an evaluation of the load-displacement behavior and load test interpretation of micropiles in rock...
TRANSCRIPT
8/3/2019 An Evaluation of the Load-Displacement Behavior and Load Test Interpretation of Micropiles in Rock by Andrew Cus…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/an-evaluation-of-the-load-displacement-behavior-and-load-test-interpretation 1/7
Ucu`r 3,5? 3
CL @VCBPC^DJL JF ^A@ BJCN-NDYUBCI@M@L^ O@ACVDJ_ CLN BJCN ^@Y^DL^@_U_@^C^DJL JF MDI_JUDB@Y DL _JIG
Clnr`x H, Ipyadlh Yij~~ C, Y~jl`ia`ig" U,@, Orcnb`t N, Icmuo`bb" U,@,
N—Cuujbjldc @lhdl``ry Orctmcl Ijly~rpi~djl Ijru, N—Cuujbjldc @lhdl``ry
Mjlrj`vdbb`" UC-PYC-303>6 Ycqjloprh" UC-PYC-36506 Mjlrj`vdbb`" UC-PYC-303>6
Yij~~ N, Njnny
Orctmcl Ijly~rpi~djl Ijru,Ycqjloprh" UC-PYC-36506
COY^_CI^
^ady ucu`r ypmmcrd{`y c y`rd`y jf l`v`r-o`fjr` r`ujr~`n cqdcb ijmur`yydjl bjcn ~`y~y ijlnpi~`n jl ydlhb` mdirjudb`y ~ac~ cr`
`mo`nn`n dl jr ijly~rpi~`n jl rjig, ^a`y` nc~c cr` cphm`l~`n ot bjcn ~`y~y jl ydmdbcr mdirjudb`y ~ac~ acv` o``l r`ujr~`n ot j~a`ry
^a` joy`rv`n ndyubci`m`l~y c~ ~a` mcqdmpm ~`y~ bjcn !SMCQ$ cln r`ujr~`n plfci~jr`n n`ydhl bjcn !SNB$ cr ypmmcrd{`n, Dl cnnd~djl
~a` ymcbb-y~rcdl bjcn-ndyubci`m`l~ o`acvdjr jf ~a`y` fjplnc~djly dy `vcbpc~`n ot ijmucrdlh ~a` dld~dcb ~clh`l~ ybju` !DY$ ~j ~a`
~a`jr`~dicb `bcy~di ybju` !@Y$" xadia dy icbipbc~`n ot mjn`bdlh ~a` mdirjudb` cy c fr``-y~clndlh ijbpml `qadod~dlh fpbbt -ijmujyd~`
o`acvdjr, ^a` nc~c n`mjly~rc~` ~ac~ ~a` @Y*DY rc~dj acy c y~rjlh n`u`ln`li` jl ~a` yb`ln`rl`yy rc~dj NWn`u~a]*OWndcm`~`r], ^a`joy`rv`n r`ypb~y fjr mdirjudb`y dl rjig cr` ndyipyy`n dl ~a` ijl~`q~ jf ~a` mdirjudb` bjcn ~`y~ cii`u~cli` ird~`rdc urjujy`n ot ~a` N``u
Fjplnc~djly Dly~d~p~` !NFD" ?553$, Dl cnnd~djl" r`ijmm`lnc~djly cr` urjujy`n fjr ~a` mcqdmpm cii`u~cob` v r~dicb ndyubci`m`l
pln`r ~a` plfci~jr`n n`ydhl bjcn fjr ypia mdirjudb`y,
DL^_JNPI^DJL
Mdirjudb` ~`ialjbjht xcy fdry~ n`v`bju`n dl D~cbt ot Nr,
F`rlclnj Bd{{d mjr` ~acl 05 t`cry chj cy c m`cly jf dl-yd~pyjdb dmurjv`m`l~" xd~a ucr~dipbcr cuubdic~djl ~j y~rpi~prcb
r`y~jrc~djl cln ybju` y~codbd{c~djl, Ydli` ~a`l" ~a` py` jf ~ady~`ialjbjht acy fbjprdya`n ~arjphajp~ ~a` xjrbn" cln dy py`n
jl cl v`r-dlir`cydlh ocydy a`r` dl ~a` Pld~`n Y~c~`y, ^a`
~`ialjbjht icl o` py`n dl c xdn` vcrd`~t jf h`j~`ialdicb
ijlnd~djly" rclhdlh frjm yjf~ ibct ~j acrn rjig,
^ady ucu`r ur`y`l~y c nc~cocy` jf bjcn ~`y~y dl cqdcb
ijmur`yydjl ijlnpi~`n jl ydlhb` mdirjudb`y `mo`nn`n dl jr
ijly~rpi~`n jl rjig, ^a` v r~dicb ndyubci`m`l~y c~ ~a`
mcqdmpm ~`y~ bjcn !SMCQ$ cln r`ujr~`n plfci~jr`n n`ydhl
bjcn !SNB$ cr` ypmmcrd{`n, ^a` joy`rv`n r`ypb~y fjr
mdirjudb`y dl rjig cr` ndyipyy`n dl ~a` ijl~`q~ jf ~a` mdirjudb`bjcn ~`y~ cii`u~cli` ird~`rdc urjujy`n ot ~a` N``uFjplnc~djly Dly~d~p~` !NFD" ?553$, Dl cnnd~djl"
r`ijmm`lnc~djly cr` urjujy`n fjr ~a` mcqdmpm cii`u~cob`
v`r~dicb ndyubci`m`l~ pln`r ~a` plfci~jr`n n`ydhl bjcn fjr
ypia mdirjudb`y,
NFD MDI_JUDB@ CII@U^CLI@ I_D^@_DC
^a` N``u Fjplnc~djly Dly~d~p~` !NFD" ?553$ urjujy`n ~a`
fjbbjxdlh h`l`rcb cii`u~cli` ird~`rdc fjr bjcn ~`y~y ijlnpi~`njl adha-icucid~t nrdbb`n cln hrjp~`n mdirjudb`y;
V`r~dicb ndyubci`m`l~ c~ ~a` plfci~jr`n n`ydhl bjcn !σNB$
^a` udb` yacbb ypy~cdl ~a` plfci~jr`n ijmur`yydv` jr ~`lydb
n`ydhl bjcn !3,5 SNB$ xd~a lj mjr` ~acl ZZZZZ dlia`y !~j o`
n`~`rmdl`n ot ~a` `lhdl``r$ jf ~j~cb v`r~dicb ndyubci`m`l~ c~
~a` ~ju jf ~a` udb` cy m`cypr`n r`bc~dv` ~j ~a` ~ju jf ~a` udb`urdjr ~j ~a` y~cr~ jf ~`y~dlh,
Ir``u O`acvdjr
^`y~ udb`y yacbb acv` c ir``u rc~` c~ ~a` `ln jf ~a` 3,95 S NB
dlir`m`l~ xadia dy lj~ hr`c~`r ~acl 5,5>5 dlia`y*bjh itib`
~dm` frjm 3 ~j 35 mdlp~`y jr 5,515 dlia`y*bjh itib` ~dm` frjm
6 ~j 65 mdlp~`y cln acy c bdl`cr jr n`ir`cydlh ir``u rc~`, ^ady
ir``u ird~`rdjl dy dn`l~dicb ~j ~ac~ cuubd`n ~j urjjf bjcn ~`y~y jl
u`rmcl`l~ yjdb cln rjig cliajry !U^D" 3446$,
8/3/2019 An Evaluation of the Load-Displacement Behavior and Load Test Interpretation of Micropiles in Rock by Andrew Cus…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/an-evaluation-of-the-load-displacement-behavior-and-load-test-interpretation 2/7
Ucu`r Lj, 3,5? ?
