tips conference 20081 urban refugees: definitions, legal position and wellbeing in south africa tips...
Post on 26-Dec-2015
213 Views
Preview:
TRANSCRIPT
TIPS Conference 2008 1
Urban refugees: definitions, legal position and wellbeing in South Africa
•TIPS 2008 •Cape Town
•T Dalton-Greyling
TIPS Conference 2008 2
INTRODUCTION
• In May 2008 foreign nationals from other African countries were attacked in several areas of South Africa due to xenophobia: – 62 people died– several hundred were injured– 25 000 displaced
• Refugees in South Africa - have increased notably from 6 619 in 1997 to almost 30 000 in 2006
• The estimated number of forced migrantsvary between 2 million and 8 million
• The xenophobia and the ever increasing numbers of refugees and migrants from neighbouring African countries pose new challenges to the South African Government
TIPS Conference 2008 3
INTRODUCTION
• New refugee act - Refugee Act 30 of 1998, adopted in 2000• It spells out the protection, rights and obligations of
refugees.• But even after the implementation of the Act there are still
many indications that the refugees in South Africa are not well off,
• for example they are:
victims of xenophobia,
displaced from their homes,
persecuted,
and returned to their homelands.
TIPS Conference 2008 4
PROBLEM STATEMENT
• The number of refugees and migrants in South Africa are increasing notably
• Xenophobia is widespread• There is a new Refugee Act to protect refugees• Against this background it is important to establish the level
of wellbeing of refugees in South Africa compared to the wellbeing of South African citizens.
• The level of wellbeing will indicate if the Refugee Act protects the rights of refugees and if government policy contributes to the wellbeing of refugees
TIPS Conference 2008 5
PREVIOUS RESEARCH
• Studies have been undertaken:• to ascertain the reasons for migration and to
emphasize the risk of impoverishment of displacees,
• to establish the wellbeing of individuals in both developed and developing countries.
• This paper may be one of the first to link the literatures on refugees and wellbeing in developing countries
TIPS Conference 2008 6
OUTLINE OF PAPER
• Definitions
• Refugee protection and support
• Analyses and comparisons of wellbeing
of refugees and South Africans
in Johannesburg
• Conclusion
TIPS Conference 2008 7
DEFINITIONS
•Voluntary displacement•Migrant
•Economic migrant •Illegal migrant
TIPS Conference 2008 8
DEFINITIONS
•Forced •displacement
•Refugees•Asylum• seekers
•Internally •displaced
TIPS Conference 2008 9
What is a refugee?
According to the 1951 Convention and the 1967 Protocol on Refugees
– A person must be persecuted due to • race, • religion, • nationality • being a member of a social group • a specific political opinion• also according to the OAU definition • violence.
– A person must be outside his/her country and fear for his/her life.
– The person can be in any geographical area.– There is no time restriction to when this “event” must have
occurred.
TIPS Conference 2008 10
Refugee status and asylum seekers
• To be classified as a refugee,– need to apply for refugee status.
