audit report - rcacp [final]

Upload: the-roanoke-times

Post on 04-Apr-2018

221 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 7/30/2019 Audit Report - Rcacp [Final]

    1/23

    EXMICIR@G @XNI^IMK ZHRAZ^

    CI^Y AL ZA@MADH

    Zhkiam`g Chm~hz laz @mie`g

    Cam~zag , Rza~hc~iam

    Ma|hejhz 0>' :20:

    Zhraz~ Mxejhz? 03226

    @xni~ Rg`m Mxejhz? 0:>20

    Exmicir`g @xni~imk Nhr`z~ehm~

    Cf`z~hzhn 09;>

    Zhraz~s `~{{{-za`madh|`-ka|

    Rfamh 8>2-683-:>Lz`xn' [`s~h' `mn @jxsh Fa~gimh 666-:38-0;:8

    http://www.roanokeva.gov/http://www.roanokeva.gov/http://www.roanokeva.gov/http://www.roanokeva.gov/
  • 7/30/2019 Audit Report - Rcacp [Final]

    2/23

  • 7/30/2019 Audit Report - Rcacp [Final]

    3/23

    ^@JGH AL CAM^HM^S

    J`cdkzaxmn ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 0

    Scarh -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- :

    Eh~fanagaky ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- :

    Ajohc~i|h 0 Nisjxzshehm~s mn Cas~ @ggac`~iam -------------------------------------------- 3

    Ajohc~i|h : Czhni~ C`zns ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- >

    Ajohc~i|h 3 F\@C `mn Zhg`~hn Shz|ichs ----------------------------------------------------- 8

    Ajohc~i|h > Carihz Hvrhmshs ------------------------------------------------------------------------

    AJOCHC^I\H :? CZHNI^ C@ZNS

    Ajohc~i|h? ^a nh~hzeimh il rzachsshs laz czhni~ c`zns rxzcf`shs {hzh `nhpx`~h ~a hmsxzh rxzcf`shs{hzh `rrzarzi`~h' cazzhc~gy `ccaxm~hn laz' `mn r`in jy ~fh azk`mi`~iam zhchi|imk ~fh jhmhli~-

    Scarh? @CS eam~fgy czhni~ c`zn s~`~hehm~s laz ~fh eam~fs Oxgy :202 ~fzaxkf Oxgy :20:-

    Camcgxsiam? Rzachsshs laz czhni~ c`zn rxzcf`shs caxgn f`|h jhhm s~zhmk~fhmhn ~a eazh zh`sam`jgyhmsxzh rxzcf`shs {hzh `rrzarzi`~h' cazzhc~gy `ccaxm~hn laz' `mn r`in jy ~fh azk`mi`~iam zhchi|imk ~fhjhmhli~-

    Ajshz|`~iams?

    0- Im eas~ c`shs' czhni~ c`zn zhchir~s nin ma~ f`|h `nhpx`~h ma~`~iams ~a nh~hzeimh {fa zhchi|hn ~fhkaans az shz|ichs az ~fh rxzrash al ~fh rxzcf`sh-

    :- ^fh eam~fgy czhni~ c zn s~`~hehm~s laz @CS {hzh ma~ rza|inhn ~a ~fh Nizhc~az al Sfhg~hz Arhz`~iams~a zh|ih{' rzh|hm~imk ~fh Nizhc~az lzae hllhc~i|hgy eami~azimk @CS rxzcf`shs laz `rrzarzi`~hmhss`mn `ccxz`cy-

    3- ^fh Nhchejhz :200 czhni~ c`zn s~ ~hehm~ {`s lighn {i~fax~ ~fh `ssaci`~hn zhchir~s-

    >- Sh|hz`g zhchir~s imcgxnhn s`ghs ~`v ~f`~ sfaxgn ma~ f`|h jhhm cf`zkhn ~a ` mam%rzali~ azka|hzmehm~ `khmcy-

    8- Rxzcf`shs ~a~`gimk .0>: nxzimk ~fh Oxmh :20: Nhzhcfa h|hm~ {hzh hzzamhaxsgy `ssxehn ~a jh laz@CS {fhm rzachsshn jy Lim`mch-

    Zhcaeehmn`~iam?

    [h zhcaeehmn nh|hgarimk rzachnxzhs ~f`~ imcgxnh?

    Zhpxizimk i~heihn zhchir~s-Zhpxizimk ~fh rxzcf`shz ~a ma~h ~fh rxzrash am ~fh zhchir~ az am ` rxzcf`sh aznhz-Zhpxizimk ~fh rxzcf`shz ~a ma~h ~fh cas~ ~a jh `ggac`~hn ~a h`cf hm~i~y-Zhpxizimk ~fh Nizhc~az al Sfhg~hz Arhz`~iams zh|ih{ `mn `rrza|h ~fh eam~fgy czhni~ c`zn s~`~hehm~rziaz ~a r`yehm~-

    Rzachnxzhs sfaxgn jh nacxehm~hn' `mn sfaxgn jh caeexmic`~hn ~a hergayhhs-

  • 7/30/2019 Audit Report - Rcacp [Final]

    9/23

    R`kh 8

    AJOHC^I\H 3? F\@C @MN ZHG@^HN SHZ\ICHS

    Ajohc~i|h? ^a nh~hzeimh il F\@C `mn zhg`~hn shz|ichs {hzh im|aichn `mn r`in `ccaznimk ~a ~fh l`cigi~yzhchi|imk shz|ichs-

    Scarh? LY :202' :200' :20:-

    Camcgxsiam? [h `zh xm`jgh ~a nh~hzeimh il F\@C `mn zhg`~hn shz|ichs {hzh im|aichn `mn r`in`ccaznimk ~a ~fh l`cigi~y zhchi|imk ~fh shz|ich {azd' j`shn am ~fh lagga{imk l`c~azs?

