received - university of wisconsin–stout · table 4.12: link documents in ... university of...
Post on 14-Aug-2018
213 Views
Preview:
TRANSCRIPT
Author: Kloth, Jeremy J Title: ImageNow Needs Assessment for the University of Wisconsin-Stout The accompanying research report is submitted to the University of Wisconsin-Stout, Graduate School in partial
completion of the requirements for the
Graduate Degree/ Major: MS Training and Development
Research Adviser: Dr. David A. Johnson, Ph.D.
Submission TermN ear: Fall, 2011
Number of Pages: 37
Style Manual Used: American Psychological Association, 61h edition
RECEIVED DEC 1 2 2011
GRADUATE SCHOOL
~ I understand that this research report must be officially approved by the Graduate School and that an electronic copy of the approved version will be made available through the University Library website ~ I attest that the research report is my original work (that any copyrightable materials have been used with the permission of the original authors), and as such, it is automatically protected by the laws, rules, and regulations of the U.S. Copyright Office.
STUDENT'S NAME: Jeremy Kloth
STUDENT'S SIGNATURE:
ADVISER' S NAME (Committee
ADVISER'S SIGNATURE:
This section forMS Plan A Thesis or EdS Project papers only Committee members (other than your adviser who is listed in the section above)
I. CMTE MEMBER'S NAME:
SIGNATURE: DATE:
2. CMTE MEMBER'S NAME:
SIGNATURE: DATE:
3. CMTE MEMBER'S NAME:
SIGNATURE: DATE:
This section to be completed by the Graduate School This final research report has been approved by the Graduate School.
(Director, Office of Graduate Studies) (Date)
Abstract
University of Wisconsin-Stout is a polytechnic university determined to stay
current with policies, procedures, and technology. Paperless initiatives are expressed as a
way to go green, eliminating excessive waste materials and helping the environment.
The ImageNow software program is one technique to help reach paperless initiatives, but
the lack of full implementation has been noted throughout depmiments located on the
University of Wisconsin-Stout campus. The purpose of this study was to conduct a needs
assessment to help determine competency issues and other problems in implementing
ImageNow software program.
2
3
Table of Contents
................................................................................................................................................... Page
Abstract ............................................................................................................................................ 2
List of Tables ................................................................................................................................... 5
Chapter I: Introduction ................................................................................................................... 6
Statement of the Problem ..................................................................................................... 7
Purpose of the Study ............................................................................................................ 7
Significance of the Study ..................................................................................................... 8
Assumptions of the Study .................................................................................................... 8
Definition ofTerms ............................................................................................................. 9
Methodology ...................................................................................................................... 1 0
Chapter II: Literature Review ........................................................................................................ 11
ImageN ow Electronic Filing Database ............................................................................. 11
Needs Assessment ............................................................................................................. 13
Training .............................................................................................................................. 17
Chapter III: Methodology .............................................................................................................. 20
Needs Assessment ............................................................................................................. 20
Subject Selection and Description ..................................................................................... 20
Instrumentation and Data Collection Procedures .............................................................. 20
Data Analysis ..................................................................................................................... 21
Limitations ......................................................................................................................... 21
Chapter IV: Results ........................................................................................................................ 22
Item Analysis .................................................................................................................... 22
Chapter V: Discussion ................................................................................................................... 30
4
Conclusions ........................................................................................................................ 30
Recommendations .............................................................................................................. 31
References ...................................................................................................................................... 3 2
Appendix A: ImageN ow Software Needs Assessment for the University of Wisconsin-
Stout Survey .................................................................................................................... 35
5
List of Tables
Table 2.1: Model of Needs Assessment. ................................................................... 15
Table 2.2: Four levels of Evaluation ........................................................................ 19
Table 4.1: Years of employment ............................................................................. 22
Table 4.2: Years at current position ......................................................................... 23
Table 4.3: Level of education ................................................................................. 23
Table 4.4: Paper documents sent weekly ................................................................... 24
Table 4.5: Previous training methods ....................................................................... 25
Table 4.6: Use oflmageNow in department ............................................................... 25
Table 4.7: Personal use oflmageNow ...................................................................... 26
Table 4.8: Hours of usage .................................................................................... 26
Table 4.9: Formal training on ImageN ow .................................................................. 27
Table 4.10: Type of formal training ......................................................................... 27
Table 4.11: Print documents into ImageN ow .............................................................. 28
Table 4.12: Link documents in ImageNow ................................................................. 28
Table 4.13: ImageNow documents sent weekly ........................................................... 29
6
Chapter 1: Introduction
The University of Wisconsin-Stout (UW-Stout) is part ofthe University of Wisconsin
system located in Menomonie, WI. The campus had over 9,000 students registered in the fall of
2010 and employs more than 1,300 faculty, staff, and graduate assistants (Facts about UW-Stout,
2010). UW-Stout's mission statement can be found at www.uwstout.edu and is as follows:
[The] University of Wisconsin-Stout is a career-focused, comprehensive polytechnic
university where diverse students, faculty and staff integrate applied learning, scientific
theory, humanistic understanding, creativity and research to solve real-world problems,
grow the economy and serve a global society (Facts about UW -Stout, 2010, para. 1 ).
