apple vs htc _english
TRANSCRIPT
-
7/31/2019 Apple vs HTC _English
1/12
-
7/31/2019 Apple vs HTC _English
2/12
lawsuit [337-TA-724] Apple is not infringement of all patents by S3, and terminate the ITC 337
investigation. ]
Apple, the recent high bids Nortel 6000 patents, but the lawsuit he and other technology giants are
also many, Samsung, Motorola, Nokia (later reconciliation), as well as harassment of the patenttrolls (NPEs). Please refer to previous articles of this website:
[ Apple sued HTC violated its smartphones patent, target Google?
[ HTC counterattack sue Apple infringement ]
[The fifth round of warring, Apple go further the HTC violation of its four patents ]
[ Apple and Samsung each other to report events observed
[ Apple Computer, Motorola filed a complaint, smart phone patent scuffle broke out ]
[ Apple and HTC patent war (Apple v. HTC) ]
Download: [337-TA-710] final sentence book
(2011.12.29) Download: [337-TA-710] final sentence
book - Additional Views on Remedy and Public Interest
(2011.12.29)
U.S. ITC final sentence in favor of Apple, HTC
infringement
Report HTC infringement case [337-TA-710] U.S. ITC
final sentence on December 19, 2011 sentencing
postponed twice, Apple results in favor of Apple, rulings
the HTC infringe US5, 946,647 patent rights, a and 8,the ban on the sale since April 19, 2012, HTC Android
phone that allegedly contains infringing features, are
not allowed to enter the U.S. sales. At the same time,
the ITC ruled that the security deposit (bond).
Four of the contested patent case the U.S. ITC against
Apple, including the initial impression was that the
infringement of two patents (US5, 946,647 and US6,
343,263), including the initial impression that is notinfringing the patent (US5, 481,721 and US6,
275,983). Final sentence ruling HTC violated US5,
946,647 patent rights items 1 and 8, while the other
three patents are not infringing.
The
disputed
patents
Of
contention
between the
rights ofentry
(Claim)
The initial
impression
infringement
Final
sentence
infringement
6471, 3, 8, 15,
and 19
1, 8, 15, and
191 and 8
2631, 2, 24, and
29
1, 2, 24, and
29X
721 1, 5, and 6 X X
983 1 and 7 X X
Page 2 of 12Patent Information: HTC [the Apple v Apple once again in the U.S. ITC court to sue HTC patent war
3/10/2012http://cdnet.stpi.org.tw/techroom/pclass/2011/pclass_11_A172.htm
-
7/31/2019 Apple vs HTC _English
3/12
Reminder: the case progress is continually updated, please do not hesitate on this page to read.
Table 1, the basic information of patent litigation: Apple and HTC each other divisions of patent
infringement
Sue date March 2, 2010 March 2, 2010 March 2, 2010 May 12, 2010 June 21, 2010
Plaintiff Apple Inc.
NeXT is at Software,
NeXT is at the
Computer
Apple Inc. Apple Inc.
NeXT is at
Software,
NeXT is at the
Computer
HTC Apple Inc.
647 patent rights items 1 and 8, mainly for
unstructured file phone numbers, address, e-mail "and
other information formats, automatic links to dial
phone, maps, e-mail program as a candidate programfor users Select from the start, is commonly used
features of a smartphone. Google and HTC should try
to patent design, to identify alternatives.
The same time, the public interest and security have
already purchased the interests of consumers of the
relevant models, the ITC agreed to the HTC can be
imported before December 19, 2013 updated version of
the phone.
Apple patent to 10 against HTC, and finally to the
infringement of a patent and narrow to two rights,
although Apple's favor, but the HTC to be a small lose.
Moreover, the embargo is only for mobile phones
containing infringing function, not all Android phones.
The patent war is the experiential learning of a high
tuition fees, but also the sidelines learning the
experience of others, technology companies should be
concerned about and from the cumulative strategic
energy to prepare for the future needs.
