arizona department of public safety · 2010-08-28 · lorraine heath, #6353 criminalist central...
TRANSCRIPT
\
AGENCY
FILENO.
OFFICER
DATE
NAME(S)
ARIZONA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY
SCIENTIFIC EXAMINATION REPORT
Phoenix Police Department
200551799055
DURAN #6287
November 29,2006
_ .. -_. - ---- --- - -------- .__ .._-_._-_._---
rr
ITEMS:
#1.
#1.1.
#1.01. .
#1.04AI.
#1.04B.
#7.0l.
#8.1.
#8.2.
#83.#OOOS.OIAOl.
#O006.01AOl.
#lA.
#2A.
#3 A.
#4A.
Two buccal swabs from Mark Goudeau
Four buccal swabs from Danny Walker
PHOENIX PD DR#200SS18S3161ATwo swabs from cell phone
Evaluated, not analyzed
Evaluated, not analyzed
Two swabs from cell phone
Two swabs from purse strap
Two swabs from outside of purse
Two swabs from purse zipper
DNA extract from driver door handle
DNA extract from vehicle
PHOENIX PD DR#200552 107772Two circumoral swabs
Two vulva swabs
Two external labia majora swabs
Four vaginal swabs
CUSTODY OF EVIDENCE
RECEIVED D.P.S. Property
DISPOSmON D.P.S. Property
DR NO. 2006732863
Picelor!'
LORRAINE HEATH, #6353CriminalistCentral Regional Crime Laboratory(602) 223-2857
Acc1'edited the ASCLD Laborato Accreditation BoardAny notes, photographs. charts. or graphs ge71eratildcluring the e;comil'Ultionwe reIQined in the /01101'010"..
- - ---=~- ~'. ::: .. ~:-- ~
~------------------~~;~
AGENCY
FILENO.
OFFICER
DATE
NAME{S)
ARlZONA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY
SCIENTIFIC EXAMINATION REPORT
Phoenix Police Department
200551799055
DURANli6287
November 29, 2006
-----_. - - -r-rr-rri--x-s-t-r-r-r-r-r-#1.05A.
#1.05B.
#1.10A.
#1H.
-~.r
#IB.
#2B.
#3B.
#lC_
#2C.
#3C.B.
#3C.C.
#4C.
#1.08B.
#IF.
#10.
#4.01A.
Two left breast swabs
Two right breast swabs
Received, not analyzed
Two buccal swabs from Leon Lemonias
DR NO. 2006732863Pa:elorJ6
PHOENIX PD DRtl200660826857Two swabs from shopping cart
Eighteen swabs from interior passenger side of vehicle
One buccal swab from Jon Felts
PHOENIX PD DRtl200SS17990S5Two extemallabia majora swabs
Two circumoral swabs
Two right breast swabs
Two left breast swabs
Two buccal swabs from Jason Lowell
Two vulva swabs
Two buccal swabs from Mitchell Toten
Two buccal swabs from Jonathan Davis
PHOENIX PD DR#200SS1499628Two portions of shirt cutting
RECEIVED
CUSTODY OF EVIDENCE
DISPOSITION
D.P .S. Property
D.P.S. Property
LORRAINE HEATH, #6353CriminalistCentral Regional Crime Laboratory(602) 223-2857
Accredited b the ASCW Laborato Accreditation BoardAny nOles. pholograplu. chQ1'U, or grQPIu genera/ed during tire examination are retained in the iaool'Cl/ory.
ARIZONA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY
SCIENTIFIC EXAMINATION REPORT
AGENCY
FILENO.
OFFICER
DATE
NAME(S)
Phoenix Police Department
200551799055DURAN #6287
November 29, 2006
DR NO. 2006732863
-- .---- . - .... ?I4:0ZA;---'--"P=o=rtion ofSliinclittiiig _. q •• _u .---.#ID. White short sleeve shirt
#2D. One buccal comb from Leon Dews
#3D. Two buccal swabs from Robert Dixon
#4D. Largecutting from shirt
#5D. Small cutting from shirt
#l.04A. Two right breast swabs
#I.D8A. Two externallabia majora swabs
#l.08AI. Two external labia majora swabs
# IE. One buccal swab from Jesus Flores
#2F.1.
#2F.2.
#2F.3.
#2F.4.
#2F.5.
#2F.6.
#2F.7.
#2F.8.