    Imcamsis~hm~ ~hs~ieamy-Inhm~ic`g hpxirehm~ xshn im ja~f jxignimks-

    @jshmch al `my n ~` im ~fh |hmnazs lihgn zhraz~ ma~hs ~f ~ nacxehm~ ~fh gac ~iam al ~fh hpxirehm~shz|ichn-G`cd al sxrraz~imk nacxehm~s sxcf `s rxzcf`sh aznhzs-

    Ajshz|`~iams?

    0- ^fh cas~ al {azd am ~fh caerx~hz sys~he xshn ~a eami~az hm|izamehm~`g sys~hes im ja~f jxignimks{`s ma~ camsis~hm~gy `ggac`~hn jh~{hhm hm~i~ihs-

    Zhcaeehmn`~iams?

    [fhm ja~f jxignimks zhpxizh shz|ichs' shr`z`~h shz|ich zhpxhs~s sfaxgn jh czh`~hn `mn ~fh {azd imh`cf jxignimk shr`z`~hgy im|aichn- [h sxkkhs~ ~f`~ ~fh |hmnazs ^hcfmici`m imcgxnh ma~hs im fis az fhzlihgn zhraz~ ~f`~ eazh srhcilic`ggy inhm~ilihs ~fh gac`~iam al ~fh hpxirehm~ shz|ichn- Ki|hm ~fh mxejhz alinhm~ic`g hpxirehm~ i~hes im ja~f jxignimks' jh~~hz ma~hs {axgn fhgr im ~z`cdimk ~fh {azd ~a imni|inx`gxmi~s-

  • 7/30/2019 Audit Report - Rcacp [Final]

    10/23

    R`kh ? CARIHZ HVRHMSHS

    Ajohc~i|h? ^a nh~hzeimh il carihz cas~s r`in jy @CS {hzh laz ~fh jhmhli~ al ~fh Zhkiam`g Chm~hz-

    Scarh? LY :202' :200' :20:-

    Camcgxsiam?Carihz cas~s {hzh hzzamhaxsgy r`in

    jy ja~f hm~i~ihs laz h`cf a~fhzs carihzs-

    Ajshz|`~iams?

    0- ^fh carihz cam~z`c~s laz ja~f l`cigi~ihs rrh`z ~a jh sh~xr xmnhz ~fh Za`madh \`gghy SRC@ `ccaxm~TZ\28U `mn jigghn ~akh~fhz am amh im|aich- ^fh g`yax~ al ~fh im|aich is camlxsimk `mn czh`~hskzh`~hz arraz~xmi~y laz hzzazs ~a accxz-

    :- [h ma~hn mh~ hzzaz al .0 r`in jy @CS laz SRC@ carihz shz|ichs- ^fis {`s 0-9( al ~fh ~a~`gcarihz hvrhmni~xzhs al .6'822 laz ~fh ~fzhh lisc`g yh`zs zh|ih{hn-

    Zhcaeehmn`~iams?

    [h zhcaeehmn ~f`~ cam~z`c~ jiggimk jh shr`z`~hn sa ~f`~ ~fh ~{a hm~i~ihs zhchi|h shr`z`~h im|aichs-^fh @CS Nizhc~az al Sfhg~hz Arhz`~iams sfaxgn zh|ih{ `mn `rrza|h `gg carihz im|aichs jigghn ~a ~fhZhkiam`g Chm~hz jhlazh ~fhy `zh r`in-

  • 7/30/2019 Audit Report - Rcacp [Final]

    11/23

    R`kh ;

    AJOHC^I\H 8? RH^^Y C@SF

    Ajohc~i|h? ^a h|`gx`~h cam~zags a|hz @CS rh~~y c`sf ~f`~ hmsxzh hvrhmni~xzhs `zh laz ~fh jhmhli~ al ~fhZhkiam`g Chm~hz-

    Scarh? Rh~~y c`sf zhiejxzshehm~s LY :202' :200' :20:-

    Camcgxsiam? ^fh cam~zags a|hz rh~~y c`sf caxgn jh s~zhmk~fhmhn ~a rza|inh eazh zh`sam`jgh`ssxz`mch ~f`~ hvrhmni~xzhs `zh laz ~fh jhmhli~ al ~fh Zhkiam`g Chm~hz-

    Ajshz|`~iams?

