another major company drops cargill over deforestation ......2020/07/06 · received by nsd/fara...

Received by NSD/FARA Registration Unit 07/06/2020 6:31:12 PM7/6/20 6 17 PM

Another major company drops Cargill over deforestation concerns

Alex Armstrong Mon 7/6/2020 10:41 AM

To: Press

MIGHTY EARTH

Another Major Company Drops Cargill over DeforestationConcerns

IntraFish reports that "Global salmon giant Grieg Seafood has excluded Cargill Aqua Nutrition from the proceeds of its $92 million green bond until its parent company Cargill has significantly reduced its soy-related deforestation risk in Brazil." In response to the news, Mighty Earth CEO Glenn Hurowitz released the following statement:

"Cargill's recklessness has destroyed forests, fueled climate change, displaced Indigenous communities, and imperiled workers from vulnerable communities in its meat plants. But today, a new victim of Cargill's recklessness has emerged - Cargill itself.

"Norwegian salmon company Grieg Seafood has announced that it will exclude Cargill from its $92 million green bond, citing concerns about Cargill's ties to deforestation in Brazil. This news is just the latest blow to Cargill's bottom line, as a growing number of consumer-facing companies are unwilling to associate their hard-earned brands with Cargill's sullied reputation. Late last year, Nestle announced it would cease purchases of Cargill's Brazilian soybeans over fears they were being grown on deforested land.

"Cargill has responded with the usual vague statements and commitments that never seem to find their way beyond a piece of paper. Major supermarket chains like Costco and Casino should take notice: Cargill hasn't changed, and doing business with deforesters is a liability that your customers will no longer accept."

Resources:

Mighty Earth reports

• Cargill: The Worst Company in the World• The Companies Behind the Burning of the Amazon• How the Sausage Gets Made

https//out oo off ce com/ma / nbox/ d/AAQ AD yYz 4NDcyLTgwNWQtNDB MSIhYTV LTM4ZWQwZ zN czNQAQALextf V5fFG 2ZQwGv6aec%3D Page 1 of 2

Received by NSD/FARA Registration Unit 07/06/2020 6:31:12 PM

7/6/20 6 17 PM

• The Ultimate Mystery Meat: Exposing the Secrets Behind Burger King and Global Meat Production

• Still At It: Cargill and Bunge Caught Destroying the Equivalent of 10,000 Football Fields for the Global Meat Trade

• Avoidable Crisis: The European Meat Industry's Environmental Catastrophe

Additional materials

• Video: Protecting Forests to Prevent Pandemics• Stop Destroying the Planet & Shop Responsibly• Grocery Stores Threatening Brazil Boycott Must Go Further to Truly Protect Forests• Big Meat Companies Are Making the Pandemic Worse• In 2020. Retailers Must Stop Stocking Environmental Destruction

High resolution photos and videos are available for use - please contact [email protected] for access.


ALEX ARMSTRONG I Senior Director I [email protected] us: Facebook I Twitter

Mighty Earth is responsible for the content of this message. The information in this email and any attachments is confidential and is intended for the addressee only. If you are not the intended recipient, please delete this message and any attachments and advise the sender.

The work of Mighty Earth is supported by Waxman Strategies. Waxman Strategies’ work on forest conservation is funded in part by the European Federation for Transport and Environment, the Center for International Policy, and AidEnvironment. Waxman is required under 22 U.S.C. § 614 to disclose that this material is distributed on behalf of the aforementioned

organization, working under grant from the Norwegian Agency for Development Cooperation. Additional information is on file with the Department of Justice, Washington, D. C.

https//out oo off ce com/ma / nbox/ d/AAQ AD yYz 4NDcyLTgwNWQtNDB MSIhYTV LTM4ZWQwZ zN czNQAQALextf V5fFG 2ZQwGv6aec%3D Page 2 of 2


Received by NSD/FARA Registration Unit 07/06/2020 6:31:12 PM 7/6/20 6 17 PM

Re: Samling Scorecard

Asha Sharma Mon 7/6/2020 12:53 PM

To: Deshpande, Girish Cc: Mcaneny, Jack

@pg.com>@pg.com>; Rapid Response ; Phil Aikman

|| 1 attachments (3 MB)

Rapid Response Report 27 final v2[1].pdf;

Hi Girish,

Thank you again for your response. As we continue to have internal conversations on the topic, I had a couple of clarifying questions that I don’t think we’ve addressed yet.

1. P&G has Sarawak Oil Palms (SOPB) listed in its mill list, which is still sourcing from Samling as highlighted in Rapid Response report 27 (p. 21 attached). SOPB has recently told us directly that some of the Samling CPO and PKO, bought by SOPB, is sold to other traders. How is P&G addressing this Samling risk with its Tier 1 suppliers?

2. Also, we have been informed by a trader that Kwantas Corporation (listed in P&G’s mill list) may also be sourcing from Samling. How is P&G addressing this potential Samling risk with its Tier 1 suppliers?