PHOENIX PD DR#20055236 I078, #200660332085, #200660489775,#200660632246 and #200661226441DNA extract from unexpended casing
Two swabs from expended casing
Two swabs from expended casing
Two swabs from expended casing and vial
Two swabs from expended casing
DNA extract from expended casing and extraction blank
Left fingernail clippings from Tina Washington
DNA extract from steering wheel cover
CUSTODY OF EVIDENCE
RECEIVED D.P.S. Property
DISPOSmON D.P.S. Property
LORRAINE HEATH, 116353CriminalistCentral Regional Crime Laboratory(602) 223-2857
Accredited b the ASCLD Laborato Accreditation BoardAny notes. photographs. charu, or grvplu gUieruteJ during the examination are retained in the laboratory.
_I~(08'0 "If~----------------------------------------~~)
r:AGENCY
FILENO.
OFFICER
DATE
NAME(S)
-------#2~
#2F.lO.
#2F.11.
#2F.l2.
#2F.l3.
#2F.l4.
, #2F.l5.
#2F.l6.
#2F.l7.~.r #2F.l8.
#2F.l9.
#2F.20.
#2F.21.
#2F.22.
#2F.23.
#2F.24.
#2F.25.
#2F.26.
#2F.27.
ARIZONA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY
SCIENTIFIC EXAMINATION REPORT
RecelveQ, notlinilyzed- ---- --.- - -- .._-._ _--_ .. -_. - ---- -- --- ---. - .---
Received, not analyzed
DNA extract from gear shift handle and extraction blank
Right nail scrapings from Chao Chou
DNA extract from belt buckle
Fingernail scrapings from Liliana Cabrera-Sanchez
Fingernail scrapings from Liliana Cabrera-Sanchez
DNA extract from fingernail scrapiags of'Lillana Cabrera-Sanchez
DNA extract from fingernail scrapings of Liliana Cabrera-Sanchez
DNA extract from right nail clippings of Kristen Gibbons and extraction blankDNA extract from left nail clippings of Kristen Gibbons
Three DNA extracts from external genital swabs of Kristen Gibbons and extractionblanksTwo swabs from front right thigh of Carmen Miranda
Two swabs from left inner thigh of Carmen Miranda
Two swabs from right hip area of Carmen Miranda
Two swabs from right outer thigh of Carmen Miranda
Two swabs from right inner thigh of Cannen Miranda
DNA extract from button and zipper of Carmen Miranda
DNA extract from right nail scrapings of Carmen Miranda
AIf)I notes, photographs. charlS. or graphs generated during the examination are retained in the laboratory.
Phoenix Police Department
200551799055
DURAN #6287
November 29. 2006
DR NO. 2006732863
CUSTODY OF EVIDENCE
RECEIVED D.P.S. Property
DISPOSITION D.P.S. Property
LORRAINE REA TH. #6353CriminalistCentral Regional Crime Laboratory(602) 223~2857
Accredited b the ASCLD Laborato Accreditation Board
AGENCY
FILENO.
OFFICER
DATE
NAME(S)
ARIZONA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY
SCIENTIFIC EXAMINATION REPORT
-" -- -1I2F.28.
#2F.29.
#2F.30.
#2F.31.
#2F.32.#2F.33.
#2F.34.
#2F.3S.
#2F.36.
#2F,37.
#2F.38.#2F.39.
#2F.40.
#2F.4L
#2F.42.
#2F.43.
#2F.44.
#2F.4S.
#2F.46.#2F,47.
Phoeni~ Police Department
200551799055
DURAN ##6287
"November29,2006
DR NO. 2006732863Pie" 5 er ts
DNiUxtraCfftoffileIrnaiIScrajjmgs-ofCiiin1"en Miranda- - ---" -"-
Two swabs from ignition switch
Two swabs from gear shift
Two swabs from steering wheel
Two swabs from turning lever
Bloodstain from Chao Chou
Two buccal swabs from Jaime Coronado
Two buccal swabs from Abel Coronado
Two buccal swabs from Jose Reyes
Two buccal swabs from Jorge-Alberta Armeta Varela
Two buccal swabs from Abel Coronado Castillo
Two DNA extracts from button and zipper of Tina Washington
Two swabs from front driver exterior door handle
Two swabs from front driver interior door arm rest
Two swabs from front driver interior door panel
Two swabs from rear driver exterior door handle
Two swabs from rear driver interior door ann rest
Two swabs from rear driver interior door panel
Cutting from jeans near right inside pocket
Cutting from left inside pocket of jeans
..CUSTODY OF EVIDENCE
RECEIVED D.P.S. Property
DISPOSITION D.P.S. Property
LORRAINE HEATH. #6353CriminalistCentral Regional Come Laboratory(602) 223-2851
Accredited b the ASCW Labora Accreditation BoardAn}' notes, phologrgphs, charts. or graphs generaud during the e:uzmlnatlo/'l are rotaineJ in the /abof'QIQT)'.
