the potential of cement stabilization in soft soil …mi, berat unit kering yang rnaksimum...
Post on 23-Oct-2020
2 Views
Preview:
TRANSCRIPT
-
THE POTENTIAL OF CEMENT STABILIZATION IN SOFT SOIL
NUR DIYANA BINTI NORDIN
AA08009
A thesis submitted in fulfillment of the requirements for the award of
Bachelor of Civil Engineering
Faculty of Civil Engineering & Earth Resources
Universiti Malaysia Pahang
DECEMBER 2010
CORE Metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk
Provided by UMP Institutional Repository
https://core.ac.uk/display/159178689?utm_source=pdf&utm_medium=banner&utm_campaign=pdf-decoration-v1
-
ABSTRACT
Soft soils often cause difficulties in construction, operation with their low strength
and low stiffness nature. However, the engineering properties of these soils can be
enhanced by soil stabilization. This research was carried out to study the potential of
cement (OPC) stabilization in soft soil around the area of Pekan, Pahang. The
objectives of this research are firstly to determine engineering properties of soft soil.
The soil was classified as clay with very high plasticity (CV), having liquid limit,
plastic limit., plastic index and shrinkage limit of 72.0%, 31.36%, 40.64%, and 7.86%
respectively, specific gravity was 2.51 and maximum &y unit weight and optimum moisture content of 14.45kN/m3 and 20.0% respectively. Secondly, to compare the
strength and characteristic of soft soil before and after treating with different range of
cement concentration, ranging from 2% to 12% of weight of soil. Compaction test
was applied to determine the maximum dry unit weight and the optimum moisture
content of the soils. From this testing, the maximum dry unit weight was obtained for
sample with 10% cement added. By compaction test with mixing water content of 401/o the samples for triaxial test (Unconsolidated Undrained Test) were prepared
and then cured in water for 0, 1,7 and 28 days respectively to allow for investigation
of the curing effect. The result showed the shear stress is increasing proportional to
the cement ratio within curing period. The maximum shear stress was observed for
samples with 10% cement added. Oedometer test was carried out to examine the
relationship between void ratio and applied pressure to the soil sample. From this
test, it showed that 4% and 6% of cement content in the soil were effective in
decreasing the settlement of the originally weak soil or another word, increasing the
applied pressure to the soil samples would decreases the void ratio of the soil
samples. For overall, 10% of cement content shows the effective amount cement added in soft soil stabilization and the objective of this research was achieved.
V
-
ABSTEAK
Tanah Iernbut sering menyebabkan kesulitan dalam operasi pembinaan dengan
kekuatan dan sifat kekerasan yang rendah. Namun sifat teknikal dari tanah dapat
dipertingkatkan dengan penstabilan tanah. Penyelidikan mi dilakukan untuk
rnengkaji potensi simen (OPC) menstabilkan tanah lembut sekitar kawasan Pekan,
Pahang.. Tujuan dari penyelidikan mi adalah pertama untuk menentukan sifat
kejuruteraan tanah lembut. Tanah dikiasifikasikan sebagai tanah hat dengan
keplastikan yang sangat tinggi (CV), mempunyai had cecair, had plastik, indek
kepiastikan dan had susut masing-masing adalah 72,00/o, 31,36%, 4064%, dan
7.86%, nilai graviti tentu adalah 2.51 dan berat unit kening yang maksimuin dan kadar air optimum, masing-masing adaiah 14.45kN1rn3 and 20.0%. Kedua adalali
untuk membandingkan kekuatan dan cini-ciri tanah iembut sebelum dan selepas
sampel tanah dicampurkan dengan kandungan simen yang berbeza bennula dan 2%
hingga 12% danipada berat tanah. Ujian pemadatan digunakan untuk menentukan
berat unit kering yang maksimum dan kadar air optimum dari tanah. Daripada ujan
mi, berat unit kering yang rnaksimum diperolehi danipath sampel yang ditaznbah
dengan 100/4 siinen. Danipada ujian pemadatan dengan kadar air pencampuran 40%, sampel untuk tjian tiga paksi (ujian tak terkukuh tak tersahir) disediakan dan
kernudiannya diawet dalam air selarna 0,1,7 dan 28 had untuk mernbolehkan kajian
kesan daripada pengaruh awetan. Keputusan menunjukkan tegangan ricih meningkat
setanding dengan nisbah simen dalam tempoh awetan. Tegangan ricih yang
maksimum diperolehi untük sampel dengan 10% kandungan simen. IJJ ian oedometer
dilakukan untük menguji hulungan antara nisbah lompang dan tekanan yang
dikenakan keatas sampel tanah. Ujian mi menunjukkan bahawa 4% dan 6% adalah
kandungan simen dalam tanah yang efektif dalam pengurangan pemendapan path
tanah yang awalnya lemah atau dalam erti kata lain, meningkatkan tekanan yang
dikenakan keatas sampel tanah akan mengurangkan nisbah lompang sampel tanah.
