an investigation of the preceptors' perceptions of benefits, rewards, supports, and commitment to...
TRANSCRIPT
-
7/25/2019 An investigation of the preceptors' perceptions of benefits, rewards, supports, and commitment to the preceptor r
1/103
LOYOLA UNIVERSITY CHICAGO
AN INVESTIGATION OF THE PRECEPTORS PERCEPTIONS OF BENEFITS,REWARDS, SUPPORTS, AND COMMITMENT TO THE PRECEPTOR ROLE
AMONG A SAMPLE OF NURSES
A DISSERTATION SUBMITTED TO
THE FACULTY OF THE GRADUATE SCHOOL
IN CANDIDACY FOR THE DEGREE OF
DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY
PROGRAM IN EDUCATIONAL PSYCHOLOGY
BY
CARMELLA MORAN
CHICAGO, ILLINOIS
MAY 2005
roduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
-
7/25/2019 An investigation of the preceptors' perceptions of benefits, rewards, supports, and commitment to the preceptor r
2/103
UMI Number: 3174254
Copyright 2005 by
Moran, Carmella
All rights reserved.
INFORMATION TO USERS
The quality of this reproduction is dependent upon the quality of the copy
submitted. Broken or indistinct print, colored or poor quality illustrations and
photographs, print bleed-through, substandard margins, and improper
alignment can adversely affect reproduction.
In the unlikely event that the author did not send a complete manuscript
and there are missing pages, these will be noted. Also, if unauthorized
copyright material had to be removed, a note will indicate the deletion.
UMIUMI Microform 3174254
Copyright 2005 by ProQuest Information and Learning Company.
All rights reserved. This microform edition is protected against
unauthorized copying under Title 17, United States Code.
ProQuest Information and Learning Company
300 North Zeeb RoadP.O. Box 1346
Ann Arbor, Ml 48106-1346
roduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
-
7/25/2019 An investigation of the preceptors' perceptions of benefits, rewards, supports, and commitment to the preceptor r
3/103
Copyright by Carmella M. Moran, 2005All rights reserved
roduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
-
7/25/2019 An investigation of the preceptors' perceptions of benefits, rewards, supports, and commitment to the preceptor r
4/103
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
I wish to express my sincere gratitude to the individuals on my dissertation
committee who provided guidance and support throughout the dissertation process.
Ronald R Morgan, chairman of the dissertation committee, has been a mentor throughout
my doctoral studies. His guidance and support have been indispensable to the completion
of this dissertation research project. Jack Kavanagh provided Ms statistical expertise and
encouragement to my efforts. Special thanks are extended to Virginia Keck, who''s
mentoring has had a significant impact on my professional growth and career. Thank you
all very much.
roduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
-
7/25/2019 An investigation of the preceptors' perceptions of benefits, rewards, supports, and commitment to the preceptor r
5/103
DEDICATION
It is with great love that I dedicate tWs dissertation to my husband Tim and my
son Joey. Your love, support, and encouragement has allowed me to complete my
doctoral studies. I would also like to dedicate this dissertation to my parents, Tony and
Toni, whose love, support, and guidance has contributed to the success of this important
milestone in my life. Finally, I would like to thank all my family and friends who have
put up with me through this long process.
roduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
-
7/25/2019 An investigation of the preceptors' perceptions of benefits, rewards, supports, and commitment to the preceptor r
6/103
TABLE OF CONTENTS
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS.................. ...... .... ..... .... .... .... .... ..... .... .... ........Iii
LIST OF FIGURES................ . ...................................................................................... vii
LIST OF TABLES.......................................................................
A B S T R A C T ..........................................................................................ix
CHAPTER I: INTROD UCT ION...................... ... ... ... ... ... ... .... .... .... .... ... .... 1
Foundations WithinTheDisciplineof Educational Psychology....................... 4
Social Constructivist Views of Learning. ............. .4
Mentoring............................................................................................................................ 5
Apprenticeship................................................................................................................... 7Distinction Between Expert and Novice Learners ........................................................ 8
Brief Description of Study. ........................................ 9Research Que stions ......................................................................................................... 10
CHAPTER II; REVIEW OF LITERATURE ...................................... ..12
Roleof Preceptor............................................................................................................... 12
Selection an dPreparation. ........................................................................................... 13
PreceptorBenefits, Support, an dRewards ........ 16
New Graduatesin SpecializedSettings.................................................... 18
ProfessionalImplications...........................................................................
21
CHAPTER HI: METHOD .................... .............24
Procedure ........................................................................................................... ............24
Participantsand SamplingPl a n ................... 25
Inst ru men ta tion .............................................................................. 27
De si g n ....................... 28
Hypotheses ............... 28
StatisticalAna lyses ....... 29
CHAPTERIV: RESULTS .... ..... ...... ..... ...... ..... ..... ...... ..... ...... ..... ...... .....3 0
SampleCharacteristics ................... 30Demographic information .......... 30
Nursing L icensu re ....................................... .33Education of Participants............... ...33
Employment In form ation .................... 36
Current Enrolm ent in a N ursing Education P rog ram ........ 40
v
roduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
-
7/25/2019 An investigation of the preceptors' perceptions of benefits, rewards, supports, and commitment to the preceptor r
7/103
Precepting Newly Hired Nurses ............................................... ............................ 41
Precep ting Nursing Students ....................... 42
Precepting T rainin g ........................................................ 44
R es u l ts R e l a t ed t o A d d ress in g Res ea rch Q u est io n l ................................... 46
ResultsRelatedto Addressing ResearchQuestion2 .................. 49
ResultsRelatedto Addressing ResearchQuestion3................
51
ResultsRelatedto AddressingResearchQuestion4 ....................................... .53
ResultsRelatedto AddressingResearchQuestion5 .......................... 55
CHA PTERV : DISCUSSION. .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ................. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .57
DiscussionrleatedtoaddressingResearchQuestion1 ............. 58
Discussionrleatedtoaddressing ResearchQuestion2 .................................... 59
Discussionrleatedto addressing Research Question3 .................................... 60
DiscussionrleatedtoaddressingResearchQuestion4 ..................... .60
Discussionrleatedtoaddressing Research Question1 .................. 60
LimitationsOfThe St u d y.................................................................................
61
Recommendations ForFutureResearch ................................................................... 62
APPENDICES
AppendixA: LetterTo PotentialParticipants...................................................... 65
AppendixB: ApprovalForConductingRe se a rch ................................................ 67
AppendixC: PreceptorQuestionnaire...................................................................... 69
Appendix D: Permiss ion To Use The Pre ce p to r Q ue s t ionn ai re ....................... 74
AppendixE: HighestRan k-OrderedMeanScoresForPreceptors
PerceptionofBenefitsand Re w a r d s................................................ 76
AppendixF: HighestRan k-orderedMea nScoresForPreceptorsPerceptionof BenefitsAnd Rewardsm D ibertand
Ggldenberg1995 St u d y .................. 78
REFERENCES ........ ........SO
VITA ......... ............86
vi
roduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
-
7/25/2019 An investigation of the preceptors' perceptions of benefits, rewards, supports, and commitment to the preceptor r
8/103
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure1: E thnicity OfParticipants ............... 32
Figu re 2: Y ea rs Licensed As A R e g i ste re d N u r s e ..................................... ..33
Figure3: BasicNursingPreparation . ........................... ................................... 34
Figure4: HighestNursingdegreeObtained.................................................................. 35
Fi g u r e s : HighestNon NursingDegree ....................... ...36
Figure6: E mploymentIn fo rm a tio n ..................................... '......................................... .37
Fi g u re?: HoursWo r k e d .................... 38
Figure8: TypeOfNursingUn it ....................................................... ....39
Figure 9: Type OfNursingProgramParticipantsAre Enrol ledIn ............. 41
Figure10: PreceptingNewlyH ired Nu r s e s....................................................................
