mentor.ieee.org · web view2020-01-29 · a compendium of motions related to the contents of the...
Post on 10-Feb-2020
0 Views
Preview:
TRANSCRIPT
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
IEEE P802.11Wireless LANs
A compendium of motions related to the contents of the draft amendment for TGay
Date: 2020-01-29
Author:Name Company Address Phone email
Edward Au Huawei Technologies 303 Terry Fox Drive, Suite 400, Ottawa, ON, K2K 3J1
edward.ks.au@ huawei.com
Compendium of motions Page 1 Edward Au (Huawei)
AbstractThis document summarizes all motions related to the contents of the draft amendment for TGay, including comment resolution for CC24, LB231, LB234, LB239, LB242, LB246, and initial Standards Association ballot.
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
2017 January
Motion #143
Do you agree to insert the following in draft? “The 11ay specification shall enable BSS discovery through transmitted DMG Beacon frames based on: Setting the Quasi-omni TX subfield to one in transmitted DMG Beacon frames to indicate the potential for
discovery based on quasi-omni transmission Appending TRN-R subfields to transmitted DMG Beacon frames Transmit antenna training by an EDMG STA based on TRN-R subfields appended to a received DMG
Beacon frame that has the Quasi-omni TX subfield equal to one.”
Moved: Hiroyuki MotozukaSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 17/0/7The motion is passed.
Motion #144
Do you agree to insert the following in draft? “The 11ay specification shall enable BSS discovery through Probe Request based on: Appending TRN-R subfields to a Probe Request frame transmitted with quasi-omni antenna pattern Transmit antenna training by an EDMG STA based on TRN-R subfields appended to a received Probe
Request frame transmitted with a quasi-omni antenna pattern.”
Moved: Hiroyuki MotozukaSeconded: Claudio da Silva
The motion is passed with unanimous consent.
Motion #145
Do you agree to add the following text into draft? “For an allocation that does not include the primary channel, its allocation information shall be completely and only included in the EDMG Extended Schedule element.”
Moved: Hiroyuki MotozukaSeconded: Claudio da Silva
The motion is passed with unanimous consent.
Compendium of motions Page 2 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #146
Do you agree to add the following text into the draft? “A Scheduling Type subfield shall be added into each Channel Allocation field of the EDMG Extended Schedule element to indicate whether an allocation is based on incremental signaling or complete signaling.”
Moved: Hiroyuki MotozukaSeconded: Claudio da Silva
The motion is passed with unanimous consent.
Motion #147
Do you agree to add the following into daft?
Moved: Assaf KascherSeconded: Claudio da Silva
The motion is passed with unanimous consent.
Motion #148
Do you agree to add the following into the draft? “For an EDMG SC PPDU, the Length field in the L-Header is set so that the spoofing error shall be smaller than one symbol block (512*Tc) and non-negative, where Spoofing error = (TXTIME calculated based on L-Header) – (TXTIME).”
Moved: Hiroyuki MotozukaSeconded: Claudio da Silva
The motion is passed with unanimous consent.
Motion #149
Do you agree to add the following field ‘DCM SQPSK over two aggregated channels field (1 bit)’ in the EDMG-header-A for an EDMG SU PPDU to the draft? A value of 1 indicates that DCM SQPSK over two aggregated channels is applied. A value of 0 indicates that DCM SQPSK over two aggregated channels is not applied. Reserved if either TX or RX does not support DCM SQPSK over two aggregated channels.
Moved: Tao WuSeconded: Yan Xin
The motion is passed with unanimous consent.
Compendium of motions Page 3 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #150
Do you agree to add to the draft? “EDMG TRN subfield for CB = 1, 2, 3, 4 and MIMO NSS = 1, 2, … 8, shall have a structure shown on slide #9 of 16/1636r0. The GaN/GbN sequence length is defined as N = 128 * CB. All sequences GaN/GbN are defined in the draft.
Moved: Alexander MaltsevSeconded: Rob Sun
The motion is passed with unanimous consent.
Motion #151
Do you agree that (1) the AGC field currently defined for single-carrier and control mode EDMG PPDUs shall be removed and (2) the training field of EDMG PPDUs shall be defined as shown below for the single-carrier and control modes? In the proposed structure, the number of TRN sequences used for channel estimation (that is, transmitted with the same AWV as the preamble/data fields) (P) and for BF training (which may use different AWV settings depending on whether transmit or receive training is used) (M) in a TRN-Unit is configurable.
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Rob Sun
The motion is passed with unanimous consent.
Motion #152
Do you agree to incorporate the additions to the BRP Request Field (slide 11 of 17/0007r1), EDMG Header A bits (slide 12 of 17/0007r1), Mandatory features (slide 13 of 17/0007r1), and Capabilities element (slides 14 and 15 of 17/0007r1) to the draft?
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Yan Xin
The motion is passed with unanimous consent.
Compendium of motions Page 4 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #153
Do you agree to insert the following in the 11ay Draft? 11ay specification shall define EDMG SU PPDU aggregation.
Moved: Takenori SakamotoSeconded: Hiroyuki Motozuka
The motion is passed with unanimous consent.
Motion #154
Do you agree with the EDMG A-PPDU formats shown in slides 3 and 5 of 11-17/0051r3 for 11ay SC mode?
Moved: Takenori SakamotoSeconded: Claudio da Silva
The motion is passed with unanimous consent.
Motion #155
Do you agree to add “Additional EDMG PPDU field” to the EDMG-Header-A?
Moved: Takenori SakamotoSeconded: Claudio da Silva
The motion is passed with unanimous consent.
Motion #156
Do you agree with the coding and modulation method shown in slide 7 of 11-17/0051r3 for EDMG-Header-A within the EDMG A-PPDU transmitted with the same bandwidth as the corresponding data field in 11ay SC mode?
Moved: Takenori SakamotoSeconded: Claudio da Silva
The motion is passed with unanimous consent.
Compendium of motions Page 5 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #157
Do you agree to include in draft the following? TXOP Owner may reduce the PPDU occupied channel width only when transmitting EDMG PPDU. A TXOP owner shall not increase the PPDU occupied channel width within the same TXOP.
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Yan Xin
The motion is passed with unanimous consent.
Motion #158
Do you agree to apply cyclic extension of EDMG-CEF field as defined on slide #6 of 17/0149r2?
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Yan Xin
The motion is passed with unanimous consent.
Motion #159
Do you agree to add the following text to the Draft? “If the Short SSW packet is transmitted during ISS and RSS and then SSW-Feedback frame and SSW-ACK frame are transmitted, SSW Feedback field within SSW-Feedback frame and SSW-ACK frame is interpreted as the figure in slide 4 of 17/0109r1. Sector Select subfield (6bits) is interpreted as CDOWN Select 1 subfield (6bits). DMG Antenna Select subfield (2bits) is interpreted as RF Chain Select subfield (2bits). Reserved bits (5bits) are interpreted as CDOWN Select 2 subfield (5bits).
Moved: SungJin ParkSeconded: JinMin Kim
The motion is passed with unanimous consent.
Motion #160
Do you agree to add the following text into draft? “Short SSW frame can be transmitted by associated STAs in A-BFT for 11ay.”
Moved: JinMin KimSeconded: Claudio da Silva
The motion is passed with unanimous consent.
Compendium of motions Page 6 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #161
Do you agree to add the following text into draft? “If short SSW frame is transmitted in A-BFT, SSW slot time for short SSW frame is the same as 11ad.”
Moved: JinMin KimSeconded: Claudio da Silva
The motion is passed with unanimous consent.
Motion #162
TBD Do you agree to add the signaling for multi-channel and multiple RX antenna SPSH using Optional Sub-elements in Directional Channel Quality Request/Report frame (shown on slides 6-7 of 17/0108r0) into the Draft?
Moved: JinMin KimSeconded: Claudio da Silva
The motion is passed with unanimous consent.
Motion #163
Do you agree to add the following text to the 802.11ay draft? An EDMG STA may support hybrid precoding (defined as a combination of analog beamforming and digital
baseband precoding) for SU-MIMO. An EDMG STA may support hybrid precoding (defined as a combination of analog beamforming and digital
baseband precoding) for MU-MIMO.
Moved: Kome OteriSeconded: Rui Yang
The motion is passed with unanimous consent.
Motion #164
Do you agree to instruct the editor to incorporate the text in document 11-16-1627r0 TX Masks into IEEE 802.11ay draft 0.1?
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Yan Xin
The motion is passed with unanimous consent.
Compendium of motions Page 7 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #165
Do you agree to instruct the editor to incorporate the draft text in document 11-16-1626-00-EDMG Capabilities into IEEE 802.11ay draft 0.1, and edit the text as necessary to be compatible with the DMG Capabilities element in IEEE 802.11-2016?
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Yan Xin
The motion is passed with unanimous consent.
Motion #166
To deal with asymmetric DMG antenna configurations, the 11ay specification shall define an enhanced SLS protocol that enables beamforming training between an AP or PCP and non-AP or non-PCP STAs that includes the following steps: adding TRN-R subfields to DMG Beacon frames transmitted in the BTI; beamforming training between the PCP/AP and non-PCP/non-AP STAs (as shown in slides 8-9 of
17/0067r1); scheduling of directional allocations in the DTI (as shown in slides 11-12 of 17/0067r1)
Moved: Alexander MaltsevSeconded: Claudio da Silva
The motion is passed with unanimous consent.
Motion #167
Do you agree that the spoofing error for EDMG control mode PPDUs shall be defined to be non-negative and less than or equal to 150ns, except between 611713 𝑇_𝑐 (approx. 347.56 μs) and 612351 𝑇_𝑐 (approx. 347.93 μs) and between 614401 𝑇_𝑐 (approx. 349.10 μs) and 617343 𝑇_𝑐 (approx. 350.76 μs) when the spoofing error shall be non-negative and less than or equal to 639 𝑇_𝑐 (approx. 364 ns) and 2943 𝑇_𝑐 (approx. 1.67 μs), respectively? Spoofing error is defined as (TXTIME calculated based on L-Header) – (TXTIME).
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Yan Xin
The motion is passed with unanimous consent.
Motion #168
Do you agree to define in the draft, the 16 bits of address field within Short SSW frame to contain RA and TA AID fields? If the TA or RA is the AP itself, the TA or RA AID field should be filled with the 8 bits of the EDMG BSS AID. In case of ISS and Unicast, the Short SSW Feedback field should be replaced by the Short Scrambled BSSID(SS-BSSID) field.
Moved: Rob SunSeconded: Claudio da Silva
The motion is passed with unanimous consent.
Compendium of motions Page 8 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #169
Do you agree to add the following to the draft? The BSSID values are scrambled with the following formula before the calculation of SS-BSSID in the Short SSW packet:
scrambled i-th word = (i-th word + scramble pattern) mod 216,where each word is the part of the BSSID which is split by 16 bits, and + is integer addition.
Moved: Rob SunSeconded: Claudio da Silva
The motion is passed with unanimous consent.
Motion #170
Do you agree to add the following to the draft? Scramble patterns for SS-BSSID calculation are defined as follows:
o Scramble pattern = (0x5795 * seed) mod 215
The seed is the scrambler initialization in the PHY header of the Short SSW packet.
Moved: Rob SunSeconded: Yan Xin
The motion is passed with unanimous consent.
Motion #171
Do you agree to add the following to the draft? The EDMG core capabilities shall contain NUC capabilities which indicate support of NUC and differentiate between NUC transmission and reception.
Moved: Dana CoichinaSeconded: Claudio da Silva
The motion is passed with unanimous consent.
Motion #172
Do you agree to add the following to the Draft? EDMG header-A and header-B shall have an indication to signal use of non-uniform constellation. The indication consists of a single bit in each header and rules of slide #5 of 17/0057r0 apply.
Moved: Dana CoichinaSeconded: Rob Sun
The motion is passed with unanimous consent.
Compendium of motions Page 9 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #173
Do you agree with the EDMG-Header-A definition proposed in slide 7 of 17/0052r1?
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Alexander Maltsev
The motion is passed with unanimous consent.
Motion #174
Do you agree to add the following capability information in the core capabilities field of the EDMG capabilities element regarding open loop precoding into the 11ay draft? Open Loop Precoding Supported field (1bit)
Moved: Hiroyuki MotozukaSeconded: Claudio da Silva
The motion is passed with unanimous consent.
Compendium of motions Page 10 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
2017 March
Motion #178
Do you agree to perform input bits parsing over the spatial streams on the round robin manner with bits grouping and padding as shown on slides #8, 9 of 11-17-0211-01-00ay? Specification text is proposed in 11-17-0214-01-00ay 29 5 7 27 Encoding.
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Lei Huang
Yes/No/Abstain: 29/0/7The motion is passed.
Motion #179
Do you agree to add the following to the draft: “The EDMG-TRN subfield for MIMO with NSS > 2 shall be defined as shown on slide #8 of 11-17-0212-01-00ay”? Specification text is proposed in 11-17-0213-00-00ay 29 9 3 26 9 TRN Subfield Definition.
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Assaf Kasher
Yes/No/Abstain: 29/0/6The motion is passed.
Motion #180
Do you agree to instruct the editor to incorporate the draft text in the contribution 17/0189r0 into IEEE 802.11ay draft 0.2?
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Thomas Handte
Yes/No/Abstain: 30/0/6The motion is passed.
Motion #181
Do you agree to incorporate the proposed changes on Measurement Request & Report elements as shown in IEEE 802.11-17/0215r2 into the next draft 11ay specification?
Moved: Lei HuangSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 31/0/5The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 11 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #182
Do you agree to incorporate the proposed changes on Spatial Sharing and Interference Mitigation as shown in IEEE 802.11-17/0217r3 into the next draft 11ay specification?
Moved: Lei HuangSeconded: Sang Kim
Yes/No/Abstain: 28/0/6The motion is passed.
Motion #183
Do you agree that the text in contribution 17/0277r0 shall be incorporated into the next draft 11ay specification?
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Lei Huang
Yes/No/Abstain: 29/0/6The motion is passed.
Motion #184
Do you agree that the text in contribution 17/0278r0 shall be incorporated into the next draft 11ay specification?
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Lei Huang
Yes/No/Abstain: 27/0/3The motion is passed.
Motion #185
Do you agree to incorporate the proposed changes on Channel Measurement Feedback element, DMG Beam Refinement element and EDMG Channel Measurement Feedback element as shown in IEEE 802.11-17/0219r2 into the next draft 11ay specification?
Moved: Lei HuangSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 24/0/5The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 12 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #186
Do you agree to adopt the mechanism described in slides 4 and 5 of 11-17/0422r0, as specified in 11-17/0420r2?
Moved: Carlos CordeiroSeconded: Assaf Kasher
Yes/No/Abstain: 25/0/3The motion is passed.
Motion #187
Do you agree that the text in contribution 17/0323r2 (Draft text for BRP Transmit Sector Sweep) shall be incorporated into the next draft 11ay specification?
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Lei Huang
Yes/No/Abstain: 24/0/5The motion is passed.
