assignments
TRANSCRIPT
Print Save to File
Printable View of: Assignments
File: Overview Assignments
File: A1 - Course Overview
Assignments Overview
The assignments are the heart of this course. Most of what you learn will come from the process of carrying them out as well as the discussion we'll have in class related to them.
Read them very carefully to be sure you understand all the requirements.ASK in class if you don't understand something
Look at the submission requirements carefully - for most team assignments each person must submit individually AND one member must submit for the team to the URL database.
Updated: 3/29/08
Course Overview - A 1
Purpose
The intent of this assignment is to start you thinking in the manner we ask in this course, and to use the tools that will be important throughout the next six months.
In essence, you're to read the syllabus, assignments and related material, reflect on it, and answer some questions based on that material as well as what we did in class.
To do so you'll have to use a web page creation tool and post the results on a web page. We will demonstrate the basics of how to use them in class if necessary.
Details
As begun in class, you are to review the entire AE-390 web site. You are then to create your own web-page which answers the questions embodied in the grading criteria. You will mount that web page on a web server of your choice (If you don't use Google Sites I recommend Dunx1 since all students have accounts on it) for viewing via the web and submit the URL to the assignments database. At the next meeting of the class students will review other's pages and evaluate them.
Read this assignment first, particularly the criteria below since they will determine the grade for the assignment. Note that this assignment will be the prototype for all the others in the course. Read the rest of the class materials on the AE-390 web site. This is the material which explains what you'll be doing for the rest of this term. The criteria for this assignment assume that you have read that material.
Create a web page answering the questions either explicitly or implicitly contained in the grading criteria.
Some students have found Powerpoint or MS Publisher very helpful, but Powerpoint can become limiting in the amount of material you can include. Most are now using Google Sites.
Note that it is sufficient to create a single web page although more experienced or ambitious students may complete linked pages if they desire. If you choose to create linked pages (or include graphics) be sure to use "local references" so that the pages may be moved to another location.
Page 1 of 50Assignments
9/22/2010https://learning.dcollege.net/webct/urw/lc1508742634121.tp1530342792081/selectItemsFo...
Drexel's Office of Information Resources and Technology has excellent tutorials on web page creation as well as some templates.
Mount the work by the deadline onto the web server of your choice.
You should be able to work directly into your "public_html" folder if you use Dunx1. We can discuss this in class.
See the AE Resources Page for help with web page creation.
Be sure to check the page using a browser to ensure that everything works as you expect it. The biggest difficulty is usually that graphics aren't incorporated into the proper directory/folder when uploading.
Enter the URL with the other necessary information into the online Submissions database - available from the course home page. Be sure to do so by pasting the URL - not typing it.
Check that it works by searching and clicking the link.
Also, submit the URL into VistaBB
Come to class on next time prepared to review other people's work and make comments on it.
Teamwork
This project is to be completed individually.
You are, however to look ahead to the future assignments in which teamwork is required and discuss how you will do that effecitvely, using explicit reference to the teamwork website.
Deliverables
You are to deliver a web site which addresses the assignment, ready to be viewed by the class and instructor. Each site should meet the following requirements.
Web page or web site.
Mount the Web Page/site on a publicly connected server - Google Sites or Dunx1 are recommended.
Submission of web site URL in online database AND to Vista Blackboard (VBB).
Web Page Identification Requirements
Your assignment site should have at least the following information on it:
The specifics defined by the assignment details and grading criteria.Course Name
Your name (yes people have forgotten that)
Assignment titleDate
Grading Criteria
The following will be be used to assess your success in meeting the project's requirements. Note that each project will be "weighted" as shown on the grading to determine the overall term grade.
General advice - BE SPECIFIC, you'll only get an average grade if you give generalities without specific numbers, details, examples to back up your generality.
Page 2 of 50Assignments
9/22/2010https://learning.dcollege.net/webct/urw/lc1508742634121.tp1530342792081/selectItemsFo...
Criteria Average Work Excellent Work Possible
Points
Course Understanding
Summarize what you are asked
to do in AE-390.
Average work+
Explain or speculate why the assignments
are in the specific sequence - giving details.
Comment on the video we viewed in the
first class - Performance by Design and its
relevance to the course.
30
Your Future Skills
Define what you should be able
to do at the end of this course
that you aren't now able to do, in
detail.
Average work+
Speculate what will be the difficult and easy
aspects of the course for you.
30
Web Page Layout & Submission
All questions answered.
Clear grammar and spelling
checked.
Page mounted & viewable on the
web.
URL submitted.
Average work+
Good use of Web features to make the work
readily understandable: Headings,
dividers, color, indentation, etc.
30
Teamwork
Read the teamwork web site.
Discuss whether you agree with
the recommendations of the web
site being specific about which
make sense and which you do
not agree with or understand.
Average work+
Define those steps that you'll take with
each new team to ensure that the team will
be effective.
10
Extra Credit - to make up points lost on other sections
Make a link to at least one web
site that you think is related to
issues raised in this assignment.
Average work+
Suggest how this assignment could be
improved for the next class.
3
Total 100
Page 3 of 50Assignments
9/22/2010https://learning.dcollege.net/webct/urw/lc1508742634121.tp1530342792081/selectItemsFo...
File: A1a - BIM
Updated: 9/21/10
A1a -BIM - Creating a Building in Revit Intelligent Building
Overview Details Teamwork Deliverables Grading
Overview
The intent is to give you a taste of working with a BIM tool AutoDesk's Revit (you may use Bentley System's equivalent as an option if you choose, but I cannot help much).
You'll create a sample building taking advantage of a few of the BIM capabilities of the software.
For newcomers we'll give step-by-step instructions, but experienced users there's an option.The end-product will be a single drawing incorporating multiple "views" of your project
You'll write some conclusions and present your project in class.
Getting Revit for Yourself
If you wish to work at home and have a computer (PC) with sufficient horsepower you can download Revit for free (while a student) at the Autdesk Students Site. You will need:
To register on the site providing proof that you're a student
Be prepared for a VERY big download - multiple Gigs if I remember correctlyNote that we're using Revit Architecture in this class. A comparison between the three versions of Revit (for 2009 version) is available from MasterGraphics
Details
Novice Revit UsersFollow the instructions on the associated page to create a simple, single-story building model and associated "sheet".
Note that the videos and instructions are based on Revit-2010 - There may be menu differences in Revit-2011
Note that there are videos that demonstrate it linked form the page so that you don't have to remember everything.
Your continuous wall is = 10 x the number of letters of your last name (e.g. Mitchell -> 8x10 = 80') - a dimension and a note showing the computation indicate this on the "sheet"
Note that you are welcome to create a more complex building than the one shown, but please be sure to create the "sheet" that shows multiple views.
When you are done write a single page (300-500 words) addressing the following questions
What worked well in following the instructions?
What problems did you have - with the program and the instructions?How does this program differ from Autocad (or Microstation)?
Do you see signficant advantages or disadvantages for using it?
Exerienced Revit UsersYou are welcome to follow the "Novice" requirements. We suggest however that you do the following:
Develop a model with an output "sheet" that includes the following.
A building model that you build for this assignment - not something from CoOp work or a prior class.
A new aspect of Revit that you haven't explored before - e.g. structural column info or a rendered view.
Return to Top
Page 4 of 50Assignments
9/22/2010https://learning.dcollege.net/webct/urw/lc1508742634121.tp1530342792081/selectItemsFo...
You must write a document similar to the one for the novices, but emphasizing your total Revit experience.
We may well share that with the entire class.
Teamwork
Each individual is to work alone on this project.
Deliverables
Revit Model submitted to VistaBB1.
Word document describing the experience, as defined above - Also submitted to VistaBB2.
Grading
To be developed
General advice - BE SPECIFIC, you'll only get an average grade if you give generalities without specific numbers, details, examples to back up your generality.