42
Figure11: PreceptingNursing St u d e n t s ....................................................................... 43
Figure12: NumberOfYearsAsPreceptor...................................................................... 44
Figure13: PreceptorTraining............................................................................................. 45
Figure14: P receptedAsA New Here ............................................................................... 46
vii
roduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
-
7/25/2019 An investigation of the preceptors' perceptions of benefits, rewards, supports, and commitment to the preceptor r
9/103
LIST OF TABLES
Table1: A ComparativeSummary OfCharacteristicsAssociatedWith
Precep tors , M entors, A n d M asters. .................... ..7
Table2: DistributionOfParticipantsAcrossNursingUnit s. ............. ..26
Table3: AgeOf Participants.............................................................. 31
Table4: CurrentEnroll men tin ANursingProgram .......... 40Table5: RelationshipBetweenPPBR Scalean dCPR Scale ....................... 47
Table6: HighestRan k-OrderedM ea nScoresForPreceptors Perception
Of Benefitsand Rewards .............................. ....49
Table7: RelationshipBetweenPPS ScaleAnd CPR Scale. ............. 50
Table8: RelationshipBetweenThe Preceptors YearsOfNursing
ExperienceAnd The Preceptors Perception OfBenefitsAnd
RewardsAssociatedWithThe Ro l e ...................................................... 51
Table9: RelationshipBetweenThePreceptors YearsOf Nursing
ExperienceAnd The Preceptors Perception OfSupport
AssociatedWith The Ro l e ..................................... 52
Table10: RelationshipBetweenThe Preceptors YearsOfNursing
ExperienceAnd The Preceptors Commitment AssociatedWith
TheRole.................................................................................................................. 53
Table 11: D ifferencesIn ResponsesOn ThePPBR, PPS And CPR Scale
AcrossNursing Units.............................................................. 54
Table12: RelationshipAmong Preceptors HavingBee nPreceptedIn
Orientation, The PPBR, PPS, And CPR Scales...................... 55
Table 13: D ifferencesBetweenPreceptors HavingBeenPreceptedIn
(M entationAnd ThePPBR, PPS, And CPR Scales.................................... 56
Table14: HighestRank-OrderedMea n ScoresForPreceptors Perception
OfBenefitsAnd RewardsIn DibertAndGoldenberg1995 Study 79
vlii
roduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
-
7/25/2019 An investigation of the preceptors' perceptions of benefits, rewards, supports, and commitment to the preceptor r
10/103
Carmella M. Moran
Loyola University Chicago
PRECEPTORS PERCEPTIONS OF BENEFITS, REWARDS, SUPPORTS, ANDCOMMITMENT TO THE PRECEPTOR ROLE
ABSTRACT
Preceptorship programs are widely used for socialization of newly hired nurses.
Apreceptor program is an organized method of training new employees by an
experienced staff nurse who serves as a resource and guide to the new graduate and/or
new hire as they learn their role. Apreceptor is defined as someone who takes the novice
with minimal skills and knowledge to a level of competency. The preceptor works one-
on-one with the new graduate (referred to as the preceptee) in structured activities to help
them master basic skills, knowledge, role expectations, andprocedures, as well as the
socialization process. Preceptors are staff who take on the role o f preceptor along with
their patient care nursing responsibilities. Preceptors agree to partner with the new hire to
share knowledge, facilitate integration of newly hired staff and obtain recognition and job
satisfaction. Preceptorship programs are encouraged to take into consideration the
special needs and concerns of the preceptors. It should be noted that the establishment
and maintenance of a preceptor program requires significant financial and human
resources. Such an investment could be lost ifpreceptors are not supported after they are
in the role.ix
roduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
-
7/25/2019 An investigation of the preceptors' perceptions of benefits, rewards, supports, and commitment to the preceptor r
11/103
This study was designed as a systematic replication of the study conducted by
Dibert and Goldenberg (1995). The overall purpose of this dissertation research project
was to examine the relationships among preceptors perceptions of benefits, rewards,
supports, and commitment to the preceptor role at a community-based medical center in
the midwestem part o f the United States. The term preceptor was defined as a registered
nurse with at least one year of clinical experience who teaches, instructs, supervises, and
serves as a role model for a graduate nurse or a student, for a set period of time, in a
formalized preceptorship program. A sample of 674 professional registered nurses were
invited to complete a four-part questionnaire consisting of the Preceptors Perception of
Benefits and Rewards (PPBR) Scale, the Preceptors Perception of Support (PPS) Scale,
the Commitment to the Preceptor Role (CPR) Scale and a demographic scale. As in the
research study conducted by Dibert and Goldenberg (1995), benefits and rewards were
defined as positive outcomes associated with a service. These outcomes were measured
using the Preceptors Perception of Benefits and Rewards (PPBR) Scale. Supports were
defined as the conditions that enabled the performance of a function. The Preceptors
Perception of Support Scale was designed to measure support. Commitment was defined
as attitudes, which reflected dedication to thepreceptor role. The Preceptor Role Scale
was used to measure commitment. Five research questions were addressed. (1) What is
the relationship between the preceptors perception of benefits and rewards associated
with the preceptor role and thepreceptors commitment to the role? (2) What is the
relationship between the preceptors perception of support for the preceptor role and the
preceptors commitment to the role? (3) What is the relationship between the preceptors
years of nursing experience and the preceptors (a) perception o f benefits and rewardsx
roduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
-
7/25/2019 An investigation of the preceptors' perceptions of benefits, rewards, supports, and commitment to the preceptor r
12/103
associated with the preceptor role, (b) perception of support for the preceptor role, and (c)
commitment to the role? (4) Are there any differences in the preceptors (a) perception
of benefits and rewards associated with thepreceptor role, (b) perception of support for
the preceptor role, and (c) commitment to the role across types of units in which the
preceptor works? (5) What is the relationship among the preceptor having been
precepted in orientation and thepreceptors (a) perception of benefits and rewards
associated with the preceptor role, (b) perception of support for the preceptor role, and (c)
commitment to the role?
A between subjects design was used to address the research questions and test the
null hypotheses. The independent variables included: the preceptors experience with
being precepted; the preceptors level of preparation; years of experience as a preceptor;
age; type of basic nursing preparation; highest nursing degree held; highest non-nursing
degree held; years licensed as a registered nurse and type of hospital unit in which the
preceptor worked. The dependent measures included; perception o f benefits and rewards;
perception of support; and commitment to the preceptor role.
Surveys were distributed to 674 registered nurses. Staff employed for at least one
year and with preceptor responsibilities were invited to participate in the study. A packet
of materials was assembled for each participant. Potential respondents (n=488) included
a sample of registered nurses who functioned as preceptors in one of 23 nursing units.
Survey results were received from 105 registered nurses. The response rate was 21.5% of
the population targeted for systematic study. An examination of the scores on the
Preceptors Perceptions of Benefits and Rewards Scale indicated that preceptors are
likely to be committed to the preceptor role when there are what they consider to be
xi
roduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
-
7/25/2019 An investigation of the preceptors' perceptions of benefits, rewards, supports, and commitment to the preceptor r
13/103
worthwhile benefits and rewards associated with the role. Participants reported that they
worked as a preceptor for the opportunity to share their knowledge with new nurses and
nursing students., to teach new staff nurses and nursing students, to assist new staff and
nursing students to integrate into the nursing unit and to contribute to their profession
and to gain personal satisfaction from the role. The items reported to be least important
were the opportunity to influence change on their nursing unit, improvement in
organizational skills, increased involvement in the organization within the hospital and
improved chances for promotion and/or advancement within the institution.
Relationships were found between the scores on the Preceptors Perception of
Support Scale and Commitment to the Preceptor Role Scale. These findings indicate that
the more the preceptors perceived that there were supports associated with the preceptor
role, the more they were committed to the role. Taken together, the findings of this study
appear to be congruent with those reported by Dibert and Goldenberg (1995).