Motion #188
Do you agree to incorporate the proposed changes on SU-MIMO beamforming and MU-MIMO beamforming as shown in IEEE 802.11-17/0287r0 into the next draft 11ay specification?
Moved: Lei HuangSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 24/0/4The motion is passed.
Motion #189
Do you agree that the text in contribution 17/0430r0 shall be incorporated into the next draft 11ay specification?
Moved: Assaf KascherSeconded: Solomon Trainin
Yes/No/Abstain: 27/0/3The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 13 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #190
Do you agree to include the text changes to occupied bandwidth as defined in Doc: 11-17-0413-00-00ay Occupied bandwidth clarification?
Moved: Solomon TraininSeconded: Assaf Kasher
Yes/No/Abstain: 31/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #191
Do you agree to implement text changes to remove EDMG Compressed BlockAckReq as defined in Doc: 11-17-0412-02-00ay Compressed BlockAckReq for EDMG?
Moved: Solomon TraininSeconded: Carlos Cordeiro
Yes/No/Abstain: 29/0/1The motion is passed.
Motion #192
Do you agree to add a mechanism to the 802.11ay specification to perform the following? In the 11ay BRP protocol there shall be an option for the BRP frame to function as an action ACK frame. The procedure to recover feedback if the response is not ready is TBD.
Moved: Kome OteriSeconded: Rui Yang
Yes/No/Abstain: 22/0/8The motion is passed.
Motion #193
Do you agree to incorporate the changes proposed in (11-17-0424-00-00ay-cr-on-mimo-phase-in-mu-mimo-bf.docx) into the draft spec?
Moved: Shunsuke FujioSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 21/0/4The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 14 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #194
Do you agree to add the following capability information in the EDMG capabilities element regarding LDPC codes into Draft IEEE 802.11ay?
Long LDPC codes capability information (1 bit) If the long LDPC codes capability field is set to 1, the STA supports LDPC long codeword for the
supported MCSs. Otherwise, the STA does not support LDPC long codeword.
Moved: Yutuka MurakamiSeconded: Sang Kim
Yes/No/Abstain: 23/0/5The motion is passed.
Motion #195
Do you agree to include mechanisms that support tracking of the digital baseband channel for SU-MIMO and MU-MIMO hybrid beamforming in 802.11ay?
Moved: Kome OteriSeconded: Rui Yang
Yes/No/Abstain: 9/3/11The motion is passed.
Motion #196
Do you agree that the text in contribution 17/0434r1 (Draft Text for Channel Allocation for SP) shall be incorporated in the 11ay draft?
Moved: Dejian LiSeconded: Jinnan Liu
Yes/No/Abstain: 24/0/4The motion is passed.
Motion #199
Do you agree to adopt the text of “11-17-0450-01-00ay-EDMG Capability and Operation Element Channel Indication_r1” into Draft of IEEE 802.11ay?
Moved: Yan XinSeconded: Yutuka Murakami
Yes/No/Abstain: 19/0/4The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 15 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
2017 May
Motion #203
Do you agree to include the text for subclause “30.5.8 Non-EDMG Duplicate Transmission” proposed in (11-17-0525-01-00ay 30 5 8 Non-EDMG Duplicate Transmission for SC PHY) to the draft amendment?
Moved: Artyom LomayevSeconded: Alexander Maltsev
Yes/No/Abstain: 11/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #204
Do you agree to insert the following text in the draft amendment: IEEE 802.11-17/0523r2 Draft Text for MIMO Channel Access.docx?
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Lei Huang
Yes/No/Abstain: 12/0/1The motion is passed.
Motion #205
Do you agree to incorporate the proposed changes on the MIMO phase of SU-MIMO beamforming and MU-MIMO beamforming as shown in IEEE 802.11-17/0541r2 into the draft amendment?
Moved: Lei HuangSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 15/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #206
Do you agree to include the text from (11-17-0588-00-00ay 30 5 6 4 4 Block Interleaver for SC mode) defining SC block interleaver for 64QAM/64NUC to the draft amendment?
Moved: Artyom LomayevSeconded: Alexander Maltsev
Yes/No/Abstain: 15/0/1The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 16 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #207
Do you agree to include the text from (11-17-0587-01-00ay 30 5 6 4 3 Space Time Block Coding) defining SC STBC scheme to the draft amendment?
Moved: Artyom LomayevSeconded: Alexander Maltsev
Yes/No/Abstain: 18/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #208
Do you agree to define OFDM signal parameters as defined in (11-17-0597-01-00ay 30 6 1 OFDM Signal Parameters) and incorporate the proposed changes into the draft amendment?
Moved: Artyom LomayevSeconded: Alexander Maltsev
Yes/No/Abstain: 18/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #209
Do you agree to include the text for EDMG-STF for EDMG OFDM mode in single channel proposed in (11-17-0546-00-00ay-EDMG-STF for OFDM in single channel) to the draft amendment?
Moved: JinMin KimSeconded: Sang Kim
Yes/No/Abstain: 18/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #210
Do you agree to include the text for Short SSW frame for A-BFT proposed in (11-17-0746-00-00ay Short SSW frame for A-BFT text) to the draft amendment?
Moved: Saehee BangSeconded: JinMin Kim
Yes/No/Abstain: 19/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 17 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #211
Do you agree to accept resolutions to CIDs 151, 476, 477, 340, 342, 452, 453, 454, 224, 225, 226, 341 in doc 11-17/0709r2?
Moved: Lei HuangSeconded: Carlos Cordeiro
Yes/No/Abstain: 18/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #212
Do you agree to accept resolutions to CIDs 331, 343 in doc 11-17/0713r1?
Moved: Lei HuangSeconded: Carlos Cordeiro
Yes/No/Abstain: 19/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #213
Do you agree to include the text for the beamforming training for channel bonding and channel aggregation proposed in (11-17-0743-00-00ay-Beamforming Training for CB & CA) to the draft amendment?
Moved: SungJin ParkSeconded: JinMin Kim
Yes/No/Abstain: 19/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #214
Do you agree to include the text for the length calculation proposed in (11-17-0788-00-00ay-Length Calculation in EDMG PPDU-Draft text) into the draft amendment as an informative text?
Moved: SungJin ParkSeconded: Hiroyuki Motozuka-san
Yes/No/Abstain: 19/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 18 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #215
Do you agree to include the text 17/0705r2 into the draft amendment?
Moved: Solomon TraininSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 20/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #216
Do you agree to include to the draft amendment the text: “EDMG Group fields of EDMG Group ID Set element should contain the STAs AIDs and the corresponding indexes of the AP TX sectors (chosen from the best sectors reported by STAs), which may be used by the AP for transmission to each STA in MU mode of operation.”?
Moved: Alexander MaltsevSeconded: Lei Huang
Yes/No/Abstain: 17/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #217
Do you agree to include the text for “Near-Far” self-classification capabilities of EDMG STAs proposed in (11-17-0764-02-00ay-text-near-far-self-classification-capabilities-of-edmg-stas) to the draft amendment?
Moved: Alexander MaltsevSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 18/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #218
Do you agree to add the amendment text of 11-17/0771r0 to D0.3
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Alexander Maltsev
Yes/No/Abstain: 19/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 19 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #219
Do you agree to include the text from (11-17-0596-00-00ay 30 6 3 OFDM EDMG-CEF Definition) defining EDMG-CEF field for PPDU transmission over the 2.16 GHz channel to the draft amendment?
Moved: Artyom LomayevSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 16/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #220
Do you agree to include the text from (11-17-0628-01-00ay 30 6 1 Pilot Sequences) defining OFDM pilots to the draft amendment?
Moved: Artyom LomayevSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 17/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #221
Do you agree to include the text from (11-17-0712-00-00ay-30 6 1 OFDM Pilot sequences) defining OFDM pilot sequences for NCB > 1 to the draft amendment?
Moved: Sang KimSeconded: SungJin Park
Yes/No/Abstain: 17/0/1The motion is passed.
Motion #222
Do you agree to accept resolutions to CID 24 in doc 11-17/0787r0?
Moved: Artyom LomayevSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 17/0/1The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 20 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #223
Do you agree to include the definition of transmitter block diagram for SC mode proposed in (11-17-0752-02-00ay 30 5 2 Transmitter Block Diagram for SC Mode) into the draft amendment?
Moved: Artyom LomayevSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 19/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #224
Do you agree to include the text proposed in (30 6 4 Encoding of EDMG-Header-B) and describing EDMG-Header-B encoding and modulation method to the draft amendment?
Moved: Artyom LomayevSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 20/0/1The motion is passed.
Motion #225
Do you agree to add the following capability information in the PHY Capability field of the EDMG capabilities element, as shown in 11-17-0757-00-00ay-text-for-phy-capability-field-in-edmg-capabilities-element, into the Draft IEEE802.11ay amendment?
SC Maximum Number of SU-MIMO Spatial Streams Supported OFDM Maximum Number of SU-MIMO Spatial Streams Supported
Moved: Yutaka MurakamiSeconded: Carlos Cordeiro
Yes/No/Abstain: 20/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #226
Do you agree to include the proposed text changes in 17/0793r1 to the draft amendment?
Moved: Dzevdan KapetanovicSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 12/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 21 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #227
Do you agree to include spec text proposed in (11-17-0753-01-00ay 30 6 6 2 Space Time Block Coding) defining STBC scheme for OFDM PHY into the draft amendment?
Moved: Artyom LomayevSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 23/0/1The motion is passed.
Motion #228
Do you agree to accept resolutions to the following CIDs 24, 127, 200, 468, 201, 310, 202, 203, 204, 205, 206, 207, 208, 209, 211, 210, 150, 213, 473, 216, 217, 218, 219, 222, 194, 223, 341, 224, 225, 226, 362, 230, 139, 234, 240, 241, 278, 242, 141, 243, 244, 245, 33, 279, 103, 281, 34, 280, 249, 273, 375, 88, 161, 181, 145, 80, 536, 537, 538, 382, 108, 109, 545, 530, 546, 532, 83, 391, 50, 164, 162, 163, 407, 516, 7, 321, 165, 166, 170, 173, 19, 22, 79, 167, 441, 169, 126, 171, 172, 168 in 17/0649r2?
Moved: Carlos CordeiroSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 27/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #229
Do you agree to include the proposed text changes in 17/0761r4 to the draft amendment?
Moved: Takenori SakamotoSeconded: Anuj Batra
Yes/No/Abstain: 26/0/1The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 22 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
2017 July
Motion #232
Do you agree to include the proposed text in 11-17-0431-00-00ay to the draft amendment?
Moved: Carlos CordeiroSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 17/0/1The motion is passed.
Motion #233
Do you agree to make the following changes per the text described in 11-17-0818-02-00ay-updates-to-edca-channel-access-in-an-edmg-bss.docx?
Moved: Carlos CordeiroSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 17/0/1The motion is passed.
Motion #234
Do you agree to accept resolutions to CID 227 in doc 11-17/0845r0?
Moved: Carlos CordeiroSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 17/0/1The motion is passed.
Motion #235
Do you agree to include the text of 17/0870r3 for the subclause 30.6.7.2 into the draft amendment?
Moved: Artyom LomayevSeconded: Carlos Cordeiro
Yes/No/Abstain: 17/0/2The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 23 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #236
Do you agree to accept the proposed comment resolution in 17/0892r4 for CIDs 4, 6, 128, 156, 158, 159, 414, and 415?
Moved: Artyom LomayevSeconded: Carlos Cordeiro
Yes/No/Abstain: 19/0/1The motion is passed.
Motion #237
Do you agree to accept the proposed comment resolution for CIDs 63 and 68 in 17/0893r2 and include the proposed changes into the draft amendment?
Moved: Artyom LomayevSeconded: Carlos Cordeiro
Yes/No/Abstain: 19/0/1The motion is passed.
Motion #238
Do you agree to define the scrambling for MCS 1 as described in (11-17-0904-00-00ay 30 5 7 3 3 Scrambler for MCS1 Encoding) and include the proposed text into the draft amendment?
Moved: Artyom LomayevSeconded: Carlos Cordeiro
Yes/No/Abstain: 19/0/1The motion is passed.
Motion #239
Do you agree to accept the resolutions given in 11-17-0919-01-00ay to the following CIDs: 73, 75, 89, 122, 123, 262, 263, 296, 298, 401, 409, 410, 411, 412, and 413?
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Carlos Cordeiro
Yes/No/Abstain: 21/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 24 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #240
Do you agree to include the changes described in 11-17-0938-03-00ay to enable Short SSW usage in CBAP by unassociated STAs in the draft amendment?
Moved: Hiroyuki MotozukaSeconded: Carlos Cordeiro
Yes/No/Abstain: 21/0/1The motion is passed.
Motion #241
Do you agree to accept comment resolutions as proposed in doc 11-17/0921r4?
Moved: Carlos CordeiroSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 24/0/2The motion is passed.
Motion #242
Do you agree to accept comment resolution for CIDs 303, 304, 305, 306, 309, 311, 317, 467, 308, 325, 336, 328, and 465 as proposed in doc 11-17/0649r5?
Moved: Carlos CordeiroSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 23/0/1The motion is passed.
Motion #243
Do you agree to include the draft text proposed in 11-17-0923-00-00ay related to TRN subfield indexing into the 802.11ay draft amendment?
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Carlos Cordeiro
Yes/No/Abstain: 21/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 25 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #244
Do you agree to include the draft text proposed in 11-17-0924-00-00ay related to data/TRN transition interval into the 802.11ay draft amendment?
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Carlos Cordeiro
Yes/No/Abstain: 20/0/1The motion is passed.
Motion #245
Do you agree to define the Control PHY PPDU transmission as defined in (11-17-1040-00-00ay Control Mode PPDU Transmission) and include the proposed text in the 802.11ay draft amendment?
Moved: Artyom LomayevSeconded: Carlos Cordeiro
Yes/No/Abstain: 22/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #246
Do you agree to define the SC PHY PPDU transmission as defined in (11-17-1043-00-00ay 30 5 8 Single Carrier PPDU Transmission) and include the proposed text in the 802.11ay draft amendment?
Moved: Artyom LomayevSeconded: Carlos Cordeiro
Yes/No/Abstain: 23/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #247
Do you agree to accept the change proposed for clause 10.24.7.7 as shown in slides 9 and 10 of 17/1026r0 and include the proposed text in the 802.11ay draft amendment?
Moved: Oren KedemSeconded: Carlos Cordeiro
Yes/No/Abstain: 21/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 26 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #248
Do you agree to include the text for comment resolution on short SSW in A-BFT (11-17-1038-00-00ay-cr-on-short-ssw-in-a-bft) in the 802.11ay draft amendment?
Moved: Saehee BangSeconded: Carlos Cordeiro
Yes/No/Abstain: 23/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #249
Do you agree to accept the proposed comment resolution in 17/1027r1 for CIDs 105, 149, 315, 316, 318, 322, 323, 324, 327, 383, 466, 482, 534 and 535?
