hazard identification and risk assessment...
Post on 01-May-2018
244 Views
Preview:
TRANSCRIPT
Final Rapid EIA Study Report – Reva Enterprise, GIDC Saykha, Bharuch Chapter - 7
Ramans Enviro Services Pvt. Ltd. | Ahmedabad
7.1
7 ADDITIONAL STUDIES
HAZARD IDENTIFICATION AND RISK ASSESSMENT STUDY
7.1 PREFACE
In order to support the Environment Impact Assessment and Environment Management
Plan, following additional studies have been included in this report.
� Risk Assessment
� On-Site / Off-Site Emergency Plan
� Occupational Health Programme
7.2 INTRODUCTION TO RISK ASSESSMENT
M/s. Reva Enterprise, for its upcoming new unit in Saykha will handle chemicals, some of
which are hazardous in nature by virtue of their intrinsic chemical properties or their
operating temperatures or pressures or a combination of them. Fire, toxic release or
combinations of them are the hazards associated with industrial plants using hazardous
chemicals. More comprehensive, systematic and sophisticated methods of Safety
Engineering, such as, Hazard Analysis and Qualitative/Quantitative Risk Assessment have
been developed to improve upon the integrity, reliability and safety of industrial plants, the
same has been discussed in detail under their respective headings.
7.2.1 OBJECTIVES OF RISK ASSESSMENT
Risk analysis follows an extensive hazard analysis. It involves the identification and
assessment of risks the neighboring populations are exposed to as a result of hazards
present. This requires a thorough knowledge of failure probability, credible accident
scenario, vulnerability of population etc. Much of this information is difficult to get or
generate. Consequently, the risk analysis is often confined to maximum credible accident
studies.
Risk assessment is carried out for the following objectives:
1. To identify hazard and risk resulting from the hazards
Annexure - Document of Risk Assessment
Final Rapid EIA Study Report – Reva Enterprise, GIDC Saykha, Bharuch Chapter - 7
Ramans Enviro Services Pvt. Ltd. | Ahmedabad
7.2
2. To study and foresee the effects of such risks on the workers, public, property and
environment and to find out necessary control measures to prevent or minimize risk.
3. To comply the legal requirement by various safety and environment laws of the
country like…
� The Factories Act, 1948 / The Gujarat Factories Act, 1963
� The Environment Protection Act and Rules, 1986
� Hazardous waste (Management & Handling) Rules, 1989
� Public Liability Insurance Act & Rules,1991
� Chemical Accident (Emergency, planning, preparedness and response) Rules, 1996
4. To get the necessary information for Emergency planning and evacuation.
7.2.2 PLANT LAYOUT
The below plant layout shows details of STORAGE FACILITIES, FIRE HYDRANT LINE
NETWORK WITHIN THE FACILITY and ADEQUATE MARGIN ALL ROUND THE
PERIPHERY for unobstructed easy movement of the emergency vehicle / fire tenders
without reversing back.
Final Rapid EIA Study Report – Reva Enterprise, GIDC Saykha, Bharuch Chapter - 7
Ramans Enviro Services Pvt. Ltd. | Ahmedabad
7.3
FIGURE 7.1: PLANT LAYOUT W.R.T RISK STUDY
Final Rapid EIA Study Report – Reva Enterprise, GIDC Saykha, Bharuch Chapter - 7
Ramans Enviro Services Pvt. Ltd. | Ahmedabad
7.4
TABLE 7.1A: STORAGE DETAILS OF RAW MATERIALS Sr. no
Name of the Raw Materials
Quantity stored, (kgs)
Mode of Storage & Material of Construction for the same
State Possible type of hazards
Proposed Control Measures
Actual
1 Tri ethyl amine (TEA) 200 HDPE Drums Liquid Flammable & Toxic � Well ventilated storage area will be provided.
� PPEs like Gloves, Lab coat, Splash goggles, safety Shoes, Vapor respirator., etc will be used.
� Source of ignition will be avoided.
� For detailed control measures & fire fighting facilities, refer section 7.5.
2 Cyclo hexane 180 MS Drums Liquid Flammable
3 Diethyl amine (DEA) 200 HDPE Drums Liquid Flammable & Toxic
TABLE 7.1B: PROPERTIES OF HAZARDOUS CHEMICALS (I.E HAZARDOUS CHARACTERISTICS & TOXICITY)
Sr. no CHEMICAL
Phy
sica
l St
ate FP
( oC) BP
( oC)
SP. GR @ 20oC
Vap. Den. vs air
Vap. Pr. @
20oC
LEL %
UEL %
LD50 ORAL mg/ kgs
LD50 DERMAL mg/kgs
LC50 mg/L
IDLH Value by ACGIH /NIOSH
STEL by
OSHA (PPM)
TLV-TWA by OSHA (PPM)
1 Tri ethyl amine (TEA)
Liq -8.3 89.7 0.73 3.48 54 mm
Hg 1.2 8 460 570 1250 200 15 10
2 Cyclohexane Liq -18 80.7 0.78 2.98 12.9 kPa 1.3 8.4 12705 18000 - 1300 300 300
3 Diethyl amine (DEA)
Liq -18 55.5 0.71 2.5 195 mmHg 1.8 10.
1 540 820 4000 200 25 10
NOTES: 1. Since, all the liquid chemicals are stored in Drums, size of the biggest storage tank and dyke part is not applicable to this unit. 2. The unit will be classified as Non Major Accident Hazard (NMAH) unit based on the quantity of Hazardous Chemicals stored at site, as the
quantity of these chemicals being stored within the factory premises are well within the threshold storage quantity as per schedules of Manufacture, Storage & Import of Hazardous Chemicals (MSIHC) Rules of major hazardous chemicals.
Final Rapid EIA Study Report – Reva Enterprise, GIDC Saykha, Bharuch Chapter - 7
Ramans Enviro Services Pvt. Ltd. | Ahmedabad
7.5
7.3 RISK ASSESSMENT
Identification of hazards in the proposed project activity is of primary significance. Hazard
states the characteristics of system/plant/process that presents potential for an accident. All
the components of a system/plant/process are need to be thoroughly examined to assess
their potential for initiating or propagating an unplanned event/sequence of events, which
can be termed as an accident.
IDENTIFICATION OF HAZARDOUS AREAS
At M/s. Reva Enterprise., major risks have been identified for the following area:
� Warehouse (Storage for Liquid & Solid Chemicals)
As a conservative approach, we have analyzed the risk qualitatively and quantitatively both.
In this study, we have considered the following:
� Storage & Handling of hazardous chemicals like DEA, Cyclo hexane and TEA, have
been considered for Consequence Analysis. Their storage location has been shown in
Figure 7.1. Hazardous (physical & chemical) properties of these chemicals have been
summarized in Table 7.1B.
� Storage & Handling of solid chemicals, caustic soda lye & Acids have been considered
for Qualitative Risk Assessment.
7.3.1 QUALITATIVE RISK ASSESSMENT
Many a times Risk involved in various processes / process equipments cannot be
addressed completely by Consequence Analysis. As a conservative approach, these risks
have been considered separately under this topic. The approach is to identify hazards
associated in operation of equipments as well as in processes, assessing its impacts,
ranking the risk posed by it and finally to propose remedial actions/mitigation measures
such that the risk is minimized to tolerable level.
The Risk Matrix presented below should be referred in evaluating this assessment.
In Qualitative Risk Assessment, risk has been analyzed using methodology called
HIRA-Hazards Identification & Risk Assessment. In HIRA, major manual activities carried
out by plant personnel as well as contract labors have been considered.
Qualitative Risk Assessment has been carried out for the following areas:
1. Storage and Handling of Solid Chemicals. 2. Storage and Handling of Caustic Soda Lye
Final Rapid EIA Study Report – Reva Enterprise, GIDC Saykha, Bharuch Chapter - 7
Ramans Enviro Services Pvt. Ltd. | Ahmedabad
7.6
3. Storage and Handling of Acids
TABLE 7.2: RISK MATRIX FOR QUALITATIVE RISK ASSESSMENT
LIKEHOOD/ PROBABILITY
SEVERITY
Catastrophic (Death/System Loss)
Major/ Critical
(Serious injury/Illness)
Moderate (Less Serious Injury/Illness)
Minor/ Marginal
(Minor Injury/Illness)
Insignificant/Negligible (No injury/illness)
1 2 3 4 5
Almost Certain E H H H M M
Likely D H H M M L
Possible C H M M M L
Unlikely B M M M L L
Impossible A M M L L L
Risk Range
Risk Acceptability
Criteria
Remarks
H Unacceptable/ High
Management’s Decision/Action Plan Required. Potential off-site Impact.
M Medium Generally Minor Impact. Acceptable with Management’s Review. Specific monitoring or SOP to be followed.
L Low Acceptable without Review. Manage through Routine Procedure.
Final Rapid EIA Study Report – Reva Enterprise, GIDC Saykha, Bharuch Chapter - 7
Ramans Enviro Services Pvt. Ltd. | Ahmedabad
7.7
TABLE 7.3 STORAGE AND HANDLING OF SOLID CHEMICALS (RISKS & RECOMMENDATIONS)
Sr No.