• Countries that signed the 1951 Convention and its 1967 Protocol have refugee status determination procedures
• If a persons fulfil the requirements – they can be classified as a refugees – and receive protection
TIPS Conference 2008 11
REFUGEE PROTECTION AND SUPPORT INTERNATIONAL AND REGIONAL
1951 United Nations Convention and
Protocol relating to the Status of Refugees
1969 Convention governing the specific aspects of Refugee Problems in Africa
TIPS Conference 2008 12
RIGHTS AND OBLIGATIONS ACCORDING TO 1951 CONVENTION AND OAU CONVENTION
Non-discriminationFreedom of religion
Free access to the courts of law The right to work
The right to housingThe right to education
The right to public relief and assistance Freedom of movement within the territory
The right not to be expelled from a countryThe right to be protected from forcible return or
refoulment
Refugees must respect the laws and the regulations of a host country
A person is not protected if he permitted a crime
TIPS Conference 2008 13
Act 30 of 98 RIGHTS OF REFUGEES
• a written recognition of refugee status• enjoy full legal protection• have the right to apply for an immigration permit in
terms of the Aliens Control Act of 1991 after five years of continuous residence in South Africa
• are entitled to identity documents (ID)• are entitled to travel documents • can seek work• refugees have the same right to basic health and
primary education as the citizens of South Africa
TIPS Conference 2008 14
Constitution of South Africa – Chapter 2
• Dignity• Life• Equality before the law• Freedom of expression, assembly and association• Freedom of movement• Right to adequate housing• Health care• Sufficient food and water• Social security• Basic education
TIPS Conference 2008 15
Wellbeing and Subjective Wellbeing Definition: Wellbeing
Amartya Sen, describes “wellbeing” as being well,
• to have the freedom of choice to choose what one can become and can do (Sen, 1999)
• to be healthy, well nourished, and educated
• Sen’s view of wellbeing influenced the way economists thought and measured wellbeing
TIPS Conference 2008 16
Subjective wellbeing
• Measuring wellbeing - objective indicators and subjective indicators.
• Subjective wellbeing became an important field of study • Clark and Oswald (1996) and Oswald (1997) - showed in
research that to maximise subjective wellbeing was the ultimate objective of most people.
• Subjective wellbeing – more theoretically attractive as:– the standard theory on utility and revealed preference often
failed to explain individual decision making (Timothy and Gruen, 2005).
– cross-sectional and panel data have become available with information on subjective wellbeing, which allows for empirical research.
TIPS Conference 2008 17
Measuring Subjective Wellbeing
• “How satisfied or dissatisfied are you with your life overall?”
• to establish individuals’ self-evaluation of their own well-being at that moment in time.
TIPS Conference 2008 18
Subjective wellbeing
• Since late 1990s the number of empirical studies have increased significantly
• psychological research has indicated that self-reported
measures of wellbeing are adequate and reliable when analysing human wellbeing (Hinks and Gruen 2006)
• Studies focused on the determinants of happiness in developed countries,
• Frey and Stutzer (2002) discussed the factors that seem to play a role in explaining human happiness.
TIPS Conference 2008 19
Subjective wellbeing in developing countries
• Determinants of wellbeing - studied in developing countries.
• Studies on South Africa were undertaken by:
– Knight & Gandhi (2004), – Powdthavee (2005) and – Hinks & Gruen (2005)
• and in other, mainly central European developing countries by:
– Namazie & Sanfey (2001) and Hayo (2003).
TIPS Conference 2008 20
Factors that influence wellbeing in developed countries
• age, • income,
• type of employment, • marital status,
• and health status.
• inflation, • unemployment,
• economic growth and • income distribution
(Clark and Oswald (1994), Oswald (1997), di Tella et al (2001), Blanchflower and Oswald (2003), Ng (1996), Diener and Scollen
(2003) and Gruen and Klasen (2005)
TIPS Conference 2008 21
Factors that influence wellbeing in South Africa
• relationship between • happiness or subjective wellbeing,
• absolute income levels, • relative income levels,
• health, • marital status
• and economic activity
• Hinks and Gruen (2006), Kingdon and Knight (2004), and Powdthavee( (2005)
TIPS Conference 2008 22
Methodology
•Ten criteria for determining wellbeing were selected
•Selection was restricted by the dataset, “Migration and the New African City” - no health data
TIPS Conference 2008 23
Methodology
The criteria were: • housing type, • marital status, • educational level, • employment status, • income per week,• age, • crime, • relative income, • future expectations • and future residence in the country.
TIPS Conference 2008 24
SAMPLE (FORCED MIGRATION STUDY PROGRAMME}
• 600 non-nationals (200 Somali, 200 Congolese and 200 Mozambicans) and a control group of 200 South Africans.
• Mozambicans - Rosettenville. • Somalis - Mayfair and Fordsburg, • Congolese Yeoville, Berea and Bertrams.