Moved: Solomon TraininSeconded: Carlos Cordeiro
Yes/No/Abstain: 22/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #250
Do you agree to accept comment resolution for CIDs 155, 38, 344, 345, 346, 348, 347, 330, 66, 60, 67 as proposed in doc 11-17/0649r5?
Moved: Carlos CordeiroSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 25/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #251
Do you agree to include the text for EDMG-STF for EDMG OFDM mode in CB>1 proposed in (11-17-1029-00-00ay-EDMG-STF for OFDM in 2,3,4CB Draft) to the spec amendment?
Moved: Sang KimSeconded: Carlos Cordeiro
Yes/No/Abstain: 24/0/1The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 27 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #252
Do you agree to include the draft text proposed in 11-17-1042-01-00ay related to CE TRN transmission in BRP TXSS into the 802.11ay draft amendment?
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Carlos Cordeiro
Yes/No/Abstain: 24/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #253
Do you agree to adopt the comment resolutions to CIDs 10, 25, 61, 62, 64, 131, 133, 320, 481, 484, 518, and 520 as proposed in document 11-17/1075r1?
Moved: Thomas HandteSeconded: Carlos Cordeiro
Yes/No/Abstain: 25/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #254
Do you agree to accept comment resolution as proposed in doc 11-17/1033r0?
Moved: Sang KimSeconded: Carlos Cordeiro
Yes/No/Abstain: 25/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #255
Do you agree to accept comment resolution as proposed in doc 11-17/1041r0?
Moved: Sang KimSeconded: Carlos Cordeiro
Yes/No/Abstain: 24/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 28 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #257
Do you agree to accept the resolution on transmission bandwidth of EDMG A-PPDU proposed in 11-17-1056-00-00ay?
Moved: Takenori SakamotoSeconded: Carlos Cordeiro
Yes/No/Abstain: 25/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #258
Do you accept the resolutions to CIDs 27, 28, 36, 100, 363, 130, 174, 358, 180, 233, 364, 235, 357, 442, 461, and 360?
Moved: Assaf KasherSeconded: Carlos Cordeiro
Yes/No/Abstain: 25/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #259
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 1, 2, 23, and 525 proposed in the contribution 17/0880r1.
Moved: Artyom LomayevSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 27/0/2The motion is passed.
Motion #260
Move to accept the proposed comment resolution in 17/1119r2 for CIDs 119 and 189.
Moved: James WangSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 29/0/2The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 29 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #261
Move to accept the comment resolution for CID 462 proposed in the contribution 17/1047r1.
Moved: Artyom LomayevSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 24/0/1The motion is passed.
Motion #262
Move to define the MCS set for EDMG OFDM PHY as described in the contribution 17/0909r0 and include the proposal in the draft amendment.
Moved: Artyom LomayevSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 33/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #263
Move to define the EDMG-CEF for OFDM PHY in case of NCB > 1 as described in the contribution 17/1108r0 and include the proposal in the draft amendment.
Moved: Artyom LomayevSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 32/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #264
Move to include the parity check matrix shown in the contribution 17/1061r1 in the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Yan XinSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 31/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 30 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #265
Move to include the changes as described in IEEE 802.11-17/1097r1 to define Beam Tracking and its associated signaling and procedures in the 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Rui YangSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 31/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #266
Move to include the text in the contribution 17/1083r0 in the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Dejian LiSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 28/0/3The motion is passed.
Motion #267
Move to adopt the comment resolutions to CIDs 135,136,137,144 as proposed in doc: IEEE 802.11-17/1095r1.
Moved: Rob SunSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 28/0/2The motion is passed.
Motion #269
Move to include the text in the contribution 17/1085r1 in the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Dejian LiSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 29/0/2The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 31 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
2017 September
Motion #272
Move to adopt the comment resolutions to CIDs 35, 81, 111, 112, 178, 192, 250, 354, 370, 372, 492, 493, 506, 507, 508, 509, 510, 515, 542, 543, 544 as proposed in 17/1112r2.
Moved: Claudo da SilvaSeconded: George Calcev
Yes/No/Abstain: 22/0/1The motion is passed.
Motion #273
Move to adopt the comment resolutions to CIDs 74, 76, 77, 102, 292, 295, 297, 301, 332, 399, 430, and 431 as proposed in 17/1175r1 and 17/1175r2.
Moved: Claudo da SilvaSeconded: George Calcev
Yes/No/Abstain: 19/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #274
Move to include the text proposed in 17/1181r0 for BRP TXSS procedure into the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Claudo da SilvaSeconded: George Calcev
Yes/No/Abstain: 17/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #275
Move to include the text that defines the modulation description of OFDM mode as proposed in 17/1170r2 into the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Claudo da SilvaSeconded: George Calcev
Yes/No/Abstain: 21/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 32 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #276
Move to accept comment resolution for CIDs 502 and 549 as proposed in doc 11-17/1185r0.
Moved: Hiroyuki MotozukaSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 22/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #277
Move to include the text proposed in 17/1184r2 for MU-MIMO BF selection into the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Hiroyuki MotozukaSeconded: Assaf Kasher
Yes/No/Abstain: 21/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #278
Move to accept the text proposed in 11-17/1221r3 for scrambler field indication into IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Assaf KasherSeconded: Yan Xin
Yes/No/Abstain: 23/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #279
Move to include the text proposed in 17/1182r2 for OFDM spoofing error length indicator into the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Yan Xin
Yes/No/Abstain: 27/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 33 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #280
Move to accept comment resolution for CIDs 138, 214, 339, 471 and 472 as proposed in doc 11-17/1229r0.
Moved: Oren KedemSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 23/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #281
Move to accept comment resolution for CIDs 104, 195, 196, 450, 212, 449, 254, 267, 268, 269, 379, and 451 as proposed in doc 11-17/1230r3.
Moved: Oren KedemSeconded: Assaf Kscher
Yes/No/Abstain: 25/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #282
Move to accept comment resolution for CID 428 as proposed in doc 11-17/1180r2.
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Yan Xin
Yes/No/Abstain: 24/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #283
Move to include the text proposed in 17/1213r0 for SM power save into the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Carlos CordeiroSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 24/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 34 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #284
Move to include the text proposed in 17/1215r1 for MU-MIMO power save into the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Carlos CordeiroSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 23/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #285
Move to include the text proposed in 17/1196r0 for the EDMG flow control mechanism into the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Assaf KasherSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 22/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #286
Move to accept comment resolution for CID 517 as proposed in doc 11-17/1292r1.
Moved: Dana CiochinaSeconded: Assaf Kasher
Yes/No/Abstain: 22/0/2The motion is passed.
Motion #287
Move to accept comment resolution for CID 429 as proposed in doc 11-17/1241r0.
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Assaf Kasher
Yes/No/Abstain: 20/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 35 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #288
Move to include the text proposed in 17/1254r0 for facilitating rank adaptation of SU-MIMO transmission into the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Li-Hsiang SunSeconded: Sang Kim
Yes/No/Abstain: 25/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #289
Move to accept comment resolution for CIDs 69 and 72 as proposed in doc 11-17/1435r0.
Moved: Assaf KasherSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 26/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #290
Move to include the text proposed in 17/1289r0 for EDMG coexistence with non-IEEE-802.11 systems into the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Yutaka Murakami
Yes/No/Abstain: 26/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #291
Move to accept comment resolution for CIDs 153, 377, 444, 445, 446, 448, 463, 469, and 470 as proposed in doc 11-17/1230r4.
Moved: Oren KedemSeconded: Assaf Kasher
Yes/No/Abstain: 24/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 36 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #292
Move to accept comment resolution for CIDs 5, 333, 334, 312, 335, 313, 337, 78, 380, 485, 456, and 527 as proposed in doc 11-17/0649r7.
Moved: Carlos CordeiroSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 25/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #293
Move to include the text proposed in 17/1437r0 for a short variant of the BRP frame into the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Assaf KasherSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 21/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #294
Move to include the text proposed in 17/1436r1 for line-of-sight beamforming training into the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Assaf KasherSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 27/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #295
Move to include the text proposed in 17/1417r0 for power save delivery into the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Oren KedemSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 22/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 37 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #296
Move to include the text proposed in 17/1452r0 related to the changes to BRP and MIMO frames to accommodate digital beamforming training into the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Dana CiochinaSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 22/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #297
Move to include the text proposed in 17/1331r0 for DMG TRN capability into the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Assaf KasherSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 25/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #298
Move to accept comment resolution for CIDs 186, 187, 188, 371, 439, 440, and 513 as proposed in doc 11-17/1422r1.
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Carlos Cordeiro
Yes/No/Abstain: 21/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #299
Move to include the text proposed in 17/1424r0 for alternative single carrier MCS 12 and MCS 13 using 8-PSK modulation into the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Chris HansenSeconded: Assaf Kasher
Yes/No/Abstain: 23/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 38 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #300
Move to include the text proposed in 17/1425r1 for unsolicited block ACK feature into the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Chris HansenSeconded: Sang Kim
Yes/No/Abstain: 24/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #301
Move to include the text proposed in 17/1297r1 related to the changes to the BRP TXSS procedure into the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Assaf Kasher
Yes/No/Abstain: 25/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #302
Move to accept comment resolution for CIDs 53, 403, 125, 291, 402, 404, 397, 190, 551, 433, 91, and 432 as proposed in doc 11-17/1298r0.
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Assaf Kasher
Yes/No/Abstain: 24/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #303
Move to include the text proposed in 17/1300r0 for EDMG-Header-A encoding and modulation into the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Assaf Kasher
Yes/No/Abstain: 19/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 39 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #304
Move to accept comment resolution for CIDs 179, 266, 314, 355, 384, 455, 491, 494, and 541 as proposed in doc 11-17/1314r2.
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Assaf Kasher
Yes/No/Abstain: 21/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #305
Move to include the text proposed in 17/1410r1 for channel bandwidth definition into the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Saehee BangSeconded: Jinmin Kim
Yes/No/Abstain: 21/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #306
Move to accept comment resolution for CIDs 183, 220, 248, 255, 270, 271, 388, 389, and 390 as proposed in doc 11-17/1407r2.
Moved: Tony HanSeconded: Yan Xin
Yes/No/Abstain: 22/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #307
Move to accept comment resolution for CIDs 129, 425, 426, and 553 as proposed in doc 11-17/1405r1.
Moved: Jinmin KimSeconded: Sang Kim
Yes/No/Abstain: 20/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 40 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #308
Move to accept comment resolution for CIDs 44, 45, 93, 193, 349, 351, 353, 393, 504, and 550 as proposed in doc 11-17/1234r1.
Moved: Hiroyuki MotozukaSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 24/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #309
Move to accept comment resolution for CIDs 272, 95, 94, 92, 96, 184, and 396 as proposed in doc 11-17/1439r2.
Moved: Hiroyuki MotozukaSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 24/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #310
Move to include the text proposed in 17/1328r1 related to the changes to enable request for sector sweep feedback for BRP-TX packets into the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Assaf KasherSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 25/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #311
Move to include the text proposed in 17/1382r2 for the delayed BRP feedback into the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Assaf KasherSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 24/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 41 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #312
Move to accept comment resolution for CIDs 40, 41, 42, 43, 113, 114, 152, and 483 as proposed in doc 11-17/1406r1.
Moved: SungJin ParkSeconded: Jinmin Kim
Yes/No/Abstain: 23/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #313
Move to accept comment resolution for CIDs 282, 283, 284, 285, 286, 287, 288, 289, 423, 424, 487, 488, 489, and 490 as proposed in doc 11-17/1404r2.
Moved: SunWoong YunSeconded: Jinmin Kim
Yes/No/Abstain: 24/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #314
Move to accept comment resolution for CIDs 70 and 71 as proposed in doc 11-17/1415r0.
Moved: Yutaka MurakamiSeconded: Sang Kim
Yes/No/Abstain: 24/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #315
Move to accept comment resolution for CIDs 3, 17, and 524 as proposed in doc 11-17/1441r0.
Moved: Yan XinSeconded: Tony Han
Yes/No/Abstain: 26/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 42 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #316
Move to accept comment resolution for CID 142 as proposed in doc 11-17/1329r0.
Moved: Assaf KasherSeconded: Kerstin Johnsson
Yes/No/Abstain: 22/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #317
Move to include the text proposed in 17/1411r2 for the EDMG-Header-A encoding and modulation for EDMG SC mode A-PPDU into the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Takenori SakamotoSeconded: Sang Kim
Yes/No/Abstain: 24/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #318
Move to accept comment resolution for CIDs 9, 253, and 378 as proposed in doc 11-17/1413r1.
Moved: Takenori SakamotoSeconded: Sang Kim
Yes/No/Abstain: 21/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #319
Move to include the text proposed in 17/1446r2 for distributed scheduling into the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Kerstin JohnssonSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 22/1/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 43 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #320
Move to include the text proposed in 17/1409r0 for MU-MIMO channel access flow into the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Tony HanSeconded: Kerstin Johnsson
Yes/No/Abstain: 26/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #321
Move to include the text proposed in 17/1432r3 for subclause 30.5.8.5.2 into the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Tao WuSeconded: Tony Han
Yes/No/Abstain: 26/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #322
Move to include the text proposed in 17/1414r0 for the EDMG segmentation and reassembly in the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Oren KedemSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 23/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 44 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
2017 November
Motion #325
Move to accept comment resolution for CIDs 98, 293, and 400 as proposed in 17/1530r0, and CID 294 as proposed in 17/1523r3.
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Assaf Kasher
Yes/No/Abstain: 20/0/1The motion is passed.
Motion #326
Move to accept comment resolution for CIDs 110, 143, 385, and 514 as proposed in 17/1532r0.
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Assaf Kasher
Yes/No/Abstain: 21/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #327
Move to include the text proposed in 17/1534r1 for hybrid beamforming feedback into the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Li-Hsiang SunSeconded: Assaf Kasher
Yes/No/Abstain: 19/0/1The motion is passed.
Motion #328
Move to include the text proposed in 17/1568r0 for the definition of OFDM PHY PPDU transmission into the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Yan Xin
Yes/No/Abstain: 23/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 45 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #329
Move to approve the removal of the multiple sector feedback mechanism from IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment as proposed in 17/1570r1.
Moved: Yan XinSeconded: Assaf Kasher
Yes/No/Abstain: 22/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #330
Move to include the text proposed in 17/1581r0 for the modification of EDMG-Header-B encoding procedure into the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Thomas Handte
Yes/No/Abstain: 25/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #331
Move to include the text proposed in 17/1584r0 that enables unsolicited RSS after BTI into the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Hiroyuki MotozukaSeconded: Assaf Kasher
Yes/No/Abstain: 24/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #332
Move to include the text proposed in 17/1583r0 that enables an EDMG AP to use multiple antennas in BTI and A-BFT of a beacon interval into the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Yan XinSeconded: Tony Han
Yes/No/Abstain: 24/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 46 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #333
Move to accept comment resolution for CIDs 175, 176, 361, 275, 39, and 359 as proposed in 17/1579r0, and CIDs 257, 258, 259, 260, 261, 56, 57, 58, and 59 as proposed in 17/1580r1.
