Analyzing Rhetoric in Just one Sentence!

Carolyn TalcottCtalcott@magnoliapublicschools.org

Wiki for the conferencehttp://northridgewp-writetoliteracy.wikispaces.com

Analyzing Rhetoric in Just one Sentence!

Warm-up

Do you enjoy watching horror movies or reading horror stories? Why or why not?

Even if you don’t enjoy horror, what do you think its appeal

might be?

Do you think it serves a purpose in our society?

Standards…Reading Informational Texts: Determine an author's point of view or purpose in a text in which the rhetoric is particularly effective, analyzing how style and content contribute to the power, persuasiveness or beauty of the text.

For a score of 8 or 9 on the Rhetorical Strategies essay: students must demonstrate a significant understanding of the passage, its intent, and how the rhetorical strategies and figurative language that the author uses enhance meaning.

Some background…

This strategy was given by Carol Elsen at an AP Language and Composition seminar.

I would do this activity after students are already familiar with rhetorical strategies and figurative language.

However, I will give you some background on ethos, pathos, logos today…

Aristotle’s Rhetorical Triangle

Ethos: convincing by the character of the speaker/author.What is the speaker’s reputation? How does he convince us we should believe him?

Logos: persuading by the use of reasoning. What evidence does the speaker use to convince us? Facts? Analogies? Anecdotes? Statistics?

Pathos: appealing to the reader’s emotions, sympathies and imagination. How does the author say what he wants to say? Diction and tone play a big part here.

Rhetorical Strategies…

Let’s brainstorm some specific strategies or literary devices you have students identify as they read.

The Rhetoric of Stephen King…

Read the Stephen King article, annotating for appeals to ethos, pathos and logos.

Pay special attention to sentence structure, placement, and diction.

You may also annotate for the devices/strategies we listed in our

brainstorm.

Pair up…

With a partner, discuss your reaction to the article.

Do you agree with King? Did he change your mind? What were his most powerful

or intriguing phrases?

What rhetorical appeals or other devices stood out to you?

Analysis Sentence

Work with a partner to write a one sentence analysis of King’s rhetoric

 

Author’s name + strong verb 

Adjective + type of appeal

Author’s purpose for using this tone

Two example phrases or words to prove/ demonstrate the strategy and purpose.

Example:

Benjamin Radford’s humorous use of logos

reveals the infallible fact that ghosts are not real

with his admirable use of proof such as:

“it’s all made up, like speculating on the different races of fairies or

dragons…” and “if ghosts are human souls, why do they

appear clothed…?”

Next step:

I usually ask students to turn in their written cards, and I type them up.

At the next class meeting I have a handout with all the sentences and we read and discuss them to check for completeness

We often vote on the best one and discuss what makes it so good.

And then…

The next step is to have students expand on their sentence by writing another one that explains the effectiveness of the strategy.

Another step is to have students examine another device/strategy the author uses and discuss how the devices/strategies effectively work together to achieve the author’s purpose.

This builds them toward the longer essay.

Students should practice this several times before moving on to a full-length essay.

You may also find AP Rhetorical Analysis sample essays online and have students search for these types of sentences to see how they are integrated into the essay.

Reflection

Take a few minutes to reflect:

How could you use this activity in your own classroom?

How might you modify or change it?

Do you have a text in mind that it will work well with?