Only nine other universities in the United States are classified under the polytechnic
description. The vision ofUW-Stout describes the roles of the polytechnic university to identify
what qualities can be found in the classroom and work environments alike.
[The] University of Wisconsin-Stout will build on its position as a distinguished
polytechnic institution and as an international leader in higher education. We prepare
lifelong learners, ethical leaders and responsible citizens through collaborative programs
that integrate applied learning, theory and research with business, education, industry,
arts and government (Facts about UW-Stout, 2010, para. 2).
UW -Stout won the Malcolm Baldrige Award in 2004, making it the first university in the
nation to receive the award. The seven areas of achievement that comprise the Malcolm
Baldrige Award include: leadership, strategic planning, student, stakeholder and market focus,
information and analysis, faculty and staff focus, process management, and organizational
performance results (Baldrige award news release, 2008). ImageNow software was introduced
to focus on the areas of information analysis, process management, and organizational
performance results. Paperless initiatives emphasized at UW-Stout are ways to improve quality,
7
as well as align with the mission and vision of serving a global society and being responsible
citizens.
ImageNow software is an electronic software program introduced to the campus to
convert most of the paper documents to electronic versions and manage those electronic
documents. Departments throughout the campus presently store student records, budget related
items and historic documents in multiple filing cabinets. These records could be filed
electronically in the ImageN ow database. The office of Budget, Planning, and Analysis
currently sends electronic versions oftheir documents, annually saving up to 1,390 pounds of
paper (Administrative activities, 2011), but the implementation of the ImageNow software
program in other UW -Stout departments is still not active.
Statement of the Problem
The lack of consistent implementation of the ImageNow software program could be a
major gap in implementing UW-Stout's paperless initiatives and quality improvement
techniques. Paper documents are still being used as the primary method of communicating
documents to campus staff and departments. Most depmiments are not using the ImageN ow
software and are still storing documents only in paper fmm in filing cabinets, using excessive
paper and copying materials and ineffectively using the work space.
Purpose of the Study
This study will use a needs assessment approach to determine if UW -Stout's
administrative assistants are competent in using the ImageNow software program. It can also
help determine other problems that are occurring within the departments that are not fully
implementing the ImageNow software.
8
Significance of the Study
ImageNow software was introduced to the UW-Stout campus in 2005, but was not
initially implemented. Faculty and staff that have access to the software will be able to convert
paper documents into electronic versions, saving time, money, and space. One of the initial
users of the ImageNow software was the Financial Aid office, which annually eliminated 36,000
paper printouts and 7,500 file folders (Administrative activities, 2011). Student Life Services
and Administrative departments noted over $4,800 of savings due to eliminated copier charges
by using the ImageNow process (Administrative activities, 2011). Thousands of dollars could be
saved annually throughout every department if the full implementation oflmageNow software
were to be executed.
Employees could focus on other work related tasks and duties, with the elimination of the
need to deliver paper documents to and from depmiments within the UW -Stout campus, saving
time and money. The documents could be transmitted with a click of a mouse button and would
be delivered as fast as an email can be sent. File cabinets located in office and storage closets
could also be downsized or even eliminated, improving aesthetics and the work environment for
faculty and staff.
Assumptions of the Study
The two assumptions of this study are:
1. The ImageNow software will be implemented in all UW-Stout departments.
2. UW-Stout employees will display a positive attitude regarding the ImageNow
software and its applications.
Definition of Terms
Document imaging-The process of taking paper documents and converting them to
electronic documents through the use of scanners, printers, microfilms, etc.
9
Document management- "Coordination and control of flow (storage, retrieval,
processing, printing, routing, and distribution) of electronic and paper documents in a secure and
efficient manner, to ensure that they are accessible to authorized personnel as and when
required" (Document management, 2011).
Enterprise Content Management (ECM)- "Strategies, methods and tools used to capture,
manage, store, preserve, and deliver content and documents related to organizational processes
(Aiim, 2011, pg. 1).
Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP)- A systematic approach to merge company's
departments functions and/or tasks to a single electronic system that adheres to each departments
needs (Enterprise resource planning, 2011).
ImageNow- Electronic content management software that is used as an electronic filing
management database for storing, sharing, and sending electronic documents.
Needs assessment- Determines the existence and nature of performance problems. Also
establishes if training in the correct solution (Lee & Nelson, 2006; Allen, 1990).
Training- Providing employees the knowledge and skills needed to successfully complete
a job. Attitude/behaviors may also be attempted to change (Werner & DeSimone, 2009).
Users- Any faculty or staff of the University of Wisconsin-Stout that have proper security
clearances to access the functions and applications ofthe ImageNow database.
