motions returnable ( 09 15 2017 ) - nj courts · 1 judge ana viscomi, j.s.c. master motion list...
Post on 06-Aug-2021
1 Views
Preview:
TRANSCRIPT
1
Judge Ana Viscomi, J.S.C. Master Motion List
Motions Returnable ( 09 15 2017 )
Opp
Docket Case Name Motion T"~e Motion# recd MOVANTSATTNY PLAINTIFF'S A TINY DISPOSITION ~ -
' ' '
L-2915 ALBAJ)RIV. adj 9/29 by
16 MAREMONT S/J 237 YES Reilly Janiczek Weitz Luxemberg ', , ACV '
GRANTED IN PART;
L-5358 DENIED IN
16 BARTLOW V. WCD S/J 151 YES Hoagland Longo Szaferman/Simon PART
' adj 9/29 by
L-2259 BEER V.ATLAS ' pltf request
16 , WELDING S/J 251 McGivney Wilentz Goldman wconsent '
' adj 9/29 by
L-2259 BEER V. ATWOOD & pltf request
16 MORILL S/J , 275 McGivney Wile'ntz Goldman wconsent - -- -
- adj 9/29 by
L-2259,. - pltf request
16. BEERV.BW/IP . S/J 305 Segal Mccambridge Wilentz Goldman wconsent - . · . .
. adj 9/29 by
L-2259 BEER V. CIDCAGO pltf request
16 _. BRIDGE S/J 239 Ricci Tyrrell Wilentz Goldman wconsent - --.
' ·-- adj 9/29 by
L-2259 BEER V. COLLINS .,. pltf request
- 16 PACKING . S/J .. · 263 Hoagland Longo Wilentz Goldman -· wconsent . -... .
·-. I . adj 9/29 by - ·.·
L-2259 . ·. __ · pltf request
16 BEER V. CRANE CO. . S/J . 295 . . __ Pascarella'· Div'ita Wilentz Goldman . . · w consent •. ' •·· .. - . .--: ~
-
.-·._ adj9/29.by 1,-2259 I . '
- -_._, pltf request I
WHentz· Go1dfua1l . 16 BEER V; CRANE PUMPS . -- S/J . .296 . . Pa:sc·arella· Divita .wConSent
2
Opp
Docket Case Name Motion T e Motion# recd MOVANTS ATTNY PLAINTIFF'S A TINY DISPOSITION
adj 9/29 by
L-2259 pltf request
16 BEERV.DAP S/J 228 McGivney Wilentz Goldman wconsent
adj 9/29 by
L-2259 BEER V. FISHER pltf request
16 SCIENTIFIC S/J 327 McCarter Wilentz Goldman w consent
adj 9/29 by
L-22591 pltf request 16 . BEER V. FLOWSERVE S/J 238 McGivney Wilentz Goldman wconsent
adj 9/29 by
L-2259 BEER V. MILLER & pltf request w
16 CIDTTY S/J 276 Reilly Janiczek Wilentz Goldnian consent
adj 9/29 by L-2259 pltf request
16 BEERY.NASH S/J 224 McGivney Wilentz-Goldman WcOnsent
adj 9/29 by L-2259 BEER V. NEW JERSEY pltf request
16 BOILERREPAffi S/J 242 McGivney Wileritz GOidman wconsent
adj 9/29 by 1.,-2259 pltf request
16 BEER V- SEABOARD S/J 240 McGivney Wilentz GoldID3n w consent
adj 9/29 by L-2259 · BEER V- TOMS RIVER I · , I pltf request
16. PLBG S/J Ricci.Tyirell ,Wilentz 'o01cilll'an -/ W consent
. STRIKE DEFT HERCULES& FILEAMDCPT
l.,-~i03f BERGBAUER.V.ACL I FOR FRAUDULENT
CONCEALMENT AND
SPOLIATION
STRIK]c EXPT<
½i~0~j 13ERGBAJJE)lV,ACL · I Jl!'T<XFDR./1 .(. ·• ;; . BRENTli"~E}'. . ·I lcoben Pbicitella I Cohen pbiciteJla ladJ9/22.
Docket
L-900-14
L-3572 17
L-3572 17
L-3572 17
L-3572 17
L-3572 17
L-3572 17
Case Name
CAIRO V. AMERICAN INTL
CARLSONV. BORGHESE
CARLSONV. BORGHESE
CARLSONV. BORGHESE
CARLSONV. BORGHESE
CARLSONV. BORGHESE
CARLSONV. BORGHESE
I
I
L-50271 CAROLANV.ALCATEL 16 . LUCENT · 1
L-5027 16
L-5027 16
CAROLAN V. DAP.
CAROLANV. Dl;CTMATE
L-50271 CAROLAN V. DllNPHEY 16 SMITH
CAROLAN V. DllRO
I
Motion Type
AMDCPT
PHVDAVID GREENSTONE I
PHV CHRISTOPHER
PANATIER I
PHV JAY STUEMKE I
PHVKEVIN PAUL I
PHV SAM IOLA [
PHVMISTY FARRIS I
. .
Motion#
384
777
779
782
786
791
792
Opp recd
3
MOVANT~_A]TNY PLAINTIFF'S ATTNY DISPOSITIQJ'i
YES I Szaferman/Levy I Szaferman/Levy
adj 9/29 by pltfw consent
Szaferman/Simon Szaferman/Simon I GRANTED
Szaferman/Simon Szaferman/Simon I GRANTED
Szaferman/Simon Szaferman/Simon I GRANTED
Szaferman/Simon Szaferman/Simon I GRANTED
Szaferman/Simon Szaferman/Simon I GRANTED
Szaferman/Simon l Szaferman/Simon \ GRANTED
, , pltfTequestw S/J I 266 I
. J adj9/29 .. bY
Porzi~_ Broinbe'rg Coh,en-PlaCltella - consent
S/J.
S/J
S/J
I< 184
adj9/2~ by p/tfrequestw
IMcGivney Cohell-Placitella , 'Consent
267 YES Delany I\kBride Cohen Placitella DENIED
235 I YES I\Vilbraham Lawler Cohen Placitella
L-5027 16 DYNE I S/J I 181 IVES [McGivn")' I Cohen Placitella
L-5027 16
I I 1
...... ·· .. · ·. .. I adj9l29by
CAROLANY,FRANB; . . .··• • .· > > .··•· . pltfrequps(w MCBRID:E S/J 176 ConneUFol~J' · ·· Cohen Placitel!a ; consent"
· ·. · •• >>!/ . adi?f,N' 1,-5021 CAROLAN.Yes. . . .. . .. · ... . . pt~requ~st,y
16 . FRANKLIN°&SONS S/J Cohen Placitella · consent .
4
Opp
Docket Case Name Motion T""'e Motion# recd MOVANTS ATTNY PLAINTIFF'S A TINY DISPOSITION
L-5027 CAROLANV. 16 HONEYWELL S/J 1~2 YES l\'larks O'Neill Cohen Placitella DENIED
L- DISMISS- .
2911° CHAPMAN V. CYPRUS FORUM NON adj 10/13 by
17 AMAX .. .. CONVENIENS 566 YES Rawle Henderson Lai1ier ACV
L- ·. DISMISS- ·. .
2911- FORUM NON adj 10/13 by
17 CHAPMANV. IMERYS · CONVENIENS 578 YES Rawle Henderson Lanier ACV ~ ·.
1 STRIKE DEFT . .
HERCULES& F1LOE AMD CPT
L-674- COMOLLI V. ACL FOR
90 YES ' 15 FRAUDULENT '
CONCEALMENT AND . I
. '
. .. .. ·. SPOLIATION . . . Cohen-Pl_acitella - CohenPJaciteUa · · adj 9/22 .. . ·-·. ·-. · .. . .. · .. · ··.· .· .
.) . · . ·.· . . · .. .....
. STRIKJ!:EXPT . I . ' ·.·
L-674- COMOLLIV.ACL ·. .
15 · .· RPTOFDR 695 YES .. .. ·
"> •. _.,,· • f BRENT FINLEY Cohen Placitella Cohen Placitella · ... ·,. adi'9/22 . .. ' ' ·. .. · .
RECONSIDERA Tl
L-4821 DALIS V. COLGATE FOR ON OF 6/30/17
15 MENNEN ORDER 1133 O'Toole Scrivo Szaferman/Simon GRANTED
L-4301 PHVDAVID
17 ESSES V. BRENNTAG GREENSTONE 805 Szaferman!Simon Szaferman/Simon GRANTED
PHV
L-4301 CHRISTOPHER
17 ESSES V. BRENNTAG PANATIER 806 Szaferman/Simon Szaferman/Simon GRANTED
L-4301 PHV JAY
17 ESSES V. BRENNTAG STUEMKE 807 Szaferman/Simon Szaferman/Simon GRANTED
L-4301 PHVKEVIN
17 ESSES V. BRENNTAG PAUL 809 Szaferman/Simon Szaferman/Simon GRANTED
L-4301 17 ESSES V. BRENNTAG PHVSAM IOLA 810 Szaferman/Simon Szaferman/Simon GRANTED
L-4301 PHVMISTY
17 ESSES V. BRENNTAG FARRIS 813 Szaferman/Simon Szaferman/Simon GRANTED
Docket I Case Name
L-932-17 ETHERIDGE V. J&J
L-932-17 ETHERIDGE V. J&J
L-23101 FARINELLA V. NEW 15 JERSEY PLBG GROUP
L-1079-
16 La
1464° 17 L-
1464-17 L-
1464-17 v
1464' 17 L-
1464-17 V
1,464-!17<
GALLUS V. A.J. FRIEDMAN
GAMBIIIIO)l'.18 LUMBER
GAMBINO V. DAL TILE
GAMBINOV. DOMCO
GANIBINO\l.ECR • 1(LITICA BOILER}.·· ,· .. · ....... , .. , ..
GANIB1r:io '-'-"~s'roN BOI.LER Y
. ·.tA?-- . ·:-,-;,_', '-'"' GAMBINOV;,.RI-I.EE.M.•• •
Motion T e
I S/J
XMTOSEAL
S/J
AMDCPT
S/J
S/J
S/J
5
Opp Motion# md MOVANTS A TINY PLAINTIFF'S A TTl\:'Y
I 302 I YES I Drinker Biddle I Szaferman/Simon
Szaferman/Simon Szafer:nian/Simon
225
666 Wilentz IWilentz Goldman
228 Reilly 'Janiczek I Szaferman/Le
217 Wilbraham I Szaferman/Le
200
~andman Co!'§i
pailf ell~ Di~tf f
DISPOSITION
adj 9/29 by
ldeftw/ consent
adj 9/29
GRANTED adj 9129 by pltfw consent adj 9/29 by pltfw co_n_sent adj 9/29 by pltfw c9n_Sent adj 9129 by pltfw consent' adj 912.9 by pltfw · consent adj9/29by pltfw · ··
collsent
6
Opp
Docket Case Name Motion T e Motion# recd MOVANTSATTl\'Y PLAINTIFF'S A TINY DISPOSITION
L- adj 9/29 by
1464- GAMBINO V. TRANE S/J 235 pltfw
17 Pascarella Divita Szaferman/Le consent
L- adj 9/29 by
1464- GAMBINO V. TREMCO S/J 232 pltfw
17 Landman Corsi Szaferman/Le consent
L- GAMBINO V. WEIL adj 9/29 by
1464- MCLAIN S/J 214 pltfW
17 McGivne Szaferman/Le ·consent
L- GAMBINOV. adj 9/29 by
1464- WOODHAVEN LUMBER S/J 107 pltfw
17 Hoagland Longo Szaferman/Levy consent
' GARDNERV, I
I I ........... ~ ...... I ._ I 1059 HONEYWELL ---· ..............
2~~9-1 GRECO V. H.M. ROYAL I S/J I
216 I IStvliades I Szaferman/Levy !GRANTED
L- GRECO V; CYPRUS ladJ9/29by 2919.- AMAX S/J 220 pltf request
10 Rawle Henderson Szaferman/Levy . w·consent
L- . adJ9/29 by 2919- GRECO V. IMERYS S/J
16 Rawle Henderson Szaferman/Levy pltf request ·wconsent
L-2919-
16
L-•STRJKE.D.EFT
.5924, M.AC~JR.lJCK "FOR NO
13 DISCOVERY' L- HARLEY V. MACK PHY CHRIS N. I 5924- 860 13
TRUCKS KOLOS I I Rawle Henderson I Cohen Placitella !GRANTED
L- PHVDAVID 4526- HILL V. BRENNTAG
GREENSTONE I 582 17 I I Szaferman/Simon ISzaferman/Simon !GRANTED
Docket Case Name
L-4526- HILL V. BRENNTAG
17 L-
4526- HILL V. BRENNTAG 17 L-
4526- HILL V. BRENNTAG 17 L-
HILL V. BRENNTAG
L- JOHNSON V. COLGATE 6651- PALMOLIVE (MENNEN)
16
L~ 2629,1 KLOOCK\hCHEVRON I
13
L-2629-
13 L-
2s29-I
L-2629-
13
KLOOCK V. E.I. DUPONT
KLOOCK.Ve EXXON
KLOOCK V. NICHOLAS SCHWAWE
I
7
Motion Tvpe Opp l
I Motion# I recd MOVANTSATTNY I PLAINTIFF'S A TINY I DISPOSITIQ~
PHV CHRISTOPHER I 583
PANATIER I lszaferman/Simon ISzaferman/Simon !GRANTED
PHVJAY
I 584
STUEMKE I I Szaferman/Simon ISzaferman/Simon !GRANTED
PHV SAM (OLA I 586 I lszaferman/Simon I Szaferman/Simon !GRANTED
PHVMISTY FARRIS I 587
YES Wilson Elser I Szaferman/Levy lmovant
COMMISSIONS FOR OOS SIP
903
O'Toole Scrivo I Szaferman/Simon I GRANTED
S/J I 257 IYES
I McEfrov·Deutscll I Keefe
S/J 153 YES I Porzio
S/J I. 258
S/J 151 YES Marks O'Neill Keefe DENIED
Docket Case Name Motion T pe
L-5027 16 KOECHER V, DAP S/J
L- KOECHERV. 7390-
ELIZABETH INDUSTRIAL S/J
15
L-50271 KOECHERV, FRANK , 16 .MCBRIDE S/J
L-50271 KOECHER V. S. 16 FRAi\KLIN & SO:<S S/J
L-50271 KOECHERV. SUPERIOR I 16 WELDING .... · S/J I
DISMISS FOR LACK OF
PERSONAL L-7336 LASHLEY V. AMERICAN JURISDICTION
16 INTL ANDFNC
L,73361 L_ASHLEYKC()l,GATE I 16 ·. . (MENNEN) · _ S/J I
LASHLEYV,COLGil:TE S/J
8
Opp Motion# recd MOVANTSATTNY
207 McGivney I
57 Tierne
196 Connell Foley I
203 YES .\lcGivney I
171 I lc-onnell,Foley I
578 Hawkins Parnell
325 I JO;T~Ole ScriVO I
328 I YES IO'Toole Scrivo
PLAINTIFF'S A TINY DISPOSITION
adj 9/29 by
CohCn Placitella I pltf request wconsent
Cohen Placitella GRANTED adj 9/29 by
Cohen Placitella l pltfrequestW
consent
Cohen Placitella I DENIED adj .9/29 by
Cohen Placitella I pltf request w
consent
adj 9/29 by pltfw
Szafeman/Simon consent adj9/29 by
S'zafoman/Simon l-pl_tf re_q_uest W
consent
adj 9/29 by movantwith
Szafeman/Simon I consent . _adJ9/291,y
pltf request w 'Con~ell(
adj9121by pltfre<juest:w
'cdOSeD-t :,,--
Docket Case Name
L. 7336· I LASHLEY V. ELI LILLY
16
USHLEY V. WCD
Motion Type
S/J
I S/J COMPEL
9
Opp Mot_ion# l_i:ecd I MOVANTSATINY
153
I 31s I YES I Hoagland Longo
PLAINTIFF'SATTNY I DISPOSITION
adj 9/29. by Szafeman/Simon · IACV
11920 LORA V.AAROMA DISCOVERY; I . 546
13 HOLDINGS COMPELDEP;
MODIFYCMO IYES
'I Locks Law Locks Law
adj 9/29 with consent of
,clrties L-4567-13
L-45570
IL YNCH V.HOKE ISIJ
13 ILYNCH V.IDEAL SUPPLYIS/J
LYNCH V. WASHINGTON L, 4567-13 DIV. OF URS IS/J
L-4557, 13
L-· 2821-
16 L-
. . LYNCHV.WELCO
. NIAUCERl"V.~ISHER SCIENTIFIC
5822-1 MAX V. MAX LUMBER 16
S/J
I 172IYES IMcGivne Wilentz
194IYES I Margolis Edelstein IWilentz
188IYE.S I Margolis Edelstein IWilentz
S/J ~2carler Weltz/Lux~n6er,
AMDCPT 246 Wilentz Wilentz
DENIED
adj 10/13 by pltf request Wccinsent
adj.10/13 by pltf request wtonsent
adj9/29by mov'ant
GRANTED
10
Opp Docket Case Name Motion T e Motion# recd MOVANTS ATTNY PLAINTIFF'S ATTNY DISPOSITION
STRIKE DEFT. HERCULES&
FILEAMDCPT
1-88-131 MUNICELLO V. ACL FOR
I FRAUDULENT I 91 IYES
CONCEALMENT AND
SPOLIATION Cohen Placitella Cohen Placitella adj9/22
STRIKEEXPT 1-88-13 I .MUNI CELLO V. ACL I RPTOFDR. I 698 IYES
BRENT FINLEY. 'Cohen Placitella I Cohen Placitella I adj 9/22
adj 9/29 by L-6103 MUOIOV0CM RECONSIDERATI movantwith
14 FURNACES ON 48S YES 6 1Toofe'-'ScriVo Wilentz Goldman. consent L-
5314- O'NEILL V. ECR S/J 270 YES 16 Landman Corsi Weitz/Luxenber1
adj 12115 by pithy
L I ls,.1 I 2281 IStyliades I Weitz l..uxenber
'cf?_ristHl(fOr_ 5;14- C>'.NEILL V.VIKING negoat(ation 16 ·,.·· PUMP s
awaiting
L- I ls,J I 1031 I Marshall Dennehey I Weitz Luxenberg
I copy of an 5314- O'NEILL V. WARREN order from 16 PUMPS movant
adj f2115by ·• pltfw
L- < ~(!l'lSer,tfor 5314- 9'.NEILLV.WEIL / J < \· . . negoatiation 16 . ; MCLAIN 177. McGivne Weitiluxent>er · .. · s ;
L-2986-17 I OSBORNE V. 0.1. IAMDCPT I 2021 lwilentz lwilentz !GRANTED
11
Docket I Case Name
I
Motion Type Opp I
I Motion # I recd MOVANTS ATTNY I PLAINTIFF'S A TINY I DISPOSITION
COMMISSIONS 1-5111- PATEL V. GENUINE FOROOSS/P 14 AUTO PARTS AND DEP I 9441 I Breuninger I Szaferman/Levv !GRANTED
COMMISSIONS
1-5111-1 .:!_4 PATEL V. NAPA
IFOROOSS/P AND DEP I 9431 I Breunin~er I Szaferman/Levv !GRANTED
L-1332- IPELLOT V. AMERICAN 15 BILTRITE
IPHV JON ALLARD I 3901 I Rawle Henderson I Belluck & Fox !GRANTED
L-1332- IPELLOT V. AMERICAN 15 BILTRITE
I PHV DAVID J. FISHER I 3921 I Rawle Henderson I Belluck & Fox !GRANTED
L-5111- STRIKE DEFT 13 PEREZ V, AMPACET ROGERS I 2191 !Lanier !Lanier ladj9/29
>STRIKE DEFT HERCUl,ES & FILEAMffCPT
L-80701 PETERSON V. ACL I FOR !YES 10 FRAUDULENT I 92
CONCEALMENT AND
SPOLIATION. I I I Cohen Ptacitella ICOhen Plac,itelia Jadj9/22
STRIKERl'T.QF
L-80701 .. . .. ·· .. DEFENSEMED
PETERSO;,!V.ACL I EXP'.):'DR- 686
I YES I Cohen Pia cite II~/ I Cohen ;il!Lua 10 RI~IIAR:q.
ATTANOOS ..