PROCESS OR
ACTIVITY
ASSOCIATED HAZARDS
HEALTH & SAFETY IMPACT (RISK)
INITIAL RISK
PROPOSED MEASURES
RESIDUAL RISK
ADDITIONAL RECOMMENDATIO
NS
SEVE
RIT
Y
LIK
ELIH
OO
D
RIS
K
SEVE
RIT
Y
LIK
ELIH
OO
D
RIS
K
1. Handling Chemical bags
� Chemical Exposure.
� Dusting.
� Skin/Eye irritation.
� Ingestion & Inhalation of dust powder.
4 C M � PPEs like suitable protective clothing, gloves, face shield, dust and splash proof safety goggles, chemically resistant safety shoes, etc. will be used.
� Standard Approved respirator will be used. � Eyewash station and safety showers will be
made available. � Air bag filters will be installed where the
product is pulverized. � Dust monitoring will be carried out
periodically.
4 B L 1. Operators/Workers to be trained for Safe Work Practices.
2. Chemical handling bags & dusty area to be labeled properly for each chemicals.
2. Cleaning of Chemical Spillage.
� Fumes Inhalation.
� Dust Exposure.
� Severe irritation to eyes, skin.
� Inhalation.
3 C M � Certified Dust respirator will be used. � PPEs will be used. � Chemicals will be stored in isolated storage
rooms having provision for natural & forced ventilation.
� Spillage will be cleaned or neutralized with suitable media.
� Fire fighting facilities will be made available near storage locations, if required.
4 B L
Final Rapid EIA Study Report – Reva Enterprise, GIDC Saykha, Bharuch Chapter - 7
Ramans Enviro Services Pvt. Ltd. | Ahmedabad
7.8
TABLE 7.4: STORAGE AND HANDLING OF ACIDS (LIKE HCL & H2SO4) (RISKS & RECOMMENDATIONS)
SR. No.
PROCESS OR
ACTIVITY
ASSOCIATED HAZARDS
HEALTH & SAFETY IMPACT (RISK)
INITIAL RISK
PROPOSED MEASURES
RESIDUAL RISK
ADDITIONAL RECOMMENDATIO
NS
SEVE
RIT
Y
LIK
ELIH
OO
D
RIS
K
SEVE
RIT
Y
LIK
ELIH
OO
D
RIS
K
1. Loading & Unloading of Drums.
� Exposure to Acid fumes due to leakage in pipe/container/valves etc.
� Spillage of liq. Acid.
� Skin/Eye irritation.
� Toxic Vapor inhalation etc.
4 C M � Loading & Unloading activity will be carried out in well ventilated area.
� Neutralization media will be made available in areas where acid is stored/handled/used.
� PPEs will be used.
4 B L
2. Working in Storage Area.
� Exposure to acid fumes.
� Severe irritation to eyes, skin.
� Body burns.
4 C M � Storage area will be well ventilated. � Neutralization will be done immediately with
soda ash/lime or spill will be absorbed in sand or by suitable adsorbent.
� PPEs like face mask, gloves etc. will be worn by concerned person.
� Floors will be made of acid proof tiles.
4 A L
3. Tank overflow/ leakage from joints etc.
� Exposure to acid fumes.
� Severe irritation to eyes, skin.
3 C M � Same as Above. 4 A L 3. Work Instruction for checking tank level to be prepared and followed.
Final Rapid EIA Study Report – Reva Enterprise, GIDC Saykha, Bharuch Chapter - 7
Ramans Enviro Services Pvt. Ltd. | Ahmedabad
7.9
TABLE 7.5: STORAGE AND HANDLING OF CAUSTIC SODA LYE (RISKS & RECOMMENDATIONS)
SR. No.
PROCESS OR
ACTIVITY
ASSOCIATED HAZARDS
HEALTH & SAFETY IMPACT (RISK)
INITIAL RISK
PROPOSED MEASURES
RESIDUAL RISK
ADDITIONAL RECOMMENDATIO
NS
SEVE
RIT
Y
LIK
ELIH
OO
D
RIS
K
SEVE
RIT
Y
LIK
ELIH
OO
D
RIS
K
1 NaOH handling /Loading & Unloading
� Exposure due to leakage from joints, corroded lines failure etc.
� Skin burn. � Eye irritation
and respiratory disorder.
4 C M � Dyke will be provided. � will be stored in well ventilated area. � Eye wash station will be made available
nearby. � Maintenance will be carried as per
schedule. � PPEs will be used.
4 B L 4. Proper trainings to be provided to the operators/workers.
5. SOPs to be prepared and followed the same.
6. Corroded lines to be painted / replaced.
2 Working in Storage Area
� Exposure due to spillage
� Severe irritation to eyes, skin etc.
� Internal body burns.
4 C M � Neutralization media will be kept available. � PPEs like face mask, gloves etc. will be
worn by concerned person. � Eye wash station will be made available
nearby.
4 A L
3 Tank overflow
� Chemical Exposure
� Eyes and Skin irritation.
3 C M � Level indicator will be installed and the same will be checked for proper operation.
� Dyke wall will be available to contain the spill.
4 A L 7. Working of level gauge to be checked.
Final Rapid EIA Study Report – Reva Enterprise, GIDC Saykha, Bharuch Chapter - 7
Ramans Enviro Services Pvt. Ltd. | Ahmedabad
7.10
7.3.2 QUANTITATIVE RISK ASSESSMENT
Quantitative Risk Assessment (QRA) is a structured approach to identifying and understanding the hazards & risks associated with Storage and Handling of flammable/toxic chemicals. The assessment starts by taking into account an inventory of hazardous chemicals stored, likelihood of leakage/spillage associated with it and selecting the worst case scenario for consequence estimation.
Finally, suggesting the measures to minimize or mitigate risks to meet appropriate acceptability criteria. The planning for emergency evacuation will be borne in mind whilst interpreting the results.
7.3.2.1 CONSEQUENCE ANALYSIS
In a plant handling hazardous chemicals, the main hazard arises due to storage and handling of hazardous chemicals as mentioned above. If these chemicals are released into the atmosphere, it may cause damage due to resulting fires or vapour clouds. Blast Overpressures depend upon the reactivity class of material between two explosive limits.
7.3.2.2 DAMAGE CRITERIA
In Consequence Analysis studies, in principle three types of exposure to hazardous effects
are distinguished:
1. Heat radiation, from a jet, pool fire, a flash fire or a BLEVE.
2. Explosion
3. Toxic effects, from toxic materials or toxic combustion products.
In the next three paragraphs, the chosen damage criteria are given and explained as per
the Guidelines for QRA – Phast (Micro) Software (DNV) & Purple Book for QRA released by
Centre for Chemical Process Safety (CCPS).
Heat Radiation
The consequence caused by exposure to heat radiation is a function of:
� The radiation energy onto the human body [kW/m2];
� The exposure duration [sec];
� The protection of the skin tissue (clothed or naked body).
In this report following damage criteria has been considered for the effects due to Fire/Explosion.
Final Rapid EIA Study Report – Reva Enterprise, GIDC Saykha, Bharuch Chapter - 7
Ramans Enviro Services Pvt. Ltd. | Ahmedabad
7.11
TABLE 7.6: EFFECTS DUE TO INCIDENT RADIATION INTENSITY
INCIDENT RADIATION – kW/m2
TYPE OF DAMAGE
37.5 Immediate ignition of wood (without flame Contact). 100 % fatal.
25 Minimum Energy required for igniting wood (Without flame contact). 100 % fatal in 1 min. Significant injury in 10 sec.
12.5 Minimum heat required to ignite wood (With flame contact). 1 % fatal in 1 min. First degree burn in 10 sec.
4 Pain after 20 sec. Blistering unlikely.
2 No discomfort for long exposure.
Explosion In case of vapour cloud explosion, two physical effects may occur:
� a flash fire over the whole length of the explosive gas cloud;
� a blast wave, with typical peak overpressures circular around ignition source.
As explained above, 100% lethality is assumed for all people who are present within the
cloud proper.
The following damage criteria may be distinguished with respect to the peak overpressures
resulting from a blast wave:
TABLE 7.7: DAMAGE DUE TO OVERPRESSURES
Peak Overpressure Damage Type
0.40 bar Ear Drum Rupture to humans
50 % probability of fatality inside
15% probability of fatality in open
0.21 bar Structural Damage to buildings
20% probability of fatality to personnel inside
0% probability of fatality in the open
0.13 bar Minor Structural Damage to nearby structures
10% probability of fatality to personnel inside
0% probability of fatality in the open
Final Rapid EIA Study Report – Reva Enterprise, GIDC Saykha, Bharuch Chapter - 7
Ramans Enviro Services Pvt. Ltd. | Ahmedabad
7.12
0.02 bar Glass Damage
0.01 bar Minor Damage
Intoxication In this report, IDLH & LC50 Concentrations have been considered for Consequence
Analysis.
7.3.2.3 ASSUMPTIONS FOR CONSEQUENCE ANALYSIS
For Consequence Analysis, assumptions regarding Meteorological, Pasquil Stability
Classes, Wind velocity, Ambient Temperature, Relative Humidity, Inventory, Ground
Roughness, Model used etc. are very important. In this report, the following assumptions
have been considered.
i. Meteorological Data
� Atmospheric Conditions: No Inversion
� Ambient Temperature: 350C has been considered as MCA approach.
