atp 2-22-9 open source intelligence (2012)

91
 G]_ 5-55.1 Hpjk-\hurlj Aktj``adjklj Fu`y 5?75 MA\]UAEZ]AHK UJ\]UAL]AHK6 Zk`aiatjm Mastraeutahk Cjgmqugrtjrs, Mjpgrtijkt hb tcj Griy

Upload: richard-j-campbell-httpstwittercom

Post on 07-Feb-2018

219 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 1/91

 

G]_ 5-55.1

Hpjk-\hurlj Aktj``adjklj

Fu`y 5?75 

MA\]UAEZ]AHK UJ\]UAL]AHK6 Zk`aiatjm Mastraeutahk

Cjgmqugrtjrs, Mjpgrtijkt hb tcj Griy

Page 2: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 2/91

Page 3: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 3/91

*G]_ 5-55.1 

MA\]UAEZ]AHK UJ\]UAL]AHK6 Zk`aiatjm Mastraeutahk 

.

*]cas pue`algtahk supjrsjmjs BIA 5-55.1, : Mjljiejr 5??2.

a

Griy ]jlckaqujs _ue`algtahk

 Kh. 5-55.1 (BIA 5-55.1)

Cjgmqugrtjrs

Mjpgrtijkt hb tcj Griy

Tgscakdthk, ML, 7? Fu`y 5?75 

Hpjk-\hurlj Aktj``adjklj

Lhktjkts

_gdj

_UJBGLJ.............................................................................................................. av 

AK]UHMZL]AHK .................................................................................................... v 

Lcgptjr 7 H_JK-\HZULJ AK]J@@ADJKLJ (H\AK]) BZKMGIJK]G@\ ........................ 7-7 

Mjbakatahk gkm ]jris .......................................................................................... 7-7 

Lcgrgltjrastals .................................................................................................... 7-7 

]cj Aktj``adjklj Tgrbadctakd Bukltahk ................................................................ 7-5 

]cj Aktj``adjklj _rhljss .................................................................................... 7-< 

]cj _`gkkakd Ujquarjijkts gkm Gssjssakd Lh``jltahk _rhljss ........................ 7-= 

]cj Ia`atgry Mjlasahkignakd _rhljss ................................................................ 7-= 

Aktj``adjklj _rjpgrgtahk hb tcj Egtt`jbaj`m ........................................................... 7-: 

Lcgptjr 5 _@GKKAKD GKM _UJ_GUG]AHK HB ]CJ H\AK] IA\\AHK ............................. 5-7 

\jltahk A “ _`gkkakd H\AK] Gltavatajs ............................................................ 5-7 

Mjbakj tcj Hpjrgtahkg` Jkvarhkijkt .................................................................. 5-7 

Mjslraej Jkvarhkijktg` Jbbjlts hk Hpjrgtahks ................................................. 5-5 

Jvg`ugtj tcj ]crjgt ............................................................................................ 5-5 

Mjtjriakj ]crjgt Lhursjs hb Gltahk .................................................................. 5-5 

\jltahk AA “ _rjpgrgtahk hb H\AK] Gltavatajs .................................................. 5-5 

H\AK] Jxp`hatgtahk ............................................................................................. 5-< 

_rjpgrgtahk Lhksamjrgtahks ................................................................................ 5-= 

\jltahk AAA “ _`gkkakd gkm _rjpgrgtahk Lhksamjrgtahks ............................... 5-4 

Hpjk-\hurlj Uj`agea`aty ...................................................................................... 5-4 

Hpjk-\hurlj Akbhrigtahk Lhktjkt Lrjmaea`aty..................................................... 5-3 

Lhip`agklj ......................................................................................................... 5-3 

Page 4: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 4/91

Lhktjkts

Hpjrgtahks \jluraty............................................................................................. 5-3 

L`gssabalgtahk ....................................................................................................... 5-1 

Lhhrmakgtahk ........................................................................................................ 5-1 

Mjljptahk gkm Eags ............................................................................................. 5-1 

Lhpyradct gkm Aktj``jltug` _rhpjrty ..................................................................... 5-1 

@akduast Ujquarjijkts ...................................................................................... 5-7? 

Iglcakj Bhrjadk @gkdugdj ]rgks`gtahk \ystjis ............................................ 5-77 

\jltahk AR “ Igkkakd tcj H\AK] \jltahk ..................................................... 5-7< 

H\AK] \jltahk Mutajs ....................................................................................... 5-7< 

H\AK] \jltahk gt tcj Eradgmj Lhiegt ]jgi @jvj` ......................................... 5-7< 

]gsn Hrdgkazgtahk Lhksamjrgtahks .................................................................... 5-7: 

Lcgptjr < LH@@JL]AKD H\AK] ......................................................................................... <-7 

Lh``jltakd _ue`al`y Gvga`ge`j Akbhrigtahk ............................................................ <-7 

Ujsjgrlc ............................................................................................................. <-< 

Lcgptjr = _UHMZLAKD H\AK] .......................................................................................... =-7 

Lgtjdhrajs hb Aktj``adjklj _rhmults .................................................................... =-7 

Jvg`ugtj Akbhrigtahk ........................................................................................... =-5 

_rhljss Akbhrigtahk ............................................................................................ =-: 

Ujphrt gkm Massjiakgtj Akbhrigtahk ................................................................ =-7? 

Ujphrtakd gkm Massjiakgtahk Lhksamjrgtahks ................................................... =-75 

Gppjkmax G @JDG@ UJ\]UAL]AHK\ GKM UJDZ@G]HUQ @AIA]G]AHK\ ........................ G-7 

Gppjkmax E LQEJU\_GLJ AK]JUKJ] GTGUJKJ\\ ...................................................... E-7 

Gppjkmax L EG\AL GKM GMRGKLJM AK]JUKJ] \JGULC ]JLCKAWZJ\ ..................... L-7 

Gppjkmax M H\AK] LHK]UAEZ]AHK\ ................................................................................. M-7 

Gppjkmax J H\AK] HUDGKAVG]AHK\ ................................................................................. J-= 

Gppjkmax B H_JK-\HZULJ UJ\HZULJ\ ............................................................................ 7 

D@H\\GUQ .......................................................................................... D`hssgry-7 

UJBJUJKLJ\ .................................................................................. Ujbjrjkljs-7 

AKMJS ......................................................................................................... Akmjx-7 

Badurjs

Badurj 7-7. ]cj aktj``adjklj prhljss ...................................................................................... 7-< 

Badurj 5-7. Eradgmj lhiegt tjgi‑s H\AK] sjltahk ............................................................. 5-7= 

Badurj <-7. _rhljss bhr lh``jltakd pue`al`y gvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk ........................................... <-5  

Page 5: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 5/91

Lhktjkts

7? Fu`y 5?75  G]_ 5-55.1 aaa

]ge`js

]ge`j 5-7. Hpjk-shurlj rj`agea`aty rgtakds ............................................................................... 5-3 

]ge`j 5-5. Hpjk-shurlj lhktjkt lrjmaea`aty rgtakds ................................................................. 5-3 

]ge`j <-7. Hpjk-shurlj ijmag, lhiphkjkts, gkm j`jijkts ................................................. <-: 

]ge`j =-7. Lgtjdhrajs hb aktj``adjklj prhmults ....................................................................... =-7 

]ge`j =-5. Lhipgrashk hb lhiiukalgtahk typjs .................................................................... =-< 

]ge`j =-<. @jvj`, bglthrs, gkm j`jijkts hb ijmag lhktrh` ...................................................... =-4  

]ge`j =-=. Cajrgrlcy hb ijmag phwjr ..................................................................................... =-3 

]ge`j L-7. Ehh`jgk `hdal hpjrgthrs, lhkkjlthrs, gkm mj`aiatjrs ........................................... L-< 

]ge`j L-5. ]ruklgtakd gkm schrtjkakd ukabhri rjshurlj `hlgthrs ......................................... L-2 

]ge`j J-7. Hpjk \hurlj Glgmjiy lurralu`ui .......................................................................J-: 

]ge`j B-7. Ia`atgry hpjk-shurlj trgakakd gkm rjshurljs ............................................................ 7 

Page 6: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 6/91

 

av G]_ 5-55.1 7? Fu`y 5?75 

_rjbglj

G]_ 5-55.1 jstge`ascjs g lhiihk ukmjrstgkmakd, bhukmgtahkg` lhkljpts, gkm ijtchms hb usj bhr Griy hpjk-shurlj aktj``adjklj (H\AK]). G]_ 5-55.1 cadc`adcts tcj lcgrgltjrazgtahk hb H\AK] gs gk aktj``adjklj maslap`akj,

ats aktjrrj`gtahkscap watc htcjr aktj``adjklj maslap`akjs, gkm ats gpp`algea`aty th ukabajm `gkm hpjrgtahks.

]cas Griy tjlckaqujs pue`algtahk ”  

  _rhvamjs bukmgijktg` praklap`js gkm tjriakh`hdy bhr Griy ukats tcgt lhkmult H\AK] jxp`hatgtahk.

  Maslussjs tgltals, tjlckaqujs, gkm prhljmurjs (]]_) bhr Griy ukats tcgt lhkmult H\AK] jxp`hatgtahk.

  _rhvamjs g lgtg`yst bhr rjkjwakd gkm jipcgsazakd Griy gwgrjkjss hb tcj vg`uj hb pue`al`y

gvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk gkm hpjk shurljs.

  Jstge`ascjs g lhiihk ukmjrstgkmakd hb H\AK].

  Mjvj`hps systjigtal gpprhglcjs th p`gk, prjpgrj, lh``jlt, gkm prhmulj aktj``adjklj brhi pue`al`y

gvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk brhi hpjk shurljs.

]cj tgrdjt gumajklj bhr tcas Griy tjlckaqujs pue`algtahk as Griy ukats gt tcj mavasahk `jvj` gkm ej`hw lhkmultakdH\AK] jxp`hatgtahk.

Mjbakjm tjris grj amjktabajm ak tcj tjxt. Mjbakatahks bhr wcalc tcas pue`algtahk as tcj prhphkjkt grj praktjm ak

 eh`mbglj. ]cjsj tjris gkm tcjar mjbakatahks wa`` ej aklhrphrgtjm akth tcj kjxt rjvasahk hb BI 7-?5. Bhr htcjr

mjbakatahks ak tcj tjxt, tcj tjri as atg`alazjm, gkm tcj kuiejr hb tcj prhphkjkt pue`algtahk bh``hws tcj mjbakatahk.

]jris bhr wcalc tcas pue`algtahk as tcj prhphkjkt grj akmalgtjm watc gk gstjrasn ak tcj d`hssgry.

‐H\AK] pjrshkkj`’ gpp`ajs th aktj``adjklj gkm khkaktj``adjklj Gltavj Griy, Griy Kgtahkg` Dugrm/Griy Kgtahkg`

Dugrm hb tcj Zkatjm \tgtjs, gkm Z.\. Griy Ujsjrvj pjrshkkj` wch jkdgdj ak iassahks akvh`vakd pue`al`y gvga`ge`j

akbhrigtahk gkm hpjk shurljs.

GU <37-7? mjbakjs g Z.\. pjrshk gs ”  

  G Z.\. latazjk.

  G Z.\. pjrigkjkt rjsamjkt g`ajk.

  Gk ukaklhrphrgtjm gsshlagtahk suestgktag``y lhiphsjm hb Z.\. latazjks hr pjrigkjkt rjsamjkt g`ajks.

  G lhrphrgtahk hr suesamagry aklhrphrgtjm ak tcj Zkatjm \tgtjs tcgt as kht marjltjm hr lhktrh``jm ey

g bhrjadk dhvjrkijkt.

]cj bh``hwakd grj prjsuijm th ej khk-Z.\. pjrshks6

  G pjrshk hr hrdgkazgtahk hutsamj hb tcj Zkatjm \tgtjs.

  G pjrshk kht g latazjk hr pjrigkjkt rjsamjkt g`ajk hb tcj Zkatjm \tgtjs.

]cj usj hr ijktahk hb tcj kgij hb gky lhiijrlag` hr pravgtj hrdgkazgtahk hr ats gsshlagtjm trgmjigrn hr sjrvaljs ey

tcj Griy mhjs kht jxprjss hr aip`y gk jkmhrsjijkt hb tcj sphkshr hr ats prhmults gkm sjrvaljs ey tcj Griy.

]cas pue`algtahk gpp`ajs th tcj Gltavj Griy, tcj Griy Kgtahkg` Dugrm/Griy Kgtahkg` Dugrm hb tcj Zkatjm

\tgtjs, gkm tcj Z.\. Griy Ujsjrvj uk`jss htcjrwasj stgtjm.Cjgmqugrtjrs, Z.\. Griy ]rgakakd gkm Mhltrakj Lhiigkm, as tcj prhphkjkt bhr tcas pue`algtahk. ]cj prjpgrakd

gdjkly as tcj Z.\. Griy Aktj``adjklj Ljktjr hb Jxlj``jklj (Z\GALhJ), Bhrt Cuglculg, GV. \jkm wrattjk

lhiijkts gkm rjlhiijkmgtahks hk MG Bhri 5?53 (Ujlhiijkmjm Lcgkdjs th _ue`algtahks gkm E`gkn Bhris)

marjlt`y th6 Lhiigkmjr, Z\GALhJ, G]]K6 G]V\-LMA-M (G]_ 5-55.1), ::? Laejquj \trjjt, Bhrt Cuglculg,

GV 3:27<-4?74.

Page 7: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 7/91

 

7? Fu`y 5?75  G]_ 5-55.1 v

Aktrhmultahk

\aklj ejbhrj tcj gmvjkt hb tcj sgtj``atj gkm htcjr gmvgkljm tjlckh`hdalg` ijgks hb dgtcjrakd akbhrigtahk,ia`atgry prhbjssahkg`s cgvj p`gkkjm, prjpgrjm, lh``jltjm, gkm prhmuljm aktj``adjklj brhi pue`al`y gvga`ge`j

akbhrigtahk gkm hpjk shurljs th dgak nkhw`jmdj gkm ukmjrstgkmakd hb bhrjadk `gkms, pjhp`js, phtjktag`

tcrjgts, gkm griajs.

Hpjk shurljs phssjss iulc hb tcj akbhrigtahk kjjmjm th ukmjrstgkm tcj pcysalg` gkm cuigk bglthrs hb tcj

hpjrgtahkg` jkvarhkijkt hb ukabajm `gkm hpjrgtahks. _cysalg` gkm cuigk bglthrs hb g davjk hpjrgtahkg`

jkvarhkijkt lgk ej gmmrjssjm uta`azakd pue`al`y gvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk th sgtasby akbhrigtahk gkm

aktj``adjklj rjquarjijkts gkm prhvamj aklrjgsjm satugtahkg` gwgrjkjss aktjrrj`gtjm watc tcj gpp`algtahk hb

tjlckalg` hr l`gssabajm rjshurljs.

]cj whr`m as ejakd rjakvjktjm ey hpjk shurljs. _ue`al`y gvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk lgk ej usjm ey g vgrajty hb

akmavamug`s th jxpgkm g erhgm spjltrui hb hefjltavjs. ]cj sadkabalgklj gkm rj`jvgklj hb hpjk-shurlj

aktj``adjklj (H\AK]) sjrvj gs gk jlhkhiy hb bhrlj, prhvamj gk gmmatahkg` `jvjrgdj lgpgea`aty, gkm luj

tjlckalg` hr l`gssabajm gssjts th rjbakj gkm vg`amgtj ehtc akbhrigtahk gkm aktj``adjklj.Gs gk aktj``adjklj maslap`akj, H\AK] as fumdjm ey ats lhktraeutahk th tcj aktj``adjklj wgrbadctakd bukltahk

ak supphrt hb htcjr wgrbadctakd bukltahks gkm ukabajm `gkm hpjrgtahks.

Page 8: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 8/91

Page 9: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 9/91

 

7? Fu`y 5?75  G]_ 5-55.1 7-7

Lcgptjr 7

Hpjk-\hurlj Aktj``adjklj (H\AK]) Bukmgijktg`s

_ahkjjr gkm rjbhrigtavj marjltavjs `jm th tcj pgssakd hb `jdas`gtahk tcgt gbbjltjm tcj Z.\.aktj``adjklj lhiiukaty gkm ats gpp`algtahk hb pue`al`y gvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk. ]cj

 Kgtahkg` \jluraty Glt hb 7115 ejdgk tcj rjbhrigtahk hb tcj Z.\. aktj` adjklj lhiiukaty

rjsu`takd ak tcj jstge`ascijkt hb tcj Hpjk \hurlj Hbbalj gkm suesjqujkt`y tcj Marjlthr hb Kgtahkg` Aktj` adjklj (MKA) Hpjk \hurlj Ljktjr (H\L) ak 5??:. ]cas lcgptjr mjslraejs

tcj bukmgijktg`s hb hpjk-shurlj aktj``adjklj (H\AK]).

MJBAKA]AHK GKM ]JUI\7-7.  Hpjk-shurlj aktj``adjklj  as tcj aktj``adjklj maslap`akj tcgt pjrtgaks th aktj``adjklj prhmuljm brhi

 pue`al`y gvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk tcgt as lh``jltjm, jxp`hatjm, gkm massjiakgtjm ak g taij`y igkkjr th gk

gpprhpragtj gumajklj bhr tcj purphsj hb gmmrjssakd g spjlabal aktj``adjklj gkm akbhrigtahk rjquarjijkt

(BI 5-?). H\AK] g`sh gpp`ajs th tcj aktj``adjklj prhmuljm ey tcgt maslap`akj.

7-5.  H\AK] as g`sh aktj``adjklj mjvj`hpjm brhi tcj hvjrt lh``jltahk gkm gkg`ysas hb pue`al`y gvga`ge`j gkm

hpjk-shurlj akbhrigtahk kht ukmjr tcj marjlt lhktrh` hb tcj Z.\. Dhvjrkijkt. H\AK] as mjravjm brhi tcj

systjigtal lh``jltahk, prhljssakd, gkm gkg`ysas hb pue`al`y gvga`ge`j, rj`jvgkt akbhrigtahk ak rjsphksj th

aktj``adjklj rjquarjijkts. ]wh aiphrtgkt rj`gtjm tjris grj hpjk shurlj gkm pue`al`y gvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk6

  Hpjk shurlj as gky pjrshk hr drhup tcgt prhvamjs akbhrigtahk watchut tcj jxpjltgtahk hb

 pravgly ““ tcj akbhrigtahk, tcj rj`gtahkscap, hr ehtc as kht prhtjltjm gdgakst pue`al masl`hsurj.

Hpjk-shurlj akbhrigtahk lgk ej pue`al`y gvga`ge`j eut kht g`` pue`al`y gvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk as

hpjk shurlj. Hpjk shurljs rjbjr th pue`al`y gvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk ijmaui gkm grj kht `aiatjm th pcysalg pjrshks.

  _ue`al`y gvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk as mgtg, bglts, akstrultahks, hr htcjr igtjrag` pue`ascjm hr

 erhgmlgst bhr djkjrg` pue`al lhksuiptahk> gvga`ge`j hk rjqujst th g ijiejr hb tcj djkjrg`

 pue`al> `gwbu``y sjjk hr cjgrm ey gky lgsug` hesjrvjr> hr igmj gvga`ge`j gt g ijjtakd hpjk th tcj

djkjrg` pue`al.

Khtj . G`` H\AK] hpjrgtahks lhkmultjm ey aktj``adjklj pjrshkkj` iust lhip`y watc tcj `jdg`

rjstraltahks gs hut`akjm ak Jxjlutavj Hrmjr (JH) 75<<<, MHM :5=?.7-U, MHMM <77:.75,

F_ 5-?, gkm GU <37-7?.

7-<.  H\AK] lh``jltahk as khrig``y gllhip`ascjm tcrhudc ihkathrakd, mgtg-iakakd, gkm rjsjgrlc. Hpjk-

shurlj prhmultahk supphrts g``-shurlj aktj``adjklj gkm tcj lhktakuakd gltavatajs hb tcj aktj``adjklj prhljss

(djkjrgtj aktj``adjklj nkhw`jmdj, gkg`yzj, gssjss, gkm massjiakgtj), gs prjslraejm ak BI 5-?. @anj htcjraktj``adjklj maslap`akjs, H\AK] as mjvj`hpjm egsjm hk tcj lhiigkmjr‑s aktj``adjklj rjquarjijkts. 

LCGUGL]JUA\]AL\

7-=.  ]cj bh``hwakd lcgrgltjrastals gmmrjss tcj rh`j hb H\AK] ak ukabajm `gkm hpjrgtahks6

  _rhvamjs tcj bhukmgtahk. Hpjk-shurlj akbhrigtahk prhvamjs tcj igfhraty hb tcj kjljssgry

 eglndrhukm akbhrigtahk hk gky grjg hb hpjrgtahks (GH). ]cas bhukmgtahk as hetgakjm tcrhudc

Page 10: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 10/91

Lcgptjr 7

7-5 G]_ 5-55.1 7? Fu`y 5?75 

hpjk-shurlj ijmag lhiphkjkts tcgt prhvamj whr`mvajw gwgrjkjss hb aktjrkgtahkg` jvjkts gkm

 pjrljptahks hb khk-Z.\. shlajtajs. ]cas bhukmgtahk as gk jssjktag` pgrt hb tcj lhktakuakd gltavaty

hb djkjrgtj aktj``adjklj nkhw`jmdj.

  Gkswjrs rjquarjijkts. ]cj gvga`gea`aty, mjptc, gkm rgkdj hb pue`al`y gvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk

jkge`js hrdgkazgtahks th sgtasby aktj``adjklj gkm akbhrigtahk rjquarjijkts watchut tcj usj hr

supphrt hb spjlag`azjm cuigk hr tjlckalg` ijgks hb lh``jltahk.

  Jkcgkljs lh``jltahk. Hpjk-shurlj rjsjgrlc supphrts survja``gklj gkm rjlhkkgassgklj gltavatajs ey gkswjrakd aktj``adjklj gkm akbhrigtahk rjquarjijkts. At g`sh prhvamjs akbhrigtahk (sulc gs

 eahdrgpcajs, lu`turg` akbhrigtahk, djhspgtag` akbhrigtahk, gkm tjlckalg` mgtg) tcgt jkcgkljs gkm

usjs ihrj tjlckalg` ijgks hb lh``jltahk.

  Jkcgkljs prhmultahk. Gs pgrt hb g iu`tamaslap`akj aktj``adjklj jbbhrt, tcj usj gkm aktjdrgtahk hb

 pue`al`y gvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk gkm hpjk shurljs jksurj lhiigkmjrs cgvj tcj ejkjbat hb g``

shurljs hb gvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk th ignj akbhrigtavj mjlasahks.

]CJ AK]J@@ADJKLJ TGUBADC]AKD BZKL]AHK

7-:.  ]cj aktj``adjklj wgrbadctakd bukltahk as lhiphsjm hb bhur mastaklt Griy tgltalg` tgsns (GU]s)6

  Aktj``adjklj supphrt th bhrlj djkjrgtahk (GU] 5.7).

  \upphrt th satugtahkg` ukmjrstgkmakd (GU] 5.5).

  _jrbhri aktj``adjklj, survja``gklj, gkm rjlhkkgassgklj (GU] 5.<).

  \upphrt th tgrdjtakd gkm akbhrigtahk supjrahraty (GU] 5.=).

7-2.  ]cj aktj``adjklj wgrbadctakd bukltahk as tcj rj`gtjm tgsns gkm systjis tcgt bgla`atgtj ukmjrstgkmakd hb

tcj hpjrgtahkg` jkvarhkijkt, jkjiy, tjrrgak, wjgtcjr, gkm lava` lhksamjrgtahks (BI 7-?5). Gs g lhktakuhus

 prhljss, tcj aktj``adjklj wgrbadctakd bukltahk akvh`vjs gkg`yzakd akbhrigtahk brhi g`` shurljs gkm

lhkmultakd hpjrgtahks th mjvj`hp tcj satugtahk. H\AK] supphrts jglc hb tcjsj GU]s.

7-4.  _ue`al`y gvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk as usjm th ”  

  \upphrt satugtahkg` ukmjrstgkmakd hb tcj tcrjgt gkm hpjrgtahkg` jkvarhkijkt.

  Hetgak akbhrigtahk gehut tcrjgt lcgrgltjrastals, tjrrgak, wjgtcjr, gkm lava` lhksamjrgtahks.

  Djkjrgtj aktj``adjklj nkhw`jmdj ejbhrj rjljapt hb iassahk th prhvamj rj`jvgkt nkhw`jmdj hb tcj

hpjrgtahkg` jkvarhkijkt.

  Ugpam`y prhvamj sullaklt gkswjrs th sgtasby tcj lhiigkmjr‑s aktj``adjklj rjquarjijkts murakdaktj``adjklj hvjrwgtlc.

  Mjvj`hp g egsj`akj hb nkhw`jmdj gkm ukmjrstgkmakd lhkljrkakd phtjktag` tcrjgt gltahks hr

aktjktahks watcak spjlabal hpjrgtahkg` jkvarhkijkts ak supphrt hb tcj lhiigkmjr‑s hkdhakd

aktj``adjklj rjquarjijkts.

  Djkjrgtj aktj``adjklj nkhw`jmdj gs tcj egsas bhr Griy aktjdrgtakd bukltahks sulc gs aktj``adjklj

 prjpgrgtahk hb tcj egtt`jbaj`m (A_E). A_E as mjsadkjm th supphrt tcj stgbb jstaigtj gkm tcj ia`atgry

mjlasahkignakd prhljss (IMI_). Ihst aktj``adjklj rjquarjijkts grj djkjrgtjm gs g rjsu`t hb

tcj A_E prhljss gkm ats aktjrrj`gtahk watc IMI_.

  \upphrt satugtahk mjvj`hpijkt ” g prhljss bhr gkg`yzakd akbhrigtahk gkm prhmulakd lurrjkt

aktj``adjklj lhkljrkakd phrtahks hb tcj iassahk vgrage`js hb jkjiy, tjrrgak gkm wjgtcjr, gkm lava`

lhksamjrgtahks watcak tcj GH ejbhrj gkm murakd hpjrgtahks (sjj BI 5-?). \atugtahk

mjvj`hpijkt ”  

  Gssasts tcj D-5/\-5 ak mjtjriakakd tcrjgt aktjktahks gkm hefjltavjs.

  Lhkbaris hr mjkajs lhursjs hb gltahk (LHGs).

  _rhvamjs gk jstaigtj hb tcrjgt lhiegt jbbjltavjkjss.

  \upphrt akbhrigtahk lh``jltahk. _`gkkakd rjquarjijkts gkm gssjssakd lh``jltahk gkg`yzjs

akbhrigtahk rjquarjijkts gkm aktj``adjklj dgps gkm gssasts ak mjtjriakakd wcalc gssjt hr

lhieakgtahk hb gssjts grj th ej usjm th sgtasby tcj rjquarjijkts.

Page 11: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 11/91

Hpjk-\hurlj Aktj``adjklj (H\AK]) Bukmgijktg`s

7? Fu`y 5?75  G]_ 5-55.1 7-<

7-3.  Bhr ihrj mjtga`jm akbhrigtahk hk tcj aktj``adjklj wgrbadctakd bukltahk, sjj BI 5-?. Bhr jxgip`js hb

chw H\AK] as usjm th supphrt htcjr aktj``adjklj maslap`akjs gkm hpjrgtahkg` tgsns, sjj gppjkmax M.

]CJ AK]J@@ADJKLJ _UHLJ\\

7-1.  ]cj aktj``adjklj prhljss lhksasts hb bhur stjps (p`gk, prjpgrj, lh``jlt, gkm prhmulj) gkm bhur

lhktakuakd gltavatajs (gkg`yzj, djkjrgtj aktj``adjklj nkhw`jmdj, gssjss, gkm massjiakgtj). Fust gs tcj

gltavatajs hb tcj hpjrgtahks prhljss (p`gk, prjpgrj, jxjlutj, gkm gssjss) hvjr`gp gkm rjlur gs tcj iassahk

mjigkms, sh mh tcj stjps hb tcj aktj``adjklj prhljss. ]cj lhktakuakd gltavatajs hllur lhktakuhus`y

tcrhudchut tcj aktj``adjklj prhljss gkm grj duamjm ey tcj lhiigkmjr‑s akput. 

7-7?.  ]cj bhur lhktakuakd gltavatajs p`us tcj lhiigkmjr‑s akput mravj, scgpj, gkm mjvj`hp tcj aktj``adjklj

 prhljss. ]cj aktj``adjklj prhljss prhvamjs g lhiihk ihmj` bhr aktj``adjklj prhbjssahkg`s th usj th duamj

tcjar tchudcts, maslussahks, p`gks, gkm gssjssijkts. ]cj aktj``adjklj prhljss rjsu`ts ak nkhw`jmdj gkm

 prhmults gehut tcj tcrjgt, tjrrgak gkm wjgtcjr, gkm lava` lhksamjrgtahks.

7-77.  H\AK] jkcgkljs gkm supphrts tcj aktj``adjklj prhljss gkm jkge`js tcj hpjrgtahks prhljss, gs

mjslraejm ak BI 5-?. ]cj aktj``adjklj prhljss jkge`js tcj systjigtal jxjlutahk hb Griy H\AK]

jxp`hatgtahk, gs wj`` gs tcj aktjdrgtahk watc vgrahus hrdgkazgtahks (sulc gs fhakt, aktjrgdjkly,

aktjrdhvjrkijktg`, gkm iu`takgtahkg`). Badurj 7-7 a``ustrgtjs tcj aktj``adjklj prhljss. (Bhr ihrj akbhrigtahk

hk tcj aktj``adjklj prhljss, sjj BI 5-?.)

Badurj 7-7. ]cj aktj``adjklj prhljss

Page 12: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 12/91

Lcgptjr 7

7-= G]_ 5-55.1 7? Fu`y 5?75 

]CJ _@GKKAKD UJWZAUJIJK]\ GKM G\\J\\AKD LH@@JL]AHK

_UHLJ\\

7-75.  Akbhrigtahk lh``jltahk akbhris mjlasahkignakd bhr tcj lhiigkmjr gkm jkge`js tcj gpp`algtahk hb

lhiegt phwjr gkm gssjssijkt hb ats jbbjlts.  Akbhrigtahk lh``jltahk as gk gltavaty tcgt syklcrhkazjs gkm

aktjdrgtjs tcj p`gkkakd gkm hpjrgtahk hb sjkshrs, gssjts, gs wj`` gs tcj prhljssakd, jxp`hatgtahk, gkm

massjiakgtahk hb systjis ak marjlt supphrt hb lurrjkt gkm buturj hpjrgtahks (BI <-::). ]cas as gk aktjdrgtjmaktj``adjklj gkm hpjrgtahks bukltahk. Bhr Griy bhrljs, tcas gltavaty as g lhieakjm gris hpjrgtahk tcgt

bhlusjs hk prahraty aktj``adjklj rjquarjijkts (_AUs) wca`j gkswjrakd tcj lhiigkmjr‑s lratalg` akbhrigtahk

rjquarjijkts (LLAUs).

7-7<.  Akbhrigtahk lh``jltjm brhi iu`tap`j shurljs gkm gkg`yzjm ejlhijs aktj``adjklj tcgt prhvamjs

gkswjrs th lhiigkmjrs‑ akbhrigtahk rjquarjijkts  lhkljrkakd tcj jkjiy gkm htcjr gmvjrsgrajs, l`aigtj,

wjgtcjr, tjrrgak, gkm phpu`gtahk. Mjvj`hpakd tcjsj rjquarjijkts as tcj bukltahk hb akbhrigtahk lh``jltahk6

  G  lhiigkmjr‑s lratalg` akbhrigtahk rjquarjijkt   as gk akbhrigtahk rjquarjijkt amjktabajm ey tcj

lhiigkmjr gs ejakd lratalg` th bgla`atgtakd taij`y mjlasahkignakd. ]cj twh njy j`jijkts grj brajkm`y

bhrlj akbhrigtahk rjquarjijkts gkm prahraty aktj``adjklj rjquarjijkts (F_ <-?).

  G  prahraty aktj``adjklj rjquarjijkt   as gk aktj``adjklj rjquarjijkt, stgtjm gs g prahraty bhr

aktj``adjklj supphrt, wcalc tcj lhiigkmjr gkm stgbb kjjm th ukmjrstgkm tcj gmvjrsgry hr tcj

hpjrgtahkg` jkvarhkijkt (F_ 5-?).   G  brajkm`y bhrlj akbhrigtahk rjquarjijkt   as akbhrigtahk tcj lhiigkmjr gkm stgbb kjjm th

ukmjrstgkm tcj stgtus hb brajkm`y bhrlj gkm supphrtakd lgpgea`atajs (F_ <-?).

7-7=.  ]cj  p`gkkakd rjquarjijkts gkm gssjssakd lh` jltahk  prhljss akvh`vjs sax lhktakuhus, khkmaslrjtj

gltavatajs. ]cjsj gltavatajs gkm suehrmakgtj stjps grj kht kjljssgra`y sjqujktag` gkm hbtjk hvjr`gp. ]cj p`gkkakd

rjquarjijkts gkm gssjssakd lh``jltahk prhljss supphrts tcj stgbb p`gkkakd gkm hpjrgtahks prhljssjs tcrhudchut

ukabajm gkm hpjrgtahks.

]CJ IA@A]GUQ MJLA\AHKIGNAKD _UHLJ\\ 

7-7:.  Zphk rjljapt hb tcj iassahk, lhiigkmjrs gkm stgbbs ejdak tcj IMI_. ]cj ia`atgry mjlasahkignakd

 prhljss as gk atjrgtavj p`gkkakd ijtchmh`hdy tcgt aktjdrgtjs tcj gltavatajs hb tcj lhiigkmjr, stgbb, suehrmakgtj

cjgmqugrtjrs, gkm htcjr pgrtkjrs th ukmjrstgkm tcj satugtahk gkm iassahk> mjvj`hp gkm lhipgrj lhursjs hb

gltahk> mjlamj hk g lhursj hb gltahk tcgt ejst gllhip`ascjs tcj iassahk> gkm prhmulj gk hpjrgtahk p`gk hrhrmjr bhr jxjlutahk (BI :-?).

7-72.  Murakd tcj sjlhkm stjp hb tcj hb tcj IMI_, iassahk gkg`ysas, lhiigkmjrs gkm stgbbs gkg`yzj tcj

rj`gtahkscaps gihkd tcj iassahk vgrage`js ” iassahk, jkjiy, tjrrgak gkm wjgtcjr, trhhps gkm supphrt gvga`ge`j,

taij gvga`ge`j, lava` lhksamjrgtahks (IJ]]-]L) ” sjjnakd th dgak g drjgtjr ukmjrstgkmakd hb tcj ”  

  Hpjrgtahkg` jkvarhkijkt, akl`umakd jkjiajs gkm lava` lhksamjrgtahks.

  Mjsarjm jkm stgtj hb tcj cadcjr cjgmqugrtjrs.

  Iassahk gkm chw at as kjstjm watc tchsj hb tcj cadcjr cjgmqugrtjrs.

  Bhrljs gkm rjshurljs gvga`ge`j th gllhip`asc tcj iassahk gkm gsshlagtjm tgsns.

7-74.  Tatcak tcj IMI_, H\AK] gssasts ak jkge`akd tcj p`gkkakd stgbb th upmgtj jstaigtjs gkm akatag`

gssjssijkts ey usakd pue`al`y gvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk gkm hpjk shurljs. Igfhr aktj``adjklj lhktraeutahks th

iassahk gkg`ysas hllur ejlgusj hb A_E. (Bhr ihrj akbhrigtahk hk tcj IMI_, sjj BI :-?.)

Khtj. Khkaktj``adjklj stgbb lgk g`sh rjsjgrlc pue`al`y gvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk th prjpgrj bukltahkg`

grjg-spjlabal jstaigtjs, pgpjrs, erajbakds, p`gks, gkm hrmjrs ak supphrt hb tcj IMI_.

Page 13: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 13/91

Hpjk-\hurlj Aktj``adjklj (H\AK]) Bukmgijktg`s

7? Fu`y 5?75  G]_ 5-55.1 7-:

AK]J@@ADJKLJ _UJ_GUG]AHK HB ]CJ EG]]@JBAJ@M

7-73.  Aktj `adjklj prjpgrgtahk hb tcj egtt jbaj m   as g systjigtal prhljss hb gkg`yzakd gkm vasug`azakd tcj

 phrtahks hb tcj iassahk vgrage`js hb tcrjgt, tjrrgak, wjgtcjr, gkm lava` lhksamjrgtahks ak g spjlabal grjg hb

aktjrjst gkm bhr g spjlabal iassahk. Ey gpp`yakd aktj``adjklj prjpgrgtahk hb tcj egtt`jbaj`m, lhiigkmjrs dgak

tcj akbhrigtahk kjljssgry th sj`jltavj`y gpp`y gkm igxaiazj hpjrgtahkg` jbbjltavjkjss gt lratalg` phakts ak

taij gkm spglj (BI 5-?7.<).

7-71.  A_E wgs hradakg``y mjsadkjm th supphrt tcj IMI_ gkm trhhp `jgmakd prhljmurjs, eut at lgk g`sh ej

aklhrphrgtjm akth htcjr prhe`ji-sh`vakd ihmj`s `anj mjsadk gkm rjm tjgiakd. H\AK] p`gys g sadkabalgkt gkm

aktjdrg` pgrt murakd A_E ak sgtasbyakd aktj``adjklj gkm akbhrigtahk rjquarjijkts akmalgtjm murakd tcj

IMI_ ak supphrt hb ukabajm `gkm hpjrgtahks. ]cj akmalgthrs tcgt lgk ej sgtasbajm usakd H\AK] murakd A_E

akl`umj eut grj kht `aiatjm th ”  

  _hpu`gtahk.

  _rhpgdgkmg.

  Lhiihmatajs.

  Jkvarhkijkt.

7-5?.  A_E as usjm praigra`y ey lhiigkmjrs gkm stgbbs gs g duamj th jvg`ugtj spjlabal mgtgsjts ak hrmjr th

dgak gk ukmjrstgkmakd hb g mjbakjm hpjrgtahkg` jkvarhkijkt. _rahr th hpjrgtahks, gk jxgiakgtahk hb

kgtahkg`, iu`takgtahk pgrtkjr, fhakt, gkm cadcjr jlcj`hk mgtgegsjs as rjquarjm th mjtjriakj ab tcj akbhrigtahkrjqujstjm as g`rjgmy gvga`ge`j. Gs hpjrgtahks lhiijklj, kjw aktj``adjklj gkm akbhrigtahk rjquarjijkts grj

burtcjr amjktabajm gs g rjsu`t hb egtt`jbaj`m lcgkdjs. _ue`al`y gvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk gkm hpjk shurljs, wcjk

 prhmuljm gkm prhpjr`y aktjdrgtjm ak supphrt hb tcj g``-shurlj aktj``adjklj jbbhrt, lgk ej usjm th sgtasby

aktj``adjklj gkm akbhrigtahk rjquarjijkts. (Bhr ihrj akbhrigtahk hk A_E gkm akmalgthrs, sjj BI 5-?7.<.)

Page 14: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 14/91

Page 15: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 15/91

 

7? Fu`y 5?75  G]_ 5-55.1 5-7

Lcgptjr 5

_`gkkakd gkm _rjpgrgtahk hb tcj H\AK] Iassahk

Marjlt`y hr akmarjlt`y, pue`al`y gvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk gkm hpjk shurljs bhri tcjbhukmgtahk bhr g`` aktj``adjklj wcjk lhkmultakd hpjrgtahks. ]cas bhukmgtahk lhijs brhihpjk-shurlj ijmag lhiphkjkts tcgt prhvamj whr`mvajw gwgrjkjss hb aktjrkgtahkg` jvjkts

gkm pjrljptahks hb khk-Z.\. shlajtajs. ]cas gwgrjkjss prhipts lhiigkmjrs th vasug`azjg p`gk. _`gkkakd hllurs wcjk aktj``adjklj gkm akbhrigtahk rjquarjijkts grj amjktabajm

gkm ijgks grj mjvj`hpjm gs th chw tcjy wa`` ej sgtasbajm. Jbbjltavj H\AK] iassahk p`gkkakd gkm prjpgrgtahk grj lhkmultjm murakd tcj Griy bhrlj djkjrgtahk (GUBHUDJK)trgak/rjgmy bhrlj phh` th jkge`j tcj jgsj hb trgksatahk th lhiegt hpjrgtahks. (\jj BI 4-?bhr ihrj akbhrigtahk hk GUBHUDJK.)

\JL]AHK A “ _@GKKAKD H\AK] GL]ARA]AJ\

5-7.  ]cj  p`gk stjp hb tcj aktj``adjklj prhljss lhksasts hb tcj gltavatajs tcgt amjktaby pjrtakjkt akbhrigtahk

rjquarjijkts gkm mjvj`hp tcj ijgks bhr sgtasbyakd tchsj rjquarjijkts gkm ijjtakd tcj lhiigkmjr‑s mjsarjm jkm

stgtj. Gs gk gspjlt hb aktj``adjklj rjgmakjss, p`gkkakd bhr H\AK] jxp`hatgtahk ejdaks ejbhrj g ukat rjljavjs gk

hbbalag` hrmjr hr tgsnakd gs pgrt hb tcj  djkjrgtj aktj``adjklj nkhw`jmdj lhktakuakd gltavaty hb tcj aktj``adjklj

 prhljss.

5-5.  ]cj bhlus hb H\AK] rjsjgrlc prahr th mjp`hyijkt as mjtjriakjm gkm marjltjm ey tcj lhiigkmjr‑s

duamgklj. \ustgakjm gkm prhgltavj hpjk-shurlj rjsjgrlc usakd egsal gkm gmvgkljm Aktjrkjt sjgrlc

tjlckaqujs p`gys g lratalg` rh`j ak ukmjrstgkmakd GHs tcrhudc bhukmgtahkg` nkhw`jmdj rjquarjm bhr ukat

rjgmakjss gkm jbbjltavj p`gkkakd. Ujsjgrlc murakd p`gkkakd bhr phssae`j iassahks prhvamjs aksadct akth chwkhktrgmatahkg` ia`atgry bhrljs, bhrjadk ia`atgry bhrljs, gkm trgkskgtahkg` tcrjgts cgvj hpjrgtjm ak saia`gr

GHs. _rahr th mjp`hyijkt, hrdgkazgtahks watc mjmalgtjm H\AK] iassahks lgk g`sh ej rjshurljm th sgtasby

aktj``adjklj gkm akbhrigtahk rjquarjijkts. (\jj gppjkmax J.)

5-<.  Gbtjr g ukat rjljavjs g iassahk, tcj bhlus hb H\AK] rjsjgrlc as burtcjr rjbakjm egsjm hk tcj GH ak wcalc

tcj ukat hpjrgtjs. H\AK] supphrts tcj lhktakuhus gssjssijkt hb ukabajm `gkm hpjrgtahks murakd p`gkkakd.

Jbbjltavj rjsjgrlc gkm p`gkkakd jksurj lhiigkmjrs rjljavj taij`y, rj`jvgkt, gkm gllurgtj aktj``adjklj gkm

akbhrigtahk th gllhip`asc gssadkjm iassahks gkm tgsns. ]cj IMI_ gkm A_E mravjk ey tcj aktj``adjklj prhljss

brgij tcj p`gkkakd hb H\AK] jxp`hatgtahk. H\AK] as aktjdrgtjm akth p`gkkakd tcrhudc tcj bhur stjps hb tcj A_E

 prhljss6

  Mjbakj tcj hpjrgtahkg` jkvarhkijkt.

  Mjslraej jkvarhkijktg` jbbjlts hk hpjrgtahks.

  Jvg`ugtj tcj tcrjgt.  Mjtjriakj tcrjgt LHGs.

MJBAKJ ]CJ H_JUG]AHKG@ JKRAUHKIJK]

5-=.  Tcjk gssjssakd tcj lhkmatahks, larluistgkljs, gkm akb`ujkljs ak tcj GH gkm grjg hb aktjrjst, tcj

aktj``adjklj stgbb jxgiakjs g`` lcgrgltjrastals hb tcj hpjrgtahkg` jkvarhkijkt. ]cjrj grj prjjxastakd pue`al`y

gvga`ge`j akputs tcgt lgk ej usjm th amjktaby sadkabalgkt vgrage`js wcjk gkg`yzakd tcj tjrrgak, wjgtcjr, tcrjgt, gkm

Page 16: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 16/91

Lcgptjr 5

5-5 G]_ 5-55.1 7? Fu`y 5?75 

lava` lhksamjrgtahks. Gt tcj jkm hb stjp hkj hb tcj A_E prhljss, pue`al`y gvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk gkm hpjk shurljs

lgk ej usjm th supphrt tcj mjvj`hpijkt hb tcj GH gssjssijkt gkm grjg hb aktjrjst gssjssijkt.

MJ\LUAEJ JKRAUHKIJK]G@ JBBJL]\ HK H_JUG]AHK\

5-:.  Tcjk gkg`yzakd tcj jkvarhkijktg` jbbjlts hk tcrjgt gkm brajkm`y hpjrgtahks, pue`al`y gvga`ge`j

akbhrigtahk gkm hpjk shurljs lgk ej usjm th mjslraej tcj ”  

  _cysalg` jkvarhkijkt (tjrrjstrag`, gar, igrataij, spglj, gkm akbhrigtahk mhigaks).

  Tjgtcjr.

  Lava` lhksamjrgtahks.

  ]crjgt.

5-2.  Lhieakj tcj jvg`ugtahk hb tcj jbbjlts hb tjrrgak, wjgtcjr, gkm lava` lhksamjrgtahks akth g prhmult tcgt

 ejst suats tcj lhiigkmjr‑s rjquarjijkts. Gt tcj jkm hb tcj sjlhkm stjp hb A_E, pue`al`y gvga`ge`j

akbhrigtahk gkm hpjk shurljs lgk ej usjm th ejttjr akbhri tcj lhiigkmjr hb phssae`j tcrjgt LHGs gkm

 prhmults gkm gssjssijkts th supphrt tcj rjigakmjr hb tcj A_E prhljss.

