asbestos-containing material inspection and smokestack and old … acm - pc report-shelby twp...

36
Asbestos-Containing Material Inspection and Paint Chip Testing Smokestack and old Venting Demolition Van Dyke Avenue Shelby Township, Michigan Shelby Township February 19, 2018

Upload: others

Post on 24-May-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Asbestos-Containing Material Inspection and Paint Chip Testing Smokestack and old Venting Demolition Van Dyke Avenue Shelby Township, Michigan

Shelby Township February 19, 2018

Asbestos-Containing Material Inspection and Paint Chip Testing

Smokestack and old Venting Demolition 52700 Van Dyke Avenue

Shelby Township, Michigan

February 19, 2018

Prepared For:

Charter Township of Shelby 52700 Van Dyke Avenue

Shelby Township, Michigan 48316

Prepared By:

ASTI Environmental 10448 Citation Drive, Suite 100

Brighton, Michigan 48116 Telephone No. 810.225.2800

ASTI Project No. 10546

Report Prepared by: Report Reviewed by: Jelaine D. Tinsley, EP David Amir, EP Asbestos Inspector No. A16395 Director Site Redevelopment Services

ASTI Project No.10546 ii Asbestos-Containing Material Inspection and Paint Chips Analysis

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Section Page Executive Summary iii

1.0 Introduction ................................................................................................................ 1

2.0 Limitation and Exceptions .......................................................................................... 2

3.0 Subject Property Description ..................................................................................... 3

4.0 Asbestos-Containing Material Inspection ................................................................... 4

4.1 Previous Asbestos-Containing Material Inspections .............................................. 4 4.2 Asbestos Inspection Methodology .......................................................................... 4 4.3 Sample Collection .................................................................................................. 5 4.4 Laboratory Analytical Results ................................................................................. 6

5.0 Paint Chip Testing ..................................................................................................... 7

6.0 Conclusions and Recommendations .......................................................................... 8

Figures Site Location Map Tables 1 Asbestos Sample Results Appendices Appendix A Resume and Accreditation of Ms. Jelaine Tinsley Appendix B Results of Sample Analysis and Chain of Custody Appendix C Results of Paint Chip Testing Analysis and Chain-of-Custody Appendix D Photo Log

ASTI Project No.10546 iii Asbestos-Containing Material Inspection and Paint Chips Analysis

Executive Summary ASTI Environmental (ASTI) was retained by The Charter Township of Shelby to conduct an asbestos-containing material (ACM) inspection at 52700 Van Dyke Avenue, Shelby Township, Michigan (Subject Property). Only the smokestack and venting line was surveyed. The information and opinions rendered in this report are for reliance by The Charter Township of Shelby ASTI will not distribute or publish this report without the consent of The Charter Township of Shelby except as required by law or court order. The services provided by ASTI in completing this assessment have been provided in a manner consistent with the normal standards of the profession. No other warranties, expressed or implied, are made.

ASTI's scope of work included the following: 1) ACM Inspection - Sampling of suspect homogeneous ACM in general conformance

with the National Emission Standards for Hazardous Air Pollutants (NESHAP) 40 CFR Part 61 Subpart M and ASTM E2356-10 Standard Practice for Comprehensive Building Asbestos Surveys.

2) Paint Chip Testing - Collection and analysis of paint chips for lead and cadmium

content. ACM Inspection During the inspection on February 14, 2018, a total of 12 bulk samples were collected for testing and a total of 15 sample layers were analyzed via polarized light microscopy (PLM) analysis. Review of the analytical results revealed that all samples collected were non-detect for asbestos.

Paint Chip Testing Preliminary paint chip testing was conducted to evaluate lead exposure risks associated with the potential presence of lead in paints on the smokestack and within the maintenance room. Paint chips were collected from the smokestack (PC-1) and from the duct work within the maintenance room (PC-2). Review of the paint chip sample results revealed lead was

ASTI Project No.10546 iv Asbestos-Containing Material Inspection and Paint Chips Analysis

identified at concentrations ranging from <0.003% to 0.074% by weight. Accordingly, the disturbance of the aforementioned painted materials should be conducted in a manner to promote lead-safe work practices in compliance with the Lead in Construction Standard (29 CFR Part 1926.62). Cadmium was below the laboratory detection limit in both samples.

