lepton flavor violation and dipole moments in the muon system at high intensity beams

Lepton Flavor Violation and Dipole Moments in the Muon

System at High Intensity Beams

Marco Incagli - INFN PisaSPSC meeting - Villars - 27 sep 2004

M. Incagli - INFN Pisa Villars SPSC meeting 22-28 sep 2004

2

• Precision Physics as complementary to Frontier Energy Physics

• Precision Measurement relevant if:– firm predictions (eventually null) from Standard

Model– relevant informations on Standard Model or on

Standard Model extensions can be extracted– experimentally accessible – (relatively) low cost

• Muons satisfy all requirements!

M. Incagli - INFN Pisa Villars SPSC meeting 22-28 sep 2004

3

Physics motivations: LFV• Lepton flavor violation processes (LFV), like e , eee , e conversion , are negligibly small in the extended Standard Model (SM) with massive Dirac neutrinos (BR 10-50)

• Super-Symmetric extensions of the SM (SUSY-GUTs) with right handed neutrinos and see-saw mechanism may produce LFV processes at significant rates

-LFV decays are therefore a clean (no SM contaminated) indication of New Physics

andthey are accessible experimentally

M. Incagli - INFN Pisa Villars SPSC meeting 22-28 sep 2004

4

Physics motivations : moments1. Magnetic Dipole Moment (g-2) :

measured and predicted with very high accuracy (10 ppb in electron; 0.5 ppm in muon), it represents the most precise test of QED ;

most extensions of SM predict a contribution to g-2 ; a 2.7 discrepancy between theory and experiment has raised

a lot of interest (and publications) .

2. Electric Dipole Moment (EDM) : Like LFV processes, a positive measurement of Electric Dipole

Moment (EDM) would be a signal of physics beyond the SM

Both experiments need a new high intensity muon source for the next generation of

measurements

M. Incagli - INFN Pisa Villars SPSC meeting 22-28 sep 2004

5

Connection between LFV and -moments

• In SUSY, g-2 and EDM probe the diagonal elements of the slepton mixing matrix, while the LFV decay e probes the off-diagonal terms

• In case SUSY particles are observed at LHC, measurements of the LFV decays and of the -moments will provide one of the cleanest measarements of tan and of the new CP violating phase .

~~~~

~~~~

VVVV

e

eee

M. Incagli - INFN Pisa Villars SPSC meeting 22-28 sep 2004

6

The Anomalous Magnetic Moment : a

2a iee q

m Schwinger 1948 (Nobel price 1965)QED Prediction:

Computed up to 4th order [Kinoshita et al.] (5th order estimated [Mohr, Taylor])

QED 10

1

11614098.1 41321.810

3014 38.1.2 0.6

n

na

QED

QED Hadronic Weak SUSY... ... or other new physics ?

0.0011612

a

corrected feb 04

Kinoshita-Nio, hep-ph/0402206

had

LBL

M. Incagli - INFN Pisa Villars SPSC meeting 22-28 sep 2004

7

Storage ring to measure a

• At magic = 29.3, corresponding to E=3.09 GeV, K=0 and precession is directely proportional to a

B (out of plane)

11

2

aK

EKBamce

msa

Precession of spin and momentum vectors in E, B fields (in the hyp. B=0) :Electric field

used for focusing (electrostatic quadrupoles)

E

Ba a

polarized

M. Incagli - INFN Pisa Villars SPSC meeting 22-28 sep 2004

8

a exp – a

SM = (25.2 ± 9.2) 10 –10

2.7 ”standard deviations“(using e+e- data only)

a SM

[e+e– ] = (11 659 182.8 ± 6.3had ± 3.5LBL ± 0.3QED+EW) 10 –10

BNL E821 (2004) : aexp = (11 659 208.0 5.8) 10 10

Including CMD2 and KLOE e+e- results Melnikov-Vainshtein, hep-ph/0312226

not yet published

not yet published

preliminary

Muon anomaly (from Hoecker’s presentation at ICHEP04 - Beijing)

and data combined together (CPT)

Observed Difference with Experiment:

M. Incagli - INFN Pisa Villars SPSC meeting 22-28 sep 2004

9

Possible new physics contribution… New physics contribution can

affect a through the muon coupling to new particles

In particular SUSY can easily predict values which contribute to a at the 1ppm level

data can be affected differently than e+e- data by this new physics

In particular H- exchange is at the same scale as W- exchange, while m(H0)>>m()

W

H

Marciano + others

M. Incagli - INFN Pisa Villars SPSC meeting 22-28 sep 2004

10

LoI to J-PARC An experiment with sensitivity of 0.05 ppm proposed at J-PARC At the moment, the project is scheduled for Phase2 (>2011) Together with the experiment there must be an improvement on: evaluation of LBL experimetal data on (had) to cover m()<s<m( and 1<s<2 GeV

M. Incagli - INFN Pisa Villars SPSC meeting 22-28 sep 2004

11

New proposal - statistics

• The new experiment aims to a precision of 0.1-0.05 ppm, which needs a factor of 25-100 more muons

• This can be achieved by increasing the …1. … number of primary protons on target target

must be redisigned 2. … number of bunches 3. … muon injection efficiency which, at E821, was

7%4. … running time (it was 7months with - at BNL)

• The J-PARC proposal is mostly working on items 2 (go from 12 90 bunches) and 3

M. Incagli - INFN Pisa Villars SPSC meeting 22-28 sep 2004

12

Intermediate step on g-2 …• As intermediate step between now ( 0.6 ppm)

and a future storage ring ( 0.05) a proposal of upgrading E821, in order to reach 0.2 ppm, has been submitted to BNL in July 2004 and defended Sep 9 positive response from PAC

M. Incagli - INFN Pisa Villars SPSC meeting 22-28 sep 2004

13

Electric Dipole Moment (EDM)• The electromagnetic interaction Hamiltonian of a

particle with both magnetic and electric dipole moment is:

0

0

22

22 wheres

mcedd

gsmcegd

EdBHE

M

• The existence of dE, in SM, is suppressed because• dE violates both P and T (and also CP in the CPT

hyp.)• only one weak phase exist in CKM

• This is not the case for SUSY where many CP phases exist

g-2 term

M. Incagli - INFN Pisa Villars SPSC meeting 22-28 sep 2004

14

Limits on EDMo Up to now EDMs have been measured only on:

1. Neutrons2. Heavy paramagnetic/diamagnetic atoms/molecules (Tl,Hg,YbF)

o Electron EDM extracted from (2.) : dE(e)<210-27 ecm New idea to measure directly the EDM on an elementary

particle : muons in storage ring

What value for mEDM if new physics exists in a at 1ppm?This New Physics would induce a DM :d

NP aNP tanCP e cm tanCP e cm

With new technique expected sensitivity is de cm

unit conversion

M. Incagli - INFN Pisa Villars SPSC meeting 22-28 sep 2004

15

New approach to EDM• Muons in storage ring: combination of , E, B that

cancels out muon spin (g-2) precession (electric field E must be radial and E=B=0) ; only EDM precession left .

rBmceBE

mce

zEKBaEKBa

EDM

a

ˆ22

0ˆ)()(

sideview

NO out of plane precession

- precession due to a

- precession due to EDM

M. Incagli - INFN Pisa Villars SPSC meeting 22-28 sep 2004

16

Muon ring for EDM measurement

Optimal momentum choice : p 300-500 MeV Below 300 MeV the muon polarization becomes a concern Above 500 MeV the radial electric field needed to cancel out g-2 precession is >20kV/cm

LOI to J-PARC with following parameters:P = 500 MeV/cBz = 0.25 TEr = 2MV/mR = 7m<R> = 11mB+E = 2.6 mIntervals = 1.7 mn. elements = 16circunference 40m

Required statistics:

NP2 = 1016

P = Beam Polarization

M. Incagli - INFN Pisa Villars SPSC meeting 22-28 sep 2004

17

Systematics• Basic idea to fight systematics: compare clockwise

vs counter-clockwise results

• Needs 2 injection points and possibility of changing polarity of dipole magnets (not necessary for quadrupoles)

cw ccw -B -BE E

BEEaBamce

211

2

Opposite sign Same sign

0 due to choice of ,B,E

M. Incagli - INFN Pisa Villars SPSC meeting 22-28 sep 2004

18

Summary on -moments Both g-2 and EDM are sensitive to new physics

beyond the SM (maybe behind the corner) Unique opportunity of studying phases of mixing

matrix for SUSY particles EDM first direct probe of dE on elementary

particle The experiments are hard but, in particular the EDM, not impossible

A large flux of polarized muons of energy 3 GeV (g-2) or 500 MeV (EDM) is required

M. Incagli - INFN Pisa Villars SPSC meeting 22-28 sep 2004

19

Lepton Flavor Violation decays• Three relevant processes :

e 3e NeN• Model Indipendent Interactions:

• Relative strength depends upon arbitrary parameters F

• In the hyp. F<<1, as in large class of SUSY-GUT theories:

BR(-e conv) 10-3 BR(e) BR(3e) 10-2 BR(e)

Dipole Transition

Direct violation

e.g. :slepton mixing

matrix

M. Incagli - INFN Pisa Villars SPSC meeting 22-28 sep 2004

20

+e+

e+ +

e = 180°Ee = E = 52.8 MeVTe = T

signal e

background

correlated e

e+ +

accidental

e e

ee eZ eZ e+ +

M. Incagli - INFN Pisa Villars SPSC meeting 22-28 sep 2004

21

+e+ : presentPresent limit B(e ) < 1.2x10-11 by the MEGA Collab. M.L.Brooks et al.

Phys.Rev.Lett. 83(1999)1521

1m

e+

Liq. Xe Scin tilla tionDetector

Drift C ham ber

Liq. Xe Scin tilla tionDetector

e+

Tim ing C ounter

Stopping TargetThin S uperconducting Coil

M uon Beam

Drift C ham ber

New approved experiment: MEG @ PSI

• Stopped beam of >107 /sec in a 150 m target

• Liquid Xenon calorimeter for detection (scintillation)

• Solenoid spectrometer & drift chambers for e+ momentum

• Scintillation counters for e+ timing

1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007Planning R & D Assembly Data Taking

nownowLoILoI ProposalProposalRevisedRevised

documentdocument

M. Incagli - INFN Pisa Villars SPSC meeting 22-28 sep 2004

22

+e+ : future• MEG sensitivity : 10-13 with 107 +/s • The PSI E5 can deliver up to 3x108 +/s • The MEG sensitivity is accidental background limited• With better detector resolutions a BR of 10-14 would

be possible

but...

Challenging !No immediate (next 10 years) need for

a more intense beam

M. Incagli - INFN Pisa Villars SPSC meeting 22-28 sep 2004

23

+e+e+e-

CoplanarityVertexingEe = m

Te+ = Te+ = Te-

signal eee

background

correlated e e e

accidental

e ee+e- e+e-

e+ +

e+

+

e+

e-

e+ +

e-

e+

+

e+

e+

e- e-

M. Incagli - INFN Pisa Villars SPSC meeting 22-28 sep 2004

24

+e+e+e- : SINDRUM I

Present limit B(3e ) < 1x10-12 U.Bellgardt et al. Nucl.Phys. B299(1985)1No other experimental proposal

SINDRUM I parameters– beam intensity 6x106 /s– momentum 25 MeV/c– magnetic field 0.33T– acceptance 24%– momentum resolution 10% FWHM– vertex resolution 2 mm2 FWHM– timing resolution ns– target length 220 mm– target density 11 mg/cm2

M. Incagli - INFN Pisa Villars SPSC meeting 22-28 sep 2004

25

+e+e+e : summary• A new experiment should aim at a sensitivity of 10-15,

which means to increase beam intensity by 103

• Technically not impossible, but uncorrelated background scales quadratically with the beam intensity, therefore six orders of magnitude of background reduction, wrt to SINDRUM I, is required four orders of magnitude could be achieved … more?

Challenging !