View the Grading Form
Return to Top
Return to Top
Return to Top
Page 5 of 50Assignments
9/22/2010https://learning.dcollege.net/webct/urw/lc1508742634121.tp1530342792081/selectItemsFo...
File: A1a - BIM Tutorial
Criteria Average Work (approx. 66%)
Excellent Work = Average +Possible Points
Revit Model
Exists
Model exists and is mounted on the
serverSame as average 30
"Sheet" exists
A 30x42 drawing "sheet" exists with at
least:
the floor plan inserted in it
Your name, project name
and date in the title block
Average +
one or more perspective views
one or more elevations
one perspective view has
shading
The floor plan meets the length
requirements specified above
20
Data extracted
from Model
The "sheet" contains a door schedule
containing:
"Mark"
Width and height of the
door
"Family" information
Average +
Door schedule contains other
relevant information
Window schedule with relevant
information
20
Document
Describing
Experience
The word document is attached with
the following characteristics:
Meets length requirements
Addresses all required
issues at least minimally
Average +
Specific details support your
descriptions
Your reflections include some
significant comments on the
applicability to this course and
other courses.
30
Updated: 9/21/10
Return to Top
A1a -BIM - Detailed Steps Intelligent Building
Revit Basic Building Tutorial
This set of steps should walk one through creating a basic building model and an output drawing using
Revit Architectural 2010. The linked videos show the same steps with minor variations. Students in AE-
390 should be able to create Assignment #A1a’s work by essentially following these steps.
Page 6 of 50Assignments
9/22/2010https://learning.dcollege.net/webct/urw/lc1508742634121.tp1530342792081/selectItemsFo...
Note that the videos and instructions are based on Revit-2010 - There may be menu differences in Revit-201
a. New Project (Video 1)Note that you'll probably want to expand the window to see the screen clearly.
b. Draw Floor
Project Browser - Select "Level-1"1.
Home Tab | Build | Floor2.
Switches to "Create Floor Boundary" in Ribbon Tab3.
Boundary Lines - be sure "chain" is selecteda.
Draw floor plan – note you can type in specific dimensions while drawing
b.
"Finish Floor" (Checkmark)c.
Are now in "Modify Floors" Ribbon Tabi.
Select the floor4.
Check that type is "Generic 12"a.
It's OK to switch to another type if you wishi.
c. Draw Exterior Walls
Switch to "Home" Tab on Ribbon1.
Select Wall tool 2.
Tab changes to "Place Wall" automatically1.
Change "Element " Properties 2.
Click on "Element Properties" Icon - Upper Half 1.
Instance Properties Dialog Box opens1.
Change the "Type" to your choice 2.
JEM chose Brick on metal studs1.
Change the following Parameters 3.
"Top Constraint" from "Unconnected" to "Up to Level 2"1.
"Location Line" to "Finish Face Exterior"2.
Trace the outside of the floor plan 3.
Choose the "Line" Icon in the "Draw" region1.
Drawing option - arrow - Pick lines2.
Trace the sides of your floor from one corner to the next 3.
Page 7 of 50Assignments
9/22/2010https://learning.dcollege.net/webct/urw/lc1508742634121.tp1530342792081/selectItemsFo...
Will show the wall1.
d. View Elevation i. Project Browser - Double Click an Elevation
1. Should see an elevation with Level indicators
May need to zoom out a bit to see indicators
e. Create 3D View i. Click on "3D" with house icon in uppermost toolbar
1. Will create 3D view in Project Browser
2. Should see walls on your floor
f. Go back to floor plan of Level-1 (Video #2) i. Project Browser - Floor Plans - Level 1 - Double Click
g. Create Interior Partitions & rooms
Choose Ribbon "Home" Tab 1.
Select Wall tool - Type Interior - Your choice - I chose 5-1/2" 2.
Behaves as before for Exterior Wall1.
Note that can modify most usual parameters directly in the toolbar above the drawing area
2.
Draw several partitions to make at least three rooms 3.
When finish click on "Modify" arrow on left1.
"Room & Area" Tab | Room Icon 4.
Choose Room tool and make rooms for each space you created 1.
Will turn blue with labels on room.1.
Click in spaces 2.
Accept the default room numbers or change them1.
h. Put on a Roof
Select Level-2 floor - double click1.
Select roof tool - Home |Build Group | Roof 2.
Note that it changes to sketch mode1.
Create an overhang - I used 2'2.
Use "Pick Walls" option to draw boundaries of roof. (Last Icon)3.
"Finish Roof" - should see roof appear 4.
Switches to "Modify Roof"1.
Page 8 of 50Assignments
9/22/2010https://learning.dcollege.net/webct/urw/lc1508742634121.tp1530342792081/selectItemsFo...
Change type to Wood rafter 8" - Asphalt5.
View in 3D - Should see roof6.
i. Doors & Windows
Put doors and windows so each room has a view and you can get into the building and each room
1.
Choose Level 1 Floor Plan1.
Change to Home Tab2.
Choose Door (or window) 3.
May want to "Load Family" to get different door types1.
Place them where you wish4.
Repeat with Window (door) 5.
j. Create a perspective view (Video 3)
Change to floor plan view1.
Change to Ribbon | View | Create | 3D View PullDown | Camera2.
Put "Camera" icon where you want to make a view 3.
Drag the view lines out far enough to encompass the building1.
Once you stop dragging the 3D view will pop up2.
You can change the view window by dragging its edges3.
Note: You have created a new "3D view" in the project browser. 4.
Can change the view properties - e.g. to produce gradient background1.
k. Create a Door Schedule - another view
Switch Back to Floor Plan1.
Pick "View" tab in Design Bar2.
Pick "Schedules" | "Schedules/Quantity"3.
Choose "Doors" to schedule 4.
Brings Up "Schedule Properties" Window1.
Fields to Include from "Properites Window" (at least these) 5.
Assembly Code1.
Description2.
Count3.
Page 9 of 50Assignments
9/22/2010https://learning.dcollege.net/webct/urw/lc1508742634121.tp1530342792081/selectItemsFo...
Height4.
Keynote5.
Mark6.
Width7.
This creates "Door Schedule" under Schedules in Project Browser6.
You can do the same for windows if you choose7.
l. Create a "Sheet" that would actually print out (Video 4)
Choose "New Sheet" from View | Sheet Composition1.
Accept default 30x42 titleblock1.
Now will have a sheet on which can put your building2.
Drag at least the following views onto the sheet from the Project Browser 2.
"Level 1" floor plan 1.
If it's too big it's possible to crop the drawing - won't do here1.
Your view created by the camera2.
Door schedule3.
One elevation4.
Change the title block to have your information 3.
Zoom in on the lower right part of the title block1.
Change at least the following by clicking on them 2.
Project Name - Call it "Revit Test"1.
Drawn by - Your Name2.
Anything else you want.3.
m. Save this and submit it to Vista BB with a one page (approximately) document that describes the following
Comparison to prior Experience
What is easier.What is more difficult.
Advantages you can see.Disadvantages you can see.
Whether you believe this tool will be applicable in other courses.
Page 10 of 50Assignments
9/22/2010https://learning.dcollege.net/webct/urw/lc1508742634121.tp1530342792081/selectItemsFo...
File: A2 - A Major Buildings
Updated: 9/21/10
A Major Building - A2
Purpose
This assignment has three purposes. It:
Introduces you to an innovative building.1.
Asks you to think in detail about three of the major systems in a building: Architecture; Structure; HVAC
2.
(Re) introduces you to a tool used during conceptual design - Sketchup3.
As a team you're asked to find a Sketchup model of a significant contemporary building and analyze it visually, with calculations, and in writing by preparing "diagrams" appropriate for several audiences and answering questions about the building.
Web Page
Document your work by creating a single web page or site for the work of your team.
