thank you tag memberse3tnw.org/documents/hvac tag 3-10-2015 final presentation... · 2015. 3....

E3TE3T EnergyEfficiencyEmerging Technologies

Thank you TAG members

Bill Livingood, NRELBruce Baccei, SMUDCindy Regnier, LBNLCindy Strecker, CleaResultEric Miller, Benton Rural ElectricGreg Douglass, Sky HeatingHarvey Sachs, ACEEEJackie Goss, Energy Trust of OregonJared Sheeks, MacDonald-MillerJennifer Anziano, NW Power CouncilJerine Ahmed, So. Cal. EdisonJerry Austin, Johnson Air ProductsJohn LeCompte, Seattle City LightJonathan Heller, Ecotope

Karl Johnson, CIEELouis Starr, NEEAMarcia Karr, WSU Energy ProgramMark Madero, Western Cooling

Efficiency CenterMary Horsey, E SourcePete Kramer, TraneReid Hart, PNNLRob Heeb, Oregon Trail ElectricRon Domitrovic, EPRISinh Tran, Snohomish PUDSrinivas Katipamula, PNNLTom Reddoch, EPRI

E3TE3T EnergyEfficiencyEmerging Technologies

Thank you TAG members

E3TE3T EnergyEfficiencyEmerging Technologies

E3T 2015 Commercial-SectorHVAC TAG

BPA E3T Commercial HVAC EmergingTechnologyTechnical Advisory Group

March 10, 2015 Meeting

3

E3TE3T EnergyEfficiencyEmerging Technologies

Thank you TAG members

Bill Livingood, NRELBruce Baccei, SMUDCindy Regnier, LBNLCindy Strecker, CleaResultEric Miller, Benton Rural ElectricGreg Douglass, Sky HeatingHarvey Sachs, ACEEEJackie Goss, Energy Trust of OregonJared Sheeks, MacDonald-MillerJennifer Anziano, NW Power CouncilJerine Ahmed, So. Cal. EdisonJerry Austin, Johnson Air ProductsJohn LeCompte, Seattle City LightJonathan Heller, Ecotope

Karl Johnson, CIEEKramer Peterson, TraneLouis Starr, NEEAMarcia Karr, WSU Energy ProgramMark Madero, Western Cooling

Efficiency CenterMary Horsey, E SourceReid Hart, PNNLRob Heeb, Oregon Trail ElectricRon Domitrovic, EPRISinh Tran, Snohomish PUDSrinivas Katipamula, PNNLTom Reddoch, EPRI

E3TE3T EnergyEfficiencyEmerging Technologies

GoToWebinar Logistics

• Please use your Telephone, notthe Mic & Speakers! Rememberto enter the PIN number!

• Minimize or maximize controlpanel

• Phone lines are muted

• Please use question field to askquestions during Q & A or if youhave any technical issues

E3TE3T EnergyEfficiencyEmerging Technologies

Meeting Agenda

9:10 Welcome Rob Penney9:15 Agenda review, logistics Karen Janowitz and Rob9:20 Meeting goals Karen9:25 TAG process & schedule Karen9:35 Value of TAGs in E3T process Keshmira McVey9:45 BPA EE Commercial Sector overview Erik Boyer9:55 TAG scope Rob Penney10:10 Break

10:20 Technologies discussion Rob Penney11:50 Rating process and instructions Karen11:55 Wrap-up Karen and Rob

E3TE3T EnergyEfficiencyEmerging Technologies

Today’s Meeting Goals

• Understand TAG process, and its significance withinthe E3T framework

• Review schedule

• Discuss technologies & strategies (ETs)

• Add ETs not on list, if appropriate

• Begin the rating process

7

E3TE3T EnergyEfficiencyEmerging Technologies

Overview of TAG Process

8

Initial MeetingBrainstormingand Discussion

about ETs

Initial MeetingBrainstormingand Discussion

about ETs

Meeting toReview Scoring

Results

Meeting toReview Scoring

Results

ShowcaseWebinar

ShowcaseWebinar

ShowcaseWebinar

ShowcaseWebinar

Score theETs

Score theETs

Final TAGReview

Final TAGReview

Rate/Prioritize

Rate/Prioritize

Score theETs

Score theETs

Screen/Recommend

Screen/Recommend

Transferknowledge

Transferknowledge

E3TE3T EnergyEfficiencyEmerging Technologies

2015 HVAC TAG Members Schedule

9

March 10 Initial meeting (that’s today!)