JRG@ZG]J ]CJ ]CUJG]

5-4.  \tjp tcrjj hb tcj A_E prhljss as th jvg`ugtj jglc hb tcj sadkabalgkt tcrjgts ak tcj GH. Ab tcj stgbb bga`s

th mjtjriakj g`` tcj tcrjgt bgltahks akvh`vjm hr tcjar lgpgea`atajs hr jquapijkt, hr th ukmjrstgkm tcjar

mhltrakj gkm tgltals, tjlckaqujs, gkm prhljmurjs (]]_), gs wj`` gs tcjar casthry, tcj stgbb wa`` `gln tcj

aktj``adjklj kjjmjm bhr p`gkkakd. Gt tcj jkm hb stjp tcrjj hb A_E, pue`al`y gvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk gkm hpjk

shurljs lgk prhvamj tcj igfhraty hb tcj akbhrigtahk rjquarjm th amjktaby tcrjgt lcgrgltjrastals, gs wj`` gs

 prhvamj phssae`j akbhrigtahk kjjmjm th upmgtj tcrjgt ihmj`s.

MJ]JUIAKJ ]CUJG] LHZU\J\ HB GL]AHK

5-3.  \tjp bhur hb tcj A_E prhljss as th amjktaby, mjvj`hp, gkm mjtjriakj `anj`y tcrjgt LHGs tcgt lgk

akb`ujklj gllhip`ascijkt hb tcj brajkm`y iassahk. ]cj jkm stgtj hb stjp bhur as th rjp`algtj tcj sjt hb LHGs

gvga`ge`j th tcj tcrjgt lhiigkmjr gkm th amjktaby tchsj grjgs gkm gltavatajs tcgt, wcjk hesjrvjm, masljrk

wcalc LHG tcj tcrjgt lhiigkmjr cgs lchsjk. Gt tcj jkm hb stjp bhur hb A_E, pue`al`y gvga`ge`j

akbhrigtahk gkm hpjk shurljs lgk ej usjm th mjtjriakj akmalgthrs gmhptjm ey tcj tcrjgt lhiigkmjr.

\JL]AHK AA “ _UJ_GUG]AHK HB H\AK] GL]ARA]AJ\

5-1.  ]cj rj`agklj hk l`gssabajm mgtgegsjs cgs hbtjk `jbt \h`majrs ukakbhrijm gkm a``-prjpgrjm th lgpatg`azj

hk tcj cudj rjsjrvhar hb ukl`gssabajm akbhrigtahk brhi pue`al`y gvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk gkm hpjk shurljs, gs

tcj bh``hwakd quhtj mjslraejs6

H\AK] wgs bgar`y kjw th us gkm hklj tcj tjri wgs ukmjrsthhm wj p`gljm g sadkg`s

aktj``adjklj gkg`yst ak lcgrdj hb H\AK]. Gt tcj tgltalg` `jvj`, at sjjijm th ej jbbjltavj

gbtjr tcj bglt. ]cjrj wjrj tcrjj sulljssbu` gttglns gdgakst lhg`atahk bhrljs garlrgbt ak g

 spjlabal grjg. Tj lhu`mk‑t badurj hut tcj ‐chw’ gkm :Ts ^ wch, wcgt, wcjk, wcjrj, wcyY

eut hur H\AK] gkg`yst bhukm g mhwkjm garlrgbt vamjh hk tcj Aktjrkjt tcgt cj`pjm us

amjktaby tcj akdrjss gkm jdrjss rhutjs usjm murakd tcj gttgln tcgt `jm th g ‐kh b`y’ grjg

gkm sulljssbu` grjg mjkag` iassahks ak hur grjg hb hpjrgtahk.

 G``-\hurlj Aktj``adjklj Gkg`yst, Lhiegt Gvagtahk EradgmjHpjrgtahk Argqa Brjjmhi 5??3-5??1,

Page 17: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 17/91

_`gkkakd gkm _rjpgrgtahk hb tcj H\AK] Iassahk

7? Fu`y 5?75  G]_ 5-55.1 5-<

H\AK] JS_@HA]G]AHK

5-7?.  Tcjk prjpgrakd th lhkmult H\AK] jxp`hatgtahk, tcj grjgs praigra`y bhlusjm hk grj ”  

  _ue`al spjgnakd bhruis.

  _ue`al mhluijkts.

  _ue`al erhgmlgsts.

  Aktjrkjt Tje satjs.

_ZE@AL \_JGNAKD BHUZI\ 

5-77.  Glquarakd akbhrigtahk gt pue`al spjgnakd bhruis rjquarjs l`hsj lhhrmakgtahk th jksurj tcgt gky hvjrt

glquasatahk as aktjdrgtjm gkm syklcrhkazjm watc tcj akbhrigtahk lh``jltahk p`gk gkm mhjs kht vah`gtj `gws

 prhcaeatakd tcj ukgutchrazjm lh``jltakd hb akbhrigtahk bhr aktj``adjklj purphsjs. (\jj gppjkmax G bhr

burtcjr akbhrigtahk hk Z.\. pjrshks.)

5-75.  Ejbhrj dgtcjrakd H\AK] akbhrigtahk gt pue`al spjgnakd bhruis ”  

  Lhhrmakgtj watc njy stgbb sjltahks, sulc gs tcj D-5S/\-5S, D-4/\-4, D-1/\-1, pue`al gbbgars

hbbaljr (_GH), gkm stgbb fumdj gmvhlgtj (\FG), prahr th lhkmultakd survja``gklj.

  Amjktaby gmmatahkg` bhrlj prhtjltahk pjrshkkj` gkm jquapijkt rjquarjijkts.

  Amjktaby tcj prhljmurj bhr jip`gljijkt gkm rjlhvjry hb gumah gkm vamjh prhljssakd jquapijkt.5-7<.  ]cj hpjrgtahk hrmjr (H_HUM), ]]_, hr ukat stgkmgrm hpjrgtakd prhljmurjs (\H_s) schu`m mjslraej

chw tcj ukat tcgt as tgsnjm watc tcj pue`al spjgnakd bhrui iassahk rjqujsts, g``hlgtjs, gkm igkgdjs bukms

th purlcgsj madatg` lgijrg gkm gumah rjlhrmakd jquapijkt g`hkd watc tcj lhiputjr cgrmwgrj gkm shbtwgrj

th p`gy gkm sthrj vamjh-rj`gtjm mgtg.

_ZE@AL MHLZIJK]\ 

5-7=.  Hrdgkazgtahks watcak gk GH lhkmult mhluijkt lh``jltahk iassahks. Hklj lh``jltjm, mhluijkts grj

gkg`yzjm gkm tcj akbhrigtahk as massjiakgtjm tcrhudchut tcj aktj``adjklj lhiiukaty. Ejbhrj jxjlutakd gky

H\AK] jxp`hatgtahk rj`gtjm th lh``jltakd pue`al mhluijkts, at as aiphrtgkt th ”  

  Lhhrmakgtj mhluijkt lh``jltahk, prhljssakd, gkm gkg`ysas gltavatajs glrhss jlcj`hks.

  Amjktaby tcj prhljmurj th mjp`hy, igaktgak, rjlhvjr, gkm trgksbjr cgrmlhpy, gkg`hd, gkm madatg`

ijmag prhljssakd gkm lhiiukalgtahks jquapijkt.  Amjktaby glgmjial gkm lhiijrlag`-hbb-tcj-scj`b (LH]\) akbhrigtahk sjrvaljs tcgt grj g`rjgmy

gvga`ge`j bhr hpjk-shurlj glquasatahk, prhljssakd, gkm prhmultahk.

5-7:.  ]cj H_HUM, ]]_, hr ukat \H_s schu`m mjslraej chw tcj ukat rjqujsts, g``hlgtjs, gkm igkgdjs bukms

bhr  ”  

  Mhluijkt lh``jltahk gkm prhljssakd sjrvaljs.

  _urlcgsakd ehhns, maltahkgrajs, aigdjs, igps, kjwspgpjrs, pjrahmalg`s, rjlhrmjm gumah gkm vamjh

atjis, lhiputjr cgrmwgrj, madatg` lgijrgs, gkm slgkkakd jquapijkt.

  ]cj lhst hb sueslraeakd th kjwspgpjrs, pjrahmalg`s, gkm htcjr rjgmge`j igtjrag`s.

5-72.  Bhr ihrj mjtga`jm akbhrigtahk hk pue`al mhluijkts gkm mhluijkt jxp`hatgtahk, sjj ]L 5-17.3.

_ZE@AL EUHGMLG\]\ 5-74.  ]cj MKA H\L lh``jlts, prhljssjs, gkm rjphrts aktjrkgtahkg` gkm rjdahkg` erhgmlgsts. ]cas jkge`js

mjp`hyjm hrdgkazgtahks th lh``jlt gkm prhljss akbhrigtahk brhi `hlg` erhgmlgsts tcgt grj hb lhiigkm

aktjrjst. Ejbhrj jxp`hatakd H\AK] rj`gtjm th pue`al erhgmlgsts, at as aiphrtgkt th ”  

  Lhhrmakgtj erhgmlgst lh``jltahk, prhljssakd, gkm prhmultahk gltavatajs watc tchsj hb tcj H\L.

  Amjktaby tcj prhljmurj th mjp`hy, igaktgak, rjlhvjr, gkm trgksbjr rgmah gkm tj`jvasahk madatg`

ijmag sthrgdj mjvaljs gkm lhktjkt prhljssakd gkm lhiiukalgtahks systjis.

Page 18: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 18/91

Lcgptjr 5

5-= G]_ 5-55.1 7? Fu`y 5?75 

  Amjktaby Aktjrkjt lh``jltahk gkm prhljssakd rjshurljs th lh``jlt hk tj`jvasahk hr rgmah stgtahk-

spjlabal Tje lgsts.

5-73.  ]cj H_HUM, ukat \H_s, hr ]]_ schu`m mjslraej chw tcj ukat tgsnjm watc pue`al erhgmlgst iassahks

rjqujsts, g``hlgtjs, gkm igkgdjs bukms th purlcgsj gktjkkg gkm lhiputjr jquapijkt, iglcakj trgks`gtahk

sjrvaljs hr shbtwgrj, gkm sueslraejs th rjdahkg` gkm aktjrkgtahkg` sgtj``atj rgmah gkm tj`jvasahk erhgmlgst

sjrvalj prhvamjrs.

AK]JUKJ] TJE \A]J\ 

5-71.  Akbhrigtahk lh``jltjm, prhljssjm, gkm prhmuljm brhi Aktjrkjt Tje satjs supphrts ukabajm `gkm

hpjrgtahks. Ejbhrj jxp`hatakd H\AK] rj`gtjm th Aktjrkjt Tje satjs ”  

  Lhhrmakgtj Aktjrkjt lh``jltahk, prhljssakd, gkm gkg`ysas gltavatajs glrhss jlcj`hks.

  Amjktaby tcj prhljmurj th mjp`hy, igaktgak, rjlhvjr, gkm trgksbjr lhiputjrs gkm gsshlagtjm

lhiiukalgtahks gkm mgtg sthrgdj systjis.

  Lhhrmakgtj watc D-2/\-2 bhr glljss th tcj AK]J@AKN-Z kjtwhrn hr gpprhvjm lhiijrlag`

Aktjrkjt sjrvalj prhvamjrs tcgt supphrt hpjk-shurlj glquasatahk, prhljssakd, sthrgdj, gkm

massjiakgtahk rjquarjijkts.

  Lhhrmakgtj watc D-2/\-2 th mjvj`hp g `ast hb gutchrazjm Z.\. gkm khk-Z.\. Aktjrkjt Tje satjs bhr

hbbalag` dhvjrkijkt usj, hpjk-shurlj rjsjgrlc, gkm khk-Z.\. Aktjrkjt Tje satjs rjstraltjm th

sj`jltjm gutchrazjm pjrshkkj` jkdgdjm ak H\AK] jxp`hatgtahk.

  Amjktaby glgmjial gkm LH]\ akbhrigtahk sjrvaljs tcgt grj g`rjgmy gvga`ge`j bhr hpjk-shurlj

akbhrigtahk glquasatahk, prhljssakd, gkm prhmultahk.

5-5?.  ]cj H_HUM, ukat \H_s, hr ]]_ schu`m mjslraej chw tcj ukat tgsnjm watc Aktjrkjt rjsjgrlc iassahks

rjqujsts, g``hlgtjs, gkm igkgdjs bukms th purlcgsj madatazjm mhluijkts, djhspgtag` akbhrigtahk, lhiputjr

cgrmwgrj gkm shbtwgrj gpp`algtahks, gs wj`` gky sueslraptahks th glgmjial gkm lhiijrlag` hk`akj

mgtgegsjs, kjwspgpjrs, pjrahmalg`s, gkm rjbjrjkljs.

_UJ_GUG]AHK LHK\AMJUG]AHK\

5-57.  _rjpgrakd bhr H\AK] jxp`hatgtahk g`sh akl`umjs ”  

  Jstge`ascakd gk H\AK] grlcatjlturj.

  _rahratazakd tgsns gkm rjqujsts.  ]gsn-hrdgkazakd gssjts.

  Mjp`hyakd gssjts.

  Gssjssakd lhip`jtjm hpjrgtahks.

J\]GE@A\CAKD GK H\AK] GULCA]JL]ZUJ 

5-55.  H\AK] lhktraeutjs th jstge`ascakd gk aktj``adjklj grlcatjlturj, spjlabalg``y GU] 5.5.5,  Jstge`asc

 Aktj``adjklj Grlcatjlturj. Jstge`ascakd gk aktj``adjklj grlcatjlturj lhiprasjs lhip`jx gkm tjlckalg` assujs

tcgt akl`umj sjkshrs, mgtg b`hw, cgrmwgrj, shbtwgrj, lhiiukalgtahks, lhiiukalgtahks sjluraty igtjrag`s,

kjtwhrn l`gssabalgtahk, tjlckalagks, mgtgegsj glljss, `agashk hbbaljrs, trgakakd, gkm bukmakd. G wj``-mjbakjm

gkm -mjsadkjm aktj``adjklj grlcatjlturj lgk hbbsjt hr iatadgtj strulturg`, hrdgkazgtahkg`, hr pjrshkkj`

`aiatgtahks. ]cas grlcatjlturj prhvamjs tcj ejst phssae`j ukmjrstgkmakd hb tcj tcrjgt, tjrrgak gkm wjgtcjr,

gkm lava` lhksamjrgtahks. Gk jstge`ascjm H\AK] grlcatjlturj aklhrphrgtjs mgtg b`hw, cgrmwgrj, shbtwgrj,lhiiukalgtahks sjluraty lhiphkjkts, gkm mgtgegsjs tcgt akl`umj ”  

  Lhkmultakd aktj``adjklj rjglc. Aktj` adjklj rjglc  as g prhljss ey wcalc aktj``adjklj hrdgkazgtahks

 prhgltavj`y gkm rgpam`y glljss akbhrigtahk brhi, rjljavj supphrt brhi, gkm lhkmult marjlt

lh``gehrgtahk gkm akbhrigtahk scgrakd watc htcjr ukats gkm gdjklajs, ehtc watcak gkm hutsamj tcj grjg

hb hpjrgtahks, uklhkstrgakjm ey djhdrgpcal prhxaiaty, jlcj`hk, hr lhiigkm (BI 5-?).

  Mjvj`hpakd gkm igaktgakakd guthigtjm aktj``adjklj kjtwhrns. ]cas tgsn jktga`s prhvamakd

akbhrigtahk systjis tcgt lhkkjlt gssjts, ukats, jlcj`hks, gdjklajs, gkm iu`takgtahkg` pgrtkjrs bhr

Page 19: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 19/91

_`gkkakd gkm _rjpgrgtahk hb tcj H\AK] Iassahk

7? Fu`y 5?75  G]_ 5-55.1 5-:

aktj``adjklj, lh``gehrgtavj gkg`ysas gkm prhmultahk, massjiakgtahk, gkm aktj``adjklj rjglc. At usjs

jxastakd guthigtjm akbhrigtahk systjis, gkm, wcjk kjljssgry, lrjgtjs hpjrgtahkg``y spjlabal

kjtwhrns.

  Jstge`ascakd gkm igaktgakakd glljss. ]cas tgsn jktga`s jstge`ascakd, prhvamakd, gkm igaktgakakd

glljss th l`gssabajm gkm ukl`gssabajm prhdrgis, mgtgegsjs, kjtwhrns, systjis, gkm htcjr Tje-egsjm

lh``gehrgtavj jkvarhkijkts bhr Griy bhrljs, fhakt bhrljs, kgtahkg` gdjklajs, gkm iu`takgtahkg`

hrdgkazgtahks.  Lrjgtakd gkm igaktgakakd mgtgegsjs. ]cas tgsn jktga`s lrjgtakd gkm igaktgakakd ukl`gssabajm gkm

l`gssabajm mgtgegsjs. Ats purphsj as th jstge`asc aktjrhpjrge`j gkm lh``gehrgtavj jkvarhkijkts bhr Griy

bhrljs, fhakt bhrljs, kgtahkg` gdjklajs, gkm iu`takgtahkg` hrdgkazgtahks. ]cas tgsn bgla`atgtjs

aktj``adjklj gkg`ysas, rjphrtakd, prhmultahk, massjiakgtahk, sustgakijkt, gkm aktj``adjklj rjglc.

Hpjrgtahkg` gkm ]jlckalg` Hpjk-\hurlj Mgtgegsjs

5-5<.  H\AK] jxp`hatgtahk rjquarjs glljss th mgtgegsjs gkm Aktjrkjt lgpgea`atajs th bgla`atgtj prhljssakd,

sthrgdj, rjtrajvg`, gkm jxlcgkdj hb pue`al`y gvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk. ]cjsj mgtgegsjs grj rjsamjkt hk `hlg`

grjg kjtwhrns (@GKs), tcj Thr`m Tamj Tje (TTT), gkm tcj Mjjp Tje (sjj gppjkmax L bhr gmmatahkg`

akbhrigtahk). ]h supphrt ukabajm `gkm hpjrgtahks, H\AK] pjrshkkj` usj jvg`ugtjm gkm gkg`yzjm pue`al`y

gvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk gkm hpjk shurljs th phpu`gtj akbhrigtahk mgtgegsjs sulc gs ”  

  Hpjrgtahkg` akbhrigtahk mgtgegsjs, wcalc  supphrt tcj lhrrj`gtahk hb hrmjrs, rjqujsts,

lh``jltahk stgtusjs, prhljssakd rjshurljs, gkm drgpcals.

  ]jlckalg` akbhrigtahk mgtgegsjs, wcalc supphrt lh``jltahk hpjrgtahks gkm lhksast hb

ukprhljssjm tjxt, gumah ba`js, vamjh ba`js, trgks`gtahks, gkm trgkslrapts.

Hpjk-\hurlj Lh``jltahk Glquasatahk Ujquarjijkt “ Igkgdjijkt \ystji

5-5=.  ]cj praigry hpjk-shurlj rjquarjijkts igkgdjijkt hpjrgtahkg` akbhrigtahk gkm tjlckalg`

akbhrigtahk mgtgegsj as tcj Hpjk-shurlj Lh``jltahk Glquasatahk Ujquarjijkt-Igkgdjijkt \ystji

(H\LGU-I\). H\LGU-I\ as g Tje-egsjm sjrvalj sphkshrjm ey tcj Hbbalj hb tcj Gssastgkt Mjputy

Marjlthr hb Kgtahkg` Aktj``adjklj bhr Hpjk \hurlj (GMMKA/H\) th prhvamj tcj Kgtahkg` Hpjk \hurlj

Jktjrprasj (KH\J) watc gk gpp`algtahk bhr igkgdakd hpjk-shurlj lh``jltahk rjquarjijkts. H\LGU-I\

`akns H\AK] prhvamjrs gkm lhksuijrs watcak tcj aktj``adjklj lhiiukaty mhwk th tcj eradgmj lhiegt tjgi

(EL]) `jvj`. _jrshkkj` gt tcj EL] `jvj` glljss H\LGU-I\ vag tcj \JLUJ] Aktjrkjt _rhthlh` Uhutjr

 Kjtwhrn (\A_UKJ]) ak hrmjr th sueiat rjqujsts bhr akbhrigtahk th tcj Mjpgrtijkt hb tcj GriyAktj``adjklj Akbhrigtahk \jrvaljs (MG AA\) rjqujst bhr akbhrigtahk phrtg`. ]cj dhg` hb tcj H\LGU-I\ as

th guthigtj gkm strjgi`akj gm chl hpjk-shurlj lh``jltahk rjquarjijkts ey ”  

  _rhvamakd usjbu` ijtrals th ukmjrstgkm H\AK] rjquarjijkts.

  G``hwakd tcj madatg` akmjxakd gkm tgddakd hb sueiattjm gkm lhip`jtjm hpjk-shurlj prhmults th ej

sjgrlcge j ak tcj @aergry hb Kgtahkg` Aktj``adjklj.

  _rhvamakd bhr `hlg` lhktrh` hb gmiakastrgtavj mgtg sulc gs ukat gllhukt igkgdjijkt, `hlg` mgtg tge`js,

gkm hlg` bhrigts.

  G``hwakd saip`j gkm b`jxae`j bhrigts tcgt jip`hy mgtgegsj guth-phpu`gtahk.

  Zsakd lhip`jtj Jkd`asc akstjgm hb glrhkyis, lhiputjr lhmjs, gkm htcjr khkaktuatavj schrtluts.

  G``hwakd akngdjs ejtwjjk rjquarjijkts, prhmults, gkm jvg`ugtahks.

  Jkge`akd aktjdrgtahk hb hpjk-shurlj usjrs bhr lh``gehrgtahk ejtwjjk gdjklajs.

  Ujmulakd rjquarjijkt mup`algtahk tcrhudc lusthijrs marjlt`y lhktraeutakd th jxastakd rjquarjijkts.

5-5:.  Bhr ihrj mjtga`jm akbhrigtahk hk H\LGU-I\ hr th sueiat H\AK] rjquarjijkts, lhktglt tcj Z.\. Griy

Aktj``adjklj gkm \jluraty Lhiigkm (AK\LHI) MG AA\ gt cttps6//www.aktj`akn.dhv/scgrjphakt/mjbgu`t.gspx.

Page 20: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 20/91

Lcgptjr 5

5-2 G]_ 5-55.1 7? Fu`y 5?75 

_UAHUA]AVAKD ]G\N\ GKM U JWZJ\]\ 

5-52.  ]cj D-5/\-5 gkm D-</\-< stgbbs usj lhiigkmjr duamgklj gkm praigry aktj``adjklj rjquarjijkts th

lhip`jtj tcj akbhrigtahk lh``jltahk p`gk. ]cj p`gk as usjm th gssadk tgsns th suehrmakgtj ukats hr sueiat rjqujsts

th supphrtakd aktj``adjklj hrdgkazgtahks th glcajvj tcj mjsarjm akbhrigtahk lh``jltahk hefjltavjs. Jiehmajm ak tcj

akbhrigtahk lh``jltahk p`gk, tcjsj tgsns mjslraej chw tcj ukat ““  

  Ujqujsts lh``jltahk gkm prhmultahk supphrt brhi fhakt, aktjrgdjkly, aktjrdhvjrkijktg`, gkm

iu`takgtahkg` hrdgkazgtahks.

  ]gsn-hrdgkazjs gkm mjp`hys hrdgkal, gttglcjm, gkm lhktrgltjm lh``jltahk, prhljssakd, gkm prhmultahk

gssjts.

  Lhkmults rjihtj, sp`at-egsjm, hr mastraeutjm lh``jltahk, prhljssakd, gkm prhmultahk.

  Ujqujsts gkm igkgdjs Z.\. gkm khk-Z.\. `akduasts egsjm hk prahraty bhr supphrt, iassahk-spjlabal

sna``s, nkhw`jmdj rjquarjijkts (sulc gs `gkdugdj, mag`jlt, gkm sna`` `jvj`), l`jgrgklj `jvj`, gkm

lgtjdhry.

5-54.  Tcjk mjvj`hpakd akbhrigtahk lh``jltahk tgsns bhr suehrmakgtj ukats, tcj D-5/\-5 gkm D-</\-< stgbbs

usj tcj tgsn gkm purphsj lhkstrult bhr mjvj`hpakd tgsn stgtjijkts th gllhukt bhr  ”  

  Tch as th jxjlutj tcj tgsn8

  Tcgt  as tcj tgsn8

  Tcjk wa`` tcj tgsn ejdak8  Tcjrj wa`` tcj tgsn hllur8

]G\N -HUDGKAVAKD G\\J]\

5-53.  Tatc tcj jxljptahk hb tcj Gsagk \tumajs Mjtglcijkt (G\M) tcgt igaktgaks gk hrdgkal tge`j hb

mastraeutahk gkm g``hwgkljs (]MG) watc tcj dhvjrkijkt hb Fgpgk ak supphrt hb Z.\. _glabal Lhiigkm

(Z\_GLHI), tcj Griy mhjs kht cgvj g ]MG hr egsj tge`j hb hrdgkazgtahk gkm jquapijkt bhr H\AK]

 pjrshkkj` hr ukats wcjk prjpgrakd th lhkmult H\AK] jxp`hatgtahk.

MJ_@HQAKD G\\J]\ 

5-51.  Mjp`hyijkt hb pue`al`y gvga`ge`j gssjts ”  

  \upphrts tcj slcjij hb igkjuvjr.

  \upphrts tcj lhiigkmjr‑s aktjkt. 

  Lhip`ajs watc ukat \H_s.

5-<?.  ]cj mjp`hyijkt hb gssjts djkjrg``y rjquarjs g sjlurj phsatahk, watc kjtwhrn lhkkjltavaty th tcj

Aktjrkjt, ak prhxaiaty th supphrtakd sustgakijkt, prhtjltahk, gkm lhiiukalgtahks rjshurljs.

G\\J\\AKD LHI_@J]JM H_JUG]AHK\

5-<7.  ]ypalg` duamj`akjs usjm th gssjss hpjrgtahks grj ”  

  Ihkathrakd hpjrgtahks.

  Lhrrj`gtakd gkm slrjjkakd rjphrts.

  Massjiakgtakd gkm prhvamakd g bjjmegln ijlcgkasi.

  Lujakd.

5-<5.  \jj pgrgdrgpc 5-24 bhr gk jxp`gkgtahk hb tcjsj duamj`akjs.

Page 21: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 21/91

_`gkkakd gkm _rjpgrgtahk hb tcj H\AK] Iassahk

7? Fu`y 5?75  G]_ 5-55.1 5-4

\JL]AHK AAA “ _@GKKAKD GKM _UJ_GUG]AHK LHK\AMJUG]AHK\

5-<<.  _`gkkakd gkm prjpgrgtahk lhksamjrgtahks wcjk p`gkkakd bhr H\AK] jxp`hatgtahk akl`umj ”  

  Hpjk-shurlj rj`agea`aty.

  Hpjk-shurlj akbhrigtahk lhktjkt lrjmaea`aty.

  Lhip`agklj.

  Hpjrgtahks sjluraty (H_\JL).

  L`gssabalgtahk.

  Lhhrmakgtahk.

  Mjljptahk gkm eags.

  Lhpyradct gkm aktj``jltug` prhpjrty.

  @akduast rjquarjijkts.

  Iglcakj bhrjadk `gkdugdj trgks`gtahk (IB@]) systjis.

H_JK-\HZULJ UJ@AGEA@A]Q

5-<=.  ]cj typjs hb shurljs usjm th jvg`ugtj akbhrigtahk grj ”  

  _raigry shurljs.

  \jlhkmgry shurljs.

5-<:.  G praigry shurlj rjbjrs th g mhluijkt hr pcysalg` hefjlt tcgt wgs wrattjk hr lrjgtjm murakd tcj taij

ukmjr stumy. ]cjsj shurljs grj prjsjkt murakd gk jxpjrajklj hr taij pjrahm gkm hbbjr gk aksamj vajw hb g

 pgrtalu`gr jvjkt. _raigry shurljs ”  

  Grj djkjrg``y lgtjdhrazjm ey lhktjkt.

  As jatcjr pue`al hr pravgtj.

  As g`sh rjbjrrjm th gs gk hradakg` shurlj hr jvamjklj.

  Ak bglt, grj usug``y brgdijktgry, gieaduhus, gkm mabbalu`t th gkg`yzj. ]cj akbhrigtahk lhktgakjm

ak praigry shurljs as g`sh suefjlt th hesh`jtj ijgkakds hb bgia`agr whrms.

5-<2.  \hij typjs hb praigry shurljs akl`umj ”  

  Hradakg` mhluijkts (jxljrpts hr trgks`gtahks) sulc gs magrajs, lhkstatutahks, rjsjgrlc fhurkg`s,

spjjlcjs, igkuslrapts, `jttjrs, hrg` aktjrvajws, kjws ba`i bhhtgdj, gutheahdrgpcajs, gkm hbbalag`rjlhrms.

  Lrjgtavj whrns sulc gs phjtry, mrgig, khvj`s, iusal, gkm grt.

  Uj`als hr grtabglts sulc gs phttjry, burkaturj, l`htcakd, grtabglts, gkm eua`makds.

  _jrshkg` kgrrgtavjs gkm ijihars.

  _jrshk hb marjlt nkhw`jmdj.

5-<4.  G sjlhkmgry shurlj aktjrprjts, gkg`yzjs, latjs, gkm eua`ms uphk praigry shurljs. \jlhkmgry shurljs

igy lhktgak palturjs, quhtjs, hr drgpcals brhi praigry shurljs. \hij typjs hb sjlhkmgry shurljs akl`umj

 pue`algtahks sulc gs ”  

  Fhurkg`s tcgt aktjrprjt bakmakds.   Casthrajs.

  ]jxtehhns.   Lratalasis.

  Igdgzakj grtal`js.

  Jklyl`hpjmags.

  Lhiijktgrajs.

Khtj. _raigry gkm sjlhkmgry shurljs grj hbtjktaijs mabbalu`t th mastakduasc gs ehtc grj suefjltavj

ak kgturj. _raigry shurljs grj kht kjljssgra`y ihrj hb gk gutchraty hr ejttjr tcgk sjlhkmgry

shurljs. Bhr gky shurlj, praigry hr sjlhkmgry, at as aiphrtgkt bhr H\AK] pjrshkkj` th jvg`ugtj

tcj rjphrt bhr mjljptahk gkm eags.

Page 22: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 22/91

Lcgptjr 5

5-3 G]_ 5-55.1 7? Fu`y 5?75 

5-<3.  Hpjk-shurlj rj`agea`aty rgtakds rgkdj brhi G (rj`age`j) th B (lgkkht ej fumdjm) gs schwk ak tge`j 5-7. G

barst-taij shurlj usjm ak tcj lrjgtahk hb H\AK] as davjk g shurlj rgtakd hb B. Gk B rgtakd mhjs kht ijgk tcj

shurlj as ukrj`age`j, eut H\AK] pjrshkkj` cgvj kh prjvahus jxpjrajklj watc tcj shurlj uphk wcalc th egsj g

mjtjriakgtahk.

]ge`j 5-7. Hpjk-shurlj rj`agea`aty rgtakds

G Uj`age`jKh mhuet hb gutcjktalaty, trustwhrtcakjss, hr lhipjtjkly> cgs g casthry hblhip`jtj rj`agea`aty.

EZsug` `y

rj`age`j

Iakhr mhuet gehut gutcjktalaty, trustwhrtcakjss, hr lhipjtjkly> cgs g casthry hb

vg`am akbhrigtahk ihst hb tcj taij.

L Bgar`y rj`age`jMhuet hb gutcjktalaty, trustwhrtcakjss, hr lhipjtjkly, eut cgs prhvamjm vg`amakbhrigtahk ak tcj pgst.

MKht usug` `y

rj`age`j

\adkabalgkt mhuet gehut gutcjktalaty, trustwhrtcakjss, hr lhipjtjkly, eut cgsprhvamjm vg`am akbhrigtahk ak tcj pgst.

J Zkrj`age`j@glnakd gutcjktalaty, trustwhrtcakjss, gkm lhipjtjkly> casthry hb akvg`amakbhrigtahk.

BLgkkht ej

 fu mdjmKh egsas jxasts bhr jvg`ugtakd tcj rj`agea`aty hb tcj shurlj.

H_JK-\HZULJ AKBHUIG]AHK LHK]JK] LUJMAEA@A]Q5-<1.  \aia`gr th hpjk-shurlj rj`agea`aty, lrjmaea`aty rgtakds rgkdj brhi hkj (lhkbarijm) th jadct (lgkkht ej

 fumdjm) gs schwk ak tge`j 5-5. Ab tcj akbhrigtahk as rjljavjm brhi g barst-taij shurlj, at as davjk g rgtakd hb

jadct gkm, `anj tcj rj`agea`aty rgtakds slg`j, mhjs kht ijgk tcj akbhrigtahk as kht lrjmae`j eut tcgt H\AK]

 pjrshkkj` cgvj kh ijgks th vjraby tcj akbhrigtahk.

]ge`j 5-5. Hpjk-shurlj lhktjkt lrjmaea`aty rgtakds

7 Lhkb arijmLhkbarijm ey htcjr akmjpjkmjkt shurljs> `hdalg` ak atsj`b> lhksastjkt watc htcjrakbhrigtahk hk tcj suefjlt.

5 _rhege`y t ruj Kht lhkbarijm> `hdalg` ak atsj`b> lhksastjkt watc htcjr akbhrigtahk hk tcj suefjlt.

< _hssae`y t rujKht lhkbarijm> rjgshkge`y `hdalg` ak atsj`b> gdrjjs watc shij htcjr akbhrigtahkhk tcj suefjlt.

= Mhuet bu` `y t ruj Kht lhkbarijm> phssae`j eut kht `hdalg`> kh htcjr akbhrigtahk hk tcj suefjlt.

: Aiprhege`jKht lhkbarijm> kht `hdalg` ak atsj`b> lhktrgmaltjm ey htcjr akbhrigtahk hk tcj

suefjlt.

2 Iasakbhrigt ahkZkaktjktahkg``y bg`sj> kht `hdalg` ak atsj`b> lhktrgmaltjm ey htcjr akbhrigtahk hktcj suefjlt> lhkbarijm ey htcjr akmjpjkmjkt shurljs.

4 Mjljpt ahkMj`aejrgtj`y bg`sj> lhktrgmaltjm ey htcjr akbhrigtahk hk tcj suefjlt> lhkbarijmey htcjr akmjpjkmjkt shurljs.

3Lgkkht ej

 fumdjmKh egsas jxasts bhr jvg`ugtakd tcj vg`amaty hb tcj akbhrigtahk.

LHI_@AGKLJ

5-=?.  Ak gllhrmgklj watc JH 75<<<, MHM :5=?.7-U, gkm GU <37-7?, prhljmurj 5, Griy aktj``adjklj gltavatajs

igy lh``jlt pue`al`y gvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk hk Z.\. pjrshks hk`y wcjk at as kjljssgry th bu`ba`` gk gssadkjmbukltahk. (Bhr ihrj akbhrigtahk hk aktj``adjklj hvjrsadct, sjj gppjkmax G.)

H_JUG]AHK\ \JLZUA]Q

5-=7.  H\AK] lhu`m ukaktjktahkg``y prhvamj prjsjkt gkm buturj akmalgthrs hb Z.\. ia`atgry hpjrgtahks.

Akbhrigtahk djkjrg``y gvga`ge`j th tcj pue`al lgk rjvjg` tcj jxastjklj hb, gkm shijtaijs mjtga`s gehut l`gssabajm

hr sjksatavj akbhrigtahk tcgt lgk ej usjm th kjutrg`azj hr jxp`hat ia`atgry hpjrgtahks. Aktj``adjklj hrdgkazgtahks

Page 23: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 23/91

_`gkkakd gkm _rjpgrgtahk hb tcj H\AK] Iassahk

7? Fu`y 5?75  G]_ 5-55.1 5-1

iust mjtjriakj tcj `jvj` hb lhktglt watc hpjk shurljs gkm tcj lh``jltahk hr glquasatahk tjlckaquj tcgt lhu`m

gbbjlt Griy hpjrgtahks.

L@G\\ABALG]AHK

5-=5.  GU <3?-: stgtjs tcgt aktj``adjklj prhmuljrs ‐iust ej wgry hb gpp`yakd sh iulc sjluraty tcgt tcjy grj

ukge`j th prhvamj g usjbu` prhmult th lhksuijrs.’ ]cas as gk gpprhpragtj wgrkakd   bhr H\AK] pjrshkkj`

wcjrj lhkljrk bhr H_\JL lgk ukmjriakj tcj gea`aty th massjiakgtj akcjrjkt`y ukl`gssabajm akbhrigtahk.

Jxgip`js hb ukl`gssabajm akbhrigtahk ejakd hvjr-l`gssabajm grj ”  

  Ujphrtjm akbhrigtahk bhukm ak g bhrjadk kjwspgpjr.

  Ijssgdj brhi g bhrjadk hbbalag` gttjkmakd gk aktjrkgtahkg` lhkbjrjklj.

5-=<.  GU <3?-: marjlts tcgt Griy pjrshkkj` wa`` kht gpp`y l`gssabalgtahk hr htcjr sjluraty igrnakds th gk

grtal`j hr phrtahk hb gk grtal`j tcgt cgs gppjgrjm ak g kjwspgpjr, igdgzakj, hr htcjr pue`al ijmaui. Bakg`

gkg`ysas hb H\AK] igy rjquarj gmmatahkg` rjstraltahks gkm ej mjjijm lhktrh``jm ukl`gssabajm akbhrigtahk hr

 sjksatavj eut ukl`gssabajm akbhrigtahk.

LHHUMAKG]AHK

5-==.  Murakd p`gkkakd, tcj D-5/\-5 gkm D-</\-< stgbb iust jksurj tcgt H\AK] iassahks gkm tgsns grj

syklcrhkazjm watc tcj slcjij hb igkjuvjr. Glquarakd hpjk-shurlj akbhrigtahk igy lhiprhiasj tcjhpjrgtahks hb htcjr aktj``adjklj maslap`akjs hr tgltalg` ukats. Hpjk-shurlj glquasatahk tcgt as kht

syklcrhkazjm igy g`sh rjsu`t ak tcj tgsnakd hb iu`tap`j gssjts gkm tcj aiprhpjr uta`azgtahk hb bhrljs gkm

jquapijkt, gmvjrsj`y gbbjltakd tcj gea`aty hb khkaktj``adjklj hrdgkazgtahks, sulc gs lava` gbbgars, ia`atgry

 ph`alj, gkm pue`al gbbgars, th gllhip`asc gssadkjm iassahks gkm tgsns. Lhkvjrsj`y, hvjrt lhktglt watc gk

hpjk shurlj ey khkaktj``adjklj hrdgkazgtahks lgk lhiprhiasj H\AK] iassahks gkm tgsns gkm `jgm th tcj

`hss hb aktj``adjklj.

MJLJ_]AHK GKM EAG\

5-=:.  Mjljptahk gkm eags as g lhkljrk ak H\AK] jxp`hatgtahk. H\AK] jxp`hatgtahk mhjs kht khrig``y

glquarj akbhrigtahk ey marjlt hesjrvgtahk hb gltavatajs gkm lhkmatahks watcak tcj GH. H\AK] jxp`hatgtahk

rj`ajs igak`y hk sjlhkmgry shurljs th glquarj gkm massjiakgtj akbhrigtahk. \jlhkmgry shurljs, sulc gs

dhvjrkijkt prjss hbbaljs, lhiijrlag` kjws hrdgkazgtahks, gkm khkdhvjrkijktg` hrdgkazgtahkssphnjspjrshks, lgk aktjktahkg``y hr ukaktjktahkg``y gmm, mj`jtj, ihmaby, hr htcjrwasj ba`tjr tcj akbhrigtahk

igmj th tcj djkjrg` pue`al. ]cjsj shurljs igy g`sh lhkvjy hkj ijssgdj ak Jkd`asc watc tcj aktjkt th swgy

Z.\. hr aktjrkgtahkg` pjrspjltavjs gkm g mabbjrjkt khk-Jkd`asc ijssgdj bhr `hlg` phpu`glj lhksuiptahk. At as

aiphrtgkt th nkhw tcj eglndrhukm hb hpjk shurljs gkm tcj purphsj hb tcj pue`al akbhrigtahk ak hrmjr th

mastakduasc hefjltavjs, bgltug` akbhrigtahk, amjktaby eags, hr cadc`adct mjljptahk jbbhrts gdgakst tcj rjgmjr

gkm tcj hvjrg`` hpjrgtahk.

LH_QUADC] GKM AK]J@@JL]ZG@ _UH_JU]Q

5-=2.  Lhpyradct   as g bhri hb prhtjltahk, bhr pue`ascjm gkm ukpue`ascjm whrns, prhvamjm ey ]at`j 74, Zkatjm

\tgtjs Lhmj (Z\L), th gutchrs hb ‐hradakg` whrns hb gutchrscap,’ akl`umakd `atjrgry, mrgigtal, iusalg`, gkm

grtastal whrns. Aktj``jltug` prhpjrty as lhksamjrjm gky lrjgtahk hb tcj iakm gkm akl`umjs, eut as kht aiatjm th ”  

  Iusalg` whrns gkm lhiphsatahks.

  Grtastal masp`gys.

  Maslhvjrajs.

  Akvjktahks.

  Thrms hr pcrgsjs.

  \yieh`s gkm mjsadks.

Page 24: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 24/91

Lcgptjr 5

5-7? G]_ 5-55.1 7? Fu`y 5?75 

5-=4.  At as a``jdg` th vah`gtj tcj radcts prhvamjm ey tcj lhpyradct `gw th tcj hwkjr hb lhpyradct. Hkj igfhr

`aiatgtahk as tcj mhltrakj hb bgar usj, wcalc as davjk g stgtuthry egsas ak \jltahk 7?4 hb tcj 7142 Lhpyradct

Glt. Gllhrmakd th tcj Z.\. Lhpyradct Hbbalj, ‐bgar usj’ hb g lhpyra dctjm whrn bhr purphsjs sulc gs

lratalasi, lhiijkt, kjws rjphrtakd, tjglcakd, slch`grscap, hr rjsjgrlc as kht gk akbrakdjijkt hb lhpyradct.

]cj bhur bglthrs ak mjtjriakakd bgar usj grj tcj ”  

  _urphsj gkm lcgrgltjr hb tcj usj.

   Kgturj hb tcj lhpyradctjm whrn.  Gihukt gkm suestgktag`aty hb tcj phrtahk usjm ak rj`gtahk th tcj lhpyradctjm whrn gs g wch`j.

  Jbbjlt hb tcj usj uphk tcj phtjktag` igrnjt bhr hr vg`uj hb tcj lhpyradctjm whrn.

5-=3.  GU 54-2? prjslraejs ph`alajs gkm prhljmurjs bhr tcj glquasatahk, prhtjltahk, trgksbjr, pgtjkt usgdj,

lhpyradcts, gkm trgmjigrns hb aktj``jltug` prhpjrty. Griy ph`aly rjlhdkazjs tcj radcts hb lhpyradct hwkjrs

lhksastjkt watc Griy iassahks gkm whr`mwamj lhiiatijkts. H\AK] pjrshkkj` wa`` kht prhmulj hr

mastraeutj lhpyradctjm whrns watchut tcj pjriassahk hb tcj lhpyradct hwkjr uk`jss sulc usj as gutchrazjm

ukmjr Z.\. lhpyradct `gw. ]cjrj as g`sh g rjquarjijkt bhr H\AK] pjrshkkj` th bhrwgrm th tcj \jrvalj \FG

bhr gpprhvg` gkm wgavjr hb khtalj th tcj lhpyradct ch`mjr, ab kjljssgry, bhr H_\JL. (Bhr ihrj akbhrigtahk

hk lhpyradct `gws gkm gpp`algea`aty, sjj tcj Aktjrkgtahkg` Lhpyradct Uj`gtahks hb tcj Zkatjm \tgtjs gt

cttp6//www.lhpyradct.dhv hr tcj `hlg` \FG hbbalj.)

@AKDZA\] UJWZAUJIJK]\5-=1.  ]cj gea`aty th dgtcjr gkm gkg`yzj bhrjadk igtjrag`s as lratalg` ak H\AK] jxp`hatgtahk. ]cj jbbjltavj

usj gkm jip`hyijkt hb `akduasts, ehtc lava`agk gkm ia`atgry, bgla`atgtjs tcas gltavaty. ]cj grjgs hb tcj cadcjst

lratalg`aty hb rjquarjm bhrjadk `gkdugdj sna``s gkm nkhw`jmdj prhbalajkly grj ”  

  ]rgkslraptahk. Ehtc `astjkakd gkm wratakd prhbalajkly ak tcj shurlj `gkdugdj grj jssjktag` bhr gk

gllurgtj trgkslrapt. G trgkslrapt as jxtrjij`y aiphrtgkt wcjk Jkd`asc `gkdugdj sna``s hb tcj

H\AK] pjrshkkj` grj akgmjqugtj bhr gutchratgtavj hr marjlt trgks`gtahk brhi gumah hr vamjh akth

Jkd`asc tjxt.

  ]rgks`gtahk. Ea`akdug` lhipjtjklj as g prjrjquasatj bhr trgks`gtahks. @akduasts iust ej ge`j th ”  

  Ujgm gkm lhiprjcjkm tcj shurlj `gkdugdj.

  Tratj lhiprjcjksae`y ak Jkd`asc.

  Lchhsj tcj jquavg`jkt jxprjssahk ak Jkd`asc tcgt bu``y lhkvjys gkm ejst igtlcjs tcj

ijgkakd aktjkmjm ak tcj shurlj `gkdugdj.  Aktjrprjtgtahk. Ea`akdug` lhipjtjklj as g prjrjquasatj bhr aktjrprjtgtahk. @akduasts iust ej ge`j

th ”  

  Cjgr gkm lhiprjcjkm tcj shurlj `gkdugdj.

  \pjgn lhiprjcjksae`y ak Jkd`asc.

