king county normative flow project parametrix, king county, herrera, & foster wheeler normative...

Parametrix, King County, Herrera, & Foster Wheeler King County Normative Flow Project

Normative Flow Studies

King County Department of Natural Resources

Water and Land Resources Division

Parametrix, King County, Herrera, & Foster Wheeler King County Normative Flow Project

Establishing links between flow regimes and aquatic ecosystem health

-

Using a normative flow approach to guide river restoration in the PNW

Parametrix, King County, Herrera, & Foster Wheeler King County Normative Flow Project

Flow Regimes and Restoration

• Historical conditions• Ecological processes• Prioritization• Design

Parametrix, King County, Herrera, & Foster Wheeler King County Normative Flow Project

GeologyClimate

Regional VegetationRunoff regime

Sediment supplyLWD supply

Land UsePollution

RoadsCIP’s

Floodplain DevelopmentRestoration/LWD

Flow RegimeHabitat

Structure &Dynamics

Biotic Condition(Salmon Viability)

King County Normative Flow Project Parametrix, King County, Herrera, & Foster Wheeler

GEOLOGY, CLIMATE

Flow variablesUnaltered flowregime

Ecological Condition‘Reference Condition’

Geomorphological, Biotic, BiogeochemicalVariables

Key FlowVariables

Key EcologicalIndicators

Parametrix, King County, Herrera, & Foster Wheeler King County Normative Flow Project

Why has this not been done in PNW?

• Most information from:– Semi-arid/arid regions– Hydroelectric/irrigation diversions

• Single-species bias• Focus on minimum flows

• ‘Noise’ associated with effects of urbanization

• Several efforts underway (TNC, King Co., Ecology….)

Parametrix, King County, Herrera, & Foster Wheeler King County Normative Flow Project

Approach

How have flows been altered?

How has this impacted PNW rivers?

Types of hydrologic alteration

Ecological effects of flow alteration

Parametrix, King County, Herrera, & Foster Wheeler King County Normative Flow Project

Change in Number of High Pulses over Time

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

50

1940 1950 1960 1970 1980 1990 2000 2010

Year

Nu

mb

er o

f p

uls

es p

er y

ear

Juanita Creek

Sw amp Creek at Kenmore

Big Soos Creek (above hatchery)

Leach Creek near Steilacoom

Leach Creah (near Fircrest)

MayCreek

Linear (Leach Creek near Steilacoom)

Linear (Juanita Creek)

Parametrix, King County, Herrera, & Foster Wheeler King County Normative Flow Project

Predicted Ecological Effects

• Literature review– Focus on 1998-present– Most common flow alterations– Most common ecological responses– Empirical relationships

• What is relevant to PNW?

Parametrix, King County, Herrera, & Foster Wheeler King County Normative Flow Project

Literature Review: Suites of Common Ecological Effects

Q

t

Connectivity

Life-history strategies

Habitat complexity

Community attributes

Parametrix, King County, Herrera, & Foster Wheeler King County Normative Flow Project

Longitudinal

Lat

eral

Ver

tica

l

Exchange of matter and energy:

•Flood pulse

•Nutrient cycling

•Productivity/food web support

Access to habitats:

•Refugia

•All life-stages

Population Viability:

•Dispersal

•Migration

•Recruitment

Changes in Flows Connectivity

Changes in Flow Habitat Complexity

•Species Diversity

•Life-history Diversity

•Genetic Diversity

•Population Structure

•Population Persistence

•Productivity

Channel form

Patch complexity

Disturbance regime

Complex, DiverseSimple, Uniform

Parametrix, King County, Herrera, & Foster Wheeler King County Normative Flow Project

Changes in Flow Life-history

Q

t

Seasonality; Predictability; Variability

Timing first floods

Life-history strategies:

Recruitment/spawning

Life-spans, age at first reproduction

Stable baseflows, drought

Changes in Flow Communities

Q

t

Seasonality; Predictability; Variability

Community attributes:

Diversity

Range expansions/contractions

Invasibility

Parametrix, King County, Herrera, & Foster Wheeler King County Normative Flow Project

Evaluate Flow Changes:Indicators and Metrics

• Connectivity• Habitat Complexity• Life-history Traits• Community Attributes

Parametrix, King County, Herrera, & Foster Wheeler King County Normative Flow Project

Habitat Complexity

Number of:

• Geomorphic surfaces

• Channel islands

• Un-vegetated patches

Length channel segments

• Patch turnover rates

• Structural diversity

• Size classes trees

• Rates channel migration

Spatial

Temporal

Parametrix, King County, Herrera, & Foster Wheeler King County Normative Flow Project

Life-History Traits

• Relative abundances/Presence-absence of life-history traits:– Timing of spawning runs– Number of runs– Length of reproductive season– Short-lived vs. long-lived species– Age at first reproduction– Generations/year– Tolerant/Intolerant

Parametrix, King County, Herrera, & Foster Wheeler King County Normative Flow Project

Approach

Can we use flow regimes to design better river restoration?

Predict effects of flow alteration on river health

Evaluate restoration actions under range of flow regimes

Parametrix, King County, Herrera, & Foster Wheeler King County Normative Flow Project

Flow Regimes and Restoration

• Historical flow regimes/existing constraints• Current flow regimes/limitations• Prioritization• Design

Historical

Feasible

Stewardship, Enhancement

Priority 2

Priority 1

Restoration

Timing of peak flows

A-seasonal high or low flows ‘Flashiness’

Frequency overbank flows

Prioritization

Parametrix, King County, Herrera, & Foster Wheeler King County Normative Flow Project

Restoration Design

• Feasibility• Potential for success• Goals and targets

Historical

Feasible

Stewardship, Enhancement

Priority 2

Priority 1

Restoration

Frequency peak flows

Magnitude peak flows

Flow Regime Geomorphic Response

•Velocity•Bedload transport capacity•Depth of bedload scour (in relation to egg pocket depths)•Grain size

Biotic Response – Individual,Population

•Egg/alevin survival

•Population size (fall spawners)

•Salmon to cutthroat•Invertebrate diversity•Species diversity•Life-history diversity

Biotic Response – Community Composition