� Relative Humidity: As the site is not in rainy zone RH of 50% has been considered.
ii. Pasquil Stability Classes
� Pasquil Stability category D/F is considered as conservative approach. iii. Other assumptions:
� Ground Roughness: Ground Roughness has been considered as 0.3 M.
� Dispersion model of both Heavy Model and also Gaussian distribution have been
used as applicable/appropriate.
� Inventory: Release of 100% of the inventory has been considered. For this, failure of
the container has been considered from the bottom.
� Storage conditions: Storage conditions have been considered as they are practically
stored at site.
Following Weather data has been used for the study:
TABLE NO 7.8: WEATHER DATA USED FOR THE STUDY
WIND SPEED (M/S) PASQUILL STABILITY
1.5 F
1.5 D
Final Rapid EIA Study Report – Reva Enterprise, GIDC Saykha, Bharuch Chapter - 7
Ramans Enviro Services Pvt. Ltd. | Ahmedabad
7.13
5 D
7.3.2.4 SOFTWARE USED FOR CALCULATIONS
PHAST MICRO has been used for calculations.
7.3.2.5 SCENARIOS CONSIDERED FOR CONSEQUENCE ANALYSIS
1. In this study, the scenarios for consequence analysis have been selected considering:
• The physical and chemical properties of hazardous materials
• Storage conditions & Modes of Storage (Above ground Drums).
• Hazards ranking by NFPA
• Guidelines by OSHA (29 CFR)
• Operating and storage conditions of handling and storage of hazardous chemical
2. This report considers the worst case scenario which is possible during any set of
operation variables and production methodologies. The objective of the study is
emergency planning, hence only holistic & conservative assumptions are used for
obvious reasons. Hence though the outcomes may look pessimistic, the planning for
emergency concept should be borne in mind whilst interpreting the results.
In this regard, the failure cases which may lead to release of hazardous chemicals are as under, out of which maximum worst case will be considered:
� Pin hole Leakage from Drum.
� Possible Release/Leakage from Drum.
� Release due to tilting of drum having open lid.
3. The scenarios of flammable solvent storage tanks (if it is stored in tanks) have been
considered assuming unavailability of bunds. Practically a bund will be provided as per
OISD guidelines.
4. In this study, results of consequence analysis will be used for;
a. Emergency Planning
b. Deciding Evacuation Routes
c. Deciding Location of Assembly Points and ECC
d. Resource Allocation for mitigation
Final Rapid EIA Study Report – Reva Enterprise, GIDC Saykha, Bharuch Chapter - 7
Ramans Enviro Services Pvt. Ltd. | Ahmedabad
7.14
5. SCENARIOS IDENTIFIED FOR CONSEQUENCE ANALYSIS
Scenarios Description of Scenario
Storage Pressure & Temp. Scenarios considered
FIRE/EXPLOSION SCENARIOS 1 Release of TEA Ambient Flash Fire, UVCE, Late Pool
Fire 2 Release of
Cyclohexane Ambient Flash Fire, UVCE, Late Pool
Fire 3 Release of DEA Ambient Flash Fire, UVCE, Late Pool
Fire TOXIC GAS RELEASE SCENARIOS
4 Release of TEA Ambient Dispersion 5 Release of DEA Ambient Dispersion
Considerations Made:
� In Case of TEA, Cyclohexane, DEA we have considered the maximum worst case
scenario as Release of Inventory due to 2” leakage from Drum.
And, for toxic gas dispersion scenario of TEA & DEA, the following parameters are
considered for the assessment.
Scenarios Description of Scenario LC50 IDLH
1 Release of TEA 1250 ppm 200 ppm 2 Release of DEA 4000 ppm 200 ppm
Note: Release of above chemicals from process equipments like Reactor or any other
equipment is not possible as these chemicals will be in diluted/intermediate form in all
process equipments and not in pure form.
� Selection Criteria of Scenarios:
o As per the relevant guidelines for consequence analysis, we have considered
the maximum credible scenarios for all the above mentioned chemicals,
which is the representative of all kinds of minor/major leakages for the
respective chemicals.
Final Rapid EIA Study Report – Reva Enterprise, GIDC Saykha, Bharuch Chapter - 7
Ramans Enviro Services Pvt. Ltd. | Ahmedabad
7.15
o Modeling has been carried out for dispersion up to IDLH concentration, in case
of toxic chemicals. Evacuation should be carried out in less than 30 min from
the areas covered under IDLH in case of relevant leakage scenario. The
purpose is to avoid irreversible health effects to persons inside the area of
IDLH concentration.
o Based on the above considerations and the input parameters considered for worst case scenarios & maximum credible scenarios, the risk contours are plotted on the plant layout map clearly showing which of the facilities would be
affected in case of an accident taking place. Based on the same the safety measures/recommendations are proposed and On-Site & Off-Site Emergency Plan will be prepared as mentioned under the section 6.6. competency
o The worst-case scenario has taken into account the maximum inventory of storage
at site at any point of time.
Final Rapid EIA Study Report – Reva Enterprise, GIDC Saykha, Bharuch Chapter - 7
Ramans Enviro Services Pvt. Ltd. | Ahmedabad
7.16
SCENARIO # 1 – RELEASE OF TRIETHYLAMINE
Basis: Possible Release/Leakage due to 2” damage to drum or tilting of drum with open lid.
Input Data
Quantity Considered (equivalent to one drum)
200 kgs
Drum gets empty 600-700 secs
Leak Size considered 50 mm
Pressure Ambient
Temperature 35 deg C
Weather Condition 1.5/F,1.5/D, 5/D
LFL 12000 ppm
UFL 80000 ppm
IDLH (toxic release) 200 ppm
LC50 (toxic release) 1250 ppm
Risk Contours for Flash Fire:
Final Rapid EIA Study Report – Reva Enterprise, GIDC Saykha, Bharuch Chapter - 7
Ramans Enviro Services Pvt. Ltd. | Ahmedabad
7.17
Risk Contours for VAPOUR CLOUD EXPLOSION (OVERPRESSURE RESULTS):
Risk Contours for Late Pool Fire:
Final Rapid EIA Study Report – Reva Enterprise, GIDC Saykha, Bharuch Chapter - 7
Ramans Enviro Services Pvt. Ltd. | Ahmedabad
7.18
Risk Contours for Toxic Gas Dispersion (IDLH):
Risk Contours for Toxic Gas Dispersion (LC50):
Final Rapid EIA Study Report – Reva Enterprise, GIDC Saykha, Bharuch Chapter - 7
Ramans Enviro Services Pvt. Ltd. | Ahmedabad
7.19
SCENARIO # 2 – RELEASE OF CYCLOHEXANE
Basis: Possible Release/Leakage due to 2” damage to drum or tilting of drum with open lid.
Input Data
Quantity Considered (equivalent to one drum)
200 kgs
Drum gets empty 500-600 secs
Leak Size considered 50 mm
Pressure Ambient
Temperature 35 deg C
Weather Condition 1.5/F,1.5/D, 5/D
LFL 13000 ppm
UFL 80000 ppm
Risk Contours for Flash Fire:
Final Rapid EIA Study Report – Reva Enterprise, GIDC Saykha, Bharuch Chapter - 7
Ramans Enviro Services Pvt. Ltd. | Ahmedabad
7.20
Risk Contours for Late Pool Fire:
Risk Contours for Vapor Cloud Explosion (Overpressure Results):
Final Rapid EIA Study Report – Reva Enterprise, GIDC Saykha, Bharuch Chapter - 7
Ramans Enviro Services Pvt. Ltd. | Ahmedabad
7.21
SCENARIO # 3 – RELEASE OF DEA
Basis: Possible Release/Leakage due to 2” damage to drum or tilting of drum with open lid.