Given the complexities, we continue to recommend a company-wide suspension of Samling palm oil to ensure leakage does occur in the present or future into P&G’s supply chains.

Thank you,Asha

ASHA SHARMA I DIRECTOR I [email protected] us: Facehook I Twitter

The work of Mighty Earth is supported by Waxman Strategies. Waxman Strategies' work on forest conservation is funded in part by

Aidenvironment. Waxman is required under 22 U.S.C. §614 to disclose that this material is distributed on behalf of the aforementioned

organization, working under grant from the Norwegian Agency for Development Cooperation. Additional information is on file with the

Department of Justice, Washington, D.C.



MIGHTY EARTH

RAPID RESPONSEPalm Oil Report


Table of ContentsCases identified using Sentinel imagery

Indonesian Companies

New Case

Fangiono family companies: PT Agrindo Green Lestari

Unresolved. Cases

QL Resources Bhd: PT Pipit Mutiara Indah

Wings Agro Group: PT Indopenta Sejahtera Abadi

Samling: PT Tunas Borneo Plantations

Malaysian Companies

Unresolved Case

Samling: LPF/0007 Samling Jelalong (OP)

Additional cases identified using filtered GLAD alerts

New Cases — No Known Supply Chain Links

PT Buana Pratama Cipta (formerly Provident Agro): PT Banyan Tumbuh Lestari

Unknown Group: PT Tualang Raya

Repeat Cases — Known Supply Chain Links

Sepanjang Group: PT Permata Sawit Mandiri

Widya Corporation: PT Mulia Inti Perkasa

Indonusa Group: PT Internusa Jaya Sejahtera

NPC Resources Bhd: PT Sumber Alam Selaras

Mulia Sawit Group: PT Persada Era Agro Kencana

Dharma Satya Nusantara: PT Putra Utama Lestari

Capitol Group: PT Medcopapua Hijau Selaras

Dhanistha Suiya Nusantara: PT Sabhantara Rawi Sentosa

Pinehill Pacific: PT Makmur Jaya Malindo

Global Enterprise Sdn Bhd: PT Bulungan Suiya Mas Pratama 2

Bumitama Group: PT Damai Agro Sejahtera

Dharma Satya Nusantara: PT Putra Utama Lestari

Hayel Saeed Anam Group: PT Megakaiya Jaya Raya

Samuel International Group: PT Bina Sarana Sawit Utama

Genting Plantations Bhd: PT Citra Sawit Cemerlang

Fangiono family companies: PT Tirta Madu Sawit Jaya


5

9

13

16

22

2 7

2 7

28

28

28

28

28

28

28

28

28

28

28

28

29

29

29

29

29


Additional cases identified using filtered GLAD alerts (continued)


Table of Contents

Repeat Cases - Known Supply Chain Links (continued)

Mulia Sawit Group: PT Persada Era Agro Kencana 29

Global Enterprise Sdn Bhd: PT Bulungan Surya Mas Pratama 29

Asian Agri (RGE): PT Usalia Sawit Unggul 29

Makin Group: PT Mekar Karya Kahuripan 29

CB Industrial Product Holding: PT Jaya Jadi Utama 29

Anglo-Eastern Plantations: PT Kahayan Agro Plantation 29

Shin Yang Group: LPF/0018 Shin Yang OP Planting Area 29

KTS Holdings Sdn Bhd: BED Plantation Bhd 29

Puncak Niaga Holdings Bhd: Danum Sinar Sdn Bhd 30

Shin Yang Group / Sarawak Oil Palms Bhd: Dataran Linau Sdn Bhd (Lot 1 Block 14 Murum LD) 30

BBC Holdings Sdn Bhd: Ahnabumi Plantation Sdn Bhd 30

Rimbunan Hijau Group: Woodijaya Sdn Bhd (Lot 197) 30

Samling Group: LPF/0006 Samling Lana 30

Shin Yang Group: Linau Sinar Sdn Bhd (Metalon OP Estate, Lot 2, Danum LD) 30

Woodman Group: Baram Estate, part of LPF/0004 30

Rimbunan Hijau Group: Timrest Sdn Bhd 30

TH Plantations Bhd: Hydroflow Sdn Bhd 30

Woodman Group: Adong estate, part of LPF 0004 30

Rimbunan Hijau Group: Poh Zhen Sdn Bhd 30

Repeat Cases - No Known Supply Chain Links

Korompis family: PT Berau Karetindo Lestari 31

Green Yield Pte Ltd: PT Tri Investama 31

Unknown Group: PT Prasetya Mitra Muda (Block II) 31

Unknown Group: PT Marita Makmur Jaya 31

Unknown Group: PT Gapura Alas Lestari 31

JSK International Co Ltd (Korea): PT Future Agropia Indonesia 31

Unknown Group: PT Citrapermata Serundung 31

IMC Plantations: PT Perkebunan Inti Sendawar 31

Supply chain information:Supply chain information included in Rapid Response reports is based on the latest public versions of mill disclosures, recent export data and grievance logs. Mighty Earth encourages companies to send updated versions of mill disclosures as soon as they become available and to share any decision to suspend relations with a given group/company listed in those mill disclosures; please send to [email protected].