Download: Notice of final sentence (Notice of in
Final ID)
The ITC will review the HTC the telegraph Apple
infringement
U.S. ITC will review the HTC the telegraph Apple
infringement case [337-TA-721], the judge in the initial
impression that HTC's four patents are valid, but Apple
does not constitute infringement. ITC announced its
acceptance of the HTC appeal of December 16, 2011,
but only one patent HTC Committee to re-examine, the
Committee is expected to make the case in the
February 17, 2012, the final sentence.
Page 3 of 12Patent Information: HTC [the Apple v Apple once again in the U.S. ITC court to sue HTC patent war
3/10/2012http://cdnet.stpi.org.tw/techroom/pclass/2011/pclass_11_A172.htm
-
7/31/2019 Apple vs HTC _English
4/12
-
7/31/2019 Apple vs HTC _English
5/12
-
7/31/2019 Apple vs HTC _English
6/12
Page 7 of 12Patent Information: HTC [the Apple v Apple once again in the U S ITC court to sue HTC patent war
-
7/31/2019 Apple vs HTC _English
7/12
Apple sued HTC infringement, the ITC Commission
review of the decision
Apple sued HTC infringement case [ 337-TA-710 ], the
ITC Commission review the decision on September 16.
HTC, Apple, on behalf of the public interest to ITC
appointment of lawyers tripartite apply for an appeal of
the ITC review, the scope not only for HTC in the initial
impression is that the infringement of two patents
(US5, 946,647 and US6, 343,263 ), including another
The two are not that HTC infringement of the patent
( US5, 481,721 and US6, 275,983 ). ITC Commission is
the final sentence results expected to be released on
December 6.
According to the ITC program, the case goes to the
review, composed of six ITC Commission no longer
accept new evidence, the only evidence submitted
during the preliminary, as to make the final decision
was based on. However, in order to clarify some of the
issues, the ITC members also put forward for Apple,
HTC 16 questions to ask both sides to answer 16
questions, especially HTC was identified in the first
instance, infringement of patent No. 263 (the
underlying applications and operating systems drivers,
digital signal processor interaction), the most by the
ITC Committee's concerns.
Google patent umbrella HTC to go further Apple
HTC to go further in September 7th, 2011 Apple in the
U.S. International Trade Commission (ITC) and the
Delaware District Court, made a total of three litigation
cases, including two amendments to pleadings for the
previous proposal, the other case is a new case . Made
a total of nine patents related to mobile phone
application software or system, including: handheld
electronic devices, keys to enter the visual feedback,
communication devices, dynamic display, protocol,
radio modem and optional pager technology.
Page 7 of 12Patent Information: HTC [the Apple v Apple once again in the U.S. ITC court to sue HTC patent war
3/10/2012http://cdnet.stpi.org.tw/techroom/pclass/2011/pclass_11_A172.htm
Page 8 of 12Patent Information: HTC [the Apple v Apple once again in the U S ITC court to sue HTC patent war
-
7/31/2019 Apple vs HTC _English
8/12
Accused Apple of infringing products, the scope,
covering almost all commercial products of the apple
have:
Personal computers (MacBook, the MacBook Pro,
iMac, and the Mac Mini)
Mobile phone (iPhone, iPhone 3G, iPhone 3GS,
and the iPhone 4)
Handheld device (iPod, the iPod Nano, iPod the
Shuffle, the iPod Touch, the iPad, and iPad 2)
Software services (Mac, MobileMe, iCloud, iTunes)
In this case HTC 9 of the contested patent:
US6473006; US6708214; US6868283; US7289772;US7020849; US5418524; US5630152; US5630159;
US5302947. 4 of these patents, or August 15, Google
announced that $ 12.5 billion cash acquisition of
Motorola mobile company's patent, an average of one
patent valued at $ 500,000. In addition, five patents
originally belong to Openwave Systems, Palm, after the
2010 acquisition by HP. However, after being acquired
before the first valuable patents sold to Google, and
then sold the company to Hewlett-Packard.