Input Data
Quantity Considered (equivalent to one drum)
200 kgs
Drum gets empty 600-700 secs
Leak Size considered 50 mm
Pressure Ambient
Temperature 35 deg C
Weather Condition 1.5/F,1.5/D, 5/D
LFL 20000 ppm
UFL 101000 ppm
IDLH (toxic release) 200 ppm
LC50 (toxic release) 4000 ppm
Risk Contours for Flash Fire:
Final Rapid EIA Study Report – Reva Enterprise, GIDC Saykha, Bharuch Chapter - 7
Ramans Enviro Services Pvt. Ltd. | Ahmedabad
7.22
Risk Contours for Vapor Cloud Explosion (Overpressure Results):
Risk Contours for Late Pool Fire:
Final Rapid EIA Study Report – Reva Enterprise, GIDC Saykha, Bharuch Chapter - 7
Ramans Enviro Services Pvt. Ltd. | Ahmedabad
7.23
Risk Contours for Toxic Gas Dispersion (IDLH):
Risk Contours for Toxic Gas Dispersion (LC50):
Final Rapid EIA Study Report – Reva Enterprise, GIDC Saykha, Bharuch Chapter - 7
Ramans Enviro Services Pvt. Ltd. | Ahmedabad
7.24
7.3.2.6 CONSEQUENCE ANALYSIS SUMMARY
Flash Fire Scenarios:
SR. No. Scenario
Concentration (ppm)
Distance (meters)
Category 1.5/F
Category 1.5/D
Category 5/D
1 Release of TEA LFL Frac.6000 12.02 13.24 2.11
LFL. 12000 8.14 7.76 1.38
2 Release of Cyclohexane
LFL Frac.6500 10.85 11.79 1.6
LFL. 13000 7.07 6.2 1.37
3 Release of DEA LFL Frac.8500 19.78 22.89 10.59
LFL. 17000 14.65 16.05 13.02 Explosion Overpressure Scenarios:
SR. No. Scenario
Overpressure (Bar)
Downwind Distance (meters)
Category 1.5/F
Category 1.5/D
Category 5/D
1 Release of TEA
0.02068 28.17 23.43 NR
0.1379 14.7 13.47 NR
0.2068 13.64 12.69 NR
2 Release of Cyclohexane
0.02068 25.11 20.77 NR
0.1379 13.91 12.78 NR
0.2068 13.02 12.15 NR
3 Release of DEA
0.02068 22.43 45.11 34.48
0.1379 13.22 26.5 16.34
0.2068 12.49 25.03 14.9
Final Rapid EIA Study Report – Reva Enterprise, GIDC Saykha, Bharuch Chapter - 7
Ramans Enviro Services Pvt. Ltd. | Ahmedabad
7.25
Late Pool Fire Scenarios:
SR. No. Scenario
Radiation Level (kW/m2)
Distance (meters)
Category 1.5/F
Category 1.5/D
Category 5/D
1 Release of TEA
4 15.02 15.08 16.9
12.5 9.12 9.18 11.85
25 5.36 5.42 8.08
37.5 3.71 3.76 5.44
2
Release of Cyclohexane
4 11.83 11.88 13.73
12.5 6.36 6.41 9.27
25 3.4 3.45 4.51
37.5 3.4 3.45 4.17
3
Release DEA
4 13.68 13.74 16.29
12.5 6.33 6.39 9.29
25 3.42 3.48 4.52
37.5 3.42 3.48 4.19
Toxic Scenarios (IDLH):
SR. No. Scenario
IDLH (ppm)
Distance (mt.)
1.5/F 1.5/D 5/D
1 Release of TEA 200 73.36 46.48 27.71
2 Release of DEA 200 80.12 55.49 26.44
Toxic Scenarios (LC50):
SR.
No.
Scenario LC50 (ppm)
Distance (mt.)
1.5/F 1.5/D 5/D
1 Release of TEA 1250 21.86 28.87 7.76
2 Release of DEA 4000 26.81 31.68 18.54
80.12 meters in downwind direction is considered as evacuation area.
Final Rapid EIA Study Report – Reva Enterprise, GIDC Saykha, Bharuch Chapter - 7
Ramans Enviro Services Pvt. Ltd. | Ahmedabad
7.26
7.4 COMMENTS / RECOMMENDATIONS BASED ON CONSEQUENCE ANALYSIS
Flash Fire and UVCE Scenarios:
� Of all the Scenarios considered above, vapor travels to the farthest distance (19.78 m)
in case of release of DEA in 1.5/F weather condition. If it gets a source of ignition
within this radius, it will create UVCE (Unconfined vapor cloud explosion) and effects
of overpressure (0.02068 bar) would be felt up to 22.43mt. and 34.48mt.
� Evacuation plan to be designed considering the worst case scenario of DEA as
mentioned above.
Late Pool Fire Scenarios:
� It can be seen from the summarized table above that the risk of late pool fire is highest
in case of release of DEA in 5/D weather condition for 4 KW/m2 radiation level.
� Scenario for Release of Cyclohexane, poses least danger of radiation for 4 KW/m2
radiation level. Toxic Release Scenarios:
� Dispersion of Diethyl amine (DEA) covers more distance in case of IDLH concentration
(200 ppm) that is 80.12 mt.
� Evacuation plan to be designed considering the worst case scenario of the same.
RECOMMENDATIONS:
1. Evacuation routes will be planned such that alternate route is available from any corner
in more than one direction.
2. Extra precautions to be taken in unloading of flammable/toxic chemicals. The details of
precautions during storage handling and transportation of chemicals have been given
in separate paragraph.
3. Fire fighting arrangements will be provided as per the guidelines of OISD.
4. In case of release of toxic chemicals, evacuation will be done up to 80.12 meters.
Final Rapid EIA Study Report – Reva Enterprise, GIDC Saykha, Bharuch Chapter - 7
Ramans Enviro Services Pvt. Ltd. | Ahmedabad
7.27
7.5 OTHER SAFETY PRECAUTIONS / RECOMMENDATIONS
7.5.1. PROPOSED SAFETY/CONTROL MEASURES TO REDUCE THE RISK OF FIRE, EXPLOSION AND TOXIC RELEASE:
Following Mitigation Measures will be followed /practiced during transportation, unloading and handling of flammable & toxic chemicals, in order to ensure health & safety of workers involved in handling of hazardous chemicals and to avoid the
human health impacts.
Sr. ACTIVITY SAFETY PRECATIONS
1 Transportation of chemicals like TEA/DEA, Cyclohexane, etc., by Truck.
� Training will be provided to driver and cleaner regarding the safe driving, hazards of Flammable chemicals, emergency handling, and use of SCBA sets.
� TREM card & SCBA set will be kept with TL. � Fire extinguishers will be kept with TL. � Flame arrestor will be provided to TL exhaust. � Instructions will be given not to stop the truck in populated area. � Hazard Identification symbol and emergency telephone number
will be displayed as per HAZCHEM CODE. � Appropriate PPEs will be kept with TL.
In case of leak or spill: � Area & Container will be isolated. � Source of leakage will be checked. � Damaged containers or spilled material will not be attended
without wearing appropriate protective clothing. � Leakage will be stopped, if possible to do so without risk. � Water spray will be used to reduce vapors (but do not put water
directly on leak, spill area or inside container). � Combustibles (wood, paper, oil, etc.) will be kept away from
spilled material.
2 Unloading of Solvent Drums from Truck.
� Priority will be given for truck to immediately enter the storage premises at site and will not be kept waiting near the gate or the main road.
� Security person will check License, TREM CARD, Fire extinguisher condition; SCBA set condition, Antidote Kit, required PPEs as per SOP laid down.
� QC check & other required checks will be done & after the approval of same, unloading procedure will be allowed.
Following precautions will be taken during unloading:
Final Rapid EIA Study Report – Reva Enterprise, GIDC Saykha, Bharuch Chapter - 7
Ramans Enviro Services Pvt. Ltd. | Ahmedabad
7.28
� Wheel stopper will be provided to TL at unloading platform. � Unloading procedure will be followed according to check list. � Only day time unloading will be permitted.
3 Chemical Storage Area safety.
� All storage areas will be isolated from all sources of open flame and well posted with “Hazardous Chemical Storage”, “No Smoking”, “Hot work Restricted” signs.
� Spark-resistant tools will be used. � Pipes and equipment will be inspected at regular intervals. � Water spray will be used to reduce vapors (by taking care that
water is not directed straight away on leak, spill area or inside container).
� Combustibles (wood, paper, oil, etc.) will be kept away from spilled material.
� MS or HDPE storage drums will be provided as per good engineering practices.
� Storage area will be provided with adequate fire fighting/extinguishing system, Fire hydrant monitor with foam attachment facility, etc. as mentioned under section: 6.5.3.
� Sand Buckets will be made available. � Workers and Operators handling such materials will be trained
for the hazards (fire/explosion, health, chemical reactivity, etc.) & safety measures associated with them.
� Area will be inspected on regular basis. � NFPA label (hazard identification) along with capacity of
chemical will be displayed on respective drums.
� Dumping /Drain vessel/alternate vessel will be provided to collect the spillage material. Spillage Kit will be made available.
� FLP type pump & electric fittings will be provided, where applicable.
� Earthing will be provided to related drums and process vessels, as per the requirement.
� Double Jumper clip will be provided to all solvent handling pipeline flanges, if applicable.
4 Solvents transfer from storage area to Process Plant.
� Double mechanical seal type FLP type pump will be provided. � Double on / off switch will be provided, if needed. Flame
arrestor will be provided, wherever required. � NRV will be provided on pump discharge line. � Double Jumper clip will be provided to all solvent handling
pipelines.
Final Rapid EIA Study Report – Reva Enterprise, GIDC Saykha, Bharuch Chapter - 7
Ramans Enviro Services Pvt. Ltd. | Ahmedabad
7.29
7.5.2 RECOMMENDATIONS TO REDUCE FUGITIVE EMISSIONS
� Regular monitoring of plant area will be conducted and records will be maintained.
� Lines of such hazardous chemicals will be tested periodically and such tests will be
recorded.
� All lines carrying toxic liquid will be continuous welded and provided with proper slopes
and special tongue and groove joints to avoid liquid stagnation and leakage.
� Spill containment kit will be made available.
� PPEs will be given to concerned personnel.
� Only trained personnel will be allowed to carry out work in this area.