A linear regression analysis procedure was used to determine if there was a
relationship between the preceptors years of nursing experience and the preceptors (a)
perception of benefits and rewards associated with the preceptor role, (b) perception of
support for the preceptor role, and (c) commitment to the role. In the original study,
Dibert and Goldenberg (1995) also found no relationship between the years of nursing
experience and the preceptors perception of benefits and rewards, and supports or
commitment to the preceptor role. No differences were found between the type o f unit
the preceptor works on and the preceptors (a) perception of benefits and rewards
associated with the preceptor role, (b) perception o f support for the preceptor role, and (c)
commitment to the role.xli
roduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
-
7/25/2019 An investigation of the preceptors' perceptions of benefits, rewards, supports, and commitment to the preceptor r
14/103
A linear regression analysis procedure was used to determine if there were
relationships among the preceptor having been precepted in orientation and the
preceptors (a) perception of benefits and rewards associated with the preceptor role, (b)
perception o f support for the preceptor role, and (c) commitment to the role. None of the
variables when examined alone accounted for any variability. However, a statistically
significant difference was found across the participant groups (those who had been
precepted in orientation compared to those who had not) on the Preceptors Perception of
Benefits and Rewards (PPBR) Scale, Preceptors Perception of Support (PPS) Scale, and
Commitment to the Preceptor Role (CPR) Scale when the variables were examined
together.
The economic climate in health care necessitates that orientation programs
prepare new hires and graduates to function effectively and efficiently as soon as
possible. It is important that educators and clinicians responsible for developing
orientation programs and selecting preceptors are informed about issues related to
successful preceptor programs. The preceptor is believed to be the key person who
contributes toward the successful completion o f the orientation process for new nurses.
Preceptors have traditionally been selected for the role because o f their clinical
expertise. While clinical expertise is a very important requirement, it cannot be the only
quality that preceptors possess. Having an interest in teaching, demonstrating good
interpersonal skills, self-confidence, and patience are all reported to be important
qualities in a preceptor. In sum, the effectiveness of the preceptorship is based on the
quality of the preceptors. Understanding the preceptors experiences and perceptions
with regard to the benefits, rewards, and supports for the relationship with graduate
xiii
roduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
-
7/25/2019 An investigation of the preceptors' perceptions of benefits, rewards, supports, and commitment to the preceptor r
15/103
nurses can be a means to improve and promote effective transition, retention, satisfaction,
and socialization to the role of professional registered nurse. The preceptor relationship
is mutually beneficial for the nurse, the preceptor, and the hospital. Such a relationship
elevates the professionalism and skill of the new hire and/or graduates as well as the
preceptors. In a period of severe shortages of experienced nurses, preceptorship
programs are believed to be particularly important with respect to mitigating the negative
effects of such a shortage by providing an efficient and effective tool to maintain quality
patient care.
roduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
-
7/25/2019 An investigation of the preceptors' perceptions of benefits, rewards, supports, and commitment to the preceptor r
16/103
CHAPTER I
Introduction
Preceptorship programs are widely used for socialization of newly hired nurses
(Shaman & Infaaber, 1985). The shortage of qualified nurses, increasedpatient acuity,
and early patient discharges puts substantial pressure on the new nursing graduate to
perform independently and quickly. In their transition to the professional role, graduate
nurses share a variety of experiences with more experienced registered nurses. These
experiences are reported to have an impact on the graduate nurses own professional
development and socialization to the professional role. For example, Thomka (2001)
reported that there is considerable literature related to the concept of mentoring in nursing
and its role in the professional development of nurses, but there is little documentation
related to the graduate nurses experiences and perceptions with regard to the initial
relationship building with experienced staff during orientation to their first practice
setting.
Challenges faced by new graduates in their transition to the role of professional
registered nurse were first identified by Kramer (1974). Approximately 35% to 60% of
new graduates change places of employment during the first year. This change inplace
of employment has been reported (Delaney, 2003) to have negative affects for nurses and
health care institutions. It is well documented (Alexander, 1993, Kotecki, 1992,
Oermann &Moffitt-Wolf, 1997, Reilly &Oermann, 1992) that new graduate orientation
programs that utilize preceptors can effectively narrow thepractice-theory gap that exists1
roduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
-
7/25/2019 An investigation of the preceptors' perceptions of benefits, rewards, supports, and commitment to the preceptor r
17/103
within the nursing profession. It should be noted that the establishment and maintenance
of a preceptor program requires significant financial and human resources. Such an
investment could be lost if preceptors are not supported after they are in the role.
The concept of preceptor originated in the 15th century to describe a teacher who
was responsible for the transmission of precepts. Precepts are defined as principles
governing conduct, actions, and/or procedures-to one or more understudies (Bowles,
1995). Shamian and Infaaber (1985) define preceptorship as a period o f time used for
orientation and socialization of new graduates. Romas (2003) defines a preceptor as
someone who takes the novice with minimal skills and knowledge to a level of
competency. The preceptor works one-on-one with the new graduate (referred to as the
preceptee) in structured activities to help them master basic skills, knowledge, role
expectations, and procedures, as well as the socialization process.
According to Finger and Pape (2002), precepting includes both personal and
professional development. Kramer (1974) provided evidence to support the view that
new graduates experience high levels of stress, value conflict and role uncertainty to the
extent that frustration, expressions of hostility, burnout, and resignation were not
uncommon during the transition to becoming professional registered nurses. Kramer
(1974) referred to the discrepancy between the concept of nursing introduced in school
and the realities of clinical practice as reality shock. Preceptors are viewed as facilitating
competence and confidence In practice while decreasing the reality shock that many new
nurses encounter.
Researchers (Bick, 2000; DeSimone, 1999) have defined preceptors roles in
numerous ways. A review of the literature by Burke (1994) contains a description of the
roduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
-
7/25/2019 An investigation of the preceptors' perceptions of benefits, rewards, supports, and commitment to the preceptor r
18/103
3
role of a preceptor as having several main functions (e.g., providing orientation and
support and the teaching and sharing of clinical expertise). Preceptors provide the new
graduate nurse with support as they transition into the role of a professional registered
nurse. Morrow (1994) defined the preceptor as a staff nurse, who teaches, counsels and
inspires, serves as a roie model, and supports growth and development of an individual
for a fixed and limited amount o f time with the specific purpose of socializing the new
graduate into the role. Cerinus and Ferguson (1994) provide documentation for the
multiplicity and complexity of the responsibilities of the preceptor. Shamian and Inhaber
(1985) compared preceptor responsibilities to the nursing process. They described the
preceptor as being responsible for the assessment of the preceptee, planning of the
preceptorship period to meet individual needs, the implementation of teaching and role
modeling, and evaluation o f the preceptee throughout the preceptorship period.
According to Squires (2002), regardless of age or educational preparation, new
graduate nurses experience similar emotions when starting a new job. Positive emotions
include excitement at the thought of being paid, a sense of accomplishment at having
successfully graduated from nursing school and passing the NCLEX-RN examination
(Squires, 2002). Negative emotions experienced by most new graduates involve fear of
making mistakes, stress over their ability to manage all aspects of care for patient
assignment, and the clash between educational preparation and the realities of clinical
practice (Hamel, 1990 & Oermann & Moffitt-Wolf, 1997).
roduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
-
7/25/2019 An investigation of the preceptors' perceptions of benefits, rewards, supports, and commitment to the preceptor r
19/103
4
Foundations within the Discipline of Educational Psychology
The study was anchored within the discipline of educational psychology. The
knowledge structures and frameworks used to organize the study included: social
constructivist views of learning; mentoring, apprenticeships; and distinctions between
expert and novice learners.
Social Constructivist Views of Learning. Social learning theory emphasizes
that we learn much by observing those around us. We acquire knowledge, skills,
attitudes, and culturally appropriate behavior, more efficiently and with fewer mistakes
when we observe the behaviors and the consequences of those behaviors. In a classic
study, Bandura (1963) illustrated the impact of and the conditions necessary for
observational learning to occur. Bandura demonstrated that exposure to a model can
affect a persons ability to learn new behavior.
The transition between nursing school and work canbe a difficult journey. A
preceptor can assist and support a successful transition from student to professional
registered nurse. The overall trend in learning theory has been toward a shift away from
behavioral to cognitive psychology. Ann Browns theory of learning is an example of a
current cognitive, social and cultural constructivist view. Ann Brown (1994) views
learners as active constructors, rather than passive recipients of knowledge. According to
Brown, the fundamental principle behind the design o f a community of learners is to lure
students into enacting roles typical of a research community. It is the role of the expert
(professional registered nurse) in the community of learners to teach other group
members (new graduate nurses) to become experts. Precepting focuses on facilitating the
learning of the members of the community.
roduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
-
7/25/2019 An investigation of the preceptors' perceptions of benefits, rewards, supports, and commitment to the preceptor r
20/103
5
The assumption that a great deal of learning takes place within a cooperative
social environment is representative of the views of Russian psychologist Lev Vygotsky.
