arctic and antarctic lakes as optical indicators of global ... › annals › 27 ›...

6
A nn aLs rifGLacio L ogy 27 1998 © Int e rn ational Gl aciol ogica l Society Arctic and Antarctic lakes as optical indicators of global change WARWI CK F. VI NCENT,i * ISABELL E LAU RIO ,2 R EIN HARD PIE NITZ 2 iAntarctic CR G, B ox 252-80, Hobart, Tasmania 7001 , Aust raLia 2 Centre d'Etudes Nordiques, D epartement de B io L ogie et D epartement de Geograplz ie , Universite L aval, Sainte - Foy, Quebec G1K 7P4, Cana da ABSTRACT. Lakes are a ma jor feat ur e of Ar c ti c an d Ant arctic landscapes and are likely to be se nsitive indi ca tors of climate change. New bio-opti ca l techn ologi es for in situ meas ur ement s (e.g. UV-profiling) a nd remote sensing (c.g. light detection and ranging) now offer a suite of options for long-term mo ni to ring at these sit es. Ce rt ain properti es of high-latitud e lakes are highly r es ponsive to changes in cl im ate forcing and could be tar- geted within a monito ring st ra tegy based on opti ca l properti es; these include lake levels, lake-ice dynamics, phytopla nkton biomass a nd chr omo ph or ic dissolved or ga nic matter ( CDOM ). Hi gh-la titud e lakes are opticall y se nsitive to changes in C DOM expo rt from th e ir s urroundin g ca tchm ents th at co uld r es ult from cl im ate effects on hydr ology a nd vegetation. Using a new model ba sed on bi ologica ll y weig ht ed tr ansparency, we show that a 20% change in C DOM conce ntr ation (as meas ur ed by dissolved orga ni c ca r bo n) ca n have a mu ch gr ea ter effect on UV inhibition of phytoplankton than a similar percent age change in str atos ph eric ozon e. Mu ch of this effect is due to UV-A, b eca use the redu ced photodama ging effect per unit energ y (i.e. Iow biologica l weighting) in this waveband is off se t by its high er in cident flu x at the lake surf ace relative to UV-B and its deeper pene- tr a tion into th e water co lumn. Th ese tr ansparen cy ca lculations also show th at small chan ges in CDOM in polar lakes will have a large effect on und erwater li ght ava il ability for photosy nth es is. Th e spec tr al absorption and nuorescence properti es of C DOM lend themselves to a variety of opti ca l moni toring a pproac hes. Future research on the paleo- optics of C DOM will a ll ow the int e rpr eta ti on of c urr ent opti ca l tr ends in high-latitude lakes relati ve to the scales of na tur al variability in th e pas t. INTRODUCTION Lakes are a pro min ent featur e of the ice-fr ee reg ions of Ant arcti ca a nd are also a major element of high-latitude northern la nd scap es . Th ey are the down str ea m int eg ra tors of a va ri ety of ca tchme nt pro cesses, and many of th eir eco- system properti es are r es pon sive to sma ll va riation s in a nnu al hea t bud ge t. The se featur es, in co mbin ation with the stron g climate-change signals and str atos ph eric ozone de pl e ti on at high la titud es, suggest th at polar lakes are hig hl y appr opriate sit es for monit oring the effects of global change. Recent a dv ances in fi eld in strumenta ti on and remote- sensing tec hn ologies have paved the way for a va riety of novel a pproach es to the monitorin g of lake ecosystem s. In this paper we exa min e some of the a pp roach es which may be of special releva nce to monitoring enviro nm ental chan ge in the No rth and South Polar regions. We focus particula rl y on tho se prop erti es of the aqu atic envir o nment which c an be meas ur ed usin g optical tec hniqu es. Th e technology in this ar ea is evolving rapidly and lend s it se lf to high-r es olution * Perm anent a ddr ess: Centr e d'e tud es no rdiqu es et Depa rt e- ment de biologie, Universite L ava l, Sainte-F oy, Quebec GIK 7P4, Canada. obse rva ti ons over space and tim e, even at high -l atitud e sit es where th e logisti cs are often difficult and exp ensive. Long-t erm mo nitoring pr ograms based on opti ca l vari- a bl es should id ea ll y focus on those properti es of lakes that not o nl y respond to clima ti c forcing but al so integrate a var iety of lake-plus- catchm ent processes. Such va riables should be meas ur able by in situ tec hniqu es, by automat ed instrum ent a ti on and/or by remote sensing. It would be ad va ntageous if such a record could al so be extend ed into the past, for exampl e via paleo limn ologi cal appro aches, to a ll ow c urr ent ob se rvations to be pl aced in their histori ca l context and to define the scales of na tur al variabili ty against which recent changes c an be assessed. In this pap er we exa min e several f ea tur es o[high-Iatitude lake ecosystems th at are likely to r es po nd to chan ges in cl imate forcing a nd which could be inco rp orated within a monitoring strategy based on opti ca l properti es : lake le ve ls, ice-cover dynamics, phytoplankton biomass and chr o lll o- phoric dissolved orga nic ma tt er (C DOM ). We pla ce special e mph as is o n CD OM b eca use it pl ays a ce ntr al role in se ve ra l ecosystem pro cesses and is dependent on ca tchment hydrol- ogy, vegeta ti on and soils, and thus climat e. It exerts an over- riding co ntr ol on unde rwater ultr aviolet radiation (U VR ) as we ll as pho to sy nth eti ca ll y ac ti ve radiation (PAR ) a nd provid es a str ong opti ca l signa tur e for long-te rm monitoring. Our r es ults pr ese nt ed here show that high-latitude lakes have C DOM conce ntr ations within a range where sma ll vari- 691