Details
As indicated above the essence of this problem is to examine and present a major existing building using the Sketchup model as the starting point for your analysis. Ideally you'll use that same model to create diagrams (drawings) of the building appropriate for different audiences. You may, however, prepare the diagrams independently if you choose, including reusing and enhancing ones that you find on the web or in books. Finally you'll analyze what you've done.
The steps you are to follow are therefore:
1) Research the building you've chosen as a team documenting at the least the following about it:
First you need to select a building. The recommended choices are in this spreadsheet that lists all the architects in the two books that are located in the CadLab - "Architecture Now! 6", and "Digital Architecture". During the first class your team will sign up for a building after checking that a model that you can use exists in Google Earth Warehouse, or Great Buildings Online. You're welcome to use other sources as well. We may approve substitute architects/buildings provided they are signficant contemporary works. DO NOT use the same buildings that were used last year - find new ones.
You will need to document the following about your building in your web page.
Page 11 of 50Assignments
9/22/2010https://learning.dcollege.net/webct/urw/lc1508742634121.tp1530342792081/selectItemsFo...
Facts
LocationBuilding Type
Owner
Number of floorsArchitect
Structural Engineer
MEP EngineersContractor
Contracting Method (Design-Build; Design-Bid-Build; Other)
Architectural Organizing PrinciplesMajor Structural System(s)
Major HVAC system(s)
Note explicitly if the information is not available for any of these items.
Opinions
Major design challenge for each of the design teams: Architect, Structural, MEP
Innovative systems used by each of the design team membersConventional systems used by each of the design team members
2) Download a Sketchup building Model in Google Earth Warehouse.
Almost all models that you'll find show the exterior only. You'll need to make assumptions about the interior systems to complete the rest of the assignment
Note that you are free to create your own model or use other programs such as Revit (an obvious choice since you'll be working simultaneously on a Revit project) if you choose. Sketchup is identified because there are so many models available in the Warehouse.
See the Google Sketchup Tutorials for suggestions on how to learn and use SketchUp.
3) Analyze and Describe the Architecture System of the building
Drawings/Diagrams
Document the building with at least the following drawings. You may extract them from sketchup or use other sources (which are likely to be much more detailed).
Plan at first floor level
Two perpendicular building sections
Two building elevationsAerial perspective view(s) chosen to illustrate the unique aspects of the building
Calculations
Calculate or indicate at least the following relevant building characteristics, being explicit about the assumptions.
Ground Floor area - footprint
Number of floorsTotal Building area
Page 12 of 50Assignments
9/22/2010https://learning.dcollege.net/webct/urw/lc1508742634121.tp1530342792081/selectItemsFo...
Number of occupants - assume 200SF/Occupant unless you get better information
Building elevation area in each major direction (usually N,E,S,W)
Analysis and Description
Analyze the architectural system using the results of your calculations answering the following questions - recognizing that some answers may be speculation.
How did the site of the building affect its form?
How does the form of the building affect its structural system?
How does the form and location of the building affect its HVAC system?
4) Analyze and Describe the Structural System of the building
Drawings/Diagrams
Document the building's structural system with at least the following drawings. You may use those from the architecture section as bases or use other sources (which are likely to be much more detailed). You'll probably want to use a 2D drawing tool such as paint.net or Inkscape to draw over the building plans or sections.
Show how the vertical loads are taken to the ground
Show how the horizontal loads are resisted This one may have to be speculative - be sure to discuss it in class.
Calculations
Calculate the following using either real values if you can find them or the assumptions given. Ask in class if you need further information.
Note that in a real project, including Senior Design, you'd need to use exact numbers for the specific material or the code requirement. Look at your textbooks for materials information and the relevant code (usually IBC in the US - MadCad database for it and other codes. These are just to help you start develop your "intution" about typical numbers.
Building dead load (weight) in pounds using the following assumptions (document them)
density of the major materials: Steel 490 PCF
Concrete 145PCF (or 100PCF for lightweight)Glass 185PCF
Partition Load 5PSF of floor area
Equipment Load 5PSF of floor areaCeiling Load 2PSF of floor area
Vertical structure area 1.5% of floor area of a given floor - don't forget the height to calculate volumeBuilding live load based on the following assumptions
40PSF residential80PSF commercial
300PSF industrial/storage
Load on Foundations Total load in pounds
Load/SF of the building footprint
Maximum Horizontal wind load using the following assumption
Page 13 of 50Assignments
9/22/2010https://learning.dcollege.net/webct/urw/lc1508742634121.tp1530342792081/selectItemsFo...
Maximum wind speed of 90mph = 21PSF
Note that windspeed varies greatly with location and with other factors. What's given here is a typical number for Philadelphia. In Miami the speed would be 140mph which would produce a pressure of 50PSF - more than double Philadelphia.
Analysis and Description
Describe the structural system using the results of your calculations to answer the following questions - recognizing that some answers may be speculation.
What are the relative magnitudes of the total Dead, Live and Horizontal loads and what implications do these have for the structure of the building?Looking at the foundation load what do you think it means for the type of foundation to be used, and what additional information would you need?Would this be an easy or a difficult building for which to develop the structural calculations (assuming you'd already completed the senior year structural sequence)? Why?
5) Analyze and Describe the HVAC System of the building
Drawings/Diagrams
Document the building's HVAC (mechanical) system with at least the following drawings. You may use those from the architecture section as bases or use other sources (which are likely to be much more detailed). You'll probably want to use a 2D drawing tool such as paint.net or Inkscape to draw over the building plans or sections.
Building fenestration - emphasizing the percentage of the building walls (and roof) through which the sun can shine.Show how the building is heated and cooled with a single-line diagram
This one may have to be speculative - be sure to discuss it in class.
Calculations
Calculate the following using either real values if you can find them or the assumptions given. Ask in class if you need further information.
Heat load out of building in cold winter night - no occupants or lights - in BTU/Hr
use the following assumptions (document them)
average nighttime winter temperature for your building's location
Your assumption about the length of the cooling season at that nighttime temperature
R-value of wall material = 10 ft²·°F·h/Btu.R-value of roof material = 30 ft²·°F·h/Btu.
R value of glass = 2 ft²·°F·h/Btu.
HVAC air flow and leakage are neglected - not realistic, but we're simplifying
Convert this number to gallons/hour of heating oil - assume 120,000 BTU/Gallon delivered
Calculate the heating cost per year assuming $2/gallon of heating oil
Building heating load that must be dealt with by the cooling system Calculate
The Hourly heat load in BTU/HR, Tons of HVAC, Watts
Page 14 of 50Assignments
9/22/2010https://learning.dcollege.net/webct/urw/lc1508742634121.tp1530342792081/selectItemsFo...
The daily heat load
Remember that that the sun moves
Make your assumptions about how to complete this calculation explicit
Estimate the season=annual cost to cool this building using these assumptions
Convert that to cost/SF as wellAssumptions in the absence of better numbers
300 BTU/hr by people 200 SF/Person 1.5 w/SF for lighting 3 w/SF for equipment 100 w/SF incident solar on horizontal surface 60 w/SF incident solar on West or east facing surface at peak time Ton of AC = 12,000 BTU/Hr per ton Seasonal Energy Efficiency Ratio (SEER) is 10 (explain what this means) Electrical Energy costs $0.10/KWH
Analysis and Description
Describe the HVAC system using the results of your calculations to answer the following questions - recognizing that some answers may be speculation.
What are the relative magnitudes of the total hourly heating and cooling loads?
What are the relative costs of heating and cooling the building?Would this be an easy or a difficult building for which to develop the HVAC calculations (assuming you'd already completed the senior year HVAC courses)? Why?
6) Evaluate What you accomplished by answering the following questions
Expectations vs results
Each individual should describe what you expected at the start of the assignment and what you believe at the end of the assignment, with an emphasis on the system that you analyzed. Identify who you are and your system.Describe what you learned from performing this analysis
System Interaction
As a group comment on what you see as the interactions and dependencies between the different systems.
Group ProcessAs a group describe the issues you faced in completing this assignment
What were the major problems?