No immediate (next 10 years) need for a more intense beam

M. Incagli - INFN Pisa Villars SPSC meeting 22-28 sep 2004

26

-e- conversion

Ee = m- EB

signal (A,Z) e (A,Z)

background

MIO (A,Z) e (A,Z)

RPC (A,Z) (A,Z-

1)

e- - (A,Z)

e- -

(A,Z)

-

(A,Z)

M. Incagli - INFN Pisa Villars SPSC meeting 22-28 sep 2004

27

-e- : present

SINDRUM II parameters

• beam intensity 3x107 /s• momentum 53 MeV/c• magnetic field 0.33T• acceptance 7%• momentum res. 2% FWHM

Main background : Radiative Pion Capture (RPC) suppressed with an 8mm carbon absorber at the entrance of the solenoid

Present limit B(e:Au ) < 8x10-13 SINDRUM II COLLABORATION

M. Incagli - INFN Pisa Villars SPSC meeting 22-28 sep 2004

28

-e- : future

Differently from other channels, this one is not limited by accidentals but by RPC

Two techinques to improve beam purity proposed for two next generation experiments:New approved experiment at BNL:

MECO (E940) BR(e) < 10-16 (2008 ??)New project LOI to J-PARC:

PRISM/PRIME BR(e) < 10-18 (>2008 ??? )

M. Incagli - INFN Pisa Villars SPSC meeting 22-28 sep 2004

29

e : beam line for MECO

New AGS beam structure:1. 21013 protons/bucket (71012

for g-2 experiment)2. Short pulses of 30nsec with

1.35 µsec separation between pulses (2 per rotation)

3. Extinction between pulses must be >109; fast kicker in transport will divert beam from production solenoid

Pulsed beam from AGS to eliminate prompt background

M. Incagli - INFN Pisa Villars SPSC meeting 22-28 sep 2004

30

-e- : MECO detectorStraw Tracker

Crystal Calorimeter

Muon Stopping Target

Superconducting Production Solenoid

(5.0 T – 2.5 T)

Superconducting Detector Solenoid

(2.0 T – 1.0 T)

Superconducting Transport Solenoid

(2.5 T – 2.1 T)

2 x 1013 incident p/sec

1 x 1011 stopping µ/sec

~ 5 signal events for 107 s (2800 hours) running if Re = 10-16

~ 0.45 expected bckg events if extinction factor = 10-9

M. Incagli - INFN Pisa Villars SPSC meeting 22-28 sep 2004

31

-e- : PRISM beam

PRISM (Phase Rotated Intense Slow Muon source): Pion capture section Decay section Phase rotation section Ejection system

Machine parameters Intensity: 1011-1012 /sec Muon momentum : 68 MeV Momentum spread : 0.5-1.0 MeV Beam repetition : 100 Hz

M. Incagli - INFN Pisa Villars SPSC meeting 22-28 sep 2004

32

-e- : PRIME detector

M. Incagli - INFN Pisa Villars SPSC meeting 22-28 sep 2004

33

-e- : summary• This channel will definitely benefit from an

increase in beam intensityBUT

• The problem of pion contamination of the muon beam is the fundamental issue

• Two proposals :– Beam extinction at <10-9 level (!) - BNL– New kind of muon extraction technique with

circular (compact) FFAG - PRISM

Very promising channel !

M. Incagli - INFN Pisa Villars SPSC meeting 22-28 sep 2004

34

EDM and e conversion with “same” beam?

• In EDM LOI to J-PARC the possibility of accomodating EDM and e in the same hall is prospected

• The FFAG system must be projected with the possibility of providing muons both of 80 and of 400 MeV

EDM ring

e detector

PRISM FFAG

M. Incagli - INFN Pisa Villars SPSC meeting 22-28 sep 2004

35

Summary table and Conclusions

Muons have historically played a key role in understanding the structure of the Standard Model (V-A, QED tests, …)

Muons are fundamental tools to discover and/or to understand the structure of any physics beyond the SM

All future projects (J-PARC, Fermilab) foresee high intensity flux of muons to be used in a storage ring and/or LFV exp.

e transitions and EDM (also g-2) seem very promising Europe (CERN) should not loose this opportunity and

aim for a leading role in the field of decays and moments