Untuk keseluruhan, 10% kandungan simen rnenunjukkan kadar yang paling efektif
dalam penstabilan tanah lembut dan objektifpenyehidikan mi tercapai.
vi
-
TABLE OF CONTENTS
CHAFFER
TITLE PAGE
TITLE PAGE i
DECLARATION ii
DEDICATION iii
ACKNOWLEGDMENT iv
ABSTRACT v
A13STRAK vi
TABLE OF CONTENTS vii
LIST OF TABLES xi
LIST OF FIGURES xii
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS xv
LIST OF SYMBOLS xvi
LIST OF APPENDICES xvii
1 INTRODUCTION
1.1 Background of Research 1
1.2 Problem Statement 3
1.3 Research Objectives 6
1.4 Scope of Study 6
1.5 Significant of Study 7
VI'
-
VIII
2
LiTERATURE REVIEW
2.1 Soft soil 9 2. 1.1 Properties 12
2.2 Soil stabilization 15 2.2.1 Mechanical stabilization 16
2.2.1.1 Soil replacement method 17 2.2.1.2 Compaction 17 2.2.1.3 Vibration by Vibmflôtation 18 2.2.1.4 Dewatering by vertical drain 19
2.2.2 Additive stabilization 21 2.2.2.1 Cement 22
2.2.2.2 Lime 23
2.2.2.3 Bitumen 24
2.2.2.4 Selection of stabilizer 25 2.3 Stabilization with Portland cement. 28
2.3.1 Types of Portland cement 30 2.4 Principles of laboratory testing 30
2.4.1 Particle Size Distribution (Mechanical Analysis) 31
2.4.1.1 Sieve Analysis 32
2.4.1.2 Laser Particle Size Analyzer 33 2.4.2 Atterberg Limit 33 2.4.3 Determination of specific gravity 34 2.4.4 Standard Proctor Test 35 2.4.5 Triaxial Test (Unconfined Undrained Test) 35 2.4.6 Oedometer Test 36
3 METHODOLOGY
3.1 Introduction 37
3.2 Soil preparation 40
3.3 Soil classification test 41
-
3.3.1 Particle Size Distribution (Mechanical Analysis)
3:3.1.1 Sieve Analysis
3.11.2 Laser Particle Size Analyzer
3.3.2 Atterbe rg Limits
3.3.2.1 Liquid Limit (LL)
3.12.2 Plastic Limit (PL)
33.2.3 Plasticity Index (P1)
3.3.2.4 Shrinkage Limit (SL)
3.3.3 DcterniLnation of Specific Gravity
3.4 Standard Proctor Test
3.5 Triaxial Test (Unconsolidated Undrained Test)
3.6 Oedometer Test
4
RESULT AND ANALYSIS
4.1 Introduction
4.2 Particle Size Distribution
4.2.1 Dry Sieving
4.2.2 Laser Particle Size Analyzer
4.3 Soil classification test
4.3.1 Atterberg Limits
4.3.2 Determination of Specific Gravity
4.4 Standard Proctor Test
4.5 Triaxiai Test (Unconsolidated Undrained Test)
4.6 Oedometer Test
5 CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS
5.1 Introduction 78 5.2 Conclusion 79
5.3 Recommendation 80
ix
42
42
44
45
46
47
48
49
so
Si
53
56
58
59
59
62
64
64
66
67
69
75
-
REFERENCES
APPENDICES A - G 85
-
LIST OF TABLES
TABLE NO. TITLE PAGE
2.1 Typical properties of soil (Reuben, 2003) 13 2.2 Permeability ranges for various soils (Reuben, 2003) 13 2.3 Guide for selecting a stabilizing additive (Das, 2007) 27 2.4 Cement requirement by Volume for Effective 29
Stabilization of Various Soils a([) 2007)
25 Typical Compressive strengths of Soils and Soil-Cement 29 Mixtures (Das, 2007)
3.1 List of tests and reference 38 3.2 U.S. standard sieve sizes 43 4.1 Compaction Test Result 68
XI
-
LIST OF FIGURES
FIGURE NO. TITLE PAGE
1.1 The location map ofPekan,Pahang 5
2.1 Peninsular Malaysia soil coverage in terms of Great ii
Soil Groups (iegHCM-PM)
2.2 Vibroflotation method (Reuban, 2003) 19
2.3 Preloading with vertical drains (Chu et al., 2004) 20
2.4 Appropriate Additive Stabilization (After Dept. of 22
Army, 1983)
2.5 Gradation triangles for aid in selecting a commercial 26
stabilizing agent .(Das, 2007)
2.6 The classification of laboratory tests (Ling, 2005) 31
2.7 Typical compaction curve (Das, 2007) 32
2.8 Moisture content versus volume relation 34
