armed forces tribunal, principal bench, new delhi · ic-57396n lt col anjan kumar sinha v/s uoi...
TRANSCRIPT
1
ARMED FORCES TRIBUNAL, PRINCIPAL BENCH, NEW DELHI LIST OF BUSINESS
Date: 29-04-2019
Timing: 10:30 AM to 01.00 PM & 02.00 PM to 04.30 PM
COURT No. 1 (Ground Floor) THIS BENCH WILL NOT ASSEMBLE TODAY
CORAM:
HON'BLE THE CHAIRPERSON HON'BLE ADMINISTRATIVE MEMBER NOT AVAILABLE
S. No. Case No. Parties Name
For Admission
Advocate for Petitioner / Respondents
101. OA 1863/2018 IC-58128W Lt Col Praveen Kumar V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey & Associates Mr. Anil Gautam
102. OA 5/2019 IC-58877M Col Jay Gaurav Manhas V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. Abhishek R Shukla Mr Harish V Shankar
103. OA 146/2019 with MA 562/2019 & 937/2019
IC-57396N Lt Col Anjan Kumar Sinha V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey & Associates Mr Karan Singh Bhati, Sr CGSC
104. OA 532/2019 with MA 1106/2019
JC-246877K Ex Nb Ris Rohitashv Kumar V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. VS Kadian Ms. Barkha Babbar
105. OA 585/2019 with MA 1159/2019
IC 60827A Lt Col SK Punia V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr SS Pandey & Associates Mr Tarunvir Singh Khehar
2 106. OA 666/2019
with MA 1262/2019
Col Neeraj Dhawan (Retd) (IC 41748 W) V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr KR Verma
None
For Orders 201. OA 1161/2018 IC 43676W Brig Rajinder Singh
V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. SS Pandey Mr. Karan Singh Bhati, Sr. CGSC for R 1-3, None for R-4
202. OA 1906/2018 IC-42805Y Brig Ratan Kumar V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. SS Pandey & Associates Mr. Anil Gautam
203. OA 1942/2018
Lt Col Chetan Dewan (IC-52622W) V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. Ajai Bhalla Mr. Harish V Shankar
204. OA 2066/2018 Col Ravi Sharma (IC-50884N) V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. Ajit Kakkar Mr. Anil Gautam
205. OA 2112/2018 Lt Col Rahul Jain (IC 52184 Y) V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr Rajiv Manglik Mr. Anil Gautam
206. OA 6/2019 Wg Cdr R S Chauhan (24077-B) V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. Ajit Kakkar Mr. Tarunvir Singh Khehar
207. RA 11/2019 in OA 464/2019
Lt Col Shailza Chaudhary (MR-09157F) V/s UOI & Ors
Mr. Ajit Kakkar & Associates Mr. Tarunvir Singh Khehar
208. MA 943/2019 in OA 1564/2018
Col Anil Kak (Retd) (IC 17211 Y) V/s UOI & Ors
Mr SS Pandey Mr. S R Swain
3 209. MA 1206/2019
in MA 885/2018 in OA 239/2015
Ex Hav Kishore Dev Thapa (6040412) V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. M K Gaur Mr Arvind Patel
210. MA 1260/2019 in OA 233/2018
Lt Cdr Sakti Singh Das (Retd) V/s UOI & Ors
Ms Archana Ramesh Mr. Harish V Shankar
211. MA 1261/2019 in OA 2034/2018
IC-53160F Col Ashish Singh V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. Indra Sen Singh/Abhishek Singh Mr. Tarunvir Singh Khehar
4
ARMED FORCES TRIBUNAL, PRINCIPAL BENCH, NEW DELHI LIST OF BUSINESS
Date: 29-04-2019
Timing: 10:30 AM to 01.00 PM & 02.00 PM to 04.30 PM
COURT No. 2 (Ground Floor) THIS BENCH WILL ASSEMBLE AFTER PRONOUNCEMENT OF JUDGEMENT IN ITEM NO 1 & 2 IN COURT NO. 3
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE V. K. SHALI HON'BLE LT. GEN. SANJIV CHACHRA Note : There shall be no passover in first three cases.