According to Vygotsky, individual intellectual development cannot be understood
without reference to the social context in which the individual exists. In Vygotskys
theory, social interactions are expected to promote development through the guidance of
people who have achieved the desired skill (Rogoffi, 1990). Vygotskys model for the
mechanism through which social interactions facilitate cognitive development resembles
an apprenticeship in which a novice learner works closely with an expert in joint problem
solving activities within a zone of proximal development (ZPD). This allows the novice
to participate in skills beyond their independent capabilities (Rogoff, 1990). Vygotskys
notion that individuals begin to learn frompeople around them, or their social world, is
applicable to the nursing profession (Gage & Berliner, 1998). According to Vygotsky,
individual intellectual development cannot be understood without reference to the social
context in which the individual exists. In Vygotskys theory, social interactions are
expected to promote development through the guidance o f people who have achieved the
desired skills. Classrooms are considered to be multiple zones of proximal development.
A zone of proximal development defines the distance between a novices current level of
learning and the level that can be reached with the help of an individual who has achieved
the desired skill (the expert) (Gage & Berliner, 1998). A new graduate nurse will have a
significant level of dependence on their preceptor and co-workers. Over time the new
graduate will assume more independence and responsibility.
Mentoring. In Websters Dictionary (Jagim, 2001), a mentor is defined as a
trusted advisor or teacher. Mentoring is an important way to team a variety of personal
roduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
-
7/25/2019 An investigation of the preceptors' perceptions of benefits, rewards, supports, and commitment to the preceptor r
21/103
6and professional skills and is considered to be one of the oldest forms of influence. It Is
believed that the concept of mentoring originated in early Greek civilization. In the
Odyssey o f Homer, the goddess Athena frequently assumes the form of Mentor when she
appears to Odysseus or Telemachus (Ryan & Brewer, 1997). Mentoring has become
synonymous to a wise and trusted teacher. Klein and DIckenson-Hazard (2000) stated
that the mentoring relationship is a lifelong process, requiring commitment of self and
time to be successful. There is considerable discussion in the literature concerning the
concept of mentoring in the nursing profession and its role in the professional
development of nurses (Usher, Nolan, Reser, Owens, & Tollefson 1999).
It should be noted that mentors are not preceptors. According to Kroil (1999),
mentors establish a long-term relationship that supports, guides and/or teaches the new
nurse. The mentor is different from other types o f teachers, such aspreceptor, supervisor,
role model, or tutor. The preceptor is often more clinically focused and serves like a role
model, whereas a mentor seeks a close and more personal relationship. The mentor is
engaged in an interactive, continuing process, whereas exposure to role models
(preceptors) is often brief. Role modeling is not necessarily interactive. Indeed a role
model may not be aware that he or she is being observed. Bhagia & Tinsley (2000)
reported that role models affect manypersons, but mentors usually have relationships
with only a few.
Mentors are usually highly experienced and seasoned professionals. However,
experience alone is no guarantee of being a successful mentor. Simmons (2000)
identified skills such as confidence, political awareness, strong moral fiber, and the
ability to motivate others as vital attributes of an effective mentor.
roduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
-
7/25/2019 An investigation of the preceptors' perceptions of benefits, rewards, supports, and commitment to the preceptor r
22/103
7
Apprenticeships. The ancientprocess of education of artisans, craftsmen, or
tradesmen w as accomplished through a master-apprentice relationship. According to
Davenport (2000), a formalized relationship is based on adherence to well outlined rules
of behavior. The role of the master is to teach the apprentice. Both previous training and
experience with a particular trade, set- of practices, or processes associated with a craft or
profession qualifies the master (expert). It is important that the master continue with the ir
individual work, despite their relationship with the apprentice. The distinguishing
characteristics among preceptors, mentors, and masters are summarized in Table!.
Table 1
A comparative summary of characteristics associated with preceptors, mentors, and
masters.
PRECEPTORS MENTORS MASTERS j
a role model, resourceperson & teacher
a trusted advisor or teacher a teacher 1
a fixed & limited timeperiod
a lifelong process a master continues their 1work, despite their Irelationship with the 1
apprentice
an organized method oftraining new workers
seeks a close & personalrelationship
a formalized relationship 1based on well outlined rules 8of behavior |
a demonstrated expertise a well experienced and
seasoned professional
a previous training &,1
experience with own trade; |practice or process of 1artistic creation qualify the 1master f
roduced with permission of the copyright owner. Furthe r reproduction prohibited without permission.
-
7/25/2019 An investigation of the preceptors' perceptions of benefits, rewards, supports, and commitment to the preceptor r
23/103
8Distinction Between Expert and Novice Learners. Experts differ from novices
in taking more time to study a problem. But once they start to work, they solve problems
faster than novices. The experts are also more likely to construct an abstract
representation of the problem in their minds. It appears that in their working memory
they hold mental representations of whatever they need to solve the problem. Experts
typically: 1) classify a problem as a particular type; 2) represent the problem visually in
their minds; and then 3) use well-known routines to solve the problem. The classification
of the problem is considered to be critically important because once a problem is
classified; the solutionseemsto follow easily. Experts have stored in memory many
problem schemata and associated actions that generally produce a solution. They have
acquired these schemata as a result of extensive experience with the phenomena in their
fields. Novices by contrast, do not appear to have developed elaborate schemata. Each
problem they face is truly new and therefore extremely difficult. It usually takes 7-10
years to become an expert (Gage & Berliner, 1998).
Benner (1984) identified the movement from novice to expert within the health
care profession as involving changes in three aspects of performance. Initially the learner
shifts from relying on abstract principles to concrete (care-based) experiences.
According to Daley (1999), a novice has little experience with real (care-based)
situations, and therefore must rely on decontextualized facts and principles. A novice
health care professional is most likely to leam through formal mechanisms such as
reading about aprocedure and/or attending a continuing education program to form
concepts. In contrast, experts tend to use more informal mechanisms such as consulting
with other health care professionals and drawing from previous situations.
roduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
-
7/25/2019 An investigation of the preceptors' perceptions of benefits, rewards, supports, and commitment to the preceptor r
24/103
9
Novice nurses move from viewing situations as discrete, and unrelated parts to
seeing situations as part of a whole (Benner, 1984). When moving from a novice to an
expert, Benner stated that the professionals position shifts from a detached observer to
an involved performer. The nurse with expertise has the ability to perceive and recognize
complex patterns in clinical situations. This specialized ability to recognize and interpret
complex patterns allows the expert to be prepared to intervene in an effort to prevent
problems before they occur. Benner (1982) reported that the expert has an intuitive grasp
of the situation and zeros in on the accurate information of the problem without wasteful
consideration of a large range of unrealistic possible solutions to a problem. Expert
nurses have the ability to recognize and interpret complex patterns in clinical situations
that are not visible to the novice. Experts recognize similarities in patient conditions in
spite of the fact that not all aspects of both conditions are the same.
Brief Description of theStudy
This study was designed as a systematic replication of a study conducted by
Dibert and Goldenberg (1995). In this study, the term preceptor was defined as a
registered nurse with at least one year of clinical experience who taught, instructed,
supervised, and served as a role model for a graduate nurse or a student, for a set period
of time, in a formalized preceptorship program. A sample of 674 professional registered
nurses from a community hospital located in the Midwestern part of the United States
was invited to complete a four-part questionnaire consisting of the Preceptors Perception
of Benefits and Rewards Scale, the Preceptors Perception of Support Scale, the
Commitment to the Preceptor Role Scale, and demographic scale. As in the original
roduced with permission of the copyright owner. Furthe r reproduction prohibited without permission.