(Liu & Evett, 2003)
3.1 Flow of activities of research 31
3.2 Percussion drilling sets 40
3.3 Percussion gauge 40
3.4 Soil sample in Percussion gouges 41
3.5 Mechanical shaker for dry sieving 44
3.6 CILAS 1180 Liquid instrument 45
3.7 Cone Penetrorneter apparatus 46
3.8 Plasticity chart 48
3.9 Density bottle method apparatus 50
xli
-
.x111
3.10 Density bottle in vacuum desiccators 51
3.11 Standard Proctor Test apparatus .52
3.12 Adiagrarn of the tiiaxial test equipment 53
3.13 Triaxial test equipment 54
3.1.4 Triaxial test apparatus 54
3.15 The, chamber of the triaxial cell, filled with water 55
3.16 'Odoemeter test machine 57
4.1 Particle Size Distribution Curve for Sample 1 60
4.2 1 article Size Distribution Curve for Sample 2 60
4.3 Particle Size Distribution Curve for Sample 3 61
4.4 Particle Size Distribution Curve (Average) 61
4.5 CILAS 1180 Liquid instrument 62
4.6 Distribution Curve (Laser particle size analyzer) 63
4.7 Graph of cone penetration versus moisture content 64
4.8 Plasticity 'Chart 65
4.9 The sample in density bottle 66
4.10 Compaction Curve 67
4.11 Curing Process 69
4.12 Shear stress with cement content 70
4.13 Stress-strain relationship for specimens with 2% of 71
cement. & curing time
4.14 Stress-strain relationship for specimens with 4% of 71
cement & curing time
4.15 Stress-strain relationship for specimens with 6% of 72
cement & curing time
4.16 Stress-strain relationship for specimens with 8 1/6 of 72
cement. & curing time
4.17 Stress-strain relationship for specimens with 10% of 73
cement & curing time
4.18 Stress-strain relationship for specimens with 12% of 73
cement & curing time
4.19 Mode of failure for triaxial sample 74
4.20 Total stress Mohr's circles and failure envelope (4 0) 75
-
xiv
4.21 Relationship between Void ratio and applied pressure 76
for specimen with different concentration of cement
content
-
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS
OPC - Ordinary Portland Cement
ASTM - American Society for Testing of Materials
BS - British Standard
LL - Liquid Limit
PL - Plastic Limit
SL - Shrinkage Limit
P1 - Plasticity Index
CD - Consolidated-drained
CU - Consolidated-undrained
UU - Unconsolidated-undrained
xv
-
LIST OF SYMBOLS
g - Gram
mm - Millimeter
m - Meter
cm - Centimeter
% - Percent
kPa - Kilo pascal
Gs - Specific gravity
L0 - Initial length
LD - Oven-dried length
V - Volume
M - Mass
W - Weight
P Density
Ywet - Wet unit weight
Yd - Dry unit weight
C - Undrained shear strength (mohr's circle)
Cu - Shear strength
e - Void ratio
- Strain
G3 - Total and effective confining stress
a1 - Total and effective axial stress at failure
4) - Angle of friction
xvi
-
LIST OF APPENDICES
APPENDIX TITLE PAGE
A Particle Size Distribution (Dry sieving) 85
B Particle Size Distribution (Laser particle size analyzer) 88
C Atterberg Limit
97
D Determination of Specific Gravity 99
E Standard Proctor Test 101
F Triaxial Test (Unconsolidated Undrained Test) 122
G One-Dimensional Test 139
-
iNTRODUCTION
1.1 Background of Research
The emergence of development in construction industry has minimized the
preferred site of geotechnical quality for construction although these sites are known
to reduce technical problems and thus the cost associated with their construction. By
that, socio-economic and political considerations have forced the use of sites of
lower quality and in particular, the site covered by compressible soils.