ASTI Project No. 10546 1 Asbestos-Containing Material Inspection and Paint Chips Analysis

1.0 INTRODUCTION ASTI Environmental (ASTI) was retained by The Charter Township of Shelby to conduct an asbestos-containing material inspection of only the smokestack and venting line at 52700 Van Dyke Avenue, Shelby Township, Michigan (Subject Property). Only the smokestack and venting line is being demolished. Refer to the attached Site Location Map for the approximate site location. The information and opinions rendered in this report are exclusively for reliance by The Charter Township of Shelby. ASTI will not distribute or publish this report without the consent of The Charter Township of Shelby except as required by law or court order. The services provided by ASTI in completing this assessment have been provided in a manner consistent with the normal standards of the profession. No other warranties, expressed or implied, are made.

ASTI Project No. 10546 2 Asbestos-Containing Material Inspection and Paint Chips Analysis

2.0 LIMITATION AND EXCEPTIONS ASTI’s scope of work included identification and sampling of suspect homogeneous ACMs in accordance with the U.S. EPA Asbestos Hazardous Emergency Response Act (AHERA) assessment protocol (40 CFR Part 763), which is also referred to by NESHAP and OSHA regulations. The scope of work for this project was limited to the smokestack and associated old venting. Suspect materials not identified within this report may be encountered in inaccessible wall cavities, chases, floor cavities, etc. during demolition activities. These materials must be presumed to be ACM until they can be sampled and analyzed for asbestos content.

ASTI Project No. 10546 3 Asbestos-Containing Material Inspection and Paint Chips Analysis

3.0 SUBJECT PROPERTY DESCRIPTION Only the two-story metal smokestack and venting line was surveyed at the 52700 Van Dyke Avenue Subject Property. The smokestack has a metal exterior with a gunite liner and a metal liner inside the gunite. The venting line was metal with insulation.

ASTI Project No. 10546 4 Asbestos-Containing Material Inspection and Paint Chips Analysis

4.0 ASBESTOS-CONTAINING MATERIAL INSPECTION Jelaine Tinsley (Asbestos Inspector No. A16395) of ASTI’s Site Redevelopment Services group conducted the asbestos inspection on February 14, 2018. A copy of Ms. Tinsley’s resume and asbestos accreditations are provided as Appendix A. 4.1 Previous Asbestos-Containing Material Inspections ASTI is not aware of any previous asbestos inspections completed at the Subject Property. 4.2 Asbestos Inspection Methodology ASTI's scope of work included identification and sampling of suspect ACMs in accordance with the NESHAP protocols. The survey included a visual inspection of the building in order to identify homogeneous areas of suspect surfacing materials, thermal system insulation, and miscellaneous materials, as well as the sampling of suspect friable and non-friable materials. The following definitions from 40 CFR Part 763 are provided below.

Asbestos-containing Materials: Any materials containing more than 1% asbestos.

Surfacing Materials (SM): material that is troweled-on, sprayed-on or otherwise applied to surfaces for acoustical, fireproofing or other purposes.

Thermal System Insulation (TSI): material applied to pipes, fittings, boilers, breeching, tanks, ducts, or other interior components to prevent heat loss or gain, or water condensation or for other purposes.

Miscellaneous Materials (MM): interior building material on structural components, structural members or fixtures such as floors and ceilings and does not include surfacing material or thermal system insulation.

Friable: material that when dry, may be crumbled pulverized or reduced to powder by hand pressure, and includes previously non-friable material after such previously non-friable material becomes damaged to the extent that when dry it may be crumbled, pulverized or reduced to powder by hand pressure.

Non-friable: material which when dry may not be crumbled, pulverized or reduced to powder by hand pressure.

Homogeneous areas (HAs): an area of surfacing material, thermal system insulation, or miscellaneous material that is uniform in color and texture.

ASTI Project No. 10546 5 Asbestos-Containing Material Inspection and Paint Chips Analysis

4.3 Sample Collection Samples were collected by physically removing a small piece of suspect material and placing it in a marked plastic bag. Samples were collected using wet methods, as appropriate. The sample collection tool was cleaned prior to each use to avoid cross contamination of samples. ASTI sampled a variety of materials types, which are listed below.