. ~. "''':...~'.
ARIZONA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY
SCIENTIFIC EXAMINATION REPORT
AGENCY
FILENO.
OFFICER
DATE
NAME(S)
Phoenix PoliceDepartment200S 51799055DURAN~287
November 29. 2006
DR NO. 2006732863
----tl2F.48.------ - CUtting fronuigbtleg of jeans ncarcrotcll- -0 ----- -- ------ -- ---- 0-
#2F.49. Cutting from right leg of jeans near knee#2F.50. Cutting from back inside right pocket of jeans
#2F.51. Cutting from right back leg of jeans#3F. Black and brown steering wheel cover#4F. Received. not analyzed
#5F. Right fingernail clippings from Tina Washington
Received, not analyzed - Eight white foil-lined envelopes and 15 coin envelopes
r EXAMINATION REQUESTED:
DNA-YSTR
RESULTS and CONCLUSIONS:
Male human DNA was isolated from Items #1 and #1.1. The DNA was characterized using thepolymerase chain reaction (PCR) at the V-chromosome short tandem repeat (STR) loci DYS456.DYS389I. DYS390, DYS389II. DYS458, DYS19, DYS38S, DYS393, DYS391, DYS439, DYS635,DYS392. Y QATA H4, DYS437, DYS438 and DYS448.
PHOENIX PD DR#2005S1499628
No semen was detected on Items #10 and #4D.
CUSTODY OF EVIDENCE LORRAINE HEATH, #6353CriminalistCentral Regional Crime Laboratory(602) 223-2857
RECEIVED
DISPOSITION
D.P.S. Property
D.P.S. Property
Accredited b the ASCW Laboratory Accreditation BoardAny notes, photographs. charts. or graphs generated Juring the examination fire retained in the /aboralt1ry.
• ~.::-''"I:-.
~f)D y1v1.~
r:
"\ ...•
ARIZONA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY
SCIENTIFIC EXAMINATION REPORT
AGENCYFILENO.OFFICER
DATENAME(S)
Phoenix Police Department DR NO. 2006732863
20055 1799055
DURAN #6287
November 29, 2006
-_ ..__ . -,--.- --.- ---_. __ ._-----_._------------- -- ------- ..
Male human DNA was isolated from Items #4.0IA, #4.02A, #10. #2D. #3D, #4D, #5D. #IE, #l.04A,# I.DSA and # I.OSA 1. The DNA was characterized using the polymerase chain reaction (peR) at theY-chromosome short tandem repeat (STR) loci DYS456, DYS389l, DYS390, DYS389Il, DYS4S8,DYS19, DYS38S, DYS393, DYS391, DYS439, DYS63S, DYS392, Y GATAH4,DYS437. DYS438and DYS448.
The male DNA profile obtained from Items #l.04A (right breast), #l.08A (extemallabia) and #1.08Al(external labia) matches the DNA profile from Item #1 (Mark Goudeau) at all 16 loci. Therefore,neither Mark Goudeau nor any of his paternally related male relatives can be excluded as thecontributor of this DNA. This profile has not been observed in the Applied Biosystems Yfilerhaplotype database and is not expected to occur more frequently than 1 in 431 Caucasian males, I in333 African-American males and 1 in 202 Hispanic males.
The male DNA profiles obtained from Items #10.1 (inside shirt) and #lD.2 (outside shirt) are mixturesof at least three individuals. Item #1 (Mark Goudeau) cannot be excluded as a contributor to thesemixtures.
Inconclusive or no results were obtained from Items #4.0 IA (portions of shirt cutting), #4.02A (portionof shirt cutting), #4D (large shirt cutting) and #5D (small shirt cutting).
Portions of Items #4.01A, #4.02A. #lD, #4D, #50, #l.04A, #l.OSA and #l.08AI have been retained inlaboratory frozen storage.