Fcdbpr` bjcn dl~`rur`~c~djl cln fci~jr jf ycf`~t c~ SNB
Fcdbpr` yacbb lj~ jiipr c~ ~a` ?,5 SNB mcqdmpm ijmur`yydjl
cln ~`lydjl bjcny, Fcdbpr` dy n`fdl`n cy ~a` bjcn c~ xadia ~a`
ybju` jf ~a` bjcn-ndyubci`m`l~ iprv` fcbby o`bjx >5 gduy*dlia,
^ady ucu`r cnnr`yy`y ~a` dyyp`y jf ~jb`rcob` v`r~dicb
ndyubci`m`l~ c~ ~a` plfci~jr`n n`ydhl bjcn !σNB$" dl cnnd~djl
~j ~a` dl~`rur`~c~djl jf ~a` fcdbpr` bjcn !Sf $ ~j ciad`v` c
mdldmpm fci~jr jf ycf`~t jf ?,5 c~ SNB,
MDI_JUDB@ NC^COCY@
^cob 3, ypmmcrd{`y c y`rd`y jf l`v`r-o`fjr` r`ujr~`n cqdcbijmur`yydjl bjcn ~`y~y ijlnpi~`n jl ydlhb` nrdbb`n cln hrjp~`n
mdirjudb`y ~ac~ cr` `mo`nn`n dl jr ijly~rpi~`n jl rjig, Cbb jf
~a` udb`y ijlydy~ jf c hrjp~-fdbb`n y~``b udu` icydlh, ^a`
fjbbjxdlh h`jm`~rdi cln bjcn-ndyubci`m`l~ nc~c cr` urjvdn`n;
n`u~a !N$" m`cypr`n frjm op~~ ~j ~du
ndcm`~`r !O$" n`fdl`n cy ~a` jp~`r ndcm`~`r jf ~a`
y~``b icydlh"
udb` yb`ln`rl`yy !N*O$"
rjig yjig`~ b`lh~a !Byjig`~ $"
~a`jr`~dicb bcy~di ybju` !@Y$"
dld~dcb ~clh`l~ ybju` !DY$" n`fdl`n cy ~a` fdry~
n`rdvc~dv` jf ~a` bjcn-ndyubci`m`l~ iprv` !`vcbpc~`nc~ {`rj bjcn$"
bjcn cln ndyubci`m`l~ c~ ~a` mcqdmpm ~`y~ bjcn
!SMCQ" σMCQ$" cln
~a` fdry~ n`rdvc~dv` jf ~a` bjcn-ndyubci`m`l~ iprv`
!nS*nσ$ c~ ~a` mcqdmpm ~`y~ bjcn" SMCQ,
Cbb jf ~a` mdirjudb`y ur`y`l~`n dl ^cob` 3 x`r` dly~cbb`n ~j
urjvdn` y~rpi~prcb ypuujr~ `d~a`r fjr ordnh` ud`ry jr ordnh`
cop~m`l~y" xd~a ~a` `qi`u~djl jf udb`y YI-3 cln YI-?" xadia
fjrm ~a` fjplnc~djl yty~`m fjr c opdbndlh, ^j cphm`l~ ~a`
nc~cocy` ur`y`l~`n dl ^cob` 3" nc~c r`ujr~`n ot j~a`ry fjr
nrdbb`n cln hrjp~`n mdirjudb`y dly~cbb`n dl rjig cln bjcn`n dl
cqdcb ijmur`yydjl cr` urjvdn`n dl ^cob` ?, ^a` bjcn clnndyubci`m`l~ c~ ~a` plfci~jr`n n`ydhl bjcn jf ~a` udb`y
dl~rjnpi`n dl ^cob`y 3 cln ? cr` urjvdn`n dl ^cob` 9, Lj~`
~ac~ fjr udb`y FF-3 ~arjpha FF-35" jlbt SNB cln σNB x`r`
cvcdbcob`,
^JB@_COB@ V@_^DICB NDYUBCI@M@L^ C^ ^A@
PLFCI^J_@N N@YDHL BJCN
^a` h`l`rcb cii`u~cli` ird~`rdc fjr adha-icucid~t nrdbb`n cln
hrjp~`n mdirjudb`y urjujy`n ot NFD !?553$ ijlydn`r ~a`
y`rvdi` bdmd~ y~c~` !YBY$ ot bdmd~dlh ~a` v`r~dicb ndyubci`m`l~
c~ SNB ~j cl cii`u~cob` vcbp` !~j o` n`~`rmdl`n ot ~a`
`lhdl``r$" cln ~ac~ ~a` udb` ucyy c ir``u ~`y~, Fjr udb`y
dly~cbb`n dl rjig" ir``u dy h`l`rcbbt lj~ c ydhldfdicl~ n`ydhl
ijli`rl cln xdbb lj~ o` ndyipyy`n fpr~a`r dl ~ady ucu`r,
^a`r`fjr`" ~a` ~jb`rcob` v`r~dicb ijmur`yydjl ndyubci`m`l~ c
~a` plfci~jr`n n`ydhl bjcn xdbb o` `muacyd{`n,
^a` plfci~jr`n n`ydhl bjcny !SNB$ jf ~a` mdirjudb`y ~ac~ cr`
ur`y`l~`n dl ^cob` 9 cr` ubj~~`n chcdly~ ~a` ijrr`yujlndlh
v`r~dicb ijmur`yydjl ndyubci`m`l~y !σNB$ dl Fdh, 3, ^a` nc~c
n`mjly~rc~` ~ac~ ~a`r` dy c ndy~dli~ bdl`cr r`bc~djlyadu o`~x``l
SNB cln σNB" dlndic~dlh ~ac~ ~a` v`r~dicb ndyubci`m`l~y c~ ~a`
plfci~jr`n n`ydhl bjcn cr` urdmcrdbt ~a` r`ypb~ jf ~a` `bcy~diijmur`yydjl jf ~a` mdirjudb`, ^a` m`cl r`bc~djlyadu o`~x``l
SNB !gduy$ cln σNB !dlia`y$" cy dn`l~dfd`n ot ~a` yjbdn bdl` dl