According to the data of the investigation the United
States Patent Office, of the nine patents are by Google
on September 1 this year (2011) transferred to the
HTC. Google transfer the patent is in a position,
according to reports Google has confirmed the patent
transferred to HTC, but declined to comment on how
the transfer. The market for Google patent transfer
mode of operation is of great concern. HTC would notconfirm the amount of the acquisition of nine patents,
but it is understood, the actual amount is less than 300
million yuan.
In fact, on September 7, 2011 On this day, HTC also to
the ITC to propose amendments to the complaint
(Amended Complaint), for the last (August 16) cases,
five new patented accused Apple of infringing. 5 of the
contested patent, Google transferred to HTC thesenine, which is patent.
Page 8 of 12Patent Information: HTC [the Apple v Apple once again in the U.S. ITC court to sue HTC patent war
3/10/2012http://cdnet.stpi.org.tw/techroom/pclass/2011/pclass_11_A172.htm
Page 9 of 12Patent Information: HTC [the Apple v Apple once again in the U.S. ITC court to sue HTC patent war
-
7/31/2019 Apple vs HTC _English
9/12
Google is hoping that by providing patent umbrella to
actively strengthen the fighting capacity of the Android
camp, to help allies resist competitors attack, the
primary rival is Apple. Next, the Android camp counter-
attack was about to start a Google camp with Apple
and Microsoft, and even litigation between the patent
cockroaches melee will be more play more intense.
In recent years, high-tech industries through patent
war as a weapon to block competitors, not only
boosted the operating costs, but also raised the
barriers to entry. Actively engaged in mergers and
acquisitions, the main purpose is to patent. Intellectual
property patent on a highly competitive industry, the
increasingly important to the future survival of the key.
(Science and Technology Industrial Information
Management Office - Written May, 2011/09/08)
HTC report Apple
HTC to go further in August 15, 2011 Apple, Google
announced the acquisition of Motorola mobile companyhas enhanced the Android patent portfolio to $ 12.5
billion in cash, HTC in the U.S. ITC and Delaware
District Court with three counts of patent infringement
for the go further Apple-related patents on wireless
technology. The case of the contested patent three:
US7, 765,414; US7, 672,219; US7, 417,944, of which
944 and 219 patents are bought by HTC to ADC
Telecommunications strategic patent. HTC accused
Apple of infringing products, including: the iMac, theiPhone, iPad tablet machines, iPods, and other devices.
The pleadings Download:
Delaware Court of Justice, the U.S. ITC
HTC Apple patent is invalid in the United Kingdom
Intellectual Property Office
g[ pp pp g p w
3/10/2012http://cdnet.stpi.org.tw/techroom/pclass/2011/pclass_11_A172.htm
Page 10 of 12Patent Information: HTC [the Apple v Apple once again in the U.S. ITC court to sue HTC patent war
-
7/31/2019 Apple vs HTC _English
10/12
HTC's European subsidiary (HTC Europe) July 29, 2011
Apple patent invalid objection to the United Kingdom
Intellectual Property Office. According to the
speculation may be that two prior to the initial
impression in the U.S. ITC against the patent on the
operating system platform architecture and data
transfer mechanisms.
Apple to report the the HTC case, the U.S. ITC
administrative law judge to make the initial impression
HTC infringed
Report for Apple HTC case [337-TA-710], the U.S.International Trade Commission (ITC), the
Administrative Law Judge issued on July 15, 2011
initial decision (ID), HTC violated 10 patents, including
two patents in Apple ; U.S. 5,946,647 related to the
computer system and method of implementation of an
action in a structure on the data ", U.S. 6,343, 263
involved in the serial transmission of data real-time
signal processing systems".