Mighty Earth is now including biofuel companies in the supply chain tables of Rapid Response reports, as these companies have both direct and indirect trading relationships with groups highlighted in these reports and should be filing grievances on these cases. These biofuel companies are listed in the ‘Traders and Biofuel Companies” tables.


Additional cases identified using filtered GLAD alerts (continued)

Repeat Cases - No Known Supply Chain Links (continned)


Table of Contents

Unknown Group: PT Cipta Karya Sesayap 31

Unknown Group: PT Sumber Sawit Mitrajaya 31

Unknown Group: PT Pipit Citra Persada 31

Shanghai Xinjiu Chemical Co Ltd: PT Sebaung Sawit Plantation 31

Unknown Group: PT Barito Riau Jaya 31

Unknown Group: PT Triomas Forestry Development Indonesia 31

Henan Jiujiu Chemical Co. Ltd: PT Palem Segar Lestari 32

Unknown Group: PT Menthobi Mitra Lestari 32

Starmas Sentosa Mandiri: PT Agrindo Sukses Sejahtera 32

Unknown Group: Telliana Enterprise Sdn Bhd 32

Unknown Group: Formerly Ekran Bhd 32

Unknown Group: Titanium Management Sdn Bhd (Part 1) 32

Unknown Group: Titanium Management Sdn Bhd (Part 2) 32

Lee Ling Timber Sdn Bhd: Limba Jaya Timber Sdn Bhd (Limbang) 32

Lee Ling Timber Sdn Bhd: LPF/0038 Limba Jaya Timber Sdn Bhd (Part 2) 32

Supply chain information:Supply chain information included in Rapid Response reports is based on the latest public versions of mill disclosures, recent export data and grievance logs. Mighty Earth encourages companies to send updated versions of mill disclosures as soon as they become available and to share any decision to suspend relations with a given group/company listed in those mill disclosures; please send to [email protected].

Mighty Earth is now including biofuel companies in the supply chain tables of Rapid Response reports, as these companies have both direct and indirect trading relationships with groups highlighted in these reports and should be filing grievances on these cases. These biofuel companies are listed in the ‘Traders and Biofuel Companies” tables.



Group: Fangiono family companiesPT Agrindo Green LestariConcession location: (-1.691, 113.874)

Deforestation and/or peat development

Report

Report 27

Deforestation(ha)

149

Peatdevelopment

(ha)

Peat forest Clearancedevelopment prep/Stacking

(ha) lines(ha)Time period

September 11,2019- February 23, 2020

Satellite imagery (see below) shows that between September 11,2019 and February 23, 2020 a total of 149 hectares of forest were cleared in the PT Agrindo Green Lestari concession. (Imagery: Contains modified Copernicus Sentinel data 2020)

VietnamPhilippines

Malaysia

Ifeionesia

PT Agrindo Green g ^PT Qwi Lmumi



Alert Imagery (before and after satellite images)Clearance location: (-1.715, 113.889)

Date: September 11,2019 Date: February 23, 2020

Mr

"ti» i (in 11

•i.i n

Clearance location: (-1.659, 113.867)

Date: September 11, 2019 Date: February 23, 2020

li ■ rt'\.

9** 'll)

t

**M

Ownership InformationPT Agrindo Green Lestari is part of the Ciliandry Anky Abadi Group (CAA),1 owned by the Fangiono family. The Fangiono family also owns Fangiono Agro Plantation (FAP).

l. Notary deeds


Supply Chain Information


Supply Chain Links: Traders and Biofuel Companies

PT Agrindo Green

Lestari

Itochu Musim Mas

Ciliandry Anky Abadi/Fangiono Agro Plantation


PT Agrindo Green

Lestari

Neste Olam Sime Darby Wilmar


Supply Chain Links: Consumer Brands

PT Agrindo Green

Lestari

AvonColgate-Palmolive

Danone FrieslandCampina



PT Agrindo Green

Lestari

General Mills HersheyJohnson & Johnson

Kellogg's




Supply Chain Information (continued)


Mondelez Nestle PepsiCo

PT Agrindo Green

Lestari



Reckitt Benckiser Unilever Vandemoortele

PT Agrindo Green Lestari




Group: QL Resources Bhd

PT Pipit Mutiara IndahConcession location: (3.349, 11 7.220)


Report

Report 21

Deforestation(ha)

50

Peat Peat forest Clearancedevelopme development prep/Stacking

nt(ha) (ha) lines(ha)Time period

January 3-October 20, 2019

Report 27 25December 22, 2019-

March 16, 2020

Satellite imagery (see below) shows that between December 22, 2019 and March 16, 2020 a total of 25 hectares of forest were cleared in the PT Pipit Mutiara Indah concession. (Imagery: Contains modified Copernicus Sentinel data 2020)

aj

VietnamPhilippines

PT Pipit Mutiara Indah £ ^ j

PT P*p« W iti nr« Indah

Mc-Olr^Uui 9C<

'• " V .. .