Moved: Assaf KasherSeconded: Yan Xin
Yes/No/Abstain: 20/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #334
Move to include the text proposed in 17/1596r0 for the modification of the description of STBC encoding for SC mode into the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Thomas Handte
Yes/No/Abstain: 22/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #335
Move to include the text proposed in 17/1595r0 for the EDMG multi-TID aggregation support into the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Assaf Kasher
Yes/No/Abstain: 21/0/1The motion is passed.
Motion #336
Move to include the text proposed in 17/1599r2 for “30.2.3 Support for non-EDMG and EDMG Formats” into the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Assaf Kasher
Yes/No/Abstain: 24/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 47 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #337
Move to accept comment resolution for CIDs 107, 274, and 329 as proposed in 17/1598r2.
Moved: Li-Hsiang SunSeconded: Yan Xin
Yes/No/Abstain: 25/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #338
Move to include the text proposed in 17/1622r1 for SLS with different Tx and Rx antennas into the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Li-Hsiang SunSeconded: Sang Kim
Yes/No/Abstain: 22/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #339
Move to include the text proposed in 17/1586r1 for the short SSW example into the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Assaf KasherSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 23/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #340
Move to accept comment resolution for CIDs 264 and 480 as proposed in 17/1658r0.
Moved: Jinmin KimSeconded: Sang Kim
Yes/No/Abstain: 23/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 48 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #341
Move to include the text proposed in 17/1674r0 for the BRP for channel aggregation into the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Jinmin KimSeconded: Sang Kim
Yes/No/Abstain: 22/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #342
Move to accept comment resolution for CIDs 82, 101, 282, 373, 374, 478, and 479 as proposed in 17/1660r1.
Moved: SungJin ParkSeconded: Sang Kim
Yes/No/Abstain: 24/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #343
Move to include the text proposed in 17/1659r0 related to a signaling method for the intended responders that should perform receive AWV training in the MU-MIMO beamforming training subphase into the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: SungJin ParkSeconded: Sang Kim
Yes/No/Abstain: 24/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #344
Move to include the text proposed in 17/1656r1 for the definition of DCM SQPSK across aggregated channels into the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: SunWoong YunSeconded: Sang Kim
Yes/No/Abstain: 23/0/1The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 49 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #345
Move to include the text proposed in 17/1691r0 for advanced MU-MIMO acknowledgement and power save flow into the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Assaf Kasher
Yes/No/Abstain: 25/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #347
Move to accept comment resolution for CIDs 14, 157, 521, 522, 523, 37, and 65 as proposed in 17/1642r0, and CID 148 as proposed in 17/1597r1.
Moved: Assaf KasherSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 23/0/1The motion is passed.
Motion #348
Move to accept comment resolution for CIDs 97, 290, 405, 416, 417, 418, 419, 420, and 519 as proposed in 17/1664r0.
Moved: Dana CiochinaSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 24/0/1The motion is passed.
Motion #349
Move to include the text proposed in 17/1688r0 for the clarification of non-uniform constellation application the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Dana CiochinaSeconded: Assaf Kasher
Yes/No/Abstain: 24/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 50 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #350
Move to include the text proposed in 17/1654r0 for the definition of OFDM TRN subfield into the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: SunWoong YunSeconded: Sang Kim
Yes/No/Abstain: 22/0/1The motion is passed.
Motion #351
Move to include the text proposed in 17/1640r0 related to a scheduling mechanism for mmWave distribution networks into the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Assaf Kasher
Yes/No/Abstain: 22/0/2The motion is passed.
Motion #352
Move to include the text proposed in 17/1713r0 related to EDMG spatial stream feedback into the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Chris HansenSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 25/0/1The motion is passed.
Motion #353
Move to accept comment resolution for CIDs 29, 32, 90, 106, 134, 154, 160, 236, 237, 238, 239, 247, 366, 368, 369, 459, 460, and 475 as proposed in 17/1714r0.
Moved: Chris HansenSeconded: Yan Xin
Yes/No/Abstain: 24/0/1The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 51 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #354
Move to include the text proposed in 17/1712r0 related to vertical MIMO coding for SC and OFDM modes into the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Chris HansenSeconded: Assaf Kasher
Yes/No/Abstain: 23/0/1The motion is passed.
Motion #355
Move to accept comment resolution for CID 11 as proposed in 17/1676r2.
Moved: Hiroyuki MotozukaSeconded: Sang Kim
Yes/No/Abstain: 23/0/1The motion is passed.
Motion #356
Move to include the text proposed in 17/1677r1 related to the definition of EDMG A-PPDU format into the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Hiroyuki MotozukaSeconded: Sang Kim
Yes/No/Abstain: 22/0/1The motion is passed.
Motion #357
Move to include the text proposed in 17/1683r0 related to the description of the waveform for the EDMG SC mode and OFDM mode A-PPDU transmission into the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Hiroyuki MotozukaSeconded: Sang Kim
Yes/No/Abstain: 23/0/1The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 52 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #358
Move to include the text proposed in 17/1678r0 related to the EDMG-Header-A encoding and modulation for EDMG SC mode A-PPDU and OFDM mode A-PPDU into the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Hiroyuki MotozukaSeconded: Assaf Kasher
Yes/No/Abstain: 22/0/1The motion is passed.
Motion #359
Move to include the text proposed in 17/1708r1 for the definition of phase hopping modulation into the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Yutaka MurakamiSeconded: Assaf Kasher
Yes/No/Abstain: 22/0/1The motion is passed.
Motion #360
Move to accept comment resolution for CID 528 as proposed in 17/1709r1.
Moved: Yutaka MurakamiSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 24/0/1The motion is passed.
Motion #361
Move to include the text proposed in 17/1735r1 related to an enhancement of the EDMG Multi-TID aggregation support into the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Jinjing JiangSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 26/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 53 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #362
Move to include the text proposed in 17/1760r1 related to the definition of the TRN subfield for channel aggregation into the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Tony HanSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 29/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #363
Move to accept comment resolution for CIDs 376 and 387 as proposed in 17/1680r2.
Moved: Li-Hsiang SunSeconded: Sang Kim
Yes/No/Abstain: 27/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #364
Move to include the text proposed in 17/1692r1 for the hybrid beamforming protocol design details into the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Kome OteriSeconded: Li-Hsiang Sun
Yes/No/Abstain: 25/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #365
Move to accept comment resolution for CIDs 277, 547, 435, 500, 177, 338, 55, and 191 as proposed in 17/0649r9.
Moved: Carlos CordeiroSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 25/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 54 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #366
Move to accept comment resolution for CID54 as proposed in 17/1675r0.
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Assaf Kasher
Yes/No/Abstain: 28/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 55 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
2018 January
Motion #370
Move to accept the text proposed in 17/1802r1 as comment resolution for CID 1007 and update the resolution status of the CID to “ACCEPTED”.
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Yan Xin
Yes/No/Abstain: 25/0/4The motion is passed.
Motion #371
Move to accept the text proposed in 17/1806r2 as comment resolution for CIDs 1006 and 1629, update the resolution status of CID 1006 to “ACCEPTED”, and update the resolution status of CID 1629 to “REVISED, TGay editor to make the changes shown in 11-17/1806r2”.
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Assaf Kasher
Yes/No/Abstain: 24/0/1The motion is passed.
Motion #372
Move to accept the text proposed in 17/1233r1 as comment resolution for CID 1138 and update the resolution status of the CID to “ACCEPTED”.
Moved: Lei Huang Seconded: Assaf Kasher
Yes/No/Abstain: 27/0/3The motion is passed.
Motion #373
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 1341, 1680, and 2337 as proposed in 18/0093r0.
Moved: Lei HuangSeconded: Assaf Kasher
Yes/No/Abstain: 25/0/1The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 56 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #374
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 1504, 1605, 1684, 1720, 1910, 2080, 2341, 2342, and 1174 as proposed in 17/1834r3.
Moved: Hiroyuki MotozukaSeconded: Assaf Kasher
Yes/No/Abstain: 25/0/1The motion is passed.
Motion #375
Move to include the text proposed in 18/0147r0 for DMG Beamforming MLME in the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Claudio da Silva Seconded: Assaf Kasher
Yes/No/Abstain: 24/0/2The motion is passed.
Motion #376
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 1027, 1028, 1795, and 2324 as proposed in 18/0089r0, CIDs 1049, 2305, 1032, 1053, 1050, 1051, 1052, 1338, 1055, and 1337 as proposed in 18/0125r1, and CIDs 1060, 1062, 1329, 1970, 1578, 2104, 1061, 1838, 2326, 1330, 1688, 1895, 1021, 1685, 2007, and
1140 as proposed in 18/0146r1.
Moved: Claudio da Silva Seconded: Lei Huang
Yes/No/Abstain: 20/0/3The motion is passed.
Motion #377
Move to accept the comment resolution for CID 2327 as proposed in 18/0172r2.
Moved: Li-Hsiang SunSeconded: Rui Yang
Yes/No/Abstain: 23/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 57 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #378
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 1717, 1948, 1737, 1738, 1193, 1389, 1422, 1834, 1674, 1631, 1882, 2229, 1433, 1989, 1087, 1678, 1924, 2221, 1724, 1559, 1177, and 1639 as proposed in 18/0047r2, and update the resolution status of these CIDs to “REVISED, TGay editor to make the changes shown in 11-18/0047r2”.
Moved: Carlos CordeiroSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 26/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #379
Move to include the text proposed in 18/0148r1 for MLME SAP (Re)Association interface in the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Claudio da Silva Seconded: Sang Kim
Yes/No/Abstain: 22/0/2The motion is passed.
Motion #380
Move to include the text proposed in 18/0069r2 for ACK/BA transmission in mmWave distribution networks in the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Lochan Verma Seconded: Assaf Kasher
Yes/No/Abstain: 25/0/1The motion is passed.
Motion #381
Move that, in TDD SP operation, the beam refinement response to a beam refinement request shall be transmitted at the start of the earliest occurring TDD Slot that allows for its transmission.
NOTE: This is introduced to prohibit bi-directional exchange of BRP request and BRP response frames in a Basic TDD Slot.
Moved: Lochan VermaSeconded: Assaf Kasher
Yes/No/Abstain: 23/0/3The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 58 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #382
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 1124, 1240, 1293, 1300, 1336, 1347, 1348, and 1481 as proposed in 18/0184r2.
Moved: Assaf KasherSeconded: Lei Huang
Yes/No/Abstain: 23/0/2The motion is passed.
Motion #383
Move to accept the comment resolution for CID 2187 as proposed in 18/0168r1.
Moved: Assaf KasherSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 20/0/2The motion is passed.
Motion #384
Move to include the text proposed in 18/0179r3 for beamforming training for TDD distributed networks in the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Oren KedemSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 20/0/3The motion is passed.
Motion #385
Move to include the text proposed in 18/0197r2 for OFDM TRN subfield for channel aggregation in the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: SunWoong YunSeconded: SungJin Park
Yes/No/Abstain: 24/0/1The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 59 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #386
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 1046, 1152 as proposed in 18/0091r1, CIDs 1154, 1974, 1995, 1821, 1977 as proposed in 18/0092r0, CIDs 1466, 1467, 2118, 2119 as proposed in 18/0095r2, and CID 1468 as proposed in 18/0135r2.
Moved: Lei HuangSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 26/0/1The motion is passed.
Motion #387
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 1111, 1157, 1356, 1357, 1412, 1358, 1371, 1779, 1780, 1781, 1789, 1945, 2139, 2140, 2141, 2142, 2317, and 2318 as proposed in 18/0158r3.
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Sang Kim
Yes/No/Abstain: 12/0/1The motion is passed.
Motion #388
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 1627, 1835, and 2031 as proposed in 18/0186r2.
Moved: Dana CiochinaSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 13/0/2The motion is passed.
Motion #389
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 1617, 2029, 2030, and 2034 as proposed in 18/0186r2.
Moved: Dana CiochinaSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 14/0/1The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 60 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #390
Move to accept the comment resolution for CID 1940 as proposed in 18/0139r1.
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Sang Kim
Yes/No/Abstain: 13/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #391
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 1425, 1426, 1587, 2226, 2227, 2334, 2335, 1610, 1611, 1670, and 1671 as proposed in 18/0167r0, and update the resolution status of these CIDs to “REVISED, TGay editor to make the changes shown in 11-18/0167r0”.
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Sang Kim
Yes/No/Abstain: 14/0/1The motion is passed.
Motion #392
Move to accept the text proposed in 17/1806r3 as comment resolution for CIDs 1006 and 1629, update the resolution status of CID 1006 to “ACCEPTED”, and update the resolution status of CID 1629 to “REVISED, TGay editor to make the changes shown in 11-17/1806r3”..
Moved: Anuj BatraSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 14/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #394
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 1527 and 1528 as proposed in 18/0188r2.
Moved: Hiroyuki MotozukaSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 15/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 61 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #395
Move to include the text proposed in 18/0193r0 for EDMG BRP Request element in the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Kome OteriSeconded: Xiaofei Wang
Yes/No/Abstain: 17/0/1The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 62 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
2018 March
Motion #399
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 1875, 1982, 1391, 2036, 1418, 1419, 2037, 2038, 1599, 2039, 2105, 2106, 2107, 1935, 1715, and
1716 as proposed in 18/0141r2; CIDs 2040, 1294, 1295, 1296, 1600, 1601, 1683, 1697, 2042, 2340, 1845, 2041, 2043, 2044, 2045, 2046,
2047, 2048, 2049, 2050, 2060, 2061, 2062, 2063, 1501, 1563, 1013, 1297, 1850, 2066, and 2064 as proposed in 18/0189r1;
CIDs 2089, 1455, 1456, 1457, 1458, 1459, 1609, and 1672 as proposed in 18/0284r0; and CIDs 1310, 1506, 2008, 1507, 1508, and 1509 as proposed in 18/0307r3.
Moved: Claudio da Silva Seconded: Assaf Kasher
Yes/No/Abstain: 27/0/1The motion is passed.
Motion #400
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 1298, 2067, 1804, 1907, 2068, 2069, 2070, 1447, 1548, 2071, 1908, 2072, 1171, 1299, 1301, 1448,
1666, 1810, 2073, 2074, 2075, 1502, 1577, 1603, 1450, 1274, 1449, 2078, 1275, 1276, 1451, 1452, 1909, 1604, 1503, 2076, 1667, 1881, 1839, 1840, 2077, 1453, 2082, 1278, 2083, 1085, 1279, 1302, 1303, 1304, 1305, 1454, 2084, 1427, 1562, 1607, 1669, 1913, 2087, 2225, 2333, 2085, 1830, 2086, 2088, 1608, 1831, 1806, 1585, 1586, 1583, 1829, 1612, 1856, 1014, 1306, 1584, 1662, 1663, 1664, 1088, 1857, 1564, and 1505 as proposed in 18/0210r7.
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Assaf Kasher
Yes/No/Abstain: 36/0/2The motion is passed.
Motion #401
Move to accept the revised comment resolution for CID 1032 as proposed in 18/0210r7.