How did you check that your results "made sense" for each system?
7) Create a web page/site combining all your results
The goal is that the site should appear to be the work of a single person although it will combine the work of all members of the team.
Submit the URL for your website two places
In the VistaBB assignment submission slot - so we can give you a grade.In the assignment database
EACH PERSON Submit the teamwork evaluation assignment in VistaBB.
Page 15 of 50Assignments
9/22/2010https://learning.dcollege.net/webct/urw/lc1508742634121.tp1530342792081/selectItemsFo...
8) Timing of Submission
You are to make your submissions by the start of your section's class (3:00 for Section-2, 5:00 for section 501)
Note that for technical reasons VistaBB is set to automatically mark assignments "late" only for the later section for each assignment. We can, however, check the actual times to ensure that all students turned their assignments in on time.
Teamwork
You are welcome to consult with your classmates for suggestions - short of direct copying. The grading is on an absolute scale so mutual assistance can only help each group.
Teams for this Assignment - Building PageIn class you'll select the building that you'll be working on. Once you've done so you'll put your names next to that building - the goal being that we know who is analyzing what system and that we don't have more than one team studying a given building.
At the end of the project, as noted above, submit an evaluation of your team's performance using the assignment in VistaBB. Do so with EACH PERSON submitting their own teamwork evaluation.
Deliverables
The web page URL submitted to the places defined above.Each individual submits their teamwork evaluation via VistaBB
Web Page Identification Requirements
The specifics defined by the assignment details and grading criteria.Course Name
Your name (yes people have forgotten that)
Assignment titleDate
Grading Criteria
The following will be be used to assess your success in meeting the project's requirements. Note that each project will be "weighted" as shown in the syllabus to determine the overall term grade.
General advice - BE SPECIFIC, you'll only get an average grade if you give generalities without specific numbers, details, examples to back up your generality.
Page 16 of 50Assignments
9/22/2010https://learning.dcollege.net/webct/urw/lc1508742634121.tp1530342792081/selectItemsFo...
Criteria Average Work Excellent Work = Average
Work +
Possible
Points
Web Page Exists
Page exists and is easy to
read with minimal
spelling errors.
Diagrams and linked
SketchUp file exist.
Accurate URL submitted
to Database, andVistaBB
on time.
The website is clear, well
written and takes advantage of
web capabilities.
10
Architecture
The Architecture System addresses
all the elements required:
Drawings Exist
Calculations exist and are
generally complete and
appropriate
Discussion exists
Drawings are
explicitly labeled and
appropriately
elaborated
Calculations are
correct and complete
including
appropriate units
and significant digits
Discussion is specific
using the results of
the diagrams and
drawings.
25
Structure
The Structural System addresses all
the elements required:
Drawings Exist
Calculations exist and are
generally complete and
appropriate
Discussion exists
Drawings are
explicitly labeled and
appropriately
elaborated
Calculations are
correct and complete
including
appropriate units
and significant digits
Discussion is specific
using the results of
the diagrams and
drawings.
25
Page 17 of 50Assignments
9/22/2010https://learning.dcollege.net/webct/urw/lc1508742634121.tp1530342792081/selectItemsFo...
HVAC
The HVAC System addresses all the
elements required:
Drawings Exist
Calculations exist and are
generally complete and
appropriate
Discussion exists
Drawings are
explicitly labeled and
appropriately
elaborated
Calculations are
correct and complete
including
appropriate units
and significant digits
Discussion is specific
using the results of
the diagrams and
drawings.
25
Evaluate
Accomplishments
Each of the elements of the
evaluation exists in a basic way:
Expectations vs results
System Interaction
Group Process
Details in each evaluation are
complete and appropriate:
Calculation results
are used to make
points.
Specific systems are
discussed - not just
generalities
The contribution of
each team member
to the process is
addressed.
The basis for
expectations is made
explicit
15
Page 18 of 50Assignments
9/22/2010https://learning.dcollege.net/webct/urw/lc1508742634121.tp1530342792081/selectItemsFo...
File: A2 Teams
Extra Credit - to
make up points
lost on other
sections
Suggestions for improving this
exercise in future.
Estimate the life-
cycle cost of this
building using the
information you've
calculated and an
assumed
construction cost of
$250/SF OR
Take your building
and put it in another
location in Google
Earth - Show the
results and comment
on the effects for the
systems OR
Enhance the
sketchup model and
other interior
elements (structural
or HVAC) and show
an improved plan
and section
5
Total Possible 100
Updated: 9/21/10
Page 19 of 50Assignments
9/22/2010https://learning.dcollege.net/webct/urw/lc1508742634121.tp1530342792081/selectItemsFo...
Teams - Assignment #2
Page 20 of 50Assignments
9/22/2010https://learning.dcollege.net/webct/urw/lc1508742634121.tp1530342792081/selectItemsFo...
Team
#Team Members
1Sara Beg; Caroline Edwards; Christopher
Snavely
2Andrea Christiani; Andrew Milner; Dylan
Short
3Lemond Brown; Monika Mickute; Samuel
Pomager
4Brandon Glencross; Alfred Uzokwe; Jason
Varounis
5 Daniel Brown; Peter Schmidt; Charlie Young
6Michael Massimi; James Monahan; Adams
Rackes
7 Davide Fratamico; Adrian Lu
8Brian Conzentino; Francesco Dicianni; Kelly
Downes
9 James Drogalis; Michael Ferraioli; Sophia Gray
10Joseph Guarneri; Justin Johnson; Martin
Khait
11Ryan Kirby; Kenneth Mariano; Jonathan
Mccarthy
12 Neil Patel; Eric Roitman
Page 21 of 50Assignments
9/22/2010https://learning.dcollege.net/webct/urw/lc1508742634121.tp1530342792081/selectItemsFo...
Assignment: A2Tm Teamwork EvaluationInstructions: Identify your team members, including the group # Describe and evaluate your contribution. Describe and evaluate your team members contributions.
Attachments:
Due Date: October 8, 2010 5:00 PM
Collaboration Type Individual
Grading Criteria:
File: Structures Variety A3
Updated: 9/21/10
Structures Variety - A3
Purpose
The intent of this exercise is to build your familiarity with the variety of structural systems and also to refine your familiarity with the system concept.
You are to explore an assigned structural system in as great a depth as possible and explain it to your peers,. applying the definition of a system that we agreed upon in class. Each group will explore a different structural system so we get as great a range of systems as possible.
Details
You are to create web page(s) addressing your assigned structural systems. You are to consider it as a system with subsystems. Comment on their characteristics, with particular emphasis on their applicability in different design situations. Using material gathered from the text and other reference sources is entirely appropriate, but you must annotate and organize it.
Number of Systems
You will address a single system, but will be expected to learn from the other groups about their systems.
Structural System Completeness
Be sure that the system description is complete. That means that you must consider how all loads (both horizontal and vertical) are carried down into the ground. To do so you will need to address how rooves and floors are created with your system as well as foundation systems.
Content of Web Pages
The web pages should present the diagrams you have assembled or created and comment on them. Using at least the following criteria:
Page 22 of 50Assignments
9/22/2010https://learning.dcollege.net/webct/urw/lc1508742634121.tp1530342792081/selectItemsFo...
Identifying the system and its components and the interactions
Identifying typical uses of each system
Find an example of contemporary use of the system that you think is particularly special.Identifying limitations on the system
Typical materials used Construction issues the system
Connections
Fabrication methods etc.
Presenting appropriate numeric parameters of the system. e.g.
Range of normal spans & associated depths Weight to span ratios
Probable deflections
Teamwork
This project is to be completed in groups that will be assigned by the instructor. You are welcome to consult with your classmates for suggestions - short of direct copying. The grading is on an absolute scale so mutual assistance can only help each group.