STRIKE RPl' OF
))EFENSl}~D I 10 ... I ' ·-·-·-Y" . -••y- IE~))R.,BR1'~1'
FlNLEY
699 IYES
• lcohen Placitella -1 C~h~ti-P-iacite11a-
Docket Case Name
L-3447- IPETRUSHEVICH V. 17
L-2857-
16 L-
1562-12
CATERPILLAR
RASCO V. ENESCO
REILLYV. BAYONNE PLBG
L-762-1 REILLYV. BAYONNE 14 PLBG
L-5869-1 SCHOENIGER V. WCD
16
L-6996-15 L-6996-15 L-6996-15 L-6996-15
SCHULTZ V. A.O. SMITH
SCHULTZ V. BRADFORD WHITE
SCHULTZ V. CARRIER
SCHULTZ V. CROWN BOILER
Motion Type
DISMISS DUE TO INSUFFICIENT PROCESS AND SERVICE
S/J
S/J
S/J
S/J
S/J
S/J
S/J
S/J
I
12
Opp Motion# I recd I MOVAN'ff:i ATTNY PLAINTIFF'S ATTNY I DISPOSIT!_ON
680 Tanenbaum Keale !Cohen Placitella GRANTED
183 Vedder Price
237 IYES Marks O'Neill
239 I YES, Marks O'Neill
150 I YES
HoaQland Lon~o
142IYES I Eckert Seamans
106 White & Williams
131 Ma ield Turner
226 Reill Janiczek
Szaferman/Simon I GRANTED
Wilentz I DENIED
Wilentz DENIED GRANTED IN PART; DENIED IN
Szaferman/Simon I PART
IWeitz/Luxemberg I DENIED
lweitz/Luxemberg !GRANTED
IWeitz/Luxemberg !GRANTED
Weitz/Luxember GRANTED ADJ 10/13 at
V ·1 . . . ···1·Dl$MISS 3RD .· ·1· .· I I . ·1the request 6996.' s.CHULTZ V. E.I. . PRTY CPT OF . .•..•..• . .. ·. .. ·. .·. > ofth<! 15 · · DUPONT · AARON & CO __ 117 · Porzio Weitz/Luxemberg parties
..,_--=-,--,------cr-c-----,---,-----c,---T-c~-C------r-~- - --·-' ... •• .· .ADJ 10/13 at L- · ·.· , DISMISS 3RD the request 6996' SCHULTZ.V. E;J. . PRTY CPT OF ofthe 15 : • DUPONT WEIL MCLAINE parties
ADJ 10113 at L, . ··.. ;: .< DISMISS 3RD / . >• . ... ··.,. th11 request 6996- SC~ULTZ V/E.I. PRTY CPTOF •.• ,_ __ , . '; .... \ ·; J ; , ••. of~he 15 DUPONT . AO. SMITH . Weiti/Luxeinberg . parties L-6996- I SCHULTZ V. FOSTER 15 WHEELER S/J 221 Tanenbaum Keale IWeitz/Luxemberq GRANTED
13
Docket Case Name I Motion Type Opp I
I Motion# I recd MOVANTSATTNY I PLAINTIFF'S ATTNY I DISPOSITION
L-6996- SCHULTZ V. GENERAL 15 ELECTRIC S/J I 2191 !Tanenbaum Keale lweitz/Luxemberg !GRANTED L-6996-15 SCHULTZ V. IMO ls1J I 2071 I Leader & Berkon I Weitz/Luxemberg !GRANTED L-6996- SCHULTZ V. SOUTH 15 AMBOYPLBG ls1J I 2221 I Wilbraham lweitz/Luxemberg !GRANTED
L-5667- STAFFORD V. CORNELL S/J
I 207 IYES
15 . · !Gibbons IWilentz I adj 9/29
L-RECONSIDERA Tl
ON DENYING 5667- STAFFORD V. CORNELL LEAVE TO FILE Al 358 IYES
15 I I 3RD PRTY CPT I
I !Gibbons IWilentz ladj 9/29 L-5667-15 STAFFORD V. EXXON S/J 127 YES McElro Deutsch Wilentz ad· 9/29
L-STAFFORD V. FISHER
5667- S/J 198 YES 15
SCIENTIFIC Mccarter. IWiientz ladj 9/29 L- STAFFORD V. HENKELS
5667-&MCCOY
S/J 215 YES Rawle& 15 Henderson Wilentz ad· 9/29 L- STAFFORD V. THOMAS
5667- S/J 172 YES 15
SCIENTIFIC Marshall Denne he Wilentz ad"9/29
L, STAFFORD V. THOMAS RECONSIDERAl"I .GOO .5667- SCIENTIFIC.
YES M.arshall Dennehey 15
ON Wilentz Goldman ad" 9/29
L-TELLADOV.
6763-09
ELE.CTROLUX Decotis Fitz atrick: Cohen Placitella ad· 9/29
Ls.
Docket Case Name Motion T e
DISMISS FOR
L- I ILACKOF 3636- • VOJACK-SMITH V. PERSONAL
JURISDICTION 17 CYPRUS AMAX
L-3376 PHVDAVID 17 WELCH V. BRENNTAG GREENSTONE
PHV L-3376 CHRISTOPHER
17 WELCH V. BRENNTAG PANATIER
L-3376 PHV JAY 17 WELCH V. BRENNTAG STUEMKE
L-3376 PHVKEVIN 17 WELCH V. BRENNTAG PAUL
L-3376 17 WELCH V. BRENNTAG PHVSAMIOLA
L-33761 PHVMISTY 17 WELCHV.BRENNTAG FARRIS
WOLF V. SOUTH DISMISS CPTOR
:~~1::r,i::> . ' :x_g;~~~~~(,· L-
5375-1 ZIEGEL V. A.O. SMITH 14
S/J
Motion#
654
821
823
824
830
832
834
108
14
Opp ,ecd MOVAI\'TSATTNY
YES Rawle. Henderson
Szaferman/Simon
Szaferman/Simon
Szaferman/Simon
Szaferman/Simon
Szaferman/Simon
Szaferman/Simon
")l• FoxFfothschild
Eckert Seamans
PLAINTIFF'S A TTNY DISPOSITION
adj .10/13 by Le ACV
Szaferman/Simon GRANTED
Szaferman/Simon GRANTED
Szaferrnan/Simon GRANTED
Szaferman/Simon !GRANTED
Szaferman/Simon !GRANTED
Szaferman/Simon !GRANTED
Wolf~w : ladj 10/20 prose
GRANTED
15
Opp Docket Case Name Motion Type Motion# recd MOVANTS A TINY PLAINTIFF'S A TINY DISPOSITION
L- prose 5375- ZIEGEL V. BUIST S/J 40 O'Toole Scrivo
14 GRANTED
liOAGLANO,LONGO MORAN, OU/ST & OOO<AS, u, ATTClff'il:YSAT LAW
NORTH JERSl:Y 40PATERSONST POOO)(ffO NEW~.NJ
SOUTH JEftSfY 701 V\lJSEY'S Mill RD SUlE202 H~ON,NJ
Jillian E. Madison, Esq. (ID# 015962012) HOAGLAND, LONGO, MORAN, DUNST & DOUKAS, LLP 40 Paterson Street, PO Box 480
FILED SEP 1 5 2017 New Brunswick, NJ 08903
(732) 545-4717 Attorne s for Defendant, Whittaker Clark & Daniels, Inc. ANA C. VISCOMI, J.S.C.
Plaintiff(s), SUPERIOR COURT OF NEW JERSEY MIDDLESEX COUNTY
LAINA JEWEL BARTLOW and KENNETH LAW DIVISION DAVID BARTLOW,
vs.
Defendant(s),
BRENNTAG NORTH AMERICA, INC., et al.
DOCKET NO. MID-L-5358-16AS
ASBESTOS LITIGATION
CIVIL ACTION
ORDER ~MARY JUDGMENT £4 f., ,,.,,..,,._;t;. I - '-/ --.J.. (;, ~ it' ~ ~ /I"·· ~ ~ .... k ~s THIS MATTER having been brought before fhe ~urt on M of/ of filoagland, Longo,
Moran, Duns! & Doukas, attorneys for the Defendant, Whittaker, Clark & Daniels, Inc., for an
Order granting said Defendant Summary Judgment in the within cause of action, and the Court
having reviewed the moving papers and for good cause shown;
IT IS ON THIS / 5 l!i day of ~ , 2017, I
ORDERED that Defendant, Whittaker, Clark & Daniels, lnc.'s, Motion for Summary . {I>~ 1-4 Judgment be and is hereby granted in favor of said Defendant a~ that Bfl'f a11d alt' claims,
c:rcl~t;s~ a11~ c~ ;Z;.~~ ~t~: he~n~;-;h . . ~. u,,·~ ~ a.. M> r hv......, prejudice; and 1 () U o
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that a copy of the within Order shall be served upon all
counsel of record within seven (7) days of the date hereof. . 1 /;~LU~; Papers filed with the Court ~T+-Fi/t""""Hcc.O,=N-'-'O=,RAc'='B'-cL""E~A-N""'A"'c-=->. v""1.,.SC-c--O.,,..,.-,M,,...l,-J""'.S,...C,,...-
( 1Answering Papers ( 1Reply Papers The within Notice of Motion was: ( --1'0pposed ( ) Unopposed
On __ f!-..·J-/.>,<5_• '-:/;,._;_the court's statement of reasons have been set forth on the record.
SZAFERMAN, LAKIND, BLUMSTEIN & BLADER P.C.
101 Grovers Mill Road, Suite 200 Lawrenceville, N.J. 08648 (609) 275-0400 By: Robert E. Lytle (ID #046331990)
SIMON GREENSTONE PANATIER BARTLETT P.C. 3232 McKinney Ave., Suite 610 FILED
SEP 15 2017
ANA C. VISCOM/, J.s.c.
Dallas, TX 75204 (214) 276-7680
By: Leah Kagan (ID #013602009)
Attorneys for Plaintiffs
PEGGY CARLSON and JOHN CARLSON,
Plaintiffs,
v.
BORGHESE, INC., et al.,
Defendants.
SUPERIOR COURT OF NEW JERSEY LAW DIVISION, MIDDLESEX COUNTY
DOCKET NO.: MID-L-3572-17AS
Civil Action - Asbestos Litigation
ORDER FOR PRO HAC VICE ADMISSION OF
DAVID GREENSTONE, ESQ.
This matter having been opened to the Court on behalf of
Plaintiffs, Peggy Carlson and John Carlson, by Szaferman, Lakind,
Blumstein & Blader, P.C. (Robert E. Lytle, Esq., appearing),
notice to all counsel of record; and this Court having considered
the moving papers, in which it is stated that Plaintiffs have a
long-standing relationship with Esq.
IT IS ON THIS I 5~ day of
ORDERED that David Greenstone, Esq. be and is hereby
admitted pro hac vice in this matter; and
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that David Greenstone, Esq.:
2477830.1
1. Shall abide by the New Jersey Rules of Court, including
all disciplinary rules, R.,_ 1:20-1, R.,_ 1:28-2 and R.,_ l:28B-l(e);
2. Shall consent to the appointment of the Clerk of the
New Jersey Supreme Court as the agent upon whom service of
process may be made for all actions against him that may arise
out of his participation in this matter;
3. Shall notify the Court immediately of any matter
affecting him standing at the bar of any other court;
4. Shall have all pleadings, briefs, and other papers
filed with the Court signed by an attorney of record authorized
to practice in this State, who shall be held responsible for
them, the conduct of the cause and the admitted attorney herein;
5. Shall abide by any further requirements concerning his
participation in this matter as the court from time to time deems
necessary;
6. Cannot be designated as trial counsel; and
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that:
1. No adjournment or delay in discovery, motions, trial,
or any other proceeding shall occur or be requested by reason of
the inability of David Greenstone to be in attendance.
2. David Greenstone shall, within ten (10) days, comply
with R.,_ 1:20-l(b), R.,_ 1:28-2 and R.,_ l:28B-l(e) by paying the
appropriate fees to the Disciplinary Oversight Committee, to the
Lawyers Assistance Program and the New Jersey Fund for Client
2477830. l
Protection and submit an affidavit of compliance no later than
February 1 of each year thereafter.
3. Automatic termination of pro hac vice admission will
occur for failure to make the required annual payment to the
Disciplinary Oversight Committee, the Lawyers Assistance Program
and the New Jersey Lawyer's Fund for Client Protection. Proof of
such payment, after filing proof of the initial payment, shall be
made no later than February 1 of each year thereafter.
4. Noncompliance with any of these requirements shall
constitute grounds for removal.
5. A copy of this Order shall be served on all parties
within seven (7) days.
Opposed
__ /u_ Unopposed
2477830. l
HON. ANA C. VISCOMI, J.S.C.
SZAFERMAN, LAKIND, BLUMSTEIN & BLADER P.C.
101 Grovers Mill Road, Suite 200 Lawrenceville, N.J. 08648 (609) 275-0400
\
By: Robert E. Lytle (ID #046331990)
FILED SEP 1 5 2017
ANA C. VISCOM/, ,J.S.C.
SIMON GREENSTONE PANATIER BARTLETT P.C. 3232 McKinney Ave., Suite 610 Dallas, TX 75204 (214) 276-7680 By: Leah Kagan (ID #013602009)
Attorneys for Plaintiffs
PEGGY CARLSON and JOHN CARLSON,
Plaintiffs,
v.
BORGHESE, INC., et al.,
Defendants.
SUPERIOR COURT OF NEW JERSEY LAW DIVISION, MIDDLESEX COUNTY
DOCKET NO.: MID-L-3572-17AS
Civil Action - Asbestos Litigation
ORDER FOR PRO HAC VICE ADMISSION OF
CHRISTOPHER PANATIER, ESQ.
This matter having been opened to the Court on behalf of
Plaintiffs, Peggy Carlson and John Carlson, by Szaferman, Lakind,
Blumstein & Blader, P.C. (Robert E. Lytle, Esq., appearing),
notice to all counsel of record; and this Court having considered
the moving papers, in which it is stated that Plaintiffs have a
long-standing relationship with Esq.
IT IS ON THIS I 5"1:: day of
ORDERED that Christopher Panatier, Esq. be and is hereby
admitted pro hac vice in this matter; and
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that Christopher Panatier, Esq.:
2477830.l
1. Shall abide by the New Jersey Rules of Court, including
all disciplinary rules, R.,_ 1:20-1, R.,_ 1:28-2 and R.,_ l:28B-l(e);
2. Shall consent to the appointment of the Clerk of the
New Jersey Supreme Court as the agent upon whom service of
process may be made for all actions against him that may arise
out of his participation in this matter;
3. Shall notify the Court immediately of any matter
affecting his standing at the bar of any other court;
4. Shall have all pleadings, briefs, and other papers
filed with the Court signed by an attorney of record authorized
to practice in this State, who shall be held responsible for
them, the conduct of the cause and the admitted attorney herein;
5. Shall abide by any further requirements concerning his
participation in this matter as the court from time to time deems
necessary;
6. Cannot be designated as trial counsel; and
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that:
1. No adjournment or delay in discovery, motions, trial,
or any other proceeding shall occur or be requested by reason of
the inability of Christopher Panatier to be in attendance.
2. Christopher Panatier shall, within ten (10) days,
comply with R.,_ 1:20-l(b), R.,_ 1:28-2 and R.,_ l:28B-l(e) by paying
the appropriate fees to the Disciplinary Oversight Committee, to
the Lawyers Assistance Program and the New Jersey Fund for Client
Protection and submit an affidavit of compliance no later than
February 1 of each year thereafter.
2477830.1
3. Automatic termination of pro hac vice admission will
occur for failure to make the required annual payment to the
Disciplinary Oversight Committee, the Lawyers Assistance Program
and the New Jersey Lawyer's Fund for Client Protection. Proof of
such payment, after filing proof of the initial payment, shall be
made no later than February 1 of each year thereafter.
4. Noncompliance with any of these requirements shall
constitute grounds for removal.
5. A copy of this Order shall be served on all parties
within seven (7) days.
Opposed
V Unopposed
2477830.1
~ c.J~ HON. ANA C. VISCOMI, J.S.C.
SZAFERMAN, LAKIND, BLUMSTEIN & BLADER P.C.
101 Grovers Mill Road, Suite 200 Lawrenceville, N.J. 08648 (609) 275-0400
I '6 '
By: Robert E. Lytle (ID #046331990) FILED SEP 1 5 2017
ANA C. VISCOMI, J.S.C.
SIMON GREENSTONE PANATIER BARTLETT P.C. 3232 McKinney Ave., Suite 610 Dallas, TX 75204 (214) 276-7680 By: Leah Kagan (ID #013602009)
Attorneys for Plaintiffs
PEGGY CARLSON and JOHN CARLSON,
Plaintiffs,
v.
BORGHESE, INC., et al.,
Defendants.
SUPERIOR COURT OF NEW JERSEY LAW DIVISION - MIDDLESEX COUNTY
DOCKET NO.: MID-L-3572-17AS
Civil Action - Asbestos Litigation
ORDER FOR PRO HAC VICE ADMISSION OF
JAY STUEMKE, ESQ.
2 \-
This matter having been opened to the Court on behalf of
Plaintiffs, Peggy Carlson and John Carlson, by Szaferman, Lakind,
Blumstein & Blader, P.C. (Robert E. Lytle, Esq., appearing), on
short notice to all counsel of record; and this Court having
considered the moving papers, in which it is stated that
Plaintiffs have a long-standing relationship with Jay Stuemke,
Esq.
IT IS ON THIS __ ,s_t!:_ day of ~ Augu.it 2017;
ORDERED that Jay Stuemke, Esq. be and is hereby admitted pro
2477830. l
q~1 ·1
{ 7
hac vice in this matter; and
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that Jay Stuemke, Esq.:
1. Shall abide by the New Jersey Rules of Court, including
all disciplinary rules, R.,_ 1:20-1, R.,_ 1:28-2 and R.,_ 1:28B-l(e);
2. Shall consent to the appointment of the Clerk of the
New Jersey Supreme Court as the agent upon whom service of
process may be made for all actions against him that may arise
out of his participation in this matter;
3. Shall notify the Court immediately of any matter
affecting his standing at the bar of any other court;
4. Shall have all pleadings, briefs, and other papers
filed with the Court signed by an attorney of record authorized
to practice in this State, who shall be held responsible for
them, the conduct of the cause and the admitted attorney herein;
5. Shall abide by any further requirements concerning his
participation in this matter as the court from time to time deems
necessary;
6. Cannot be designated as trial counsel; and
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that:
1. No adjournment or delay in discovery, motions, trial,
or any other proceeding shall occur or be requested by reason of
the inability of Jay Stuemke to be in attendance.
2. Jay Stuemke shall, within ten (10) days, comply with R.,_
1:20-l(b), R.,_ 1:28-2 and R.,_ 1:28B-l(e) by paying the appropriate
2477830.1
fees to the Disciplinary Oversight Committee, to the Lawyers
Assistance Program and the New Jersey Fund for Client Protection
and submit an affidavit of compliance no later than February 1 of
each year thereafter.
3. Automatic termination of pro hac vice admission will
occur for failure to make the required annual payment to the
Disciplinary Oversight Committee, the Lawyers Assistance Program
and the New Jersey Lawyer's Fund for Client Protection. Proof of
such payment, after filing proof of the initial payment, shall be
made no later than February 1 of each year thereafter.
4. Noncompliance with any of these requirements shall
constitute grounds for removal.
5. A copy of this Order shall be served on all parties
within seven (7) days.
Opposed
V Unopposed
2477830.l
HON. ANA C. VISCOMI, J.S.C.
SZAFERMAN, LAKIND, BLUMSTEIN & BLADER P.C.
101 Grovers Mill Road, Suite 200 Lawrenceville, N.J. 08648 (609) 275-0400
"-1 s I
By: Robert E. Lytle (ID #046331990)
SIMON GREENSTONE PANATIER BARTLETT P.C. 3232 McKinney Ave., Suite 610 Dallas, TX 75204 (214) 276-7680 By: Leah Kagan (ID #013602009)
Attorneys for Plaintiffs
PEGGY CARLSON and JOHN CARLSON,
Plaintiffs,
v.
BORGHESE, INC., et al.,
Defendants.
SUPERIOR COURT OF NEW JERSEY LAW DIVISION, MIDDLESEX COUNTY
DOCKET NO.: MID-L-3572-17AS
Civil Action - Asbestos Litigation
ORDER FOR PRO HAC VICE ADMISSION OF
KEVIN PAUL, ESQ.
This matter having been opened to the Court on behalf of
Plaintiffs, Peggy Carlson and John Carlson, by Szaferman, Lakind,
Blumstein & Blader, P.C. (Robert E. Lytle, Esq., appearing),
notice to all counsel of record; and this Court having considered
the moving papers, in which it is stated that Plaintiffs have a
long-standing relationship with Kevin Paul, Esq.
IT IS ON THIS /'5#! day of ~01 7;
ORDERED that Kevin Paul, Esq. be and is hereby admitted pro
hac vice in this matter; and
2477830.1
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that Kevin Paul, Esq.:
1. Shall abide by the New Jersey Rules of Court, including
all disciplinary rules, R.,_ 1:20-1, R.,_ 1:28-2 and R.,_ l:28B-l(e);
2. Shall consent to the appointment of the Clerk of the
New Jersey Supreme Court as the agent upon whom service of
process may be made for all actions against him that may arise
out of his participation in this matter;
3. Shall notify the Court immediately of any matter
affecting his standing at the bar of any other court;
4. Shall have all pleadings, briefs, and other papers
filed with the Court signed by an attorney of record authorized
to practice in this State, who shall be held responsible for
them, the conduct of the cause and the admitted attorney herein;
5. Shall abide by any further requirements concerning his
participation in this matter as the court from time to time deems
necessary;
6. Cannot be designated as trial counsel; and
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that:
1. No adjournment or delay in discovery, motions, trial,
or any other proceeding shall occur or be requested by reason of
the inability of Kevin Paul to be in attendance.
