an osh inspector’s perspective: nano diesel particulate ... · bogger operator 9 57.9 136.4 0.7...
TRANSCRIPT
15/12/2019
1
An OSH Inspector’s Perspective: Nano Diesel Particulate Matter in a Single Underground Mine
Lindy Nield MAIOH, MSc, BSc(Hons), Grad. Dip. Occ. Hyg.
OSH InspectorStatewide Health Team
• A Study of Nano Diesel Particulate Matter (nDPM) Behaviour and Physico-chemical changes in Underground Hard Rock Mines of Western Australia (MRIWA PROJECT M495) – final report 13 June 2019
Silvia Black and Ben Mullinshttp://www.dmp.wa.gov.au/Safety/Reports-16199.aspx
• Potential Health Effects on Workers from Exposure to Diesel Engine Exhaust (DEE) in an Underground Gold Mine – to be published peer-reviewed journals
Alison Reid and Ben MullinsPublished separately in peer-reviewed journals
• Critical review of recent diesel exhaust exposure health impact research relevant to the underground hardrock mining industry
Katherine Landwehr, Alex Larcombe, Alison Reid and Ben Mullinshttp://www.dmp.wa.gov.au/Documents/Safety/MSH_nPDM_Study_LitReview.pdf
Independent research commissioned by MIACFunded by DMIRS and MRIWA
1
2
15/12/2019
2
A Study of Nano Diesel Particulate Matter (nDPM) Behaviour and Physico-chemical changes in Underground Hard Rock Mines of Western Australia
• To assess:
− character of nDPM, its behaviour and also size, number and mass-based concentrations in underground hard rock mine environments
− examine the effects of elevated pressures and temperatures (as found in deeper mines) on nDPM formation and evolution
− Whether conventional monitoring (EC / NIOSH 5040) is less relevant to modern engines?
DEEE Characterisation and Exposure Monitoring – Methodology Overview
Over a two week period in October 2017, in a single underground gold mine:
• Part 1 – Tracer gas technology & computational fluid dynamics (CFD)− SF6 tracer gas monitoring as a surrogate for diesel engine exhaust emissions
(DEEE)− CFD – 2 dimensional model
• Part 2 – DEEE exposure monitoring− nDPM in situ real-time and personal exposure monitoring − Components of DEEE mixture
• Part 3 – Deep mine studies− Chamber studies investigating chemical changes under pressure
3
4
15/12/2019
3
5
Methodology – Part 1 – SF6 simulation
Tracer gas study on the Bogging activity.
5
6
15/12/2019
4
7
Findings – Part 1 – SF6 simulation
8
Findings – Part 1 – SF6 simulation
7
8
15/12/2019
5
Tracer study output
Ventilation conditions
9
10
15/12/2019
6
Findings – Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) Studies
Findings – Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) Studies
11
12
15/12/2019
7
Findings – Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) Studies
Methodology – Exposure Monitoring
Over a two week period in October 2017, in a single underground gold mine:
• Fixed in situ real-time gas and nDPM monitors compared to personal monitoring for:
− nDPM as EC - (NIOSH 5040/EC)
− VOCs
− NOx
− CO and CO2
− SOx
• Comparison of personal exposures of workers conducting specified tasks by underground and on-surface workers
13
14
15/12/2019
8
Particle size monitoring during the Charging activity
Part 2 – Methodology – Deep mine studies
• To investigate generation of “new” or secondary nanoparticles (under elevated pressures) at depth, based on the potential influence elevated pressure and ammonia concentrations may have on the physiochemical characteristics of diesel exhaust particulate matter.