  Lchhsj tcj jquavg`jkt jxprjssahk ak Jkd`asc tcgt bu``y lhkvjys gkm ejst igtlcjs tcj

ijgkakd aktjkmjm ak tcj shurlj `gkdugdj.

Khtj. Aktjrprjtgtahk as g spjlabal sna`` ak wcalc kht g`` `akduasts grj trgakjm.

5-:?.  ]h jbbjltavj`y p`gk gkm jip`hy `akduasts, lhiigkmjrs gkm stgbbs iust ukmjrstgkm tcj Griy `akduast

 prhbalajkly jvg`ugtahk systji. Jvg`ugtahk gkm rjjvg`utahk hb `akduast prhbalajkly as lhvjrjm ak mjtga` ak

GU 77-2, lcgptjr :. @gkdugdj tjstakd as rjquarjm bhr g`` Griy pjrshkkj`, ak g `gkdugdj-mjpjkmjkt ia`atgryhllupgtahkg` spjlag`ty (IH\) hr Griy hllupgtahkg` lhmj (GHL), wch cgvj rjljavjm bhrjadk `gkdugdj

trgakakd. Htcjr Griy pjrshkkj` wch cgvj nkhw`jmdj hb g bhrjadk `gkdugdj grj jklhurgdjm th tgnj tcj

 prhbalajkly tjst gkm igy whrn gs `akduasts.

5-:7.  ]cj Griy usjs tcj Mjbjksj @gkdugdj _rhbalajkly ]jst (M@_]) th ijgsurj tcj prhbalajkly `jvj` ak g

spjlabal `gkdugdj. ]cj M@_] as gk akmalgtahk hb bhrjadk `gkdugdj lgpgea`aty, eut at as kht tcj mjbakatavj

jvg`ugtahk hb gk akmavamug`‑s gea`aty th pjrbhri `akduast supphrt.

Page 25: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 25/91

_`gkkakd gkm _rjpgrgtahk hb tcj H\AK] Iassahk

7? Fu`y 5?75  G]_ 5-55.1 5-77

5-:5.  ]cj Griy usjs Aktjrgdjkly @gkdugdj Uhukmtge`j (A@U) mjslraptahks hb tcj prhbalajkly `jvj`s bhr tcj

sna``s hb spjgnakd, `astjkakd, rjgmakd, gkm wratakd g bhrjadk `gkdugdj. Mjtga`jm mjslraptahks hb tcjsj `jvj`s

grj gvga`ge`j gt cttp6//www.dhvta`r.hrd. ]cj p`us-`jvj` mjsadkgthrs, schwk gs g ‐+’ syieh`, grj usjm th

mjsadkgtj wcjk g `akduast as gehvj g egsj `jvj`, eut kht yjt th tcj lgpgea`aty hb tcj kjxt `jvj`. ]cj sax egsj

`jvj`s hb prhbalajkly gs jstge`ascjm ey tcj M@_] grj ”  

  @jvj` ? (kh prhbalajkly). ]cj \h`majr cgs kh bukltahkg` bhrjadk `gkdugdj gea`aty. @jvj` ?+ as tcj

iakaiui stgkmgrm bhr spjlag`-bhrljs pjrshkkj` gkm akmalgtjs g ijihrazjm prhbalajkly hk`y.  @jvj` 7 (j`jijktgry prhbalajkly). ]cj \h`majr cgs `aiatjm lhktrh` hb tcj bhrjadk `gkdugdj sna``

grjg th ijjt `aiatjm prgltalg` kjjms gkm j`jijktgry bhrjadk `gkdugdj rjquarjijkts.

  @jvj` 5 (`aiatjm whrnakd prhbalajkly). ]cj `akduast as subbalajkt`y sna``jm th ej ge`j th sgtasby

rhutakj bhrjadk `gkdugdj mjigkms gkm `aiatjm whrn rjquarjijkts.

  @jvj` < (djkjrg` prhbjssahkg` prhbalajkly).]cj akduast as lgpge`j hb pjrbhriakd ihst djkjrg`,

tjlckalg`, bhrig`, gkm akbhrig` bhrjadk `gkdugdj tgsns hk g prgltalg`, shlag`, gkm prhbjssahkg` `jvj`.

  @jvj` = (gmvgkljm prhbjssahkg` prhbalajkly). ]cj `akduast as lgpge`j hb pjrbhriakd gmvgkljm

 prhbjssahkg` bhrjadk `gkdugdj tgsns b`ujkt`y gkm gllurgtj`y hk g`` `jvj`s.

  @jvj` : (bukltahkg``y kgtavj prhbalajkly). ]cj `akduast as bukltahkg``y jquavg`jkt th gk

grtalu`gtj gkm wj``-jmulgtjm kgtavj ak g`` bhrjadk `gkdugdj sna``s> tcj `akduast rjb`jlts tcj lu`turg`

stgkmgrms hb tcj lhuktry wcjrj tcj bhrjadk `gkdugdj as kgtavj`y sphnjk.

5-:<.  ]cj gehvj prhbalajkly egsj `jvj`s mjsadkgtj prhbalajkly ak gky hb tcj bhur `gkdugdj sna``s ” astjkakd,rjgmakd, spjgnakd, gkm wratakd. ]cj M@_] hk`y jvg`ugtjs rjgmakd gkm `astjkakd sna``s (bhr jxgip`j, 5+/<, hr

</7+). Lurrjkt`y, tcjsj tjsts mh kht jvg`ugtj `akduasts gehvj tcj <-prhbalajkly `jvj`. ]cj lurrjkt Griy

stgkmgrm th ej lhksamjrjm g qug`abajm `akduast as g `jvj` 5. Hrg` prhbalajkly aktjrvajws jvg`ugtj spjgnakd

 prhbalajkly gkm igy ej usjm th prhvamj g `astjkakd slhrj. ]cjsj aktjrvajws igy prhvamj gk jvg`ugtahk g``

tcj wgy up th tcj :-prhbalajkly `jvj`.

5-:=.  G`hkd watc prhbalajkly gkm b`ujkly, H\AK] pjrshkkj` iust lhksamjr tcj eagsjs gkm lu`turg` eglndrhukms

hb lava`agk aktjrprjtjrs wcjk gkg`yzakd khk-Jkd`asc hpjk-shurlj akbhrigtahk. Tcjk p`gkkakd th uta`azj `akduasts,

lhiigkmjrs iust amjktaby rjquarjijkts ey lgtjdhry. @akduast slrjjkakd lgtjdhrajs grj ”  

  Lgtjdhry A. @akduasts iust gt `jgst cgvj gmvgkljm prhbjssahkg` prhbalajkly ak tcj tgrdjt `gkdugdj, g

`jvj` = gs ijgsurjm ey tcj A@U gkm djkjrg` whrnakd prhbalajkly (A@U 5+) ak Jkd`asc. ]cjy igy ej

`hlg``y carjm hr brhi g rjdahk hutsamj tcj GH. ]cjy mh kht rjquarj g sjluraty l`jgrgklj.

  Lgtjdhry AA. @akduasts grj Z.\. latazjks drgktjm glljss th g \jlrjt l`jgrgklj ey tcj mjsadkgtjm Z.\.

Dhvjrkijkt pjrshkkj` sjluraty gutchraty. ]cjy iust gt `jgst cgvj gmvgkljm prhbjssahkg` prhbalajkly

ak tcj tgrdjt gkdugdj (A@U =) gkm djkjrg` whrnakd prhbalajkly (A@U 5+) ak Jkd`asc.

  Lgtjdhry AAA.  @akduasts grj Z.\. latazjks drgktjm ]hp \jlrjt (]\)/\jksatavj Lhipgrtijktjm

Akbhrigtahk (\LA) hr gk aktjrai ]\/\LA l`jgrgklj ey tcj mjsadkgtjm Z.\. Dhvjrkijkt pjrshkkj`

sjluraty gutchraty. ]cjy iust ijjt g iakaiui hb A@U < ak ehtc tcj tgrdjt `gkdugdj gkm Jkd`asc.

IGLCAKJ BHUJADK @GKDZGDJ ]UGK\@G]AHK \Q\]JI\

5-::.  Mjvj`hpakd g rj`age`j gkm prhbalajkt `akduast rjquarjs g drjgt mjg` hb taij, ehtc bhr trgakakd gkm dgakakd

jxpjrajklj. ]cas jxtjkmjm taij`akj hbtjk rjsu`ts ak schrtgdjs hb `akduast pjrshkkj`. ]h ba`` pjrshkkj` vglgklajs

tcrhudchut Griy ukats gkm th ijjt `gkdugdj rjquarjijkts gkm mjigkms, IB@] systjis grj usjm. Tcjk

jip`hyjm prhpjr`y, IB@] systjis lgk prhvamj gk aklrjgsjm lgpgea`aty bhr trgks`gtahk ak supphrt hb ukabajm

`gkm hpjrgtahks.

5-:2.  Uj`age`j IB@] lgpgea`aty jxasts th trgks`gtj ijmag erhgmlgsts akth Jkd`asc gkm tcjrj as rjgma`y gvga`ge`j

shbtwgrj th trgks`gtj Aktjrkjt shurljs akth Jkd`asc gs wj``. ]cjrj grj `aiatjm spjjlc-th-spjjlc (\5\)

lgpgea`atajs ak usj.

Page 26: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 26/91

Lcgptjr 5

5-75 G]_ 5-55.1 7? Fu`y 5?75 

BHUJADK IJMAG IHKA]HUAKD 

5-:4.  Ijmag ihkathrakd systjis `anj tcj EEK Erhgmlgst Ihkathrakd \ystji℥ (EI\℥) lrjgtj g lhktakuhus

sjgrlcge`j grlcavj hb aktjrkgtahkg` tj`jvasahk erhgmlgsts. ]cjsj systjis guthigtalg``y trgkslraej tcj rjg`-taij

gumah strjgi gkm trgks`gtj at akth Jkd`asc. Ehtc tcj trgkslrapt gkm trgks`gtahk grj sjgrlcge`j gkm syklcrhkazjm th

tcj vamjh, prhvamakd phwjrbu` lgpgea`atajs bhr jbbjltavj rjtrajvg` gkm prjlasj p`gyegln hb tcj vamjh egsjm hk ats

spjjlc lhktjkt. Tatc tcas systji, aktj``adjklj gkg`ysts lgk sabt tcrhudc vgst lh``jltahks hb kjws lhktjkt ak htcjr

`gkdugdjs qualn`y gkm jbbalajkt`y.

5-:3.  ]cjsj systjis prhvamj rjg`-taij trgkslraptahk gkm trgks`gtahk hb erhgmlgst tj`jvasahk kjws, g``hwakd

Jkd`asc spjgnjrs th rgpam`y tragdj khk-Jkd`asc tj`jvasahk lhktjkt, ej g`jrtjm wcjk kjw lhktjkt tcgt igtlcjs g

 prhba j as lgpturjm ey tcj systji, gkm whrn l hsj y watc cuigk `akduasts gkm lu`turg` jxpjrts th lrjgtj gltahkge`j

cadc-qug`aty trgks`gtahks hb jxtrgltjm lhktjkt.

5-:1.  ]cj aktjrbglj g``hws usjrs th qualn`y sjgrlc bhr spjlabal sphnjk lhktjkt ak tcj vamjh grlcavj tcrhudc

njywhrm qujrajs ak Jkd`asc hr tcj shurlj `gkdugdj. \jgrlc tjris grj cadc`adctjm ak tcj rjsu`ts, wcalc schw gk

aigdj tcuiekga`, tcj trgkslrapt sjdijkt ak tcj hradakg` `gkdugdj, gkm gk Jkd`asc trgks`gtahk. L`alnakd hk g rjsu`t

 ejdaks p gyegln hb tcj sjdijkt.

5-2?.  Zsjrs aktjrglt watc tcj systji brhi gky pjrshkg` lhiputjr (_L) hr `gpthp vag g lhiihk cadc-spjjm

Aktjrkjt lhkkjltahk. ]cj hk`y rjquarjm l`ajkt shbtwgrj as Ialrhshbt® Aktjrkjt Jxp`hrjr gkm Takmhws Ijmag®

_`gyjr.

5-27.  ]cj EEK EI\℥ lhktakuhus`y lgpturjs, jklhmjs, gkg`yzjs, gkm sthrjs `avj vamjh strjgis ak gk

guthigtalg``y igaktgakjm, mykgial lglcj lhktgakakd <? mgys hb rjlhrmjm gumah hr vamjh. Gs tcj vamjh p`gys

 egln, tcj systji cadc adcts tcj sphnjk whrms ak ehtc tcj hradakg` `gkdugdj gkm tcj trgks`gtahk. ]cj trgkslrapt as

jkralcjm ey cadc`adctakd tcj kgijs hb pjhp`j, `hlgtahks, gkm hrdgkazgtahks, gkm ey sjpgrgtakd tcj spjgnjrs ak tcj

gumah ba`j. Zsjrs lgk fuip th gky phakt ak tcj lglcj gkm ejdak p`gyegln.

5-25.  Zsjrs lgk jxtrglt vamjh sjdijkts hr sta`` pchths bhr scgrakd, prjsjktgtahk, gkm lh``gehrgtahk.

Mjihkstrgtahk lhipglt masls (LMs) lhktgak jxtrgltjm sjdijkts tcgt prjsjrvj tcj cadc`adctakd gkm

syklcrhkazgtahk hb vamjh, trgkslrapt, gkm trgks`gtahk murakd p`gyegln.

5-2<.  ]cj EEK EI\℥ lurrjkt`y trgks`gtjs”  

  Ihmjrk \tgkmgrm Grgeal.

  Igkmgrak Lcakjsj.

  Tjstjrk Cjiaspcjrj \pgkasc.

  _jrsagk Bgrsa.

   Khrtc Gijralgk Jkd`asc.

  Zkatjm Nakdmhi Jkd`asc.

  Brjklc.

  Egcgsg Akmhkjsagk.

  Cakma.

  Zrmu.

5-2=.  ]cj EEK EI\℥ mhjs kht rjquarj gky cgrmwgrj sjtup, shbtwgrj akstg``gtahk, hr hksatj gmiakastrgtahk

hr igaktjkgklj ey tcj lusthijr.

\_JJLC-]H-\_JJLC 5-2:.  Griy gkm Igrakj ukats lhktakuj th gttjipt th aktjdrgtj gvga`ge`j LH]\ \5\ trgks`gtahk mjvaljs akth

 prjmjp`hyijkt trgakakd gkm ia`atgry hpjrgtahks wca`j mjp`hyjm. ]cj praigry tgltalg` usj bhr tcjsj mjvaljs

cgs ejjk `gkdugdj trgks`gtahk watcak sjluraty hpjrgtahks lhkmultjm ak gkm gihkd g djkjrg` phpu`gtahk hb

khk-Jkd`asc spjgnakd pjhp`j.

Page 27: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 27/91

_`gkkakd gkm _rjpgrgtahk hb tcj H\AK] Iassahk

7? Fu`y 5?75  G]_ 5-55.1 5-7<

\JL]AHK AR “ IGKKAKD ]CJ H\AK] \JL]AHK

5-22.  H\AK] pjrshkkj` tcgt lhiprasj tcj H\AK] sjltahk watcak tcj aktj``adjklj stgbb sjltahk lgk lhksast hb

 ehtc aktj``adjklj gkm khkaktj``adjklj akmavamug`s watc tcj tjlckalg` lhipjtjklj, lrjgtavaty, bhrjtchudct,

lu`turg` nkhw`jmdj, gkm shlag` gwgrjkjss th jxp`hat hpjk shurljs jbbjltavj`y. ]cj mjsadkgtahk hb H\AK]

 pjrshkkj` th sgtasby rjquarjijkts, iassahks, gkm tgsns as djkjrg``y amjktabajm ey lhiigkmjrs gkm tgsn-

hrdgkazjm tcrhudc hrdgkal gssjts (aktj``adjklj pjrshkkj`, khkaktj``adjklj pjrshkkj`, Z.\. gkm khk-Z.\.lhktrglthr pjrshkkj`, hr `akduasts) ak supphrt hb ukabajm `gkm hpjrgtahks.

H\AK] \JL]AHK MZ]AJ\

5-24.  ]cj mutajs hb tcj H\AK] sjltahk grj th ”  

  Ihkathr hpjrgtahks. ]cas jksurjs rjsphksavjkjss th tcj lurrjkt satugtahk gkm th gktalapgtj buturj

glquasatahk, prhljssakd, rjphrtakd, gkm syklcrhkazgtahk rjquarjijkts.

  Lhrrj`gtj rjphrts. Ujphrts (wrattjk, vjreg``y, hr drgpcalg``y) schu`m lhrrj`gtj l`gssabajm rjphrts

tcrhudc H\AK] vg`amgtahk.

  \lrjjk rjphrts. Akbhrigtahk as slrjjkjm ak gllhrmgklj watc tcj LLAUs gkm lhiigkmjr‑s

duamgklj th jksurj tcgt pjrtakjkt gkm rj`jvgkt akbhrigtahk as kht hvjr`hhnjm gkm tcj akbhrigtahk

as rjmuljm th g whrnge`j sazj. \lrjjkakd schu`m jklhipgss tcj j`jijkts hb taij`akjss,

lhip`jtjkjss, gkm rj`jvgklj th sgtasby aktj``adjklj rjquarjijkts.  Massjiakgtj aktj``adjklj gkm akbhrigtahk. \gtasbajm H\AK] rjquarjijkts grj massjiakgtjm th

lusthijrs ak tcj bhri hb usjge`j prhmults gkm rjphrts.

  Luj. Jbbjltavj lujakd ey H\AK] th ihrj tjlckalg` akbhrigtahk lh``jltahk gssjts, sulc gs cuigk

aktj``adjklj (CZIAK]) gkm lhuktjraktj``adjklj (LA) aiprhvjs tcj hvjrg`` akbhrigtahk lh``jltahk

jbbhrt ey njjpakd hrdgkazgtahks gerjgst hb jijrdakd ukl`gssabajm akbhrigtahk gkm hpphrtukatajs

gs wj`` gs jkge`akd tcj usj hb g iu`tamaslap`akj gpprhglc th lhkbari hr mjky akbhrigtahk ey

gkhtcjr akbhrigtahk shurlj, lh``jltahk hrdgkazgtahk, hr prhmultahk gltavaty.

  _rhvamj bjjmegln. Gk jstge`ascjm bjjmegln ijlcgkasi as rjquarjm th tcj supphrtjm lhiigkmjr

hr lusthijr hk tcj stgtus hb aktj``adjklj gkm akbhrigtahk rjquarjijkts.

H\AK] \JL]AHK G] ]CJ EUADGMJ LHIEG] ]JGI @JRJ@

5-23.  Jglc lhiegtgkt lhiigkm igy cgvj g tgsn-hrdgkazjm H\AK] lj`` hr sjltahk th shij vgryakd mjdrjj akslhpj gkm pjrshkkj`. Gt tcj tgltalg` `jvj` hb hpjrgtahks, at as lhiihkp`glj bhr lhiigkmjrs th lrjgtj H\AK]

lj``s brhi hrdgkal aktj``adjklj pjrshkkj` th sgtasby aktj``adjklj rjquarjijkts.

5-21.  ]cj bh``hwakd quhtj a``ustrgtjs chw tgsn hrdgkazgtahk hb hrdgkal pjrshkkj` watcak tcj lhiihk drhukm

stgtahk (LD\) lgk gssast ak sgtasbyakd aktj``adjklj gkm akbhrigtahk rjquarjijkts usakd tcj Khksjlurj Aktjrkjt

_rhthlh` Uhutakd Kjtwhrn (KA_UKJ]) gkm vgrahus j`jltrhkal mjvaljs, sulc gs gk gip`atumj ihmu`gtahk gkm

brjqujkly ihmu`gtahk (GI/BI) rgmah, vamjh lgssjttj rjlhrmjr (RLU), gkm madatg` vamjh masl (MRM) p`gyjr, th

jksurj tcj sulljss hb tcjar EL] th pjrbhri akbhrigtahk lh``jltahk gt tcj tgltalg` hpjrgtahks ljktjr (]HL)6

Page 28: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 28/91

Lcgptjr 5

5-7= G]_ 5-55.1 7? Fu`y 5?75 

Tatc tcjar LD\ tjgi, bhur th bavj aktjrprjtjrs, gkm g stjgmy b`hw hb rgmah, tj`jvasahk, gkm

kjwspgpjr rjphrts, tcj hpjk-shurlj aktj``adjklj tjgi prhmuljm g mga`y rh``up watc

gkg`ysas. ]cjar hbbalj lhksastjm hb hkj tj`jvasahk watc `hlg` gkm aktjrkgtahkg` lge`j, hkj

`gpthp lhkkjltjm th tcj KA_UKJ], GI/BI rgmah, gkm tcj mga`y kjwspgpjr. G`sh, tcj

tjgi glquarjm g RLU gkm MRM p`gyjr th stumy lhkbaslgtjm prhpgdgkmg gkm htcjr ijmag.

]cjy ukmjrstgkm tcj aiphrtgklj hb `hlg` rjphrtakd th tcj sulljss hb tcj EL] lgipgadk

gkm cgvj igmj at g phakt th lhkmult tchrhudc rjsjgrlc hk thpals hb `hlg` aiphrtgklj.

]cjar prhmult wgs stumajm gkm burtcjr gkg`yzjm ey tcj (akbhrigtahk lh``jltahk) gkg`ysas

tjgi gt tcj EL] ]HL prahr th sueiassahk th tcj EL] \-5 gkm massjiakgtahk th egttg`ahks

hr mavasahk.

Ia`atgry Aktj``adjklj Lhipgky Lhiigkmjr, <AM,Hpjrgtahk Argqa Brjjmhi 5??=”5??:

5-4?.  Gs masp`gyjm ak badurj 5-7, pjrshkkj` lhiprasakd tcj H\AK] sjltahk gt tcj EL] `jvj` akl`umj ”  

  \jltahk `jgmjr.

  Ujquarjijkts igkgdjr.

  \atugtahk mjvj`hpijkt gkg`yst.

  ]grdjt mjvj`hpijkt gkg`yst.

Badurj 5-7. Eradgmj lhiegt tjgi‑s H\AK] sjltahk

\JL]AHK @JGMJU  

5-47.  ]cj sjltahk `jgmjr  ”  

  As tcj praigry `agashk gkm lhhrmakgthr watc tcj EL] \-5.

  _rhvamjs supjrvashry gkm igkgdjrag` lgpglaty hvjrsadct.

  \jts tcj prahraty hb tgsns.

  Ihkathrs hkdhakd aktj``adjklj supphrt rjquarjm ey tcj EL] \-5.

  Jksurjs tcgt g`` H\AK] prhmults grj akl`umjm ak tcj p`gkkakd bhr lurrjkt gkm buturj hpjrgtahks.

Page 29: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 29/91

_`gkkakd gkm _rjpgrgtahk hb tcj H\AK] Iassahk

7? Fu`y 5?75  G]_ 5-55.1 5-7:

U JWZAUJIJK]\ IGKGDJU  

5-45.  ]cj rjquarjijkts igkgdjr  ”  

  Jksurjs tcgt satugtahk mjvj`hpijkt gkm tgrdjt mjvj`hpijkt supphrt tcj hvjrg`` jbbhrts hb tcj

sjltahk.

  Rjrabajs tcj gvga`gea`aty hb lh``jltahk gssjts.

  _jrbhris qug`aty lhktrh` bhr satugtahk mjvj`hpijkt gkm tgrdjt mjvj`hpijkt prhmults.  \upjrvasjs tcj rjljapt, gkg`ysas, gkm massjiakgtahk hb H\AK] prhmults.

\A]ZG]AHK MJRJ@H_IJK] GKG@Q\] 

5-4<.  ]cj satugtahk mjvj`hpijkt gkg`yst ”  

  Ihkathrs pue`al`y gvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk gkm hpjk shurljs ak hrmjr th jksurj tcj ihst gllurgtj

lhiihk hpjrgtahkg` palturj.

  Gkg`yzjs akbhrigtahk gkm prhmuljs lurrjkt aktj``adjklj gehut tcj hpjrgtahkg` jkvarhkijkt, jkjiy,

tjrrgak, gkm lava` lhksamjrgtahks ejbhrj gkm murakd hpjrgtahks.

  Ujbakjs akbhrigtahk rjljavjm hk tcrjgt aktjktahks, hefjltavjs, lhiegt jbbjltavjkjss, gkm phtjktag`

iassahks.

  Lhkbaris hr mjkajs tcrjgt LHGs egsjm hk pue`al`y gvga`ge`j akmalgthrs.

  _rhvamjs akbhrigtahk th ejttjr ukmjrstgkm tcj `hlg` phpu`gtahk ak grjgs tcgt akl`umj, eut grj kht`aiatjm th ”  

  ]raeg` gbba`agtahks.

  _h`atalg` ej`ajbs.

  Uj`adahus tjkjts.

  Njy `jgmjrs.

  \upphrt drhups.

  Aklhij shurljs.

]GUDJ] MJRJ@H_IJK] GKG@Q\] 

5-4=.  ]cj tgrdjt mjvj`hpijkt gkg`yst ”  

  Amjktabajs tcj lhiphkjkts, j`jijkts, gkm lcgrgltjrastals hb spjlabal tgrdjts, ehtc `jtcg` gkmkhk`jtcg`.

  Amjktabajs lava` gkm htcjr khk-tgrdjt lhksamjrgtahks watcak tcj GH.

  _rhvamjs pue`al`y gvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk hk tcrjgt lgpgea`atajs gkm `aiatgtahks.

]G\N HUDGKAVG]AHK LHK\AMJUG]AHK\

5-4:.  Tcjk tgsn-hrdgkazakd tcj H\AK] sjltahk th sgtasby aktj``adjklj gkm akbhrigtahk rjquarjijkts, ukats

iust lhksamjr  ”  

  Iassahk lhiigkm.

  Glquasatahk.

  Lh``jltakd gkm prhljssakd.

  _rhmultahk.  Lhiputjr systjis.

Page 30: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 30/91

Lcgptjr 5

5-72 G]_ 5-55.1 7? Fu`y 5?75 

IA\\AHK LHIIGKM 

5-42.  Mjmalgtjm iassahk lhiigkm pjrshkkj` grj kjjmjm ak hrmjr th prhvamj igkgdjijkt gkm hvjrsadct hb

H\AK] jxp`hatgtahk th jksurj lhktakujm syklcrhkazgtahk watc igkjuvjr j`jijkts, tgsns, gkm rjqujsts.

GLWZA\A]AHK 

5-44.  Muj th tcj vh`uijs hb pue`al`y gvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk, glquasatahk tcrhudc jstge`ascjm akbhrigtahklh``jltahk gltavatajs gkm systjis grj kjljssgry ak hrmjr th jksurj tcgt hpjk-shurlj akbhrigtahk as kht `hst hr

iasp`gljm tcgt lhu`m prhvamj jssjktag` gkm kjljssgry iassahk-rj`gtjm akbhrigtahk. _ue`al`y gvga`ge`j

akbhrigtahk glquarjm brhi hpjk shurljs schu`m ej rjphrtjm ak gllhrmgklj watc jstge`ascjm ukat \H_s.

LH@@JL]AKD GKM _UHLJ\\AKD 

5-43.  H\AK] prhpjr`y aktjdrgtjm akth hvjrg`` lh``jltahk p`gks murakd hpjrgtahks grj usjm th sgtasby LLAUs.

Ak hrmjr th glljss tcj bu`` grrgy hb mhijstal gkm bhrjadk pue`al`y gvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk, tcj prhljssakd hb

igtjrag`s hbtjktaijs rjquarjs H\AK] supphrt th pjrshkkj` hpjrgtakd ak tcj grjgs hb mhluijkt jxp`hatgtahk

(MHLJS).

Khtj. _jrshkkj` jkdgdakd ak tcj lh``jltakd gkm prhljssakd hb akbhrigtahk akvh`vakd tcjsj gspjlts

wa`` rjquarj gk ukmjrstgkmakd hb tchsj atjis gkm igtjrag`s tcgt grj lhiihkp`glj gkm tchsj tcgt

lhu`m phssjss aktj``adjklj vg`uj. ]cjy iust burtcjr ej vjrsjm ak tcj gmmatahkg` rjdu`gtahks bhr

Marjlthr, Kgtahkg` \jluraty Gdjkly (MAUK\G) hvjrsadct. Zk`jss bhrjadk pue`al`y gvga`ge`j

akbhrigtahk gkm hpjk shurljs grj lh``jltjm gkm suesjqujkt`y prhljssjm akth g suatge`j bhri, tcj

akbhrigtahk wa`` `hsj aktj``adjklj vg`uj.

_UHMZL]AHK 

5-41.  _rhmultahk hb gltahkge`j gkm taij`y pue`al`y gvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk tcrhudc hpjk shurljs as vatg` ak

H\AK] jxp`hatgtahk. Ujsjgrlc ijtchms, Aktjrkjt tjlckaqujs (egsal gkm gmvgkljm), gkm htcjr gsshlagtjm

thh`s grj uta`azjm th rjtrajvj, aktjdrgtj, jvg`ugtj, gkg`yzj, gkm aktjrprjt akbhrigtahk akth H\AK]. Ujsjgrlc

akbhrigtahk gkm bakg`azjm ijtgmgtg gs prhmults grj sthrjm ak mgtgegsjs glljssae`j th htcjr aktj``adjklj gkm

khkaktj``adjklj pjrshkkj` tcgt cgvj vjstjm H\AK] jxp`hatgtahk rjquarjijkts.

LHI_Z]JU \Q\]JI\ 

5-3?.  H\AK] pjrshkkj` lhkmultakd H\AK] jxp`hatgtahk kjjm th cgvj shbtwgrj g``hlgtjm th tcj gpprhpragtj

tgsn. ]cj kjljssgry ukbjttjrjm jxp`hatgtahk suatj akl`umjs sulc prhdrgis gs Gkg`yst Khtjehhn, _hrtge`j

Mhluijkt Bhrigt (_MB) Ignjr, gkm ]jxt Lcgrt.

Page 31: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 31/91

 

7? Fu`y 5?75  G]_ 5-55.1 <-7

Lcgptjr <

Lh``jltakd H\AK]

Muj th tcj ukl`gssabajm kgturj hb pue`al`y gvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk, tchsj jkdgdakd akH\AK] lh``jltahk gltavatajs lgk ejdak rjsjgrlcakd eglndrhukm akbhrigtahk hk tcjargssadkjm grjg hb rjsphksaea`aty `hkd ejbhrj tcj assugklj hb gk hbbalag` ia`atgry mjp`hyijkt

hrmjr wca`j djkjrgtakd aktj``adjklj nkhw`jmdj. A_E, gk aktjdrgtakd prhljss bhr Griybhrljs, as tcj ijlcgkasi amjktabyakd aktj``adjklj gkm akbhrigtahk rjquarjijkts tcgt lgk

 ej sgtasbajm uta azakd pue al`y gvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk gkm hpjk shurljs.

LH@@JL]AKD _ZE@AL@Q GRGA@GE@J AKBHUIG]AHK<-7.  _ue`al`y gvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk gkm hpjk-shurlj rjsjgrlc, gpp`ajm gs gk jlhkhiy hb bhrlj, as gk

jbbjltavj ijgks hb gssaia`gtakd gutchratgtavj gkm mjtga`jm akbhrigtahk hk tcj iassahk vgrage`js (IJ]]-]L)

gkm hpjrgtahkg` vgrage`js (ph`atalg`, ia`atgry, jlhkhial, shlag`, akbhrigtahk, akbrgstrulturj, pcysalg`

jkvarhkijkt, taij ^_IJ\AA-_]Y). ]cj lhipa`gtahk hb ukgkswjrjm aktj``adjklj gkm akbhrigtahk

rjquarjijkts mjtjriakjm gt tcj lhkl`usahk hb tcj IMI_ gkm A_E grj jxjrlasjm tcrhudc tcj lhiigkmjr ‑s

akput. Lhiigkmjr ‑s akput ”  

  As jxprjssjm ak tcj tjris hb mjslraej, vasug`azj, gkm marjlt.

  As tcj lhrkjrsthkj hb duamgklj usjm ey H\AK] pjrshkkj`.

  Rg`amgtjs aktj``adjklj gkm akbhrigtahk rjquarjijkts.

<-5.  Lhiigkmjr‑s akput as jxprjssjm gs LLAUs gkm lgtjdhrazjm gs brajkm`y bhrlj akbhrigtahk

rjquarjijkts (BBAUs) gkm _AUs. Lhktakuhus rjsjgrlc gkm prhljssakd ijtchms, lhup`jm watc tcj

lhiigkmjr ‑s akput gkm aktj``adjklj gkm akbhrigtahk rjquarjijkts, H\AK] pjrshkkj` lh``jlt pue`al`ygvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk bhr jxp`hatgtahk. ]cj lh``jlt   stjp hb tcj aktj``adjklj prhljss akvh`vjs lh``jltakd,

 prhljssakd, gkm rjphrtakd akbhrigtahk ak rjsphksj th akbhrigtahk lh``jltahk tgsns. Lh``jltjm akbhrigtahk as

tcj bhukmgtahk hb aktj``adjklj mgtgegsjs, aktj``adjklj prhmultahk, gkm satugtahkg` gwgrjkjss.

<-<.  H\AK] as aktjdrgtjm akth p`gkkakd tcrhudc tcj lhktakuhus prhljss hb A_E. _jrshkkj` jkdgdakd ak

H\AK] jxp`hatgtahk iust akatagtj lh``jltahk gkm rjqujsts bhr akbhrigtahk th sgtasby LLAUs th tcj `jvj` hb

mjtga` rjquarjm. Lh``jltakd hpjk-shurlj akbhrigtahk lhiprasjs bhur stjps, gs schwk ak badurj <-7 hk

 pgdj <-56

  Amjktaby akbhrigtahk gkm aktj``adjklj rjquarjijkts.

  Lgtjdhrazj aktj``adjklj rjquarjijkts ey typj.

  Amjktaby shurlj th lh``jlt tcj akbhrigtahk.

  Mjtjriakj lh``jltahk tjlckaquj.

AMJK]ABQ AKBHUIG]AHK GKM AK]J@@ADJKLJ U JWZAUJIJK]\ 

<-=.  Aktj``adjklj gkm akbhrigtahk dgps grj amjktabajm murakd tcj A_E prhljss. ]cjsj dgps schu`m ej

mjvj`hpjm gkm brgijm grhukm tcj iassahk gkm hpjrgtahkg` vgrage`js ak hrmjr th jksurj tcj lhiigkmjr

rjljavjs tcj akbhrigtahk kjjmjm th supphrt g`` `akjs hb hpjrgtahks hr `akjs hb jbbhrt. Gs akbhrigtahk gkm

aktj``adjklj grj rjljavjm, H\AK] pjrshkkj` upmgtj A_E prhmults gkm akbhri tcj lhiigkmjr hb gky rj`jvgkt

lcgkdjs. H\AK] kjjms l`jgr`y stgtjm akbhrigtahk gkm aktj``adjklj rjquarjijkts th jbbjltavj`y bhlus

Page 32: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 32/91

Lcgptjr <

<-5 G]_ 5-55.1 7? Fu`y 5?75 

glquasatahk gkm prhmultahk gkm schu`m ej aklhrphrgtjm akth lh``jltahk p`gks ak hrmjr th sgtasby tcjsj

rjquarjijkts.

Khtj. H\AK] lgkkht j`aiakgtj g`` tcj uknkhwk gspjlts hr ukljrtgaktajs tcgt lhkljrk

lhiigkmjrs gkm stgbbs. ]cj D-5/\-5 iust ej prjpgrjm th ba`` dgps watc rjgshkge`j gssuiptahks>

hklj dgps grj ba``jm, tcj D-5/\-5 iust ejdak mjvj`hpakd mgtgegsjs gt tcj ukat `jvj` ak hrmjr th

cgvj akbhrigtahk rjgma`y gvga`ge`j. ]cas rjmuljs tcj kuiejr hb kjw rjqujsts bhr akbhrigtahk

brhi suehrmakgtj ukats hr hrdgkazgtahks. 

Badurj <-7. _rhljss bhr lh``jltakd pue`al`y gvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk

LG]JDHUAVJ AK]J@@ADJKLJ U JWZAUJIJK]\ EQ ]Q_J

<-:.  Aktj``adjklj rjquarjijkts tcgt kjjm th ej sgtasbajm lgk jxtjkm ejyhkm tcj slhpj hb H\AK], rjsu`takd

ak dgps. H\AK] as suefjlt th akbhrigtahk gkm aktj``adjklj dgps tcgt kjjm th ej sgtasbajm usakd htcjr

gpprhpragtj ijtchms th l`hsj tchsj dgps.

<-2.  A_E as usjm th l`gssaby aktj``adjklj gkm akbhrigtahk rjquarjijkts ey typj egsjm hk iassahk gkg`ysas

gkm brajkm`y LHGs. H\AK] pjrshkkj` prhvamj akput murakd tcas stjp. ]wh aiphrtgkt rj`gtjm tjris tcgt whrn

ak lhkljrt watc H\AK] grj pravgtj akbhrigtahk gkm pue`al`y gvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk6

  _ravgtj akbhrigtahk lhiprasjs mgtg, bglts, akstrultahks, hr htcjr igtjrag` aktjkmjm bhr hr rjstraltjm th

g pgrtalu`gr pjrshk, drhup, hr hrdgkazgtahk. Aktj``adjklj rjquarjijkts tcgt rjquarj pravgtj akbhrigtahkgrj kht gssadkjm th H\AK] sjltahks. ]cjrj grj twh suelgtjdhrajs hb pravgtj akbhrigtahk6

  Lhktrh``jm ukl`gssabajm akbhrigtahk   rjquarjs tcj gpp`algtahk hb lhktrh`s gkm prhtjltavj

ijgsurjs, bhr g vgrajty hb rjgshks (tcgt as, sjksatavj eut ukl`gssabajm  hr bhr hbbalag` usj hk`y).

  L`gssab ajm akb hrigtahk  rjquarjs prhtjltahk gdgakst ukgutchrazjm masl`hsurj gkm as igrnjm th

akmalgtj ats l`gssabajm stgtus wcjk prhmuljm hr massjiakgtjm.

  _ue`al`y gvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk lhiprasjs mgtg, bglts, akstrultahks, hr htcjr igtjrag` pue`ascjm hr

 erhgmlgst bhr djkjrg pue`al lhksuiptahk> gvga ge`j hk rjqujst th g ijiejr hb tcj djkjrg pue al>

`gwbu``y sjjk hr cjgrm ey gky lgsug` hesjrvjr> hr igmj gvga`ge`j gt g ijjtakd hpjk th tcj djkjrg`

 pue al.

Khtj. ]cj gihukt hb l`gssabajm akbhrigtahk prhmuljm hk gky hkj thpal lgk ej `aiatjm gkm tgnjk

hut hb lhktjxt ab vajwjm brhi g sh`j`y l`gssabajm pjrspjltavj. H\AK] vg`amgtahk as kjljssgry

wcjk mjg`akd watc g `grdj gihukt hb l`gssabajm akbhrigtahk. H\AK] vg`amgtahk as usjm wcjkl`gssabajm shurljs grj ukgvga`ge`j hr th lhkbari hr supphrt prjjxastakd l`gssabajm shurljs. ]cas

strjkdtcjks tcj lrjmaea`aty hb H\AK] prhmults ak supphrt hb g``-shurlj aktj``adjklj. H\AK]

vg`amgtahk prhvamjs tcj gea`aty th luj htcjr gssjts tcus jkcgklakd tcj gllurgly gkm prjlasahk hb

dgakjm aktj``adjklj.

Page 33: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 33/91

Lh``jltakd H\AK]

7? Fu`y 5?75  G]_ 5-55.1 <-<

AMJK]ABQ \HZULJ ]H LH@@JL] AKBHUIG]AHK 

<-4.  Amjktabyakd tcj shurlj as pgrt hb p`gkkakd rjquarjijkts gkm gssjssakd lh``jltahk p`gks. ]cj twh typjs

hb shurljs usjm th lh``jlt akbhrigtahk grj lhkbamjktag` shurljs gkm hpjk shurljs6

  Lhkbamjktag` shurljs lhiprasj gky pjrshks, drhups, hr systjis tcgt prhvamj akbhrigtahk watc

tcj jxpjltgtahk tcgt tcj akbhrigtahk, rj`gtahkscap, hr ehtc grj prhtjltjm gdgakst pue`al masl`hsurj.

Akbhrigtahk gkm aktj``adjklj rjquarjijkts tcgt rjquarj lhkbamjktag` shurljs grj kht gssadkjm th

H\AK] sjltahks.

  Hpjk shurljs lhiprasj gky pjrshk hr drhup tcgt prhvamjs akbhrigtahk watchut tcj jxpjltgtahk

hb lhpyradct hr pravgly ” tcj akbhrigtahk, tcj rj`gtahkscap, hr ehtc as kht prhtjltjm gdgakst pue`al

masl`hsurj. Hpjk shurljs akl`umj eut grj kht `aiatjm th ”  

  Glgmjiag. Lhursjwgrj, massjrtgtahks, `jlturjs, prjsjktgtahks, rjsjgrlc pgpjrs, gkm stumajs ak

 ehtc cgrmlhpy gkm shbtlhpy lhvjrakd suefjlts gkm thpals hk jlhkhials, djhdrgpcy

(pcysalg`, lu`turg`, gkm ph`atalg`-ia`atgry), aktjrkgtahkg` rj`gtahks, rjdahkg` sjluraty, gkm

slajklj gkm tjlckh`hdy.

  Dhvjrkijkt gdjklajs gkm khkdhvjrkijktg` hrdgkazgtahks. Mgtgegsjs, phstjm akbhrigtahk,

gkm praktjm rjphrts hk g wamj vgrajty hb jlhkhial, jkvarhkijktg`, djhdrgpcal,

cuigkatgragk, sjluraty, gkm slajklj gkm tjlckh`hdy assujs.

  Lhiijrlag` gkm pue`a l akb hrigtahk sjrvaljs.  Erhgmlgstjm, phstjm, gkm praktjm kjws hk

lurrjkt aktjrkgtahkg`, rjdahkg`, gkm `hlg` thpals.  @aergrajs gkm rjsjgrlc ljktjrs. _raktjm mhluijkts gkm madatg` mgtgegsjs hk g rgkdj hb thpals.

  A kmavamug`s gkm drhups. Cgkmwrattjk, pgaktjm, phstjm, praktjm, gkm erhgmlgstjm akbhrigtahk

hk suefjlts gkm thpals hk grt, drgbbata, `jgb`jts, phstjrs, tgtthhs, gkm Tje satjs.

  Drgy `atjrgturj.  Igtjrag`s gkm akbhrigtahk tcgt grj bhukm usakd gmvgkljm Aktjrkjt sjgrlc

tjlckaqujs hk tcj Mjjp Tje lhksastakd hb tjlckalg` rjphrts, slajktabal rjsjgrlc pgpjrs, gkm

wcatj pgpjrs.

MJ]JUIAKJ LH@@JL]AHK ]JLCKAWZJ

<-3.  Lh``jltahk aip`ajs dgtcjrakd, ey g vgrajty hb ijgks, rgw mgtg gkm akbhrigtahk brhi wcalc bakg`azjm

aktj``adjklj as tcjk lrjgtjm hr syktcjsazjm, gkm massjiakgtjm. Lh``jltjm akbhrigtahk as gkg`yzjm gkm

aklhrphrgtjm akth g``-shurlj gkm htcjr aktj``adjklj maslap`akj prhmults. ]cjsj prhmults grj massjiakgtjm pjr

ukat \H_s, H_HUMs, htcjr jstge`ascjm bjjmegln ijlcgkasi, hr aktj``adjklj grlcatjlturj. ]cjsj tjlckaqujslhkbari tcj prjsjklj hb p`gkkjm tgrdjts gkm prhvamj g egsj`akj hb gltavaty gkm akbhrigtahk hk shurljs

watcak tcj GH bhr burtcjr mjvj`hpijkt gkm buturj vg`amgtahk. Tcjk dgtcjrakd akbhrigtahk, tcj uta`azjm

tjlckaquj akl`umjs spjlabal akbhrigtahk rjqujsts, hefjltavjs, prahratajs, taijbrgij hb jxpjltjm gltavaty,

`gtjst (hr jgr`ajst) taij tcj akbhrigtahk as hb vg`uj (@]AHR), gkm rjphrtakd akstrultahks.

<-1.  Hpjk-shurlj akbhrigtahk tcgt sgtasbajs g LLAU as massjiakgtjm gs qualn`y gs phssae`j th tcj

lhiigkmjr gkm htcjr stgbb pjrshkkj` pjr ukat \H_s hr H_HUMs. H\AK] lgk usj ukaktrusavj lh``jltahk

tjlckaqujs th luj ihrj tjlckalg` lh``jltahk gssjts. Lh``jltahk tjlckaqujs, mjpjkmakd hk hpjrgtahk

lhip`jxatajs, lgk jkcgklj tcj lcgkljs hb sgtasbyakd aktj``adjklj gkm akbhrigtahk rjquarjijkts.

<-7?.  Hpjk-shurlj glquasatahk hb akbhrigtahk gkm aktj``adjklj rjquarjijkts grj gssadkjm th H\AK]

 pjrshkkj`. Hpjk-shurlj lh``jltahk akl`umjs tcj glquasatahk hb igtjrag` ak tcj pue`al mhigak. ]cj jxtjkt th

wcalc hpjk-shurlj lh``jltahk yaj`ms vg`uge`j akbhrigtahk vgrajs drjgt`y watc tcj kgturj hb tcj tgrdjt gkm tcj

suefjlt akvh`vjm. ]cj akbhrigtahk iadct ej lh``jltjm ey akmavamug`s wch euy ehhns gkm fhurkg`s, hesjrvj

ia`atgry pgrgmjs, hr rjlhrm tj`jvasahk gkm rgmah prhdrgis.

UJ\JGULC

<-77.  Gbtjr mjtjriakakd tcj lh``jltahk tjlckaquj, H\AK] pjrshkkj` lhkmult rjsjgrlc th sgtasby aktj``adjklj

gkm akbhrigtahk rjquarjijkts.