Upload: others

Post on 05-Jul-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Arctic and Antarctic lakes as optical indicators of global ... › annals › 27 › igs_annals_vol27_year1998_pg6… · Lakes are a major feature of Arctic and Antarctic landscapes

AnnaLs rifGLacioLogy 27 1998 © International Glaciological Society

Arctic and Antarctic lakes as optical indicators of global change

WARWICK F. VINCENT,i * ISABELLE LAU RIO ,2 R E INHARD PIEN IT Z 2

iAntarctic CR G, Box 252-80, Hobart, Tasmania 7001, AustraLia 2Centre d'Etudes Nordiques, Departement de BioLogie et Departement de Geograplz ie, Universite Laval, Sainte-Foy, Quebec G1K 7P4, Canada

ABSTRACT. La kes a re a major feature of Arctic and Anta rctic landscapes and a re likely to be sensitive indicators of climate change. New bio-optical technologies for in situ measurements (e.g. U V-profiling) and remote sensing (c.g. light detec tion and ranging) now offer a sui te of options for long-term moni to ring at these sites. Certain properti es of high-latitude lakes a re highly responsive to changes in cl imate forcing and could be ta r­geted within a monitoring strategy based on optical properti es; these include lake levels, lake-ice dyna mics, phytoplankton biomass and chromophoric dissolved organic matter (CDOM). High-latitude lakes a re optically sensitive to changes in CDOM export from their surrounding catchments tha t could resul t from climate effects on hydrology and vegetation. Using a new model based on biologicall y weighted transparency, we show that a 20% change in CDOM concentration (as measured by dissolved organic carbon ) can have a much greater effect on U V inhibition of phytoplankton than a simil a r percentage change in stratospheric ozone. Much of this effect is due to U V-A, because the reduced photodamaging effect per unit energy (i.e. Iow biological weighting) in this waveband is offse t by its higher incident flux at the lake surface rela tive to UV-B and its deeper pene­tra tion into the wa ter co lumn. These transpa rency ca lcul a tions a lso show tha t small changes in CDOM in pola r la kes will have a la rge effect on underwater light avail ability for photosynthesis. The spec tra l absorption and nuorescence properti es of CDOM lend themselves to a va ri ety of optical monito ring approaches. Future research on the pa leo­optics of CDOM will a llow the interpreta tion of current optical trends in high-la titude lakes relative to the scales of natural variability in the past.

INTRODUCTION

Lakes are a prominent feature of the ice-free regions of Anta rctica and a re also a maj or element of high-latitude northern landscapes. They a re the downstream integrators of a va ri ety of catchment processes, and m any of their eco­system properties a re responsive to small variations in annual heat budget. These features, in combination with the strong climate-change signa ls and stratospheric ozone depletion a t high latitudes, suggest that polar la kes a re highl y appropriate sites for monitoring the effects of global change.

Recent advances in fi eld instrumenta tion a nd remote­

sensing technologies have paved the way for a vari ety of novel approaches to the monitoring of lake ecosystems. In this paper we examine some of the approaches which may be of specia l relevance to monitoring environmental change in the North a nd South Polar regions. We focus particul a rl y on those properties of the aquatic environment which can be

measured using optical techniques. The technology in this a rea is evolving rapidly and lends itself to high-resolution

* Permanent address: Centre d'etudes nordiques et Depa rte­

ment de biologie, Universite Laval, Sainte-Foy, Quebec GIK 7P4, Canada.

obse rvations over space and time, even at high-latitude sites where the logistics a re often difficult a nd expensive.

Long-term monitoring programs based on optical vari­ables should ideally focus on those properties of lakes that not onl y respond to climatic forcing but also integrate a variety of lake-plus-catchment processes. Such variables should be measurable by in situ techniques, by automated instrumentation and/or by remote sensing. It wou ld be advantageous if such a record could also be extended into the pas t, for example via paleolimnological approaches, to allow current observations to be pl aced in their historical context and to defin e the scales of natural va ri abili ty aga i nst which recent changes can be assessed.

