via scsc electronic service · 2016-07-11 · 17 taken before kimberley richardson, rpr, ccrr 18...

P:\DOCS\Western Nat.Cilker\Letter\Outgoing\Counsel20160606[Bartholomew Fees].docx

1851 EAST FIRST STREET, 10

TH FLOOR, SANTA ANA, CALIFORNIA 92705-4052

p. 714.918.7000 fx. 714.918.6996 www.greenhall.com gh@greenhall.com

Samuel M. Danskin, Partner sdanskin@greenhall.com

NORTHERN CALIFORNIA SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA

June 6, 2016

VIA SCSC ELECTRONIC SERVICE ALL COUNSEL

Re: Cilker Apartments, LLC v. Western National Construction, et al. Our File No.: 2120.188

Dear Counsel:

In follow up to the deposition of Lee Bartholomew which occurred on June 3, 2016, below is a breakdown of the expert fees owed by each party in attendance at the deposition.

Deposition Date Total Fee Fee Breakdown

June 3, 2016 5 hours x $300/hour = $1,500 $1,500/20 parties = $75 per party

A copy of the appearances pages from the court reporter for the day of deposition is enclosed for reference.

Fees are to be paid directly to Bartholomew Associates, Inc. and a copy of the completed W9 form is enclosed for your convenience.

Thank you for your attention to the above.

Sincerely,

Samuel M. Danskin

SMD:se Enclosures cc: Bartholomew Associates, Inc.

P:\DOCS\Western Nat.Cilker\Discovery\Deposition Transcripts\Bartholomew, Lee\Appearances20160603.docx

ROUGH --- DO NOT QUOTE

1 IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

2 IN AND FOR THE COUNTY OF SANTA CLARA

3 ---O0O---

4 CILKER APARTMENTS, LLC,

5 Plaintiff,

6 vs. No. 113CV258281

7 WESTERN NATIONAL CONSTRUCTION,

et al.,

8

9 Defendants.

______________________________/

10 AND ALL RELATED CROSS-ACTIONS.

______________________________/

11

12

13

14

15 DEPOSITION OF LEE BARTHOLOMEW

16

17 Taken before KIMBERLEY RICHARDSON, RPR, CCRR

18 CSR No. 5915

19 June 3, 2016

20

21

22

Aiken Welch Court Reporting

23 One Kaiser Plaza, Suite 250

Oakland, California 94612

24 (510) 451-1580/(877) 451-1580

Fax (510) 451-3797

25 www.aikenwelch.com

P:\DOCS\Western Nat.Cilker\Discovery\Deposition Transcripts\Bartholomew, Lee\Appearances20160603.docx

2

ROUGH --- DO NOT QUOTE

1 I N D E X

2 PAGE

3 EXAMINATION BY MS. GREENFIELD

4 EXAMINATION BY

5

6

7

8

9

10 E X H I B I T S

11 NO. PAGE

12 Exhibit 983 Western National Construction's

Designation of Expert

13 Witnesses for Lee Bartholomew

and Resumé

14

15 Exhibit 984 Invoices

16 Exhibit 985 Professional Resume (December,

2015)

17 (WNC-BAI 012928-012935)

18 Exhibit 986 Bartholomew's summary document

19 Exhibit 987 Excel Spreadsheets

(WNC-BAI 012851-012869)

20

21 Exhibit 988 Rents survey spreadsheets

(WNC-BAI 012601-012647)

22

23 Exhibit 989 Axiometrics, Inc. Competitive

Pricing Survey

24 (WNC-BAI 012403-012430)

P:\DOCS\Western Nat.Cilker\Discovery\Deposition Transcripts\Bartholomew, Lee\Appearances20160603.docx

25

3

ROUGH --- DO NOT QUOTE

1 Exhibit 990 Axiometrics, Inc., Annual Sub

Market Trend Report

2 (WNC-BAI 012448-012451)

3 Exhibit 991 Real Answers document

(WNC-BAI 012488-012498)

4

Exhibit 992 Document headed "Average Rent

5 Rate, San Jose Market and

Subject Property"

6 (WNC-BAI 012470-012487)

7 Exhibit 993 Diagram of One Pearl Place

(WNC-BAI 000189)

8

Exhibit 994 Comparison of apartments in

9 SJ built within 10 years of

subject that have within

10 100 units of subject

(WNC-BAI 012467-012469)

11

12 Exhibit 995 Market sales extracted from

CoStar comps

13 (Bates not readable)

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

P:\DOCS\Western Nat.Cilker\Discovery\Deposition Transcripts\Bartholomew, Lee\Appearances20160603.docx

24

25

4

ROUGH --- DO NOT QUOTE

1 DEPOSITION OF LEE BARTHOLOMEW

2

3 BE IT REMEMBERED, that pursuant to Notice, and on

4 the 3rd day of June 2016, commencing at the hour of

5 10:03, in the offices of Aiken Welch Court Reporters,

6 111 N. Market Street, Suite 300, San Jose, California,

7 before me, KIMBERLEY RICHARDSON, a Certified Shorthand

8 Reporter, personally appeared LEE BARTHOLOMEW, produced

9 as a witness in said action, and being by me first duly

10 sworn, was thereupon examined as a witness in said

11 cause.

12

13 ---o0o---

14 APPEARANCES:

15 For the Plaintiff Cilker Apartments, LLC:

16 JON B. ZIMMERMAN

Robinson & Wood, Inc.

17 227 North First Street

San Jose, California 95113

18 408-298-7120

jbz@robinsonwood.com

19

20 For the Defendant Madera Framing, Inc.:

21 ALEXANDER R. MOORE

Boornazian, Jensen & Garthe

22 555 12th Street

Suite 1800

23 Oakland, California 94607

P:\DOCS\Western Nat.Cilker\Discovery\Deposition Transcripts\Bartholomew, Lee\Appearances20160603.docx

510-834-4350

24 amoore@bjg.com

25

5

ROUGH --- DO NOT QUOTE

1 For the Defendant McLarand, Vasquez & Partners, Inc.:

2 STEPHEN B. LITCHFIELD

Collins, Collins, Muir & Stewart LLP

3 1999 Harrison Street

Suite 1700

4 Oakland, California 94612

510-844-5100

5 slitchfield@ccmslaw.com

6

7 For the Defendant Dimetrius Painting:

8 GEORGE GEOFFREY WOOD

(By Telephone)

9 Ericksen, Arbuthnot

2300 Clayton Road

10 Suite 350.

Concord, California 94520

11 510-832-7770

gwood@ericksenarbuthnot.com

12

13

14 For the Defendant Pyramid Builders, Inc.:

15 BRYAN KERNEY

(By Telephone)

16 Fischer Kerney

888 Munras Avenue

17 Monterey, California 93940

831-372-9200

18 bpk@fk-legal.com

19

For the Defendant Joseph J. Albanese, Inc.:

20

MICHAEL MARX

21 DENISE R. SUTHERLAND

(By Telephone)

22 Goodman Neuman Hamilton, LLP

417 Montgomery Street

P:\DOCS\Western Nat.Cilker\Discovery\Deposition Transcripts\Bartholomew, Lee\Appearances20160603.docx

23 10th Floor

San Francisco, California 94104

24 415-705-0400

dsutherland@gnhllp.com

25

6

ROUGH --- DO NOT QUOTE

1

For the Defendant Western National Construction:

2

SAMUEL M. DANSKIN

3 Green & Hall

1851 East First Street

4 10th Floor

Santa Ana, California 92705

5 714-918-7000

sdanskin@greenhall.com

6

7

8 For the Defendant Pyramid Builders:

9 MARK PHILLIPS

(By Telephone)

10 Kramer, deBoer & Keane, LLP

425 Market Street

11 Suite 2200

San Francisco, California 94105

12 415-933-7855

mphillips@kdeklaw.com

13

14

For the Defendant AMPAM Parks Mechanical, Inc.:

15

ROBYN McCLAIN

16 (By Telephone)

Letofsky McClain

17 3655 Nobel Drive

Suite 400

18 San Diego, California 92122

858-642-1372

19 rmcclain@letofskymcclain.com

20

21

For the Defendant Los Nietos Construction:

22

P:\DOCS\Western Nat.Cilker\Discovery\Deposition Transcripts\Bartholomew, Lee\Appearances20160603.docx

JOSEPH LONG

23 (By Telephone)

Long Blumberg LLP

24 2950 Buskirk Avenue

Suite 315

25 Walnut Creek, California 94597

925-941-0090

7

ROUGH --- DO NOT QUOTE

1 jlong@longblumberg.com

2

3 For the Defendant Western National Construction:

4 SEAN D. ALLEN

Lorber Greenfield Polito

5 13985 Stowe Drive.

Poway, California 92064

6 858-513-1020

sallen@lorberlaw.com

7

8

For the Defendant Casey-Fogli Concrete Contractors,

9 Inc.:

10 THOMAS YEN

Law Offices of Michael Pollard

11 525 Market Street

Suite 2850

12 San Francisco, California 94105

415-227-2343

13 thomas.yen@zurichna.com

14

For the Defendant Anderson Truss:

15

ANDREW D. BORISKIN

16 Porter Scott

350 University Avenue

17 Suite 200

Sacramento, California 95825

18 916-329-1482

aboriskin@porterscott.com

19

20

For the Defendant Cell-Crete Corporation:

21

P:\DOCS\Western Nat.Cilker\Discovery\Deposition Transcripts\Bartholomew, Lee\Appearances20160603.docx

GARY BERTICEVICH

22 Ryan & Lifter

2000 Crow Canyon Place

23 Suite 400

San Ramon, California 94583

24 925-884-2080

gberticevich@rallaw.com

25

8

ROUGH --- DO NOT QUOTE

1

2 For the Defendant California Classic Pavers:

3 THOMAS KIRVIN

Santana, Tcheng, Vierra & Symonds

4 71 Stevenson Street

Suite 700

5 San Francisco, California 94105

415-777-1308

6 tom0689.kirvin@libertymutual.com

7

8 For the Defendant Madera Construction:

9 PHILIP BAZZANO

Sellar, Hazard & Lucia

10 201 North Civic Drive

Suite 145

11 Walnut Creek, California 94596

925-938-1430

12 pbazzano@sellarlaw.com

13

14 For the Defendant Jeld-Wen, Inc., dba Summit Window &

Patio Door:

15

LUKE G. PEARS-DICKSON

16 The Sieving Law Firm

100 Howe Avenue

17 Suite 220N

Sacramento, California 95825

18 916-444-3366

lpearsdickson@sievinglawfirm.com

19

20 For the Defendant Courtney Waterproofing:

P:\DOCS\Western Nat.Cilker\Discovery\Deposition Transcripts\Bartholomew, Lee\Appearances20160603.docx

21 KATHRYN KIM

Springel & Fink, LLP

22 575 Market Street

Suite 2200

23 San Francisco, California 94105

415-541-5363

24 kkim@springelfink.com

25

9

ROUGH --- DO NOT QUOTE

1 For the Defendants LDI Mechanical, Inc.; AMPAM LDI

Mechanical:

2

COURTNEY B. McFATE

3 Van De Poel, Levy, Allen & Arneal, LLP

1600 South Main Plaza

4 Suite 325

Walnut Creek, California 94596

5 925-934-6102

cmcfate@vanlevylaw.com

6

7

For the Defendant Davey Roofing:

8

ALBERT BLAKE

9 Law Offices of Timothy R. Wagner

1655 Grant Street

10 Suite 800-B

Concord, California 94520

11 925-681-3600

albert.blake@aig.com

12

13

For the Defendant Tara Coatings, Inc.:

14

DANICA CHANG

15 Wait & Hufnagel

250 West First Street

16 Suite 222

Claremont, California 91711

17 909-621-5672

dchang@wait-hufnagel.com

18

19

For the Defendant Alliance Building Products:

20

P:\DOCS\Western Nat.Cilker\Discovery\Deposition Transcripts\Bartholomew, Lee\Appearances20160603.docx

REBECCA J. COLLACO

21 Wolfe & Wyman LLP

2175 N. California Boulevard

22 Suite 645

Walnut Creek, California 94596

23 925-280-0004

rjcollaco@wolfewyman.com

24

25