ats ps poster final - cdn.branchcms.com€¦ · e-eomics e 1 g 1. s 2 r 3 r 3 s 3 1 – c, n 3 –;...

1
A Novel Method For Discovery of Peripheral Blood Biomarkers in Idiopathic Pulmonary Fibrosis Using Extensive Depletion and TMTcalibrator™ Tissue-Enhanced Plasma Proteomics I. Pike 1 , M. Bremang 1 , P.J. Wolters 2 , R. Gaster 3 , S. Turner 3 , M. Decaris 3 1 – Proteome Sciences plc, Hamilton House, Mabledon Place, London, WC1H 9BB, UK; 2 – University of California at San Francisco, San Francisco, USA; 3 – PLIANT Therapeutics, 700 Saginaw Drive, Suite 150, Redwood City, CA 94063, USA Introduction Peripheral biomarkers related to the pathogenesis of idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis (IPF) are urgently needed to improve diagnosis, selection and assessment of treatment, particularly in the context of new drug development. Recent improvements in the depletion of high and medium abundant proteins and development of tissue-enhanced fluid proteomics have increased the breadth and depth of plasma proteome coverage. We have now combined these methods to obtain unparalleled coverage of the IPF plasma proteome. Method Longitudinal archival plasma samples (n=25) from six individuals with IPF and five control individuals were obtained from the UCSF Biobank and processed as shown in Figure 1. Super-depletion of the top ~70 high and medium abundant proteins using Seppro ® IgY14 and Supermix ® columns (Merck). Plex #1-5 each comprised 6 plasma samples with 4 tissue trigger/calibrant samples. Plex 6 comprised 10 plasma samples only. Each TMT ® 10plex was analysed using 30 x 2 hour gradient on an Orbitrap ® Fusion Tribrid ® mass spectrometer with in-line uHPLC. MS files were processed with a sequential SEQUEST search strategy in Proteome Discoverer v1.4 (Thermo Scientific) with a standard search followed by a bespoke method in the residual unmatched spectra with variable modification for less-common post-translational modifications such as hydroxylation of proline and lysine. Data integration, normalisation, quantitation and statistical analyses were performed within Proteome Sciences’ in- house bioinformatics workflows. Reported plasma abundance of select IPF-related proteins was obtained through the human plasma proteome database and/or PubMed searches. Results & Conclusion • Super-depletion removed ~99% of total plasma protein (Figure 2). • Detection limit in mid-pg/ml range in plasma channels when using the tissue trigger. • ~4,000 proteins quantified with Super-depletion only, more than doubled to ~9,000 when tissue trigger added (Table 1). • Key post-translationally modified proteins only detected when using tissue trigger (Table 1.) • Improved coverage of select IPF-related proteins (Table 2). • Distributions for GO cellular components (Figure 3A) or biological processes (Figure 3B) were similar with or without tissue trigger. • Proportionally greater impact on detection of cellular vs secreted protein classes (Figure 4A) and for lung-associated proteins with TMTcalibrator™ than in Super-depleted plasma alone (Figure 4B). • TMTcalibrator™ with Super-depletion provides outstanding proteome coverage for plasma biomarker discovery offering deeper insights into IPF disease processes and response to treatment. • Larger studies required for replication/validation