Worliflow-The flow or amount ofwork to and from office, department, or employee.
10
Methodology
A needs assessment will be used to determine the performance gaps in implementing the
ImageNow software program across the campus. The study population will consist of the
administrative assistants that deal with paper files on a daily basis. Through an online survey,
data will be collected using Qualtrics. An analysis of the survey results and conclusions will be a
part of this study.
11
Chapter II: Literature Review
The ImageNow software program was created by Perceptive Software and is classified
under "enterprise content management (ECM) software" (About ImageN ow, 2011, p. 1 ).
Perceptive Software has a patented technology called LearnMode that interacts with the
enterprise resource planning (ERP) applications. LearnMode allows the ImageNow software
program to be adaptable with various business ERPs and conforms to the usability of the client
(About ImageN ow, 2011 ). This chapter will cover information about ImageN ow and describe a
needs assessment including the purpose, roles, benefits, and the process of a needs assessment.
This chapter will also depict what training is as well as concerns that might affect the training
results.
ImageNow Electronic Filing Database
The ImageNow electronic filing database has several different processes that ultimately
lead into one thing-taking paper documents and creating an electronic management system. The
program is made up of"document imaging, document management, workflow, e-forms, and
records and information management" (About ImageNow, 2011, p. 6). By scanning or
importing documents into the ImageNow server, electronic versions are created that can be
retrieved and distributed through emailing, printing or faxing (ImageNow, 2010). Users can link
documents that are inside the database according to various keywords or numbers set up similar
to how a search engine searches the internet for websites. After the documents are linked into
the system, users can access those documents in a quick and convenient manner, send the
documents to others, and collaborate with fellow employees throughout the database.
Hackensack University Medical Center (20 11) was facing problems such as having an
overwhelming number of filed documents taking a substantial amount of time to find and
retrieve specific inf01mation. Paper and copying expenses were increasing and employee stress
12
levels were heightening because of the paper barrage, so a new process was sought out, and the
Human Resource team turned to the ImageNow program.
ImageNow delivered an obvious and quick return on investment, immediately liberating
400 square feet of storage space and saving employees hours of searching and filing time.
Hackensack University Medical Center has eliminated its HR file cabinets, off-site
storage fees, delivery fees, printing and paper costs. ImageNow has also been an
important tool for the organization's green initiative by reducing paper waste.
The New Jersey hospital expects productivity, storage, and resource savings beyond
$200,000 in just the first year of using ImageNow and nearly $500,000 over four years
(para. 2-3).
University of Minnesota System applied the ImageNow software to over 30 departments
and plans to keep expanding the number of departments each year. "Staff members are free from
the frustrations of paper, and eliminating the filing, physical transportation of documents and
frequent searches for lost documents has resulted in higher productivity and more time to focus
on primary duties" (University of Minnesota, 2011, para 2). Other university institutions
including the Bangor University, Cornell University, Illinois State University, Indiana Wesleyan
University, and the Kansas State University have given account to similar findings with the use
of the ImageNow software program. California Institute of Technology (2011) has reported a
33% increase in their workflow of processed applications, production rates went up by 40% and
student service increased as well. University of Michigan-Flint have saved over $5 million
dollars with the direct use ofthe ImageNow software program, calculating a ROI of 1,550%
(University of Michigan- Flint, 2011).
13
Needs Assessment
A need is the gap between what is and what should be (Lawson, 2006; Rossett, 1987;
Rothwell, & Kazansas, 2008; Witkin, & Altschuld, 1995). Roger Kaufman is said to be the
"father of the needs assessment" (Lee & Reeves, 2009), who determined gaps through inputs
which are only the means to the end to accomplish the desired outcome. Various needs
assessments have evolved, including specific individual needs assessments to extensive
organizational needs assessments. Some examples consist of the SWOT analysis, force field
analysis, and training needs assessments. Witkin and Alschuld (1995) explain that by stating
priorities and deciding on program/organizational improvement techniques through the
distribution of resources, a needs assessment can be performed. Those priorities, however, are
according to the needs of the employees and the organization.
It is critical for any organization to conduct a needs assessment before a training program
is implemented (Lee & Nelson, 2006; Allen, 1990). This is to determine ifthere is an actual
training solution to solve the performance problems. Needs assessment is the method to
recognize performance problems and to verify iftraining is the correct solution (Allen, 1990; Lee
& Nelson, 2006; Phillips & Holton, 1995). "Gaps" are found when performance problems arise
by comparing current employee performances to the desired performance of employees. The
needs assessment may show one or more of these gaps and tries to identify if it is a training or
non-training problem.