� In the process area, all the strategic pumps will be of submerged type so as to
eliminate leakages from glands.
� Safe Operating Procedures and EMERGENCY RESPONSE PROCEDURES will be
followed strictly.
7.5.3 FIRE CONTROL PLAN
M/s. Reva Enterprise has considered fire prevention measures at the project planning
stage for its upcoming new facility to avoid any outbreak of fire By looking to the hazardous
nature of process and the chemicals that are handled and processed, the chances of
outbreak of fire cannot be totally ignored. Hence to tackle such a situation, company has
developed proposed, well-resourced and adequate fire protection system/fire fighting
network.
The company has planned to keep the different types of fire extinguishers at various
conspicuous locations.
Other Fire fighting Measures to be updated for the new facilities, if required, will be:
� Fire load calculation will be carried out and accordingly fire fighting facilities comprising
of main pump, stand by pump, jockey pump, diesel driven pump, Hydrant Network,
Hose Box, Hose reels, Manual call points, Fire & Smoke detectors, fire alarms, fire
buckets, etc will be provided as per the GFR and TAC guidelines.
� Also, flame detectors, smoke / temperature actuated heat detectors with alarms,
automatic sprinkler system, will be installed at conspicuous locations as per the
requirements.
� Company will have Fire Water Tank of adequate capacity to combat the emergency, if
Final Rapid EIA Study Report – Reva Enterprise, GIDC Saykha, Bharuch Chapter - 7
Ramans Enviro Services Pvt. Ltd. | Ahmedabad
7.30
arise, GIDC water reservoir will also be made available, if required.
� Working staff will be trained to operate DCP, CO2 and foam extinguishers.
� DG set will be made available as a separate power backup for fire network, in case of
emergency or power failure.
� Company will do tie up with GIDC Fire Brigade and nearby companies, for handling
emergency situations.
� Electric driven Alarms & Sirens will be placed at the conspicuous locations. Hand Bell
will be used in case of power failure.
Factory Layout will be designed in such a way, that it will have a provision for separate
entry and exist with adequate margin all around the periphery for unobstructed easy
movement of the emergency vehicle / fire tenders without reversing back.
7.5.4. DO’S & DON’TS
Management has listed some of the Do's & Don'ts activities to strengthen the SAFETY AT WORK, which will be followed strictly:
For Preventive Maintenance Do's:
� Inspection of Storage Area, Earthing & Bonding system.
� Inspection of all Fire Fighting Facilities /Check Alarms operation.
� Ensuring that operators / workers etc. follows the SOPs, Safety procedures &
standards, work permit system etc.
� Checking the availability of Spill Containment Kit.
� Making sure fire extinguishers are fully charged and ready for action.
� Inspections of plant, machinery, tools, equipment, premises, work practices,
processes, procedures and general environment must be carried out for the health
and safety of plant, people and surrounding.
� On-site and Offsite Emergency Plans will be reviewed and updated, as per the
requirement. Don’ts:
� Don't allow anyone who hasn't received specific safety and operational training to get
indulge in any site activity.
� Don't perform your own maintenance.
� Don’t compromise on Design and Engineering part.
Final Rapid EIA Study Report – Reva Enterprise, GIDC Saykha, Bharuch Chapter - 7
Ramans Enviro Services Pvt. Ltd. | Ahmedabad
7.31
� Don't perform any activity without proper permit.
� Don't panic if you are in a risky situation.
� Don't allow spilled chemicals to drain to sewers/gutters etc.
Strengthening of HSE (Applicable for Manufacturing Utility Staff) Do's:
� Follow instructions. Do not take chances. If you don’t know, ask.
� Correct or report unsafe conditions.
� Include a timeline for completion of each recommendation.
� Make recommendations that are measurable and track able.
� Ensure that each recommendation is assigned to an individual to oversee
implementation.
� Help keep things clean & orderly. Keep gangways clear.
� Do not Horseplay. Do not run. Avoid distracting others. Avoid throwing things.
� Report all injuries. Get first aid promptly.
� Use, adjust and repair equipment only, when authorized.
� Use right tools & equipments for the job, use them safely.
� Do not smoke in restricted areas. Do not flick cigarette / beedi in company.
� Use prescribed protective equipment; keep them in good working conditions.
� Respect signs / warnings. Abide by rules laid down for your safety.
Don’ts: 1) No worker in a factory-
� will willfully interfere with or misuse any appliance, convenience or other thing
provided in the factory for the purpose of securing the Health, Safety or Welfare of the
workers therein:
� will willfully and without reasonable cause do anything likely to endanger himself
� or others; and
� will willfully neglect to make use of any appliance or other thing provided in the factory
for the purposes of securing the Health or Safety of the workers therein.
� Do not make vague statements, do not overrule supervisor, and do not adopt
shortcuts.
Final Rapid EIA Study Report – Reva Enterprise, GIDC Saykha, Bharuch Chapter - 7
Ramans Enviro Services Pvt. Ltd. | Ahmedabad
7.32
7.5.5. ANTIDOTES DETAILS
Appropriate Antidotes, First Aid Measures & Medical treatment for major hazardous
chemicals will be kept available at site. Some of them are given as below:
Chemical Antidote / Medical Treatment
Tri Ethyl amine � Immediate first aid: Ensure that adequate decontamination has been carried out. If patient is not breathing, start artificial respiration, preferably with a demand-valve resuscitator, bag-valve-mask device, or pocket mask, as trained.
� Perform CPR as necessary. � If eyes get in contact with TEA, immediately flush contaminated eyes
with gently flowing water. Di Ethyl amine � EYES: First check the victim for contact lenses and remove if present.
Flush victim's eyes with water or normal saline solution for 20 to 30 minutes while simultaneously calling a hospital or poison control center. Do not put any ointments, oils, or medication in the victim's eyes without specific instructions from a physician
� SKIN: IMMEDIATELY flood affected skin with water while removing and isolating all contaminated clothing. Gently wash all affected skin areas thoroughly with soap and water.
� INHALATION: Provide proper respiratory protection to rescuers entering an unknown atmosphere. Whenever possible, Self-Contained Breathing Apparatus (SCBA) should be used; if not available, use a level of protection greater than or equal to that advised under Protective Clothing.
Cyclohexane
7.5.6. WAYS TO MINIMIZE THE MANUAL HANDLING OF THE HAZARDOUS CHEMICALS
1. Fork lifts will be used for unloading chemical bags, bags movements within plant, drums etc.
2. Cranes, hoists, pallet trucks, conveyors, etc. will be used as per the requirement, to eliminate manual handling.
3. Lifting tools & tackles will be used, wherever required.
4. SOPs, work instructions will be prepared and followed.
5. Trainings will be provided to relevant staff, operators, workers for the risk associated with manual handling of hazardous chemicals, ways to overcome those risk, etc.
Final Rapid EIA Study Report – Reva Enterprise, GIDC Saykha, Bharuch Chapter - 7
Ramans Enviro Services Pvt. Ltd. | Ahmedabad
7.33
7.6 ON-SITE / OFF-SITE EMERGENCY PLAN
M/s. Reva Enterprise will prepare the Proposed On-Site / Off-Site Emergency Plan which will be followed from the project construction & erection phase.
The purpose of this plan is to provide M/s. Reva Enterprise with the means to effectively utilize all the resources at its disposal for the protection of life, environment and property.
The details of the same are discussed in the following sections.
7.6.1 DEFINING THE NATURE/LEVEL OF EMERGENCY
THE LEVEL OF EMERGENCY CAN BE CLASSIFIED IN THREE CATEGORIES:
LEVEL - 1: The leakage or emergency, which is confinable within the plant/area which may arise due to:
a) Small pipe/valve rupture or similar leakages that do not affect outside premises.
b) Release of toxic chemicals for short duration.
c) Small fire in the plant. LEVEL - 2: The emergency, which is confinable within the factory premises which may
arise due to -
a) Leakage of toxic chemicals for long duration.
b) Medium scale explosion confined to the factory premises.
c) Medium scale fire inside the factory premises.
LEVEL - 3: The emergency, which is not confinable within the factory premises and general public in the vicinity are likely to be affected. It may arise due to -
a) Heavy / Profuse leakage of toxic / flammable gases for a long duration.
b) Explosion of high magnitude affecting the adjacent area.
c) Major fire inside the factory premises.
7.6.2 OBJECTIVES OF EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT SYSTEM
The objectives of the emergency management system are summarized as under.
� To identify and assess types of emergencies due to different types of hazards.
� To work out plan with all provisions to handle emergencies and safeguard employees and people in the vicinity of the factory.
� To provide for emergency preparedness and the periodical rehearsal of the plan.
� To plan mode of proper communication and actions to be followed in the event of emergency.
� To keep all necessary information with respect to hazard/accident control and emergency contacts in one document for easy and speedy reference.
Final Rapid EIA Study Report – Reva Enterprise, GIDC Saykha, Bharuch Chapter - 7
Ramans Enviro Services Pvt. Ltd. | Ahmedabad
7.34
� To inform employees, general public and the authorities about the hazards/risk if any and the role to be played by them in the event of emergency.
� To control and contain the accident.
� To effect rescue and treatment of casualties.