Page 34: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 34/91

Lcgptjr <

<-= G]_ 5-55.1 7? Fu`y 5?75 

<-75.  Ujsjgrlc ”  

  @jgms th tcj phpu`gtahk hb akbhrigtahk gkm aktj``adjklj mgtgegsjs. ]cjsj mgtgegsjs jkge`j

H\AK] pjrshkkj` th gllurgtj`y rjsphkm th lcgkdjs watcak tcj GH ey prhvamakd rjqujstjm

akbhrigtahk th sgtasby rjquarjijkts.

  As usjm th dgtcjr akbhrigtahk tcgt lhktraeutjs th prhvamakd gk ukmjrstgkmakd hb g prhe`ji gkm

hrdgkazakd tcj rjsu`ts lhiprjcjksavj`y.

  As usjm th djkjrgtj aktj``adjklj nkhw`jmdj ejbhrj gkm murakd mjp`hyijkts.

<-7<.  ]wh typjs hb rjsjgrlc ijtchms tcgt lgk ej usjm grj ”  

  Baj`m rjsjgrlc.  _jrshkkj` brhi glgmjial, dhvjrkijktg`, aktjrdhvjrkijktg`, gkm

khkdhvjrkijktg` hrdgkazgtahks glquarj mgtg brhi praigry shurljs, gs wj`` gs rjtrajvj mgtg gkm

akbhrigtahk brhi sjlhkmgry shurljs. Baj`m rjsjgrlc ”  

  Lhksasts hb pgrtalapgkt hesjrvgtahk, mgtg lh``jltahk, gkm survjy rjsjgrlc.

  As typalg``y lhkmultjm gt tcj hpjrgtahkg` gkm strgtjdal `jvj`s wcjk taij as kht g bglthr ak tcj

mjvj`hpijkt hb akbhrigtahk gkm aktj``adjklj hb tcj hpjrgtahkg` vgrage`js (_IJ\AA-_]) th

 prhvamj lhiigkmjrs satugtahkg` gwgrjkjss.

  _rgltalg` rjsjgrlc.  Aktj``adjklj pjrshkkj` rjtrajvj jxastakd mgtg gkm akbhrigtahk brhi

sjlhkmgry shurljs. _rgltalg` rjsjgrlc ”  

  As typalg``y lhkmultjm gt tcj tgltalg` `jvj` wcjk taij as g bglthr ak tcj mjvj`hpijkt hb

akbhrigtahk gkm aktj``adjklj hb tcj iassahk vgrage`js (IJ]]-]L) ak prhvamakd lhiigkmjrssatugtahkg` gwgrjkjss.

  As praigra`y usjm gihkd aktj``adjklj pjrshkkj` tcgt jkdgdj ak H\AK] jxp`hatgtahk.

<-7=.  G`` rjsjgrlc ejdaks watc tcj mjtjriakgtahk hb g rjsjgrlc qujstahk gkm tcj mjvj`hpijkt hb g rjsjgrlc p`gk.

MJ]JUIAKJ U J\JGULC WZJ\]AHK 

<-7:.  Ujsjgrlc ejdaks watc tcj mjtjriakgtahk hb g rjsjgrlc qujstahk jxprjssjm ak tcj bhri hb LLAUs rjdgrmakd g

davjk thpal. Ak H\AK] jxp`hatgtahk, tcj rjsjgrlc qujstahk lgk ej egsjm hk tcj iassahk vgrage`js (IJ]]-]L) gkm

hpjrgtahkg` vgrage`js (_IJ\AA-_]). ]cj rjsjgrlc qujstahk as rjbakjm tcrhudc tcj mjvj`hpijkt hb akbhrigtahk gkm

aktj``adjklj rjquarjijkts th ej sgtasbajm. ]chsj rjquarjijkts tcgt grj kht sgtasbajm grj akl`umjm ak tcj p`gkkakd

rjquarjijkts gkm gssjssakd lh``jltahk p`gk wcjrj ihrj tjlckalg` ijgks hb lh``jltahk lgk ej uta`azjm.

MJRJ@H_ U J\JGULC _@GK 

<-72.  Mabbjrjkt bgljts hb g qujstahk igy ej jxprjssjm gs akbhrigtahk gkm aktj``adjklj rjquarjijkts. ]cjsj

rjquarjijkts bhri tcj egsas bhr tcj rjsjgrlc p`gk. G rjsjgrlc p`gk lgk usj ehtc baj`m rjsjgrlc gkm prgltalg`

rjsjgrlc. ]cj p`gk lhksasts hb  ”  

  Amjktabalgtahk hb akbhrigtahk shurljs (ehtc praigry gkm sjlhkmgry).

  Mjslraptahk hb chw th glljss tchsj shurljs.

  Bhrigt bhr lhipa`akd tcj mgtg.

  Ujsjgrlc ijtchmh`hdy.

  Massjiakgtahk bhrigt.

AI_@JIJK] U J\JGULC _@GK 

<-74.  Zta`azakd hpjk-shurlj ijmag ” tcj ijgks hb sjkmakd, rjljavakd, gkm rjlhrmakd akbhrigtahk ” 

lhiphkjkts, gkm gsshlagtjm j`jijkts (sjj tge`j <-7), H\AK] pjrshkkj` aip`jijkt g rjsjgrlc p`gk. ]cj

 praigry ijmag usjm th aip`jijkt g rjsjgrlc p`gk akl`umj ”  

  _ue`al spjgnakd bhruis.

  _ue`al mhluijkts.

  _ue`al erhgmlgsts.

  Aktjrkjt Tje satjs.

Page 35: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 35/91

Lh``jltakd H\AK]

7? Fu`y 5?75  G]_ 5-55.1 <-:

Khtj. ]cj tge`j mhjs kht a``ustrgtj gk g``-akl`usavj `ast hb hpjk-shurlj ijmag typjs eut rgtcjr tcj

lgtjdhrajs hb hpjk-shurlj ijmag th lhksamjr wcjk lh``jltakd hpjk-shurlj akbhrigtahk.

]ge`j <-7. Hpjk-shurlj ijmag, lhiphkjkts, gkm j`jijkts

Ijmag Lhip hkjkts J`jijkts

_ue`al \pjgnakd

\pjgnjr   \phkshr  Uj`gtahkscap

  Ijssgdj

Bhrigt

  Lhkbjrjklj

  Mjegtj

  Mjihkstrgtahk

  \pjjlcjs

  @jlturj

  Ug``y

  @hum spjgnjrs

  ]g`n schws

 Gumajklj   @hlgtahk   Lhiphsatahk

_ue`alMhluijkts

Drgpcal

  Mrgwakd

  Jkdrgvakd

  _gaktakd

  Drgbbata

  _chthdrgpc

  _rakt

  _hstjrs

Ujlhrmjm

  Lhipglt mgtgsthrgdj mjvalj

  Madatg` vamjh masn

  Cgrm masn

  ]gpj

_raktjm

  Ehhn

  Erhlcurj

  Kjwspgpjrs

  Igdgzakjs

  Dhvjrkijkt rj`jgsjs

  ‐Muipstjr mavakd’ 

  Gkkug`s

  _jrahmalg`

  _gipc`jt

  Ujphrt

  Khvj`tajs

  Khk-dhvjrkijkt rj`jgsjs

  @jgb`jts

  Eusakjss lgrms

_ue`al

Erhgmlgsts

Ugmah

 @hw brjqujkly GIrgmah

 Ijmaui brjqujkly GIrgmah

 \chrt wgvj rgmah

  RCB BI rgmah

  \gtj``atj rgmah

  \tgkmgrm wgvj rgmah

]j`jvasahk

  Nu egkm sgtj``atj tj`jvasahk

  RCB gkm ZCB tjrrjstrag` tj`jvasahk

  Gmvjrtasjijkts

  Ihtahk palturjs

Aktjrkjt Tje\atjs

Lhiiukalgtahks  Lcgt

  J-iga`

  Kjws> kjwsdrhup

  Tje lgi

  Tje lgst

  Tje `hd

Mgtgegsjs  Lhiijrlj

  Jmulgtahk

  Dhvjrkijkt

  Ia`atgry hrdgkazgtahks

Akbhrigtahk

(Tje pgdj lhktjkt)

  Lhiijrlj

  Jmulgtahk

  Dhvjrkijkt

  Ia`atgry hrdgkazgtahks

\jrvaljs

  Maltahkgry

  Marjlthry

  Mhwk`hgms

  Bakgklag`

  Djhspgtag`

  \jgrlc gkm ZU@ `hhnup

  ]jlckalg` supphrt

  ]rgks`gtahk

 GIBIZCB

gip`atumj ihmu`gtahkbrjqujkly ihmu`gtahku`trgcadc brjqujkly

ZU@RCB

ukabhri rjshurlj hlgthrvjry cadc brjqujkly

Page 36: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 36/91

Lcgptjr <

<-2 G]_ 5-55.1 7? Fu`y 5?75 

_ue`al \pjgnakd Bhruis

<-73.  H\AK] pjrshkkj` lhkmult rjsjgrlc ey gttjkmakd pue`al spjgnakd bhruis sulc gs lhkbjrjkljs,

`jlturjs, pue`al ijjtakds, whrnakd drhups, mjegtjs, gkm mjihkstrgtahks. Gttjkmakd tcjsj gkm saia`gr jvjkts

grj hpphrtukatajs th eua`m rj`gtahkscaps watc khkia`atgry prhbjssahkg`s gkm hrdgkazgtahks. Aktj``adjklj

 pjrshkkj` rjquarj g tchrhudc ukmjrstgkmakd hb tcj `hlg` lu`turj gkm `gws th jksurj gky lh``jltahk gltavatajs

grj ukaktrusavj gkm mh kht vah`gtj `hlg` lusthis hr `gws, sulc gs tcj Lcgtcgi Chusj Uu`j. At as

rjlhiijkmjm th cgvj tcj \FG‑s  hvjrsadct murakd sulc lh``jltahk iassahks th jksurj lhip`agklj watcGU <37-7?, prhljmurj 7?. H\AK] pjrshkkj` rjquarj satugtahkg` gwgrjkjss gkm lu`turg` ukmjrstgkmakd tcgt

as typalg``y mhkj ey jstge`ascakd ehtc ia`atgry gkm khkia`atgry rj`gtahkscaps watc gttjkmjjs, amjktabyakd gky

ihmabalgtahks hb g spjgnjr‑s ijssgdj, gkm amjktabyakd pjrshkkj` hb aktjrjst gttjkmakd tcj jvjkt.  

<-71.  H\AK] pjrshkkj` jkdgdakd ak hpjk-shurlj jxp`hatgtahk, uta`azj pue`al spjgnakd bhruis typalg``y ak

hpjrgtahkg` jkvarhkijkts mhiakgtjm ey jatcjr stgea`aty hpjrgtahks hr lhuktjraksurdjkly hpjrgtahks wcjrj

tcj `jvj` hb vah`jklj as `hw.

Khtj. ]cj Lcgtcgi Chusj Uu`j stgtjs, ‐Tcjk g ijjtakd, hr pgrt tcjrjhb, as cj`m ukmjr tcj

Lcgtcgi Chusj Uu`j, pgrtalapgkts grj brjj th usj tcj akbhrigtahk rjljavjm, eut kjatcjr tcj

amjktaty khr tcj gbba`agtahk hb tcj spjgnjrs, khr gky htcjr pgrtalapgkts, igy ej rjvjg `jm.’ 

Wujstahkakd tcj akvhlgtahk hb tcj Lcgtcgi Chusj Uu`j schu`m ej akquarjm ejbhrj tcj

jkdgdjijkt ejdaks. Gk akvhnjm Lcgtcgi Chusj Uu`j lcgkdjs tcj lcgrgltjrazgtahk hb tcj shurlj

brhi gk hpjk th g lhkbamjktag` shurlj gkm igy mjigkm lh``jltahk rjstraltahks th jksurj

lhip`agklj watc aktj``adjklj hvjrsadct `aiatgtahks. (\jj gppjkmax G.)

_ue`al Mhluijkts

<-5?.  Tcjk glquarakd pue`al mhluijkts, H\AK] pjrshkkj` iust ej gwgrj hb tcj `hlg` jkvarhkijkt gkm usj g

tjlckaquj tcgt as ukaktrusavj gkm gpprhpragtj bhr tcj satugtahk. ]cjsj tjlckaqujs akl`umj eut grj kht aiatjm th ”  

  _chthdrgpcakd gkm lhpyakd mhluijkts gvga`ge`j ak pue`al bhruis sulc gs thwk cg``s, `aergrajs, gkm

iusjuis.

  Bakmakd maslgrmjm mhluijkts ak g pue`al grjg sulc gs strjjts, igrnjts, gkm rjstrhhis.

  _chthdrgpcakd mhluijkts ak pue`al grjgs sulc gs egkkjrs, drgbbata, gkm phstjrs.

  _urlcgsakd mhluijkts marjlt`y brhi strjjt vjkmhrs, kjwspgpjr stgkms, ehhn sthrjs, gkm pue`ascjrs.

  _urlcgsakd mhluijkts tcrhudc g tcarm pgrty sulc gs g wch`jsg`j mastraeuthr hr ehhn l`ue.  Ujljavakd mhluijkts uphk rjqujst watchut lcgrdj brhi tcj gutchr, lhkbjrjkljs, trgmj bgars,

marjlt iga` gmvjrtasakd.

_ue`al Erhgmlgsts

<-57.  Ujdahkg` eurjgus hb tcj MKA H\L lh``jlt hk rjdahkg` gkm aktjrkgtahkg` erhgmlgst kjtwhrns ak

gllhrmgklj watc hpjk-shurlj akbhrigtahk gkm aktj``adjklj rjquarjijkts. Lhvjrgdj hb rjdahkg` gkm

aktjrkgtahkg` erhgmlgsts jkge`js H\AK] pjrshkkj` gkm hrdgkazgtahks th usj gssjts brhi g`rjgmy amjktabajm

shurljs. ]cj bhur tjlckaqujs usjm th glquarj akbhrigtahk hb pue`al erhgmlgsts grj ”  

  \pjltrui sjgrlc. \jgrlcakd tcj jktarj spjltrui th mjtjlt, amjktaby, gkm `hlgtj g`` jiattjrs th

lhkbari hvjrg`` gltavaty. ]cas sjgrlc prhvamjs gk hvjrvajw hb tcj gihukt gkm typjs hb gltavatajs

gkm wcjrj tcjy grj `hlgtjm ak tcj spjltrui.

  Egkm sjgrlc.  \jgrlcakd g pgrtalu`gr sjdijkt hb tcj spjltrui th lhkbari hvjrg`` gltavaty. Ey`aiatakd tcj sazj hb tcj sjgrlc egkm, tcj gssjt lgk aiprhvj tcj hmms hb glquarakd g sadkg`.

  Brjqujkly sjgrlc. \jgrlcakd bhr rgmah hr tj`jvasahk brjqujklajs.

  _rhdrgi sjgrlc. \jgrlcakd bhr rgmah hr tj`jvasahk prhdrgis. _rhdrgis vgry ey typj, lhktjkt

lcgrgltjrastals, gkm ijmag bhrigt. _rhdrgi survja``gklj vjrabajs gkm jxpgkms uphk akatag` rjsu`ts.

Page 37: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 37/91

Lh``jltakd H\AK]

7? Fu`y 5?75  G]_ 5-55.1 <-4

Khtj. Bhr ejst rjsu`ts, H\AK] pjrshkkj` schu`m usj tcjsj tjlckaqujs ak lhieakgtahk rgtcjr tcgk

akmjpjkmjkt`y th djkjrgtj aktj``adjklj nkhw`jmdj. ]cj sj`jltahk hb tcj tjlckaqujs mjpjkms hk

tcj iassahk, tcj kuiejr hb pjrshkkj`, gkm lgpgea`atajs.

<-55.  Bhr mjtga`jm akbhrigtahk hk lh``jltakd akbhrigtahk brhi pue`al erhgmlgsts, sjj tcj MKA H\L.

Aktjrkjt Tje \atjs

<-5<.  ]cj bhur stjps th glquarj akbhrigtahk hk Aktjrkjt Tje satjs grj ”  

  _`gk Aktjrkjt sjgrlc.

  Lhkmult Aktjrkjt sjgrlc.

  Ujbakj Aktjrkjt sjgrlc.

  Ujlhrm rjsu`ts.

<-5=.  Bhr ihrj mjtga`jm akbhrigtahk hk rjsjgrlc usakd Aktjrkjt Tje satjs, sjj gppjkmax L.

Page 38: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 38/91

Page 39: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 39/91

 

7? Fu`y 5?75  G]_ 5-55.1 =-7

Lcgptjr =

_rhmulakd H\AK]

]cj Griy hpjrgtjs ak mavjrsj jkvarhkijkts grhukm tcj whr`m. ]cas mavjrsaty rjquarjs prhpjr usj hb pue`al`y gvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk gkm hpjk shurljs ak tcj prhmultahk hbH\AK]. Davjk tcj vh`uij hb jxastakd pue`al`y gvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk gkm tcj

ukprjmaltgea`aty hb rjqujsts bhr akbhrigtahk gkm aktj``adjklj rjquarjijkts, H\AK] pjrshkkj` jkdgdakd ak hpjk-shurlj jxp`hatgtahk iust ej b`uam`y gwgrj hb gkm b`jxae`j

wcjk prhmulakd H\AK]. Jbbjltavj prhmultahk jksurjs tcgt lhiigkmjrs gkmsuehrmakgtjs rjljavj taij`y, rj`jvgkt, gkm gllurgtj aktj``adjklj. H\AK] pjrshkkj`

 prhmulj H\AK] ey jvg`ugtakd, gkg`yzakd, rjphrtakd, gkm massjiakgtakd aktj `adjklj gsgssjssijkts, stumajs, gkm jstaigtjs.

LG]JDHUAJ\ HB AK]J@@ADJKLJ _UHMZL]\

=-7.  Gbtjr rjljavakd g iassahk tcrhudc tcj IMI_ gkm lhiigkmjr‑s aktjkt” jxprjssjm ak tjris hb

mjslraej, vasug`azj, gkm marjlt  ” aktj``adjklj gkm akbhrigtahk rjquarjijkts grj amjktabajm. _jrshkkj`

jkdgdakd ak H\AK] jxp`hatgtahk typalg``y dgtcjr gkm rjljavj akbhrigtahk, pjrbhri rjsjgrlc, gkm rjphrt gkm

massjiakgtj akbhrigtahk ak gllhrmgklj watc tcj lgtjdhrajs hb aktj``adjklj prhmults. (\jj tge`j =-7.) H\AK]

 prhmults grj lgtjdhrazjm ey aktjkmjm usj gkm purphsj. Lgtjdhrajs lgk hvjr`gp gkm shij pue`al`y gvga`ge`j

gkm hpjk-shurlj akbhrigtahk lgk ej usjm ak ihrj tcgk hkj prhmult. (Bhr ihrj mjtga`jm akbhrigtahk hk tcj

lgtjdhrajs hb aktj``adjklj prhmults, sjj BI 5-?.)

]ge`j =-7. Lgtjdhrajs hb aktj``adjklj prhmults

Akmalgt ahks gkm Tgrkakd

Akmalgtahks gkm wgrkakd  grj aktj``adjklj gltavatajs aktjkmjm th mjtjlt gkm rjphrt taij-sjksatavj aktj``adjkljakbhrigtahk hk bhrjadk mjvj`hpijkts tcgt lhu`m akvh`vj gk tcrjgt th tcj Zkatjm \tgtjs, Z.\. g``y, hr Z.\.latazjks gerhgm. At akl`umjs bhrjwgrkakd hb chsta`j gltahks hr aktjktahks gdgakst tcj Zkatjm \tgtjs, atsgltavatajs, hvjrsjgs bhrljs, hr g``ajm/lhg`atahk kgtahks (F_ 5-?).

Lurrjkt Aktj`` adjklj

Lurrjkt aktj``adjklj supphrts hkdhakd hpjrgtahks> at akvh`vjs tcj aktjdrgtahk hb taij-sjksatavj, g``-shurljaktj``adjklj gkm akbhrigtahk akth lhklasj, gllurgtj, gkm hefjltavj rjphrtakd hk tcj grjg hb hpjrgtahks (GH)gkm lurrjkt tcrjgt satugtahk. Hkj hb tcj ihst aiphrtgkt bhris hb lurrjkt aktj``adjklj as tcj tcrjgt satugtahkphrtahk hb tcj lhiihk hpjrgtahkg` palturj. ]cj aktj``adjklj hbbaljr as rjsphksae`j bhr prhmulakd lurrjktaktj``adjklj bhr tcj ukat. Ak gmmatahk th tcj lurrjkt satugtahk, lurrjkt aktj``adjklj schu`m prhvamj prhfjltahkshb tcj tcrjgt‑s gktalapgtjm gltahks gkm tcjar aip`algtahks hk tcj brajkm`y hpjrgtahk. (\jj F_ 5-?.)

Djkjrg` Ia`atgry Aktj`` ad jklj

Djkjrg` ia`atgry aktj``adjklj as aktj``adjklj lhkljrkakd (7) ia`atgry lgpgea`atajs hb bhrjadk lhuktrajs hrhrdgkazgtahks hr (5) thpals gbbjltakd phtjktag` Z.\. hr iu`takgtahkg` ia`atgry hpjrgtahks rj`gtakd th grijmbhrljs lgpgea`atajs, akl`umakd tcrjgt lcgrgltjrastals, hrdgkazgtahk, trgakakd, tgltals, mhltrakj, strgtjdy, gkmhtcjr bglthrs ejgrakd hk ia`atgry strjkdtc gkm jbbjltavjkjss gkm grjg tjrrgak aktj``adjklj… (jxl`umjsslajktabal gkm tjlckalg` aktj``adjklj (F_ 5-?). ]cas erhgm lgtjdhry hb aktj``adjklj as khrig``y gsshlagtjmwatc `hkd-tjri p`gkkakd gt tcj kgtahkg` `jvj`.Khtj. ]cas mjbakatahk wgs schrtjkjm bhr erjvaty. ]cj lhip`jtj mjbakatahk as gvga`ge`j ak F_ 5-?.

Page 40: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 40/91

Lcgptjr =

=-5 G]_ 5-55.1 7? Fu`y 5?75 

]ge`j =-7. Lgtjdhrajs hb aktj``adjklj prhmults (lhktakujm)

]grdjt Aktj`` adjk lj

Aktj``adjklj tcgt phrtrgys gkm `hlgtjs tcj lhiphkjkts hb g tgrdjt hr tgrdjt lhip`jx gkm akmalgtjs atsvu`kjrgea`aty gkm rj`gtavj aiphrtgklj (F_ <-2?). ]grdjt aktj``adjklj as tcj gkg`ysas hb tcrjgt ukats,masphsatahks, bgla`atajs, gkm systjis th amjktaby gkm khiakgtj spjlabal gssjts hr vu`kjrgea`atajs bhr gttgln,rjgttgln, hr jxp`hatgtahk. At lhksasts hb tgrdjt mjvj`hpijkt gkm lhiegt gssjssijkt. ]grdjt mjvj`hpijkt

as tcj systjigtal jvg`ugtahk gkm gkg`ysas hb tgrdjt systjis, systji lhiphkjkts, gkm lhiphkjktj`jijkts th amjktaby cadc-vg`uj tgrdjts bhr phtjktag` jkdgdjijkt tcrhudc `jtcg` hr khk`jtcg` ijgks.Lhiegt gssjssijkts prhvamj g taij`y gkm gllurgtj jstaigtj hb tcj jbbjlts hb tcj gpp`algtahk hb ia`atgrybhrlj (`jtcg` hr khk`jtcg`) gkm iassahk lhiigkm wgrbgrj hk tgrdjts gkm tgrdjt systjis egsjm hkprjmjtjriakjm hefjltavjs. 

\lajkt a b al gkm ]jlckalg` Aktj` ` adjklj

\lajktabal gkm tjlckalg` aktj``adjklj as tcj prhmult rjsu`takd brhi tcj lh``jltahk, jvg`ugtahk, gkg`ysas, gkmaktjrprjtgtahk hb bhrjadk slajktabal gkm tjlckalg` akbhrigtahk. \lajktabal gkm tjlckalg` aktj``adjklj lhvjrsbhrjadk mjvj`hpijkts ak egsal gkm gpp`ajm rjsjgrlc gkm ak gpp`ajm jkdakjjrakd tjlckaqujs gkm slajktabalgkm tjlckalg` lcgrgltjrastals, lgpgea`atajs, gkm aiatgtahks hb g`` bhrjadk ia`atgry systjis, wjgphks, wjgphksystjis, gkm igtjraj`, tcj rj`gtjm rjsjgrlc gkm mjvj`hpijkt, gkm tcj prhmultahk ijtchms jip`hyjm bhrtcjar igkubglturj (F_ 5-?7).

Lhuktjr aktj` ` adjklj

Akbhrigtahk dgtcjrjm gkm gltavatajs lhkmultjm th amjktaby, mjljavj, jxp`hat, masrupt, hr prhtjlt gdgakst jspahkgdj,

htcjr aktj``adjklj gltavatajs, sgehtgdj, hr gssgssakgtahks lhkmultjm bhr hr hk ejcg`b hb bhrjadk phwjrs,hrdgkazgtahks hr pjrshks hr tcjar gdjkts, hr aktjrkgtahkg` tjrrhrast hrdgkazgtahks hr gltavatajs (JH 75<<<).Lhuktjraktj``adjklj gkg`yzjs tcj tcrjgts phsjm ey bhrjadk aktj``adjklj gkm sjluraty sjrvaljs, gkm aktjrkgtahkg`tjrrhrast hrdgkazgtahks, gkm tcj aktj``adjklj gltavatajs hb khk-stgtj glthrs sulc gs hrdgkazjm lraij, tjrrhrastdrhups, gkm mrud trgbbalnjrs.

Jst aigt avj

Aktj``adjklj tcgt amjktabajs, mjslraejs, gkm bhrjlgsts gmvjrsgry lgpgea`atajs gkm tcj aip`algtahks bhrp`gkkakd gkm jxjlutakd ia`atgry hpjrgtahks (F_ 5-?). Jstaigtjs prhvamj bhrjlgsts hk chw g satugtahk igymjvj`hp gkm tcj aip`algtahks hb p`gkkakd gkm jxjlutakd ia`atgry hpjrgtahks. Jstaigtavj aktj``adjklj dhjsejyhkm mjslraptahks hb tcrjgt lgpgea`atajs hr rjphrtakd hb tcrjgt gltavaty gkm trajs th bhrjlgst tcj uknkhwkegsjm hk gk gkg`ysas hb nkhwk bglts usakd tjlckaqujs sulc gs pgttjrk gkg`ysas, akbjrjklj, gkm stgtastalg`prhegea`aty.

JRG@ZG]J AKBHUIG]AHK=-5.  Hpjk shurljs grj hvjrt gkm ukl`gssabajm. Muj th tcjsj gspjlts hb pue`al`y gvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk gkm hpjk

shurljs, mjljptahk, eags, gkm masakbhrigtahk grj hb pgrtalu`gr lhkljrk wcjk jvg`ugtakd shurljs hb akbhrigtahk

murakd H\AK] jxp`hatgtahk. Akbhrigtahk as jvg`ugtjm ak tjris hb  ”  

  Lhiiukalgtahks.

  Akbhrigtahk rj`agea`aty gkm lrjmaea`aty.

LHIIZKALG]AHK\ 

=-<.  G saip`j lhiiukalgtahks ihmj` as typalg``y twh-wgy gkm lhksasts hb sax pgrts6

  Aktjkmjm ijssgdj.

  \pjgnjr (sjkmjr).

  \pjgnjr‑s jklhmjm ijssgdj.   @astjkjr (rjljavjr).

  @astjkjr‑s mjlhmjm ijssgdj. 

  _jrljavjm ijssgdj.

=-=.  ]cj spjgnjr gkm `astjkjr jglc cgvj mabbjrjkt pjrspjltavjs gkm gspjlts hb lhiiukalgtahks (gs schwk

ak tge`j =-5 hk pgdj =-=). ]cjrj grj drjgt lcg``jkdjs bglakd lhiiukalgthrs gs tcj ijssgdj ejlhijs

jklhmjm ey tcj spjgnjr gkm mjlhmjm ey tcj `astjkjr.

Page 41: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 41/91

_rhmulakd H\AK]

7? Fu`y 5?75  G]_ 5-55.1 =-<

=-:.  Lhiiukalgtahks murakd pue`al spjgnakd jkdgdjijkts grj hbtjk mabbalu`t th jvg`ugtj davjk tcj iyragm hb

j`jijkts tcgt lgk prjvjkt g sulljssbu``y trgksiattjm ijssgdj. Davjk tcj iu`tap`j j`jijkts tgnjk saiu`tgkjhus`y,

 pue al spjgnakd jvjkts grj suefjltavj gkm lgk ej iasukmjrsthhm.

=-2.  ]cj spjgnjr cgs gk aktjkmjm ijssgdj tcrhudc g vjreg`, khkvjreg`, vhlg`, hr vasug` ijmag lcgkkj` hr

lhieakgtahk tcjrjhb. Tatcak lhiiukalgtahks, tcj grjgs typalg``y akvh`vjm ak prjvjktakd tcj truj aktjkt hb tcj

ijssgdj grj tcj sjkmakd ijtchm, jkvarhkijkt, gkm rjljavakd ijtchm. Cgvakd gk ukmjrstgkmakd hb tcjsj grjgs

djkjrg``y yaj`ms g drjgtjr sulljss rgtj ejtwjjk tcj spjgnjr gkm `astjkjr.

=-4.  Rjreg` lhiiukalgtahk ejdaks watc g spjgnjr aipgrtakd hr aktjrlcgkdakd tchudcts, hpakahks, hr

akbhrigtahk. ]cas lhiiukalgtahk lgk ej jatcjr phsatavj hr kjdgtavj. ]cj typalg` spjgnjr cgs g lhiiukalgtahk

typj6

  _gssavj.

  Gddrjssavj.

  _gssavj-gddrjssavj.

  Gssjrtavj.

=-3.  \pjgnjrs lhiiukalgtj vjreg``y gkm khkvjreg``y egsjm hk tcjar ej`ajbs, jihtahks, hr dhg`s. ]cjsj

typjs hb lhiiukalgtahk grj akmalgtjm ak tge`j =-5 hk pgdj =-=. At as aiphrtgkt th ukmjrstgkm tcj mabbjrjkljs

ak lhiiukalgtahk sty`js, chw tcjy grj aktjrprjtjm ey gk gumajklj ak hrmjr th jbbjltavj`y lhiiukalgtj tcj

ijssgdj aktjkmjm gkm gvham iasukmjrstgkmakds. Jvg`ugtakd akbhrigtahk glquarjm tcrhudc pue`al spjgnakd

vjkujs lgk ej lcg``jkdakd egsjm hk tcjsj bglthrs. Zsakd tcj tge`j th lhipgrj tcjsj typjs hb lhiiukalgtahk

lgk gssast lh``jltahk pjrshkkj` ak mjtjriakakd tcj akb`ujkljs surrhukmakd lhiiukalgthrs gkm prjmaltakd

chw tcj ijssgdjs igy ej pjrljavjm. ]ge`j =-5 a``ustrgtjs gkm prhvamjs g duamj`akj th gssast ak mjtjriakakd

tcj typj hb masp`gyjm ejcgvahr, ej`ajbs, jihtahks, gkm dhg`s.

Khtj.  ]ge`j =-5 as kht aktjkmjm th stgkm g`hkj eut usjm ak supphrt hb g``-shurlj aktj``adjklj.

_ue`al`y gvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk gkm hpjk shurljs grj usjm th mjvj`hp pjrshkg`aty gkm

lcgrgltjrastal trgats hb gk akmavamug`. ]cjsj trgats akl`umj prjvahus spjjlcjs, `jlturjs, sjrihks, hr

stgtjijkts tcgt grj usjm th mjtjriakj g egsj`akj hb gktalapgtjm ejcgvahr gkm rjsphksjs. ]cjrj grj

jxtjrkg` akb`ujkljs tcgt lgk phsatavj`y hr kjdgtavj`y gbbjlt gk akmavamug`. ]cjsj jxtjrkg`

akb`ujkljs akl`umj eut grj kht `aiatjm th lhksjqujkljs hb masputakd g supjrahr‑s hpakahk, tcj

gtihspcjrj hr sjttakd (sulc gs glgmjial, rj`adahus, hr ph`atalg`), hr gk aiprhiptu pue`al

aktjrvajw usakd g qujstahk gkm gkswjr bhrigt.

AKBHUIG]AHK U J@AGEA@A]Q GKM LUJMAEA@A]Q 

=-1.  H\AK] pjrshkkj` jvg`ugtj akbhrigtahk watc rjspjlt th rj`agea`aty gkm lrjmaea`aty. At as aiphrtgkt th jvg`ugtj

tcj rj`agea`aty hb hpjk shurljs ak hrmjr th mastakduasc hefjltavj, bgltug` akbhrigtahk> eags> hr mjljptahk. ]cj rgtakd

as egsjm hk tcj suefjltavj fumdijkt hb tcj jvg`ugthr gkm tcj gllurgly hb prjvahus akbhrigtahk prhmuljm ey tcj

sgij shurlj.

=-7?.  H\AK] pjrshkkj` iust gssjss tcj rj`agea`aty gkm tcj lrjmaea`aty hb tcj akbhrigtahk akmjpjkmjkt`y hb jglc

htcjr th gvham eags. ]cj tcrjj typjs hb shurljs usjm th jvg`ugtj gkm gkg`yzj rjljavjm akbhrigtahk grj ”  

  _raigry shurljs. Cgvj marjlt glljss th tcj akbhrigtahk gkm lhkvjys tcj akbhrigtahk marjlt`y gkm

lhip`jtj`y.

  \jlhkmgry shurljs. Lhkvjys akbhrigtahk tcrhudc aktjrijmagry shurljs usakd tcj vjrkglu`gr gkm

suiigrazjs hr pgrgpcrgsjs akbhrigtahk.  Gutchratgtavj shurljs. Gllurgtj`y rjphrts akbhrigtahk brhi tcj jgmjr, dhvjrkijkt, hr ru`akd pgrty.

Khtj. \jlhkmgry gkm gutchratgtavj shurljs, sulc gs dhvjrkijkt prjss hbbaljs, lhiijrlag` kjws

hrdgkazgtahks, ph`atalg` lgipgadk stgbbs, rjsjgrlc ljktjr pue`algtahks, kjwspgpjrs, pjrahmalg`s,

mgtgegsjs, gkm `aergrajs, lgk aktjktahkg``y hr ukaktjktahkg``y gmm, mj`jtj, ihmaby, hr ba`tjr tcj

akbhrigtahk igmj gvga`ge`j th tcj pue`al.

Page 42: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 42/91

Lcgptjr =

=-= G]_ 5-55.1 7? Fu`y 5?75 

]ge`j =-5. Lhipgrashk hb lhiiukalgtahk typjs

_gssavj Gddrjssavj_gssavj- 

GddrjssavjGssjrt avj

Ejcgvahr  

 Njjps quajt.

 Mhjs kht sgy wcgtas gltug``y bj`t,

kjjmjm, hr wgktjm. Brjqujkt`y puts

hkjsj`b mhwk.

 Gph`hdazjs wcjkjxprjssakd hkjsj`b.

 Mjkajs bjj`akds hbmasgdrjjijkts hrakmabbjrjkljs.

 Jxprjssjsbjj`akds gkmwgkts gs tchudc

gky htcjr vajw asukrjgshkge`j hrstupam.

 Masiassjs,adkhrjs, hr aksu`tstcj kjjms, wgkts,gkm hpakahks hbhtcjrs.

 Bga`s th ijjt tcjjxpjltgtahks hbhtcjrs tcrhudc

–mjkage`j‑ ijgks(sulc gs bhrdjttakdhr mj`gys).

 Mjkajs pjrshkg`rjsphksaea`aty bhrgltahks.

 Jxprjssjs kjjms,wgkts, gkm bjj`akdsmarjlt`y gkm

chkjst`y. Mhjs kht gssuij

lhrrjltkjss hrjvjryhkj bjj`ssaia`gr.

 G``hws htcjrs thch`m htcjr vajwswatchut masiassg`hr aksu`ts.

Khkvjreg`

Lhiiukalgtahk  

 Iakaiazjs hkjsj`b.

 @hhns mhwk,cuklcjs schu`mjrs,gvhams jyj lhktglt.

 \pjgns shbt`y.

 Jk`grdjs hkjsj`bgkm gppjgrstcrjgtjkakd.

 Jyj lhktglt asbaxjm gkm

pjkjtrgtakd. Rhalj as `hum,

pjrcgps schutakd.

 ]ypalg``y iaialstcj pgssavj sty`j.

 Ehmy as rj`gxjm,gkm ihvjijktsgrj lgsug`.

 Jyj lhktglt asbrjqujkt eut kht

d`grakd.

Ej`ajbs  

 Htcjrs‑ kjjms grjihrj aiphrtgkt.

 Htcjrs cgvj ihrjradcts.

 Htcjrs‑lhktraeutahks grjihrj vg`uge`j.

 _jrshkg` kjjmsgrj ihrjaiphrtgkt gkmihrj fustabajm tcgkhtcjrs‑. 

 Htcjrs cgvj khpjrshkg` radcts.

 _jrshkg`lhktraeutahks grjihrj vg`uge`j.

 Jktat`jm th djt hwkwgy, jvjk gbtjrignakdlhiiatijkts thhtcjrs.

 Kht rjsphksae`j bhrpjrshkg` gltahks.

 Jvjryhkj‑s kjjmsgrj jqug``yaiphrtgkt.

 Jvjryhkj cgsjqug` radcts th ejjxprjssavj.

 Jvjryhkj cgsvg`uge`jlhktraeutahks.

 Ujsphksae`j bhrpjrshkg` ejcgvahr.

Jihtahks  

 Bjgrs rjfjltahk.

 Bjj`s cj`p`jss,brustrgtahk, gkmgkdjr.

 Ejgrs rjsjktijktthwgrm htcjrs‑iastrjgtijkt.

 Cgs rjmuljm sj`b-rjspjlt.

 Gkdry hr phwjrbu`gt tcj taij hbvalthry.

 Bjj`s rjihrsj,dua`t, hr sj`b-cgtrjmbhr curtakd htcjrs.

 Bjgrsgssjrtavjkjss.

 Ujsjkts tcjmjigkms hb htcjrs.

 Bjgrs hb ejakdlhkbrhktjm.

 Bjj`s phsatavjgehut hkjsj`b gkmtcj trjgtijkt hbhtcjrs.

 Cadc `jvj` hb sj`b-jstjji.

Dhg`s

 Gvhams lhkb`alt.

 _`jgsjs htcjrs gtgky jxpjksj.

 Davjs htcjrs

lhktrh`.

 Taks gt gkyjxpjksj th htcjrs.

 Djts lhktrh` hvjrhtcjrs.

 Djts pjrshkg` wgywatchut cgvakd thtgnj rjsphksaea`aty.

 \j`b-rjspjlt as njptey jvjryhkj.

 Jxprjssjs hkjsj`bwatchut cgvakd th

wak g`` tcj taij. Kh hkj lhktrh`s

gkyhkj j`sj.

=-77.  Khkgutchratgtavj shurljs `gln rj`agea`aty gkm trustwhrtcakjss gkm sj`mhi stgkm gpgrt brhi gutchratgtavj

shurljs. ]cj akbhrigtahk prhvamjm ey khkgutchratgtavj shurljs djkjrg``y mhjs kht supphrt thpals gdrjjm uphk gs

 ejakd truj gkm rj`age j ak glgmjiag. Khkgutchratgtavj shurljs g`sh ignj bakmakd gmmatahkg` ak-mjptc akbhrigtahk

mabbalu`t th hlgtj.

Page 43: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 43/91

_rhmulakd H\AK]

7? Fu`y 5?75  G]_ 5-55.1 =-:

=-75.  Khkgutchratgtavj shurljs grj djkjrg` y ukgvga`ge j gkm akglljssae`j ey tcj pue al. Khkgutchratgtavj

shurljs grj uklhrrhehrgtjm ey iu`tap`j pue`al shurljs hb akbhrigtahk. Jxgip`js hb khkgutchratgtavj shurljs

akl`umj eut as kht aiatjm th ”  

  Zkrjvajwjm mhluijkts brhi sj`b-pue`ascjm Tje rjphsathrajs sulc gs e`hds, Tanapjmag, ph`atalg`

satjs, gkm lhiijrlag` gmvjrtasakd.

  Igtjrag` rjljavjm vag uklhrrhehrgtjm j-iga`, cjgrsgy, hr stgtjijkts sh`j`y ak hrg` bhri.

  Akbhrig` pjrshkg` lhiiukalgtahks sulc gs `jttjrs th tcj jmathr gkm hpakahk jssgys.

=-7<.  Tcjk jvg`ugtakd shurljs hb akbhrigtahk th mjtjriakj rj`agea`aty gkm lrjmaea`aty lhksamjr  ”  

  Amjktaty. Tch prhmuljm tcj akbhrigtahk (bhr jxgip`j g stumjkt, tjglcjr, ph`atalg` hrdgkazgtahk, hr

rjphrtjr)8

  Gutchraty. Chw iulc mhjs tcj shurlj nkhw gehut tcj akbhrigtahk8

  Ihtavj. Tcy wgs tcj akbhrigtahk pue`ascjm8

  Glljss. Mam tcj shurlj cgvj marjlt glljss th tcj jvjkt hr akbhrigtahk8

  ]aij`akjss.Tcgt  as tcj mgtj hb tcj akbhrigtahk8

  Aktjrkg` gkm jxtjrkg` lhksastjkly. Mhjs tcj akbhrigtahk lhktrgmalt dhvjrkijktg` ph`alajs gihkd

`hlg` latazjks8

_UHLJ\\ AKBHUIG]AHK =-7=.  _rhljss  as gk akbhrigtahk igkgdjijkt gltavaty6 th rgasj tcj ijgkakd hb akbhrigtahk brhi mgtg th

nkhw`jmdj (BI 2-?). ]cj bukltahk hb prhljssakd, g`tchudc kht g lhiphkjkt hb tcj aktj``adjklj prhljss, as g

lratalg` j`jijkt ak tcj gkg`yzakd gkm prhmulakd hb H\AK]. _ue`al`y gvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk gkswjrs

aktj``adjklj gkm akbhrigtahk rjquarjijkts. Egsjm hk tcj typj hb akbhrigtahk rjljavjm, at iust ej prhljssjm

 ejbhrj ejakd rjphrtjm gkm massjiakgtjm gs bakg`azjm H\AK]. Aktj``adjklj pjrshkkj` trgksbhri pue`al`y

gvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk gkm hpjk shurljs akth g bhri suatge`j bhr prhljssakd ey ”  

  Madatazakd.

  ]rgkslraeakd gkm trgks`gtakd.

MADA]AVAKD 

=-7:.  H\AK] pjrshkkj` lrjgtj g madatg` rjlhrm hb mhluijkts ey slgkkakd hr tgnakd madatg` pchthdrgpcs.

_jrtakjkt akbhrigtahk gehut tcj mhluijkt iust ej gkkhtgtjm th jksurj gllhuktgea`aty gkm trgljgea`aty.Madatazgtahk jkge`js tcj massjiakgtahk hb tcj mhluijkt th jxtjrkg` mgtgegsjs gkm hrdgkazgtahks, gs wj`` gs

jkge`js tcj usj hb iglcakj trgks`gtahk thh`s th slrjjk mhluijkts bhr njywhrms, kgijs, gkm pcrgsjs.

]UGK\LUAEAKD GKM ]UGK\@G]AKD 

=-72.  G trgkslrapt  rjbjrs th g wrattjk vjregtai, kgtavj `gkdugdj rjkmjrakd hb tcj sphnjk whrms ak gk gumah hr

vamjh rjlhrmakd. Ehtc `astjkakd gkm wratakd prhbalajkly ak tcj shurlj `gkdugdj grj jssjktag` bhr gk gllurgtj

trgkslrapt. ]cj trgkslrapt akl`umjs mjslraptahks hb tcj gltavaty, eglndrhukm, gkm lhkmatahks tcgt tcj trgkslraejr

cjgrs ak tcj gumah gkm hesjrvjs ak tcj vamjh. ]cj `akduast usjs hk`akj maltahkgrajs, dgzjttjjrs, whrnakd gams, gkm

shbtwgrj th aiprhvj tcj trgkslrapt. Hklj lhip`jtjm, tcj trgkslraptahk as sjkt th g qug`aty lhktrh` akduast.

=-74.  G trgks`gtahk  as kht vjregtai eut gk gpprhxaigtahk hb tcj `atjrg` gkm aip`ajm ijgkakd hb tcj bhrjadk

`gkdugdj. ]cj `akduast iust ej ge`j th rjgm gkm lhiprjcjkm tcj shurlj `gkdugdj, wratj lhiprjcjksae`y ak

Jkd`asc, gkm lchhsj tcj jquavg`jkt jxprjssahk ak Jkd`asc tcgt bu``y lhkvjys gkm ejst igtlcjs tcj ijgkakdaktjkmjm ak tcj shurlj `gkdugdj.

=-73.  Murakd prhljssakd, g `akduast lrjgtjs jatcjr gk jxtrglt, g suiigry, hr g bu`` trgks`gtahk hb tcj hradakg`

mhluijkt hr trgkslrapt akth g stgkmgrmazjm bhrigt jstge`ascjm ey ukat \H_s. ]cj `akduast usjs hk`akj maltahkgrajs,

dgzjttjjrs, whrnakd gams, gkm shbtwgrj th aiprhvj tcj trgks`gtahk. Hklj lhip`jtjm, tcj trgks`gtahk as sjkt th g

qug`aty lhktrh` akduast.