In developed country such as Malaysia, the chances to have good quality
construction sites become rarer and it is necessary to choose sites that include
compressible soils, especially for industrial structures and transportation projects.
Therefore, the tasks to do constructions on these problematic soils have become a
challenge for geotechnical engineers all over the world. The ground or soil condition
is one of the important factors in foundation design. Before starting to design a
foundation, a civil engineer must first obtain the required soil, information from soil
investigation carried out at the proposed site. Therefore, a civil engineer must have
an adequate knowledge on the properties of soil and the soil testing.
Soils with characteristics of low strength and compressible exist all over the
world. One of the most significant problems arises because of its characteristics that
are difficulties in supporting loads on such foundation. The problem arises with low
-
PA
strength is that it leads to difficulties in guaranteeing the stability of the structure on
this type of soil.
Therefore, the stabilization of soil is important to be done in the construction.
The main purposes of soil stabilization are to modify the soil, expedite construction,
and improve the strength and durability of the soil. Besides that, soil stabilization
also can be defined as the modification or improvement of the characteristics of soil
in order to enhance the engineering performance of the soil. For example, improve
the density of soil, mixing the soil with additives to change the chemical and physical
properties such as stiffness, compressibility, permeability, workability, lower the
ground water level, and eliminate weak soil.
The term modification implies a minor change in the properties of a soil,
while stabilization means that the engineering properties of the soil have been
changed enough to allow field construction to take place. There are two primary
methods of soil stabilization used today, mechanical and additives. The method of
soil stabilization is determined by the amount of stabilizing required and the
conditions encountered on the project. An accurate soil description and classification
is essential to the selection of the correct materials and procedures. The most
common improvements achieved through stabilization include better soil gradation,
reduction of plasticity index or swelling potential, and increases in durability and
strength.
Mechanical stabilization is the process of altering soil properties by changing
the gradation through mixing with other soils, densifying the soils using compaction
efforts, or undercutting the existing soils and replacing them with granular material.
The examples of mechanical method are soil replacement, vibroflotation, compaction
and others.
In additive method, stabilization of soils to improve strength and durability
properties often relies on cement, lime, fly ash, and asphalt emulsion. These
materials are inexpensive, relatively easy to apply, and provide benefits to many
different soil types. However, there are varieties of non-traditional soil
-
3
stabilization/modification additives available from the commercial sector such as
polymer emulsions, acids, lignin derivatives, enzymes, tree resin emulsions, and
silicates. These additives may be in liquid or solid form and are often touted to be
applicable for most soils. Previous research studies in this area have demonstrated
that many soil additives have little to no benefit for silt and sandy soil types (Santoni
et. al, 1787).
1.2 Problem Statement
Malaysia is a developing country located in South-East Asia. The demands
for buildings, for commercial or residential use are high especially in Kuala Lumpur,
the capital city of Malaysia. A building is designed to support the load applied to it
safely. The ability of building to sustain the applied loads depends on the soil below
the foundation of the building. The superstructure loads will be transferred to the
underlying soil. Without a proper design and earthwork construction, problem such
as cracking, settlement of building may occur and even to the extent, the whole
building may collapse within its design life. Therefore, a proper earthwork required
to maintain the safeness of a building.
