>?<�70;�9Q7�9OC�9O>Ae h�<�E_;05?3�Lj9OCp �©leIM<�3�F�5ï�_HN>85?zNHNC�BDR�>?<�HO3�58ED<|9QF�F�9�e,R�HNMgJU>8<y@

��§

Page 16: AWAXB YZP[Uhahn/research/CERP/papCERP.pdf$- ./ ! 0 +( 1#324 57678&9:; + ! ) ? @3ACB DCEGFHJILKMFB1N OQPR@3A STH/BVU AWAXB YZP[U \^]/H_EGET`ba[cRd>` efef` ghH NiP[j3AXF

M<�C�3o9OFnep3�H]MHNF�<x3�L�9OC ¯ sÕ�OuOu~L�BDM~9QC.zN<�CD<�7^a �>8HNCj<y3|9O>�v?s ��¥N¥N¥ byv�¨�LD<cR�BDF�FG<�C�3|E�9Q3�9~7�<y3R�HOC�3�9O58CU7­3�LD<T<w�UJUF�<�7G7�5?HNCcHOVD3�LD<�tIsØuNuNu0zN<�CD<�7�;05A3�LWLD58zNLU<�7G3�M58CD5?M~9O>O58C�3�<�CD7�5A3�ex9OR�FGHN7�7�3�LD< ¯ t3�5?7�7GBD<�7�9OMJD>?<�7�v�¨�LD<�zNH�9Q>ILD<�F�<�5?7�3�H�R�>\9O7G7�5AV e}CD<y;dBUCD>\9OSl<�>?<�E}3�587G7�BD<�7�9OMgJU>8<�7�9O7*Sl<�58CUz�R�9OC @R�<�F�HNBU7�HNF�CDHNCDR�9OCDR�<�F�HNBU7�v�¨�LD<}E�9Q3o9g9OF�<}9�[O9Q58>\9QSD>8<|9Q3ZL�3�3�J�³ÕÔNÔ�Mg5?R�F�HN9OF�F�9�eOvØJUF�58CUR�<�3�HNC¡vÏ<�EDB�ÔHNCDR�HN>8HOzOeUÔO9Q©leIED9Q3o9�Ô�58CDED<w��vØL�3�M>rv

÷"c ³ s ]_`�EGEGHj¼�½f`w¾§H_AXB A� stF�\^m Hj½f`.]JE�½A?g¹· Ev¾§g A?D?\�B Kù½Z¾ H���HO¾Cû Æ>89OF�zO<�C�BDM:Sl<�F=HOV�<�C�[ 5?F�HNCDM<�C�3�9O>�RoLU<�M58R�9Q>87�¤ CUH¬;0C,9Q7T<�CUEDHIR�F�5?CD<y@4ED587GF�BDJU3�58CDzWRoLD<�M58R�9O>87^�ª�²|¢T7�bZ9OF�<W7�BD7GJ�<�R�3�<�E{HOV�ED587GF�BDJI3�58CUz]<�CDEUHIR�F�58CU<WVXBDCDRy3�5?HNCD7�S�epMg5?Mg5?Ro¤ 5?CDz6HNF�9QC�3�9OzNHNCU58hy@58CUzxCD9Q3�BDF�9O>�LDHNFGMgHOCD<�7�58Cg9OCD5?M~9Q>87(9QCDE~L�BDMg9OCD7�^�·�58>?<�Mg9OC¡s ��¥O¥�¦ byv�¨�LD<���¢T¨0µº^���9Q3�5?HNC�9O>¢T<�C�3�<�FcVXHNF}¨­H��I58R�HO>8HNzN5?R�9O>�µ0<�7G<�9OFGRoL�b:<�7G3�F�HNzO<�Ck9OR�3�5?[ 5?3�e{E�9�3o9j7�<y36R�HNCU7�587n3�7cHOV�t ´ t�7G3�F�BDRw@3�BUF�9O>?>?e&ED5A[N<�F�7�<}RoLD<�M58R�9O>87�v� �MgHNCUzg3�LU<�7�<ct ´ t7�9OMJD>8<�7�s ��´U� RoLU<�M58R�9Q>87�<y�ILD58SU5?3�<�7G3�F�HNzO<�CF�<�R�<�JU3�HNF�SD58CDEU58CDz�9OR�3�5?[ 5?3�eW9OCUE � u � 9OF�<=58C�9ORy3�5A[N<T5?C:9ZR�HNMJ�<y3�5?3�5?[O<�<�7G3�F�HNzN<�CcF�<�R�<�JI3�HNF(SU58CDEI@58CUz~9O7G7�9�e®^��=>\9O5?F�<�3�9O>rvAsltOuNuOu�byv�¨�LD<�7G<:RoLD<�Mg5?R�9O>?70;=<�FG<W7G<�>?<�R�3�<�E.96JDFG58HNFG5�S�9O7�<�E�HNCp7G3�F�BDRw@3�BUF�9O>�RoL�9OF�9OR�3�<�FG587G3�58R�7�9OCDE3�<�7G3�<�E]58C~9x;=<�>?>�[Q9O>?58E�9�3�<�Eg9OCDEg7G3�9OCDE�9OFGED58h�<�E]5?C[ 5A3�F�HxF�9�3TBU3�<�F @58CU<}R�e�3�HN7�HN>�ª�µºR�HNMgJl<�3�5?3�5?[N<w@�SD5?CDED5?CDz9O7�7�9�e�^��=>\9O5?F�<y3�9O>�v?s�tOuNuOuU�¡�TF�9OCDL�9QM�<y3�9O>�v?s�tOuNuNtNbyv¨�LD5?7�7n3�F�BUR�3�BUF�9O>?>?e&ED5A[N<�F�7�<WE�9Q3�9g7�<y3ZLD9O7 ´I� tJDFG<�ED5?R�3�HNF�7�zN<�CU<�F�9�3�<�EpBD7�5?CDzg3�LD<}qpHN>8R�HNCDCI@��7�HQV 3�;�9OFG< § vÖu ¦ ^XL�3G3�J¡³ÖÔNÔ�;�;�;|vØ9OM7�vÏ7�BDC�e 7�S�vØ<�EDB�ÔN×£LD9OLDC�ÔQFG<�7G<�9OFGRoL�ÔN¢�ª�µ�¼�ÔQ<�7G3�F�HNzN<�C¡v 3G� 3wbwv

÷"c Õ s ]_`�EGEGHj¼�½f`w¾§H_AXB A�+k�\lç�IC\^m HJ` å�çËô�¾Cû>x1\^E¨�LD<�Ð|HO>8BDSP>8<�BD¤O<�Mg589.E�9Q3o9�7�<y3587658C�3�FGHIEUBDR�<�E¶5?C¶HNCU<_HQVZ3�LU<_7G<�M58C�9Q>�J�9OJl<�F�79OJUJD>?e 58CUz7G3�9Q3�5?7G3�58R�9Q>�R�>\9Q7�7�5 � R�9�3�58HOC,3�<�RoLDCU5 m BD<�7�3�HgMg5?R�F�HN9OF�F�9�e~E�9Q3�9Uv�Ð�HN>8BUSp<y3�9O>�v$^ ��¥N¥N¥ b�R�>89O7�7G5 � <�E9OR�BU3�<cM}eO<�HN>?HN58E�>8<�BU¤O<�M5\9j^a �qpÃ�b�9QCDE�9OR�BI3�<c>?e MJDLDHNSU>\9O7n3�58Rx>8<�BD¤O<�Mg589�^a Zííb�7GBDSU3�e Jl<�7BD7G58CDz}9x[Q9OF�589OC�3THQV�>85?CD<�9OF�ED5?7�R�F�58M58CD9OC�3�9OC�9O>AeI7G587�S�9O7G<�E&HNCgzN<�CD<�<y�IJDFG<�7�7G58HNC&JUF�H � >?58CDzUv�±®<L�9�[N<T58CDR�>8BDED<�E}5A3�LU<�F�<T9Oz�9O5?Cx3�HZ5?>8>8BU7G3�F�9Q3�<�¢�ª�µ�¼{HOC:9�ED9Q3o9�7�<�3�;05?3�L}¤�CDH�;0C69OCDE}[Q9O>?58E�9�3�<�EJl<�FGVXHOF�Mg9OCDR�<gBD7�5?CDzj7n3o9Q3�<y@�HQV\@43�LU<y@ 9QFG3WR�>\9Q7�7�5 � <�FG7}7GBDRoLk9O7W3�LDHN7�<~7G3�BUED58<�EK58CK²�BDEUHN5?3W<�3:9O>rv^rtQuNu�tNbwvW¨�LD<c3�F�9O5?CD58CDz~7�<�3xHNFG58zN5?C�9O>?>?e&BD7G<�E{58Cj3�LD<69OC�9O>Ae 7�587�S�e.Ð|HN>?BDS.<�3x9Q>rv�5?CDR�>?BDED<�E ´N°7�9QMgJD>?<�70HOV� �Ã$ÃK9OCDEp �q�Ã*v� ZCp9OEDED5A3�5?HNC�9O> ´Q§ 7�9OMgJU>8<�7�;=<�FG<W3�LU<�C�BU7�<�Ej9O7�3�LD<|3�<�7n3Z7G<�3�v

� �

Page 17: AWAXB YZP[Uhahn/research/CERP/papCERP.pdf$- ./ ! 0 +( 1#324 57678&9:; + ! ) ? @3ACB DCEGFHJILKMFB1N OQPR@3A STH/BVU AWAXB YZP[U \^]/H_EGET`ba[cRd>` efef` ghH NiP[j3AXF

 Z7}EDHNCD<g58CK²�BDEUHN5?3W<�3:9O>rvAs�;=<]R�HOM:SD58CU<�Ef3�LD<~3�F�9O58CU58CDzp9OCDEf3�<�7n3c7�<y3�7:VXHNFxHNBDF}9OC�9O>AeI7G<�7�s3�LU<�F�<yVXHNF�<}HNSU3o9Q58CD5?CDz §�¦  �Ã$ÃP9OCDE�tO�g �q�ÃP7�9QMgJD>?<�7�vZ¨�LD<:ED9Q3o9g;=<�FG<:HNSU3�9O58CU<�E�3�LDF�HNBUzNL3�LU<W;=<�S.7�5A3�<xL�3�3�J�³ÕÔNÔ¬;�;�;|vØSDFGH�9OE¡vÏM5?3�vÏ<�EUB�ÔQR�9QCDR�<�FoÔQ7GHOV 3�;�9QF�<�Ô�zN<�CD<�J�9Q3G3�<�FGC�ÔQE�9�3o9O7G<�3�7�Ô_9QCDE;=<�F�<�JDFG<y@�JUF�H R�<�7G7�<�E~9O7�ED<�7�R�F�58Sl<�E58CÐ�HN>?BDSc<�3=9O>�vO7�BURoL3�L�9Q3 ´ sÖ� ¦I� zN<�CD<�7*;=<�F�<05?C63�LD<�E�9Q3�97�<y3�v

� �ÓÝ�â(-.á�%(â

±®<&<�[Q9O>8BD9Q3�<�E�3�LD<,JDFG<�ED5?R�3�5?HNCK9OR�R�BDF�9OR�e�HOV03�LD<_¢�ª�µ�¼Å9OJDJDFGH�9ORoLk9O7:;=<�>?>�9O769jS�9O>89OCDR�<Sl<�3�;=<�<�Cd7�<�CU7�5?3�5?[ 5?3�e�9OCDEk7�Jl<�R�5 � R�5?3�eKBD7G58CDz�3�LU<,VXHOBDFcE�9Q3�9�7G<�3�7gED5?7�R�BD7�7G<�EÂ5?Cd� <�R�3�58HNC¶�Iv�T<yVXHNF�<�9OJDJD>Ae 58CDz�3�LU<�M<�3�LDHIEU7�s�;T<�F�<�MgH�[N<�Eg3�LD<�JUF�<�EU58R�3�HNF�7�3�LD9Q3�L�9OE~5?ED<�C�3�58R�9Q>D[O9Q>8BD<�7�VXHOFMHNF�<x3�L�9OC ¥N°�� HOV*3�LD<c7�9QMgJD>?<�7�5?CjHNFGED<�FZ3�H&F�<�EDBDR�<:3�LD<cJlHN7�7G58SD5?>85?3�e&3�L�9Q3|9]JUF�<�EU58R�3�HNF�5?C9c>8<�9OF�CD5?CDzc7�<y30;THNBU>8E,CDHO3�L�9�[N<|ED5?7G3�58CDRy3�[O9Q>8BD<�7�58C&3�LD<W¢=¾ÑVXHNF�SUBD58>?ED58CDz69QC_HOJU3�5?M~9O>�3�FG<�<Qv��HNFW3�LD<]<�7G3�FGHNzN<�CKE�9Q3o9Is�tN�Ou�HOBU3cHOV ´U� t_JDFG<�ED5?R�3�HOF�7};=<�FG<&7�<�>?<�Ry3�<�EPBD7G58CDzp3�LD5?7}R�FG5?3�<�F�5?HNC¡s9OCDE�VXHNF�3�LD<6zN<�CD<58MJDFG58C�3�5?CDz~E�9�3o9Us � t §N° HOBU3|HOV ��§N§�¯ JDF�<�ED58Ry3�HNFG7�;T<�F�<g7�<�>?<�Ry3�<�E�VXHNF�3�LU<9OC�9Q>?e 7�5?7�v��HNF�3�LD<6R�HO>8HNC{9OCDE®>8<�BD¤O<�Mg589,ED9Q3o9&7�<y3�7�s(9O>?>�3�LD<JDFG<�ED5?R�3�HOF�7�;T<�F�<58CDR�>8BDEU<�E{S�e3�LU587R�F�5A3�<�F�58HOC¡v¸¨�LD<j<�[Q9O>?B�9Q3�58HNC¶9OCDEÂR�HNMJ�9OF�5?7�HNCkHOVW¢�ª�µ�¼¿9QCDEÂHO3�LD<�FgMg<y3�LDH ED7g;=<�FG<R�HOCDEDBDRy3�<�EdS�ek9�[O<�F�9QzN58CDz�3�LU<_FG<�7GBD>?3�7VXFGHNM tOu�F�<�JD>85?R�9Q3�58HNCD7}HOV � u¬@4VXHN>?Ek¢=¾¹5?CkHOF�ED<�F63�H9ORoLD5?<�[O<|9:7G3o9QSD>8<�F�<�7GBD>?3�v*¨�;T<�C�3�ep¢=¾�7�7�LUHNBD>8E&Sl<�7GBL²R�58<�C�3�9OR�R�HNF�ED5?CDz}3�HqpHN>85?C�9OFGH}<�3�9O>rv^rtQuNu��Nb�;0LUHgFG<�R�HOMgM<�CDEU<�E � ucF�BDCD7�HOV � u�@rVXHN>8E,¢=¾Ñ3�HgL�9�[O<x>?H�;Ñqj�Uªd9OCDE_SD5\9O7�v