Page 44: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 44/91

Lcgptjr =

=-2 G]_ 5-55.1 7? Fu`y 5?75 

=-71.  @akduasts pjrbhri qug`aty lhktrh` rjvajws hb jglc trgkslraptahk gkm trgks`gtahk th jksurj ehtc qug`aty

gkm lhksastjkly watc jstge`ascjm ukat \H_s. G Z.\. Dhvjrkijkt hr ia`atgry `akduast schu`m rjvajw g``

akbhrigtahk tcgt g khk-Z.\. Dhvjrkijkt `akduast prhljssjs watc jxljptahks akvh`vakd `hkd-tjri

iu`takgtahkg` pgrtkjrs hb tcj Zkatjm \tgtjs gkm Z.\. lhktrglthrs watc tcj rjquasatj sna``s gkm tcj lhkbamjklj

hb tcj lhiigkm. @akduastal qug`aty lhktrh` as gk aiphrtgkt bgljt th prhljss bhrjadk pue`al`y gvga`ge`j

akbhrigtahk. Jglc trgkslraptahk gkm trgks`gtahk ukmjrdhjs twh `jvj`s hb rjvajw6

  Wug`aty lhktrh`. Murakd qug`aty lhktrh`, g qug`abajm `akduast jksurjs tcgt tcj trgkslraptahk hrtrgks`gtahk as gllurgtj, lhip`jtj, brjj hb eags, gkm ak gllhrmgklj watc rjphrtakd gkm

massjiakgtahk stgkmgrms. ]cj Z.\. `akduast rjturks tcj trgkslrapt hr trgks`gtahk bhr lhrrjltahk,

gmms hr lhrrjlts iassjm lhktjkt, hr lhrrjlts iakhr bhrigt jrrhrs. Zphk lhip`jtahk hb qug`aty

lhktrh`, tcj trgkslraptahk hr trgks`gtahk as gvga`ge`j bhr prhljssakd.

  Wug`aty gssurgklj. Murakd qug`aty gssurgklj, g qug`abajm Z.\. `akduast hr H\AK] gkg`yst

rjvajws tcj trgkslrapt hr trgks`gtahk th jksurj tcgt at lhktgaks g`` rjquarjm akbhrigtahk gkm rjgms

kgturg``y ak Jkd`asc. Hklj rjvajwjm, tcj lhip`jtjm trgkslraptahk hr trgks`gtahk as sgvjm th

aktjrkg` mgtgegsjs th ej prhljssjm bhr rjphrtakd gkm massjiakgtahk.

GKG@Q\A\ HB IJMAG \HZULJ\ 

=-5?.  Gkg`ysas hb tcj ijmag as tcj systjigtal lhipgrashk hb tcj lhktjkt, ejcgvahr, pgttjrks, gkm trjkms hb

hrdgkal ijmag hrdgkazgtahks gkm shurljs hb g lhuktry. Gkg`ysas hb tcj ijmag gs gk gltavaty wgs mjvj`hpjm

gkm egsjm hk ijtchms gkm jxpjrajklj dgakjm murakd H\AK] jxp`hatgtahk gdgakst gutchratgragk ph`atalg`systjis murakd tcj Thr`m Tgr AA gkm Lh`m Tgr jrgs wcjrj ijmag wgs dhvjrkijkt-lhktrh``jm. _ue`al`y

gvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk gkm hpjk shurljs iust ej gkg`yzjm bhr prhpjr akl`usahk ak H\AK] prhljssakd.

H\AK] pjrshkkj` wjadc ijmag gkg`ysas gdgakst sjt lratjrahk. ]cjsj lratjrahks gssast H\AK] pjrshkkj` th

masljrk bglts, akmalgthrs, pgttjrks, gkm trjkms ak akbhrigtahk gkm rj`gtahkscaps. ]cas akvh`vjs akmultavj hr

mjmultavj rjgshkakd th ukmjrstgkm tcj ijgkakd hb pgst jvjkts gkm prjmalt buturj gltahks.

=-57.  Lhipgrashk hb trjkms ak tcj lhktjkt hb akmavamug` ijmag watc scabts ak hbbalag` ph`aly suddjsts tcgt

shij ijmag lhktakujs th iarrhr tcj mhiakgkt ph`aly `akj. Ey jstge`ascakd g trgln rjlhrm bhr ijmag tcgt as

vu`kjrge`j th jxtjrkg` gkm aktjrkg` prjssurj th bh``hw tcj ljktrg` ph`aly `akj, H\AK] pjrshkkj` lgk amjktaby

 phtjktag` ph`aly scabts. Lhipgrashk hb wcgt as sgam  gkm wcgt as kht sgam  gdgakst tcj eglndrhukm hb wcgt

htcjrs grj sgyakd  gkm wcgt cgs ejjk sgam  ejbhrj as tcj lhrj hb ijmag shurlj gkg`ysas.

=-55.  Ijmag shurlj gkg`ysas as g`sh aiphrtgkt ak sjia-lhktrh``jm gkm akmjpjkmjkt ijmag jkvarhkijkts. Ak

ijmag jkvarhkijkts wcjrj ehtc hbbalag` gkm khkhbbalag` ijmag grj prjsjkt, hbbalag` ijmag igy ej prjssurjmth bh``hw tcj ljktrg` ph`aly `akj. Gkg`yzakd ijmag ak tcjsj jkvarhkijkts iust jklhipgss ehtc tcj

 fhurkg`ast gkm lhiijktgthr `jvj`. At as aiphrtgkt th jstge`asc tcj trgln rjlhrm hb sulc akmavamug`s th maslhvjr

glljss th aksamjr akbhrigtahk brhi pgrts hb tcj dhvjrkijkt hr ejakd usjm ey hbbalag`s th b`hgt ph`alajs.

Khtj. Mabbjrjkljs ak lhktjkt ejtwjjk ijmag hut`jts lhktrh``jm ey mabbjrjkt hbbalag` j`atjs lgk

rjvjg` ph`aly gkm `jgmjrscap masputjs. Bhr jxgip`j, g rjphrt hk g spjjlc ey tcj _rjsamjkt

lhvjrjm ey dhvjrkijkt-lhktrh``jm ijmag igy rjvjg` mabbjrjkljs brhi rjphrts lhvjrakd tcj sgij

spjjlc ak jatcjr g sjia-lhktrh``jm hr akmjpjkmjkt ijmag jkvarhkijkt.

=-5<.  ]cj tcrjj gspjlts hb ijmag shurlj gkg`ysas grj ”  

  Ijmag lhktrh`.

  Ijmag strulturj.

  Ijmag lhktjkt.

Page 45: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 45/91

_rhmulakd H\AK]

7? Fu`y 5?75  G]_ 5-55.1 =-4

Ijmag Lhktrh` 

=-5=.  Gkg`yzakd ijmag jkvarhkijkts ak tjris hb ijmag lhktrh` rjquarjs gwgrjkjss ey aktj``adjklj

 pjrshkkj` hb chw mabbjrjkt j`jijkts hb tcj ijmag glt, akb`ujklj, gkm grj hb aktj``adjklj vg`uj. Lgrjbu`

jxgiakgtahk hb tcj mabbjrjkljs ak chw ijmag as cgkm`jm ak mabbjrjkt typjs hb jkvarhkijkts lgk prhvamj

aksadct akth mhijstal gkm bhrjadk dhvjrkijkt strgtjdajs. Ijmag jkvarhkijkts grj lgtjdhrazjm gs ”  

  Dhvjrkijkt-lhktrh``jm.

  Lhktrh` hvjr tcj ijmag as ljktrg`azjm.

  ]cj mhiakgkt j`jijkt hb lhktrh` as tcj dhvjrkijkt gkm cadcjr tajrs hb ph`atalg` `jgmjrscap.

  Dhvjrkijkts usj ljkshrscap ijlcgkasis th jxjrlasj lhktrh` hvjr ijmag lhktjkt prahr th

massjiakgtahk hb akbhrigtahk.

  \jia-lhktrh``jm.

  Lhktrh` hvjr tcj ijmag as sjia-ljktrg`azjm.

  Dhvjrkijkts jxjrlasj gkm prhihtj sj`b-ljkshrscap ey prjssurakd ijmag igkgdjrs gkm

 fhurkg`asts prahr th massjiakgtahk hb akbhrigtahk.

  Akmjpjkmjkt.

  Lhktrh` hvjr tcj ijmag as mjljktrg`azjm.

  Dhvjrkijkts igy rjdu`gtj g``hlgtahk hb erhgmlgst brjqujklajs, ihrg`aty ak lhktjkt,

hwkjrscap ak ijmag igrnjts, gkm hllgsahkg``y gpp`y ph`atalg` prjssurj gdgakst ijmag hr fhurkg`asts.

  Jlhkhial bglthrs, khris hb tcj fhurkg`ast prhbjssahk, tcj prjbjrjkljs hb pjhp`j wch igkgdj

ijmag, gkm tcj qug`atajs hb akmavamug` fhurkg`asts wch rjphrt hr lhiijkt hk tcj kjws g``

akb`ujklj hr lhktrh` ijmag lhktjkt.

=-5:.  G`` ijmag jkvarhkijkts grj lhktrh``jm th shij mjdrjj gkm tcjrjbhrj jgsajr th pjrbhri ijmag shurlj

gkg`ysas. ]cj lcg``jkdj bhr H\AK] pjrshkkj` as th mjtjriakj tcj `jvj`, bglthrs, gkm j`jijkts (sjj tge`j =-<) tcgt

j`atjs, akstatutahks, hr akmavamug`s jxjrlasj lhktrh`, chw iulc phwjr jglc phssjssjs, gkm wcgt grjgs grj hb aktjrjst

th sgtasby aktj``adjklj gkm akbhrigtahk rjquarjijkts.

]ge`j =-<. @jvj`, bglthrs, gkm j`jijkts hb ijmag lhktrh`

@jvj` Bglthr J`jijkts

_h`at alg`

]cj `gws gkm khris dhvjrkakd

hpjrgtahks hb tcj ijmag, hbbalag`s, gkmtcj mastraeutahk hb phwjr

  ]hp `jgmjrscap lhksjksus

  ]hp `jgmjrs akmavamug``y

  Akstatutahks

Fhurkg` as t

]cj mjdrjj hb brjjmhi gbbhrmjm thtcj ijmag ey tcj ph`atalg` systji tcgtas suehrmakgtjm brhi ijmagjxjlutavjs, th ijmag igkgdjrs, gkmth akmavamug` fhurkg`asts

  Ehgrm hb marjlthrs hb ijmaglhipgkajs

  Akmavamug` marjlthrs

  Akb`ujktag` scgrjch`mjrs

  Igkgdakd jmathrs

  Mjpgrtijkt jmathrs

  _rhdrgi prhmuljrs

  Gklchrs

  Akmavamug` fhurkg`ast

Akmav amug`

]cj `gws gkm khris dhvjrkakd tcjgppjgrgklj gkm ejcgvahr hbakmavamug`s ak tcj ijmag

  Drhup hb suefjlts hr pgrtalapgkts

  Akmavamug` suefjlt hr pgrtalapgkt

Ijmag \trulturj

=-52.  Ijmag strulturj jklhipgssjs gttraeutjs hb ijmag igtjrag`. ]cjrj grj strulturg` j`jijkts tcgt gbbjlt tcj

ijgkakd gkm sadkabalgklj hb tcj lhktjkt hb tcj atji gkm grj hbtjk gs aiphrtgkt gs tcj lhktjkt atsj`b. Gkg`ysas hb

tcjsj j`jijkts uklhvjrs aksadcts akth tcj phakts hb vajw hb pjrshkkj` ak dhvjrkijkt-lhktrh``jm, sjia-lhktrh``jm,

gkm akmjpjkmjkt jkvarhkijkts th jstge`asc tcj strulturj hb ijmag j`jijkts.

Page 46: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 46/91

Lcgptjr =

=-3 G]_ 5-55.1 7? Fu`y 5?75 

=-54.  ]cj ijmag strulturg` j`jijkts grj ”  

  \j`jltahk, hiassahk, gkm s`gkt.

  Cajrgrlcy hb phwjr.

  Bhrigt.

  Ijmag typj.

  _rhiakjklj.

  Massjiakgtahk.

  ]aiakd.

\jjltahk, Hiassahk, gkm \`gkt

=-53.  \j`jltahk hb ijmag atjis as g bukmgijktg` jmathrag` mjlasahk gt tcj lhrj hb kjws rjphrtakd. \j`jltahk

akl`umjs ijmag igkgdjr mjlasahks gehut wcalc sthrajs grj lhvjrjm, wcalc sthrajs grj kht lhvjrjm, gkm wcalc

s`gkt (vajwphakt), aigdjs, gkm akbhrigtahk schu`m ej akl`umjm, jipcgsazjm, mjjipcgsazjm, hr hiattjm ak g kjws

atji.

C ajrgrlcy hb _hwjr

=-51.  G`` ph`atalg` systjis akvh`vj g cajrgrlcy hb phwjr (sjj tge`j =-=) tcgt `hdalg``y bh``hws hbbalag` stgtjijkts

assujm ey j`jijkts ak lhrrjsphkmakd cajrgrlcy hb gutchratgtavjkjss. Gutchratgtavjkjss as tcj `anj`achhm tcgt tcj

vajws jxprjssjm ak tcj stgtjijkt rjprjsjkt tcj mhiakgkt vajwphakt watcak tcj ph`atalg` systji. ]cj cajrgrlcy as

hevahus gt tcj ph`atalg` jvj ” g stgtjijkt ey tcj praij iakastjr truips g stgtjijkt ey g iakastjr. Ak htcjr lgsjs,

tcj cajrgrlcy igy kht ej sh hevahus ” g spjjlc ey tcj pgrty lcgarigk as ihrj gutchratgtavj tcgk tcj cjgm hb stgtj.

]ge`j =-=. Cajrgrlcy hb ijmag phwjr

Akbhrigtahk

]ypj_urphsj Jxgip`j

Ujphrts Akbhri tcj vajwjr, `astjkjr, hr rjgmjr Gutchratgtavj hr khkgutchratgtavj egsjm hk trglnrjlhrm

Lhiijktgrygkm jmathrag`s

\tgtj g phsatahk hr hpakahk gkm pjrsugmjtcj vajwjr, `astjkjr, hr rjgmjr

Lhiijktgthrs Gutchratgtavj6

  Nkhw psjumhkyi hb thp `jgmjr

  Nkhwk gmvashr th _raij Iakastjr

  Gsshlagtjm watc igfhr pgrty

  Lhktraeuthr th g igfhr pgpjr

Jmathrs

 Gutchratgtavj6

  Uu`akd pgrty‑s `jgmjrs hr `grdj mhkhrs 

  @grdj sjdijkt hb ph`atalg` hr bakgklag` j`atj

  @grdj kuiejrs hb vhtjrs hr sig``lgipgadk lhktraeuthrs

  \ig`` sjdijkt hb vhtjrs hr phpu`gtahk watcspjlag` aktjrjsts hr rgmalg` vajws

  @hlg` hbbalag`s gkm latazjks

Hbbalag`\tgtjijkt

Mjl`grgtahk hb ph`aly hr phsatahk ey gkhbbaljr hr gk jxjlutavj ehmy hb tcjdhvjrkijkt hr ru`akd pgrty

 Gutchratgtavj6

  _rjsamjkt  \jlrjtgry hb \tgtj

  \tgtj Mjpgrtijkt sphnjspjrshk

Page 47: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 47/91

_rhmulakd H\AK]

7? Fu`y 5?75  G]_ 5-55.1 =-1

Bhrigt

=-<?.  Bhrigt lhksasts hb chw ijmag as prhmuljm gkm massjiakgtjm bhr pue`al lhksuiptahk. Bhrigt lgk ej

ak tcj bhri hb g `avj kjws rjphrt, g `avj aktjrvajw, hr g prjrjlhrmjm rjphrt hr aktjrvajw tcgt davjs

akmavamug`s ihrj hpphrtukaty th akb`ujklj tcj lhktjxt mj`avjrjm th lhksuijrs.

Ijmag ]ypj

=-<7.  ]j`jvasahk as tcj ijmaui watc tcj `grdjst phtjktag` gumajklj ak ijmag jkvarhkijkts gkm cgs g

sadkabalgkt aipglt ak scgpakd tcj aiprjssahks hb tcj djkjrg` vajwakd pue`al. ]j`jvasahk cgs rjp`gljm rgmah

gs tcj igak shurlj hb kjws jxljpt ak ijmag jkvarhkijkts wcjrj phvjrty prjvjkts igss glljss th tj`jvasahk.

Bjwjr pjhp`j igy djt akbhrigtahk brhi kjwspgpjrs gkm Aktjrkjt kjws Tje satjs, eut tcjsj pjhp`j igy ej

ralcjr, ejttjr jmulgtjm, gkm ihrj akb`ujktag` tcgk tcj djkjrg` tj`jvasahk gumajklj. \pjlag`azjm prakt

 pue`algtahks gkm Aktjrkjt Tje satjs rjglc g sta`` sig``jr gumajklj, eut tcj gumajklj wa`` `anj`y akl`umj

hbbalag`s gkm jxpjrts wch tcgt cgvj akb`ujklj hk ph`aly mjegtjs gkm hutlhijs.

_rhiakjklj

=-<5.  Wujstahks th lhksamjr pjrtgakakd th prhiakjklj hb ijmag sthrajs grj ”  

  Mhjs tcj sthry gppjgr hk tcj brhkt pgdj hb kjwspgpjrs hr hk tcj chijpgdj hb kjws Tje satjs8

  Chw iulc spglj as tcj sthry davjk8

  Ak wcgt hrmjr mhjs tcj sthry gppjgr ak tcj kjws erhgmlgst8

  As at bjgturjm ak tcj hpjkakd prjvajws hb tcj kjwslgst8

  Chw brjqujkt`y as tcj sthry rjerhgmlgst hk suesjqujkt kjwslgsts hr eu``jtaks8

  Chw iulc gartaij mam at djt8

Massjiakgtahk

=-<<.  Gttjktahk th pgttjrks hb massjiakgtahk hb `jgmjr stgtjijkts as aiphrtgkt ak dhvjrkijkt-lhktrh``jm

ijmag jkvarhkijkts. @jgmjrs lhiiukalgtj pue`al`y ak g vgrajty hb wgys sulc gs bhrig` ph`aly stgtjijkts,

bhrig` aktjrvajws, gkm aiprhiptu rjigrns. Ey lhipgrakd tcj vh`uij hb ijmag gttjktahk davjk th g

stgtjijkt, mjtjriakgtahk as igmj th wcjtcjr tcj stgtjijkt wgs aktjkmjm th ej tgnjk gs g prhkhukljijkt hb

jstge`ascjm ph`aly hr ijrj`y gs gk gm chl, uklhhrmakgtjm jxprjssahk prhiptjm ey kgrrhw lhktjxtug` hr

tjiphrg` lhkmatahks.

]aiakd

=-<=.  H\AK] pjrshkkj` cgvj trgmatahkg``y pgam l`hsj gttjktahk th tcj taiakd hb tcj gppjgrgklj hb

akbhrigtahk ak tcj ijmag gs tcj akbhrigtahk lhrrjsphkms th tcj kjws lyl`j. G kjws lyl`j as tcj prhljss gkm

taiakd ey wcalc mabbjrjkt typjs hb ijmag shurljs hetgak akbhrigtahk, aklhrphrgtj hr turk tcj akbhrigtahk

akth g prhmult, gkm ignj tcj prhmult gvga`ge`j th tcj pue`al.

Ijmag Lhktjkt

=-<:.  Zkmjrstgkmakd tcj sadkabalgklj hb ijmag lhktjkt lgk jkcgklj tcj vg`uj hb ijmag shurlj gkg`ysas.

Ijmag lhktjkt jklhipgssjs tcj j`jijkts hb  ”  

  Igkabjst lhktjkt.

  @gtjkt lhktjkt.

Igkab jst Lhktjkt

=-<2.  Igkabjst lhktjkt as tcj gltug` whrms, aigdjs, gkm shukms lhkvjyjm ey hpjk shurljs. Hkj hb tcj ihst

aiphrtgkt bhris hb ijmag shurlj gkg`ysas akvh`vjs tcj lgrjbu` lhipgrashk hb tcj lhktjkt hb gutchratgtavj

hbbalag` stgtjijkts th amjktaby tcj ph`alajs hr aktjktahks rjprjsjktjm. Dhvjrkijkts, ph`atalg` jktatajs, gkm

glthrs usj stgtjijkts gkm akbhrigtahk rj`jgsjm th tcj ijmag th strjkdtcjk, supphrt, gkm prhihtj ph`alajs.

Page 48: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 48/91

Lcgptjr =

=-7? G]_ 5-55.1 7? Fu`y 5?75 

=-<4.  Igkabjst lhktjkt gkg`ysas hb gutchratgtavj pue`al stgtjijkts as gk jbbjltavj thh` th masljrk `jgmjrscap

aktjktahks gkm gttatumjs. Igkabjst lhktjkt, ak hrmjr th ej jbbjltavj, lhksasts hb tcj bh``hwakd6

  Jshtjral lhiiukalgtahks hr ‐rjgmakd ejtwjjk tcj `akjs’ grj pue`al stgtjijkts wchsj surbglj

ijgkakd (igkabjst lhktjkt) mhjs kht rjvjg` tcj rjg` purphsj, ijgkakd, hr sadkabalgklj (`gtjkt

lhktjkt) hb tcj gutchr. Jshtjral lhiiukalgtahk as pgrtalu`gr`y jvamjkt ak ph`atalg` systjis watc

strhkd tgehhs gdgakst pue`al lhktjktahk hr ak lgsjs wcjrj sjksatavj assujs grj gt stgnj. Jshtjral

lhiiukalgtahk as ihrj bhrig`azjm ak shij ijmag jkvarhkijkts tcgk ak htcjrs eut as lhiihk akg`` ph`atalg` lhiiukalgtahks.

  Iu`taijmag lhktjkt  gkg`ysas lhksamjrs j`jijkts hb lhktjkt ejyhkm tcj whrms usjm sulc gs

bglag` jxprjssahks, vhalj akb`jltahks hb `jgmjrs davakd g spjjlcjs hr wca`j ejakd aktjrvajwjm, hr

tcj rjgmakd hb g slrapt ey g kjws erhgmlgstjr g`` prhvamj akmalgthrs gehut tcj vajws hb g suefjlt

hr thpal. ]cjsj akmalgthrs gssast th mjtjriakj wcjtcjr g stgtjijkt wgs sjrahus`y lhksamjrjm,

aktjkmjm th ej cuihrhus, hr saip`y aiprhiptu.

  Casthralg` hr pgst ejcgvahr  hb hpjk shurljs iust ej lhksamjrjm. Akb`ujkljs sulc gs ijmag

hut`jt, fhurkg`ast, kjwsignjr, hr kjws erhgmlgstjr grj bglthrs ejyhkm aiijmagtj lhktrh`. Htcjr

assujs sulc gs taij prjssurjs, mjgm`akjs, hr tjlckalg` ig`bukltahks, igy g`sh gbbjlt tcj lhktjkt hr

lhktjxt hb pue`al akbhrigtahk. Gkg`ysts‑ fumdijkts gehut shurlj ejcgvahr iust ej igmj watc

lgrjbu` lhksamjrgtahk hb prjvahus ejcgvahr.

@gtjkt Lhktjkt

=-<3.  @gtjkt lhktjkt rjbjrs th tcj cammjk ijgkakd hb g tchudct. @gtjkt lhktjkt lgk rjvjg` pgttjrks gehut tcj

vajws gkm gltahks hb tcj ijmag lhktrh``jrs. ]cjsj pgttjrks gkm ru`js lhij brhi tcj ukstgtjm lhktjkt tcgt prhvamjs

tcj ukmjr`yakd ijgkakd hb ijmag lhktjkt gkm ejcgvahr. Tcjk g pgttjrk hb lhktjkt as lcgkdjm, akbjrjklj hb g

lcgkdj ak tcj vajwphakt hb tcj lhktrh``jr hr g lcgkdj ak tcj eg`gklj hb phwjr gihkd mabbjrjkt lhktrh``akd

j`jijkts cgs hllurrjm.

UJ_HU] GKM MA\\JIAKG]J AKBHUIG]AHK

=-<1.  Aktj``adjklj gkm akbhrigtahk rjquarjijkts sgtasbajm tcrhudc pue`al`y gvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk gkm hpjk

shurljs schu`m ej aiijmagtj`y rjphrtjm gkm massjiakgtjm ak gllhrmgklj watc ukat \H_s tcgt grj djkjrg``y

ljktjrjm hk aktj``adjklj rjquarjijkts, akbhrigtahk lratalg`aty, gkm akbhrigtahk sjksatavaty.

Khtj . \tgbb pjrshkkj` kht marjlt`y gssadkjm th tcj H\AK] sjltahk g`sh glquarj akbhrigtahk tcgt asaklhrphrgtjm watcak tcj rukkakd jstaigtj hb jglc stgbb j`jijkt. L`hsj lhhpjrgtahk ejtwjjk tcjsj

akmavamug`s bhstjrs g supphrtavj jkvarhkijkt gehut wcgt   gkm chw  th rjphrt akbhrigtahk hb

 phtjktag` hpjrgtahkg` hr aktj``adjklj vg`uj tcrhudc tcj prhpjr lcgkkj`s.

=-=?.  Bakg`azjm H\AK] sjrvjs kh purphsj uk`jss at as taij`y, gllurgtj, gkm prhpjr`y massjiakgtjm th

lhiigkmjrs gkm lusthijrs ak g usjge`j bhri. Ujphrtakd gkm massjiakgtakd g bakg`azjm H\AK] prhmult tcgt

sgtasbajs aktj``adjklj gkm akbhrigtahk rjquarjijkts akl`umj eut grj kht `aiatjm th ”  

  \akd`j maslap`akj hr iu`tamaslap`akj jstaigtjs hr gssjssijkts.

  \tgtjijkts hb bglts.

  Jvg`ugtahks hb tcrjgt lgpgea`atajs gkm `aiatgtahks.

  ]cj tcrjgt‑s `anj`y LHGs.

U J_HU]AKD DZAMJ@AKJ\ GKM IJ]CHM\ 

=-=7.  Jbbjltavj massjiakgtahk lrjgtjs g ijlcgkasi hb bjjmegln ak hrmjr th gssjss usjbu`kjss gkm prjmalt hr

gssjss buturj aktj``adjklj gkm akbhrigtahk rjquarjijkts. ]cj hefjltavj ak rjphrtakd gkm massjiakgtakd

aktj``adjklj gkm akbhrigtahk as th prhvamj rj`jvgkly th supphrt lhkmultakd (p`gkkakd, prjpgrakd, jxjlutakd,

gkm gssjssakd) hpjrgtahks.

Page 49: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 49/91

_rhmulakd H\AK]

7? Fu`y 5?75  G]_ 5-55.1 =-77

=-=5.  ]cj egsal duamj`akjs ak prjpgrakd prhmults bhr rjphrtakd gkm massjiakgtakd akbhrigtahk grj ”  

  ]aij`y. Akbhrigtahk schu`m ej rjphrtjm th gbbjltjm ukats watchut mj`gy bhr tcj sh`j purphsj hb

jksurakd tcj lhrrjlt bhrigt.

  Uj`jvgkt. Akbhrigtahk iust lhktraeutj th tcj gkswjrakd hb aktj``adjklj rjquarjijkts. Uj`jvgkt

akbhrigtahk rjmuljs lh``jltahk, hrdgkazgtahk, gkm trgksiassahk taijs.

  Lhip`jtj. _rjslraejm bhrigts gkm \H_s jksurj lhip`jtjkjss hb trgksiattjm akbhrigtahk.

=-=<.  ]cj tcrjj rjphrtakd ijtchms usjm th lhkvjy aktj``adjklj gkm akbhrigtahk grj ”  

  Trattjk. Ijtchms akl`umj bhrigts (spht rjphrts), tgltalg` rjphrts (]GLUJ_s), hr akbhrigtahk

aktj``adjklj rjphrts (AAUs).

  Drgpcal. Tje-egsjm rjphrt massjiakgtahk as gk jbbjltavj tjlckaquj th jksurj tcj wamjst gwgrjkjss hb

wrattjk gkm drgpcalg` akbhrigtahk glrhss jlcj`hks. H\AK] pjrshkkj` lgk lh``gehrgtj gkm prhvamj

stgtusjs hb aktj``adjklj rjquarjijkts tcrhudc Tje satjs. Akbhrigtahk lgk g`sh ej up`hgmjm th vgrahus

mgtgegsjs th supphrt buturj hpjk-shurlj iassahks gkm hpjrgtahks.

  Rjreg` gkm vhalj. ]cj ihst lhiihk wgy th massjiakgtj aktj``adjklj gkm akbhrigtahk vjreg``y as

tcrhudc g ia`atgry erajbakd. Egsjm hk tcj lratalg`aty, sjksatavaty, gkm taij`akjss hb tcj akbhrigtahk, gm

chl gkm aiprhiptu vjreg` lhiiukalgtahk ijtchms grj tcj ihst jbbalajkt th mj`avjr akbhrigtahk th

lhiigkmjrs.

\JLZUA]Q MHIGAK\ =-==.  H\AK] as massjiakgtjm vag sjluraty mhigaks. G sjluraty mhigak as gk gpp`algtahk hr lh``jltahk hb

gpp`algtahks tcgt scgrj tcj sgij gutcjktalgtahk hr gutchrazgtahk. G sjluraty mhigak mjtjriakjs tcj hvjrg``

l`gssabalgtahk hb gk jkl`gvj hb sjrvjrs, lhiputjrs, hr kjtwhrns. Kjtwhrns grj sjpgrgtjm ey l`gssabalgtahk ak

hrmjr th prjvjkt tcj lhiprhiasj hb akbhrigtahk. H\AK] hrdgkazgtahks lgk jxlcgkdj pue`al`y gvga`ge`j

akbhrigtahk hk ukl`gssabajm gkm l`gssabajm kjtwhrns glrhss jlcj`hks ejtwjjk Griy gkm htcjr grijm bhrljs

gs wj`` gs fhakt hrdgkazgtahks gkm bjmjrg`, stgtj, gkm `hlg` dhvjrkijkt gdjklajs.

=-=:.  ]cj rjp`algtahk hb Tje satjs gkm mgtgegsjs brhi ukl`gssabajm kjtwhrns th l`gssabajm kjtwhrns jksurj

 pue`al`y gvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk, hpjk shurljs, gkm bakg`azjm H\AK] prhmults grj rjphrtjm gkm massjiakgtjm

th aktj``adjklj gkm khkaktj``adjklj pjrshkkj` th supphrt ukabajm `gkm hpjrgtahks. ]cj jstge`ascijkt hb gk

jbbjltavj H\AK] grlcatjlturj akvh`vjs tcj prhpjr uta`azgtahk hb tcj tcrjj praigry sjluraty mhigaks6

  Fhakt Thr`mwamj Aktj``adjklj Lhiiukalgtahks \ystji (FTAL\).

  \A_UKJ].   KA_UKJ].

Fhakt Thr`mwamj Aktj``adjklj Lhiiukalgtahks \ystji

=-=2.  FTAL\ as g systji hb aktjrlhkkjltjm lhiputjr kjtwhrns usjm ey vgrahus Z.\. Dhvjrkijkt mjpgrtijkts th

trgksiat ]\/\LA hvjr tcj trgksiassahk lhktrh` prhthlh`/Aktjrkjt prhthlh` (]L_/A_) suatj ak g sjlurj jkvarhkijkt.

FTAL\ supphrts tcj syklcrhkazgtahk hb H\AK] jxp`hatgtahk, massjiakgtahk hb H\AK] gkm supphrtakd ijtgmgtg,

gkm lh``gehrgtahk ejtwjjk mjp`hyjm gkm supphrtakd aktj``adjklj pjrshkkj`.

\JLUJ] Aktjrkjt _rhthlh` Uhutjr Kjtwhrn

=-=4.  \A_UKJ] as g systji hb aktjrlhkkjltjm lhiputjr kjtwhrns usjm ey vgrahus Z.\. Dhvjrkijkt

mjpgrtijkts th trgksiat l`gssabajm akbhrigtahk hvjr tcj ]L_/A_ ak g sjlurj jkvarhkijkt. \A_UKJ] as tcj

 praklapg iassahk-lhiigkm mgtg kjtwhrn gt tcj tgltalg` `jvj`. ]cj kjtwhrn g` hws glljss th H\AK] sjrvaljs gkm

 prhmults tcrhudc vgrahus mgtgegsjs, gs wj`` gs davjs aktj `adjklj gkm khkaktj` adjklj pjrshkkj tcj gea`aty th

lh``gehrgtj, vajw, sueiat, gkm trgln H\AK] aktj``adjklj gkm akbhrigtahk rjquarjijkts.

Page 50: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 50/91

Lcgptjr =

=-75 G]_ 5-55.1 7? Fu`y 5?75 

Khksjlurj Aktjrkjt _rhthlh` Uhutjr Kjtwhrn

=-=3.  KA_UKJ] as usjm ey vgrahus Z.\. Dhvjrkijkt mjpgrtijkts th jxlcgkdj akbhrigtahk up th tcj

sjksatavj eut ukl`gssabajm `jvj`. KA_UKJ] as lhkbadurjm th prhvamj glljss th Aktjrkjt-egsjm lgpgea`atajs

glrhss g`` MHM lhiphkjkts. At as tcj mhigak ihst lhiihk`y usjm th lhkmult hpjk-shurlj rjsjgrlc gkm prhmulj

H\AK].

UJ_HU]AKD GKM MA\\JIAKG]AHK LHK\AMJUG]AHK\

=-=1.  Tcjk rjphrtakd gkm massjiakgtakd H\AK] prhmults, lhksamjrgtahks akl`umj eut grj kht `aiatjm th ”  

  L`gssabalgtahk. Tcjk lrjgtakd prhmults brhi rgw akbhrigtahk, wratj-th-rj`jgsj gt tcj `hwjst

l`gssabalgtahk `jvj` th bgla`atgtj tcj wamjst mastraeutahk hb tcj aktj``adjklj. Zsj tjgr`akj rjphrt

bhrigts th bgla`atgtj tcj sjpgrgtahk hb l`gssabajm gkm ukl`gssabajm akbhrigtahk bhr usjrs hpjrgtakd

hk lhiiukalgtahks kjtwhrns hb mabbjrakd sjluraty `jvj`s. Hrdgkazgtahks watc hradakg` l`gssabalgtahk

gutchraty hr pjrshkkj` watc mjravgtavj l`gssabalgtahk rjsphksaea`atajs iust prhvamj suehrmakgtj

hrdgkazgtahks gkm pjrshkkj` watc g sjluraty l`gssabalgtahk duamj hr duamgklj bhr akbhrigtahk gkm

aktj``adjklj mjravjm brhi pue`al`y gvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk gkm hpjk shurljs ak gllhrmgklj watc tcj

 ph`aly gkm prhljmurjs ak GU <3?-:.

  Bjjmegln-ijlcgkasi mjvj`hpijkt. J-iga`, phstg` gmmrjssjs, rgtakd systjis, gkm survjy bhris

grj ijlcgkasis tcgt H\AK] pjrshkkj` lgk usj ak hrmjr th ukmjrstgkm tcj akbhrigtahk

rjquarjijkts bhr lusthijrs.  Aktj``jltug` prhpjrty amjktabalgtahk. Amjktaby aktj``jltug` prhpjrty tcgt gk gutchr hr gk

hrdgkazgtahk cgs lhpyradctjm, pgtjktjm, hr trgmjigrnjm tgnjk th prjsjrvj radcts th tcj

akbhrigtahk. H\AK] jxp`hatgtahk mhjs kht akvh`vj tcj sj``akd, aiphrtakd, hr jxphrtakd hb

aktj``jltug` prhpjrty. H\AK] pjrshkkj` jkdgdakd ak jxp`hatgtahk schu`m latj g`` shurljs usjm ak

rjphrtjm gkm massjiakgtjm prhmults. Tcjk ukljrtgak, H\AK] pjrshkkj` schu`m lhktglt tcj

supphrtakd \FG hbbalj ejbhrj rjphrtakd gkm massjiakgtakd g bakg`azjm H\AK] prhmult.

  Zsj hb jxastakd massjiakgtahk ijtchms, wcjk gkm ab phssae`j. Lrjgtakd kjw massjiakgtahk

ijtchms lgk gt taijs lhip`algtj jxastakd massjiakgtahk ijtchms.

  Gkg`ytalg` patbg``s.  Gkg`ysts kjjm th ej lhdkazgkt tcgt tcjrj grj patbg``s wcjk rjphrtakd gkm

massjiakgtakd H\AK]. ]cj jrrhrs, rjbjrrjm th gs bg``glajs (hiassahk gkm gssuiptahk), grj usug``y

lhiiattjm gllamjktg``y g`tchudc shijtaijs tcjy grj mj`aejrgtj`y usjm th pjrsugmj, lhkvaklj, hr

mjljavj. Gkg`ysts iust g`sh ej gwgrj hb cgsty djkjrg`azgtahk, bg`sj lgusj, iasusj hb gkg`hdajs

gkm `gkdugdjs, eagsjs (lu`turg`, pjrshkg`, hrdgkazgtahkg`, lhdkatavj), gkm cakmsadct. (Bhr ihrj

akbhrigtahk hk gkg`ytalg` patbg``s, sjj ]L 5-<<.=.)

Page 51: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 51/91

 

7? Fu`y 5?75  G]_ 5-55.1 G-7

Gppjkmax G 

@jdg` Ujstraltahks gkm Ujdu`gthry @aiatgtahks

_ue`al`y gvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk gkm hpjk shurljs lhvjr g wamj grrgy hb grjgs.Jxp`hrakd, gssjssakd, gkm lh``jltakd pue`al`y gvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk gkm hpjk shurljscgs tcj phtjktag` th gmvjrsj`y gbbjlt hrdgkazgtahks tcgt jxjlutj H\AK] iassahks. Ak

shij rjdgrms, H\AK] iassahks lhu`m akvh`vj akbhrigtahk jatcjr dgtcjrjm gdgakst hrmj`avjrjm ey Z.\. pjrshks. Davjk tcj slhpj hb H\AK] gkm ats gpp`algea`aty watcak tcjaktj``adjklj lhiiukaty, cgvakd g bari gwgrjkjss hb aktj``adjklj hvjrsadct gkm ats

rjdu`gthry gpp`algtahks as kjljssgry.

JSJLZ]ARJ HUMJU 75<<<G-7.  G`` H\AK] jxp`hatgtahk lhkmultjm ey aktj``adjklj gkm khkaktj``adjklj pjrshkkj` iust lhip`y watc

tcj `jdg` rjstraltahks, ph`alajs, gkm duamj`akjs hut`akjm ak JH 75<<< gkm htcjr gsshlagtjm rjdu`gtahks,

akstrultahks, hr marjltavjs.

G-5.  JH 75<<< stgtjs tcj dhg` hb tcj kgtahkg` aktj``adjklj jbbhrt as th prhvamj tcj _rjsamjkt gkm tcj

 Kgtahkg` \jluraty Lhukla` tcj kjljssgry akbhrigtahk hk wcalc th egsj mjlasahks lhkljrkakd tcj lhkmult

gkm mjvj`hpijkt hb bhrjadk mjbjksj, jlhkhial ph`aly, gkm prhtjltahk hb Z.\. kgtahkg` aktjrjsts.

G-<.  JH 75<<< hradakgtjm brhi hpjrgtahks tcgt MHM aktj``adjklj ukats lhkmultjm gdgakst Z.\. pjrshks

akvh`vjm ak tcj Lava` Uadcts gkm gkta-Rajtkgi Tgr ihvjijkts. MHM aktj``adjklj pjrshkkj` usjm hvjrt gkm

lhvjrt ijgks th lh``jlt akbhrigtahk hk tcj ph`atalg` phsatahks hb Z.\. pjrshks, rjtgakjm tcj akbhrigtahk ak g

kgtahkwamj mgtgegsj, gkm massjiakgtjm tcj akbhrigtahk th `gw jkbhrljijkt gutchratajs.

G-=.  ]cj purphsj hb JH 75<<< as th jkcgklj cuigk gkm tjlckalg` lh``jltahk tjlckaqujs, tcj glquasatahk hbbhrjadk aktj``adjklj, gkm tcj lhuktjrakd hb aktjrkgtahkg` tjrrhrast gltavatajs lhkmultjm ey bhrjadk phwjrs

jspjlag``y tchsj ukmjrtgnjk gerhgm, gkm tcj glquasatahk hb sadkabalgkt bhrjadk aktj``adjklj, gs wj`` gs tcj

mjtjltahk gkm lhuktjrakd hb aktjrkgtahkg` tjrrhrast gltavatajs gkm jspahkgdj lhkmultjm ey bhrjadk phwjrs.

Gllurgtj gkm taij`y akbhrigtahk gehut tcj lgpgea`atajs, aktjktahks, gkm gltavatajs hb bhrjadk phwjrs,

hrdgkazgtahks, gkm suehrmakgtj gdjkts as jssjktag` th akbhrijm kgtahkg` mjbjksj mjlasahks. Lh``jltahk hb sulc

akbhrigtahk as g prahraty hefjltavj, pursujm ak g vadhrhus, akkhvgtavj, gkm rjsphksae`j igkkjr tcgt as

lhksastjkt watc tcj Z.\. Lhkstatutahk gkm gpp`alge`j `gws gkm praklap`js.

AK]JU_UJ]G]AHK GKM AI_@JIJK]G]AHK

G-:.  GU <37-7? aktjrprjts gkm aip`jijkts JH 75<<< gkm MHM :5=?.7-U. GU <37-7? jkge`js tcj

aktj``adjklj lhiiukaty th pjrbhri gutchrazjm aktj``adjklj bukltahks ak g igkkjr tcgt prhtjlts tcj

lhkstatutahkg` radcts hb Z.\. pjrshks. ]cj rjdu`gtahk mhjs kht gutchrazj aktj``adjklj gltavaty. Gk Griyaktj``adjklj ukat hr hrdgkazgtahk iust cgvj tcj iassahk th lhkmult gky aktj``adjklj gltavaty marjltjm gdgakst

Z.\. pjrshks. Ak gllhrmgklj watc tcj _hssj Lhiatgtus Glt (\jltahk 7<3:, ]at`j 73, Z\L), tcj rjdu`gtahk

mhjs kht gpp`y th Griy aktj``adjklj ukats hr hrdgkazgtahks wcjk jkdgdjm ak lava` masturegklj hr `gw

jkbhrljijkt gltavatajs watchut prahr gpprhvg` ey tcj \jlrjtgry hb Mjbjksj.

Page 52: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 52/91

Gppjkmax G

G-5 G]_ 5-55.1 7? Fu`y 5?75 

G\\ADKJM BZKL]AHK\ 

G-2.  Egsjm hk JH 75<<<, tcj gssadkjm aktj``adjklj bukltahks hb tcj Griy grj th ”  

  Lh``jlt, prhmulj, gkm massjiakgtj ia`atgry-rj`gtjm bhrjadk aktj``adjklj gs rjquarjm bhr jxjlutahk

hb rjsphksaea`aty hb tcj \jlrjtgry hb Mjbjksj.

  Lhkmult prhdrgis gkm iassahks kjljssgry th bu`ba`` mjpgrtijktg` bhrjadk aktj``adjklj

rjquarjijkts.  Lhkmult gltavatajs ak supphrt hb MHM lhiphkjkts hutsamj tcj Zkatjm \tgtjs ak lhhrmakgtahk watc

tcj Ljktrg` Aktj``adjklj Gdjkly (LAG) gkm watcak tcj Zkatjm \tgtjs ak lhhrmakgtahk watc tcj

Bjmjrg` Eurjgu hb akvjstadgtahk (BEA) pursugkt th prhljmurjs gdrjjm uphk ey tcj \jlrjtgry hb

Mjbjksj gkm tcj Gtthrkjy Djkjrg`.

  _rhtjlt tcj sjluraty hb MHM akstg``gtahks th akl`umj ats gltavatajs, prhpjrty, akbhrigtahk, gkm

jip`hyjm Z.\. pjrshks ey gpprhpragtj ijgks.

  Lhhpjrgtj watc gpprhpragtj `gw jkbhrljijkt gdjklajs th prhtjlt jip`hyjm Z.\. pjrshks,

akbhrigtahk, prhpjrty, gkm bgla`atajs hb gky gdjkly watcak tcj aktj``adjklj lhiiukaty.

  _grtalapgtj watc `gw jkbhrljijkt gdjklajs th akvjstadgtj hr prjvjkt l`gkmjstakj aktj``adjklj

gltavatajs ey bhrjadk phwjrs hr aktjrkgtahkg` tjrrhrasts.

  _rhvamj spjlag`azjm jquapijkt, tjlckalg` nkhw`jmdj, hr gssastgklj th Z.\. pjrshks bhr usj ey

gky mjpgrtijkt hr gdjkly, hr, wcjk `avjs grj jkmgkdjrjm, th supphrt `hlg` `gw jkbhrljijkt

gdjklajs.

GUIQ UJDZ@G]AHK <37-7?

G-4.  GU <37-7? jkge`js gky Griy lhiphkjkt th pjrbhri aktj``adjklj bukltahks ak g igkkjr tcgt prhtjlts tcj

lhkstatutahkg` radcts hb Z.\. pjrshks. At g`sh prhvamjs duamgklj hk lh``jltahk tjlckaqujs usjm th hetgak

akbhrigtahk bhr bhrjadk aktj``adjklj gkm LA purphsjs. Aktj``adjklj gltavaty as kht gutchrazjm ey tcas rjdu`gtahk.

LH@@JL]AHK HB Z.\. _JU\HK AKBHUIG]AHK 

G-3.  Lh``jltahk, ak tcas lhktjxt, as tcj dgtcjrakd hr rjljavakd akbhrigtahk ey aktj``adjklj pjrshkkj` ak tcj

lhursj hb hbbalag` mutajs watc tcj aktjkt th usj hr rjtgak tcj akbhrigtahk bhr aktj``adjklj purphsjs. Gltahk

iust ej tgnjk th mjihkstrgtj aktjkmjm usj hb tcj lh``jltjm akbhrigtahk sulc gs prhmulakd gk aktj``adjklj

akbhrigtahk rjphrt, aklamjkt rjphrt, hr gmmakd tcj akbhrigtahk th gk aktj``adjklj mgtgegsj.