S. No. Case No. Parties Name Advocate for Petitioner / Respondents
For Admission 1. OA 1406/2018 Ex Sub Maj Ram Niwas (JC-834349-L)
V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr Virender Singh Kadian
Mr Rajesh Kumar Das
2. OA 656/2019 Gp Capt Arun Marwaha V/s UOI & Ors.
Ms. M Monica, Mr. Rasmi Kumar Panda, Mr SS Dash, Ms. Anita Padhi & Ms. Sunita Padhi
None
For Orders 3. OA 495/2013
(OA 15/2013 (RB, Guwahati)
Col(TS) Mahender Singh Yadav V/s UOI & Ors
in person Mr Anil Gautam
For Hearing 4. OA 1154/2016
with MA 906/2019
Sqn Ldr Pooja Khanna V/s UOI & Ors.
Ms Archana Ramesh Ms Jyotsana Kaushik
5 WITH
5. OA 1155/2016 Sqn Ldr Siddhi Tamrakar V/s UOI & Ors.
Ms. Archana Ramesh
Mr Arvind Patel
WITH
6. OA 1156/2016 Sqn Ldr K Jisha V/s UOI & Ors.
Ms Archana Ramesh Mr Avdhesh Kumar Singh
WITH
7. OA 1158/2016 Sqn Ldr Parul Gaur V/s UOI & Ors.
Ms Archana Ramesh Mr Shyam Narayan
WITH
8. OA 1159/2016 Sqn Ldr Seema Rani Dahiya V/s UOI & Ors.
Ms Archana Ramesh Mr VS Tomar
9. OA (Appeal) 80/2018
Sepoy Krashan Pal (Thru his brother Satyapal Kashyap) V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. Anand Kumar Mr Anil Gautam
10. OA 1001/2018 with MA 488/2019
52393-Z Lt Cdr (IN) Ashish V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey & Associates Mr. Harish V Shankar
11. OA (Appeal) 1277/2018 (OA (Appeal) 167/2014 (RB, Lucknow)
Hav Govind Singh Bisht (4185892-Y) V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. Ankur Chhibber Mr. J S Yadav
12. MA 1259/2019 in OA 98/2016
IC-55774H Lt Col Amit Sharma V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. R K Tripathi Mr. Arvind Patel
6 Regular hearing matters List 1 1. OA (Appeal)
1922/2018 With MA 2125/2018
N. 4576674M Hav Sham Das D Thru his wife Mrs. Raji R Nair V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. Anand Kumar Mr. Karan Singh Bhati, Sr CGSC
2. OA 1388/2018 Ex Brig Amit Kumar Chatterjee (IC-48355H) V/s UOI & Ors.
Ms Archana Ramesh
Mr Karan Singh Bhati, Sr CGSC
3. OA 489/2010 with MA 1399/2018 (TA 36/2012 (RB Kolkata)
Ex. Lt. Col. Prawin Kumar V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S. S. Pandey Mr Anil Gautam
4. TA 9/2015 with TA 35/2015 (RB Chandigarh)
Sqn Ldr Ravi Goel V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr Amjid Maqbool Mr KK Tyagi
5. OA (Appeal) 333/2015
Lt Cdr Mahesh V Birajdar V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. D J Singh Mr Harish V Shankar
6. OA (Appeal) 455/2015 with MA 486/2015 & 487/2015
Ex Sep Uday Singh V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr SS Pandey Mr Anil Gautam
7. OA 682/2017 Ex Cpl Rajiv Kumar Singh V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr SS Pandey & Subodh Kumar Mr Prabodh Kumar
8. MA 1501/2018 in OA (Appeal) 460/2016
No. 14413656X Ex Hav (GD) Lokendra Singh Thru his Father Mr. Deshraj Singh V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey & Associates Mr. Avdhesh Kumar
9. MA 1502/2018 in OA (Appeal) 163/2017
No. 15155622H Ex Gnr Upnil Kumar Thru his wife Ankan Sharma V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey & Associates
Mr Karan Singh Bhati, Sr CGSC
7 10. MA 1503/2018
in OA (Appeal) 569/2015