Moved: Claudio da Silva Seconded: Yan Xin
Yes/No/Abstain: 34/0/1The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 63 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #402
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 2166, 1288, and 1280 as proposed in 18/0231r2.
Moved: Xingxin ZhangSeconded: George Calcev
Yes/No/Abstain: 38/0/2The motion is passed.
Motion #403
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 1956 and 2272 as proposed in 18/0137r2; and CIDs 1101, 1645, 1647, 1648, 1735, 1765, 1767, 2135, 2207, 2208, 2209, 2210, and 2211 as proposed in
18/0278r2.
Moved: Assaf KasherSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 38/0/2The motion is passed.
Motion #404
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 1136, 1137, 1139, 1141, 1142, 1243, 1898, 1899, 1900, 1901, 2306, 1133, 1143, 1144, and 1807 as
proposed in 18/0281r1; CIDs 1146, 1147, 1246, 1340, 2022, 2023, 2310, 2311, 2312, and 2313 as proposed in 18/0298r1; and CIDs 1145, 1343, 1344, 1345, 1498, 1499, 1752, 1148, 1403, 1244, 1339, 1902, 1809, 2006, 2314, 1818,
and 2309 as proposed in 18/0299r1.
Moved: Lei Huang Seconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 38/0/2The motion is passed.
Motion #405
Move to accept the editorial changes to the subclause 30.5.9.5.4 Block interleaver as shown in 18/0345r0 to clarify the order of the block interleaver and \pi/2 rotation operations.
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Assaf Kasher
Yes/No/Abstain: 23/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #406
Compendium of motions Page 64 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Move to accept the editorial changes to the subclause 30.5.9.3 Scrambler as shown in 18/0346r1.
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Assaf Kasher
Yes/No/Abstain: 30/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #407
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 1242, 1393, 1054, 2099, 1396, 1395, and 1490 as proposed in 18/0392r1; CIDs 2319, 2320, 2321, 2322, 1792, 1793, 1691, 1026, 1030, 1363, and 1367 as proposed in 18/0393r0;
and CIDs 1149, 1150, 1151, 1401, 1628, 1784, 1836, 1331, 1582, 1057, 1920, 1056, 1919, 1058, 1921, and
1059 as proposed in 18/0394r2.
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Assaf Kasher
Yes/No/Abstain: 32/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #408
Move to accept the comment resolution for CID 1540 as proposed in 18/0333r0; CIDs 1522, 1523, 1524, 1526, 2325, 1550, 1530, 1531, 1533, 1319, 1532, 1535, 1623, 1621, 1622, 1536,
1537, and 1538 as proposed in 18/0332r3; CIDs 2092, 1520, 1521, and 1539 as proposed in 18/0275r1; and CID 1529 as proposed in 18/0400r0.
Moved: Motozuka HiroyukiSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 32/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #409
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 1708, 1943, 1097, 1463, 2111, 2343, 1003, 1009, 1094, 1035, 1942, 1109, 1266, 2112, 1098, 1248, and 1249 as proposed in 18/0377r2.
Moved: Oren KedemSeconded: Solomon Trainin
Yes/No/Abstain: 38/0/0The motion is passed.Motion #410
Compendium of motions Page 65 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 1198, 1865, 1283, 1284, 1287, 1431, 1593, 1595, 1368, 1554, 2157, 1439, 1555, 1556, 1557, 1594, 2150, 2153, 1596, 1785, 1966, 1702, 1704, 2010, 1755, 2151, 1757, 1758, 1760, 1761, 1769, 1777, 1778, 1937, 1938, 1998, 2003, 2004, 2144, 2145, 2146, 2149, 2147, 2152, 2154, 2156, 2158, 2159, 2160, 2289, and 1776 as proposed in 18/0355r2.
Moved: Cheng ChenSeconded: Solomon Trainin
Yes/No/Abstain: 38/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #411
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 2298, 2299, and 1131 as proposed in 18/0449r1.
Moved: Yanchun LiSeconded: Yan Xin
Yes/No/Abstain: 41/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #412
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 1483, 1546, and 1547 as proposed in 18/0497r1.
Moved: Li-Hsiang SunSeconded: Rui Yang
Yes/No/Abstain: 37/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #413
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 1472, 1484, 1634, 1689, 1690, 1866, 2184, 2300, 2301, and 2302 as proposed in 18/0323r2; CIDs 1165, 1496, 1682, 1803, 2179, and 2339 as proposed in 18/0385r2; and CID 1387 as proposed in 18/0386r1.
Moved: Assaf KasherSeconded: Solomon Trainin
Yes/No/Abstain: 42/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 66 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #414
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 1065, 1721, 1117, 1551, 1183, 1863, and 1218 as proposed in 18/0067r4.
Moved: Carlos CordeiroSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 36/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #415
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 1360, 1290, 1967, 1980, 1873, 1979, 1872, 1978, 1413, and 1398 as proposed in 18/0067r4.
Moved: Carlos CordeiroSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 38/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #416
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 1118, 1132, 1746, 1786, 1787, and 1953 as proposed in 18/0506r1.
Moved: Dejian LiSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 24/0/1The motion is passed.
Motion #417
Move to include the text proposed in 18/0410r1 for the revised transmission rules for Beam Refinement Request and Response in the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Sang Kim
Yes/No/Abstain: 25/0/1The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 67 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #418
Move to accept the comment resolution for CID 1525 as proposed in 18/0332r4; and CID 2138 as proposed in 18/0275r1;
Moved: Motozuka HiroyukiSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 24/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #419
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 1487, 1488, and 2303 as proposed in 18/0510r1.
Moved: Alecsander EitanSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 29/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #420
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 2103, 1878, 1985, 1837, 1359, 1397, 2330, 1574, 1575, 2052, 2053, 2054, 2055, 2056, 2057, 2058, and 2059 as proposed in 18/0395r1.
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Assaf Kasher
Yes/No/Abstain: 28/0/1The motion is passed.
Motion #421
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 1589 and 2035 as proposed in 18/0489r2.
Moved: Dana Ciochina Seconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 30/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 68 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #422
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 1473, 1474, 1641, 1957, 1958, 1959, 1963, 2120, 2121, 2122, 2123, 2124, 2247, 2248, 2249, 2250,
2251, 2253, 2254, 1568, and 1573 as proposed in 18/0376r2; CIDs 1078 and 2176 as proposed in 18/0375r2.
Moved: Oren KedemSeconded: Solomon Trainin
Yes/No/Abstain: 32/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #423
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 2245, 2266, 2273, 2274, 1725, 1734, 2206, and 2275 as proposed in 18/0336r2.
Moved: Solomon TraininSeconded: Oren Kedem
Yes/No/Abstain: 28/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #424
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 1077, 1469, 2224, 1445, 1591, 1676, 1936, 1034, 1093, 1705, 1731, 2336, 2171, 1063, 1553, 1182, 1074, 1235, and 1236 as proposed in 18/0067r5.
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Assaf Kasher
Yes/No/Abstain: 32/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #426
Move to accept include the support of Ng = 2, 4, and 8 for compressed BF feedback with (6, 4) quantization in the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: SunWoong YunSeconded: Sang Kim
Yes/No/Abstain: 19/5/7The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 69 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #427
Move to accept the proposed text for 64 QAM rate ½ as proposed in 18/0403r2 into the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Alecsander EitanSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 27/0/2The motion is passed.
Motion #428
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 1925 and 1926 as proposed in 18/0500r0; and CIDs 1376 and 1377 as proposed in 18/0499r0.
Moved: Kome OteriSeconded: Li-Hsiang Sun
Yes/No/Abstain: 24/0/1The motion is passed.
Motion #429
Move to insert the draft text that fixes the CTS_DTS Control Trailer for SU-MIMO Channel Access as proposed in 18/0502r0 into the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Kome OteriSeconded: Li-Hsiang Sun
Yes/No/Abstain: 24/0/1The motion is passed.
Motion #430
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 1096, 1215, 1282, and 1764 as proposed in 18/0530r1.
Moved: Xingxin ZhangSeconded: Yan Xin
Yes/No/Abstain: 30/0/1The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 70 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
2018 May
Motion #434
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 1080, 1214, 1964, 2257, 2261, 2126, 2127, 2255, 2125, 2256, 1079, 1566, 1567, 1565, 1852, 1853, 1854, and 1965 as proposed in 18/0375r4.
Moved: Oren KedemSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 21/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #435
Move to accept the comment resolution for CID 1606 as proposed in 18/0210r7; CID 1632 as proposed in 18/0307r3; CIDs 1512, 1929, 1930, 1932, 2177, 1931, 1514, 1933, 1515, 1414, 1614, 1615, 1270, 1271, 1812, 1813,
1814, 1822, 1616, 1618, 2032, 1549, 1619, 1916, 1928, 1399, 1668, 1517, 1518, 1519, 1516, 1511, 1312, and 1513 as proposed in 18/0308r3; and
CIDs 1315, 1626, 1316, 2093, 1317, 2094, 1815, 1816, 1625, 1320, 1318, 1319, 1623, 1621, 1534, 1622, 1322, and 1969 as proposed in 18/0325r1.
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Cheng Chen
Yes/No/Abstain: 21/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #436
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 1665, 2100, 2101, 2102, 2329, 1325, 1326, 1327, 1825, 1173, and 1415 as proposed in 18/0330r3; CIDs 2095, 2096, 1624, 2033, and 2097 as proposed in 18/0331r2; CIDs 1314, 2328, 1332, 2091, 1321, and 2098 as proposed in 18/0639r1; and CIDs 1934 and 1569 as proposed in 18/0640r1.
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Assaf Kasher
Yes/No/Abstain: 21/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 71 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #437
Move to include the text proposed in 18/0641r1 related to the updated RXTIME computation formula for control mode PPDU in the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Cheng Chen
Yes/No/Abstain: 21/0/1The motion is passed.
Motion #438
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 1975, 1996, 2018, 2237, and 2019 as proposed in 18/0430r2; and CIDs 1903, 1904, 1976, 2001, 2020, 2239, and 1342 as proposed in 18/0610r1.
Moved: Hiroyuki MotozukaSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 19/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #439
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 1949 and 1465 as proposed in 18/0636r4.
Moved: Hiroyuki MotozukaSeconded: Carlos Cordeiro
Yes/No/Abstain: X/0/XThe motion is passed.
Motion #440
Move to the comment resolution for CIDs 1069, 1072, 1081, 2400, 1083, 1112, 1163, 1164, 1722, 1188, 1189, 1217, 1254, 1255, 1256, 1257, 1285, 1380, 1381, 1656, 1692, 1858, 1859, 1867, 1940, 1943, 2113, 2202, 2114, 2173, 2174, 2201, 1258, 1259, 1260, and 2203 as proposed in 18/0667r1.
Moved: Solomon TraininSeconded: Assaf Kasher
Yes/No/Abstain: 19/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 72 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #441
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 1388, 1423, 1047, 1673, 1247, 1432, 1561, 1630, 2228, 1833, 1881, 1988, 1824, 1679, 1922, 2220, 1086, 1736, 1558, 1176, and 1638 as proposed in 18/0643r5.
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Chris Hansen
Yes/No/Abstain: 15/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #442
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 1202, 1906, 1408, and 2170 as proposed in 18/0712r3; CIDs 2189, 2194, 1178, and 2193 as proposed in 18/0851r0; CIDs 1192 and 1210 as proposed in 18/0852r1; and CIDs 1718, 1694, 1221, and 1231 as proposed in 18/0853r1.
Moved: James WangSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 15/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #443
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 1120, 1203, 1207, 1272, 1386, and 2234 as proposed in 18/0679r3; and CIDs 1103, 1104, 1105, and 1106 as proposed in 18/0820r0.
Moved: Chris HansenSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 14/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #444
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 1048 and 1633 as proposed in 18/0730r0; CIDs 1794, 1394, 1364, 1365, and 1366 as proposed in 18/0731r0; and CIDs 1510, 2238, 1250, 1001, 1328, 1912, 1544, 1545, 1460, 1602, and 2051 as proposed in 18/0732r0.
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Sang Kim
Yes/No/Abstain: 16/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 73 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #445
Move to accept the comment resolution for CID 1160 as proposed in 18/0735r1.
Moved: Yutaka MurakamiSeconded: Sang Kim
Yes/No/Abstain: 19/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #446
Move to include the text proposed in 18/0547r4 that supports additional TDD beamforming procedures in the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Tony HanSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 17/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #449
Move to include the text proposed in 18/0681r2 that clarifies the TXSS sector list feedback in the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Hiroyuki MotozukaSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 23/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #450
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 1355, 1597, and 1955 as proposed in 18/0722r1; CIDs 1228, 1229, 1230, 1372, 1373, 1378, 1379, 1409, 1681, 1897, 2005, 2182, 2338, 1405, 1406, 1407,
1475, 2291, 1477, 1570, 1654, 1655, 1782, 1783, 2292, 1894, 2293, 2294, and 2296 as proposed in 18/0723r4; and
CIDs 1290, 1384, 1592, 1745, 1754, 2002, 2246, 1743, 1744, 1770, 1774, 1798, 1939, 2148, 2155, 2161, 2162, 2163, and 2164 as proposed in 18/0721r1.
Moved: Cheng ChenSeconded: Solomon Trainin
Yes/No/Abstain: 23/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 74 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #451
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 1158, 1791, and 1790 as proposed in 18/0731r1; CID 1802 as proposed in 18/0732r1; CIDs 1323, 1620, 1888, 1917, and 2090 as proposed in 18/0713r3
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Cheng Chen
Yes/No/Abstain: 25/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #452
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 1375, 1579, 1580, 1581, 1905, and 2026 as proposed in 18/0441r2.
Moved: JinMin KimSeconded: Sang Kim
Yes/No/Abstain: 27/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #453
Move to accept the comment resolution for CID 2297 as proposed in 18/0714r0; and CIDs 1354, 1374, 1844, 1351, 2024, 2025, 2027, 1491, 1346, 1349, 1350, 1352, and 1489 as proposed in
18/0715r0
Moved: Kome OteriSeconded: Li-Hsiang Sun
Yes/No/Abstain: 27/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #454
Move to include the text proposed in 18/0746r0 that proposes MLME definition for TDD slot structure and TDD slot schedule in the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Lochan VermaSeconded: Sang Kim
Yes/No/Abstain: 25/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 75 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #455
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 1464, 2204, 2212, 2213, 2214, 2215, 2216, 2217, 2218, 2219, 2231, 2235, 2244, 2245, 2260, and 2265 as proposed in 18/0832r2.
Moved: Solomon TraininSeconded: George Calcev
Yes/No/Abstain: 26/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #456
Move to accept the comment resolution for CID 1636 as proposed in 18/0841r1.
Moved: SungJin ParkSeconded: Sang Kim
Yes/No/Abstain: 27/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #457
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 1107, 1116, 1220, 1646, 1649, 2200, 2205, and 2238 as proposed in 18/0958r0.