In this paper we examine severa l features o[high-Iatitude

lake ecosystems that are likely to respond to changes in climate forcing and which could be incorporated within a monitoring strategy based on optical properti es: lake levels, ice-cover dynamics, phytoplankton biomass and chrolllo­phoric di ssolved organic matter (CDOM). We place special emphas is on CD OM because it pl ays a central role in several ecosystem processes and is dependent on catchment hydrol­ogy, vegetation and soils, and thus clim ate. It exerts an over­riding control on underwater ultraviolet radi ation (U VR) as well as photosynthetically active radi ation (PAR) and provides a strong optical signature for long-term monitoring. Our results presented here show that high-latitude lakes have CDOM concentrations within a range where small va ri-

691

Page 2: Arctic and Antarctic lakes as optical indicators of global ... › annals › 27 › igs_annals_vol27_year1998_pg6… · Lakes are a major feature of Arctic and Antarctic landscapes

Vincent and others: Arctic and Antarctic lakes as global-change indicators

ations result in biologically significant shifts in underwater UV-A (UVR in the range 320- 400 nm ) as well as U V-B (280- 320 nm ). Such effects contrast with those induced by stratospheric ozone depletion which a re limited to changes in UV-B, a waveband that penetra tes to much shallower depths than U V-A in natural waters.

LAKE LEVELS

One of the likely consequences of climate change is a n altera tion in the hydrological ba lance ofl akes and their sur­roundi ng catchments. For example, a long-term warming trend in the boreal forest zone of Canada has been accom­panied by reduced precipi tation, decreased runoff and increased hydrau lic residence time of the lakes of that region (Schindler and others, 1996). For glacier-fed endo­rheic lakes, including those at many high-latitude sites, changes in the radiation balance at the glacier face can lead

to la rge shifts in the quantity of inflowing meltwater and thus variations in lake a rea, depth and volume. Chinn (1993) showed that lakes in the M cMurdo Dry Valleys have consistently ri sen in water level th roughout the 20th cen­tury, while measurements by Gibson and Burton (1996) a t lakes in the Vest fold Hills (East Antarctica) indicated a more complex pattern, with rising water between 1978 a nd the mid-1980s, followed by dropping water levels. These latter authors noted tha t vari ations in water level in saline meromictic systems are accompanied by cha nges in the vertical structure of the water column which in turn can be used to infer past climates. Given the la rge differences in refl ectance between land, water and ice, changes in lake level could be conveniently monitored by ae ri al photogra­phy or by satell ite, in particul ar via the associated changes in lake a rea. Alternatively, depth could be determined directly via airborne LIDAR (light detection and ranging) observations which can be used to estimate, under ideal con­ditions, sha llows up to about 40 m deep (Gauldie and others, 1996).

LAKE-ICE DYNAMICS

T he dates of ice freeze-up and break-up, ice thickness and duration a re a ll likely to be sensitive indicators of vari ations in climate. These vari ables will also have a wide-ranging infl uence on many physical and chemical properti es of the aquatic ecosystem that directly or indirectly affect the biota, for example through changes in the length of the growing season, wind-induced mixing, gas transfer and underwater light availabili ty. Walsh (1995) summari zed the evidence for changing ice dynamics at a number of lake sites, and drew a ttention to the untapped potential of thi s approach to large-scale cl imate monitoring. Lake ice-cover thinning has been observed in continental Antarctica, suggestive of

a warming trend, while measurements in the eastern Canadian Arctic show an increased frequency of multi-year lake ice (Doran and others, 1996) consistent with a cooling trend in thi s region.

Ice measurements can be made photographicall y (e.g. by automated cameras) or by sensors on aircraft or satelli tes (e.g. the advanced very high resolution radiometer). These optical approaches a re likely to be superseded by satellite observations using synthetic aperture rada r (SAR) based on active microwave sensing. SAR systems a re continuing

692

to improve in spatial resolution (30- 100 m for RADAR­SAT) a nd they can be used to establish ice-cover extent even at night or under thick cloud cover (Massom, 1995). SAR data have been successfull y applied to measure the duration of ice cover and other surface ice p roperti es of lakes in the Yukon a nd northern Al as ka (Morris and others, 1995) and in the subarctic region nea r Hudson Bay (unpublished data from C. R . Duguay and P. M. Lafl eur).

PHYTOPLANKTON

The potentia l for major shifts in the distribution and pro­ductivity of plant communities has been of particular inter­est to terrestria l ecologists in their development of climate­change scenarios for high-l a titude environments. Va riou in­dices of greenness have been applied to some high-latitude environments, most recently by M yneni and others (1997) who presented evidence of a 10 year consistent rise in the

Normali zed Difference Vegetation Index for latitudes higher than 45° N. C limate change is also likely to result in chan­ging nutrient export from catchments, changes in the hydraulic res idence time of lakes, a nd var iat ions in lake­water mixing regimes, a ll of which may infl uence the species composition and biomass oflake phytoplankton.