±f<ZR�HNMJ�9OFG<�E~3�LD<�JDFG<�ED5?R�3�5?HNC&9OR�R�BDF�9OR�egHOV�¢�@4¨Æ¢�ª�µ�¼d9OCUE&Ã$µ�@4¨ ¢�ª�µ�¼k;05A3�L]HQ3�LD<�F7G3�9OCDE�9QF�E.R�>89O7�7G5 � R�9Q3�5?HNC_Mg<y3�LDH ED7�v���58zNBUF�<}tgED<�JU58R�3�7Z3�LU<:9OR�R�BDF�9OR�e�HOV*<�9QRoL.R�>\9Q7�7�5 � R�9�3�58HOCMHIED<�>�;05?3�Ld9 � @47�E¶S�9OFgVXHOF3�LD<_VXHOBDF~E�9�3o9®7G<�3�7�s�S�9O7G<�E�HNCk3�LD<�9�[N<�F�9OzN<pHOVxtOu{F�BDCD7gHOV� u�@rVXHN>8Eg¢=¾}v ¨�9OSD>?<�7Tt�3�LDF�HOBDzNL § JDF�H�[ 58EU<�3�LD<Z9QR�R�BUF�9ORyegHQV¡<�9QRoL]Mg<y3�LDH E¡s�;05?3�Lg7G<�CD7G5?3�5?[ 5?3�e9OCDEK7GJ�<�R�5 � R�5A3�efVXHNF}3�LD< � FG7G3:3�LDF�<�<&E�9Q3o9j7G<�3�7�v���HNFW3�LD<]>?<�BD¤Q<�M5\9jE�9�3o9Us(3�LD<]S�9O>89OCDR�<]HOV7�<�CD7�5A3�5A[I5A3�e69OCDE67GJ�<�R�5 � R�5?3�58<�7�5?7*CDHO3�9OC587G7�BD<0EDBU<03�H}9Q>8MHN7G3*Jl<�FnVX<�Ry3=R�>\9O7G7�5 � R�9Q3�58HNCcS�e6MHN7G3HOV�3�LD<0R�>89O7�7G5 � R�9Q3�5?HNC6Mg<y3�LDH ED7�v(¨�L�BD7=;=<�EUHWCDHQ3=JUF�H�[ 58ED<�9�3o9OSD>?<Ov���HOF�3�LD<0>8<�BD¤O<�Mg589|ED9Q3o9Us9O>?>¡3�LD<WMg<y3�LDH ED7�R�HNCD7G58ED<�F�<�Ej58C,3�LD5?7�7n3�BDEIep<w�IR�<�JI3x¢T �µ�¨ÇzN9�[O<}LD5?zNLp9OR�R�BDF�9OR�58<�7ZF�9QCDzN58CUzVXF�HOM ¥ � � 3�H ¥N°�� v�¨�LD<,9OR�R�BDF�9QR�e�HQV�¢T Zµ�¨È;�9Q7CU<�9OF ° t � s(;0LD58>?<&Í�ËZª��I¨¿z�9�[N<&3�LU<

��¯

Page 18: AWAXB YZP[Uhahn/research/CERP/papCERP.pdf$- ./ ! 0 +( 1#324 57678&9:; + ! ) ? @3ACB DCEGFHJILKMFB1N OQPR@3A STH/BVU AWAXB YZP[U \^]/H_EGET`ba[cRd>` efef` ghH NiP[j3AXF

9OR�R�BDF�9OR�e�HOV ¥N¯�� vx��HNF�3�LD<:M<�3�LUHIED7�;05?3�Lp[O9QF�5\9QSD>8<x7�<�>8<�Ry3�5?HNC¡s�3�LD<c9�[N<�F�9OzN<cC�BDM}S�<�F�76^X7�E58C{J�9OFG<�C�3�LU<�7�<�7ob}HOV�JDF�<�ED58Ry3�HNF|[Q9OF�589OSD>8<�7|7�<�>?<�Ry3�<�Ef58C®3�LD<63�F�9Q58CD5?CDzpJUL�9O7�<;T<�F�< ��¥�¦ ^��Ou ¦ bVXHNF=¤I���Ws �¬¦O° ^ � � � b(VXHNFT�(Ã$²� Ws ��§ u]^ ´O¯�¦ b�VXHOFT²�Ã$²0 �9OCDE&tOu&^ ��¯ b�VXHNFT�D¢ZvU��HOFT¤ �Z�xsI3�LU<9�[N<�F�9OzN<~^a7GEp5?C&J�9OFG<�C�3�LD<�7�<�7ob0[Q9O>?BD<�HOV*Ì];T9O7 ´ v � ^ ´ v ´ byv

2�CÆ3�LU<®R�HNMgJD9OF�5?7�HNC HOV}3�LD<{Mg<y3�LDH ED7�sx¢�ª�µ�¼ûED58E CDHO3pF�< m BU58F�<®9OC�e � CD<�3�BDCU58CDzkHOVJ�9OF�9OM<�3�<�F�7:Sl<�R�9OBD7G<]3�LD<yeK9OFG<]ED<�3�<�FGMg5?CD<�EK5?Cf3�LD<g3�F�9Q58CD5?CDz�JDLD9O7�<&5?CD7�5?ED<g3�LD<]JDFGHNzNF�9QMpv��HNF�3�LD<gMgHO7G3WF�<�>?<�[Q9OC�3WR�HNMJ�9OFG587�HOC¡s�;T<]JUF�H�[ 58ED<63�LD<gS�<�7G3WF�<�7�BD>A3};=<~HNSU3�9O58CU<�E�VXHNFW<�9ORoLE�9Q3�9K7�<�3,VXHNF]3�LD<.HO3�LD<�F,M<�3�LUHIED7,9QCDE¸7�Jl<�R�5AV eÂ3�LU<{JD9OF�9OM<�3�<�FG7&BD7�<�EÄ5?C¸3�LD<.VXHIHQ3�CDHO3�<Ov��HNF�3�LU<gM<�3�LDHIEU7xFG< m BD5?F�58CUz,[Q9OFG5\9OSU>8<cJDFG<y@�7G<�>?<�R�3�58HNC�s�9QC®HNJI3�58Mg9O>�C BUM:S�<�FWHQVT[Q9OF�589OSD>?<�7�5?77�<�9OF�RoLU<�Ek9OCDEf3�LD<~[Q9OFG5\9OSD>?<�7W9OF�<g7�<�>8R�3�<�EKS�e{3�LD<~�=± F�9Q3�58H_58Cf3�LD<g3�F�9O5?CD58CDzpJDL�9O7G<Ov.��HNF¤ �Z�xs�3�LU<}HNJU3�58Mg9O>¡[Q9O>8BU<WHOV�Ìp587Z9O>87GHgHNSI3o9O5?CD<�Ej5?C�CD<�7G3�<�E{¢=¾:v� ZC�9Q>?e 7�5?7�HOV*9~JDF�<y[ 58HNBD7G>?eJDBDSU>8587GLD<�ER�HO>8HNC6E�9Q3�9�7�<�3�;T9O7=7G58M58>89OF­3�Hx3�LD<0F�<�7�BD>A3�7�HNSU3�9O58CD<�EgS�e6HO3�LD<�FG7�BD7�5?CDzx3�LD<�7G<Z9QCDEF�<�>\9Q3�<�E:M<�3�LDH ED70^a �>8HNCW<�3�9Q>rvAs ��¥N¥O¥ �N¨�7�9Q5U<�3*9O>rvAs�tOuOu § �N �M:SDF�HO587�<T9OCDEqpR�Ã$9ORoLD>\9QC¡s�tOuNuNtNbyv�IHNM<�HOVD3�LD<=7n3o9OCUE�9OF�EWMg<y3�LDH ED7$58CUR�>8BUED<�EW58CxHNBDF$R�HNMJ�9OFG587GHNCWzN9�[O<=LU58zNLD<�F�9QR�R�BUF�9OR�58<�7$3�LD9OC3�LU<�7�<xJDFG<�[ 58HNBU7�FG<�7�BU>?3�7�v=¨�LU58707�LDH�;07�HNBDF0<�©�HNFn3�3�HgHOSU3o9O5?C&3�LD<|Sl<�7G3�JlHN7�7G58SD>?<�F�<�7GBD>?3�7�VXF�HNM3�LU<�7�<xM<�3�LUHIED7�v

¨�9QSD>8<,t_7�LDH�;07c3�L�9�3:VXHNFW3�LD<]zN<�CD<&58MJDFG58C�3�5?CDzpED9Q3o9Us�3�LD<&7G<�CD7G5?3�5A[ 5?3�e®9OCDEK7GJ�<�R�5 � R�5?3�e;=<�F�< ¦ t � 9QCDE ¥ � � s�F�<�7�Jl<�R�3�5?[O<�>?eOs�S�eÄ¢�@�¨ó¢�ª�µ�¼�s�;0LD58>?<j3�LD<ye�;T<�F�< ¯ � � 9OCUE ¥N¥�� sF�<�7�Jl<�Ry3�5?[O<�>AeNs�S�e�µ��=vl¨�LU<�7�<}F�<�7GBD>?3�7Z7GBDJDJlHNFG3�3�LD<WR�F�5A3�5?R�587GM 9OSlHNBU3Zµ��kHNCp3�LD<:58M}S�9O>\9QCDR�<S�e�²�BUEDHN5?3}9OCDEP��FG58ED>Ae�9OCDEÂ^rtOuOu ´ byvp��HNF:µ��Ts�;=<]3�F�5?<�E{[O9QF�58HOBD7}RoLDHO58R�<�7}VXHNFx3�LD<]C�BDM}S�<�FHOV([Q9OFG5\9OSU>8<�703�H~S�<W7�<�>?<�Ry3�<�E.5?C�<�9ORoL.CDH ED<}HOV*9g3�FG<�<Os�9OCDE�3�LD<}C�BDM}S�<�FZHOV*3�F�<�<�7�58CUR�>8BUED58CDz3�LU<xEU<�Va9OBD>A30[O9Q>8BD<�7�v=qpHNFG<�H�[N<�F�s�;T<x<y�U9OM58CD<�E&[O9QF�58HOBD70R�BU3n@�HO©k^ 3�LDFG<�7GLDHN>8E�b�HOJU3�5?HNCD7�58Cpµ��J�9ORo¤�9OzO<&HOV�µxs�SDBU3:3�LD<&F�<�7�BD>A3cED5?E�CDHO3c7GBDSD7n3o9OC�3�589O>8>Ae{ED5?©�<�FWS�<yeNHNCDEK3�LD<&F�9OCUEDHNMY<�F�FGHNF�v�THO3�L.¢�ª�µ�¼Ä9OCUEjµ��¶Jl<�FGVXHOF�M<�E�Sl<�3G3�<�F�3�LD9OC�3�LU<}HO3�LD<�F�Mg<y3�LDH ED7�58C,3�<�FGMg7�HOV�9OR�R�BDF�9OR�eVXHNFZ3�LD<6E�9Q3�9Uv:��HNF�²�Ã$²0 }sl3�LD<69OR�R�BDF�9OR�ejF�<�9QRoLD<�E{3�LD<cLD5?zNLD<�7G3�;0LD<�Cf9]>89OF�zN<}C BUM:S�<�F�HOV[Q9OF�589OSD>?<�7|;T<�F�<&JDFG<y@�7G<�>?<�R�3�<�E¡v{�U¢ÈHOSU3o9O5?CD<�E®3�LD<]Sl<�7n3cJl<�FGVXHOF�Mg9OCDR�<;0LD<�CP9Q>8>�JDF�<�ED58Ry3�HNFG7;=<�F�<x58CUR�>8BUED<�E¡v

��HNFZ3�LU<cR�HN>?HNC.E�9Q3�9®^X7�<�<c¨�9OSU>8< ´ bws�Ã$µ�@4¨Å¢�ª�µ�¼Æz�9�[N< ° � � HOV�JDFG<�ED5?R�3�5?HNC�9OR�R�BDF�9OR�eOv

�¬¦

Page 19: AWAXB YZP[Uhahn/research/CERP/papCERP.pdf$- ./ ! 0 +( 1#324 57678&9:; + ! ) ? @3ACB DCEGFHJILKMFB1N OQPR@3A STH/BVU AWAXB YZP[U \^]/H_EGET`ba[cRd>` efef` ghH NiP[j3AXF

Accuracies for imprinting

Accu

racy

C−

T C

ER

P

LR

−T

CE

RP

RF

SV

M L

ine

ar

SV

M R

BF

Ad

aB

oo

st

Lo

gitB

oo

st

kN

N

FL

DA

DL

DA

SC

CA

RT

QU

ES

T

0.65

0.70

0.75

0.80

0.85

0.90Accuracies for colon

Accu

racy

C−

T C

ER

P

LR

−T

CE

RP

RF

SV

M L

ine

ar

SV

M R

BF

Ad

aB

oo

st

Lo

gitB

oo

st

kN

N

FL

DA

DL

DA

SC

CA

RT

QU

ES

T

0.70

0.75

0.80

0.85

Accuracies for estrogen

Accu

racy

C−

T C

ER

P

LR

−T

CE

RP

RF

SV

M L

ine

ar

SV

M R

BF

Ad

aB

oo

st

Lo

gitB

oo

st

kN

N

FL

DA

DL

DA

SC

CA

RT

QU

ES

T

0.65

0.70

0.75

0.80

0.85

Accuracies for leukemia

Accu

racy

C−

T C

ER

P

LR

−T

CE

RP

RF

SV

M L

ine

ar

SV

M R

BF

Ad

aB

oo

st

Lo

gitB

oo

st

kN

N

FL

DA

DL

DA

SC

CA

RT

QU

ES

T

0.80

0.85

0.90

0.95

��5?zNBDF�<�tI³(¢THOMgJ�9QF�587GHNC:HOV�9OR�R�BDF�9OR�5?<�7�^X;05A3�L � @47�EcS�9QF�7ob�HQV�R�>\9O7G7�5 � R�9Q3�58HNC}Mg<y3�LDH ED7(VXHNF(<�9ORoLE�9Q3�9c7�<�3�S�9Q7�<�EpHNC&3�;T<�C�3�e�FG<�JD>?58R�9�3�58HOCD7THOV � u�@rVXHN>8E_¢=¾}v

��°

Page 20: AWAXB YZP[Uhahn/research/CERP/papCERP.pdf$- ./ ! 0 +( 1#324 57678&9:; + ! ) ? @3ACB DCEGFHJILKMFB1N OQPR@3A STH/BVU AWAXB YZP[U \^]/H_EGET`ba[cRd>` efef` ghH NiP[j3AXF

¨�9OSD>8<ctI³ ÕCÝ�Ý�ÙÛÖJß�Ý°ô + Ú_ç�àóä�åZßÉÖJæ!ä�Ü_ï%æ!Ú_æ!Ú`,C×�ê�Ý�Þ·ß�ÚJÚ_àâáTÝ�ßÉÜ_àã×�äÇé�æ�Ü_ï%×QçÛÚXêù×�ÖpÜ_ï%æ�ø�æ!ä%æ �X����Ò'�b�GÑ%�b���çÛßÉÜ_ß�î?à·Ü_ïÐA 8 Ý�ß�Ú|æ!Ú�ß�äÛç�6�6�Ý°×�ä�Ü|ÖJ×�Þ·Ú�ö�÷.î�æ!äoÜ�ôÇÖ_æ�å§æ�Ü_àãÜ_àã×�äÛÚC×�ê?;�2�ëËêù×�Þ·ç ��� î�æ�ÖJæ�åGæ�ÖJê´×�ÖJé[æ!ç�êù×�Öæ!ß�ÝJïþé�æ�Ü_ï%×QçðÙÛäÛÞãæ!ÚJÚ�×�Ü_ïÛæ�Ö_î?à·Ú|æ0Ú|å§æ!Ý�àâáTæ!ç ö �tï%æ!äðèÉßÉÖJà·ßÉØZÞãæ�Ú|æ!Þãæ!Ý°Ü_à·×�äÌà·Ú�ç%×�ä%æ�à·ä Ü_ï%æ0Ü|Ö/ß�à·äÛà·ä%øåZïÛß�Ú_æ�í%Ü_ï%æ�é�æ!ß�ä0èÉß�Þ·Ù%æp×�ê&Ü_ï%æpåZÖ_æ!çÛà·Ý°Ü|×�ÖJÚ + ÚJç�à·ä0åZßÉÖJæ!ä�Ü_ï%æ!Ú_æ!Ú`,à·Úø�àãè�æ!ähö