Geisler and Justus (1998) identify four primary functions of a needs assessment. These
include if training is the correct solution, the specific participants in the training (if applicable),
the deliverables of the training procedure, and the applications of the newly acquired KSAs from
the training to the workplace. Lee & Nelson (2006) also state that needs assessments:
• Gather data on perceived needs
14
• Identify knowledge, skills, and behavior discrepancies
• Assist trainers, human resource development (HRD) personnel, administrators, and
instructors in developing relevant curriculum materials
• Gather information that brings beneficial change to an organization or community
• Assess organizational needs
• Promote buy-in by participants (p. 78)
Employee, as well as upper managements' commitment can be seen if a quality needs
assessment is conducted.
Proficiency is being able to complete a task at optimal standards according to the
standard operating procedures (SOPs) of the organization. The needs assessment takes
proficiency and breaks it down into the three learning domains: knowledge, skills and attitudes
(KSAs ). These three domains are measured to determine the needs and the gaps. Rothwell and
Kazansas (2008) specify that a need should always be connected to the KSA's in order to
achieve competency and desired results.
The needs of the organization and the employees can be integrated through the needs
assessment (Lee & Nelson, 2006). Organizational transformations and program commitment can
alter the work environment in a positive way if a thorough needs assessment is conducted. If an
employee understands the needs of the organization and the organization understands the needs
of the employee, productivity can increase and a more positive work environment can be the
result. Also, future recommendations on organizational transformations may be noted once the
support and understanding of needs is sustained by the organization and employees alike.
A systematic procedure can lead to accurate results while conducting a needs assessment.
Figure 2.1 shows how Lee and Nelson (2006) have conducted their needs assessment in a
consistent method that has proven effective in many different scenarios.
MODEL OF NEEDS ASSESSMENT PROCESS
1. Identify the Purpose -----
1 2. Identify Information Needs }
• Current status • Desired level ----~/ • Environrnent
I ' 3. Identify Target Population ----~--!
I 4. Collect Cata }
• Select sarnple ·Select/develop instrurnent ------ Feedback · Gather data
I 5. Analyze Cata ~-~----·-------
) 6. Report Results-----------\
j 7. Apply/Use Results~-~-------
1 a. Evaluate Outcomes~--~~------
15
Figure 2.1. From Lee, H, & Nelson, 0. (2006).Instructional analysis and course development. Homeland, IL: American Technical Publishers, Inc.
Lee and Nelson (2006) further break down the steps into detail. Identifying the purpose
shows where the needs assessment is going and what the planning process is. Informational
needs give more insight on the purpose of the needs assessment, clearly recognizing elements
that need to be addressed and their interconnections. Specifying the correct audience is a very
important piece of the needs assessment, because training the wrong audience is not only a waste
of time, but a waste of money. Collecting the data can be distinguished into three steps:
planning, picking/creating data gathering methods, and finally collecting the data.
Eliminating biases should be an emphasis while analyzing the results in step five of Lee
and Nelson's (2006) model. Computers are more efficient when used to analyze results,
especially when dealing with quantifiable statistics. Reporting those results can either be done in
16
written form or orally, depending on the situation the researcher should choose the appropriate
method. The results of the needs assessment need to be applied in a timely fashion because
otherwise the needs assessment starts losing validity. Evaluating outcomes can be performed
two different ways. The first way is the formative evaluation method which is the procedure of
evaluating the needs assessment through each step of the process. The other evaluating outcome
is the summative evaluation which evaluates the needs assessment at the very end of the process.
Witkin and Altschuld (1995) divide needs assessment into three phases. The first phase
of the needs assessment is called the preassessment (exploration) phase. It starts with a plan
from management describing the purpose of the needs assessment, similar to the first step of Lee
and Nelson (2006). After the major issues are identified, the examination of archival data takes
place within the organization. Determining what data to collect, the sources the data will derive
from, methods used to analyze the data, how the data will be used, and eventually the analysis of
the data leads into the second phase of the needs assessment.
Phase two is the actual data gathering, or assessment phase. This phase determines the
situation, range and limitations of the needs assessment through the data collected. Priorities of
needs, based on the organization's needs, vision, and goals are to be recognized. Afterwards a
causal analysis takes place to analyze the needs, scoping the specific target, and examining the
resources that either affects the needs in a positive or negative manner.
Phase three is the last phase and is known as the postassessment or utilization phase. The
application of needs ranked in priority is set and solutions are recommended. The development
of an action plan is then created to give direction to the solutions recommended from the needs
assessment. After the action plan has been created and implemented, an evaluation examines the
effectiveness of the needs assessment. The final step of phase three is to create reports and make
a presentation to the management about the needs assessment.
17
Training
"Training is a process to change employee's behavior at work through the application of
learning principles. This behavioural change usually has a focus on knowledge or information,
skills or activities, and attitudes or belief and value systems" (Anderson, 1993, p. 1 ). The
learning principles typically are connected to the organization's goals and the new skill acquired
is to be used in particular situation to improve results (Mayo, & DuBois, 1987). Werner and
DeSimone (2009) describe three categories for training which are: on-the-job, in the classroom
and self-paced which includes electronic delivery such as the internet.
