“continuous metered injection of coal into … · balance of gasifier island 113,116 113,116...

31
“CONTINUOUS METERED INJECTION OF COAL INTO GASIFICATION AND PFBC SYSTEM OPERATING PRESSURES EXCEEDING 38 Bar (560 PSI)” Authors: Authors: Derek Aldred, Timothy Saunders Derek Aldred, Timothy Saunders - Stamet Inc., Stamet Inc., International Freiberg Conference on IGCC & International Freiberg Conference on IGCC & XtL XtL Technologies Technologies June 16-18, 2005

Upload: others

Post on 20-Aug-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: “CONTINUOUS METERED INJECTION OF COAL INTO … · Balance of Gasifier Island 113,116 113,116 Total Gasifier Island 158,249 131,014 TOTAL GASIFIER ISLAND ($/kW) 611 516. Plant Operating

“CONTINUOUS METERED INJECTION OF COAL INTO GASIFICATION AND PFBC

SYSTEM OPERATING PRESSURES EXCEEDING 38 Bar (560 PSI)”

Authors:Authors: Derek Aldred, Timothy Saunders Derek Aldred, Timothy Saunders -- Stamet Inc., Stamet Inc.,

International Freiberg Conference on IGCC & International Freiberg Conference on IGCC & XtLXtLTechnologiesTechnologies

June 16-18, 2005

Page 2: “CONTINUOUS METERED INJECTION OF COAL INTO … · Balance of Gasifier Island 113,116 113,116 Total Gasifier Island 158,249 131,014 TOTAL GASIFIER ISLAND ($/kW) 611 516. Plant Operating

DOE Advanced Gasification Objectives:DOE Advanced Gasification Objectives:

• Expanding Coal-based power production.

• Efficient use of fossil-fuel resources, particularly coal.

• Minimizing emissions.

• Higher operating pressures for improved performance.

• Commercial acceptance.

Page 3: “CONTINUOUS METERED INJECTION OF COAL INTO … · Balance of Gasifier Island 113,116 113,116 Total Gasifier Island 158,249 131,014 TOTAL GASIFIER ISLAND ($/kW) 611 516. Plant Operating

Gasification Feed Objectives:Gasification Feed Objectives:

• Provide a simple, accurate and reliable feed system.

• Establish controlled, continuous level delivery of coal.

• Minimize gas losses.

• Eliminate high maintenance costs and substantial risks of downtime for existing feed systems.

• Inject at pressures at and beyond 500 PSI (34 Bar).

Page 4: “CONTINUOUS METERED INJECTION OF COAL INTO … · Balance of Gasifier Island 113,116 113,116 Total Gasifier Island 158,249 131,014 TOTAL GASIFIER ISLAND ($/kW) 611 516. Plant Operating

““FIRTH” Solids PumpFIRTH” Solids Pump

•First Prototype 1978

•Tested the week oil shale program cancelled!

•Concept idle for 10 years

•Stamet Inc., formed to develop concept

Page 5: “CONTINUOUS METERED INJECTION OF COAL INTO … · Balance of Gasifier Island 113,116 113,116 Total Gasifier Island 158,249 131,014 TOTAL GASIFIER ISLAND ($/kW) 611 516. Plant Operating

Stamet Stamet ““PosimetricPosimetric®”®” Pump TechnologyPump Technology

• Unique concept named for “Positive Metering” of solids.

•One simple continuously rotating element, providing precise flow control.

•Configured machines can deliver solids directly into atmospheric or pressurized environments.

Page 6: “CONTINUOUS METERED INJECTION OF COAL INTO … · Balance of Gasifier Island 113,116 113,116 Total Gasifier Island 158,249 131,014 TOTAL GASIFIER ISLAND ($/kW) 611 516. Plant Operating

Posimetric Pressure Pump ConfigurationPosimetric Pressure Pump Configuration

Page 7: “CONTINUOUS METERED INJECTION OF COAL INTO … · Balance of Gasifier Island 113,116 113,116 Total Gasifier Island 158,249 131,014 TOTAL GASIFIER ISLAND ($/kW) 611 516. Plant Operating

First Posimetric First Posimetric Pressure FeederPressure Feeder

•Development Funded by US DOE Clean Coal Program (1994)

•Feeder achieved then record coal injection pressure - over 250 PSI (17 Bar) gas environment

Page 8: “CONTINUOUS METERED INJECTION OF COAL INTO … · Balance of Gasifier Island 113,116 113,116 Total Gasifier Island 158,249 131,014 TOTAL GASIFIER ISLAND ($/kW) 611 516. Plant Operating

Current DOE Research ProgramCurrent DOE Research Program

• Two year Program schedule Gasifier Visits – define industry needs

– identify typical Coal specificationsSelect Commercial Fuel for Feeder Testing.

