Page

17

/ WIS

EST

Spec

ial I

ssue

/ Vo

lum

e 2

/ DO

I:10.

2917

3/aa

r54

albertaacademicreview.com

Analyzing the Rare Earth Elements (REE’s) and Trace Metals in TailingsRachel Butler1, Deepak Pudasainee1, Md Khan1, Rajender Gupta1

1Department of Chemical and Materials Engineering, University of Alberta

Key words:bitumen, froth treatment tailings, Gupta lab, rare earth elements, trace metals, oil sands, TGA, alberta, chemical engineering

Abstract

In the process of producing bitumen from oil sand, a by-product called tailings is produced. Tailings are a mixture of clay, fine particles, water, solvent and residual bitumen. The industry’s current approach is to leave them in tailings ponds; however, that may cause environmental impacts to the ecosystems around them due in part to the toxic trace metals found in them. Research has shown that there are also valuable rare Earth elements (REEs) present in tailings. REEs found in tailings include Cerium, Neodymium, Lanthanum etc. Iron, Titanium, and Zirconium are not considered REEs but are still valuable enough to be extracted. The objective of this research was to determine the concentration of REEs and trace metals in bitumen froth treatment tailings (FTT). Our research team used acid digestion and inductively coupled plasma mass spectroscopy (ICP-MS) to measure the concentration of REEs and trace metals in several samples of FTT ash. We learned that Cerium was the most prevalent REE in tailings samples (>1000ppm), followed by Neodymium and Lanthanum. Zirconium was the most prevalent trace metal found in this tailings sample (>1000ppm), followed closely by Vanadium. Knowing the exact concentration of harmful trace metals in tailings will allow us to determine the extent of tailings ponds environmental effect and toxicity. Collecting and selling expensive metals found in tailings could be the start of a new precious metals economy in Alberta, which would provide new investment opportunities and jobs. This would also encourage corporations to invest in finding new ways to extract these precious metals, resulting in more purified tailings and less tailings overall going into tailings ponds.

Cite as: Butler R., Pudasainee D., Khan M., Gupta R. 2019. Analyzing the rare earth elements (REEs) and trace metals in tailings. Alberta Academic Review, Vol 2 (2) 17-18, WISEST Special Issue (non peer-reviewed), DOI 10.29173/aar54.

ISSN 2561-5327 (print)ISSN 2561-5335 (online)

Page

18

/ WIS

EST

Spec

ial I

ssue

/ V

olum

e 2

/ DO

I: 10

.291

73/a

ar54

albertaacademicreview.com

Intr

oduc

tion

Met

hods

Res

ults

Ack

now

ledg

emen

tsIw

ould

like

toth

ank

Can

ada

Sum

mer

Jobs

,the

Facu

ltyof

Eng

inee

ring

atU

nive

rsity

ofA

lber

ta,t

heW

ISE

STte

am,a

ndm

ypa

rtner

Iqm

atIy

iola

.

This

proj

ecti

nD

r.G

upta

’sgr

oup

was

supp

orte

dby

Alb

erta

Env

ironm

ent

and

Par

ks.

Ana

lysis

of R

are

Eart

h El

emen

ts a

nd T

race

Met

als i

n Ta

iling

s

Rac

hel B

utle

r, D

eepa

k Pu

dasa

inee

, Md

Kha

n, R

ajen

dar G

upta

Dep

artm

ent o

f Che

mic

al a

nd M

ater

ials

Eng

inee

ring,

Uni

vers

ity o

f Alb

erta

Lite

ratu

re C

ited

1. E

lliot,

Trac

y, H

owar

d, B

ret,

Eva

n, &

Ban

k. (2

017,

Apr

il 05

). R

are

Ear

th E

lem

ents

in A

lber

ta O

ilS

and

Pro

cess

Stre

ams.

Ret

rieve

d Ju

ly 3

1, 2

019,

from

http

s://w

ww

.ost

i.gov

/pag

es/s

ervl

ets/

purl/

1393

393

2. N

. (19

87, M

arch

01)

. Eco

nom

ic a

nd E

nviro

nmen

tal B

enef

its fr

om F

roth

Flo

tatio

n R

ecov

ery

ofTi

tani

um, Z

ircon

ium

, Iro

n an

d R

are

Ear

th M

iner

als

from

Oils

and

Taili

ngs.

Ret

rieve

d Ju

ly 3

1, 2

019,

from

http

s://i

wap

onlin

e.co

m/w

st/a

rticl

e/19

/3-4

/323

/228

80/E

cono

mic

-and

-Env

ironm

enta

l-Ben

efits

-fro

m-F

roth

Figu

re 5

. REE

s in

FTT

ash

. The

conc

entra

tion

is p

rese

nted

in lo

g sc

ale

•Th

eFT

Tlo

stup

to90

%of

itsin

itial

wei

ghtw

hen

heat

edto

550

°C.I

tha

sa

mos

tlyst

eady

wei

ght

loss

exce

ptfo

rno

tabl

edr

ops

at10

0°C

and

400°

C.