Fdh, 3" icl o` `qur`yy`n ot @sl, 3 o`bjx,
138
$gduy!S$dlia`y! NB
NB=σ !3$
@spc~djl 3 xcy n`v`bju`n pydlh 0> nc~c ujdl~y" cln icl o`
py`n ~j n`~`rmdl` ~a` ‒mjy~ bdg`bt” !m`cl$ vcbp` jf v`r~dicb
ijmur`yydjl ndyubci`m`l~ jf mdirjudb`y dl rjig c~ ~a`
plfci~jr`n n`ydhl bjcn, Df @sl, 3 dy py`n dl ~ady fcyadjl" ~a`
`rrjr dl `y~dmc~dlh σNB icl o` `qur`yy`n ot cl jv`rcbb
ij`ffdid`l~ jf vcrdc~djl !IJV = Y~clncrn N`vdc~djl * M`cl$ j
cuurjqdmc~`bt 5,00" ur`ypmdlh ~ac~ ~a` cuubd`n ijmur`yydjlbjcn SNB dy n`~`rmdldy~di,
^a` joy`rv`n puu`r ojpln jf σNB cy c fpli~djl jf SNB
dn`l~dfd`n ot ~a` ncya`n bdl` dl Fdh, 3," icl o` `qur`yy`n ot
@sl, ? o`bjx,
969
$gduy!S$dlia`y! NB
NB=σ !?$
Ydli` @sl, ? r`ur`y`l~y ~a` puu`r-ojpln ~j `qdy~dlh n`ydhl
urci~di` c~ ~a` YBY fjr cii`u~cobt-u`rfjrmdlh nrdbb`n cln
hrjp~`n mdirjudb`y dl rjig" ~a` cp~ajry r`ijmm`ln ~ac~ d
y`rv` cy ~a` mcqdmpm cii`u~cob` vcbp` jf ~j~cb v`r~dicbijmur`yydjl ndyubci`m`l~ c~ SNB, Dl ~a` coy`li` jf cnnd~djlc
~`y~ nc~c c~ adha`r bjcny" @sl, ? yajpbn o` bdmd~`n ~j vcbp`y jf
SNB b`yy ~acl jr `spcb ~j 055 gduy,
Fjr ijmucrdyjl" c bdmd~`n cmjpl~ jf bjcn ~`y~ nc~c xcy
ijbb`i~`n jl nrdv`l A-udb`y o`crdlh jl rjig cln bjcn`n dl
cqdcb ijmur`yydjl !^cob` >$, ^a`y` nc~c cr` ubj~~`n jl Fdh, 3
cln dlndic~` ~ac~ @sl, ? fjr nrdbb`n cln hrjp~`n mdirjudb y mct
cbyj o` cuubdicob` ~j ~a`y` nrdv`l A-udb`y,
FCDBP_@ BJCN DL^@_U_@^C^DJL
Dl h`l`rcb" ~a` bjcn-ndyubci`m`l~ iprv`y jo~cdl`n frjm cqdcb
bjcn ~`y~y jl n``u fjplnc~djly ijlfjrm ~j jl` jf ~a` ~ar``
iprv`y yajxl dl Fdh, ?, Iprv` C jf Fdh, ? r`cia`y c x`bb-
n`fdl`n u`cg bjcn" ljrmcbbt dl~`rur`~`n cy ~a` fcdbpr` bjcn Sf
cf~`r xadia ~a` bjcn n`ir`cy`y xd~a cnnd~djlcb fjplnc~djlmjv`m`l~, Fjr Iprv` O" ~a` bjcn r`cia`y cl cytmu~j~di
mcqdmpm vcbp`" cbyj dl~`rur`~`n cy Sf ,
8/3/2019 An Evaluation of the Load-Displacement Behavior and Load Test Interpretation of Micropiles in Rock by Andrew Cus…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/an-evaluation-of-the-load-displacement-behavior-and-load-test-interpretation 3/7
Ucu`r Lj, 3,5? 9
^cob` 3, Orctmcl-N—Cuujbjldc Cqdcb Ijmur`yydjl Bjcn ^`y~ Nc~cocy` jf Mdirjudb`y dl _jig
Udb` DN Bjic~djlN
!f~,$
O
!f~,$N*O
Byjig`~
!f~,$
@Y!gduy*
dlia$
DY!gduy*
dlia$@Y*DY
SMCQ
!gduy$
σMCQ
!dl,$
nS*nσ
!gduy*dl,$
c~ SMCQ
YI-3 Y~c~` Ijbb`h`" UC 18,5 5,019 3>4 35,5 900 >14 5,89 905 3,51 368
YI-? Y~c~` Ijbb`h`" UC 41,5 5,019 361 35,0 936 969 5,18 905 3,34 3>0
II-3 Ud~~yoprha" UC 09,0 5,019 4? ?,5 4?1 3?68 5,89 955 5,65 946
II-? Ud~~yoprha" UC 03,5 5,019 18 ?,5 48> 85> 3,91 955 5,85 ?61II-9 Ud~~yoprha" UC 03,5 5,019 18 ?,5 48> 4?8 3,50 955 5,>3 684
?34-3 NpOjdy" UC >1,5 5,019 1? 5,3 64> >40 3,>5 98? 5,45 063
?34-? NpOjdy" UC >1,5 5,019 1? 5,3 64> 31>5 5,64 98? 5,9> 868
?34-9 NpOjdy" UC >1,5 5,019 1? 5,3 64> >14 3,>3 98? 5,63 094
99-3c @cy~jl" UC 18,5 5,15? 351 ?,5 63? 3??5 5,05 >55 5,>4 >86
99-3o @cy~jl" UC 18,5 5,15? 351 ?,5 63? 3?44 5,>8 >55 5,9> 3333