• Duct insulation • Insulation tape • Caulk • Gunite stack lining

The suspect ACMs appeared to be in generally good condition during ASTI’s inspection. ASTI collected 12 bulk samples from the suspect ACMs identified, with a total of 15 sample layers being analyzed via polarized light microscopy (PLM). The bulk samples were transmitted under chain-of-custody protocol to Sanair Technologies Laboratory in Powhatan, Virginia for asbestos analysis using polarized light microscopy with dispersion staining (PLM/DS) in accordance with the US Environmental Protection Agency’s (US EPA’s) “Interim Method for the Determination of Asbestos in Bulk Building Materials” (EPA 600/R-93/116), December 1993).

ASTI Project No. 10546 6 Asbestos-Containing Material Inspection and Paint Chips Analysis

4.4 Laboratory Analytical Results Building materials identified to contain greater than 1% asbestos are defined as ACMs. Review of the analytical results revealed all samples were non-detect for asbestos. Refer to Table 1 for results.

ASTI Project No. 10546 7 Asbestos-Containing Material Inspection and Paint Chips Analysis

5.0 PAINT CHIP TESTING On February 14, 2018, ASTI personnel collected paint chip samples from various components. ASTI submitted two samples for analysis of lead and cadmium from paint chips collected from the Smokestack (PC-1) and from the duct on the south side of the maintenance room (PC-2). Samples were submitted to Sanair Technologies Laboratory in Powhatan, Virginia for lead and cadmium analysis. Refer to Appendix C for a copy of the lead and cadmium laboratory data. A summary of the locations and results is presented below:

ASTI SAMPLE ID

PAINT COLOR LOCATION/DESCRIPTION

LEAD CONCENTRATION

in % by Weight

CADMIUM COCENTRATION in % by Weight

PC-1 Brown West entrance/Smokestack <0.003 <0.003

PC-2 Gray South side of maintenance room 0.074 <0.003

ASTI Project No. 10546 8 Asbestos-Containing Material Inspection and Paint Chips Analysis

6.0 CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS Based on the results of the inspection completed at the Subject Property, ASTI has made the following conclusion and recommendations. Asbestos Testing Review of the analytical results revealed that all samples collected were non-detect for asbestos. Paint Chip Testing Preliminary paint chip testing was conducted to evaluate potential lead and cadmium exposure risks associated with the potential presence of lead and cadmium in paints in the smokestack and duct work. ASTI submitted two samples for analysis of lead from paint chips collected from the Smokestack (PC-1) and from the duct on the south side of the maintenance room (PC-2). Review of the paint chip sample results revealed lead was identified at concentrations ranging from <0.003% to 0.074%. Accordingly, the disturbance of the aforementioned painted materials should be conducted in a manner to promote lead-safe work practices in compliance with the Lead in Construction Standard (29 CFR Part 1926.62). Cadmium was below the laboratory detection limit in both samples.

ASTI Project No. 10546 Asbestos-Containing Material Inspection Paint Chips Analysis

Figures

Site Location Map

§̈¦94

§̈¦696

Macomb CountyShelby Charter

Township

Site Location MapCreated for: Charter Township of ShelbyCreated by: BJG, February 20, 2018, ASTI Project 10546

52700 Van Dyke AvenueShelby Township, MI 2,000 0 2,0001,000

Feet

Site

Smokestack and Old Vent Testing (Ð%N

ASTI Project No. 10546 Asbestos-Containing Material Inspection Paint Chips Analysis

Tables

1 Asbestos Sample Table

NA = Not AnalyzedNAD = No Asbestos Detected Shaded = Positive for Asbestos

PC = Point CountedNOB = Non-Organically Bound

ASTI Sample ID Material/Description Sample Location Asbestos Results

Insulation -yellow North maintenance room

Cover-white North maintenance room

Insulation -yellow Middle maintenance room

Cover-white Middle maintenance room

Insulation -yellow South maintenance room

Cover-white South maintenance room

2A Tape on duct insulation North maintenance room NAD

2B Tape on duct insulation Middle maintenance room NAD

2C Tape on duct insulation South maintenance room NAD

3A Caulk/ smokestack -tan West maintenance room NAD

3B Caulk/smokestack-tan East maintenance room NAD

3C Caulk/smokestack-tan Hatch NAD4A Interior lining of smokestack-brown Smokestack NAD4B Interior lining of smokestack-brown Smokestack NAD4C Interior lining of smokestack-brown Smokestack NAD

