inspire annex ii+iii data specifications consultation & testing

1

INSPIRE Annex II+III Data Specifications

Consultation & Testing

Michael Lutz

European Commission – Joint Research CentreInstitute for Environment & Sustainability, SDI Unit

30th June 2011

2INSPIRE Annex II+III Data Specifications Consultation & Testing – INSPIRE Conference, 30 June 2011

I II III IV

Annex II/III Roadmap

2012

2010

2011

II III IV I II III

Kick-off: 19-20.04 2010

Data Specification v1 (29.10.2010)

Data Specification v2 (06.2011)

Testing/Consultation (06-10.2011)

Data Specification v3 (04.2012)

Draft IR (09.2012)

3INSPIRE Annex II+III Data Specifications Consultation & Testing – INSPIRE Conference, 30 June 2011

Consultation & Testing

• Two separate, but closely related activities– Common aim: Report back to the INSPIRE CT and TWGs

gained experience will be used to improve the data specifications for v3.0 basis for amendment of the legal act

• Consultation:– Review of data specification documents (v2.0)– Domain-specific aspects– Cross-thematic aspects (overlaps and gaps, inconsistencies)

• Testing:– Test feasibility of implementation and fitness for purpose of

data specifications (v2.0) under real-world conditions – Provide the first test bed for interaction with and between the

participating stakeholders (teaming up, exchange of experience)

4INSPIRE Annex II+III Data Specifications Consultation & Testing – INSPIRE Conference, 30 June 2011

Scope / content

• Documents under consultation– D2.8.I.x Data Specification on <Theme Name> –

Draft Guidelines: 24 PDF documents[+ GML Application Schemas]

– Proposed updates to D2.5 and D2.7 – D2.9 INSPIRE O&M Guidelines (New document)

• For Reference– UML Model (svn, XMI, EAP, HTML):

http://inspire.jrc.ec.europa.eu/index.cfm/pageid/2/list/datamodels

– The “INSPIRE Data Specifications Cost-benefit considerations” document

– INSPIRE Annex I testing summary report

5

How to read the data specifications

• Foreword• General Executive Summary• Theme-specific Executive

Summary

1. Scope

2. Overview (incl. 2.2 informal description)

3. Specification scopes

4. Identification information

5. Data content and structure5.1 Basic notions5.2 – 5.x Application schemas (incl. UML diagrams and feature catalogues)

6. Reference Systems

7. Data Quality7.1 DQ Elements7.2 Minimum DQ Requirements

8. Metadata8.1 Common MD elements8.2 MD Elements for data quality8.3 Theme-specific MD elements8.4 Guidelines for common elements

9. Delivery (incl. Encodings)

10. Data Capture

11. Portrayal (incl. layers, styles)•Annex A: ATS•Annex B: Use cases•Other Annexes (e.g. examples)

6

How to read the data specifications

Watch out for

Legal requirement

Implementation requirement

Implementation recommendation

Open issues your input requested

7INSPIRE Annex II+III Data Specifications Consultation & Testing – INSPIRE Conference, 30 June 2011

Overview

• Feasibility testing main focus of testing– measure technical feasibility and effort related to

transforming existing data (e.g., from Member States’ organisations) into data compliant with the requirements and schemas proposed in the data specification documents

• Fitness for purpose testing– assess the benefits of harmonised data specifications from

an end-user or application point of view

• Provide cost-benefit information– Related to the testing– Contextual / not directly related to testing

8INSPIRE Annex II+III Data Specifications Consultation & Testing – INSPIRE Conference, 30 June 2011

Testing – Communication

• Calls for participation– Initial set of information

• Testing Kick off meeting– Dedicated presentations for the testing– Questions & answers session

• INSPIRE Forum– Exchange testing releated information– Source of relevant information– Communication platform– Uploading and sharing results of the testing

9INSPIRE Annex II+III Data Specifications Consultation & Testing – INSPIRE Conference, 30 June 2011

Testing20/6 – 21/10/2011

Consultation20/6 – 21/10/2011

Call for TestingPublished on 08/04/2011

Call for ConsultationPublished on 22/06/2011

Issue tracking system

SDIC/LMO DB

Testing Reports

(WebForm)

XLS templatefor comments

XLS templatefor comments

From Testing– SDICs/LMOs: Testing

report via WebForm– SDICs/LMOs:

Comments delivered via XLS spredsheet

From Consultation– SDICs/LMOs:

Comments delivered via XLS spreadsheet

Both– INSPIRE CT: Import XLS

comments to DS issue tracking system

Outcomes

10INSPIRE Annex II+III Data Specifications Consultation & Testing – INSPIRE Conference, 30 June 2011

How you can get involved

11INSPIRE Annex II+III Data Specifications Consultation & Testing – INSPIRE Conference, 30 June 2011

Where you can find partners…

… for the testing

12

http://inspire.jrc.ec.europa.eu/index.cfm/pageid/2

Thank you!

13INSPIRE Annex II+III Data Specifications Consultation & Testing – INSPIRE Conference, 30 June 2011

Purpose of the testing

•Ensure proposed data specifications are feasible– i.e. existing spatial data can be mapped and

transformed to the proposed target common INSPIRE structure

•Provide evidence that data specifications are fit for purpose– as defined by use cases identified either in data

specifications as well as testing participants

• Identification of costs and benefits– related to the current status with comparison of

the scenario with INSPIRE implementation

14INSPIRE Annex II+III Data Specifications Consultation & Testing – INSPIRE Conference, 30 June 2011

• Higher priority• Purpose

– measure technical feasibility and effort related to transforming existing data into data compliant with the requirements and schemas proposed in the data specification documents

– Reference systems, Data Quality, Dataset-level metadata, Encoding, Portrayal to be also considered

• Expectations– Identify areas, where it is difficult or impossible to transform

national data sets into the proposed INSPIRE schema– Provide results of the transformations as an base for fitness

for purpose testing as well as future INSPIRE implementation– Documentation of transformation methodologies

Feasibility testing

15INSPIRE Annex II+III Data Specifications Consultation & Testing – INSPIRE Conference, 30 June 2011

Fitness for purpose testing

• Lower priority• Purpose

– Assess the benefits of harmonised data specifications from an end-user or application point of view

– Demonstrate the usefulness of spatial data compliant with the INSPIRE data specifications when addressing real applications – the use cases

– To address cross theme, cross border, cross language aspects

• Expectations– Collection of use cases identified by testing participants– Documentation of used testing approach– Testing outputs (applications, tasks/processes

descriptions)

16INSPIRE Annex II+III Data Specifications Consultation & Testing – INSPIRE Conference, 30 June 2011

Cost benefit considerations

• Purpose– Assess feasibility and proportionality of the proposed INSPIRE

spatial data specifications– Consider contextual / not directly testing related

aspects

• Costs: Mainly related to feasibility testing• Benefits: Mainly related to feasibility testing

– Putting INSPIRE compliant data in existing applications are highly appreciated, which provides sound basis for comparison.

– Repeating the same testing exercise with compliant and non-compliant data gives extraordinary value for assessing the potential benefits.

• Conclusions– Expected reporting/commenting of issues as well as positive

aspects related with data specifications implementation