99-? @cy~jl" UC 61,> 5,15? 10 ?,5 881 ?055 5,93 >55 5,?6 ?881
99-9 @cy~jl" UC 8?,9 5,15? 45 ?,5 896 >368 5,31 655 5,68 040
MFQ-3 Xcyadlh~jl Ij," UC 91,> 5,15? >1 34,5 3940 9>8? 5,>5 3555 5,89 199
MFQ-? Xcyadlh~jl Ij," UC 66,5 5,15? 1? 35,5 156 ?96> 5,9> >35 5,?9 36?0
MFQ-9 Xcyadlh~jl Ij," UC >5,1 5,15? 03 ?3,5 3959 ?3>5 5,63 354? 5,0? ?3>5
MFQ-> Xcyadlh~jl Ij," UC 4?,4 5,15? 336 31,? 089 3?05 5,>6 458 5,86 3?05
FU-3c Ud~~yoprha" UC 83,5 5,019 3?? ?9,5 >64 040 5,84 905 3,39 ?56FU-3o Ud~~yoprha" UC 83,5 5,019 3?? ?9,5 >64 >14 5,46 905 5,8? 9>3
FU-? Ud~~yoprha" UC 83,5 5,019 3?? ?9,5 >64 3301 5,>3 905 5,8? 9>3
FU-9 Ud~~yoprha" UC 83,5 5,019 3?? ?9,5 >64 040 5,84 905 5,04 968
FU-> Ud~~yoprha" UC 83,5 5,019 3?? ?9,5 >64 005 5,10 905 3,54 344
B_-3 Ud~~yoprha" UC -- -- -- -- -- 3908 -- 955 5,?8 405
^cob` ?, Cqdc b Ijmur`yydjl Bjcn ^`y~ Nc~cocy` jf Mdirjudb`y dl _jig ’ _`ujr~`n Ot J~a`ry
Udb` DN Bjic~djlN
!f~,$
O
!f~,$N*O
Byjig`~
!f~,$
@Y
!gduy*
dlia$
DY
!gduy*
dlia$
@Y*DYSMCQ
!gduy$
σMCQ
!dl,$
nS*nσ
!gduy*dl,$
c~ SMCQ
G-35-C!3$
Uadbcn`buadc" UC 63,5 5,019 350 3>,5 135 3908 5,65 915 5,05 6?0
K,3-4-C!3$
Uadbcn`buadc" UC 63,5 5,019 350 3>,5 135 3908 5,65 915 5,06 00?
G-6-C!3$
Uadbcn`buadc" UC 331 5,019 ?5? 3>,5 901 405 5,91 915 3,5> ?48
B-4-C!3$
Uadbcn`buadc" UC 355 5,019 383 3>,5 058 3311 5,>9 915 5,11 9>8
D-3!?$
Dlndc ?5,8 5,>4? >? 9,6 3?48 >64? 5,?1 936 5,?0 159
DB-3!9$
Iadichj" DB 45,5 5,019 30> ?,5 >3> 610 5,65 >55 3,58 939
IA-3!>$
Iacu`b Adbb" LI >6,1 5,690 8> 3?,5 -- 3434 -- 805 3,59 853
^U-O??!0$
Gpcbc Bpmupr"
Mcbctydc315 5,1?5 ??5 0?,0 940 ?36? 5,31 0>5 5,15 054
^U-I?8!0$
Gpcbc Bpmupr"
Mcbctydc396 5,1?5 366 ?6,? 69> ?108 5,?? 0>5 5,84 680
DB-?!6$
Iadichj" DB ?,5 5,019 9,> ?,5 3863> 4449 3,86 3555 5,83 855
DB-9!6$ Iadichj" DB >,5 5,019 6,4 >,5 1158 ?003 9,>0 155 3,91 938
DB->!6$
Iadichj" DB 6,5 5,019 35 6,5 0183 9366 3,10 3555 5,>8 3585
!3$„Hcbbcha`r cln Bclhcl !?55?$7 !?$„Ncvd` cln Y`lcuc~at !?55?$7 !9$„Fdllj cln Yia`r`r !?555$7 !>$„Ycln`ry" `~ cb, !3444$7
!0$„Hp` cln Bd`x !3441$7 !6$„Fdllj" `~ cb, !?55?$
8/3/2019 An Evaluation of the Load-Displacement Behavior and Load Test Interpretation of Micropiles in Rock by Andrew Cus…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/an-evaluation-of-the-load-displacement-behavior-and-load-test-interpretation 4/7
Ucu`r Lj, 3,5? >
^cob` ?, !Ijl~dlp`n$
Udb` DN Bjic~djlN
!f~,$
O
!f~,$N*O
Byjig`~
!f~,$
@Y
!gduy*
dlia$
DY
!gduy*
dlia$
@Y*DYSMCQ
!gduy$
σMCQ
!dl,$
nS*nσ
!gduy*dl,$
c~ SMCQ
BT-3!8$
Btliaoprh" VC -- 5,055 -- -- -- -- -- 955 5,39 --
XX-9!1$
X`y~ Xad~`bcln" UC 9>,1 5,019 04,8 4,1 401 3308 5,19 805 5,43 64>
XX->
!1$
X`y~ Xad~`bcln" UC ?1,4 5,019 >4,6 4,1 330> 310> 5,6? 655 5,03 169XX-0!1$ X`y~ Xad~`bcln" UC 9>,3 5,019 01,0 4,1 488 ?433 5,9> 655 5,03 3539
XX-6!1$
X`y~ Xad~`bcln" UC >1,4 5,019 19,4 4,1 835 3>36 5,05 185 3,55 081
XX-8!1$
X`y~ Xad~`bcln" UC 335 5,019 314 4,1 954 6?> 5,05 610 3,95 00?