-
7/25/2019 An investigation of the preceptors' perceptions of benefits, rewards, supports, and commitment to the preceptor r
25/103
10
study conducted by Dibert and Goldenberg (1995), benefits and rewards were defined as
positive outcomes associated with provision of a service. Benefits and rewards were
measured by the Preceptors Perception of Benefits & Rewards (PPBR) Scale. Dibert
and Goldenberg defined Supports as the conditions which enabled the performance of a
function. The Preceptors Perception of Support Scale was used to measure support.
Commitment was defined as attitudes which reflected dedication to the preceptor role.
The Preceptor Role Scale was used to measure commitment.
Research Questions
It should be noted that the first three research questions are the same as the
original research questions targeted for study by Dibert and Goldenberg (1995).
Research questions four and five are new questions. The following research questions
were addressed:
1. What is the relationship between the preceptors perception of benefits and
rewards associated with the preceptor role and the preceptors commitment to the
role?
2. What is the relationship between the preceptors perception of support for the
preceptor role and the preceptors commitment to the role?
3. What is the relationship between thepreceptors years of nursing experience and
the preceptors (a) perception of benefits and rewards associated with the
preceptor role, (b) perception of support for the preceptor role, and (c)
commitment to the role?
roduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
-
7/25/2019 An investigation of the preceptors' perceptions of benefits, rewards, supports, and commitment to the preceptor r
26/103
II
4. Are there differences in the preceptors (a) perception of benefits and rewards
associated with the preceptor role, (b) perception of support for the preceptor role,
and (c) commitment to the role across types of units in which the preceptor
works?
5. What is the relationship among the preceptor having been precepted in orientation
and the preceptors (a) perception of benefits and rewards associated with the
preceptor role, (b) perception of support for the preceptor role, and (c)
commitment to the role?
roduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
-
7/25/2019 An investigation of the preceptors' perceptions of benefits, rewards, supports, and commitment to the preceptor r
27/103
CHAPTER II
Review of the Literature
In this chapter, the following areas of research will be described and critically
evaluated: the role of the preceptor; selection and preparation of preceptors; preceptor
benefits, supports, and rewards; new graduates in specialized settings; and professional
implications.
Role of Preceptor
A review of the literature supports the use of preceptorship programs for
socialization of new graduates to the role of professional registered nurse (Dibert &
Goldenberg, 1995). In nursing, apreceptor is usually a staff nurse with demonstrated
expertise who serves as a role model, resource person, and teacher (Brasler, 1993, p.
158). A preceptor program is an organized method of training new employees by an
experienced staff nurse who serves as a resource and guide to the new graduate and/or
new hire as they learn their role. Programs designed to orient the new graduate must take
into consideration the needs and concerns of the preceptors (Beaman, Jernigan, &
Hensley, 1999).
Preceptors are staff who take on the role of preceptor along with their patient care
nursing responsibilities. Preceptors agree to partner with new hire to share knowledge,
facilitate integration of newly hired staff and obtain recognition and job satisfaction
(Shamian & Inhaber, 1985, & Young et al., 1989). Preceptors are expected to possess12
roduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
-
7/25/2019 An investigation of the preceptors' perceptions of benefits, rewards, supports, and commitment to the preceptor r
28/103
13
experience, advanced clinical skills, and a willingness to teach (Wright, 2002). The
formality o f the relationship is limited to the time frame of orientation. It does not
usually include a contractual component and does not necessarily include a personal
element.
The current literature does stress the importance o f a comprehensive orientation
program for new nurses (Balcain, Lendrum, Bowler, Doucette & Maskell, 1997; Beeman,
Jemigan, &Hensley, 1999). Brasler (1993) examined the effectiveness of the various
components o f an orientation program on the clinical performance of novice nurses. The
results indicated that there was a positive relationship between preceptor expertise and
novice nurses clinical performance. This finding provides support for the view that the
provision of an orientation program that addresses both knowledge and skill needs in
preceptors yields positive outcomes. As hospitals hire increasing numbers of nurses with
little or no clinical experience, the staff may be asked repeatedly to orient novice nurses.
This situation can contribute to burnout (Greene & Puetzer, 2002).
Selection and Preparation of Preceptors
Much has been written (Balcain et a i, 1997, Craven & Broyles, 1996 & Staab et
al, 1996) about the importance of training the nurse preceptors who will be working with
new graduates. Beeman, Jemigan, and Hensley (1999) claim that the preceptor should be
provided structured education to facilitate the development o f skills necessary to
effectively interact with the new graduate nurse. According to Staab et al. (1996),
preceptor training should include role modeling, completion of required documentation,
confrontation, coaching, counseling, communication models, characteristics of the adult
roduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
-
7/25/2019 An investigation of the preceptors' perceptions of benefits, rewards, supports, and commitment to the preceptor r
29/103
14
learner, learning styles, and managing those learning experiences. Staab, Granneman, and
Page-Reahr (1996) identified the preceptor as having concerns that center on the ability
to successfully meet multiple demands. These include: (a) managing individual
workload; and (b) orienting the new graduate and completing the extensive paperwork
required to document the competency of the new nurse. The preceptor is often selected
because of their clinical skills, teaching ability, and willingness to train new employees.
Johantgen (2001) provided evidence to support the notion that preceptors demonstrate
personality characteristics of maturity, enthusiasm, self-confidence, responsibility, and
respect.
A formal preceptor preparation program is essential to any orientation process and
is designed to prepare qualified staff nurses as preceptors who will ensure the
development of competent and safe practitioners. One of the challenges for educators is
to design preceptor programs with the essential content. Content should be practical and
applicable to orientation of new hires (Baltimore, 2004). Clay et al. (1999) identified
four adult educational principles that preceptor development programs should be based
on (the content is based on the perceived learning needs of the learner, material is
repeated and sequenced in a logical fashion, active learning methods facilitate retention,
and a safe, and supportive learning environment must be provided for the learners).
A key concept of adult education theory is the belief that learning for adults
should be needs-based (Cafferella, 1994; Courtney, 1992; Darkenwald &Mariam, 1982;
Knowles, 1973; & Vella, 1995). Secondly, adults dont tolerate disorganization, the
order of what will be taught, the transition from one topic to another, and the overall
understanding of the program o f study must be understood by the adult learner
roduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
-
7/25/2019 An investigation of the preceptors' perceptions of benefits, rewards, supports, and commitment to the preceptor r
30/103
15(Cafferella, 1994). Thirdly, adults expect and desire to be active learners (Cafferella,
1994; Knowles, 1973; and Vella, 1995). Vella (1995) claims that as a group, adult
learners would rather discuss a topic than hear a lecture. Knowles (1973) reported that
adults learn by -watching others (e.g., role modeling). A supportive and safe environment
improves the adults ability to team (Knowles, 1973 & Vella, 1995). OMalley et al.
(2000) proposed that the following components be included in a preceptor training
program: a definition of preceptorship and the roles of those involved; the aims and
objectives of the preceptorship; the desired qualities and responsibilities o f the
preceptors: the responsibilities of preceptees; and the benefits and disadvantages
associated with apreceptorship.
Preceptors responsibilities include role modeling, socializing, and educating
newly hired staff (Baltimore, 2004). As role models, preceptors display a competence
that others strive to emulate. Preceptors behave as socializers when actively integrating
orientees into the social culture of the unit and the facility. Helping new hires to feel
welcomed bypeers and coworkers, and assisting them in establishing relationships and
becoming familiar with the written and unwritten norms of the unit manifest further
examples of the socializing role. Educator responsibilities requires the preceptor to
assess orientation needs, plan learning experiences, and assist in the assignment selection
to facilitate the new hires achievement of learning needs and goals.
Preceptors have traditionally been selected because of their level of clinical
experience. While one would not debate this as a critical requirement, it cannot be the
only characterisitic the preceptor possesses. Having an interest in teaching, serving as a
mentor, coaching, having good communication skills, self-confidence, patience, and the
roduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
-
7/25/2019 An investigation of the preceptors' perceptions of benefits, rewards, supports, and commitment to the preceptor r
31/103
16
ability to assess learning are also considered to be key characteristics of a preceptor
(Horn, 2003). According to Fawcett (2002), preceptors who are described as
unforgettable have patience, enthusiasm, knowledge, a sense of humor and the respect of
their peers. Leadership and communication skills, decision-making ability, and a strong
interest in professional growth have also been documented as important criteria for a
preceptor (OMalley et al., 2004). Preceptors are believed to be one o f the key
individuals who influence a new graduate or newly hired nurse during orientation.