PHOENIX PD DR#200S51799055
CUSTODY OF EVIDENCE LORRAINE HEATH,1I6353CriminalistCentral Regional Crime Laboratory(602) 223~2857
RECEIVED
DISPOSITION
D.P.S. Property
D.P.S. Property
Accredited b the ASCLD Laborato Accreditation BoardAny noles. photographs. charts. or graphs generated during the examination cue retained in 'he laborQ/ory.
- ,-..,-- .. :"
ARIZONA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY
SCIENTIFIC EXAMINATION REPORT
AGENCY
FILENO.
OFFICER
DATE
NAME(S)
PhoenixPoliceDepartment
200551799055DURAN #6287November 29, 2006
DR NO. 2006732863
Human DNA was isolated from Items #1 and #3C.C. The DNA was characterized using thepolymerase chain reaction (PCR) at amelogenin and the short tandem repeat (STR) loci D3S 1358,vWA, FGA, D8S1179, D21S11, DI8S51, D5S818, D13S317, 07S820, Dl6S539. THOI, TPOX andCSFlPO.
The DNA profile from Item #}C.C Oeft breast) is a mixture of at least three individuals and isconsistent with the combined profiles ofItems #2.01A [Alejandra Lara)", #1.01 (Lorena Lara)" and #1(Mark Goudeau).
Y-STR RESULTSMale human DNA was isolated from Items #IC. #2C, #3C.B, #3C.C, MC, #IF. #10 and #1.08B. TheDNA was characterized using the polymerase chain reaction (PCR) at the Y-chromosome short tandemrepeat (STR) loci DYS4S6, DYS389I, OYS390, OYS389II, DYS458, DYSI9, DYS385, DYS393,DYS39l, DYS439, DYS635, DYS392, Y GATA H4, DYS437, DYS438 and DYS448.
The male DNA profile obtained from Item #3C.C (left breast) matches the DNA profile from Item.# 1(Mark Goudeau) at all 16 loci. Therefore, neither Mark Goudeau nor any of his paternally related malerelatives can be excluded as the contributor of this DNA. This profile has not been observed in theApplied Biosystems Yfiler haplotype database. It is 470 trillion times more likely to observe thecombined STR and Y-STR profiles if Items #2.01A (Alejandra Lara)", #1.01 (Lorena Lara)" and #1(Mark Goudeau) are the contributors than if Items #2.01A (Alejandra)", #1.01 (Lorena)" and a randomunrelated Caucasian male are the contributors, 360 trillion times more likely than if Items #2.0IA(Alejandra)", 1#1.01 (Lorene)" and a random unrelated African-American male are the contributors and340 trillion times more likely than ifIterns #2.0IA (Aleiandra)", #1.01 (Lorena)" and a random
CUSTODY OF EVIDENCE LORRAINE HEATH, #6353CriminalistCentral Regional Crime Laboratory(602) 223-2857
RECEIVED
DISPOSITION
D.P.S. Property
D.P.S. Property
Accredited b th« ASCLD Laborato Accreditation BoardAny notes, phOIOgraplu. clJaru. or graphs gmeTaled during Ihe aami1lQ(ioll art retained in the /aboralory.
- !""'"'",:-,_--.
)41'[;~Dr-------------------------------------------------------~--~ARIZONA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY
SCIENTIFIC EXAMINATION REPORT
AGENCY
FILENO.
OFFICER
DATE
NAME(S)
Phoenix Police Department
200551799055
DURAN #6287
November 29, 2006
DR NO. 2006732863
l'IIee90U6
unrelated HiSpanIC-malearetlle-coiimburors:-(tlritlion-= ·I,OOO,OOO;(lOO,OO{})-----. - . - ---- .
The male DNA profile obtained from Items #IC (extemal labia) and #I.OBB (vulva) matches the DNAprofile from Item #1 (Mark Goudeau) at all 16 loci. Therefore, neither Mark Goudeau nor any of hispaternally related male relatives can be excluded as the contributor of this DNA. This profile has notbeen observed in the Applied Biosystems Yfiler haplotype database and is not expected to occur morefrequently than I in 431 Caucasian males. 1 in 333 African-American males and 1 in 202 Hispanicmales.
Thc partial male DNA profile obtained from Item #3C.B (right breast) matches the DNA profile fromItem #1 (Mark Goudeau) at 9 Y-STRloci. Therefore, neither Mark Goudeau nor any of his paternallyrelated male relatives can be excluded as the contributor of this DNA. Inconclusive or no results wereobtained at DYS389II, DYS385. DYS439, DYS635. DYS392, Y GATA H4 and DYS44B.