alaysia

Indonesia

.#>•• r o- *



Alert Imagery (before and after satellite images)Clearance location: (3.388, 117.236)

Date: December 22, 2019 Date: March 16, 2020

Ownership InformationPT Pipit Mutiara Indah is part of QL Resources Bhd.2

2. QL Resources Bhd Annual Report 2019: http://ql.listedcompany.com/misc/ar2019.pdf.





PT Pipit Mutiara

Indah

ADM CargillLouis

Itochu Dreyfus

QL Resources Bhd




PT Pipit Mutiara Indah

QL Resources Bhd


General Mills Hershey Kellogg's


QL Resources Bhd


Mars Mondelez Nestle Nisshin Oillio

PT Pipit Mutiara

Indah

QL Resources Bhd





PepsiCo PZ CussonsReckitt

Benckiser

PT Pipit Mutiara

Indah

QL Resources Bhd


Unilever Upfield


QL Resources Bhd


Received by NSD/FARA Registration Unitiirzi

07/06/2020 6:31:12 PM

Group: Wings Agro GroupPT Indopenta Sejahtera AbadiConcession location: (-2.110, 114.952)


Report

Report 19

Deforestation(ha)

54

Peatdevelopme

nt(ha)

Peat forest Clearancedevelopment prep/Stacking

(ha) lines(ha)Time period

May 12-August 21, 2019

Report 20 43 (GLAD alerts)August 15-

september 15,2019

Report 21 12 (GLAD alerts)September 16-

October 15, 2019

Report 27 11October 11,2019-

March 18, 2020

Satellite imagery (see below) shows that between October 11, 2019 and March 18, 2020 a total of 11 hectares of forest were cleared in the PT Indopenta Sejahtera Abadi concession. (Imagery: Contains modified Copernicus Sentinel data 2020)

Vietnam ^Philippines

Malaysia

Indonesia

PT Indopenta Se- £ ) ah ter a Abadi

PT Irxtop^U Abac*

*i.»

*

L .CT.



Alert Imagery (before and after satellite images)Clearance location: (-2.110, 114.952)

Date: October 11, 2019 Date: March 18, 2020

S3

Ownership InformationPT Indopenta Sejahtera Abadi is part of the Wings Agro Group.3 3

3. Wings Agro website: www.wingsagro.com/eng/ourbusines.





PT Indopenta

Sejahtera Abadi

Cargill Fuji Oil Neste

Wings Agro Group


General Mills Hershey Kellogg's Nestle

PT Indopenta

Sejahtera Abadi

Wings Agro Group


PepsiCo PZ Cussons Unilever

PT Indopenta

Sejahtera Abadi

Wings Agro Group



Group: SamlingPT Tunas Borneo PlantationsConcession location: (2.591, 11 7.522)


Report

Report 18

Deforestation(ha)

13

Peat Peat forest Clearancedevelopment development prep/Stacking

(ha) (ha) lines (ha)Time period

May 3-August 3, 2019

Report 27 85February 22-April 27,

2020

Satellite imagery (see below) shows that between February 22, 2020 and April 27, 2020 a total of 85 hectares of forest were cleared in the PT Tunas Borneo Plantations concession. (Imagery: Contains modified Copernicus Sentinel data 2020)

aj

Vietnam

PT Tunas Borneo Plantations

PT Turws Borneo Plantations

O ~

Philippines

□ □

sESalaysia

Indonesia




Date: February 22, 2020

Received by NSD/FARA Registration Unit 07/06/2020 6:31:12 PMCase NotesSince February 2020, ADM, Cargill, Fuji Oil, IOI, KLK, LDC, Sime Darby and Wilmar - as well as Hershey’s, Mars, P&G, and Upheld - have all informed Mighty Earth that they have suspended Sanding from their supply chains.

Sime Darby informed Mighty Earth that: “We would like to confirm that we have notified Samlmg that we will no longer be sourcing from them due to cojicerns raised by our key customers. Central to these concerns is the adoption ofNDPE conunitments across the whole Sajnling Group, and 7wt just for Glenealy Plantatiojis.”

On 15 April 2020, Sanding responded to these suspensions - not by halting all Sanding group-wide deforestation, but by offering up the smallest fig leaf: Glenealy Plantations Sdn Bhd announced an NDPE policy and a memo issuing a “group-wide moratoj'ium oji any lajid clearing for all greenfield development on mineral soil and peatland 1'egai'dless of depth with immediate effect until further notice.’”

Several traders and biodiesel companies - AAK, BLD, Neste, Olam, Sarawak Oil Palms Bhd (SOPB) - and consumer brands, including Mondelez, Nestle, and PepsiCo, have yet to take action to suspend Sanding from their supply chains.