of novel candidate biomarkers. Figure 1 – TMTcalibrator™ workflow with plasma Super-depletion and incorporation of four-point trigger/calibrant. TMT126 – 131N = Tandem Mass Tag reporter ion mass-to-charge. Table 2 – Peptide coverage of select IPF-related proteins. TMTcal+SD = Super-depleted plasma with four-channel trigger/calibrant; SD = Super-depletion only; Concentrations from plasmaproteomedatabase.org; NR = not reported www.proteomics.com TMTCalibrator™ with Super-depletion TMT 126 TMT 127N TMT 127C TMT 128N TMT 128C TMT 129N TMT 129C TMT 130N TMT 130C TMT 131N TMT 10plex Reagent Labelling & Mixing bRP Fractionation F1 F2 F3 F4 F5 F6 F7 F8 …… F30 Lung Tissue Trigger/Calibrant 1 4 6 10 IntegrinαV Longitudinal Plasma Samples Protein Extraction & Trypsin Digestion Figure 4 – Increased coverage of the proteome using TMTcalibrator™ with Super-depletion. A – Protein class; B – Lung proteins (based on 186 genes defined as overexpressed in lung at proteinatlas.org). TMTcal+SD = Super- depleted plasma with four-channel trigger/calibrant; SD = Super-depleted plasma Figure 2 – SDS-PAGE gels showing consistent plasma depletion – Left panel = IgY14 depletion; Right panel = IgY14 + Supermix depletion 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 All 'Lung' MS4A15 SFTA2 SFTPA1 LRRN4 SCGB3A2 SFTPC SFTPD NAPSA SFTB AGER SLC34A2 SFTPA2 Number of Peptides Gene Name SD TMTcal + SD 0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 Storage protein Extracellular matrix protein Surfactant Defense/immunity protein Signaling molecule Cell adhesion molecule Chaperone Hydrolase Cytoskeletal protein Isomerase Receptor Enzyme modulator Calcium-binding protein Lyase Structural protein Membrane traffic protein Transfer/carrier protein Ligase Oxidoreductase Cell junction protein Transferase Viral protein Transmembrane receptor Transporter Nucleic acid binding Transcription factor % Change Percentage change in Protein Class detected with TMTcal + SD vs SD A B 1 – Molecular weight markers 2 – Crude plasma, 4µg 3 – Depletion D1-1, 2µg 4 – Depletion D1-2, 2µg 5 – Depletion D1-3, 2µg 1 – Molecular weight markers 2 – Crude plasma, 4µg 3 – Depletion D1-1, 2µg 4 – Depletion D1-2, 2µg 5 – Depletion D1-3, 2µg 6 – Depletion D2, 2µg IgY14 IgY14 + Supermix 1 2 3 4 5 6 1 2 3 4 5 Gene Symbol TMTcal+SD (# peptides) SD (# peptides) Plasma Concn POSTN 195 162 200 ng/ml Collagen I/IV 1240 371 ~100 ng/ml CHI3L1 10 11 40 ng/ml CCL18 3 0 31 ng/ml SP-A 70 31 30 ng/ml TGFB1 8 20 5 ng/ml KRT18 24 0 4 ng/ml MMP7 2 1 4 ng/ml KRT8 42 1 3 ng/ml TGFB2 2 0 0.2 ng/ml LOXL2 1 0 0.1 ng/ml TGM2 30 1 NR ITGAV 55 6 NR ITGB6 22 0 NR MUC1 19 2 NR TGFBR1 1 2 NR Figure 3 – Biological coverage of TMTcalibrator™ vs Super-depletion alone. A – GO Cellular Compartment; B – GO Biological Process. TMTcal+SD = Super- depleted plasma with four-channel trigger/calibrant; SD = Super-depleted plasma only A B Table 1 – Output metrics for TMTcalibrator™ and TMT ® MS2 analysis of IPF plasma – Standard Search (upper panel); Sequential PTM search (lower panel) IP & MB are paid employees and hold stock and/or stock options in Proteome Sciences plc. IP is an inventor on patents covering the TMTcalibrator™ technology ST & MD are paid employees and hold stock and/or stock options in Pliant Therapeutics Inc. who funded the study