Rapid changes in the workplace are seen in today's society and staying cuiTent with
trends and technologies is crucial for staying competitive. Staying current and staying
competitive means that a need for training will always exist. Training also needs to be cuiTent
due to changing demographics and technologies in order to be successful. Besides one-on-one
training techniques, new technologies allow training to happen in and out of the workroom.
Computer-based learning, simulations, and artificial intelligences (Prior, 1994) are just some
examples of the types of training that can occur in the workplace or even in the employees'
house, making training flexible and more open to various situations and scenarios.
Training can increase profits and raise productivity of the organization. This can be
considered an "investment in the people", which can be a direct link to strategic planning if
performed coiTectly. Companies will have a more open attitude about training and its potential
when facing significant changes such as "mergers, expansion, contraction, response to
competition, relocation, restructuring - to say nothing about changes to management style or
organizational culture" (Prior, 1994, p. 21 ). Anderson (1993) also gives various reasons why
training is used:
18
• Changing organization structures
• Dealings with problems of growth
• De-centralization
• Changing technology
• Contingency planning
• Inter-unit knowledge requirements
• Integration of policy and philosophy
• Team building (p. 14)
Issues concerning training include the question if the training actually increased the
organization's productivity, the design of the training, the changing workplace, and evaluating
the effectiveness of the training (Goldstein, 1989). Often training is conducted for the sake of
training and does not serve an actual purpose to the organization's production or profitability,
thereby emphasizing the requirement for needs assessment. The design of the training needs to
consider the characteristics of the audience, otherwise it will be ineffective, which will waste the
organization's time and resources. The changing workplace proves that current trends need to be
analyzed before the design of the training is done which also ties into the design of the training
and the importance of adhering to the audience of the training program.
Training evaluation needs to be on ongoing process even after the training is completed.
To properly evaluate a training program takes several months. Kirkpatrick (20 11) developed a
four level evaluation model which is shown in figure 2.2. The first level is reaction, which
considers the level of favorable reaction of the participants to the training. The second level of
evaluation is learning. This level measures the improvement within the KSA's achieved through
participating in the training program. Behavior is the third level and it describes the applicability
of what was learned during training back in the work place. The fourth level is results. This
19
level of evaluation calculates the differences between the factors before and after training in
reaching the organizational desired outcomes (Kirkpatrick, 2011 ).
Level 1 u.we< 2 Level 3 Le.,.el 4 Reaction Le-arfnr'lg BtJ-h<l>IIIOf Results
Figure 2.2. Kirkpatrick, D. (2011). The Kirkpatrick philosophy. Retrieved from http://www.kirkpatrickpartners.com/OurPhilosophy/tabid/66/Default.aspx
"The end is the beginning (Kirkpatrick, 2011, pg. 2)", is one of Kirkpatrick's founding
principles. The training program must be directed towards the desired workplace behaviors, as
well as, incorporate participants' characteristics and demographic factors in order to achieve a
positive and encouraging reaction from the participants.
20
Chapter III: Methodology
ImageNow is not being fully implemented in most departments on the UW-Stout campus.
Because of the lack of full implementation, miscommunication between the paperless initiatives
UW-Stout is trying to achieve and the processes of handling documents is being created.
Although there are some depmiments, like the office of Budget, Planning, and Analysis, who are
implementing the ImageN ow program, most departments are not incorporating the paperless
initiatives. This is seen through the procedures of handling documents and the stacks of file
cabinets located in many offices and storage closets across the campus. This chapter will
include the needs assessment method, subjects selected, the online survey instrument, data
collection procedures, analysis of the data and limitations of the study.
Needs Assessment
The needs assessment model created by Lee and Nelson (2006) will be used as the
framework of conducting the needs assessment. The needs assessment is critical to identify the
performance problems for the ImageNow program and if training is a viable solution to that
problem.
Subject Selection and Description
A list of administrative assistants was obtained from UW-Stout's Human Resources to
send the online survey throughout the various departments. Email addresses of those personnel
provided the contact information for the initial distribution of the data collection survey.
Instrumentation and Data Collection Procedures
The online survey was created not only for the needs assessment instrument, but also to
keep the alignment of the paperless initiatives intact. The Qualtrics program will be used to
create, disseminate, and analyze the data. Once the survey is completed, the data will be sent to
the researcher. The participants will be asked to complete the on-line survey within one week of
21
distribution. A follow-up email will be sent to all participants to ask to complete the survey if
they have not done so.
Data analysis.
Qualtrics is a software program that not only creates and distributes online surveys, but
analyzes the quantifiable data as well. Frequencies, comparative statistics, and percentages of
answered questions will be the main forms of analysis in the survey.
Limitations
This study will have two limitations:
1. Small survey sample size.
2. The online survey may not collect the employees' complete attitudes and opinions
of the ImageN ow software program.
22
Chapter IV: Results
Chapter IV discusses the results of the needs assessment. Through the use of Qualtrics
software, a 14 question survey was distributed to administrative assistants at UW -Stout to
determine ifthere was a lack ofKSAs in the applications ofthe ImageNow software. The
response rate totaled 53%, with 9 of 17 administrative assistants completing the online survey.