2. Kevin Paul shall, within ten (10) days, comply with R.,_
1:20-l(b), R.,_ 1:28-2 and R.,_ l:28B-l(e) by paying the appropriate
fees to the Disciplinary Oversight Committee, to the Lawyers
2477830. I
Assistance Program and the New Jersey Fund for Client Protection
and submit an affidavit of compliance no later than February 1 of
each year thereafter.
3. Automatic termination of pro hac vice admission will
occur for failure to make the required annual payment to the
Disciplinary Oversight Committee, the Lawyers Assistance Program
and the New Jersey Lawyer's Fund for Client Protection. Proof of
such payment, after filing proof of the initial payment, shall be
made no later than February 1 of each year thereafter.
4. Noncompliance with any of these requirements shall
constitute grounds for removal.
5. A copy of this Order shall be served on all parties
within seven (7) days.
Opposed
V Unopposed
2477830. l
HON. ANA C. VISCOMI, J.S.C.
SZAFERMAN, LAKIND, BLUMSTEIN & BLADER P.C.
101 Grovers Mill Road, Suite 200 Lawrenceville, N.J. 08648 (609) 275-0400
By: Robert E. Lytle (ID #046331990) FILED SEP 1 5 2017
ANA C. V\SCOMI, J.S.C.
SIMON GREENSTONE PANATIER BARTLETT P.C.
3232 McKinney Ave., Suite 610 Dallas, TX 75204 (214) 276-7680 By: Leah Kagan (ID #013602009)
Attorneys for Plaintiffs
PEGGY CARLSON and JOHN CARLSON,
Plaintiffs,
v.
BORGHESE, INC., et al.,
Defendants.
SUPERIOR COURT OF NEW JERSEY LAW DIVISION, MIDDLESEX COUNTY
DOCKET NO.: MID-L-3572-17AS
Civil Action - Asbestos Litigation
ORDER FOR PRO HAC VICE ADMISSION OF SAM IOLA, ESQ.
17
This matter having been opened to the Court on behalf of
Plaintiffs, Peggy Carlson and John Carlson, by Szaferman, Lakind,
Blumstein & Blader, P.C. (Robert E. Lytle, Esq., appearing),
notice to all counsel of record; and this Court having considered
the moving papers, in which it is stated that Plaintiffs have a
long-standing relationship with
IT IS ON THIS day
Sam Iola, Esq.
of~017;
ORDERED that Sam Iola, Esq. be and is hereby admitted pro
hac vice in this matter; and
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that Sam Iola, Esq.:
2477830.1
1. Shall abide by the New Jersey Rules of Court, including
all disciplinary rules, R.,_ 1:20-1, R.,_ 1:28-2 and R.,_ l:28B-l(e);
2. Shall consent to the appointment of the Clerk of the
New Jersey Supreme Court as the agent upon whom service of
process may be made for all actions against him that may arise
out of his participation in this matter;
3. Shall notify the Court immediately of any matter
affecting his standing at the bar of any other court;
4. Shall have all pleadings, briefs, and other papers
filed with the Court signed by an attorney of record authorized
to practice in this State, who shall be held responsible for
them, the conduct of the cause and the admitted attorney herein;
5. Shall abide by any further requirements concerning his
participation in this matter as the court from time to time deems
necessary;
6. Cannot be designated as trial counsel; and
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that:
1. No adjournment or delay in discovery, motions, trial,
or any other proceeding shall occur or be requested by reason of
the inability of Sam Iola to be in attendance.
2. Sam Iola shall, within ten (10) days, comply with R.,_
1:20-l(b), R.,_ 1:28-2 and R.,_ l:28B-l(e) by paying the appropriate
fees to the Disciplinary Oversight Committee, to the Lawyers
Assistance Program and the New Jersey Fund for Client Protection
and submit an affidavit of compliance no later than February 1 of
2477830,l
each year thereafter.
3. Automatic termination of pro hac vice admission will
occur for failure to make the required annual payment to the
Disciplinary Oversight Committee, the Lawyers Assistance Program
and the New Jersey Lawyer's Fund for Client Protection. Proof of
such payment, .::.i-Ft-,c::,r fili:r:u~J prnnf of the initial payment, shall be
made no later than February 1 of each year thereafter.
4. Noncompliance with any of these requirements shall
constitute grounds for removal.
5. A copy of this Order shall be served on all parties
within seven (7) days.
Opposed
/unopposed
2477830.1
HON. ANA C. VISCOMI, J.S.C.
SZAFERMAN, LAKIND, BLUMSTEIN & BLADER P.C.
101 Grovers Mill Road, Suite 200 Lawrenceville, N.J. 08648 (609) 275-0400
By: Robert E. Lytle (ID #046331990)
SIMON GREENSTONE PANATIER BARTLETT P.C. 3232 McKinney Ave., Suite 610 FILED
SEP t 5 2017
ANA C. VISCOMI, J.S.C,
Dallas, TX 75204 (214) 276-7680
By: Leah Kagan (ID #013602009)
Attorneys for Plaintiffs
PEGGY CARLSON and JOHN CARLSON,
Plaintiffs,
v.
BORGHESE, INC., et al.,
Defendants.
! SUPERIOR COURT OF NEW JERSEY I LAW DIVISION, MIDDLESEX COUNTY
!. DOCKET NO.: MID-L-3572-l 7AS
Civil Action - Asbestos Litigation
ORDER FOR PRO HAC VICE ADMISSION OF
MISTY FARRIS, ESQ.
'1 ··!
This matter having been opened to the Court on behalf of
Plaintiffs, Peggy Carlson and John Carlson, by Szaferman, Lakind,
Blumstein & Blader, P.C. (Robert E. Lytle, Esq., appearing),
notice to all counsel of record; and this Court having considered
the moving papers, in which it is stated that Plaintiffs have a
long-standing relationship with Misty Farris, Esq.
of~17; IT IS ON THIS 1stA day
ORDERED that Misty Farris, Esq. be and is hereby admitted
pro hac vice in this matter; and
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that Misty Farris, Esq.:
1. Shall abide by the New Jersey Rules of Court, including
2477830.1
7
7
3. Automatic termination of pro hac vice admission will
occur for failure to make the required annual payment to the
Disciplinary Oversight Committee, the Lawyers Assistance Program
and the New Jersey Lawyer's Fund for Client Protection. Proof of
such payment, after filing proof of the initial payment, shall be
made no later than February 1 of each year thereafter.
4. Noncompliance with any of these requirements shall
constitute grounds for removal.
5. A copy of this Order shall be served on all parties
within seven (7) days.
-/pposed
V Unopposed
2477830.l
~c.J~ HON. ANA C. VISCOMI, J.S.C.
COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, P.C. 127 Maple Avenue Red Bank, New Jersey 07701 Tel.: (732) 747-9003 Attorneys for Plaintiffs
PAUL CAROLAN,
Plaintiff,
vs.
3M COMPANY, et al.;
Defendants.
FILED SEP 15 to I z
ANA C. VISCOMI, J.S.C.
SUPERIOR COURT OF NEW JERSEY LAW DIVISION MIDDLESEX COUNTY
DOCKET NO. MID- L-05027-16 AS
CIVIL ACTION ASBESTOS LITIGATION
ORDER
This matter having been opened to the Court by Cohen, Placitella & Roth, P .C., attorneys
for the above named Plaintiffs, for an Order denying Defendant Ductmate Industries, Inc.' s
Motion for Summary Judgment, and for good cause being shown;
IT IS ON THIS /> 1ay of ~017 ORDERED as follows:
The Motion for Summary Judgment of Defendant Ductmate Industries, Inc. is hereby
DENIED;
It is FURTHER ORDERED that a copy of the within Order shall be served upon all
counsel ofrecord within seven (7) days of the date of this entry.
By ~,~c.J~ Ho.ANA C. VISCOMI
On '1, / 5 · {1- the
court's statement of reasons have been set forth on the record.
COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, P.C. 127 Maple Avenue · Red Bank, New Jersey 07701 Tel.: (732) 747-9003 Attorneys for Plaintiffs
FILED SEP 1 5 2017
ANA C. VISCOMI, J.S.C ..
--------------------------------------------------------------------·
PAUL CAROLAN,
Plaintiff,
vs.
3M COMPANY, et al.;
' i SUPERIOR COURT OF NEW JERSEY i LAW DIVISION MIDDLESEX COUNTY ' ' ' i DOCKET NO. MID- L-05027-16 AS ' ' i CIVIL ACTION
ASBESTOS LITIGATION
ORDER Defendants.
This matter having been opened to the Court by Cohen, Placitella & Roth, P .C., attorneys
for the above named Plaintiffs, for an Order denying Defendant Honeywell Inc.' s Motion for
Summary Judgment, and for good cause being shown;
IT IS ON THIS /S''iay of ~17 ORDERED as follows: 7
The Motion for Summary Judgment of Defendant Honeywell Inc. is hereby DENIED;
It is FURTHER ORDERED that a copy of the within Order shall be served upon all
counsel ofrecord within seven (7) days of the date of this entry.
(;J I, By: ',{ A C. u t,.U,1»,_._ _ _'
HO ~AC. VISCOMI
On q,15./"J- the court's statement of reasons have been set forth on the record.
SZAFERMAN, LAKIND, BLUMSTEIN & BLADER P.C.
101 Grovers Mill Road, Suite 200 Lawrenceville, N.J. 08648 (609) 275-0400
By: Robert E. Lytle (ID #046331990)
SIMON GREENSTONE PANATIER BARTLETT P.C. 3232 McKinney Ave., Suite 610
FILED SEP 1 5 2017
ANA C. VISCOMI, J.S.C
Dallas, TX 75204 (214) 276-7680 By: Leah Kagan (ID #013602009)
Attorneys for Plaintiffs
JUSTIN ESSES and STEPHANIE BATTAGLIA-ESSES,
Plaintiffs,
v.
BRENNTAG NORTH AMERICA, INC. (sued individually and as successor-in-interest to MINERAL PIGMENT SOLUTIONS, INC. and as successor-in-interest to WHITTAKER, CLARK & DANIELS, INC. ) , et al . ,
Defendants.
SUPERIOR COURT OF NEW JERSEY LAW DIVISION, MIDDLESEX COUNTY
DOCKET NO.: MID-L-4301-17AS
Civil Action - Asbestos Litigation
ORDER FOR PRO HAC VICE ADMISSION OF
DAVID GREENSTONE, ESQ.
This matter having been opened to the Court on behalf of
Plaintiffs, Justin Esses and Stephanie Battaglia-Esses, by Szaferman,
Lakind, Blumstein & Blader, P.C. (Robert E. Lytle, Esq., appearing),
notice to all counsel of record; and this Court having considered the
moving papers, in which it is stated that Plaintiffs have a long-
standing relationship with David Greenstone, Esq.
day of ~ e~ 01 7; IT IS ON THIS IS~
ORDERED that David Greenstone, Esq. be and is hereby admitted pro
hac vice in this matter; and
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that David Greenstone, Esq.:
2475714.l
1. Shall abide by the New Jersey Rules of Court, including all
disciplinary rules, & 1:20-1, & 1:28-2 and & l:28B-l(e);
2. Shall consent to the appointment of the Clerk of the New
Jersey Supreme Court as the agent upon whom service of process may be
made for all actions against him that may arise out of his
participation in this matter;
3. Shall notify the Court immediately of any matter affecting
him standing at the bar of any other court;
4. Shall have all pleadings, briefs, and other papers filed
with the Court signed by an attorney of record authorized to practice
in this State, who shall be held responsible for them, the conduct of
the cause and the admitted attorney herein;
5. Shall abide by any further requirements concerning his
participation in this matter as the court from time to time deems
necessary;
6. Cannot be designated as trial counsel; and
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that:
1. No adjournment or delay in discovery, motions, trial, or any
other proceeding shall occur or be requested by reason of the
inability of David Greenstone to be in attendance.
2. David Greenstone shall, within ten (10) days, comply with R..,_
1:20-l(b), R..,_ 1:28-2 and R..,_ l:28B-l(e) by paying the appropriate fees
to the Disciplinary Oversight Committee, to the Lawyers Assistance
Program and the New Jersey Fund for Client Protection and submit an
affidavit of compliance no later than February 1 of each year
thereafter.
2475714. l
3. Automatic termination of pro hac vice admission will occur
for failure to make the required annual payment to the Disciplinary
Oversight Committee, the Lawyers Assistance Program and the New Jersey
Lawyer's Fund for Client Protection. Proof of such payment, after
filing proof of the initial payment, shall be made no later than
February 1 of each year thereafter.
4. Noncompliance with any of these requirements shall
constitute grounds for removal.
5. A copy of this Order shall be served on all parties within
seven (7) days.
Opposed
/ Unopposed
2475714.l
a__c.J~ HON. ANA C. VISCOMI, J.S.C.
SZAFERMAN, LAKIND, BLUMSTEIN & BLADER P.C.
101 Grovers Mill Road, Suite 200 Lawrenceville, N.J. 08648 (609) 275-0400 By: Robert E. Lytle (ID #046331990)
SIMON GREENSTONE PANATIER BARTLETT P.C. 3232 McKinney Ave., Suite 610 Dallas, TX 75204 (214) 276-7680
By: Leah Kagan (ID #013602009)
Attorneys for Plaintiffs
FILED SEP 1 5 2017
ANA C. VISCOMI, J.S.C,
JUSTIN ESSES and SUPERIOR COURT OF NEW JERSEY STEPHANIE BATTAGLIA-ESSES, LAW DIVISION, MIDDLESEX COUNTY
Plaintiffs, DOCKET NO.: MID-L-4301-17AS
v. Civil Action - Asbestos Litigation
BRENNTAG NORTH AMERICA, INC. (sued individually and as ORDER FOR PRO HAC VICE successor-in-interest to MINERAL ADMISSION OF PIGMENT SOLUTIONS, INC. and as CHRISTOPHER PANATIER, ESQ. successor-in-interest to WHITTAKER, CLARK & DANIELS, INC.) , et al. ,
Defendants.
This matter having been opened to the Court on behalf of
Plaintiffs, Justin Esses and Stephanie Battaglia-Esses, by Szaferman,
Lakind, Blumstein & Blader, P.C. (Robert E. Lytle, Esq., appearing),
notice to all counsel of record; and this Court having considered the
moving papers, in which it is stated that Plaintiffs have a long-
standing relationship with Christopher Panatier,
__ /_5_~_ day of ~ 7; IT IS ON THIS
Esq.
ORDERED that Christopher Panatier, Esq. be and is hereby admitted
pro hac vice in this matter; and
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that Christopher Panatier, Esq.:
2475714.1
1. Shall abide by the New Jersey Rules of Court, including all
disciplinary rules, R.,_ 1:20-1, R.,_ 1:28-2 and R.,_ 1:28B-l(e);
2. Shall consent to the appointment of the Clerk of the New
Jersey Supreme Court as the agent upon whom service of process may be
made for all actions against him that may arise out of his
participation in this matter;
3. Shall notify the Court immediately of any matter affecting
his standing at the bar of any other court;
4. Shall have all pleadings, briefs, and other papers filed
with the Court signed by an attorney of record authorized to practice
in this State, who shall be held responsible for them, the conduct of
the cause and the admitted attorney herein;
5. Shall abide by any further requirements concerning his
participation in this matter as the court from time to time deems
necessary;
6. Cannot be designated as trial counsel; and
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that:
1. No adjournment or delay in discovery, motions, trial, or any
other proceeding shall occur or be requested by reason of the
inability of Christopher Panatier to be in attendance.
2. Christopher Panatier shall, within ten (10) days, comply
with R.,_ 1:20-l(b), R.,_ 1:28-2 and R.,_ 1:28B-l(e) by paying the
appropriate fees to the Disciplinary Oversight Committee, to the
Lawyers Assistance Program and the New Jersey Fund for Client
Protection and submit an affidavit of compliance no later than
February 1 of each year thereafter.
3. Automatic termination of pro hac vice admission will occur
for failure to make the required annual payment to the Disciplinary
2475714.l
Oversight Committee, the Lawyers Assistance Program and the New Jersey
Lawyer's Fund for Client Protection. Proof of such payment, after
filing proof of the initial payment, shall be made no later than
February 1 of each year thereafter.
4. Noncompliance with any of these requirements shall
constitute grounds for removal.
5. A copy of this Order shall be served on all parties within
seven (7) days.
Opposed
7unopposed
2475714.1
HON. ANA C. VISCOMI, J.S.C.
SZAFERMAN, LAKIND, BLUMSTEIN & BLADER P.C.
101 Grovers Mill Road, Suite 200 Lawrenceville, N.J. 08648 (609) 275-0400 By: Robert E. Lytle (ID #046331990)
SIMON GREENSTONE PANATIER BARTLETT P.C. 3232 McKinney Ave., Suite 610 Dallas, TX 75204 (214) 276-7680 By: Leah Kagan (ID #013602009)
Attorneys for Plaintiffs
FILED SEP 1 5 2017
ANA C. VISCOMI, J.S.C.
JUSTIN ESSES and SUPERIOR COURT OF NEW JERSEY STEPHANIE BATTAGLIA-ESSES, LAW DIVISION - MIDDLESEX COUNTY
Plaintiff, DOCKET NO.: MID-L-4301-17AS
v. Civil Action - Asbestos Litigation
BRENNTAG NORTH AMERICA, INC. (sued individually and as ORDER FOR PRO HAC VICE successor-in-interest to MINERAL ADMISSION OF PIGMENT SOLUTIONS, INC. and as JAY STUEMKE, ESQ. successor-in-interest to WHITTAKER, CLARK & DANIELS, INC. ) , et al . ,
Defendants.
This matter having been opened to the Court on behalf of
Plaintiffs, Justin Esses and Stephanie Battaglia-Esses, by Szaferman,
Lakind, Blumstein & Blader, P.C. (Robert E. Lytle, Esq., appearing),
on short notice to all counsel of record; and this Court having
considered the moving papers, in which it is stated that Plaintiffs
have a long-standing relationship with Jay Stuemke, Esq.
IT IS ON THIS /S!J day of ~17;
ORDERED that Jay Stuemke, Esq. be and is hereby admitted pro hac
vice in this matter; and
2475714.1
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that Jay Stuemke, Esq.:
1. Shall abide by the New Jersey Rules of Court, including all
disciplinary rules, ]L. 1:20-1, ]L. 1:28-2 and ]L. 1:28B-l(e);
2. Shall consent to the appointment of the Clerk of the New
Jersey Supreme Court as the agent upon whom service of process may be
made for all actions against him that may arise out of his
participation in this matter;
3. Shall notify the Court immediately of any matter affecting
his standing at the bar of any other court;
4. Shall have all pleadings, briefs, and other papers filed
with the Court signed by an attorney of record authorized to practice
in this State, who shall be held responsible for them, the conduct of
the cause and the admitted attorney herein;
5. Shall abide by any further requirements concerning his
participation in this matter as the court from time to time deems
necessary;
6. Cannot be designated as trial counsel; and
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that:
1. No adjournment or delay in discovery, motions, trial, or any
other proceeding shall occur or be requested by reason of the
inability of Jay Stuemke to be in attendance.
2. Jay Stuemke shall, within ten (10) days, comply with ]L.
1:20-l(b), ]L. 1:28-2 and ]L. 1:28B-l(e) by paying the appropriate fees
to the Disciplinary Oversight Committee, to the Lawyers Assistance
Program and the New Jersey Fund for Client Protection and submit an
affidavit of compliance no later than February 1 of each year
2475714.l
thereafter.
3. Automatic termination of pro hac vice admission will occur
for failure to make the required annual payment to the Disciplinary
Oversight Committee, the Lawyers Assistance Program and the New Jersey
Lawyer's Fund for Client Protection. Proof of such payment, after
filing proof of the initial payment, shall be made no later than
February 1 of each year thereafter.
4. Noncompliance with any of these requirements shall
constitute grounds for removal.
5. A copy of this Order shall be served on all parties within
seven (7) days.
Opposed
Vunopposed
2475714.1
HON. ANA C. VISCOMI, J.S.C.
SZAFERMAN, LAKIND, BLUMSTEIN & BLADER P.C.
101 Grovers Mill Road, Suite 200 Lawrenceville, N.J. 08648 (609) 275-0400 By: Robert E. Lytle (ID #046331990)
SIMON GREENSTONE PANATIER BARTLETT P.C. 3232 McKinney Ave., Suite 610
FILED SEP 1 5 2017
ANA C. VISCOMI, J.S.C. Dallas, TX 75204 (214) 276-7680 By: Leah Kagan (ID #013602009)
Attorneys for Plaintiffs
JUSTIN ESSES and STEPHANIE BATTAGLIA-ESSES,
Plaintiff,
v.
BRENNTAG NORTH AMERICA, INC. (sued individually and as successor-in-interest to MINERAL PIGMENT SOLUTIONS, INC. and as successor-in-interest to WHITTAKER, CLARK & DANIELS, INC.) , et al. ,
Defendants.
SUPERIOR COURT OF NEW JERSEY LAW DIVISION, MIDDLESEX COUNTY
DOCKET NO.: MID-L-4301-17AS
Civil Action - Asbestos Litigation
ORDER FOR PRO HAC VICE ADMISSION OF
KEVIN PAUL, ESQ.