Nowadays, many construction have face the problem of soil where the soil
cannot reach the required specification such as bearing capacity of soft soil too weak
to support superstructure above it. The existing soil at a construction site may not
always be totally suitable for supporting structures such as buildings, bridges,
highways, and dams. Due to that, the understanding and knowledge of engineering
characteristics of soft soil are critical and should be understand by people related in
this field. The selection of construction method on this formation is restricted by
cost, duration of completion, and benefits. in this study, the type of soil will be
focused on soft soil.
-
4
Soft soil is chosen as a sample in this study because of their low strength and
high compressibility. Usually, due to sedimentary process on different environments,
both physical and engineering properties (namely void ratio, water content, grain size
distribution, compressibility, permeability, and strength) show a significant variation.
Further, they exhibit high compressibility (including an important secondary
consolidation), reduced strength, low Permeability and compactness, and
consequently low quality for construction.
The problem of settlement is significant when dealing with structure such as
roads, housing and embankment constructions on soft soil. Due to the characteristic
of soft soil, the structure may settle excessively both due to high compressibility and
low shear strength. The settlement may take a long time depending on the ability of
the soil to dissipate the excess prop induced by the construction. Structures built on
soft soil are subject to settlement and some settlement is often inevitable, depending
on the circumstances, and tolerable. For example, small uniform settlement of a
building throughout the floor area might be tolerable, whereas non-uniform
settlement of the same building might not be
Clay soils can be classified as a soft soil. Some clay soils undergo slow
volume changes that occur independently of loading and are attributable to swelling
or shrinkage. These volume changes can give rise to ground movements that can also
cause damage to structures. Low rise buildings are particularly vulnerable to such
ground movements since they generally do not have sufficient weight or strength to resist.
In certain cases, the soft soil failed to support the foundation of the structure.
In this case, the softer layers are found under the intermediate layers. The presence of intermediate hard layers makes it difficult to penetrate the soil using driven or
jacking piles. It may results in the piles being falsely terminated on top of the intermediate layer. Consequently, the high building loads are transferred to the softer
layers which underlain the intermediate hard layers. This wills leads to building settlement as the loads are not properly transferred to the actual founding level.
-
5
This study was conducted in Pekan, Pahang. The soft soil sample was taken
near to the river mouth of Sungai Pahang. Figure 1.1 shows the location map of
pekan, Pahang.
KELANTAN
-
!4L TERENG'ANU / Q
t'U.. •'O 'a 7 . • PERAK PAHANG
.
i-fth I L.' C'-.i,,rC "- lCHr, I I •
•1%h 4SELANGOP
KA
Loft U-9
sh
,s.
I 3 - C
' • i TqiP j It. J.l. ,7'•_,•• Piu'M • - i " •. ItI1 ct F*&LIIW
A.. .. NEGERI T •7i SEME3tLAN -
*'Vjk^ Koba. ^^-Wb A-W /11
I IfrI..
JOl-IOR -,
Figure 1.1: The location map of Pekan, Pahang
-
1.3 Research Objectives
The objectives of the project are:
1. To determine engineering properties of soft soil.
2. To compare the strength and characteristic of soft soil before and after
treating with different concentration of cement and curing periods.
3. To determine the effectiveness of cement in soft soil.
1.4 Scope of Study
The term of soft soils had been used in this study to describe soils that have a
high moisture content, approaching that of the liquid limit and have a high
sensitivity. Soil samples from various locations in Pekan, Pahang were collected.
Undisturbed and disturbed soil sample was taken and brought to the laboratory for
classified and to be investigated for use in soil cement. The soil samples were chosen
to represent plasticity index is less than about 25 and clay fraction (passing No. 200
sieve) are less than about 40 percent.
Ordinary Portland Cement (OPC) was used in this research. Portland cement
had proven to be a very good method of base stabilization by decrease the liquid
limit and increase the plasticity index and workability of soft soil.
For soils classification, soils included size of particle, specific gravity, and
water content, In soil classification tests, there are three laboratory testing were
carried out that are Particle size distribution test, Atterberg limits test, and Specific
gravity test. Each testing was conducted with three samples of soil to get the average
results.
