shifting the focus: lesson plans for learning megan oakleaf, mls, phd library instruction seminar...

Shifting the Focus:Lesson Plans for Learning

Megan Oakleaf, MLS, PhDLibrary Instruction Seminar

SUNY FredoniaJanuary 15, 2008

Agenda

• Overview

• Standards for Proficiencies for Instruction Librarians and Coordinators

• Lesson Plan Components

• ADDIE Approach

• “Understanding by Design” Approach

• Guided Activity

• Crafting the Plan

• Practice Activity & Reporting Out

• Conclusion

Standards for Proficiencies for Instruction Librarians and Coordinators

The effective instruction librarian:• 6.2. Sequences information in a lesson

plan to guide the instruction session, course, workshop, or other instructional material.

• 8.1. Plans presentation content and delivery in advance, and manages preparation time for instruction.

The Lesson Plan

Why use a lesson plan?• Preparing in advance encourages more

deliberate instructional decision-making; inclusion of learning styles; alignment of outcomes, activities, & assessment.

• Having a plan relaxes the presenter.• You may become a rock star. • You may be out sick.

Lesson Plan Components

• Course/lesson title• Materials• Preparation• Outcomes• Standards• Introduction• Hook/anticipatory set• Elicit prior knowledge• Teaching strategies &

procedures

• Modifications for disabilities

• Comprehension checks• Evidence of student

learning• Closing• Wrap up• Lesson evaluation • Estimated times

http://eben.com/press/wp-content/uploads/2007/05/nytimes_smbz_postit.jpg

http://www.getworksheets.com/samples/lessonplans/langarts.gif

ADDIE Approach

• Analyze - analyze learner characteristics/needs, task to be learned, etc.

• Design - develop learning outcomes, select an instructional approach

• Develop - create instructional materials • Implement - deliver instructional materials • Evaluate – check to see if the desired goals are

achieved

“Understanding by Design”Approach

1. What do you want students to learn?

2. How will you know if they’ve learned it?

3. What activities will help them learn?

What do you want students to learn?

1. Start with student needs & standards.

Assignment Requirements

ACRL Standards• Information Literacy Competency Standards for

Higher Education• Objectives for Information Literacy Instruction: A

Model Statement for Academic Librarians

Local Standards

2. Grasp the big picture.

• What enduring understandings (transferable to life and other content areas) should students come to? (Wiggins & McTighe)

• What essential questions do you want students to ask and answer? What questions will prompt them to explore and interact with the “big picture”? (Wiggins & McTighe)

Enduring Understandings

• Information can be described in a structured way.

• Information seeking is a problem-solving process.

• Information sources are not equal.• Ethical information behavior includes

acknowledging others’ intellectual property.

Essential QuestionsGrant Wiggins

http://www.authenticeducation.org/bigideas/article.lasso?artId=53&-session=Auth:45CA24900297027F80wrY1F66777

A question is essential when it:  • causes genuine and relevant inquiry into the big ideas and

core content; • provokes deep thought, lively discussion, sustained inquiry,

and new understanding as well as more questions; • requires students to consider alternatives, weigh evidence,

support their ideas, and justify their answers; • stimulates vital, on-going rethinking of big ideas, assumptions,

and prior lessons; • sparks meaningful connections with prior learning and

personal experiences; • naturally recurs, creating opportunities for transfer to other

situations and subjects.

Essential Questions

• How can you describe an information source?

• What actions can you take to solve an information need?

• What makes one information source “better” than another?

• Why is it important to cite sources?

3. Break the big picture into component parts.

• What specific knowledge and skills do students need to question and understand?

Standards for Proficiencies for Instruction Librarians and Coordinators

Identification & Articulation of Outcomes• 6.1. Collaborates with classroom faculty by

defining expectations and desired learning outcomes in order to determine appropriate information literacy proficiencies and resources to be introduced in library instruction.

• 6.5. Scales presentation content to the amount of time and space available.

