“magnetic fields in young galaxies” · 2013. 3. 14. · jennifer schober zentrum für...

25
Jennifer Schober Zentrum für Astronomie Heidelberg “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” Collaborators: Ralf Klessen, Simon Glover (Heidelberg, Germany) Dominik Schleicher, Stefano Bovino (Göttingen, Germany) Christoph Federrath (Melbourne, Australia) Robi Banerjee (Hamburg, Germany) MFU IV, Playa del Carmen 2013

Upload: others

Post on 14-Mar-2021

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” · 2013. 3. 14. · Jennifer Schober Zentrum für Astronomie Heidelberg “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” Collaborators: Ralf Klessen,

Jennifer Schober Zentrum für Astronomie Heidelberg

“Magnetic Fieldsin Young Galaxies”

Collaborators:

Ralf Klessen, Simon Glover (Heidelberg, Germany)Dominik Schleicher, Stefano Bovino (Göttingen, Germany)

Christoph Federrath (Melbourne, Australia)Robi Banerjee (Hamburg, Germany)

MFU IV, Playa del Carmen 2013

Page 2: “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” · 2013. 3. 14. · Jennifer Schober Zentrum für Astronomie Heidelberg “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” Collaborators: Ralf Klessen,

“ B-Fields in Young

Galaxies”

1. Introduction

2. Small-Scale Dynamo - Theory

3. Magnetic Fields in Primordial Halos

4. Conclusion

1. Introduction

J. Schober(ZAH Heidelberg)

Page 3: “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” · 2013. 3. 14. · Jennifer Schober Zentrum für Astronomie Heidelberg “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” Collaborators: Ralf Klessen,

1. Introduction

2. Small-Scale Dynamo - Theory

3. Magnetic Fields in Primordial Halos

4. Conclusion

The First Stars and Galaxies

[http://www.wpclipart.com/space/stars_universe/universe_timeline_light.jpg.html]

“ B-Fields in Young

Galaxies”

J. Schober(ZAH Heidelberg)

Page 4: “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” · 2013. 3. 14. · Jennifer Schober Zentrum für Astronomie Heidelberg “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” Collaborators: Ralf Klessen,

1. Introduction

2. Small-Scale Dynamo - Theory

3. Magnetic Fields in Primordial Halos

4. Conclusion

● turbulence driven by accretion and SN explosions

● weak magnetic seed fields

- phase transitions in the early Universe: [QCD phase transition, 10 Mpc comoving scale,e.g. Sigl et al. 1997]

- battery processes: [Biermann battery, kpc scale, e.g. Xu et al. 2008]

The First Stars and Galaxies

Fig.: Mach number in Primordial Halo[Greif et al. 2008]

=> dynamo action is possible

“ B-Fields in Young

Galaxies”

J. Schober(ZAH Heidelberg)

Page 5: “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” · 2013. 3. 14. · Jennifer Schober Zentrum für Astronomie Heidelberg “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” Collaborators: Ralf Klessen,

2. The Small-Scale Dynamo

“ B-Fields in Young

Galaxies”

1. Introduction

2. Small-Scale Dynamo - Theory

3. Magnetic Fields in Primordial Halos

4. Conclusion

J. Schober(ZAH Heidelberg)

Page 6: “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” · 2013. 3. 14. · Jennifer Schober Zentrum für Astronomie Heidelberg “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” Collaborators: Ralf Klessen,

1. Introduction

2. Small-Scale Dynamo - Theory

3. Magnetic Fields in Primordial Halos

4. Conclusion

Small-Scale Dynamo

● definition: “small-scale dynamo”

Mechanism that converts turbulent kinetic energy into magnetic energy.

● depends strongly on environment:

- magnetic Prandtl number

- type of turbulence (in inertial range)

Kolmogorov Burgers (incompressible) (highly compressible)

“ B-Fields in Young

Galaxies”

J. Schober(ZAH Heidelberg)

Page 7: “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” · 2013. 3. 14. · Jennifer Schober Zentrum für Astronomie Heidelberg “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” Collaborators: Ralf Klessen,

Stretch-Twist-Fold Dynamo

1. Introduction

2. Small-Scale Dynamo - Theory

3. Magnetic Fields in Primordial Halos

4. Conclusion

→ fastest on length scale with shortest eddy time scale = viscous scale (smallest scale of inertial range)

“ B-Fields in Young

Galaxies”

J. Schober(ZAH Heidelberg)

Page 8: “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” · 2013. 3. 14. · Jennifer Schober Zentrum für Astronomie Heidelberg “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” Collaborators: Ralf Klessen,