    0- Zhchir~s sxrraz~imk rh~~y c`sf hvrhmni~xzhs im khmhz`g na ma~ f`|h ~fh rxzrash al ~fh rxzcf`sh az~fh m`eh al ~fh rhzsam zhchi|imk ~fh kaans nacxehm~hn am ~fhe-

    :- @ zhiejxzshehm~ al .0:6 am 3!08!0: f`n ma zhchir~s ~a inhm~ily {f`~ {`s rxzcf`shn4 amgy ma~h~f`~ i~ {`s laz ` rxzcf`sh {i~f ` srhcilic |hmnaz-

    3- @l~hz `noxs~imk laz zaxmnimk' sfaz~`khs im ~fh lxmn ~a~`ghn .03:' {i~f ~fh g`zkhs~ imni|inx`g sfaz~`khjhimk .;;- ^a~`g rh~~y c`sf rxzcf`shs laz LY02 ~fzx LY0: {hzh .8':62-

    >- Rh~~y c`sf rxzcf`shs imcgxnhn kil~ c`zns' lxhg' rh~ laan' `mn khmhz`g sxrrgihs ~f`~ zh sieig`z im`eaxm~ `mn m`~xzh ~a rxzcf`shs maze`ggy e`nh jy cfhcd az czhni~ c`zn-

    Zhcaeehmn`~iam?

    [h zhcaeehmn ~f`~ ` rh~~y c`sf zhpxhs~ laze jh nh|hgarhn ~f`~ c`m jh xshn ~a nacxehm~ ~fh mhhn !rxzrash al rxzcf`shs e`nh {i~f rh~~y c`sf' ~fh hergayhh zhpxhs~imk ~fh rxzcf`sh' `mn ~fh gimh i~he`ccaxm~ ~a jh cf`zkhn-

  • 7/30/2019 Audit Report - Rcacp [Final]

    12/23

    R`kh 6

    AJOHC^I\H

  • 7/30/2019 Audit Report - Rcacp [Final]

    13/23

    R`kh 9

    AJOHC^I\H ;? E@IM^HM@MCH' O@MI^AZI@G , A^FHZ SHZ\ICHS

    Ajohc~i|h? ^a nh~hzeimh il ~fh cas~s laz e`im~hm`mch `mn o`mi~azi`g shz|ichs rza|inhn jy @CS s~`ll lazZa`madh \`gghy SRC@ l`cigi~ihs {hzh `nhpx`~hgy `ccaxm~hn laz jy ~fh Za`madh \`gghy SRC@-

    Scarh? Oxgy 0' :22; ~fzaxkf @xkxs~ 30' :20:-

    Camcgxsiam? ^fh Za`madh \`gghy SRC@ nin ma~ `nhpx`~hgy `ccaxm~ laz ~fh cas~s laz e`im~hm`mch `mno`mi~azi`g shz|ichs rza|inhn jy @CS s~`ll laz Za`madh \`gghy SRC@ l`cigi~ihs-

    [h `gsa inhm~ilihn shz|ichs rza|inhn jy Za`madh \`gghy SRC@ hergayhhs laz ~fh jhmhli~ al ~fhZhkiam`g Chm~hz ~f`~ sieig`zgy {hzh ma~ `nhpx`~hgy `ccaxm~hn laz az nacxehm~hn-

    Ajshz|`~iams?

    0- ^fhzh {hzh ma zhcazns nacxehm~imk ~fh e`im~hm`mch `mn o mi~azi`g {azd laz h`cf hm~i~y rziaz ~aAc~ajhz :200-

    :- ^fh laxz &>) faxz rhz {hhd `ggac`~iam laz @CS s~ ll ~a rza|inh cgh`mimk `mn e`im~hm`mch `ssis~`mch`~ ~fh Za`madh \`gghy SRC@ nxzimk ~fh lisc`g yh`z hmnimk ) faxzs rhzeam~f eazh-

    `- Amh hergayhh {`s zhkxg`zgy scfhnxghn ~a rhzlaze cgh`mimk ~ ~fh Za`madh \`gghy SRC@h|hzy Lzin`y laz laxz &>) faxzs' {ficf camshz|`~i|hgy `ccaxm~s laz `m `|hz`kh al 0< faxzsrhz eam~f-

    j- Amh hergayhh {azdhn ~{a &:) ~a ~fzhh &3) n`ys rhz eam~f lzae ~{a &:) ~a laxz &>) faxzsh`cf ~ieh im ~fh h|hmimks' {ficf camshz|`~i|hgy `ccaxm~s laz laxz &>) faxzs rhz eam~f-

    3- I~ {`s khmhz`ggy `cdma{ghnkhn ~f`~ @CS s~`ll {azdhn am ~fh zhgac`~iam al ~fh Za`madh \`gghySRC@s rh~ cheh~hzy- ^fh ~ieh {azdhn {`s ma~ nacxehm~hn `mn caxgn ma~ jh zh`sam`jgyhs~ie`~hn j`shn am ~fh ~hs~ieamy-

    >- ^fh L`cigi~y E`m`khz {`s ` sf`zhn zhsaxzch ~f`~ {`s r`z~i`ggy lxmnhn jy ~fh Za`madh \`gghySRC@- Fis {azd faxzs {hzh ma~ ~z`cdhn `s ~a ~fh l`cigi~y zhchi|imk ~fh shz|ichs `mn ~fhzhlazh {h{hzh xm`jgh ~a zh`sam`jgy nh~hzeimh il ~fh 62$ faxzs al rh~ cheh~hzy zhg`~hn {azd li~ {i~fim fisa|hz`gg `ggac`~hn faxzs laz ~fh lisc`g yh`z hmnimk

  • 7/30/2019 Audit Report - Rcacp [Final]