No. 14435695W Ex Nk (TA) Sunil Kumar Thru his wife Smt. Suman Lata V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey & Associates Mr. Anil Gautam
11. MA 1504/2018 in OA (Appeal) 228/2017
No. 14431609H Ex Hav (GD) Sarabjeet Singh Thru his brother Gagandeep Singh V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey & Associates Mr. Karan Singh Bhati, Sr CGSC
12 MA 1505/2018 in OA (Appeal) 162/2017
No. 15137452F Ex Hav (TA) Tapas Ranjan Rout Thru his father Dhaneswar Raut V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey & Associates
Mr Karan Singh Bhati, Sr CGSC
13 MA 1506/2018 in OA (Appeal) 462/2016
No. 15156180F Ex L/Nk (Opr) Amresh Kumar Tiwari Thru his brother Ashutosh Kumar Tiwari V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey & Associates
Mr JS Rawat
14 MA 1507/2018 in OA (Appeal) 1015/2017
No. 15116695Y Ex Hav (DMT) Naseer Mohammed Thru his wife Smt. Patasi V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey & Associates
Mr. Karan Singh Bhati, Sr CGSC
15 MA 1508/2018 in OA (Appeal) 867/2017
No. 15180736Y Ex Gnr (GD) Bikramjit Singh Thru his father Sh. Shukhwinder Singh V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey & Associates Mr. Karan Singh Bhati, Sr CGSC
16 OA (Appeal) 1263/2018 with MA 1205/2018
No 15151563K Ex L/Nk Naryan Swami V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. SS Pandey Mr SR Swain
Regular hearing matters List 2 1. OA 509/2014
Ex Carporal D.S. Khan V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr CK Sharma Mr JS Rawat
WITH
2. OA 558/2014
Ex Carporal Manish Sinha V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr CK Sharma
Mr SD Windlesh
8 3. OA 277/2015
with MA 724/2017
Sub M/Tech Opto Gurjeet Singh V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey Mr Ashok Chaitanya
4. OA 283/2015 with MA 1061/2015
Hav Jaswant Singh V/s UOI & Ors.
Ms Archana Ramesh Dr Vijendra Singh Mahndiyan
5. OA 308/2015
Brig A Umar Farook V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr IS Singh & Abhishek Singh Mr Karan Singh Bhati, Sr CGSC with Mr Arvind Patel
9
ARMED FORCES TRIBUNAL, PRINCIPAL BENCH, NEW DELHI LIST OF BUSINESS
Date: 29-04-2019
Timing: 10:30 AM to 01.00 PM & 02.00 PM to 04.30 PM
COURT No. 3 (First Floor) CORAM: HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE SUNITA GUPTA HON'BLE LT. GEN. SANJIV CHACHRA
S. No. Case No. Parties Name Advocate for Petitioner / Respondents
For Judgement 1. OA 206/2016 Ex Petty Officer Rajesh Prasad
V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. V S Kadian Mr VS Tomar
2. OA 1701/2016 Lt Col Vivek Singh V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. H S Tiwari Niyati Arun ,Somya & S S Pandey Mr VS Tomar
THIS BENCH WILL ASSEMBLE AFTER PRONOUNCEMENT OF JUDGEMENT IN ITEM NO 1 & 2 MENTIONED ABOVE
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE SUNITA GUPTA HON'BLE LT. GEN. PHILIP CAMPOSE
S. No. Case No. Parties Name Advocate for Petitioner / Respondents
For Admission 1. OA 1833/2018 Ex HFL Dharam Vir Tyagi (No
644842R) V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr Praveen Kumar Mr. Arvind Patel
10 2. OA 14/2019 IC-45180 Col Veerendra Mohan
(Retd.) V/s UOI & Ors.
