structural comparison of quality assurance systems in europe and the united states

Christopher Vinger, Berkeley College30th Annual EAIR ForumCopenhagen, Denmark

US model of quality assurance

European model of quality assurance

Comparison of QA structures

Comparison of QA processes

Discussion

Explicit representation of various constituent groups in EHEA, while US has more restricted participation

Tensions between state and national policy interests (US)

Tensions between national and supra-national policy interests (EHEA)

Differing levels of influence of various policy actors

Implications for continued or growing institutional autonomy

QA processes focused on accountability or quality improvement – what is the appropriate mix?

ENQA approach as purposeful response to globalisation pressures?

Diversity of US institution types often leads to disparate strategies, creating winners and losers in globalisation

Comments, critiques, observations, and thoughts?

Contact info:Christopher Vingercjv@berkeleycollege.edu212-986-4343 x1110