Teams for this Assignment
Submit an evaluation of your team's performance on this project - an opportunity to address any problems. Do so by submitting to the VistaBB assignment an evaluation including:
Your team number (from the team page)
State whether or not there were teamwork problems for this assignment
If there are teamwork problems then state the following A comment on each team member, starting with yourself including whether their performance was "average" or a little or a lot more or less than the average.Any other comment about the problem that you believe should affect the grade.
Deliverables
You are to deliver a web site which addresses the assignment, ready to be viewed by the class and instructor. Each site should meet the following requirements.
Web page or web site.Mount the Web Page/site on a publicly connected server - Dunx1 is recommended.
Submission of web site URL in online database.
Web Page Identification Requirements
Your assignment site should have at least the following information on it:
The specifics defined by the assignment details and grading criteria.Course Name
Your name (yes people have forgotten that)
Assignment titleDate
Grading Criteria
Page 23 of 50Assignments
9/22/2010https://learning.dcollege.net/webct/urw/lc1508742634121.tp1530342792081/selectItemsFo...
The following will be be used to assess your success in meeting the project's requirements. Note that each project will be "weighted" as shown on the grading to determine the overall term grade.
General advice - BE SPECIFIC, you'll only get an average grade if you give generalities without specific numbers, details, examples to back up your generality.
Page 24 of 50Assignments
9/22/2010https://learning.dcollege.net/webct/urw/lc1508742634121.tp1530342792081/selectItemsFo...
Criteria Average Work (60% Approx.)Excellent Work = Average +
Possible
Points
System fully
described
The system is described,
including how loads are taken
into the ground.. Accurate
Accurate URL submitted to
Database on time.
Average work +
Good use of the web to
make your description
clear.
All possible loads
addressed and a variety of
possible foundation
systems.
20
System
presented
effectively in
the terms
identified for
this course
The system is presented and labeled using
the standard terminology with at least
some explanation of system function.
Average work +
The system is presented
with excellent quality
graphics, text and numbers.
The use of terms and the
reference to the class
definition is clear, with
explanation of subsystems
where appropriate.
Comments on the systems
functions are presented.
20
Typical uses of
the system
given
At least three typical uses are presented
with explanation of why the system is
appropriate. If a system is appropriate in
only one or two situations the reasons are
given.
Average work +
A complete range of
possible uses of the system
is presented with
explanations of why the
system is appropriate.
In some cases explanations
of why the system is
inappropriate may be
presented.
You present an outstanding
example of the use of the
system in a contemporary
building.
20
Page 25 of 50Assignments
9/22/2010https://learning.dcollege.net/webct/urw/lc1508742634121.tp1530342792081/selectItemsFo...
File: A3 Teams
Limitations of
the systems
identified
The limitations of the system are
described in words.
Average work +
The limitations of the system are fully
considered with reference to materials
considerations, numeric parameters
and construction standards.
10
Materials and
Construction
Issues
Identified
Standard materials used in the system are
presented.
Average work +
The full range of materials possible
for the system is considered with
explanations of why they are either
appropriate or inappropriate.
10
Numeric
Parameters
presented.
At least three parameters are presented
for the system with typical values and
some comment.
Average work +
An extensive range of
numeric parameters are
presented with standard
units and maximum,
minimum and typical
values.
Comments are made on
each parameter and
graphical ranges presented
where appropriate.
20
Extra Credit
- to make up
points lost
on other
sections
At least one generalization about the
system considered is presented and
explained.
Average work +
Multiple relationships between your
system and the others chosen by the
class are considered and
generalizations presented with
suggestions for further exploration.
3
Total 100
Updated: 9/16/10
Page 26 of 50Assignments
9/22/2010https://learning.dcollege.net/webct/urw/lc1508742634121.tp1530342792081/selectItemsFo...
Teams - Assignment #3,4
Page 27 of 50Assignments
9/22/2010https://learning.dcollege.net/webct/urw/lc1508742634121.tp1530342792081/selectItemsFo...
Team
#
Structural
System (Ass#3)Team Members
Building (Ass#4)
(NOT for A#3)Location Size
1Frame - Steel,
Concrete
Contemporary Art
Gallery
Atlantic City,
NJ
20,000 SF,
Single Story
2
Two-
Dimensional
Compression
Automated Book
Distribution WarehouseChicago, IL
100,000 SF -
3 Stories
3
Three-
Dimensional
Compression
Chapel in National ParkDenali Park,
Alaska900 SF
4 Pneumatic
Archaeologist
Temporary Dinosaur
Workshop
Desert in
China6,000 SF
5 Frame - Wood Light Truck Assembly
Plant
Detroit,
Michigan150,000 SF
6 Tensegrity Airplane Hangar Houston, TXTo take 787
Dreamliner
7
Three-
Dimensional
Tension
Tornado-resistant
Emergency
communications center
Kansas City,
MO3,000 SF
8 Pneumatic Permanent, Occupied
Weather Station
Mount
Washington1,200 SF
9
Three-
Dimensional
Compression
10 Story Apt Bldg New York, NY15,000 SF /
Floor
Page 28 of 50Assignments
9/22/2010https://learning.dcollege.net/webct/urw/lc1508742634121.tp1530342792081/selectItemsFo...
Assignment: A3Tm Teamwork EvaluationInstructions: Identify your team members, including the group # Describe and evaluate your contribution. Describe and evaluate your team members contributions.
Attachments:
Due Date: October 20, 2010 5:00 PM
Collaboration Type Individual
Grading Criteria:
File: Structures Selection A4
10Frame - Steel,
Concrete
Meditation Space for
College CampusSan Diego, CA 1,200 SF
11 Frame - Wood Explosives Research
Lab
Wilmington,
DE4,000 SF
12
Three-
Dimensional
Tension
ASCE Headquarters Reston, VA 35,000 SF
Updated: 9/20/10
Structures Selection
Purpose
The selection Process - Background
One of the most important tasks you'll have in your professional life is making decisions about the "right" system to use for a particular building. When you start you typically know only that there is a desire for a building with particular use and spatial characteristics. It is your job to decide which of the many possible structural systems will meet the service requirements in an economical manner. There isn't any absolute way to make a decision because there are so many more variables than can be simultaneously optimized. Instead one has to learn a process of making a wise selection. This process typically involves drawing on prior experience ("what did we do last time?"), cost measures, engineering analysis and published information.
Page 29 of 50Assignments
9/22/2010https://learning.dcollege.net/webct/urw/lc1508742634121.tp1530342792081/selectItemsFo...
In AE-390 we emphasize developing understanding and skill at this selection process. This is the first exercise in which we ask you to address it. In a later assignment (HVAC Selection) we'll ask you to take the process to the next stage and create a "criteria matrix" which allows you to pick the "best" solution by answering a set of questions. The final assignment of this term will ask you to understand how the designers of a Drexel building probably made their selection. And then next term you'll have the chance to use the process in action by designing the systems for a building.
The Assignment
More specifically, we ask you now to prepare a web page which presents as many structural systems as possible and the criteria which a working engineer might use to make a selection for a particular building. We'll test your understanding by asking you to use your web page to explain how the information you provide is used to make a selection.
Details
At the beginning of the project each group will be assigned:
A building type from amongst the following - shown on the teams assignment pageA particular location and building size to be used for your illustration.
You then have three tasks to be presented in a web page
Research and present the structural systems which could be appropriate for your building type Develop and present the list of criteria which should be considered by the engineer to narrow the selection to the "best" solution for a particular project. Be sure to keep these criteria as general as possible, not focusing on your particular site in this portion.
Apply those criteria to your particular site in order to illustrate how a system might be selected. You will probably have to supply "reasonable" values to your criteria in order to do so. You will present the web page to your fellow students and perhaps to guests.
Teamwork
The teams for the assignment are the same as for the last assignment. You are welcome to consult with your classmates for suggestions - short of direct copying. The grading is on an absolute scale so mutual assistance can only help each group.