    14/23

    R`kh 02

    ;- Hvhcx~i|h e`m`khehm~ nin ma~ f`|h n`~` ~a sxrraz~ sh~~imk ~fh Za`madh \`gghy SRC@srzaraz~iam`g sf`zh al ~fh L`cigi~y E`m`khzs s`g`zy `mn jhmhli~s `~ :2( T6! {hhdU- E`m`khehm~ ninma~ ~z`cd `c~x`g faxzs {azdhn laz ~fh jhmhli~ al ~fh Za`madh \`gghy SRC@ `~ `my ~ieh jh~{hhm:22; `mn Shr~hejhz :200' ~f`~ {axgn f`|h hm`jghn ~fhe ~a nh|hgar ` eazh sxrraz~`jgh hs~ie`~h-

    6- Im :22;' Za`madh \`gghy SRC@ e`m`khehm~ jhk`m f`|imk i~s Jhf`|iazis~ sshss `gg naks zhchi|hnjy ~fh Zhkiam`g Chm~hz- ^fhsh `sshssehm~s fhgrhn e`m`khehm~ jh~~hz xmnhzs~`mn cf`z`c~hzis~icsal ~fh rarxg`~iam al `mie`gs caeimk im~a ~fh Zhkiam`g Chm~hz- H|hm~x`ggy' ~fh `sshssehm~s fhgrhnim rg`cimk `mie`gs {i~f rrzarzi`~h zhscxh azk`mi`~iams- ^fh Jhf`|iazis~s ~ieh im ~fh Zhkiam`gChm~hz {`s ma~ zhcaznhn `mn Za`madh \`gghy SRC@ e`m`khehm~ nin ma~ zhpxhs~ caerhms`~iamlzae ~fh Zhkiam`g Chm~hz-

    9- @~ ~fh zhpxhs~ al ~fh gac`gi~ihs' ~fh Za`madh \`gghy SRC@ \agxm~hhz Caaznim`~az im|hs~hnsxjs~`m~i`g ~ieh im nh|hgarimk ` |agxm~hhz rzakz`e `~ ~fh Zhkiam`g Chm~hz lzae @rzig :200 ~fzaxkfShr~hejhz :200- Fhz ~ieh {`s ma~ ~z`cdhn jx~ is h|inhmchn jy ~fh nh|hgarehm~ al ` |agxm~hhzf`mnjaad `mn imi~i`~iam al ` |agxm~hhz rzakz`e im g`~h :200- ^fh Za`madh \`gghy SRC@ nin ma~zhpxhs~ zhiejxzshehm~ laz ~fh cas~s laz nh|hgarimk ~fh rzakz`e-

    Im Ma|hejhz :200' ~fh Zhkiam`g Chm~hz jhk`m r`yimk ` raz~iam al ~fh \agxm~hhz Caaznim`~azss`g`zy- ^fh Za`madh \`gghy SRC@ eami~azhn ~fh Caaznim`~azs `c~x`g ~ieh {azdhn am ~fh Zhkiam`gChm~hz rzakz`e `mn nh~hzeimhn ~f`~ i~ sikmilic`m~gy hvchhnhn ~fh hs~ie`~hn ~ieh r`in jy ~fhZhkiam`g Chm~hz nxzimk lisc`g :20:- Im Oxgy :20:' ~fh Zhkiam`g Chm~hz jhk`m r`yimk ~fh \agxm~hhzCaaznim`~az j`shn am `c~x`g faxzs {azdhn `~ ~fh Chm~hz-

    Zhcaeehmn`~iams? Mamh `~ ~fis ~ieh-

  • 7/30/2019 Audit Report - Rcacp [Final]

    15/23

    R`kh 00

    AJOHC^I\H 6? \H^HZIM@ZY SHZ\ICHS

    Ajohc~i|h? ^a nh~hzeimh il ~fh |h~hzim`zy shz|ichs rza|inhn ~a ~fh Zhkiam`g Chm~hz jy ~fh Za`madh\`gghy SRC@ `zh zh`sam`jgh `mn sxrraz~hn-

    Scarh? Lisc`g yh`z hmnimk

  • 7/30/2019 Audit Report - Rcacp [Final]

    16/23

    R`kh 0:

    AJOHC^I\H 9? FXE@M ZHSAXZCHS

    Ajohc~i|h? ^a h|`gx`~h ~fh rzachsshs im rg`ch ~a rza|inh fxe`m zhsaxzchs sxrraz~ laz @CShergayhhs-

    Scarh? Rzachsshs im rg`ch `s al @xkxs~ ::' :20:-

    Camcgxsiams? A|hz`gg' ~fh rhzsammhg e`mx`g' azihm~`~iam cfhcdgis~' mn a~fhz lazes rrh`z ~a jhzh`sam`jgy {hgg nh|hgarhn- J`shn am ~fh e`mx`g `mn eheas {h zh|ih{hn' ~fhzh {`s `m h`zmhs~hllaz~ ~a ierza|h caeexmic`~iams {i~fim ~fh azk`mi`~iam- @ [fis~ghjga{hz ragicy {`s `nar~hn imLhjzx`zy :229 `mn `m Arhm Naaz ! Sxkkhs~iams ragicy {`s `nar~hn im Ac~ajhz :200- Fa{h|hz' `gglaze`g rza~acags ~a `nnzhss camchzms xg~ie`~hgy ~hzeim`~h {i~f ~fh Hvhcx~i|h Nizhc~az al ~fh Za`madh\`gghy SRC@ `mn ~fh Za`madh \`gghy SRC@ Ja`zn-

    Zhcaeehmn`~iams?

    [h zhcaeehmn ~fh lagga{imk?