Upload: others

Post on 26-Jun-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: ATS PS Poster Final - cdn.branchcms.com€¦ · e-eomics e 1 g 1. s 2 r 3 r 3 s 3 1 – c, n 3 –; 3 – SA n l s d to e s of ic y s) e y needed to e, n and ent of t, y in e xt of

A N

ovel

Met

hod

For D

isco

very

of P

erip

hera

l Blo

od B

iom

arke

rs in

Idio

path

ic P

ulm

onar

y Fi

bros

is U

sing

Ext

ensi

ve D

eple

tion

and

TMTc

alib

rato

r™ T

issu

e-En

hanc

ed P

lasm

a Pr

oteo

mic

sI.

Pike

1 , M

. Bre

man

g1, P

.J. W

olte

rs2 ,

R. G

aste

r3, S

. Tur

ner3

, M. D

ecar

is3

1 –

Prot

eom

e Sc

ienc

es p

lc, H

amilt

on H

ouse

, Mab

ledo

nPl

ace,

Lon

don,

WC

1H 9

BB, U

K; 2

–U

nive

rsity

of C

alifo

rnia

at S

an F

ranc

isco

, San

Fra

ncis

co, U

SA;

3 –

PLIA

NT

Ther

apeu

tics,

700

Sag

inaw

Driv

e, S

uite

150

, Red

woo

d C

ity, C

A 94

063,

USA

Intr

oduc

tion

Perip

hera

lbi

omar

kers

rela

ted

toth

epa

thog

enes

isof

idio

path

icpu

lmon

ary

fibro

sis

(IPF)

are

urge

ntly

need

edto

impr

ove

diag

nosi

s,se

lect

ion

and

asse

ssm

ent

oftre

atm

ent,

parti

cula

rlyin

the

cont

exto

fnew

drug

deve

lopm

ent.

Rec

ent

impr

ovem

ents

inth

ede

plet

ion

ofhi

ghan

dm

ediu

mab

unda

ntpr

otei

nsan

dde

velo

pmen

tof

tissu

e-en

hanc

edflu

idpr

oteo

mic

sha

vein

crea

sed

the

brea

dth

and

dept

hof

plas

ma

prot

eom

eco

vera

ge.W

eha

veno

wco

mbi

ned

thes

em

etho

dsto

obta

inun

para

llele

dco

vera

geof

the

IPF

plas

ma

prot

eom

e.

Met

hod

Long

itudi

nal

arch

ival

plas

ma

sam

ples

(n=2

5)fro

msi

xin

divi

dual

sw

ithIP

Fan

dfiv

eco

ntro

lin

divi

dual

sw

ere

obta

ined

from

the

UC

SFBi

oban

kan

dpr

oces

sed

assh

own

inFi

gure

1.•

Supe

r-dep

letio

nof

the

top

~70

high

and

med

ium

abun

dant

prot

eins

usin

gSe

ppro

®Ig

Y14

and

Supe

rmix

®

colu

mns

(Mer

ck).

•Pl

ex#1

-5ea

chco

mpr

ised

6pl

asm

asa

mpl

esw

ith4

tissu

etri

gger

/cal

ibra

ntsa

mpl

es.

Plex

6co

mpr

ised

10pl

asm

asa

mpl

eson

ly.•

Each

TMT®

10pl

exw

asan

alys

edus

ing

30x

2ho

urgr

adie

nton

anO

rbitr

ap®

Fusi

onTr

ibrid

®m

ass

spec

trom

eter

with

in-li

neuH

PLC

.•

MS

files

wer

epr

oces

sed

with

ase

quen

tial

SEQ

UES

Tse

arch

stra

tegy

inPr

oteo

me

Dis

cove

rer

v1.4

(The

rmo

Scie

ntifi

c)w

itha

stan

dard

sear

chfo

llow

edby

abe

spok

em

etho

din

the

resi

dual

unm

atch

edsp

ectra

with

varia

ble

mod

ifica

tion

for

less

-com

mon

post

-tran

slat

iona

lm

odifi

catio

nssu

chas

hydr

oxyl

atio

nof

prol

ine

and

lysi

ne.

•D

ata

inte

grat

ion,

norm

alis

atio

n,qu

antit

atio

nan

dst

atis

tical

anal

yses

wer

epe

rform

edw

ithin

Prot

eom

eSc

ienc

es’i

n-ho

use

bioi

nfor

mat

ics

wor

kflo

ws.

•R

epor

ted

plas

ma

abun

danc

eof

sele

ctIP

F-re

late

dpr

otei

nsw

asob

tain

edth

roug

hth

ehu

man

plas

ma

prot

eom

eda

taba

sean

d/or

PubM

edse

arch

es.

Res

ults

&C

oncl

usio

n•

Supe

r-dep

letio

nre

mov

ed~9

9%of

tota

lpla

sma

prot

ein

(Fig

ure

2).

•D

etec

tion

limit

inm

id-p

g/m

lra

nge

inpl

asm

ach

anne

lsw

hen

usin

gth

etis

sue

trigg

er.