Teams for this Assignment
Submit an evaluation of your team's performance on this project - an opportunity to address any problems. Do so by submitting to the VistaBB assignment an evaluation including:
Your team number (from the team page)State whether or not there were teamwork problems for this assignment
If there are teamwork problems then state the following
A comment on each team member, starting with yourself including whether their performance was "average" or a little or a lot more or less than the average.
Any other comment about the problem that you believe should affect the grade.
Deliverables
You are to deliver a web site which addresses the assignment, ready to be viewed by the class and instructor. Each site should meet the following requirements.
Page 30 of 50Assignments
9/22/2010https://learning.dcollege.net/webct/urw/lc1508742634121.tp1530342792081/selectItemsFo...
Web page or web site.
Mount the Web Page/site on a publicly connected server - Dunx1 is recommended.
Submission of web site URL in online database.
Web Page Identification Requirements
Your assignment site should have at least the following information on it:
The specifics defined by the assignment details and grading criteria.
Course NameYour name (yes people have forgotten that)
Assignment title
Date
Grading Criteria
The following will be be used to assess your success in meeting the project's requirements. Note that each project will be "weighted" as shown on the grading to determine the overall term grade.
General advice - BE SPECIFIC, you'll only get an average grade if you give generalities without specific numbers, details, examples to back up your generality.
Page 31 of 50Assignments
9/22/2010https://learning.dcollege.net/webct/urw/lc1508742634121.tp1530342792081/selectItemsFo...
Criteria Average Work Excellent Work = Average + Possible
Points
Relevant
Structural
Systems
A "reasonable" range of
structural systems is
presented with some
justification of why they are
appropriate for the selected
building type.
Accurate URL submitted to
Database on time.
An exhaustive range of structural
systems is presented with
explanations of why they are
appropriately considered for this
building type as well as comments on
their strengths and limitations. Both
charts and typical numbers are
presented for relevant parameters.
40
Criteria for
System
Selection
A "reasonable" range of criteria is
presented with addressing the major
types shown under "excellent".
A full range of appropriate criteria is
presented with annotations of why
they are appropriate. The criteria will
consider at least: Owner's concerns
(e.g. cost, maintenance),
environmental factors (e.g.
earthquake zone), inherent
characteristics of the systems (e.g.
rigidity), performance measures (e.g.
L/D).
The criteria are organized in such a
way that an engineer will find it easy
to apply them to the different systems
40
Specific
Building
Selection
Example
A specific system is selected and
justified in terms of the criteria
defined previously. Explanations are
given why the other systems are
rejected.
The full range of criteria are used and
explained in the selection process in
an understandable and logical
manner.
20
Extra
Credit - to
make up
points lost
on other
sections
A logical set of steps to generalize the
process is presented.
A flow path or organized manner of
considering the selection process is
presented with comment on how it
would work in practice and the
limitations and strengths of this type
of approach.
5
Page 32 of 50Assignments
9/22/2010https://learning.dcollege.net/webct/urw/lc1508742634121.tp1530342792081/selectItemsFo...
Assignment: A4Tm Teamwork EvaluationInstructions: Identify your team members, including the group # Describe and evaluate your contribution. Describe and evaluate your team members contributions.
Attachments:
Due Date: October 27, 2010 5:00 PM
Collaboration Type Individual
Grading Criteria:
File: HVAC Variety A5
Total 100
Updated: 9/16/10
HVAC Systems Variety - A5
Purpose
You are to explore as great a variety of HVAC systems as possible by finding (or preparing if you choose) and explaining a diagram that illustrates that system. Apply the definition of a system that we agreed upon in class.
As with the structural systems page the intent of this exercise is to build your familiarity with the variety of HVAC systems and also to refine your familiarity with the system concept.
Details
You are to create web page(s) addressing both the Primary and Secondary components of HVAC systems. You are to consider them as systems and subsystems and comment on their characteristics, with particular emphasis on their applicability in different design situations. Using material gathered from the text and other reference sources is entirely appropriate, but you must annotate and organize it.
Number of Systems
You should address at least three primary systems and two secondary systems attempting to find as great a variety as possible. One of each of these will be a "major" system in common use in commercial buildings. The others shall be unusual systems, at one of which promotes economical energy use.
Content of Web Pages
The web pages should present the diagrams you have assembled or created and comment on them. Using at least the following criteria:
Page 33 of 50Assignments
9/22/2010https://learning.dcollege.net/webct/urw/lc1508742634121.tp1530342792081/selectItemsFo...
Identifying the system and whether it is primary or secondary, its components and their interactions
Identifying typical uses of each system
Identifying limitations on the system
Typical materials used
Construction issues for each system - e.g.
Clearances
Wall penetration requirements
Presenting appropriate numeric parameters of the system. e.g.
Energy efficiency
Temperature control capabilities
Range of outdoor air temperature suitabilities
Heating or cooling maximum sizes/unit
Teamwork
This project is to be completed in groups that will be assigned by the instructor. You are welcome to consult with your classmates for suggestions - short of direct copying. The grading is on an absolute scale so mutual assistance can only help each group.
Teams for this Assignment
Submit an evaluation of your team's performance on this project - an opportunity to address any problems. Do so by submitting to the VistaBB assignment an evaluation including:
Your team number (from the team page)
State whether or not there were teamwork problems for this assignment
If there are teamwork problems then state the following A comment on each team member, starting with yourself including whether their performance was "average" or a little or a lot more or less than the average.Any other comment about the problem that you believe should affect the grade.
Deliverables
You are to deliver a web site which addresses the assignment, ready to be viewed by the class and instructor. Each site should meet the following requirements.
Web page or web site.Mount the Web Page/site on a publicly connected server - Dunx1 is recommended.
Submission of web site URL in online database.
Web Page Identification Requirements
Your assignment site should have at least the following information on it:
The specifics defined by the assignment details and grading criteria.
Course Name
Your name (yes people have forgotten that)
Page 34 of 50Assignments
9/22/2010https://learning.dcollege.net/webct/urw/lc1508742634121.tp1530342792081/selectItemsFo...
Assignment title
Date
Grading Criteria
The following will be be used to assess your success in meeting the project's requirements. Note that each project will be "weighted" as shown on the grading to determine the overall term grade.
General advice - BE SPECIFIC, you'll only get an average grade if you give generalities without specific numbers, details, examples to back up your generality.
Page 35 of 50Assignments
9/22/2010https://learning.dcollege.net/webct/urw/lc1508742634121.tp1530342792081/selectItemsFo...
Criteria Average Work Excellent Work = Average+ Possible
Points
Number of
Systems
Addressed
Effectively
3 pimrary and 2 secondary
systems presented with adequate
use of the web so the user can see
the materials and move effectively
through the web site.
Accurate URL submitted to
Database on time.
At least 5 systems presented
making good use of the
capabilities of the web including
effective layout and graphics.
20
Systems
presented
effectively
in the terms
identified
for this
course
The systems are presented and labeled using
the standard terminology with at least some
explanation of system function.
The systems are presented with
excellent quality graphics, text
and numbers. The use of terms
and the reference to the class
definition is clear, with
explanation of subsystems
where appropriate. Comments
on the systems functions are
presented.
The relationship between the
primary and secondary systems
is considered including which
are likely to be used together.
30
Typical
uses of the
system
given
At least three typical uses are presented with
explanation of why the system is
appropriate. If a system is appropriate in
only one or two situations the reasons are
given.
A complete range of possible
uses of the systems is presented
with explanations of why the
system is appropriate. In some
cases explanations of why a
possible system is inappropriate
may be presented.
10
Page 36 of 50Assignments
9/22/2010https://learning.dcollege.net/webct/urw/lc1508742634121.tp1530342792081/selectItemsFo...
File: A5 Teams
Limitations
of the
systems
identified
The limitations of each system are described
in words
The limitations of each system
are fully considered with
reference to materials
considerations, numeric
parameters and construction
standards.
10
Numeric
Parameters
presented.