This matter having been opened to the Court on behalf of
Plaintiffs, Justin Esses and Stephanie Battaglia-Esses, by Szaferman,
Lakind, Blumstein & Blader, P.C. (Robert E. Lytle, Esq., appearing),
notice to all counsel of record; and this Court having considered the
moving papers, in which it is stated that Plaintiffs have a long
standing relationship with Kevin Paul, Esq.
IT IS ON THIS /Sf!. day of ~017;
ORDERED that Kevin Paul, Esq. be and is hereby admitted pro hac
vice in this matter; and
2475714.1
1
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that Kevin Paul, Esq.:
1. Shall abide by the New Jersey Rules of Court, including all
disciplinary rules, R.,_ 1:20-1, R.,_ 1:28-2 and R.,_ 1:28B-l(e);
2. Shall consent to the appointment of the Clerk of the New
Jersey Supreme Court as the agent upon whom service of process may be
made for all actions against him that may arise out of his
participation in this matter;
3. Shall notify the Court immediately of any matter affecting
his standing at the bar of any other court;
4. Shall have all pleadings, briefs, and other papers filed
with the Court signed by an attorney of record authorized to practice
in this State, who shall be held responsible for them, the conduct of
the cause and the admitted attorney herein;
5. Shall abide by any further requirements concerning his
participation in this matter as the court from time to time deems
necessary;
6. Cannot be designated as trial counsel; and
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that:
1. No adjournment or delay in discovery, motions, trial, or any
other proceeding shall occur or be requested by reason of the
inability of Kevin Paul to be in attendance.
2. Kevin Paul shall, within ten (10) days, comply with R.,_ 1:20-
l(b), R.,_ 1:28-2 and R.,_ 1:28B-l(e) by paying the appropriate fees to
the Disciplinary Oversight Committee, to the Lawyers Assistance
Program and the New Jersey Fund for Client Protection and submit an
affidavit of compliance no later than February 1 of each year
2475714.1
thereafter.
3. Automatic termination of pro hac vice admission will occur
for failure to make the required annual payment to the Disciplinary
Oversight Committee, the Lawyers Assistance Program and the New Jersey
Lawyer's Fund for Client Protection. Proof of such payment, after
filing proof of the initial payment, shall be made no later than
February 1 of each year thereafter.
4. Noncompliance with any of these requirements shall
constitute grounds for removal.
5. A copy of this Order shall be served on all parties within
seven (7) days.
2475714.1
Opposed
Unopposed
HON. ANA C. VISCOMI, J.S.C.
SZAFERMAN, LAKIND, BLUMSTEIN & BLADER P.C.
101 Grovers Mill Road, Suite 200 Lawrenceville, N.J. 08648 (609) 275-0400 By: Robert E. Lytle (ID #046331990)
SIMON GREENSTONE PANATIER BARTLETT P.C. 3232 McKinney Ave., Suite 610
FILED SEP 15 2017
ANA C. VISCOMI, J.S.C. Dallas, TX 75204 (214) 276-7680 By: Leab Kagan (ID #013602009)
Attorneys for Plaintiffs
JUSTIN ESSES and STEPHANIE BATTAGLIA-ESSES,
Plaintiff,
v.
BRENNTAG NORTH AMERICA, INC. (sued individually and as successor-in-interest to MINERAL PIGMENT SOLUTIONS, INC. and as successor-in-interest to WHITTAKER, CLARK & DANIELS, INC. } , et al. ,
Defendants.
SUPERIOR COURT OF NEW JERSEY LAW DIVISION, MIDDLESEX COUNTY
DOCKET NO.: MID-L-4301-17AS
Civil Action - Asbestos Litigation
ORDER FOR PRO HAC VICE ADMISSION OF
SAM IOLA, ESQ.
This matter having been opened to the Court on behalf of
Plaintiffs, Justin Esses and Stephanie Battaglia-Esses, by Szaferman,
Lakind, Blumstein & Blader, P.C. (Robert E. Lytle, Esq., appearing},
notice to all counsel of record; and this Court having considered the
moving papers, in which it is stated that Plaintiffs have a long-
standing relationship with Sam Iola, Esq.
IT IS ON THIS ~,.,~
day of' t2017;
ORDERED that Sam Iola, Esq. be and is hereby admitted pro hac
vice in this matter; and
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that Sam Iola, Esq.:
2475714.l
1. Shall abide by the New Jersey Rules of Court, including all
disciplinary rules, IL 1:20-1, IL 1:28-2 and IL 1:28B-l(e);
2. Shall consent to the appointment of the Clerk of the New
Jersey Supreme Court as the agent upon whom service of process may be
made for all actions against him that may arise out of his
participation in this matter;
3. Shall notify the Court immediately of any matter affecting
his standing at the bar of any other court;
4. Shall have all pleadings, briefs, and other papers filed
with the Court signed by an attorney of record authorized to practice
in this State, who shall be held responsible for them, the conduct of
the cause and the admitted attorney herein;
5. Shall abide by any further requirements concerning his
participation in this matter as the court from time to time deems
necessary;
6. Cannot be designated as trial counsel; and
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that:
1. No adjournment or delay in discovery, motions, trial, or any
other proceeding shall occur or be requested by reason of the
inability of Sam Iola to be in attendance.
2. Sam Iola shall, within ten (10) days, comply with IL 1:20-
l(b), IL 1:28-2 and IL 1:28B-l(e) by paying the appropriate fees to
the Disciplinary Oversight Committee, to the Lawyers Assistance
Program and the New Jersey Fund for Client Protection and submit an
affidavit of compliance no later than February 1 of each year
thereafter.
3. Automatic termination of pro hac vice admission will occur
2475714.1
for failure to make the required annual payment to the Disciplinary
Oversight Committee, the Lawyers Assistance Program and the New Jersey
Lawyer's Fund for Client Protection. Proof of such payment, after
filing proof of the initial payment, shall be made no later than
February 1 of each year thereafter.
4. Noncompliance with any of these requirements shall
constitute grounds for removal.
5. A copy of this Order shall be served on all parties within
seven (7) days.
Opposed
L Unopposed
2475714.1
HON. ANA C. VISCOMI, J.S.C.
SZAFERMAN, LAKIND, BLUMSTEIN & BLADER P.C.
101 Grovers Mill Road, Suite 200 Lawrenceville, N.J. 08648 (609) 275-0400 By: Robert E. Lytle (ID #046331990)
SIMON GREENSTONE PANATIER BARTLETT P.C. 3232 McKinney Ave., Suite 610
FILED SEP f 5 2017
ANA C. VISCOMJ, J.S.C.
Dallas, TX 75204 (214) 276-7680 By: Leah Kagan (ID #013602009)
Attorneys for Plaintiffs
JUSTIN ESSES and STEPHANIE BATTAGLIA-ESSES,
Plaintiff,
v.
BRENNTAG NORTH AMERICA, INC. (sued individually and as successor-in-interest to MINERAL PIGMENT SOLUTIONS, INC. and as successor-in-interest to WHITTAKER, CLARK & DANIELS, INC.) ' et al. '
Defendants.
SUPERIOR COURT OF NEW JERSEY LAW DIVISION, MIDDLESEX COUNTY
DOCKET NO.: MID-L-4301-17AS
Civil Action - Asbestos Litigation
ORDER FOR PRO HAC VICE ADMISSION OF
MISTY FARRIS, ESQ.
This matter having been opened to the Court on behalf of
Plaintiffs, Justin Esses and Stephanie Battaglia-Esses, by Szaferman,
Lakind, Blumstein & Blader, P.C. (Robert E. Lytle, Esq., appearing),
notice to all counsel of record; and this Court having considered the
moving papers, in which it is stated that Plaintiffs have a long-
standing relationship with Misty Farris, Esq.
IT IS ON THIS __ /~5-~_ day of ~,...201 7;
ORDERED that Misty Farris, Esq. be and is hereby admitted pro hac
vice in this matter; and
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that Misty Farris, Esq.:
1. Shall abide by the New Jersey Rules of Court, including all
disciplinary rules, L 1:20-1, L 1:28-2 and L 1:28B-l(e);
2475714.1
f
2. Shall consent to the appointment of the Clerk of the New
Jersey Supreme Court as the agent upon whom service of process may be
made for all actions against her that may arise out of her
participation in this matter;
3. Shall notify the Court immediately of any matter affecting
her standing at the bar of any other court;
4. Shall have all pleadings, briefs, and other papers filed
with the Court signed by an attorney of record authorized to practice
in this State, who shall be held responsible for them, the conduct of
the cause and the admitted attorney herein;
5. Shall abide by any further requirements concerning her
participation in this matter as the court from time to time deems
necessary;
6. Cannot be designated as trial counsel; and
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that:
1. No adjournment or delay in discovery, motions, trial, or any
other proceeding shall occur or be requested by reason of the inability
of Misty Farris to be in attendance.
2. Misty Farris shall, within ten (10) days, comply with R.,_
1:20-l(b), R.,_ 1:28-2 and R.,_ 1:28B-l(e) by paying the appropriate fees
to the Disciplinary Oversight Committee, to the Lawyers Assistance
Program and the New Jersey Fund for Client Protection and submit an
affidavit of compliance no later than February 1 of each year
thereafter.
3. Automatic termination of pro hac vice admission will occur
for failure to make the required annual payment to the Disciplinary
Oversight Committee, the Lawyers Assistance Program and the New Jersey
Lawyer's Fund for Client Protection. Proof of such payment, after
filing proof of the initial payment, shall be made no later than 2475714.1
February 1 of each year thereafter.
4. Noncompliance with any of these requirements shall
constitute grounds for removal.
5. A copy of this Order shall be served on all parties within
seven (7) days.
Opposed
V Unopposed
2475714.1
/2,,. C. J~ HON. ANA C. VISCOMI, J.S.C.
WILENTZ, GOLDMAN & SPITZER, 90 Woodbridge Center Drive P.O. Box 10
P.A. f\\..EO
Woodbridge, New Jersey 07095 (732) 636-8000
$£.? \ 15 20\i
Attorneys for Plaintiffs LYNNE M. KIZIS, ESQ. (ID No.
/>J\{\ c. \J\SCOMI, J.S.C-037831987)
---------------------------------------x ROSE ANNE GALLUS, Executrix of the
Estate of ESTELLE GALLUS;
Plaintiff,
vs.
A.J. FRIEDMAN SUPPLY co., INC., et al.;
Defendants. ---------------------------------------x
SUPERIOR COURT OF NEW JERSEY LAW DIVISION-MIDDLESEX COUNTY DOCKET No. MID-L-1079-16AS
ASBESTOS LITIGATION
Civil Action
ORDER
THIS MATTER having been opened to the Court upon the motion of
Wilentz, Goldman & Spitzer, P.A., counsel for plaintiff, and the Court
having considered the moving papers, and for other good and just cause
shown;
IT IS on the \ s day of S{.pi::-mlaes, 2017;
ORDERED that plaintiff is hereby granted leave to file and serve
an Amended Complaint, as set forth in the accompanying Certification, to
name August Arace & Sons, Inc., Flowserve Corporation, John W. Wallace &
Co., Johnson & Johnson, Raritan Valley Plumbing Supply Co., and Spirax
Saree, Inc., as additional defendantsi and
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that all defendants who have been served
with the motion papers shall be deemed to have been served with the Amended
Complaint and defendants' previously filed Answers and Cross-Claims shall be
deemed responsive to the amended pleadingSi and
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that a copy of this Order be served upon
all counsel of record within i days of the date of its entry.
··Having reviewed the above motion, I find it to be meritorious on its face and is unopposed. Pursuant to R.1 :6-2, it therefore will be granted essentially for the reasons set forth in the moving papers."
#9399848.1 (164609.002)
a .. c.J~ ANA C. VISCOMI, J.S.C.
( ff
BY: MARK F. MACDONALD, ESQUIRE ATTY ID# 033541985 FILED
S£p 15 201? Styliades, Mezzanotte & Hasson 520 Walnut Street, Suite 1650 Philadelphia, PA 19106 215-627-3087
ANAc
ATTORNEY FOR DEFENDANT, H.M. ROYAL, INC. · V1scoM l,J.s.c.
ROBERT GRECO
Plaintiff,
vs.
H.M. ROYAL, INC., et al.
SUPERIOR COURT OF NEW JERSEY LAW DIVISION-MIDDLESEX COUNTY
DOCKET NO.: L-2919-16AS CIVIL ACTION
:ORDERFORSUMMARYJUDGMENT Defendants. : OF DEFENDANT
L_---------'----'-----'--==-----
ORDER
This matter having come before the Court on Motion of Styliades, Mezzanotte &Hasson,
attorneys for H.M. Royal, Co., and the Court having reviewed the moving and opposition papers, if
any, and for good cause shown;
ITISONTHIS ~s DAYOF S,p-te,n\oe_r ,2017,ORDERED
that summary judgment is hereby granted and the Complaint and any Counterclaims and Cross
Claims are hereby dismissed with prejudice.
ORDERED that a copy of this Order shall be served upon all counsel within seven (7) days
of the date hereof.
"Having reviewed the above motion, I find_it to be meritorious on its face and is unopposed. Pursuant to R.1:6-2, it therelore will be granted e~sent1ally 10,'. the reasons set forth in the moving papeis.
Honorable Ana C. Viscomi, J.S.C
7
RAWLE & HENDERSON LLP John C. McMeekin II, Esquire,# 036331997
The Widener Building, 16th Floor
SUPERIOR COURT OF NEW JERSEY LAW DIVISION: MIDDLESEX COUNTY
One South Penn Square DOCKET NO. L-5924-13 AS FILED
SEP 1 5 2017 Philadelphia, Pa 19107 (215) 575-4200 Attorneys For Mack Trucks, Inc.
,JAMES HARLEY, INDIVIDUALLY AND AS
EXECUTOR OF THE EST ATE OF JAMES
,JAMIESON HARLEY, JR., AND INDIVIDUAL
HEIRS OF THE ESTA TE OF JAMES ,JAMIESON HARLEY, JR.,
Plaintiffs,
v.
ABEX CORPORATION, et al
Defendants,
, SCOMI, J.S.C. ASBESTOS LITIGATION
CIVIL ACTION
ORDER ADMITTING CHRIS N. KOLOS, ESQUIRE PRO HAC VICE
THIS MATTER having been opened by Rawle & Henderson LLP, attorneys for
Defendant Mack Trucks, Inc., upon application for an Order pursuant to R, I :21-2 granting pro
hac vice admission to Chris N. Kolos, Esquire, and the Court having considered the submission
of the parties and for good cause shown:
IT IS on this IS~ day of 1~2017; ORDERED that the motion is
GRANTED and Chris N. Kolos, Esquire is hereby admitted pro hac vice.
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that there is a finding of good cause shown for the
admission of Chris N. Kolos, Esquire as he has an established long-standing attorney client
relationship with Mack Trucks, Inc. and this matter involves a complex area and Chris N. Kolos,
Esquire is a specialist.
10795115-1
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that Chris N, Kolos, Esquire will be subject to the
following conditions:
( 1) Chris N. Kolos, Esquire shall abide by the New Jersey Court Rules including all
disciplinary rules; and
(2) Chris N. Kolos, Esquire shall consent to the appointment of the Clerk of the
Supreme Court as an agent upon whom service of process may be made for all actions against
him or his firm that may arise out of the attorney's participation in the matter; and
(3) Chris N. Kolos, Esquire shall notify the Couii immediately of any matter affecting
the attorney's standing at the bar of any other court in any jurisdiction; and
(4) All pleadings, briefs, and other papers filed with the Comi shall be signed by an
attorney of record authorized to practice in this State, who shall be responsible for them, the
conduct of the cause and counsel admitted pro hac vice by virtue of this Order; and
(5) Chris N. Kolos, Esquire shall within ten (JO) days of the date of this Order
comply with R. 1 :20-l(b), R. 1 :28-2, and R. I :28B-I (e); and
(6) Chris N. Kolos, Esquire shall not be designated as trial counsel; and
(7) No adjournment or delay in discovery, motions, trial, or any other proceedings
will be requested by reason of Chris N. Kolos' inability to appear; and
(8) Automatic termination of pro hac vice admission shall occur for failure to make
the required annual payment to the Lawyers' Assistance Fund, the Disciplinary Oversight
Committee, and the New Jersey Lawyers' Fund for Client Protection. Proof of such payment,
after filing proof of the initial payment, shall be made no later than February I of each year; and
10795115-1
(9) Noncompliance with any of these requirements shall constitute grounds for
removal; and
Rawle & Henderson LLP shall serve a copy of this Order upon all counsel of record within
seven (7) days of the date of entry hereof.
__ Opposed
Y Unopposed
10795115-l
Honorable Ana C. Viscomi, J.S.C.
SZAFERMAN, LAKIND, BLUMSTEIN & BLADER P.C.
101 Grovers Mill Road, Suite 200 Lawrenceville, N.J. 08648 (609) 275-0400
5 -;
By: Robert E. Lytle (ID #046331990)
FILED SEP 15 2017
ANA C. VISCOM/, J.s.c.
SIMON GREENSTONE PANATIER BARTLETT P.C. 3232 McKinney Ave., Suite 610 Dallas, TX 75204 (214) 276-7680
By: Leah Kagan (ID #013602009)
Attorneys for Plaintiff
JOANN HILL,
Plaintiff,
v.
BRENNTAG NORTH AMERICA, INC. (sued individually and as successor-in-interest to MINERAL PIGMENT SOLUTIONS, INC. and as successor-ininterest to WHITTAKER, CLARK & DANIELS, INC.), et al.,
Defendants.
SUPERIOR COURT OF NEW JERSEY LAW DIVISION, MIDDLESEX COUNTY
DOCKET NO.: MID-L-4526-17AS
Civil Action - Asbestos Litigation
ORDER FOR PRO HAC VICE ADMISSION OF
DAVID GREENSTONE, ESQ.
This matter having been opened to the Court on behalf of
Plaintiff, Joann Hill, by Szaferman, Lakind, Blumstein & Blader,
P.C. (Robert E. Lytle, Esq., appearing), notice to all counsel of
record; and this Court having considered the moving papers, in
which it is stated that Plaintiff has a long-standing
relationship with David Greenstone, Esq.
IT IS ON THIS /5'~ day of ~17;
ORDERED that David Greenstone, Esq. be and is hereby
admitted pro hac vice in this matter; and
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that David Greenstone, Esq.:
1. Shall abide by the New Jersey Rules of Court, including
all disciplinary rules, R.,__ 1:20-1, R.,__ 1:28-2 and R.,__ 1:28B-l(e);
2. Shall consent to the appointment of the Clerk of the
New Jersey Supreme Court as the agent upon whom service of
process may be made for all actions against him that may arise
out of his participation in this matter;
3. Shall notify the Court immediately of any matter
affecting him standing at the bar of any other court;
4. Shall have all pleadings, briefs, and other papers
filed with the Court signed by an attorney of record authorized
to practice in this State, who shall be held responsible for
them, the conduct of the cause and the admitted attorney herein;
5. Shall abide by any further requirements concerning his
participation in this matter as the court from time to time deems
necessary;
6. Cannot be designated as trial counsel; and
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that:
1. No adjournment or delay in discovery, motions, trial,
or any other proceeding shall occur or be requested by reason of
the inability of David Greenstone to be in attendance.
2. David Greenstone shall, within ten (10) days, comply
with R.,__ 1:20-l(b), R.,__ 1:28-2 and R.,__ 1:28B-l(e) by paying the
appropriate fees to the Disciplinary Oversight Committee, to the
Lawyers Assistance Program and the New Jersey Fund for Client
Protection and submit an affidavit of compliance no later than
February 1 of each year thereafter.
3. Automatic termination of pro hac vice admission will
occur for failure to make the required annual payment to the
Disciplinary Oversight Committee, the Lawyers Assistance Program
and the New Jersey Lawyer's Fund for Client Protection. Proof of
such payment, after filing proof of the initial payment, shall be
made no later than February 1 of each year thereafter.
4. Noncompliance with any of these requirements shall
constitute grounds for removal.
5. A copy of this Order shall be served on all parties
within seven (7) days.
Opposed
V Unopposed
t4,.,._c.J~ HON. ANA C. VISCOMI, J.S.C.
SZAFERMAN, LAKIND, BLUMSTEIN & BLADER P.C.
101 Grovers Mill Road, Suite 200 Lawrenceville, N.J. 08648 (609) 275-0400 By: Robert E. Lytle (ID #046331990) FILED
SEP f 5 2017
ANA C. VISCOMI, J.S.C.
SIMON GREENSTONE PANATIER BARTLETT P.C.
3232 McKinney Ave., Suite 610 Dallas, TX 75204 (214) 276-7680 By: Leah Kagan (ID #013602009)
Attorneys for Plaintiff
JOANN HILL,
Plaintiff,
v.
BRENNTAG NORTH AMERICA, INC. (sued individually and as successor-in-interest to MINERAL PIGMENT SOLUTIONS, INC. and as successor-ininterest to WHITTAKER, CLARK & DANIELS, INC.), et al.,
Defendants.
SUPERIOR COURT OF NEW JERSEY LAW DIVISION, MIDDLESEX COUNTY
DOCKET NO.: MID-L-4526-17AS
Civil Action - Asbestos Litigation
ORDER FOR PRO HAC VICE ADMISSION OF
CHRISTOPHER PANATIER, ESQ.