�7æ�Ü_ï%×Qç ßÉåZåÛÖ_×�ß�ÝJï !>åÛÖ_æ!çÛàóÝ°Ü|×�ÖJÚ ÿXè�æ�Ö/ß�Þ·Þ "Qæ!äÛÚ_àãÜ_àãèQàãÜ�ô "iå§æ!Ý�àâáTÝ�àãÜ�ô­�¯ �!° � ë�÷ � ( ��±l> ß�Þ·Þ ö16�6 + ö92F;�, ö54�B + ö92 8 , ö17�0 + ö92�A�,�l��ë�÷ � ( �?±lD ß�Þ·Þ ö16�7 + ö92F;�, ö54�B + ö92�A�, ö17:4 + ö92:B:,�$#&% ß�Þ·Þ ö16�6 + ö92F;�, ö13�0 + ö92 8 , ö17�7 + ö92F;�,�('*) �-àóä ö&û�æ�ÖJä%æ!Þ ß�Þ·Þ ö16�0 + ö92:B:, ö13�7 + ö92�A�, ö17�B + ö92:B:,�Cúý � ß�Þ·Þ ö54�6 + ö92 8 , öRA�A + ö92:3:, ö17'A + ö92:B:,+ �V�ZÐ�Ñ'�X��� ÕXçÛß�ú�×o×�Ú_Ü ß�Þ·Þ ö54�B + ö92�A�, öRA�A + ö92:7:, ö16�0 + ö92 8 ,�h×�ø�àãÜ_ú�×i×�Ú|Ü ß�Þ·Þ ö16'A + ö92:B:, ö54�B + ö92 8 , ö17�2 + ö92 8 ,,.-/- B�3<; + 8 B�B:,10 Î 2 ö54�6 + ö92:B:, ö13:4 + ö92:0:, ö16'A + ö92 8 ,3w� Î ý¡��4.Õ A:2 + ;�;�, 0 ö54�7 + ö92:B:, ö13 8 + ö92:3:, ö16�6 + ö92 8 ,4���4.Õ 8 7<; + ;�2Ü4�,10 ö16�3 + ö92:B:, ö13 8 + ö92�A�, ö17:4 + ö92F;�,�Z­ ß�Þ·Þ ö16'A + ö92F;�, ö54'2 + ö92:B:, ö17<; + ö92F;�,�V�b����ªX� � Õ=�&÷ ß�Þ·Þ ö54�0 + ö92 8 , ö54�4 + ö92:3:, ö54%A + ö92�A�,Ñ;Ò%�C� 576 ( "Q÷ ß�Þ·Þ ö13:4 + ö92 8 , ö 8 4 + ö@;�;�, ö16�B + ö92�A�,G KNMjTnmXKYOT98�Km\J\P JXPRIOH WXP;:NT.8ETNmxTNH W\TNfZS QRT�<>=�=`z {u KNMjTNmbKYOT98�Km\J\P J\PRIOHwWXP;:NT?8ETNmxTnH-WXTNfZS QRT�<>= ö z @A HhU f�S�TNmvI�B�J\mXTNTNWC< {OÏOÏED H`U-fZSETNmxI�BF8-mXTNa PRo_JXIOm\W�W\TNQRTno_J\TNa PRH TnKob[wH I`a-T�I�BÜK�JXm\TnT�<Üa TGB KU Q J�pIH�IhIOm1J K&LNMCOCP tQ mbKa P9KQ%S�KWXPRWRB U-H o_JXPRIOH�p a TGB KU Q J�I�8-JXPRIOHSB IOmFJ\[ T�TVU.W B U-H o_JXPRIOH PRH J\[ T9XY8�Ko[ZKYOT]\C^`_Va�^ tb fgTnKH�p5WXa PRHc8 KmXTNHhJ\[ TNWXTNW t HhU fZSETNmXWvI�BF8 m\Tna-PRoNJ\IOmXWxWXTNQRTNo_JXTNa PRHéJ\[ TVJXmXKPRH PRH Yd8-[�KWXTe KnMjTNmbKYOTgp5WXa PRHc8�Km\TNHhJ\[ TNWXTNW t I�B ÿ IOS`JbKPRH TNa PRHlJX[-T JXmXKPRH PRH Yf8 [ KWXT�< � z =gp ö z = t

¨�LD<6�TH HN7n3�58CUz~M<�3�LUHIED7�ED58E�CDHO3�zN5A[N<WLD58zNLU<�F�3�L�9OC ¦ � � H�[O<�F�9Q>8>�JUF�<�EU58R�3�58HNC�F�9Q3�<WVXHNF�3�LD5?7J�9OFn3�5?R�BD>89OF0E�9Q3o97�<y3�s�9O>?3�LDHNBDzNL_3�LD<ye_J�<�FGVXHNFGMg<�E m BD5?3�<x;=<�>?>�HOCp3�LU<}HO3�LD<�F�3�LDFG<�<}ED9Q3o97�<�3�7;=<®<w�D9QMg5?CD<�E¡v¿ ZM}SDF�HN5?7�<{9OCDEÆqpR�í9QRoLD>\9OC½^rtQuNu�tNb~R�HNMgJD9OF�<�E 3�LD<®EU5?©�<�F�<�CDR�<{58C¸<�F�F�HOF<�7n3�5?M~9Q3�<�7�Sl<�3�;=<�<�C®5?C�3�<�FGC�9O>�9OCDE.<y� 3�<�F�CD9O>�¢=¾�7|BD7G58CDz&� ¾|q ;05?3�L�9]R�HNM}SD58C�9�3�58HOC�HOV�3�LU<>85?CD<�9QF}¤O<�F�CD<�>09OCDEP9jS�9QRo¤�;T9OFGE¶<�>858M58CD9Q3�5?HNC�zN<�CD<&7G<�>?<�R�3�58HNCKJUF�H R�<�EUBDF�<Qv®¨�LD<yeKF�<�J�HOFG3�<�E3�LD9Q3�9O>8>�JDF�<�ED58Ry3�58HOC,9OR�R�BDF�9OR�58<�7�;=<�FG<x;=<�>?>¡S�<�>8H�; ° � � S�9Q7�<�EpHNC,<y� 3�<�F�C�9Q>�¢=¾}v�¨�7�9O5�<y3�9O>rv^rtQuNu § b$F�<�JlHNFn3�<�Ec3�L�9Q3(3�LD<�5?F(M~9¬�U5?M:BDMÑJDFG<�ED5?R�3�5?HNC69OR�R�BDF�9OR�e}BD7�5?CDz�¤ �Z�Ñ^X;05A3�LÌñ � b�9QCDE� ¾�qó;T9O7 °O§�� v�±f<xHNSU3�9O58CU<�E_7�>85?zNL�3�>Ae]Sl<�3�3�<�F�F�<�7�BD>A3�703�L�9OC,3�LU<�7�<WJDF�<y[ 58HNBD70;=HNF�¤&VXHNF�3�LU<ED5?7�R�FG58M58C�9QC�3(9OC�9O>Ae 7�587�HNF(CD<�9OF�<�7G3�CD<�5?zNL�S�HOF0^aR�<�C�3�FGHN58E�b­Mg<y3�LDH ED7�v(�(Ã$²� Â7GLDH�;T<�E]9�7n3�F�HOCDzJl<�FGVXHOF�Mg9OCDR�<:;05A3�L °�¦�� 9OR�R�BDF�9QR�ej;0LD<�C{[Q9OFG5\9OSU>8<:7G<�>8<�R�3�58HNC.;T9O7|CDHO3|Jl<�FGVXHOF�M<�E¡v:2�C�HNBUF7G3�BDEUeOs�²�Ã$²� º7�LDH�;=<�E{9OCp58MJDF�H�[N<�E.9OR�R�BDF�9OR�e_;0LD<�Cj[Q9OFG5\9OSU>8<�70;=<�F�<}JDF�<w@�7�<�>8<�R�3�<�E¡v���¾|qJl<�FGVXHOF�M<�E6S�<y3�3�<�F�;0LD<�C3�LD<0>85?CD<�9QF*¤O<�FGCD<�>�;T9O7�BD7�<�E~58CU7G3�<�9OEHOV�3�LD<�F�9OED589O>DS�9Q7�<�E6VXBDCDRy3�5?HNC^�µ����*bwvU²�Ã$²0 }s ¤ �Z��9OCUE,�D¢Âz�9�[N<�FG<�>\9�3�5?[O<�>Ae6LD58zNL~9OR�R�BDF�9QR�e~;0LU<�C,JDF�<�ED58Ry3�HNFG7=;=<�FG<�JDF�<w@

��¥

Page 21: AWAXB YZP[Uhahn/research/CERP/papCERP.pdf$- ./ ! 0 +( 1#324 57678&9:; + ! ) ? @3ACB DCEGFHJILKMFB1N OQPR@3A STH/BVU AWAXB YZP[U \^]/H_EGET`ba[cRd>` efef` ghH NiP[j3AXF

¨�9OSD>8< ´ ³ ÕCÝ�Ý�Ù%Ö/ß�Ý°ô + Ú_ç)à·ä[åZßÉÖJæ!ä�Ü_ï%æ!Ú_æ!Ú`,^×�êhÝ�Þ·ß�Ú_Ú_àâáGÝ�ßÉÜ_àã×�ä1é[æ�Ü_ï%×içZÚqêù×�Ö�Ü_ïÛæ Ô:�Lª\�L� çÛßÉÜ_ß�î?àãÜ_ïÞB�BÝ�ß�Ú|æ!Úpß�äÛçÐA:2�Ý°×�ä�Ü|Ö_×�ÞóÚ�öX÷.î�æ!äoÜ�ô�ÖJæ�åGæ�Ü_à·Ü_àã×�äÛÚ.×�ê?;�2�ëËê´×�Þ·ç ��� î�æ�Ö_æ>å§æ�Ö_ê´×�Ö/é�æ!ç�êù×�ÖCæ!ß�Ý/ï�é�æ�Ü_ï%×Qç ö�tï%æ!ä0èÉßÉÖJà·ßÉØZÞãæ"Ú|æ!Þãæ!Ý°Ü_à·×�ä�à·Úç%×�ä%æWà·ä)Ü_ï%æpÜ|Ö/ß�à·äÛà·ä%ø>åZïÛß�Ú_æ�í%Ü_ï%æWé�æ!ß�ä0èÉß�Þ·Ù%æ"×�ê�Ü_ï%æpåÛÖ_æ!çÛàóÝ°Ü|×�ÖJÚ + Ú_çà·ä�åZßÉÖJæ!ä�Ü_ï%æ!Ú_æ!Ú`,à·Úø�àãè�æ!ähö

�7æ�Ü_ï%×Qç ÕCåÛåÛÖ_×�ß�Ý/ï !>åÛÖ_æ!çÛàóÝ°Ü|×�ÖJÚ ÿXè�æ�Ö/ß�Þ·Þ "Qæ!äÛÚ_àãÜ_àãèQàãÜ�ô "iå§æ!Ý�àâáTÝ�àãÜ�ô­�¯ �!° � ë�÷ � ( ��±l> ß�Þ·Þ ö16'A + ö92F;�, ö16:4 + ö92:B:, ö16�2 + ö92 8 ,�l��ë�÷ � ( �?±lD ß�Þ·Þ ö16�0 + ö92:B:, ö16:4 + ö92F;�, ö16 8 + ö92:0:,�$#&% ß�Þ·Þ ö16 8 + ö92:B:, ö16�7 + ö92F;�, ö54�B + ö92:0:,�('*) �-àóä ö&û�æ�ÖJä%æ!Þ ß�Þ·Þ ö16'A + ö92:B:, ö16:4 + ö92:B:, ö16�2 + ö92:0:,�Cúý � ß�Þ·Þ ö16�B + ö92:B:, ö17'A + ö92F;�, ö10�7 + ö92:0:,+ �V�ZÐ�Ñ'�X��� ÕXçÛß�ú�×o×�Ú_Ü ß�Þ·Þ ö54%A + ö92�A�, ö16 8 + ö92�A�, ö10�7 + ö92:6:,�h×�ø�àãÜ_ú�×i×�Ú|Ü ß�Þ·Þ ö54 8 + ö92 8 , ö16 8 + ö92�A�, ö10�3 + ö92:3:,,.-/- 8 2 8 + 8 7:4�,10 Î 2 ö16'A + ö92�A�, ö16�6 + ö92:B:, ö54�0 + ö92:6:,3w� Î ý¡��4.Õ ß�Þ·Þ ö16:4 + ö92:B:, ö16�7 + ö92:B:, ö16�0 + ö92:0:,4���4.Õ 8 B + B�0:,10 ö16�0 + ö92:B:, ö16�3 + ö92:B:, ö16 8 + ö92�A�,�Z­ AÜ3 + ;�;�4�, 0 ö16�0 + ö92:B:, ö16:4 + ö92:B:, ö16<; + ö92Ü4�,�V�b����ªX� � Õ=�&÷ ß�Þ·Þ ö54�B + ö92�A�, ö54�7 + ö92:0:, ö13�2 + ö92:6:,Ñ;Ò%�C� 576 ( "Q÷ ß�Þ·Þ ö16�B + ö92 8 , ö16�3 + ö92 8 , ö54�0 + ö92:3:,G KNMjTnmXKYOT98�Km\J\P JXPRIOH WXP;:NT.8ETNmxTNH W\TNfZS QRT�<hg r z Ïu KNMjTNmbKYOT98�Km\J\P J\PRIOHwWXP;:NT?8ETNmxTnH-WXTNfZS QRT�< ö = � z @A HhU f�S�TNmvI�B�J\mXTNTNWC< �OÏOÏED H`U-fZSETNmxI�BF8-mXTNa PRo_JXIOm\W�W\TNQRTno_J\TNa PRH TnKob[wH I`a-T�I�BÜK�JXm\TnT�<Üa TGB KU Q J�pIH�IhIOm1J K&LNMCOCP tQ mbKa P9KQ%S�KWXPRWRB U-H o_JXPRIOH�p a TGB KU Q J�I�8-JXPRIOHSB IOmFJ\[ T�TVU.W B U-H o_JXPRIOH PRH J\[ T9XY8�Ko[ZKYOT]\C^`_Va�^ tb fgTnKH�p5WXa PRHc8 KmXTNHhJ\[ TNWXTNW t HhU fZSETNmXWvI�BF8 m\Tna-PRoNJ\IOmXWxWXTNQRTNo_JXTNa PRHéJ\[ TVJXmXKPRH PRH Yd8-[�KWXTe KnMjTNmbKYOTgp5WXa PRHc8�Km\TNHhJ\[ TNWXTNW t I�B ÿ IOS`JbKPRH TNa PRHlJX[-T JXmXKPRH PRH Yf8 [ KWXT�< { z ö p � z @ t