XX-1!1$
X`y~ Xad~`bcln" UC 15,> 5,019 391 4,1 >?0 949 3,51 610 3,14 9>>
XX-4!1$
X`y~ Xad~`bcln" UC >>,4 5,019 88,5 4,1 880 3360 5,68 610 5,80 865
U_-3!4$
Urjvdn`li`" _D 60,5 5,055 395 1,5 -- -- -- ??5 5,85 --
^_-3!4$
^rcffjrn" UC 96,5 5,>38 16,> 5,3 -- -- -- >5 5,56 --
^L-3!4$ Cbijc" ^L >5,5 5,>01 18,9 3,5 -- -- -- ?15 5,>6 --
UC-3!4$
Xcrr`l Ij," UC >>,5 5,851 6?,3 30,5 -- -- -- >>1 5,>5 --
!8$„xxx,~`ialdicbfjplnc~djly,ijm7 !1$„Icnn`l" `~ cb, !?553$7 !4$„Orpi` !3414$
^cob` 9, V`r~dicb Ijmur`yydjl Ndyubci`m`l~y !σNB$ jf Mdirjudb`y dl _jig c~ ~a` _`ujr~`n Xjrgdlh !N`ydhl$ Bjcn
!SNB$
Udb` DNSNB
!gduy$σNB
!dl,$Udb` DN
SNB
!gduy$σNB
!dl,$
YI-3 380 5,980 DB-3 ?55 5,>01
YI-? 380 5,>94 IA-3 955 5,?>?
II-3 305 5,?04 ^U-O?? ?85 5,?6>
II-? 305 5,?>4 ^U-I?8 ?85 5,?>1
II-9 305 5,310 DB-? 055 5,?40
B_-3 305 5,3?9 DB-9 >55 5,116
?34-3 316 5,055 DB-> 055 5,??6?34-? 316 5,394 XX-9 955 5,?45
?34-9 316 5,?4> XX-> 955 5,385
99-3c ?55 5,?31 XX-0 955 5,385
99-3o ?55 5,363 XX-6 955 5,?05
99-? ?55 5,339 XX-8 955 5,09?
99-9 ?55 5,318 XX-1 955 5,1?8
MFQ-3 >55 5,?95 XX-4 955 5,?05
MFQ-? >55 5,??1 FF-3!3$
33? 5,565
MFQ-9 >55 5,?3> FF-?!3$
44 5,399
MFQ-> >55 5,963 FF-9!3$
84 5,500
FU-3c 380 5,98? FF->!3$
45 5,513
FU-3o 380 5,?48 FF-0!3$
44 5,350
FU-? 380 5,?69 FF-6!3$ 44 5,??5
FU-9 380 5,?9> FF-8!3$
11 5,56>
FU-> 380 5,>5? FF-1!3$
390 5,5>5
G-35-C 345 5,?>5 FF-4!3$
84 5,546
K,3-4-C 345 5,?>5 FF-35!3$
390 5,598
G-6-C 345 5,>?5 FF-33!3$
45 5,541
B-4-C 345 5,905 FF-3?!3$
351 5,358
D-3 3?3 5,599 FF-39!3$
351 5,393
!3$„xxx,fjln`ndb` -fjplnc~djly,b~n,pg*urjnucbdnc~c,a~mb
5
355
?55
955
>55
055
655
5,5 5,0 3,5 3,0 ?,5
V`r~dicb Ndyubci`m`l~ c~ N`ydhl Bjcn" σNB !dl,$
P l
f c i
~ j r `
n N ` y
d h l
B j c
n "
S N B
! g d u y $
Mdirjudb`y
Nrdv`l Udb`y
Xjrgdlh Bjcn Ndyubci`m`l~y fjr
Mdirjudb`y dl _jig;
M`cl; σNB !dl,$ = SNB !gduy$ * 138
IJV = 00% l = 0>Mcq; σNB !dl,$ = SNB !gduy$ * 969
Fdh, 3, V`r~dicb Ijmur`yydjl Ndyubci`m`l~y !σ NB$ c~ ~a`
Plfci~jr`n N`ydhl !Xjrgdlh$ Bjcn !S NB$ fjr Mdirjudb`y dl
_jig
^cob` >, V`r~dicb Ijmur`yydjl Ndyubci`m`l~y !σNB$ jf Nrdv`lUdb`y O`crdlh jl _jig c~ ~a` _`ujr~`n Xjrgdlh Bjcn SNB
Udb` SNB σNB
DNBjic~djl
!gduy$ !dl,$
33!3$
Iadichj" DB 655 5,>5
30!3$
N`crojrl" MD 955 5,64
36!3$ N`crojrl" MD ?45 5,68
38!3$
Mdbxcpg``" XD 655 3,?5
31!3$
Mdbxcpg``" XD 655 3,05
9-3!?$
Bcigcxcllc" LT 3>5 5,3>
9-?!?$
Bcigcxcllc" LT ?45 5,?8
9-9!?$
@cy~ Iadichj" DL ?55 5,95
!3$„CDYD !3480$
!?$„O`~ab`a`m Y~``b !3484$
8/3/2019 An Evaluation of the Load-Displacement Behavior and Load Test Interpretation of Micropiles in Rock by Andrew Cus…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/an-evaluation-of-the-load-displacement-behavior-and-load-test-interpretation 5/7
Ucu`r Lj, 3,5? 0
Fdh, ?, Bjcn-Ndyubci`m`l~ Iprv`y fjr N``u Fjplnc~djly
Ajx`v`r" mjy~ bjcn-ndyubci`m`l~ iprv`y ~cg` ~a` fjrm jf
Iprv` I" dl xadia lj ib`crbt n`fdl`n u`cg bjcn dy ciad`v`n,Fjr ypia icy`y" ~a` fcdbpr` bjcn dy ndffdipb~ ~j cyy`yy, Cbb jf ~a`
bjcn-ndyubci`m`l~ iprv`y fjr ~a` bjcn ~`y~y ur`y`l~`n dl ~ady
ucu`r cr` jf ~tu` I,
NFD Fcdbpr` Bjcn Ird~`rdjl
Cy ndyipyy`n ur`vdjpybt" ~a` NFD !?553$ mdirjudb` cii`u~cli`
ird~`rdc n`fdl`y ~a` fcdbpr` bjcn Sf cy ~a` ujdl~ jl ~a` bjcn-
ndyubci`m`l~ iprv` c~ xadia ~a` ybju` jf ~a` iprv` !nS*nσ$
o`hdly ~j fcbb o`bjx >5 gduy*dlia, ^a` cqdcb ijmur`yydjl bjcn