March 16 Rating survey sent to you

March 18 Rating surveys due

April 2 Showcase Webinar Presentations #1

April 3 Presentation #1 scoring surveys due

April 8 Showcase Webinar Presentations #2

April 9 Presentation #2 scoring surveys due

April 14 Final meeting and scoring result discussion

B O N N E V I L L E P O W E R A D M I N I S T R A T I O N

IntroductionCommercial HVAC TAG

Technical Advisory GroupMarch 10, 2015

B O N N E V I L L E P O W E R A D M I N I S T R A T I O N

TAGS - BPA’s Secret Weapon

• Help scan the environment for up and comingtechnologies

• Use expertise to prioritize the most promisingtechnologies, best practices or protocols

• Identify research questions for furtherassessment

• Provide guidance on how to best implementrecommendations into utility programs

11

B O N N E V I L L E P O W E R A D M I N I S T R A T I O N

2009 HVAC2009 Lighting2010 HVAC2011 Energy Management2012 LED Lighting2012 FLASHTAG Smart Residential Thermostats2013 Lighting Controls2013 IT Data Centers2014 Commercial High Performance Buildings2014 Residential High Performance Buildings

12

History of E3T TAGs

* Had Commercial HVAC Technology Recommendations

*

**

**

B O N N E V I L L E P O W E R A D M I N I S T R A T I O N

Technology OutcomesDemand Controlled Ventilation Moved to RTU Controls and Advanced Design

Demand Controlled Ventilation forCommercial Kitchens

BPA Qualified Measure

Variable Refrigerant Flow Heat Pumps ET Field Tests 2013 - 2014

Variable Capacity Compressors VCHP Proven MeasureEPRI Variable Capacity Heat PumpTechnology Transfer Award

Web Based Small CommercialThermostats

BPA Qualified Measures for Small Commercialand Schools

Advanced Design Rooftop HVAC Unit Watching DOE Advanced RTU Challenge

Advanced Rooftop Controls Work lead to ARC Verification StudyUtility Grant Program for ARC – Light FanSavings

13

2009 - 2010 HVAC TAG Recommendations and Follow Up

B O N N E V I L L E P O W E R A D M I N I S T R A T I O N

About this TAG

Focus on Commercial HVAC 2010 last time we looked at HVAC Key objectives:

• What new technologies or improvements arehappening

• Priorities for research/programs• Input to shape innovative program design and

delivery for future implementation

14

B O N N E V I L L E P O W E R A D M I N I S T R A T I O N

Commercially available Potential energy savings Has non-energy benefits Shows promise for cost effectiveness Opportunities for adoption in the NW

E3T’s Definition of ETs

15

B O N N E V I L L E P O W E R A D M I N I S T R A T I O N

How do TAGs fit into the E3T Framework

TechnicalAdvisoryGroups

TechnicalAdvisoryGroups

Scan Screen AssessNew Measure

DocumentationNew Measure

Documentation

CollaborationCollaborationLab & Field

TestsLab & Field

TestsMeasureDesign

MeasureDesign

16

B O N N E V I L L E P O W E R A D M I N I S T R A T I O N

BPA Commercial Sector Overview

Commercial market made up of many players with different: Characteristics – size, type of business, functions Budgets Decision chains Distribution channels Technology options

One size does not fit all when it comes to solutions or measures.

Less than 5 tons Less than 25 tons More than 25 tons

17

B O N N E V I L L E P O W E R A D M I N I S T R A T I O N

Complexity of the Market

Segments with differentneeds

Expensive equipment Retrofit until it can’t be

fixed Complex solutions

Huge number of players Hard to reach Focused on bottom line Limited funds Limited time

Larger buildings - Evenmore complex andexpensive solutions

Multi-decision makers

According to DOE small and medium sized businesses make up95% of floor space and use 50% of energy for commercial buildings.