Solar radiation (% surface) J .r5 _________ 1~.O--------~2.~O-----3·rO--_,4. 0

PERMANENT ICE COVER 5 1----::---------------------------1

......... 10 g £ 15 a. Cl)

Cl 20

25 I . Transmittance

30~~ __ ~-----L----~------L-----J 100 80 60 40 20

Transmittance (%)

Fig. 1. Bio -optical prqfiles for the east lobe if Lake Bonney, AlcA1urdo D Iy Valleys, Antarctica, 14 December 1995 (1215 h): downwelling radiation at 320nm (UVR ), down­welling photosynthetically active radiation ( PAR) and transmittance at 660 nm ( note the scale reversal to show the upper and lower pigment maxima). Measurements were made with a B iospherical PUV-500 prqfiling radiometer fitted with a Seatech 10 cm tmnsnzissometer.

o

A broad range of optical technologies is now available

for rapid in situ measurements of phytoplankton distribu­tion and abundance. High-resolution measurements of particle di stribution can be made by fluorometry or trans­missometry which a llow subsurface pigment maxima to be accurately located and quantifi ed (Fig. I). Techniques such as sola r-induced fluorescence can provide information about the photosynthetic activity of phytoplankton as a function of depth in the water column (e.g. Garcia-Mendoza and M aske, 1996), and have been applied to lakes in both the North and South Polar zones (Vincent and others, in press).

Page 3: Arctic and Antarctic lakes as optical indicators of global ... › annals › 27 › igs_annals_vol27_year1998_pg6… · Lakes are a major feature of Arctic and Antarctic landscapes

A variety of remote-sensing options are available for phyto­plankton measurements, and the advent of new satellite

observation systems with high spatial resolution, such as

MERIS and MODIS with resolution of 250- 300 m (Massom, 1995), is o[~pecial interest to limnologists. Recent advances in laser fluorosensors indicate that LIDAR has considerable potential for airborne measurements of Chi a

in the surface waters of lakes and coastal environments

(Nieke and others, 1997b). There is a great variety of paleo­

limnological techniques based on the measurement of fossil algal remains in lake sediments (Charles and others, 1994 and references therein), and these approaches will continue to provide new insights into the long-term variability of high-latitude lakes (e.g. Pienitz and Smol, 1993).

CDOM

Climate-related changes in the hydrology and vegetation ecology of catchments are likely to have a strong effect on

the export of dissolved organic compounds into receiving streams and lake waters. There is increasing evidence that such compounds exert a major influence on many proper­ties of lake ecosystems, including radiative transfer (Laurion and others, 1997), mixing regimes (Fee and others, 1996) and microbial carbon dynamics (Wetzel, 1995). In the Experimental Lakes Area a decrease in runoff and increased hydraulic residence time were accompanied by a 15- 20% decrease in dissolved organic carbon (DOC) over 20 years (Schindler and others, 1996). The coloured fraction of the dissolved organics, referred to as CDOM, largely con­trols the spectral penetration ofUVR and, to a lesser extent, photosynthetically available radiation (PAR). In this sec­tion we evaluate the magnitude of these effects in high-lati­tude lakes, and the potential for monitoring coupled lake­catchment systems via the optical changes induced by varia­tions in CDOM.

CDOM effects on underwater UVR

UVR penetrates deeply in high-latitude lakes as a result of the low concentration and low UVR-absorbing characteris­tics of CDOM in these waters (Laurion and others, 1997). Measurements of underwater spectral irradiance along lati­tudinal transects in northern North America show a major

increase in the UV transparency of lakes across the transi­tional forest- tundra region of the sub-Arctic, and a further abrupt increase across the transition from tundra to polar desert (Vincent and Pienitz, 1996; Pienitz and others, 1997 a, b; Vincent, in press ). These changes are associated with the trend of decreasing concentration of eDOM with increasing latitude. Antarctic lakes are similarly character­ized by low CDOM and the deep penetration ofUVR (Fig. I). High-latitude lakes are therefore little protected from the effects of stratospheric ozone depletion and rising UV-B, which are proceeding most rapidly in the polar regions.

Our previous measurements ofUVR in Arctic, sub-Arc­

tic and Antarctic lakes have been made with a profiling radiometer (model PUV-500 from Biospherical Instrument Inc.) that measures downwelling UVR at 305, 320, 340 and 380 nm. From these measurements a set of empirical rela­tionships was derived [or attenuation length or "transpar­

ency" (T(>"), = 1/ K where K is the diffuse attenuation coefficient ) as a function of DOe concentration (Table 1). The striking goodness-of-fit of this log- log model (Fig. 2)

Vincent and others: Arctic and Antarctic lakes as global-change indicators

Table 1. Empirically derived relationships between attenua­tion length (1/ K) and DOe concentrationJor Arctic, sub ­Arctic and Antarctic lakes

11 (wdenglh Il 'J

m ,..-

305 nll1 0.12 - 1.68 7 0.93 320 nll1 0.42 - 1.98 20 0.95 340 nll1 0.58 - 2.04 20 0.95 380 nll1 0.75 - 1.91 20 0.94 PAR 0.99 - 1.11 20 0.90

. Yole: CoefTicients are for the equation log (1/ l\) = C + In log [DOC]; n = number of lakes sampled. DOC was measured with a Shimadzu

TOe Analyser. An illustrative scatter plot is given in Figure 2 (further details in Vincent and others, in press ).

may in part reflect the lack o[ bio-optical diversity amongst

the sampled lakes; all are oligotrophic, non-turbid systems

in which seston (biotic and abiotic suspensoids ) p lays only a minor role in light absorption and scattering.

