rk - unine 1 raoul kaenzig, university of neuchâtel, switzerland17.07.2013 bolivian andes:...

RK - Unine 1Raoul Kaenzig, University of Neuchâtel, Switzerland 17.07.2013

BOLIVIAN ANDES: NARRATIVES ON GLACIAL RETREAT AND MIGRATION

RK - Unine 2

CASE STUDY IN THE BOLIVIAN ANDES

RK - Unine 3

RESEARCH

2 approaches :

• 1) On narrativesHow the relation between glacial retreat and migration is framed in the medias?

• 2) On mechanismsHow glacial retreat may affect the decision to migrate?

RK - Unine 4

« In Bolivia, Water and Ice tell of climate change » NYT, 2009

“El deshielo empuja la emigración en una comunidad indígena de Bolivia.” CNN Mexico, 2011

RK - Unine 5

Images: Vergara, 2008; RK 2010

RK - Unine 6

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

janv

..09

févr

..09

mar

s.09

avr.

.09

mai

.09

juin

.09

juil.

.09

août

.09

sept

..09

oct..

09

nov.

.09

déc.

.09

janv

..10

févr

..10

mar

s.10

avr.

.10

mai

.10

juin

.10

juil.

.10

août

.10

sept

..10

oct..

10

nov.

.10

déc.

.10

janv

..11

févr

..11

mar

s.11Nom

bre

de ré

sulta

ts (

page

s in

tern

et)

sur

Goo

gle

La communauté de Khapi sur internet

"climate change" (milliers)

"climate refugees" (dizaines)

"Khapi" (unité)

RK - Unine 7

RK - Unine 8

RK - Unine 9

Villagers say: yes!“My four brothers are gone, they live in the city; because we lack terrain and we lack water. This year there is no water coming down the glacier!” (Khapi, man 32 y.o., 2012)

Experts say: no! “They are enjoying an extra-amount of water. Until now, they have not experienced out-migration because of this.” (Environmental NGO director, La Paz, 2012).

MECHANISMS BETWEEN GLACIAL RETREAT AND MIGRATION

RK - Unine 10

MECHANISMS BETWEEN GLACIAL RETREAT AND MIGRATION

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

16

0

50

100

150

200

250

300

350

400

450

J F M A M J J A S O N D

Tem

pera

ture

s (C

°)

Rain

fall

(mm

.)an

d gl

acie

r run

off

(l./s

.)

RainfallRunoffTemp.

RK - Unine 11

CONCLUSION AND FURTHER REMARKS

• Mediatisation of the villages: Victims VS agency…. A way to adapt?

• Visual dimension of retreating glaciers has a strong impacts on decisions: migration as an anticipatory adaptive strategy?

• Importance to consider the temporal dimension; Are they “sitting on a melting bomb?”

• Moving to vulnerable destinations (cities), and then?

RK - Unine 12

Raoul.Kaenzig@unine.ch www.unine.ch/geographie

THANK YOU !