G-1.  ]cjrj iust ej g `akn ejtwjjk tcj lh``jltahk hb tcj Z.\. pjrshk akbhrigtahk gkm tcj aktj``adjklj

gdjkly gssadkjm iassahk. ]cas `akn as pgrtalu`gr`y aiphrtgkt wcjk mjg`akd watc pue`al`y gvga`ge`j

akbhrigtahk, hpjk-shurlj akbhrigtahk, gkm akbhrigtahk mgtg jxp`hatgtahk.

G-7?. Griy aktj``adjklj lhiphkjkts igy lh``jlt Z.\. pjrshk akbhrigtahk ey `gwbu` ijgks eut iust ej

`aiatjm th tcj `jgst aktrusavj ijgks bjgsae`j gkm scg`` kht vah`gtj tcj `gw (sjj MHM :5=?.7-U). ]cjsj `jgst

aktrusavj lh``jltahk ijgks iust ej gttjiptjm ejbhrj uta`azakd ihrj aktrusavj lh``jltahk ijgks sulc gs ”  

  Glquasatahk brhi pue`al`y gvga`ge`j shurljs hr watc tcj lhksjkt hb tcj Z.\. pjrshk hb aktjrjst.

  Ab prhvjk ukbjgsae`j hr akjbbalajkt, glquasatahk brhi lhhpjrgtakd shurljs.

  Ab prhvjk ukbjgsae`j hr akjbbalajkt, glquasatahk brhi htcjr `gwbu` ijgks tcgt mh kht rjquarj g

wgrrgkt hr Gtthrkjy Djkjrg` gpprhvg`.

  Ab prhvjk ukbjgsae`j hr akjbbalajkt, gk gpprhvg` rjqujst bhr tcj usj hb tjlckaqujs rjquarakd g

wgrrgkt hr Gtthrkjy Djkjrg` gpprhvg`.

G-77. Tatcak tcj Zkatjm \tgtjs, Griy aktj``adjklj lhiphkjkts igy lh``jlt bhrjadk aktj``adjklj lhkljrkakd

Z.\. pjrshks ey hvjrt ijgks wcjk tcj bh``hwakd lhkmatahks grj ijt6

  ]cj bhrjadk aktj``adjklj shudct as sadkabalgkt gkm mhjs kht lhkljrk tcj mhijstal gltavaty hb tcj

Z.\. pjrshk.

  ]cj bhrjadk aktj``adjklj lgkkht ej rjgshkge`y hetgakjm ey hvjrt ijgks.

Page 53: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 53/91

@jdg` Ujstraltahks gkm Ujdu`gthry @aiatgtahks

7? Fu`y 5?75  G]_ 5-55.1 G-<

  Lh``jltahk cgs ejjk lhhrmakgtjm watc tcj BEA ak hrmjr th prjvjkt tcj masruptahk hb lurrjkt

hpjrgtahks.

G-75. ]cj bh``hwakd lhksamjrgtahks gpp`y th tcj lh``jltahk hb Z.\. pjrshk akbhrigtahk brhi tcj Aktjrkjt6

  Griy aktj``adjklj lhiphkjkts iust usj dhvjrkijkt lhiputjrs th glljss tcj Aktjrkjt bhr hbbalag`

dhvjrkijkt eusakjss uk`jss htcjrwasj gutchrazjm.

  A_ gmmrjssjs, ukabhri rjshurlj `hlgthrs (ZU@s), gkm j-iga` gmmrjssjs tcgt grj kht gsshlagtjm

watc g Z.\. pjrshk igy ej glquarjm, rjtgakjm, gkm prhljssjm ey Griy aktj``adjklj lhiphkjkts

watchut ignakd gk jbbhrt th mjtjriakj gsshlagtahk watc g Z.\. pjrshk gs `hkd gs tcj lhiphkjkt

mhjs kht jkdgdj ak gkg`ysas bhlusjm uphk spjlabal gmmrjssjs.

G-7<. GU <37-7? mhjs kht gutchrazj tcj lh``jltahk hb gky akbhrigtahk rj`gtakd th g Z.\. pjrshk sh`j`y

 ejlgusj hb pjrshkg` `gwbu` gmvhlgly hb ijgsurjs hpphsjm th dhvjrkijkt ph`aly gs jiehmajm ak tcj Barst

Gijkmijkt th tcj Z.\. Lhkstatutahk. ]cj Barst Gijkmijkt stgtjs tcgt Lhkdrjss scg`` ignj kh `gw

rjspjltakd gk jstge`ascijkt hb rj`adahk, hr prhcaeatakd tcj brjj jxjrlasj tcjrjhb> hr geramdakd tcj brjjmhi hb

spjjlc, hr hb tcj prjss> hr tcj radct hb tcj pjhp`j pjgljge`y th gssjie`j, gkm th pjtatahk tcj dhvjrkijkt bhr

g rjmrjss hb drajvgkljs.

U J]JK]AHK HB Z.\. _JU\HK AKBHUIG]AHK

G-7=.  Ujtjktahk  rjbjrs hk`y th igaktgakakd akbhrigtahk gehut Z.\. pjrshks tcgt tcj Griy aktj``adjklj

lhiphkjkt lgk rjtrajvj ey tcj pjrshk‑s kgij hr htcjr pjrshkg` amjktabyakd mgtg. GU <37-7?, prhljmurj <,

mjslraejs tcj nakms hb Z.\. pjrshk akbhrigtahk tcgt gk Griy aktj``adjklj lhiphkjkt igy nkhwakd`y rjtgak

watchut tcj akmavamug`‑s lhksjkt.

G-7:. GU <37-7? gutchrazjs tcj rjtjktahk hb Z.\. pjrshk akbhrigtahk ukmjr tcj bh``hwakd lratjrag6

  Akbhrigtahk prhpjr`y lh``jltjm ak gllhrmgklj watc GU <37-7?, prhljmurj 5.

  Griy aktj``adjklj lhiphkjkts glquarjm tcj akbhrigtahk aklamjktg` th gk htcjrwasj gutchrazjm

lh``jltahk gltavaty, gkm rjtgakjm tcj akbhrigtahk ab at ““  

  Lhu`m cgvj ejjk lh``jltjm aktjktahkg``y ukmjr tcj prhvasahks hb GU <37-7?, prhljmurj 5.

  As kjljssgry th ukmjrstgkm hr gssjss bhrjadk aktj``adjklj hr LA.

  As bhrjadk aktj``adjklj hr LA lh``jltjm brhi gutchrazjm j`jltrhkal survja``gklj.

Khtj.   J`jltrhkal survja``gklj  rjbjrs th tcj glquasatahk hb g khkpue`al lhiiukalgtahk ey

j`jltrhkal ijgks watchut tcj lhksjkt hb g pjrshk wch as g pgrty th gk j`jltrhkal lhiiukalgtahk

hr, ak tcj lgsj hb g khkj`jltrhkal lhiiukalgtahk, watchut tcj lhksjkt hb g pjrshk wch as vasae`y

 prjsjkt gt tcj p`glj hb lhiiukalgtahk, eut kht akl`umakd tcj usj hb rgmah marjltahk-bakmakd

jquapijkt sh`j`y th mjtjriakj tcj `hlgtahk hb g trgksiattjr.

  As aklamjktg` th gutchrazjm lh``jltahk gkm igy akmalgtj akvh`vjijkt ak gltavatajs tcgt igy

vah`gtj bjmjrg`, stgtj, `hlg`, hr bhrjadk `gw.

  Akbhrigtahk rj`gtakd th bukltahks hb htcjr Griy gltavatajs, MHM lhiphkjkts, hr khk-MHM gdjklajs.

]cj akbhrigtahk pjrtgaks sh`j`y th tcj bukltahks gkm rjsphksaea`atajs hb htcjr gltavatajs, lhiphkjkts hr

gdjklajs, gkm as rjtgakjm hk`y gs kjljssgry th trgksiat tcj akbhrigtahk th tcgt gdjkly. ]cj trgksiattg`

as ba`jm gkm mjstrhyjm ukmjr djkjrg` lhrrjsphkmjklj rjlhrms igkgdjijkt. Griy aktj``adjklj

lhiphkjkts wa`` kht rjtgak tcj akbhrigtahk ak aktj``adjklj mgtgegsjs hr rjphsathrajs.

G-72. ]jiphrgry rjtjktahk  rjbjrs th tcj gutchrazgtahk bhr Griy aktj``adjklj lhiphkjkts th rjtgakakbhrigtahk up th 1? mgys, sh`j`y th mjtjriakj ab tcj akbhrigtahk as, ak bglt, rjtgakge`j ukmjr tcas rjdu`gtahk.

]cj 1?-mgy pjrahm stgrts uphk rjljapt hb tcj akbhrigtahk.

G-74. Htcjr akbhrigtahk  rjtgakjm ey Griy aktj``adjklj lhiphkjkts iust ej rjphrtjm bhr hvjrsadct

 purphsjs gkm bhr kjljssgry suesjqujkt prhljjmakds.

G-73. Glljss th Z.\. pjrshk akbhrigtahk rjtgakjm ak aktj``adjklj ba`js, mgtgegsjs, gkm rjphsathrajs as `aiatjm

th tchsj watc g kjjm th nkhw tcj akbhrigtahk. Z.\. pjrshk akbhrigtahk ak aktj``adjklj ba`js, mgtgegsjs, gkm

Page 54: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 54/91

Gppjkmax G

G-= G]_ 5-55.1 7? Fu`y 5?75 

rjphsathrajs as rjtgakjm ak gllhrmgklj watc masphsatahk lratjrag ak GU 5:-=??-5. Aktj``adjklj lhiphkjkts

wa`` rjvajw aktj``adjklj ba`js gkm mgtgegsjs gkkug``y. Aktj``adjklj lhiphkjkts wa`` spjlabalg``y rjvajw Z.\.

 pjrshk akbhrigtahk th jksurj ats rjtjktahk as sta`` kjljssgry th gk gssadkjm bukltahk. ]cas jksurjs Z.\.

 pjrshk akbhrigtahk as kht cj`m ejyhkm jstge`ascjm masphsatahk lratjrag, as rjtgakjm bhr gk gutchrazjm

bukltahk, gkm wgs kht rjtgakjm ak vah`gtahk hb tcas rjdu`gtahk. ]cas mhjs kht gpp`y th tcj Akvjstadgtavj

Ujlhrms Ujphsathry hr htcjr gutchrazjm `hkd-tjri rjlhrms ch`makd grjgs.

MA\\JIAKG]AHK HB Z.\. _JU\HK AKBHUIG]AHK 

G-71.  Massjiakgtj, gk akbhrigtahk igkgdjijkt gltavaty, rjbjrs th lhiiukalgtakd rj`jvgkt akbhrigtahk hb

gky nakm brhi hkj pjrshk hr p`glj th gkhtcjr ak g usge`j bhri ey gky ijgks th aiprhvj ukmjrstgkmakd hr th

akatagtj hr dhvjrk gltahk (BI 2-?). Ak htcjr whrms, massjiakgtahk as tcj mj`avjry hb aktj``adjklj th usjrs ak g

suatge`j bhri watc gpp`algtahk hb tcj aktj``adjklj th gpprhpragtj iassahks, tgsns, gkm bukltahks. GU <37-7?,

 prhljmurj =, dhvjrks tcj typjs hb akbhrigtahk rjdgrmakd Z.\. pjrshks tcgt Griy aktj``adjklj hrdgkazgtahks

igy massjiakgtj watchut tcj pjrshk‑s lhksjkt hutsamj tcj lhiphkjkt wcalc lh``jltjm gkm rjtgakjm tcj

akbhrigtahk.

WZJ\]AHKGE@J AK]J@@ADJKLJ GL]ARA]Q 

G-5?. Wujstahkge`j aktj``adjklj gltavaty hllurs wcjk aktj``adjklj hpjrgtahks phtjktag``y vah`gtj ”  

  @gws.  JHs.

  _rjsamjktag` marjltavjs.

  MHM hr Griy ph`alajs.

G-57. Aktj``adjklj pjrshkkj` schu`m rjphrt qujstahkge`j aktj``adjklj gltavaty tcrhudc tcj lcgak hb lhiigkm,

tcj akspjlthr djkjrg`, hr marjlt`y th tcj Gssastgkt th tcj \jlrjtgry hb Mjbjksj bhr Aktj``adjklj Hvjrsadct ak

gllhrmgklj watc GU <37-7?. ]cj bh``hwakd grj jxgip`js hb qujstahkge`j aktj``adjklj gltavaty hk aiprhpjr

lh``jltakd, rjtgakakd, hr massjiakgtakd hb Z.\. pjrshk akbhrigtahk6

  Lh``jltakd gkm dgtcjrakd akbhrigtahk gehut Z.\. mhijstal drhups kht lhkkjltjm watc g bhrjadk

 phwjr hr aktjrkgtahkg` tjrrhrasi.

  _rhmulakd gkm massjiakgtakd aktj``adjklj tcrjgt gssjssijkts lhktgakakd Z.\. pjrshk akbhrigtahk

watchut g l`jgr jxp`gkgtahk hb tcj aktj``adjklj purphsj bhr wcalc tcj akbhrigtahk wgs lh``jltjm.

  Lh``jltakd gkm dgtcjrakd Z.\. pjrshk akbhrigtahk bhr bhrlj prhtjltahk purphsjs watchutmjtjriakakd ab tcj aktj``adjklj bukltahk as gutchrazjm.

  Lh``jltakd gkm dgtcjrakd Z.\. pjrshk akbhrigtahk brhi hpjk shurljs watchut g `hdalg`

lhkkjltahk th tcj iassahk hb tcj ukat.

G-55. GU <37-7? marjlts aktj``adjklj hrdgkazgtahks th rjbjr qujstahks lhkljrkakd tcj aktjrprjtgtahk hb tcj

akstrultahks hk lh``jltahk, rjtjktahk, gkm massjiakgtahk hb Z.\. pjrshk akbhrigtahk th tcj `hlg` \FG‑s hbbalj.  

G\\A\]GK] MJ_Z]Q MAUJL]HU HB KG]AHKG@ AK]J@@ADJKLJ BHU H_JK \HZULJ

G-5<. ]cj rjsphksaea`atajs hb tcj GMMKA/H\ akl`umj ”  

  Jxjrlasakd tcj aktjdrgtahk, jvg`ugtahk, gkm hvjrsadct bhr tcj KH\J.

  _rhvamakd strgtjdal hvjrsadct hb gkm duamjs strgtjdal akvh`vjijkt hb H\AK].

  Lcgarakd tcj Kgtahkg` Hpjk \hurlj Lhiiattjj (KH\L) gkm Hpjk \hurlj Ehgrm hb Gmvashrs.  Hvjrsjjakd tcj MKA H\L gkm tcj mastraeutjm KH\J.

  Jksurakd tcj aktjdrgtahk hb tcj hpjk-shurlj lh``jltahk igkgdjijkt strgtjdy.

  Mjvj`hpakd hvjrsadct hb tcj KH\J.

  Hvjrsjjakd aktjrgdjkly scgrakd hb hpjk-shurlj akbhrigtahk.

Page 55: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 55/91

@jdg` Ujstraltahks gkm Ujdu`gthry @aiatgtahks

7? Fu`y 5?75  G]_ 5-55.1 G-:

AK]J@@ADJKLJ LHIIZKA]Q 

G-5=. ]cj rjsphksaea`atajs hb tcj aktj``adjklj lhiiukaty akl`umj ”  

  Mjvj`hpakd prhdrgiigtal hvjrsadct gkm jvg`ugtahk th ej ljktrg`azjm ukmjr tcj GMMKA/H\.

  \upphrtakd g`` aktj``adjklj maslap`akjs.

  Jstge`ascakd gpprhpragtj shurlj gkm akbhrigtahk vg`amgtahk gkm vjrabalgtahk prhljmurjs hb g``

hpjk-shurlj jxp`hatgtahk jbbhrts.  Mjvj`hpakd ijtrals bhr hvjrg`` hpjk-shurlj gltavatajs.

  Ignakd g`` hpjk-shurlj akbhrigtahk, prhmults, gkm sjrvaljs gvga`ge`j tcrhudchut tcj aktj``adjklj

lhiiukaty.

KG]AHKG@ H_JK-\HZULJ LHIIA]]JJ 

G-5:. ]cj KH\L prhvamjs duamgklj th tcj KH\J. ]cj rjsphksaea`atajs hb tcj KH\L akl`umj ”  

  Mjvj`hpakd gpprhpragtj hpjrgtahkg` stgkmgrms bhr shurlj hr akbhrigtahk vjrabalgtahk, trgmjlrgbt,

gkm trgakakd.

  Mjvj`hpakd slajklj gkm tjlckh`hdy stgkmgrms bhr ijtgmgtg tgddakd gkm sthrgdj.

MAUJL]HU HB KG]AHKG@ AK]J@@ADJKLJ H_JK-\HZULJ LJK]JU  

G-52. ]cj MKA H\L sjrvjs th gmvgklj tcj jxp`hatgtahk hb hpjk-shurlj akbhrigtahk tcrhudc glquasatahk,

 prhlurjijkt, gkg`ysas, gkm massjiakgtahk hb prhmults gkm sjrvaljs. ]cj rjsphksaea`atajs hb tcj MKA H\L

akl`umj ”  

  Bgla`atgtakd hpjk-shurlj jxp`hatgtahk bhr Z.\. Dhvjrkijkt pgrtkjrs gkm lusthijrs.

  \jlurakd gpprhpragtj `aljksakd gdrjjijkts bhr hpjk-shurlj lusthijrs.

  Mjvj`hpakd hpjk-shurlj prhdrgis.

  ]rgakakd pjrshkkj` th prhpjr`y jxp`hat hpjk-shurlj akbhrigtahk ak gllhrmgklj watc sjluraty

 prgltaljs.

Page 56: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 56/91

Page 57: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 57/91

 

7? Fu`y 5?75  G]_ 5-55.1 E-7

Gppjkmax E 

Lyejrspglj Aktjrkjt Gwgrjkjss

Aktj``adjklj gkm khkaktj``adjklj pjrshkkj` lhkmultakd hpjk-shurlj rjsjgrlc iust ejgwgrj hb tcj madatg` hpjrgtahkg` jkvarhkijkt ey iakaiazakd gkm rjmulakd lyejr‐bhhtprakts,’ prgltalakd jbbjltavj lyejr H_\JL, uta`azakd sgbj hk`akj surbakd

tjlckaqujs gkm cgeats, gkm ukmjrstgkmakd tcgt jiejmmjm ijtgmgtg lgk ej lhktgakjmak mhluijkts.

LQEJU\_GLJ \A]ZG]AHKG@ GTGUJKJ\\ GKM LQEJU\JLZUA]Q

E-7.  Ihrj tcgk gky htcjr aktj``adjklj maslap`akj, rjsjgrlc akvh`vakd pue`al`y gvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk gkm

hpjk shurljs lhu`m ukaktjktahkg``y rjvjg` LLAUs. Hpjk-shurlj rjsjgrlc shijtaijs rjquarjs glljss th

Aktjrkjt Tje satjs tcgt e`hln erhwsakd sjssahks hradakgtakd brhi .ia`   hr .dhv  shurljs. Ak tcj grjgs hb

lhiputjr akbhrigtahk gssurgklj gkm Aktjrkjt sjluraty, aktjrkjt gwgrjkjss as kjjmjm ak hrmjr th ej jbbjltavj,

gddrjssavj, gkm th sulljssbu``y lhkmult hpjk-shurlj rjsjgrlc gkm jxp`hatgtahk. Zkfustabajm Aktjrkjt Tje-

satj rjstraltahks cgvj tcj phtjktag` th sjvjrj`y aipjmj glquarakd gkm tcj suesjqujkt prhljssakd, rjphrtakd,

gkm massjiakgtakd hb pue`al`y gvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk gkm hpjk shurljs.

E-5.  Gwgrjkjss as tcj ejdakkakd hb jbbjltavj lyejr sjluraty. Lhiputjrs trgksiat iglcakj spjlabalgtahks

sulc gs hpjrgtakd systji, typj hb vjrsahk hb jglc jkge`jm prhdrgi, sjluraty `jvj`s, g casthry hb Tje satjs

vasatjm, lhhnaj akbhrigtahk, usjr prjbjrjkljs, A_ gmmrjssjs, jkge`jm `gkdugdjs, gkm rjbjrrakd ZU@ wcjk

sjgrlcakd tcj Aktjrkjt. Rasathrs grj brjqujkt`y rjmarjltjm th g`tjrkgtj Tje satjs egsjm hk sjgrlc lratjrahk,

`hlgtahk, `gkdugdj, gkm taij tcj sjgrlc as lhkmultjm.

E-<.  ]cj Aktjrkjt as mjslraejm gs g ‐kjtwhrn hb kjtwhrns’ muj th tcj cukmrjms hb tchusgkms hb

aktjrlhkkjltjm kjtwhrns lhksastakd hb ia``ahks hb lhiputjrs. Lhiputjrs gkm usjrs lhkkjltjm th tcj

Aktjrkjt grj amjktabajm ey g systji-spjlabal A_ gmmrjss tcgt mjsadkgtjs `hlgtahk. ]cj A_ gmmrjss sjrvjs gs tcj

gmmrjss wcjrj trgksbjrrjm akbhrigtahk gkm mgtui as mj`avjrjm. ]cj lhkljrk tcjrjak rjsts ak tcj

ukmjrstgkmakd tcgt wca`j vasatakd khkstgkmgrm hr qujstahkge`j Aktjrkjt Tje satjs ak gllhrmgklj watc hbbalag`

mutajs, sjksatavj ukat akbhrigtahk lhu`m akgmvjrtjkt`y ej rjvjg`jm.

E-=.  Lyejrspglj as g d`heg` mhigak watcak tcj akbhrigtahk jkvarhkijkt lhksastakd hb tcj aktjrmjpjkmjkt

kjtwhrn hb akbhrigtahk tjlckh`hdy akbrgstrulturjs, akl`umakd tcj Aktjrkjt, tj`jlhiiukalgtahks kjtwhrns,

lhiputjr systjis, jiejmmjm prhljsshrs, gkm lhktrh``jrs (F_ 7-?5). ]cj Griy hpjrgtjs ak gkm tcrhudc tcj

lyejrspglj mhigak, usakd gkm igkgdakd tcj j`jltrhigdkjtal spjltrui gs g ch`astal gkm aktjdrgtjm pgrt hb

ukabajm `gkm hpjrgtahks. _jrshkkj` jkdgdakd ak H\AK] jxp`hatgtahk kjjm th ukmjrstgkm tcj lyejrspglj

jkvarhkijkt ak hrmjr th mjvj`hp gkm amjktaby hutlhijs-egsjm, aktjdrgtahk-bhlusjm, gkm rjshurlj-akbhrijm

sh`utahks bhr lyejr satugtahkg` gwgrjkjss lhkljrks. 

Page 58: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 58/91

Gppjkmax E

E-5 G]_ 5-55.1 7? Fu`y 5?75 

E-:.  Lyejr satugtahkg` gwgrjkjss  as tcj nkhw`jmdj hb brajkm`y, kjutrg`, gkm tcrjgt rj`jvgkt akbhrigtahk

rjdgrmakd gltavatajs ak gkm tcrhudc lyejrspglj gkm tcj j`jltrhigdkjtal spjltrui (BI 7-?5).  Lyejrspglj

gkm lyejr sjluraty akvh`vj aklrjgsakd lyejr satugtahkg` gwgrjkjss ey ”  

  Amjktabyakd tcrjgt hpjrgtahks th mjtjriakj tcj jbbjlt hk brajkm`y hpjrgtahks gkm lhuktjrijgsurjs.

  Mjtjriakakd chw th usj lyejrspglj th dgak supphrt brhi brajkm`y gkm kjutrg` jktatajs.

  Mjtjriakakd chw th dgak, igaktgak, gkm jxp`hat tjlckalg` gkm hpjrgtahkg` gmvgktgdjs.

E-2.  ]cjrj grj H_\JL gkm lhiputjr sjluraty rasns th sjgrlcakd gkm aktjrgltakd watc Aktjrkjt Tje satjs.

\jgrlcakd tcj Aktjrkjt lgk lhiprhiasj H_\JL ey `jgvakd ‐madatg` bhhtprakts’ hk vasatjm Tje satjs.

‐\urbakd’ hk Aktjrkjt Tje satjs lgk lhiprhiasj lhiputjr sjluraty ey jxphsakd tcj lhiputjr gkm kjtwhrn

th ig`alahus shbtwgrj (sulc gs varusjs, whris, gkm ]rhfgk Chrsjs) hr ukgutchrazjm glljss. Aktj``adjklj

 pjrshkkj` iust ej vada`gkt th phtjktag` tcrjgts, usj hk`y gutchrazjm cgrmwgrj gkm shbtwgrj, gkm lhip`y watc

jstge`ascjm ukat hpjrgtahks sjluraty ijgsurjs.

E-4.  ZU@ akbhrigtahk brhi tcj prjvahus Tje satj vasatjm as brjqujkt`y gk H_\JL assuj gkm at amjktabajs

lcgrgltjrastals gkm aktjrjsts hb tcj usjr. Tca`j kjljssgry bhr gk jbbjltavj rjsjgrlc, tcj usj hb spjlabal gkm

bhlusjm sjgrlc tjris cgvj phtjktag` H_\JL aip`algtahks.

Lyejr \jluraty Jxgip`jAb tcj usjr jktjrs tcj sjgrlc tjris ^ergm`jy us griyY, tcj rjbjrrakd ZU@ brhi tcj Dhhd`jcat ast whu`m ej6 cttp6//www.dhhd`j.lhi/sjgrlc8c`9jk&q9ergm`jy+us+griy. ]cas tj``s tcjvasatjm satj tcgt tcj usjr as sjgrlcakd ak Jkd`asc (c`9jk) bhr akbhrigtahk hk Griy Djkjrg`hb tcj Griy Higr K. Ergm`jy hr tcj Z.\. Griy‑s Ergm`jy akbgktry badctakd vjcal`j. 

E-3.  G`` gltahks hk g Tje satj grj `hddjm gkm sgvjm. ]cj akbhrigtahk as sgvjm gkm `aknjm th wcgt as

rjbjrrjm th gs lhhnaj mgtg. Zsjr gltahks akl`umj eut grj kht `aiatjm th ”  

  Thrms typjm ak sjgrlc pgrgijtjr baj`ms.

  Mrhp-mhwk ijku lchaljs.

  Lcjln ehxjs.

  Tje satj ihvjijkt pgttjrks sulc gs lcgkdakd mhigak kgij hr Tje satj gmmrjss.

E-1.  Hk igky Tje satjs, akbhrigtahk tcgt tcj usjr prhvamjs hr ba``s ak ejlhijs pgrt hb tcj Tje satj gkm as

sjgrlcge`j. Njy akbhrigtahk th gvham scgrakd akl`umjs eut as kht `aiatjm th ”  

  Ia`atgry p`gks.

  Hpjrgtahks.

  Jxjrlasjs.

  Igps gkm lcgrts.

  @hlgtahks.

  \lcjmu`js.

  Jquapijkt vu`kjrgea`atajs, lgpgea`atajs, gkm schrtbg``s.

   Kgijs gkm rj`gtjm kuiejrs6

  ]j`jpchkj kuiejrs.

  Eartc mgtjs.

  Amjktabalgtahk kuiejrs.

E-7?. ]rgmatahkg` gkm arrjdu`gr tcrjgts grj masruptavj ak kgturj gkm usj tcj lyejrspglj mhigak th lhkmult

hpjrgtahks gdgakst tcj Griy. ]cjsj tcrjgts grj akkhvgtavj, kjtwhrnjm, gkm tjlckh`hdalg``y gmjpt. ]cjsj

tcrjgts lgpatg`azj hk jijrdakd tjlckh`hdajs th jstge`asc gkm igaktgak g lu`turg` gkm shlag` gmvgktgdj

`jvjrgdakd grjgs, th akl`umj eut kht `aiatjm th iassahk lhiigkm, rjlruatakd, `hdastals, bukm rgasakd gkm

`gukmjrakd, AH, gkm prhpgdgkmg.

Page 59: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 59/91

Lyejrspglj Aktjrkjt Gwgrjkjss

7? Fu`y 5?75  G]_ 5-55.1 E-<

E-77. Tcjk jkdgdjm ak H\AK] jxp`hatgtahk uta`azakd lhiputjr systjis gkm Aktjrkjt usgdj, lyejrspglj

gwgrjkjss gssjssijkts schu`m ej mjvj`hpjm gkm lhvjr grjgs akl`umakd eut kht `aiatjm th kjtwhrn

vu`kjrgea`atajs, kjtwhrn tcrjgts (pcysalg` gkm vartug`), gkm buturj rasns.

E-75. Bhr ihrj mjtga`jm akbhrigtahk gehut lyejr sjluraty tcrjgts gkm taps sjj tcj Z.\. Lhiputjr \jluraty

Ujgmakjss ]jgi‑s Tje.

Page 60: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 60/91

Page 61: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 61/91

 

7? Fu`y 5?75  G]_ 5-55.1 L-7

Gppjkmax L 

Egsal gkm Gmvgkljm Aktjrkjt \jgrlc ]jlckaqujs

]cj gea`aty th sjgrlc tcj Aktjrkjt as gk jssjktag` sna`` bhr hpjk-shurlj rjsjgrlc gkmglquasatahk. ]cj Aktjrkjt, lhksamjrjm g rjlhkkgassgklj gkm survja``gklj rjsjgrlc thh`,

 prhvamjs glljss th Tje satjs gkm mgtgegsjs tcgt ch`m g wamj rgkdj hb akbhrigtahk hk

lurrjkt, p`gkkjm, gkm phtjktag` grjgs hb hpjrgtahk. ]cj jxphkjktag` drhwtc ak lhiputjrtjlckh`hdy gkm tcj Aktjrkjt cgs p`gljm ihrj pue`al`y gvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk gkm

 prhljssakd phwjr gt tcj bakdjrtaps hb \h`majrs tcgk jvjr ejbhrj. G ehmy hb nkhw`jmdj hk

lu`turj, jlhkhials, djhdrgpcy, ia`atgry gbbgars, gkm ph`atals tcgt wgs hklj akglljssae`j thshij mjdrjj, khw rjst ak tcj cgkms hb cadc slchh` gkm lh``jdj stumjkts ” buturj `jgmjrs hb

tcj Griy.

]CJ THU@M TAMJ TJE GKM MJJ_ TJE

L-7.  ]cj Aktjrkjt as g mykgial akbhrigtahk jkvarhkijkt lhksastakd hb stgtahkgry gkm ihvakd vartug` gkm

tgrdjt Tje satjs lhktgakakd g iaxturj hb h`m gkm kjw lhktjkt. ]cjrj grj kuijrhus vartug` mgtgegsjs tcgt

drhw gt jxphkjktag` rgtjs. Njjpakd pglj watc tjlckh`hdy as gk jkmurakd lcg``jkdj bhr pjrshkkj` tcgt jkdgdj

ak H\AK] jxp`hatgtahk uta`azakd tcj TTT gkm Mjjp Tje.

THU@M TAMJ TJE 

L-5.  ]cj TTT as akmjxjm ey stgkmgrm sjgrlc jkdakjs. \tgkmgrm sjgrlc jkdakjs grj typalg``y aklgpge`j hb

glljssakd hr rjtrajvakd tcj typj hb akbhrigtahk kjljssgry bhr lhkmultakd jbbjltavj hpjk-shurlj rjsjgrlc.

]cj thtg` gihukt hb Aktjrkjt akbhrigtahk as jstaigtjm th ej hvjr 4,:?? tjrgeytjs gkm lhktakujs th aklrjgsj.

Hb tcas gihukt, lusthigry sjgrlc jkdakjs hk tcj Aktjrkjt grj jstaigtjm th akmjx hk`y hkj-qugrtjr hb tcj

akbhrigtahk. Lhksamjrjm g vjry `grdj gihukt hb akbhrigtahk, at hk`y rjprjsjkts g brgltahk hb tcj gihukt hb

hpjk-shurlj akbhrigtahk gvga`ge`j murakd rjsjgrlc uta`azakd pue`al`y gvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk. ]cj htcjr tcrjj-

qugrtjrs (hr rhudc`y :,25: tjrgeytjs) grj lhktgakjm hk wcgt as lg``jm tcj  Mjjp Tje.

]CJ MJJ_ TJE

L-<.  ]cj Mjjp Tje rjbjrs th lhktjkt tcgt as kht pgrt hb tcj trgmatahkg` TTT. ]cas lhktjkt as jstaigtjm th

 ej ihrj tcgk twalj tcj lhktjkt sgvjm gkm glljssae`j hk tcj trgmatahkg` TTT. ]cj lhktjkt gkm akbhrigtahk

lhktgakjm hk tcj Mjjp Tje as mjsadkjm grhukm Tje-egsjm mgtgegsjs. Zk`anj tcj TTT, tcj Mjjp Tje as

kht akmjxjm. Khkstgtal Tje satjs gkm mgtgegsjs `hlgtjm hk tcj Mjjp Tje lgkkht ej glljssjm hr akmjxjm ey

trgmatahkg` sjgrlc jkdakjs. ]cj Mjjp Tje hbbjrs g trjijkmhus gihukt hb rjshurljs. Mjjp Tje rjshurljs

lhu`m bg`` akth hkj hr ihrj hb tcj bh``hwakd6

  Mykgial lhktjkt. Tje pgdjs tcgt grj rjturkjm ak rjsphksj th g sueiattjm qujry.

  Zk`aknjm lhktjkt. Tje pgdjs tcgt grj kht `aknjm th htcjr Tje pgdjs tcgt prjvjkt stgkmgrm Tje

lrgw`akd prhdrgis brhi glljssakd tcj lhktjkt.

  _ravgtj Tje lhktjkt. Tje pgdjs watchut egln`akns hr ak`akns.

  @aiatjm glljss lhktjkt. Tje satjs tcgt aiat glljss th akbhrigtahk.

  Khkcypjrtjxt igrnup `gkdugdj lhktjkt. ]jxtug` lhktjkt jklhmjm ak iu`taijmag ba`js tcgt grj kht

cgkm`jm ey sjgrlc jkdakjs.

Page 62: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 62/91

Gppjkmax L

L-5 G]_ 5-55.1 7? Fu`y 5?75 

\JGULC JKDAKJ\

L-=.  \jgrlc jkdakjs grj tcj praigry thh`s tcgt pjrshkkj` jkdgdakd ak H\AK] gltavatajs usj wcjk

lhkmultakd rjsjgrlc hb pue`al`y gvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk tcrhudc hpjk shurljs. H\AK] pjrshkkj` usj sjgrlc

jkdakjs gkm sjgrlc tjris th `hlgtj tjxt, aigdjs, gkm akbhrigtahk hk tchusgkms hb Tje satjs. ]jlckalg``y,

sjgrlc jkdakjs grj gltug``y sjgrlcakd tcrhudc tcj akmjx hb Tje satjs. Lhiijrlag` gkm dhvjrkijkt sjgrlc

jkdakjs vgry ak wcgt pgrgijtjrs grj sjgrlcjm, chw sjgrlcjs grj prhljssjm, gkm chw sjgrlc rjsu`ts grj

masp`gyjm. Ihst sjgrlc jkdakjs usj prhdrgis lg``jm wje lrgw`jrs  th eua`m akmjxjm mgtgegsjs. G wjelrgw`jr sjgrlcjs Aktjrkjt Tje satjs gkm ba`js gkm sgvjs tcj rjsu`ts ak g mgtgegsj.

L-:.  Ihst sjgrlc jkdakjs usj rj`jvgkly bhriu`gs th masp`gy rjsu`ts ak g spjlabal hrmjr watc g erajb

mjslraptahk gkm cypjr`akn th tcj rjbjrjklj Aktjrkjt ba`j. Uj`jvgkly bhriu`gs jvg`ugtj chw wj`` tcj qujry

igtlcjs tcj rjqujst. Uj`jvgkly bhriu`gs grj sadkabalgkt th tcj usjr gs sjgrlc jkdakjs jvh`vj gkm wa`` kht g``

yaj`m saia`gr rjsu`ts. ]cj p`gljijkt hb njywhrms yaj`m mabbjrjkt rjsu`ts ab rjgrrgkdjm muj th ihrj jipcgsas

 p`gljm hk hkj whrm hvjr gkhtcjr. Gs sjgrlc jkdakjs cgvj jvh`vjm, shij cgvj ejlhij gmjpt gt bakmakd

spjlabal typjs hb akbhrigtahk, sulc gs stgtastalg`, bakgklag`, gkm kjws, ihrj jbbjltavj`y. ]h hvjrlhij tcas

spjlag`azgtahk, shbtwgrj jkdakjjrs cgvj mjvj`hpjm ijtgsjgrlc jkdakjs tcgt g``hw tcj usjr th qujry ihrj

tcgk hkj sjgrlc jkdakj gt g taij.

\jgrlc Jkdakjs

Ab g pgrtalu`gr sjgrlc jkdakj lgkkht gllhiihmgtj pcrgsjs ak quhtgtahk igrns hrhtcjr typjs hb Ehh`jgk bukltahks, tcjk tcj ijtgsjgrlc jkdakj j`aiakgtjs tcgt bukltahkbrhi tcj sjgrlc. ]cj rjsu`takd sjgrlc tcjk ejlhijs thh erhgm gkm `jss usjbu` tcgk gwj``-bhrigttjm sjgrlc usakd g spjlag`azjm sjgrlc jkdakj.

L-2.  Tatc gk ukmjrstgkmakd hb chw sjgrlc jkdakjs whrn, aktj``adjklj pjrshkkj  ”  

  Lhkmult akatag` sjgrlcjs usakd ukaquj njywhrms gkm lhieakgtahks.

  Gpp`y Ehh`jgk `hdal th aiprhvj sjgrlc pgrgijtjrs.

  Lhkmult bh``hw-hk sjgrlcjs usakd kgturg` `gkdugdj.

\JGULC EQ N JQTHUM 

L-4.  Ak njywhrm-egsjm sjgrlcjs, H\AK] pjrshkkj` schu`m lhksamjr wcgt njywhrms grj ukaquj th tcj

akbhrigtahk ejakd rjsjgrlcjm. Njywhrms schu`m ej eg`gkljm th yaj`m rj`jvgkt rjsu`ts watchut gk hvjrgeukmgklj hb arrj`jvgkt akbhrigtahk. Lhiihk whrms th ej gvhamjm akl`umj ”  

  G.

  Gk.

  Gkm.

  ]cj.

L-3.  ]cjsj whrms schu`m ej gvhamjm ak sjgrlc tjris uk`jss pgrt hb tcj tat`j hb g ehhn hr grtal`j. Ihst

sjgrlc jkdakjs adkhrj lhiihk whrms. Bhr jxgip`j, ab `hhnakd bhr akbhrigtahk gehut Uussagk gkm Lcakjsj

tgkn sg`js th Argq, mh kht usj tgkn  gs tcj hk`y njywhrm ak tcj sjgrlc. Akstjgm, usj gmmatahkg` mjbakakd whrms

sulc gs ‐Uussagk Lcakjsj tgkn sg`js Argq.’ 

EHH@JGK @HDAL H_JUG]HU\, LHKKJL]HU\, GKM MJ@AIA]JU\ 

L-1.  Tcjk sjgrlcakd tcj Aktjrkjt, tcj vgst mgtg gvga`ge`j lgk ej sjgrlcjm gllhrmakd th tcj ru`js hb

lhiputjr mgtgegsj sjgrlcjs. ]cj `hdalg` rj`gtahkscap ejtwjjk sjgrlc tjris as rjbjrrjm th gs  Ehh`jgk `hdal.

]cas ijtchm hb sjgrlcakd prhvamjs hptahks bhr lhkstrultakd `hdalg` rj`gtahkscaps gihkd sjgrlc tjris usakd

`hlg` hpjrgthrs, lhkkjlthrs, gkm mj`aiatjrs.

L-7?. Ehh`jgk `hdal hpjrgthrs, lhkkjlthrs, gkm mj`aiatjrs gssast aktj``adjklj pjrshkkj` ak jstge`ascakd

rj`gtahkscaps ejtwjjk njywhrms th aiprhvj sjgrlc gltavatajs.

Page 63: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 63/91

Egsal gkm Gmvgkljm Aktjrkjt \jgrlc ]jlckaqujs

7? Fu`y 5?75  G]_ 5-55.1 L-<

Jxgip`j hb Zsakd Ehh`jgk @hdal Hpjrgthrs Gpp`yakd tcj bh``hwakd jxgip`j, usakd tcj hpjrgthrs (sjj tge`j L-7), tcj sjgrlcjkdakj sjgrlcjs bhr Uussagk gkm tgkn  thdjtcjr wcjk p`gljm watcak pgrjktcjsjs”bhrjxgip`j, (Uussagk tgkn)”gkm th jxl`umj Lcakjsj tgkn sg`js brhi tcj sjgrlc rjsu`t,usj (Uussagk tgkn) KH] (Lcakjsj tgkn) sg`j Argq ak tcj sjgrlc. Aktj``adjkljpjrshkkj` lgk g`sh usj g KJGU   sjgrlc wcjk tcj rj`gtahkscap gkm tcj mastgklj

ejtwjjk tcj tjris grj wj`` jstge`ascjm. Bhr jxgip`j, ab aktj``adjklj pjrshkkj` grj`hhnakd bhr aklamjkts hb tgkn sg`js ak Egdcmgm gkm kjws grtal`js khrig``y p`glj tcjkgij hb tcj `hlgtahk watcak bavj whrms hb tgkn sg`js  ak tcj tat`j hb tcj ehmy hb tcjgrtal`j tcjk usj tgkn sg`js KJGU/:  ak tcj sjgrlc.

]ge`j L-7. Ehh`jgk `hdal hpjrgthrs, lhkkjlthrs, gkm mj`aiatjrs

Buklt ahk Ehh`jgk Jxgip`j  Iust ej prjsjkt *

 GKMLcjialg` GKM wjgphk

lcjialg` *wjgphk

Iust kht ej prjsjkt KH] Gbralg KH] \umgk

Igy ej prjsjkt HU Lcjialg` HU eah`hdalg`

Lhip`jtj pcrgsj * * *Lcakjsj tgkn sg`js th Argq*Kjstjm ( ) (\cakakd _gtc)

Kjgr** KJGU ‐Tcatj Chusj’ KJGU ‐garspglj aklursahk’ 

Ta`mlgrms Thrm* hr *whrm Duk* (dukphwmjr)

Khtj. Ehh`jgk sjgrlcjs igy kht whrn hk g`` sjgrlc jkdakjs. Zsakd tcj ‐Gmvgkljm \jgrlc’ hptahk as

gvga`ge`j hk igky wje erhwsjrs. Gmvgkljm sjgrlc pgdjs akl`umj baj`ms th ba`` ak sulc gs ‐Bakm wje

 pgdjs tcgt lhktgak g`` tcjsj whrms>’ ‐tcas jxglt whrmakd hr pcrgsj>’ hr ‐Mh kht schw pgdjs akl`umakd

gky hb tcjsj whrms.’ 

\JGULC AK KG]ZUG@ @GKDZGDJ 

L-77. Gk g`tjrkgtavj th usakd g njywhrm sjgrlc as tcj kgturg` `gkdugdj  qujstahk bhrigt gs ihst hb tcj

igfhr sjgrlc jkdakjs g``hw tcas lgpgea`aty. H\AK] pjrshkkj` hetgak tcj ejst rjsu`ts wcjk tcj qujstahk

lhktgaks dhhm njywhrms. Hkj hb tcj igfhr mhwksamjs th tcas tjlckaquj as tcj `grdj kuiejr hb rjsu`ts. Ab tcj

kjjmjm akbhrigtahk as kht bhukm ak tcj rjsu`ts hb tcj barst bjw pgdjs tcj qujstahk schu`m ej rjbakjm th

akatagtj g kjw sjgrlc usakd mabbjrjkt pgrgijtjrs.

AK]JUKJ] TJE \A]J\

L-75. ]cj bhur stjps usjm th jxp`hat pue`al`y gvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk gkm hpjk shurljs hk Aktjrkjt Tje satjs grj ”  

  _`gk Aktjrkjt sjgrlc.

  Lhkmult Aktjrkjt sjgrlc.

  Ujbakj Aktjrkjt sjgrlc.

  Ujlhrm rjsu`ts.

_@GK AK]JUKJ] \JGULC 

L-7<. H\AK] pjrshkkj` usj gk ukmjrstgkmakd hb aktj``adjklj gkm akbhrigtahk rjquarjijkts th p`gk Aktjrkjt

sjgrlcjs. Aktj``adjklj gkm akbhrigtahk rjquarjijkts cj`p th mjtjriakj wcgt akbhrigtahk th sjgrlc bhr, wcjrj th

sjgrlc, gkm prhvamjs tcj bhlus gkm akatag` njywhrms usjm ak tcj sjgrlc. Gbtjr mjtjriakakd tcj bhlus gkm

njywhrms, H\AK] pjrshkkj` usj Aktjrkjt erhwsjrs gkm sjgrlc jkdakjs th lhkkjlt th g prjvahus`y amjktabajm

Aktjrkjt Tje satj.

Page 64: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 64/91

Gppjkmax L

L-= G]_ 5-55.1 7? Fu`y 5?75 

Njywhrm \jgrlcjsAb g ukat as p`gkkakd g cuigkatgragk gssastgklj hpjrgtahk ak g pgrtalu`gr lhuktry,aktj``adjklj rjquarjijkts igy ej th `hlgtj rjbudjj lhkljktrgtahks ak tcgt lhuktry.]cj tgsn bhr gk H\AK] lj`` lhu`m akl`umj th `hlgtj” 

  Cuigkatgragk rj`ajb hrdgkazgtahks hpjrgtakd bhhm mastraeutahk ljktjrs.

  _hpu`gtahk ljktjrs ak tcj lhuktry.  Lhkljktrgtahks hb ia`atag bhrljs.

  Grjgs hb ia`atag hpjrgtahks watcak ak tcj `gst <? mgys.