This matter having been opened to the Court on behalf of
Plaintiff, Joann Hill, by Szaferman, Lakind, Blumstein & Blader,
P.C. (Robert E. Lytle, Esq., appearing), notice to all counsel of
record; and this Court having considered the moving papers, in
which it is stated that Plaintiff has a long-standing
relationship with Christopher Panatier, Esq.
IT IS ON THIS /'5'-J!> day of ~017;
ORDERED that Christopher Panatier, Esq. be and is hereby
admitted pro hac vice in this matter; and
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that Christopher Panatier, Esq.:
1. Shall abide by the New Jersey Rules of Court, including
all disciplinary rules, R.,_ 1:20-1, R.,_ 1:28-2 and R.,_ l:28B-l(e);
2. Shall consent to the appointment of the Clerk of the
New Jersey Supreme Court as the agent upon whom service of
process may be made for all actions against him that may arise
out of his participation in this matter;
3. Shall notify the Court immediately of any matter
affecting his standing at the bar of any other court;
4. Shall have all pleadings, briefs, and other papers
filed with the Court signed by an attorney of record authorized
to practice in this State, who shall be held responsible for
them, the conduct of the cause and the admitted attorney herein;
5. Shall abide by any further requirements concerning his
participation in this matter as the court from time to time deems
necessary;
6. Cannot be designated as trial counsel; and
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that:
1. No adjournment or delay in discovery, motions, trial,
or any other proceeding shall occur or be requested by reason of
the inability of Christopher Panatier to be in attendance.
2. Christopher Panatier shall, within ten (10) days,
comply with R.,_ 1:20-l(b), R.,_ 1:28-2 and R.,_ 1:28B-l(e) by paying
the appropriate fees to the Disciplinary Oversight Committee, to
the Lawyers Assistance Program and the New Jersey Fund for Client
Protection and submit an affidavit of compliance no later than
February 1 of each year thereafter.
3. Automatic termination of pro hac vice admission will
occur for failure to make the required annual payment to the
Disciplinary Oversight Committee, the Lawyers Assistance Program
and the New Jersey Lawyer's Fund for Client Protection. Proof of
such payment, after filing proof of the initial payment, shall be
made no later than February 1 of each year thereafter.
4. Noncompliance with any of these requirements shall
constitute grounds for removal.
5. A copy of this Order shall be served on all parties
within seven (7) days.
/ Opposed
Unopposed
HON. ANA C. VISCOMI, J.S.C.
SZAFERMAN, LAKIND, BLUMSTEIN & BLADER P.C.
101 Grovers Mill Road, Suite 200 Lawrenceville, N.J. 08648 (609) 275-0400 By: Robert E. Lytle (ID #046331990) ~ILEo
S£p 15 2017
ANA c. VtscoM,, J.s.c.
SIMON GREENSTONE PANATIER BARTLETT P.C.
3232 McKinney Ave., Suite 610 Dallas, TX 75204 (214) 276-7680 By: Leah Kagan (ID #013602009)
Attorneys for Plaintiff
JOANN HILL,
Plaintiff,
v.
BRENNTAG NORTH AMERICA, INC. (sued individually and as successor-in-interest to MINERAL PIGMENT SOLUTIONS, INC. and as successor-ininterest to WHITTAKER, CLARK & DANIELS, INC.), et al.,
Defendants.
SUPERIOR COURT OF NEW JERSEY
I LAW DIVISION - MIDDLESEX COUNTY
·,.i:, DOCKECTi'vNi'ol.: MID-L-4526-17AS
Action - Asbestos Litigation
ORDER FOR PRO HAC VICE ADMISSION OF
JAY STUEMKE, ESQ.
This matter having been opened to the Court on behalf of
Plaintiff, Joann Hill, by Szaferman, Lakind, Blumstein & Blader,
P.C. (Robert E. Lytle, Esq., appearing), on short notice to all
counsel of record; and this Court having considered the moving
papers, in which it is stated that Plaintiff has a long-standing
relationship with Jay
IT IS ON THIS
Stuemke, Esq.
/'51!, day of ~17;
ORDERED that Jay Stuemke, Esq. be and is hereby admitted pro
hac vice in this matter; and
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that Jay Stuemke, Esq.:
1. Shall abide by the New Jersey Rules of Court, including
all disciplinary rules, R.,_ 1:20-1, R.,_ 1:28-2 and R.,_ l:28B-l(e);
2. Shall consent to the appointment of the Clerk of the
New Jersey Supreme Court as the agent upon whom service of
process may be made for all actions against him that may arise
out of his participation in this matter;
3. Shall notify the Court immediately of any matter
affecting his standing at the bar of any other court;
4. Shall have all pleadings, briefs, and other papers
filed with the Court signed by an attorney of record authorized
to practice in this State, who shall be held responsible for
them, the conduct of the cause and the admitted attorney herein;
5. Shall abide by any further requirements concerning his
participation in this matter as the court from time to time deems
necessary;
6. Cannot be designated as trial counsel; and
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that:
1. No adjournment or delay in discovery, motions, trial,
or any other proceeding shall occur or be requested by reason of
the inability of Jay Stuemke to be in attendance.
2. Jay Stuemke shall, within ten (10) days, comply with R.,_
1:20-l(b), R.,_ 1:28-2 and R.,_ 1:28B-l(e) by paying the appropriate
fees to the Disciplinary Oversight Committee, to the Lawyers
Assistance Program and the New Jersey Fund for Client Protection
and submit an affidavit of compliance no later than February 1 of
each year thereafter.
3. Automatic termination of pro hac vice admission will
occur for failure to make the required annual payment to the
Disciplinary Oversight Committee, the Lawyers Assistance Program
and the New Jersey Lawyer's Fund for Client Protection. Proof of
such payment, after filing proof of the initial payment, shall be
made no later than February 1 of each year thereafter.
4. Noncompliance with any of these requirements shall
constitute grounds for removal.
5. A copy of this Order shall be served on all parties
within seven (7) days.
/ Opposed
Unopposed
HON. ANA C. VISCOMI, J.S.C.
SZAFERMAN, LAKIND, BLUMSTEIN & BLADER P.C.
101 Grovers Mill Road, Suite 200 Lawrenceville, N.J. 08648 (609) 275-0400 By: Robert E. Lytle (ID #046331990) FILED
SEP 15 2017
ANA C. VISCOMI, J.S.C.
SIMON GREENSTONE PANATIER BARTLETT P.C.
3232 McKinney Ave., Suite 610 Dallas, TX 75204 (214) 276-7680 By: Leah Kagan (ID #013602009)
Attorneys for Plaintiff
JOANN HILL,
Plaintiff,
v.
BRENNTAG NORTH AMERICA, INC. (sued individually and as successor-in-interest to MINERAL PIGMENT SOLUTIONS, INC. and as successor-ininterest to WHITTAKER, CLARK & DANIELS, INC.), et al.,
Defendants.
! SUPERIOR COURT OF NEW JERSEY i LAW DIVISION, MIDDLESEX COUNTY
DOCKET NO.: MID-L-4526-17AS
Civil Action - Asbestos Litigation
ORDER FOR PRO HAC VICE ADMISSION OF
SAM IOLA, ESQ.
This matter having been opened to the Court on behalf of
Plaintiff, Joann Hill, by Szaferman, Lakind, Blumstein & Blader,
P.C. (Robert E. Lytle, Esq., appearing), notice to all counsel of
record; and this Court having considered the moving papers, in
which it is stated that Plaintiff has a long-standing
relationship with Sam Iola, Esq.
IT IS ON THIS , ,.,;~ day of~017;
ORDERED that Sam Iola, Esq. be and is hereby admitted pro
hac vice in this matter; and
and submit an affidavit of compliance no later than February 1 of
each year thereafter.
3. Automatic termination of pro hac vice admission will
occur for failure to make the required annual payment to the
Disciplinary Oversight Committee, the Lawyers Assistance Program
and the New Jersey Lawyer's Fund for Client Protection. Proof of
such payment, after filing proof of the initial payment, shall be
made no later than February 1 of each year thereafter.
4. Noncompliance with any of these requirements shall
constitute grounds for removal.
5. A copy of this Order shall be served on all parties
within seven (7) days.
/ Opposed
Unopposed
aw..c.J~ HON. ANA C. VISCOMI, J.S.C.
SZAFERMAN, LAKIND, BLUMSTEIN & BLADER P.C.
101 Grovers Mill Road, Suite 200
Lawrenceville, N.J. 08648 (609) 275-0400 By: Robert E. Lytle (ID #046331990)
SIMON GREENSTONE PANATIER BARTLETT P.C.
3232 McKinney Ave., Suite 610 FILED SEP 15 2017
ANA C. VISCOMI, J.S.C.
Dallas, TX 75204 (214) 276-7680 By: Leah Kagan (ID #013602009)
Attorneys for Plaintiff
JOANN HILL,
Plaintiff,
V.
BRENNTAG NORTH AMERICA, INC.
(sued individually and as successor-in-interest to MINERAL PIGMENT SOLUTIONS, INC. and as successor-ininterest to WHITTAKER, CLARK
& DANIELS, INC.), et al.,
Defendants.
SUPERIOR COURT OF NEW JERSEY
LAW DIVISION, MIDDLESEX COUNTY
DOCKET NO.: MID-L-4526-17AS
Civil Action - Asbestos Litigation
ORDER FOR PRO HAC VICE ADMISSION OF
MISTY FARRIS, ESQ.
This matter having been opened to the Court on behalf of
Plaintiff, Joann Hill, by Szaferman, Lakind, Blumstein & Blader,
P.C. (Robert E. Lytle, Esq., appearing), notice to all counsel of
record; and this Court having considered the moving papers, in
which it is stated that Plaintiff have a long-standing
relationship with Misty Farris,
IT IS ON THIS /5~ day
Esq.
of ~017;
ORDERED that Misty Farris, Esq. be and is hereby admitted
pro hac vice in this matter; and
1 !
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that Misty Farris, Esq.:
1. Shall abide by the New Jersey Rules of Court, including
all disciplinary rules, R.,_ 1:20-1, R.,_ 1:28-2 and R.,_ l:28B-l(e);
2. Shall consent to the appointment of the Clerk of the
New Jersey Supreme Court as the agent upon whom service of
process may be made for all actions against her that may arise
out of her participation in this matter;
3. Shall notify the Court immediately of any matter
affecting her standing at the bar of any other court;
4. Shall have all pleadings, briefs, and other papers
filed with the Court signed by an attorney of record authorized
to practice in this State, who shall be held responsible for
them, the conduct of the cause and the admitted attorney herein;
5. Shall abide by any further requirements concerning her
participation in this matter as the court from time to time deems
necessary;
6. Cannot be designated as trial counsel; and
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that:
1. No adjournment or delay in discovery, motions, trial,
or any other proceeding shall occur or be requested by reason of
the inability of Misty Farris to be in attendance.
2. Misty Farris shall, within ten (10) days, comply with
R.,_ 1:20-l(b), R.,_ 1:28-2 and R.,_ l:28B-l(e) by paying the
appropriate fees to the Disciplinary Oversight Committee, to the
Lawyers Assistance Program and the New Jersey Fund for Client
Protection and submit an affidavit of compliance no later than
February 1 of each year thereafter.
3. Automatic termination of pro hac vice admission will
occur for failure to make the required annual payment to the
Disciplinary Oversight Committee, the Lawyers Assistance Program
and the New Jersey Lawyer's Fund for Client Protection. Proof of
such payment, after filing proof of the initial payment, shall be
made no later than February 1 of each year thereafter.
4. Noncompliance with any of these requirements shall
constitute grounds for removal.
5. A copy of this Order shall be served on all parties
within seven (7) days.
Opposed
Unopposed
HON. ANA C. VISCOMI, J.S.C.
PORZIO, BROMBERG & NEWMAN A Professional Corporation Michelle Molinaro Burke (023772005) 100 Southgate Parkway Morristown, NJ 07962-1997 (973) 538-4006 Attorneys for Defendant E. I. du Pont de Nemours and Company DAWN KLOOCK, Individually and as Executrix and Executrix ad Prosequendum of the Estate of ARNOLD KLOOCK,
Plaintiff,
V.
CALON INSULATION CORPORATION; E. I. du PONT de NEMOURS AND COMPANY, et al.,
Defendants.
SUPERIOR COURT OF NEW JERSEY LAW DIVISION: MIDDLESEX COUNTY DOCKET N°f \t1\:!-0629-13 AS
SEP 1 5 2G17
ANA C. VISCOMI, J.S.C.
ASBESTOS LITIGATION
CIVIL ACTION
ORDER GRANTING SUMMARY JUDGMENT TO DEFENDANT
E. I. DU PONT DE NEMOURS AND COMPANY
This matter having come before the Court on Motion of Porzio, Bromberg & Newman,
P.C., attorneys for E. I. du Pont de Nemours and Company, and the Court having reviewed the
moving and opposition papers, if any, and for good cause shown;
IT IS ON THIS /,£ t!:, DAY OF ~017,
ORDERED that the motion of Defendant E. I. du Pont de Nemours and Company for
summary judgment is hereby granted, and the Complaint and all Cross-Claims are hereby
dismissed with prejudice.
ORDERED that a copy of this Order shall be served on all counsel within seven (7) days
of the date hereof.
3692668
on-2._· /,',Jl: h r~ourt's statement of reasons t e have been set forth on the record.
7 cu~:
ANA C.VISCOMI, J.S.C.
MARKS, O'NEILL, O'BRIEN, DOHERTY & KELLY, P.C. BY: SEBASTIAN A. GOLDSTEIN, ESQUIRE CHERRY TREE CORPORATE CENTER 535 ROUTE 38 EAST, SUITE 501 CHERRY HILL, NJ 08002 (856) 663-4300
1022-99676(SAG)
Plaintiffs,
DAWN KLOOCK INDIVIDUALLY AND AS THE EXECUTRIX OF THE ESTATE OF ARNOLD KLOOCK
v.
Defendants,
NICHOLAS SCHW ALJE, INC. ET AL, et. al.
fl li- I S-1
(,,-Zl-17
ATTORNEYS FOR DEFENDANT, NICHOLAS SCHW ALJE, INf= ILE D
SEP 1 5 2017
FILED ANA C. VISCOMI, J.S.C.
SEP 1 ~
ANA C. \/ISCOMI. J.S.C.
SUPERIOR COURT OF NEW JERSEY LAW DIVISION
MIDDLESEX COUNTY
Docket No. MID-L-2629-13 AS
ASBESTOS LITIGATION Civil Action
den. ORDER FeR: i~ARY JUDGMENT
FOR DEFENDANT NICHOLAS SCHWALJE, INC.
THIS MATTER having come before the court on Motion of Marks, O'Neill, O'Brien,
Doherty & Kelly, P.C., attorneys for defendant, NICHOLAS SCHWALJE, INC., and the Court
having reviewed the moving and opposition papers, if any, and for good cause shown;
ITISONTHIS /5~ DAYOF 7~,2017,
ORDERED the motion of Defe.!l.dant, NICHOLAS SCHW ALJE, INC., for sµmmary ~ - 7J, ~ ~ ~-.,,:.. fo ,.J•tf· a....---
juct_;m;~ ~antsd ~o:'.a~~ any Crnmte~~~~
hereby dismissed Hitft ~11,:eff jz;,~,v.-,.«.<OC, _J 0
ORDERED that a copy of this Order shall be served on all counsel within seven (7) days
of the date hereof.
On q, IS, [t court's statement of the h b reasons
ave een set forth on th e record.
e2J~) Honor ble Ana Viscomi, J.S.C.
(NJ753260.I}
TIERNEY LAW OFFICES, P.C. Mark G. Turner, Esquire Identification No. 032652001 Michael J. Murphy, Esquire Identification No. 025902012 1125 Land Title Bldg 100 S. Broad Street Philadelphia, PA 19110 (215)790-2400 tierneylaw@aol.com Our File Number: 49739-G
ARNOLD KOECHER AND MARY BELL, Husband and "Wife,
Plaintiff( s ),
vs.
3M Co., et al.,
Defendant(s).
Attorneys for Defendant: Elizabeth Industrial Supply Co., a division of Charles F. Guyon (inconectly designated as Elizabeth Industrial Hardware Co., a/k/a Elizabeth Industrial Supply Co., a division
FI LE (j Guyon General Piping, Inc.)
SEP 15 2011-
ANA C. VISCOMI, J.S.C
SUPERIOR COURT OF NEW JERSEY MIDDLESEX COUNTY: LAW DIVISION
DOCKET NO. L-7390-15 AS CIVIL ACTION
ASBESTOS LITIGATION
ORDER
This matter having been brought to the Court on Motion of Tierney Law Offices, P.C.,
attorneys for Defendant, Elizabeth Industrial Supply Co., Inc., for an Order granting Summary
Judgment, and the Court having reviewed the moving papers, and any opposition thereto and for
good cause shown,
, 2017,
ORDERED that Summary Judgment be and is hereby GRANTED m favor of
Defendant, Elizabeth Industrial Supply Co., Inc., dismissing all claims of the Plaintiff and all
claims including cross-claims of all other parties against Elizabeth Industrial Supply Co., Inc.
with prejudice.
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that a copy of this Order shall be served upon all counsel
ofrecord within seven (7) days of the date of this Order.
Opposed Unopposed
on~rable Ana C. Viscomi, J.S.C.
v
"Having reviewed the above motion, I find it to be meritorious on its face and is unopposed. Pursuant to R.1 :6-2, it therefore will be granted essentially for the reasons set forth in the moving papers."
COHEN, PLACITELLA & ROTH, P.C. 127 Maple Avenue Red Bank, New Jersey 07701 Tel.: (732) 747-9003 Attorneys for Plaintiff(s)
MARY BELL, Individually; GARY KOECHER, as Executor of the Estate of ARNOLD KOECHER and Individual Heirs of ARNOLD KOECHER,
Plaintiffs,
vs.
3M COMPANY; et al.
Defendants.
SUPERIOR COURT OF NEW JERSEY LAW DIVISION MIDDLESEX COUNTY
DOCKET NO. MID-L-7390-15 AS
CIVIL ACTION ASBESTOS LITIGATION
ORDER FILED
SEP 1 5 ?.D17
ANA C. VISCOMI, J.S.C.
This matter having been opened to the Court by Cohen, Placitella & Roth, P .C., attorneys
for the above named Plaintiffs, for an Order denying Defendant S. Franklin & Sons, Inc.'s
Motion for Sununary Judgment, and for good cause being shown;
IT IS ON THIS /S~ay of ~ 2017 ORDERED as follows: I
The Motion for Summary Judgment of Defendant S. Franklin & Sons, Inc. is hereby
DENIED;
It is FURTHER ORDERED that a copy of the within Order shall be served upon all
counsel of record within seven (7) days of the date of this entry.
1
C UUUm-.·
On q. I ~ , Cl: the court's statement of reasons have been set forth on the record.
17
McGIVNEY, KLUGER & COOK, P.C.
Derrick A. Grant, Esq. (I.D. No. 165052015)
23 Vreeland Road, Suite 220 Florham Park, NJ 07932 973-822-1110 Attorneys for the Defendant, Hoke, Inc.
PAUL LYNCH,
FILED SEP 1 5 2017
ANA C. VISCOMI, J.S.G.
)
776-110
SUPERIOR COURT OF NEW JERSEY
Plaintiff(s), LAW DIVISION: MIDDLESEX COUNTY
DOCKET NO.: MID-L-4567-13AS
v.
A.J. FRIEDMAN SUPPLY CO., INC., et al.,
Defendants.
Civil Action Asbestos Litigation
ORDER
THIS MATTER having been opened to the Court by application of Defendant, Hoke,
Inc., by and through its attorneys, McGivney, Kluger & Cook, P.C., for an Order granting
summary judgment in favor of Hoke, Inc., and the Court having read the submissions of counsel
and considered the oral arguments presented, if any, and for good cause having been shown,
IT IS on this IS ~day of /'-~017; V
~ that the Motion for Summary Judgment of Defendant, Hoke, Inc., is hereby
granted and that Plaintiffs Complaint and any and all cross-claims asserted against this
Defendant are hereby dismissed with ptej udice; and it is fmther;
ORDERED that a copy of this Order shall be served upon all attorneys of record within
seven (7) days of the date hereof.
~-
__ Opposed __ Unopposed
{f1558759-l}
0 .,s-1r h on __ i:__~-::----t e court's statement of reasons have been set forth on the record.
WILENTZ, GOLDMAN & SPITZER, 90 Woodbridge Center Drive P.O. Box 10 Woodbridge, New Jersey 07095 (732) 636-8000 Attorneys for Plaintiffs LYNNE M. KIZIS, ESQ. (ID No.
P.A. f\t.E.0 m(l
sf'? '':I O''\ .i.s.C
\J\SC '"' ' 037831987 )p,_~/1-c.
( cJ .. ~/ ! .
SUPERIOR COURT OF NEW JERSEY LAW DIVISION-MIDDLESEX COUNTY DOCKET No. MID-L-5822-16AS
---------------------------------------x DAVID MAX and REBEKKA RUDIN,
his wife;
Plaintiffs,
vs.