Moved: Chris HansenSeconded: Nelson Costa
Yes/No/Abstain: 26/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #458
Move to include the text proposed in 18/0850r2 related to the MU Exclusive Beamforming Report field in the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: JinMin KimSeconded: Sang Kim
Yes/No/Abstain: 26/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 76 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #459
Move to accept the comment resolution for CID 2168 as proposed in 18/0843r2.
Moved: Saehee BangSeconded: Sang Kim
Yes/No/Abstain: 23/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #460
Move to include the text proposed in 18/0951r0 related to the modification of the TDD Slot Schedule element in the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Saehee BangSeconded: Sang Kim
Yes/No/Abstain: 23/0/1The motion is passed.
Motion #461
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 1070, 1187, 1709, 1710, 1071, 1073, 2116, 1286, 1713, 1712, 1135, 2115, 2117, 2240, 2241, 1125,
1713, 2130, 2131, 2133, 1108, 1219, 1876, 1983, 2137, 2267, 2276, 2277, 2278, 2280, 2281, 2268, and 2282 as proposed in 18/0766r2;
CIDs 1002, 1181, 1700, 1701, 1090, 1890, 2192, and 1739 as proposed in 18/0783r1.
Moved: Oren KedemSeconded: Solomon Trainin
Yes/No/Abstain: 23/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #462
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 1435, 2188, 1089, 2190, 1429, 1698, 1726, 2191, 1889, 1430, 2195, 2196, 1004, 1823, 1005, 1941, 1732, 1153, 1497, 1827, 2009, 1968, 2178, 1277, 1826, 1914, 1915, 1134, and 1291 as proposed in 18/0067r7.
Moved: Carlos CordeiroSeconded: Solomon Trainin
Yes/No/Abstain: 24/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 77 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #463
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 1361, 1362, and 2079 as proposed in 18/0782r2.
Moved: Oren KedemSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 23/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #464
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 1874 and 1981 as proposed in 18/0814r0.
Moved: Alecsander EitanSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 24/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #465
Move to accept the comment resolution for CID 1637 as proposed in 18/0839r0; and CIDs 1010, 1012, 1011, 1082, 2128, 2332, 1216, and 1733 as proposed in 18/0840r2
Moved: SungJin ParkSeconded: Sang Kim
Yes/No/Abstain: 26/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #466
Move to include the text proposed in 18/0786r3 in the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Payam TorabSeconded: Lochan Verma
Yes/No/Abstain: 22/5/7The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 78 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
2018 July
Motion #469
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 1311, 1313, 1589, and 1590 as proposed in 18/0696r0.
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Cheng Chen
Yes/No/Abstain: 23/0/3The motion is passed.
Motion #470
Move to include the text proposed in 18/0950r0 related to the modification of the TDD slot start time in clause 10.36.6.2.2 of Draft 1.4 of the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Saehee BangSeconded: Sang Kim
Yes/No/Abstain: 23/0/4The motion is passed.
Motion #471
Move to accept the comment resolution for CID 2021 as proposed in 18/0995r3, CIDs 2307 and 2315 as proposed in 18/0993r0.
Moved: Yan XinSeconded: Sang Kim
Yes/No/Abstain: 22/0/3The motion is passed.
Motion #472
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 1805, 1390, 1675, 2169, 1990, 1883, 2230, 1436, 1428, 1677, 1832, 1923, 2222, 1175, 1560, and 2183 as proposed in 18/1004r1.
Moved: Carlos CordeiroSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 22/0/3The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 79 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #473
Move to accept the comment resolution for CID 1099 as proposed in 18/1018r1.
Moved: Yan XinSeconded: George Calcev
Yes/No/Abstain: 21/0/5The motion is passed.
Motion #474
Move to include the text proposed in 18/1035r1 related to the addition of a Tx Antenna Mask subfield to the Digital Feedback Control Field in the MIMO Feedback Control element in clause 9.4.2.261 of Draft 1.4 of the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Mengyao MaSeconded: Yan Xin
Yes/No/Abstain: 23/0/4The motion is passed.
Motion #475
Move to accept the comment resolution for CID 1951 as proposed in 18/1054r1; and CIDs 1263, 1264, 1482, 1695, 1952, 1495, 1961, 2108, 2269, 1967, and 2287 as proposed in 18/1070r0.
Moved: Solomon TraininSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 22/0/3The motion is passed.
Motion #476
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 1095, 1261, 1262, 1420, 1421, 1703, 1891, 2165, 2197, and 2331 as proposed in 18/1053r1; and CIDs 1209, 1706, and 1707 as proposed in 18/1094r2.
Moved: Cheng ChenSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 24/0/4The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 80 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #477
Move to include the text proposed in 18/1083r0 related to the additional fields for the EDMG-Header-A and EDMG-Header-B in clause 29.3.3.2.4.1 of Draft 1.4 of the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Ilya Bolotin
Yes/No/Abstain: 22/0/4The motion is passed.
Motion #478
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 1161, 1657, 1796, 1797, and 1801 as proposed in 18/0905r0.
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Sang Kim
Yes/No/Abstain: 22/0/4The motion is passed.
Motion #479
Move to include the text proposed in 18/1102r1 related to the modification of differential EDMG-MCS signalling in clause 29.3.3.2.4.1 of Draft 1.4 of the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Ilya Bolotin
Yes/No/Abstain: 24/0/3The motion is passed.
Motion #480
Instruct the editor to remove EDMG FAA authentication scheme from the Draft 1.4 of the IEEE 802.11ay amendment.
Moved: Chris HansenSeconded: Nelson Costa
Yes/No/Abstain: 14/2/6The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 81 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #481
Approve the resolution of the CIDs 1064, 1067, 1180, 1289, 1437, 1438, 1440, 1441, 1442, 1443, 1444, 1446, 1552, 1640, 1658, 1659, 1660, 1661, 1728, 1729, 1862, 1869, 2011, 2012, 2013, 2014, 2015, 2016, 2017, 2198, and 2199 as revised with the following resolution text: “EDMG FAA authentication mechanism has been removed from the draft 1.4 of the IEEE 802.11ay amendment as indicated in motion #480”.
Moved: Carlos CordeiroSeconded: Chris Hansen
Yes/No/Abstain: 18/4/3The motion is passed.
Motion #482
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 1292, 1572, 1740, 1772, 1773, 1775, and 1778 as proposed in 18/1107r1, CIDs 1191, 1476, 1478, 1479, 1492, 1896, 1973, and 2236 as proposed in 18/1108r1.
Moved: Cheng ChenSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 25/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #483
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 2271, 2402, 2401, 2323, and 2286 as proposed in 18/1117r2.
Moved: Solomon TraininSeconded: George Calcev
Yes/No/Abstain: 27/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #484
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 1238, 1265, and 2143 as proposed in 18/0484r3.
Moved: Yan XinSeconded: Mengyao Ma
Yes/No/Abstain: 24/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 82 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #485
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 1204, 1971, 2279, 1470, 1748, 1749, and 1750 as proposed in 18/0921r2, CIDs 1102, 1220, 1768, 2242, 2270, 2132, 2134, and 2284 as proposed in 18/1001r2.
Moved: Chris HansenSeconded: Nelson Costa
Yes/No/Abstain: 26/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #486
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 1075, 1076, 1129, 1404, 1411, 1642, 1650, 1651, 1762, 1763, 1860, 1944, 1947, 1960, 1962, 2175, 2252, 2258, 2259, 2285, 2288, and 2295 as proposed in 18/0757r3.
Moved: Ilya BolotinSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 26/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #487
Move to accept the comment resolution for CID 1771 as proposed in 18/1203r2.
Moved: Mohamed AbouelseoudSeconded: George Calcev
Yes/No/Abstain: 23/0/2The motion is passed.
Motion #488
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 2308 and 2316 as proposed in 18/0994r2.
Moved: Lei HuangSeconded: Assaf Kasher
Yes/No/Abstain: 26/0/1The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 83 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #489
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 1324, 1885, 1918, and 1992 as proposed in 18/1152r0 CIDs 1886 and 1993 as proposed in 18/1153r1 CIDs 1273, 2000, 1588, 2109, 1884, 1991, and 1571 as proposed in 18/1154r2
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Sang Kim
Yes/No/Abstain: 27/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #490
Move to accept the comment resolution for CID 1693 as proposed in 18/0459r1.
Moved: George CalcevSeconded: Yan Xin
Yes/No/Abstain: 26/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #491
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 1353, 1887, 1911, 1927, and 1944 as proposed in 18/1182r1.
Moved: Kome OteriSeconded: Thomas Handte
Yes/No/Abstain: 27/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #492
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 1115, 1267, 2232, and 1335 as proposed in 18/1230r4; and CIDs 1269 and 1486 as proposed in 18/1288r1.
Moved: Yan XinSeconded: Mengyao Ma
Yes/No/Abstain: 28/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 84 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #493
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 1126, 1084, 1416, 1417, 1541, 1766, 2136, 2186, 1954, 1168, 1169, 1485, 1471, 1788, 1994, 1099, 2110, and 1369 as proposed in 18/0067r10.
Moved: Carlos CordeiroSeconded: George Calcev
Yes/No/Abstain: 27/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #494
Move to accept the comment resolution for CID 2283 as proposed in 18/0958r0.
Moved: Chris HansenSeconded: Nelson Costa
Yes/No/Abstain: 27/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #495
Move to include the text proposed in 18/0845r3 for ACK operation in TDD SP in clause 10.3.2.10 of Draft 1.4 of the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Saehee BangSeconded: Jinmin Kim
Yes/No/Abstain: 28/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #496
Move to include the text proposed in 18/1173r2 for Power management in TDD SP in clause 11.2.7.1 of Draft 1.4 of the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Saehee BangSeconded: Jinmin Kim
Yes/No/Abstain: 27/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 85 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #497
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 1224, 1226, 1227, 1370, 1480, 1635, 1652, 1868, 1950, 2185, 2223, 2263, and 2290 as proposed in 18/1141r2.
Moved: Sungjin ParkSeconded: Jinmin Kin
Yes/No/Abstain: 28/0/1The motion is passed.
Motion #498
Move to include the text proposed in 18/1142r0 related to consecutive transmission of EDMG BRP packet in the TDD SP in clause 10.39.9.2.2.3.2 of Draft 1.4 of the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Sungjin ParkSeconded: Jinmin Kim
Yes/No/Abstain: 25/0/1The motion is passed.
Motion #499
Move to include the text proposed in 18/1115r1 related to the use of the DMG TRN only capability and the “DMG TRN” EDMG-A header field in clauses 10.39.6.4.1, 30.9.2.2.3, 30.9.2.23, and Annex B of Draft 1.4 of the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Assaf KasherSeconded: George Calcev
Yes/No/Abstain: 26/0/1The motion is passed.
Motion #500
Move to resolve the comment resolution for CID 1944 as proposed in 18/0757r3.
Moved: Assaf KasherSeconded: Carlos Cordeiro
Yes/No/Abstain: 27/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 86 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
2018 September
Motion #505
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 3085, 3619, 3242, 3584, 3471, 3465, 3001, 3286, 3666, 3033, 3012, 3023, 3248, 3002, 3026, 3025, 3384, and 3467 as proposed in 18/1483r2.
Moved: Carlos CordeiroSeconded: Sang Kim
Yes/No/Abstain: 17/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #506
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 3646, 3647, 3650, 3651, 3659, and 3664 as proposed in 18/1513r1.
Moved: Solomon TraininSeconded: Cheng Chen
Yes/No/Abstain: 16/0/0 The motion is passed.
Motion #507
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 3555, 3394, 3556, and 3557 as proposed in 18/1527r1.
Moved: Hiroyuki MotozukaSeconded: Yan Xin
Yes/No/Abstain: 16/0/0 The motion is passed.
Motion #508
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 3169, 3270, 3709, 3185, 3217, 3733, 3300, 3218, 3219, 3277, 3536, 3389, 3693, 3350, 3351, 3352, 3028, 3078, 3529, 3237, 3530, and 3532 as proposed in 18/1569r1.
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Yan Xin
Yes/No/Abstain: 16/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 87 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #509
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 3008, 3020, 3021, 3022, 3343, 3348, 3349, 3354, 3396, 3482, 3488, 3551, 3565, and 3566 as proposed in 18/1560r0, and change the status of CID 3488 from Accept to Revise.
Moved: Cheng ChenSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 15/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #510
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 3195, 3370, 3371, 3372, 3700, and 3199 as proposed in 18/1526r1.
Moved: Assaf KasherSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 15/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #511
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 3515, 3362, 3059, 3516, 3517, 3514, 3307, 3060, 3513, 3061, and 3356 as proposed in 18/1584r3.
Moved: Mohamed AbouelseoudSeconded: Kazuyuki Sakoda
Yes/No/Abstain: 21/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #512
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 3245 and 3652 as proposed in 18/1539r5.
Moved: Cheng ChenSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 19/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 88 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #513
Move to accept the comment resolution for CID 3580 as proposed in 18/1648r3.
Moved: Alecsander EitanSeconded: Assaf Kasher
Move to table the motion:
Moved: Carlos CordeiroSeconded: Sean Coffey
Yes/No/Abstain: 19/0/02The motion is tabled.
Compendium of motions Page 89 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
2018 November
Motion #516
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 3311, 3382, 3312, 3313, 3314, 3315, 3316, 3331, 3332, 3333, 3334, 3375, 3376, 3596, 3622, 3704,
3377, 3623, 3705, 3201, 3378, 3624, 3706, 3202, 3625, 3301, 3732, 3175, 3720, 3721, 3724, 3212, 3213, 3178, 3179, 3725, 3214, 3730, 3722, 3602, 3381, 3380, 3268, 3177, 3180, 3181, 3172, 3173, 3174, 3183, 3090, 3091, 3166, 3740, 3086, 3092, 3093, 3088, 3087, 3089, 3130, 3120, 3121, 3122, 3123, 3062, 3064, and 3065 as proposed in 18/1678r1;
CID 3667 as proposed in 18/1347r0; and CIDs 3317, 3318, 3319, 3320, 3321, 3322, 3323, 3324, 3325, 3326, 3327, 3328, 3329, 3330, and 3288 as
proposed in 18/1753r0.
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Assaf Kasher
Yes/No/Abstain: 15/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #517
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 3031, 3272, 3672, 3675, 3674, 3678, 3681, 3677, 3676, 3683, 3682, 3686, 3673, 3687, 3684, 3679, 3680, and 3685 as proposed in 18/1691r0.
Moved: Claudio da SilvsaSeconded: Alecsander Eitan
Yes/No/Abstain: 15/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #518
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 3007, 3267, 3448, 3231, 3719, 3399, 3367, 3525, and 3526 as proposed in 18/1751r1.
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Assaf Kasher
Yes/No/Abstain: 14/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 90 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #519
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 3106, 3107, 3114, 3115, 3116, 3117, 3197, 3274, 3368, 3698, 3695, 3696, 3697, 3699, 3701, 3702, and 3703 as proposed in 18/1773r0.