~`y~ nc~c ur`y`l~`n dl ^cob`y 3 cln ? dlndic~` ~ac~" c~ ~a`
mcqdmpm ~`y~ bjcn SMCQ" ~a` ymcbb`y~ vcbp` jf nS*nσ
`lijpl~`r`n xcy 3>0 gduy*dlia !Udb` YI-?$" xd~a c
ijrr`yujlndlh σMCQ jf 3,54 dlia`y, ^a`r`fjr`" ljl` jf ~a`
mdirjudb`y ur`y`l~`n dl ~ady ucu`r r`cia`n ~a` fcdbpr` bjcn S f "
cy n`fdl`n ot NFD !?553$,
Frjm ~a` nc~c ur`y`l~`n dl ^cob`y 3 cln ?" vcbp`y jf nS*nσ c~
~a` mcqdmpm ~`y~ bjcn SMCQ cr` ubj~~`n chcdly~ ~a`
ijrr`yujlndlh vcbp`y jf σMCQ dl Fdh, 9, ^a`y` nc~c dlndic~`~ac~ c r`bc~djlyadu `qdy~y o`~x``l ~a`y` ~xj ucrcm`~`ry fjr
mdirjudb`y dl rjig pln`r cqdcb ijmur`yydjl, ^a` m`cl
~r`lnbdl` yajxl dl Fdh, 9 dlndic~`y ~ac~ c vcbp` jf nS*nσ = >5
gduy*dlia ijrr`yujlny ~j c vcbp` jf σ = 3,19 dlia`y, Ajx`v`r"
~a` mdirjudb` xd~a ~a` bcrh`y~ vcbp` jf σMCQ ur`y`l~`n dl ~ady
ucu`r !3,14 dlia`y fjr mdirjudb` XX-1$ acy nS*nσ = 9>> < >5
gduy*dlia, Ijlydn`rdlh ~a`y` fci~y cln ~a` nc~c ur`y`l~`n dl
Fdh, 9" d~ dy r`cyjlcob` ~j cyypm` ~ac~ ~a` NFD !?553$ fcdbpr`
ird~`rdjl jf nS*nσ 2 >5 gduy*dlia ijrr`yujlny ~j cl coyjbp~`
v`r~dicb ijmur`yydjl ndyubci`m`l~ jf cuurjqdmc~`bt ?,5
dlia`y fjr mdirjudb`y dl rjig,
Df ~a` fcdbpr` bjcn dy n`fdl`n c~ c v`r~dicb ijmur`yydjl
ndyubci`m`l~ `spcb ~j ?,5 dlia`y" ~a`l ~a` ijrr`yujlndlh σNB
xdbb o` b`yy ~acl jr `spcb ~j 3,5 dlia !fjr FY = S f *SNB ≠ ?,5$,
^a` cbbjxcob` ijmur`yydjl ndyubci`m`l~ c~ SNB" qur`yy`n ot
@sl, ?" mpy~ cbyj o` ia`ig`n, Dl cnnd~djl" ~a` plfci~jr`n
Mdirjudb`y dl _jig;
nS*nσ !gduy*dl,$ = -60? Bl!σMCQ$ ' >9?
r?= 5,914
l = >3
LJ^@; nS*nσ !gduy*dl,$ = >5 E
M`cl; σMCQ = 3,19 dl,7
Mdl; σMCQ = 3,05 dl,
5
055
3555
3055
?555
?055
9555
9055
>555
>055
0555
5,5 5,0 3,5 3,0 ?,5
V`r~dicb Ndyubci`m`l~ c~ Mcq ^`y~ Bjcn" σMCQ !dl,$
n S * n σ c
~ M c q
^ ` y
~ B j c
n ! g d u y
* d l
, $
Fdh, 9, nS*n σc~ S MCQ V`rypy ~a` V`r~dicb Ijmur`yydjl
Ndyubci`m`l~ c~ S MCQ !σ MCQ $ fjr Mdirjudb`y dl _jig
5
?55
>55
655
155
3555
3?55
5,5 5,0 3,5 3,0 ?,5
V`r~dicb Ndyubci`m`l~y; σNB" σMCQ !dl,$
B j c
n y ;
S N B "
S M C Q
! g d u y
$
N`ydhl !Xjrgdlh$ BjcnMcq `y~ Bjcn
Mdirjudb`y dl _jig;
Fdh, >, Ijmucrdyjl jf V`r~dicb Ijmur`yydjl Ndyubci`m`l~y c
S NB cln S MCQ fjr Mdirjudb`y dl _jig
n`ydhl bjcn SNB mpy~ lj~ `qi``n ~a` cbbjxcob` y~rpi~prcbicucid~t jf ~a` udb`,
Df ~a` bjcn ~`y~ dy ~`rmdlc~`n urdjr ~j ~a` v`r~dicb ijmur`yydjl
ndyubci`m`l~ r`ciadlh ?,5 dlia`y" ~a`l Sf yajpbn o` ~cg`l cy
SMCQ,
Cl `vcbpc~djl jf ~a` nc~c ur`y`l~`n dl ^cob`y 3 cln ?
dlndic~` ~ac~" frjm c h`j~`ialdicb u`ryu`i~dv`" ~a` mcqdmpm
n`ydhl bjcn fjr mdirjudb`y dl rjig dy hjv`rl`n urdmcrdbt ot ~a`
cbbjxcob` v`r~dicb ijmur`yydjl ndyubci`m`l~ c~ SNB rc~a`r
~acl ~a` cuubdic~djl jf FY ≠ ?,5 jl Sf , ^ady ijli`u~ dy
`qadod~`n hrcuadicbbt dl Fdh, >" xa`r` ~a` vcbp`y jf σMCQ" fjr
~a` mjy~ ucr~" fcbb xd~adl ~a` ndyubci`m`l~ bdmd~ `qur`yy`n ot@sl, ?,
Ndyipyydjl jf J~a`r Dl~`rur`~c~djl M`~ajny
^a` cp~ajry r`ijhld{` ~ac~ c lpmo`r jf j~a`r bjcn ~`y
dl~`rur`~c~djl urji`npr`y `qdy~ ~j `vcbpc~` S f fjr n``u
fjplnc~djly, ^a` Ncvdyyjl !348?$ urji`npr`" xadia xcy
jrdhdlcbbt n`v`bju`n fjr nrdv`l A-udb`y" dn`l~dfd y Sf cy ~a`
8/3/2019 An Evaluation of the Load-Displacement Behavior and Load Test Interpretation of Micropiles in Rock by Andrew Cus…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/an-evaluation-of-the-load-displacement-behavior-and-load-test-interpretation 6/7