'!\le can extend these empirical transparency models by considering the penetration of UVR weighted [or its biolo­gical effectiveness and for the changes in incident spectral radiation that result from ozone depletion. A parameter T*(>"), the "weighted transparency" at each wavelength, may be defined as:

T*(>") = (1/ K)EEoreIF (1)

where K is the diffuse attenuation coefficient at that wave­

length (>.. ), E is the biological weighting function which ex­presses the damaging effect of radiation at that wavelength on a relative scale (E = 1.0 at 300 lllll ), E Orcl is the surface irradiance at that wavelength, also on a relative scale (E Orel = 1.0 at 400 nm ), and F is the [actor of enhancement in surface radiation f1ux at the wavelength for a given stra­

tospheric ozone depletion. This weighted transparency

100 r--------.--------,-----,

---S 10 >­u c CJ.) .... ctl c.. en c: ctl .... ~

0.1

0.01 0 .1 10

Fig. 2. Relationship between UVR transparency (1/ K (>..), here illustrated by >.. = 340 nm) and Doe concentration for Antarctic lakes (solid circles) and sub-Arctic lakes (open circles).

693

Page 4: Arctic and Antarctic lakes as optical indicators of global ... › annals › 27 › igs_annals_vol27_year1998_pg6… · Lakes are a major feature of Arctic and Antarctic landscapes

Vincent and others: Arctic and Antarctic lakes as global-change indicators

Table 2. Effect of ozone depletion vs CD OM reduction on the weighted transparency (10-3 m) of a water column to UVR

UVR wavelength 305n1l1 320nm 340nm 380nm Total

2mgDOC I I 20.4 15.2 19.8 10.5 14.3 Ozone depletion 48.6 (138% ) 17.9 (18% ) 19.8 (0% ) 10.5 (0% ) l7.7 (24% ) CDOM reduction 29.6 (45% ) 23.6 (48% ) 31.2 (57% ) 16. 1 (53% ) 22.0 (54% )

ImgDOel- 1 65.1 59.9 81.3 39.6 54.6 Ozone depletion 155 (138%) 70.7 (18% ) 81.3 (0%) 39.6 (0%) 65.7 (20% ) CDOM reduction 153 (135%) 165 (175 %) 230 (183 %) 105 (165% ) 147 (169%)

Note: The va lues at each wavelength are for T ' (oX) as in Equation (1), or TCVR' the mean values for the UVR waveband as approllimated in Equation (3). Ozone depletion refers to a 20.6% decrease in total colum n ozone (from 310 to 250 DU, as in Frederick and Snell (1988)); e DOM reduction refers to a 0.4 mg DOe I I decrease from ini tial conditions (2 or Img DOe I \ The percenLagc increase in weighted transparency rei aLive to initi a l conditions is given in parentheses.

index can be averaged across a sen es of wavelengths to produce a mean value for a particular waveband:

I ( + 6.>. T;v = ~). l >. T * ()') d)'. (2)

T;v for the UVR waveband can be approximated in terms

ofT*(A) values for each of the four measured wavelengths:

T~VR ~ O.IT* (305 nm) + 0.2T* (320 nm)

+ 0.2T* (340 nm) + 0.5T* (380 nm) (3)

where the coefficients in this equation are for rectangular integration across the UVR range.

Table 2 presents the results of a series of calculations based on Equations (I) and (3) and the bio-optical relation­ships for high-latitude waters given in Table 1. For these cal­culations we used f. values based on Cullen and others (1992). These were derived for UVR photo-inhibition ofphotosyn­thesis of marine diatoms, but they have also provided rea­sonable biological weightings for UVR inhibition of growth by Antarctic cyanobacteria (Quesada and Vincent, 1997). E Orel values were obtained for an incident solar radi­a tion curve (Milot-Roy and Vincent, 1994, fig. 7), and F values were derived from Frederick and Snell (1988, fig. 2B) for a total column ozone thickness of 310 and 250 Dobson Units (DU ).