    Zh|ish ~fh {fis~ghjga{hz ragicy ~a imcgxnh ` zhpxizhehm~ ~f`~ ~fh @n|isazy Ja`zn jh imlazehn al`gghk`~iams im|ag|imk ~fh Zhkiam`g Chm~hzs arhz`~iams az l`cigi~y- ^fh @n|isazy Ja`zn sfaxgn `gsazhchi|h ` {zi~~hm zhraz~ caeexmic`~imk ~fh im|hs~ik`~iam {azd rhzlazehn' ~fh zhsxg~s' `mn `my`c~iams ~`dhm ~a zhsag|h ~fh issxhs-

    Zh|ish ~fh rhzsammhg e`mx`g ~a imcazraz`~h ~fh {fis~ghjga{hz ragicy `mn ~fh arhm naaz ragicy' `mnxrn`~h ~fh azk`mi`~iam cf`z~ `mn oaj ~i~ghs-

  • 7/30/2019 Audit Report - Rcacp [Final]

    17/23

    R`kh 03

    AJOHC^I\H 02? @N\ISAZY JA@ZN

    Ajohc~i|h? ^a nh~hzeimh il ~fh @n|isazy Ja`zn {`s `nhpx`~hgy imlazehn `jax~ ~fh zh`sams laz~hzeim`~iams al lazehz Nizhc~azs al Sfhg~hz Arhz`~iams `mn ~fh ~hzes al ~fhiz shr`z`~iam-

    Scarh? LY :200' LY :20:-

    Camcgxsiams?

    [h camcgxnh ~f`~ gac`gi~y zhrzhshm~`~i|hs am ~fh @n|isazy Ja`zn {hzh ma~ `nhpx`~hgy imlazehn `jax~~fh zh`sams laz ~hzeim`~iams al lazehz Nizhc~azs al Sfhg~hz Arhz`~iams az ~fh ~hzes al ~fhiz shr`z`~iam-

    @nni~iam`ggy' {h camcgxnh ~f`~ ~fh s~zxc~xzh al ~fh @n|isazy Ja`zn is ma~ `nhpx`~h ~a hllhc~i|hgy ka|hzm~fh Zhkiam`g Chm~hz `s ` rxjgicgy lxmnhn lxmc~iam-

    Ajshz|`~iams?

    0- ^fh imlaze`~iam rza|inhn ~a ~fh r`z~icir`~imk gac`gi~ihs zhrzhshm~`~i|hs am ~fh @n|isazy Ja`zn {`sma~ sxllicihm~ ~a hm`jgh ~fhe ~a cagghc~i|hgy hmsxzh ~fh?

    `- Zhgi`jigi~y `mn im~hkzi~y al lim`mci`g mn arhz`~iam`g imlaze`~iamj- Hllhc~i|hmhss `mn hllicihmcy al arhz`~iamsc- S`lhkx`znimk al rxjgic `ssh~sn- Caergi`mch {i~f g`{s' zhkxg`~iams' `mn cam~z`c~s

    :- ^fh Nizhc~az al Sfhg~hz Arhz`~iams {azdhn `~ ~fh rgh`sxzh al ~fh Hvhcx~i|h Nizhc~az al ~fh Za`madh\`gghy SRC@ `mn {`s `llaznhn ma rza~hc~iams lzae ~hzeim`~iam sfaxgn fh az sfh lhhg ~f`~ ~fhim~hzhs~s al ~fh Zhkiam`g Chm~hz {hzh ma~ jhimk `nhpx`~hgy rzaea~hn `mn rza~hc~hn-

    3- ^fh @n|isazy Ja`zn {`s hs~`jgisfhn im @z~icgh IIal ~fh Za`madh \`gghy Zhkiam`g Raxmn L`cigi~yShz|ichs @kzhhehm~- ^fh `kzhhehm~ rza|inhs ~f`~ r`z~icir`~imk gac`gi~ihs {igg `rraim~ li|hehejhzs ~a ~fh Ja`zn `mn ~fh Za`madh \`gghy SRC@ {igg `rraim~ laxz ehejhzs4 ~fh Za`madh\`gghy SRC@ Hvhcx~i|h Nizhc~az shz|hs `s `m hv%allicia mam%|a~imk ehejhz- ^fis nhsikm rza|inhssxjs~`m~i`g imlgxhmch laz ~fh cam~z`c~az TZ\SRC@U {fae ~fh Ja`zn is cf`zkhn {i~f a|hzshhimk- I~czh`~hs ` s~zxc~xz`g camlgic~ al im~hzhs~ ~f`~ f`s ~fh ra~hm~i`g ~a sxrrzhss caeexmic`~iam `jax~Zhkiam`g Chm~hz arhz`~iams jh~{hhm ~fh Nizhc~az al Sfhg~hz Arhz`~iams `mn ~fh Ja`zn-

    >- ^fh Za`madh \`gghy Zhkiam`g Raxmn L`cigi~y Shz|ichs @kzhhehm~ gsa rza|inhs ~f`~ ~fh @n|isazyJa`zn is zhsramsijgh laz khmhz`g lisc`g `mn e`m`khehm~ ragicy laz ~fh Mh{ Raxmn L`cigi~y-Nx~ihs imcgxnhn camsinhzimk laz `rrza|`g ~fh hergayehm~ `mn rzacxzhehm~ al `neimis~z`~azsT:-0-0 &j) &ii)U- ^fh Hvhcx~i|h Nizhc~az al ~fh Za`madh \`gghy SRC@ nin ma~ shhd ~fh `rrza|`g al~fh @n|isazy Ja`zn im fizimk ~fh Nizhc~az al Sfhg~hz Arhz`~iams-