1A NAD

1B NAD

1C NAD

Table 1Asbestos Sample Results

Shelby Township, MichiganASTI Project No.: 10546

52700 Van Dyke Avenue

ASTI Project No. 10546 Asbestos-Containing Material Inspection Paint Chips Analysis

Appendix A

Resume and Accreditation of Ms. Jelaine Tinsley

RESUME A S T I E N V I R O N M E N T A L

JELAINE D. TINSLEY Environmental Professional

PROFILE Certifications/Licenses OSHA 29 CFR 1910.120 HAZWOPER 40-Hour and 8-Hour Refresher (2017) Asbestos Inspector-Michigan (License No. A16395) Asbestos Inspector-Illinois (License No. 100-19756) Asbestos Inspector-Indiana (License No. 19A007625) Asbestos Hazard Evaluation Specialist-Ohio (License No. ES36108) Certified Confined Space Entrant and Attendant American Red Cross First Aide and Adult CPR Certified ASTM Certification in RBCA Applied at Petroleum Release Sites Bituminous Testing Technician Michigan Provisional Teaching Certificate Education Western Michigan University, B.S., Earth Science and Education, 1984 Experience History Environmental Professional, ASTI ENVIRONMENTAL Project Manager, Yeoman Group Project Manager, A&F Environmental Environmental Consultant, DLZ Corporation Environmental Consultant, AKT Peerless Geologist, ATC Associates Geologist, NUS Corporation Teacher, Detroit Public Schools Staff Scientist, CTI and Associates, Inc. Professional Memberships and Service Michigan Association of Environmental Professionals (MAEP) Commercial Real Estate Women (CREW) Professional Background Ms. Tinsley has more than 28 years experience in the environmental industry in a variety of areas including Phase I environmental site assessments (ESAs), Phase II ESAs, baseline environmental assessments (BEAs), subsurface investigations (soil and groundwater testing), soil and groundwater evaluations, asbestos and mold inspections, abatement oversight and specification development. Ms. Tinsley has also coordinated numerous hazardous material and pre-demolition surveys which included evaluations of asbestos, mold, radon and universal wastes for municipal, commercial and industrial facilities. Years Experience:

3 --- ASTI 25 --- other Firms

Page 2

ENVIRONMENTAL DUE DILIGENCE AND SITE INVESTIGATION PROJECTS Environmental Site Assessments Completed numerous site assessments for a variety of projects (vacant land, agricultural, residential, commercial, and industrial) to determine the environmental condition of sites for real estate transactions. Projects involved both surface and subsurface evaluations of sites for a variety of hazardous substances. Responsibilities included the preparation and/or review of ASTM Phase I and Phase II ESAs, Baseline Environmental Assessments (BEAs), and Due Care Plans. Ms. Tinsley also has performed listing site evaluations for a dedicated contactor to the US EPA. Ms. Tinsley is also knowledgeable with All Appropriate Inquiries (AAI) per 40 CFR Part 312 and meets the requirements of an Environmental Professional per AAI. Customer Training Provided training for financial institutions on the types properties that should have environmental evaluations. Vapor Intrusion Evaluation, Jackson, Michigan Conducted vapor intrusion studies at commercial properties to assess potential vapor migration. Scope of work included coordination of vapor intrusion points, vapor sample collection and coordination of chemical testing. CONSTRUCTION TESTING Conducted construction material analysis which included soil proctors, soil sieve analysis, asphalt extractions, concrete stress testing ASBESTOS INSPECTIONS AND ABATEMENT COORDINATION/OVERSIGHT Responsible for asbestos program management including coordination and technical lead for hazardous material surveys, asbestos and mold related testing activities. Asbestos Inspections, City of Detroit Neighborhood Redevelopment Project Inspector of asbestos hazards at over 300 residential and commercial properties.

Collected samples of suspect ACM for laboratory analysis. Provided report to the City of Detroit with findings and compliance requirements. Book-Cadillac Hotel Detroit, Michigan Inspected the hotel property as part of a team. Collected samples, reviewed laboratory analysis and provided client a report of methods and findings. Performed oversight of ACM abatement. Pfizer Complex Kalamazoo, Michigan Responsible for coordination of field activities for the ACM abatement of the complex. Conducted schedule and strategy meetings. CONTACT INFORMATION Ms. Tinsley can be reached at ASTI Environmental (ASTI), 10448 Citation Drive, Suite 100, Brighton, MI 48116, or by calling 810.225.2800 (Toll-Free 800.395.ASTI). Her email address is [email protected]. More information about ASTI is available on the web at www.asti-env.com.