Zsjbu` sjgrlc tjris whu`m akl`umj” 

  Ujbudjj.

  Cuigkatgragk rj`ajb.

  Ia`atag.

  Tgtjr shurljs.

  Bhhm mastraeutahk.

@hlgtakd phssae`j akmalgthrs hb wcjrj rjbudjjs igy hr igy kht lhkljktrgtj akl`umj ” 

  Khkdhvjrkijktg` hrdgkazgtahk gam ljktjrs.

  Bhhm.

  Tgtjr.

  Chsta`j ia`atag bhrljs.

Egsjm hk aktj``adjklj rjquarjijkts, tcj sjgrlc hefjltavj as th `hlgtj rjbudjjlhkljktrgtahks egsjm hk tcj phsatahk hb supp`ajs gkm ia`atag bhrljs ak tcj lhuktry.

LHKMZL] AK]JUKJ] \JGULC 

L-7=. H\AK] pjrshkkj` lhkmult gk akatag` sjgrlc hb `anj`y shurljs usakd rj`gtjm tjris hr suefjlt igttjr bhr

tcj rjsjgrlc qujstahk. ]cj akatag` sjgrlc as tcj barst hb phtjktag``y igky suesjqujkt sjgrlcjs bhr mgtg gkm

akbhrigtahk tcgt as rjtrajvjm gkm rjlhrmjm ak gllhrmgklj watc tcj rjsjgrlc p`gk. Hklj rjtrajvjm, tcj

akbhrigtahk as aktjdrgtjm akth tcj gpprhpragtj madatg` hr gkg`hd mgtgegsj. H\AK] pjrshkkj` schu`m gvham tcj

tjiptgtahk hb usakd hk`y hkj sjgrlc jkdakj gs jglc cgs strjkdtcs gkm wjgnkjssjs. Hrdgkazgtahkg` stgkmgrms,rjsjgrlc jxpjrajklj, gkm pjjr rjlhiijkmgtahks typalg``y duamj tcj sj`jltahk hb wcalc sjgrlc jkdakj th usj.

Khtj. Ab tcj akbhrigtahk as kht amjktabajm usakd iu`tap`j sjgrlc jkdakjs watcak <? iakutjs, at as

 phssae`j tcgt tcj akbhrigtahk mhjs kht jxast hk tcj Aktjrkjt, cgs kht ejjk akmjxjm, hr as kht ak g

rjtrajvge`j bhrigt.

U JBAKJ AK]JUKJ] \JGULC 

L-7:. ]ypalg``y, tcj barst bjw pgdjs hb sjgrlc rjsu`ts grj tcj ihst rj`jvgkt. Egsjm hk tcjsj pgdjs, H\AK]

 pjrshkkj` jxp`hat tcj akatag` sjgrlc rjsu`ts bhr rj`jvgkly gkm gllurgly bhr bh``hw-hk sjgrlcjs th mjtjriakj ab

tcj rjsu`ts sgtasbajm tcj aktj``adjklj hr akbhrigtahk rjquarjijkt. Akatag` Aktjrkjt sjgrlcjs lgk yaj`m ukmjsarjm

rjsu`ts th sgtasby aktj``adjklj gkm akbhrigtahk rjquarjijkts. H\AK] pjrshkkj` typalg``y usj ijgsurjs th

rjbakj Aktjrkjt rjsu`ts, akl`umakd eut kht `aiatjm th ”  

  Ujhrmjrakd sjgrlc tjris.   Lcgkdakd spj``akd gkm drgiigr.

  Gmfustakd uppjr hr `hwjr lgsj.   Zsakd njywhrm vgragkts.

  \jgrlcakd watcak rjsu`ts.   \jgrlcakd ey baj`m.

  \jgrlcakd ak tcj lglcj gkm grlcavj.   ]ruklgtakd tcj ZU@.

  Tje satj mhigaks.

Page 65: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 65/91

Egsal gkm Gmvgkljm Aktjrkjt \jgrlc ]jlckaqujs

7? Fu`y 5?75  G]_ 5-55.1 L-:

Ujhrmjr \jgrlc ]jris

L-72. \jgrlc jkdakjs igy p`glj g cadcjr vg`uj hk tcj barst whrm hr whrms ak g iu`tap`j whrm hr pcrgsj

sjgrlc strakd. Bhr jxgip`j, lcgkdakd tcj whrm hrmjr brhi mjvaljs jxp`hsavj th jxp`hsavj mjvaljs igy yaj`m

mabbjrjkt sjgrlc rjsu`ts.

Lcgkdj \pj``akd gkm Drgiigr

L-74. \jgrlc jkdakjs gttjipt th igtlc tcj jxglt spj``akd hb tcj whrms ak tcj sjgrlc strakd. ]cjrj grj sjgrlc

jkdakjs tcgt rjlhdkazj g`tjrkgtj spj``akds hr prhipt tcj usjr th lhrrjlt lhiihk iasspj``akds. Bhr jxgip`j,

lcgkdakd tcj spj``akd hb g whrm brhi tcj Gijralgk-Jkd`asc ljktjr   th tcj Eratasc-Jkd`asc ljktrj  igy yaj`m

mabbjrjkt rjsu`ts. Ehh`jgk `hdal lgk g`sh ej usjm ak hrmjr th larluivjkt phtjktag` spj``akd iastgnjs. Gmmatahkg``y,

lcgkdakd tcj spj``akd hb g trgks`atjrgtjm kgij djkjrgtjs mabbjrjkt rjsu`ts tcgt igy ej usjbu` mjpjkmakd uphk tcj

hefjltavj hb tcj sjgrlc, sulc gs tcj spj``akd vgragtahks hb tcj kgij ”  

   G`-Wgjmg.

  g`-Wgamg.

  g`-Wg‑amg.

  j`-Wgamg.

  g` Wgjmg.

Gmfust Zppjr hr @hwjr Lgsj

L-73. \jgrlc jkdakjs igy hr igy kht supphrt lgsj sjksatavj sjgrlcjs. \hij sjgrlc jkdakjs gttjipt th

igtlc tcj whrm jxglt`y gs jktjrjm ak tcj sjgrlc. Ihst sjgrlcjs schu`m ej g`` `hwjrlgsj `jttjrs. Tcjk

`hhnakd bhr tcj kgij hb g pjrshk, djhdrgpcalg` `hlgtahk, tat`j, hr htcjr khrig``y lgpatg`azjm whrm, usj g lgsj

sjksatavj sjgrlc jkdakj. Bhr jxgip`j, lcgkdakd tcj lgsj hb g whrm sulc gs fgvg th FGRG lcgkdjs tcj rjsu`ts

brhi lhbbjj Tje satjs th shbtwgrj prhdrgi Tje satjs.

Zsj Njywhrm Rgragkts

L-71. H\AK] pjrshkkj` usj tjris tcgt grj lu`turg``y hr djhdrgpcalg``y lhiihk. Zsakd vgragkts hb g

njywhrm sulc gs lcgkdakd  ph`aljigk  th lhp, eheey,  djkmgrij, lgrgeakajrj,  ph`alég,  ph`atzja, hr htcjr

bhris igy aiprhvj sjgrlc rjsu`ts.

\jgrlc Tatcak Ujsu`ts

L-5?. Ab tcj akatag` hr bh``hw-hk sjgrlc prhmuljs dhhm eut sta`` uksgtasbglthry rjsu`ts, H\AK] pjrshkkj` lgk

sjgrlc watcak tcjsj rjsu`ts th prhmulj g cadcjr prhegea`aty hb bakmakd tcj mjsarjm rjsu`ts. Ihst sjgrlc

jkdakjs masp`gy gk hptahk sulc gs sjgrlc watcak tcjsj rjsu`ts hr saia`gr pgdjs th gssast tcj usjr.

\jgrlc ey Baj`m

L-57. Ak g baj`m sjgrlc, H\AK] pjrshkkj` `hhn bhr njywhrms watcak tcj ZU@ gs hpphsjm th sjgrlcakd tcj

Aktjrkjt. ]cas as typalg``y mhkj wcjk tcj sjgrlc jkdakj rjturkjm g `grdj kuiejr hb rjsu`ts. Tca`j lgpgea`atajs vgry

 ey sjgrlc jkdakj, shij hb tcj lhiihk baj`m sjgrlc hpjrgthrs grj ”  

  Gklchr. \jgrlcjs bhr Tje satjs watc g spjlabajm cypjr`akn.

  Mhigak. \jgrlcjs bhr spjlabal mhigaks.

  @anj. \jgrlcjs bhr Tje satjs saia`gr hr rj`gtjm ak shij wgy th spjlabajm ZU@s.  @akn. \jgrlcjs bhr spjlabal cypjr`akns jiejmmjm ak g Tje satj.

  ]jxt. \jgrlcjs bhr spjlabal tjxt ak tcj ehmy hb tcj Tje satj.

  ZU@. \jgrlcjs bhr spjlabal tjxt ak lhip`jtj Tje satj gmmrjssjs.

Page 66: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 66/91

Gppjkmax L

L-2 G]_ 5-55.1 7? Fu`y 5?75 

\jgrlc ak Lglcj gkm Grlcavj

L-55. \hijtaijs g sjgrlc hr gk gttjipt th sjgrlc watc rjsu`ts rjturks g ZU@ tcgt igtlcjs jxglt`y tcj sjgrlc

hefjltavj eut wcjk glljssjm tcj Tje satj as kh `hkdjr gltavj. Ab tcj sjgrlc jkdakj lgpturjs mgtg gs wj`` gs tcj

ZU@ `hlgthr, sj`jlt tcj lglcjm `akn th glljss tcj hradakg` mgtg. H\AK] pjrshkkj` lgk g`sh sjgrlc gk Aktjrkjt

grlcavj Tje satj, sulc gs www.grlcavj.hrd, bhr tcj lhktjkt. H\AK] pjrshkkj` kjjm th cgvj gwgrjkjss tcgt tcas

akbhrigtahk as casthralg` gkm kht suefjlt th upmgtj ey hradakg` lrjgthrs.

]ruklgtj tcj Zkabhri Ujshurlj @hlgthr

L-5<. Egsjm hk tcj thpal hb tcj akbhrigtahk hr aktj``adjklj rjquarjijkt, H\AK] pjrshkkj` lgk igkug``y

sjgrlc watcak tcj rjsu`ts ey truklgtakd tcj ZU@ th g Tje satj. H\AK] pjrshkkj` whrn eglnwgrms brhi tcj

hradakg` sjgrlc rjsu`t th tcj Tje satj lhktgakakd tcj mjsarjm akbhrigtahk hr mgtgegsj ey mj`jtakd tcj jkm

sjdijkts hb tcj ZU@ gt tcj bhrwgrm s`gsc. \jj igkug``y truklgtakd g ZU@ jxgip`j ak tge`j L-5.

L-5=. ]cjrj grj g`sh ZU@ schrtjkakd gssastgklj Tje satjs tcgt rjmarjlt g usjr brhi g schrt ZU@ (sulc gs ak

tcj sjlhkm pgrt hb tge`j L-5) th g iulc `hkdjr ZU@ sjrvakd gs tcj gltug` gmmrjss hb tcj Tje satj. ]cjsj grj

hbtjk usjm ak shlag` ijmag sjrvaljs `anj ]wattjr muj th tcj lcgrgltjr rjstraltahks p`gljm hk usjrs.

]ge`j L-5. ]ruklgtakd gkm schrtjkakd ukabhri rjshurlj `hlgthrs

Igkug` `y ]ruklgt akd g Zkabhri Ujshurlj @hlgthr (ZU@)

Jxgip`j ZU@ th truklgtj  cttp6//www.wjesatj.lhi/mjbgu`t.gspx8utiXshurlj9twattjr&utiXijmaui9shlag`-ijmag 

Mj`jtj g`` eut tcj igak pgrt hb tcj Tjesatj gmmrjss 

cttp6//www.wjesatj.lhi/ 

\chrtjkakd ZU@s Zsakd \chrtjkakd Gssastgklj

Jxgip`j ZU@ th pgstj akth schrtjkakdgssastgklj Tje satj 

cttp6//www.gigzhk.lhi/Nakm`j-Tarj`jss-Ujgmakd-Masp`gy-D`heg``y/mp/E??<B\ZMI=/rjb9gieX`aknX<:<5:1:25X58pbXrmXi9G]R_MNAN S?MJU&pbXrmXs9ljktjr-7?&pbXrmXr977JQN]K235G41]<4?GI<&pbXrmXt95?7&pbXrmXp9754?13:135&pbXrmXa9E??5Q54_<I

]cj schrtjkakd Tje satj prhmuljs tcjjxgip`j ZU@ th usj ak shlag` ijmagsjttakds hr ak j-iga`

cttp6//takyur`.lhi/Nakm`jTarj`jss 

Tje \atj Mhigaks

L-5:. Mhigak kgijs hk tcj Aktjrkjt grj amjktabyakd `gej`s gkm grj usjm ak vgrahus kjtwhrnakd lhktjxts. ]cjy

grj usjm gs saip`j amjktabalgtahk `gej`s th akmalgtj hwkjrscap hr lhktrh` hb g rjshurlj. Tatc tcj ia``ahks hb

ZU@s hk TTT, aktj``adjklj pjrshkkj` grj bgljm watc g iyragm hb Tje satjs tcgt igy hr igy kht prhmulj hr

igaktgak tcj akbhrigtahk prjsjktjm ak tcgt mhigak. Ljrtgak mhigaks, sulc gs tchsj `astjm ak tge`j L-<, grj

lhksastjkt`y rj`age`j gs ejakd gmiakastjrjm gkm gutchrjm ey tchsj typjs hb hrdgkazgtahks.

Khtj.  H\AK] pjrshkkj` jxp`hatakd pue`al`y gvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk gkm hpjk shurljs iust kht

tgnj .hrd , .akbh, hr .kjt  jxtjksahks gs kjljssgra`y prhmuljm ey g ehkg bamj hrdgkazgtahk bhr tcgt

mhigak.

Page 67: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 67/91

Egsal gkm Gmvgkljm Aktjrkjt \jgrlc ]jlckaqujs

7? Fu`y 5?75  G]_ 5-55.1 L-4

]ge`j L-<. Lhiihk Tje satj mhigaks

Mhigak Mjslr apt ahk

.gjrh Ujsjrvjm bhr ijiejrs hb tcj gar trgksphrt akmustry

.eaz Ujstraltjm th eusakjssjs

.lhi Zkrjstraltjm thp-`jvj` mhigak aktjkmjm bhr lhiijrlag` lhktjkt

.lhhp Ujsjrvjm bhr lhhpjrgtavj gsshlagtahks.jmu Ujsjrvjm bhr phstsjlhkmgry akstatutahks gllrjmatjm ey gk gdjkly hk tcj Z.\. Mjpgrtijkt hb

Jmulgtahk‑s ast hb Kgtahkg``y Ujlhdkazjm Gllrjmatakd Gdjklajs

.dhv Ujsjrvjm jxl`usavj`y bhr tcj Z.\. Dhvjrkijkt

.akbh Zkrjstraltjm thp-`jvj` mhigak

.akt Zsjm hk`y bhr rjdastjrakd hrdgkazgtahks jstge`ascjm ey aktjrkgtahkg` trjgtajs ejtwjjkdhvjrkijkts

.fhes Ujsjrvjm bhr cuigk rjshurlj igkgdjrs

.ia` Ujsjrvjm jxl`usavj`y bhr tcj Z.\. ia`atgry

.iusjui Ujsjrvjm bhr iusjuis

.kgij Ujsjrvjm bhr akmavamug`s

.kjt Ujsjrvjm bhr kjtwhrnakd tjlckh`hdalg` akmavamug`s

.hrd Aktjkmjm bhr khklhiijrlag` usj eut hpjk th g`` lhiiukatajs

.prh Ujstraltjm th lrjmjktag`jm prhbjssahkg`s gkm rj`gtjm jktatajs

H_JK-\HZULJ MG]GEG\J\, \HB]TGUJ, GKM ]HH@\

L-52. ]cjrj grj kuijrhus LH]\ shbtwgrj gpp`algtahks, thh`s, gkm mgtgegsjs tcgt grj sjgrlcge`j usakd qujry

whrms bhr rjsjgrlc. \jgrlc jkdakjs usjm bhr rjsjgrlc akl`umj eut grj kht `aiatjm th ”  

  Dhhd`j \lch`gr. Dhhd`j \lch`gr prhvamjs g saip`j wgy th erhgm`y sjgrlc bhr slch`gr`y `atjrgturj.

Brhi hkj p`glj, sjgrlcjs jxpgkm glrhss igky maslap`akjs gkm shurljs tcgt akl`umj grtal`js, tcjsjs,

 ehhns, gkm gestrglts. Dhhd j \lch`gr cj`ps `hlgtj rj`jvgkt whrn glrhss tcj whr m hb slch gr`y

rjsjgrlc.

  \phnjh. \phnjh spjlag`azjs ak hrdgkazakd pjhp`j-rj`gtjm akbhrigtahk (kgijs, gmmrjssjs, pchkj

kuiejrs) brhi pchkj ehhns, shlag` kjtwhrns, igrnjtakd `asts, eusakjss Tje satjs, gkm htcjr pue`al

shurljs. \phnjh usjs g`dhratcis th pajlj thdjtcjr mgtg akth lhcjrjkt prhba`js.  E`hd _u`sj. E`hd_u`sj as gk guthigtjm trjkm maslhvjry systji bhr e`hds ey gpp`yakd iglcakj-

`jgrkakd gkm kgturg` `gkdugdj prhljssakd tjlckaqujs.

  _ap`. _ap` qujry jkdakj cj`ps `hlgtj Mjjp Tje pgdjs tcgt lgkkht ej bhukm hk rjdu`gr hr stgkmgrm

sjgrlc jkdakjs. _ap` usjs gmvgkljm `gkdugdj-gkg`ysas gkm rgknakd g`dhratcis th rjtrajvj tcj ihst

rj`jvgkt akbhrigtahk gehut gk akmavamug`.

  Ihkattjr. Ihkattjr as g erhwsjr-egsjm ]wattjr sjgrlc jkdakj. Ihkattjr masp`gys tcrjj lhkstgkt`y

upmgtjm njywhrm sjgrlcjs pgrg``j` th jglc htcjr ak yhur erhwsjr.

  Ig`tjdh. Ig`tjdh as g bhrjksal gpp`algtahk tcgt hbbjrs mgtg-iakakd gkm dgtcjrakd hb akbhrigtahk akth

 pglngdjm rjprjsjktgtahks. Ig tjdh g``hws tcj amjktabalgtahk hb njy rj`gtahkscaps ejtwjjk akbhrigtahk

gkm amjktaby prjvahus`y uknkhwk rj`gtahkscaps.

Page 68: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 68/91

Gppjkmax L

L-3 G]_ 5-55.1 7? Fu`y 5?75 

DHHD@J ]HH@\

L-54. Dhhd`j thh`s gssast ak jxp`hatakd pue`al`y gvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk gkm hpjk shurljs tcrhudc ”  

  Wujry whrms.

  Wujry typjs.

  Wujry ihmabajrs.

WZJUQ THUM\ 

L-53. Dhhd`j supphrts sjvjrg` gmvgkljm Ehh`jgk `hdal hpjrgthrs, wcalc grj qujry whrms tcgt cgvj spjlag`

ijgkakd th Dhhd`j. ]ypalg``y qujry typjs gkm qujry ihmabajrs, wcjk gpp`ajm ey hpjrgthrs, ihmaby tcj

 pgrgijtjrs gkm rjsu`ts hb sjgrlc jkdakjs.

WZJUQ ]Q_J\ 

L-51. Bhur lgtjdhrajs lhvjrakd ihst Tje-sjgrlc qujrajs akl`umj ”  

  Lglcj. Ab htcjr whrms grj akl`umjm ak tcj qujry, Dhhd`j cadc`adcts tchsj whrms watcak tcj

lglcjm mhluijkt. Bhr jxgip`j, ^lglcj6www.dhhd`j.lhi wjeY schws tcj lglcjm lhktjkt watc

tcj whrm ‐wje’ cadc`adctjm. 

  @akn. ]cj qujry ^`akn6Y `asts Tje pgdjs tcgt cgvj `akns th tcj spjlabajm Tje pgdj. Bhr jxgip`j,

^`akn6www.dhhd`j.lhiY `asts Tje pgdjs tcgt cgvj `akns phaktakd th tcj Dhhd`j chijpgdj.

  Uj`gtjm. ]cj qujry ^rj`gtjm6Y `asts Tje pgdjs tcgt grj saia`gr th g spjlabajm Tje pgdj. Bhr

jxgip`j, ^rj`gtjm6www.dhhd`j.lhiY `asts Tje pgdjs tcgt grj saia`gr th tcj Dhhd`j chijpgdj.

  Akbh. ]cj qujry ^akbh6Y prjsjkts shij akbhrigtahk tcgt Dhhd`j cgs gehut tcgt Tje pgdj. Bhr

jxgip`j, ^akbh6www.dhhd`j.lhiY schws akbhrigtahk gehut tcj Dhhd`j chijpgdj.

WZJUQ IHMABAJU\ 

L-<?. Ujsjgrlc usakd g spjlabal sjgrlc qujry lgk ej ihmabajm usakd tcj bh``hwakd ihmabajrs6

  \atj. Ab ^satj6Y as akl`umjm ak tcj qujry, tcj rjsu`ts grj rjstraltjm th tchsj Tje satjs ak tcj davjk

mhigak. Bhr jxgip`j, ^cj`p satj6www.dhhd`j.lhiY bakms pgdjs gehut cj`p  watcak

www.dhhd`j.lhi. ^cj`p satj6lhiY bakms pgdjs gehut cj`p watcak .lhi ZU@s.

  G``aktat`j. Ab g qujry stgrts watc ^g``aktat`j6Y, tcj rjsu`ts grj rjstraltjm th tchsj Tje satjs watc g``

hb tcj qujry whrms ak tcj tat`j. Bhr jxgip`j, ^g``aktat`j6 dhhd`j sjgrlcY rjturks hk`y mhluijkts

tcgt cgvj ehtc dhhd`j gkm sjgrlc ak tcj tat`j.

  Aktat`j. Ab ^aktat`j6Y as akl`umjm ak tcj qujry, tcj rjsu`ts grj rjstraltjm th mhluijkts lhktgakakd tcgt

whrm ak tcj tat`j. Bhr jxgip`j, ^aktat`j6dhhd`j sjgrlcY rjturks mhluijkts tcgt cgvj tcj whrm

 dhhd`j ak tcjar tat`j, gkm cgvj tcj whrm  sjgrlc gkywcjrj ak tcj mhluijkt (tat`j hr kht). _uttakd

^aktat`j6Y ak brhkt hb jvjry whrm ak tcj qujry as jquavg`jkt th puttakd ^g``aktat`j6Y gt tcj brhkt hb tcj

qujry6 ^aktat`j6dhhd`j aktat`j6sjgrlcY as tcj sgij gs ^g``aktat`j6 dhhd`j sjgrlcY.

  G``akur`. Ab g qujry stgrts watc ^g``akur`6Y, tcj rjsu`ts grj rjstraltjm th tchsj Tje satjs watc g`` hb

tcj qujry whrms ak tcj ZU@. Bhr jxgip`j, ^g``akur`6 dhhd`j sjgrlcY rjturks hk`y mhluijkts tcgt

cgvj ehtc dhhd`j gkm sjgrlc ak tcj ZU@.

  Akur`. Ab ^akur`6Y as akl`umjm ak tcj qujry, tcj rjsu`ts grj rjstraltjm th tchsj mhluijkts lhktgakakd

tcgt whrm ak tcj ZU@. Bhr jxgip`j, ^akur`6dhhd`j sjgrlcY rjturks mhluijkts tcgt cgvj tcj whrm

 dhhd`j  ak tcjar ZU@s, gkm cgvj tcj whrm  sjgrlc  gkywcjrj ak tcj mhluijkt (ZU@ hr kht)._uttakd ‐akur`6’ ak brhkt hb jvjry whrm ak tcj qujry as jquavg`jkt th puttakd ‐g``akur`6’ gt tcj brhkt

hb tcj qujry6 ^akur`6dhhd`j akur`6sjgrlcY as tcj sgij gs ^g``akur`6 dhhd`j sjgrlcY.

AK]JUKG]AHKG@ AK]JUKJ] TJE \A]J\

]cj kuiejr hb khk-Jkd`asc-`gkdugdj usjrs hk tcj TTT gkm Mjjp Tje grj aklrjgsakd`y surpgssakd

Jkd`asc usjrs. ]cas aktjrkgtahkg` rjglc rjsu`ts ak tcj lrjgtahk hb bhrjadk Tje satjs watc spjlabal lhuktry

Page 69: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 69/91

Egsal gkm Gmvgkljm Aktjrkjt \jgrlc ]jlckaqujs

7? Fu`y 5?75  G]_ 5-55.1 L-1

lhmjs. H\AK] pjrshkkj` iust ej gwgrj hb tcj hradak hb bhrjadk Tje satjs gkm tcj phtjktag` vu`kjrgea`atajs

akcjrjkt ak glljssakd tcjsj Tje satjs.

AK]JUKJ] \JGULC ]JLCKAWZJ LHK\AMJUG]AHK\

L-<7. Tcjk lhkmultakd Aktjrkjt egsal gkm gmvgkljm sjgrlcjs, tjlckaquj grjgs tcgt schu`m ej lhksamjrjm grj ”  

  LH]\ shbtwgrj. Tcjk uta`azakd LH]\ thh`s gkm shbtwgrj, H\AK] pjrshkkj` iust lhksamjr tcj

thh`s gkm shbtwgrj uta`azjm ak gllhrmgklj watc ukat \H_s, duamj`akjs gkm ph`alajs.

  Lgtg`hdakd gkm grlcavakd. Muj th tcj kgturj hb Aktjrkjt Tje satjs gkm tcj `gln hb lhktrh`

rjstraltahks, Tje satjs lgk ej rjihvjm brhi tcj TTT watchut prahr khtalj.

  Gutchrscap. Hpjk-shurlj prhmults lgk hbtjktaijs ej gutchrjm tcrhudc gkhkyiaty.

  Amjktabajm Tje satjs gkm phrtg`s. Bgia`agrazgtahk hb pue`al`y gvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk djkjrg``y

rjsu`ts ak stgkmgrmazjm Tje satjs gkm phrtg`s usjm bhr rjsjgrlc. Tje satjs gkm phrtg`s grj

suefjltavj ak kgturj muj th tcj eagsjs gkm pjrljptahks hb tcj Tje satj gmiakastrgthr hr mjsadkjr.

  Hbb-`akj erhwsjrs. Muj th tcj vh`gta`j gkm ukprjmaltgea`aty hb Tje satjs, jbbjltavj usj hb hbb-`akj

 erhwsjrs lgk jkcgklj Aktjrkjt rjsjgrlc.

AK]JUKJ] GKM H_JUG]AHK\ \JLZUA]Q RZ@KJUGEA@A]AJ\

L-<5. ]cj aktjkt hb H\AK] as th jxp`hat pue`al`y gvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk gkm hpjk shurljs watchut rjvjg`akdusjr hr hrdgkazgtahkg` amjktatajs. Jxp`hatakd pue`al`y gvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk gkm hpjk shurljs as typalg``y

gkhkyihus gkm lhkmultjm watc g `hw rasn hb phtjktag` H_\JL lhiprhiasj. ]cjrj grj akcjrjkt tcrjgts

wcjk lhkmultakd rjsjgrlc hk tcj TTT gkm Mjjp Tje. Hpjk-shurlj rjsjgrlc lgk lhiprhiasj H_\JL

gkm rjvjg` usjr amjktabalgtahk gkm tcj `hlgtahk hb tcj lhiputjr systjis tcrhudc A_ gmmrjssjs. Gky kuiejr

hb systji masruptahk thh`s lgk rjkmjr hpjk-shurlj lh``jltahk gltavatajs akjbbjltavj. ]cjsj akl`umj eut grj kht

`aiatjm th ”  

  Rarusjs. Lhiputjr lhmjs tcgt gttglc th lhiputjr prhdrgis. Hklj gttglcjm, varusjs akbjlt htcjr

lhiputjr systjis tcrhudc rjp`algtahk.

  ]rhfgk chrsjs. Lhiputjr prhdrgis tcgt prjvjkt usjr-gltavgtjm lhiigkms.

  Thris. \j`b-lhktgakjm lhiputjr prhdrgis tcgt akbjlt lhiputjrs tcrhudc rjp`algtahk. Thris

lrjgtj trgbbal hk Tje satjs watc tcj hefjltavj hb mjlrjgsakd vasaea`aty ey lhkmultakd mjkag` hb

sjrvalj gttglns.

Khtj. H\AK] pjrshkkj` schu`m lhksu`t watc hrdgkal ukat‑s \-2/D-2 gkm akbhrigtahk gssurgklj

 pjrshkkj` bhr lurrjkt tcrjgts gkm duamj`akjs th jksurj tcgt hpjrgtakd systjis gkm erhwsjrs grj

usakd tcj ihst lurrjkt sjluraty pgtlcjs, gktavarus, gkm gktaspywgrj prhtjltahk shbtwgrj.

Page 70: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 70/91

Page 71: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 71/91

 

7? Fu`y 5?75  G]_ 5-55.1 M-7

Gppjkmax M 

H\AK] Lhktraeutahks

]cj vadkjttjs gkm maslussahks ak tcas gppjkmax a``ustrgtj chw aktjdrgtjm H\AK]supphrts hr lhktraeutjs th ”  

  Zkabajm `gkm hpjrgtahks gkm gsshlagtjm iassahks gkm tgsns.

  Htcjr aktj``adjklj maslap`akjs.

  Htcjr bukltahks, sulc gs satj jxp`hatgtahk (\J) gkm shurlj vjttakd.

]cj jxgip`js prhvamjm mh kht lhkstatutj g lhiprjcjksavj `ast.

\Z__HU] ]H ]GUDJ]AKD, LHZK]JUAK\ZUDJKLQ, GKMAI_UHRA\JM JS_@H\ARJ MJRALJ MJBJG] H_JUG]AHK\ 

M-7.  Gs g rjsu`t hb tgrdjt mjvj`hpijkt, H\AK] lhktraeutjs th tcj prhmults sulc gs tgrdjt `asts, tgrdjt

bh`mjrs, tgrdjt erajbs, gkm jxp`hatgtahk rjquarjijkts. ]cj bh``hwakd vadkjttj mjslraejs hkj satugtahk wcjrj

H\AK] lhktraeutjs th tgrdjtakd. (Bhr ihrj akbhrigtahk hk tgrdjtakd sjj BI <-2?.)

Jxgip`j hb H\AK] Lhktraeutahks th ]grdjtakd]cj Zkatjm \tgtjs as dhakd th wgr gdgakst Lhuktry S. ]cj Zkatjm \tgtjs cgs gkhefjltavj th `aiat tcj lhuktjrstranj lgpgea`atajs hb Lhuktry S. ]cjrj as g sadkabalgktia`atgry sthlnpa`j tcgt Lhuktry S purphsj`y lh``hlgtjm ey g rj`adahus ljktjr. \chu`mtcj Zkatjm \tgtjs mjstrhy tcj sthlnpa`j nkhwakd tcjrj as g drjgt lcgklj tcgt tcj

syieh`al rj`adahus ljktjr wa`` ej mjstrhyjm gs lh``gtjrg` mgigdj8H\AK] lgk supphrt tcas hefjltavj ey prhvamakd akbhrigtahk sulc gs” 

  Tcgt as tcj rj`adahus eglndrhukm hb tcj phpu`gtahk avakd kjgr tcj rj`adahus ljktjr8

  As tcj rj`adahus ljktjr lu`turg``y sadkabalgkt8

  As at gk casthralg` `gkmigrn8

  Tcgt as tcj ignjup hb tcj lhkdrjdgtahk8

  Tcgt grj tcj khrig` taijs tcgt pjhp`j lhkdrjdgtj8

  Tcgt grj tcj tjlckalg` mjslraptahks hb tcj jquapijkt ak tcj sthlnpa`j8

M-5.  Ak supphrt hb lhuktjraksurdjkly hpjrgtahks, pue`al`y gvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk as vg`uge`j bhr

ukmjrstgkmakd tcj hpjrgtahkg` jkvarhkijkt. At as hbtjk ihrj usjbu` tcgk gky htcjr maslap`akj bhr

ukmjrstgkmakd pue`al gttatumjs gkm pue`al supphrt murakd lhuktjraksurdjkly hpjrgtahks. _ue`al`y gvga`ge`j

akbhrigtahk as g`sh gk aiphrtgkt ijgks hb mjtjriakakd tcj jbbjltavjkjss hb akbhri gkm akb`ujklj gltavatajsgihkd tcj `hlg` phpu`glj. Ihkathrakd pue`al ijmag ejkjbats lhuktjraksurdjkly hpjrgtahks. Ab phssae`j,

ihkathrakd schu`m hllur gt jvjry jlcj`hk ak supphrt hb _AUs. Jglc jlcj`hk schu`m ihkathr tcj ijmag tcgt

lhktgak akbhrigtahk rj`jvgkt th hpjrgtahks gt tcgt jlcj`hk. Bhr akstgklj, gt tcj lhrps `jvj`, igfhr kjws

kjtwhrns schu`m ej ihkathrjm> ak lhktrgst, gt tcj tgltalg` `jvj`, `hlg` kjwspgpjrs hr rgmah stgtahks igy ej

ihrj aiphrtgkt. (Bhr gmmatahkg` akbhrigtahk hk lhuktjraksurdjkly hpjrgtahks, sjj BI <-5=.)

Page 72: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 72/91

Gppjkmax M

M-5 G]_ 5-55.1 7? Fu`y 5?75 

M-<.  Ak supphrt hb aiprhvasjm jxp`hsavj mjvalj (AJM) mjbjgt hpjrgtahks, pue`al`y gvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk

lgk ej usjm th ”  

  Lh``jlt gkm ihkathr AJM-rj`gtjm akbhrigtahk maslussjm murakd jvjkts tcgt grj hpjk th tcj pue`al

hr hllur ak pue`al grjgs.

  Lh``jlt gkm ihkathr AJM-rj`gtjm akbhrigtahk tcgt as `hlgtjm ak gky rjlhrmjm pue`al mhluijkt

(sulc gs kjwspgpjrs, igdgzakjs, `jgb`jts, erhlcurjs, phstjrs).

  Lh``jlt gkm ihkathr AJM-rj`gtjm akbhrigtahk tcgt as erhgmlgst bhr djkjrg` pue`al lhksuiptahk thg`` rjljavjrs hr tjriakg`s watcak g lhiputjr, rgmah, hr tj`jvasahk kjtwhrn.

  Ihkathr tcrjgt hr AJM-rj`gtjm Aktjrkjt Tje satjs tcgt igy prhvamj akmalgtahks gkm wgrkakd hb

tcrjgt aktjktahks, lgpgea`atajs, gltavatajs, gkm rjsphksae`j jktatajs bhr g spjlabal aklamjkt.

M-=.  \jj BI <-1?.771 bhr ihrj akbhrigtahk hk lhieakjm gris AJM mjbjgt hpjrgtahks.

\Z__HU] ]H H]CJU AK]J@@ADJKLJ MA\LA_@AKJ\

M-:.  _ue`al`y gvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk gkm hpjk shurljs mjvj`hpjm gs bakg`azjm H\AK] lgk g`sh supphrt

htcjr aktj``adjklj maslap`akjs.

CZIGK AK]J@@ADJKLJ 

M-2.  H\AK] supphrts CZIAK] lh``jltahk hpjrgtahks ey prhvamakd hpjk-shurlj igtjrag`s th tcjgpprhpragtj F/D/\-5S gkm aktj``adjklj lhiiukaty gdjklajs gkm `agashk hbbaljrs. ]cjsj igtjrag`s akl`umj eut

grj kht `aiatjm th ”  

  Igps.

  Lcgrts.

  _chkj marjlthrajs.

  Eusakjss marjlthrajs.

   Kjwspgpjrs.

  Ramjh gkm gumah ijmag (akl`umakd tgpjs gkm LMs).

M-4.  Bhr burtcjr akbhrigtahk hk CZIAK] lh``jlthr hpjrgtahks sjj BI 5-55.<.

\ADKG@\ AK]J@@ADJKLJ GKM DJH\_G]AG@ AK]J@@ADJKLJ 

M-3.  ]cj bh``hwakd vadkjttj mjslraejs g spjlabal satugtahk wcjrj H\AK] marjlt`y lhktraeutjs th sadkg`s

aktj``adjklj (\ADAK]) gkm djhspgtag` aktj``adjklj (DJHAK]).

Page 73: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 73/91

H\AK] Hrdgkazgtahks

7? Fu`y 5?75  G]_ 5-55.1 M-<

Jxgip`j hb H\AK] Lhktraeutahks th \ADAK]]cj sadkg`s hbbaljr bhr Zkat L as prjpgrakd gk gssjssijkt egsjm hk gk uplhiakdhpjrgtahk. ]cj sadkg`s hbbaljr mhjs kht cgvj glljss th l`gssabajm systjis. Zkat L asprjpgrakd th lhkmult hpjrgtahks ak gk grjg wcjrj tcj ijmag as stgtj-lhktrh``jm ey gthtg`atgragk dhvjrkijkt.

H\AK] lgk supphrt tcj sadkg`s hbbaljr ey prhvamakd akbhrigtahk sulc gs”   ]cj amjktabalgtahk hb `hlg``y tj`jvasjm lcgkkj`s g`hkd watc supphrtakd lhiphkjkts

gkm systjis.

  Tje satjs usjm th lhiiukalgtj th tcj hlg` phpu`glj.

Jxgip`j hb H\AK] Lhktraeutahks th DJHAK]Murakd iassahk p`gkkakd, Jkdakjjr M as hesjrvakd tcj phtjktag` jbbjlts hb eua`makd gkjw rga` systji. ]cj rga` systji wa`` easjlt gk gdralu`turg` lhiiukaty `hlgtjm g`hkd gpraigry arradgtahk pgtc. ]cjrj as gk aklrjgsjm phtjktag` tcgt tcj rga` systji wa`` masruptgkm lgusj mgigdj th tcj arradgtahk lgkg`s. ]cjrj grj taij lhkstrgakts prjvjktakd tcjrjqujst hb sgtj``atj aigdjry ak hrmjr th prhvamj gk hvjrcjgm vajw hb tcj grjg bhrgssjssijkt. Ab tcj rga` systji mgigdjs tcj arradgtahk lgkg`s, tcj rjsu`ts wa`` ihrj

tcgk `anj`y mjstrhy rj`gtahkscaps jstge`ascjm ejtwjjk ukat `jgmjrscap gkm traeg``jgmjrs.

H\AK] lgk supphrt aigdjry aktj``adjklj (AIAK]) ey prhvamakd akbhrigtahk sulc gsDhhd`j Jgrtc gkm htcjr LH]\ aigdjry th amjktaby g`tjrkgtavj wgtjrwgys, buturjarradgtahk mrgakakd grjgs, gkm wgtjr pgtcs ak tcj jvjkt hb b`hhmakd.

]JLCKALG@ AK]J@@ADJKLJ GKM LHZK]JUAK]J@@ADJKLJ 

M-1.  _ue`al`y gvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk supphrts tjlckalg` aktj``adjklj (]JLCAK]) jbbhrts ak sadkabalgkt wgys.

G`tchudc gmvjrsgrajs gkm phtjktag` tcrjgts gttjipt th l`hsj`y prhtjlt lgpgea`atajs gkm vu`kjrgea`atajs gs wj`` gs

aktjkt, tcj akjvatge`j rjsu`ts hb tjlckh`hdalg` gmvgkljs, sulc gs tcj Aktjrkjt gkm Dhhd`j Jgrtc, prhvamj

jxp`hatgtahk hpphrtukatajs akth jvjk tcj ihst sjlrjtavj kgtahks gkm hrdgkazgtahks. (Bhr burtcjr akbhrigtahk hk

]JLCAK], sjj ]L 5-55.=.)

M-7?. Ak supphrt hb LA, pue`al`y gvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk lgk ej usjm th hetgak akbhrigtahk tcgt sgtasbajs _AUs hr

htcjr stgkmakd LA lh``jltahk rjquarjijkts. ]cj lh``jlthrs hb Griy H\AK] grj tcj ia`atgry aktj``adjklj eradgmjs.

Ia`atgry aktj``adjklj \h`majrs rjljavj H\AK] trgakakd gt tcjar slchh`s, gs gpp`alge`j. Zphk grravg` gt pjrigkjkt

muty stgtahks, ukat trgakakd schu`m akl`umj H\AK] trgakakd rj`jvgkt th muty gssadkijkts. (Bhr ihrj akbhrigtahk

hk LA, sjj BI 5-55.5.)

Page 74: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 74/91

Gppjkmax J

J-= G]_ 5-55.1 7? Fu`y 5?75 

Gppjkmax J 

H\AK] Hrdgkazgtahks

H\AK] jxpgkms tcj jktarj erjgtc hb tcj aktj``adjklj lhiiukaty brhi tcj kgtahkg``jvj` th tcj tgltalg` `jvj` hb hpjrgtahks. Z.\. Dhvjrkijkt hrdgkazgtahks, sulc gsMHM, `gw jkbhrljijkt gdjklajs, gkm htcjrs tcgt lh``jlt, glquarj, jxp`hat, gkg`yzj,

massjiakgtj, hr uta`azj H\AK] gs g lusthijr akl`umj ”  

  Mjbjksj Hpjk \hurlj Lhukla` (MH\L).

  AK\LHI.

  MG AA\.

  MKA H\L.  Hpjk \hurlj Glgmjiy.

  G\M.

  BEA.

  Bjmjrg` Ujsjgrlc Mavasahk (BUM), @aergry hb Lhkdrjss.

MJBJK\J H_JK \HZULJ LHZKLA@

J-7.  ]cj MH\L as tcj praigry dhvjrkgklj ijlcgkasi bhr MHM H\AK]. At sjrvjs gs g bhrui bhr tcj

lhhrmakgtahk gkm bgla`atgtahk hb H\AK] gltavatajs gkm prhdrgis bhr g`` \jrvaljs gkm lhiegtgkt lhiigkms.

]cj MH\L gmvaljs gkm rjphrts th tcj Zkmjr \jlrjtgry hb Mjbjksj bhr Aktj``adjklj (Z\M^AY) hk H\AK]

assujs gkm rjlhiijkms akatagtavjs th aiprhvj tcj jbbjltavjkjss gkm jbbalajkly hb H\AK] prhdrgis,

gltavatajs, gkm systjis hb tcj MHM. ]cj rjsphksaea`atajs hb tcj MH\L akl`umj eut grj kht `aiatjm th ”  

  ]cj lhhrmakgtahk hb gltavatajs gkm tcj rjsh`utahk hb H\AK] prhdrgis gkm gltavatajs.

  ]cj prahratazgtahk hb H\AK] rjquarjijkts.

Z.\. GUIQ AK]J@@ADJKLJ GKM \JLZUA]Q LHIIGKM

J-5.  AK\LHI lhkmults iu`tamaslap`akj gkm g``-shurlj aktj``adjklj hpjrgtahks th akl`umj lh``jltahk, gkg`ysas,

 prhmultahk, gkm massjiakgtahk> nkhw`jmdj igkgdjijkt bhr tcj Griy aktj``adjklj jktjrprasj> gs wj`` gs mj avjrs

spjlag`azjm qualn rjgltahk lgpgea`atajs, gmvgkljm sna``s trgakakd, gkm `akduast supphrt bhr mjp`hyakd bhrljs th

jkge`j egtt`j lhiigkm th supphrt ukabajm gkm hpjrgtahks.

J-<.  AK\LHI rjdahkg``y supphrts jglc hb tcj djhdrgpcal lhiegtgkt lhiigkms tcrhudc suehrmakgtj

rjdahkg``y bhlusjm iu`tabukltahkg` ia`atgry aktj``adjklj eradgmjs. Jglc eradgmj igkgdjs aktj``adjklj

rjquarjijkts (th akl`umj H\AK]) gkm prhvamjs supphrt th Griy tgltalg` ukats mjp`hyakd th hr hpjrgtakd

watcak g ukabajm lhiegtgkt lhiigkm‑s  grjg hb rjsphksaea`aty hr hpjrgtahkg` jkvarhkijkt. Jglc

iu`tabukltahkg` eradgmj cgs tcj lgpgea`aty th prhmulj H\AK], djkjrgtj rjqujsts th cadcjr gdjklajs, gkm

gkswjr lh``jltahk rjquarjijkts sueiattjm ey suehrmakgtj ukats gt tcj tgltalg` `jvj` tcrhudc H\LGU-I\.

Page 75: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 75/91

H\AK] Hrdgkazgtahks

7? Fu`y 5?75  G]_ 5-55.1 J-:

MJ_GU]IJK] HB ]CJ GUIQ AK]J@@ADJKLJ AKBHUIG]AHK\JURALJ

J-=.  MG AA\ prhvamjs g erhgm spjltrui hb aktj``adjklj supphrt bukltahks th Griy gkm aktj``adjklj lhiiukaty

lusthijrs. MG AA\ as tcj praigry H\AK] akbhrigtahk gkm massjiakgtahk prhphkjkt bhr tcj Griy. MG AA\ as gk

j`jijkt hb Griy D-5, Aktj``adjklj Akbhrigtahk Igkgdjijkt Marjlthrgtj (MGIA-AI) gkm hpjrgtahkg` lhktrh` as

gssadkjm th tcj AK\LHI D-<. MG AA\ as tcj praigry aktj``adjklj akbhrigtahk massjiakgtahk hbbalj bhr tcj Griy.

MG AA\ prhvamjs g erhgm spjltrui hb aktj``adjklj supphrt bukltahks th Griy gkm aktj``adjklj lhiiukaty

lusthijrs, akl`umakd Griy Hpjk-\hurlj Lh``jltahks Ujquarjijkts Igkgdjijkt.