    8- ^fh Zhkiam`g Chm~hz r`in `rrzavie`~hgy .0;'822 im sh|hz`mch ~a ` lazehz Nizhc~az al Sfhg~hzArhz`~iams im :200 {i~fax~ ~fh @n|isazy Ja`zns dma{ghnkh `mn j`shn am `m `kzhhehm~ ~f`~rzafiji~hn fie lzae niscgasimk ~fh hvis~hmch al ~fh `kzhhehm~- ^fh ~hzes al ~fh `kzhhehm~ `rrh`z~a jhmhli~ @CS `mn ~fh Za`madh \`gghy SRC@ hvcgxsi|hgy' {i~f ma ehm~iam al ` linxci`zy nx~y az `nx~y al gay`g~y ~a ~fh Zhkiam`g Chm~hz-

  • 7/30/2019 Audit Report - Rcacp [Final]

    18/23

    R`kh 0>

    ~fh r`yehm~s f`n jhhm e`nh-

    Zhcaeehmn`~iams?

    [h zhcaeehmn `~ ` eimiexe ~f`~ ~fh @n|isazy Ja`zn f`|h ` laze`g zhg`~iamsfir {i~f ~fh Zhkiam`gChm~hz Nizhc~az al Sfhg~hz Arhz`~iams im ~hzes al fizimk' rhzlaze`mch h|`gx`~iam' `mn ~hzeim`~iam-

    ^fh @n|isazy Ja`zn sfaxgn laze`ggy hs~`jgisf i~s ka`gs laz `mie`g nisrasi~iam `mn ~fh s~`mn`zn al c`zh~a jh rza|inhn ~a `mie`gs-

    Lim`ggy' {h zhcaeehmn ~f`~ ~fh Za`madh \`gghy SRC@ ma~ f`|h `my |a~imk ehejhzs am ~fh @n|isazyJa`zn am ~fh lagga{imk j`sis?

    ^fh Za`madh \`gghy SRC@ shz|hs im ~fh c`r`ci~y al ` cam~z`c~az laz ~fh @n|isazy Ja`zn' arhz`~imk`mn e`m`kimk ~fh Zhkiam`g Chm~hz- Shz|imk `s ja~f cam~z`c~az `mn `s r`z~ al ~fh ka|hzmimk janyczh`~hs ` ra~hm~i`g camlgic~ al im~hzhs~-

    @n|isazy Ja`zn ehejhzs zhrzhshm~imk ~fh r`z~icir`~imk gac`gi~ihs exs~ {hikf Zhkiam`g Chm~hz

    lxmnimk nhcisiams `k`ims~ caerh~imk gac`g ka|hzmehm~ rziazi~ihs- ^fhsh caerh~imk rziazi~ihs `zhjhyamn ~fh scarh al ~fh Za`madh \`gghy SRC@s eissiam-

    ^fh Za`madh \`gghy SRC@ is `m ieraz~`m~ r`z~mhz {i~f ~fh r`z~icir`~imk gac`gi~ihs `mn sfaxgn cam~imxh~a f`|h ` s~zamk |aich im nhgijhz`~iams zhk`znimk lxmnimk `mn ragicy `~ ~fh Zhkiam`g Chm~hz laz @mie`gCam~zag `mn Rza~hc~iam-

  • 7/30/2019 Audit Report - Rcacp [Final]

    19/23

    R`kh 08

    AJOHC^I\H 00? NIS^ZIJX^IAM AL HVCHSS LXMNS

    J`cdkzaxmn? ^fh Za`madh \`gghy Zhkiam`g Raxmn L`cigi~y Shz|ichs @kzhhehm~ rza|inhs laz ~fzhhzhshz|h lxmns im~hmnhn ~a hmsxzh ~fh Zhkiam`g Chm~hz zhe`ims lisc`ggy saxmn-

    0- Arhz`~imk Zhshz|h Lxmn hpx`g ~a 92 n`ys mh~ hvrhmshs' hvcgxnimk nhj~ shz|ich `mn zhshz|h

    r`yehm~s-

    :- E`im~hm`mch Zhshz|h Lxmn hpx`g ~a 08( al ~fh azikim`g c`ri~`g cas~s al ~fh l`cigi~y-

    3- Nhj~ Shz|ich Zhshz|h Lxmn ~a r`y ~fh ga`m laz cams~zxc~iam al ~fh l`cigi~y-

    Amch ~fhsh zhshz|hs `zh lxggy lxmnhn' `my hvchss lxmns zhe`imimk `~ ~fh hmn al h`cf lisc`g yh`z `zh ~ajh srgi~ jh~{hhm ~fh r`z~icir`~imk gac`gi~ihs `mn ~fh Za`madh \`gghy SRC@- Shc~iam ;-; &:) al ~fh`kzhhehm~ s~`~hs ~f`~ 0!: al ~fh Hvchss Lxmns sf`gg jh zhlxmnhn ~a `gg al ~fh R`z~icir`~imkGac`gi~ihs0!: al ~fh Hvchss Lxmns sf`gg jh r`in ~a ~fh Z\SRC@ ~a jh xshn laz Z\SRC@ rzakz`es~f`~ shz|h ~a zhnxch ~fh mxejhz al S~z`y @mie`gs `mn A{mhz Zhgh`sh @mie`gs-

    J`shn am ~fh `ccaxm~imk zhcazns laz @CS' i~ `rrh`zs ~fh r`z~icir`~imk gac`gi~ihs `mn ~fh Za`madh \`gghySRC@ f`|h `gga{hn @CS ~a zh~`im hvchss lxmns h|hzy yh`z hvchr~ amh simch ~fh Zhkiam`g Chm~hzarhmhn im :22>- ^fh ~`jgh jhga{ sfa{s ~fh hvchss lxmns zh~ imhn jy @CS h`cf yh`z `s mh~ imcaeh?