Inconclusive or no results were obtained from Item #2C (circumoral swabs).
Portions ofltems #IC, #2C, #3C.B. #3C.C and #1.08B have been retained in laboratory frozen storage.
• From Phoenix PD report DR#200SS17990S5-0006 dated 1-3-06
PHOENIX PD DRH200S518S3161A
Male human DNA was isolated from Items #1.01, #B.I, #8.2, #8.3 and #0006.0IAOl. TbeDNA wascharacterized using the polymerase chain reaction (PCR) at the Y-chromosome short tandem repeat(STR) loci DYS456, DYS389I. DYS390. DYS389II, DYS458, DYS 19, DYS38S, DYS393, DYS391,
CUSTODY OF EVIDENCE LORRAINE HEATH. #6353CriminalistCentral Regional Crime Laboratory(602) 223-2857
RECEIVED
DlSPOSmON
D.P.S. Property
D.P.S. Property
Accredited by the ASCLD Laborato Accrediuuion BoardAny notes, photogrophs. cluulS. or graphs generated during the examination are retained in lire laboratory.
~ -~--~~,,:-. -.
/~ ~O~ff~'Or~
~\ .-.1
ARIZONA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY
SCIENTIFIC EXAMINATION REPORT
AGENCYFILENO.
OFFICER
DATENAME(S)
Phoenix Police Department
200551799055
DURAN #6287
November 29,2006
DR NO. 2006732963
Pale 10 ar 16
---DYS439, DYS635, DYS392,-Y GATA 1I4, I>YS437;DYSII38 ana DYS-4'Jz:---- -- .--_.
No male DNA was detected on Items #7.01 (cell phone) and #0005.01AOI (extract from driver doorhandle).
The male DNA profiles obtained from Items #8.2 (outside of purse) and #8.3 (purse zipper) aremixtures of at least three individuals. Item # 1 (Mark Goudeau) cannot be excluded as a contributor tothese mixtures.
The partial male DNA profile obtained from Item #8.1 (purse strap) is a mixture of at least twoindividuals. The inclusion ofItem #1 (Mark Goudeau) as a contributor to the mixture is inconclusive.
The partial male DNA profile obtained from Item #1.01 (cell phone) does not match any knownstandards in this case examined prior to this report and is from an unknown male individual.
Inconclusive or no results were obtained from Item #O006.0IAOI (extract from vehicle).
Portions ofltems #1.01, #7.01, #8.1, #8.2, #8.3, #OOOS.OIAOI and #0006.0IAOI have been retained inlaboratory frozen storage.
PHOENIX PD DR#200S52 107772
Male human DNA was isolated from Items #IA, #2A, #4A, #IH, #l.05A and #l.05B. The DNA wascharacterized using the polymerase chain reaction (PCR) at the Y-chromosome short tandem repeat(STR) loci DYS456, DYS389I, DYS390, DYS389II, DYS458, DYS19, DYS385, DYS393, DYS39l,
CUSTODY OF EVIDENCE LORRAINE HEATH, #6353CriminalistCentral Regional Crime Laboratory(602) 223-2857
RECEIVED
DISPOSITION
D.P.S. Property
D.P.S. Property
Accredited b the ASCLD Laborato Accreditation BoardAny notes,pholographs. charu. or graphs general~ during Ihe examination are reUJln~ in the laboratory .
. ". -..•.......~...
- ----.- ----DYS439;1)YS6JS;-DYS392;-y-OJ\'f.kH4,DYS437;-I'>YS438 and DYS44B-;----· -- - ..
~r,
ARIZONA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY
SCIENTIFIC EXAMINATION REPORT
AGENCY
FILENO.
OFFICER
DATE
NAME(S)
Phoenix Police Department DR NO. 2006732863
200551799055DURAN#6287
November 29, 2006
Pml:0U orl6
The male DNA profiles obtained from Items #l.OSA (left breast) and #l.OSB (right breast) arc mixturesof at least two individuals. The major component of both mixtures matches the DNA profile from Item# 1 (Mark Goudeau) at all 16 loci. Therefore. neither Mark Goudeau nor any of his paternally relatedmale relatives can be excluded as the contributor of this DNA. This profile has not been observed inthe Applied Biosystems Yfiler haplotype database and is not expected to occur more frequently than 1in 431 Caucasian males, 1 in 333 African-American males and 1 in 202 Hispanic males, Item #lH(Leon Lemonias) cannot be excluded as a minor contributor to both of these mixtures.