Relative to the initial conditions of 2 mg Doe I I and 310 DU, a 20.6% reduction in ozone results in a > 100% increase in T*()') at short UVR wavelengths, but no change in long-wavelength UVR (Table 2). By contrast, a 20% decrease in DOC from 2 to 1.6 mg C I I results in a la rge (>40% ) increase in T*()') at all UVR wavelengths, and the relative increase in total waveband TUVR is twice that induced by the ozone depletion. These effects are more strik­ing at lower DOe concentrations. i'or example, the same absolute change in DOC, but from I to 0.6 mg 1- ', results in a > 130% increase inT* (A) at a ll UVR wavelengths; TUVR increases by 169%, an effect some 8 times greater than that caused by 60 DU of ozone depletion (Table 2).

This analysis of weighted UVR penetration into natural waters illustrates the pivotal role played by eDOM and is consistent with earlier suggestions by Schindler and others (1996) and Williamson and others (1996) of the importance of such effects relative to changes in incident UVR. Our result show that in the 10w-eDOM regime which charac­terizes high-latitude lakes, changes in the concentration of DOe can have a greater effect on biologically weighted un-

694

derwater UVR than the equivalent percentage change in stratospheric ozone. Much of this effect is due to UV-A, because the reduced photodamaging effect per unit energy (i.e. Iow E) in this waveband is offset by its deeper penetration and higher incident flux at the la ke surface relative to UV-B.

CDOM effects on underwater PAR and UVR/PAR

Although eDOM absorbance of solar radiation is espe­ciall y strong in the UVR region of the spectrum, there is a lso some absorbance in the PAR range. Our measurements in high-latitude northern la kes indicate that eDOM can account for a la rge percentage of the total photon budget for PAR and that climate-related shifts in DOe export to lakes cou ld also influence the availability of underwater light for photosynthesis (unpublished data from S. M arka­ger and W. F. Vincent). Arrigo and Brown (1996) modelled the combined effects of eDOM on UVR screening and PAR removal in the sea, and concluded that the latter can eliminate or exceed the pos itive effects of the former. For a decrease in eDOM from 2.0 to 1.6 mg DOe I- I, as above, we calculate that the transparency of the water column to PAR would increase by only 11 %, but a shift from I to 0.6 mg I I

would increase transparency (e.g. the depth of the I % PAR level) by 76%.

UVR impairment of biological systems is likely to rep­resent the net balance between photochemical damage and biosynthetic repair. The latter is determined in part by the UVR flux, while biosynthesis in phototrophic organisms may depend on PAR availability. The spectral ratio of UVR to PAR may therefore be a more meaningful index of damage potential than UVR alone. Studies on high-lati­tude lakes in the northern circumpolar region (Vincent a nd Pienitz, 1996; Laurion and others, 1997) as well as Antarctica (Vincent and others, in press ) have shown these waters lie within a eDOM concentration range where this ratio rises sharply with decreasing DOe. For the two eDOM scenar­ios and the empirical relationships given in Table I, the UVR (320nm )/PAR ratio would rise by 22% for the shift from 2 to 1.6 mg DOe I I, and by 56% for the shift from I to 0.6 mg DOe 1- '.

Optical monitoring of CDOM

The preceding subsections have emphasized how eDOM controls the underwater light fi eld in high-latitude lakes. It foll ows that certain optical properties of these lakes can be

Page 5: Arctic and Antarctic lakes as optical indicators of global ... › annals › 27 › igs_annals_vol27_year1998_pg6… · Lakes are a major feature of Arctic and Antarctic landscapes

used as sensitive proxies for CDOM, for example attenua­tion lengths derived from in situ UVR profiles (Fig. I; Table

I). For remote-sensing applications, attention has especially focused on the spectral fluorescence properties of CDOM, in particular its emission maximum normalized to the Ra­man scattering peak for water (Green and Blough, 1995; Nieke and others, 1997a). Figure 3 shows the emission spec­tra for two lakes at opposite ends of the CDOM continuum

for high-latitude waters: Lake Bonney (Antarctica) in which CDOM emission is small relative to the Raman peak (DOC = 0.7 mg I- i), and a sub-Arctic lake characterized by much higher concentrations of CDOM (8 mg DOC 1 i) in which the Raman peak is a small contribution to total fluor­escence. Emission signals of this type from surface waters can be detected and quantified by active remote-sensing techniques such as LIDAR (Vodacek and others, 1995; Nieke and others, 1997a). CDOM can be incorporated into the ice of northern lakes during freeze-up (R. Pienitz and ,"'- F. Vincent, unpublished observations ) and the organic content

of lake ice might a lso be monitored in this way, although such measurements would be obstructed by any overlying snow.

(l) u c (l) U Cl) (l) ..... 0 ~ I;:

(l) > :;::; ca

Q) c:::

2.5 Antarctic 2.0

1.5

1.0

0.5 ""-""""-. ~ ..",....--......... ... ~ I

0.0 -350 400 450 500 550

10

8 Sub-Arctic

6

4

2

0

350 400 450 500 550

Wavelength (nm)

Fig. 3. Fluorescence emission spectra for 0.22 J-lm filtered water from an Antarctic lake ( Lake Bonney) and a sub -Arc­tic lake (near Lac a l'eau claire, northern Quebec). Excitation was at 348 nm, and measurements were obtained with a Shimad;cu spectrqfluorometer model RF5000.