How will you know if students have learned?

Performance Assessments

• What does learning look like?– Consider indicators of learning– Consider levels of learning

• What activities will show learning?

• Are there activities that will help students learn and, at the same time, provide assessment data?

Standards for Proficiencies for Instruction Librarians and Coordinators

Assessment• 2.1 Designs effective assessments of student learning and

uses the data collected to guide personal teaching and professional development.

• 6.4. Assists learners to assess their own information needs, differentiate among sources of information and help them to develop skills to effectively identify, locate, and evaluate sources.

• 9.5. Practices or refines instruction content as necessary in order to achieve familiarity and confidence with planned presentation.

• 12.6 Reflects on practice in order to improve teaching skills and acquires new knowledge of teaching methods and learning theories.

What activities will helpstudents learn?

Teaching Strategies

• Use multiple strategies to meet multiple learner needs/styles. Offer choices when possible. Balance group and individual focus.

• Allow students to create meaning, rather than telling them the meaning. Students should be hands-on and active, not passive.

• Use a model-try-feedback-refine cycle.• Provide opportunities for students to explain,

interpret, apply, shift perspective, empathize, and self-assess. (Wiggins & McTighe)

Standards for Proficiencies for Instruction Librarians and Coordinators

Learner-Centered Design• 3.1. Maintains awareness of communication needs of different learning styles, and adjusts

own communication style and methods accordingly.• 6.3. Creates learner-centered course content and incorporates activities directly tied to

learning outcomes.• 6.6. Designs instruction to best meet the common learning characteristics of learners,

including prior knowledge and experience, motivation to learn, cognitive abilities, and circumstances under which they will be learning.

• 9.2. Presents instructional content in diverse ways (written, oral, visual, online, or using presentation software) and selects appropriate delivery methods according to class needs.

• 9.4. Seeks to clarify confusing terminology, avoids excessive jargon, and uses vocabulary appropriate for level of students.

• 12.1 Creates a learner-centered teaching environment by using active, collaborative, and other appropriate learning activities.

• 12.2 Modifies teaching methods and delivery to address different learning styles, language abilities, developmental skills, age groups, and the diverse needs of student learners.

• 12.3 Participates in constructive student-teacher exchanges by encouraging students to ask and answer questions by allowing adequate time, rephrasing questions, and asking probing or engaging questions.

• 12.4 Modifies teaching methods to match the class style and setting.

Learning Styles

http://serc.carleton.edu/images/introgeo/enviroprojects/kolb_cycle.gifhttp://www.animators.com/aal/images/survey_results/Learning_Types.jpghttp://elc.polyu.edu.hk/CiLL/staff/GardnersPieChart7int.gif

Scenario

Communications 101

Persuasive speeches

Students required to use scholarly journals

The instructor has asked you to teach the students the difference between a scholarly journal and a popular magazine.

What do you want students to learn?

Students will be able to…(complete their assignments!)

Knowledgearrangedefineduplicatelabellistmatchmemorizenameorderquoterecognizerecallrepeatreproducerestateretain

Comprehensioncharacterizeclassifycompletedepictdescribediscussestablishexplainexpressidentifyillustratelocaterecognizereportrelatereviewsorttranslate

Applicationadministerapplycalculatechoosecomputeconductdemonstratedramatizeemployimplementinterpretoperateperformpracticeprescriberoleplaysketchsolve

http://www.acu.edu/academics/adamscenter/resources/coursedev/syllabus/verbs.html

Students will be able to…Analysisanalyzeappraisecategorizecomparecontrastcritiquediagramdifferentiatediscriminatedistinguishexamineexperimentexploreinventoryinvestigatequestionresearchtest

Synthesiscombinecomposeconsolidateconstructcreatedesignformulatehypothesizeintegratemergeorganizeplanproposesynthesizesystematizetheorizeunitewrite

Evaluation appraiseargueassesscritiquedefendenvisionestimateevaluateexaminegradeinspectjudgejustifyrankratereviewvalue

http://www.acu.edu/academics/adamscenter/resources/coursedev/syllabus/verbs.html

Consider IL standards.