This case a preliminary decision (Initial Determination),
identified the HTC products against Apple advocates
are two of the 10 patents, including patent 5,946,647
No. of 1, 8, 15 and 19 request items and 6,343,263
Patent No. 1, 2, 24 and 29 claims.
Case [337-TA-710] There is also a defendant as Nokia,
also convicted of the infringement. However, due to his
pre-sentence to achieve a comprehensive settlement
with Apple. Therefore, this judgment had no effect on
the Nokia.
ITC initial impression, not to the final determination.
Until this year (2011) the end of ITC ruled HTC
infringement determine, the ITC has the right to
prohibit the infringing products into the U.S.. Apple,
HTC, reconciliation, otherwise the product of HTC will
no longer export to the United States.
g[ pp pp g p
3/10/2012http://cdnet.stpi.org.tw/techroom/pclass/2011/pclass_11_A172.htm
Page 11 of 12Patent Information: HTC [the Apple v Apple once again in the U.S. ITC court to sue HTC patent war
-
7/31/2019 Apple vs HTC _English
11/12
Morgan Stanley estimates, assumptions HTC Each
phone 4-5 U.S. dollars will pay Apple royalties this year
(2011) estimated 50 million shipments, more than 9
percent is the Android system to calculate the total
premium of about 2.25 to $ 250 million.
ITC initial impression infringement of these two Apple
patent 647 and 263, also used against Motorola and
Nokia. Nokia phone leading position has long been
occupied, the cumulative number of important core
patented technology, forcing Apple had reached a
settlement with Nokia. Motorola since its inception in
1928, master has accumulated a lot of the core patents
should also be some bargaining chip in negotiations
with Apple. Since 2003 Apple to buy Freescale 200
patents. Freescale was Motorola's semiconductor
division in 2004, an independent portal. Therefore,
there is some cooperation between Apple and
Freescale.
However, entrants to this type of HTC, although by the
Google Android open platform and similar destructive
innovative attempt to open up a road, but seems to fall
into the Android and Apple and Microsoft camp siege.
HTC holding which chips are available, in addition to
the acquisition of S3 Graphics to the patent, but also
more chips to the job.
This is an apple war Android camp, it now appears the
apple slightly to stand upwind.
Preliminary information :
The Smartrac on Leighton filed RFID
patent non-infringement and invalid v.2011/07/07
Round Rock, patent licensing company,
sued Oracle and Dell violation of
computer chip patent
2011/07/07
Transcenic sued Microsoft and Google
Maps, 3D imaging patent infringement 2011/07/06
3/10/2012http://cdnet.stpi.org.tw/techroom/pclass/2011/pclass_11_A172.htm
Page 12 of 12Patent Information: HTC [the Apple v Apple once again in the U.S. ITC court to sue HTC patent war
-
7/31/2019 Apple vs HTC _English
12/12
4.5 billion of Apple's Microsoft alliance
grabbed Nortel patents2011/07/02
Random Biometrics, charged with Tyco
International and other companiesagainst biometrics patents
2011/06/29
... more
Touch the technology and market application
album
(Touchscreen Panel) in the United States patent
litigation survey
[Statement]a technology industry Information Office published the article does not mean that agree with the statement or description only provide more information, nor does it constitute any investment advice.Copyright, and by this website written consent shall not be modified in this article in any form, copy, store, disseminate or reproduce The Centre reserves the right to legal recourse.
National Applied Research Institute of Science and Technology Policy Research and Information Centre Information Service Technology Industry Information Room 2003-2009, All Rights Reserved.
Taipei 106-36 Heping East Road, Section No. 106, 14th floor (Science and Technology Building, 14th f loor) / TEL: (02) 2737-7660 / FAX: (02) 2737-7258 / Email: [email protected]
Version recommend MSIE 8.0 resolution of 1024x768 or higher Visitors: Since 2003/03/10 | page updated: 2012/01/09
3/10/2012http://cdnet.stpi.org.tw/techroom/pclass/2011/pclass_11_A172.htm