The male DNA profiles obtained from Items #2A (external genitals) and #4A (vaginal swabs) aremixtures consistent with the combined DNA profiles ofItem #1 (Mark Goudeau) and #IH (Lemonias).
The male DNA profile obtained from Item #IA (circumoral swabs) is a mixture of at Jeast threeindividuals. Item #1 (Mark Goudeau) and #lH (Lemonias) cannot be excluded as contributors to thismixture.
Portions of Items #IA. #2A, #4A, 111.05A and #1.058 have been retained in laboratory frozen storage.
PHOENIX PD DR#200660826857
Male human DNA was isolated from Items #lB. #2B and #38. The DNA was characterized using thepolymerase chain reaction (peR) at the Y-chromosome short tandem repeat (STR) loci DYS456.DYS389I. DYS390. DYS389I1. DYS458. DYS 19.DYS38S. DYS393. DYS391. DYS439. DYS635.DYS392. Y GATA H4. DYS437. DYS438 and DYS448.
CUSTODY OF EVIDENCE LORRAINE HEATH. #6353CriminalistCentral Regional Crime Laboratory(602) 223-2857
RECEIVED
DISPOSITION
D.P.S. Property
D.P.S. Property
Accredited b the ASCLD Laborato Accreditation BoardAny nC1II'.S, photographs, ~u, ar graplu gllnilrTlllld ,",rinK the:GamUratioll are retained in the laboratory.
0110
"r
r- ..'
SCIENTIFIC EXAMINATION REPORT
ARIZONA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY
AGENCY
FILENO.
OFFICER
DATE
NAME(S)
Phoenix Police Department
2005S1799055
DURAN #6287
Novcmbcr29,2006
DR NO. 2G06732863
Palle 110f16
- ------ ._--- -----. ---_. --- ..
The male DNA profile obtained from Item # IB (shopping cart) is a mixture of at least three individuals.Item #1 (Mark Goudeau) cannot be excluded as a contributor to this mixture.
The partial male DNA profile obtained from Item #2B.l (seat levers) matches the DNA profile fromItem #3B (Jon Felts) at 14 Y -STR loci. Inconclusive results were obtained at DYS389II and DYS385.
The partial male DNA profile obtained from Item #2B.2 (bead rest) matches the DNA profile from Item#3B (Felts) at 12 Y-STR loci. Inconclusive results were obtained at DYS389I, DYS390, DYS3891l andDYS439.
The male DNA profile obtained from Item #2B.3 (various vehicle swabs) is a mixture. The majorcomponent matches the DNA profile from Item #3B (Felts) at all 16 loci. The minor component isinconclusive.
Portions ofItems #IB and #2B have been retained in laboratory frozen storage.
PHOENIX PD DR#20055236 1078
Preliminary tests were positive for blood on Item #2F.7. No blood was detected on Item #5F.
Male human DNA was isolated from Items #2F.7, #2F.39 and #SF. The DNA was characterized usingthe polymerase chain reaction (PCR) at the Y-chromosome short tandem repeat (STR) loci DYS456,DYS389I. DYS390. DYS389II, DYS4S8, DYS19, DYS385, DYS393, DYS391, DYS439, DYS635.DYS392. Y GATAH4. DYS437. DYS438 and DYS448.
CUSTODY OF EVIDENCE LORRAINE HEATH. #6353CriminalistCentral Regional Crime Laboratory(602) 223·2857
RECEIVED
DISPOSITION
D.P.S. Property
D.P.S. Property
Accredited b the ASCLD Laborato Accreditation BoardAny notes. photographs. charts. or grtlPhs generated during the examination are retained in the laboratory.
,....~ __~\A1-1/(j -A.J) r I
r>:
}~r' '..
ARIZONA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY
SCIENTIFIC EXAMINATION REPORT
AGENCY
FILENO.
OFFICER
Phoenix Police Department
200551799055
DURAN #6287
DR NO. 2006732863Pae_13.fI6
DATE November 29. 2006NAME(S)
.. --- ._----- -~--------..._--_._-- ..-._- ---- - - - .
No male DNA was detected on Item #2F.l (casings).