• Higher costs for solutions• More technology choices• Technologies more complex – more system focused• Multi-party decision making in design and build• Longer sales cycle – planned retrofits

18

B O N N E V I L L E P O W E R A D M I N I S T R A T I O N

Tend to be part of a system or systems Harder to isolate savings EE savings may not be key driver Slower evolution of products and

services development Longer market adoption More expensive replacement or retrofit

costs

HVAC Technologies

19

B O N N E V I L L E P O W E R A D M I N I S T R A T I O N

Trends in Commercial Measures

Deemed Measures

Custom Projects

Custom Programs

Measuring individualwidgets or practicesto identify savings

Systems ApproachWhole buildingPay for performance

Sensors and Controls

Interconnected Devices

Wireless

EnablingTechnologies

Sub-metering

MonitoringSystems

20

B O N N E V I L L E P O W E R A D M I N I S T R A T I O N

BPA Commercial HVAC Programs

Deemed Measures

Custom Projects

Custom Programs

Incentivizing individual widgets or practices for savings

DCV CKV

Tools i.e.ECAM Modeling

CalculatorsStreamlinedProcesses

Insulationmeasures

Harder tofind

SlowUptake

Takesresources

Cannotbe easilyreplicated

21

Challenges

B O N N E V I L L E P O W E R A D M I N I S T R A T I O N

Status Quo Just Won’t Do

StatusQuo

• Business asusual notbringing the EEsavings

• Need newsolutions

• Newtechnologies andnew ways todeliver measureswill be critical tolong termsuccess inCommercialSector

22

B O N N E V I L L E P O W E R A D M I N I S T R A T I O N

Asking this TAG to Think Outside of the Box

TypicalUtility

Programs

InnovativePrograms

Design andDelivery

Deliver aMWs savings to the region and incentive dollars to utilities andend users

23

E3TE3T EnergyEfficiencyEmerging Technologies

TAG Scope

• Commercial-sector HVAC– Existing ETs, limited market share

• Reduce electric-resistance heat• Retrofit• Not in BPA utility programs• Excluded technologies:

– Data center– Residential only

E3TE3T EnergyEfficiencyEmerging Technologies

ETs Brainstorm

E3T Qualifying Criteria1. Commercially available and new – that is, not

in common use – in the Northwest.2. Quantifiable and reliable electric energy

savings in the Northwest?3. Will it work as intended?

E3TE3T EnergyEfficiencyEmerging Technologies

Commercial-Sector HVACEmerging Technologies

Discussion and Brainstorm

E3TE3T EnergyEfficiencyEmerging Technologies

Rating Criteria• Energy Savings – How significant and reliable are the energy savings per

unit?

• Non-Energy Benefits– How great are the non-energy advantages forthe end user for adopting this technology?

• Technology Readiness – How ready are the product(s) and providers toscale up for widespread use in the Pacific Northwest?

• Ease of Adoption – How easy is it for the end user to change to theproposed technology?

• Value – Considering all costs and all benefits, how good of a buy is thistechnology for the owner?

27

E3TE3T EnergyEfficiencyEmerging Technologies

28

Example of Rating Survey

E3TE3T EnergyEfficiencyEmerging Technologies

Rating Example – Data Center TAG

29

E3TE3T EnergyEfficiencyEmerging Technologies

E3TNW.org

30

E3TE3T EnergyEfficiencyEmerging Technologies

Communications

• Listserv: tag-hvac@listserv.energy.wsu.edu

• Technical Lead: Rob Penney,penneyr@energy.wsu.edu, 360-956-2053

• Communications Lead: Karen Janowitz,janowitzk@energy.wsu.edu, 360-956-2096

• http://E3TNW.org

• The HVAC TAG Portalhttp://e3tnw.org/TAGPortal/2015HVACCommercialTAG.aspx

31

E3TE3T EnergyEfficiencyEmerging Technologies

HVAC TAG Roles

WSU E3T Staff• Rob Penney• Karen Janowitz• Karen Messmer• Jennifer Carter• Lisa Terefenko• Nels Christianson

32

BPA E3T SteeringCommittee• Erik Boyer• John Wilson• Janice Peterson• Mira Vowles• Chris Wolgamot• James Anthony

Other BPA E3T Staff• Keshmira McVey• Debra Bristow• Tyler Dillavou• Jack Callahan• Bonnie Watson

E3TE3T EnergyEfficiencyEmerging Technologies

Next Steps

• Rating survey sent to you March 16• Rating survey due back to use March 18

• Discuss ETs with each other -tag-hvac@listserv.energy.wsu.edu

33

E3TE3T EnergyEfficiencyEmerging Technologies

2015 HVAC TAG

THANK YOU!We so appreciate your participation!

34