� To inform and help relatives of casualties.
� To secure rehabilitation of affected area and restore normalcy.
� To provide information to media and government agencies.
� To preserve record, equipment etc. for investigating cause of emergency.
� To be ready for “mutual aid” if need arises to help neighboring units.
7.6.3 STRUCTURE OF EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT SYSTEM
M/s. Reva Enterprise will develop an Emergency Management Team. The management structure will include the following personnel’s;
� Site Main Controllers
� Incident Controllers and Deputy Incident Controllers
� Key Personnel’s
� Essential Workers
The other elements of Emergency Plan will be:
� Assembly points
� Emergency control center
� Fire control arrangements
� Medical arrangements
� Other arrangements
7.6.3.1 SITE MAIN CONTROLLER
Senior most Executives (i.e. Director& Supervisor) of the company will be nominated as SMC. His task will be to co-ordinate all internal and external activities from the Emergency Control Centre at Main Security Gate, from where all operations will be directed. He will:
� Immediately on being informed of the emergency and its location, will arrive at the site, review the situation and control further actions.
� Direct all Emergency Operations within the approved area with the following priorities:
a. Personnel Safety,
b. Plant, Property and Environment Safety and
Final Rapid EIA Study Report – Reva Enterprise, GIDC Saykha, Bharuch Chapter - 7
Ramans Enviro Services Pvt. Ltd. | Ahmedabad
7.35
c. Minimum loss of production.
� Co-ordinate to avail services from external agencies like fire brigade, hospitals etc, if called for, following the declaration of major emergency. If necessary, major installations in the vicinity may also be informed of the situation.
� Exercise direct operational control of the unaffected section of the plant.
� In consultation with the advisory team, expedite the shutting down of loading / unloading operations and if necessary, instruct the supervisor / security personnel to evacuate that area.
� Ensure that all employees are evacuated from the affected area and the casualties, if any, are given necessary medical attention. Instruct P & A Assistant / Security for rushing casualties to hospitals if required.
� Liaise with fire and police officials, pollution control board officials and other statutory bodies and advise them of all possible consequence effects outside the premises.
� Arrange for relief of personnel when emergency is prolonged.
� Issue authorized statement or press release to the news – media.
� Ensure preservation of evidence for enquiries to be conducted by statutory authorities.
� Authorize the sounding of “All Clear” and “Evacuation Siren”.
� Arrange for obtaining the head – count of all personnel within the premises and cross-checking with the data from records available for no. of persons within the premises.
Nominate a person from advisory team, to maintain chronological log of event during the entire period of emergency.
7.6.3.2 ROLE OF INCIDENT CONTROLLER AND DEPUTY INCIDENT CONTROLLER
His/her primary duties will be to take charge at the scene of the incident. In the initial stage he/she may be required to take decisions involving the operation of the other plants or to stop or continue any process and to take technical decisions to control the incident. The deputy incident controller will take the charge of incident controller, if he/she is not available due to any reason. They will be always available in each shift and can take charge of the incident.
Responsibilities/Duties of Incident Controller and Deputy Incident Controller:
� Managers connected with Plants/the respective Plant-In-Charge from each shift have been designated as I.C.
� Two Production officers in each shift will be identified as Deputy Incident
Final Rapid EIA Study Report – Reva Enterprise, GIDC Saykha, Bharuch Chapter - 7
Ramans Enviro Services Pvt. Ltd. | Ahmedabad
7.36
Controllers.
� He will take charge at the scene of incident.
� He will immediately assess the gravity of risk and alert panel and field operators to start controlling their respective section.
� He will work under the direction of the SMC, but till his arrival he may have to execute following responsibilities.
� He will ensure that all the Key Personnel are called.
� Direct for evacuation of plant and areas likely to be affected by the emergency.
� He will communicate to the SMC the type of outside help needed.
� He will direct all emergency operations within the affected area with the following priorities.
� Personnel safety, including of surrounding community.
� Minimum damage to Plant, Property and Environment.
� Appropriate actions to minimize loss of Production and Material.
� Give information to the head of fire fighting and rescue team and other emergency services.
� Depending on the incident, instruct partial or total shut down, isolations, depressurization, Nitrogen purging, fire fighting, rescue operations.
� Instruct upstream/downstream units to take emergency shutdown /cutting off supply and other appropriate actions and emergency evacuation help etc.
� Direct for search of casualties.
� Evacuate non-essential workers/visitors/contractors to safe assembly points.
� Brief site main controller and keep him informed about the developments.
� Preserve evidences. This will be necessary for investigation for cause and concluding preventive measures.
7.6.3.3 KEY PERSONNEL
Senior officers of various departments like Fire, Security, Safety, Administration, Engineering, Project, Production, Transport, Pollution control, Technical Services and Stores will be nominated as Key Personnel in their respective fields. As necessary, they will decides the actions needed to shutdown plants, evacuate personnel, carryout emergency engineering work, arrange for supplies of equipments, utilities, carryout environment monitoring, provide catering facilities, liaise with police, fire brigade and other local authorities, relative of casualties, hospital, press & neighboring industries, action at assembly points, outside shelters and mutual aid center under the direction of the SMC. All
Final Rapid EIA Study Report – Reva Enterprise, GIDC Saykha, Bharuch Chapter - 7
Ramans Enviro Services Pvt. Ltd. | Ahmedabad
7.37
the key personnel and other called in so to assist, will report to the ECC. They are available at any time on duty or on call or on holidays.
7.6.3.4 ESSENTIAL WORKERS
Essential Workers will be those who will be trained in Fire Fighting and First Aid. One Supervisor and two helpers from each shift will be identified as E.W.’s & are supposed to report at EMERGENCY SITE to take instructions from I.C. or Dy. I.C. Such work instructions will include:
� Fire fighting and spill control till a Fire Brigade takes the charge.
� To help the Fire Brigade and mutual aid teams, if it is so required.
� Shutting down plant and making it safe.
� Emergency engineering work e.g. isolating equipment, material process, providing temporary by-pass lines, safe transfer of materials, urgent repairing or replacement, electrical work, etc.
� Provision of emergency power, water, lighting, instruments, equipments, materials, etc.
� Movement of equipment, special vehicle and transport to or from the scene of the accident.
� Search, evacuation, rescue and welfare.
� The injured will be given First Aid.
� Carrying out atmospheric test and pollution control.
� Manning of assembly points to record the arrival of evacuated personnel. Manning for outside shelters and welfare of evacuated persons there.
� Assistance at causalities reception areas to record details of causalities.
� Assistance at communication centers to handle out going and incoming calls and to act as messengers if necessary.
� Manning of works entrances in liaison with the police to direct emergency vehicles entering the work, to control traffic leaving the works and to turn away or make alternative safe arrangements for visitors, contractors and other traffic arriving at the works.
� Informing surrounding factories and the public as well as directed by the Site Main Controller.
� Any special help required.
OTHER ELEMENTS OF DMP:
Final Rapid EIA Study Report – Reva Enterprise, GIDC Saykha, Bharuch Chapter - 7
Ramans Enviro Services Pvt. Ltd. | Ahmedabad
7.38
7.6.3.5 ASSEMBLY POINT
In affected & vulnerable plants, all nonessential workers (who are not assigned any
emergency duty) will be evacuated from the area & they will report to specified Assembly
Points. Minimum 2 nos. of Assembly Points will be marked at a safe place well away from
area of risk and least affected by the down wind direction.
To ensure that workers do not have to approach the affected area to reach the Assembly
Point, proper location and number will be marked at Assembly Points. Each Assembly
Point will be manned by a nominated person to record the names and dept. At each
Assembly Point, duties of Assembly Point In-charge are displayed in brief. Before reaching
an Assembly Point or subsequently, if it is required to pass through an affected area or due
to presence of toxic substances, suitable PPE's including respirators, helmet etc., will be
issued & made available with workers.
7.6.3.6 EMERGENCY CONTROL CENTER
The Emergency Control Center is the place or room from where the operations to handle
the emergency are directed and coordinated. A safe room near security gate will be
earmarked /identified as the Emergency Control Room.
Telephone and other facilities required with necessary documents will be displayed in ECC
for ready reference. Designated trained personnel will operate ECC. In case of Major
Emergency, the Site Main Controller will operate from ECC.
The ECC center will be equipped with the following facilities.
1. Internal and external telephone including STD facility
2. Telephone directory/ Telephone nos. of mutual aid centers
3. First Aid
4. Muster roll of Workers
5. Identity card register
6. Layout plan of the factory showing the location of hazardous materials, assembly point, first aid centers etc.
7. Map of surrounding area with Fire Extinguishers location
8. M.S.D.S
9. Copy of ON SITE OFF SITE PLAN
10. Stationeries like- note book, pen, pencils etc.
11. S.B. Apparatus
Final Rapid EIA Study Report – Reva Enterprise, GIDC Saykha, Bharuch Chapter - 7
Ramans Enviro Services Pvt. Ltd. | Ahmedabad
7.39
12. List of Government Agencies /Local press agencies with phone no.
13. Sand Buckets & Hydrant Network
14. Adequate numbers of PPE's
7.6.3.7 FIRE CONTROL ARRANGEMENTS (FIRE FIGHTING, GAS LEAK CONTROL AND RESCUE OPERATION)
A) Role of Manager (Fire and Safety) / Shift In-Charge (Fire & Safety): 1. Incident Controller will direct the fire fighting and Emergency operation. His duties
include:
2. Keep the constant touch with the SMC / In charge - EHS.
3. Direct the crew members to the scene of emergency and arrange replenishment of Manpower / equipment / extinguishing media etc.