• Two-Phased approach:1. Develop semi-scale intermediate pressure feeder2. Develop semi-scale full pressure feeder

Page 9: “CONTINUOUS METERED INJECTION OF COAL INTO … · Balance of Gasifier Island 113,116 113,116 Total Gasifier Island 158,249 131,014 TOTAL GASIFIER ISLAND ($/kW) 611 516. Plant Operating

Test Feeder Spool AssemblyTest Feeder Spool Assembly

• Shaft

• 2 Discs

• Hub Spacer

• 1 Bearing (of 2)

Page 10: “CONTINUOUS METERED INJECTION OF COAL INTO … · Balance of Gasifier Island 113,116 113,116 Total Gasifier Island 158,249 131,014 TOTAL GASIFIER ISLAND ($/kW) 611 516. Plant Operating

Test Feeder BodyTest Feeder Body

• Side view showing seal and bearing location

• Body designed for ease of outlet removal and modification

Page 11: “CONTINUOUS METERED INJECTION OF COAL INTO … · Balance of Gasifier Island 113,116 113,116 Total Gasifier Island 158,249 131,014 TOTAL GASIFIER ISLAND ($/kW) 611 516. Plant Operating

Test Feeder Rig AssemblyTest Feeder Rig Assembly

• Compact for portability

• Tested at multiple locations

• 600 Psi (40 Bar) Vessel pressure rating

Page 12: “CONTINUOUS METERED INJECTION OF COAL INTO … · Balance of Gasifier Island 113,116 113,116 Total Gasifier Island 158,249 131,014 TOTAL GASIFIER ISLAND ($/kW) 611 516. Plant Operating

Phase 1 Successful Gas Pressure RunPhase 1 Successful Gas Pressure Run

First Run to 300psi

0

50

100

150

200

250

300

350

0 10 20 30 40

Time

Pre

ssur

e, p

sig

0

5000

10000

15000

20000

25000

30000

Torq

ue

Pout psi

Torque ft/lb 300psi Achieved24 Bar >

<33900 Nm

Torque

Page 13: “CONTINUOUS METERED INJECTION OF COAL INTO … · Balance of Gasifier Island 113,116 113,116 Total Gasifier Island 158,249 131,014 TOTAL GASIFIER ISLAND ($/kW) 611 516. Plant Operating

Phase 1 Torque Effect on CoalPhase 1 Torque Effect on Coal

• Compacted Coal Extruded in Feeder Outlet

• High Torque Cause/Effect

• Plug Size 25mm x 50mm x 200mm

Page 14: “CONTINUOUS METERED INJECTION OF COAL INTO … · Balance of Gasifier Island 113,116 113,116 Total Gasifier Island 158,249 131,014 TOTAL GASIFIER ISLAND ($/kW) 611 516. Plant Operating

Phase 1 Outlet ChangesPhase 1 Outlet Changes

Page 15: “CONTINUOUS METERED INJECTION OF COAL INTO … · Balance of Gasifier Island 113,116 113,116 Total Gasifier Island 158,249 131,014 TOTAL GASIFIER ISLAND ($/kW) 611 516. Plant Operating

Phase 1 AchievementsPhase 1 Achievements

• Target Feeding into 300psi (20 Bar) Gas Pressure Successfully Achieved

• Optimization Reduced Torque 25%

• Delivery Linear across Full Pressure Range

• High Grip Achieved from Design - Potential for Reduced Machine Size

Page 16: “CONTINUOUS METERED INJECTION OF COAL INTO … · Balance of Gasifier Island 113,116 113,116 Total Gasifier Island 158,249 131,014 TOTAL GASIFIER ISLAND ($/kW) 611 516. Plant Operating

PhasePhase 2 Objectives2 Objectives

• Develop, test and modify as required a machine for injection of coal into 500 PSI (34 Bar).

• Outline commercial Posimetric® Pump design for coal injection at 500 PSI (34 Bar).