Moved: Thomas HandteSeconded: Oren Kedem
Yes/No/Abstain: 15/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #520
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 3265, 3437, 3438, 3439, 3440, 3441, 3442, 3483, 3484, 3485, 3486, 3490, 3567, 3568, 3653, 3691, 3726, 3097, 3294, 3459, 3360, 3405, 3406, 3408, 3417, 3434, and 3436 as proposed in 18/1768r2.
Moved: Oren KedemSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 14/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #521
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 3139, 3271, and 3694 as proposed in 18/1569r1.
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Sang Kim
Yes/No/Abstain: 14/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #522
Move to accept the comment resolution for CID 3580 as proposed in 18/1648r3.
Moved: Alecsander EitanSeconded: Oren Kedem
Yes/No/Abstain: 14/1/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 91 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #523
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 3216, 3461, 3226, and 3229 as proposed in 18/1751r1; and CIDs 3232, 3228, 3230, 3235, 3390, 3449, 3710, and 3084 as proposed in 18/1766r0.
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Assaf Kasher
Yes/No/Abstain: 13/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #524
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 3472, 3473, 3512, 3487, 3511, and 3631 as proposed in 18/1838r0; CIDs 3003, 3004, 3005, 3006, 3282, 3283, 3336, 3337, 3345, 3395, 3421, 3427, 3464, 3468, 3469, 3717,
and 3718 as proposed in 18/1839r2; and CIDs 3096, 3463, 3474, 3735, 3664, 3716, 3737, and 3738 as proposed in 18/1895r0.
Moved: Oren KedemSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 15/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #525
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 3200, 3550, 3524, 3554, 3553, 3559, 3450, 3452, 3457, 3204, 3203, 3205, 3207, 3383, and 3727 as
proposed in 18/1770r1; CIDs 3191, 3192, and 3193 as proposed in 18/1788r1; and CIDs 3460 and 3285 as proposed in 18/1791r0.
Moved: Assaf KasherSeconded: Oren Kedem
Yes/No/Abstain: 120/0The motion is passed.
Motion #526
Move to accept the comment resolution for CID 3103 as proposed in 18/1773r1.
Moved: Thomas HandteSeconded: Mohamed Abouelseoud
Yes/No/Abstain: 10/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 92 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #527
Move to accept the comment resolution for CID 3259 as proposed in 18/1786r0; CIDs 3014, 3015, and 3016 as proposed in 18/1745r0; CIDs 3100 and 3111 as proposed in 18/1789r2; and CIDs 3289, 3533, 3534, and 3535 as proposed in 18/1787r1.
Moved: Alecsander EitanSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 13/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #528
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 3385, 3454, 3386, 3387, 3233, 3456, and 3621 as proposed in 18/1683r2; and CID 3364 as proposed in 18/1899r1.
Moved: Hiroyuki MotozulaSeconded: Sang Kim
Yes/No/Abstain: 13/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #529
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 3358, 3479, 3578, 3586, 3626, 3627, 3628, 3629, 3633, 3641, 3642, 3643, 3654, and 3481 as
proposed in 18/1801r0; and CIDs 3462 and 3663 as proposed in 18/1879r1.
Moved: Alecsander EitanSeconded: Assaf Kasher
Yes/No/Abstain: 13/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #530
Move to accept the comment resolution for CID 3443 as proposed in 18/1895r1.
Moved: Li-Hsiang SunSeconded: Sang Kim
Yes/No/Abstain: 13/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 93 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #531
Move to include the text proposed in 18/2032r0 related to the EVM tests and requirements in clauses 29.5.11.1.1 and 29.6.11.1.1 of Draft 2.1 of the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Anuj BatraSeconded: Alecsander Eitan
Yes/No/Abstain: 13/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #532
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 3252, 3253, 3254, 3255, 3256, 3257, 3269, 3403, 3419, and 3428 as proposed in 18/1854r1.
Moved: Chris HansenSeconded: George Calcev
Yes/No/Abstain: 11/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #533
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 3236, 3276, 3279, 3280, 3281, and 3707 as proposed in 18/1970r1.
Moved: Li-Hsiang SunSeconded: Sang Kim
Yes/No/Abstain: 13/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #534
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 3058, 3221, 3310, 3505, 3506, and 3549 as proposed in 18/1890r1.
Moved: Tony HanSeconded: Assaf Kasher
Yes/No/Abstain: 16/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 94 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #535
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 3476, 3508, 3509, 3548, 3220, 3477, 3478, 3547, 3222, 3546, 3498, 3502, 3499, 3500, 3501, 3504, 3503, 3224, 3507, 3508, 3509, 3542, 3639, 3633, and 3589 as proposed in 18/1837r2.
Moved: Oren KedemSeconded: Claudio ds Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 14/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #536
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 3056, 3057, 3238, 3239, 3240, 3241, 3305, 3306, 3363, 3402, and 3711 as proposed in 18/1894r3.
Moved: George CalcevSeconded: Tony Han
Yes/No/Abstain: 16/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 95 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
2019 January
Motion #539
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 3472, 3473, 3512, 3487, 3511, and 3631 as proposed in 18/1838r0; CIDs 3003, 3004, 3005, 3006, 3282, 3283, 3336, 3337, 3345, 3395,3421, 3427, 3464, 3468, 3469, 3717,
and 3718 as proposed in 18/1839r2; and CIDs 3096, 3463, 3474, 3735, 3664, 3716, 3737, and 3738 as proposed in 18/1985r0.
Moved: Oren KedemSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 19/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #540
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 3055, 3562, 3353, 3066, 3409, and 3410 as proposed in 18/2067r1; CIDs 3539, 3540, and 3541 as proposed in 18/2146r0; and CID 3266 as proposed in 18/2120r2.
Moved: Solomon TraininSeconded: Assaf Kasher
Yes/No/Abstain: 16/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #541
Move to accept the comment resolution for CID 3585 as proposed in 18/2075r1; and CIDs 3373, 3374, 3690, 3032, 3206, and 3475 as proposed in 18/2147r0.
Moved: Assaf KasherSeconded: Alecsander Eitan
Yes/No/Abstain: 18/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #542
Move to accept the comment resolution for CID 3398 as proposed in 18/1766r1.
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Yan Xin
Yes/No/Abstain: 19/0/0
Compendium of motions Page 96 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
The motion is passed.Motion #543
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 3073, 3397, 3569, and 3570 as proposed in 18/2144r0.
Moved: Alecsander EitanSeconded: Yan Xin
Yes/No/Abstain: 18/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #544
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 3492 and 3692 as proposed in 18/2154r0; and CIDs 3246, 3308, 3344, 3429, 3430, 3431, 3432, 3543, 3544, 3545, 3564, and 3662 as proposed in
18/2155r0.
Moved: Ilya BolotinSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 18/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #545
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 3234 and 3455 as proposed in 18/2150r0.
Moved: Lei HuangSeconded: Yan Xin
Yes/No/Abstain: 18/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #546
Move to include the text proposed in 18/2149r0 related to Figure 62 in clause 9.4.2.252 of Draft 2.1 of the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Lei HuangSeconded: Yan Xin
Yes/No/Abstain: 19/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 97 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #548
Move to include the text proposed in 18/2168r1 related to clause 10.43.6.4.2, clause 10.43.10.5.1, and Annex B of Draft 2.1 of the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Assaf KasherSeconded: Solomon Trainin
Yes/No/Abstain: 19/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #549
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 3009, 3011, 3338, 3412, 3413, 3415, 3416, 3418, 3420, 3422, 3423, 3424, 3425, 3426, 3433, 3458, 3632, 3669, 3712, and 3715 as proposed in 18/2119r2.
Moved: Oren KedemSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 17/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #550
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 3243 and 3357 as proposed in 19/0001r2; CIDs 3573, 3583, 3592, 3638, 3657, and 3689 as proposed in 18/2158r1; and CID 3581 as proposed in 19/0010r1.
Moved: Solomon TraininSeconded: Alecsander Eitan
Yes/No/Abstain: 17/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #551
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 3053, 3365, 3369, 3290, 3187, 3190, 3188, 3597, 3723, 3388, 3184, and 3186 as proposed in 19/0043r1.
Moved: Motozuka HiroyukiSeconded: Sang Kim
Yes/No/Abstain: 21/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 98 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #552
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 3054 and 3523 as proposed in 19/0075r1.
Moved: Kome OteriSeconded: Li-Hsiang Sun
Yes/No/Abstain: 19/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #553
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 3739, 3359, 3510, 3261, and 3262 as proposed in 19/0060r2.
Moved: Cheng ChenSeconded: Oren Kedem
Yes/No/Abstain: 20/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #554
Move to include the text proposed in 19/0059r0 related to the format of Link Measurement Request/Report frame in clauses 6.3.32.2, 9.6.6.4, 9.6.6.5, and 10.44 of Draft 2.2 of the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Cheng ChenSeconded: Solomon Trainin
Yes/No/Abstain: 19/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #555
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 3576 and 3577 as proposed in 19/0109r2.
Moved: Solomon TraininSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 20/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 99 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #556
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 3043, 3044, 3045, 3046, 3047, 3048, 3049, 3050, 3000, 3042, 3075, 3587 and 3591 as proposed in
18/1785r2; and CID 3579 as proposed in 18/2121r1.
Moved: Alecsander EitanSeconded: George Calcev
Yes/No/Abstain: 19/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #557
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 3215 and 3713 as proposed in 19/0032r0.
Moved: Sakamoto TakenoriSeconded: Alecsander Eitan
Yes/No/Abstain: 14/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #558
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 3227, 3444, 3445, 3446, and 3447 as proposed in 19/0088r0.
Moved: George CalcevSeconded: Tony Han
Yes/No/Abstain: 15/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #559
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 3094, 3095, 3098, 3588, 3571, 3572, 3521, 3522, 3574, and 3634 as proposed in 18/2079r3.
Moved: Alecsander EitanSeconded: George Calcev
Yes/No/Abstain: 14/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 100 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #560
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 3171 and 3189 as proposed in 19/0043r3.
Moved: Assaf KasherSeconded: Sang Kim
Yes/No/Abstain: 12/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #561
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 3110, 3112, 3561, and 3736 as proposed in 18/2119r2.
Moved: Oren KedemSeconded: Alecsander Eitan
Yes/No/Abstain: 14/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #562
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 3034, 3035, 3036, 3558, and 3635 as proposed in 19/0157r1.
Moved: Carlos CordeiroSeconded: Cheng Chen
Yes/No/Abstain: 15/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #563
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 3297, 3361, 3480, 3658, and 3688 as proposed in 18/2090r2.
Moved: Solomon TraininSeconded: Alecsander Eitan
Yes/No/Abstain: 14/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #564
Move to include the text proposed in 19/0164r1 related to clause 9.4.2.250.4 and Annex C of Draft 2.2 of the IEEE 802.11ay draft amendment.
Moved: Assaf KasherSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 16/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 101 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #565
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 3138 and 3527 as proposed in 19/0112r0.
Moved: George CalcevSeconded: Alecsander Eitan
Yes/No/Abstain: 16/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #566
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 3630, 3582, 3637, 3645, 3648, 3649, and 3655 as proposed in 18/2075r4.
Moved: Assaf KasherSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 15/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #567
Move to accept the comment resolution for CID 3518 as proposed in 19/0020r1.
Moved: Mohammed AbouelseoudSeconded: Alecsander Eitan
Yes/No/Abstain: 16/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #568
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 3298, 3469, 3299, 3666, and 3211 as proposed in 18/1483r5.
Moved: Carlos CordeiroSeconded: Assaf Kasher
Yes/No/Abstain: 15/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #569
Move to reject CIDs 3595, 3594, 3593, 3575, 3636, 3661, 3644, and 3660 due to the lack of submission.
Moved: Carlos CordeiroSeconded: Assaf Kasher
Yes/No/Abstain: 16/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 102 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #570
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 3298, 3489, 3299, 3656, and 3211 as proposed in 18/1483r5.
Moved: Carlos CordeiroSeconded: Assaf Kasher
Yes/No/Abstain: 14/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #571
Move to incorporate the text change suggested in 18/2095r1 into the Draft 2.2 of the IEEE 802.11ay amendment.
Moved: Assaf KasherSeconded: Solomon Trainin
Yes/No/Abstain: 15/3/5The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 103 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
2019 March
Motion #575
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 4038, 4041, 4261, 4096, 4057, 4089, 4260, and 4312 as proposed in 19/0308r3; CIDs 4039, 4093, 4060, 4094, 4095, and 4279 as proposed in 19/0318r2; CIDs 4061 and 4147 as proposed in 19/0337r0;
Moved: Alecsander EitanSeconded: Solomon Trainin
Yes/No/Abstain: 25/0/1The motion is passed.
Motion #576
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 4212, 4232 and 4286 as proposed in 19/0347r2.
Moved: Mohamed AbouelseoulSeconded: Solomon Trainin
Yes/No/Abstain: 25/0/1The motion is passed.
Motion #577
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 4003, 4004, 4304, 4305, 4351, 4352, 4358, 4361, 4363, 4427, 4362, 4026, 4284, 4357, 4360, and
4365 as proposed in 19/0350r2; CIDs 4359 and 4431 as proposed in 19/0280r1.
Moved: Solomon TraininSeconded: Alecsander Eitan
Yes/No/Abstain: 26/0/1The motion is passed.
Motion #578
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 4157, 4190, 4191, 4194, 4464, 4080, 4081, and 4193 as proposed in 19/0353r3; CID 4467 as proposed in 19/0432r0.
Moved: Hiroyuki MotozukaSeconded: Sang Kim
Yes/No/Abstain: 26/0/1The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 104 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #579
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 4210 and 4211 as proposed in 19/0363r1.
Moved: Takenori SakamotoSeconded: Sang Kim
Yes/No/Abstain: 25/0/1The motion is passed.
Motion #580
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 4461, 4462, 4109, 4141, 4169, 4268, 4460, 4023, 4209, 4208, 4339, 4340, 4342, and 4345 as proposed in 19/0323r1.
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Sang Kim
Yes/No/Abstain: 26/0/1The motion is passed.
Motion #581
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 4078, 4234, and 4477 as proposed in 19/0321r0; CIDs 4259, 4258, 4036, 4037, 4205, 4311, 4314, 4318, 4319, 4320, 4317, 4263, 4044, 4323 and 4119 as
proposed in 19/0355r1.
Moved: Alecsander EitanSeconded: Solomon Trainin
Yes/No/Abstain: 25/0/1The motion is passed.
Motion #582
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 4098, 4128, 4249, 4122, 4123, 4240, 4335, 4242, 4224, 4126, 4127, 4334, and 4336 as proposed in
19/0333r4; CID 4250 as proposed in 19/0362r2.
Moved: Lei HuangSeconded: Sang Kim
Yes/No/Abstain: 240/1The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 105 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #583
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 4079, 4294, 4000, 4375, 4458, 4377, 4366, 4367, 4379, 4381, 4382, 4383, 4296, 4207, 4016, 4376, 4378, 4384, 4380, 4417, and 4227 as proposed in 19/0297r3.