B) Role of EHS Representative: 1. On being notified about the location of fire/ gas leakage, he will immediately proceeds to
the help.
2. Decides his line of action in consultation with Incident controller and takes appropriate measures to handle the emergency.
3. will assess the severity of the incident & will immediately report to emergency controller about the gravity of the situation.
4. He will also assess the extra requirement required if any, from the neighboring industry.
C) Fire crew members:
1. On hearing fire alarm & emergency siren, they will immediately reports to control room and proceed to the scene of emergency and work under the direction of IC/ Dy IC.
2. The personnel availability at the scene of incident will be made optimize. D) Emergency Squad Members:
1. On hearing Emergency Siren, they will immediately reports to site main controller, safety in charge or incident controller.
2. They will combat the emergency situation as per the direction of site main controller, safety in charge or incident controller.
3. They will help for safe evacuation.
7.6.3.8 MEDICAL SERVICES
The roles of Medical officers are as follows;
a) He/she will report immediately to the SMC/IC.
b) He/she will render necessary treatment, at Occupational Health Center.
Final Rapid EIA Study Report – Reva Enterprise, GIDC Saykha, Bharuch Chapter - 7
Ramans Enviro Services Pvt. Ltd. | Ahmedabad
7.40
c) He/she will arrange for Hospitalization and Treatment at outside hospitals, if required.
d) He/she will mobilize in getting the services of External medical agencies, other Para
–medical services etc. and transportation services etc.
e) He/she will arrange for extra medical assistance/antidotes, from out, if required.
f) He/she will arrange for first-aid trained volunteers for necessary help.
g) He/she will liaise with the Government Health Authorities for treatment of the affected
persons nearby.
7.6.3.9 ROLE OF SECURITY IN-CHARGE (SECURITY OFFICER)
� On hearing the emergency siren, he will find out the location of the incident (fire / gas
leak / spill / explosion) and inform the location of the same to the key personnel coming
to the plant.
� He will depute the security guards for managing gates and traffic control at the incident
site & send remaining guards to the site of incident.
� He will prevent unauthorized entry in to the site
� He will render assistance as demanded by the safety in-charge.
� He will mobilize additional security force for help, if required.
� He will direct ambulance(s) and emergency vehicle(s) to the scene of incident.
� He will help evacuate persons within the scene of incident.
� As directed by the site main controller, he may be required to address the public of
surrounding villages for warning / evacuation.
7.6.3.10 ROLE OF MUTUAL-AID MEMBERS
� Company will have Mutual Aid with various nearby factories.
� On receiving the call, they will proceed immediately with fire squad & fire tenders.
� They will be guided to the place of the incident by the main gate security guard.
� The fire squad in-charge will report to the safety in-charge of the unit in which the
incident has occurred.
7.6.3.11 OTHER ARRANGEMENTS
Other arrangements include external transport (transport centre), heavy vehicles,
lift/cranes, generator sets to supply emergency power, environment monitoring equipment,
Final Rapid EIA Study Report – Reva Enterprise, GIDC Saykha, Bharuch Chapter - 7
Ramans Enviro Services Pvt. Ltd. | Ahmedabad
7.41
special instruments/equipments, rescue items etc. will be made available (if required) from
near-by Industries /locations, when available resources do not meet the requirements.
STANDARD OPERATING PROCEDURE (will BE FOLLWED DURING EMERGENCY) � As soon as emergency alarm is heard, all essential workers will report to IC or SMC.
� They will carefully listen to the instructions given by IC or SMC
� According to the type of emergency/accident, they will get equipped with PPE/Fire-fighting equipment and devices.
� The runner among the workers will inform SMC/IC and key personnel if they are not at site.
� The messenger amongst the workers will deliver messages to nearby units as per the instructions of SMC/IC.
� The in-charge of medical arrangements will prepare first-aid and other required facilities for the injured.
� The other essential workers will try to control the emergency as per the instructions given to IC.
� IC would keep SMC informed about the status of control measures being taken at the site and ask for other requirements eg. Mutual aid, equipment, etc if he find necessary.
� SMC would co-ordinate with outside agencies regarding control measures being taken, need for external help, evacuation, medical treatment etc.
7.6.4 COMMMUNICATION SYSTEM
Communication System is a Crucial Factor while handling emergency. Company has quick &
effective Communication System through which, any situation, which can lead to emergency,
can be informed or known to…
i. All persons working inside the plant.
ii. Key Personnel outside during normal working hours & during off-duty hours.
iii. Outside emergency services, Statutory and Local Authorities and
iv. Neighboring facilities and public leaving in vicinity.
Each and every section, Plant & Department of the Factory will be connected by internal
telephones with SMC, Supervisor or IC’s. External Phone at Office and Residence and
Mobile will also be made available with Key Personnel and top executive of the factory.
The Communication System will begins with raising the alarm declaring the emergency,
Telephone messages and Procedure to communicate the emergency to other persons &
General Public.
Final Rapid EIA Study Report – Reva Enterprise, GIDC Saykha, Bharuch Chapter - 7
Ramans Enviro Services Pvt. Ltd. | Ahmedabad
7.42
7.6.4.1 RAISING THE ALARM
As soon as incident takes place inside the factory and is noticed by someone, the first step
will be to raise the nearest manual emergency bell to alert the nearby people. Next, he/she
will inform the security persons to raise the emergency siren located at the factory gate.
The security personnel sound the siren.
The alarm sound informs the I.C and the S.M.C that an emergency has been created and
emergency organization is to be activated. The I.C. rushes to the site and will takes charge
of the scene.
7.6.4.2 DECLARING THE MAJOR EMERGENCY
Major emergency is declared after sufficient and thorough check because the declaration
of major emergency puts many agencies on action and it may disturb the running system,
which may be Costly at, time or its Consequence may be Serious. Therefore, major
emergency must not be decided on whims or immature judgment or without proper
thought. Looking to all the above, we will nominate the persons (SMC: Director & Incident
Controllers) who can declare the emergency; we have selected them on the basis of their
knowledge & experience. These persons will be technically qualified and experienced. The
decision about major emergency will be taken as early as possible and without wasting
time so that control action can be started immediately.
7.6.4.3 TELEPHONE MESSAGES
A Telephone operator who is precise, sharp, attentive and quick in receiving and noting the
message and subsequently effective in further Communication, will be appointed. A form to
record emergency telephone calls will be available with telephone operator or Person
available in Emergency Control Center, who will record such calls during emergency.
Telephonic messages will be given out by the telephone operator to Site main Controller
and key personnel as per the instructions of the Incident Controller. Telephonic messages
will also be given to authorities and external agencies to describe the type of emergency.
All details of emergency will be collected/delivered according to this format, available with
the telephone operator.
7.6.4.4 COMMUNICATION OF EMERGENCY & STATUTORY INFORMATION
Communication of Emergency
An effective system to communicate emergency will be made to communicate about the
Final Rapid EIA Study Report – Reva Enterprise, GIDC Saykha, Bharuch Chapter - 7
Ramans Enviro Services Pvt. Ltd. | Ahmedabad
7.43
emergency situation as mentioned below:
� Inside the factory i.e. workers including key personnel and essential workers, on duty &
inside during normal working hours.
� To key personnel and essential workers not on duty and outside during normal working
hours.
� To the outside emergency services and the Government authorities.
� To the neighboring factory & the General Public in the vicinity.
STATUTORY INFORMATION
a) Information to Workers
Set of Statutory information regarding types of hazards and their prevention and control as
directed in the Factories Act will be prepared by the unit. This information will be printed in
the local language and will be given in the form of booklet to all workers including contract
workers.
b) To the outside emergency services and authorities
Statutory information in the form of booklet will be given to outside emergency services and
authorities, if required.
c) To neighboring firms and the general public
Statutory information in the form of booklet will be given to neighboring units and the
general public of the villages in the vicinity of the unit, if required.
7.6.5 EMERGENCY TIME ACTIVITIES
The probable emergency situation that can arise in the unit and the corresponding control
actions as described below will be followed: 1. FLAMMABLE RELEASES Source / Incident – Fire involving spilled combustible material near or in flammable storage
areas
Following Control actions will be taken –
1. Any one who notices fire will sound emergency alarm.
2. SMC/IC who is at site, will immediately rush to the scene and assess the situation.
For fire due to spillage of combustible material, he activates the on-site plan as -
� He cuts off electric supply to that area and evacuates all the persons to safe
assembly points.
Final Rapid EIA Study Report – Reva Enterprise, GIDC Saykha, Bharuch Chapter - 7
Ramans Enviro Services Pvt. Ltd. | Ahmedabad
7.44
� He calls in DIC (if DIC is not present there) and asks essential workers to fight fire
with dry chemical / CO2 fire extinguisher or sand.