MAX LUMBER & MILLWORK CORP., et al.;
Defendants. ---------------------------------------x
ASBESTOS LITIGATION
Civil Action
ORDER
THIS MATTER having been opened to the Court upon the motion of
Wilentz, Goldman & Spitzer, P.A., counsel for Plaintiffs, and the Court
having considered the moving papers, and for other good and just cause
shown;
IT IS on the / 5~ day of ~ / 2017;
ORDERED that Plaintiffs are hereby granted leave to file and
7 i
serve an Amended Complaint, as set forth in the accompanying Certification,
to name A.J. Friedman Supply Co., Inc., A.W. Chesterton Company, Allied
Building Products Corp., Amtico International, Inc., Bayonne Steel Products
Co., Bird Incorporated Of Massachusetts, Caulktite Corporation, CBS
Corporation, Certainteed Corporation, Dashco, Inc., Elizabeth Industrial
Hardware Co., Fort Kent Holdings, Inc., Georgia-Pacific LLC, Global
Management, Inc., Greene Tweed & Company, Inc., Homasote Company,
International Paper Company, Jersey Gypsum Supply Co. Inc., Kane Carpet Co.,
Inc., Kenseal Construction Products, LLC., Lafarge North America Inc., Major
Incorporated, Minnesota Mining & Manufacturing Company, Northern Jersey
Reserve Supply, Notte Safety Appliance Company, Paint Applicator Corporation
Of America, P.R.F., Inc., Spirax Sarao, Inc., Tamko Building Products, Inc.,
and United Roofing & Building Materials Co., Inc., as additional defendants;
#9384843.1 (164830.002)
and
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that all Defendants who have been served
with the motion papers shall be deemed to have been served with the Amended
Complaint and Defendants' previously filed Answers and Cross-Claims shall be
deemed responsive to the amended pleadings; and
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that a copy of this Order be served upon
all counsel of record within L days of the date of its entry,
"Having reviewed the above motion, I find it to be meritorious on its face and is unopposed. Pursuant to R.1 :6-2, it therefore will be granted essentially for the reasons set forth in the moving papers."
#9384843.1 (164830.002)
ANA C. VISCOMI, J.S.C.
WILENTZ, GOLDMAN & SPITZER, P.A. 90 Woodbridge Center Drive P.O. Box 10 Woodbridge, New Jersey 07095 (732) 636-8000 Attorneys for Plaintiffs
f\\..e.o St~ \ 5 ?.0\1
r,.N/>. C. \J\SCOl-AI, J,S,C,
LYNNE M. KIZIS, ESQ. (ID No. 037831987)
SUPERIOR COURT OF NEW JERSEY LAW DIVISION-MIDDLESEX COUNTY DOCKET No. MID-L-2986-17AS
---------------------------------------x JOSEPH C. OSBORNE;
Plaintiff,
vs.
OWENS-ILLINOIS, INC.;
Defendants. ---------------------------------------x
ASBESTOS LITIGATION
Civil Action
ORDER
THIS MATTER having been opened to the Court upon the motion
of Wilentz, Goldman & Spitzer, P.A., counsel for plaintiff, and the Court
having considered the moving papers, and for other good and just cause
shown;
IT IS on the IS ORDERED that plaintiff is hereby granted leave to file and
serve an Amended Complaint, as set forth in the accompanying
Certification, to name, David Joseph Osborne, as Executor of The
Estate of Joseph C. Osborne and to set forth his claims pursuant to
the New Jersey Wrongful Death statute; and
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that all defendants who have been
served with the motion papers shall be deemed to have been served with
the Amended Complaint and defendants' previously filed Answers and Cross
Claims shall be deemed responsive to the amended pleadings; and
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that a copy of this Order be served
upon all counsel of record within 1- days of the date of its entry.
"Having reviewed the above motion, I find. it to be meritorious on its face and 1s unopposed. Pursuant to R.1:6-2, ii therefore will be granted essentially for the reasons set forth in the moving papers."
#9382431.1 (165701.002)
~c.J~ ANA C. VISCOMI, J.S.C.
RAWLE & HENDERSON LLP
John C. McMeekin II, Esquire, # 036331997
The Widener Building, 16th Floor One South Penn Square Philadelphia, Pa 19107 (215) 575-4200 Attorneys for American Biltrite Inc.
SAMUEL PELLOT, JR., AS
EXECUTOR OF THE EST ATE OF
SAMUEL PELLOT, SR., DECEASED,
Plaintiff,
v.
AIR & LIQUID SYSTEMS CORP., et al.
Defendants,
SUPERIOR COURT OF NEW JERSEY
LAW DIVISION: MIDDLESEX COUNTY
DOCKET NO. L-1332-15 AS
ASBESTOS LITIGATION
CIVIL ACTION
fFILEo SEP 15 2017
ANAc V · ISCOMJ ,J.s.c.
ORDER ADMITTING JON ALLARD,
JR., ESQUIRE PRO HAC VICE
THIS MATTER having been opened by Rawle & Henderson LLP, attorneys for
Defendant American Biltrite Inc. upon application for an Order pursuant to ,R. 1 :21-2 granting
pro hac vice admission to Jon Allard, Jr., Esquire, and the Court having considered the
submission of the parties and for good cause shown:
IT IS on this /S~day of~2017; ORDERED that the motion is
GRANTED and Jon Allard, Jr. is hereby admitted pro hac vice.
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that there is a finding of good cause shown for the
admission of Jon Allard, Jr., Esquire as he has an established long-standing attorney client
relationship with American Biltrite Inc., and this matter involves a complex area and Jon Allard,
Jr. is a specialist.
10774098-1
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that Jon Allard, Jr., Esquire will be subject to the
following conditions:
(I) Jon Allard, Jr., Esquire shall abide by the New Jersey Court Rules including all
disciplinary rules; and
(2) Jon Allard, Jr., Esquire shall consent to the appointment of the Clerk of the
Supreme Court as an agent upon whom service of process may be made for all actions against
him or his firm that may arise out of the attorney's participation in the matter; and
(3) Jon Allard, Jr., Esquire shall notify the Court immediately of any matter affecting
the attorney's standing at the bar of any other court in any jurisdiction; and
( 4) All pleadings, briefs, and other papers filed with the Court shall be signed by an
attorney of record authorized to practice in this State, who shall be responsible for them, the
conduct of the cause and counsel admitted pro hac vice by virtue of this Order; and
(5) Jon Allard, Jr., Esquire shall within ten (JO) days of the date of this Order comply
withR. l:20-J(b),R. l:28-2,andR. l:28B-l(e);and
(6) Jon Allard, Jr. shall not be designated as trial counsel; and
(7) No adjournment or delay in discovery, motions, trial, or any other proceedings
will be requested by reason of Jon Allard, Jr. 's inability to appear; and
(8) Automatic termination of pro hac vice admission shall occur for failure to make
the required annual payment to the Lawyers' Assistance Fund, the Disciplinary Oversight
Committee, and the New Jersey Lawyers' Fund for Client Protection. Proof of such payment,
after filing proof of the initial payment, shall be made no later than February I of each year; and
(9) Noncompliance with any of these requirements shall constitute grounds for
removal; and
10774098-J
Rawle & Henderson LLP shall serve a copy of this Order upon all counsel of record within
seven (7) days of the date of entry hereof.
__ Opposed
i/onopposed
10774098-1
Honorable Ana C. Viscomi, J.S.C.
RAWLE & HENDERSON LLP
John C. McMeekin II, Esquire,# 036331997
The Widener Building, 1611' Floor
One South Penn Square
Philadelphia, Pa 19107
(215) 575-4200 Attorneys for American Biltrite Inc,
SAMUEL PELLOT, JR., AS
EXECUTOR OF THE ESTATE OF
SAMUEL PELLOT, SR., DECEASED,
Plaintiff,
v.
AIR & LIQUID SYSTEMS CORP., et al.
Defendants,
SUPERIOR COURT OF NEW JERSEY
LAW DIVISION: MIDDLESEX COUNTY
DOCKET NO. L-1332-15 AS
ASBESTOS LITIGATION
CIVIL ACTION
FILED Sfp 15 2017
c. VtscoM, ,J.s.c
ORDER ADMITTING DAVID J. FISHER,
ESQUIRE PRO HAC VICE
THIS MATTER having been opened by Rawle & Henderson LLP, attorneys for
Defendant American Biltrite Inc. upon application for an Order pursuant to R, I :21-2 granting
pro hac vice admission to David J. Fisher, Esquire, and the Court having considered the
submission of the parties and for good cause shown:
IT IS on this IS~ day of~2017; ORDERED that the motion is
GRANTED and David J. Fisher is hereby admitted pro hac vice.
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that there is a finding of good cause shown for the
admission of David J. Fisher, Esquire as he has an established long-standing attorney client
relationship with American Biltrite Inc., and this matter involves a complex area and David J.
Fisher is a specialist.
10766632·1
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that David J. Fisher, Esquire will be subject to the
following conditions:
(1) David J. Fisher, Esquire shall abide by the New Jersey Court Rules including all
disciplinary rules; and
(2) David J. Fisher, Esquire shall consent to the appointment of the Clerk of the
Supreme Court as an agent upon whom service of process may be made for all actions against
him or his firm that may arise out of the attorney's participation in the matter; and
(3) David J. Fisher, Esquire shall notify the Court immediately of any matter
affecting the attorney's standing at the bar of any other court in any jurisdiction; and
(4) All pleadings, briefs, and other papers filed with the Court shall be signed by an
attorney of record authorized to practice in this State, who shall be responsible for them, the
conduct of the cause and counsel admitted pro hac vice by virtue of this Order; and
(5) David .J. Fisher, Esquire shall within ten (10) days of the date of this Order
comply with R. 1:20-l(b), R. 1 :28-2, and R. 1 :28B-l(e); and
(6) David J. Fisher shall not be designated as trial counsel; and
(7) No adjournment or delay in discovery, motions, trial, or any other proceedings
will be requested by reason of David J. Fisher's inability to appear; and
(8) Automatic termination of pro hac vice admission shall occur for failure to make
the required annual payment to the Lawyers' Assistance Fund, the Disciplinary Oversight
Committee, and the New Jersey Lawyers' Fund for Client Protection. Proof of such payment,
after filing proof of the initial payment, shall be made no later than February 1 of each year; and
(9) Noncompliance with any of these requirements shall constitute grounds for
removal; and
I 0766632-1
Rawle & Henderson LLP shall serve a copy of this Order upon all counsel of record within
seven (7) days of the date of entry hereof,
__ Opposed
/unopposed
10766632-1
Honorable Ana C. Viscomi, J.S.C.
Robert M. Gilmartin, Jr. Attorney I.D. No: 22991998
TANENBAUM KEALE, LLP One Newark Center, 16th Floor
Newark, New Jersey 07102 (973) 242-0002 Attorneys for Defendant, Caterpillar Inc, improperly
plead as Caterpillar Inc., Individually and as
Successor in Interest to Perkins Engines Company
Limited
FILED SEP 15 2011
ANA C. VISCOM/, J.S.C.
RICHARD PETRUSHEVICH,
Plaintiff,
-against-
SUPERIOR COURT OF NEW JERSEY
LAW DIVISION: MIDDLESEX COUNTY
DOCKET NO. MID-L-3447-17AS
Civil Action
ORDER GRANTING MOTION TO
CATERPILLAR INC., et al., DISMISS DEFENDANT CATERPILLAR
INC., AS SUCCESSOR TO PERKINS
Defendants. : ENGINES COMP ANY LIMITED,
PURSUANT TO R. 4:6-2.
Tills MATTER having come before the Court on Motion of Tanenbaum Keale, LLP,
attorneys for defendant Caterpillar Inc, improperly plead as Caterpillar Inc., Individually and as
Successor in Interest to Perkins Engines Company Limited, and the Court having reviewed the
moving and opposition papers, if any, and for good cause shown;
IT IS ON THIS \:) day of s e..:p4en.be_c- , 2017,
ORDERED that the motion of Defendant, Caterpillar Inc. to dismiss claims against
Caterpillar Inc., as Successor to Perkins Engines Company Limited is hereby granted, and the
Complaint and any Counterclaims and Cross-Claims against Caterpillar Inc., as Successor to
Perkins Engines Company Limited are hereby dismissed; and it is further
ORDERED that the Court's decision on this motion does not impact plaintiffs claims
against Caterpillar Inc., Individually; and it is further
7
ORDERED that a copy of this Order shall be served on all counsel within seven (7) days
of the date hereof.
"Having reviewed the above motion, I find_it to be meritorious on its face and 1s unopposed. Pursuant to R.1 :6-2, it therefore will be granted essentially for the reasons set forth in the moving papers."
Honorable Ana C. Viscomi, J.S.C.
{
MARC B. SCHLESINGER (ATTORNEY ID #027992010)
VEDDER PRICE P.C. FILED SEP 1 5 2017
ANA C. VISCOMI, J.S.C
1633 BROADWAY, 318T FLOOR
NEW YORK, NEW YORK 10019 TEL.: (212) 407-7700 ATTORNEYS FOR DEFENDANT ENESCO LLC
MATTHEW RASCO, individually and as Executor and Executor ad Prosequendum of the Estate of SHARLENE RASCO,
Plaintiffs,
vs.
BRENNTAG NORTH AMERICA, INC. (sued individually and as successor-in-interest to MINERAL PIGMENT SOLUTIONS, INC., as successor-in-interest to WHITTAKER, CLARK & DANIELS, INC.) ;
BRENNTAG SPECIALTIES, INC., f/k/a MINERAL PIGMENT SOLUTIONS, INC., as successorin-interest to WHITTAKER, CLARK
& DANIELS, INC. ;
COLGATE-PALMOLIVE COMPANY (sued
individually and as successorin-interest to THE MENNEN COMPANY);
CYPRUS AMAX MINERALS COMPANY (sued individually and as successor to SIERRA TALC COMPANY and UNITED TALC COMPANY);
ENESCO LLC f/k/a ENESCO GROUP, INC. (sued individually and as
successor-in-interest to STANHOME, INC. f/k/a STANLEY HOME PRODUCTS, INC.);
NEWYORK/#465891
1
SUPERIOR COURT OF NEW JERSEY LAW DIVISION: MIDDLESEX COUNTY
DOCKET NO.: MID-L-2857-16AS
Civil Action
Asbestos Litigation
ORDER GRANTING DEFENDANT ENESCO LLC'S
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
I . I
FULLER INDUSTRIES LLC f/k/a FULLER BRUSH INDUSTRIES LLC
(sued as successor-in-interest
to STANLEY HOME PRODUCTS, INC.) ;
GEORGIA PACIFIC CONSUMER
OPERATIONS, LLC;
WHITTAKER CLARK & DANIELS,
INC.;
JOHN DOE CORPORATIONS 1-50
(fictitious);
BUCKINGHAM PARTNERS II, L.P., sued individually and as successor-in-interest to CPAC,
INC. and STANLEY HOME PRODUCTS,
INC. and THE FULLER BRUSH COMPANY;
CPAC, INC. d/b/a THE FULLER
BRUSH COMPANY (sued individually and as successor
in-interest to STANLEY HOME
PRODUCTS INC. ;
VICTORY PARK CAPITAL ADVISORS,
LLC (sued individually and as
successor-in-interest to FULLER
BRUSH COMPANY, and STANLEY HOME
PRODUCTS, INC.);
BUCKINGHAM CAPITAL PARTNERS,
II, L.P.; sued individually and
as successor-in-interest to CPAC, INC., and STANLEY HOME
PRODUCTS, INC., and THE FULLER
BRUSH COMPANY;
VPC FULLER BRUSH OPERATING
CORP., d/b/a The Fuller Brush
Company;
Defendants.
NEWYORK/#465891
2
This matter having been brought before the Court on motion
for summary judgment by Vedder Price P.C., 1633 Broadway, 31st
Floor, New York, New York 10019, attorneys for Defendant Enesco
LLC ( "Enesco") , which is improperly identified in this case as
"Enesco LLC f/k/a Enesco Group, Inc. (sued individually and as
successor-in-interest to Stanhome, Inc. f/k/a Stanley Home
Products, Inc.) , " and the Court having considered the papers
submitted and for good cause shown;
It is on this 16 day of ~p\e--,..,......\oe_(""' '
2017,
ORDERED, that Enesco's motion for summary judgment is
hereby granted; and
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED, that plaintiffs' complaint and all
amended complaints and any and all claims, counterclaims and
crossclaims of any k;ind asserted against Enesco in the above
captioned litigation are dismissed as against Enesco with
prejudice; and
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that a copy of this Order shall be
served upon all parties in interest within __± days of the
date or receipt hereof by the moving party.
3 NEWYORK/#465891
Dated: JJ.i.l.l>y---,~2no11
Papers filed with the Court:
* ( ) Answering papers
) Reply papers
* List parties if necessary
NEWYORK/#465891
4
a.c.J~ Honorable Ana C. Viscomi, J.S.C.
"Having reviewed the above motion, J find it to be meritorious on its face and is unopposed. Pursuant to R.1 :6-2, it therefore will be granted essentially for the reasons set forth in the moving papers."
MARKS, O'NEILL, O'BRIEN, DOHERTY & KELLY, P.C. BY: SEBASTIAN A. GOLDSTEIN, ESQ ATTORNEY ID: 040052001 535 ROUTE 38 EAST, SUITE 501 CHERRY HILL, NJ 08002 (856) 663-4300
242-93662(SAG)
Plaintiffs,
YVONNE REILLY, Executrix of the Estate of THOMAS A. REILLY, SR.
v.
Defendants,
BAYONNE PLUMBING SUPPLY CO., INC., et. al.
ATTORNEYS FOR DEFENDANT, BAYONNE PLUMBING SUPPLY CO., INC.
FILED FILED
SEP 1" • SEP 1 5 1,"'7
ANA C. VISCOMt~tt. VISCOMI, J.S.C.
SUPERIOR COURT OF NEW JERSEY LAW DIVISION
MIDDLESEX COUNTY
Docket No. L-1562-12 AS
ASBESTOS LITIGATION Civil Action
d '"1y ORDER ~MNIARY JUDGMENT
FOR DEFENDANT BAYONNE PLUMBING SUPPLY CO., INC.
THIS MATTER having come before the comi on Motion of Marks, 0 'Neill, 0 'Brien,
Doherty & Kelly, P.C., attorneys for defendant, BAYONNE PLUMBING SUPPLY CO., INC.,
and the Court having reviewed the moving and opposition papers, if any, and for good cause
shown; 0 ,_ , ITISONTHIS 15~ DAYOF
7~ ,2017
ORDERED the motion of Defenda BAYONNE PLUMBING SUPPLY CO., INC., for
summary judgment is hereby
m-e hereby clismissed witb prejudice.
ORDERED that a copy of this Order shall be served on all counsel within seven (7) days
of the date hereof.
On Cr,/~·/'f the court's statement of reasons · ,.·, ·,,,._,,;
have been set forth on the record.
{NJ776170.J}
MARKS, O'NEILL, O'BRIEN,
DOHERTY & KELLY, P.C. BY: SEBASTIAN A. GOLDSTEIN, ESQ.
ATTORNEY ID: 040052001 535 ROUTE 38 EAST, SUITE 501
CHERRY HILL, NJ 08002 (856) 663-4300
242-98897(SAG)
Plaintiffs,
JOSEPH REILLY
v.
Defendants,
BAYONNE PLUMBING SUPPLY CO.,
INC., et. al.
ATTORNEYS FOR DEFENDANT,
BAYONNE PLUMBING SUPPLY CO., INC.
FILED SEP 15 Wl7
ANA C. VISCOMI, J.S.C.
SUPERIOR COURT OF NEW JERSEY LAW DIVISION
MIDDLESEX COUNTY
Docket No. L-762-14 AS
ASBESTOS LITIGATION Civil Action
de.VJ ';,i,; n 'S.,-0 RD ER Fi8R SU~ARY JUDGMENT
FOR DEFENDANT BAYONNE PLUMBING SUPPLY CO., INC.
THIS MATTER having come before the court on Motion of Marks, O'Neill, O'Brien,
Doherty & Kelly, P.C., attorneys for defendant, BAYONNE PLUMBING SUPPLY CO., INC.,
and the Court having reviewed the moving and opposition papers, if any, and for good cause
shown;
ITISONTHIS f $~ DAYOF ;&/~,2017,
ORDERED the motion ~t, BA?ott PLUMBING SUPPLY CO., INC., for
summary judgment is hereby grnnted aru:l the Complaint and any Counterclaims and Cross-Claims
are hereby dismissed with prejudice.
ORDERED that a copy of this Order shall be served on all counsel within seven (7) days
of the date hereof.
_on --:Lj_£_j_ 9--·-0ll rl s statement f--------- the .. h b o reason
ave een set forth on th s erecord.
{NJ443 l30. l}
7
HOAGLAND, LONGO MORAN, DUNST & DOUKAS,LLP ATTORNEYS AT LAW
NORTH JERSEY 40PATERSONST PO BOX460 NEWBRUNSV'ACK, NJ
SOUTH JERSEY 701 V'-llLTSEY'S MILL RD SUITE202 HM/MONTON, NJ
Mti l ~o
Li Jl
Jillian E. Madison, Esq. (ID# 015962012) HOAGLAND, LONGO, MORAN, DUNST & DOUKAS, LLP 40 Paterson Street, PO Box 480 FILED
SEP 1 5 2017
ANA C. VISCOMI, J.S,C,
New Brunswick, NJ 08903 (732) 545-4717 Attorneys for Defendant, Whittaker Clark & Daniels, Inc.
