an evaluation of the effectiveness of the group (smg) crisis … · an evaluation of the...

45
An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Safe Management Group (SMG) Crisis Intervention Training Program Dr. Bruce Linder, C. Psych, BCBA-D Vice President, SMG Presented to Ontario Shores 2012 Research Day March, 2012 © 2010

Upload: others

Post on 23-Aug-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Group (SMG) Crisis … · An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Safe Management Group (SMG) Crisis ... (OnLine vs Classroom) Educational

An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the  Safe Management Group (SMG) Crisis 

Intervention Training Program

Dr. Bruce Linder, C. Psych, BCBA-DVice President, SMG

Presented to Ontario Shores 2012 Research DayMarch, 2012

© 2010

Page 3: An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Group (SMG) Crisis … · An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Safe Management Group (SMG) Crisis ... (OnLine vs Classroom) Educational

Presentation Overview

Page 4: An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Group (SMG) Crisis … · An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Safe Management Group (SMG) Crisis ... (OnLine vs Classroom) Educational
Page 5: An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Group (SMG) Crisis … · An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Safe Management Group (SMG) Crisis ... (OnLine vs Classroom) Educational

Staff Crisis Intervention Training

Page 6: An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Group (SMG) Crisis … · An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Safe Management Group (SMG) Crisis ... (OnLine vs Classroom) Educational

103 Agencies ServicedAs at February 29, 2012

Page 7: An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Group (SMG) Crisis … · An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Safe Management Group (SMG) Crisis ... (OnLine vs Classroom) Educational

23,414 Staff TrainedAs at February 29, 2012

Page 8: An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Group (SMG) Crisis … · An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Safe Management Group (SMG) Crisis ... (OnLine vs Classroom) Educational

Ontario Shores & SMG

Page 9: An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Group (SMG) Crisis … · An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Safe Management Group (SMG) Crisis ... (OnLine vs Classroom) Educational

MCSS Approval - 2003

Page 10: An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Group (SMG) Crisis … · An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Safe Management Group (SMG) Crisis ... (OnLine vs Classroom) Educational

Ontario PSHSA  Partnership 2010

Page 11: An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Group (SMG) Crisis … · An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Safe Management Group (SMG) Crisis ... (OnLine vs Classroom) Educational
Page 12: An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Group (SMG) Crisis … · An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Safe Management Group (SMG) Crisis ... (OnLine vs Classroom) Educational

What is “crisis intervention”

training?Teaching skills in how to prevent

and 

manage

patient verbal and physically  aggressive behaviour

Page 13: An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Group (SMG) Crisis … · An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Safe Management Group (SMG) Crisis ... (OnLine vs Classroom) Educational

Philosophical Basis of SMG

Page 14: An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Group (SMG) Crisis … · An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Safe Management Group (SMG) Crisis ... (OnLine vs Classroom) Educational

Course Content

Page 15: An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Group (SMG) Crisis … · An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Safe Management Group (SMG) Crisis ... (OnLine vs Classroom) Educational

Risk Management

Page 16: An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Group (SMG) Crisis … · An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Safe Management Group (SMG) Crisis ... (OnLine vs Classroom) Educational

Relationship Management

Page 17: An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Group (SMG) Crisis … · An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Safe Management Group (SMG) Crisis ... (OnLine vs Classroom) Educational

Behaviour Management

Page 18: An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Group (SMG) Crisis … · An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Safe Management Group (SMG) Crisis ... (OnLine vs Classroom) Educational

Aggression Escalation  Continuum

Page 19: An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Group (SMG) Crisis … · An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Safe Management Group (SMG) Crisis ... (OnLine vs Classroom) Educational

Aggression Management

Page 20: An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Group (SMG) Crisis … · An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Safe Management Group (SMG) Crisis ... (OnLine vs Classroom) Educational

Instructional Model

Page 21: An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Group (SMG) Crisis … · An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Safe Management Group (SMG) Crisis ... (OnLine vs Classroom) Educational

Multi‐level Training  System

Page 22: An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Group (SMG) Crisis … · An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Safe Management Group (SMG) Crisis ... (OnLine vs Classroom) Educational

Classroom Training

Page 23: An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Group (SMG) Crisis … · An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Safe Management Group (SMG) Crisis ... (OnLine vs Classroom) Educational

Online Training

Page 24: An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Group (SMG) Crisis … · An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Safe Management Group (SMG) Crisis ... (OnLine vs Classroom) Educational

Advanced Training 

Page 25: An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Group (SMG) Crisis … · An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Safe Management Group (SMG) Crisis ... (OnLine vs Classroom) Educational