Moved: Carlos CordeiroSeconded: Sang Kim
Yes/No/Abstain: 26/0/1The motion is passed.
Motion #584
Move to accept the comment resolution for CID 4219 as proposed in 19/0471r3.
Moved: Kazuyuki SakodaSeconded: Sang Kim
Yes/No/Abstain: 26/0/1The motion is passed.
Motion #585
Move to incorporate the text change suggested in 19/0504r0 into the Draft 3.0 of the IEEE 802.11ay amendment.
Moved: Kazuyuki SakodaSeconded: Mohamed Abouelseoud
Yes/No/Abstain: 25/0/1The motion is passed.
Motion #586
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 4003, 4004, 4304, 4305, 4351, 4352, 4358, 4361, 4363, 4427, 4362, 4284, 4357, 4360, and 4365 as
proposed in 19/0350r2; CIDs 4359 and 4431 as proposed in 19/0280r1.
Moved: Solomon TraininSeconded: Alecsander Eitan
Yes/No/Abstain: 26/0/1The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 106 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
2019 May
Motion #589
Move to accept the comment resolution for – CIDs 4098, 4128, 4249, 4122, 4123, 4240, 4335, 4242, 4244, 4246, 4127, 4334, and 4336 as proposed in
19/0333r4; and– CID 4250 as proposed in 19/0362r2.
Moved: George CalcevSeconded: Assaf Kasher
Yes/No/Abstain: 18/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #590
Move to accept the comment resolution for – CIDs 4116, 4168, 4175, and 4333 as proposed in 19/0535r2; – CIDs 4326, 4144, and 4195 as proposed in 19/0536r0; and– CIDs 4131, 4132, 4133, 4135, 4136, 4137, 4138, 4139, and 4140 as proposed in 19/0620r1.
Moved: Assaf Kasher Seconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 18/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #591
Move to accept the comment resolution for – CIDs 4083, 4084, 4085, 4086, 4198, 4149, 4152, 4064, 4076, 4077, 4171, 4154, and 4159 as proposed in
19/0546r2; and– CID 4466 as proposed in 19/0667r1.
Moved: Ilya Bolotin Seconded: Sang Kim
Yes/No/Abstain: 18/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 107 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #592
Move to accept the comment resolution for – CIDs 4215, 4230, 4257, 4280, 4291, 4295, 4234, 4346, 4348, 4350, 4372, 4428, 4435, 4436, 4439, 4443,
4444, 4445, 4446, 4447, 4452, 4453, 4454, 4455, and 4463 as proposed in 19/0490r2; – CIDs 4058, 4073, 4106, 4107, 4108, 4420, 4421, 4422, and 4423 as proposed in 19/0578r0;– CIDs 4055, 4059, 4072, 4145, 4264, 4265, 4274, 4300, 4347, 4349, 4353, 4354, 4355, 4356, 4364, 4371,
4385, 4391, 4393, 4394, and 4429 as proposed in 19/0281r2; and– CIDs 4070, 4223, 4419, 4424, 4425, 4426, and 4030 as proposed in 19/0665r0.
Moved: Solomon Trainin Seconded: George Calcev
Yes/No/Abstain: 18/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #593
Move to accept the comment resolution for – CIDs 4062, 4134, 4231, 4315, 4329, and 4344 as proposed in 19/0554r0; and– CID 4310 as proposed in 19/0555r0.
Moved: Li-Hsiang Sun Seconded: George Calcev
Yes/No/Abstain: 18/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #594
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 4142, 4143, and 4469 as proposed in 19/0547r2.
Moved: Claudio da Silva Seconded: Ilya Bolotin
Yes/No/Abstain: 18/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 108 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #595
Move to accept the comment resolution for – CIDs 4221, 4216, 4292, 4285, 4293, 4451, 4411, 4450, and 4449 as proposed in 19/0621r3.– CIDs 4251, 4282, 4456, 4457, 4030, 4031, 4032, 4048, 4050, 4052, 4027, 4028, 4029, 4049, 4051, 4053,
4047, 4413, 4111, 4112, 4118, 4272, 4275, 4298, 4299, 4301, 4302, 4308, 4271, 4117, 4254, 4255, 4273, 4269, 4277, 4270, 4278, 4252, 4253, 4368, 4374, 4297, 4373, 4395, 4401, 4009, 4369, 4370, 4017, 4018, 4019, 4020, 4022, 4008, 4289, and 4290 as proposed in 19/0648r4.
Moved: Cheng Chen Seconded: Solomon Trainin
Yes/No/Abstain: 18/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #596
Move to accept the comment resolution for – CID 4267 as proposed in 19/0532r2; and– CID 4433 as proposed in 19/0587r0.
Moved: Assaf KasherSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 17/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #597
Move to reject CID 4067 with a resolution of “The commenter has indicated to the Chair and Editor that he wishes to withdraw the comment”.
Moved: Assaf Kasher Seconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 17/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #598
Move to approve the proposed resolution for 123 editorial comments assigned to Carlos Cordeiro in 19/0297r6 and incorporate the indicated changes into the Draft 3.0 of the IEEE 802.11ay amendment.
Moved: Carlos CordeiroSeconded: Sang Kim
Yes/No/Abstain: 18/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 109 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #599
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 4124, 4243, 4125, 4248, 4129, 4337, 4130, and 4126 as proposed in 19/0658r0.
Moved: Yan XinSeconded: Assaf Kasher
Yes/No/Abstain: 18/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #600
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 4173 and 4174 as proposed in 19/0655r0.
Moved: George Calcev Seconded: Sang Kim
Yes/No/Abstain: 18/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #601
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 4014, 4024, 4025, 4069, 4063, 4068, 4229, 4303, 4386, 4390, 4418, 4459, 4471, 4472, and 4473 as proposed in 19/0664r1.
Moved: Cheng ChenSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 18/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #602
Move to accept the comment resolution for CID 4324 as proposed in 19/0490r2; and CID 4430 as proposed in 19/0665r0.
Moved: Solomon Trainin Seconded: Carlos Cordeiro
Yes/No/Abstain: 17/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 110 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #603
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 4387, 4388, 4389, 4437, 4438, 4440, 4441, and 4442 as proposed in 19/0647r1.
Moved: Cheng ChenSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 14/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #604
Move to accept the comment resolution for CID 4256 as proposed in 19/0730r0.
Moved: Tony HanSeconded: Yan Xin
Yes/No/Abstain: 15/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #605
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 4474, 4475, and 4476 as proposed in 19/0690r0; and CIDs 4284 and 4365 as proposed in 19/0746r0.
Moved: Solomon Trainin Seconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 15/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #606
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 4071, 4146, 4403, 4404, 4266, and 4400 as proposed in 19/0647r0; CIDs 4309 and 4416 as proposed in 19/0321r1; CID 4166 as proposed in 19/0896r1; and CID 4262 as proposed in 19/0906r1.
Moved: Assaf Kasher Seconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 14/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 111 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #607
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 4148, 4150, and 4151 as proposed in 19/0438r2; and CIDs 4448 and 4470 as proposed in 19/0853r2.
Moved: Chris Hansen Seconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 14/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #608
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 4392, 4406, 4407, 4408, and 4410 as proposed in 19/0668r1; and CID 4415 as proposed in 19/0862r2.
Moved: Payam Torab Seconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 14/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #609
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 4220 and 4225 as proposed in 19/0471r6; and CID 4228 as proposed in 19/0759r2.
Moved: Mohamed Abouelseoud Seconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 15/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #610
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 4233 and 4306 as proposed in 19/0879r1.
Moved: Mohamed Abouelseoud Seconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 14/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 112 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #611
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 4224 and 4405 as proposed in 19/0297r7.
Moved: Claudio da Silva Seconded: Assaf Kasher
Yes/No/Abstain: 14/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #612
Move to reject CIDs 4412 and 4414 with a resolution of “The commenter has indicated to the Chair and Editor that he wishes to withdraw the comment and resubmits similar comments to a later ballot”.
Moved: Payam TorabSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 13/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #613
Move to reject CIDs 4035 and 4434 with a resolution of “The task group could not reach consensus on the changes necessary to address the comment as proposed in 19/0284r1. The outcome of a straw poll was 8 Yes, 9 No, and 5 abstain”.
Moved: Assaf KasherSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 14/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #614
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 4387, 4388, 4389, 4437, 4438, 4440, 4441, and 4442 as proposed in 19/0670r1.
Moved: Cheng ChenSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 15/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 113 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #615
Move to incorporate the text change suggested in 19/0629r0 into the Draft 3.1 of the IEEE 802.11ay amendment.
Moved: Claudio da Silva Seconded: Carlos Cordeiro
Yes/No/Abstain: 14/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #616
Move to incorporate the text change suggested in 19/0695r0 into the Draft 3.1 of the IEEE 802.11ay amendment.
Moved: Thomas Handte Seconded: Carlos Cordeiro
Yes/No/Abstain: 15/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #617
Move to incorporate the change suggested in 19/0681r4 into the Draft 3.1 of the IEEE 802.11ay amendment.
Moved: Carlos CordeiroSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 15/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #619
Move to reject CID 4026 with a resolution of “The commenter has indicated to the Chair and Editor that he wishes to withdraw the comment and resubmits a similar comment to a later ballot”.
Moved: Carlos CordeiroSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 14/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 114 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
2019 July
Motion #623
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 5033, 5034, 5039, 5042, 5043, 5063, and 5061 as proposed in 19/1220r0.
Moved: Solomon TraininSeconded: Claudio da Silva
Yes/No/Abstain: 18/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #624
Move to accept the comment resolution for CID 5060 as proposed in 19/1270r0.
Moved: Li-Hsiang SunSeconded: Sang Kim
Yes/No/Abstain: 17/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #625
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 5044, 5053, 5052, 5062, 5035, 5030, 5056, 5057, and 5025 as proposed in 19/1180r3.
Moved: Carlos CordeiroSeconded: Solomon Trainin
Yes/No/Abstain: 17/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #626
Move to approve the proposed resolution for 42 editorial comments assigned to Carlos Cordeiro and Motozuka Hiroyuki in 19/1180r3 and incorporate the indicated changes into the Draft 4.0 of the IEEE 802.11ay amendment.
Moved: Carlos CordeiroSeconded: Solomon Trainin
Yes/No/Abstain: 17/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 115 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
2019 September
Motion #629
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 5054 and 5055 as proposed in 19/1375r0.
Moved: Hiroyuki MotozukaSeconded: Sang Kim
Yes/No/Abstain: 15/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #630
Move to accept the comment resolution for CID 5027 as proposed in 19/1379r0.
Moved: Hiroyuki MotozukaSeconded: Sang Kim
Yes/No/Abstain: 16/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #631
Move to accept the comment resolution for CID 5059 as proposed in 19/1421r1.
Moved: Assaf KasherSeconded: Alecsander Eitan
Yes/No/Abstain: 16/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #632
Move to accept the revised comment resolution for CID 5005 from Accepted to Revised with the following resolution: Replace Table 9-234 with Table 9-256.
Moved: Carlos CordeiroSeconded: Sang Kim
Yes/No/Abstain: 16/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 116 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Motion #633
Move to accept the revised comment resolution for CID 5005 from Accepted to Revised with the following resolution: Replace Table 9-234 with Table 9-256.
Moved: Carlos CordeiroSeconded: Sang Kim
Yes/No/Abstain: 16/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #634
Move to accept the comment resolution for CID 5058 as proposed in 19/1440r1.
Moved: Alecsander EitanSeconded: Assaf Kasher
Yes/No/Abstain: 11/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #635
Move to accept the comment resolution for CID 5061 as proposed in 19/1467r0.
Moved: Alecsander EitanSeconded: Assaf Kasher
Yes/No/Abstain: 11/0/0The motion is passed.
Motion #636
Move to incorporate the proposed changes in 19/1602r0 into Draft 4.1 of the IEEE 802.11ay amendment.
Moved: Thomas HandteSeconded: Alecsander Eitan
Yes/No/Abstain: 13/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 117 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
2019 November
Motion #639
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 6000, 6001, 6002, 6003, 6004, 6005, and 6006 as proposed in 19/1964r1.
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Alecsander Eitan
Yes/No/Abstain: 19/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 118 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
2020 January 29
Motion #642
Move to accept the comment resolution for CIDs 6120, 6124, 6125, 6126, 6145, 6151, 6152, 6153, 6222, 6223, 6225, and 6226 as proposed in 20/0112r1.
Moved: Claudio da SilvaSeconded: Assaf Kasher
Yes/No/Abstain: 8/0/0The motion is passed.
Compendium of motions Page 119 Edward Au (Huawei)
January 2020 IEEE 802.11-17/0186r1818
Revision History
Author Revision Date DescriptionEdward Au R0 January 20, 2017 Initial version.
Start of revision history tracking.Incorporate Motions #143 – #174 that are considered in January 2017 interim.
Edward Au R1 March 17, 2017 Incorporate Motions #178 – #196 and #199 that are considered in March 2017 plenary.
Edward Au R2 May 11, 2017 Incorporate Motions #203 – #229 that are considered in May 2017 interim.
Edward Au R3 July 15, 2017 Incorporate Motions #232 – #256, #258 – #267, and #269 that are considered in July 2017 plenary.
Edward Au R4 September 14, 2017 Incorporate Motions #272 – #322 that are considered in September 2017 interim.
Edward Au R5 November 9, 2017 Incorporate Motions #325 – #345 and #347 – #366 that are considered in November 2017 plenary.
Edward Au R6 January 21, 2018 Incorporate Motions #370 – #392 and #394 – #395 that are considered in January 2018 interim.
Edward Au R7 March 10, 2018 Incorporate Motions #399 – #424 and #426 – #430 that are considered in March 2018 plenary.
Edward Au R8 May 12, 2018 Incorporate Motions #434 – #446 and #449 – #466 that are considered in May 2018 interim.
Edward Au R9 July 14, 2018 Incorporate Motions #469 – #500 that are considered in July 2018 plenary.
Edward Au R10 September 15, 2018 Incorporate Motions #505 – #513 that are considered in September 2018 interim.
Edward Au R11 November 16, 2018 Incorporate Motions #516 – #536 that are considered in November 2018 plenary.
Edward Au R12 January 18, 2019 Incorporate Motions #539 – #546 and #548 – #571 that are considered in January 2019 interim.
Edward Au R13 March 14, 2019 Incorporate Motions #575 – #586 that are considered in March 2019 plenary.
Edward Au R14 May 16, 2019 Incorporate Motions #589 – #617 and #619 that are considered in May 2019 interim.
Edward Au R15 July 18, 2019 Incorporate Motions #623 – #626 that are considered in July 2019 plenary.
Edward Au R16 September 18, 2019 Incorporate Motions #629 – #636 that are considered in September 2019 interim.
Edward Au R17 November 12, 2019 Incorporate Motion #639 that is considered in November 2019 plenary.
Edward Au R18 January 29, 2020 Incorporate Motion #642 that is considered in the January 29th, 2020, CRC teleconference call.
Compendium of motions Page 120 Edward Au (Huawei)
top related