Glenealy has also been circulating information to traders claiming that ‘Glenealy holds all the oil palm estates and mills’ and that the company owns 100% of the shares in Timor Enterprise Sdn Bhd (through Puncak Selasih Sdn Bhd) which owns the Jelalong, Lana and Belaja palm oil operations, Sanding Plantations Sdn Bhd and other entities (see left graphic below).

Based on this information, it would be assumed that the moratorium applies to all Glenealy-owned plantation areas. However, according to shareholder ownership data obtained from the Companies Commission of Malaysia, Glenealy Plantations only owns 15.31% of Timor Enterprise Sdn Bhd. The majority shareholder (84.68%) in Timor Enterprise Sdn Bhd is Lingui Developments Sdn Bhd, which is 100% owned by Sanding Malaysia Incorporated, registered in the British Virgin Islands (see right graphic below).

*GUKAIY PUNTATUNS SON IHD

mHJSCA* SEIASH SCMHD

mTtfORENTEIPKESSONMD

Cfcrtf mdd (MbUCHOfn

(01 Mft • TON i> * Mil hteMri)

MIMDIM :K ■■dir mk«itn

Pt»««roTte





BLD Plantation Bhd

Itochu Lipsa

Samling


PT Tunas Borneo

Plantations

Neste Olam Sarawak Oil Palms

Samling


PT Tunas Borneo

Plantations



Samling



General MillsJohnson & Johnson

Kellogg's Mondelez

Samling





Nestle Nisshin Oillio PepsiCo PZ Cussons

PT Tunas Borneo

Plantations

Samling


Reckitt Benckiser Vandemoortele


Samling




Although SOPB published an NDPE policy in January 2019, the company has not published a mill list disclosing its suppliers and sources of palm oil. While SOPB has listed several of Mighty Earth’s Rapid Response cases on Samling in its grievance list, the company has failed to address these grievances or suspend Samling.

Several traders, biofuel companies and consumers brands are sourcing palm oil originating from SOPB (see tables below). These companies should file grievances with SOPB, requesting that it acts on the Samling case and suspends them.


Sarawak Oil Palms

Cargill Lipsa


Sarawak Oil Palms

Louis Dreyfus Mewah Neste Sime Darby


Sarawak Oil Palms

AvonColgate- FrieslandPalmolive Campina

HersheyJohnson & Johnson


Sarawak Oil Palms

Kellogg's Mars PepsiCo

Supply Chain Links: PZ ReckittConsumer Brands Cussons Benckiser

Unilever Upfield Vandemoortele

Sarawak Oil Palms


Received by NSD/FARA Registration Unit 07/06/2020 6:31:12 PMT/~

Group: SamlingLPF/0007 Samling Jelalong (OP)Concession location: (3.313, 113.885)


Report

Report 18

Deforestation(ha)

33 (via GLAD)

Peat Peat forest Clearancedevelopment development prep/Stacking

(ha) (ha) lines (ha)Time period

June 15-July 15, 2019

Report 19 95 (via GLAD)July 15-August 15,

2019

Report 20 96 (via GLAD)August 15-

>eptember 1 5, 2019

Report 21 38 (via GLAD)September 16-

October 15, 2019

Report 23 131 (via GLAD)November 15-

December 6, 2019

Report 240.15 (via GLAD)

December 15, 2019- January 15, 2020

Report 25 68 (via GLAD)January 15-February

17, 2020

Report 26 72 (via GLAD)February 17-March

16, 2020

Report 27 91May 24, 2019-April

17, 2020

Satellite imagery (see below) shows that between May 24, 2019 and April 27, 2020 a total of 91 hectares of forest were cleared in the LPF/0007 Samling Jelalong (OP) concession. (Imagery: Contains modified Copernicus Sentinel data 2020)

rma)

VietnamPhilippines

Malaysia

Indonesia

LPF/OCO r Samling Join * a |



Date: May 24, 2019 Date: April 17, 2020

3.310568. 113.848542 ■---- 500m---

Ownership InformationLPF/0007 Samling Jelalong (OP) is part of the Samling Group.5

Case NotesSee case notes for previous Samling case (PT Tunas Borneo Plantations) on page 17.

5. www.samling.com/





LPF/0007 Samling

Jelalong (OP)

BLD Plantation Bhd

Itochu Lipsa

Samling


LPF/0007 Samling

Jelalong (OP)

Neste Olam Sarawak Oil Palms

Samling


LPF/0007 Samling

Jelalong (OP)



Samling


LPF/0007 Samling

Jelalong (OP)

General MillsJohnson & Johnson

Kellogg's Mondelez

Samling





Nestle Nisshin Oillio PepsiCo PZ Cussons

LPF/0007 Samling

Jelalong (OP)

Samling


Reckitt Benckiser Vandemoortele

LPF/0007 Samling

Jelalong (OP)

Samling



Supply Chain Information (continued)Although SOPB published an NDPE in January 2019, the company has not published a mill list disclosing its suppliers and sources of palm oil. Although, SOPB has listed several Mighty Earth cases on Sanding in its grievance list, the company have failed to address these grievances or suspend Sanding.