Ucu`r Lj, 3,5? 6
bjcn ijrr`yujlndlh ~j ~a` dl~`ry`i~djl jf ~a` bjcn-
ndyubci`m`l~ iprv` xd~a ~a` `bcy~di bdl`" xadia dy ijly~rpi~`n
c~ c yu idfd`n ndyubci`m`l~ jffy`~ frjm ~a` jrdhdl c~ cl
dlibdlc~djl `spcb ~j ~a` `bcy~di ybju` !@Y$,
^a` jffy`~ urjujy`n ot Ncvdyyjl !348?$ dy `spcb ~j 5,30 dlia
' WO !dlia`y$ * 3?5]" xa`r` O = udb` ndcm`~`r, ^ady jffy`~ dy
ocy`n jl ~a` ur`ypmu~djl ~ac~ ~a` pb~dmc~` ~du r`ydy~cli` jf c
3? dlia n``u A-udb` dy mjodbd{`n c~ c ~du ndyubci`m`l~ `spcb ~j5,?0 dlia, Ncvdyyjl !348?$ ijli`n`n ~a` ujyydodbd~t ~ac~ ~a`
~du ndyubci`m`l~ r`spdr`n ~j mjodbd{` ~a` pb~dmc~` ~du
r`ydy~cli` fjr ypia c udb` mdha~ `qi``n 5,?0 dlia, Dl r`cbd~t"
~a` ndyubci`m`l~ r`spdr`n ~j mjodbd{` pb~ dmc~` ~du r`ydy~cli`
n`u`lny jl ~a` lc~pr` jf ~a` udb` irjyy-y`i~djl, Fjr n``u
fjplnc~djly xd~a yjbdn" idripbcr irjyy y`i~djly" ~du
ndyubci`m`l~y jf 5,50O ~j 5,3O ~tudicbbt cr` r`spdr`n ~j
mjodbd{` ~a` pb~dmc~` ~du r`ydy~cli`, Fjr ~a` mdirjudb`y
ijlydn`r`n dl ~ady y~pnt" O rclh`y frjm cuurjqdmc~`bt 6 ~j 35
dlia`y, ^a`r`fjr`" ~a` ~du ndyubci`m`l~y r`spdr`n ~j mjodbd{`
pb~dmc~` `ln o`crdlh icl rclh` frjm 5,9 ~j 3,5 dlia, Df ~a`
`bcy~di ijmur`yydjl jf ypia udb`y dy ijlydn`r`n" ~a` ~j~cb
v`r~dicb ndyubci`m`l~ jf ~a` udb` op~~ icl `spcb jr `qi``n ?,5
dlia`y xd~ajp~ `qu`rd`lidlh fpbb h`j~`ialdicb fcdbpr`,
^a`r`fjr`" ~a` py` jf ~a` Ncvdyyjl !348?$ urji`npr` icl r`ypb~dl vcbpc~djly jf S f ~ac~ cr` jv`rbt ijly`rvc~dv`,
Dl ~a` ybju`-~clh`l~ m`~ajn" ~a` dld~dcb ~clh`l~ ybju` !DY$ jf
~a` bjcn-ndyubci`m`l~ iprv` dy py`n rc~a`r ~acl ~a` `bcy~di
ybju` !@Y$, Ajx`v`r" @Y dy lj~ l`i`yycrdbt `spcb ~j DY,
Vcbp`y jf @Y*DY frjm ~a` mdirjudb`y ur`y`l~`n dl ^cob`y 3 cln
? cr` ubj~~`n chcdly~ ~a` yb`ln`rl`yy rc~dj !N*O$ dl Fdh, 0, Cy
N*O dlir`cy`y" @Y*DY ~`lny ~j n`ir`cy`, Ib`crbt" vcrdc~djl dl
@Y*DY icl acv` c ydhldfdicl~ dlfbp`li` jl ~a` dl~`rur`~`n
fcdbpr` bjcn S f ,
YPMMC_T CLN _@IJMM@LNC^DJLY
^ady ucu`r acy r`ujr~`n ~a` r`ypb~y jf c y~pnt jf ~a` bjcn-
ndyubci`m`l~ o`acvdjr jf nrdbb`n cln hrjp~`n mdirjudb`y
`mo`nn`n dl jr ijly~rpi~`n jl rjig, C y`rd`y jf l`v`r-o`fjr`
r`ujr~`n cqdcb ijmur`yydjl bjcn ~`y~y ijlnpi~`n jl ydlhb`
mdirjudb`y dy ur`y`l~`n cln ypoy`sp`l~bt cphm`l~`n ot bjcn
~`y~y r`ujr~`n ot j~a`ry,
Cl `vcbpc~djl jf ~a` plfci~jr`n n`ydhl bjcn !SNB$ cln
ijrr`yujlndlh v`r~dicb ndyubci`m`l~ !σNB$ fjr ~a` mdirjudb`y
ndyipyy`n a`r`dl acy r`ypb~`n dl ~a` r`ijmm`lnc~djl ~ac~ ~a`
cbbjxcob` v`r~dicb ijmur`yydjl ndyubci`m`l~ o` bdmd~`n ~j
SNB
!gduy$*969 fjr mdirjudb`y dl rjig,
Cl `vcbpc~djl jf ~a` fcdbpr` bjcn dl~`rur`~c~djl m`~ajn y`~
fjr~a ot ~a` N``u Fjplnc~djly Dly~d~p~` !NFD" ?553$ xcy cbyj
ijlnpi~`n, ^a` nc~c ur`y`l~`n dl ~ady ucu`r yphh`y~y ~ac~ ~a`
NFD !?553$ fcdbpr` ird~`rdjl jf nS*nσ 2 >5 gduy*dlia icl
r`cyjlcobt o` cyyjidc~`n xd~a c ~j~cb v`r~dicb ijmur`yydjl
ndyubci`m`l~ jf cuurjqdmc~`bt ?,5 dlia`y, ^a` cuubdic~djl jf
c fci~jr jf ycf`~t FY = ?,5 ~j ~a` vcbp` jf Sf xdbb ~tudicbbt
r`ypb~ dl σNB 2 3,5 dlia, Ajx`v`r" ~a` r`ijmm`ln`n
5
05
355
305
?55
?05
5,5 5,0 3,5 3,0 ?,5 ?,0 9,5 9,0@Y * DY
N
* O
Mdirjudb`y dl _jig
N = ^j~cb Udb` B`lh~aO = Jp~`r Ndcm`~`r jf Y~``b Icydlh
@Y = @bcy~di Ybju`
DY = Dld~dcb ^clh`l~ Ybju`
Fdh, 0, @Y*DY v`rypy N*O fjr Mdirjudb y dl _jig
bdmd~c~djl jl σNB n`yirdo`n cojv` mpy~ o` ia`ig`n
dln`u`ln`l~bt, Dl cnnd~djl" ~a` n`ydhl bjcn SNB mpy~ lj
