infant mental health in community & primary care practice contexts catherine maguire senior...

Infant Mental Health in Community & Primary Care Practice Contexts

Catherine Maguire Senior Clinical Psychologist and Infant Mental Health Specialist Child, Adolescent and Family Psychology Service, North CorkHealth Service Executive- South

President, Irish Association of Infant Mental Health ©

Why Infant Mental Health?

• Everybody knows a baby…• What about the baby’s social and

emotional development? Can you remember?

Why is Infant Mental Health important?1. Why early experiences and early

relationships matter2. Creating a fluency about early social and

emotional development 3. Two case examples from practice

What is Infant Mental Health?

Copyright Catherine Maguire & Rochelle Matacz ©

• To experience, regulate & express emotions • Form close & secure relationships• Explore the environment & learn “All of these capacities will be best accomplished within the contexts of caregiving environments that include family, community, and cultural expectations for young children” (Zero to Three, 2001)

Why is Infant Mental Health so important?

What difference does it make?

● A window of opportunity exists in infancy and early toddlerhood

● The early years are a sensitive and critical period of development

● Extensive research on brain development studies highlight the crucial role of relationship based experiences for the child’s future mental health

Copyright Catherine Maguire & Rochelle Matacz ©

Importance of the parent-child relationship

Copyright Catherine Maguire & Rochelle Matacz ©

“Among the most significant developments during the past quarter

of a century has been the steady growth in evidence that the quality of parental care which a child receives

in its earliest years is of vital importance for his future mental

health”

(John Bowlby, 1953)

Babies can’t wait

• A critical window of opportunity exists in the first months

• Spurts in brain growth will occur at a rate that will not be repeated in later years

• Pathways are experience dependent

Copyright Catherine Maguire & Rochelle Matacz ©

Importance of the parenting relationship

The majority of parents, provide their children with • A loving safe home• Protect & comfort • Play with, praise & enjoy them

“In more extreme circumstances of hostile, neglectful environments, babies fail to thrive and their normal development is very seriously compromised”(Joyce 2005)

Copyright Catherine Maguire & Rochelle Matacz ©

Importance of Parent-Child Relationship

• As the P-C relationship develops, the parent helps the infant develop the ability to regulate his/her emotions

• Predictable and caring parent –infant responses = infant develops a secure template

• Positive experience of early relationships sets the stage for other relationships

• Quality of P-C relationship facilitates development of attachment

• Parents own parenting experiences tend to be repeated

• P-C relationship cannot happen in isolation

Still Face Experiment

Understanding social & emotional development in

Infancy & Toddlerhood

Copyright Catherine Maguire & Rochelle Matacz ©

• Social & emotional development is largely expressed through behaviour

• Problems at this developmental stage often misunderstood as ‘misbehaviour’

• Parents sometimes struggle to interpret the meaning of the cues and signals or misinterpret their child’s emotional displays

CASE NO 1: IMH INTERVENTION

• Case identified by Clinician with IMH skills Baby & Mother commenced intervention when Baby 2 months old

• Denial regarding her pregnancy, absence of support

• Overwhelming feeling of ambivalence for her newborn

• Mother’s own dysregulation & unresolved early childhood experiences

• IMH model of service provision implemented

CASE NO 2: WITHOUT IMH INTERVENTION

• Case not identified until 13 months (child taken into care)

• Unplanned pregnancy, difficult early childhood, ambivalent relationship with her baby

• Mother known to Social Work Department as an adolescent

• Mother places baby in foster care at beginning second year of life

• 2 years later, her toddler is unable to manage a relationship with her

• Child in long term foster placement until 18yrs• No relationship based therapeutic intervention to

date

CASE 1 vs CASE 2 CASE 2-without intervention

•Cost to the HSE = • Cost of Foster Care (17yrs) at €350 approx per week•Clinical skills of Social Work • Foster Social Worker,• Legal costs to HSE.

OutcomesChild in secure placement P-C relationship disruptedFamily no longer in intact Child removed from her Community must adjust to new surroundingsSociety will be required to support their mental health needs for some time to come

CASE 1-with intervention

• Cost to the HSE = • 92 clinical hours of

Clinical Psychologist time

20 hours in travel time Clinical Supervision

OutcomesP-c relationship repairFamily intactChild remains in his CommunitySociety + benefits

Concluding Remarks• Fluency regarding early social and emotional development on a

par with physical development needs to be fully understood at all levels of family, community and society.

• 0-3 period require awareness across society skills especially - Promotion, prevention and repairing of parent-child relationships

• Integrate the extensive science available regarding this 0-3 into service delivery.

• Workforce capacity skills required - Michigan Association of IMH endorsement competencies

• Future mental health of society can be changed through our primary care teams.

• A critical window of opportunity exists in infancy.

• This change must start with the baby and his/her first relationship.

Conclusion

“In my Beginning is my End”(TS Eliot, 1888-1965) (from the four Quartets No 2 of 4, East Croker 1943)