De Blois, (1991) and Westra and Graziano (1992) identified teaching/learning
strategies, principles of adult education, communication skills, values and role
clarification, conflict resolution, assessment of individual learning needs, and evaluation
of preceptee performance as being the core components o f preceptor training. Hospitals
have a responsibility to provide preceptors with the knowledge and skills necessary to
supervise and teach newly hired staff nurses. A formal preceptor preparation program is
considered essential for any successful orientation program. Qualified staff nurses are
prepared to function as preceptors. Preceptors ensure the development o f competent
practitioners.
Preceptor Benefits, Supports and Rewards
PreceptorsMps have been used to bridge the gap between nursing education and
the reality of the workplace. A competent, interested preceptor during orientation can
facilitate a successful transition from the role of student to a professional nurse. Turnbull
(1983) reported that reward mechanisms are integral to the success of preceptor
programs. Shamian and Inhaber (1985) have documented a set of intrinsic and extrinsic
roduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
-
7/25/2019 An investigation of the preceptors' perceptions of benefits, rewards, supports, and commitment to the preceptor r
32/103
17rewards associated with preceptor programs. Preceptors are more likely to be committed
to the role when they perceive the rewards to be personally and/or professionally
beneficial (OMara & Welton, 1995). According to Wright (2002), one reward for
preceptors is the satisfaction of seeing a new nurse develop into a confident professional.
McGregor (1999) stated that a preceptors realization of Ms or her own growth in the role
of a teacher can be a positive factor with respect to preventing and/or reversing burnout
in an experienced nurse. The most frequently identified preceptor benefits are the
opportunity to teach and influence practice, increase a persons knowledge base,
stimulate a persons thinking, and individualize orientation to meet preceptees learning
needs (Bizek & Oermann, 1990). In a study by conducted by Bizek and Germane (1990),
it was found that there was little or no job satisfaction associated with the preceptor role.
A case was made for the view that these negative findings were due to lack of time, little
workload relief, and low incentives. Young et al (1989) identified several issues
associated with the role of preceptor: lack of flexibility in the orientation program to meet
individual learning needs; lack of support from non-preceptor colleagues; and insufficient
time to spend with new staff and schedule changes. The researchers stressed the
importance of developing clearly identified roles and responsibilities, clinical objectives,
and providing ongoing support and guidance to overcome problematic issues.
In the Dibert and Goldenberg (1995) study, the investigators claimed that
assisting new hires to integrate into the nursing unit, teaching, improving their teaching
skills, sharing knowledge, and gaining personal satisfaction from preceptoring were the
rewarding aspects of preceptoring. In Diberts and Goldenbergs (1995) study of 59
Canadian nurses, they found that preceptors are likely to be committed to the role of
roduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
-
7/25/2019 An investigation of the preceptors' perceptions of benefits, rewards, supports, and commitment to the preceptor r
33/103
18
preceptor when there are worthwhile benefits, rewards, and supports. As noted in
Chapter I, the overall purpose of this dissertation research replication study was to
compare the Diberts and Goldenbergs findings with a sample of nurses in the United
States. Researchers, Letizia and Jennrich (1998) and Ohrling and Hailberg (2000) have
documented a number of positive intrinsic influences on preceptors. They include: the
opportunity to improve existing skills by preparation for a new role; sharing knowledge;
and stimulating personal thinking and satisfaction.
Several investigators (HitcMngs, 1989, Begle & Willis, 1984) have identified
extrinsic rewards that may be useful. They include: preceptor luncheons; journal
subscriptions; the opportunity to attend conferences; tuition waivers; and letters of
commendation. Shogan et al. (1985) administered a survey to 76 preceptors. He found
that preceptors have a broadened knowledge base and a set of clinical skills, increased
professional growth, and job satisfaction as a result o f precepting. Fehm, (1990)
identified support for preceptors as being essential to the success of preceptor programs.
Dibert and Goldenberg (1995) identified lack of support from management and other
staff and insufficient time to fulfill the preceptor role along with their other
responsibilities as problematic issues related to the successful implementation of
preceptorship programs.
New Graduates in Specialized Settings
According to Kells and Koemer, (2000) the most stressful time of a nurses career
is the first three months of employment. There are several reasons for high stress at this
point in a nurses career. First, the current educational process allows the student nurse
roduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
-
7/25/2019 An investigation of the preceptors' perceptions of benefits, rewards, supports, and commitment to the preceptor r
34/103
19less time working in the hospital environment than in previous training programs.
Second, due to the present shortage of trained nurses, newly hired nurses are often
responsible for their own patients soon after being hired. As new members of the
profession, graduate nurses will have a variety of mentoring experiences with registered
nurses during their transition to the professional role. In nursing, graduate nurses depend
on professional registered nurses for assistance with the practical application of newly
acquired nursing knowledge and the acquisition of technical skills (Thomka, 2001). The
new graduate nurse is prepared as a generalist. Passage of the licensure examination
(NCLEX-RN) only indicates that the graduate is a minimally safe practitioner. It is the
preceptor who will model the behaviors and technical skills and aid in socializing the new
graduate. The one-on-one guidance from the preceptor allows the nurse to become
familiar with an institutions policies and equipment. The preceptor provides a set of
opportunities for the new staff nurse to learn and assume increased responsibility under
the guidance of a competent experienced nurse (Wright, 2002).
As a new nurse graduate begins his or her professional career in a specialty setting
(e.g., critical care, perioperative, perinatal, mental health or community health), he or she
must develop the technical skills and demonstrate the competencies needed to provide
safe care in the desired specialty setting. The critical care setting exemplifies the
disparity between competencies that are possessed by the graduate nurse and those that
are required for the critical care setting. The new graduate is unfamiliar with the
individual agency where they choose to practice. The preceptor models behaviors and
technical skills expected on the unit, and aids in socializing the new graduate into the
work setting (Carey & Campell, 1994). Many researchers have identified that the
roduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
-
7/25/2019 An investigation of the preceptors' perceptions of benefits, rewards, supports, and commitment to the preceptor r
35/103
20
implications o f hiring inexperienced graduate nurses directly into a critical care area are
related to a decrease in quality of patient care and productivity, clinical judgment, stress,
accountability, and lack of supervision (Hughes, 1987),
Authors (Graling, Rusynko, &Penprase) have identified the perioperative setting
as being particularly challenging for new graduate nurses. The perioperative setting has
been hard hit by the nursing shortage. Two prominent reasons have been identified as
having an impact on perioperative nursing (lack o f student exposure to the perioperative
setting and a decreasing number of nurses choosing to enter the field). Penprase (2000)
discussed how an orientation program utilizing preceptors can reduce the reality shock
and prepare nurses for perioperative nursing after graduation. According to Graling &
Rusynko (2001), two years after implementation of a nurse fellowship program at a
health care system consisting of five hospitals in Virginia, the operating room nurse
vacancy rates decreased from 27% to 15.5%.
The perinatal setting is not an exception to the challenges faced by the new
graduate nurse. Clinical education hours spent in labor and delivery are often limited.
Many nursing students do not even spend an entire shift on a unit during their clinical
experience. According to Horn (2003), preceptors are one of the key individuals
impacting the new graduates transition.
According to a review o f the literature conducted by Durkin (2002), psychiatric
nursing may be at a recruitment disadvantage compared to other nursing specialties. In a
similar study, Happell (1999) stated that psychiatric nursing was one o f the least popular
specialty career choices for nurses. Results o f a study done at a large urban mental health
facility (Thomka, 2001), indicated that there is considerable consistency regarding the
roduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
-
7/25/2019 An investigation of the preceptors' perceptions of benefits, rewards, supports, and commitment to the preceptor r
36/103
21
way in which graduate psychiatric nurses receive assistance in their professional
development and role socialization.
In sum, my review of the literature related to the orientation of new graduates in
psychiatric mental health and community health settings indicated that there is a distinct
lack of information. That is to say that there appears to be very little information related
to the orientation and training of new graduates in these specialized areas.