J-:.  ]cj iassahk hb tcj MG AA\ as th lhhrmakgtj, massjiakgtj, gkm vg`amgtj tcj strgtjdal-`jvj` rjqujsts bhr

hpjk-shurlj rjquarjijkts Griy-wamj ukmjr tcj marjltahk hb tcj Griy D-5. ]cas as mhkj ey prhvamakd

akbhrigtahk scgrakd sjrvaljs glrhss tcj aktj``adjklj lhiiukaty. ]cj MG AA\ as g vhtakd ijiejr hb tcj

Hbbalj hb tcj Marjlthr hb Kgtahkg` Aktj``adjklj (HMKA) KH\L Lh``jltahk Ujquarjijkts Igkgdjijkt

(LUI) suelhiiattjj. MG AA\ as tcj Griy prhphkjkt hbbalj bhr H\AK]. Gs sulc at gmmrjssjs g`` gspjlts hb

H\AK] ph`aly, trgakakd, hpjrgtahkg` supphrt, lh``jltahk, prhmultahk, gkg`ysas, gkm massjiakgtahk.

MAUJL]HU HB KG]AHKG@ AK]J@@ADJKLJ H_JK \HZULJLJK]JU

J-2.  ]cj MKA H\L supphrts tcj KH\J gs marjltjm ey tcj GMMKA/H\. ]cj H\L as gk hrdgkazgtahk watcaktcj aktj``adjklj lhiiukaty, Z.\. Dhvjrkijkt, pravgtj sjlthr, gkm glgmjiag.

J-4.  ]cj hpjrgtahks hb tcj H\L grj mravjk ey stgkmakd hpjk-shurlj rjquarjijkts lhktgakjm ak tcj H\L‑s 

gkkug``y rjvajwjm gkm gpprhvjm akbhrigtahk lh``jltahk p`gks. ]cj H\L igaktgaks g whr`mwamj kjtwhrn hb

iu`ta`akdug` rjdahkg` jxpjrts tcgt rjsphkm th aktj``adjklj gkm akbhrigtahk rjquarjijkts usakd pue`al`y

gvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk gkm hpjk shurljs sulc gs rgmah, tj`jvasahk, kjwspgpjrs, kjws gdjklajs, mgtgegsjs,

gkm tcj Aktjrkjt. ]cj H\L ihkathrs hpjk shurljs ak ihrj tcgk 72? lhuktrajs ak hvjr 3? `gkdugdjs gkm

glquarjs hpjk-shurlj mgtg whr`mwamj bhr hrdgkazgtahks glrhss MHM, Z.\. dhvjrkijkt gdjklajs, gkm `hlg`

`gw jkbhrljijkt mjpgrtijkts.

J-3.  H\L sjrvaljs gkm thh`s bgla`atgtj H\AK] jbbhrts hb gdjklajs gkm hbbaljs tcrhudchut tcj Z.\.

Dhvjrkijkt gkm aktj``adjklj lhiiukaty ey jkge`akd tcj lrjgtahk, igkgdjijkt, gkm massjiakgtahk hb

ukl`gssabajm prhmults. ]cj jbbjltavjkjss gkm gmgptgea`aty hb H\L thh`s grj ”  

  Cadc`y mjvj`hpjm bhr hpjk-shurlj jxp`hatgtahk gkm prhmult lrjgtahk.  Mjsadkjm th supphrt gkm prhvamj rjshurljs th g mjljktrg`azjm lusthijr-egsj igak`y tcrhudc tcj

Aktjrkjt gkm rjgma`y gvga`ge`j, purlcgsjm LH]\ lhktjkt.

  Lhksastjkt watc aktj``adjklj lhiiukaty sjluraty, tjlckalg`, gkm ijtgmgtg stgkmgrms.

J-1.  ]cj H\L gkg`yzjs tcj lhktjkt gkm ejcgvahr hb ijmag gkm Aktjrkjt Tje satjs hb kgtahks gkm htcjr

aktjrkgtahkg` glthrs hb sadkabalgkt ph`aly aktjrjst th tcj Z.\. Dhvjrkijkt.

H_JK \HZULJ GLGMJIQ

J-7?. ]cj Hpjk \hurlj Glgmjiy as g `jgmakd prhvamjr hb hpjk-shurlj trgmjlrgbt trgakakd. Gs aktj``adjklj

lhksuijrs p`glj g drjgtjr vg`uj hk H\AK], hpjk-shurlj spjlag`asts tcrhudchut tcj Z.\. Dhvjrkijkt grj

turkakd th Hpjk \hurlj Glgmjiy lhursjs (sjj tge`j J-7) th eua`m hpjk-shurlj sna``s gkm th stgy gerjgst hb

jvh`vakd H\AK] tjlckh`hdajs. ]cj Hpjk \hurlj Glgmjiy as eua`makd rj`gtahkscaps watc lhiiukaty

`jgmjrs glrhss tcj aktj``adjklj lhiiukaty th mjvj`hp g lhiprjcjksavj gpprhglc th aksta``akd hpjk-shurljtrgmjlrgbt sna``s. ]cj glgmjiy chsts pgrtalapgkts jxpgkmakd glrhss MHM, bjmjrg` gdjklajs, gs wj`` gs `hlg`

`gw jkbhrljijkt mjpgrtijkts.

]ge`j J-7. Hpjk \hurlj Glgmjiy lurralu`ui

  Aktrhmultahk th tcj Baj`m

  @aergry Ujshurljs gkm Ujsjgrlc ]jlckaqujs

  Ijmag Gkg`ysas

  Rasug` _jrsugsahk Ijtchmh`hdy GmvgkljmDhhd`akd

  Gumajklj Ujshkgklj Ijtchmh`hdy

Page 76: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 76/91

Gppjkmax J

J-2 G]_ 5-55.1 7? Fu`y 5?75 

  Kjwlhijr‑s Egsal Mjsnthp 

  Hpjk-shurlj Ujsjgrlc gkm Gkg`ysas

  Hrajktgtahk th tcj Hpjk \hurlj Ljktjr

  H\ 7?76 Hpjk-shurlj Bukmgijktg`s

  H\ 5?76 Hpjk-shurlj 5?7

  Hpjk-shurlj Aktj``adjklj (H\AK]) gkm tcj

Htcjr Aktj``adjkljs  Hvjrvajw hb tcj Hpjk \hurlj Ljktjr

Lh``jltahk Ujquarjijkts _rhljss

  \jluraty gkm _ravgly Assujs bhr Aktjrkjt Zsjrs

  \igrt Ujsjgrlc”_grtkjrakd watc tcj @aergry

  ]jiphrgry Muty Thrnschp

  ]hh`s gkm Mgtg \hurljs

  L`gssabalgtahk Thrnschp

  Lhiiukaty Madatg` Gumah Ramjh Jktjrprasj(MGRJ) \ystji

  Lrjgtakd Iu`ta-ijmag _rhmults

  MGRJ Jxjlutavj Hvjrvajw

  Massjiakgtahks

  Jssjktag`s hb Hpjk-shurlj Gkg`ysas  Baj`m Igkgdjijkt

  Bukmgijktg`s hb Hpjk \hurlj Ljktjr ]jxtug`_rhmultahk gkm Hpjrgtahks (_UH_\)

  Djhspgtag` Gkg`ysas6 Gk Aktrhmultahk

  Cammjk Zkavjrsjs hb Akbhrigtahk hk tcj Aktjrkjt

  Cadc-jkm Thrnstgtahk E`hln AA 7?7

  Cadc-jkm Thrnstgtahk E`hln AA 5?7

Z.\. GUIQ G\AGK \]ZMAJ\ MJ]GLCIJK]

J-77. ]cj G\M as tcj h`mjst, `grdjst, gkm hkj hb tcj ihst wj``-jstge`ascjm H\AK] gltavatajs ak MHM tcgt

mjihkstrgtjs tcj lcgrgltjrastals hb sustgakjm H\AK] jxp`hatgtahk. ]cj G\M lh``jlts, gkg`yzjs, jxp`hats,

 prhljssjs, gkm rjphrts schrt-th-iam-tjri gkg`ysjs hb pue`al`y gvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk hk ia`atgry lgpgea`atajs,

bhrlj prhtjltahk tcrjgts, gkm htcjr hpjrgtahkg`-`jvj` aktj``adjklj akbhrigtahk hk lhuktrajs, bhrljs, gkm

khkstgtj glthrs hb aktjrjst ak tcj Z\_GLHI grjg hb rjsphksaea`aty. \ulc rjquarjijkts akl`umj tcj

lgpgea`atajs, masphsatahk, gkm rjgmakjss hb ia`atgry bhrljs ak Lcakg, Khrtc Nhrjg, gkm tcj Uussagk Bgr Jgst,

gs wj`` gs mjbjksj-rj`gtjm thpals tcrhudchut \hutc gkm \hutcjgst Gsag. ]cj G\M sjrvjs gs g ihmj` bhr

lhiegtgkt lhiigkm-`jvj` H\AK] jxp`hatgtahk. ]cj G\M whrnbhrlj lhksasts hb Mjpgrtijkt hb tcj Griy

Lava`agks gkm Griy Ujsjrvj gkm Kgtahkg` Dugrm \h`majrs wch sjrvj gs iassahk igkgdjrs gkm jmathrag` stgbb

gkm Dhvjrkijkt hb Fgpgk-bukmjm bhrjadk kgtahkg`s wch pjrbhri g`` hb tcj lh``jltahk, gkg`ysas, trgks`gtahk,

rjphrtakd, `aergry, gkm drgpcals supphrt bukltahks.

J-75. ]cj iassahk hb tcj G\M as th lh``jlt, gkg`yzj, jxp`hat, gkm rjphrt bhrjadk H\AK] ak rjsphksj th

Z\_GLHI gkm Z.\. Griy _glabal tgsnakds gkm htcjr kgtahkg`-`jvj` aktj``adjklj rjquarjijkts. G\M‑s

H\AK] lh``jlthrs, gkg`ysts, gkm rjphrtjrs gllhip`asc tcjar wamj-slhpj iassahk tcrhudc tcj jxp`hatgtahk hb

 prakt gkm Aktjrkjt ijmag igtjrag`s.

J-7<. G\M pjrshkkj` jxtrglt gkm lhipa`j akbhrigtahk akth gkg`ytalg` prhmults gkswjrakd spjlabal tgsnakdsrjljavjm vag tcj H\LGU-I\. ]cj G\M syktcjsazjs gkm latjs hpjk-shurlj rjbjrjkljs ak hpjk-shurlj

aktj``adjklj rjphrt bhrigt saia`gr th rjsjgrlc pgpjrs hr jssgys. G\M‑s lurrjkt hpjrgtahks sjltahk prhvamjs g

suatj hb mga`y ijmag suiigry prhmults lhktgakakd prjss grtal`js rjsphkmakd th ihrj aiijmagtj gkm taij-

sjksatavj rjquarjijkts bhr bhrjadk ijmag rjb`jltahks hb Z.\. gltavatajs gkm htcjr thpals hb aktjrjst. ]cj

sjrvaljs gkm thh`s tcgt tcj G\M prhvamj akl`umj eut grj kht `aiatjm th ”  

  H\AK] prhmults rjsphkmakd th H\LGU-I\ rjquarjijkts.

  Gkg`ytalg` hpjk-shurlj aktj``adjklj rjphrts.

  Mga`y bhrlj prhtjltahk/satugtahkg` gwgrjkjss rjphrts (B_\GUs).

  Mga`y grjg surrhukmakd Fgpgk hpjk-shurlj aktj``adjklj rjphrts (G\FHUs).

  Mga`y satugtahkg` rjphrts (\A]UJ_s).

  Tjjn`y Lcakg gkm ]gawgk Ia`atgry pchths rjphrts.

  Gm chl rjphrtakd gs rjqujstjm ey lusthijr ak H\LGU-I\.  H\AK] prhmult mastraeutahk hk KA_UKJ], \A_UKJ], gkm FTAL\.

  Igp lh``jltahk.

  Ijmag suiigry rjphrts.

Page 77: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 77/91

H\AK] Hrdgkazgtahks

7? Fu`y 5?75  G]_ 5-55.1 J-4

BJMJUG@ EZUJGZ HB AKRJ\]ADG]AHK

J-7=. ]cj BEA as gk gdjkly hb tcj Mjpgrtijkt hb Fustalj tcgt sjrvjs gs ehtc g bjmjrg` lraiakg` akvjstadgtavj

 ehmy gkm gk aktjrkg` aktj``adjklj gdjkly. ]cj BEA cgs akvjstadgtavj furasmaltahk hvjr vah`gtahks hb ihrj

tcgk 5?? lgtjdhrajs hb bjmjrg` lraij.

J-7:. ]cj igak iassahks hb tcj BEA grj th prhtjlt gkm mjbjkm tcj Zkatjm \tgtjs gdgakst tjrrhrast gkm bhrjadk

aktj``adjklj tcrjgts gkm th upch`m gkm jkbhrlj lraiakg` `gws. ]cas as mhkj ey bhlusakd hk spjlabal lgtjdhrajstcgt akl`umj eut grj kht `aiatjm th ”  

  Egkn rheejry.

  Uheejry gkm jxthrtahk gbbjltakd aktjrstgtj lhiijrlj.

  Mruds.

  Lhkspargly.

  \jxug` jxp`hatgtahk hb iakhrs.

  Iga` brgum.

  Egkn brgum.

  Brgum ey warj, rgmah, hr tj`jvasahk.

  A``jdg` dgie`akd eusakjssjs.

J-72. ]cj BEA usjs pue`al`y gvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk tcrhudc hpjk shurljs ak tcj grjgs hb lhuktjrtjrrhrasi,

LA, lyejrlraij, akbhrigtahk tjlckh`hdy, gkm bhrjksals. Tatcak tcj iassahk slhpj hb tcj BEA, tcj sjrvaljs

gkm thh`s prhvamjm akl`umj eut grj kht `aiatjm th ”  

  @gw jkbhrljijkt eu``jtaks.

  Lraij igppakd.

  \tgtastals (lyejrlraij, wcatj-lh``gr lraij, gkm vah`jkt lraij).

BJMJUG@ UJ\JGULC MARA\AHK, @AEUGUQ HB LHKDUJ\\

J-74. ]cj BUM wgs hrdgkazjm murakd Thr`m Tgr AA th lh``jlt gkm lhkmult rjsjgrlc hk lgpturjm

gjrhkgutalg` gkm tjlckalg` rjphrts hk Djrigk gkm Fgpgkjsj bhrljs. ]cjsj lh``jltahks prhvamjm aksadct th

buturj Z.\. mjbjksavj phsturj mjvj`hpijkts gkm suesjqujkt`y gssastjm ak tcj aktj``adjklj jbbhrt `jgmakd th

tcj mjbjgt hb tcj Gxas phwjrs.

J-73. ]cj iassahk hb tcj BUM as th prhvamj marjltjm rjsjgrlc gkm gkg`ysas hk mhijstal gkm aktjrkgtahkg`suefjlts th gdjklajs hb tcj Z.\. Dhvjrkijkt, tcj Mastralt hb Lh`uieag, gkm gutchrazjm bjmjrg` lhktrglthrs.

]cj BUM lhkmults hpjk-shurlj rjsjgrlc bhr tcj Z.\. @aergry hb Lhkdrjss. ]cj sjrvaljs gkm thh`s tcgt tcj

BUM prhvamj akl`umj eut grj kht `aiatjm th ”  

  _raigry rjsjgrlc igtjrag`, akl`umakd mhluijkt mj`avjry.

  Bhrjadk `gkdugdj gestrgltakd gkm trgks`gtahk.

  Gkkhtgtjm eae`ahdrgpcajs.

  Hrdgkazgtahkg` gkm `jdas`gtavj casthrajs.

  \tumajs gkm rjphrts.

  Ehhns.

  Ia`atgry `jdg` rjshurljs.

  Lhuktry stumajs.

  Lhuktry prhba`js.

  ]jrrhrasi gkm lraiakg` stumajs gkm gssjssijkts.

Page 78: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 78/91

Page 79: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 79/91

 

7? Fu`y 5?75  G]_ 5-55.1 Hpjk-\hurlj Ujshurljs-7

Gppjkmax B 

Hpjk-\hurlj Ujshurljs

Aktj``adjklj pjrshkkj` cgvj glljss th vgst gihukts hb akbhrigtahk murakd rjsjgrlc.Zkmjrstgkmakd gkm gwgrjkjss hb wcjrj th ejdak th `hhn bhr spjlabal akbhrigtahk lgk

 ej tcj `grdjst hestgl`j gkg`ysts jklhuktjr. ]cj tge`js ak tcas gppjkmax `ast shij

stgrtakd rjbjrjklj phakts bhr hetgakakd akbhrigtahk tcgt lgk ej mjvj`hpjm gkm prhmuljm akth bakg`azjm H\AK]. ]ge`j B-7 `asts hpjk-shurlj trgakakd gkm rjshurljstcgt grj spjlabalg``y ia`atgry.

]ge`j B-7. Ia`atgry hpjk-shurlj trgakakd gkm rjshurljs

Aktj``adjklj Nkhw `jmdj Kjtwhrn (ANK)6  ANK as g nkhw`jmdj igkgdjijkt thh` tcgt jkge`js aktj``adjklj \h`majrs whr`mwamj th lhiiukalgtj,lh``gehrgtj, gkm akvjstadgtj. ANK” 

  Chsts maslussahk bhruis. 

  \jrvjs gs g sakd`j phakt hb jktry th djt th Z.\. Griy Aktj``adjklj Ljktjr hb Jxlj``jklj (Z\GALhJ) gkmhtcjr aktj``adjklj lhiiukaty Tje satjs. 

  Chsts g vgrajty hb pue`al gkm pravgtj Tje gpp`algtahks tcgt supphrt tcj aktj``adjklj lhiiukaty. 

Zkavjrsaty hb Ia`atgry Aktj``adjklj (ZIA)6

ZIA as tcj mastgklj `jgrkakd gri hb tcj ia`atgry aktj``adjklj slchh`chusj. Brhi tcj ZIA Tje satj, ia`atgryaktj``adjklj prhbjssahkg`s lgk glljss” 

  \j`b-pgljm gkm rjglcegln trgakakd. 

  ]cj Lu`turg`, Bhrjadk @gkdugdj Aktjdrgtahk Ljktjr. 

  Ia`atgry aktj``adjklj trgakakd rjshurljs. 

Griy N khw`jmdj Hk`akj (GNH)Aktj``adjklj6

 GNH Aktj``adjklj bjgturjs” 

  ]cj Aktj``adjklj Lh``gehrgtahk Ljktjr. 

  Nkhw`jmdj Ljktjr (mhluijkts, BIs, ]Ls, G]]_s, gkm htcjrs). 

  ]rgakakd, gdjklajs, ph`aly, mhltrakj, gkm `akns th htcjr aktj``adjklj-rj`gtjm Tje satjs. 

GNH Hpjk-\hurlj _rhdrgi6  

 GNH Griy Hpjk-\hurlj _rhdrgi bjgturjs Hpjk-\hurlj” 

  Jvjkts.    Aktj``adjklj prhmults. 

  Maslussahk bhruis.    Cgkmehhns. 

  @akns hb aktjrjst. 

Ia`atgry Aktj``adjklj @aergry 6   Gvga`ge`j vag tcj ANK gkm Tgrbadc tjr Bhrui chi jpgdj

Ia`atgry Aktj``adjklj @aergry Ujbjrjklj Ljktjr akl`umjs igky mgtgegsjs gkm rjshurljs, sulc gs”   Fhurkg`s gkm igdgzakjs.    Casthralg` mhluijkts. 

  Bhris gkm pue`algtahks.   Lu`turg` baj`m rjgmakds.

  Ujshurlj duamj.   Ia`atgry Aktj``adjklj Bhrjadk @gkdugdj ]rgakakd Ljktjr(IAB@]L).

Page 80: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 80/91

Hpjk-\hurlj Ujshurljs

Hpjk-\hurlj Ujshurljs-5 G]_ 5-55.1 7? Fu`y 5?75 

]ge`j B-7. Ia`atgry hpjk-shurlj trgakakd gkm rjshurljs (lhktakujm)

MG AA\ Lhuk try Ujsjgrlc _hrtg`6 Gvga`ge`j vag tcj MG AA\ phrtg` brhi tcj GNH chijpgdj  

]cj Mjpgrtijkt hb tcj Griy Aktj``adjklj Akbhrigtahk \jrvalj (MG AA\) Lhuktry Ujsjgrlc phrtg` cgs rhgm-igppjmgkm mgtg-iakjm kjtwhrns rjsu`takd ak g hkj-sthp-schp bhr aktj``adjklj akbhrigtahk. 

\hij hb tcj `akns hk tcas Tje satj akl`umj” 

  Hpjk-shurlj mhluijkts sulc gs Jgr`y Earm, ]jrrhrasi Mga`y Zpmgtj, Egdcmgm Ihsquath, Egsrg Eud`j,

gkm htcjrs. 

  Aktj``adjklj lhiiukaty.   Lhiegtgkt lhiigkms.

  Gkg`yst rjbjrjkljs.   Bhukmry prhdrgi.Khtj. Mgtg as glljssae`j tcrhudc iu`tap`j kjtwhrns th jksurj tcgt aktj` adjklj lhksuijrs cgvj g` rjquarjm akbhrigtahkkjljssgry bhr iassahk sulljss.

Aktj`akn-Z6

Aktj`akn-Z as tcj mjsadkgtjm kjtwhrn hb tcj Mjpgrtijkt hb Kgtahkg` Aktj``adjklj (MKA) bhr aktj``adjkljlh``gehrgtahk. ]cj Aktj`akn-Z as” 

  Igkgdjm ey tcj Aktj`akn Igkgdjijkt Hbbalj.

  G fhakt-usj, rjihtj`y glljssjm, gkm hpjrgtahkg``y-aip`jijktjm akbhrigtahk sjrvalj tcgt as usjm thglljss gkm prhljss ukl`gssabajm, pue`al`y glljssae`j akbhrigtahk hk`y.

  _rhvamjs g prhtjltjm jkvarhkijkt th jxlcgkdj gutchrazjm ukl`gssabajm, ukl`gssabajm bhr hbbalag` usjhk`y, gkm sjksatavj eut ukl`gssabajm akbhrigtahk gihkd pjrshkkj` hb tcj MHM.

Khtj. Glljss th Aktj`akn-Z sjrvaljs as aip`jijktjm tcrhudc iu`tap`j vartug` pravgtj kjtwhrns.

Fhakt Ia`atgry Aktj``adjklj ]rgakakd Ljktjr6

Griajs hb tcj Thr`m

 Grijm Bhrljs hb tcj Thr`mKhtj. Ujquarjs gllhukt `hd ak th glljss tcj pgdj.

Lhieakjm Gris Ujsjgrlc @aergry

Ljktjr bhr G riy @ jsshks @ jgrkjm (LG@@)

LG@@ 

Ia`atgry Hpjrgtahks ak Zre gk ]jrrgak (IHZ])  

IHZ] 

Ia`atgry \jrvalj Aktj``adjklj Hrd gkazgtahks  

Z.\. Griy Aktj``adjklj gkm \jluratyLhiigkm (AK\LHI) Hbbalj hb Kgvg` Aktj``adjklj 

 Gar Bhrlj Aktj` adjklj, \urvja``gklj, gkmUjlhkkgassgklj (A\U) Gdjkly Igrakj Lhrps Aktj``adjklj Gltavaty 

Zkabajm Lhiigkm Aktj``adjklj Hrdgkazgtahks

Z.\. Ljktrg` Lhiigkm Z.\. Jurhpjgk Lhiigkm Z.\. _glabal Lhiigkm Z.\. \hutcjrk Lhiigkm Z.\. Gbralg Lhiigkm Z.\. Gar Bhrlj \pglj Lhiigkm 

Z.\. \pjlag` Hpjrgtahks Lhiigkm Z.\. \trgtjdal Lhiigkm Z.\. ]rgksphrtgtahk Lhiigkm 

Page 81: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 81/91

D`hssgry t)

7? Fu`y 5?75  G]_ 5-55.1 D`hssgry-<

D`hssgry

\JL]AHK A  “ GLUHKQI\ GKM GEEUJRAG]AHK\

5S cuigk aktj``adjklj gkm lhuktjraktj``adjklj stgbb j`jijkt

GMMKA/H\ gssastgkt mjputy th tcj Marjlthr hb Kgtahkg` Aktj``adjklj bhr Hpjk-shurlj

GI gip`atumj ihmu`gtahk

GH grjg hb hpjrgtahks

GU Griy rjdu`gtahk

GU] Griy tgltalg` tgsns

G]_ Griy tjlckaqujs pue`algtahk

G]]_ Griy tgltals, tjlckaqujs, gkm prhljmurjs

EL]  eradgmj lhiegt tjgi

LLAU lhiigkmjr‑s lratalg` akbhrigtahk rjquarjijkt 

LA lhuktjraktj``adjklj

LAG Ljktrg` Aktj``adjklj Gdjkly

LHG lhursj hb gltahk

LHKZ\ lhktakjktg` Zkatjm \tgtjs

LH]\ lhiijrlag`-hbb-tcj-scj`b

LUI lh``jltahk rjquarjijkts igkgdjijkt

MG Mjpgrtijkt hb tcj Griy

MG AA\ Mjpgrtijkt hb tcj Griy Aktj``adjklj Akbhrigtahk \jrvalj

MHM Mjpgrtijkt hb Mjbjksj

MHMM Mjpgrtijkt hb Mjbjksj marjltavj

MHMA Mjpgrtijkt hb Mjbjksj akstrultahk

MH\L Mjbjksj Hpjk \hurlj Lhukla`

MRM madatg` vamjh mjvalj

JH jxjlutavj hrmjr

BEA Bjmjrg` Eurjgu hb Akvjstadgtahk

BEA\ Bhrjadk Erhgmlgst Akbhrigtahk \jrvalj

BBAU brajkm`y bhrlj akbhrigtahk rjquarjijkt

BI baj`m igkug`

BIA baj`m igkug` aktjrai

BUM Bjmjrg` Ujsjgrlc Mavasahk

D-5 gssastgkt lcajb hb stgbb, aktj``adjklj

D-< gssastgkt lcajb hb stgbb, hpjrgtahks

D-2 gssastgkt lcajb hb stgbb, sadkg`

Page 82: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 82/91

D`hssgry 

D`hssgry-= G]_ 5-55.1 7? Fu`y 5?75 

D-4 gssastgkt lcajb hb stgbb, akbhri gkm akb`ujklj gltavatajs

D-1 gssastgkt lcajb hb stgbb, lava` gbbgars hpjrgtahks

DJHAK] djhspgtag` aktj``adjklj

CR] cadc-vg`uj tgrdjt

ALM aktj``adjklj lhiiukaty marjltavj

AJM aiprhvasjm jxp`hsavj mjvalj

AAU aktj``adjklj akbhrigtahk rjphrt

A@U Aktjrgdjkly @gkdugdj Uhukmtge`j

AK\LHI Zkatjm \tgtjs Griy Aktj``adjklj gkm \jluraty Lhiigkm

AH akbhrigtahk hpjrgtahks

A_ Aktjrkjt prhthlh`

A_E aktj``adjklj prjpgrgtahk hb tcj egtt`jbaj`m

A\_ Aktjrkjt sjrvalj prhvamjr

F_  fhakt pue`algtahk

FTAL\ Fhakt Thr`mwamj Aktj``adjklj Lhiiuklgtahks \ystji

IMI_ ia`atgry mjlasahkignakd prhljss

IJ]]-]L iassahk, tcrjgt, tjrrgak gkm wjgtcjr, trhhps gkm supphrt gvga`ge`j, taij

gvga`ge`j, gkm lava` lhksamjrgtahks (iassahk vgrage`js)

IB@] iglcakj bhrjadk `gkdugdj trgks`gtahk

ii ia``aijtjr

KA_UKJ]  Khksjlurj Aktjrkjt _rhthlh` Uhutjr Kjtwhrn

KH\L  Kgtahkg` Hpjk \hurlj Lhiiattjj

KH\J  Kgtahkg` Hpjk \hurlj Jktjrprasj

K\G  Kgtahkg` \jluraty Gdjkly

HMKA Hbbalj hb tcj Marjlthr hb Kgtahkg` Aktj``adjklj

H_\JL hpjrgtahks sjluraty

H\L Hpjk \hurlj Ljktjr

H\LGU-I\ hpjk-shurlj lh``jltahk glquasatahk rjquarjijkt igkgdjijkt systji

H\AK] hpjk-shurlj aktj``adjklj

_AU  prahraty aktj``adjklj rjquarjijkt

_IJ\AA-_]  ph`atalg`, ia`atgry, jlhkhial, shlag`, akbhrigtahk, akbrgstrulturj, pcysalg`

jkvarhkijkt, gkm taij (hpjrgtahkg` vgrage`js)

\-5 aktj``adjklj stgbb hbbaljr

\-< hpjrgtahks stgbb hbbaljr

\-2 sadkg` stgbb hbbaljr

\-4 akbhri gkm akb`ujklj gltavatajs stgbb hbbaljr

\-1 lava` gbbgars hpjrgtahks stgbb hbbaljr

\LA sjksatavj lhipgrtijktjm akbhrigtahk

\A_UKJ] \JLUJ] Aktjrkjt _rhthlh` Uhutjr Kjtwhrn

\H_ stgkmgrm hpjrgtakd prhljmurj

]L_/A_ trgksiassahk lhktrh` prhthlh`/Aktjrkjt prhthlh`

Page 83: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 83/91

D`hssgry t)

7? Fu`y 5?75  G]_ 5-55.1 D`hssgry-:

]]_ tgltals, tjlckaqujs, gkm prhljmurjs

ZU@ ukabhri rjshurlj `hlgthr

Z.\. Zkatjm \tgtjs

Z\L Zkatjm \tgtjs Lhmj

TTT Thr`m Tamj Tje

\JL]AHK AA  “ ]JUI\

jshtjral lhiiukalgtahks

_ue`al stgtjijkts wchsj surbglj ijgkakd (igkabjst lhktjkt) mhjs kht rjvjg` tcj rjg` purphsj, ijgkakd,

hr sadkabalgklj (`gtjkt lhktjkt) hb tcj gutchr.

ijmag shurlj gkg`ysas

]cj systjigtal lhipgrashk hb tcj lhktjkt, ejcgvahr, pgttjrks, gkm trjkms hb hrdgkal ijmag

hrdgkazgtahks gkm shurljs hb g lhuktry.

hpjk shurlj

Gky pjrshk hr drhup tcgt prhvamjs akbhrigtahk watchut tcj jxpjltgtahk hb pravgly ” tcj akbhrigtahk,tcj rj`gtahkscap, hr ehtc as kht prhtjltjm gdgakst pue`al masl`hsurj.

hpjk-shurlj aktj``adjklj

]cj maslap`akj tcgt pjrtgaks th aktj``adjklj prhmuljm brhi pue`al`y gvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk tcgt as

lh``jltjm, jxp`hatjm, gkm massjiakgtjm ak g taij`y igkkjr th gk gpprhpragtj gumajklj bhr tcj purphsj hb

gmmrjssakd g spjlabal aktj``adjklj rjquarjijkt. (BI 5-?)

pravgtj akbhrigtahk

Mgtg, bglts, akstrultahks, hr htcjr igtjrag` aktjkmjm bhr hr rjstraltjm th g pgrtalu`gr pjrshk, drhup, hr

hrdgkazgtahk.

pue`al`y gvga`ge`j akbhrigtahk

Mgtg, bglts, akstrultahks, hr htcjr igtjrag` pue`ascjm hr erhgmlgst bhr djkjrg` pue`al lhksuiptahk>

gvga`ge`j hk rjqujst th g ijiejr hb tcj djkjrg` pue`al> `gwbu``y sjjk hr cjgrm ey gky lgsug` hesjrvjr>

hr igmj gvga`ge`j gt g ijjtakd hpjk th tcj djkjrg` pue`al.

Page 84: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 84/91

Page 85: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 85/91

 

7? Fu`y 5?75  G]_ 5-55.1 Ujbjrjkljs-7

Ujbjrjkljs

UJWZAUJM _ZE@ALG]AHK\]cjsj mhluijkts iust ej gvga`ge`j th tcj aktjkmjm usjr hb tcas pue`algtahk.

BI 7-?5. Hpjrgtahkg` ]jris gkm Drgpcals. 57 \jptjiejr 5??=.

UJ@G]JM _ZE@ALG]AHK\]cjsj shurljs lhktgak rj`jvgkt supp`jijktg` akbhrigtahk.

GU 77-2. Griy Bhrjadk @gkdugdj _rhdrgi. <7 Gudust 5??1.

GU 5:-=??-5. ]cj Griy Ujlhrms Akbhrigtahk Igkgdjijkt \ystji (GUAI\).  5 Hlthejr 5??4.

GU 54-2?. Aktj``jltug` _rhpjrty. 7 Fukj 711<.

GU 71?-7<. ]cj Griy _cysalg` \jluraty _rhdrgi. 5: Bjerugry 5?77.

GU <3?-:. Mjpgrtijkt hb tcj Griy Akbhrigtahk \jluraty _rhdrgi. 51 \jptjiejr 5???.GU <3?-24. Mjpgrtijkt hb tcj Griy _jrshkkj` \jluraty _rhdrgi. 1 \jptjiejr 7133.

GU <37-7?. Z.\. Griy Aktj``adjklj Gltavatajs. < Igy 5??4.

GU :<?-7. Hpjrgtahks \jluraty (H_\JL). 71 Gpra` 5??4.

G]]_ 5-17.2. ]gltals, ]jlckaqujs, gkm _rhljmurjs bhr Aktj``adjklj \upphrt th \atj Jxp`hatgtahk.

54 Mjljiejr 5?7?.

Lgrkjdaj Ij``hk \hbtwgrj Jkdakjjrakd Akstatutj.

Lcgtcgi Chusj.

Mjpgrtijkt hb tcj Griy Aktj``adjklj Akbhrigtahk \jrvaljs.

MHM :5=?.7-U. MhM Aktj``adjklj Gltavatajs. 7 Mjljiejr 7135.

MHMM :7??.5?. Kgtahkg` \jluraty Gdjkly/Ljktrg` \jluraty \jrvalj (K\G/L\\). 52 Fgkugry 5?7?.

MHMM <77:.75. Hpjk \hurlj Aktj``adjklj (H\AK]). 5= Gudust 5?7?.

JH 75<<<. Zkatjm \tgtjs Aktj``adjklj Gltavatajs. = Mjljiejr 7137.

BI 5-?7.<. Aktj``adjklj _rjpgrgtahk hb tcj Egtt`jbaj`m/Egtt`jspglj. 7: Hlthejr 5??1.

BI 5-71.=. Eradgmj Lhiegt ]jgi Aktj``adjklj Hpjrgtahks. 5: Khvjiejr 5??3.

BI 5-55.5. Lhuktjraktj``adjklj. 57 Hlthejr 5?7?.

BI 5-55.<. Cuigk  Aktj``adjklj Lh``jlthr Hpjrgtahks. 2 \jptjiejr 5??2.

BI <-5=. Lhuktjraksurdjkly. 7: Mjljiejr 5??2.

BI <-::. Akbhrigtahk Lh``jltahk. 7= Mjljiejr 5?77.

BI <-2?. ]cj ]grdjtakd _rhljss. 52 Khvjiejr 5?7?.

BI <-1?.771. Lhieakjm Gris Aiprhvasjm Jxp`hsavj Mjvalj Mjbjgt Hpjrgtahks. 57 \jptjiejr 5??4.

BI :-?. ]cj Hpjrgtahks _rhljss. 52 Igrlc 5?7?.BI 2-?. Iassahk Lhiigkm. 7< \jptjiejr 5?77. 

BI 4-?. ]rgakakd Zkats gkm Mjvj`hpakd @jgmjrs bhr Bu`` \pjltrui Hpjrgtahks. 5< Bjerugry 5?77.

BI 4-7:. ]cj Griy Zkavjrsg` ]gsn @ast. 54 Bjerugry 5??1.

F_ 7-?5. Mjpgrtijkt hb Mjbjksj Maltahkgry hb Gsshlagtjm ]jris. 3 Khvjiejr 5?7?.

F_ 5-?. Fhakt Aktj``adjklj. 55 Fukj 5??4.

F_ 5-?7. Fhakt gkm Kgtahkg` Aktj``adjklj \upphrt th Ia`atgry Hpjrgtahks. 4 Hlthejr 5??=.

F_ <-?. Fhakt Hpjrgtahks. 74 \jptjiejr 5??2.

Page 86: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 86/91

Ujbjrjkljs 

Ujbjrjkljs-5 G]_ 5-55.1 7? Fu`y 5?75 

F_ <-<:. Mjp`hyijkt gkm Ujmjp`hyijkt Hpjrgtahks. 4 Igy 5??4.

F_ <-:1. Ijtjhrh`hdalg` gkm Hljgkal Hpjrgtahks. 5= \jptjiejr 5??3.

F_ <-2?. Fhakt ]grdjtakd . 7< Gpra` 5??4.

F_ =-?. Fhakt @hdastals. 73 Fu`y 5??3.

F_ :-?. Mhltrakj bhr _`gkkakd Fhakt Hpjrgtahks. 5? Fgkugry 5??:.

@gkalla, Fhck I. ‐Aktjdrgtakd Tjgtcjr Jxp`hatgtahk akth Gar gkm \pglj _hwjr Mhltrakj.’  Gar _hwjr75, Kh. 5. \uiijr 71136 :5-2<.

@aergry hb Lhkdrjss, Bjmjrg` Ujsjgrlc Mavasahk.

Hpjk \hurlj Ljktjr.

]L 5-55.=. ]jlckalg` Aktj``adjklj. 71 Khvjiejr 5??1.

]L 5-<<.=. Aktj``adjklj Gkg`ysas. 7 Fu`y 5??1.

]L 5-17.3. Mhluijkt gkm Ijmag Jxp`hatgtahk. 2 Gudust 5?7?.

Z.\. Lhiputjr \jluraty Ujgmakjss ]jgi.

]at`j 74 Z\L. Lhpyradcts.

]at`j 73 Z\L. Lraijs gkm Lraiakg` _rhljmurj.

_UJ\LUAEJM BHUI\ Khkj.

UJBJUJKLJM BHUI\MG Bhri 5?53. Ujlhiijkmjm Lcgkdjs th _ue`algtahks gkm E`gkn Bhris.

Page 87: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 87/91

 

7? Fu`y 5?75  ]L 5-55.35 Akmjx-7

Akmjx

Jktrajs grj ey pgrgdrgpc kuiejr.

gkg`ysas, 7-5aktj``adjklj, 5-55Aktjrkjt, 5-71ijmag, =-5?iassahk, 7-72, <-2pue`al mhluijkts, 5-7=rjquarjijkts bhr, 5-45

Lcgtcgi Chusj Uu`j. \jj pue`al spjgnakd bhruis.

lh``jltahk, 7-<, 7-4, <-5gkm gkg`ysas, 7-5lhkbamjktag` shurljs, <-4mhluijkt, 5-7=bhrjadk ijmag ihkathrakd,

5-:4akbhrigtahk, 7-75`akduast rjquarjijkts, 5-=1iglcakj bhrjadk `gkdugdj

trgks`gtahk systjis, 5-::hpjk shurljs, <-4tjlckaquj, <-3Z.\. pjrshk akbhrigtahk,

5-=?

lyejrspglj

lyejr satugtahkg`gwgrjkjss, E-2

mjbakjm, E-:

mgtgegsjs, <-75, L-52hpjrgtahkg` akbhrigtahk,

5-5<tjlckalg` akbhrigtahk, 5-5<

massjiakgtahklhksamjrgtahks, =-=1madatazgtahk, =-7:duamj`akjs, =-=5ijmag, =-<<

ijtchms, =-=<stgkmgrms, =-71Z.\. pjrshk akbhrigtahk,

 G-71

akbhrigtahklh``jltahk, 7-75jvg`ugtj, =-5

hpjrgtahks sjluraty, 5-=7pue`al`y gvga`ge`j, 7-5, 7-4,

<-7, =-5rj`agea`aty gkm lrjmaea`aty, =-1rjphrt gkm massjiakgtj,

=-<1

aktj``adjklj prhmults, =-7

AktjrkjtEhh`jgk `hdal, L-1, L-51lhhnaj mgtg, E-1Mjjp Tje, L-<aktjrkgtahkg` Tje satjs,

L-<5

hpjrgtahks sjluratyvu`kjrgea`atajs, L-<:

pue`al`y gvga`ge`jakbhrigtahk, L-75

sjgrlc jkdakjs, L-=sjgrlc, L-7:truklgtj tcj ukabhri

rjshurlj `hlgthr, L-5<Tje satj mhigaks, L-5:Tje satjs, 5-71, <-5<Thr`m Tamj Tje, L-5

`jdg` rjstraltahks GU 54-2?, 5-=3 GU <37-7?, G-4lhpyradct, 5-=2Jxjlutavj Hrmjr 75<<<, G-7bgar usj, 5-=4aktj``jltug` prhpjrty, 5-=2Aktj``adjklj Lhiiukaty

Marjltavj <??, G-5<Aktj``adjklj Lhiiukaty

Marjltavj <?7, G-5<

IMI_, 7-7:

ijmaggkg`ysas, =-5?

lhktjkt, =-<:lhktrh`, =-5=strulturj, =-52

ia`atgry mjlasahkignakd prhljss.\jj IMI_.

hpjk shurlj, 7-7

hpjk-shurljlrjmaea`aty, 5-<1rj`agea`aty, 5-<=

hpjk-shurlj aktj``adjklj. \jj H\AK].

H\AK], 7-7gkm tcj aktj``adjklj

prhljss, 7-77lcgrgltjrastals, 7-=lhktraeutahks th

lhuktjraksurdjklyhpjrgtahks, M-7

lhktraeutahks th DJHAK],M-1lhktraeutahks th CZIAK],

M-2lhktraeutahks th aiprhvasjm

jxp`hsavj mjvalj mjbjgthpjrgtahks, M-7

lhktraeutahks th aktj``adjkljprjpgrgtahk hb tcjegtt`jbaj`m, 7-73

lhktraeutahks th \ADAK],M-1

lhktraeutahks th satjjxp`hatgtahk, M-75

lhktraeutahks th shurlj

vjttakd, M-75lhktraeutahks th tgrdjtakd

hpjrgtahks, M-7lhhrmakgtahk, 5-==mjljptahk gkm eags, 5-=:mjbakjm, 7-7jxp`hatgtahk, 5-77, 5-57pjrshkkj`, 5-22p`gkkakd, 5-7pravgtj akbhrigtahk, <-2pue`al`y gvga`ge`j

akbhrigtahk, <-2

H\AK] hrdgkazgtahks Gsagk \tumajs Mjtglcijkt,

5-53, J-7<

 Gssastgkt Mjputy Marjlthr hbKgtahkg` Aktj``adjklj bhrHpjk \hurlj, G-5:

Mjbjksj Hpjk \hurljLhukla`, J-7

Mjpgrtijkt hb tcj GriyAktj``adjklj Akbhrigtahk\jrvalj, J-=

Page 88: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 88/91

Akmjx

Jktrajs grj ey pgrgdrgpc kuiejr.

Akmjx-5 G]_ 5-55.1 7? Fu`y 5?75 

Marjlthr hb Kgtahkg`Aktj``adjklj Hpjk \hurljLjktjr, G-53, J-3

Bjmjrg` Eurjgu hbAkvjstadgtahk, J-72

Bjmjrg` Ujsjgrlc Mavasahk,@aergry hb Lhkdrjss, J-5?

Z.\. Griy Aktj``adjklj gkm\jluraty Lhiigkm, J-5

Kgtahkg` Hpjk-\hurljLhiiattjj, G-54

Hpjk \hurlj Glgmjiy,J-75

pue`al erhgmlgsts, 5-74, <-57

pue`al mhluijkts, 5-7=, <-5?

pue`al spjgnakd bhruis, 5-77,<-73Lcgtcgi Chusj Uu`j, <-73

U rjquarjijkt

lhiigkmjr's lratalag`akbhrigtahk, 7-7<, <-5

brajkm`y bhrlj akbhrigtahk,7-7<, <-5

prahraty aktj``adjklj, 7-7<,<-5

aktj``adjklj, <-:

prahraty aktj``adjklj, <-5

rjsjgrlc, <-77baj`m rjsjgrlc, <-7<hpjk-shurlj, <-7p`gk, <-72prgltalg`, <-7<qujstahk, <-7:

sjluraty mhigaks, =-==Fhakt Thr`mwamj Aktj``adjklj

Lhiiukalgtahks \ystji,=-=2

Khksjlurj Aktjrkjt _rhthlh`

Uhutjr Kjtwhrn, =-=3

\JLUJ] Aktjrkjt _rhthlh`Uhutjr Kjtwhrn, =-=4

shurljsgkg`ysas hb tcj ijmag, =-5?gutchratgtavj, =-7?lhkbamjktag`, <-4

lrjmaea`aty rgtakds, 5-<1khkgutchratgtavj, =-77hpjk, 7-7, <-4praigry, 5-<:rj`agea`aty rgtakds, 5-<3sjlhkmgry, 5-<4

tcrjgtlhursjs hb gltahk, 5-3jvg`ugtj, 5-4

Z.\. pjrshk akbhrigtahklh``jltahk hb 5-=?, G-3

massjiakgtahk hb, G-71rjtjktahk hb, G-7=

Page 89: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 89/91

 

G]_ 5-55.1 7? Fu`y 5?75 

Ey hrmjr hb tcj \jlrjtgry hb tcj Griy6

UGQIHKM ]. HMAJUKHDjkjrg`, Zkatjm \tgtjs Griy

Lcajb hb \tgbb

Hbbalag`6

FHQLJ J. IHUUHT Gmiakastrgtavj Gssastgkt th tcj

\jlrjtgry hb tcj Griy

MA\]UAEZ]AHK6

Zk`aiatjm Mastraeutahk> Kht th ej mastraeutjm> j`jltrhkal ijmag hk`y.

Page 90: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 90/91

Page 91: ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

7/21/2019 ATP 2-22-9 Open Source Intelligence (2012)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/atp-2-22-9-open-source-intelligence-2012 91/91