A number of traders, biofuel companies and consumers brands are sourcing palm oil originating from SOPB (see tables below). These companies should file grievances with SOPB, requesting that it acts on the Sanding case and suspends them.


Sarawak Oil Palms

Cargill Lipsa


Sarawak Oil Palms

Louis Dreyfus Mewah Neste Sime Darby


Sarawak Oil Palms


FrieslandCampina

HersheyJohnson & Johnson


Sarawak Oil Palms

Kellogg's Mars PepsiCo

Supply Chain Links: PZ ReckittConsumer Brands Cussons Benckiser

Unilever Upfield Vandemoortele

Sarawak Oil Palms



The following cases have been identified through screened GLAD alerts (see methodology below). As these cases are either repeat cases from previous Rapid Response reports or where Mighty Earth did not determine any supply chain links for these concessions/groups, no satellite image analysis was conducted for these cases to save resources.

Mighty Earth expects that palm oil traders and biofuel companies conduct their own due diligence to determine if they are exposed to sncli companies/Groups and conduct their own satellite image analysis of these cases.

Methodology:For Indonesia, GLAD alerts are screened using the Indonesia Ministry of Forestry and the Environment land cover dataset for 2017 which classifies existing palm oil plantations and primary and secondary forest. Hence, only GLAD alerts in primary and secondary forest according to that dataset are included.

For Malaysia, GLAD alerts are screened to exclude known plantation areas using the Global Forest Watch (GFW) plantations dataset. This automatically eliminates the most common false positives, i.e. the replanting of palm that existed prior to the year 2000.

New Cases - Unknown Supply Chain Links

Concession license area Group/ownershipArea covered byscreened GLAD Time periodalerts (ha)

PT Banyan Tumbuh Lestari PT Buana Pratama Cipta (formerly Provident Agro) 14.02

March 16-April 15, 2020

PTTualang Raya Unknown Group 27.32March 16-April 15, 2020



Repeat Cases - Known Supply Chain Links

Concession license area

PT Citra Agro Abadi

Group/ownership

Cilandry Anky Abadi Group

Areacovered by screened GLAD alerts (ha)

160.70

Time period


RapidResponsereports relatedto each case*

Reports 17, 23, 25, 26

PT Permata Sawit MandiriSepanjang Group (PT PSM formerly owned 484.40


Reports 15, 16, 17, 19, 20,23, 24

PT Mulia Inti Perkasa Widya Corporation 134.66March 16-April 15, 2020

Reports 6, 15, 16,20,21,22, 23, 24, 25, 26

PT Internusa Jaya Sejahtera Indonusa Group 111.11March 16-April 15,2020

Reports 7, 10,11, 12, 15, 16,17, 20, 22,23,25

PT Sumber Alam Selaras NPC Resources Bhd 101.69March 16-April 15, 2020

Reports 23, 25, 26

PT Persada Era Agro Kencana Mulia Sawit Group 83.56March 16-April 15, 2020

Reports 9, 10, 11, 12, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 22, 23, 24, 25

PT Putra Utama LestariDharma Satya Nusantara

37.33March 16-April 15, 2020

Reports 20 and 23

PT Medcopapua Hijau Selaras Capitol Group 35.08March 16-April 15, 2020

Reports 25 and 26

PT Sabhantara Rawi SentosaDhanistha Surya Nusantara

25.79March 16-April 15, 2020

Reports 21,23, 26

PT Makmur Jaya Malindo Pinehill Pacific 22.30March 16-April 15, 2020

Reports 18 and 19

PT Bulungan Surya Mas Pratama 2

Global Enterprise Sdn Bhd 22.19


Report 21

PT Damai Agro Sejahtera Bumitama Group 20.90March 16-April 15, 2020

Reports 22, 23, 26

* Rapid Response reports available on Mighty Earth’s Rapid Response website page, linked here





PT Putra Utama Lestari

Group/ownership

Dharma Satya Nusantara


20.14

Time period



Reports 20 and 23

PT Megakarya Jaya RayaHayel Saeed Anam Group

19.78March 16-April 15, 2020

Reports 5, 23, 26

PT Bina Sarana Sawit UtamaSamuel International Group 18.28


Reports 19, 20, 24, 26

PT Citra Sawit CemerlangGentinq Plantations Bhd 17.65

March 16-April 15,2020

Reports 14, 15, 16, 17, 19, 23, 24

PT Tirta Madu Sawit Jaya Fangiono family 16.38March 16-April 15, 2020

Reports 22, 24, 25

PT Persada Era Agro Kencana Mulia Sawit Group 14.08March 16-April 15, 2020

Reports 9, 10, 11, 12, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 22, 23, 24, 25