    N`~hMh~ Imcaeh

    &gass)Mh~ @ssh~s

    J`g`mch03) 36'

    ^fh @n|isazy Ja`zn eimx~hs na ma~ nacxehm~ ~fh azikim`g nhcisiam' fa{h|hz4 ~fh eimx~hs im E`zcf:202 ma~h ~f`~ ~fis {`s ~fh Ja`zns r`s~ rz`c~ich- ^fh hvchss lxmns {hzh ~a jh zh~`imhn laz lx~xzharhz`~imk mhhns al ~fh Zhkiam`g Chm~hz-

    Im hsshmch' ~fh Za`madh \`gghy SRC@ f`s lazkamh `rrzavie`~hgy .83'222 im lxmns ~f`~ i~ caxgn f`|hzhchi|hn xmnhz ~fh ~hzes al ~fh azikim`g `kzhhehm~- ^fis is `m `neiz`jgh nisrg y al ~fh Za`madh \`gghySRC@s caeei~ehm~ ~a ~fh Zhkiam`g Chm~hz `mn ~fh {hgl`zh al ~fh `mie`gs ~fh Chm~hz shz|hs-

    [h gaadhn `~ ~fh saxzch al hvchss lxmns im :229 `mn :200- Im ja~f yh`zs' ~fh hvchss lxmns {hzh

    khmhz`~hn hm~izhgy lzae s`|imks im s`g`zihs `mn jhmhli~s ~f`~ `cczxhn {fhm rasi~iams zhe`imhn |`c`m~laz hv~hmnhn rhzians al ~ieh- Arhm rasi~iams zhnxch ~fh a|hz`gg s~`ll ~ieh `|`ig`jgh ~a c`zh laz `mie`gs-[h nin ma~ h|`gx`~h dhmmhg arhz`~iams a~fhz ~f`m ~fh xsh al dhmmhg s~`ll ~a `ssis~ {i~f e`im~hm`mch `mn

    o`mi~azi`g ~`sds- Chz~`imgy' ~fh gh|hg al dhmmhg c`zh sfaxgn jh c`zhlxggy j`g`mchn {i~f hllaz~s ~a `cfih|harhz`~iam`g s`|imks-

  • 7/30/2019 Audit Report - Rcacp [Final]

    20/23

  • 7/30/2019 Audit Report - Rcacp [Final]

    21/23

    R`kh 0;

    ZHSRAMSH ZA@MADH \@GGHY SRC@

    Nhchejhz 32' :20:

    Sxee`zy S~`~hehm~

    ^fh Za`madh \`gghy SRC@ is |hzy rgh`shn {i~f ~fh zhsxg~s al ~fh zh|ih{- Lzae ~fh

    jhkimmimk' li|h eam~fs `ka' {h ~aad ~fhsh e`~~hzs |hzy shziaxsgy `mn f`|h caarhz`~hn imh|hzy {`y rassijgh- [h h|hm f`n zhsrhc~hn lazhmsic `ccaxm~`m~ na axz a{m im~hzm`gzh|ih{ `mn sf`zhn fis {azd {i~f ~fh Ci~y @xni~az-

    I~ is hsrhci`ggy kz`~ilyimk ~f`~ ~fis @xni~?

    &0) Limns ma h|inhmch al eis`rrzarzi`~iam al lxmns-&:)Nacxehm~s ~f`~ a|hz ~fh sh|hm yh`zs al axz e`m`khehm~ al ~fh exmicir`g l`cigi~y

    ~fhzh f`s jhhm ` ~a~`g sxzrgxs al zh|hmxhs a|hz hvrhmshs al .02

  • 7/30/2019 Audit Report - Rcacp [Final]

    22/23

    R`kh 06

    [h `cdma{ghnkh saeh rzachsshs `mn cam~zags mhhnhn ~a jh ~ikf~hmhn `mn eazhcgashgy eami~azhn sxcf `s ~fash ehm~iamhn im zhk`zn ~a rh~~y c`sf `mn ~fh xsh al czhni~c`zns- Jx~ `my nisczhr`mcihs lga{hn ja~f {`ys `mn im `gg c`shs {hzh

    nh eimiexs-

    ^fizn Ajshz|`~iam

    @geas~ a|hzgaadhn im `gg ~fis is ~fh l`c~ ~f`~ ~fh Zhkiam`g Chm~hz f`s arhz`~hn im ~fh

    jg`cd xmnhz axz e`m`khehm~ laz sh|hm yh`zs- R`kh 08 al ~fh @xni~ nahs `cdma{ghnkh ~fis-