•~4

,000

prot

eins

quan

tifie

dw

ithSu

per-d

eple

tion

only,

mor

eth

ando

uble

dto

~9,0

00w

hen

tissu

etri

gger

adde

d(T

able

1).

•Ke

ypo

st-tr

ansl

atio

nally

mod

ified

prot

eins

only

dete

cted

whe

nus

ing

tissu

etri

gger

(Tab

le1.

)•

Impr

oved

cove

rage

ofse

lect

IPF-

rela

ted

prot

eins

(Tab

le2)

.•

Dis

tribu

tions

for

GO

cellu

lar

com

pone

nts

(Fig

ure

3A)

orbi

olog

ical

proc

esse

s(F

igur

e3B

)w

ere

sim

ilarw

ithor

with

outt

issu

etri

gger

.•

Prop

ortio

nally

grea

ter

impa

cton

dete

ctio

nof

cellu

lar

vsse

cret

edpr

otei

ncl

asse

s(F

igur

e4A

)an

dfo

rlu

ng-a

ssoc

iate

dpr

otei

nsw

ithTM

Tcal

ibra

tor™

than

inSu

per-d

eple

ted

plas

ma

alon

e(F

igur

e4B

).•

TMTc

alib

rato

r™w

ithSu

per-d

eple

tion

prov

ides

outs

tand

ing

prot

eom

eco

vera

gefo

rpl

asm

abi

omar

ker

disc

over

yof

ferin

gde

eper

insi

ghts

into

IPF

dise

ase

proc

esse

san

dre

spon

seto

treat

men

t.•

Larg

erst

udie

sre

quire

dfo

rrep

licat

ion/

valid

atio

nof

nove

lcan

dida

tebi

omar

kers

.

Figu

re 1

–TM

Tcal

ibra

tor™

wor

kflo

w w

ith p

lasm

a Su

per-d

eple

tion

and

inco

rpor

atio

n of

four

-poi

nt tr

igge

r/cal

ibra

nt. T

MT1

26 –

131N

= T

ande

m M

ass

Tag

repo

rter i

on m

ass-

to-c

harg

e.

Tabl

e 2

–Pe

ptid

e co

vera

ge o

f sel

ect I

PF-re

late

d pr

otei

ns. T

MTc

al+S

D=

Supe

r-dep

lete

d pl

asm

a w

ith fo

ur-c

hann

el tr

igge

r/cal

ibra

nt; S

D =

Sup

er-d

eple

tion

only

; C

once

ntra

tions

from

plasmaproteomedatabase.org;

NR

= n

ot re

porte

d

ww

w.pr

oteo

mic

s.co

m

TMTC

alibrator™

with

Sup

er-dep

letio

n

TMT126

TMT127N

TMT127C

TMT128N

TMT128C

TMT129N

TMT129C

TMT130N

TMT130C

TMT131N

TMT10plexReagentLabelling&Mixing

bRPFractionation

F1

F2

F3

F4

F5

F6

F7

F8

……

F30

LungTissueTrigger/Calibrant

1 4 6 10

0.000

1.000

2.000

3.000

4.000

5.000

6.000

7.000

IPFT0

IPF

T3

IPFT6

IPF

T9

IPFT1

2

CTL

CAL1CA

L2CA

L3CA

L4

Integrin

αV

LongitudinalPlasmaSamples

ProteinExtraction&TrypsinDigestion

Figu

re 4

–In

crea

sed

cove

rage

of t

he p

rote

ome

usin

g TM

Tcal

ibra

tor™

with

Su

per-d

eple

tion.