Ms. Spitti A Sarkar Mr. Tarunvir Singh Khehar
3. OA 329/2019 Ex Hony Nb Sub Bhawani Ram (No 3167122N) V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. BS Chaudhary & Mr. Jasbir Chaudhary Mr. S D Windlesh
4. OA 389/2019 with MA 942/2019
No. 15474062-P Ex Dfr Devendra Singh V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. V S Kadian Mr. Shyam Narayan
5. OA 616/2019 Ex Sgt Manoj Kumar Singh (738024-T) V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. Omprakash Kr. Srivastava & Vinay Makhija
None
6. OA 617/2019 No. 4478282H Hav (PA) Kulbir Singh V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. Indra Sen Singh/Abhishek Singh
None
For Orders 7. MA 1033/2019
in OA 147/2017
SL-5062K Lt Col Chandan Singh (Retd.) V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. Virender Singh Kadian Mr. K K Tyagi
For Hearing 8. OA 1182/2018
with MA 707/2019
JC-761059H Sub Mahendra Pal Shrivastava (Retd) V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. SS Pandey Mr. Avdesh Kumar Singh
9. OA 14/2017 Ex Rect Kuldip Kumar V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. V S Kadian Mr Arvind Patel
11 10. OA 141/2017
with MA 131/2017
Ex Hav Subhash Babu V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. V S Kadian Ms Barkha Babbar
11. OA 189/2017 with MA 148/2017
Ex Rect Vishnu Pal Singh V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. V S Kadian Mr V Pattabhi Ram
12. OA 660/2017 with MA 560/2017
Col I S Shergil V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr Ajai Bhalla Mr VS Tomar
13. OA 1966/2017 IC 40544X Col Salil Kumar (Retd) V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr.Aditya Singh Puar Mr J S Yadav
14. OA 694/2018 with MA 390/2019
Gp Capt (TS) Anoop Sood (Retd) (17207-R) V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. Ajit Kakkar Mr Shyam Narayan
15. OA 927/2018 with MA 798/2018
Ex Sep Puran (No 3138125) V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr Virender Singh Kadian Mr. J S Yadav
16. OA 1280/2018 with MA 505/2019
Ms. Amrita Rana Gaha V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. I S Singh/Abhishek Singh Ms. Barkha Babbar
17. OA 357/2016 Shri Bhawani Dutt Notyal V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. Abhay Kumar Mr J S Rawat
18. OA 1126/2016 Ex Nk Ram Kishan V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. M K Gaur Mr SD Windlesh
12 WITH 19. OA 1086/2016 Ex Hav Krishana Kumar Gaurh
V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. Mohan Kumar, Rashmi Singh, Rohit Pratap & Associates Mr Avdhesh Kumar Singh
WITH 20. OA 1087/2016 Ex Nk Kul Bahadur Gurung
V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. Mohan Kumar ,Rashmi Singh ,Rohit Pratap & Assocaites Mr KK Tyagi
WITH 21. OA 1088/2016 Ex Nk Balramji Mishra
V/s UOI & Ors.
Mohan Kumar, Rashmi Singh, Rohit Pratap & Associates Mr Prabodh Kumar
22. OA 1367/2016 Ex Hav Padam Singh Rajput V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. M K Gaur Mr Arvind Patel
23. OA 29/2017 with MA 12/2017
Ex HFO Om Prakash Sheoran V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. Praveen Kumar Mr Shyam Narayan
24. OA 816/2017 Col Prabh Preet Singh Mallhi (Retd.) V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. Ajit Kakkar Ms Barkha Babbar
25. OA 1960/2017 SL-05091Y Lt Col Sukhdev Singh (Retd) V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. V S Kadian Mr Ashok Chaitanya
26. OA 1625/2018 Ex. Sub (AEC) Umed Singh (JC-803904M) V/s UOI & Ors.
Ms. Sangeeta Tomar Mr. S P Sharma
13 Part Heard 27. TA 396/2009
Writ Petition No. 17758/2004
Ex Hav Hans Raj V/s UOI & Ors
Mr H S Tiwari Mr JS Yadav
WITH 28. TA 130/2010 (Writ
Petition (Civil) No. 11588/2004)
Smt. Sunita Devi V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr H S Tiwari Mr JS Yadav
WITH 29. TA 4/2015 (WP(C)
12329/2005) Maj. Sanjay Ahlawat V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr H S Tiwari Mr VS Tomar
WITH 30. TA 533/2010
(WP(C) 18279/2005)
Ex. Nb. Sub. Asim Kumar Mitra V/s UOI & Ors.
In person Mr Ashok Chaitanya
Note : The Cause List is also available at www.aftdelhi.nic.in ,www.aftpbba.in