The male DNA profile obtained from Item #2F.7 (left nail clippings) is a mixture of at least twoindividuals. The inclusion ofItem #1 (Mark Goudeau) as a contributor to this mixture is inconclusive.
The male DNA profile obtained from Item #5F (right nail clippings) is a mixture of at least twoindividuals. Item #1 (Mark Goudeau) cannot be excluded as a contributor to this mixture.
Inconclusive or no results were obtained from Item #2F.39 (button & zipper) due to data below thereporting threshold; however, Item #1 (Mark Goudeau) is excluded as a contributor of this DNA.
Portions ofItems #2F.l. #2F.7. #2F.39 and #5F have been retained in laboratory frozen storage.
PHOENIX PD DR#200660332085
Preliminary tests were positive for blood on Item #2F.4.
Male human DNA was isolated from Item #2F .4. The DNA was characterized using the polymerasechain reaction (PCR) at the Y-chromosome short tandem repeat (STR) loci DYS456. DYS389I.DYS390, DYS389II. DYS458, DYS19, DYS385, DYS393, DYS391. DYS439, DYS635. DYS392, YGATA H4, DYS437. DYS438 and DYS448.
Inconclusive or no results were obtained from Item #2FA (casing).
CUSTODY OF EVIDENCE LORRAINE HEATH. #6353CriminalistCentral Regional Crime Laboratory(602) 223-2857
RECEIVED D.P.S. Property
D.P.S. PropertyDISPosmON
Accredited b the ASCLD Laboratorv Accreditation Board.Any notes, plwlographs. charts. or graphs generated during the examination are retained in the Itlbo,.lI/It"..
OAO
ARIZONA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY
SCIENTIFIC EXAMINATION REPORT
AGENCY Phoenix Police Department
200551799055
DURAN #6287
DR NO. 2006732863Plze 14006FILENO.
OFFICER
DATE November 29. 2006
NAME(S)
PHOENIX PD DR#200660489775
Preliminary tests were positive for blood on Items #2F.5. #2F.14 and #2F.lS.
Male human DNA was isolated from Items #2F.5. #2F.8. #2F.12. #2F.13, #2F.14, #2F.15 and #2F.33.The DNA was characterized using the polymerase chain reaction (peR) at the Y -chromosome shorttandem repeat (STR) loci DYS4S6, DYS389l, DYS390, DYS389II, DYS458, DYS19, DYS385,DYS393, DYS391, DYS439. DYS635, DYS392, Y GATA H4, DYS437. DYS438 and DYS448.
The partial male DNA profile obtained from Item #2F.5 (casing) is a mixture of at least two individuals.Item #2F.33 (Chao Chou) cannot be excluded and Item #1 (Mark Goudeau) is excluded as contributorsto the mixture.
The male DNA profile obtained ftom Items #2F.8 (steering wheel & gear shift) and #2F.l2 (tissue fromright nail clippings) matches the DNA profile from Item #2F.33 (Chou) at all 16 loci.
Inconclusive or no results were obtained from Items #2F.13 (extract from belt buckle), #2F.14(fingernail scrapings) and #2F.lS (fingernail scrapings),
Portions ofItems #2F.5, #2F.8, #2F.12, #2F.13, #2F.l4 and #2F.15 have beenretaincd in laboratoryfrozen storage.
CUSTODY OF EVIDENCE LORRAINE HEATH, #6353CriminalistCentral Regional Crime Laboratory(602) 223-2857
RECEIVED
DISPOSITION
D.P.S. Property
D.P.S. Property
Accredited b the ASCLD Laborato Accreditation BoardAny notes, phologrophs. Moru, or graphs generoled during the esamtnatton are relained In the /oborll/fJry.
~ ~~~~~11{
ARIZONA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY
SCIENTIFIC EXAMINATION REPORT
PHOENIX PD DR:II200~06n24o ---_.- -_. _ .. ----. - . - ---------_. . - "--- ._--- --
Any notes. phofographs. charts, or graphs generated during the examlnation are retained in Ihe labora/ory.
: "; )-. ....-~.- -
AGENCY
FILENO.
OFFICER
DATE
NAME(S)
Phoenix Police Department
200551799055
DURAN #6287
November 29, 2006
DR NO. 2006732863
Male human DNA was isolated from Items #2F.l.8 and #2F.19. The DNA was characterized using thepolymerase chain reaction (peR) at the Y -chrcmosome short tandem repeat (STR) loci DYS456,DYS389I. DYS390, DYS389II. DYS458, DYS19, DYS385, DYS393, DYS391, DYS439, DYS635,DYS392, Y GAT A H4, DYS437, DYS438 and DYS448.