7�<�>8<�R�3�<�E¡v_243}5?7W5?C�3�<�FG<�7G3�58CDz_3�L�9�3W;05A3�L�9Q>8>*3�LD<[Q9OF�589OSD>8<�7|58C�3�LD<gMgH ED<�>�s���í²0 �HNSU3�9O58CD<�E3�LU<~LD5?zNLD<�7n3c9OR�R�BDF�9OR�eOs(;0LD58>?<~²�Ã$²0 £Jl<�FnVXHNF�M<�E®J�H HNFG>?eNv,243}587xCDHO3o9QSD>8<63�L�9�36Í�ËZª��I¨È5?7R�HOMgJ�9QF�9OSD>?<g3�H�µ��ÆVXHNFx3�LD<&R�HN>8HOCP9OCDEK>8<�BD¤O<�Mg589�E�9Q3�9j7�<y3�7�s�;0LD5?>8<]5A3};T9O7cR�HNCU7�58EU<�F�9QSD>?e;=HNF�7G<Z3�L�9QC&µ���VXHNF�3�LD<�HO3�LD<�F=3�;=H:E�9Q3�9}7�<y3�7�v���HOF�3�LD587�E�9Q3�9}7�<y3�sDµ��®FG< m BD5?F�<�EgVX<�;=<�FT3�F�<�<�7VXHNF�3�LD<|HNJU3�5?M~9Q>�Jl<�FGVXHOF�Mg9OCDR�<�R�HNMJ�9OF�<�E&3�HHO3�LD<�F�E�9Q3�967G<�3�7�v

��HNF�3�LD<|<�7G3�FGHNzN<�C�E�9Q3�9Us�²�Ã$²0 ÇED58E,CDHO30Jl<�FnVXHNF�M£;T<�>8>�<�[O<�C_;05?3�L_9c[Q9OF�589OSD>8<�7�<�>8<�Ry3�5?HNCSl<�R�9QBD7�<&5A3c9O7G7�BDM<�7}3�L�9Q3:VX<�9Q3�BUF�<�7:9OF�<]CUHO3cR�HOF�F�<�>\9Q3�<�E¡vj�(Ã$²� »Jl<�FnVXHNF�M<�EfS�<y3�3�<�F}3�LD9OC²�Ã$²� Ä;05?3�L_9:[Q9OF�589OSD>?<Z7�<�>8<�R�3�5?HNC¡sDSUBU305?3�;T9O707G3�58>?>�58CIVX<�F�5?HNF=3�Hc3�LD<�3�HNJI@�Jl<�FnVXHNF�M58CUz:Mg<y3�LI@H ED7�v*¨�LD<�J�<�FGVXHNFGM~9QCDR�<�HOV¡3�LD<Z9QzNzNF�<�z�9Q3�58HNCMg<y3�LDH ED7�;T<�F�<�7n3�FGHNCDzW;0LU<�C]3�LU<ZSl<�7G3THNJU3�58HNCD7;=<�F�<.BU7�<�E�vÑ�T<�R�9OBD7�<j3�LD<�ED9Q3o9�9QF�<jFG<�9O7GHNC�9OSD>AekS�9O>\9QCDR�<�EÑ^aJDFGHNJlHNFG3�58HNC¶HOV�3�LD<�J�HN7G5?3�5?[N<F�<�7�JlHNCD7G<�7:5?C®3�LU<~E�9Q3�9p5?7gvÖ� ¯ bws­3�LD<~S�9Q>\9OCDR�<gHQV�7�<�CD7�5A3�5?[ 5A3�ef9QCDEf7GJ�<�R�5 � R�5?3�e�;T9O7}zOHIH Ef5?CMHN7G3WHOV�3�LD<~M<�3�LDHIEU7�v,2�CP� ¾�q®s(µ����ÄJl<�FnVXHNF�M<�E®S�<y3�3�<�FW3�L�9OC®>858CU<�9OF|¤O<�F�CD<�>TBDCU>858¤Q<~5?C3�LU<~HO3�LD<�FWE�9Q3o9p7�<�3�7�vp243c9OJDJl<�9QF�7W3�HjSl<~EDBD<3�H.9_CDHNCD>?58CD<�9OFxF�<�>89Q3�5?HNCD7GLD58J�3�L�9�3W;T9O7:CDHQ3

tOu

Page 22: AWAXB YZP[Uhahn/research/CERP/papCERP.pdf$- ./ ! 0 +( 1#324 57678&9:; + ! ) ? @3ACB DCEGFHJILKMFB1N OQPR@3A STH/BVU AWAXB YZP[U \^]/H_EGET`ba[cRd>` efef` ghH NiP[j3AXF

¨�9OSD>8< § ³ ÕXÝ�Ý�Ù%ÖJß�Ý°ô + Ú_çÌà·äðåTßÉÖ_æ!ä�Ü_ïÛæ!Ú|æ!Ú`,�×�êWÝ�Þóß�Ú_Ú_àâáTÝ�ßÉÜ_à·×�äÌé�æ�Ü_ï%×QçÛÚ�êù×�ÖRÜ_ï%æ �oÐ!ѽÒ%�i�x�<� çÛßÉÜ_ßî?àãÜ_ï"; 8 ;"Ý�ß�Ú|æ!Ú�ß�äÛç�;�2F;"Ý°×�ä�Ü|ÖJ×�Þ·Ú�ö^÷�î�æ!äoÜ�ôRÖJæ�åGæ�Ü_à·Ü_àã×�äÛÚq×�ê ;�2�ëËê´×�Þ·ç �j� î�æ�ÖJæCå§æ�Ö_êù×�ÖJé�æ!ç1ê´×�Öæ!ß�Ý/ïé�æ�Ü_ï%×Qç�ÙÛäÛÞ·æ!Ú_Ú?×�Ü_ïÛæ�Ö_î?à·Ú|æ�Ú|å§æ!Ý�àâáTæ!ç ök�tï%æ!ä�è�ßÉÖ/à·ßÉØZÞãæ�Ú|æ!Þãæ!Ý°Ü_àã×�ä�àóÚpç%×�ä%æ�à·äÇÜ_ï%æ�Ü|ÖJß�à·äÛàóä%ø1åTïÛß�Ú|æ�íÜ_ï%æ�é[æ!ß�ä0è�ß�ÞóÙ%æp×�ê©Ü_ïÛæWåÛÖ_æ!çÛàóÝ°Ü|×�ÖJÚ + Ú_ç�à·ä�åTßÉÖ_æ!ä�Ü_ïÛæ!Ú|æ!Ú`,à·Ú.ø�àãè�æ!ä ö

��æ�Ü_ï%×Qç ÕCåÛåÛÖ_×�ß�Ý/ï !>åÛÖ_æ!çÛàóÝ°Ü|×�ÖJÚ ÿXè�æ�Ö/ß�Þ·Þ "iæ!äZÚ_àãÜ_àãèQàãÜ�ô "iå§æ!Ý�àâáTÝ�àãÜ�ô­�¯ �Þ° � ë�÷ � ( ��±l> ß�Þ·Þ ö16'A + ö92F;�, ö16�6 + ö92:B:, ö16�2 + ö92:B:,�l��ë�÷ � ( �?±lD ß�Þ·Þ ö16�0 + ö92F;�, ö16�7 + ö92F;�, ö54�7 + ö92:B:,�$#&% ß�Þ·Þ ö16�0 + ö92F;�, ö16�6 + ö92F;�, ö16�2 + ö92F;�,�('*) �-àóä öfû�æ�ÖJä%æ!Þ ß�Þ·Þ ö54�7 + ö92:B:, ö16 8 + ö92:B:, ö54%A + ö92 8 ,�?úý � ß�Þ·Þ ö16 8 + ö92F;�, ö16�7 + ö92F;�, ö54�0 + ö92:B:,+ �V�ZÐ�Ñ'�X��� ÕXçÛß�ú�×i×�Ú|Ü ß�Þ·Þ ö54�6 + ö92F;�, ö16�7 + ö92F;�, ö13 8 + ö92:B:,�h×�ø�à·Ü_ú�×i×�Ú|Ü ß�Þ·Þ ö16�2 + ö92:B:, ö16'A + ö92:B:, ö54�3 + ö92 8 ,,.-/- 3 8 + 3 8 ,10 Î 2 ö54%A + ö92 8 , ö16 8 + ö92 8 , ö13�B + ö92:0:,3w� Î ý���4.Õ 3�2 + B�0:, 0 ö54�6 + ö92:B:, ö16:4 + ö92:B:, ö13�3 + ö92 8 ,4T��4.Õ AÜ7 + 8�8 ,10 ö54 8 + ö92F;�, ö54�3 + ö92:B:, ö13�7 + ö92:B:,�Z­ 0<; + 0<;�, 0 ö54'2 + ö92:B:, ö54�0 + ö92 8 , ö13 8 + ö92:B:,�]�X����ªX� � ÕT��÷ ß�Þ·Þ ö54�3 + ö92:B:, ö54�7 + ö92 8 , ö54%A + ö92 8 ,Ñ;Ò%�C� 576 ( "Q÷ ß�Þ·Þ ö13:4 + ö92 8 , ö54 8 + ö92 8 , ö13�2 + ö92:0:,G KNMjTnmXKYOT98�Km\J\P JXPRIOH WXP;:NT.8ETNmxTNH W\TNfZS QRT�< ön{ z {u KNMjTNmbKYOT98�Km\J\P J\PRIOHwWXP;:NT?8ETNmxTnH-WXTNfZS QRT�< ö�ö z öA HhU f�S�TNmvI�B�J\mXTNTNWC< {OÏOÏED H`U-fZSETNmxI�BF8-mXTNa PRo_JXIOm\W�W\TNQRTno_J\TNa PRH TnKob[wH I`a-T�I�BÜK�JXm\TnT�<Üa TGB KU Q J�pIH�IhIOm1J K&LNMCOCP tQ mbKa P9KQ%S�KWXPRWRB U-H o_JXPRIOH�p a TGB KU Q J�I�8-JXPRIOHSB IOmFJ\[ T�TVU.W B U-H o_JXPRIOH PRH J\[ T9XY8�Ko[ZKYOT]\C^`_Va�^ tb fgTnKH�p5WXa PRHc8 KmXTNHhJ\[ TNWXTNW t HhU fZSETNmXWvI�BF8 m\Tna-PRoNJ\IOmXWxWXTNQRTNo_JXTNa PRHéJ\[ TVJXmXKPRH PRH Yd8-[�KWXTe KnMjTNmbKYOTgp5WXa PRHc8�Km\TNHhJ\[ TNWXTNW t I�B ÿ IOS`JbKPRH TNa PRHlJX[-T JXmXKPRH PRH Yf8 [ KWXT�<�@-z ö p � z �jt

R�9QJU3�BDFG<�EjBU7�58CUz~96>85?CD<�9OF�VXBUCDR�3�58HNCpHOV�3�LD<WJUF�<�EU58R�3�HNF�7�v�¨�LD<WJ�<�FGVXHNFGM~9OCUR�<|HOV(¤ ���½9OCDE��D¢;T9O7�CUHO30R�HNMJ�9OF�9OSD>?<Z3�H6Mg9OC�e&HO3�LU<�F0Mg<y3�LDH ED7�<y[N<�C�9QV 3�<�F�9c[Q9OFG5\9OSU>8<�7G<�>8<�R�3�58HNC¡v

��F�HNM�3�LD<�7�<|F�<�7�BD>A3�7�sD5?3T587�R�>8<�9QFT3�L�9�3�¢�ª�µ�¼dJl<�FnVXHNF�M7�R�HNCD7�5?7G3�<�C�3�>Ae~;=<�>8>�v(2�C_9OEDED5A3�5?HNC¡s3�LU<ZS�9O>89OCDR�<ZSl<�3�;=<�<�C,7G<�CD7G5?3�5A[ 5?3�eg9OCDE]7GJ�<�R�5 � R�5A3�egLD9O7�CDHO3=Sl<�<�C&>?HN7G3�sI<y[N<�C_HOC~BDC�S�9O>89OCDR�<�EE�9Q3�9®>?58¤O<,3�LU<�58MJDFG58C�3�5?CDz.E�9Q3�9®7�<y3{^aF�9Q3�<_HOV�JlHN7G5?3�5A[N<_F�<�7�JlHNCD7�<�7�³ ´N´�� b69OCDEd3�LD<�R�HN>8HOCR�9QCDR�<�F�E�9Q3o9�^XJ�HO7�5?3�5?[O<:F�9Q3�<O³ ¯ � � byvx¨�LD<cBDC�S�9O>89OCDR�<�E�E�9Q3�9]JDF�<�7�<�C�3W9]ED5ö²gR�BD>?3�e_3�H&7GHNM<HOV­3�LD<|HO3�LD<�F0M<�3�LDHIEU7�BDCDED<�F�R�HNCD7�5?ED<�F�9Q3�5?HNC¡sI58CDR�>8BDED5?CDz6µ��Tv

2�C¶zO<�CD<�F�9O>�s�FG<�7GBD>?3�76VXFGHNMý3�LD<_�TH HN7G3�58CDz.M<�3�LDHIEU7:;T<�F�<_CDHO39O7czNH H E¶9Q7:3�LDHN7G<&VXF�HNM3�LU<}HO3�LD<�F�Mg<y3�LDH ED7�<y�IR�<�JU3�VXHNF03�LD<W7�5?CDzN>8<|3�FG<�<�7�v0±f<}9O>87GHg3�FG58<�Ej9gFG<�zNBU>\9OFG58h�<�E_[O<�FG7�58HOCjHOV ZED9N�TH HN7G3�7GBDRoL]9O7�ª*JD7G58>8HOCI@ �TH HN7n3�58CUzDsOSDBI3=5A3(;T9O7=R�HNMJDBU3o9�3�58HOC�9O>8>Ae|BDCD7n3o9OSD>?<�9OCDE6ED58E6CDHQ39O>A3�<�F � CUED58CDzO7}M<�9OCD5?CDzOVXBD>?>?eOvg±®<~HNSD7G<�Fn[N<�EK3�L�9Q3}²�í²0 �;�9O7WR�HNMJ�9OF�9OSD>?<63�Hj9O>?>�HOV�3�LU<HO3�LD<�F*7n3o9OCDED9OF�EMg<y3�LDH ED7*R�HNCD7�5?ED<�FG<�Eg58C:3�LU587*J�9OJl<�F�<w�UR�<�JU3�VXHNF�3�LD<0<�7n3�F�HOzN<�CE�9Q3�9Uv*²�Ã$²� 9OCDE�¤I����HOV 3�<�CjFG< m BD5?F�<:9F�<�EDBDR�<�E�7�<�3ZHOV(VX<�9Q3�BDFG<�7ZVXHOFZ9S�<y3�3�<�FZJl<�FnVXHNF�Mg9OCDR�<Os�3�LDHNBUzNLj5?3

t �

Page 23: AWAXB YZP[Uhahn/research/CERP/papCERP.pdf$- ./ ! 0 +( 1#324 57678&9:; + ! ) ? @3ACB DCEGFHJILKMFB1N OQPR@3A STH/BVU AWAXB YZP[U \^]/H_EGET`ba[cRd>` efef` ghH NiP[j3AXF