A –

Prot

ein

clas

s; B

–Lu

ng p

rote

ins

(bas

ed o

n 18

6 ge

nes

defin

ed a

s ov

erex

pres

sed

in lu

ng a

t proteinatlas.org)

. TM

Tcal

+SD

= Su

per-

depl

eted

pla

sma

with

four

-cha

nnel

trig

ger/c

alib

rant

; SD

= S

uper

-dep

lete

d pl

asm

a

Figu

re 2

–SD

S-PA

GE

gels

sho

win

g co

nsis

tent

pla

sma

depl

etio

n –

Left

pane

l = Ig

Y14

depl

etio

n; R

ight

pan

el =

IgY1

4 +

Supe

rmix

depl

etio

n

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

All'Lung'MS4A15

SFTA2

SFTPA1

LRRN4SCGB3A2SFTPC

SFTPD

NAPSA

SFTB

AGER

SLC34A2SFTPA2

NumberofPeptides

GeneName

SD

TMTcal+SD

050

100

150

200

250

300

350

Storageprotein

Extracellularmatrixprotein

Surfactant

Defen

se/immunityprotein

Signalingmolecule

Cellad

hesionm

olecule

Chap

erone

Hydrolase

Cytoskeletalprotein

Isomerase

Recep

tor

Enzymemodulator

Calcium-bindingprotein

Lyase

Structuralprotein

Mem

branetrafficprotein

Tran

sfer/carrierprotein

Ligase

Oxidoreductase

Celljunctionprotein

Tran

sferase

Viralprotein

Tran

smem

branereceptor

Tran

sporter

Nucleicacidbinding

Tran

scriptionfactor

%Change

Percentagechan

geinProteinClassdetectedwithTMTcal+SDvsSD

A B

1 –

Mol

ecul

ar w

eigh

t mar

kers

2 –

Cru

de p

lasm

a, 4

µg3

–D

eple

tion

D1-

1, 2

µg4

–D

eple

tion

D1-

2, 2

µg5

–D

eple

tion

D1-

3, 2

µg

1 –

Mol

ecul

ar w

eigh

t mar

kers

2 –

Cru

de p

lasm

a, 4

µg3

–D

eple

tion

D1-

1, 2

µg4

–D

eple

tion

D1-

2, 2

µg5

–D

eple

tion

D1-

3, 2

µg6

–D

eple

tion

D2,

2µg

IgY1

4Ig

Y14

+ Su

perm

ix1

2

3

4 5

6

1

2

3

4 5

Gen

e Sy

mbo

lTM

Tcal

+SD

(# p

eptid

es)

SD(#

pep

tides

)Pl

asm

a C

oncn

POST

N19

516

220

0 ng

/ml

Col

lage

nI/I

V12

4037

1~1

00 n

g/m

lC

HI3

L110

1140

ng/

ml

CC

L18

30

31 n

g/m

lSP

-A70

3130

ng/

ml

TGFB

18

205

ng/m

lKR

T18

240

4 ng

/ml

MM

P72

14

ng/m

lKR

T842

13

ng/m

lTG

FB2

20

0.2

ng/m

lLO

XL2

10

0.1

ng/m

lTG

M2

301

NR

ITG

AV55

6N

RIT

GB6

220

NR

MU

C1

192

NR

TGFB

R1

12

NR

Figu

re 3

–Bi

olog

ical

cov

erag

e of

TM

Tcal

ibra

tor™

vs

Supe

r-dep

letio

n al

one.

A

–G

O C

ellu

lar C

ompa

rtmen

t; B

–G

O B

iolo

gica

l Pro

cess

. TM

Tcal

+SD

= Su

per-

depl

eted

pla

sma

with

four

-cha

nnel

trig

ger/c

alib

rant

; SD

= S

uper

-dep

lete

d pl

asm

a on

ly

A B

Tabl

e 1

–O

utpu

t met

rics

for T

MTc

alib

rato

r™ a

nd T

MT®

MS2

ana

lysi

s of

IPF

plas

ma

–St

anda

rd S

earc

h (u

pper

pan

el);

Sequ

entia

l PTM

sea

rch

(low

er

pane

l)

IP &

MB

are

paid

em

ploy

ees

and

hold

sto

ck a

nd/o

r sto

ck o

ptio

ns in

Pro

teom

e Sc

ienc

es p

lc. I

P is

an

inve

ntor

on

pate

nts

cove

ring

the

TMTc

alib

rato

r™ te

chno

logy

ST &

MD

are

paid

em

ploy

ees

and

hold

sto

ck a

nd/o

r sto

ck o

ptio

ns in

Plia

nt

Ther

apeu

tics

Inc.

who

fund

ed th

e st

udy