ASTI Project No. 10546 Asbestos-Containing Material Inspection Paint Chips Analysis

Appendix B

Results of Sample Analysis and Chain of Custody Document

SanAir ID#: 18006328

Project #: 10546

Project Name: 52700 Van Dyke

Report Date: 2/16/2018

Analysis Report prepared forASTI Environmental

Page 1 of 6

Dear J. Tinsley,

We at SanAir would like to thank you for the work you recently submitted. The 12 sample(s) were received on Thursday, February 15, 2018 via FedEx. The final report(s) is enclosed for the following sample(s): 1A, 1B, 1C, 2A,2B, 2C, 3A, 3B, 3C, 4A, 4B, 4C.

These results only pertain to this job and should not be used in the interpretation of any other job. This report is only complete in its entirety. Refer to the listing below of the pages included in a complete final report.

Sincerely,

Sandra SobrinoAsbestos & Materials Laboratory ManagerSanAir Technologies Laboratory

Final Report Includes:- Cover Letter- Analysis Pages- Disclaimers and Additional Information

Sample conditions:12 samples in Good condition.

1551 Oakbridge Dr. Suite B, Powhatan, VA 23139 | 804.897.1177 | Fax: 804.897.0070 | www.SanAir.com | [email protected]

10546Project Number:P.O. Number:

Project Name: 52700 Van Dyke2/14/2018Collected Date:2/15/2018 10:35:00 AMReceived Date:

2/16/2018 2:02:33 PM

18006328SanAir ID Number

FINAL REPORT

ASTI EnvironmentalName:Address: 10448 Citation Dr.

Suite 100Brighton, MI 48116810-225-2800Phone:

Page 2 of 6

Analyst: Vaughan, Nathaniel

Asbestos Bulk PLM EPA 600/R-93/116Stereoscopic Components

SanAir ID / Description Appearance % Fibrous % Non Fiberous Asbestos Fibers

1A / 18006328-001Duct Insulation/ North, Insulation

YellowFibrous

Heterogeneous

90% Glass 10% Other None Detected

1A / 18006328-001Duct Insulation/ North, Cover

WhiteFibrous

Heterogeneous

65% Cellulose 35% Other None Detected

1B / 18006328-002Duct Insulation/ Middle, Insulation

YellowFibrous

Heterogeneous

90% Glass 10% Other None Detected

1B / 18006328-002Duct Insulation/ Middle, Cover

WhiteFibrous

Heterogeneous

65% Cellulose 35% Other None Detected

1C / 18006328-003Duct Insulation/ South, Insulation

YellowFibrous

Heterogeneous

90% Glass 10% Other None Detected

1C / 18006328-003Duct Insulation/ South, Cover

WhiteFibrous

Heterogeneous

65% Cellulose 35% Other None Detected

2A / 18006328-004Tape On Duct/ North

WhiteFibrous

Heterogeneous

65% Cellulose 35% Other None Detected

2B / 18006328-005Tape On Duct/ Middle

WhiteFibrous

Heterogeneous

65% Cellulose 35% Other None Detected

2C / 18006328-006Tape On Duct/ South

WhiteFibrous

Heterogeneous

65% Cellulose 35% Other None Detected

3A / 18006328-007Caulk/ Smoke Stack West

TanNon-Fibrous

Heterogeneous

100% Other None Detected

Certification

Analyst:

Analysis Date: 2/16/2018 Date: 2/16/2018

Approved Signatory:

10546Project Number:P.O. Number:

Project Name: 52700 Van Dyke2/14/2018Collected Date:2/15/2018 10:35:00 AMReceived Date:

2/16/2018 2:02:33 PM

18006328SanAir ID Number

FINAL REPORT

ASTI EnvironmentalName:Address: 10448 Citation Dr.