15
16
15/12/2019
9
Experiment flow
Part 2 – Methodology and Findings Deep mine studies
17
18
15/12/2019
10
Part 3 - Findings - DEE exposure
ExposuresUnderground
(median)
Surface
(median)
EC (μg/m3) 56.5 1.4
Total VOCs (μg/m3) 111.5 51.2
NO2 (μg/m3) 0.33 0.02
Particle number (pt/ccm) 52,740 8,763
Particle size (nm) 57.8 50.4
Exposure standards:
EC is 100 μg/m3 8 hour TWA & NO2 is 5600 μg/m3 8 hour TWA
Findings - Highest exposures by job type
Job title
N EC
(median)
(μg/m3)
VOCs
(median)
(μg/m3)
NO2
(median)
(μg/m3)
Particle
number
(median)
(pt/ccm)
Particle size
(median)
(nm)
Service crew 8 89.5 93.8 0.7 85,400 61
Driller / offsider 15 68.9 93.3 0.4 95,100 50
Jumbo operator 7 65.4 192.4 0.3 54,800 66
Bogger operator 9 57.9 136.4 0.7 41,500 65
Nipper 3 41.3 189.9 0.5 82,100 57
Exposure standards: EC is 100 μg/m3 8 hour TWA, NO2 is 5600 μg/m3 8 hour TWA
19
20
15/12/2019
11
Part 4 - Health Study - what participants did
Before work
• Completed a questionnaire
• Provided a urine sample
• Height /weight/ blood pressure/ lung function measured
• Fitted with personal monitoring equipment
After work
• Completed a questionnaire
• Post-exposure urine sample
• Post-exposure lung function test
• Provided a blood sample – DNA methylation analysis
Results for Underground Miners
• Fewer years overall working in the mining industry (7.8 v 12.5 years)
• Higher systolic blood pressure (142.6 mmHg v 135.5 mmHg)
• More current smokers (37.5% v 15%) but difference not statistically
significant
• Body Mass Index – 85% overweight or obese
• No other statistically significant differences in the demographics data
between underground and above ground miners
21
22
15/12/2019
12
Summary of lung function testing results
• Statistical differences in lung function between above and underground miners
• Lung function decreased over the 12 hour shift for underground miners
• The decrease was associated with diesel exposure, and remained after adjusting for smoking, age, height, shift on swing, years in mining
• On average, the decrease was 70 mL.− A ‘normal’ lung function result can vary by 150 mL diurnally
− Hence, reported changes observed were within the normal range of diurnal variation, on average.
Draft manuscript - Association between diesel engine exhaust exposure and lung
function in Australian gold miners
Urine Biomarker and Blood results
• These next results contribute to a general understanding of the effects of workers’ exposure to diesel.
• They don’t provide any information about the current health status of individual workers.
− Use for biological monitoring to detect individual exposure levels is not supported as no strong correlation between exposure to DEE and either of the metrics was shown consistently.
Du M, Mullins BJ, Franklin P, Musk AW, Elliot NSJ, Sodhi-Berry N, Junaldi E, de Klerk NH, Reid A. (2019) Measurement of urinary 1-aminopyrene and 1-hydroxypyrene as biomarkers of exposure to diesel particulate matter in gold miners. Science of the Total Environment. Vol 685;723-728.
23
24
15/12/2019
13
Urinary biomarkers of diesel exposure
Two biomarkers associated with diesel exposure measured:
• 1-hydroxypyrene (1-OHP) and 1-aminopyrene (1-AP)
• 1-OHP is the more commonly used measure, but is more strongly
influenced by smoking and diet
• 1-AP is a ‘better’ measure as it only responds to diesel exposure
• Both measures increased at the end of the 12 hour shift.
• 1-AP is a useful measure of DE uptake and is easy to measure (no
monitoring equipment to wear).
Blood analysis – DNA methylation
• Single blood sample collected at end of shift used to measure DNA
methylation
• After accounting for age and smoking status, we found 41/20,000
genes had reduced methylation (below the average level), which
appeared to be associated with diesel exposure.
• Cigarette smoking also reduces methylation, however to a much
greater extent. Studies in smokers find this is largely reversible after
five years of quitting.
• There is no evidence that the methylation levels found in this study
will lead to any health effects.
Draft manuscript - DNA Methylation following exposure to diesel particulate matter in an underground mine: Relationship to exposure parameters.
25
26
15/12/2019
14
Study recommendations
• Ensure ventilation in place and functioning – especially at dead-ends
• Improve systems around the spraymech to reduce exhaust exposure
• Change cabin air filters regularly
Individual workers
• Keep cab doors and windows closed
• Wear appropriate respirators / RPE when working underground
• Ensure proper respirator fit and regularly maintain it (if not disposable).
Historical DPM results submitted to DMIRS
27
28
15/12/2019
15
The good news …… from DMIRS
• Ventilation Management Plans are in place
− Diesel particulate filters (DPF) on machines have successfully reduced
diesel emission counts since 2006
− 4 out of 100 measurements are too high rather than most.
• Learnings from this study:
− Real-time monitors are now available to measure particle counts
− Alarms can be set to indicate when to switch off or remove vehicles
from an area to make it safer.
− Ventilation models are effective and are recommended to assist
ventilation design at all stages of operations and assessment.
Part 4 – Literature Review - Recommendations
− TWA (8 hour) of <50mg/m3 diesel particles (ultrafine)
− People with respiratory and cardiovascular conditions are the most susceptible to DEE
− The study takes a public health view to protect workers (!?!)
− Based on a lowest adverse observable effect level approach
− 35mg/m3 elemental carbon to limit health effects
− Improve testing of DEE mixture – possibly combining EC and NOx
− Equip diesel engines with after-treatment technology (DPF, Adblue)
29
30