Safe Passage Program

Page 26: An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Group (SMG) Crisis … · An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Safe Management Group (SMG) Crisis ... (OnLine vs Classroom) Educational

Specialized Certification  (1‐Day) 

Page 27: An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Group (SMG) Crisis … · An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Safe Management Group (SMG) Crisis ... (OnLine vs Classroom) Educational

Training Program Assumptions

Page 28: An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Group (SMG) Crisis … · An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Safe Management Group (SMG) Crisis ... (OnLine vs Classroom) Educational

If generic techniques don’t work! Individual Specialized Consultation

Individualized Risk Assessment and  Recommended Physical Interventions

Page 29: An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Group (SMG) Crisis … · An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Safe Management Group (SMG) Crisis ... (OnLine vs Classroom) Educational

How effective is SMG?

Page 30: An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Group (SMG) Crisis … · An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Safe Management Group (SMG) Crisis ... (OnLine vs Classroom) Educational

Study Design

Page 31: An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Group (SMG) Crisis … · An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Safe Management Group (SMG) Crisis ... (OnLine vs Classroom) Educational

Outcome Measure

Page 32: An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Group (SMG) Crisis … · An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Safe Management Group (SMG) Crisis ... (OnLine vs Classroom) Educational

Subject’s Age & Gender

Mean Age = 33.6, SD = 10.7

Page 33: An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Group (SMG) Crisis … · An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Safe Management Group (SMG) Crisis ... (OnLine vs Classroom) Educational

Subject’s Work

Page 34: An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Group (SMG) Crisis … · An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Safe Management Group (SMG) Crisis ... (OnLine vs Classroom) Educational

Subject’s Level of Education

Page 35: An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Group (SMG) Crisis … · An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Safe Management Group (SMG) Crisis ... (OnLine vs Classroom) Educational

Teaching Effectiveness (OnLine vs Classroom)

Educational differences that were correlated with Pretest scores

Page 36: An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Group (SMG) Crisis … · An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Safe Management Group (SMG) Crisis ... (OnLine vs Classroom) Educational

Retention of Learning

Page 37: An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Group (SMG) Crisis … · An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Safe Management Group (SMG) Crisis ... (OnLine vs Classroom) Educational

Online vs Classroom Ratings N = 30

Page 38: An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Group (SMG) Crisis … · An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Safe Management Group (SMG) Crisis ... (OnLine vs Classroom) Educational

Performance By Unit

Page 39: An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Group (SMG) Crisis … · An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Safe Management Group (SMG) Crisis ... (OnLine vs Classroom) Educational

Weakest Knowledge Areas (Questions < 50% Correct)

Question Unit Pretest

Coercion cycle (2) Relationship Mgnt 20%

Boundaries & Limits Relationship Mgnt 27%

Power & Equity Relationship Mgnt 29%

No data Behaviour Mgnt 31%

Empathy Relationship Mgnt 32%

Staff Stress (2) Risk Mgnt 33%

Poor Implementation Risk Risk Mgnt 35%

Order of Agg Esc Levels Excalation Continuum 41%

Subtle Stage Excalation Continuum 44%

Page 40: An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Group (SMG) Crisis … · An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Safe Management Group (SMG) Crisis ... (OnLine vs Classroom) Educational

Summary

• SMG effective in teaching staff• Online teaches as well as 

classroom• 70% retain knowledge for at 

least 1 year• Online refresher is effective• Relationship & Behaviour 

Management ‐

areas of  greatest need for training

Page 41: An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Group (SMG) Crisis … · An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Safe Management Group (SMG) Crisis ... (OnLine vs Classroom) Educational

Future Directions?

Assessing Performance Skills

Page 42: An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Group (SMG) Crisis … · An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Safe Management Group (SMG) Crisis ... (OnLine vs Classroom) Educational

Future Directions?

Page 43: An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Group (SMG) Crisis … · An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Safe Management Group (SMG) Crisis ... (OnLine vs Classroom) Educational

Questions

Page 44: An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Group (SMG) Crisis … · An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Safe Management Group (SMG) Crisis ... (OnLine vs Classroom) Educational

Partners

Ontario Public Services  Health & Safety 

Association

Page 45: An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Group (SMG) Crisis … · An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Safe Management Group (SMG) Crisis ... (OnLine vs Classroom) Educational

The End

345 Lakeshore Rd. East., Suite 506Oakville, Ontario L6J 1J5

[email protected]

Tel: 905-849-0967© 2010