PT Bulungan Surya Mas Pratama

Global Enterprise Sdn Bhd 13.38


Report 21

PT Usaha Sawit Unggul Asian Agri (RGE) 12.31March 16-April 15, 2020

Reports 17, 18, 20, 24, 26

PT Mekar Karya Kahuripan Makin Group 12.00March 16-April 15, 2020

Reports 17, 21, 22, 23, 26

PT Jaya Jadi UtamaCB Industrial Product Holding 11.93


Reports 15, 20, 23, 26

PT Kahayan Agro Plantation Anglo-EasternPlantations 10.30


Reports 1,14, 15, 18, 19, 20, 23, 24, 25

LPF/0018 Shin Yang OP Planting Area

Shin Yang Group 101.11March 16-April 15, 2020

LPF/0018 Shin Yang OP Planting Area

BLD Plantation BhdKTS Holdings Sdn Bhd 54.86


BLD Plantation Bhd

* Rapid Response reports available on Mighty Earth’s Rapid Response website page, linked here





Danum Sinar Sdn Bhd

Group/ownership

Puncak Niaga Holdings Bhd


52.99

Time period



Danum Sinar Sdn Bhd

Dataran Linau Sdn Bhd (Lot 1 Block 14 Murum LD)

Shin Yang Group / Sarawak Oil Palms Bhd

47.19March 16-April 15, 2020

Dataran Linau Sdn Bhd (Lot 1 Block 14 Murum

122____________

Almabumi Plantation Sdn BhdBBC Holdings Sdn Bhd 19.72


Almabumi Plantation Sdn Bhd

Woodijaya Sdn Bhd (Lot 197) Rimbunan Hijau Group

16.84March 16-April 15, 2020

Woodijaya Sdn Bhd (Lot 197)

LPF/0006 Samling Lana Samling Group 13.54March 16-April 15, 2020

LPF/0006 Samling Lana

Linau Sinar Sdn Bhd (Metalon OP Estate, Lot 2, Danum LD)

Shin Yang Group 13.23March 16-April 15, 2020

Linau Sinar Sdn Bhd (Metalon OP Estate, Lot 2, Danum LD)

Baram Estate, part of LPF/0004 Woodman Group 9.96March 16-April 15, 2020

Baram Estate, part of LPF/0004

Timrest Sdn BhdRimbunan Hijau Group

9.74March 16-April 15, 2020

Timrest Sdn Bhd

Hydroflow Sdn Bhd TH Plantations Bhd 9.60March 16-April 15, 2020

Hydroflow Sdn Bhd

Adong estate, part of LPF 0004 Woodman Group 8.26March 16-April 15, 2020

Adong estate, part of LPF 0004

Poh Zhen Sdn Bhd Rimbunan Hijau Group

7.89March 16-April 15, 2020

Poh Zhen Sdn Bhd

"Rapid Response reports available on Mighty Earth’s Rapid Response website page, linked here.




Concession license area Group/ownership

PT Berau Karetindo Lestari Korompis family


100.06

Time period



Reports 2, 6, 9, 15, 16, 19, 20, 21,22

PT Tri In vesta ma Green Yield Pte Ltd 11.07March 16-April 15, 2020

Reports 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25

PT Prasetya Mitra Muda (BlockUnknown Group 14.17


Reports 6, 17, 19

PT Marita Makmur Jaya Unknown Group 14.24March 16-April 15, 2020

Reports 12, 15, 17, 19, 22, 24, 26

PT Gapura Alas Lestari Unknown Group 14.87March 16-April 15, 2020

Reports 16, 19, 20,23,25, 26

PT Future Agropia Indonesia JSK International Co Ltd (Korea) 15.78


Reports 17 and 20

PT Citrapermata Serundung Unknown Group 15.88March 16-April 15, 2020

Reports 20, 23, 26

PT Perkebunan Inti Sendawar IMC Plantations 17.81March 16-April 15, 2020

Reports 23 and 26

PT Cipta Karya Sesayap Unknown Group 19.55March 16-April 15, 2020

Reports 17, 22,23,25

PT Sumber Sawit Mitrajaya Unknown Group 20.06March 16-April 15, 2020

Reports 15, 17, 23, 25, 26

PT Pipit Citra Persada Unknown Group 22.03March 16-April 15, 2020 Reports 6, 17, 20

PT Sebaung Sawit PlantationShanghai Xinjiu Chemical Co Ltd 22.87


Reports 8, 12, 13, 16,20, 21, 22, 23, 25

PT Barito Riau Jaya Unknown Group 24.01March 16-April 15, 2020

Reports 22, 23, 26

•Rapid Response reports available on Mighty Earth’s Rapid Response website page, linked here





PT Triomas Forestry Development Indonesia

Group/ownership

Unknown Group


43.99

Time period



Reports 17, 22, 23, 24

PT Palem Segar Lestari Henan Jiujiu Chemical Co. Ltd 57.88


Reports 5, 7, 12, 16, 18, 20,21, 22, 23, 25, 26

PT Menthobi Mitra Lestari

Unknown Group (PT MML formerly owned by PT Bakrie Sumatra 64.25


Reports 16, 17,20, 22

PT Agrindo Sukses Sejahtera Starmas Sentosa Mandiri 95.34


Reports 8, 16, 22, 26

Telliana Enterprise Sdn Bhd Unknown Group 37.09March 16-April 15, 2020

Reports 18, 19, 20, 26

Formerly Ekran Bhd Unknown Group 27.30March 16-April 15, 2020

Reports 19, 20, 21, 23, 25, 26

Titanium Management Sdn Bhd (Part 1)

