social aspects of river restoration: or some experiences from my phd as an interpretive researcher...
Post on 13-Dec-2015
215 Views
Preview:
TRANSCRIPT
Social aspects of river restoration:or some experiences from my PhD as an interpretive
researcher
Emma Westlinge.l.westling@bradford.ac.uk
Background
PhD – social aspects of river restoration
Public values and perceptions of restored rivers in the north of England Consideration of social objectives in river restoration processes seeking to deliver multiple benefits
“a vibrant water environment for wildlife and people […] by aiming to achieve environmental, social and economic benefits concurrently” (EA, 2006)
“recognising the benefits of water to people, both now and in the future, to use and enjoy” (Defra, 2002)
After
Before
The River Restoration Centre (year unknown)
River restoration practice
• Expert-led exercise• Clear boundaries of roles and responsibilities• Social objectives rarely considered• Passive rather than active public engagement
Missed opportunities to understand relationships between environmental improvements and public values
A willingness to be involved
“It is always nice to be asked what you think it would be like or have you got any ideas to put forward. Just to be told what’s happening would be good rather than just see a load of bulldozers arrive and start ripping the flood banks apart and not knowing what’s happening.”
I'm even sure that local people would get involved in caring for the river. I think sometimes it's about giving it (the river) back to the people isn’t it?”
“I should imagine a lot of people would be interested in what’s happening down in the river because a lot of people in the village use the river.”
Unpacking values and aspirations
• Public engagement – key to river restoration success and multifunctional riverine environments
• Complex web of factors underpinning perceptions and values of the river
• New ways needed to capture these values and to use the understanding in river restoration design
Interpretive approaches in river restoration planning and implementation
Interpretive research impacting upon river restoration processes
Allow for an open dialogue where opinions can be expressed
Critical evaluation of the expert-led scientific processes
Unpack discourses underpinning public and ‘expert’ values and aspirations about the riverine environment Allow for roles and
responsibilities to be shifted
Impacts so far
Research community
Research colleagues- Interpretive research in an
engineering and ecology context
Publications- Publishing interpretive
research in environmental journals
Practice
Involved in EA/Arup habitat enhancement scheme- Briefing on community values and opinions
Community interviews- Discuss roles and responsibilities of
river management
Opportunities and barriers:interpretive approaches in river restoration
Ideal river restoration schemeRecognise the value of interpretive perspectives alongside positivist
Allow for an open dialogue where a range of perceptions and aspirations were emphasised
Encourage active public engagement throughout and beyond the restoration process
Allow for shift of roles and responsibilities and being open for different types of knowledge
- Facilitate dialogue
- Evaluate process and encourage learning
Role of interpretive researcher:
... or really the role of policy makers and practitioners
Opportunities and barriers:interpretive approaches in river restoration
Lack of interest and capability amongst practitioners
Maintaining traditional power structures
BUT need to recognise that aspirations of multifunctional landscapes are not likely to be met with current approaches
Barriers to overcome (some examples...)
Thank you!
top related