Kinematic Phase

1. Introduction

2. Small-Scale Dynamo - Theory

3. Magnetic Fields in Primordial Halos

4. Conclusion

“ B-Fields in Young

Galaxies”

● evolution of the spectrum (schematically):

J. Schober(ZAH Heidelberg)

Page 9: “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” · 2013. 3. 14. · Jennifer Schober Zentrum für Astronomie Heidelberg “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” Collaborators: Ralf Klessen,

Kinematic Phase

1. Introduction

2. Small-Scale Dynamo - Theory

3. Magnetic Fields in Primordial Halos

4. Conclusion

“ B-Fields in Young

Galaxies”

● evolution of the spectrum (schematically):

J. Schober(ZAH Heidelberg)

Page 10: “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” · 2013. 3. 14. · Jennifer Schober Zentrum für Astronomie Heidelberg “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” Collaborators: Ralf Klessen,

Kinematic Phase

1. Introduction

2. Small-Scale Dynamo - Theory

3. Magnetic Fields in Primordial Halos

4. Conclusion

“ B-Fields in Young

Galaxies”

● evolution of the spectrum (schematically):

J. Schober(ZAH Heidelberg)

Page 11: “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” · 2013. 3. 14. · Jennifer Schober Zentrum für Astronomie Heidelberg “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” Collaborators: Ralf Klessen,

● evolution of the spectrum (schematically):

● magnetic field growth:

(from Kazantsev theory)

● growth rate on :

[see also: Bovino et al. 2013]

Kinematic Phase

1. Introduction

2. Small-Scale Dynamo - Theory

3. Magnetic Fields in Primordial Halos

4. Conclusion

[Schober et al. 2012a]

[Schober et al. 2012c]

“ B-Fields in Young

Galaxies”

J. Schober(ZAH Heidelberg)

Page 12: “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” · 2013. 3. 14. · Jennifer Schober Zentrum für Astronomie Heidelberg “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” Collaborators: Ralf Klessen,

Non-Linear Phase

● evolution of the spectrum (schematically):

1. Introduction

2. Small-Scale Dynamo - Theory

3. Magnetic Fields in Primordial Halos

4. Conclusion

“ B-Fields in Young

Galaxies”

J. Schober(ZAH Heidelberg)

Page 13: “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” · 2013. 3. 14. · Jennifer Schober Zentrum für Astronomie Heidelberg “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” Collaborators: Ralf Klessen,

Non-Linear Phase

● evolution of the spectrum (schematically):

1. Introduction

2. Small-Scale Dynamo - Theory

3. Magnetic Fields in Primordial Halos

4. Conclusion

“ B-Fields in Young

Galaxies”

J. Schober(ZAH Heidelberg)

Page 14: “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” · 2013. 3. 14. · Jennifer Schober Zentrum für Astronomie Heidelberg “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” Collaborators: Ralf Klessen,

Non-Linear Phase

● evolution of the spectrum (schematically):

1. Introduction

2. Small-Scale Dynamo - Theory

3. Magnetic Fields in Primordial Halos

4. Conclusion

“ B-Fields in Young

Galaxies”

J. Schober(ZAH Heidelberg)

Page 15: “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” · 2013. 3. 14. · Jennifer Schober Zentrum für Astronomie Heidelberg “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” Collaborators: Ralf Klessen,

Non-Linear Phase

● evolution of the spectrum (schematically):

● Fokker-Planck model (see e.g. Schekochihin 2002) with assumption that peak scale shifts on eddy time scale

● no more dependence on

● magnetic field growth:

[Schleicher et al. 2013]

1. Introduction

2. Small-Scale Dynamo - Theory

3. Magnetic Fields in Primordial Halos

4. Conclusion

“ B-Fields in Young

Galaxies”

J. Schober(ZAH Heidelberg)

Page 16: “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” · 2013. 3. 14. · Jennifer Schober Zentrum für Astronomie Heidelberg “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” Collaborators: Ralf Klessen,

3. Magnetic Fieldsin Young Galaxies

“ B-Fields in Young

Galaxies”

1. Introduction

2. Small-Scale Dynamo - Theory

3. Magnetic Fields in Primordial Halos

4. Conclusion

J. Schober(ZAH Heidelberg)

Page 17: “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” · 2013. 3. 14. · Jennifer Schober Zentrum für Astronomie Heidelberg “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” Collaborators: Ralf Klessen,

● spherical core

● radius:

● density:

● temperature:

→ gas is ionised

● sources of turbulence:

- accretion

- SNe (not in this talk)

worst case assumption: compressive turbulence ( )

1. Introduction

2. Small-Scale Dynamo - Theory

3. Magnetic Fields in Primordial Halos

4. Conclusion

Simple Model for Primordial Halo

Fig.: Density in the center of a protogalaxy. [Latif et al. 2012]

“ B-Fields in Young

Galaxies”

J. Schober(ZAH Heidelberg)

Page 18: “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” · 2013. 3. 14. · Jennifer Schober Zentrum für Astronomie Heidelberg “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” Collaborators: Ralf Klessen,

● viscosity:

● resistivity:

● sound speed:

● turbulent velocity:

Mach number percentage that goes into turbulence

(motivated by simulation of protogalaxies by Latif et al. 2012)

● Reynolds numbers:

(hydrodynamic)

(magnetic)

1. Introduction

2. Small-Scale Dynamo - Theory

3. Magnetic Fields in Primordial Halos

4. Conclusion

Simple Model for Primordial Halo“ B-Fields in Young

Galaxies”

J. Schober(ZAH Heidelberg)

Page 19: “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” · 2013. 3. 14. · Jennifer Schober Zentrum für Astronomie Heidelberg “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” Collaborators: Ralf Klessen,

Kinematic Phase

● kinematic growth of magnetic energy (on viscous scale):

● maximum field strength:

from equipartition efficiency factor for with kinetic energy Mach 2 and compressive forcing (Federrath et al. 2011) scaling velocity down to viscous scale

1. Introduction

2. Small-Scale Dynamo - Theory

3. Magnetic Fields in Primordial Halos

4. Conclusion

“ B-Fields in Young

Galaxies”

J. Schober(ZAH Heidelberg)

Page 20: “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” · 2013. 3. 14. · Jennifer Schober Zentrum für Astronomie Heidelberg “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” Collaborators: Ralf Klessen,

J. Schober(ZAH Heidelberg)

Kinematic Phase

● kinematic growth of magnetic energy (on viscous scale):

● maximum field strength:

1. Introduction

2. Small-Scale Dynamo - Theory

3. Magnetic Fields in Primordial Halos

4. Conclusion

“ B-Fields in Young

Galaxies”

Page 21: “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” · 2013. 3. 14. · Jennifer Schober Zentrum für Astronomie Heidelberg “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” Collaborators: Ralf Klessen,

Non-Linear Phase

● non-linear growth of magnetic energy :

● maximum field strength on forcing scale:

from equipartition efficiency factor for with kinetic energy Mach 2 and compressive

forcing (Federrath et al. 2011)

1. Introduction

2. Small-Scale Dynamo - Theory

3. Magnetic Fields in Primordial Halos

4. Conclusion

“ B-Fields in Young

Galaxies”

J. Schober(ZAH Heidelberg)

Page 22: “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” · 2013. 3. 14. · Jennifer Schober Zentrum für Astronomie Heidelberg “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” Collaborators: Ralf Klessen,

Non-Linear Phase

● non-linear growth of magnetic energy :

● maximum field strength on forcing scale:

1. Introduction

2. Small-Scale Dynamo - Theory

3. Magnetic Fields in Primordial Halos

4. Conclusion

“ B-Fields in Young

Galaxies”

J. Schober(ZAH Heidelberg)

Page 23: “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” · 2013. 3. 14. · Jennifer Schober Zentrum für Astronomie Heidelberg “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” Collaborators: Ralf Klessen,

4. Conclusions

“ B-Fields in Young

Galaxies”

1. Introduction

2. Small-Scale Dynamo - Theory

3. Magnetic Fields in Primordial Halos

4. Conclusion

J. Schober(ZAH Heidelberg)

Page 24: “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” · 2013. 3. 14. · Jennifer Schober Zentrum für Astronomie Heidelberg “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” Collaborators: Ralf Klessen,

1. Introduction

2. Small-Scale Dynamo - Theory

3. Magnetic Fields in Primordial Halos

4. Conclusion

● dynamo amplification in kinematic phase:

● dynamo amplification in non-linear phase:

● small-scale dynamo in formation of first stars & galaxies:

Dynamical important magnetic fields can be generated on small time scales compared to free-fall time.

=> magnetisation of the primordial ISM

Conclusion“ B-Fields in Young

Galaxies”

J. Schober(ZAH Heidelberg)

Page 25: “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” · 2013. 3. 14. · Jennifer Schober Zentrum für Astronomie Heidelberg “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” Collaborators: Ralf Klessen,

Thanks for your attention!

Further questions/comments?→ [email protected]