Unknown Group 26.03March 16-April 15, 2020

Reports 18, 19,21,26

Titanium Management Sdn Bhd (Part 2)

Unknown Group 17.39March 16-April 15, 2020

Reports 18, 19,21,26

Limba Jaya Timber Sdn Bhd (Limbang)

Lee Linq Timber Sdn Bhd 7.95


Reports 18, 21, 26

LPF/0038 Limba Jaya Timber Sdn Bhd (Part 2)

Lee Linq Timber Sdn Bhd 7.88


Reports 18, 21, 26

* Rapid Response reports available on Mighty Earth’s Rapid Response website page, linked here.

The work of Mighty Earth is supported by Waxman Strategies. Waxman Strategies’ work on forest conservation is funded in part by Aidenvironment. Waxman is required under 22 U.S.C. § 614 to disclose that this material is distributed on behalf of the aforementioned organization, working under grant from the Norwegian Agency for Development Cooperation. Additional information is on file with the Department of Justice, Washington, D.C.



Re: Rapid Response Report 29

Asha Sharma Mon 7/6/2020 3:19 PM

To: Nasuha Thaha @cargill.com>; Rapid Response ; Phil Aikman

Cc: Alexandra Experton @cargill.com>; Sophie Hoo @cargill.com>Hi Nasuha,

Thank you for your response. I will update our records so that future reports will go to Sophie not Gifty.

Please let me know if you have further questions or concerns.

ASHA SHARMA I DIRECTOR I [email protected] Follow us:_______ I ter


Best,Asha



Samling Scorecard

Asha Sharma Mon 7/6/2020 5:20 PMTo: Ake, Jean-Philippe Cc: [email protected] ; [email protected] ; [email protected]

Dear JP:

I hope this email finds you well! I am writing to confirm your score in our forthcoming scorecard that will be evaluating consumer brands’ response to Samling Group’s continued clearance of tropical forests in Malaysia. As mentioned in previouscorrespondence, Samling Group is a Malaysian conglomerate that owns and operates oil palm plantations and timber concessions. Our Rapid Response monitoring system has identified at least 779 hectares of deforestation within four of the company’s concessions in Sarawak, Malaysia. Furthermore, the company has a long history of human rights abuses. Therefore, buying from Samling constitutes a serious violation of No Deforestation and No Exploitation policies.

Our scoring rubric is as followed:

A: Full SuspensionCompany has communicated a “no-buy” requirement to their palm oil suppliers to ensure Samling is excluded from their supply chainsB: Partial SuspensionCompany has not issued a formal “no-buy” requirement; however, the company has taken other significant action to ensure Samling palm oil is excluded from their supply chainC: EngagementCompany is engaging their suppliers on the issue of SamlingF: No responseCompany has not responded to Mighty Earth’s emails

The Hershey Company currently has a score of “A.” Please confirm if our information is correct by Friday, July 10th.

Please let me know if you have any questions or concerns.

Best,Asha Sharma

ASHA SHARMA I DIRECTOR I [email protected] us: Facebook I Twitter


https//out oo off ce com/ma / nbox/ d/AAQ AD yYz 4NDcyLTgwNWQtNDB MSIhYTV LTM4ZWQwZ zN czNQAQAEhlERPaDX OhEn9dhOGAu %3D Page 1 of 2



FW: Invitation: hosting role for international partners and indigenous leaders event

Margaret Hansbrough Mon 7/6/2020 6:17 PM

To: Compliance

From: Margaret HansbroughDate: Monday, July 6, 2020 at 6:16 PMTo: Garcia, ChristopherCc: Rose Garr; Van der Heide, JenniferSubject: Re: Invitation: hosting role for international partners and indigenous leaders event

Hey Chris,

Would 3:30 work on your end? I can send an invite.

Thanks.

-Margaret

MARGARET HANSBROUGH I DIRECTOR I WAXMAN [email protected] I 816.210.9545

1150 Connecticut Avenue NW I Suite 800 I Washington, DC, 20036www.waxmanstrategies.com

Waxman Strategies’ work on forest conservation is funded in part by the European Federation for Transport and Environment and National Wildlife

Federation. Waxman is required under 22 U.S.C. § 614 to disclose that this material is distributed on behalf of the aforementioned organization,

working under grant from the Norwegian Agency for Development Cooperation. Additional information is on file with the Department of Justice,

Washington, D.C.

https//out oo off ce com/ma / nbox/ d/AAQ AD yYz 4NDcyLTgw...MS1hYTV LTM4ZWQwZ zN czNQAQAD7Gw%2Fd2M ZFh WOJh%2FpJ%2Bs%3D Page 1 of 1


another major company drops cargill over deforestation ......2020/07/06 · received by nsd/fara...

Documents