Professional Implications
The economic climate in health care necessitates that orientation programs
prepare new hires and graduates to function effectively and efficiently as soon as
possible. It is important that educators and clinicians responsible for developing
orientation programs and selecting preceptors are informed about issues related to
successful preceptor programs (Bain, 1996). According to research conducted by
Messner, Abelleria, and Erb (1995), traditional orientation programs can cost from
$8,000 to 50,000. Experts estimate that the cost of turnover can reach as high as 150% of
the new graduates annual compensation (Contino, 2002). Considering the current and
projected nursing shortages and their effect on health care, nurse educators and
administrators need to develop preceptor programs that increase the likelihood ofnew
graduate nurse success. The current shortage of nurses requires a nurse to be
independently responsible for a patient assignment earlier than in the past.
Squires (2002) reported that the rural community hospitals challenge with new
graduate retention clearly acknowledges the importance of orientation programs.
roduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
-
7/25/2019 An investigation of the preceptors' perceptions of benefits, rewards, supports, and commitment to the preceptor r
37/103
22Retention rates for new graduates one year after hire had fallen to 30% for a rural
community hospital. Feedback obtained from new graduates indicated that a lack of a
structured orientation process wasa significant factor related to retention failure.
Implementation of an orientation program with a consistent preceptor was reported to
increase the one-year retention rate to 77% (Squires, 2002).
The preceptor is believed to be the key person who contributes toward the
successful completion o f the orientation process for new graduate nurses. Preceptors have
traditionally been selected for the role because of their clinical expertise. While clinical
expertise is a very important requirement, it cannot be the only quality that preceptors
possess. Having an interest in teaching, demonstrating good interpersonal skills, self-
confidence, and patience are all reported to be important qualities in a preceptor. In sum,
the effectiveness of the preceptorship is based on the quality o f the preceptors.
Understanding the preceptors experiences and perceptions with regard to the benefits,
rewards, and supports for the relationship with graduate nurses can be a means to
improve and promote effective transition, retention, satisfaction, and socialization to the
role of professional registered nurse. The preceptor relationship is mutually beneficial
for the nurse, the preceptor, and the hospital. Such a relationship elevates the
professionalism and skill of both the new graduates as well as the preceptors.
Marshall (2001) claims that the current nursing shortage is different and more
critical than what has prevailed in the past. The shortage is projected to be of
unprecedented severity and to proceed long into the future. Two-thirds of the nurse
workforce are now over the age of 40. Between 40 percent and 60 percent of these nurses
are expected to retire within the next 15 years (Cordeniz, 2002). In a period of severe
roduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
-
7/25/2019 An investigation of the preceptors' perceptions of benefits, rewards, supports, and commitment to the preceptor r
38/103
23shortages of experienced nurses, preceptorship programs are believed to be particularly
important with respect to mitigating the negative effects of such a shortage by providing
an efficient and effective tool to maintain quality patient care.
roduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
-
7/25/2019 An investigation of the preceptors' perceptions of benefits, rewards, supports, and commitment to the preceptor r
39/103
CHAPTER HI
Method
Procedures
The overall purpose of this dissertation research project was to examine the
relationships among preceptors perceptions of benefits, rewards, support and
commitment to the preceptor role. The study took place at a community-based medical
center located in the midwestem part of the United States. A letter describing the
research project was sent to all potential participants (see Appendix A). The investigator
received permission from the Vice President - Chief Nurse Executive at the Medical
Center to utilize staff nurses at the institution targeted for systematic study (see Appendix
B). A preceptor program was established in the hospital as part of the orientation process
for newly hired registered nurses.
A four-part preceptor questionnaire (see Appendix C) was distributed to a sample
of approximately 674 registered nurses. It should be noted that the institution does not
keep records regarding the identity of the staff members who function as preceptors for
newly hired registered nurses and/or students. Permission to utilize the Preceptor
Questionnaire was obtained from Goldenberg (see Appendix D). A packet of
information was provided for each registered nurse employed foil or part-time on the unit
who functions as a preceptor. The packet contained the letter describing the study (see
Appendix A) and the four-part preceptor questionnaire (see Appendix C). The packet of
24
roduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
-
7/25/2019 An investigation of the preceptors' perceptions of benefits, rewards, supports, and commitment to the preceptor r
40/103
25
information was placed in each staff nurses employee mailbox. Instructions directed the
respondent to return their completed survey in an interoffice envelope provided by the
investigator. Preceptors were assured that their replies were anonymous and confidential
and that return o f the completed questionnaires implied their consent to participate in the
study.
Participants and Sampling Plan
A community hospital located in the midwestem part ofthe United States was
selected as the institution targeted for systematic study. The hospital employs 674
registered professional nurses. The hospital educator could not provide data regarding
how many of the employed registered nurses function as preceptors. It should be noted
that staff have to be employed for a minimum of one year at the institution before they
are allowed to function as a preceptor. The Human Resources department was contacted
to determine the number of staff who would not be eligible to participate in the study
since they had not been employed at the hospital for at least a year. It was reported that
186 professional registered nurses had been hired during the period of time between
September 2003 to September 2004, which made them ineligible for inclusion in the
study. Surveys were distributed to all registered nurses. Staff with preceptor
responsibilities were invited to participate in the study. Potential respondents (n = 488)
included a sample of registered nurses who functioned as preceptors in one o f the 23
nursing units (intensive care unit, cardiac care unit, cardiovascular intensive care unit,
operating room, same day surgery, recovery room, emergency room, ambulatory care,
cardiac catheterization lab, 2E-telemetry, 2W-telemetry, 3E-orthopedics, 3W-neurology,
roduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
-
7/25/2019 An investigation of the preceptors' perceptions of benefits, rewards, supports, and commitment to the preceptor r
41/103
4E-medical, 4W-oncology, 5E-medical/surgical, 5W-pediatrics, nursery, labor &
delivery, postpartum, 6E-surgica! and 6W-surgical and rehabilitation units). In-patient
nursing units were selected for study based upon the ability o f the investigator to obtain
data from nurses assigned to these units. Table 2 contains information related to
distribution of participants across the nursing units.
Table 2: Distribution of Participants Across Nursing Units
Nursing Unit
Number of
RespondentsIntensive Care Unit /Cardiac Care Unit 16
Cardiovascular Intensive Care Unit 5
Operating Room 4
Same Day Surgery 9
Recovery Room 0
Emergency Room 4
Ambulatory Care 1
Cardiac Catherterization Lab 0
2E-te!emetry 6
2W-telemetry 6
3E-orthopedics 3
3W-neurololgy 3
4E-medical 6
4W-oncology 4
5E-medica!/surgical 3
5W-pediatrics 1
Nursery 4
Labor &Delivery 10
Postpartum 2
6E-surgical 9
6W-$urgicai 1Rehabilitation Unit 5
Undeclared 3
roduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
-
7/25/2019 An investigation of the preceptors' perceptions of benefits, rewards, supports, and commitment to the preceptor r
42/103
27
Instrumentation
A four-part questionnaire was used to collect data [the Preceptors Perception of
Benefits and Rewards (PPBR) Scale, the Preceptors Perception of Support (PPS) Scale,
the Commitment to the Preceptor Role (CPR) Scale, and a demographic information
component (see Appendix C)]. The PPBR Scale includes 14 items rated on a 6-point
Likert scale (where a 1 indicates strongly disagree and a 6 indicates strongly agree)
developed by Dibert and Goldenberg (1995). The scale was based on the literature
related to a set of rewards and benefits associated with the role of the preceptor The PPS
Scale includes 17 items that are also rated on a 6-point scale to measure preceptors
perceptions of support for the preceptor role. The questions were based on factors
identified by Dibert and Goldenbergs in their review of the literature related to what is
known about the perceived supports for the preceptor role. The 10-item CPR Scale was
adapted by Dibert (1993) [in Dibert & Goldenberg (1995)] from the Organizational
Commitment Questionnaire (OCQ) developed by Mowday et al. (1979). The CPR Scale
consists of 10 items rated on a 6-point scale that was developed to measure commitment
to the preceptor role (Usher et al., 1999). Reliability analyses of the three scales (PPBR,
PPS, & CPR) were reported by Dibert and Goldenberg (1995). The scales were reported
to have alpha coefficients of 0.91,0.86, and 0.87, respectively. Usher, Nolan, Reser,
Owens, and Tollefson (1999) discussed the variability in the literature concerning the
minimum level of alpha that is considered to be desirable for a scale that has been
developed to measure a particular construct.. Bums and Grove (1993) identified 0.80 as
the lowest acceptable alpha value for a well-developed instrument, while less refined
roduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
-
7/25/2019 An investigation of the preceptors' perceptions of benefits, rewards, supports, and commitment to the preceptor r
43/103
28
useable scales can have reliability estimates as low as 0.70. Using these criteria to
determine the adequacy o f the scales, the scales appear to be reliable.