Individual survey questions will be analyzed and discussed.
Item analysis
The purpose of this study was to collect and analyze data regarding administrative
assistants use of the ImageNow software program throughout various departments on the UW
Stout campus. The survey questions were grouped into four categories including: demographics,
applications, training, and abilities. The first three questions gathered information about the
background ofthe administrative assistants.
The first question asked how many years the employee had worked at UW -Stout.
Employees' employment dates ranged considerably throughout departments, but the distribution
was grouped in only two categories: 3-4 years and 7 years or more. Most participants (78%) had
been at UW-Stout for more than seven years.
Table 4.1 - Years of employment at UW -Stout #of Responses Percentage
Less than 1 year 0 -
1-2 years 0 -
3-4 years 2 22%
5-6 years 0 -
7 years or more 7 78%
23
Question two asked how long the administrative assistant had been in their cunent
position. Due to transfers and hiring throughout the UW -Stout campus, this question might have
provided insight that some or all participants were still new at their positions and may have not
had the chance to experience the ImageNow software program. Results show that this was not
the case, with the majority of participants working their cunent position for three years or more.
Table 4.2 - Years at cunent position # of Responses Percentage
Less than 1 year 0 -
1-2 years 1 11%
3-4 years 2 22%
5-6 years 2 22%
7 years or more 4 44%
Question three gathered the educational level of the participants, which has future
application for training administrative assistants. The training should be based on the
educational level of the participants to maintain effectiveness. The distribution was fairly even
between high school diploma and Bachelor's degree.
Table 4.3 - Level of education # of Responses Percentage
High school diploma 4 44%
Some college courses 2 22%
Bachelor's degree 3 33%
Some Master's degree courses taken 0 -
Master's degree or higher 0 -
24
Question four considered the application of communication throughout the UW -Stout
campus. Seeing how many times in an average week paper documents were being sent
throughout the university revealed how often ImageNow could replace the current method of
communication by the use of electronic mailing. Fully implementing the ImageN ow software
program can lead to a reduction in the amount of paper used.
Table 4.4- Paper documents sent weekly # of Responses Percentage
1-10 times 3 33%
11-20 times 2 22%
21-30 times 3 33%
41 times or more 1 11%
Not applicable 0 -
Question five inquired about past training methods that have been effective at UW -Stout.
Given various training methods while providing opportunity to include any other type of
training, this question revealed that group training was considered the preferred training method.
More than one selection, if applicable, was permitted to be chosen. Although there was not a
wide spread distribution, every participant chose group training as the perceived most effective
training method.
25
Table 4.5- Previous training methods # of Responses Percentage
One-to-one training 7 28%
Computer-based training 5 20%
Reading a manual 3 12%
Group training 9 36%
Other (please specify) 1 4%
-Attending classes
The following two questions (six and seven) examined the application of the ImageNow
software. Question six asked if any employees in the administrative assistant's department
applied the ImageNow software program in the workplace. The distribution was almost split, but
56% of the participants stated that employees in their departments applied the ImageNow
software program in the workplace.
Table 4.6- Use oflmageNow in department # of Responses Percentage
No 4 44%
Yes 5 56%
Question seven asked the survey participants if they had used the ImageNow software
program. Administrative assistants have the responsibility for completing filing duties in each of
the UW -Stout depmiments. These employees handle and distribute files on a daily average of 20
times per week, as found in question four. Time and money could be saved if full
implementation of the ImageNow software reduced or eliminated the need to save, store, and
send paper documents in each department. Two-thirds of the participants had never used the
ImageN ow software. If respondents answered no to this question, the survey was complete due
26
to the fact that the rest ofthe survey dealt with experiences of the ImageNow software. Sixty
seven percent of the respondents answered no to this question.
Table 4.7- Use oflmageNow personally # of Responses Percentage
No 6 67%
Yes 3 33%
Question eight asked how often participants used the ImageN ow software. How often the
software was applied should be surveyed before and after full implementation to help gauge the
benefits and effectiveness of the ImageNow software. The results showed that the software was
being used three hours or less on a daily basis among all participants.
Table 4.8- Hours of usage # of Responses Percentage
0-1 hours 2 67%
2-3 hours 1 33%
4-5 hours 0 -
6-7 hours 0 -
8 or more hours 0 -
Training on ImageN ow was examined in the following two questions. To determine if
formal training was conducted and what methods were used may help in the consideration of
new training methods/techniques. If the patiicipant answered no to this question, the next
question was skipped because it did not apply. Two of the three participants had received
fmmal training in the ImageNow software.
27
Table 4.9- Formal training on ImageNow # of Responses Percentage
No 1 33%
Yes 2 66%
Question ten asked about the type of formal training participants had received. The
purpose of this question was to document the type of training already incorporated with the
ImageNow software program, as well as consider how it corresponded with what participants
viewed as effective training methods found in question five. One participant had received one-
to-one training and the other received group training.