R�9QC�S�<g9OJDJU>858<�E®3�H�E�9Q3�9_;0LD<�CPi � `.v_ Z>A3�LDHOBDzNL{CDHO3:FG<�JlHNFG3�<�E¡s­3�LD<gJ�<�FGVXHNFGM~9QCDR�<HOV¤ �Z�xs�Ã$²0 ½9QCDEj�U¢ ;�9Q7ZJlHIHNF�5?CpzO<�CD<�F�9O>�;0LD<�C.9O>8>�3�LD<xJDF�<�ED58Ry3�HNFG7�;=<�FG<}5?CDR�>?BDED<�E_58C,3�LU<MHIED<�>rv­ Â7�5?MgJU>8<T7GR�FG<�<�CU58CDz�3�H HN>I7�BDRoLg9O7(3�LU<0�=± F�9Q3�58H�5?7(BDC�9OSU>8<T3�H�R�9OJU3�BDF�<05?C�3�<�F�9OR�3�58HNCD758Cg3�LD<�ED9Q3o9:9QCDE][Q9OF�589OSD>8<�7�<�>8<�R�3�5?HNC~[ 5\9WF�9OCD¤�5?CDz:Mg9�eFG<�7�BU>?3�5?C&9:7�<y3�HOV$LD5?zNLD>Ae6R�HNFGF�<�>89Q3�<�ER�>89O7�7G5 � <�F�7�vZ¨�LD<�F�<�VXHOF�<Osl3�LD<}HNJU3�5?M~9Q>�C BUM:S�<�FZHOV�[O9QF�5\9QSD>8<�7�M:BU7G3�Sl<}EU<�3�<�F�M58CD<�E¡v���HOF�3�LU<zN<�CD<:58MJDFG58C�3�5?CDzgED9Q3o9Us�M~9QC�e_VX<�9�3�BDFG<�7�9OFG<:LD5?zNLD>?e,R�HNF�FG<�>89Q3�<�E¡s�;0LD5?RoL.R�HNC�3�FG58SDBI3�<�7�3�H]3�LU<JlHIHNF�F�<�>\9Q3�5?[O<WJl<�FnVXHNF�Mg9OCDR�<:9QV 3�<�F0[O9QF�5\9QSD>8<|7�R�F�<�<�CD5?CDz]VXHNF�>8H�;T<�F�[Q9O>?BD<�7�HOV*`.v Ñ CD<WHOV*3�LU<7G3�F�<�CDzO3�LU7ZHOV*¢�ª�µ�¼�587�3�LD9Q3ZCUHg[Q9OF�589OSD>?<�7�R�FG<�<�CD58CDzg5870CD<�R�<�7G7�9OFnel��;T<WM~9�e,R�HNCD7�5?ED<�F�9O>?>¡HOV3�LU<|VX<�9Q3�BUF�<�707G58M:BD>A3o9OCU<�HNBD7G>?e~58C&BD7G58CDzM:BD>A3�58JU>8<Z<�CD7�<�M:SD>?<�7�v

¨�LD<]Jl<�FnVXHNF�Mg9OCDR�<gHOV�� ¾|q ;�9O7}LD58zNLU>?e.ED<�J�<�CDED<�C�3:HNC®3�LD<~RoLDHO58R�<gHOV09_¤O<�FGCD<�>�v,¨�LD<ED<yVa9OBD>?3�HNJI3�58HOCgHOV¡µ��T�{5?Cg3�LU<Zµ¸� ¾�qÓJ�9ORo¤�9OzO<�z�9�[O<ZLD5?zNLD<�F�9OR�R�BDF�9OR�e63�L�9OC~>?58CD<�9OF*¤O<�F�CD<�>VXHNF�3�LD<|<�7G3�F�HNzO<�C_E�9Q3o9IsD;0LD58>?<�5?30z�9�[O<x>?H�;T<�F�9QR�R�BUF�9ORye&VXHNF�3�LD<|HO3�LD<�F�3�LDF�<�<xED9Q3o9c7�<y3�7�v

243]5?7gR�>8<�9QF63�L�9Q3]¢�ª�µ�¼¿9OCDEdµ��º7�LDH�;�9®7G58zNCU5 � R�9OC�3~5?MgJDFGH�[N<�M<�C�3gH�[N<�F3�LD<p7�5?CDzN>8<HNJU3�58Mg9O>­¢T �µ�¨�v�¨�LD<WH�[N<�F�9O>8>­9OR�R�BDF�9OR�epHOV�Í�Ë�ª=� ¨Ç587�R�HNMJ�9OF�9OSD>8<�3�H~HO3�LD<�FZ9OzNzNFG<�z�9Q3�58HNCM<�3�LUHIED70VXHNF03�LD<WR�HN>?HNCj9QCDEj>8<�BD¤O<�Mg589ED9Q3o9Us�;0LD5?>8<|5?3�587�J�H HNF�VXHNF03�LD<W<�7n3�F�HOzN<�C�9OCUE�zN<�CD<58MJDFG58C�3�5?CDz:E�9Q3�9Uv

±¸LD<�C|;=<�Jl<�FnVXHNF�M<�Ex¢=¾}s�3�LD<*FGBDC�3�5?Mg<(HQVD¢�ª�µ�¼p;T9O7$F�<�9Q7�HNC�9QSD>8<*R�HNMgJD9OF�<�E�3�H�3�L�9�3�HOVµ��¶9OCUEj�TH HN7G3�58CDzUvT��HNF�3�LU<WzN<�CD<x58MJDF�5?C�3�58CDzcED9Q3o9UsDVXHOF�<w�U9OMgJU>8<Os�5A3�3�H HN¤&9OJDJUF�H��I58Mg9Q3�<�>?e¦ Mg5?C�BU3�<�7]3�H � CD5?7�L 9 � u�@rVXHN>8E¸¢=¾ÒVXHOF_¢�@�¨¹¢�ª�µ�¼£;05A3�L �N� <�CU7�<�M}SD>8<�7�s�9OCUE 5A3]3�H HN¤9OJDJUF�H��I58Mg9Q3�<�>?eVXHNBDF�M58C�BU3�<�7�VXHNF0µ��KHNC_9c±¸58CDEUH¬;07ml�¼�tIv ° Ð|·�h|Mg9ORoLD5?CD<Ov

n �ý1�â(/�-.â(â(1�)#

±®<�L�9�[N<x58C�3�FGHIEDBUR�<�E_9cCD<y;�<�CU7�<�M}SD>8<w@�S�9O7G<�E_R�>89O7�7G5 � <�F�R�9O>?>8<�E_¢�ª�µ�¼�vl¢�ª�µ�¼d587TSDBD58>A3�BD7 @58CUz<�CD7�<�M:SD>?<�70HOV�R�>\9Q7�7�5 � R�9�3�58HOC,3�F�<�<�7W^r¢�@4¨Ç¢�ª�µ�¼�b09OCDE_>8HNzO587G3�58R�F�<�zOF�<�7G7�5?HNC_3�F�<�<�7W^�Ã$µ�@�¨¢�ª�µ�¼�b�9O7|S�9O7G<gR�>\9O7G7�5 � <�FG7�vc2�C�3�LD5?7�7�<�CU7�<Os­3�LD<6M<�3�LDHIE�5?7�CDHO3|VXBDCDE�9QMg<�C�3�9O>8>Ae�EU5?©�<�F�<�C�3VXF�HOMǵ��=s�;0LD58RoLW587¡3�F�<�<w@�S�9Q7�<�E}9O>87GHDv�·�H�;T<y[N<�F�sNHNCU<�5?MgJlHNFn3o9OC�3$ED5?7G3�5?CDR�3�58HNC�Sl<�3�;=<�<�C6¢�ª�µ�¼9OCDE]µ��{587�3�LD<Z;T9�eg3�LD<ZLU58zNLI@4ED58M<�CU7�58HOC�9O>DE�9�3o9}9QF�<ZLD9OCDED>?<�E¡v�¢�ª�µ�¼PBU7�<�7�9}J�9OFn3�5?3�58HNCU58CDz7�RoLU<�M<Z3�H:R�F�<�9Q3�<�M:BU3�BD9O>8>Aec<y�IR�>?BD7�5A[N<�7GBDSD7G<�3�7�HQV�3�LD<�VX<�9Q3�BDF�<�7�sI;0LU58>8<�µ��®F�9QCDEDHNM>?e67�9OM6@

tNt

Page 24: AWAXB YZP[Uhahn/research/CERP/papCERP.pdf$- ./ ! 0 +( 1#324 57678&9:; + ! ) ? @3ACB DCEGFHJILKMFB1N OQPR@3A STH/BVU AWAXB YZP[U \^]/H_EGET`ba[cRd>` efef` ghH NiP[j3AXF

JD>?<�7�VXF�HOM¿3�LD<|<�C�3�5?F�<�JlHIHN>�HOV$VX<�9Q3�BDF�<�709Q30<�9QRoLpCDH ED<Qv��THO3�L,5?C�3�F�H EDBDR�<�ED5?[O<�F�7G5?3�eOsU;0LD58RoL,5?7CD<�R�<�7G7�9OFnec3�H�JUF�H EDBDR�<�zN9O58CD7�S�eW3o9O¤�5?CDz�9�R�HOCD7�<�CD7�BD7�HOVlMg9OC�e}R�>\9O7G7�5 � <�FG7�v( �C69OEU[Q9OC�3o9OzO<�HOV¢�ª�µ�¼{H�[N<�F�µ���587�3�L�9Q3�;T<0R�9QCg9QRoLD58<y[N<09�F�9QJD58Ec5?MgJDFGH�[N<�M<�C�3*HQVl3�LD<�JDFG<�ED5?R�3�58HNC69OR�R�BDF�9OR�eS�e:<�CD7�<�M:SD>8<�[OHO3�5?CDz�EDBU<�3�H|9�7�Mg9O>?>IR�HNF�FG<�>\9�3�58HOC:9OMHNCDzZ3�LD<�3�FG<�<�7*S�e:9�[NHN5?ED58CDz�3�LD<�H�[N<�F�>89OJHOV�<�9ORoL�7�BDSD7G<�3|;0LD<�F�<:3�LU<c58CDED5A[ 58EDB�9Q>$3�F�<�<:587�R�HNCD7n3�F�BUR�3�<�E¡v|±f<cL�9�[O<c7�LDH�;0C�<�MJD58FG58R�9O>8>Ae3�LD9Q3(L�BDzN<�ED9Q3o9Z7G<�3�7(CD<�<�E6CDHO3(Sl<�L�9QCDED>8<�Ec9O7*9�;0LDHN>8<Q�N3�LD<T7�BDSD7GJ�9OR�<�7�HOV�3�LU<TVX<�9Q3�BDF�<T7�J�9OR�<R�FG<�9Q3�<�E�3�LDFGHNBDzNL�J�9QFG3�5A3�5?HNCD58CUz]M~9�e�S�<:3�F�<�9�3�<�E{58CUED<�Jl<�CDEU<�C�3�>Ae�9OCDE�7�<�J�9OF�9Q3�<�>?e.BDC�3�58>*9QV\@3�<�FZ3�LU<:R�>89O7�7G5 � <�F�7|9OFG<}ED<y[N<�>?HNJl<�E¡vx¨�LD587ZzN5?[O<�7|¢�ª�µ�¼Æ9]L�BDzN<cR�HNMgJUBU3o9Q3�58HNCD9O>­9OEU[Q9OC�3o9OzO<3�Hc3�9ORo¤�>858CUz63�LD<|zNF�H�;05?CDz6JDF�HNSU>8<�MîHOV�EU58M<�CD7G58HNC�9Q>85?3�eOv*Ã�58¤Q<Wµ��Ts�¢�ª�µ�¼ÂEDH <�70CDHO3�F�< m BD58FG<[Q9OF�589OSD>?<TJDFG<y@�7G<�>?<�R�3�58HNC�sO3�L�BD7�5?3(587(7n3�F�9Q58zNL�3�VXHOFG;T9OF�E69OCUE<�9O7Ge}3�H�58MJD>?<�M<�C�3�3�LD<09O>8zOHNF�5A3�LDM_v

±f<�9O>87GH}7�LUH¬;=<�E&3�L�9Q30¢�ª�µ�¼k5?7TR�HNMgJD9OF�9OSU>8<�3�H:R�HNC�[N<�C�3�58HNCD9O>�R�>\9O7G7�5 � R�9Q3�58HNCgMg<y3�LDH ED7�v¨�LD<&R�>\9O7G7�5 � R�9Q3�58HNC�M<�3�LDH ED7};=<_7G<�>?<�R�3�<�EKVXHNF:R�HNMJ�9OF�5?7�HNCfJ�<�FGVXHNFGMg<�E�;T<�>8>=;05A3�LKCDH�HNCU<M<�3�LUHIE.HNBI3�Jl<�FGVXHOF�M58CDz3�LD<:HQ3�LD<�F�7�R�HOCD7�5?7G3�<�C�3�>?eOv}Ë�7�5?CDz,9&¢=¾�<�7n3�5?M~9Q3�<Os�;=<69ORoLD5?<�[O<�E{9R�HOCD7�5?7G3�<�C�3�>?e]LD58zNL_9OR�R�BDF�9OR�e,BU7�58CUz]¢�ª�µ�¼�v�¨�LD5870LD5?zNL_9OR�R�BDF�9QR�e&;T9O7�9ORoLD58<y[N<�EjEDBD<�3�H63�LU<ED5A[N<�FG7�5A3�e&R�FG<�9Q3�<�E�Sl<�3�;=<�<�C�R�>\9O7G7�5 � <�F�7�v

 ZR�R�HNFGED58CDzx3�HxHNBDF�7G3�BDEUeNsIµ��{5?7�R�HNMJ�9OF�9QSD>8<�3�HxHO3�LD<�F�<y�I587n3�5?CDzWR�>\9O7G7�5 � R�9Q3�58HNC6M<�3�LDHIEU758C�[ 58<y;KHOVU9OR�R�BDF�9QR�eNv(·�H�;T<y[N<�F�sN5A3$L�9O7$S�<�<�CW7�LDH�;0C}3�H�Jl<�FnVXHNF�MÆJ�H HNF�>Ae�5?Cx5?CD7G3�9OCDR�<�7­HOVDR�>\9O7G758M}S�9O>\9QCDR�<}^r�I<�z�9O>�s�tOuNu § byv�²�BDEDHN5A3�9OCDE,��FG58ED>Ae�9OCDEj^rtOuOu ´ b�CUHO3�<�E]3�L�9Q3�µ��fLD9OE&ED5\²R�BD>?3�58<�7;05?3�LKBDC�S�9O>89OCDR�<�EPR�>\9Q7�7:7G58h�<�769OCDEk9O>?MgHN7n3:9Q>?;T9�e 7cJDFG<�ED5?R�3�<�EK3�LD<&Mg9¬«GHNFG5?3�e{R�>89O7�7�v�¢TLU<�C<�3x9Q>rv�^rtOuNu § b�7n3o9Q3�<�E.3�L�9�3�MgHO7G3�R�HNMMgHNCU>?e_BD7�<�E�R�>\9Q7�7�5 � R�9�3�58HOC.9O>8zOHNF�5A3�LDM7�EUH&CDHO3�;=HNF�¤;=<�>8>�VXHNFc3�LD<�5?M:S�9O>89OCDR�<&HQV�7�<�CD7�5A3�5A[I5A3�ek9OCDE¶7�Jl<�R�5 � R�5A3�ePS�<�R�9OBU7�<p3�LD<�e¶9O5?M 3�H{M58CD5?Mg5?h�<3�LU<xH�[O<�F�9Q>8>¡<�F�F�HOF�F�9Q3�<Os�F�9�3�LD<�F�3�L�9OC_J�9�e 58CDz67GJ�<�R�5\9Q>�9Q3�3�<�C�3�5?HNC&3�Hc3�LU<xM58CUHNF�5A3�egR�>\9O7G7�v*±®<9O>?7�H}VXHNBUCDE&58C~3�LD<�7n3�BDEUe~HNC]3�LU<�zN<�CU<�58MJDF�5?C�3�58CDzxE�9Q3�9W3�LD9Q30µ��fzN5?[O<�709}JlH HNFT7G<�CD7G5?3�5A[ 5?3�eNs;0LD5?>8<~5A3:zN5A[N<�7c9O>8MHN7n3:Jl<�FGVX<�R�3c7GJ�<�R�5 � R�5A3�eNv�¨�LD587}58M:S�9Q>\9OCDR�<g5?7:CDHO3:ED<�7G58F�9QSD>8<gS�<�R�9OBD7G<,9zNH�9Q>­LU<�F�<x58703�Hg58ED<�C�3�5?V e]MgHNFG<WJlHN7G5?3�5A[N<�7:^X58MJDF�5?C�3�<�E,zN<�CD<�7�byvZ¢�ª�µ�¼¸9OJDJl<�9OFG7�3�H~Jl<�FnVXHNF�M;=<�>8>�5?CgSD9O>\9OCUR�58CUz�7�Jl<�R�5 � R�5A3�e9OCDE7�<�CD7�5A3�5?[ 5A3�ec58C6BDC�S�9O>89OCDR�<�E~ED9Q3o9|7�<y3�7�v*¨�LU<�Mg9O58CcFG<�9O7GHNC587�3�L�9�3�3�LD<:S�9O7G<}3�FG<�<�7�HOV=¢�ª�µ�¼ 9OFG<}HNJU3�58Mg9O>¡3�FG<�<�7�s�;0LD5?>8<|3�LDHO7�<:HOV*µ��Â9QF�<WVXBU>8>?e,zOF�H�;0C3�FG<�<�7$;05A3�LDHOBU3$JDF�BUCD58CDzUv�2�CWÃ$µ�@4¨�¢�ª�µ�¼�s�3�LU<�HOJU3�5?M~9O>¬3�LUF�<�7GLDHN>?EWRoLDHO58R�<�LD<�>8JD7�5?MgJUF�H�[N<*3�LU<

t ´

Page 25: AWAXB YZP[Uhahn/research/CERP/papCERP.pdf$- ./ ! 0 +( 1#324 57678&9:; + ! ) ? @3ACB DCEGFHJILKMFB1N OQPR@3A STH/BVU AWAXB YZP[U \^]/H_EGET`ba[cRd>` efef` ghH NiP[j3AXF