Recent advances in paleolimnology have led to the de­velopment of new analytical and statistical techniques for reconstructing past lake environments (Charles and others, 1994). These approaches are of special interest for high-lati­tude lakes, where there is a paucity of hi storical data but a potentially interesting record of variations because of their high sensitivity to natural as well as human perturbation. Pienitz and Smol (1993) have shown that dissolved organic carbon levels in Canadian lakes can be successfull y hindcast

Vincent and others: Arctic and Antarctic lakes as global-change indicators

from the multivariate analysis of diatom microfossils con­tained within their sediments. In combination with the bio­

optical models now available for high-latitude lakes (Table 1), this leads to the exciting prospect of reconstructing past underwater light regimes and the extension of records for optical variables such as T* into the past. This new lheme in paleolimnology, "lake paleo-optics" (Vincent and Pienitz, 1996), offers opportunities for integrating studies from the

present-day optical monitoring oflakes, as proposed above, with knowledge of their historical variations in underwater light regime.

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

This work was supported by grants from the Fonds pour la Formation de Chercheurs et Ij\ide a la Recherche (FCAR, Quebec) and the Natural Sciences and Enginee ring Resea rch Council (NSERC, Canada). Logistic support was provided by the United States Antarctic Research Program, Centre d'e tudes nordiques and Polar Continental Shelf Project (this is publication No. PCSP/EPCP 01897). We thank K. Michael, J. C. Ellis-Evans and]. A. E. Gibson for their helpful review comments.

REFERENCES

Arrigo, K. R. and C. W. Brown. 1996. Impact of chromophoric dissolved organic matter on UV inhibition of primary productivity in the sea. Mar. Ecol. Prog. Ser., 140 (1 - 3),207- 216.

Charles, D. F. , j. P Smol and D. R. Engstrom. 1994. Pa leoli mnological ap­proaches to biologica l monitoring. [ ll Loeb, S. L. and A. Spacie, eds. Bio ­logicalmollitoring qf aquatic systems. Boca R a ton, FL, C RC Press, 233-293.

Chinn, T]. 1993. Physica l hydrology of the Dry Valley la kes. [ /I Green, W.].

and E.1. Friedmanl" eds. Physical and biogeochemical processes ill Antarctic lakes. Washington, DC, American G eophysica l Union, I- 51. (Antarctic Resea rch Series 59.)

Cullen, j.J. , PJ. Neale and M. P. Lesser. 1992. Biological weighting func ­tion for the inhibition of phytoplankton photosynthesis by ultraviolet radiat ion. Science, 258 (5082),646- 650.

Dora n, P. T , C. P M cK ay, \t". P AdalTIs, M. C. English, R. A. Wharton, Jr

a nd M. A. M eyer. 1996. C limate forcing and thermal feedback of res i­dual lake-ice covers in the high Arctic. Limnol. Oceanogr.. 41 (5), 839-848.

Fee, E.j. , R. E. H ecky, S. E. K asia n a nd D. R. Cruikshank. 1996. Effects of lake size, water clarity and climatic var iability on mixing depths in Canad ian Shield lakes. Limno!. Oceallogl:, 41 (5), 912- 920.

Frederick,j. E. a nd H . E. Snell. 1988. Ultraviolet radiation levels during the Antarctic spring. Science, 241 (4864),438- 440.

Garcia-Mendoza, E. a nd H. Maske. 1996. The relationship ofsolar-stimu­lated natural Ouorescenee and primary productivity in Mexican Pacific waters. Limnol. Oceallogl: , 41 (8), 1697- 1710.

Gauldie, R. w. . S. K. Sharllla a nd C. E. H elsley. 1996. LIDAR applicat ion to

fi sheries monitoring and problems. Call.] Fish. Aquat. Sei., 53 (6), 1459- 1468. Gibson, j. A. E. and H. R. Burton. 1996. Meromictic la kes as recorders of

climate cha nge: the st ructu res of Ace a nd Organic La kes, Vestfold Hill s,

Antarctica. Proceedings of the Royal SOCifty qfTasmallia, 130 (2),73- 78. Green, S. A. a nd N. V. Blough. 1994. Optica l absorption a nd Ouorescence

properties of chromophoric di ssolved organic matter in na tura l waters. Lirnllo/. Oceallogr., 39(8), 1903- 1916.

Laurion, 1. , \IV. E Vincent and D. R. S. Lean. 1997. Underwater ultraviolet radiation: development of spectral models for northern high latitude lakes. Photochem. Pholobiol. , 65 (1), 107-114.