Plaintiff( s ),
CAROL SCHOENIGER,
vs.
Defendant( s ),
SUPERIOR COURT OF NEW JERSEY MIDDLESEX COUNTY LAW DIVISION
DOCKET NO. MID-L-5869-16
ASBESTOS LITIGATION
BRENNTAG NORTH AMERICA, INC., et al. CIVIL ACTION 1.,
~ 111111 if ORDER ffiR SUMMARY JUDGMENT ill
,:,.J.,~ -THIS MATTER having been brought beC'the Court on IV1otl6n :~-;:;~Jand, ongo,
Moran, Dunst & Doukas, attorneys for the Defendant, Whittaker, Clark & Daniels, Inc., for an
Order granting said Defendant Summary Judgment in the within cause of action, and the .. Court
having reviewed the moving papers and for good cause shown;
IT IS ON THIS /S~day of 7~J.µ.,._., , 2017,
ORDERED that Defendant, Whittaker, Clark & Daniels, lnc.'s, Motion for Summary
a.., /. ~ {,µ.; ~ Judgment be and is hereby granted in favor of said Defendirnt and that any ar,d all claims,
counterelaims, and/or orossclaims asserted against this Dsfe~ he'.~"~
~J .... ,.,p d.,g,I ft, c,n,.,J- s (~!..A) o..,..,J.. W'I u q
pr~; and "' /-1 ~ J.i.,L- ~"""if-
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that a copy of the within Order shall be served upon all
counsel of record within seven (7) days of the date hereof.
~cJ~. Papers filed with the Court THE HONORABLE ANA C. VISCOMI, J.S.C.
( ---f Answering Papers
( ,{Reply Papers
The within Notice of Motion was:
( --1 Opposed
( ) Unopposed On 9· /S. ('t the court's statement of reasons have been set forth on the record.
Stephanie L. Coleman, Esq. (NJ Attorney ID: 00428-2008)
ECKERT SEAMANS CHERIN & MELLOTT, LLC FIL ED Four Gateway Center, Suite 401
100 Mulberry Street $£p 15 2011 Newark New Jersey 07102 ANA (973) 855-4700 c. VtscoM, J Attorneys for Defendant A. 0. Smith Water Prodncts Company ' .S.C.
MARY SCHULTZ, Plaintiff,
v.
A.O. SMITH WATER PRODUCTS CO., et al.,
Defendant(s).
SUPERIOR COURT OF NEW JERSEY LAW DIVISION - MIDDLESEX COUNTY
DOCKET NO.: MID-L-6996-15 AS
Civil Action Asbestos Litigation
ORDER
THIS MATTER having come before the Court on Motion of ECKERT SEAMANS CHERIN
& MELLOTT, LLC, Attorneys for Defendant A. 0. Smith Water Products Company ("A. 0. Smith")
and the Court having reviewed the moving and opposition papers, if any, and for good cause
shown;
IT IS on this I '5 day of 5:..,_pt,..,.-.\c::;ec- , 2017;
ORDERED that the Motion for Summary Judgment filed on behalf of Defendant A. 0.
":Dec,·, ed. . Smith is hereby grantee! m,d the Complaint ancl any Cottnterelaims and Cross-Claims are bereb¥
-0isnrissed witlr prejudice.-
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that a copy of this Order shall be served on all counsel
within seven (7) days of the date of this Order.
/4posed
~Unopposed
{S0051900.1)
Honorable Ana C. Viscomi, J.S.C.
On -~q~, 1-I ::...f~· /-:-1-' __ the court's statement of reasons have been set forth on the record.
WHITE AND WILLIAMS LLP BY: Victor J. Zarrilli Identification No(s). 034392002 Libe1iyView I 457 Haddonfield Road, Suite 400 I Che11'y Hill, NJ 08002-2220 856.317.3600 Attorney for Defendant, Bradford White Corporation
MARY SCHULTZ
V.
Plaintiff,
A.O. SMITH WATER PRODUCTS CO., et al.
Defendants.
I
FILED SEP 1 5 2011'
ANA C. VISCOMI, J.S.C
SUPERIOR COURT OF NEW JERSEY LAW DIVISION - MIDDLESEX COUNTY DOCKET NO.: MID-L-6996-15AS
CIVIL ACTION -ASBESTOS LITIGATION
ORDER
THIS MATTER having been opened to the Court by White and Williams, LLP, counsel
for Defendant, Bradford White Corporation, and this Court having read and considered the
papers filed in support of its Motion for Summary Judgment, as well as any papers served upon
the Court in opposition to the Motion, argument of counsel, if any, and for good cause shown;
IT IS on this~ day of ~p¾'r<ikt.<2017, hereby:
ORDERED that the Motion for Summary Judgment of Defendant Bradford White
Corporation to dismiss Plaintiffs Amended Complaint and any and all cross-claims with
prejudice as against Defendant Bradford White Corporation is hereby GRANTED; and
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that Plaintiffs Amended Complaint, all prior complaints,
as well as any and all cross-claims against Defendant Bradford White Corporation are hereby
DISMISSED WITH PREJUDICE; and
l9175054v.1
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that a copr of this Order shall be served on all counsel
within seven (7) days of receipt hereof.
19175054v.l
J,8.@.
ANA C. VISCOMI, J.S.C.
"Having reviewed the above motion, I find it to be meritorious on its face and is unopposed. Pursuant to H.1 :6-2, it therefore will be granted essentially for the reasons set forth in the moving papers."
-2-
MAYFIELD, TURNER, O'MARA & DONNELLY, P.C. Sara K. Saltsman, Esquire Attorney ID#002732010 2201 Route 38, Suite 300 Cherry Hill, NJ 08002 856-667-2600 Attorneys for Defendant, Carrier Cor oration
MARY SCHULTZ,
Plaintiffs,
vs.
SUPERIOR COURT OF
LAW DIVISION: MIDDLESEX COUNTY
DOCKET NO. MID-L-6996-15-AS
ASBESTOS MOTION
Civil Action
A.O. SMITH WATER PRODUCTS CO., et al., f\LEO
SEP \ S 20\i
ORDER
Defendants. C
THIS MATTER having been presented to the court by Sara K. Saltsman,
Esquire, of the firm of Mayfield, Turner, O'Mara & Donnelly, P.C., attorneys for
defendant Carrier Corporation, seeking an Order granting summary judgment;
and the Court having considered these papers and any response thereto;
IT IS on this lS day of 5:x:p-!e=loe, , 2017,
ORDERED that defendant Carrier Corporation's motion for summary
judgment is hereby GRANTED thereby dismissing any and all claims and
cross-claims asserted against it with prejudice; and it is further
ORDERED that a copy of this Order be served upon all parties within
~- days of the date hereof.
~NOPPOSED
OPPOSED
ANA c. VISCOMI, J.s.c.
"Having reviewed the above motion, I find it to be meritorious on its face and is unopposed. Pursuant to R.1 :6-2, it therefore will be granted essentially for the reasons set forth in the moving papers."
.:J,S. e.
i 7
FILED SEP 1 5 2017
l=i ~// - / S- f /
ANA C. VISCOMI, J.S.C. REILLY, JANICZEK, MCDEVITT, ATTORNEY FOR DEFENDANT,
HENRICH & CH OLDEN, P.C. CROWN BOILER COMPANY
BY: KAREN STANZIONE-CONTE, ESQUIRE (IMPROPERLY PLED AS CROWN
IDENTIFICATION NO.: 027011996 BOILER CO., F!K/A CROWN
ADRIANNA F. EXLER, ESQUIRE INDUSTRIES, INC.)
IDENTIFICATION NO.: 117222014 2500 MCCLELLAN BOULEY ARD, SUITE 240
MERCHANTVILLE, NEW JERSEY 08109 (856) 317-7180
OUR FILE NO.: 350-1243
MARY SCHULTZ,
PLAINTIFF(S),
v.
CROWN BOILER COMPANY (IMPROPERLY PLED AS CROWN BOILER CO., F!K/A CROWN INDUSTRIES, INC.), ET AL.
DEFENDANT(S).
SUPERIOR COURT OF NEW JERSEY LAW DIVISION MIDDLESEX COUNTY
DOCKET NO.: MID-L-6996-15 AS
CIVIL ACTION
ORDER
This matter comes before the Court on Motion of Reilly, Janiczek, McDevitt, Henrich &
Cholden, P.C., attorneys for Defendant, Crown Boiler Company (improperly pied as Crown Boiler Co.,
f/k/a Crown Industries, Inc.), and the Court having reviewed the moving and opposition papers, if any,
and for good cause shown;
It is on this L 6 dayof S,_@·~t,e_r , 2017, ORDERED the motion of
Defendant, Crown Boiler Company, for Summary Judgment is hereby granted and the Complaint and any
Counter claims and Cross-Claims are hereby dismissed with prejudice. ORDERED that a copy of this
Order shall be served on all counsel within seven (7) days of the date hereof.
~cJ~-"Having reviewed the above motion, I find it Honorable Ana C. Viscomi, J.S.C.
to be meritorious on its face and is unopposed. Pursuant to R.1 :6-2, it therefore will be granted essentially for the reasons set forth in the moving papers."
David S. Blow Attorney I.D. Number: 010951997 TANENBAUM KEALE LLP One Newark Center, 16th Floor Newark, NJ 07102 Telephone: 973.242.0002 Facsimile: 973.242.8099 Attorneys for Defendant, Foster Wheeler LLC
FILED SEP 1 5 2017
ANA C. VISCOMI, J.S.C.
I
MARY SCHULTZ, Plaintiffs,
SUPERIOR COURT OF NEW JERSEY LAW DIVISION: MIDDLESEX COUNTY DOCKET NO.MID- L-6996-15 AS
-against- Civil Action - Asbestos Litigation
A.O. SMITH WATER PRODUCTS CO., et : ORDER GRANTING SUMMARY
al. JUDGMENT TO FOSTER WHEELER LLC
Defendants.
THIS MATTER having come before the Comi on Motion of Tanenbaum Keale LLP,
attorneys for defendant Foster Wheeler LLC and the Court having reviewed the moving and
opposition papers, if any, and for good cause shown;
IT IS ON THIS __ l Q ____ day of ~GOb€-, , 2017,
ORDERED that the motion of Defendant Foster Wheeler LLC for summary judgment is
hereby GRANTED and the Complaint and any Counterclaims and Cross-Claims are hereby
dismissed with prejudice;
ORDERED that a copy of this Order shall be served on all counsel within seven (7)
days of the date hereof.
"Having reviewed the above motion, I find it to be meritorious on its face and is unopposed. Pursuant to R.1 :6-2, it therefore will be granted essentially for the reasons set forth in the moving papers."
84143332vl
~c.J~ Honorable Ana C. Viscomi, J.S.C.
David S. Blow Attorney I.D. Number: 010951997 TANENBAUM KEALE LLP One Newark Center, 16th Floor Newark, NJ 07102 Telephone: 973.242.0002 Facsimile: 973.242.8099 Attorneys for Defendant, General Electric Company
MARY SCHULTZ,
-against-
Plaintiffs,
A.O. SMITH WATER PRODUCTS CO., et:
al. Defendants.
FILED SEP 15 tJJ
ANA C. VISCOMI, J.S.C
SUPERIORCOURTOFNEW JERSEY
LAW DIVISION: MIDDLESEX COUNTY DOCKET NO.MID- L-6996-15 AS
Civil Action - Asbestos Litigation
ORDER GRANTING SUMMARY JUDGMENT TO GENERAL ELECTRIC
COMPANY
THIS MATTER having come before the Court on Motion of Tanenbaum Keale LLP,
attorneys for defendant General Electric Company and the Court having reviewed the moving
and opposition papers, if any, and for good cause shown;
IT IS ON THIS ~l~D~~~day of C'.::Je.pernb~ , 2017,
ORDERED that the motion of Defendant General Electric Company for summary
judgment is hereby GRANTED and the Complaint and any Counterclaims and Cross-Claims are
hereby dismissed with prejudice;
0 RD ERED that a copy ofthis Order shall be served on all counsel within seven (7)
days of the date hereof.
·'Having reviewed the above motion, I find. it to bo meritorious on its face and 1s unopposed. Pursuant to R.1 :6-2, it !hernforn will be granted essentially for the rQt\Sons set forth in the moving papers."
OA 1 A-,-,-,.-,.,1
Honoralile Ana C. Viscomi, J.S.C.
I
Joseph I. Fontak, Esq. Attorney ID: 046951991 Leader & Berkon LLP
FILED SEP 1 5 2017
q I
630 Third Avenue, 17th floor New York, NY 10017 ANA C. VISCOMI, J.S.C.
(212) 486-2400 Attorney for Defendant Imo Industries Inc. --------------------------------------------------------------X MARY SCHULTZ,
Plaintiff,
vs.
A.O. SMITH WATER PRODUCTS CO., et al.,
Defendants.
----X
SUPERIOR COURT OF NEW JERSEY LAW DIVISION, MIDDLESEX COUNTY
DOCKET NO. MID-L-6996-15 AS
ASBESTOS LITIGATION
Civil Action
ORDER FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT FOR IMO INDUSTRIES INC.
THIS MATTER having come before the Court on Motion of Leader & Berkon LLP,
attorneys for Defendant Imo Industries Inc., and the Court having reviewed the moving and
opposition papers, if any, and for good cause shown;
IT IS ON THIS __ _,_I ~--=----- day of ~ephn 6e C , 2017,
ORDERED that the Motion of Defendant Imo Industries Inc.'s motion for summary
judgment is hereby granted and the Complaint and any Counterclaims and Cross-Claims are
hereby dismissed with prejudice;
ORDERED that a copy of this Order shall be served on all counsel within seven (7) days
of the date hereof.
"Having reviewed the above motion, I find_it to be meritorious on its face and 1s unopposed. Pursuant to R.1 :6-2, it therefore will be granted essentially for the reasons set forth in the moving papers."
~ ..... CJ~ norable Ana Viscomi, J.S.C.
WILBRAHAM, LAWLER & BUBA By: Bashi J. Buba, Esquire (002511992) FI LED
Bernard E. Kueny, Esquire (036411987) Anisha S. Abraham, Esquire (031862007) SEP 1 5 2011
30 Washington Ave., Suite B3 Haddonfield, NJ 08033-3341 ANA C. VISCOMI, J.S.C. (856) 795-4422 Attorneys for Defendant, South Amboy Plumbing Supply Corp.
MARY SCHULTZ, SUPERIOR COURT OF NEW JERSEY LAW DIVISION
Plaintiff, MIDDLESEX COUNTY
v. NO. MID-L-6996-15 AS
SOUTH AMBOY PLUMBING SUPPLY CIVIL ACTION CORP., et al., ASBESTOS LITIGATION
Defendants. ORDER FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT BY DEFENDANT SOUTH AMBOY PLUMBING SUPPLY CORP.
This matter having come before the Court by Motion of Wilbraham, Lawler & Buba,
attorneys for Defendant South Amboy Plumbing Supply Corp., and the Court having reviewed the
moving and opposition papers, if any, and for good cause shown:
IT IS ON THIS ) ·s day of \:Je ~m\aer. 2017,
ORDERED that the motion of Defendant South Amboy Plumbing Supply Corp. for
summary judgment is hereby granted and the Complaint and any Counterclaims and Cross-Claims
are hereby dismissed with prejudice.
ORDERED that a copy of this Order shall be served on all counsel within seven (7) days
of the date hereof.
_ Opposed
~opposed
~cJ~. Hon. Ana C. Viscomi, J.S.C
"Having reviewed the above motion, I find_it to be meritorious on its face and 1s unopposed. Pursuant to R.1 :6-2, it therefore will be granted essentially for the reasons set forth in the moving papers."
SZAFERMAN, LAKIND,
BLUMSTEIN & BLADER P.C.
101 Grovers Mill Road, Suite 200
Lawrenceville, N.J. 08648
(609) 275-0400
By: Robert E. Lytle (ID #046331990)
SIMON GREENSTONE PANATIER BARTLETT P.C.
3232 McKinney Ave., Suite 610
FILED SEP 1 5 2017
ANA C. VISCOMI, J.S.C. Dallas, TX 75204
(214) 276-7680
By: Leah Kagan (ID #013602009)
Attorneys for Plaintiffs
MARY FLETCHER AND LAURA
MINER, Individually and as
Co-Executors and Co-Executors
ad Prosequendum of the Estate
of GAIL WELCH, Deceased,
Plaintiffs,
v.
BRENNTAG NORTH AMERICA, INC.
(sued individually and as
successor-in-interest to
MINERAL PIGMENT SOLUTIONS,
INC. and as successor-in
interest to WHITTAKER CLARK &
DANIELS, INC.),et al.,
Defendants.
SUPERIOR COURT OF NEW JERSEY
LAW DIVISION, MIDDLESEX COUNTY
DOCKET NO.: MID-L-3376-17AS
Civil Action - Asbestos Litigation
ORDER FOR PRO HAC VICE
ADMISSION OF
DAVID GREENSTONE, ESQ.
This matter having been opened to the Court on behalf of
Plaintiffs, Mary Fletcher and Laura Miner, Individually and as
Co-Executors and Co-Executors ad Prosequendum of the Estate of
Gail Welch, Deceased, by Szaferman, Lakind, Blumstein & Blader, P.C.
(Robert E. Lytle, Esq., appearing), notice to all counsel of record;
2480481.1
and this Court having considered the moving papers, in which it is
stated that Plaintiffs have a long-standing relationship with David
Greenstone, Esq.
day of~l7; IT IS ON THIS I Si:!:
ORDERED that David Greenstone, Esq. be and is hereby admitted pro
hac vice in this matter; and
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that David Greenstone, Esq.:
1. Shall abide by the New Jersey Rules of Court, including all
disciplinary rules, B..,_ 1:20-1, B..,_ 1:28-2 and B..,_ l:28B-l(e);
2. Shall consent to the appointment of the Clerk of the New
Jersey Supreme Court as the agent upon whom service of process may be
made for all actions against him that may arise out of his
participation in this matter;
3. Shall notify the Court immediately of any matter affecting
him standing at the bar of any other court;
4. Shall have all pleadings, briefs, and other papers filed
with the Court signed by an attorney of record authorized to practice
in this State, who shall be held responsible for them, the conduct of
the cause and the admitted attorney herein;
5. Shall abide by any further requirements concerning his
participation in this matter as the court from time to time deems
necessary;
6. Cannot be designated as trial counsel; and
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that:
2480481.1
1. No adjournment or delay in discovery, motions, trial, or any
other proceeding shall occur or be requested by reason of the
inability of David Greenstone to be in attendance.
2. David Greenstone shall, within ten (10) days, comply with R..,_
1:20-l(b), R..,_ 1:28-2 and R..,_ l:28B-l(e) by paying the appropriate fees
to the Disciplinary Oversight Committee, to the Lawyers Assistance
Program and the New Jersey Fund for Client Protection and submit an
affidavit of compliance no later than February 1 of each year
thereafter.
3. Automatic termination of pro hac vice admission will occur
for failure to make the required annual payment to the Disciplinary
Oversight Committee, the Lawyers Assistance Program and the New Jersey
Lawyer's Fund for Client Protection. Proof of such payment, after
filing proof of the initial payment, shall be made no later than
February 1 of each year thereafter.
4. Noncompliance with any of these requirements shall
constitute grounds for removal.
5. A copy of this Order shall be served on all parties within
seven (7) days.
Opposed
~Unopposed
2480481.1
~c.J~ HON. ANA C. VISCOMI, J.S.C.
SZAFERMAN, LAKIND,
BLUMSTEIN & BLADER P.C.
101 Grovers Mill Road, Suite 200
Lawrenceville, N.J. 08648
(609) 275-0400
By: Robert E. Lytle (ID #046331990)
SIMON GREENSTONE PANATIER BARTLETT P.C.
3232 McKinney Ave., Suite 610
FILED SEP 1 5 2017
ANA C. VISCOMJ, J.S.C, Dallas, TX 75204
(214) 276-7680
By: Leah Kagan (ID #013602009)
Attorneys for Plaintiffs
MARY FLETCHER AND LAURA MINER, Individually and as Co-Executors and Co-Executors
ad Prosequendum of the Estate
of GAIL WELCH, Deceased,
Plaintiffs,
v.
BRENNTAG NORTH AMERICA, INC. (sued individually and as successor-in-interest to MINERAL PIGMENT SOLUTIONS, INC. and as successor-ininterest to WHITTAKER CLARK &
DANIELS, INC.),et al.,
Defendants.
SUPERIOR COURT OF NEW JERSEY
LAW DIVISION, MIDDLESEX COUNTY
DOCKET NO.: MID-L-3376-l?AS
Civil Action - Asbestos Litigation
ORDER FOR PRO HAC VICE
ADMISSION OF
CHRISTOPHER PANATIER, ESQ.