Table 4.10- Type of formal training for # of Responses Percentage ImageN ow
One-to-one training 1 50%
Reading a manual 0 -
Computer-based training 0 -
I have not received any type of formal training 0 -
Other (please specify) 1 50%
-Group training
Questions 11 and 12 studied the abilities of participants to use the ImageNow software
program. The two primary steps for managing documents in the ImageNow database are
printing documents into ImageNow and conectly linking those documents in the database. The
ability to perform each step was documented by assessing the participants overall KSA's of the
ImageNow software.
28
Table 4.11 -Print documents into ImageNow # of Responses Percentage
Poor 1 33%
Adequate 1 33%
Proficient 1 33%
Not applicable 0 -
Question 12 considered the participants ability to link documents into the ImageNow
database. Not doing this step correctly and systematically would result in an unorganized file
cabinet and an unusable electronic database. Only one participant was proficient at this task.
Table 4.12- Link documents into ImageNow # of Responses Percentage
Poor 1 33%
Adequate 0 -
Proficient 1 33%
Not applicable 1 33%
Question 13 examined how often ImageNow was currently being implemented in
communicating documents throughout the campus. All participants responded that they used the
software on average 1-10 times per week to send documents.
29
Table 4.13- ImageNow documents sent # of Responses Percentage weekly
1-10 times 3 100%
11-20 times 0 -
21-30 times 0 -
41 times or more 0 -
Not applicable 0 -
The final question provided an opportunity for participants to make any additional
comments about the ImageNow software, paper distribution, survey, or any other thoughts.
There were no additional comment responses provided.
30
Chapter V: Discussion
The purpose of this study was to conduct a needs assessment to determine if the UW
Stout administrative assistants were competent at using the ImageNow software program.
ImageN ow could save thousands of dollars as well as valuable time in the process of filing and
maintaining faculty, staff, and student records if it were fully utilized.
Administrative assistants were the target population of this study because the majority of
the filing process were completed through them. Part of their duties and tasks were collecting,
organizing, filing, and maintaining records in their departments. Through UW-Stout's laptop
policy, all administrative assistants were provided an university laptop computer capable of
running the ImageNow software program upon employment.
To coincide with the paperless initiative, an online survey was used for data collection.
Qualtrics software was used in the data collection process, allowing participants to complete this
survey in the designated one week timeframe. Survey results were recorded, charted and
analyzed through an Excel spreadsheet provided by Qualtrics. The conclusions and
recommendations of the results will be displayed in this chapter.
Conclusions
The needs assessment revealed that the UW -Stout ImageN ow software program was not
being fully implemented, with six of the nine administrative assistants having no working
experience with the software.
The lack of knowledge or formal training of the ImageNow software program resulted in
administrative assistants not fully utilizing the software program. Out of the three participants
that used the software, only one participate proficiently used the ImageNow software program.
Six of nine (66%) ofthe administrative assistants never experienced the ImageNow software and
only one of nine ( 11%) was proficient in printing and linking documents.
31
Demographic data provided information on the participants' educational level, which
ranged from a high school diploma to a Bachelor's degree. Four of nine (44%) participants had a
high school diploma, two of nine (22%) had taken some college courses and three of nine (33%)
had a Bachelor's degree.
Recommendations
Overall, UW-Stout administrative assistants lack fmmal training on the ImageNow
software program. Formal training was provided to only two of the participants, which resulted
in most administrative assistants lacking experience and knowledge of the ImageN ow software
program. The primary training method that was deemed most effective by participants was
group training (9/9). Group training was actually used to train one participant in the ImageNow
software program and could be the most appropriate method to train all administrative assistants
on the ImageNow software. Accordingly, this study recommends two actions: (1) ensure that the
ImageNow software program is installed in each administrative assistants' university provided
laptop computer. (2) design and deliver a formal ImageNow software training program using
group training techniques to train all of the UW -Stout administrative assistants.
32
References
About ImageNow. (2011). Retrieved from http://www.perceptivesoftware.com/company/about-
. . 1magenow.ps1
Administrative activities. (2011). Retrieved from http://www.uwstout.edu/sustainability/
clearinghouse_ administrative.cfm
Aiim. (2011). Retrieved from http://www.aiim.org/What-is-ECM-Enterprise-Content-
Management.aspx
Allen, E.L. (Ed.). (1990). ASTD trainer's toolkit: needs assessment instruments. Alexandria,
VA: American Society for Training and Development.
Anderson, A.H. (1993). Successful training practice: a manager's guide to personnel
development. Cambridge, MA: Blackwell Publishers.