M assom, R . 1995. Satellite remote sensing of polar snow and ice: present

status and future directions. Polar Rec., 31 (177),99- 114. Milot-Roy, V. a nd W. F. Vincent. 1994. U V radiation effects on photosyn­

thes is: the importance of near-surface thennoclines in a subarctie lake. [/1 Williamson, C. E. and H. E. Zagarese, eds. lr.:pacl of UV-B radialion 011

peLagicji-eshwaterecosystems. Stuttgart, E. Schweizerba rt'sche Verl agsbuch­ha ndlung, 171- 184. (Advances in Limnology 43.)

Ylorris, K. , M . 0. J effri es a nd W. F. Weeks. 1995. Ice processes and growth

hi story on Arctic a nd sub-Arctic lakes using ERS-I SAR data . Pol. Rec., 31 (177), 115- 128.

:vLyneni, R . B. , C. D. Keel ing, C. j. Tucker, G. Asrar a nd R. R. Nemani. 1997. Increased plant growth in the northern high la titudes from 1981 to 1991.

695

Page 6: Arctic and Antarctic lakes as optical indicators of global ... › annals › 27 › igs_annals_vol27_year1998_pg6… · Lakes are a major feature of Arctic and Antarctic landscapes

Vincent and others: Arctic and Antarctic lakes as global-change indicators

.Nature, 386 (6626), 698- 702. Nieke, B. , R. Reuter, R. Heuermann, H. Wang, M. Babin and ].-c.

Therriault. 1997a. Light absorption and nuorescence properti es of chromophoric dissolved organic matter (CDO]V[ ) in the St. Lawrence ESlUa ry (Case 2 waters). Continental Shelf Res., 17 (3), 235- 252.

Nieke, B. , W. F. Vincent,]. -c. Therriauit, L. Legendre, ]. -F. Berthon and A. Gonda!. 1997b. Use ofa shipborne laser nuorosensor for remote sensing of chlorophyll a in a coastal environment. Remote Sensing Environ., 60 (2), 140- 152.

Pienitz, R. a nd]. P Smol. 1993. Di atom assemblages and their relationship to environmental va ri ables in la kes from the borea l forest- tundra eCOlone nea r Yellowknife, Northwest Territories, Canada. Hydrobiologia, 269-270,391- 404.

Pienitz, R. , ]. P. Smol and D. R. S. Lean. 1997a. Physica l a nd chemica l

limnology of 24 lakes located between the Yellowknife and Gontwoyto La ke, Northwest Territories (Canada). Call. ] Fish. Aqua!. Sei., 54 (2), 347- 358.

Pienitz, R ., j. P. Smol a nd D. R. S. Lea n. 1997b. Phys ica l and chemicallim­nology of 59 lakes loca ted between the south ern Yukon and the Tuk­toya ktuk Peninsula, Northwest Territor ies (Canada ). Can.] Fish. Aquat. Sei., 54 (2), 330- 346.

Qucsada, A. and W. F. Vincent. 1997. Strategies of adaptation by Anta rctic

cyanobacteri a to UVradiation. EUTO/Jean] Phyeo!., 32 (4),335- 342. Schindler, D. W., P]. Curtis, B. R. Parker and M. P. Stainton. 1996. Conse-

696

quences of climate warming and la ke acidificati on for UV-B penetra­ti on in North American boreallakes . .Nature, 379 (6567), 705- 708.

Vincent, VV. E In press. Pol a r desert ecosystems in a changing environment: a north- south perspective. In Lyons, E. B. , I. Hawes and C. Howa rd­VVilli a ms, eds. Antarctic desert ecosystems. Rotterdam, A. A. Balkema.

Vincent, W. 10 a nd R. Pienitz. 1996. Sensitivity of high latitude freshwater

ecosys tems to global change: temperature and solar ultraviolet radi a­

tion. Ceosei. Can., 23 (4),231 - 236. Vincent, W. F. , R. Rae, I. LaLII' ion, C. Howa rd-Williams and]. C. Prisc u. In

press. u 'a nspa rency of Antarctic la kes to ultraviolet radiation. Liml/ol. Oeeal/og/:.

Vodacek, A., E E. Hoge, R. N. Swift, R. N. Yungel and N.Y. Blough. 1995. The use of in situ a nd airborne nuorescence measurements to determine

UVabsorption coeffi cients a nd DOG concentrations in surface waters.

Limllol. Oeeanogr. , 40 (2), 411 - 415. Wa lsh,]. E. 1995. Long-term observations for monitoring of the cryosphere.

Climatic Change, 31 (2-4),369- 394. 'Vc tzel , R. C. 1995. Death, detritus a nd energy now in aquatic ecosystems.

Freshwater Bioi., 33 (1), 83- 89. Willi am son, C. E., R. S. Stembergcr, D. P. Morris, T. M. Frost and S. C.

Paul sen. 1996. Ultraviolet radi ation in North American lakes: attenua­

tion estimates from DOG measurements a nd implications for plankton

communiti es. Linzno!. Oreanogr. , 41 (5), 1024-1034.