The information literate student:• ACRL 1.2.d. Identifies the purpose and audience of

potential resources (e.g., popular vs. scholarly, current vs. historical).

• ACRL 3.2.a. Examines and compares information from various sources in order to evaluate reliability, validity, accuracy, authority, timeliness, and point of view or bias.

• ACRL 3.4.g. Distinguishes among various information sources in terms of established evaluation criteria (e.g., content, authority, currency).

Grasp the big picture.

• What understandings about scholarly and popular information can students transfer to life and/or other academic content areas?

• What essential questions about scholarly and popular information will prompt them to explore and interact with “big picture” issues?

Break the big picture into component parts.

• What specific knowledge and skills about scholarly and popular information do students need to know?

How will you know if students have learned?

Performance Assessments

• What does knowledge of the difference between scholarly journals and popular magazines look like?

• Consider indicators of learning• Consider levels of learning

• What activities will both support and demonstrate learning?

Possible Performance Assessments

• List indicators or hallmarks of scholarly journals and popular magazines

• Divide a stack of periodicals into two stacks…one scholarly, one popular

• Compare multiple HTML articles and divide into scholarly and popular categories

• Examine a bibliography and determine which articles are scholarly• Find 3 scholarly articles on their persuasive speech topic in a

familiar database• Find a popular article on their persuasive speech topic and explain

why it’s inappropriate for their assignment• What else?

What activities will helpstudents learn?

Possible Teaching Strategies

Distinguishing Scholarly from Popular• Behavior modeling – librarian models thought process; thinks aloud

through indicators of popular or scholarly work; then students practice behavior with guidance

• Brainstorming – equipped with popular and scholarly article examples, students generate ideas about the differences between the two

• Case Study – students read a scenario in which a student tries to determine which articles are acceptable for an assignment; students analyze the scenario and make recommendations for action

• Critique – students use indicators of scholarly work to analyze an article for strengths and weaknesses

• Discussion – students discuss the importance of using scholarly information and how popular sources should or should not be used

Possible Teaching Strategies

Distinguishing Scholarly from Popular• Drill – students work through a pile of periodicals or articles,

categorizing them into scholarly and popular sources, then discuss their results; could be aided by a checklist

• Game – students in teams play competitively to determine the scholarly or popular nature of information sources

• Interview – students question a panel of librarians or faculty about the importance of scholarly sources and how they might be different in varying academic content areas

• Role play – students enact trying to decide on sources for their speeches, or perhaps justifying a choice to their instructor

• Think-Pair-Share – students work individually, then in pairs, to determine the hallmarks of a scholarly or popular article; pairs report findings to larger group

• What else?

Crafting the Plan

What’s left to figure out?• Materials• Introduction• Comprehension Checks• Closing

Materials

Librarian/Teacher• Handouts• Props• Dry erase markers• Stapler• Databases/websites• Technology back up• Etc.

Student• Pen/pencil• Assignment sheet• Topic• Pre-workshop

assignment

Introduction

• Welcome students• Introduce self• Outline goals and agenda for session• Give directions• Get attention with a “hook” or “anticipatory set”

– Question, quote, picture, personal experience/need

• Elicit prior knowledge and/or pre-assess student knowledge and skills

Comprehension Checks

• Check for learning

• Give feedback

• Emphasize enduring understandings and essential questions (“big picture”)

• Transition to next teaching strategy

Closing

• Collect evidence of student learning

• Identify “next steps”

• Summarize learning; reflect

• Refer to “hook” or “anticipatory set”

• Thank students

• Encourage librarian contact

Putting it all together…

Reporting out…

Why is this lesson plan a good one?

What else makes a great lesson?

• Clear organization

• Two-way communication

• Awareness of student

preferences & needs

• Interest in students

• Enthusiasm

• You!

Questions?