analysing sftp information from the first enhanced annual return ian hicks policy, education...
TRANSCRIPT
Analysing SFTP information from the first
Enhanced Annual Return
Ian HicksPolicy, Education Directorate, GMC
Cases per school
221 cases in total across 31 medical schoolsAverage 7.13 casesMedian: 5 casesIncludes cases where FTP ‘non-impaired’
Two schools presented zero casesSeven schools presented 57% of cases (n=125)
# of Cases by Outcome (Total: 221)
1
9 9 1013 15 17 17
2023
27
60
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
Not st
ated
Condi
tions
Expuls
ion
Suspe
nsio
n/Tem
p with
draw
al
Under
takin
g
War
ning
+
Info
rmal
Und
erta
king
With
draw
l
Not co
mple
te
War
ning
Non F
TP
Suppo
rt
Outcome
# o
f C
as
es
Stage Reached # (Total) %
Support 59 26.7%
Investigation 43 19.5%
FTP Committee 74 33.5%
Health and Conduct Committee 17 7.7%
Student Progress Committee 22 10.0%
Disciplinary 3 1.4%
Other 3 1.4%
Total 221 100.0%
Stage Reached # (excl. Non FTP) %
Support 58 29.9%
Investigation 28 14.4%
FTP Committee 68 35.1%
Health and Conduct Committee 15 7.7%
Student Progress Committee 21 10.8%
Disciplinary 3 1.5%
Other 1 0.5%
Total 194 100.0%
Stage Reached # (only Non FTP) %
Support 1 3.7%
Investigation 15 55.6%
FTP Committee 6 22.2%
Health and Conduct Committee 2 7.4%
Student Progress Committee 1 3.7%
Disciplinary 0 0.0%
Other 2 7.4%
Total 27 100.0%
Cases, outcomes and stage summary
221 cases
52% resolved informally
(support, informal undertaking, and warning+)
26.2% received a sanction4% expulsion 7.6% withdrawal
12.2% FTP ‘non-impaired’Most FTP ‘non-impaired’ resolved at investigation stage
Since 2007, five schools had decisions overturned by Uni.
FTP Concern # %
Conduct 123 63.4%
Health 22 11.3%
Health/Conduct 22 11.3%
Conduct; conviction/caution 24 12.4%
Health; conduct; conviction/caution 1 0.5%
Conduct; conviction/caution; other 2 1.0%
Total cases 194 100.0%
Type of concern
FTP Concern by Type (Total: 194)
12322
22
2412
Conduct
Health
Health/Conduct
Conduct; conviction/caution
Health; conduct; conviction/caution
Conduct; conviction/caution; other
FTP Concern: Conduct # %
Conduct 123 63.4%
Health 22 11.3%
Health/Conduct 22 11.3%
Conduct; conviction/caution 24 12.4%
Health; conduct; conviction/caution 1 0.5%
Conduct; conviction/caution; other 2 1.0%
Total cases 172 88.6%
FTP Concern: Conduct detail # %
Dishonesty 37 21.5%
Academic 21 12.2%
Absent 51 29.7%
Professionalism 13 7.6%
Theft 1 0.6%
Insight 5 2.9%
Traffic 4 2.3%
Behaviour 37 21.5%
Drug 3 1.7%
Engagement 11 6.4%
Total cases 170
FTP Concern: Health # %
Conduct 123 63.4%
Health 22 11.3%
Health/conduct 22 11.3%
Conduct; conviction/caution 24 12.4%
Health; conduct; conviction/caution 1 0.5%
Conduct; conviction/caution; other 2 1.0%
Total cases 45 23.1%
FTP Concern: Health detail # %
Health generic 27 60.0%
Mental health 18 40.0%
Total cases 45 100%
FTP Concern: Conviction/Caution # %
Misconduct 123 63.4%
Health 22 11.3%
Health/Misconduct 22 11.3%
Misconduct; conviction/caution 24 12.4%
Health; misconduct; conviction/caution 1 0.5%
Misconduct; conviction/caution; other 2 1.0%
Total cases 27 13.9%
FTP Concern: Conviction/Caution detail # %
Criminal Damage 2 7.4%
Bodily harm 3 11.1%
Drug 4 14.8%
Traffic 7 25.9%
Sexual 4 14.8%
Theft 1 3.7%
Fraud 2 7.4%
Not stated 5 18.5%
Total cases 27
Type of concern summary
88.6% of cases presented with conduct23.1% with health13.9% with conviction/caution
9.2% with mental health concerns
# Cases with FTP outcome by Year of Study (Total: 194)
17
35 35
44
36
2 24
19
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
50
1 2 3 4 5 6 F1 Other Notstated
Year of Study
Type of concern by Year of Study 1 to 5 (Total: 164)
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
50
1 2 3 4 5
Year of Study
# o
f ca
ses
Conduct; conviction/caution; other
Health; Conduct;conviction/caution
Conduct; conviction/caution
Health
Health/Conduct
Conduct
Outcomes by Year of Study 1 to 5 (excl. not complete, Non FTP or not stated) (Total: 146)
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
1 2 3 4 5
Year of Study
# o
f ca
ses
Informal Undertaking
Support
Warning +
Conditions/Undertakings
Suspension/Temp withdrawal
Expulsion/withdrawl
Representation # %
Legal 14 7.2%
Student rep 7 3.6%
Family 3 1.5%
No 22 11.3%
Yes 1 0.5%
Absent 2 1.0%
Not stated 15 7.7%
Other 12 6.2%
N/A 118 60.8%
Total 194 100.0%
Representation N/A # %
FTP Committee 13 11.0%
HC Committee 14 11.9%
SP Committee 16 13.6%
Investigation 19 16.1%
Support 55 46.6%
Other 1 0.8%
Total 118 100.0%
Panel composition
External members on FTP panels?
Yes: 30 schools
No: One school
Medical professional on appeals panels?
Yes: 25 schools
No: Six schools
Future Enhanced Annual Returns
Mental health?E and D data (Ethnicity, age, gender)?Data Protection concerns?Standardising terms?OIA involvement?A more complete data set
Analysing SFTP information from the first
Enhanced Annual Return
Ian HicksPolicy, Education Directorate, GMC