Page 17: “CONTINUOUS METERED INJECTION OF COAL INTO … · Balance of Gasifier Island 113,116 113,116 Total Gasifier Island 158,249 131,014 TOTAL GASIFIER ISLAND ($/kW) 611 516. Plant Operating

Phase 2 Flow AnalysisPhase 2 Flow Analysis

• Clear disc testing

• Beads used to identify flow regime

• Valuable visualization

of internal flow patterns

Page 18: “CONTINUOUS METERED INJECTION OF COAL INTO … · Balance of Gasifier Island 113,116 113,116 Total Gasifier Island 158,249 131,014 TOTAL GASIFIER ISLAND ($/kW) 611 516. Plant Operating

Phase 2 Outlet ChangesPhase 2 Outlet Changes

• Revised outlet produced by 3D techniques

• Smoothed transition for flow exiting discs

• Outlet length reduced progressively to determine effect on torque

Page 19: “CONTINUOUS METERED INJECTION OF COAL INTO … · Balance of Gasifier Island 113,116 113,116 Total Gasifier Island 158,249 131,014 TOTAL GASIFIER ISLAND ($/kW) 611 516. Plant Operating

Phase 2 Success!Phase 2 Success!

Page 20: “CONTINUOUS METERED INJECTION OF COAL INTO … · Balance of Gasifier Island 113,116 113,116 Total Gasifier Island 158,249 131,014 TOTAL GASIFIER ISLAND ($/kW) 611 516. Plant Operating

Phase 2 FlowPhase 2 Flow--rate Linearityrate Linearity

02-113 DOE Pressure Injection -Test 216. Feeding at 500 psi

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

0 10 20 30 40 50

Cumulative Revs

Wei

ght

Pum

ped,

lbs

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

Ou

tlet

Pre

ssu

re, p

si /

%

Sp

eed

.

Outlet Pressure

Weight Pumped

% Speed

< 48 Bar45 Kg >

Page 21: “CONTINUOUS METERED INJECTION OF COAL INTO … · Balance of Gasifier Island 113,116 113,116 Total Gasifier Island 158,249 131,014 TOTAL GASIFIER ISLAND ($/kW) 611 516. Plant Operating

Phase 2 Gas ConsumptionPhase 2 Gas Consumption

Make-up Gas Consumption vs Outlet Pressure

0

0.25

0.5

0.75

1

1.25

1.5

200 250 300 350 400 450 500 550

Outlet Pressure, psi

Mak

e-u

p G

as C

on

sum

pti

on

, scf

m

^38 Bar

0.04 M3 >

Page 22: “CONTINUOUS METERED INJECTION OF COAL INTO … · Balance of Gasifier Island 113,116 113,116 Total Gasifier Island 158,249 131,014 TOTAL GASIFIER ISLAND ($/kW) 611 516. Plant Operating

Phase 2 Geometry Optimization ResultsPhase 2 Geometry Optimization Results

Outlet Pressure vs Drive Torque Requirements

0

2000

4000

6000

8000

10000

12000

14000

16000

18000

20000

0 100 200 300 400 500 600

Outlet Pressure, psig

Dri

ve T

orq

ue,

ft.

lbs.

Phase 1 Start

Phase 1 Final

Phase 2

^41 Bar

27000 Nm>

Page 23: “CONTINUOUS METERED INJECTION OF COAL INTO … · Balance of Gasifier Island 113,116 113,116 Total Gasifier Island 158,249 131,014 TOTAL GASIFIER ISLAND ($/kW) 611 516. Plant Operating

Phase 2 Coal ConditionPhase 2 Coal Condition

• Coal extrusion showing little consolidation.

• “Log” breaks up easily indicating minimal impact from pressure rise.

Page 24: “CONTINUOUS METERED INJECTION OF COAL INTO … · Balance of Gasifier Island 113,116 113,116 Total Gasifier Island 158,249 131,014 TOTAL GASIFIER ISLAND ($/kW) 611 516. Plant Operating

Phase 2 AchievementsPhase 2 Achievements

• Record pressure level achieved – 560 PSI (38 Bar).

• Very consistent feeder performance.

• Torque reduced 70% over Phase 1.

• Continued linear output against pressure.

• No problems stopping or starting against pressure.

• Coal at outlet little changed from that at inlet.

Page 25: “CONTINUOUS METERED INJECTION OF COAL INTO … · Balance of Gasifier Island 113,116 113,116 Total Gasifier Island 158,249 131,014 TOTAL GASIFIER ISLAND ($/kW) 611 516. Plant Operating

Phase 2 DeliverablesPhase 2 Deliverables

• Commercial design arrangement finalized.