S�9O>89OCDR�<Ov$±f<�9OFG<*M~9Q58CD>Ae�5?C�3�<�FG<�7n3�<�Ex58C|7GLDH�;058CDz�3�LU<*<�CDL�9QCDR�<�E:9OR�R�BDF�9OR�e�5?C�3�LD5?7¡J�9OJl<�F�sQSDBI33�LU<WSl<�3G3�<�F�S�9O>89OCDR�<x5?7�97n3�F�HOCDz~9�3�3�FG58SDBI3�<|HOV�¢�ª�µ�¼�9O70;T<�>8>rv=��BDFG3�LD<�F�<y�IJD>?HNF�9�3�58HOC_HQV�3�LU<Jl<�FGVXHOF�Mg9OCDR�<0HOV$¢�ª�µ�¼�;05?3�LgFG<�7�Jl<�Ry3T3�HW5?M:S�9O>89OCDR�<�;05?>8>DSl<�EUHNCD<�58CgVXBI3�BDFG<�;=HNF�¤�v* �MgHNCUz3�LU<_R�>\9O7G7�5 � R�9Q3�58HNCk9OCUE¶ED5?7�R�F�58M58CD9Q3�5?HNCfM<�3�LDHIEU7R�HNCD7G58ED<�F�<�E¶58CK3�LU58767G3�BDEUeNsTÃ$²� Ws*¤I���9OCDE{�U¢Ñ7GLDH�;T<�Ef9~FGHNSDBD7n3|S�9O>89OCDR�<WHOV�3�LD<}7�<�CU7�5?3�5?[ 5?3�e�9OCDE.7GJ�<�R�5 � R�5A3�e�;05?3�L.9]F�<�9O7�HOC�9OSD>?<9OR�R�BDF�9OR�eOv®·�H�;T<y[N<�F�s�9jEDF�9�;0S�9ORo¤®HOV�3�LU<�7�<&M<�3�LDH ED7}5?7W3�LD9Q3:3�LU<�e®HOV 3�<�CKF�< m BD5?F�<&9pJDF�<w@7�<�>8<�R�3�5?HNCjHOV�JUF�<�EU58R�3�HNF�7�VXHNF�9]zNH H E�Jl<�FGVXHOF�Mg9OCDR�<Qv� �[Q9OFG5\9OSD>?<W7G<�>?<�R�3�58HNC.R�9OC.Sl<}R�HOMgJD>?<y�9OCDE,3�5?Mg<ZR�HNCD7GBDM58CDzDv

�I58CUR�<p9O>8>�3�LD<pJD9OF�9OM<�3�<�FG7g9QF�<_ED<�3�<�F�M58CU<�Ed5?Ck3�LD<,3�F�9Q58CD5?CDz.JDL�9O7G<�HOV�3�LD<_JDFGHNzNF�9QMps¢�ª�µ�¼¶ED58E,CDHO30FG< m BD5?F�<|9OC�e � CU<|3�BDCD5?CDz:VXHNF�7�Jl<�R�5 � R|E�9�3o9c7�<y3�7058C&3�LU<�R�HNMJ�9OFG587�HOC¡v(¨�L�BD75?3gR�9QCdSl<�BD7G<�EÂVXHNFg9OC�eP3�eIJl<jHOV�LD58zNL @�ED5?Mg<�CD7�5?HNC�9O>�ED9Q3o9{7�<�3�vÄ �>?3�LDHNBDzNLdµ��Ñ3�<�CDED7g3�HJl<�FGVXHOF�M�;T<�>8>�;05A3�L]3�LU<�ED<�Va9QBD>?3�JD9OF�9OM<�3�<�FT[Q9O>?BD<�7�sI3�LD<�J�<�FGVXHNFGM~9QCDR�<�Mg9�e~EU<�Jl<�CDE,HNC&3�LU<C�BDM:Sl<�F*HOVlR�>\9O7G7�5 � <�F�7�HNF(C�BDM:Sl<�F*HOV�F�9OCDEDHOMg>AeW7G<�>?<�R�3�<�EJDF�<�ED58Ry3�HNFG7(58Cc<�9ORoL6CDH ED<�HOV�9Z3�FG<�<Qv±¸LD<�CpBD7G58CDz:3�LD<xµ��T��¤O<�FGCD<�>¡VXHOF�� ¾|qp7�s�9 � CD<�3�BUCD58CDzcHQV�3�LD<�F�<�>8<�[Q9OC�30J�9QF�9OM<�3�<�F�7T7�BDRoL9O7�¤O<�F�CD<�>­;05?EU3�Lp5870CD<�<�ED<�E�v Ñ V 3�<�C�9gED<yVa9OBD>?3�EDH <�7�CDHO30;=HNF�¤&[O<�FGe,;=<�>?>$VXHOF�>89OF�zO<xC�BDM}S�<�FHOV�9Q3�3�F�5?SDBU3�<�7�v

 ZC~9OEU[Q9OC�3o9OzO<03�HWR�HNM:SD5?CD58CUz�ED<�R�587�5?HNCc3�FG<�<�7�587*3�L�9Q3�;T<�9OFG<�9QSD>8<�3�H|BD7G<�LU58zNLD>AeÞã�<w�I58SD>?<MHIED<�>87�v� �V 3�<�F�9�[N<�F�9OzN5?CDz~3�LD<}JDFG<�ED5?R�3�58HNCD7�9OR�F�HN7G7�S�9O7G<:R�>89O7�7G5 � <�F�7�s�;=<c9OF�<}9OSD>?<x3�H]F�<y3o9O5?C3�LU<j58C�3�<�F�9ORy3�5?HNCD7]9QCDE�CDHNCI@4>85?CD<�9OFR�HOMgJlHNCD<�C�3�7~VXHNBDCUE�58CÂ<�9ORoL�HOV|3�LD<p3�F�<�<�7�v�·�H�;T<y[N<�F�s¢�ª�µ�¼ÄCD<�<�EfCDHO3|CU<�R�<�7�7�9OF�5?>?e.Sl<c3�F�<�<y@4S�9O7�<�E¡vg¢THNCDR�<�JU3�B�9O>8>AeNs­9OC�ej3�e Jl<HQVTS�9Q7�<6R�>89O7�7G5 � <�FR�9QCpSl<|BD7�<�E¡v�¨�LD587�;058>?>�Sl<x9c3�HNJD5?R�HOV�VXBI3�BDFG<xFG<�7G<�9OFGRoL¡v

�THO3�Lj¢�ª�µ�¼�9OCDEpµ��K7�LUH¬;�7�58zOCD5 � R�9OC�3�58MJDF�H�[N<�Mg<�C�30H¬[O<�FZ¢T �µ�¨�v� �>?3�LUHNBDzNLp¢�ª�µ�¼9OJDJl<�9QF�7|3�H�Jl<�FnVXHNF�MÒR�HNCD7G587G3�<�C�3�>Ae.;T<�>8>�HNC®E�9Q3o9,7�<y3�7xVXF�HNMÒED5A©�<�F�<�C�3}9OFG<�9O7�s(9&VX<�;�587G7�BD<�7F�<�M~9Q58C�3�H&S�<:5?C�[N<�7n3�5?z�9Q3�<�E¡vx ZC.HNS�[ 58HNBU7�R�HN7n3|HOV�3�LD5?7�HNF�9QC�ep<�CU7�<�M}SD>8<69OJUJDF�H�9QRoL{5?7Z3�LU<�GSD>89ORo¤�SlH��U��>\9ORo¤�HQVD58C�3�<�F�JUF�<�3�9OSD5?>85?3�e�HOVI3�LD<�F�<�7�BD>A3�58CUz�R�>\9O7G7�5 � <�F�v�·�H�;=<�[O<�F�s�9Q7$3�LD<�Mg5?R�F�HN9OFn@F�9�e�>?5?3�<�F�9Q3�BDF�<6L�9Q7W7GLDH�;0C¡s�3�LU< � C�9Q>�MH ED<�>*5?7WL�9QF�ED>Ae � � C�9Q>8�p9OCDE®[Q9OFG5\9OSU>8<c58MJlHNFG3�9OCDR�<M:BD7n3­S�<*3�FG<�9Q3�<�EWR�9OBU3�58HNBU7�>?eZzN5?[O<�C|3�LD<�R�HNMgJUBU3o9Q3�58HNCD9O>NSDBDFGED<�CWHOV ;T<�58zNLD5?CDz0<�9ORoLx[Q9OF�589OSD>8<QÎØ7R�HOC�3�F�5?SDBU3�5?HNC]9QMgHNCUz:9O>?>�R�HNM:SU58C�9Q3�58HNCU7=HOV¡HO3�LD<�F=[Q9OFG5\9OSD>?<�7�v(��HNFTJUF�<�EU58R�3�5?[O<ZJDBDFGJ�HO7�<�7�sD5?3�5?7

t §

Page 26: AWAXB YZP[Uhahn/research/CERP/papCERP.pdf$- ./ ! 0 +( 1#324 57678&9:; + ! ) ? @3ACB DCEGFHJILKMFB1N OQPR@3A STH/BVU AWAXB YZP[U \^]/H_EGET`ba[cRd>` efef` ghH NiP[j3AXF

MHN7G3Z58MJ�HNFn3o9OC�3�3�H&zN<�CD<�F�9Q3�<:9OC�9OR�R�BDF�9�3�<c9OCUE.F�HNSDBU7G3|MHIED<�>rs�;05?3�LjED<�7GR�FG58JU3�5?[N<69Q7�Jl<�R�3�7>8<yV 3W9O7:9_7�<�JD9OF�9Q3�<~<w�U<�F�R�587�<]9OCDEfCUHO3:zN<�CD<�F�9Q3�<�EK9O7W9pS�e�@�JDFGHIEUBDR�3cHQV�HNCD<gF�<�JDF�<�7�<�C�3�9Q3�5A[N<MHIED<�>rv�±®<�;058>?>�<y�IJD>?HNF�<�[Q9OFG5\9OSD>?<�58MJlHNFG3�9OCDR�<Z58C&VXBU3�BUF�<|7G3�BDED58<�7�v

o /qp&#j)srëá�Ý�+jçgÞ Ý�#&%

·�HOCDzN7�LU58¤~ �LDC¡ÎÏ70F�<�7G<�9OFGRoL_;T9O70J�9OFn3�589O>8>Ae67�BDJDJlHNFn3�<�E,S�e]3�LD<|��9OR�BD>A3�e]µ0<�7G<�9OFGRoLj¼�9OFG3�58R�5?J�9�@3�5?HNC&¼*F�HOzNF�9OM¿9Q3=3�LD<���¢T¨0µ�9OEUMg5?CD587n3�<�FG<�EgS�eg3�LD< Ñ 9Q¤~µ058EDzO<�2�CD7n3�5A3�BU3�<ZVXHNF�� R�58<�CDR�<|9QCDEª*EDBDR�9Q3�5?HNC&3�LDFGHNBDzNLp9OC,58C�3�<�F�9OzO<�CDRye_9OzNF�<�<�M<�C�30Sl<�3�;=<�<�CjË��U² Ñ ªÂ9OCUEpËZ�U�(²0 }v

�ÓÝ�ßNÝ�'�Ý�#./�Ý�â

 �LDC¡s�·xv�9OCDE�¢TLD<�C�sd�Uvt�UvAs ��¥N¥�¦ v­¨­F�<�<y@47G3�FGBDR�3�BDF�<�EW>?HNzN5?7G3�5?R�MHIEU<�>QVXHOF¡H�[N<�F @�ED5?7�Jl<�FG7�<�ESD5?CDHNM5\9O>�E�9Q3�9_;05?3�L�9OJUJD>85?R�9Q3�58HNCj3�H�MHIED<�>85?CDz&ED<�[O<�>?HNJDM<�C�3o9O>�<�©�<�Ry3�7�vvumw ÚhxÛ"ß�Ân¿ wdõ àzy]{9| §N´ �¬@ § �N�Iv

 �¤�9O58¤Q<Os�·xv?s ��¥�¦�§ vP �CU<�;»>?HIHO¤�9Q3c3�LD<p7n3o9Q3�587n3�58R�9O>T5?ED<�C�3�5 � R�9Q3�5?HNCPMgH ED<�>�v~}z�&�&�� ¿-ÁCØLà'Á õ  w ÚÜØ�ÚÜØ����xÂOÚÜÛÐÁC wdõ�� ÚÜØVÂn¿ ÚÜñ�y���� ¦ ��¯ @ ¦ t ´ v

 �>8HNC�sDËWvAs���9OFG¤�9O5rs��xv?sD��HO3G3�<�FGM~9QC¡s�²:vD Wv?slÐ�587GL¡s�Êcv?s(��S�9OFGF�9Us��lv?slq�9QRo¤lsl²:v09OCUEWÃ�<y[I5?CD<Os Wv��UvAs ��¥N¥O¥ v��=F�H�9OE}J�9Q3�3�<�FGCD7*HOV�zN<�CD<�<w�UJUF�<�7G7�5?HNC6F�<�[O<�9O>?<�EcS�eWR�>8BU7G3�<�F�5?CDz�9OC�9Q>A@e 7�5?7ZHOV�3�BDMHNF�9OCDE�CUHNF�Mg9O>$R�HN>?HNCp3�587G7�BD<�7ZJDFGHNS�<�EjS�e_HN>85?zNHNC�BDR�>?<�HO3�58ED<|9QF�F�9�e 7�v� ¿ Ú õ ß�ß-Ù w Ø��Üà©Ú����ËÁC w ÚÜØ�ÁCñt� õ ÁFÙxß�Û���Ú��Y� õ�w ß�Ø õ ßzyf�t� ¯�¦Q§ �¬@ ¯�¦ �OuIv