-
7
The main testing Was carried out to compare the strength and characteristic of
soft soil before and after treating with different concentration of cement. The testing
were Standard Proctor test, Triaxial test (Unconsolidated Undrained test), and
Oedometer test. There were seven different ratios (00/o, 2%, 4%, 6%, 8%, 10%, and
12%) of cement content were mixed -with the soft soil to make soil samples. Cement
ratio is ratio of the weight of cement to the weight of soil sample.
Standard proctor test was applied to determine the maximum dry unit weight
and the optimum moisture content of the soils. Triaxial Test was conducted to
determine shear strength parameters and to allow for investigation of the curing
effect. Triaxial specimens were about in diameter and 76mm long was used
and the testing was tested fteozuriing period of 0, 1,7 and 28 days. Lastly, odometer
test was conducted to determine the consolidation characteristics of soil, for low
permeability.
1.5 Significant of Study
Many studies and researches had been carried out Demonstrating cement
stabilized soil has a significant enhancement in strength and other soil engineering
properties. With this research, tests are carried to investigate whether the sets of
tested cement stabilized has enough strength to withstand the increasing load. it
provides a reference for the behavior of compressive strength on cement stabilized
soft soil under different amount of cement contents.
Soil stabilization with cement has been successfully applied in engineering
Construction. Applications of this method have recently been further expanded. The
more Common uses today are for stream bank protection, grade control (drop)
structures, and pond liners. Soil cement has been proven in all of these uses to be cost effective, aesthetically pleasing, performance and time tested. Other uses for soil
cement are retaining walls, streets, shoulders, airports, parking and storage areas.
-
8
As the soil cement is placed and compacted, the cement hydrates and the mix
becomes a structural slab-like material. After construction and curing, soil cement is
hardly affected by water or the freeze thaw cycle, therefore does not pump under
construction traffic or rut during spring thaws, and can bridge over soft sub grade.
Treatment of soils offers technical, economic, ecological and environmental
advantages. For technical advantage, treatment with cement allows production and
use of homogeneous, long-lasting and stable materials with mechanical
characteristics. In addition, these materials are characterised by great stiffness and
excellent fatigue strength. They show good performance in hot weather, with no
deformation or rutting, and good performance on exposure to freeze-thaw cycles due
to the stiffness of the material.
For economic advantage, field recycling is a significant savings factor as this
reduces to a minimum stripping cuts, landfill, provision of aggregates and thus the
cost of their transport. The absence of transport of aggregates and of cuts to the
landfill contributes to preserving the road network in the vicinity of the building site.
-
CHAPTER 2
LITERATURE REVIEW
2.1 Soft soil
Soil is a natural body consisting of layers (soil horizons) of mineral
constituents of variable thicknesses, which differ from the parent materials in their
morphological, physical, chemical, and mineralogical characteristics
(Birkeland, 1999).
Soft soils can be considered as near-normally consolidated clays, clayey silts
and peat The special features of these materials are their high degree of
compressibility. But in the same time soft soil has a high sensitivity and low strength
compared to another types of soil and the most important problem related to building
on soft soil is settlement which is relatively large and takes long time to complete.
Usually, due to sedimentary process on different environments, both physical
and engineering properties such as void ratio, water content, grain size distribution, compressibility, permeability and strength are show a significant variation. Further,
they exhibit high compressibility (including an important secondary consolidation),
reduced strength, low permeability and compactness, and consequently low quality for construction.
-
10
Due to the rapid increase in population and associated development activities
taking place, especially in the congested coastal areas, construction activities have
become concentrated UI low-lying marshy areas, which are comprised of highly
compressible weak organic and peaty soils of varying thickness (Indraratna et al.,
1992). The entire coastal belt is dotted with very soft clays up to significant depths.
These soft clay deposits have very low bearing capacity and excessive settlement
characteristics, affecting major infrastructure including buildings, roads, and rail
tracks (Johnson, 1970). Figure 2.1 shows the Peninsular Malaysia soil coverage in
terms of Great Soil Groups
Page 1Page 2Page 3Page 4Page 5Page 6Page 7Page 8Page 9Page 10Page 11Page 12Page 13Page 14Page 15Page 16Page 17Page 18Page 19Page 20Page 21Page 22Page 23Page 24
top related