Suite 100Brighton, MI 48116810-225-2800Phone:

Page 3 of 6

Analyst: Vaughan, Nathaniel

Asbestos Bulk PLM EPA 600/R-93/116Stereoscopic Components

SanAir ID / Description Appearance % Fibrous % Non Fiberous Asbestos Fibers

3B / 18006328-008Caulk/ Smoke Stack East

TanNon-Fibrous

Heterogeneous

100% Other None Detected

3C / 18006328-009Caulk/ Smoke Stack Hatch

TanNon-Fibrous

Heterogeneous

100% Other None Detected

4A / 18006328-010Interior Lining Of Smoke Stack

BrownNon-Fibrous

Heterogeneous

100% Other None Detected

4B / 18006328-011Interior Lining Of Smoke Stack

BrownNon-Fibrous

Heterogeneous

100% Other None Detected

4C / 18006328-012Interior Lining Of Smoke Stack

BrownNon-Fibrous

Heterogeneous

100% Other None Detected

Certification

Analyst:

Analysis Date: 2/16/2018 Date: 2/16/2018

Approved Signatory:

1551 Oakbridge Dr. Suite B, Powhatan, VA 23139 | 804.897.1177 | Fax: 804.897.0070 | www.SanAir.com | [email protected]

10546Project Number:P.O. Number:

Project Name: 52700 Van Dyke2/14/2018Collected Date:2/15/2018 10:35:00 AMReceived Date:

2/16/2018 2:02:33 PM

18006328SanAir ID Number

FINAL REPORT

ASTI EnvironmentalName:Address: 10448 Citation Dr.

Suite 100Brighton, MI 48116810-225-2800Phone:

Page 4 of 6

Disclaimer

The final report cannot be reproduced, except in full, without written authorization from SanAir. Fibers smaller than 5 microns cannot be seen with this method due to scope limitations. The accuracy of the results is dependent upon the client’s sampling procedure and information provided to the laboratory by the client. SanAir assumes no responsibility for the sampling procedure and will provide evaluation reports based solely on the sample and information provided by the client. This report may not be used by the client to claim product endorsement by NVLAP or any other agency of the U.S. government. Samples are held for a period of 60 days. For NY state samples, method EPA 600/M4-82-020 is performed. Polarized- light microscopy is not consistently reliable in detecting asbestos in floor covering and similar non-friable organically bound materials. Quantitative transmission electron microscopy is currently the only method that can be used to determine if this material can be considered or treated as non-asbestos containing. Asbestos Certifications NVLAP lab code 200870 City of Philadelphia: ALL-460 PA Department of Environmental Protection Number: 68-05397 California License Number: 2915 Colorado License Number: AL-23143 Connecticut License Number: PH-0105 Massachusetts License Number: AA000222 Maine License Number: LB-0075 New York ELAP lab ID: 11983 Rhode Island License Number: AAL-126 Texas Department of State Health Services License Number: 300440 Commonwealth of Virginia 3333000323 Washington State License Number: C989 West Virginia License Number: LT000566 Vermont License: AL166318

Revision Date: 11/30/2017

Page 5 of 6

Page 6 of 6

ASTI Project No. 10546 Asbestos-Containing Material Inspection Paint Chips Analysis

Appendix C

Results of Paint Chip Sample Analysis and Chain-of-Custody Document

SanAir Technologies LaboratorySanAir Technologies Laboratory

Analysis Reportprepared for

ASTI Environmental

Report Date: 2/16/2018Project Name: 52700 Van DykeProject #: 10546SanAir ID#: 18006292

804.897.1177 www.sanair.com804.897.1177 www.sanair.com

Page 1 of 5

SanAir Technologies Laboratory, Inc.1551 Oakbridge Drive, Suite B, Powhatan, VA 23139804.897.1177 Toll Free: 888.895.1177 Fax: 804.897.0070Web: http://www.sanair.com E-mail: [email protected]

ASTI Environmental10448 Citation Dr.Suite 100Brighton, MI 48116

February 16, 2018

SanAir ID # 18006292Project Name: 52700 Van DykeProject Number: 10546

Dear J. Tinsley,

We at SanAir would like to thank you for the work you recently submitted. The 2 sample(s) werereceived on Thursday, February 15, 2018 via FedEx. The final report(s) is enclosed for the followingsample(s): PC-1, PC-2.

These results only pertain to this job and should not be used in the interpretation of any other job.This report is only complete in its entirety. Refer to the listing below of the pages included in acomplete final report.