Baldrige award news release. (2008, February 4). Retrieved from
http://www. uwstout.edu/mba/news _release.cfm
California Institute ofTechnology. (2011). Retrieved from
https://www.perceptivesoftware.com/casestudies/California-Institute-of-Technology
Document management. (2011). Retrieved from
http://www. businessdictionary .com/ definition/ document-managemnet.html
Enterprise resource planning. (2011, August 5). Retrieved from http://www.tech-
faq .com/ enterprise-resource-planning.html
Facts about UW-Stout. (2010, November 29). Retrieved from
http://www. uwstout.edu/ geninfo/facts.cfm
Geisler, C. & Justus, R. (1998). Training: a strategic tool for ISO and QS-9000 implementation.
liE Solutions, 30(4), 24.
33
Goldstein, I.L. (1989). Training and development in organizations. San Francisco, CA: Jossey
Bass Publishers.
Hackensack university medical center. (20 11 ). Retrieved from
https ://www. perceptivesoftware. com/ casestudies/Hackensack-University-Medical-Center
ImageNow. (2010). Unpublished manuscript, Office oflnf01mation Technology, University of
Minnesota, Minneapolis, Minnesota. Retrieved from www.oit.umn.edu
Kirkpatrick, D. (2011). The Kirkpatrick philosophy. Retrieved from
http://www.kirkpatrickpartners.com/OurPhilosophy/tabid/66/Default.aspx
Lawson, K. (2006). The trainer's handbook. San Francisco, CA: Pfeiffer.
Lee, H, & Nelson, 0. (2006). Instructional analysis and course development. Homeland, IL:
American Technical Publishers, Inc.
Lee, S. & Reeves, T. (2009). Roger Kaufman: a significant contributor to the field of educational
technology. Educational Technology, 43-45.
Mayo, G.D., & DuBois, P.H. (1987). The complete book of training: theory, principles, and
techniques. San Diego, CA: University Associates, Inc.
Phillips, J.J., & Holton III, E.F. (Ed.). (1995). In action: conducting a needs assessment.
Alexandria, VA: American Society for Training and Development.
Prior, J.P. (Ed.). (1994). Gower handbook of training and development. Hampshire, England:
Gower Publishing Limited.
Rossett, A. (1987). Training Needs Assessment. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Educational Technology
Publishing Co.
Rothwell, W.J., & Kazanas, H.C. (2008). Mastering the instructional design process. (41h ed.).
San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Banks Inc.
University of Michigan - Flint. (20 11 ). Retrieved from
http://www. perceptivesoftware.com/ case studies IU ni versity -of-Michigan---Flint
University of Minnesota System. (20 11 ). Retrieved from
http://www.perceptivesoftware.com/casestudies/University-of-Minnesota-System
Watkins, R. (2008). Models. Retrieved from http://www.needsassessment.org;
34
Werner, J., & DeSimone, R. (2009). Human resource development. (5e ed.). Mason, OH: South
Western Cengage Learning.
Witkin, B.R., & Altschuld, J.W. (1995). Planning and conducting needs assessment. Thousand
Oaks, CA: Sage Publications, Inc.
Appendix A
ImageNow Software Needs Assessment for the
University of Wisconsin-Stout Survey
1. How many years have you been working at UW -Stout?
a. Less than 1 year
b. 1-2 years
c. 3-4 years
d. 5-6 years
e. 7 years or more
2. How long have you been working at your current position?
a. Less than 1 year
b. 1-2 years
c. 3-4 years
d. 5-6 years
e. 7 years or more
3. What is your level of education?
a. High school diploma
b. Some college courses
c. Bachelors degree
d. Some Masters degree courses taken
e. Masters degree or higher
35
4. How often a week do you send paper documents to other staff, faculty and departments
on the UW -Stout campus?
a. 1-1 0 times
b. 11-20 times
c. 21-30 times
d. 41 times or more
e. Not applicable
5. What type of training at your position has been effective for you? (circle all that apply)
a. One-to-one training
b. Computer-based training
c. Reading a manual
d. Group training
e. Other (please specify)
6. Do fellow employees in your depmiment use ImageNow?
a. No
b. Yes
7. Have you ever used the ImageNow electronic filing database? a. No (end survey)
b. Yes
8. If yes, how often a week do you use it?
a. 0-1 hours
b. 2-3 hours
c. 4-5 hours
d. 6-7 hours
e. 8 or more hours
9. Have you ever been formally trained on how to use the ImageNow electronic filing
database?
a. No (skip to question 11)
b. Yes
10. If yes, how was it conducted?
a. One-on-one training
b. Reading a manual
c. Computer-based training
d. I have not received any type of formal training
Other (please specify)
11. How would you rate your ability to print documents into the ImageNow database?
a. Poor
b. Adequate
c. Proficient
d. Not applicable
12. How would you rate your ability to link documents into the ImageNow database?
a. Poor
b. Adequate
c. Proficient
d. Not applicable
36
13. How often a week do you send electronic documents from the ImageNow database to
other staff, faculty and departments located on the UW -Stout campus?
a. 1-1 0 times
b. 11-20 times
c. 21-30 times
top related