 �M:SDFGHN587G<Os�¢Zv�9OCUE�q_R�Ã$9ORoLD>89OC¡slÐcvt�Uv?s�tOuNuNtIv¸�I<�>8<�Ry3�5?HNC¶SU5\9O758CkzN<�CU<�<y� 3�F�9ORy3�58HOCHNC_3�LD<xS�9O7G587�HOV(M58R�F�H�9QF�F�9�e~zN<�CD<w@�<w�UJUF�<�7G7�5?HNC.E�9Q3�9Uv�� ¿ Ú õ ß�ß-Ù w Ø��Üà Ú�����ÁC w ÚÜØ�ÁCñ� õ ÁFÙxß�Û���Ú���� õ�w ß�Ø õ ßzy��9� ¯ � ¯ t¬@ ¯ � ¯N¯ v

�=>\9O5?F�sIµxvAs���9OCDzDs�·xv?sD�TF�9OCUL�9OM_sU±Ñvl��vAs�·Z9O7G7�s��ZvAs�²�5\9O>�sD�lv�Ã�vAs�qpHN>89OCDE¡s�¢Zv¬Ã*vAs�¨­HNCDzUs±ÑvAs�� LD5rs=Ã*v?s=¼�<�F�¤�58CD7�s�µ|v*9OCDE¶�ILU<�<�LD9OC¡s�²:v�q{v?sTtOuNuNuIvKª*7G3�FGHNzN<�C¶FG<�R�<�JU3�HOFFG<�>\9�3�5?[O<&SD58CUED58CDz{9�²CD5A3�5?<�7cHOV ��°N° C�9Q3�BDF�9Q>09OCDEK�U<�CDH RoLD<�M58R�9O>87�³���3�F�BUR�3�BUF�9O>ED5A[N<�F�7�5A3�e&HOV�>85?z�9OCDED7�v$� Ú�� wdõ ÚÜñXÚE� wdõ ÁCñt� õ�w ß�Ø õ ß�àzyf{.� ��´N° @ � � ´ v

�=F�9OCDLD9OMps ±Ñvl��vAs�²�5\9O>�sD��v�Ã*vAslqpHN>89OCDE¡s�¢Zv�Ã*vAs�·Z9Q7�7�sl�Zvl�lv?s��T>89O58F�sUµ|vlq®vAs��l9QCDzDs¬·WvAs�ILU5rsIÃ�vAs ¨�HNCUzDs ±ÑvAsD¼­<�FG¤ 5?CD7�sDµxv 9OCDE&�ILD<�<�L�9OC¡sU²:vDq{v?sUtOuNu�t v*¼*L�e�3�HI<�7G3�FGHNzN<�CD79OCUEMWeIR�HI<�7G3�F�HNzN<�CD7�SD58CDEc3�H�3�LD<0F�9�3�BU3�<�F�58CU<�<�7G3�F�HNzO<�CF�<�R�<�JU3�HNF�v��f� ß7�]Úh�x¿EØ�ÁCñÚ������xÂ�¿ w  w ÚÜØ(y���|t� ¯ � ° @ ¯N¯O§ v

�=F�<�5?M~9QC¡sDÃ*vAs ��¥N¥N¯ v*�T9OzNzN5?CDzcJDF�<�ED58Ry3�HNFG7�v7� Á õz��w ØZß� éß-ÁC¿�Ø w Ø��hy��?� � t ´ @ ��§ uUv

tN�

Page 27: AWAXB YZP[Uhahn/research/CERP/papCERP.pdf$- ./ ! 0 +( 1#324 57678&9:; + ! ) ? @3ACB DCEGFHJILKMFB1N OQPR@3A STH/BVU AWAXB YZP[U \^]/H_EGET`ba[cRd>` efef` ghH NiP[j3AXF

�=F�<�5?M~9QC¡sDÃ*vAs ��¥N¥N° v( �F�R�58CDz6R�>89O7�7G5 � <�F�7�v*�f� ß¡��ØVØ�ÁCñ à©Ú��Y�]ÂÁC w à� wdõ àzy]�9� ° u � @ °O§N¥ v�=F�<�5?M~9QC¡sDÃ*vAsZtQuNu � v*µ�9OCDEUHNMîVXHNFG<�7G3�v7� Á õz��w ØZß� éß-ÁC¿EØ w Ø��hy���{ �¬@ ´ tIv�=F�<�5?M~9QC¡sDÃ*vAs���FG58<�EDM~9QC¡s.�Uv�·xv?s Ñ >?7�LD<�C¡s�µxvU }v�9OCDE�� 3�HNCD<Osl¢Zvt�UvAs ��¥N°O§ v¢� ñöÁÜà�à w ï&xõ ÁC w ÚÜØÖÁCØ�Ù × ß1�C¿ ß�à�à w ÚÜØ � ¿ ß�ß�ण ±�9OEU7G;=HNFG3�L¡s��T<�>?MgHOC�3�s�¢T }v�=BDF�CDLD9OMpsDÊ6vD¼�v�9OCDE_ ZCUED<�FG7�HNC¡sl²:v�µ|vAsZtQuNu�tIv�� Ú'Ùxß�ñi�«ß�ñXß õ  w ÚÜØ�ÁCØ�Ù � ��ñe w ØZÚÜÛ w ÁCñ

} Ø¥��ß�¿�ß�Ø õ ߤ¦c� � ¿`Á õ  wdõ ÁCñ } Ø¥��ÚÜ¿EÛÐÁC w ÚÜØ.x �f� ß�ÚÜ¿ ß� wdõ �úÀFÀ�¿ Ú'Á õz��^�tQCDE�<�E¡vÕbwsN� JDF�5?CDzN<�F¾�<�F�>\9QzDsD��<�;§��HNFG¤�v

¢TLU<�C¡sl¢ZvAs�Ã�5\9�;|s� }v�9QCDE��=F�<�5?M~9QC¡sDÃ*vAsZtQuNu § vË�7G58CDz,F�9OCDEDHNMÓVXHNF�<�7G3|3�H_>8<�9OF�C�58Mc@S�9Q>\9OCDR�<�EgE�9Q3o9Iv0^F� ß õz� Ø wdõ ÁCñV¿�ßOÀVÚÜ¿EÂ�¨�©�©�©ªy ²�<�J�9OFn3�M<�C�3THQV­� 3o9�3�587n3�5?R�7�s Ë�CD5?[O<�Fn@7G5?3�e&HOV(¢�9O>?5?VXHNFGCD5\9Us �T<�F�¤Q<�>8<yeNv

¢TLU<�C¡st�Uvt�UvAs�¨�7�9O5�s�¢Zv� }vAs(��HNBDCUzDst�Uv��Tv�9OCUEpÊ�H ED<�>?>rsUµxv�Ã*vAs�tOuNu��IvÅ¢T>\9O7G7�5 � R�9Q3�58HNC<�CD7�<�M:SD>8<�7cVXHNF:BDC�S�9O>89OCDR�<�EPR�>89O7�7c7G58h�<�7658CKJDFG<�ED5?R�3�5A[N<]3�H��I5?R�HN>?HNzOeNv �i� × ÁCØ�Ù« �i� ׬w Ø � Ø.­ w ¿�ÚÜØVÛ"ß�ØVÂdÁCñ × ß�à�ß-ÁC¿ õz� y���� � �¬¦ @ �Nt ¥ v

²�<y3�3�>858CUzDsDq{v�9OCDEp�TBDLD>?M~9OC�sD¼�vAs�tOuNu ´ v��TH HN7G3�58CDz{VXHNFg3�BDMHNF~R�>\9O7G7�5 � R�9Q3�58HNCP;05?3�LzN<�CD<|<y�IJDFG<�7�7G58HNCpE�9Q3�9Uvqukw Ú w Ø¥��ÚÜ¿EÛÐÁC wdõ àzy���� � u ¯U� @ � u ¯N¥ v

²�HOMg5?CDzNHN7�sU¼­v?s ��¥N¥O¥ v(q_<�3o9QR�HN7n3�³­ dÐ�<�CU<�F�9Q>Uq_<�3�LUHIExVXHNF�q�9O¤�58CDzZ¢T>\9Q7�7�5 � <�FG7(¢THO7G3G@�I<�CD7�5A3�5A[N<Ov2�C¡³�� ¿�Ú õ ß�ß-Ù w Ø��Üà"Ú��  � ߯®C � � }±°�²Y³�³´} ØVÂOß�¿EØ�ÁC w ÚÜØ�ÁCñ � ÚÜØ¥��ß�¿�ß�Ø õ ßÚÜØ ² ØZÚhµÇñXß-Ùª�xß ³Yw à õ Úh­Cß�¿�� ÁCØ�Ù ³ ÁCÂdÁ �¶w Ø w Ø��hy  �¢�q�¼�FG<�7G7�s��U9OC�²�5?<�zNHDs�¢T }s� �O�¬@ ��¯Q§ v

²�BUEDHN5?3�s���v�9QCDE_��FG58ED>Ae�9OCUE¡s9�UvAsZtQuNu ´ vg¢T>\9Q7�7�5 � R�9�3�58HOC{5?C®M58R�F�H�9QF�F�9�ep<y�IJl<�F�5?Mg<�C�3�7�v2�C¡³�¨�vI¼­vD� J�<�<�E.^aª*E¡vÕbws �]ÂdÁC w à� wdõ ÁCñi��Ø�ÁCñ·�:à w à�Ú�� ° ß�ØZß � �%À�¿ ß�à�à w ÚÜØ �¶wdõ ¿ Ú'ÁC¿�¿`Á>�³ ÁCÂdÁhy ¢TL�9OJDMg9OC_9OCDEp·Z9O>?> ÔN¢�µ�¢¸¼*FG<�7�7�s��=HIR�9µ�9Q3�HNC¡s��(Ã*s�¢TLD9OJU3�<�F ´ v

²�BUEDHN5?3�s���vAs���F�5?ED>?eN9OCDE¡s?�Uv�9OCDE��IJ�<�<�E¡s�¨�v�¼­v?s�tOuOu�tIvÑ¢THNMJ�9OFG587GHNCÂHOV|ED5?7�R�F�58M58CD9�@3�58HNCpMg<y3�LDH ED7�VXHOF�3�LD<:R�>89O7�7G5 � R�9Q3�5?HNC_HOV*3�BDMHNFG7ZBD7G58CDzgzN<�CD<}<y�IJDF�<�7�7G58HNC.E�9�3o9Uv�VÚh�x¿�Ø�ÁCñwÚ��  � ß���Û"ß�¿ wdõ ÁCض�]ÂdÁC w à� wdõ ÁCñt��à�à�Ú õ�w ÁC w ÚÜØ(yf��¸ ¦N¦ @ °�¦ v

²�BU58C¡sUµxv�¼­vU±Ñv�9OCDE_¨�9¬��s�²:v�q®vt�Uv?s�tOuOuNuUv0ª��IJ�<�F�58M<�C�3�7�;05?3�L�R�>\9O7G7�5 � <�F�R�HNM:SU58CI@5?CDzpFGBD>8<�7�v]2�C�³��Uv­Ê�5?3�3�>8<�F�9OCDEf�Tv­µ�HN>?50^�ª*ED7�vÕbws  éß õ ¹��¿ ß*�!ÚÜÂOß�à w Ø � ÚÜÛ�Àt��ÂOß�¿� õ�w ß�Ø õ ßzy���º9{d¸ �IJDF�5?CDzN<�F�s��T<�F�>?58CD<Qs ��¯ @ t ¥ v

��FG<�BDCDE�s(�cv�9OCUEj�IRoLD9OJD58FG<Os�µ|v?s ��¥O¥N¯ vѪ��IJ�<�F�58M<�C�3�7~;05?3�L¸9�CD<�;ÓS�H HN7n3�58CUz�9O>?zNHQ@FG5?3�LUMpv*2�C»� Á õz��w ØZßY éß-ÁC¿EØ w Ø���¦ � ¿�Ú õ ß�ß-Ù w Ø��ÜàÞÚ��� � ß �f��w ¿EÂOß�ß�ØV �¯} ØVÂjß�¿EØ�ÁC w ÚÜØ�ÁCñ� ÚÜØ¥��ß�¿ ß�Ø õ ßzy JDJ¡v ��§�° @ � � ¯ v

��FG<�BDCDE�s(�cv�9OCUEj�IRoLD9OJD58FG<Os�µ|v?s ��¥O¥�¦ v} ÈEU<�R�5?7�5?HNCI@43�LD<�HOF�<�3�58RWzN<�CD<�F�9O>?58h�9Q3�5?HNCjHOV=HNCI@>?58CD<>8<�9OF�CD5?CDzp9OCDEP9OCK9QJDJD>85?R�9Q3�58HNC.3�HjS�H HN7n3�58CUzDv �VÚh�x¿EØ�ÁCñ�Ú�� � ÚÜÛ�Àt�xÂjß�¿�ÁCØ�Ù�9��à�Âjß�Û¼� õ�w ß�Ø õ ß�àzyf{9{ �O��¥ @ ��´N¥ v

t ¯

Page 28: AWAXB YZP[Uhahn/research/CERP/papCERP.pdf$- ./ ! 0 +( 1#324 57678&9:; + ! ) ? @3ACB DCEGFHJILKMFB1N OQPR@3A STH/BVU AWAXB YZP[U \^]/H_EGET`ba[cRd>` efef` ghH NiP[j3AXF

Ð�HN>?BDS¡sU¨�v�µ|vAs��I>8HOCD58M_sD²:v�ÊcvAsD¨�9OM~9�eOHDs�¼�vAs�·�B�9QF�E¡sl¢ZvAslÐx9O9O7�<�C Sl<�<�¤�s�q{v?s�qp<�7�58FGH�[�s�Uv�¼­v?sI¢THN>?>8<�F�s�·xv?s�Ã�HNL¡sIq®vNÃ�vAs�²�H�;0CD58CUzDs��Uv�µ|v?sI¢�9O>?58zN5?BDF�5�sOq{v� }vAs��T>8H HNM � <�>?E¡s¢Zv$²:v�9QCDE{í9QCDED<�F�s­ª0v­�lv?s ��¥O¥N¥ v6qpHO>8<�R�BD>\9QF�R�>89O7�7G5 � R�9Q3�5?HNC.HOV=R�9OCDR�<�F�³}¢T>89O7�7ED5?7�R�H¬[O<�Fnek9OCDEkR�>\9Q7�76JDF�<�ED58Ry3�5?HNCPS�ePzO<�CD<,<y�IJDFG<�7G7�58HOCdMHNCD5?3�HNF�5?CDzDv � õ�w ß�Ø õ ßzy�9º9�]½¾{?�d|9��¿ � ´U� @ � ´�¦ v

Ð�F�<�9O>8>AeNs(�Uvlq®vAsZtQuNu�tIv½�ILDHNFn3&58C�3�<�F�7GJ�<�F�7G<�E¸3�F�9QCD7�JlHN7�9QSD>8<.<�>8<�M<�C�3�7�^r�I2 ��ª*7ob&9OF�<<w�UR�>8BDEU<�EPVXF�HNMý58MJDF�5?C�3�<�EKFG<�zN5?HNCD7c58C�3�LD<,L�BDM~9QCkzO<�CDHNM<OvÀ� ¿ Ú õ ß�ß-Ù w Ø��Üà�Ú���ËÁC w ÚÜØ�ÁCñt� õ ÁFÙxß�Û���Ú��Y� õ�w ß�Ø õ ßzyf�t� ´ t ¦ @ ´N´ tIv