•C

eriu

mis

the

mos

tpre

vale

ntR

EE

inta

iling

s(>

1000

ppm

),fo

llow

edby

Neo

dym

ium

and

Lant

hanu

m.

•Zi

rcon

ium

isth

em

ost

prev

alen

ttra

cem

etal

foun

din

this

taili

ngs

sam

ple

(>10

00pp

m),

follo

wed

clos

ely

byVa

nadi

um.

Mer

cury

,Le

ad,

and

Ars

enic

are

also

conf

irmed

tobe

pres

ent

inta

iling

sbu

tth

eir

exac

tcon

cent

ratio

nsar

eye

tto

bede

term

ined

.

•Th

ene

xtst

epin

this

rese

arch

wou

ldbe

findi

ngsu

itabl

e,lo

w-c

ost

met

hods

toex

tract

RE

Esan

dtre

atto

xic

trace

met

als

inFT

T.

•R

esea

rch

one

step

furth

erco

uld

look

atca

ptur

ing

thes

em

iner

als

and

solv

ents

befo

reth

eyre

ach

taili

ngs

pond

s.C

ombi

ned,

thes

etw

oap

proa

ches

wou

ldre

duce

tota

lw

ater

usag

ew

hile

acce

lera

ting

the

recl

amat

ion

proc

ess.

Con

clus

ion

•R

are

Ear

thE

lem

ents

(RE

Es)

and

trace

met

als

are

conc

entra

ted

mos

tlyin

taili

ngs

com

pare

dto

othe

rpar

tsof

the

oils

ands

prod

uctio

npr

oces

s,th

ough

this

isst

illa

rela

tivel

ylo

wco

ncen

tratio

n.[1

]

•R

EEs

foun

din

taili

ngs

incl

ude

Cer

ium

,N

eody

miu

m,

and

Lant

hanu

met

c.Iro

n,Ti

tani

um,a

ndZi

rcon

ium

are

notc

onsi

dere

dR

EE

sbu

tare

still

valu

able

enou

ghto

beex

tract

ed.[2

]

•R

EEs

are

curr

ently

not

bein

gco

llect

edfro

mta

iling

s,bu

tif

they

wer

eth

isco

uld

supp

ort

Alb

erta

’spr

ecio

usm

iner

als

econ

omy

asw

ell

aspo

tent

ially

redu

ceth

eam

ount

ofta

iling

sbe

ing

dum

ped

inta

iling

spo

nds.

•Tr

ace

met

als

incl

ude

elem

ents

such

asLe

ad,

Cad

miu

m,

Mer

cury

,Va

nadi

um.M

any

are

toxi

cto

hum

ans

and

wild

life.

•Th

eob

ject

ive

ofth

isre

sear

chis

tode

term

ine

the

conc

entra

tion

ofR

EEs

and

trace

met

als

inbi

tum

enfro

thtre

atm

entt

ailin

gs.

Figu

re 2

.Muf

fle F

urna

ce

Pla

ce F

TT in

Cer

amic

Cru

cibl

es

Pla

ce F

TT in

Muf

fle F

urna

ce

Figu

re 1

.Cru

cibl

eH

eat a

t 10°C

/min

to 8

00°C

Res

iden

ce ti

me

of 2

hou

rs

Col

lect

ash

for a

naly

sis

Ash

pre

para

tion

from

taili

ngs

Met

hods

(co

nt’d

)

Ana

lysi

s fo

r met

als

Indu

ctiv

ely

coup

led

plas

ma

mas

ssp

ectro

scop

y an

alys

is (I

CP

-MS

)

Aci

d D

iges

tion

Ana

lysi

s fo

r REE

s

Thre

e st

ep a

cid

dige

stio

n

Figu

re 8

.Tra

ce E

lem

ents

in F

TT a

sh.

The

conc

entra

tion

is p

rese

nted

in lo

gsc

ale

Figu

re 3

.The

rmal

beh

avio

r of F

TT in

ther

mo

grav

imet

ric a

naly

zer

(TG

A)

App

licat

ion

•K

now

ing

the

exac

tco

ncen

tratio

nof

harm

ful

trace

met

als

inta

iling

sw

illal

low

rese

arch

ers

tode

term

ine

the

exte

ntof

taili

ngs

pond

sen

viro

nmen

tald

amag

ean

dto

xici

ty.

•La

ntha

num

and

Yttr

ium

are

both

expe

nsiv

em

etal

s.C

olle

ctin

gan

dse

lling

them

from

taili

ngs

coul

dbe

the

star

tofa

new

prec

ious

met

als

econ

omy

inA

lber

ta,

whi

chw

ould

prov

ide

new

inve

stm

ent

oppo

rtuni

ties

and

jobs

.

Indu

ctiv

ely

coup

led

plas

ma

mas

ssp

ectro

scop

yan

alys

is (I

CP

-MS

)

Figu

re 4

.The

rmo

grav

imet

rican

alyz

er

Figu

re7.

FTT

Ash

Figu

re 6

.Drie

dFT

T

Butler et al., 2019