    ^fh azikim`g `kzhhehm~ c`ggs laz amh f`gl al `my arhz`~imk sxzrgxs ~a jh r`in ~a ~fhSRC@ `s `m imchm~i|h laz hllicihm~ arhz`~iams-

    Axz lazehz Hvhcx~i|h Nizhc~az allhzhn ~a rx~ axz sf`zh al ~f`~ sxzrgxs im~a ` shr`z`~harhz`~imk zhshz|h il ~fh exmicir`gi~ihs {axgn na ~fh s`eh {i~f ~fhiz f`gl- Ma~imk ~f`~ ~fis is `mxmxsx`ggy l`|az`jgh zz`mkhehm~ laz ~fh exmicir`gi~ihs ~a f`|h mamrzali~ sxjsiniimk ~fhiz`mie`g cam~zag arhz`~iam' ~fh @xni~ camcgxnhs ~f`~ ~fh SRC@ f`s lazhkamh .83'222 a|hz ~fh

    r`s~ siv yh`zs `mn c`ggs ~f`~ `m `neiz`jgh nisrg`y al ~fh Za`madh \`gghy SRC@s caeei~ehm~~a ~fh Zhkiam`g Chm~hz `mn ~fh {hgl`zh al ~fh `mie`gs ~fh Chm~hz shz|hs-

    @nni~iam`g Zhgh|`m~ Imlaze`~iam

    Im h`zgy @xkxs~ {fhm i~ jhc`eh cgh`z ~f`~ ~fh exmicir`gi~ihs {hzh rg`mmimk `m @xni~ al~fh ZC@CR arhz`~iams' ~fh Za`madh \`gghy SRC@ hmk`khn axz a{m lazhmsic `ccaxm~`m~ ~a

    zh|ih{ ~fh arhz`~iam {i~f srhci`g `~~hm~iam ~a ~fh `ggac`~iam al lxmnimk laz sf`zhn hergayhhs'~fh azikim`g camchzm-

    [`g~hz C- Oamhs' CR@!CLL' CLH arhz`~hs Lazhmsic , Im|hs~ik`~i|h Shz|ichs' GGC' gi~ik`~iamcamsxg~imk ~a `~~azmhys- Ez- Oamhs is fikfgy zhk`znhn `mn im kzh`~ nhe`mn jy `zh` ~~azmhys-

    Fh lighn fis zhraz~ {i~f xs am @xkxs~ :: {i~f ~fh lagga{imk camcgxsiam?

    ^fhzh `zh ma `gghk`~iams az h|hm `m imlhzhmch al eis`rrzarzi`~iam-^fhzh is ma imnic`~iam al ierzarhz `ccaxm~imk az l`igxzh ~a `ccaxm~-

    ^fh eh~fan al zhiejxzshehm~s laz czass%sf`zimk al hergayhhs {`sj`shn am kaan l`i~f hs~ie`~hs- ^fh xsh al hs~ie`~hs `mn `ssxer~iams'imcgxnimk ~fh `ggac`~iam al lxmc~iam`g hvrhmshs' is im camlazei~y {i~fkhmhz`ggy `cchr~hn `ccaxm~imk rzimcirghs- ^fh SRC@ {`s `c~x`ggyr`yimk laz eazh fhgr ~f`m ~fhy {hzh zhchi|imk- ^fis camcgxsiam is

    cam~z`zy ~a ~fh cg`ie ~f`~ ~fh SRC@ {`s xsimk dhmmhg rhzsammhg ~a `ssis~

    SRC@ `mn SRC@ {`s ma~ r`yimk `rrzarzi`~h `eaxm~s-

    Camcgxsiam

    ^fh @xni~ cazzhc~gy fikfgikf~s rzachsshs `mn rzachnxzhs ~f`~ mhhn ~a jh ~ikf~hmhn `mneami~azhn eazh cgashgy- [h jhgih|h sieig`z nisca|hzihs caxgn jh laxmn im `geas~ `my e`~xzhhm~hzrzish rx~ xmnhz sieig`z sczx~imy- [h `zh rgh`shn ~f`~ ma~fimk al `my e`kmi~xnh {`snisca|hzhn `s ` nh~ziehm~ ~a ~fh ZC@CR-

  • 7/30/2019 Audit Report - Rcacp [Final]

    23/23

    R`kh 09

    [h `zh khmximhgy rxghn ~f`~ ~fis exmicir`g `xni~ f`s ~`dhm li|h eam~fs ~a caergh~h-^fh nhg`y f`s c`xshn camlxsiam `mn camchzm `eamk axz namazs `mn sxrraz~hzs `mn c`xshn

    xs sikmilic`m~ lim`mci`g f`znsfir' ma~ ~a ehm~iam ~fh sikmilic`m~ ~agg ~fis f`s ~`dhm am axznhnic`~hn `mn f`zn{azdimk hergayhhs-

    I~ is ~ieh ~a ea|h laz{`zn- [h `zh kz`~hlxg ~a f`|h ~fis jhfimn xs `mn gaad laz{`zn ~ajhimk `jgh ~a lacxs axz sagh `~~hm~iam am axz rzimcir`g eissiam al `nar~iams' las~hz c`zh'

    hnxc`~iam `mn sr`y!mhx~hz `s ~fh ka|hzmehm~s jhkim ~a arhz`~h ~fh Zhkiam`g Chm~hz~fheshg|hs-

    J`zj`z` N`gfaxsh' Rzhsinhm~

    Za`madh \`gghy SRC@