·�9OCD7G<�C¡s�Ã*v�Êcv�9OCDE��U9O>89OMHNC¡sD¼­v?s ��¥O¥ uUv­��<�BDF�9O>OCD<�3�;=HNF�¤Z<�CD7G<�M:SD>?<�7�v�}z�&�&��� ¿`ÁCØLà�xÁ õ  w ÚÜØLà©ÚÜØ � ÁCÂ�ÂOß�¿EØ���Ø�ÁCñ·�:à w à�ÁCØ�Ù � Á õz��w ØZß } ØVÂjß�ñ_ñ w �xß�Ø õ ßzyc��� ¥O¥N´ @ � uNu � v·�9O7G3�58<QsD¨�v?s�¨�5?SD7�LU58F�9QCD5rsUµxv�9OCUEp��FG58<�EUM~9OC�s.�UvAsZtQuNu � v��f� ß � ñXß�Û"ß�ØVÂ_àËÚ��m�]ÂdÁC w à� wdõ ÁCñ

 éß-ÁC¿EØ w Ø���¦ ³ ÁCÂdÁ �Áw Ø w Ø��hy } Ø¥��ß�¿ ß�Ø õ ßzy�ÁCØ�Ù � ¿ ß-Ù wdõ  w ÚÜØt£ � JDF�5?CDzN<�F�¾�<�F�>89OzDs���<�;��HNFG¤�v

·�58>?<�Mg9OC¡sI�Zv?s ��¥O¥�¦ v=·�HNFGMgHNCU<�ED587GF�BDJU3�<�F�F�<�7�<�9QF�RoLj<w�UJD9OCDED7�v��c� ß�Û wdõ ÁCñ � Ø�� w ØZß�ß�¿Âxw Ø��*��ß�µwàzy�¸?{ t § @ntO�Iv

·�HDsD¨�v�ÊcvAs ��¥N¥N° v$¨�LD<�F�9QCDEDHNM 7�BDSU7�J�9OR�<=M<�3�LDH E�VXHNF¡R�HOCD7G3�F�BDRy3�58CUz�EU<�R�5?7�5?HNC�VXHNF�<�7G3�7�v}¾���&�Ã� ¿`ÁCØLà'Á õ  w ÚÜØLàäÚÜØ � ÁCÂnÂOß�¿�ØÄ��Ø�ÁCñ·��à w àúÁCØ�Ù � Á õz��w ØZß } ØVÂjß�ñ_ñ w �xß�Ø õ ßzyR�9Å °N´ t¬@°O§O§ v

Ê�BDCURoLD<�[Q9Us�Ã*v�2ovAsD±¸LD5?3�9O¤O<�F�sl¢Zvt�UvAsl�ILD58JUJ¡s�¢Zv� }v�9QCDE�²�BU58C¡sUµxv�¼­vU±Ñv?sZtOuNu ´ v­Ã$5?M6@5A3�7�HOC}3�LD<�Mg9¬«GHNFG5?3�e�[OHO3�<�9QR�R�BUF�9ORye:58C}R�>\9Q7�7�5 � <�F­VXBD7�5?HNC¡v&� ÁCÂnÂOß�¿�Ø���Ø�ÁCñ·�:à w à�ÁCØ�Ù�úÀFÀ�ñ wdõ ÁC w ÚÜØ(y�� tOt¬@ ´U� v

Ã$9OM_sDÃ*v�9OCUE�� BD<�C¡s�¢Zv(�:v?s ��¥N¥N¦ v  �JDJD>85?R�9Q3�58HNCÆHOV~Mg9¬«GHNFG5?3�e¸[NHQ3�58CUz¸3�H¸J�9Q3�3�<�FGCFG<�R�HOzNCD5?3�58HNC�³� ZC®9OC�9O>AeI7G587�HOV=5?3�7|S�<�L�9�[I5?HNFx9OCDE{J�<�FGVXHNFGM~9QCDR�<Qv¯}¾�&���Æ� ¿`ÁCØLà�xÁ õ  w ÚÜØ ÚÜØÁ�9��à�Âjß�ÛÞàzy � ÁCØ(yúÁCØ�Ù � � î ß�¿EØZß� wdõ àzy���¸ �N� ´ @ � ¯N° v

Ã�HNL�sU±Ñv @C�cv�9OCUE�� LD58L¡s(�:v���vAs ��¥N¥�¦ v�� JD>85A3]7�<�>8<�R�3�5?HNC¸Mg<y3�LDH ED7&VXHNF&R�>\9O7G7�5 � R�9Q3�58HNC3�F�<�<�7�v �]ÂdÁC w à� wdõ Á/� w Ø wdõ Áhyc¸ °U� �¬@ °O§ uUv

q_58RoLD5?<�>87�s���vAs�Ê�HN7�R�58<�>8C�eNsl��v�9QCDE_·�58>?>rsU¢Zv?sZtOuNuN�Iv ¼*FG<�ED5?R�3�5?HNCÇHOVgR�9OCUR�<�F.HOBU3�R�HNMg<;05A3�L�M58R�FGH�9OFGF�9�e 7�³¡ KM:BU>?3�5?JD>8<­F�9QCDEDHNM [O9Q>858ED9Q3�5?HNCZ7n3�F�9�3�<�zQeNv  gÁCØ õ ß�ÂGyi|9�9{]½¾�?�d{9º�¿§�°O° @ §�¥ tIv

q_58>8>?<�F�sI Wv?s�tOuNuNtIv �9� î à�ß�Â��«ß�ñXß õ  w ÚÜØ w Ø × ß1�C¿ ß�à�à w ÚÜØ(y ^�tQCDE�<�E¡vÕbwsW¢TL�9OJDMg9OCÇ9OCUE·�9O>8>\ÔN¢�µ�¢ZsDÃ�HN70 �CDzN<�>?<�7�sl¢T }v

q_HN>85?C�9OF�HUsI Wvlq®v?sl� 58MHNC¡sDµ|v�9OCDE_¼(VX<�5A©�<�F�s�µ|v�q®vAs�tOuNu��Iv»¼�FG<�ED5?R�3�58HNCÄ<�F�FGHNF_<�7G3�5A@Mg9Q3�5?HNC¡³� ½R�HNMgJD9OF�5?7�HNC_HOV*FG<�7�9QMgJD>?58CDzM<�3�LUHIED7�v�ukw Ú w Ø¥��ÚÜ¿EÛÐÁC wdõ àzy]�]� ´N´ u � @´N´ u ¦ v

¼�9Oh�h�9OCD5�s�q®vAslqp<�FGhOs�¢Zv?slq_BDF�JDL�eOs�¼­v?s� �>85�sDÊcv?s�·�BDM<OsD¨�vl9OCDE_�TFGBDCD¤�s�¢Zv?s ��¥O¥O§ v­µ�<w@EDBUR�58CUzpM587GR�>\9Q7�7�5 � R�9�3�58HOCjR�HN7n3�7�³:Ê�CDH�;0>8<�EDzN<y@458C�3�<�CD7�5A[N<9OJDJUF�H�9ORoLU<�7W3�H,>8<�9QF�CI@5?CDz:VXF�HNM¿CDHN5?7Ge~E�9Q3o9Ivq� ¿ Ú õ ß�ß-Ù w Ø��Üà�Ú��Ë � ß!êFêC ��} ØVÂOß�¿�Ø�ÁC w ÚÜØ�ÁCñ � ÚÜØ¥��ß�¿ ß�Ø õ ß!ÚÜØ� Á õz��w ØZß� éß-ÁC¿EØ w Ø��hy ��<�;Ç�=F�BDCD7n;058Ro¤�sl���Uslq�Ã�@ ¥O§ sDJDJ�t �¬¦ @ tNtN�Iv

t ¦

Page 29: AWAXB YZP[Uhahn/research/CERP/papCERP.pdf$- ./ ! 0 +( 1#324 57678&9:; + ! ) ? @3ACB DCEGFHJILKMFB1N OQPR@3A STH/BVU AWAXB YZP[U \^]/H_EGET`ba[cRd>` efef` ghH NiP[j3AXF

¼*FG<�C�3�5?R�<Os�µ|v�Ã*vAs ��¥N°N¯ v��T5?C�9OFGe~F�<�zNF�<�7�7�5?HNC_BD7�5?CDz~9QC_<w� 3�<�CUED<�EjSl<�3�9�@�SU58CDHNM5\9Q>�ED5?7n@3�F�58SUBU3�5?HNC¡s�;05?3�L|ED587GR�BD7G7�58HOCWHOVUR�HNFGF�<�>\9Q3�58HNC�5?CDEDBDR�<�ExS�e|R�H�[O9QF�5\9�3�<*M<�9O7GBDF�<�Mg<�C�3<�F�F�HOF�7�v �VÚh�x¿�Ø�ÁCñlÚ��� � ß���Û"ß�¿ wdõ ÁCض�]ÂdÁC w à� wdõ ÁCñt��à�à�Ú õ�w ÁC w ÚÜØ(yfº�� ´ t � @ ´ t ¦ v

µ0<�5?¤�sU±Ñv�9OCDE&±f9O>?3�<�F�s.�Uv?s�tOuNu � v(Ð�<�CUHNMg5?R�58MJDF�5?C�3�58CDzU³�¼�9OFG<�C�3o9Q>U58C�ã�BD<�CUR�<THOC}3�LD<zN<�CDHNM<Ov �ËÁCÂC�x¿ ß × ß�­ w ß�µwद ° ß�ØZß� wdõ àzy��]½¤�(¿ t � @ ´ t v

� RoL�9OJD5?F�<Os�µ|v�ª�vAs ��¥N¥ uUvc¨�LD<67n3�F�<�CDzO3�LfHOV�;T<�9O¤.>8<�9OF�CD9OSD58>?5?3�eOv*� Á õz��w ØZß� éß-ÁC¿EØ w Ø��hy{ ��¥�¦ @ tNt ¦ v

� <�z�9O>�s�q®v�µ|vAsZtQuNu § v�¢T<�C�3�<�F�VXHNF$SD5?HN58CIVXHNF�Mg9Q3�5?R�7�ÇÂMHN>?<�R�BU>\9OF¡SU58HN7n3o9Q3�587G3�58R�7�vT^F� ß õz� xØ wdõ ÁCñ × ßOÀVÚÜ¿EÂGyÄÈlØ w ­Cß�¿ à w ¹��Ú�� � ÁCñ w ��ÚÜ¿EØ w Áhyj��ÁCØ�Ý«¿`ÁCØ õ�w à õ Ú byv� J�9OF�9QCDHDs9�Uv� Wv?s���9Oh�h�9OFG5rs�q{vt�Uv�9OCDEp¢TLD58>?ED7�slÐcvAs�tOuNu��Iv�¢T>?58CD5?R�9O>Q9OJDJD>?58R�9Q3�5?HNCZHOV MHN>8<�Ry@

BD>89OF�JDFGH � >?58CDzc5?C_SUF�<�9Q7G3�R�9OCUR�<�F�v Ýd�xÂC�x¿ ß/ÉäØ õ ÚÜñXÚE�>�Fy�� §�° �¬@ §�¥O¯ v� BDE�9UsD¨�vAslÊ|9Q3�HNL�s�q®vAs�·�58F�9Q3�7GBD¤�9Us�q®vAs���B�«G5?;T9OF�9Us�q®vAs�2�F�5?h�9�;�9Isi�cv�9OCUE Ñ 7�LU58M:BDF�9Us�q{v?s

tOuOu ´ vWË�7�<cHQV=FG<�9O>ï@43�58M<}µ�¨T@�¼�¢�µ�VXHNFZ3�LD<cED<�3�<�Ry3�58HOC{HQVT9Q>8>8<�>85?RW<w�UJUF�<�7G7�5?HNC®HQV9OC{58MJDFG58C�3�<�E{zO<�CD<QvÊ} ØVÂOß�¿EØ�ÁC w ÚÜØ�ÁCñc�]Úh�x¿EØ�ÁCñ?Ú�� � ÚÜñXß õ ��ñöÁC¿ � ß-Ù wdõ�w ØZßzy¡���S½E�d¿t §N´ @nt §N¯ v

¨�LU<�F�CU<�9OB¡s�¨�vlq®v�9QCDE, �3�¤�58CD7GHNC¡slª�vt�Uv?s ��¥O¥�¦ v� �C~5?C�3�F�H EDBDRy3�58HOC3�HWFG<�R�BUF�7�5A[N<�JD9OFn@3�5?3�5?HNCD5?CDzpBU7�58CUz�3�LD<]µ�¼l �µ�¨�F�HOBU3�5?CD<�7�vk^F� ß õz� Ø wdõ ÁCñ × ßOÀVÚÜ¿EÂËy � Á>�FÚ#ÝlÚh��Ø�ÙFÁ>x w ÚÜØ byv

¨�5?SD7�LU58F�9QCD5rsUµxvAs�·Z9Q7G3�5?<Os�¨�vAs��Z9OF�9O7�5?MgLD9OC¡sD��v�9OCDEp¢TL�B¡s�Ð6v�tOuOu�tIv­²�5\9OzOCDHN7�5?7�HOVIM:BD>ï@3�58JD>?<WR�9OCDR�<�F�3�e J�<�7�S�ep7�LUF�BDCD¤Q<�C{R�<�C�3�F�HN5?ED7�HOV�zO<�CD<:<w�IJDF�<�7�7�5?HNC¡v�� ¿ Ú õ ß�ß-Ù w Ø��ÜàÚ����ËÁC w ÚÜØ�ÁCñt� õ ÁFÙxß�Û�� Ú���� õ�w ß�Ø õ ßzy��t� ¯ � ¯�¦ @ ¯ � ¦ tIv

¨�7�9O5rs�¢Zv� }vAsl¢TLD<�C¡s�¢Zv�·xv?s�Ã�<�<Qs�¨�vl¢Zv?s�·�HDs�2ov�¢ZvAs?�=9OCDzDs�Ëxvl¢Zv�9OCDEp¢TLD<�C¡s��Uvt�Uv?s�tOuNu § vÐ�<�CD<�7�<�>8<�R�3�5?HNCgVXHOF=7�9OMgJU>8<0R�>89O7�7G5 � R�9Q3�5?HNCD7�58CMg5?R�FGH�9OF�F�9�ec<y�IJl<�F�5?Mg<�C�3�7�vq³ �k�ÁCØ�Ù � ß�ñ_ñ ukw ÚÜñXÚE�>�Fy��9| ¯ u ¦ @ ¯U��§ v

¾�9QJDCD58¤�sU¾}v?s ��¥O¥ �IvÄ�f� ßm�ËÁC¹��¿ ß�Ú��m�]ÂÁC w à� wdõ ÁCñ( lß-ÁC¿EØ w Ø�� �f� ß�ÚÜ¿Â�>£ � JDF�5?CDzN<�F(¾�<�F�>89OzDs��<�;Ã��HOF�¤�v

±¸5?>8>?5\9OM7�s�²:vD Wv?s ��¥N¦ �Iv�¨�LD<®9OC�9O>AeI7G587&HOVWSD5?C�9OFGeÂF�<�7GJ�HOCD7�<�7pVXF�HOM 3�H��I58R�HN>8HOzN58R�9O><w�UJl<�FG58M<�C�3�7g58C�[NHO>?[ 58CDz®F�<�JDF�H EDBDRy3�58HOCÂ9OCDE¶3�<�F�9Q3�HOzN<�CD5?R�5A3�eNvÌukw ÚÜÛ"ß�Ân¿ wdõ àzy�|��¥O§N¥ @ ¥ �OtIv

t °