At least three parameters are presented for
each system with typical values and some
comment.
An extensive range of numeric
parameters are presented with
standard units and maximum,
minimum and typical values.
Comments are made on each
parameter and graphical ranges
presented where appropriate.
30
Extra
Credit - to
make up
points lost
on other
sections
At least one generalization about the systems
considered is presented and explained.
Multiple relationships between
the different systems chosen are
extensively considered and
generalizations presented with
suggestions for further
exploration.
3
Total 100
Updated: 9/16/10
Page 37 of 50Assignments
9/22/2010https://learning.dcollege.net/webct/urw/lc1508742634121.tp1530342792081/selectItemsFo...
Teams - Assignment #5,6
Page 38 of 50Assignments
9/22/2010https://learning.dcollege.net/webct/urw/lc1508742634121.tp1530342792081/selectItemsFo...
Team
#Team Members Building (Ass#6)
1 Bakery - Humidity critical
2 Telpehone Switching Center
3 Offices for Greenpeace
4 Emergency Ice Storage Center
for Disaster Relief
5 Demonstration Kitchens for
Whole Foods
6 College Non-Demoninational
Chapel
7 TV Studio
8 Arctic Plants Research Lab
9 High School Swimming Pool
10 Food Products Manufacturer
Testing Lab
11 College dormroom - student
satisfaction emphasis
12 Computer Server "Farm"
Page 39 of 50Assignments
9/22/2010https://learning.dcollege.net/webct/urw/lc1508742634121.tp1530342792081/selectItemsFo...
Assignment: A5Tm Teamwork EvaluationInstructions: Identify your team members, including the group # Describe and evaluate your contribution. Describe and evaluate your team members contributions.
Attachments:
Due Date: November 3, 2010 5:00 PM
Collaboration Type Individual
Grading Criteria:
File: HVAC Selection A6
Updated: 9/20/10
HVAC Selection - A6
Purpose
In this exercise we'll build on the selection process you began in the Structural Selection assignment. We ask you to make the process as formal as possible with the intent of illustrating how one can make fairly rational decisions. In particular we're asking you to develop a "criteria matrix" in which you weigh a variety of systems (you decide which ones) against a set of criteria ( again you decide which ones).
The proof of your selection process will be demonstrated when we use it to evaluate several different buildings.
You are to use the references given in the syllabus, your texts from this and other courses, and any other relevant materials to develop a spreadsheet which presents the variety of HVAC systems a working engineer might use for a particular building type (see the Teams Page). You will also present the criteria (e.g questions, numeric parameters etc) that the engineer might consider when making a selection of one of your possible HVAC systems from among the many you've presented. Your spreadsheet will embody the logic to select a single system "best" suited for a particular set of conditions.
Criteria Matrix
The difference between what we're asking you to do this time and what you created in the Structural Selection project is that you are asked to produce a working model that makes a recommendation of a particular system given answers by the user to a set of questions (ie. values to a set of criteria). You'll do this by creating a "Criteria Matrix" which has as its elements the variety of possible systems and the criteria which will be used to make the selection. By providing values for each of the criteria the matrix will calculate which system is "best" for that set of choices.
The criteria matrix will be created using an Excel spreadsheet (we have models from prior classes you may use as a starting point). Your charge is to decide the systems, the criteria, and then the logic and weighting factors that make the criteria matrix work.
Page 40 of 50Assignments
9/22/2010https://learning.dcollege.net/webct/urw/lc1508742634121.tp1530342792081/selectItemsFo...
In the final presentation you will use the matrix that you've created to make a particular selection for a building.
Energy Analysis
We also ask you to refresh your knowledge of Energy analysis software and incorporate its use into the decision process.
Details
Detailed Assignment
As for the structural project each group will be assigned a project, defined on the teams page:
You then have four tasks to be presented in a web page
Research and present the primary and secondary HVAC systems which would be appropriate for your building type
when located in different climate situations and also of different total size.
Develop and present the list of criteria which should be considered by the engineer to narrow the selection to the
"best" solution for a particular project.
Apply those criteria to your particular building type in order to illustrate how a primary and secondary system might
be selected. You will probably have to supply "reasonable" values to your criteria in order to do so.
As part of the criteria we are explicitly asking you to include the use of energy. You are to make use of Energy-10 (or
the more advanced program eQuest) to demonstrate how you would develop objective comparisons of different
systems.
Climate Locations
You will present the spreadsheet to your fellow students and perhaps to guests. At that time I will ask you to demonstrate its use under some combination of the following conditions.
New York, New York
Anchorage, Alaska
Phoenix, Arizona Miami, Florida
Millwaukee, Wisconsin
Sizes
Small
Medium
Large
Energy Analysis
You are to model your building and use Energy-10 (or eQuest, a more advanced package) to evaluate that building's energy use
in the different locations assigned locations. Because Energy10 is limited in the number of systems we are not asking you to
Page 41 of 50Assignments
9/22/2010https://learning.dcollege.net/webct/urw/lc1508742634121.tp1530342792081/selectItemsFo...
model more than one HVAC system, but you are to use different climates with one of your major choices and comment on how
using an energy analysis program can be used effectively in the decision process.
Teamwork
The teams for this assignment are the same as for the last one. You are welcome to consult with your classmates for suggestions - short of direct copying. The grading is on an absolute scale so mutual assistance can only help each group.
Teams for this Assignment
Submit an evaluation of your team's performance on this project - an opportunity to address any problems. Do so by submitting to the VistaBB assignment an evaluation including:
Your team number (from the team page)
State whether or not there were teamwork problems for this assignment If there are teamwork problems then state the following
A comment on each team member, starting with yourself including whether their performance was "average" or a little or a lot more or less than the average.
Any other comment about the problem that you believe should affect the grade.
Deliverables
You are to deliver a web site which addresses the assignment, ready to be viewed by the class and instructor. Each site should meet the following requirements.
Web page or web site.
Mount the Web Page/site on a publicly connected server - Dunx1 is recommended.
Submission of web site URL in online database.
Web Page Identification Requirements
Your assignment site should have at least the following information on it:
The specifics defined by the assignment details and grading criteria.
Course Name
Your name (yes people have forgotten that)Assignment title
Date
Grading Criteria
The following will be be used to assess your success in meeting the project's requirements. Note that each project will be "weighted" as shown on the grading to determine the overall term grade.
General advice - BE SPECIFIC, you'll only get an average grade if you give generalities without specific numbers, details, examples to back up your generality.
Page 42 of 50Assignments
9/22/2010https://learning.dcollege.net/webct/urw/lc1508742634121.tp1530342792081/selectItemsFo...
Criteria Average Work Excellent Work = Average +
Relevant
HVAC
Systems
A "reasonable" range of both primary and
secondary HVAC systems are presented
with some justification of why they are
appropriate for the selected building type.
Accurate URL submitted to Database on
time.
An exhaustive range of both primary and secondary HVAC
systems is presented with explanations of why they are
appropriately considered for this building type as well as
comments on their strengths and limitations. Both charts and
typical numbers are presented for relevant parameters.
Criteria
for System
Selection
A "reasonable" range of criteria is presented
addressing the major types shown under "excellent".
A full range of appropriate criteria is presented with
annotations of why they are appropriate. The criteria will
consider at least: Owner's concerns (e.g. cost, maintenance),
environmental factors (e.g. design temperature & Rh),
inherent characteristics of the systems (e.g.flow rates, noise),
performance measures (e.g. capacity, efficiency).
The criteria are annotated to explain their importance.
Criteria
Matrix for
Building
Type
A working criteria matrix makes "plausible" system
selections in the various conditions specified.
The full range of criteria are used and explained in the
selection process in an understandable and logical manner.
The "logic" of the criteria matrix is clearly documented and
justified
Energy
Analysis
The website shows the results of analyzing your
building with one possible HVAC system in at least
three different geographic locations.
