inequality: why does it matter; how does it differ to focussing on poverty? duncan green oxfam gb...

Inequality: Why Does it Matter; How Does it Differ to Focussing on

Poverty?

Duncan GreenOxfam GB

Ambedkar UniversityNovember 2013

What do we mean by Poverty?

Absolute v Relative income Multidimensional – narrow (eg Human

Development Index) Asking Poor People (Voices of the Poor) Well/ Ill being Static v Dynamic – fear of tomorrow

What’s happening to income poverty?

What do we mean by inequality?

Income– Opportunity: soft and hard versions– Outcomes

Multidimensional inequality Vertical v Horizontal (spatial) Intergenerational (temporal) Measurement: Gini v deciles Power

Inequality is a rising concern

Shared by just about everybody

IMF links to major financial crises (rich elites recycling $) and social cohesion

World Bank highlights how much harder it is to end poverty in unequal countries (eg South Africa)

Stiglitz linking to political capture and positive feedback loops from influence

Planetary boundaries and the finite cake Behavioural economics and link to well-

being

What’s happening to global income inequality?

Global Gini improving due to rise of BRICS Global extremes getting worse 100 richest people = 4x poorest 1.4bn Gini within countries mixed Deteriorating in all but 4 G20 countries But improving in many non-G20 countries,

eg in Latin America

Globally, it’s the 2%

G20 doing badly

And good and bad performers converging

Brazil v the RICS

Brazil’s success story on inequality

Over last decade, incomes of the poorest Brazilians have risen more than x5 faster than those of the richest

Hunger ‘largely dealt with’ Cf New Deal or post War UK Women > men Blacks > whites Northeast > Southeast

Cutting inequality needs much more than social protection

Rights-based constitution Centre-left government Full employment Rising minimum wage, universal pension An integrated and effective public

administration A high level of public participation Political and economic stability

Gabriel Palma the most interesting

Deciles tell you more than Gini (Convergence)

In all countries, deciles 5-9 have (and keep) about 50% of wealth

Rest is up for grabs between top 10% and bottom 40%

Key political question is whether middle class allies with top or bottom

What might an NGO inequality agenda look like?

Structures matter (oil v jobs) Taxation – quantity and quality Ceilings v floors (eg land) Redistribution > income (eg tertiary ed =

16% social spending in Brazil) More on attitudes and beliefs: gender, but

also caste, ethnicity, children, disability Focus on inequality between or within

countries?

Oxfam India on Inequality

Income Missing Jobs, Low Wages and Discrimination Education & Health Public v Private To Have or Not a Toilet About Networks and Chances Rents and Redistribution

Thanks!