`qi``n ~a` cbbjxcob` y~rpi~prcb icucid~t jf ~a` udb`,
Df ~a` bjcn ~`y~ dy ~`rmdlc~`n urdjr ~j ~a` ndyubci`m`l~ r`ciadlh
~a` NFD !?553$ fcdbpr` bjcn ird~`rdjl" ~a`l Sf yajpbn o` ~cg`l
cy SMCQ,
Frjm c h`j~`ialdicb u`ryu`i~dv`" ~a` mcqdmpm n`ydhl bjcn
fjr mdirjudb`y dl rjig dy hjv`rl`n urdmcrdbt ot ~a` cbbjxcob`
ndyubci`m`l~ c~ SNB rc~a`r ~acl ~a` cuubdic~djl jf FY ≠ ?,5 jl
Sf , ^ady ijli`u~ dy o`y~ `qadod~`n ot ~a` nc~c ur`y`l~`n dl
Fdh, >,
^a` fdlndlhy y`~ fjr~a dl ~ady ucu`r cuubt jlbt ~j nrdbb`n cln
hrjp~`n mdirjudb`y dl rjig pln`r cqdcb ijmur`yydjl" cln cr`
yjb`bt ~ajy` jf ~a` dlndvdnpcb cp~ajry,
CIGLJXB@NHM@L^Y
^a` cp~ajry xjpbn bdg` ~j r`ijhld{` Kjy`ua X, Ur`mj{di cln
Iardy~jua`r K, B`xdy jf N—Cuujbjldc cln Ncld`b N
Prcljxygd jf ~a` Orctmcl Ijly~rpi~djl Ijrujrc~djl fjr ~a dr
cyydy~cli` dl ~a` ur`ucrc~djl cln r`vd`x jf ~ady mclpyirdu~,
_@F@_@LI@Y
CDYD W3480], ‒Y~``b Udb` Bjcn ^`y~ Nc~c"” Cm`rdicl Drjl cln
Y~``b Dly~d~p~`" Xcyadlh~jl" N,I," 1> u, !_`ujr~ ur`ucr`n ot
@, N—Cuujbjldc Ijlypb~dlh @lhdl``ry$
O`~ab`a`m Y~``b W3484], ‒ O`~ab`a`m Y~``b A-Udb`y"”
O`~ab`a`m Y~``b Ijrujrc~djl" 6? u,
Orpi`" N,C, W3414], ‒Cm`rdicl N`v`bjum`l~y dl ~a` Py` jf
Ymcbb Ndcm`~`r Dly`r~y cy Udb`y cln Dl-Yd~p _`dlfjri`m`l~"”
Urji, Dl~`rl, Ijlf, jl Udbdlh cln N``u Flnly, " Bjlnjl"
Vjb, D" uu, 33-??,
8/3/2019 An Evaluation of the Load-Displacement Behavior and Load Test Interpretation of Micropiles in Rock by Andrew Cus…
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/an-evaluation-of-the-load-displacement-behavior-and-load-test-interpretation 7/7
Ucu`r Lj, 3,5? 8
Icnn`l" C,X," N,C, Orpi`" cln B,M, Idcmud~~d W?553],
‒Mdirjudb`y dl Gcry~; C Icy` Ady~jrt jf Ndffdipb~d`y cln
Ypii`yy"” Flnly, cln Hrjpln Dmurjv`m`l~ !CYI@ HYU Lj,
339$ " uu, ?5>-?30,
Ncvd`" K,_, cln A, Y`lcuc~at W?55?], ‒Pln`rudlldlh c 9555-
^jl Y~rpi~pr` xd~a Adha-Icucid~t Mdld-Udb`y"” N``u Flnly,
?55? !CYI@ HYU Lj, 336$" Vjb, D" uu, 6>8-60>,
Ncvdyyjl" M,^, W348?], ‒Adha Icucid~t Udb`y"” Urji," B`i~pr`
Y`rd`y jl Dlljvc~djly dl Fjplnc~djl Ijly~rpi~djl" CYI@
Dbbdljdy Y`i~djl" Iadichj" 0? u,
NFD W?553], ‒Hpdn` ~j Nrcf~dlh c Yu`idfdic~djl fjr Adha
Icucid~t Nrdbb`n cln Hrjp~`n Mdirjudb`y fjr Y~rpi~prcb
Ypuujr~"” N``u Fjplnc~djly Dly~d~p~` !cln `lnjry`n ot
CNYI-DCFN$
Fdllj" _,K," Y,N, Yia`r`r" O, Ucdl`cp" cln K, _jojygd W?55?],
‒Bjcn ^rclyf`r Iacrci~`rdy~diy jf Mdirjudb`y dl Njbjmd~`"”
N``u Flnly, ?55? !CYI@ HYU Lj, 336$" Vjb, DD" uu, 3591-
3509,
Fdllj" _,K, cln Y,N, Yia`r`r W?555], ‒@vcbpc~djl jf Icucid~tjf Mdirjudb`y @mo`nn`n dl _jig"” C Kjdl~ Urjujycb ot ~a`
N`ucr~m`l~ jf Idvdb @lhdl``rdlh c~ Ljr~ax`y~`rl Pldv`ryd~t
~j ~a` Dlfrcy~rpi~pr` ^`ialjbjht Dly~d~p~`" 1 u,
Hcbbcha`r" M,K, cln O,F, Bclhcl W?55?], ‒Fjplnc~djl N`ydhl
cln Ijly~rpi~djl jv`r c Xcy~` Fdbb`n Bdm`y~jl` Spcrrt"”
N``u Flnly, ?55? !CYI@ HYU Lj, 336$" uu, 886-84?,
Hp`" Y,Y, cln Y,Y, Bd`x W3441], ‒N`ydhl" Dly~cbbc~djl" cln
U`rfjrmcli` jf Mdirjudb`y dl Gpcbc Bpmupr Cr`c" Mcbctydc"”
Urji, 39~a
Yjp~a`cy~ Cydcl H`j~`ialdicb Ijlf`r`li`" ^cdu`d"
^cdxcl,
U^D W3446], ‒_`ijmm`lnc~djly fjr Ur`y~r`yy`n _jig cln Yjdb
Cliajry"” Ujy~-^`lydjldlh Dly~d~p~`" Uaj`ldq" Crd{jlc" 85 u,
Ycln`ry" _,@," K,N, Apyydl" cln V,@, Apbb W3444], ‒Mdldudb`y
Ypuujr~ Adha _dy` Ajyud~cb ^arjpha Ojpbn`ry dl _`ydnpcb
Yjdb"” Urji," H`jIjlhr`yy 44" CYI@" uu, 3?9-399,