You define on the website how you would make use of this
kind of energy analysis in the the decision process.
You include comments on the difficulties and benefits of
making such an analysis.
Extra
Credit - to
make up
points lost
on other
sections
Suggestions for improvements to the problem for the
next AE class to receive this problem.
A description of the strengths and weakness of this approach
with suggestions for further improvements to be undertaken
with more time and experience available
OR
Use eQuest to analyze your building and comment on its
strengths and weaknesses.
Total
Page 43 of 50Assignments
9/22/2010https://learning.dcollege.net/webct/urw/lc1508742634121.tp1530342792081/selectItemsFo...
Assignment: A6Tm Teamwork EvaluationInstructions: Identify your team members, including the group # Describe and evaluate your contribution. Describe and evaluate your team members contributions.
Attachments:
Due Date: November 12, 2010 5:00 PM
Collaboration Type Individual
Grading Criteria:
File: Building Analysis A7
Updated: 9/21/10
Building Analysis - A7
Purpose
Analysis, presentation and critical evaluation of an existing building. This problem is an opportunity to apply and enhance the knowledge gained in the first half of the term as well as to develop presentation skills.
We expect that by performing this analysis you will accomplish several course objectives:
Present your understanding of each of the major systems Explore the interaction between the systems
Develop an initial understanding of useful ways to compare buildings
Develop skills and knowledge which will allow you to design a building in AE-Design-II Display your knowledge of presentation skills using the Internet
Details
Each team is required to perform a comprehensive building analysis of a building which will be made available during the term or a building of your own choice which has been approved by the instructor. Scrutinize the building in terms of its engineering as well as its architectural qualities. In particular, you are to develop a rigorous system of analysis by which the building can be defined and evaluated in terms of the known building systems. Moreover, you are required to critically evaluate overall building efficiency and, if necessary, suggest modifications/improvements which would enhance the quality of the building.
Include any parameters/criteria that you feel are significant to your analysis and facilitate overall assessment. You should endeavor to include at least the following:
Area, Volume, Weight, Operating Energy, Embodied Energy
Interior Zoning, Circulation Patterns, Access/Egress Facilities
Page 44 of 50Assignments
9/22/2010https://learning.dcollege.net/webct/urw/lc1508742634121.tp1530342792081/selectItemsFo...
Typical Users (Age Range; Sex; etc....)
Construction Cost, Construction Time, Technology, Maintenance Costs.
Site-related aspects , Parking Facilities Critical Environmental Criteria
Materials and relevant characteristics.How are lateral loads transmitted to the ground
HVAC single-line (and others)
Building space allocationsCirculation path for people, materials, vehicles
Teamwork
This project is to be completed in groups that you are to choose yourself. You are welcome to consult with your classmates for suggestions - short of direct copying. The grading is on an absolute scale so mutual assistance can only help each group.
Teams for this Assignment
Submit an evaluation of your team's performance on this project - an opportunity to address any problems. Do so by submitting to the VistaBB assignment an evaluation including:
Your team number (from the team page)
State whether or not there were teamwork problems for this assignment If there are teamwork problems then state the following
A comment on each team member, starting with yourself including whether their performance was "average" or a little or a lot more or less than the average.
Any other comment about the problem that you believe should affect the grad
Deliverables
You are to deliver a web site which addresses the assignment, ready to be viewed by the class and instructor. Each site should meet the following requirements.
The presentation should include Engineering Analysis of the systems presented.
A detailed numeric portion may be presented in "Appendix" form (as a linkable detail document) but should be summarized in the main presentation body and represented in the form of numeric parameters and diagrams/charts of key results.
Juxtapose analysis results and standards developed in class or obtained from reference sources.
Graphic Analysis
2-Dimensional Plans, Sections, Elevations & Diagrams
3-Dimensional representations of systems
Web Page Identification Requirements
Your assignment site should have at least the following information on it:
The specifics defined by the assignment details and grading criteria.
Course NameYour name (yes people have forgotten that)
Assignment title
Page 45 of 50Assignments
9/22/2010https://learning.dcollege.net/webct/urw/lc1508742634121.tp1530342792081/selectItemsFo...
Date
Short In-Class Presentation
Each group will be responsible for a five minute in-class presentation of their work at the end of the project. This presentation will be graded separately. The grading criteria for the presentation are:
Criteria CommentMaximum Points
Attendance Are all the team present? 2
TeamworkDoes the team work together will all members
contributing in a coordinated manner?4
AudibilityAre all the team members audible to throughout the
room?4
Content
Is the substance of the presentation technically
complete, appropriate and accurate. Are the able to
answer audience questions?
6
OverallAn overall evaluation of the quality of the
presentation4
Total 20
Grading Criteria
The following will be be used to assess your success in meeting the project's requirements. Note that each project will be "weighted" as shown on the grading to determine the overall term grade.
General advice - BE SPECIFIC, you'll only get an average grade if you give generalities without specific numbers, details, examples to back up your generality.
Page 46 of 50Assignments
9/22/2010https://learning.dcollege.net/webct/urw/lc1508742634121.tp1530342792081/selectItemsFo...
Criteria Average Work Excellent Work = Average+
Structural
System
The system is documented numerically, graphically and
with written comments. The probable reasons for the
designer's selection of that systems are explained.
Gravity and Lateral load paths to foundation
are shown
The system is fully documented numerically, graphically and with
written comments. The probable reasons for the designer's selection
of that systems are explained, with reference where possible to prior
work of the team members.
Suggestions for improvements to the system are offered if
appropriate.
HVAC System Same as for structural.
HVAC single-line diagram shown
Same as for structural.
Electrical &
Lighting
Systems
Same as for structural.
Electrical single-line diagram shown
Same as for structural.
Architectural
System
Same as for structural.
Building Space Allocations documented
Circulation Paths shown for people, materials,
vehicles.
Same as for structural.
Other
Systems
At least one system in the building is documented in the
same way (though in less detail) as the major systems
above.
At least two other systems in the building are documented in the
same way (though in less detail) as the major systems above.
Web Site
Organization
&
Presentation
The web site is clearly understood by AE
students with easy navigation through the site.
Accurate URL submitted to Database on time.
The web site is readily understood by both AE students and working
professionals with easy navigation through the site and good use of
Web capabilities such as links and graphics.
Interaction
Between
Systems
At least one example is given of the probable effects of
one system selection on other systems. (e.g. the choice of
a particular HVAC system influences the structural
system).
At least two examples are given of the probable effects
system selection on other systems. (e.g. the choice of a particular
HVAC system influences the structural system). Comment is made
on the implications of this interaction on an efficient design
process.
Page 47 of 50Assignments
9/22/2010https://learning.dcollege.net/webct/urw/lc1508742634121.tp1530342792081/selectItemsFo...
File: A7 Teams
Extra Credit -
to make up
points lost on
other
sections
Describe how you will apply what you've learned on this
assignment in your senior design project.
Consider the probable design sequence of the building and how
Engineers and Architects should work together to be both efficient
and produce a superior product.
Total
Updated: 9/16/10
Teams - Assignment #7
FirstItem
Page 48 of 50Assignments
9/22/2010https://learning.dcollege.net/webct/urw/lc1508742634121.tp1530342792081/selectItemsFo...
Team
#Team Members Building (Ass#7)
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
Updated: 9/16/10
Page 49 of 50Assignments
9/22/2010https://learning.dcollege.net/webct/urw/lc1508742634121.tp1530342792081/selectItemsFo...
Assignment: A7Tm Teamwork EvaluationInstructions: Identify your team members, including the group # Describe and evaluate your contribution. Describe and evaluate your team members contributions.
Attachments:
Due Date: December 3, 2010 5:00 PM
Collaboration Type Individual
Grading Criteria:
Print Save to File
Page 50 of 50Assignments
9/22/2010https://learning.dcollege.net/webct/urw/lc1508742634121.tp1530342792081/selectItemsFo...