TIPS Conference 2008 25
SAMPLE (FORCED MIGRATION STUDY PROGRAMME}
• Considered only refugees and asylum seekers and South African citizens - not other migrants
• 403 refugees and asylum seekers • 199 South African citizens
TIPS Conference 2008 26
Figure 1: Housing type
0 10 20 30 40 50
Free Standing House
Semi-Detached House
Apartment (Single Family)
Apartment (Multi-Family)
Hostel, Dormitory, BoardingHouse
Self-Built or informal housing
Ty
pe
of
ho
us
ing
Percentage (%)
Refugees
South African
TIPS Conference 2008 27
Table 1: Marital status
South Africans
%
Refugees
%
No response/ Do not know 3.5
Single (never married) 50.3 39.4
Living with Partner 11.1 4.2
Married 24.5 39.9
Married but Temporarily Living Apart 4.5 9.6
Divorced or Permanently Separated 2.5 5.7
Widowed 3.5 1.2
Total 100.0 100.0
Source: Forced Migration Study Programme, 2006
TIPS Conference 2008 28
Figure 2: Education level – percentage of individuals that completed different educational levels
South Africans
No formal schooling/some primary education
Finished Primary Education
Finished Secondary Education
Finished Tertiary Education (BA, BS, Diploma, etc.)
Post-grad degree (Masters, doctorate, post-graduatediploma)
Refugees
No response/ Do not know
No formal schooling/some primary education
Finished Primary Education
Finished Secondary Education
Finished Tertiary Education (BA, BS, Diploma, etc.)
Post-grad degree (Masters, doctorate, post-graduate diploma)
Source: Forced Migration Study Programme, 2006
TIPS Conference 2008 29
Figure 3: Employment status– percentage of individuals according to economic activity
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
50
Unem
ploye
d
Wor
king
part-
time
(form
al/inf
orm
al se
ctor)
Wor
king
full-t
ime
(form
al/inf
orm
al se
ctor)
Casua
l em
ploym
ent/t
empo
rary
wor
ker
Self-e
mplo
yed
(run
small
bus
iness
/inco
me
gene
ratio
n pr
oject)
Volunt
ary w
orke
r (re
ceive
no
mon
ey)
House
wife/h
omem
aker
Univer
sity/t
echn
ikon/
corre
spon
denc
e stu
dent
Employment Status
Per
cen
tag
e (%
)
South Africans
Refugees
TIPS Conference 2008 30
Figure 4: Income per week
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35
No response/ Do not know
0/nothing
Less than R199
R200-499
R500-799
R800-1099
R1100-1499
R1500-1999
>R2500
Inco
me
per
wee
k
Percentage (%)
Refugees
South Africans
TIPS Conference 2008 31
Table 2: A victim of crime
South Africans
%
Refugees
%
No response/ Do not know 0.5 0.5
Yes 42.9 68.4
No 56.6 31.4
Total 100.0 100.0
Source: Forced Migration Study Programme, 2006
TIPS Conference 2008 32
Table 3: Age
South Africans
%
Refugees
%
18-25 Yrs 34.8 19.9
26-30 Yrs 18.2 27.9
31-35 Yrs 12.1 27.4
36-40 Yrs 11.1 16.2
41-45 Yrs 8.6 4.2
46- 50 Yrs 4.0 2.5
51-55 Yrs 2.5 0.2
56+ 8.6 1.5
Total 100.0 100
Source: Forced Migration Study Programme, 2006
TIPS Conference 2008 33
Table 4: Income compared to income of others in the community
South Africans Refugees
Do not know 1.5 6.7
Poorer than
Average 27.4 31.6
About Average 56.9 57.5
Better Off Than
Average 14.2 4.2
Total 100.0 100.0
Source: Forced Migration Study Programme, 2006
TIPS Conference 2008 34
Figure 5: Do you expect your children’s lives will be better or worse than your own life?