Design
A quantitative between subjects design was used to address the research questions
and test the null hypotheses. The independent variables include: the preceptors
experience with being precepted; the preceptors level of preparation; years of experience
as a preceptor; age; type of basic nursing preparation; highest nursing degree held;
highest non-nursing degree held; years licensed as a registered nurse; and type o f hospital
unit preceptor worked in. The dependent measures include: perception of benefits and
rewards; perception o f support; and commitment to the preceptor role. These measures
were obtained from the participants responses to the four-part questionnaire (Preceptors
Perception o f Benefits and Rewards (PPBR) Scale, Preceptors Perception o f Support
(PPS) Scale, Commitment to the Preceptor Role (CPR) Scale, and a demographic
information component (see Appendix C).
The following null hypotheses were tested:
1. There are no significant relationships in the outcome measures (perception of
benefits & rewards associated with the preceptor role) and the preceptors
commitment to the role.
2. There are no significant relationships in the outcome measures (perception of
support for the preceptor role) and the preceptors commitment to the role.
roduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
-
7/25/2019 An investigation of the preceptors' perceptions of benefits, rewards, supports, and commitment to the preceptor r
44/103
29
3. There axe no significant relationships in the outcome measures (perception of
benefits & rewards, perception of support, and commitment to the role) across
years o f nursing experience.
4. There are no significant differences in the outcome measures (perception of
benefits & rewards, perception of support, and commitment to role) across
hospital unit types.
5. There are no significant relationships in the outcome measures (perception of
benefits & rewards, perception of support, and commitment to role) across '
preceptor experience conditions.
Statistical Analyses
The data sets were analyzed using the Statistical Package for Social Sciences
(SPSS). Descriptive statistics were used to analyze the data collected from the
demographic questionnaire. Combinations of ANOVA, FAMOVA, and multiple
regression analysis procedures were used to analyze the quantitative (survey) data sets.
The level of significance selected for interpreting the findings was 0.05 (2-tailed
significance).
roduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
-
7/25/2019 An investigation of the preceptors' perceptions of benefits, rewards, supports, and commitment to the preceptor r
45/103
CHAPTER IV
Results
Sample Characteristics
As noted in Chapter HI, surveys were distributed to 674 registered nurses
employed at a medical center hospital located in the midwestem part of the United States.
Data was collected during the fall of2004. Staff members employed for at least one year
and with preceptor responsibilities were invited to participate in the study. Potential
respondents (n=488) included a sample of registered nurses who functioned as preceptors
in one of 23 nursing units. Survey results were received from 105 registered nurses. The
response rate was 21.5% of the population targeted for systematic study.
Demographic information. The surveys were returned from a diverse group of
registered nurses employed at the institution targeted for study. Females represented
98.1% of the participants (n = 103) and 1.9% were males (n = 2). Men still comprise a
small percentage of the total RN population. According to the findings of the National
Sample Survey of Registered Nurses in 2000, there were an estimated 2,694,540
registered nurses in the United States. Males comprise 146,902 or 5.4% of the registered
nurse population in the United States (Spratley, Johnson, Sochalstic, Fritz, and Spencer,
2000). The lower proportion of male participants to female participants may be a result
of the small sample size (n = 105) compared to a national sample (n = 2,694,540).
30
roduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
-
7/25/2019 An investigation of the preceptors' perceptions of benefits, rewards, supports, and commitment to the preceptor r
46/103
31
The age of the participants ranged from 22 to 62 years. The mean age was 41.75
years. Most of the respondents were between 40 and 49 years of age (n = 32; 30.5%).
Twenty-seven (25.7%) of the respondents were 50 years and above. The age ranges of
20-29 (n = 20; 19%) and 30-39 (n - 22; 21%) represented in the sample were very similar
in number. Age was indeterminate for 4 of the respondents. Theparticipants responses
were clustered into the four age ranges presented in Table 3.
Table 3: Age of Participants
Frequency Percent Valid PercentCumulative
PercentValid 20-29 20 19.0 19.0 19.0
30-39 22 21.0 21.0 40.0
40-49 32 30.5 30.5 70.5
50 and above 27 25.7 25.7 96.2
Not provided 4 3.8 3.8 100.0
Total 105 100.0 100.0
The National Sample Survey of Registered Nurses documents the continuing
trend of aging in the registered nurse population. The average age of the RN population
was 45.2 in 2000 compared to 44.3 in 1996. The reported age of participants was 3.45
years younger than the overall age of nurses in the National Sample Survey of Registered
Nurses represented in 2000 (Spratley, Johnson, Sochalstic, Fritz, and Spencer, 2000).
Spratley and associates (2000) reported that nurses employed in hospital settings are
younger than the average age of all registered nurses nationwide.
Individuals from three ethnic backgrounds participated in the study. The majority
of the participants were Caucasians (n = 5; 81%), followed by Asians (a - 17; 16.2%),
roduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
-
7/25/2019 An investigation of the preceptors' perceptions of benefits, rewards, supports, and commitment to the preceptor r
47/103
32
and Hispanics (n = 3; 2.9%). Figure 1 displays the ethnic diversity represented within the
sample of respondents.
Figure 1: Ethnicity of Participants
lif^panie
3.00/ 2.9%
Asian
17.00/ 16.2%
The percent of Caucasian participants (81%) was slightly lower than the percent
of Caucasian registered nurses (86.6%) reported nationally (Spratley et. al, 2000). The
percent o f Asian participants (16.2) was more than four times higher than the percent of
Asian registered nurses (3.7%) reported nationally (Spratley et. al, 2000). There appears
to be no specific explanation for the differences identified in the ethnicity of participants..
roduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
-
7/25/2019 An investigation of the preceptors' perceptions of benefits, rewards, supports, and commitment to the preceptor r
48/103
33Nursing Licensure, The majority of the participants reported having had a
registered nurse license for 6 to 10 years (n = 29; 27.6%), followed by 26 or more years
(n - 24; 22.9%), 1 to 5 years (n = 22; 21.0%), 11 to 15 years (n = 14; 13.3%), 21 to 25
years (n = 11; 10.5%) and 16 to 20 years (n = 5; 4.8%). Figure 2 displays information
related to the length of time respondents reported having a nursing license.
Figure 2: Years Licensed as a Registered Nurse
3 0 -
0=24n=22
2 0 -
n=14
5
u.21-25 26 or more6-10 11-15 16-201-5
Number of Yearn Licensed asa RegisteredNurse
Education of Participants. The types of programs from whichparticipants
received their basic nursing education included Diploma, Associate, and Baccalaureate
degree programs of study. The majority of respondents reported receiving their basic
nursing degree from a Baccalaureate program (n = 55; 52.4%). The number of
participants reporting receiving their basic nursing degree from a Baccalaureate program
roduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
-
7/25/2019 An investigation of the preceptors' perceptions of benefits, rewards, supports, and commitment to the preceptor r
49/103
34
was higher than the national average of 30% (Spratley et al., 2000). This finding was
anticipated because the hospital in which the study was conducted offers an onsite
bachelors degree completion program for employees with a diploma or associate degree.
The second most common type of basic nursing preparation program was anAssociate
program (n = 35; 33.3%), followed by a Diploma program (n = 15; 14.3%). A
comparative display of the types o f basic nursing educational preparation among the
respondents is presented in Figure 3.
A Baccalaureate degree was reported by the majority of respondents as the
highest nursing deg