• Semi-commercial test location identified.

• Off-line site tests anticipated before yearend 2005.

Page 26: “CONTINUOUS METERED INJECTION OF COAL INTO … · Balance of Gasifier Island 113,116 113,116 Total Gasifier Island 158,249 131,014 TOTAL GASIFIER ISLAND ($/kW) 611 516. Plant Operating

Economic Benefit AnalysisEconomic Benefit Analysis

• Pump Performance data Provided to DOE

• DOE/Parsons Undertaking Benefits Analysis

• Study of Capital and operating cost Savings for Transport and Oxygen Blown (Shell) Gasifiers

• Stamet Pump Eliminates Coal Slurrying/Drying

Page 27: “CONTINUOUS METERED INJECTION OF COAL INTO … · Balance of Gasifier Island 113,116 113,116 Total Gasifier Island 158,249 131,014 TOTAL GASIFIER ISLAND ($/kW) 611 516. Plant Operating

Plant Capital Cost AnalysisPlant Capital Cost Analysis

Transport Gasifier

Plant Area ($000’s) Design W/Stamet

Coal Prep and Feed 44,473 17,069

Engineering & Contingency 11,118 6,828Auxiliary Power 835 1,988

TOTAL CAPITAL COSTS 56,426 25,885

Balance of Gasifier Island 75,942 75,942

Total Gasifier Island 132,368 101,827

TOTAL GASIFIER ISLAND ($/KW) 437 339

Page 28: “CONTINUOUS METERED INJECTION OF COAL INTO … · Balance of Gasifier Island 113,116 113,116 Total Gasifier Island 158,249 131,014 TOTAL GASIFIER ISLAND ($/kW) 611 516. Plant Operating

Plant Capital Cost AnalysisPlant Capital Cost Analysis

Shell Gasifier IGCC

Plant Area ($000’s) Design W/Stamet

Coal Prep and Feed 35,670 11,856

Engineering & Contingency 8,918 4,742Auxiliary Power 546 1,300

TOTAL CAPITAL COSTS 45,134 17,898

Balance of Gasifier Island 113,116 113,116

Total Gasifier Island 158,249 131,014

TOTAL GASIFIER ISLAND ($/kW) 611 516

Page 29: “CONTINUOUS METERED INJECTION OF COAL INTO … · Balance of Gasifier Island 113,116 113,116 Total Gasifier Island 158,249 131,014 TOTAL GASIFIER ISLAND ($/kW) 611 516. Plant Operating

Plant Operating Cost AnalysisPlant Operating Cost Analysis

Transport Gasifier

Plant Output (kWe) Design W/StametGas Turbine Power 197,000 197,000

Steam Turbine Power 140,540 144,000

Auxiliary Load 35,770 39,923

Net Plant Power 301,770 301,077

Net Plant Efficiency (HHV) 40.5% 40.7%

Net Plant Heat Rate (HHV) 8,416 8,386

Page 30: “CONTINUOUS METERED INJECTION OF COAL INTO … · Balance of Gasifier Island 113,116 113,116 Total Gasifier Island 158,249 131,014 TOTAL GASIFIER ISLAND ($/kW) 611 516. Plant Operating

Plant Operating Cost AnalysisPlant Operating Cost Analysis

Shell Gasifier IGCC

Plant Output (kWe) Design W/StametGas Turbine Power 197,000 197,000

Steam Turbine Power 105,292 107,600

Auxiliary Load 43,150 44,240

Net Plant Power 259,142 260,360

Net Plant Efficiency (HHV) 40.6% 40.9%

Net Plant Heat Rate (HHV) 8,411 8,345

Page 31: “CONTINUOUS METERED INJECTION OF COAL INTO … · Balance of Gasifier Island 113,116 113,116 Total Gasifier Island 158,249 131,014 TOTAL GASIFIER ISLAND ($/kW) 611 516. Plant Operating

Phase 3 ProgramPhase 3 Program

Expectations:

• 1000 PSI (69 Bar) target for DOE Phase 3.

• Further torque reductions anticipated from

ongoing optimization program.

• Commercial 500 PSI (34 Bar) feeder in 2005.

• 1300 PSI (90 Bar) commercial target requested.

Proposal Submitted – Awaiting Award!