South Africans
DO NOT KNOW
Their lives will better
Their lives will be the same
Their lives will be worse
Refugees
DO NOT KNOW
Their lives will better
Their lives will be the same
Source: Forced Migration Study Programme, 2006
TIPS Conference 2008 35
Figure 6: Where do you expect to stay two years from now?
0 10 20 30 40 50 60
DO NOT KNOW
Where I am now
In another part of South Africa
In my community of origin
In another part of my homecountry
In a third country
Whe
re to
sta
y 2y
ears
from
now
Percentage (%)
Refugees
South Africans
TIPS Conference 2008 36
Table 5: Summary of the main findings
Criteria South Africans Refugees
Housing type:
Free standing house
30.2% 3.2%
Marital status:
Married
40.1% 53.7 %
Education level:
Tertiary education
14.1 30.7
Employment status
Unemployed:
43.3 36.0
Income per week:
More than R1500
7.1 1.5
Age
31-35 years 12.1 27.4
Victim of crime:
Yes 42.9 68.4
Relative Income:
Poorer than average 27.4 31.6
Future expectations -
children’s lives:
Worse off
0.5
3.2
Future residence:
Move to a third country
2 21.5
Total number of criteria that
reflects better wellbeing for
SOUTH AFRICANS
8
Total number of criteria that
reflects better wellbeing for
REFUGEES
3
Source: Summary of findings – Greyling, 2008
TIPS Conference 2008 37
Table 5: Summary of the main findings
Criteria South Africans Refugees
Housing type:
Free standing house
30.2% 3.2%
Marital status:
Married
40.1% 53.7 %
Education level:
Tertiary education
14.1 30.7
Employment status
Unemployed:
43.3 36.0
Income per week:
More than R1500
7.1 1.5
TIPS Conference 2008 38
Table 5: Summary of the main findings (continued)
Age
31-35 years 12.1 27.4
Victim of crime:
Yes 42.9 68.4
Relative Income:
Poorer than average 27.4 31.6
Future expectations -
children’s lives:
Worse off
0.5
3.2
Future residence:
Move to a third country
2 21.5
Total number of criteria that
reflects better wellbeing for
SOUTH AFRICANS
8
Total number of criteria that
reflects better wellbeing for
REFUGEES
3
Source: Summary of findings – Greyling, 2008
TIPS Conference 2008 39
CONCLUSION
.Majority of the criteria indicated that the percentage of refugees experiencing wellbeing was lower than the percentage of South Africans.
Subjective questions
1. the majority of refugees felt that they were poorer than average
2. 32% of the refugees would rather move to either a third country or their home country than stay in South Africa,
3. more than six times more refugees felt that their children will be worse off in South Africa than themselves.
TIPS Conference 2008 40
REASONS FOR THE LOWER LEVEL OF WELLBEING
• Act 30 of 1998, which establishes the rights of refugees in South Africa - is not fully enforced,
– for example the I.Ds issued to refugees have 12 digits instead of 13.
• xenophobia experienced in South Africa. • xenophobia also leads to lack of job opportunities and a
tendency to underpay refugees. • misconceptions of locals about refugees for example their
low level of education and the “stealing of South Africans jobs”
TIPS Conference 2008 41
RECOMMENDATIONS
• Government should address problems experienced with the implementation of Act 30 of 1998
• Locals should be informed about refugees and the misconceptions they have must be addressed.
• The scarce skills refugees have should be used to contribute in the development of South Africa.
• Active policy measures should be taken to provide protection to refugees and change the attitude of law enforcement officers against foreigners in South Africa.
• All this will also contribute to decreasing xenophobia.
TIPS Conference 2008 42
FUTURE RESEARCH
• To estimate the subjective wellbeing function of refugees (Logit).
• To address the problems of implementation of the rights of refugees.
• Current research performed by FMSP examines the contributing factors to xenophobia
TIPS Conference 2008 43
QUESTIONS
top related