This matter having been opened to the Court on behalf of
Plaintiffs, Mary Fletcher and Laura Miner, Individually and as
Co-Executors and Co-Executors ad Prosequendum of the Estate of
Gail Welch, Deceased, by Szaferman, Lakind, Blumstein & Blader, P.C.
(Robert E. Lytle, Esq., appearing), notice to all counsel of record;
2480481.l
1
and this Court having considered the moving papers, in which it is
stated that Plaintiffs have a long-standing relationship with
Christopher Panatier, Esq.
IT IS ON THIS day of~017;
ORDERED that Christopher Panatier, Esq. be and is hereby admitted
pro hac vice in this matter; and
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that Christopher Panatier, Esq.:
1. Shall abide by the New Jersey Rules of Court, including all
disciplinary rules, R,_ 1:20-1, R,_ 1:28-2 and R,_ 1:28B-l(e);
2. Shall consent to the appointment of the Clerk of the New
Jersey Supreme Court as the agent upon whom service of process may be
made for all actions against him that may arise out of his
participation in this matter;
3. Shall notify the Court immediately of any matter affecting
his standing at the bar of any other court;
4. Shall have all pleadings, briefs, and other papers filed
with the Court signed by an attorney of record authorized to practice
in this State, who shall be held responsible for them, the conduct of
the cause and the admitted attorney herein;
5. Shall abide by any further requirements concerning his
participation in this matter as the court from time to time deems
necessary;
6. Cannot be designated as trial counsel; and
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that:
2480481.1
1. No adjournment or delay in discovery, motions, trial, or any
other proceeding shall occur or be requested by reason of the
inability of Christopher Panatier to be in attendance.
2. Christopher Panatier shall, within ten (10) days, comply
with R.,_ 1:20-l(b), R.,_ 1:28-2 and R.,_ l:28B-l(e) by paying the
appropriate fees to the Disciplinary oversight Committee, to the
Lawyers Assistance Program and the New Jersey Fund for Client
Protection and submit an affidavit of compliance no later than
February 1 of each year thereafter.
3. Automatic termination of pro hac vice admission will occur
for failure to make the required annual payment to the Disciplinary
Oversight Committee, the Lawyers Assistance Program and the New Jersey
Lawyer's Fund for Client Protection. Proof of such payment, after
filing proof of the initial payment, shall be made no later than
February 1 of each year thereafter.
4. Noncompliance with any of these requirements shall
constitute grounds for removal.
5. A copy of this Order shall be served on all parties within
seven (7) days.
Opposed
V Unopposed
2480481.l
a__c.J~ HON. ANA C. VISCOMI, J.S.C.
SZAFERMAN, LAKIND,
BLUMSTEIN & BLADER P.C.
101 Grovers Mill Road, Suite 200
Lawrenceville, N.J. 08648
(609) 275-0400
By: Robert E. Lytle (ID #046331990)
FILED SEP 1 5 2017
ANA C. VISCOMI, J,S.C. SIMON GREENSTONE PANATIER BARTLETT P.C.
3232 McKinney Ave., Suite 610
Dallas, TX 75204
(214) 276-7680
By: Leah Kagan (ID #013602009)
Attorneys for Plaintiffs
MARY FLETCHER AND LAURA MINER, Individually and as Co-Executors and Co-Executors
ad Prosequendum of the Estate of GAIL WELCH, Deceased,
Plaintiffs,
v.
BRENNTAG NORTH AMERICA, INC. (sued individually and as successor-in-interest to MINERAL PIGMENT SOLUTIONS, INC. and as successor-ininterest to WHITTAKER CLARK &
DANIELS, INC.) ,et al.,
Defendants.
SUPERIOR COURT OF NEW JERSEY
LAW DIVISION - MIDDLESEX COUNTY
DOCKET NO.: MID-L-3376-17AS
Civil Action - Asbestos Litigation
ORDER FOR PRO HAC VICE
ADMISSION OF
JAY STUEMKE, ESQ,
This matter having been opened to the Court on behalf of
Plaintiffs, Mary Fletcher and Laura Miner, Individually and as
Co-Executors and Co-Executors ad Prosequendum of the Estate of
Gail Welch, Deceased, by Szaferman, Lakind, Blumstein & Blader, P.C.
(Robert E. Lytle, Esq., appearing), on short notice to all counsel of
2480481.l
record; and,this Court having considered the moving papers, in which
it is stated that Plaintiffs have a long-standing relationship with
Jay Stuemke, Esq.
IT IS ON THIS /5~ day of ~17;
ORDERED that Jay Stuemke, Esq. be and is hereby admitted pro hac
vice in this matter; and
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that Jay Stuemke, Esq.:
1. Shall abide by the New Jersey Rules of Court, including all
disciplinary rules, R.,_ 1:20-1, R.,_ 1:28-2 and R.,_ l:28B-l(e);
2. Shall consent to the appointment of the Clerk of the New
Jersey Supreme Court as the agent upon whom service of process may be
made for all actions against him that may arise out of his
participation in this matter;
3. Shall notify the Court immediately of any matter affecting
his standing at the bar of any other court;
4. Shall have all pleadings, briefs, and other papers filed
with the Court signed by an attorney of record authorized to practice
in this State, who shall be held responsible for them, the conduct of
the cause and the admitted attorney herein;
5. Shall abide by any further requirements concerning his
participation in this matter as the court from time to time deems
necessary;
6. Cannot be designated as trial counsel; and
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that:
2480481.1
1. No adjournment or delay in discovery, motions, trial, or any
other proceeding shall occur or be requested by reason of the
inability of Jay Stuemke to be in attendance.
2. Jay Stuemke shall, within ten (10) days, comply with JL.
1:20-l(b), JL. 1:28-2 and JL. l:28B-l(e) by paying the appropriate fees
to the Disciplinary Oversight Committee, to the Lawyers Assistance
Program and the New Jersey Fund for Client Protection and submit an
affidavit of compliance no later than February 1 of each year
thereafter.
3. Automatic termination of pro hac vice admission will occur
for failure to make the required annual payment to the Disciplinary
Oversight Committee, the Lawyers Assistance Program and the New Jersey
Lawyer's Fund for Client Protection. Proof of such payment, after
filing proof of the initial payment, shall be made no later than
February 1 of each year thereafter.
4. Noncompliance with any of these requirements shall
constitute grounds for removal.
5. A copy of this Order shall be served on all parties within
seven (7) days.
HON. ANA C. VISCOMI, J.S.C.
7 Opposed
Unopposed
2480481.1
SZAFERMAN, LAKIND,
BLUMSTEIN & BLADER P.C.
101 Grovers Mill Road, Suite 200
Lawrenceville, N.J. 08648
(609) 275-0400
By: Robert E. Lytle (ID #046331990)
SIMON GREENSTONE PANATIER BARTLETT P.C.
3232 McKinney Ave., Suite 610
FILED SEP 1 5 2017
ANA C. VISCOMI, J.S.C. Dallas, TX 75204
(214) 276-7680
By: Leah Kagan (ID #013602009)
Attorneys for Plaintiffs
MARY FLETCHER AND LAURA MINER, Individually and as Co-Executors and Co-Executors ad Prosequendum of the Estate of GAIL WELCH, Deceased,
Plaintiffs,
v.
BRENNTAG NORTH AMERICA, INC. (sued individually and as successor-in-interest to MINERAL PIGMENT SOLUTIONS, INC. and as successor-ininterest to WHITTAKER CLARK &
DANIELS, INC.) ,et al.,
Defendants.
SUPERIOR COURT OF NEW JERSEY
LAW DIVISION, MIDDLESEX COUNTY
DOCKET NO.: MID-L-3376-17AS
Civil Action - Asbestos Litigation
ORDER FOR PRO HAC VICE
ADMISSION OF
KEVIN PAUL, ESQ.
This matter having been opened to the Court on behalf of
Plaintiffs, Mary Fletcher and Laura Miner, Individually and as
Co-Executors and Co-Executors ad Prosequendum of the Estate of
Gail Welch, Deceased, by Szaferman, Lakind, Blumstein & Blader, P.C.
2480481.l
7
(Robert E. Lytle, Esq., appearing), notice to all counsel of record;
and this Court having considered the moving papers, in which it is
stated that Plaintiffs have a long-standing relationship with Kevin
Paul, Esq.
IT IS ON THIS /51 day of A~•~:7;
ORDERED that Kevin Paul, Esq. be and is hereby admitted pro hac
vice in this matter; and
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that Kevin Paul, Esq.:
1. Shall abide by the New Jersey Rules of Court, including all
disciplinary rules, li.,_ 1,20-1, li.,_ 1:28-2 and li.,_ l:28B-l(e);
2. Shall consent to the appointment of the Clerk of the New
Jersey Supreme Court as the agent upon whom service of process may be
made for all actions against him that may arise out of his
participation in this matter;
3. Shall notify the Court immediately of any matter affecting
his standing at the bar of any other court;
4. Shall have all pleadings, briefs, and other papers filed
with the Court signed by an attorney of record authorized to practice
in this State, who shall be held responsible for them, the conduct of
the cause and the admitted attorney herein;
5. Shall abide by any further requirements concerning his
participation in this matter as the court from time to time deems
necessary;
6. Cannot be designated as trial counsel; and
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that:
2480481.l
1. No adjournment or delay in discovery, motions, trial, or any
other proceeding shall occur or be requested by reason of the
inability of Kevin Paul to be in attendance.
2. Kevin Paul shall, within ten (10) days, comply with R..,_ 1:20-
l(b), R..,_ 1:28-2 and R..,_ 1:28B-l(e) by paying the appropriate fees to
the Disciplinary Oversight Committee, to the Lawyers Assistance
Program and the New Jersey Fund for Client Protection and submit an
affidavit of compliance no later than February 1 of each year
thereafter.
3. Automatic termination of pro hac vice admission will occur
for failure to make the required annual payment to the Disciplinary
Oversight Committee, the Lawyers Assistance Program and the New Jersey
Lawyer's Fund for Client Protection. Proof of such payment, after
filing proof of the initial payment, shall be made no later than
February 1 of each year thereafter.
4. Noncompliance with any of these requirements shall
constitute grounds for removal.
5. A copy of this Order shall be served on all parties within
seven (7) days.
Opposed
t/ Unopposed
2480481.l
HON. ANA C. VISCOMI, J.S.C.
SZAFERMAN, LAKIND,
BLUMSTEIN & BLADER P.C.
101 Grovers Mill Road, Suite 200
Lawrenceville, N.J. 08648
(609) 275-0400
By: Robert E. Lytle (ID #046331990)
SIMON GREENSTONE PANATIER BARTLETT P.C.
3232 McKinney Ave., suite 610
FILED SEP 15 2017
ANA C. VISCOM/, J.s.c, Dallas, TX 75204
(214) 276-7680
By: Leah Kagan (ID #013602009)
Attorneys for Plaintiffs
MARY FLETCHER AND LAURA MINER, Individually and as
Co-Executors and Co-Executors
ad Prosequendum of the Estate
of GAIL WELCH, Deceased,
Plaintiffs,
v.
BRENNTAG NORTH AMERICA, INC.
(sued individually and as
successor-in-interest to MINERAL PIGMENT SOLUTIONS,
INC. and as successor-ininterest to WHITTAKER CLARK &
DANIELS, INC.) ,et al.,
Defendants.
SUPERIOR COURT OF NEW JERSEY
LAW DIVISION, MIDDLESEX COUNTY
DOCKET NO,: MID-L-3376-17AS
Civil Action - Asbestos Litigation
ORDER FOR PRO HAC VICE
ADMISSION OF
SAM IOLA, ESQ.
This matter having been opened to the Court on behalf of
Plaintiffs, Mary Fletcher and Laura Miner, Individually and as
Co-Executors and Co-Executors ad Prosequendum of the Estate of
Gail Welch, Deceased, by Szaferman, Lakind, Blumstein & Blader, P.C.
(Robert E. Lytle, Esq., appearing), notice to all counsel of record;
2480481.l
and this Court having considered the moving papers, in which it is
stated that Plaintiffs have a long-standing relationship with Sam
Iola, Esq.
IT IS ON THIS /S~ day of ~7;
ORDERED that Sam Iola, Esq. be and is hereby admitted pro hac
vice in this matter; and
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that Sam Iola, Esq.:
1. Shall abide by the New Jersey Rules of Court, including all
disciplinary rules, R.,_ 1:20-1, R.,_ 1:28-2 and R.,_ 1:28B-l(e);
2. Shall consent to the appointment of the Clerk of the New
Jersey Supreme Court as the agent upon whom service of process may be
made for all actions against him that may arise out of his
participation in this matter;
3. Shall notify the Court immediately of any matter affecting
his standing at the bar of any other court;
4. Shall have all pleadings, briefs, and other papers filed
with the Court signed by an attorney of record authorized to practice
in this State, who shall be held responsible for them, the conduct of
the cause and the admitted attorney herein;
5. Shall abide by any further requirements concerning his
participation in this matter as the court from time to time deems
necessary;
6. Cannot be designated as trial counsel; and
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that:
2480481.1
1. No adjournment or delay in discovery, motions, trial, or any
other proceeding shall occur or be requested by reason of the
inability of Sam Iola to be in attendance.
2. Sam Iola shall, within ten (10) days, comply with g_,_ 1:20-
l(b), JL._ 1:28-2 and JL._ 1:28B-l(e) by paying the appropriate fees to
the Disciplinary Oversight Committee, to the Lawyers Assistance
Program and the New Jersey Fund for Client Protection and submit an
affidavit of compliance no later than February 1 of each year
thereafter.
3. Automatic termination of pro hac vice admission will occur
for failure to make the required annual payment to the Disciplinary
Oversight Committee, the Lawyers Assistance Program and the New Jersey
Lawyer's Fund for Client Protection. Proof of such payment, after
filing proof of the initial payment, shall be made no later than
February 1 of each year thereafter.
4. Noncompliance with any of these requirements shall
constitute grounds for removal.
5. A copy of this Order shall be served on all parties within
seven (7) days.
Opposed
/ Unopposed
2480481.I
u... c.J~ HON. ANA C. VISCOMI, J.S.C.
SZAFERMAN, LAKIND,
BLUMSTEIN & BLADER P.C.·
101 Grovers Mill Road, Suite 200
Lawrenceville, N.J. 08648
(609) 275-0400
By: Robert E. Lytle (ID #046331990)
SIMON GREENSTONE PANATIER BARTLETT P.C.
3232 McKinney Ave., suite 610
FILED SEP 1 5 2017
ANA C. VISCOMI, J.S.C. Dallas, TX 75204
(214) 276-7680
By: Leah Kagan (ID #013602009)
Attorneys for Plaintiffs
MARY FLETCHER AND LAURA
MINER, Individually and as
Co-Executors and Co-Executors
ad Prosequendum of the Estate
of GAIL WELCH, Deceased,
Plaintiffs,
v.
BRENNTAG NORTH AMERICA, INC.
(sued individually and as
successor-in-interest to
MINERAL PIGMENT SOLUTIONS,
INC. and as successor-in
interest to WHITTAKER CLARK &
DANIELS, INC.),et al.,
Defendants.
SUPERIOR COURT OF NEW JERSEY
LAW DIVISION, MIDDLESEX COUNTY
DOCKET NO.: MID-L-3376-17AS
Civil Action - Asbestos Litigation
ORDER FOR PRO HAC VICE
ADMISSION OF
MISTY FARRIS, ESQ.
This matter having been opened to the Court on behalf of
Plaintiffs, Mary Fletcher and Laura Miner, Individually and as
Co-Executors and Co-Executors ad Prosequendum of the Estate of
Gail Welch, Deceased, by Szaferman, Lakind, Blumstein & Blader, P.C.
(Robert E. Lytle, Esq., appearing), notice to all counsel of record;
and this Court having considered the moving papers, in which it is
2480481.1
j -·; ,1
stated that Plaintiffs have a long-standing relationship with Misty
Farris, Esq.
IT IS ON THIS day of~7;
ORDERED that Misty Farris, Esq. be and is hereby admitted pro hac
vice in this matter; and
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that Misty Farris, Esq.:
1. Shall abide by the New Jersey Rules of Court, including all
disciplinary rules, R.,_ 1:20-1, R.,_ 1:28-2 and R.,_ 1:28B-l(e);
2. Shall consent to the appointment of the Clerk of the New
Jersey Supreme Court as the agent upon whom service of process may be
made for all actions against her that may arise out of her
participation in this matter;
3. Shall notify the Court immediately of any matter affecting
her standing at the bar of any other court;
4. Shall have all pleadings, briefs, and other papers filed
with the Court signed by an attorney of record authorized to practice
in this State, who shall be held responsible for them, the conduct of
the cause and the admitted attorney herein;
5. Shall abide by any further requirements concerning her
participation in this matter as the court from time to time deems
necessary;
6. Cannot be designated as trial counsel; and
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that:
1. No adjournment or delay in discovery, motions, trial, or any
other proceeding shall occur or be requested by reason of the inability
of Misty Farris to be in attendance.
2480481.1
2. Misty Farris shall, within ten (10) days, comply with R.,_
1:20-l(b), R.,_ 1:28-2 and R.,_ 1:28B-l(e) by paying the appropriate fees
to the Disciplinary Oversight Committee, to the Lawyers Assistance
Program and the New Jersey Fund for Client Protection and submit an
affidavit of compliance no later than February 1 of each year
thereafter.
3. Automatic termination of pro hac vice admission will occur
for failure to make the required annual payment to the Disciplinary
Oversight Committee, the Lawyers Assistance Program and the New Jersey
Lawyer's Fund for Client Protection. Proof of such payment, after
filing proof of the initial payment, shall be made no later than
February 1 of each year thereafter.
4. Noncompliance with any of these requirements shall
constitute grounds for removal.
5. A copy of this Order shall be served on all parties within
seven (7) days.
HON. ANA C. VISCOMI, J.S.C.
Opposed
Unopposed
2480481.1
YJ,- j
Stephanie L. Coleman, Esq. Attorney ID No.: 00428-2008 FI l ED ECKERT SEAMANS CHERIN & MELLOTT, LLC
Four Gateway Center, Suite 401 SEP 1 5 201/ 100 Mulberry Street
Newark New Jersey 07102 ANA C. VISCOM/, J.S.C.
(973) 855-4700 · Attorneys for Defendant A.O. Smith Water Products Company,
Itnproperly pied as A. 0. Smith Corporation, Individually and as successor to Burkay
George Ziegel, Plaintiffs,
V.
' ' ; ' ; '
SUPERIOR COURT OF NEW JERSEY
LAW DIVISION - MIDDLESEX COUNTY
DOCKET NO.: MID-L-5375-14 AS ;
' 3M COMPANY, et al.,
; ;
' Defendant( s ). !
Civil Action Asbestos Litigation
' ; ; !
ORDERFOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
THIS MATTER having come before the Court on Motion ofECKJ;:RT SEAMANS CHERIN &
MELLOTT, Attorneys for Defendant A. 0. Smith _Water Products·comp!lfly, and the Court having
reviewed the moving and opposition papers, ifany, .and for good ca1.1se shown;
IT IS on this i ~ , 2017;
ORl)ERED that the Motion for Summary Judgment filed on behalf of Defendant, A. 0. Smith
Water Products Company, is hereby granted and the Complaint and any Counterclaims and Cross
Claims are fa,reby dismissed with prejudice.
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that a copy of this Order shall be served on all counsel
within seven (7)diJ.ys of the date of this Order.
-~osed
_VD_Unnnopposed
{S0055539.1)
Honorable Ana C. Viscomi, J.S.C.
·1~avlng reviewed the above motion, I find it
to be meritoriol1s on its face and is unopposed. Pursuant to R.1 :6-2, it lhorn,fore will be granted essentially for the masons set forth in the moving papers."
Casey ChaJUra ID#O 13832009
O'TOOLE SCRIVO FERNANDEZ WEINER
VAN LIEU A Limited Liability Company
14 Village Park Road Cedar Grove, New Jersey 07009
(973) 239-5700 Attome s for Defendant, Buist, lnc.
GEORGE ZIEGEL
Plaintiff
vs.
3M COMP ANY, ET AL
Defendants
- f - I
FILED SEP 1 5 20!1
ANA C. VISCOM/, J.S.C.
SUPERIOR COURT OF NEW JERSEY
LAW DIVISION: MIDDLESEX COUNTY
DOCKET NO. MID-L-5375-14AS
Civil Action
Asbestos Litigation
ORDERFOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
This matter having come before the Court on motion of O'Toole Scrivo Fernandez Weiner
Van Lieu, LLC, attorneys for Defendant, Buist lnc., and the Court having reviewed the moving and
opposition papers, if any, and for good cause shown;
IT IS ON THIS I 5 DAY OF Sp:te·doe,, 2017
ORDERED the motion of Defendant, Buist lnc., for summary judgment is hereby granted
and the Complaint and any Counterclaims and Cross-Claims are hereby dismissed with prejudice.
ORDERED that a copy of this Order shall be served on all counsel within seven (7) days
of the date hereof.
Pa~nsidered: ~-Moving Papers ~- Opposing Papers
Ana C. Viscomi, J.S.C.
"Having reviewed the above motion, I find it
to be meritorious on its face and is unopposed. Pursuant to R.1 :6-2, it therefore will be granted essentially for the
rea.sons set forth in the moving papers."
17
top related