No male DNA was detected on Item #2F.20 (extract from external genitals).
The partial male DNA profile obtained from Item #2F.18 (extract from right nail clippings) is amixture. Item #1 (Mark Goudeau) is excluded as a contributor to this mixture.
Inconclusive or no results were obtained from Item #2F.19 (extract from left nail clippings).
Portions of Items #2F .18, #2F.19 and #2F.20 bave been retained in laboratory frozen storage.
PHOENIX PD DR:ll20066122644I
Preliminary tests were positive for blood on Items #2F.46, #2F.47 and #2F.50. No blood was detectedon Items #2F.48 and #2F.51.
Male human DNA was isolated from Items #2F.21, #2F.26, #2F.27, #2F.28, #2F.29, #2F.34, #2F,35,#2F.36, #2F.37, #2F.38, #2F.40, #2F.41, #2F.43, #2F.44 and #2F.46. The DNA was characterizedusing the polymerase chain reaction (peR) at the Y -chromosome short tandem repeat (STR) lociDYS456, DYS389I, DYS390, DYS389II, DYS4S8, DYS19, DYS385, DYS393, DYS391, DYS439,
CUSTODY OF EVIDENCE LORRAINE HEATH, #6353CriminalistCentral Regional Crime Laboratory(602) 223-2857
RECEIVED
DISPOSITION
D.P.S. Property
D.P.S. Property
".IAccredited b the ASCLD Laboratory Accreditation Board
~ ~A~O,)~~
r-~-,-: ..•.
DYS63S. DYS392;YUATAH4;-DYS437,-DYS4381md-DYS44"8;---- --- ------------------ - - --- -
ARIZONA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETYSCIENTIFIC EXAMINATION REPORT
AGENCY
FILENO.
OFFICER
DATE
NAME(S)
Phoenix Police Department
200551799055
DURAN #6287
November 29. 2006
DR NO. 2006732863Pale 160rl6
The male DNA profile obtained from Item #2F.29 (driving area) is a mixture of at least two individuals,The major component matches the DNA profile obtained from Items #2F.34 (Jaime Coronado) and#2F.35 (Abel Coronado) at all 16 loci. The minor component does Dot match any known standards inthis case examined prior to this report and is from an unknown male individual.
The partial male DNA profile obtained from Item #2F.41 (front driver interior door) is a mixture of atleast two individuals. Items #2F.34 (Jaime Coronado) and #2F.35 (Abel Coronado) cannot be excludedas the major contributors to this mixture. The minor component is inconclusive. The inclusion ofItem# 1 (Mark Goudeau) as a contributor to this mixture is inconclusive.
The male DNA profile obtained from Item #2F.44 (rear driver interior door) is a mixture of at leastthree individuals. Items #2F.34 (Jaime Coronado), #2F.35 (Abel Coronado), #2F.38 (Abel Castillo)and #2F.36 (Jose Reyes) cannot be excluded as contributors to this mixture. The minor component isinconclusive. The inclusion ofItem #1 (Mark Goudeau) as a contributor to this mixture is inconclusive.
The male DNA profile obtained from Item #2F.46 (jean cuttings) is a mixture of at least threeindividuals, Item #1 (Mark Goudeau) cannot be excluded as a contributor to this mixture.
Inconclusive or no results were obtained from Items #2F.21 (thigh & hip), #2F.26 (extract from button& zipper), #2F.21 (extract from right nail scrapings), #2F.28 (extract from left nail clippings), #2F.40(front exterior driver handle) and #2F.43 (rear exterior driver handle).
Portions ofItems #2F.21, #2F.26, #2F.27, #2F.28, #2F_29, #2F.40, #2F.41, #2F.43, #2F.44 and #2F.46have been retained in laboratory frozen storage.
CUSTODY OF EVIDENCE LORRAINE REATH, #6353CriminalistCentral Regional Crime Laboratory(602) 223~2857
RECEIVED
DISPOSITION
D.P.S. Property
D.P.S. Property
Accredited b the ASCLD Laborato Accreditation BoardAll)llIOtes. phatagrapirs. charu. or graphs generated during the examination are retained in the Iabaratory: