using writing and vocabulary in mathematics classes to accelerate learning for ells

Using Writing and Vocabulary in Mathematics Classes to

Accelerate Learning for ELLs

Mary H. RussellMathematics Consultant, NC Department of Public Instructionmrussell@dpi.state.nc.us

Welcome and Housekeeping

Discussion/Interactive Format

Quick Polling

Co presenter addressing questions in the text chat area

Those participating via teleconference can email questions to: mrussell@dpi.state.nc.us

Switch to teleconference if audio is lost

Quick Poll

Today’s Goal Is To:

•Explore importance of vocabulary and writing in the learning of mathematics

•Provide vocabulary and writing strategies

•Share and discuss students’ work samples

•Allow for collaboration among teachers

Vocabulary and Writing, Why are They Important?

• Mathematics language

•Word knowledge, oral expression

•Clarify thinking

“Student mastery of a word means they can decode,

pronounce, spell, define it, write a meaningful sentence with it, and recognize it in a

different contest.” (Calderon, 2007)

NCSCS: Collect, organize, analyze, and display data (including scatterplots) to solve problems

The scatterplot above shows the number of people at the swimming pool from 1:00 – 5:30. What conclusion can be made about the number of people at the pool during this time span? How can a manager use this information to staff the pool?

1. What would a correct response contain?

1. What vocabulary would prevent your students from being able to answer successfully?

Compare the students’ responses that follow.

1.Which response is the most acceptable? Why?

1.What role does vocabulary play in the clarity of each response?

1.Which words appear to be the issue?

Student 1

Teacher: In reading this question, it says the scatterplot above shows the number of people in the swimming pool from 1:00 -5:30. What conclusion can be made about the number of people at the pool during this time span?

Student 1: Uh. That it decreased as time passed. As it got later a lot of people started to leave.

Teacher: Ok. How can a manager use this information to staff the pool?

Student: I think that they shouldn’t need that many staff, much staff because there is not that many people there. So they could use to use fewer people, fewer staff.

Teacher: Ok. Now looking at this graph, how many people were at the pool at 2:30?

Student: About 14 people.

Teacher: Ok. At what time were there about 9 people at the pool?

Student: Uh, about 30, 35.

Teacher: Ok. What does the data pair (5:30, 5) represent?

Student: Uh. 5:30 is the hour and 5 is the number of people that were there.

Teacher: Do you see anything else, you want to say about the graph?

Student: That it’s a line graph.

Teacher: Thank you, very much.

Student 2

Teacher: In reading this question, it says the scatterplot above shows the number of people in the swimming pool from 1:00 -5:30. What conculsion can be made about the number of people at the pool during this time span?

Student: Uh. More people go at 1 o’clock and at 6:30 more people go. It lowers down at 3:00. It’s going down.

Teacher: Anything else?

Student: No.

Teacher: How can the manager use this information to staff the pool?

Student: He needs like to open early because there’s a lots of people go early. And, uh, he needs to know what time he needs to close to and when people need to leave. And that there is more people coming at 1:00.

Teacher: How many people were at the pool at 2:30?

Student: About 14.

Teacher: At what time was there about nine people at the pool?

Student: At 4.

Teacher: Ok. What does the data pair (5:30, 5) present?

Student: Uh. The number of people at the pool.

Teacher: Ok. Anything else?

Student: No.

Student 3

Teacher: I’m going to ask you a few questions about this graph. , it says the scatterplot above shows the number of people in the swimming pool from 1:00 -5:30. What conclusion can be made about the number of people at the pool during this time span?

Student: Doing, the time span? Ummm. (wait) well it’s like at 1 to 5:30 people come to the pool. Then it was at well it’s at more people at the pool at 1:30. Then when it comes 5:30 people are leaving the pool or something. That’s what I think it might mean.

Teacher: Ok. How can a manager use this information to staff the pool?

Student: So he will know how many people are there. How many people to monitor. And how many people he has to watch over.

Teacher: Ok. How many people were at the pool at 2:30?

Student: Ummm. About 14.

Teacher: At what time was there about 9 people at the pool?

Student: Um. At, I would say about 4, or 4.5

Teacher: What does the data pair (5:30, 5) represent?

Student: How many people were at the pool at 5:30.

Teacher: Alright, thank you.

Quick Poll

Which student response demonstrates a lack of word

mastery? Why?

Words to Understanding

ELLs and At Risk Students

Manager

Conclusion

Staff

Time Span

Math terms

Scatterplot

Data points

Correlations

Axis

Meaning of data

Key Vocabulary Issues for ELLs

•Same Words Different Meaning

•Similar Meanings Different Precision

•Complete understanding

Why is vocabulary so challenging in mathematics?

•Signal Words (transitions and connectors)

•Cognates

•Symbols

•Homophones

•Polysemous

Teach words that are needed to:

•Understand a text

•Use in writing

•Answer a test question

•Enhance academic verbal repertoire

Signal Words

Topic Words

Addition Sum, Increased by, More than

Subtraction Decreased by, Subtract, Take away

Multiplication Product, Doubled, Times as much

Division Per, Quotient, Contained in

Equality Is, Will be, Results

Inequality Greater than, Greater than or equal to, Less than, Less than or equal to

Cognates

English Spanish

equality igualdad

equation ecuación

number número

complement complementar

decimal decimal

factor factor

base base

fraction fracción

irrational irracional

negative negativo

False Cognates

Spanish English

fábrica Fabric but means factory, mill, plant

lector Lecturer but means reader

Popa Pop or pope but means a stern of a ship

Calderon, 2007

HomophonesGeneral Mathematics Other

sum some

pair pear

whole hole

Plane plain

pi pie

profit prophet

gnu/knew/new

hail/hale

rain/reign/rein

rapped/rapt/wrapped

Hugh/hew/hue

seas/sees/seize

their/there/they’re

way/weigh/whey

Polysemous

Words Meanings

table 1. a piece of furniture2. a tool for organizing

information in rows and columns

up 1. from a lower to higher position

2. cut up into pieces

pace 1. a step made in walking2. a rate of speed at which

a person or animal walks or run

golden 1. having the color of gold2. very favorable and

advantageous

Symbols

Symbol Meaning

Right angle

≠ Is not equal to√ Square root

÷ Divide

± Plus or minus

⁄ Divide

< Less than

> Greaterthan

≤ Less than or equal to

≥ Greater than or equal to

Example of Cultural Differences

American German

3,895 3.895

45.69 45,69

twenty-one einundzwanz

Babylon.com

Tier 1 Tier 2 Tier 3

Most DifficultTargeted for instruction

Subject specific words—usually highlighted in text

Basic words Polysemous words across academic content areas

Polysemous and false cognates

Simple idioms ( make up your mind, sit up)

Words with instructional potential andless common idioms, phrases that take on a meaning of their own (stimulus package)

Connectors (so, if, then, however, finally)

Words in which students already have conceptual understanding (so, at, however, within, if

Cognates Cognates Many are cognates

Method of Selecting Vocabulary

Calderón, 2007)

Vocabulary Strategies

1. Graphic Organizers

2. Identify and Classify Vocabulary

3. Games• Vocabulary w/words and pictures• Role play• Guessing game

1. Grouping• Identify, highlight, and define

1. Teach Vocabulary Before, During and After• Use vocabulary indicators• Word wall

Staff

Definition (in own words)

Facts/Characteristics

Examples Nonexamples

Staff

Definition (in own words)

Facts/Characteristics

Examples Nonexamples

Someone who works at the pool

stickcanebatonpole

lifeguard

cashier

pool cleaner

Must do what is asked

Has specific assignment

Is paid for assignment

Vocabulary Indicators1. Teacher says word and student repeats 3 times

2. Provide word in context from the text

3. Provides dictionary or technical definition

4. Provide definition in student friendly terms

5. Prove example(s) of word use, including multiple meanings when necessary

6. Point out helpful structures: prefix, suffix, cognate, tense, compound word, spelling, polysemy, pronunciation

7. Engage 100% of the students in the production of the word

Calderón, 2007

Vocabulary References

Calderón, M. (2007). Teaching reading to english language learners. CA: Corwin Press.

Ellis, M.W. and Malloy, C. E. eds (2008). Mathematics for every student: responding to diversity, grades 6-8. VA: The National Council of Teachers of Mathematics, Inc.

Nash, R. (1997). NTC’s dictionary of spanish cognates: thematically organized. New York: McGraw.

Quick Poll

Why write?

“Exposure to the written word and basic reading skills helps

students develop a larger vocabulary.” (Calderon, 2007)

Advantages for Students

• Helps student raise questions about new ideas

• Allows chance for reflection on what is known

• Allow students to construct mathematics for themselves

• Helps student keep thoughts organized

• Helps address issue of “math anxiety”

Writing Types to Use in Mathematics

• Journals

• Freewriting

• Learning Logs

• Note to Teacher

• Mathographies

• Formal Writing

• Expository

As teachers of mathematics, we sometimes forget that the words and phrases that are familiar to us are foreign to our students. Students need to master this language if they are to read, understand, and discuss mathematical ideas.

- Thompson & Rubenstein

Student 1

1. What does the data pair (5:30, 5) represent?

Student response: That less people swim at later times of the day.

Student 2

Student response: 1 I can conclude that more people swim in earlier times of the day, and that less people swim in later times of the day. 2 She could use this information so that she can know how many staff to hire for certain jobs.

1What conclusion can be made about the number of people at the pool from 1:00-5:30? 2How can a manager use this information to staff the pool?

Quick Poll

Helpful-tips(n.d.).Sourcejeanoram.com

1. Purpose

1. Start Slow

1. Affective, Open-Ended

1. Word Limits

1. Math Concepts

Writing Prompts

1. I’m having problems with…

2. Number 3 was the most difficult problem

because…..

3. When solving word problems I feel…

Sample Mathematics Concept Prompts

1. Explain how to subtract integers.

2. Explain how can proportional reasoning be used to find missing values in a problem.

Expository Writing and Word Problems

• Revelation of Conceptions and misconceptions

• Exploration of many multiple methods and solutions

• Authors of own ideas

• Experience creative side of mathematics

Expository Writing and Word Problems

• Writing activities promote mathematical inquiry

• Encourages focus on thinking

• Students use own language

• Words are tools for thinking

Graphic Organizers for Writing

References

Calderon, M. (2007). Teaching reading to english language learners, grades 6-12: a framework for improving achievement in the content areas. CA: Corwin Press.

Colorincolorado! Retreived on January 13 from http://www.colorincolorado.org/educators/content/vocabulary.

Free graphic organizers. Retreived on January 13 from http://freeology.com/graphicorgs/page6.php.

Helpful-tips(n.d.).Retrieved on January from jeanoram.com.

References cont…

Online translation. Retrieved on January 13 from http://translation.babylon.com/.

Nash, R. Ph.D (1997). NTC”s dictionary of spanish cognates: thematically organized. New York, McGraw.

Prado, M. (1993). NTC’s dictionary of spanish false cognates. Chicago: NTC.

McIver, M. and Urquhart, V. (2005) Teaching writing in the content areas. VA: Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development.