Sincerely,

Abisola KasaliMetals Laboratory DirectorSanAir Technologies Laboratory

Final Report Includes:- Cover Letter

- Analysis Pages- Disclaimers and Additional Information

sample conditions:2 sample(s) in Good condition

Page 2 of 5

Page 3 of 5

SanAir Technologies Laboratory, Inc.1551 Oakbridge Dr, Suite B Powhatan, VA 23139804.897.1177 Toll Free 888.895.1177 Fax: 804.897.0070www.sanair.com email:[email protected]

Name: ASTI Environmental Project Number:Address: 10448 Citation Dr. P.O. Number:

Brighton, MI 48116 Project Name:

Collected Date:Received Date:

Report Date:Analyst Abisola O. Kasali

Analyte Requested: Paint: Cadmium (Cd), Lead (Pb)Test Method: EPA M3050B /6010C

Lab Sample # Field Sample # Analyte MRL (%)

Cadmium (Cd)Lead (Pb)

Cadmium (Cd)Lead (Pb)

MRL: Method Reporting Limit base on 0.1ug aliquot

Amended: Revised report format to % by weight per client request. 2/20/18 AOKCertification

Signature: Reviewed:Date: 2/15/2018 Date:

Disclaimer

Lead Exposure LimitsAir

0.0030.074

PC-2 Gray/ Duct

<0.003<0.00318006292-01

Sample Description

PC-1 Brown/ Smoke Stack

Results in % by Weight

18006292-02 <0.003

SanAir ID Number

18006292Amended Final Report

10546

52700 Van Dyke

0.003

2/14/20182/15/2018 10:35 AM2/16/2018 4:55 PM

2/16/2018

REPORT OF ANALYSIS

Final reports cannot be reproduced, except in full, without written authorization from SanAir Technologies Laboratory, Inc. SanAir is not responsible for sample collection or interpretation made by others. This report does not constitute endorsement by AIHA/NVLAP and/or any other U.S. governmental Agencies; and may not be certified by every local, state or federal regulatory agencies. SanAir Technologies Laboratory, Inc only assures the precision and accuracy of the data it generates and assumes no responsibility for errors or biasing that occur during collection prior to SanAir’s receipt of the the sample. SanAir’s Method Detection Limits (MDL) and Reporting Limits (RL) have been derived using wipe materials meeting ASTM-E1792. The MDL and RL may not be elevant or applicable for other forms of wipe materials. All quality control results are acceptable unless otherwise noted. Results are not corrected for blanks

SanAir Technologies Laboratory, Inc participates in the certification for environmental Lead as administered by AIHA-ELLAP (Lab Id 162952) and the State of New York-ELAP (Lab Id 11983, and has met the EPA's NLLAP program standards.

Page 4 of 5

1.5 μg/m3 EPA National Ambient Air Quality Standard (Quality Time – Weight Average)30 μg/m3 OSHA Action Level (8-hour time weighted average)50 μg/m3 OSHA Permissible Exposure Limit (General Industry)

Dust

250ug/ft2 HUD Clearance Level for Window Sills

Grant Funded Clearance (OLHCHH; LBPHC; LHRD Grantees):

100ug/ft2 HUD Clearance Level for Window Sills and Window Troughs40ug/ft2 HUD Clearance Level for Porch Floors

Water

Paint0.5% by weight HUD definition of lead based paint1.0 mg/cm25000 ppm

Soil400 ppm HUD-Play areas and high-contact areas for children

TCLP EPA Limits

50 μg/m3 OSHA Permissible Exposure Limit (Construction)

Non-Grant Funded Projects (Standard Clearance Applies):40ug/ft2 HUD Clearance Level for Floors

400ug/ft2 HUD Clearance Level for Window Troughs

10ug/ft2 HUD Clearance Level for Floors

15 ppb (μg/liter) EPA Maximum Containment Level

5.0 mg/L Silver (Ag) 100 mg/L Barium (Ba) 5.0 mg/L Chromium (Cr) 5.0 mg/L Lead (Pb)5.0 mg/L Arsenic (As) 1.0 mg/L Cadmium (Cd) 0.2 mg/L Mercury (Hg) 1.0 mg/L Selenium (Se)

Page 5 of 5

ASTI Project No. 10546 Asbestos-Containing Material Inspection Paint Chips Analysis

Appendix D

Photo Log

PHOTO LOG 52700 Van Dyke Avenue, Shelby Township, Michigan

ASTI Project No. 10546 February 14, 2018 Photographed By Jelaine Tinsley

Photo 1. A view of the smokestack at the west entrance of the building

Photo 2. A view of brown paint on smokestack

Photo 3. View of curling gray paint on duct work in maintenance room