� He inform fire brigade telling them in briefly about kind of fire and type of
extinguishers required
� He informs mutual aid teams and asks for necessary help.
� He arranges first-aid / hospitalization for the affected persons.
� Fire officer on reaching the site, takes charge of the fire-fighting operations
� Mutual aid teams are asked for help in the form of first-aid, transport etc.
� If fire is growing, fire officer informs IC who alerts neighboring units and through
SMC gets more fire-fighting help.
� Fire fighting will be continued till fire is fully overcome
� After extinguishing fire, fire officer cools the entire area with water spray and checks
that no re-ignition is likely to occur. After that, he declares the area safe.
� IC tells essential workers to sound all clear.
� The incident will be recorded.
� SMC arranges to inform families / relatives of injured / dead.
� SMC issues authorized statement to press / media.
� SMC informs Factories Inspector about the incident and related information 2. TOXIC RELEASES
� Source / Incident – Pressure release due to failure of
- Stuffing box gland packing
- Pressure release valve
- Vessel / pipeline failure
Following Control Actions will be taken –
1. Any one who notices the release will sound emergency alarm.
2. SMC/IC who is at site, will immediately rush to the scene and assess the situation.
For toxic release from a reactor, he activates the on-site plan as -
� He evacuates all the persons to safe assembly point.
� He calls in DIC (if DIC is not present there) and asks essential workers to wear
self-breathing apparatus and if the reaction is exothermic, start cooling water flow in
the reactor jacket and cool the reactor as soon as possible.
� The essential workers stop all the charging pumps of that reactor and the nearby
reactors.
Final Rapid EIA Study Report – Reva Enterprise, GIDC Saykha, Bharuch Chapter - 7
Ramans Enviro Services Pvt. Ltd. | Ahmedabad
7.45
� He informs mutual aid teams and asks for necessary help.
� He arranges first-aid / hospitalization for the affected persons.
� Mutual aid teams will be asked for help in the form of first-aid, transport etc.
� When the leak stops and the air will clear of toxic release, IC tells essential workers
to sound all clear.
� The vessel / rupture disc/gland packing will be attended by maintenance
department.
� The incident will be recorded
� SMC arranges to inform families / relatives of injured / dead.
� SMC issues authorized statement to press / media.
� SMC informs Factories Inspector about the incident and related information
3. CHEMICAL SPILL Most of the chemicals will be stored in Drums & drums will be located in separate isolated
storage area. Neutralizing material will be kept available. Spill containment kit will be kept
available. For dilution, water connection will be provided on all sides of Storage Area. Sand
buckets will be available for covering spillage of flammable / corrosive materials. Fire
fighting facilities will be made available nearby.
7.7 OCCUPATIONAL HEALTH & SAFETY PROGRAMME
M/s. Reva Enterprise, has prepared the Occupational Health Surveillance Program
which will be followed right from the project construction & erection phase and the same
will be updated for the upcoming new facility, if required.
The details of the same are described in the following sections.
7.7.1 OCCUPATIONAL HEALTH
Occupational health needs attention both during construction & erection and operation &
maintenance phases. However, the problem varies both in magnitude and variety in the
above phases.
7.7.2 HOSPITAL FACILITIES /FACTORY MEDICAL OFFICER & OHC
Company will made formal agreements with nearby hospitals having facilities to attend fire
and toxic effect cases, emergency cases, attending the affected persons in the emergency
arising out of accidents, if any, etc.
Final Rapid EIA Study Report – Reva Enterprise, GIDC Saykha, Bharuch Chapter - 7
Ramans Enviro Services Pvt. Ltd. | Ahmedabad
7.46
A qualified doctor will be appointed as FMO on retainer shift basis. Apart from him, required
medical facilities applicable as per Gujarat Factories Rules and Factories Act will also be
made available.
All types of first aid related accessories, Medicines & Antidotes as prescribed by FMO, etc
will be made available at conspicuous locations.
7.7.3 AMBULANCE VAN & FIRST AID BOX
An Emergency Vehicle will be made available round the clock to be used as an Ambulance
during emergency.
First Aid Boxes will be made available at the different location in the plant. Training will be
given to employees for First Aid.
7.7.4 PLAN FOR PERIODIC MEDICAL CHECKUP
Periodic Medical Examination will be conducted as per the following schedule;
Workers employed will be examined by a Qualified Medical Practitioner/ Factory Medical
Officer, in the following manner:
(a) Before employment, to ascertain physical fitness of the person;
(b) During employment, every six months (blood & physical examination) as per
Gujarat Factories Rules, to ascertain physical fitness of the person to do the
particular job;
7.7.5 DETAILS OF OCCUPATIONAL HEALTH IMPACTS AND SAFETY HAZARDS
Occupational Hazards Identification
� Exposure to Toxic Chemicals.
� Exposure to Flammable Solvents.
� Fire due to Static charge generation
� Slip/trip, fall, electric shock, etc.
� Spillage/leakage,
� Overflow,
� Exposure to Corrosive Chemicals.
Occupational Health Impacts
� Toxication, Irritation,
� Fall Injury, Electrocution,
� Body Injury, Burns, Skin sensitization,
� Severe irritation to eyes & skin,
� Respiratory disorder,
� Damage to nearby equipments,
� Fatality, etc
Mitigation measures/Safety Measures proposed to avoid the human health hazards are
mentioned under section 6.5. In addition to these safety measures, personal protective
Final Rapid EIA Study Report – Reva Enterprise, GIDC Saykha, Bharuch Chapter - 7
Ramans Enviro Services Pvt. Ltd. | Ahmedabad
7.47
equipment (IS approved) like safety Helmet, Safety shoes/ Gumboots Hand gloves, Gas
Mask / Nose Mask, PVC apron, SCBA Set, PVC pressure suit, goggles, hood, etc. will also
be provided to the required personnel.
7.7.6 DETAILS OF WORK PLACE AMBIENT AIR QUALITY MONITORING PLAN
Work zone monitoring will be carried out by independent competent third party regularly.
Records will be kept in Form No. 37 as per Gujarat Factories Rules. Location for samplings
will be identified. Ambient Air & Noise Monitoring will be done every 3 months as per GPCB
CCA requirements. Following information will be incorporated in the format for maintaining
records of work zone monitoring:
Location/Operation monitored
� Identified contaminant
� Sampling instrument used
� Number of Samples
� Range of contaminant concentration as measured in sample
� Average concentration
� TWA concentration of contaminant (As given in Second Schedule of Factories Act)
� Reference method used for analysis
� Number of workers exposed at the location being monitored
� Signature of the person taking samples
� Other relevant details
7.7.7 MONITORING OF THE OCCUPATIONAL INJURY & IT’S IMPACT ON WORKERS
Following action plan will be prepared & followed to monitor the occupational injury to
workers:
� Each workplace will be evaluated for the work conditions.
� Unsafe Act & Unsafe Practices will be identified.
� Unsafe equipments, unsafe areas, etc., will be identified.
� Area will be checked for proper Ventilation and Illumination.
� Air-borne concentration of toxic chemicals will be measured and records will be
kept.
� Evaluation of training & on the job work.
Impact of the above mentioned unsafe conditions on workers will be studied and remedial
measures for the same will be adopted.
Final Rapid EIA Study Report – Reva Enterprise, GIDC Saykha, Bharuch Chapter - 7
Ramans Enviro Services Pvt. Ltd. | Ahmedabad
7.48
7.7.8 PROVISION OF INDUSTRIAL HYGIENIST & HEALTH EVALUATION OF WORKERS
� It is proposed that management will device a plan to check and evaluate the
exposure specific health status evaluation of workers.
� Workers will be checked for physical fitness with special reference to the possible
health hazards likely to be present, where he/she is being expected to work before
being employed for that purpose. Complete medical examinations including PFT,
Urine and Blood examination, Liver Function tests, chest X-ray, Audiometry,
Spirometry Vision testing, ECG, etc. will be carried out. However, the parameters and
frequency of such examination will be decided in consultation with Factory Medical
Officer and Industrial Hygienists.
� While in work also, all the workers will be periodically examined for the health with
specific reference to the hazards which they are likely to be exposed to during work.
Again, the parameters and frequency of such examination will be decided in
consultation with Factory Medical Officer and Industrial Hygienists. Plan of monthly
and yearly report of the health status of workers with special reference to
Occupational Health and Safety, will be maintained.
7.7.9 SAFETY TRAININGS & MOCK DRILLS
Safety trainings (on Safe Material Handling, First Aid, & all Safety Aspects) will be provided
every 15 days by the Safety Officers with the assistance of faculty members called from
other Professional Safety Institutions and Universities. In addition to regular employees,
limited contractor labors will also be given safety training. To create safety awareness,
safety films will be shown to workers and leaflets are distributed.
MOCK DRILLS
To evaluate the effectiveness of emergency preparedness and to spread the awareness
among employees mock drill will be carried out at the interval of every six months.
After completion of the mock drill, summary report will be made and corrections will be
done if any weakness has been observed.
FREQUENCY OF MOCK DRILLS:
On-site emergency: Once every 6 months & Off-site emergency : Once every year
top related